Gamesurf's Scores

  • Games
For 357 reviews, this publication has graded:
  • 49% higher than the average critic
  • 12% same as the average critic
  • 39% lower than the average critic
On average, this publication grades 0.3 points higher than other critics. (0-100 point scale)
Average Game review score: 75
Highest review score: 100 Monster Hunter Wilds
Lowest review score: 45 Dollhouse: Behind The Broken Mirror
Score distribution:
  1. Negative: 6 out of 357
363 game reviews
    • 86 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Silent Hill f proves to be a remarkable restart for the series: brave and divisive, it may not find favor with series purists but traces a potential new future.
    • 83 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Talking about MLB The Show 25 means discussing yet another excellent installment of a franchise that stands as a true benchmark for all baseball enthusiasts. A vast array of playable modes blends with a more than solid technical department, featuring gameplay that improves year after year and offers extensive customization, making MLB The Show 25 perfect for both newcomers and seasoned players alike. Applause for the gameplay, which allows for a seamless transition from an arcade style to a more simulation-oriented approach, maintaining high standards in both cases. Perhaps the player models could have been updated, but the overall visual quality remains impressive. The only real flaw I encountered was lag in online matches, likely due to the fact that I was always playing against overseas opponents. That said, once again, there’s only one thing left to say: MLB The Show 25 hits a massive home run.
    • 88 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    There’s nothing like Mullet MadJack on the market, and it’s a must-have for your collection. Run, slide, and shoot in a race against time where the countdown is just as deadly as the enemies you face. You might risk frying your brain... but all in all, it’s a sacrifice well worth the effort.
    • 88 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    If you own an Xbox or a gaming PC, chances are you haven’t missed the chance to throw on a fedora and leather jacket—whip included—in digital form. But if all you have at home is a PlayStation 5, this is a golden opportunity to experience what’s likely one of the best stories featuring the American archaeologist. Enjoy it for the gameplay, the story, or Indy’s personality—but whatever the reason, make it yours.
    • 68 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    JDM is absolutely "raw", it has a huge heart, some flaws, but it doesn't miss a beat when it comes to doing real "drift". If you like arcade racing... buy it! If you like drifting in a more or less thorough way, with pad or steering wheel, don't leave it on the shelf.
    • 74 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Intense, captivating, and visually perfect, Bye Sweet Carole is a little gem that Italy should be proud of. Without sacrificing horror and mature themes, Chris Darril once again hits the mark with a great production that, we're sure, will be echoed by future productions. Make it yours: the price is affordable, it's hilarious, and there's no shortage of moments for reflection. You couldn't ask for more.
    • 81 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Borderlands 4 is everything fans were waiting for. Too bad that its way of being "more of the same" ends up being less than expected. It sticks to the gameplay formula stubbornly — the new approach to combat is insane — but the graphics, which don’t make a strong visual impression, also carry a heavy toll in terms of performance and system requirements. The missions take on a new style, but they’re less impactful than in previous installments. It’s not so much the added seriousness that makes the formula less satisfying, but rather that sometimes the motivations of the heroes or villains feel like they just don’t care enough to be compelling... But in the end, who cares? Grab a gun and jump into the arena: there’s lead, madness, and flying guts for everyone.
    • 76 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Let's start with the premise that Super Mario Party Jamboree is a great, huge game that offers a huge amount of challenges, mini-games, scoreboards, and collectibles, and it comes back on Switch 2 with a new outfit for the occasion. The Jamboree TV is a nice addition, designed to take special advantage of the camera and put a face on all the participants, but also the new Joycon 2 features. The critical point, of course, is the price, certainly not low, but justified in Nintendo's view by the high (and undeniable) quality of the game. Making objective evaluations on the money is always complicated, but from our point of view Super Mario Party Jamboree is a really hilarious and engaging experience, especially if you don't mind Nintendo's usual long-windedness between menus and various skits, including the new Jamboree TV, which doesn't revolutionize the formula, but takes good advantage of the new hardware potential.
    • 78 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    EA SPORTS FC 26 takes several steps forward, resulting in an enhanced gameplay experience. The two gameplay styles, Realistic and Competitive, manage to offer players a choice that can meet the needs of different audiences. However, it would have been interesting to allow all Realistic gameplay fans to play in competitive online modes, facing (naturally) only those who use the same gameplay style. That said, the improvements are clear and noticeable—goalkeepers above all—but in general progress has been made in almost every aspect, even if some rebounds during tackles leave something to be desired, and the overwhelming technical superiority of certain players still persists, with the risk of facing opponents who secure victories by endlessly spamming tricks. Aside from that, EA SPORTS FC 26 is a title with a simply boundless amount of content, and it surely has something to offer every football enthusiast—whether it’s for those who can’t resist the temptation of opening packs, those who are satisfied with a quick match every now and then, or those who dream of building their own career as a player or manager. Yes, we are certain that as the months go by, some issues will inevitably arise, but expecting everything to run smoothly in such a vast and ever-evolving title is far from realistic. For now, we step onto the pitch and enjoy EA SPORTS FC 26, thanks to the growth path the development team is taking more and more seriously, year after year.
