The Witcher

:

Season 1
  • Network: Netflix
  • Series Premiere Date: Dec 20, 2019
Season #: 4, 3.5, 3, 2, 1
User Score
7.5

Generally favorable reviews- based on 2682 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 2,028 out of 2682
  2. Mixed: 201 out of 2682
  3. Negative: 453 out of 2682

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

view
per page
  1. Boorberry
    Dec 21, 2019
    10
    The show is really good, high production value, good acting jobs by the cast all around and lots of action scenes.

    HIGHLY RECOMMENDED, can't wait for Season 2!!
  2. smentek
    Dec 21, 2019
    5
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Acting is good but nothing spectacular. Including Cavill as Geralt. But he convinced me, and I think I will see him in more positive light later in show Freya Allan is actually very good.
    It looks to me like most of the comments here giving 10.0 is artificial. Nothing justify that high score! Not if you are fan of books/game and it is even less likely if you new to it. The show is rather bad. But if you are teen or big fan of fantasy, then you may still like it. But giving it 10? No way. I watched first episode and may continue it another day, but without enthusiasm. One of the best short stories from the books, is trimmed mercilessly in order to push some well known 'fall of the kingdom' drama cliche into episode. It could be add later on, in couple of short scenes, as retrospective. But no. We have to say it all "again" at start, to have that "grand opening" that someone envisioned. I'm really open to new ("old" I should say) ideas, but it have to work well. Instead it ends up with utter lack of tension! They had great book do adapt, and safe would be to keep plot close to it. Even if it would end up being miniseries. The problem is: Sapkowski short stories are really well written. There is not much to cut off or trim from it without destroying it utterly.
    Fighting scenes do not work either. All bogus. It lacks of speed it lacks of "reality" - that may not the best word for it, as some better CGI is also needed. But above all much more production time and effort! Also stunt doubles. Martial art masters? Would it be so difficult to hire some? We do not need Cavill doing it all by himself. Without high quality fighting choreography this show will not fly. Unfortunately money went on horses instead. But not for the music, is terrible! Violence and sex all PG-13. That I can understand. But some of the stuff i do not get at all. For instance in first episode Geralt is being told by other characters that he needs new clothes (repeatedly - It may be that they "think" he stinks, after bath in the swamp, but it ended up about cloths in dialogues. Magician door is open for everyone. Guarded only by illusion. But worst is that in last scene Geralt leaves market first, in result allowing Sorcerer to continue his intended work. What kind of men would do that?! So our main character is compromised already. Not the Geralt I like or respect.    … Expand
  3. samkaz
    Dec 24, 2019
    10
    If you read the books, comics and/or played the video game (and liked those) you will love the Witcher. The cinematography, writing, characters and pacing make it more of a Game of Thrones epic saga than a cheap video game spin-off. The casting is impeccable (Cavill is perfect) and the European style storytelling is interesting, charming, moving and gripping all at once. Ignore theIf you read the books, comics and/or played the video game (and liked those) you will love the Witcher. The cinematography, writing, characters and pacing make it more of a Game of Thrones epic saga than a cheap video game spin-off. The casting is impeccable (Cavill is perfect) and the European style storytelling is interesting, charming, moving and gripping all at once. Ignore the negative reviews on here; most of their gripes are about the supporting casts' skin colour. Atrocious. I loved this show. Cannot wait for the sequel(s). If you're looking for a great new fantasy franchise, this is it. Best TV show of the year for me, hands down.… Expand
  4. stevej7
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    Rare to see an actor with so much passion about the character he's playing. I feel it shows in his performance and was definitely pleasantly surprised.
    I understand that this is getting and probably going to continue getting review bombed because it doesn't stay 100% true to the books but neither did the Lord of The Rings films or Harry Potter or Game of Thrones. I enjoy this and all of    Rare to see an actor with so much passion about the character he's playing. I feel it shows in his performance and was definitely pleasantly surprised.
    I understand that this is getting and probably going to continue getting review bombed because it doesn't stay 100% true to the books but neither did the Lord of The Rings films or Harry Potter or Game of Thrones. I enjoy this and all of those others because they are their own thing. I don't need a scene by scene replication of a book in film version. The games aren't identical to the books and they're still strong. I think this is off to a good start and I hope they build strongly on these foundations.    … Expand
  5. Mendax89
    Dec 20, 2019
    1
    The Woker, a SJW Netflix story. SJWs writers ruined a great book series.
    Another franchise ruined by SJWs and Netlfix.
  6. wildorgan
    Dec 21, 2019
    0
    just no, slow boring, poor wardrobe, confusing story, generic characters devoid of personality smh
  7. Augustus75
    Dec 21, 2019
    7
    The performances are strong. I'm tired of angry white men complaining about a cast of color. Grow up. I fell in love with the cast. Only issue was pacing and the writing.
  8. golibethesda
    Dec 21, 2019
    1
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Terrible show with badly cast actors, awful writing, awful lighting (everything looks grey), FX, scenography, etc. etc. Dialogues were poorly written, they've added some new scenes which are atrocious (like Yennefer's training), plus they omitted some good ones from the books. There are constant jumps in space and time which makes this show hard to follow for those who don't know the books. Not to mention that going from one place to another and from one time to another diminishes the roles of each character and in the end we don't get to know either of them.… Expand
  9. Stigma
    Dec 24, 2019
    9
    Yes, there were changes made to this show that bothered me as a huge fan of the Witcher. But I was entertained throughout, and I can't say that for the first season of Game of Thrones (the subsequent ones were mostly brilliant). People angry about 'woke' and SJW stuff should be careful of giving this show such a poor review, because the Witcher was light on that stuff, and assigned 0 andYes, there were changes made to this show that bothered me as a huge fan of the Witcher. But I was entertained throughout, and I can't say that for the first season of Game of Thrones (the subsequent ones were mostly brilliant). People angry about 'woke' and SJW stuff should be careful of giving this show such a poor review, because the Witcher was light on that stuff, and assigned 0 and 1 scores are going to practically assure that Netflicks will keep doling out guilt trips and drastically altering the source material to appease the offended. I thought this was a great 1st season.… Expand
  10. Warlok9
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    I’m not sure what books these folks read that are giving the show a zero rating? Many of the user reviews say the show is too much of a departure from the source material. Huh?I thought the show runners did an admirable job of staying with the story the books told. I mean the first couple books are just non-chronological stories plucked out of the timeline anyways. Who cares if they jumbleI’m not sure what books these folks read that are giving the show a zero rating? Many of the user reviews say the show is too much of a departure from the source material. Huh?I thought the show runners did an admirable job of staying with the story the books told. I mean the first couple books are just non-chronological stories plucked out of the timeline anyways. Who cares if they jumble the stories around to make more sense for a show.

    What I believe these people mean is that they are angry the show wasn’t cast “white enough”. Yennefer isn’t the pale sorceress as described in the books, Triss is changed to a person of color. There are many others I suppose. I think the cast was great! NONE of the changes effect the story in any way, shape or form. I maybe would have an issue with the main character being changed because his look is so iconic at this point.