    • 75 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Years go by, but Milestone continues to deliver for both its fans and MotoGP enthusiasts. MotoGP 26 is a solid and entertaining title, capable of satisfying players willing to put in the effort to master these two-wheeled beasts, while also welcoming more casual gamers thanks to its arcade mode. Compared to the previous installment, there are several additions in terms of both content and gameplay, although most of them are refinements to the handling system and physics rather than major innovations. There’s no revolution here, but tampering too much with the series’ core formula would have been a mistake considering how much enjoyment it already provides to fans. Of course, we would have liked to see a deeper career mode and slightly more reactive AI, but that doesn’t take away from the overall quality of the package offered by MotoGP 26. If you want an experience capable of making you fully appreciate everything the MotoGP world has to offer, this is definitely the game for you. And it doesn’t matter if a few flaws still remain: learning how to truly understand your bike and mastering every corner of every track until you finally set the perfect lap time is a satisfaction beyond compare. Are you ready to jump into the saddle and challenge Marc Márquez and Marco Bezzecchi for the top step of the podium?
    • 82 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Vampire Crawlers: The Turbo Wildcard works as a creative experiment that translates the chaotic and ironic soul of Vampire Survivors into a fast and unpredictable card formula: it's not as deep as a traditional deck-builder, but it bets everything on rhythm, surprises and short sessions, offering a light and fun experience especially for those who love the original universe and want something different without too many complications.
    • 75 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Occasionally clunky controls and cryptic progression keep Chronicles of the Wolf from reaching true greatness, but it remains an excellent old-school metroidvania and a heartfelt tribute to Konami’s Igavanias. Long, challenging in all the right ways, and consistently fun, with top-notch presentation and a superb soundtrack; hard to ask for much more.
    • tbd Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Drop Duchy and its DLC The Tribe represent a beautiful combination of strategy and creativity, where every element fits together with precision in a refined ludic mosaic that always manages to surprise. The base game offers a deep experience capable of blending different genres into an entertaining formula, while the expansion enriches everything with a new mystical faction, innovative mechanics, and an alternative vision of the game world. Its only flaw is that it sometimes tends to divert the player's attention a bit, as they are somewhat forced to repeat the same actions continuously, but it works quite well overall.
    • 81 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Ground Zero is a masterful love letter to classic 90s survival horror. By blending the nostalgic charm of pre-rendered backgrounds and fixed cameras with brilliant modernizations like free aim, fluid movement, and a rewarding parry system, it entirely avoids the pitfalls of clunky retro clones. Boasting crisp Unreal Engine 5 visuals, a gripping branching narrative set in post-apocalyptic Busan, and a stellar resource management loop, it perfectly bridges the gap between past and present. An absolute must-play for genre veterans.
    • 87 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Lumines Arise isn’t content with simply being a sequel; it may well be the definitive realization of Mizuguchi’s vision. Accessible, deep, artistically sublime, and featuring a VR component that makes it almost transcendental, it is an essential title for anyone who loves puzzle games and high-level audiovisual experiences.
    • 83 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    MIO: Memories in Orbit doesn’t reinvent the wheel, yet it stands out thanks to its rock-solid foundations, immaculate presentation, and a demanding, multifaceted gameplay loop. Its verbose navigation in the latter half and some steep difficulty spikes keep it from being a must-have for every metroidvania fan, but the most dedicated players will find a rewarding challenge and a truly memorable journey in this small French gem.
    • 85 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    If you love narrative-driven games and intricate puzzles you piece together one clue at a time, and you’re willing to embrace its roguelite mechanics, Blue Prince will enchant you. Dogubomb has crafted a true indie gem: a brilliant example of clever game design that stands out for its charm and creativity. Every detail feels intentional, with just the right amount of randomness to keep both logic-lovers and casual explorers engaged, though at times, it may push that randomness a bit too far. Is it a masterpiece? Hard to say. But it’s definitely a game you should experience, even if roguelikes aren’t usually your thing, and easily one of the most intriguing titles of early 2025.
    • 77 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    CloverPit is a highly successful experiment that elevates the tension of gambling to a form of psychological horror based on risk management. The Panik Arcade team has successfully taken a mechanic founded on RNG and injected it with strategic depth reminiscent of the best deckbuilders available.