    My actual score is an 8 for the show, but to help offset the spammed zero scores I’m giving it a 10. The acting is GREAT. I can’t think of one actor who didn’t do fantastic. The storytelling moves a bit slow and feels disjointed at times, I would think especially for those unfamiliar with the books. The lighting and color grading are very good and consistent.

    The effects are mostly good. All are high enough quality for a show like this. The practical effects are superb (the Striga fight!) but the cgi is a mixed bag. Cgi creatures are passable for the most part, but if you are hoping for GOT level Dragons and cgi you will be disappointed. The atmospheric and environmental cgi effects are fantastic, however. From the spell effects to the depiction of terrain and strongholds, it’s all top quality.

    Hopefully the show is set for a second season right away and they can improve upon what they have created here, which is solid.    … Expand
  11. Mandiven
    Dec 21, 2019
    10
    A surprise hit for me. I loved Witcher 3 and read a bit from the books and I definetly recommend this if you enjoyed the lore and story from any of the games, obviously if you read the books also. If your not a fan of fantasy medieval inspired shows then you will probably not enjoy this.
  12. greenisgood
    Dec 22, 2019
    8
    TL;DR - There is a lot of good stuff going on here far out-weighing some of the bad technical aspects and for people who played the games like myself I am sure will find more enjoyment compared to someone who wants a pixel perfect portrayal of what they envisioned in their own head while reading the books and or agenda pushing flag bearers telling what should and should not be in aTL;DR - There is a lot of good stuff going on here far out-weighing some of the bad technical aspects and for people who played the games like myself I am sure will find more enjoyment compared to someone who wants a pixel perfect portrayal of what they envisioned in their own head while reading the books and or agenda pushing flag bearers telling what should and should not be in a high-fantasy series written by a Polish Man adapted by an American Company.

    Totally understand some of the negativity and makes sense, totally do not understand some other parts of the general negativity. The racial tensions exist within the canon itself and is a constant point of contention humans vs elves vs dwarves vs monsters vs mages vs queens vs kings vs women vs men and so on and so forth. For everyone who has the capability to separate themselves from the political road-maps of our current generation there is good-slow story telling and some amazing portrayals of beloved characters and I urge everyone to make up their own minds after completing the show, positive or negative experience from your own minds and not from what everyone says how you 'Should' feel.

    The Good
    I have only played The Witcher 3, neither the books nor the first two games have any influence on me and also neither does racial representation and or political agendas, unless I get it forcefully shoved down my throat without some form of organic reason for it existing.
    The only things that give my joy a pause while watching a story being told is unskilled actors, writers, editors and directors. So believe me when I say I absolutely hated Cavill in Man of Steel and the movie itself more so on a storytelling level.
    But after watching Count of Monte Cristo and Fallout I believed that maybe my insipid taste for Cavill was not for his acting. I am happy the Character of Geralt was where my misconceptions of Henry being a bad actor were totally resolved.

    I do not know if there is some post recording artificial modulation to his voice but it is as if Doug Cockle leaped out from the game and took on Henry's form as Geralt of Rivia, his grunts his sighs his inflections and the single worded "F#CK's" were some of the best moments. Geralt/Henry is the absolute best thing about this show and I say this on all levels from his character writing, dialogue writing and appearance which means hats off to the costume department. The casting for everyone else was well done and based on what I saw did not feel forced due to beliefs or agendas, everyone who played their roles played them well and did so with passion which always bring out the best in everything.

    The show itself is well written and slow thankfully taking it's time setting up the frankly vast sea of world building that exists for the franchise. The direction as well is competent as well as decent cinematography hold this show up along with the aforementioned Geralt portrayal.

    The Bad
    A few things a bit lacking though and I believe this would be solved with some more finesse, some of the editing is a little bit lacklustre especially during the battle scenes. It is clear that Henry has spent time with swords for this portrayal but it always seems that the cameras keeps shying away from the battle scenes couple this with some not so great editing for these scenes make the eventual gory finishers not as satisfying. Some of the pacing also drops at certain places but spends some time fleshing the characters out which makes it acceptable. The whole two timelines thing was a bit jarring in a few places as you are not too sure of the time frame for what is happening but this is minute since the climax episode brings it all to an end in a way that sorts this out.    … Expand
  13. Benaud
    Dec 21, 2019
    8
    Great! Loved it. My background is pretty much from playing the three series games here, although I have just started into the first book.
    Casting generally okay, although I am struggling to see Triss in that actress. She's too different. Fringilla I can handle, but I view Triss as one of four mains in this story and I like her too much for her to change so radically, plus I'm not sure    Great! Loved it. My background is pretty much from playing the three series games here, although I have just started into the first book.
    Casting generally okay, although I am struggling to see Triss in that actress. She's too different. Fringilla I can handle, but I view Triss as one of four mains in this story and I like her too much for her to change so radically, plus I'm not sure she's being played as mischeviously and as the kindly soul she should be (team Merigold here!) Thank god she at least has a smattering of freckles. I think I really like Yennefer here though so good news! And the wardrobe she gets to parade around in...
    Apart from that, yeah great start. Give me more of it. Characters are all likeable, the world feels a long way from black and white and production values seem excellent.
    There is room for this show to grow into what it should be. A faithful recreation of the story and feeling of the world of The Witcher, even if your casting was driven from a less-than-faithful narrative to turn the story into something it wasn't.    … Expand
  14. badtactic
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    You would think by now that production companies would have learned that a viewer must also be familiar with the books, games, etc to enjoy a series - than it shouldn't be made. But, in the case of the Witcher, it seems like the creators have either blatantly ignored this lesson - or simply not understood it.

    The Witcher presents a slew of issues: a groaning and bland performance from    You would think by now that production companies would have learned that a viewer must also be familiar with the books, games, etc to enjoy a series - than it shouldn't be made. But, in the case of the Witcher, it seems like the creators have either blatantly ignored this lesson - or simply not understood it.

    The Witcher presents a slew of issues: a groaning and bland performance from Cavill, a film stylistic choice more reminiscent of a CW tween show, an exceptionally mundane storyline, and more.