    • 82 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Blizzard successfully navigates the technical debt of two decades, delivering a cinematic restoration of Quel'Thalas that feels both hauntingly familiar and radically modern. While Midnight leans heavily on the fragile legacy of the Windrunners to fill its charisma void, the long-awaited Player Housing finally offers a persistent sanctuary rather than a mere battlefield. Despite some optimization hurdles and aggressive monetization in decor, this second chapter of the Worldsoul Saga is an essential, high-stakes evolution for the MMO genre.
    • 87 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Absolum puts and mixes together several already known themes and mechanics, but it does so in an overall original way, creating an absolutly enjoyable product, full of variet, twists and more. A little treasure that will be surely appreciated by beat'em up lovers.
    • 69 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Bye Sweet Carole is a game that stays with you even after you’ve finished it. Beneath its animated fairytale appearance lies a story that touches deep emotional chords — one of fear, guilt, and tenderness. Chris Darril delivers a mature and personal work, crafted with great attention to detail, where horror becomes a gentle language rather than a threat. It’s not a perfect title, but it’s sincere, and that makes it rare. Some choices may feel slow, but they serve to give the story room to breathe — allowing the player to truly feel what Lana Benton experiences. The art direction, music, and pacing merge into a narrative that strikes with both intensity and grace, remaining in memory more for what it suggests than for what it shows. Bye Sweet Carole doesn’t aim to astonish — it aims to stay with you. And it succeeds: with the sensitivity of a fairy tale that has lost its innocence, but not its ability to move you.
    • 73 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    The question is always the same: is it really worth opening your wallet and buying this new incarnation of baseball from Sony San Diego Studio? Once again, the answer is yes, marked by steady growth without losing its identity, both in terms of gameplay and in its technical aspects and content. Everything that was already great about the series remains in MLB The Show 26, but this year too brings some interesting new features that make virtual baseball even more satisfying and believable. The revamped controls for batting and pitching will win over both newcomers and veteran players, while those who prefer not to change their style can still rely on the comfort zone of previous options. Sure, there’s no revolution, but it’s guaranteed fun for anyone who loves baseball—or perhaps wants to get closer to this fantastic sport.
    • 71 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Little Nightmares 3 doesn’t rewrite the rules of the saga, but it expands them intelligently. Supermassive Games inherits a remarkable legacy and translates it into a new cooperative grammar, where fear no longer stems from isolation, but from the possibility of losing the one beside you. The design remains true to the series’ poetics - environments that speak for themselves, ambient puzzles, silences loaded with meaning - while the online co-op introduces an emotional and gameplay dimension that feels surprisingly natural. There are some imperfections: slightly rigid controls, imprecise checkpoints, and an AI that occasionally hesitates. Yet the overall picture retains great artistic and technical value. Visually sumptuous, sonically unsettling, and always faithful to its dark fairy-tale vision, Little Nightmares 3 proves that the nightmare can evolve without losing its soul. An experience more empathetic, more alive and still capable of making you tremble.
    • 84 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    It may not be the most “suitable” game to showcase the full potential of the Switch 2, but Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster remains a superb JRPG. The content is virtually identical to the 2013 original, so if you’ve already played it thoroughly, there’s little incentive to upgrade; otherwise, there’s no reason to look back, as this is the definitive edition of this small masterpiece. The release on Game-Key Card might make collectors raise an eyebrow, but the affordable price makes it a truly tempting purchase. A must-have for fans of the genre.
    • 80 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    While Oblivion may not be the best Elder Scrolls game, it still packs a punch in 2025. Despite being a product of its time, it remains a thoroughly enjoyable experience—even with its original quirks and the occasional early-era bug. This is a game worth buying, if only for the joy of embarking on a long and wondrous journey through lands and characters you'll remember for years to come. A piece of gaming history that shouldn't be left behind—and likely a must-play if you've never experienced it before.
    • 82 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Bringing Frostpunk 2 to consoles was no small task, but the result is impressive. Technically, the game holds up remarkably well, with only a few reasonable compromises compared to high-end PCs. Performance is solid, and the transition to Xbox and PlayStation 5 feels natural. That said, there are a couple of drawbacks. Controller navigation—especially moving across hexes—can feel clunky, and the on-screen text is frustratingly tiny, even at maximum size. These issues aside, this is still the same outstanding city-builder we know: challenging, rewarding, and packed with tough decisions that keep you constantly balancing fleeting victories against looming crises. With its meticulous attention to detail, striking art direction, and relentless sense of urgency, Frostpunk 2 remains a must-play. Sure, you’ll need to accept some compromises, but the payoff—saving your people from the brink of extinction—is well worth it.