    If you're looking for something to skip - this is one of them.    … Expand
  15. Fianna
    Dec 21, 2019
    10
    This show was excellent and I am praying that it goes for at least 5 seasons. All the reviews saying that it was hard to follow and this in turn made it bad are hard to empathize with because I found that element of mystery and confusion just made me want to watch more of this great show.
  16. Nurarihyon
    Dec 21, 2019
    9
    Amazing introduction to the Series with great skilled actors. Just need to fix some small details in next seasons
  17. burgersmash
    Dec 22, 2019
    8
    Objectively speaking any review that is less then 5 and more then 8 or 9 is probably not from someone who has actually watched the show. I quite enjoy the word of the Witcher so I’m willing to give the show a better score then it may deserve and I’m also not racist so I’m ok with any of the changes the show made to it’s characters. I look forward to another season and hope Netflix willObjectively speaking any review that is less then 5 and more then 8 or 9 is probably not from someone who has actually watched the show. I quite enjoy the word of the Witcher so I’m willing to give the show a better score then it may deserve and I’m also not racist so I’m ok with any of the changes the show made to it’s characters. I look forward to another season and hope Netflix will continue to upset bigots the world over.… Expand
  18. McMiRo
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    I had so much fun watching this show. A few improvements should be made, for example the villages and cities seems to be pretty empty. For people who don't have any experience with books or games it could be pretty difficult to watch it at beggining. I am looking forward to see more seasons of this show. Great work!
  19. Galatey
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    Если вы не читали книг вам будет иногда трудно понять что происходит, т.к. иногда за сценой в настоящем следует сцена из прошлого , а потом опять сцена из настоящего.Это может вводить в заблуждение , учитывая то,что королева Калантэ какого-то черта не стареет. Если честно даже Йен мне понравилась , чего не могу сказать о Трисс. Такое чувство , что она решила не пользоваться чарами дляЕсли вы не читали книг вам будет иногда трудно понять что происходит, т.к. иногда за сценой в настоящем следует сцена из прошлого , а потом опять сцена из настоящего.Это может вводить в заблуждение , учитывая то,что королева Калантэ какого-то черта не стареет. Если честно даже Йен мне понравилась , чего не могу сказать о Трисс. Такое чувство , что она решила не пользоваться чарами для своей красоты, и на возраст ей по барабану. Поэтому мы наблюдаем 45 летнюю Трисс .В остальном сериал мне понравился и я советую его посмотреть фанатам Ведьмака. И я все больше удостовериваюсь в том , что из ведьмака сделать что-то плохое очень сложно.… Expand
  20. Altamore12
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    Stunning show without any bad feeling while you are watching and after and make you missed the game of this series a lot with it 10/10
  21. MrEmanuelSantos
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    Despite the confusion of initial 3 timelines, The Witcher series proves to be a competent series in discussing about family, empathy and acceptance. Great action scenes, very well directed. A wonderful concern with diversity and plurality in the cast and characters of the series. The care taken when representing minorities is somewhat respectable and must be valued for the next medievalDespite the confusion of initial 3 timelines, The Witcher series proves to be a competent series in discussing about family, empathy and acceptance. Great action scenes, very well directed. A wonderful concern with diversity and plurality in the cast and characters of the series. The care taken when representing minorities is somewhat respectable and must be valued for the next medieval productions to come out of the false idea and that they must cover the white cast to be "faithful to a historical period".… Expand
  22. Mcmcaruso
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    The Witcher has some great elements. CG and the lead actor are especially great, but this show fails in the writing and storyline. It goes off the rails, feels more like the video game equivalent to a bunch of side quests instead of the main quest.
    + There is an overall tone of immasculated, unintelligent men at the aid of every powerful woman. It's obvious the writer/director is a woman    The Witcher has some great elements. CG and the lead actor are especially great, but this show fails in the writing and storyline. It goes off the rails, feels more like the video game equivalent to a bunch of side quests instead of the main quest.
    + There is an overall tone of immasculated, unintelligent men at the aid of every powerful woman. It's obvious the writer/director is a woman that is angry at the world.

    Also I love how the main actress, which was the ugliest, deformed woman just starts putting on make up and stops hunching over. Now she is the most beautiful girl in all the land. Thank God for medieval Sephora.    … Expand
  23. Witchersasat
    Dec 20, 2019
    0
    Ужасно, ни сюжета, просто набор глупостей. Местами ужасная графика, отсутствует логика
  24. tec
    Dec 20, 2019
    0
    Focus on Drama & really dumb behaviour. PoC look super out of place, dont know why they were casted into this roles other than being a low key racist and putting thoose as boost of his own twisted morale. Facts from the book straight up ignored. Funny how some fans with 1/100th of the budget were able to create something way more faithfull than nextflix with his millions. Another proofFocus on Drama & really dumb behaviour. PoC look super out of place, dont know why they were casted into this roles other than being a low key racist and putting thoose as boost of his own twisted morale. Facts from the book straight up ignored. Funny how some fans with 1/100th of the budget were able to create something way more faithfull than nextflix with his millions. Another proof that money cant buy everything, in that case creativity, authenticity & coherence. Either watch the original series from 2002 or straight up the fan movie on youtube.… Expand
  25. Vikhus
    Dec 21, 2019
    10
    By the far one of the best tv series on this year, Cavill fit 100% on Geralt. on weekend i will see for the second time all 10 episodes.
  26. DarthShel
    Dec 20, 2019
    3
    Dull characters, too much colored characters who totally ruin the spirit of that world, where all blacks are from Zerrikania or Ofir. Plus the battles suck so much compared to GoT. This 40 vs 40 ugly wired soldiers fight is literally crap. Just compare it to lower-budget Battle of Bastards. Geralt is awesome. But rest of the cast feels weird and non-canon both compared to the books andDull characters, too much colored characters who totally ruin the spirit of that world, where all blacks are from Zerrikania or Ofir. Plus the battles suck so much compared to GoT. This 40 vs 40 ugly wired soldiers fight is literally crap. Just compare it to lower-budget Battle of Bastards. Geralt is awesome. But rest of the cast feels weird and non-canon both compared to the books and games. Dialogues ain’t complicated at all. I can’t understand why creators keep comparing their show to Game of Thrones when Witcher seems to be so much worse. And even the story. In GoT you understand very quickly who is who and what was their past. And in the very end of ep.1 they made you want to watch more by a very cool plot twist. And this just doesn’t happen to be in the Witcher… Expand
  27. Ashot667
    Dec 20, 2019
    0
    Просто какойто ужас всю атмосферу книг и игр взяли и викинули вон добавля в сериал африканцев и азиатов поймите это сериал про словаков а не африканцев тем самым такое чувства что я смотрю сериал где действа происходит не в среднивиковой польши а в какойто африке.Просто какойто ужас всю атмосферу книг и игр взяли и викинули вон добавля в сериал африканцев и азиатов поймите это сериал про словаков а не африканцев тем самым такое чувства что я смотрю сериал где действа происходит не в среднивиковой польши а в какойто африке.
  28. lilkillpappy
    Dec 21, 2019
    0
    I tried to love this show and I could tolerate many of the problems with it but the acting is horrible. Dull, uninspired acting that has not been seen on a show for decades. Thank you for reminding me of how bad television acting used to be.
  29. Ky3mi4_raider71
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    Black people in Eastern Europe???Are you kidding? No, thanks. It's obviously not how i imagined adaptation of this book
  30. Alcarin
    Dec 21, 2019
    10
    Its an awesome interpretation of the first short stories and the last video game. Sometimes its a bit too much hollywood, but it doesnt deserve most of the 0 star reviews.
  31. veeminer
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    It sent shivers down my spine. Gerald and Yennefer are awesome! As a fan of books I was delighted to see this on screen
  32. alsione
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    expectations were not high. but after watching I was very surprised. The show was great. Geralt and Einifer played very well. I look forward to continuing. Если отбросить нелепо смотрящихся актеров негроидной рассы в данном сеттинге то в целом мне очень понравилось.
  33. WhiteWolf_1984
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    Great adult fantasy show. It has the solid acting and intriguing characters of Game of Thrones with the rich world, deadly creatures and sword fighting action of Lord of The Ring. It's top drawer stuff. The writing is intelligent, the wit is snappy, the dialogue is smart and the story is a fantasy lovers dream. There is lots of world building and heavy lore so you have to pay attention butGreat adult fantasy show. It has the solid acting and intriguing characters of Game of Thrones with the rich world, deadly creatures and sword fighting action of Lord of The Ring. It's top drawer stuff. The writing is intelligent, the wit is snappy, the dialogue is smart and the story is a fantasy lovers dream. There is lots of world building and heavy lore so you have to pay attention but it's worth taking in every bit of the Witcher world as it's excellent. It's sexy and mature. The action is gritty and raw with gory violence, sprinkled with some cool magic. The only small negative is the slow pace of the first episode but every episode after just gets better and better. All the sets are quality, the locations are epic and while the CGI isn't the greatest it still looks premium for TV. Henry Cavill is awesome, he plays the brooding, fearless, sarcastic witcher Geralt brilliantly. The supporting cast put in rock solid performances and their characters are fleshed out more than I expected going in. It's not all about Geralt, other characters are given ample time to shine. It is a must watch show.… Expand
  34. sudey88
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    Понравился сериал. Бой на мечах в первой серии очень-очень эпично. Угодить игрокам Ведьмака очень тяжело, за это я накидываю пару балов. жду второй сезон
  35. Fascinated
    Dec 21, 2019
    6
    The voice of Gerald of Pornhub Parody. That's all what do you must know before watching.
  36. Theclutch3
    Dec 21, 2019
    9
    Great quality for debut season, only some strange cast choices, for some worldwide appeal, that this big franchise doesnt need.
  37. wr1ter
    Dec 20, 2019
    0
    **** happens.. no atmosphere here, just one more cheap series (
    I think twice now buy or not cyberpunk (((
  38. KittysGameCorne
    Dec 20, 2019
    7
    Normally I don't to reviews for Tv shows, but this time I will since I do not think Metacritic is doing this TV show justice. The show is great, its fun to watch and it's a witcher world. Does story get a bit confusing at times, yes, but that does not make it that bad.
  39. Mordson
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    Great story,cast and fight scenes. The Witcher becamed one of my favorite TV Shows. Netflix Nailed It.
  40. Frungo
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    Отличный сериал, отличная адаптация, хорошие актеры, Генри молодец!
  41. ReticentRobot
    Dec 20, 2019
    10
    Watched it straight through - first time since Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Firefly that I'll watch it through a second time ASAP. Loved it.
  42. AigleAveugle
    Dec 20, 2019
    9
    Never read the books, played all the games. This is it, Everything here is at its place, the pace, combat, the story, characters, dialogue, everything is Witcher all the way. Bravo! I would have given it a 10 if Marcin Przybyłowicz made the soundtrack.
  43. TomTomGo92
    Dec 20, 2019
    8
    The Witcher is a dark and fitting adaption of the books and video game. Season 2 can not arrive soon enough.
  44. Tengokuji
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    No for everyone.This TV series just like the game is not for everyone. As always some people will quote "It is not like in the books." Others will find it too violent and others will be curbed by their desire to simply say "another adaptation of a game that goes wrong".

    This series is a superb entertainment, the role of the actors is up to the budget of the project and even higher. The    No for everyone.This TV series just like the game is not for everyone. As always some people will quote "It is not like in the books." Others will find it too violent and others will be curbed by their desire to simply say "another adaptation of a game that goes wrong".

    This series is a superb entertainment, the role of the actors is up to the budget of the project and even higher. The views and as well as the special effects and digital image sound of good quality.

    Honestly, very good for me.    … Expand
  45. Fistan
    Dec 21, 2019
    7
    For Witcher fans or any other Fantasy fans out there, i'll summarize it in this. This show is worth watching. It is overall enjoyable but there are a lot of problems that are made as a choise by creators. There are few battle scenes, but when they are on screen it is great fun. Henry is really good with a sword and i loved watching him fight every single time, especially in the firstFor Witcher fans or any other Fantasy fans out there, i'll summarize it in this. This show is worth watching. It is overall enjoyable but there are a lot of problems that are made as a choise by creators. There are few battle scenes, but when they are on screen it is great fun. Henry is really good with a sword and i loved watching him fight every single time, especially in the first episode or the monster in ep3. Main trio of the cast is good, they have problems again but compared to rest of the cast it is far less glaring.

    Now the thing that glare most obviously is the blafication of eastern europe setting. We have black elves, black dryads(makes no sense deep in the forest) or intentional change of characters with lighter skin into darker ones like Redhead Triss is not a redhead or Fringilla straight up being african black. It is so obvious that it kills suspension of disbelief everytime you see one of these things. These characters are not black in either books or the games.

    Nilfgaardians are not done well one bit. They are evil for the sake of being evil. Every dialogue scene with them is tropy, they are behaving as if Emperor is a prophet but there is actually no philosophical discussion or even single line of dialogue that actually explains what they believe in. It simply is as it is because creators needed unwavering loyalty in Nilfgaardians. They are in the category of "Stupid Evil". Sacrificing invaluable resources for momentary gains. Last episode is a good show of this. And dont get me started on the ballsack armor ugh..

    The show also has tempo problems. I understand they need to do a proper exposition to main characters, but the current day events about Ciri is strecthed out the whole season which completely diminishes the impact it'd have had on us if they just condensed it into one or two episodes. Show constanly goes between past and the present as a way of exposition and it creates problems. I could keep up because i know the books but would make no sense to people who are learning about them the first time.

    Great deal of characters are not portrayed properly. Especially the last episode involves an event if done well would've been crown jewel of television. However they needed a far bigger budget to pull it off, and we could tell from directing and the decisions it was lacking. Thats why the characters in the episode are far weaker than their book or game counterparts except Yennefer which makes no sense. Especially when you see how that one particular character fights, compared to whom she was far weaker in the books. Basically they are very liberal about book material despite what creators claim.

    Still overall it is not a bad show. Dialogue is generally good, action scenes are done well and directing is decent. I even liked Jaskier(dandelion in games) which may be the best of the cast in terms of how well he fits. Songs should have more Polish/folk vibe however, as it is still too western. Overall if you just want to watch a decent fantasy show, the witcher will do the job. It is good enough.    … Expand
  46. Vika-98
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    A very good serial! Can't wait for the next season. At least, I hope it will be)
  47. T-Rein
    Dec 21, 2019
    9
    Holds up as one of the best fantasy series I've seen, if you want more like Game of thrones consider giving this a look.
  48. funkymonkey
    Dec 22, 2019
    8
    Hey Metacritic, do the right thing and take EW's review off your site. The critic only watched 1/4 of the show before giving it a 0. It should be taken down and not have an impact on the overall rating of the show.
  49. Frisbiek
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    I gotta say, I am REALLY impressed. As a fan of the witcher games (haven't ready the books), I didn't have much hope for a netflix series based on the witcher.

    Now I am hooked. I can't stop watching it, and it's making me want to read the books. Superb acting not just by Henry Caville, but the whole cast. Great story telling. Great fighting and impressive screen play. One of my    I gotta say, I am REALLY impressed. As a fan of the witcher games (haven't ready the books), I didn't have much hope for a netflix series based on the witcher.

    Now I am hooked. I can't stop watching it, and it's making me want to read the books. Superb acting not just by Henry Caville, but the whole cast. Great story telling. Great fighting and impressive screen play. One of my major pet peeves are rushed shows and corny acting. I was also worried that this was going to be a show pressured to scratch that "game of thrones" itch, and would suffer trying to be too ambitious. Instead, what I've found is a show done right, and it stands on its own.