    • 85 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Helldivers 2 still got it: a year and a half after its release, Arrowhead's shooter is still extremely fun to play. A little less so to master. The sparse tutorial serves more as a metaphor for military inefficiency than an introduction to the game, but fortunately for Helldivers 2, there are still some players willing to help on the battlefield. The game brings with it the strengths and weaknesses of its PS5 counterpart on Xbox, and today the former still far outnumber the latter.
    • 90 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    A true video game enthusiast cannot remain indifferent to the romantic figure of the solo developer who brings their creation to life driven by pure passion, even going so far as to program the game engine themselves just to translate their aspirations into the form they deem most authentic. If this developer then manages to craft a high-level gaming experience — one of the best in the metroidvania genre — supporting them becomes the least one can do, not just because it's the right thing to do, but because rewarding the most valuable and passionate projects is the best way to ensure we’ll see more beautiful games in the future. Experiencing something like Animal Well is an act of love, both for oneself and for video games.
    • 79 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Kirby Air Riders is pure adrenaline! It's the return that few expected but many longed for. A game that combines accessibility, style, a good level of customization, numerous challenges to tackle, and an infinite amount of content. The game's spirit and numerous game modes offer variety and a fun-filled experience. Technically solid, artistically top-notch, and with an explosive soundtrack, Sakurai's new project is one of Nintendo's best games of this year.
    • 84 Metascore
    • 85 Critic Score
    Stellar Blade doesn’t reinvent the action genre, but it delivers a well-balanced experience with precise combat, solid pacing, and a distinct visual identity. The PC version is impressively optimized, offering excellent performance, clean ultrawide support, and deep customization options. While the story treads familiar ground, the execution is polished and engaging. A technically refined port that rewards focus and delivers style without sacrificing substance.
This publication does not provide a score for their reviews.
This publication has not posted a final review score yet.
These unscored reviews do not factor into the Metascore calculation.

In Progress & Unscored

?
    • tbd Metascore
    • Critic Score
    Despite it being an Early Access, therefore subject to future improvements, Sancticide is a project that should be taken and redone from the ground up. It's not just a matter of bugs or technical problems of any kind, but of a completely poorly thought out and implemented gameplay system, as well as an unproposable narration and dubbing. The only, very small aspect that we can save concerns the sketches of the enemies and in particular of the non-human creatures, along with their descriptions, but it is certainly not enough to lift from the ground a game that is the cause of its own apocalypse. [Early Access Review]
    • tbd Metascore
    • Critic Score
    Nightmare Frontier does its part, between novelties and good ideas, unfortunately the latter run out quickly and the rest is a good filler, but certainly less interesting than the first hours. Certainly the seeds of a structure that deserves a posthumous study have been planted. [Early Access Review Score = 70]
    • tbd Metascore
    • Critic Score
    Windrose is a crystalline ambition that still has to reckon with an unrefined MMO past. While the pivot from Crosswind successfully reclaimed the project’s soul, it failed to resolve the inherent clunkiness of an engine too heavy for its own good. The core loop remains magnetic and the navigation is easily among the genre’s finest, but technical setbacks, severe memory leaks, and tedious ground combat frictions significantly dampen the experience. It is a diamond in the rough for purists willing to fight the hardware: a title in desperate need of a few more optimization cycles before it can truly shine. [Early Access Score = 75]
    • tbd Metascore
    • Critic Score
    In its Early Access phase, Titan Quest 2 already shows a solid core and a strong sense of identity, with all the room for growth you’d expect from a work in progress. The Greek setting is atmospheric and richly detailed, the loot system feels rewarding, and the variety of builds — including my full Storm experiment — hints at huge potential for long-term replayability. Sure, graphics optimization still needs refinement and combat mechanics could use sharper precision, but the foundation is solid, and the overall experience is already engaging. If the developers deliver on their promise to expand the content and fine-tune performance, this could earn a well-deserved spot among the genre’s most memorable ARPGs. [Early Access Review]
    • tbd Metascore
    • Critic Score
    Into the Dead: Our Darkest Days is an ambitious survival management game, already solid in its structure but still in development. The atmosphere is well-crafted, the tension constant, and every choice has real consequences. If you enjoy games where time is your enemy and survival requires careful planning, give it a shot. But remember: it's in early access. Consider your options carefully and keep an eye on the official update roadmap. [Early Access Review]
    • tbd Metascore
    • Critic Score
    Mars Attracts is an original management game, capable of reversing roles and perspectives with pulp irony and a touch of cruelty. The basic graphics and improved interface don't overshadow the love for the franchise, evident in the grotesque gimmicks and Martian dialogue. It's just the beginning, but if the team can expand its content and refinements, this title could become a unique experience in the management game landscape.

Top Trailers