    I have to give Caville a lot of credit- he captures Geralt of Rivia exactly as I would picture him. You can tell he not only did his homework, but cleary has an interest in the games and/or books. So well done!

    My only minor annoyance is that there are some details that aren't explained and makes the assumption you know what's going on. The fourth episode in, I was royally confused as to what was going on, because I didn't realize right away that we were going back and forth in time to tell the story, and what was going on with the characters in some of the scenes. I suppose though, this is what makes me want to read the books now and replay the games!

    REALLY looking forward to this series continuing, and I urge everyone to watch it!    … Expand
  50. jesus045
    Dec 24, 2019
    10
    Very good show, wasn't expecting anything from him and he delighted everyone! Great atmosphere, story, production, music. Many do not like the casting, at first also doubted, but everything is harmonious and beautiful. I look forward to continuing.
  51. Gloin
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    The book were really well respected and adapted even the pertubing (at first) chronology.
    A great show, well acted.
  52. flaviofearn
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    For the ones that have read the first 2 books. Will be a delight and also you won't feel so lost. But for the ones that never read or played any game. The series will be a little confusing because of the way the time line was constructed. Awesome actor performances and directors are a plus.
  53. verydarksun
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    Each episode gets better. Stick with it it's worth the journey. Going to blow the dust on my ps4 Witcher start exploring again
  54. ShadowPixel
    Dec 23, 2019
    9
    Casting for Geralt is great, as it is for most of the other characters. It's a joy to watch. I had no problems suspending disbelief, although it's baffling that mages apparently have to travel by boat, when they're so good at making portals :)
    I hope to see several seasons of this show! I love how it doesn't skirt the violence or sex, while still being funny and down to earth.
    The    Casting for Geralt is great, as it is for most of the other characters. It's a joy to watch. I had no problems suspending disbelief, although it's baffling that mages apparently have to travel by boat, when they're so good at making portals :)
    I hope to see several seasons of this show! I love how it doesn't skirt the violence or sex, while still being funny and down to earth.
    The narrative buildup especially was great. It slowly dawns on the watcher, how things are connected, and I had no problems following it.
    A+, but only a score of 9, because of the boats. Next time, just portal in.    … Expand
  55. Wawer
    Dec 26, 2019
    10
    Very good acting, especialy from Henry. The show has great potential and we want more!
  56. kito78
    Dec 24, 2019
    10
    I red Witcher books in 1996. Since that time I red them many times. Characters were living in my imagination for a long, long time. I know every detail of canon, and I know series is not covering many of details. I do not like Yen in Netflix series and yet I enjoy watching all episodes a lot. I think it’s great and I wish to thanks Netflix for creating it :)
  57. itkovian1128
    Dec 22, 2019
    8
    I wanted to give 7 but for a brilliant ending 2 episode (yes I am after 2 episode) and a penny, 'Drop a penny to a witcher', I give 8. It's worth watching with good English dialogues and inscriptions in the native language.

    After 2 episodes I played better than after the entire 8th season of Game of Thrones. Cavil is brilliant. The 8 for the fact that the actors are not equal. Good    I wanted to give 7 but for a brilliant ending 2 episode (yes I am after 2 episode) and a penny, 'Drop a penny to a witcher', I give 8. It's worth watching with good English dialogues and inscriptions in the native language.

    After 2 episodes I played better than after the entire 8th season of Game of Thrones. Cavil is brilliant. The 8 for the fact that the actors are not equal. Good
    Renri, Calante I can't convince Ciri and the rest without expression. And the actor playing Dandelion has a problem because he'll sing, but somehow I don't like it but this song again ...

    You can see that this is not the Game of Thrones budget yet but the series has potential.    … Expand
  58. Keith__
    Dec 25, 2019
    10
    Super, lepszy niż Gra o Tron. Czekam na drugi sezon
    Świetna gra aktorska
    Polecam obejrzeć całość,
  59. Wranek
    Dec 24, 2019
    8
    Solid bookadaption of the witcher shortstory books. I damit that if you are not familiär with the unsiverse, the plot is hard to follow. Some background knowledge makes ist much easier to understand whats going on wirh all that timejumps. The actors are solid, but with costumes and maskbuilding i personally prefer the way CD Project Red did their work. Most whats bothering me are theSolid bookadaption of the witcher shortstory books. I damit that if you are not familiär with the unsiverse, the plot is hard to follow. Some background knowledge makes ist much easier to understand whats going on wirh all that timejumps. The actors are solid, but with costumes and maskbuilding i personally prefer the way CD Project Red did their work. Most whats bothering me are the missing cateyes of Gerald and any other witcher.… Expand
  60. Yabs
    Dec 23, 2019
    8
    I wrote a review yesterday here on metacritic based on the Netflix series The Witcher, both giving my review and calling out review bombers for rejecting and giving low scores based rejection of the Witcher solely on their race of the cast.

    Shame on metacritc and CBS.
  61. mp303
    Jan 3, 2020
    8
    Its a show with some room to improve, especially on the script and timeline, but the acting is spot on, the fights are also very good, the conversations between the characters are fluid and deep, really good job. One can only hope they put Disney level of budget on this show to make it a more awesome.
  62. Gyrusho
    Dec 24, 2019
    10
    If you like heavy, semi-uncencored action, this is it.. like.. the thing in 2019. Action. Superman in a role you've never seen before (mad probs) lot of story pauses and relapses, a big clusterf*uck.. and then.. you're like.. ooh **** it was this!....
    Lauren.. get the grammy already. Season 2.. when..?
  63. joesteak
    Dec 21, 2019
    9
    While there is some vary from the book, overall I feel like it was very well done and set up the second season well.
  64. EerieDemonble
    Dec 22, 2019
    6
    The very definition of average.
    I don't hate it. But there's barely anything to love. Guess Netflix wanted their own GoT but with 1/10 of a budget/talent and it shows.
    Lead actors are ok, but supporting cast are not even trying. Miscasting is a real problem. Fight scenes choreography - good, would've been great if not for those silly spinning moves. Costume designer needs to be fired.    The very definition of average.
    I don't hate it. But there's barely anything to love. Guess Netflix wanted their own GoT but with 1/10 of a budget/talent and it shows.
    Lead actors are ok, but supporting cast are not even trying. Miscasting is a real problem.
    Fight scenes choreography - good, would've been great if not for those silly spinning moves.
    Costume designer needs to be fired. Many costumes look fake or just stupid. A dress made out of ropes...for battle...really?
    I guess nilfgaardian soldiers are allergic to shields and full plate provides less then 0 protection. *Realism intensifies*
    But still, it's "The Witcher". Source material is good, you need to try really hard to waste it. Oh, and they tried.
    I don't mind few more seasons of this. Not that many fantasy TV shows to choose from this days.    … Expand
  65. Imm0rtal
    Dec 28, 2019
    9
    The show is incredible! It isn't without its flaws and there are a few questionable casting choices, but it's still a great watch. Ultimately, Henry plays the role of Geralt splendidly and as a fan of the games, I was not disappointed.
  66. laoshao
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    ho ritrovato in questa trasposizione la stessa sensazione che ebbi nel leggere i libri tanti anni da.
    un pò confusionario a livello di time line ma fantastico.
  67. NapoMMC
    Dec 23, 2019
    10
    Pretty good, worth watching. Not quite a 10 but I'll give it a 10 for Henry Cavill. He is doing a pretty good Geralt. I like that they are working a lot on building all the characters and it is not "The Geralt Show". The show could be a lot better but imagine how bad it could have been in this times. I guess we need to appreciate when someone does not directly **** on the fandom.
  68. Hutake
    Dec 21, 2019
    8
    I enjoyed a lot how they adapted the book stories into a tv show. Okay, I prefere the Ciri and Geralt momment in the Brokilon florest (book), but beside that moment I think the show adapted pretty well the original sotry. The actors are good; scenery and clothing are... fine but the fight scenes are amazing!
    The only bad thing, in my opinion, is ... it seems that the show needed more    I enjoyed a lot how they adapted the book stories into a tv show. Okay, I prefere the Ciri and Geralt momment in the Brokilon florest (book), but beside that moment I think the show adapted pretty well the original sotry. The actors are good; scenery and clothing are... fine but the fight scenes are amazing!
    The only bad thing, in my opinion, is ... it seems that the show needed more episodes to show and explain everything they wanted... sometimes it felt too rushed.
    Overall, I enjoyed a lot. Had a great time watching everything. I still prefer de books... but it is in fact a good show.

    8/10    … Expand
  69. backohead74
    Dec 23, 2019
    8
    Well here we are, like Star Wars, another series where the Internetz will love it or downright hate it for some good reasons and mostly stupid ones. Just remember, like what you want, don't watch what you don't and leave people alone to like what they like. Henry Cavill is excellent as Geralt, perfectly cast. I too had some minor issues w/ the casting but wow, Anya Cholotra has beenWell here we are, like Star Wars, another series where the Internetz will love it or downright hate it for some good reasons and mostly stupid ones. Just remember, like what you want, don't watch what you don't and leave people alone to like what they like. Henry Cavill is excellent as Geralt, perfectly cast. I too had some minor issues w/ the casting but wow, Anya Cholotra has been fantastic as Yennefer. Triss isnt in it much, her actress is fine but not sure why they changed her look so much, she is well known for her red hair through the books and games, but no biggie though I expect her role to grow substantially. Ciri, well again the actress is good but her character is not very fleshed out in the first season so we will see. The biggest issue with the show is that if you have no previous Witcher knowledge, be it the games or books I can totally understand you being lost more often then not. I am also not sure how I feel about the Time jumps or more how they showed it or actually didn't show them etc. All in all though its a really good show, I really enjoyed it though I wish the first season was a few episodes longer.… Expand
  70. joystick0406
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    A good show, but lacking in grasping the violence, racism and horror of the witcher universe, it would've been perfect without the politically correct adaptation of certain situations.
    I can't wait for the second season, and to see how they will adapt some of the most brutal and shocking scenes (yes, the witcher is far more schocking than GoT, in the books)
  71. GarethB
    Dec 22, 2019
    8
    A good adaptation of the books, I had low expectations going in but it proved highly entertaining despite some the unusual character changes for medieval polish fantasy.
  72. gersonbessa
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    Foi ótimo. 10/10. Era tudo que eu esperava. Aguardando a segunda temporada.
  73. Maxx_thor
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    awesome representation of the world of the witcher, high expectation from gamers who played the game with plenty of politics, lies and sex. the acclaimed game is 100 times more raw than the series, but is a good entertainment series.
  74. imay42
    Dec 22, 2019
    8
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Amazin Geralt and depictions of his early adventures are a pleasure to watch. Details and main features of witcher's character transmitted very well. Other main characters are also great. Now, i didnt like dryads. They should have been at least painted in green and there is too much armour on them. They are not fighters, but for some reason look like ones. The overall passing is a bit off. But in general i was able to keep attention and understand what is happenkng and when. Wish for a bit better cgi, sword fighting and yeah... That war sequence in the end is just weak to me. And that nilfgaardian armour is still looks silly. Sorry.… Expand
  75. Pokemonashgreen
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    I don't understand why the show runners wanted to tell a story in three different time lines. Was confusing at first too me but, I mange to figure it out. I still need to read the books. Mainly played the games which take place right after the books. Henry really brings out Gault and she his acting chops and skill so he wont be tight cast as Superman. The supporting cast ready shine.
  76. Wolchara
    Dec 23, 2019
    10
    Отличный сериал и актерская игра. Генри Кавил справился на столько же хорошо, как и Михал Жебровский в свое время. Но, в отличие от старого сериала, тут подтянули всех остальных персонажей. Калантэ - тоже выше всяких похвал) Вопреки всеобщему бугурту Аня Чалотра набрала немного килограммов и прекрасно справилась с ролью Йенифер. Все кто считает, что сериал не торт, потому что не буква вОтличный сериал и актерская игра. Генри Кавил справился на столько же хорошо, как и Михал Жебровский в свое время. Но, в отличие от старого сериала, тут подтянули всех остальных персонажей. Калантэ - тоже выше всяких похвал) Вопреки всеобщему бугурту Аня Чалотра набрала немного килограммов и прекрасно справилась с ролью Йенифер. Все кто считает, что сериал не торт, потому что не буква в букву книга - идите лесом смотреть новые ЗВ.

    Из минусов:
    1) Достаточно рваное повествование по таймлайнам. Если не знакомы со вселенной и книгами, то смотреть будет тяжеловато, потому что есть очень резкие перескоки во времени действия и не посвященному человеко будет не понятно что события происходят в разное время. Например вполне нормально сначала увидеть сцены из обучения Йенифер, а потом сожжение Цинтры, но повествование выставлено так, что кажется будто все происходит параллельно, а по факту, между событиями добрых три десятка лет.

    2) В сериале, "О УЖАС" есть актеры негроидной расы, но они достаточно органично вписаны в сюжет и не выглядят не на своих местах. Даже темный цвет кожи Фрингилии достаточно аргументирован. Что касается дриад Брокелона - они все обмазаны зеленой жижей, так что там даже не разобрать кто с каким цветом кожи особо.

    3) Трисс - единственный лютый мискаст. Но это только на мой вкус.

    4) Небольшие отклонения по сюжету от книги в незначительных моментах. Например мотивация Геральта по вылавливанию урны с джином. И зачем-то убрали шутку про "древнеэльфийское" заклинание по изгонению Джина.

    Лично мне сериал очень зашел. И всем хейтерастам еще раз напомню, что сериал опирается в первую очередь на КНИЖНЫЙ оригинал. Все кому не нравится "ШО ВСЕ НЕ КАК В ИГРЕ"!

    Из Плюсов:

    1) Актерская игра - без комментариев. Все отлично. Все выложились на 100%

    2) Общий размах и продакшн. ДОРОГО БОХАТО! Игра престолов порой нервно покуривает в сторонке.

    3) Соответствие книжному оригиналу. Снято не буква в букву, как адаптация - очень уверенное произведение.

    4) Очень большой сюжетный пласт дополнительно уделен Йенифер и ее жизни до знакомства с Геральтом. То на что Сапковский добросовестно забил болт теперь обряло отображение в виде полноценной сюжетной линии. Йен теперь не просто взбалмошная шальная императрица. У ее стервозности и характера теперь есть конкретное обоснование. Аретуза - это вам не Хогвардс. Тут и концы отдать можно так и не доучившись. А в большинстве случаев отдать концы ИМЕННО доучившись, но не пройдя подтверждение квалификации)

    Вывод: Если Вам нравится книжная вселенная - обязательно посмотрите и Вам скорее всего понравится. Если Вам не понравится, ну чтож... Мне Вас очень жаль)

    P.S.S. Ну и как же без этого) «Ведьмаку заплатите чеканной монетой»    … Expand
  77. blackhaat92
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    nao faz sentido a critica querer avaliar the witcher mal,,, essa serie é 10/10 facil muuuuitoo fodaaa
  78. Shekky84
    Dec 21, 2019
    9
    Good show much better then what critics make it out to be. Henry Cavill plays Geralt well its definitely outside the norm for the types of characters he plays but I am enjoying the show either way.
  79. Romanoid
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    I did not expect much from it.
    But i really was suprised, dialogs are good, Cavill is quite convincing, colors and filters are eyecatcing.
    Still, there is no feling of slavic culture, it is an american tv show and whether you like or not....well, it is. Yet in my opinion pros is much better thatn cons. I have not read books just played witcher game and did not expected characters to be    I did not expect much from it.
    But i really was suprised, dialogs are good, Cavill is quite convincing, colors and filters are eyecatcing.
    Still, there is no feling of slavic culture, it is an american tv show and whether you like or not....well, it is.
    Yet in my opinion pros is much better thatn cons.
    I have not read books just played witcher game and did not expected characters to be 100% similar.    … Expand
  80. JelloWasabi
    Dec 21, 2019
    8
    This show is pretty great. Right now I'm trying to get past some of the bad castings but the show is winning me over. Cavil is great. Perfect Geralt.

    Battle scenes are killer.
  81. JohnMCouch
    Dec 23, 2019
    10
    I see others reviews stating poor adaptation and forced diversity, but I can't figure out what in the world they are even talking about. Seems more like people trying to force an agenda that doesn't exist in this show.

    The Witcher so far has been awesome!!! Yennifer, fantastic! Dialogue, scenery, plots...very good. I pray they continue with this series.
  82. Givno69
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    Это великолепно, есть сходство с книгами, но и расхождение так как это все таки сериал и чтобы зритель не скучал есть свои условности. Сериал 9/10
    This is great, there are similarities with books, but there is also a discrepancy, since this is still a serial, and therefore the viewer will not get tired. Serial 9/10    Это великолепно, есть сходство с книгами, но и расхождение так как это все таки сериал и чтобы зритель не скучал есть свои условности. Сериал 9/10
    This is great, there are similarities with books, but there is also a discrepancy, since this is still a serial, and therefore the viewer will not get tired. Serial 9/10
  83. GrumpyMike
    Jan 6, 2020
    8
    One of most enjoyable tv shows. If you are The Telegraph journalist it may be confusing.
  84. bwestpha
    Dec 24, 2019
    10
    Great show, great fights. The feeling is similar to the game - which is obviously a good thing ;) !
  85. Amiga4ever81
    Dec 27, 2019
    10
    I've read Witcher saga many times, I've finished every Witcher game. I just love Witcher. TV show is also amazing! I didn't expect that!
  86. marconeves
    Dec 21, 2019
    10
    This will please fans of the books AND the video games. General audience will understand the universe eventually and realize its brilliance. Acting, writing, tone, look, ambiance, music are all excellent. Henry Cavill is PERFECT. He's the perfect mix between game Geralt and book Geralt (which were already almost identical, truth be said). But Cavill really evokes the game voice, and that'sThis will please fans of the books AND the video games. General audience will understand the universe eventually and realize its brilliance. Acting, writing, tone, look, ambiance, music are all excellent. Henry Cavill is PERFECT. He's the perfect mix between game Geralt and book Geralt (which were already almost identical, truth be said). But Cavill really evokes the game voice, and that's appreciated by the hard core fans. Even his style of sword fighting is almost like a ballet, compared to everyone else. Although some plot lines are slightly different, this really respects the source materials. Bravo!… Expand
  87. Markb
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    Really good adaptation and nice introduction to the world of the witcher !
    The serie kept its promise and build up throughout the episodes and announce the best for next seasons.
    To watch without looking for a witcher 3 cosplay parade. Furthermore, please ignore people complaining about colored people in medieval poland, this is still a fictional world with portals and stuff, who knows    Really good adaptation and nice introduction to the world of the witcher !
    The serie kept its promise and build up throughout the episodes and announce the best for next seasons.
    To watch without looking for a witcher 3 cosplay parade.
    Furthermore, please ignore people complaining about colored people in medieval poland, this is still a fictional world with portals and stuff, who knows about the migratory flows in the continent !    … Expand
  88. Bill_Nye
    Dec 21, 2019
    9
    Henry Cavil is perfect for playing Gerard. But as for many Netflix originals the first season has a curse. But once the show is renewed, Henry won’t have to reconsider working with dc again
  89. V_BigBoss
    Dec 21, 2019
    9
    Henry lo hace genial como brujo pero siento que la serie puede mejorar, apresura las cosas un poco pero caracteriza bien a a algunos de los personajes principales, tiene representación de las criaturas buena pero falla en algunos aspectos. Espero en futuras temporadas mejoren el desarrollo de la historia
  90. Aleksrip
    Dec 21, 2019
    8
    Series rather liked than not liked. But still, Netflix, why risk a potential hit, for the sake of fulfilling stupid tolerance quotas, why? You pander to people who won't even watch this show, and those who will be watching your violations of the Canon not like. Triss is horribly matched, doesn't fit at all, triads are African-American like elves. Why? For the story it does not matter, andSeries rather liked than not liked. But still, Netflix, why risk a potential hit, for the sake of fulfilling stupid tolerance quotas, why? You pander to people who won't even watch this show, and those who will be watching your violations of the Canon not like. Triss is horribly matched, doesn't fit at all, triads are African-American like elves. Why? For the story it does not matter, and for the audience it is once again to honor the film. You want the show brought a profit, why are you doing this? I apologize for illiteracy, translated through the translator.… Expand
  91. Diablizz
    Dec 21, 2019
    10
    Damn I can’t wait for season 2... The show is phenomenal. I’m not really the type to watch shows or tv in general but holy hell was this a fun one!
  92. Validus
    Dec 21, 2019
    7
    3 episodes so far and I have to admit that I was a bit scared at the beginning. The first scene is a bit cheesy when you know how Geralt generaly prepare his encounters with monsters but after that the show is ok. Cavill does a good job with his role which he takes seriously. Yennefer is not bad too. Ciri is acting well but I dont get used to her face yet. Triss Merigold is bad and the3 episodes so far and I have to admit that I was a bit scared at the beginning. The first scene is a bit cheesy when you know how Geralt generaly prepare his encounters with monsters but after that the show is ok. Cavill does a good job with his role which he takes seriously. Yennefer is not bad too. Ciri is acting well but I dont get used to her face yet. Triss Merigold is bad and the choice of this actress is completely irrelevant. The habit Netflix has to put minorities everywhere even when its overly out of context is tiring but it doesnt change the quality of the show, fortuntely. Story seems confused if you are new with the universe but time will make some order in this chaos, I guess. Problem is that mixing narrative arcs AND timelines is not a good idea for new comers and can be hard to follow. Fights are energic and well done but CGI are sometimes weak and are lacking of post production work. I cant compare with GOT cauz I am probably one the few who didnt like this show on the planet but I'm pretty sure that the dialogues were better. At least, political subject like racism between humans, dwarves, elfs and witchers/sentient monsters is not silenced to fit with Netflix agenda, hooray… Expand
  93. MohamedElShamy
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    As someone who played the games, The Witcher series nailed the feelling of the games, great acting and direction, really enjoyed it.
    last episode was a little bit off for me, felt like it as dragging for a bit.
    but Henry Cavil as Geralt was just on point, he carried the show, and stayed true to Geralt's monotone voice/ character.
  94. Litlrob
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    Very close to the book. Cavill as Geralt is mesmerizing. The only thing that I had an issue with was the timeline. But after taking it all in and re watching and thinking about. It all makes sense. MUST WATCH for Witcher fans!
  95. ExoticMortgage
    Dec 22, 2019
    4
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Just SAD. Had to create an account just to rate this as one of my favorite franchises is getting destroyed by a staff with ulterior motives.

    Let's start with the positives:
    - Henry Cavill gives a good shot at portraying Geralt, good voice acting, simple dialogue, sarcasm a bit here and there.
    - Combat scenes (apart from the first Nilfgaardian battle) are good and thought out.
    - Some CGI of monsters and practical effects are also very good.
    - Some of the landscape that was not CGI is beautiful too.
    - Music feels authentic.

    And that is it.

    Now the negatives:
    - The plot is a mess. Everything is getting thrown all around with confusing timelines and lore is being force fed to user like it was a Foie Gras duck. The creators don't give time to explain all of this. The mini stories (curse ones) of each episode are too fast paced and you don't get the feeling of any story developing at all. It just moves forward like a machine.
    - The dialogues are bad. You don't feel any chemistry between characters. The lines are being dropped once again in a lazy fashion. Ciri met an elf that saved her from Nilfgardian patrol, he doesn't speak. He later saves her again from a camp; later in Brokilon realizes she is a royal descendant. Then he starts to drop truthbombs about how her grandmother had slain his relatives. All this with no feeling or soul whatsoever. Their conflict is forced upon us. It had no chance of developing naturally because everything is too fast paced. There is no character revelation. Not a single character has a compelling story arc.
    - Miscasting - Physical appearances are way off. Yen has to be a feared mage yet she looks almost like a kid with puppy eyes. Triss and Fringilla ? More like Friss and Tringilla - the nonexistent characters of Witcher universe that the writer did not include.
    - Diversity. I think it was time creators obsessed with gender and race inclusivity started to make their own projects and stopped piggyriding on established canons. Totally ruins the immersion. I wouldn't want to watch John Q with Brad Pitt portraying him. Creator Lauren Hirssich spent her time arguing on Twitter why it is a good thing and why skin color doesn't matter because books don't focus on it. Well there is a lot of 'pale face' mentions attributed to characters that now somehow have become black in the show.
    - Lazy CGI. You have parts where everything is great and then there are just inexcusable scenes.

    In general you have a feeling that The Witcher TV series has been made by creators who don't love the source material or don't understand it and just pretend to be on the bandwagon. Good writing and sticking to great storytelling has been exchanged for dull jokes, appealing to minorities and pressing social norms.
    Game of Thrones had set a good bar of character development and storytelling (not talking about the total massacre of characters from s6 and upwards). Why not learn from it?    … Expand
  96. KaiserAta
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    First season is a great way to start the series. Henry Cavill plays Geralt spectacular.He really has a passion for both games and books and i couldn't think of another actor to play Geralt this good.The show has one of the best sword fightings i've ever seen, and guess what, Henry doesn't have a stunt double so all of the actions Geralt does, Henry does them himself which is pretty awesomeFirst season is a great way to start the series. Henry Cavill plays Geralt spectacular.He really has a passion for both games and books and i couldn't think of another actor to play Geralt this good.The show has one of the best sword fightings i've ever seen, and guess what, Henry doesn't have a stunt double so all of the actions Geralt does, Henry does them himself which is pretty awesome since most of the actors now need a stunt double for little things.
    Music (specially Jaskier-Dandelion's) is great.Main theme has a similar tone to Witcher 3's theme.

    The only casting that i've a problem is Triss.She isn't even similar to her.Yes, her acting may be good, but the looks is not.Grealt is great,Jaskier is great,Ciri will grow, Yennefer is okay.

    My only problem with this series is time transitions.It doesn't say anything when an episode is from the past or not, so you have to figure it out yourself which is hard in the beginning (and if you didn't read the books) but you get used to it.

    Overall, it's definetly worth watching even if you are a fan of games/books or not.    … Expand
  97. ElnarSilmor
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    I love it yet knowing how much it can do better. The Witcher vibe is here, the actors and their chemistry is great, they don't shy from the magic while explaining how it works in the Witcher world well. If you were feeling lost at times, get to the books, you won't regret it.
  98. vivicwhite
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    Плюсы:
    - Очень хорошая игра актеров
    - Очень хороший саундтрек
    - Очень хороший темп повествования
    - Очень хорошо показаны боевые сцены

    Минусы:
    - Не очень удачно переработаны сюжетные линии
  99. Cybershaman26
    Dec 22, 2019
    9
    It’s very interesting. I believe it will be new “game of the thrones” I’m waiting new season, and lets more money on CGI
  100. Wadeinca1
    Dec 22, 2019
    8
    Thought the monster effects and fight scenes were excellent the time jumps in the story were well done gave a feeling to how it must be for someone who lives for centuries in this universe
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Most Discussed TV Season of 2019
77
#77 Most Shared TV Season of 2019

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
53

Mixed or average reviews - based on 17 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 6 out of 17
  2. Mixed: 8 out of 17
  3. Negative: 3 out of 17
  1. The Independent
    Reviewed by: Nick Hilton
    Jan 3, 2020
    40
    The Witcher is a messy tangle of plotlines in a world underdeveloped to the point of obscurity.
    Read full review
  2. The Telegraph
    Reviewed by: Ed Power
    Jan 3, 2020
    60
    As a mindless fantasy rollercoaster, Geralt’s journey is five stars all the way to tea-time. Sadly, for those who like brains with their brawn, it may be more of a slog.
    Read full review
  3. Time
    Reviewed by: Judy Berman
    Dec 20, 2019
    30
    It takes a while for viewers to learn how these characters are connected, via an exasperating Westworld-esque narrative knot that takes much of the season to unfurl. ... The Witcher heightens our confusion by fumbling details that would have helped it set a cohesive tone. Dialogue vacillates, from line to line, between theatrical fantasy-speak and modern colloquialisms (“Dragons are, in fact, a thing!”).
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »