Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

9

blahblahblah69Dec 17, 2016

After seeing Kevin Smith's reaction to the movie I immediately went and saw it opening day. What a rewarding experience it turned out to be. While watching the movie I felt somewhat skeptical as to the direction everything was going, but theAfter seeing Kevin Smith's reaction to the movie I immediately went and saw it opening day. What a rewarding experience it turned out to be. While watching the movie I felt somewhat skeptical as to the direction everything was going, but the third act is a breath taking edge of your seat roller coaster ride that delivers on so many levels and ended on such a high note. Totally recommend. Righteous prequel to A New Hope. Do yourself a favor, see this movie in theaters and share the experience with as many people as you know. This movie will be more and more revered for its place in star wars cinematographic entries as time goes on.… Expand

17 of 29 users found this helpful1712

All this user's reviews

8

jenglish451Dec 17, 2016

Rogue One is thankfully another admirable Hollywood film that sincerely honors sacrifice, persistence, and hope. Of the Star Wars films, it's probably the best since the original three, and it links fairly well to the first.

It would be niceRogue One is thankfully another admirable Hollywood film that sincerely honors sacrifice, persistence, and hope. Of the Star Wars films, it's probably the best since the original three, and it links fairly well to the first.

It would be nice to know more about some of the characters, to sense even more deeply what they've suffered, but the film's focus on the story of the ensemble and how it miraculously comes together leads to another fascinating point: Arguably its handling of the idea of the Force or of a force behind the force may be more suggestive of a beneficent divine Providence, and thus closer to the Judeo-Christian God, than in the original three films which seemed to say that the Force requires balance--the light side requires a dark side, and so on (e.g. any victory of the good side is always only temporary, to be followed by the ascendancy of the dark side due to the purported balanced nature of the Force). The new film's seeming shift is a positive development. That notion of balance, of equal eternal opposition of good and evil, failed (even in the fictional world) to adequately or helpfully distinguish between good and evil so as to recognize good as higher than or better than or transcendent over evil. One could even argue from this development that the original films involved untrustworthy narration that is only now being revealed. Perhaps full investment in the themes stated above required this development. Hope would be unfounded without it.

And in its more unmitigated sense of a beneficent divine Providence watching over, superintending events, it feels reminiscent of the divine Providence and Creator (Eru Iluvitar) behind the scenes in The Lord of the Rings. But I guess time will tell if Star Wars really moves in this direction.… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

10

DPtdrysteDec 17, 2016

Really just reviewing this a 10 to balance the critic reviews. As a casual Star Wars fan I want to say 3 quick things about this movie:

1. It is a very "efficiently" produced film. No scene seems unnecessary. 2. It is accessible for non-StarReally just reviewing this a 10 to balance the critic reviews. As a casual Star Wars fan I want to say 3 quick things about this movie:

1. It is a very "efficiently" produced film. No scene seems unnecessary.
2. It is accessible for non-Star Wars die-hards like me, and today I'm actually gonna watch 4, 5, and 6 because it has piqued my interest in the series.
3. Based on talking about this with friends, it feels like what "Reach" was to the Halo series. As Vox has put it, while a Disney movie, this is a movie about war.

I really liked this movie. It was better than the last movie I saw in theatres, Arrival, and I really liked that movie too. This movie isn't as deep and provocative, but it's better.

If you are an experienced consumer of culture stuffs like games, music, movies, and TV shows I would say that a good lens to try to see this movie from is you as a kid, watching a serious war movie. As I get older I tend to compare everything to the best entries in the entire gamut of the culture genre, but if we are just going to compare every game to The Last of Us and every show to Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones, everything is going to suck comparatively.

Rogue One is definitely worth your $15 to watch in 3D. Go with someone younger than you, I went with my niece, and she really liked it.… Expand

8 of 17 users found this helpful89

All this user's reviews

10

OlrikusDec 17, 2016

-- Spoiler Free --
Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since original trilogy. Period.
Significant to say it adds weight to original trilogy and that is a worthy achievement itself. Lore of original trilogy was left intact and overall it is-- Spoiler Free --
Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since original trilogy. Period.
Significant to say it adds weight to original trilogy and that is a worthy achievement itself. Lore of original trilogy was left intact and overall it is a must see film.

Also it is a completely unusual film for Star Wars franchise and some people will dislike this film for that since it has no light saber duels and it's more focused on the heart of rebellion and it's people.… Expand

8 of 18 users found this helpful810

All this user's reviews

9

lupaf5Dec 17, 2016

Amazing star wars movie, it has his problems but at least is something different, the prequel we deserve, now i have a lot of fait in this new anthology movies. (please check the negative reviews, its incredible how people can be so stupid, iAmazing star wars movie, it has his problems but at least is something different, the prequel we deserve, now i have a lot of fait in this new anthology movies. (please check the negative reviews, its incredible how people can be so stupid, i mean i know its their opinion but damn alot of them didnt even know what movie they were watching)… Expand

15 of 25 users found this helpful1510

All this user's reviews

6

Sirik_MatakDec 17, 2016

Surprisingly for me - this movie is OK! I expected it to be a total disaster. It didn't try to recreate anything, it's just a decent action/character story picture with a Star Wars paint over it. And even if they actually did break theSurprisingly for me - this movie is OK! I expected it to be a total disaster. It didn't try to recreate anything, it's just a decent action/character story picture with a Star Wars paint over it. And even if they actually did break the barrier of the cringe here and there, I liked it a lot. Rolled my eyes a lot on some parts and still forced humour, but despite that, I still liked it. I was afraid that the "diversity hurrr" gimmick will kill this movie, but even if some characters are weak, they were characters with personalities (maybe except them monk dudes and the main lead, which is Rey 2.0 who can barely act), not token characters.
A quick meal that tastes good. Also, it's a relief to know that they ended all main characters in the same movie they were introduced in and don't plan to sequel their story.… Expand

2 of 10 users found this helpful28

All this user's reviews

9

RathaelDec 17, 2016

ROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force! Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore byROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force!

Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore by doing so, and introducing us to many new and reminding us of a quite a few old characters, in different scopes of screen time, some important to the plot, others more of fan service, letting us know they do exist in this ever expanding universe.

Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso, Alan Tyduk as K2S0 and Forest Whitaker as Saw Gerrera steal the show. Yes that is that Saw Gerrera to who ever watched Clone Wars animated series. Felicity Jones carries the entire movie with her conviction and fearlessness. K-2SO provides the most of the part of the comic relief but not in a way that anyone has seen before, think of him as of more cynical version of C-3PO, that way I do not go into much details or spoil much of his character. Forest Whitaker is fantastic as war grizzled Saw Gerrera that shows us just exactly how much war can change anyone, regardless of what side you are on.

Another big surprise in this movie was just how much screen-time was dedicated to the Empire and its characters with Ben Mendelsohn as Commander Krennic, puts a real face to the Empire, and how the people behind it, were as divided and human as any of the other rebel characters. That is probably partially true, as he's one of the only real Imperial characters really developed on screen other than Vader/Palpatine before, and it was very interesting to see that side of the war as well. This is where the movie really shines as well, as it shows that even Imperial officers like him, have their own agendas and dreams.

Rest of the cast is very very capable as well with Mads Mikellsen leading the cast as the imperial science officer, and Donnie Yen (Yeah!) as a blind staff wielding warrior, and its Donnie Yen in Star Wars movie, that's all that really needs to be said about that! Rest of the cast is also very capable and the charisma and the connection between these characters is very well established.

Gareth Edwards manages to make an adult version of Star Wars not saying the others were not adult oriented movies, but this one is not really relying on humor but establishing the true struggle that rebellion had to do against the Empire. And Edwards manages to do so, without making the movie dreary all the way, managing levity just enough to keep the story fun and exciting.

Another big departure here is that this is the first Star Wars movie not composed by John Williams but Michael Giacchino whose music fits to the feel of this movie, even though there are some famous Star Wars beats in the movie, most of this soundtrack feels very original, and he has put his stamp on the Star Wars universe, which is an amazing accomplishment.

Everything about this movie feels authentic, and its really the small things from the aesthetic feel of the movie and how certain shots were framed and how certain sequences were established is done very well, almost as a painting at some points, and there was that scene that was scene with a Star Destroyer, that I believe was shown in trailers, that scene gives you goosebumps.

Overall this movie does what a very very few movies can succeed at and that is take established universe, remove most of the main characters from that universe and make a compelling movie, make the universe feel more lived in. Manage to expand on the known universe in such a way that is meaningful, introduce us to some of the new characters that we can cheer for: Either Rebel or Imperial, and as I could believe this is first time that both Rebel Alliance hierarchy is kind of explained, and that adds to their plight. And this last statement I am going to probably catch a lot of crap for, but I believe it to be true. This movie managed to do an impossible, make an original trilogy even better movies.

4 out of 4 stars.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

2

conorfDec 17, 2016

Deserving of the flak, the prequels were extremely disappointing for sure. But Rogue One has to go down as one of the biggest disappointments of the entire Star Wars series. Convoluted, joyless and dull throughout, the only saving grace hereDeserving of the flak, the prequels were extremely disappointing for sure. But Rogue One has to go down as one of the biggest disappointments of the entire Star Wars series. Convoluted, joyless and dull throughout, the only saving grace here is the ending, which does a grand job of leading through to Episode 4. Sadly this is the worst movie of the entire series.… Expand

11 of 29 users found this helpful1118

All this user's reviews

6

samichsupernovaDec 17, 2016

This film was entertaining but ultimately adds up to less than the sum of its parts. The Good: The insane (amount and quality of) action, cinematography, and some performances. Felicity Jones and Ben Mendohlson did a lot with weak materialThis film was entertaining but ultimately adds up to less than the sum of its parts. The Good: The insane (amount and quality of) action, cinematography, and some performances. Felicity Jones and Ben Mendohlson did a lot with weak material and were seriously great. Alan Tudyk, Donnie Yen and Diego Luna's characters are cool. Certain cameos work really well. There's some poetry and clever visual ideas in the prolonged conflict in the third act, which almost makes up for the terrible first 1/2 of the movie (Jyn dispatches Stormtroopers with a stick... OK...). The action kind of feels like a kid playing with Star Wars action figures, in both good and bad ways. Oh and there's a monkey Rebel gunner.

The Bad: Everything else. The script tries to be darker and more realistic but there's hardly any depths of conflict beyond "good guys" VS "bad guys" where one good guy is only slightly more morally compromised than the others. There's no character development whatsoever. The story overall is paint-by-the-numbers. A total missed opportunity there. Forest Whitaker's character dies early on for no reason. The score is weak. There is little dramatic drive because we all know how this story will end. Too much "fan-service" and nostalgia. Callbacks to the original trilogy can only go so far.

The Ugly: How much money this is going to make, undeservedly. Unless you REALLY need to see the epic finale on the big screen, just wait for it to hit home video.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

0

pissedoffpersonDec 17, 2016

This is literally the worst movie I have ever seen. I feel offended. I went into it blind and I thought I was going into episode 8, I was not. At the 30 minute mark, I had finally realized that I was not watching that, but boring fan fictionThis is literally the worst movie I have ever seen. I feel offended. I went into it blind and I thought I was going into episode 8, I was not. At the 30 minute mark, I had finally realized that I was not watching that, but boring fan fiction made up by a literal child. Absolutely everything in this movie is boring, there's barely a plot and it pisses me off how disgusting and boring every single character is. The cherry on top of the **** cake is that I realized that this was a prologue to episode 4 before the movie even ended. At least the characters got the fate I wanted them to get.

TL;DR:Do not see this movie, it's a lie, it's a trap, it's the worst thing ever… Expand

13 of 34 users found this helpful1321

All this user's reviews

9

MrMovieBuffDec 17, 2016

The last time the "Star Wars" franchise decided it wanted to make prequels... we got outraged fans who lost faith in the iconic franchise. Luckily, Gareth Edwards directs 'Rogue One: A Star Wars Story', a title that might put-off some fans,The last time the "Star Wars" franchise decided it wanted to make prequels... we got outraged fans who lost faith in the iconic franchise. Luckily, Gareth Edwards directs 'Rogue One: A Star Wars Story', a title that might put-off some fans, but the movie itself is definitely worth a watch. We meet a young girl named Jyn (Felicity Jones) who had to escape after her father, Galen (Mads Mikkelsen) is informed by Director Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) forces Galen to work on the crafting of the Death Star. After some decade and a half, Jyn meets Rebel Officer Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) and she is informed about the Death Star.

She also meets a droid named K-2SO (a very funny Alan Tudyk) whose mannerisms and personality seem unusual, but helpful. They travel from planet to planet to find more clues on how to get the plans to destroy the Death Star, and they also find more characters to come and help. There is so much of this movie to talk about, but a "Star Wars" review can be easily spoiled, so I'm just going to summarize my thoughts on the movie. This is a really steady paced, dark and thrilling movie. The third act is one of the best third acts in any "Star Wars" movie, ever. The war battle that rages reminded me of the opening battle scene in 'Saving Private Ryan' (1998), obviously not that violent, but for this franchise's standards, it is. There are many familiar faces that return in this movie, most notably, Darth Vader (reprising the voice of James Earl Jones), who only makes two small appearances in this movie. But, they are so great, I cannot elaborate further without spoiling it, so I'll leave it there. This movie, which takes place before the events of 'Star Wars: A New Hope' (1977), really relies mostly on story as opposed to character. You get to know a lot about Jyn, a little bit about Cassian and K-2SO... but the rest are kind of glossed over as far as development goes. Director Gareth Edwards did a capable job of actually making this feel like a "War" movie, whereas the other movies were a space-opera spectacle. The first two acts are a little pacey here and there... but that third act is truly one of the best highlights for this entire franchise.… Expand

19 of 30 users found this helpful1911

All this user's reviews

9

NiikopolDec 17, 2016

The movie has bit too quick of a start. You are jumping from one planet to another in span of few minutes and can get lost there. However, with second act of the movie this is gone and third one is probably best epic space fight we saw inThe movie has bit too quick of a start. You are jumping from one planet to another in span of few minutes and can get lost there. However, with second act of the movie this is gone and third one is probably best epic space fight we saw in Star Wars universe ever. The movie does a lot of fanservice, obvious to any SW fan, but which non-fans and first timers would probably didnt even notice (Hammerhead class ship from KoToR), however is funny, quick paced, the plot gets it together in second act and ties up really great at the end, the acting was very well done (especially Donnie Yen). Great movie, go watch, 6.5/10 average by "professional" critics is absurd.… Expand

17 of 28 users found this helpful1711

All this user's reviews

8

RobBob99Dec 17, 2016

Black Hawk Down meets Star Wars, that is what it's like watching Rogue One and it truly delivers on the action. This has some of the absolute best action sequences in any Star Wars film and it actually has what many of the films have lacked,Black Hawk Down meets Star Wars, that is what it's like watching Rogue One and it truly delivers on the action. This has some of the absolute best action sequences in any Star Wars film and it actually has what many of the films have lacked, stakes. Through good characters and terrific acting, Rogue One manages to succeed what most prequels fail to do, enhance the impact of later films. I see myself watching A New Hope through a new point of view and I have to say, Gareth Edwards made a Star Wars movie that stands on its own. Yes it's not a perfect movie, but it's a really good movie with minor flaws.… Expand

20 of 31 users found this helpful2011

All this user's reviews

10

NaxDec 17, 2016

I was 7 when I watched my first Star Wars movie "A New Hope" it was the year 1987. I guess I can say that I prefer old movies above all else, maybe because of that I hated every frame of it. Before I was going to ROGIU ONE I honestly had noI was 7 when I watched my first Star Wars movie "A New Hope" it was the year 1987. I guess I can say that I prefer old movies above all else, maybe because of that I hated every frame of it. Before I was going to ROGIU ONE I honestly had no expectations, NO HOPE at all.

My GOD. I was gonna cry in the end. That was the movie I was waiting for since "Empire Strikes Back". Visually the movie is a masterpiece, way and way better then "Episode VII". Battles are breath taking, I dont wanna spoil it that is why I cant go into detail. THIS MOVIE DESCRIBES THE "WAR" in STAR WARS. A real war, where everyone SUFFERS, where darkness looms, innocent & evil die, this story shows what we have never seen before.

And such an ending, thanks to Gareth Edwards, really I can die in peace now, this movie is the one and one only that almost made me cry, smile, laugh, made me sit on the edge of my seat on the second part.

I GUARANTEE YOU, if you love EPISODE 4-5-6 the most, THIS IS THE MOVIE YOU HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR.… Expand

26 of 42 users found this helpful2616

All this user's reviews

3

KulkuriDec 17, 2016

Honestly the worst Star Wars film I've seen and a huge **** you" to long-time Star Wars fans. Story was underdeveloped, it underestimates viewer's intelligence and is a complete insult to Expanded Universe. It's like non-canonical fan filmHonestly the worst Star Wars film I've seen and a huge **** you" to long-time Star Wars fans. Story was underdeveloped, it underestimates viewer's intelligence and is a complete insult to Expanded Universe. It's like non-canonical fan film with a 100 million dollar budget that was rushed out before its time. And I'll never forgive them for casting Kyle Katarn away into a meaningless role. That made this film uncanonical in my head and I have to ignore that this film even exists. GCI was great and action was great. And I like that it's a more serious Star Wars film for adults. However it's a dumb Hollywood blockbuster film without actual substance in it.

Characters were unnatural, completely void of any kind of personality and their lines were poorly written & poorly thought as well. They have a bit of a Mary Sue as their leading character as well. She always has answer to everything and is just about perfect in any kind of sense including a perfect sob-story as her background. Also the film gives a strong impression that the roles where given based on external factors like actors' & actresses' ethnicity and not their actual skills as actors. The actors behave like complete wooden blocks which might or might not be an intentional thing given how the plot progresses. But hey at least it's "diverse" which to some people seems to be more important than actual good acting, good writing, good directing, good visual art, good music and many other things which usually make up a good film.

This film also tries to distance itself from other Star Wars films in various ways which is probably not a good idea considering how we're expecting certain things to be in Star Wars films and without them it just doesn't feel right. It feels more like a trashy fan-film that degrades the value of Star Wars in our eyes. Disney needs to stop this. They're making too many films too fast. And while Episode VII was barely acceptable I just cannot give Rogue One free pass.… Expand

12 of 29 users found this helpful1217

All this user's reviews

4

bugashiDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The story is just "meh", while the characters are forgettable. The visuals are mostly nice, but that's about it.

Everything you need to know about what happens comes from the first act, and all the times people picked on the glaring weakness of the Death Star. The motive laid plain and bare, with enough crumbs to make a cookie out of. As for the rest of the story, there's really nothing there. They just slog through the motions, which didn't really make me want to find out how they lead into Episode 4. Anyone who knows anything about the films would know that none of the characters important to the story would be coming back. So you would think they would at least try to make them a bit more memorable or worthwhile. Instead we get a 20-some teenager who initially could care less about the rebels that has an out of place change of heart because the story called for it, their backup character who was setup to become the friction on the team but doesn't really cause anything to happen, and droid sidekick who is more memorable than the rest of the cast combined (seriously, it's like someone who knew the flaws of the script wrote their lines).

They get teamed up with an attempt at an odd couple of a blind monk that follows the force like a religion, and a heavy weapons dwarf that doesn't buy into it. The monk is perhaps the second memorable character due to the staff fighting, which turns into a bow-like blaster. They also try to fill the mystical all seeing character, but most of the attempts are rather... forced. As for the heavy weapons dwarf, that's really the best way to describe them because they could have been replaced with just about any other kind of character and no one would have been the wiser. There is a part at the end where they have a change of heart, but it comes such a stereotypical moment and feels so out of place.

Then there's the pilot they pick up. Initially they were important because of a message they were trying to relay to the rebels. Instead he runs into some extremist who don't trust what he has to say, so they use a giant brain leach to snack on the guy's memory. Afterwards he's left in a holding cell to rot after the unhealthy dose of brain damage, but somehow returns from becoming a mindless doll and quickly turns into a competent member of the team. Then they become important in giving the team the call sign "rouge one" in which is met with the obvious "there is no rouge one, there is now" moment, and CinemaSins coming in with "roll credits" (ding)

As for the rest of the film, there's a few things that'll appear in Episode 4, but they're mostly there as a wink and a nod to assure the audience that this is (much like the title says) a Star Wars story. Even Darth Vader's appearance in the film feels like it was added just for the sake of getting people hyped to see what amounts to manufactured plot with no character development. Everything is done because the plot demands it. They even allude to things that might have made better features, but leave them as a cliffs notes because they got to get through the two and a half hour film. Kinda makes me think it would have been better as a TV series instead, because then we might actually have a chance to connect with the characters.

Though apparently now Vader has a dark sense of humor for some reason? It was so awkward of a joke that no one laughed. As a matter of fact, no one in the theater had any reaction to anything in the film at all. The awe and spectacle of the original series just wasn't there for this film. Even when they fired the Death Star twice, the whole thing comes off as under powered and weak when compared to the original.

Aside from all that, most of the visuals were nice. When the Death Star eclipsed the sun before firing did add a nice touch, and the appearance of Vader at the end was done well. Aside from that, the film isn't worth a fraction of the hype it received. If it were any other franchise, Rouge One would have been direct to DVD.… Expand

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

5

Ejdjski1234Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. IT bored me and felt a bit long but had its moments. Everyone gets blown up which is upsetting but Vader has a badass scene and it opens up for a new hope… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

8

tonywar93Dec 17, 2016

Rogue One is a great movie with a few drops here and there. The movie flows averagely pretty well for 2h15m, from an explanatory and choppy intro to one of the most breathtaking battles the Star Wars saga has ever seen and to what could beRogue One is a great movie with a few drops here and there. The movie flows averagely pretty well for 2h15m, from an explanatory and choppy intro to one of the most breathtaking battles the Star Wars saga has ever seen and to what could be considered a true nerd-gasm in the final scenes. Lots of pleasant surprises, lots of welcome call-backs, maybe some lack of characters's depth. Non-fans will enjoy an alternative war movie; fans will thank Gareth Edwards for realizing their innest geeky dreams.… Expand

12 of 27 users found this helpful1215

All this user's reviews

10

ChopperGunnerNLDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Star Wars Rogue One was personally one of my favorite Star Wars movies. The movie takes a while to get the viewer's attention, but after that the movie became very interessting. CGI was well done, casting and acting was good and storyline was well written and unpredictable. (SPOILER ALERT): This is also one of the few action movies and the only Star Wars movie were they main characters die.… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

9

DefinitelyMaybDec 17, 2016

Rogue one is perhaps one of the greatest Star Wars film ever made -but not a great film in itself. I agree character and pacing is a bit off, but I think people forget that Star Wars never really had great character development to begin withRogue one is perhaps one of the greatest Star Wars film ever made -but not a great film in itself. I agree character and pacing is a bit off, but I think people forget that Star Wars never really had great character development to begin with but rather great actors giving a really good performance (ie Harrison Ford's lines a lot of his one-liners were ad lib). My personal gripe with this film is probably that a lot of the characters felt a bit tagged on - like the blind dude etc, and some of the choices they do (ie in the ending) feels forced and illogical -and could have been written better in terms of what happens to them. The ending is rather unambiguous and a certain CGI character appears too much and does something at the end for no reason (only to ensure there won't be a sequel). Also Gareth Edwards could've shot some of the action scenes better and give some character's a proper arc which was lacking. Lack of a crawl and insistence of using location cards were a bit off-putting.

However Rogue One has the best world building, plot development, costume design, lighting and story flow out of the other Star Wars films. The film doesnt rely on wipes to get to one place to another which is great. Rogue one also have amazing action sequences and impeccable sound design. All the locations feel like real worlds compared to Force Awaken (which felt like small set designs). Although the score lacked more distinguishable motifs, I thought it flowed really well with the action o the films - and more of the traditional motifs were integrated well. Overall I thought Rogue One was a better Star Wars film than TFA and maybe even ROTJ, only because the world building and action was impeccable.… Expand

19 of 33 users found this helpful1914

All this user's reviews

10

dannytran555Dec 17, 2016

**** the critic that all i can say. This film is pure gold with great visual and story telling. star wars rogue one is perfect link between ep 3 and 4 also there so many good character in flim with marvel sense of humor . If u wonder should**** the critic that all i can say. This film is pure gold with great visual and story telling. star wars rogue one is perfect link between ep 3 and 4 also there so many good character in flim with marvel sense of humor . If u wonder should you watch this then the answer is yes… Expand

23 of 41 users found this helpful2318

All this user's reviews

5

Joe95Dec 17, 2016

A movie which tries desperately to recreate the magic of the original trilogy failing it's goal. A bad soundtrack as we've never seen on Star Wars before, a meaningless plot, useless characters with no charm who add nothing to the Star WarsA movie which tries desperately to recreate the magic of the original trilogy failing it's goal. A bad soundtrack as we've never seen on Star Wars before, a meaningless plot, useless characters with no charm who add nothing to the Star Wars mithology. A junble of CGI characters who could have compleately been avoided. After all we were able to do worse than the sequel trilogy, but this time with no Jar-Jar. P.s.: What the f*** went wrong with Darth Vader armor?
P.p.s.: After all Vader smashing rebels was great!… Expand

38 of 99 users found this helpful3861

All this user's reviews

10

HeavypointDec 17, 2016

This Movie is a love letter to the originals and fills the gap on why the Death Star was able to have such a weakness.

I love this movie plain and simple its a Star Wars movie done well and you must go and see it for yourself!!!This Movie is a love letter to the originals and fills the gap on why the Death Star was able to have such a weakness.

I love this movie plain and simple its a Star Wars movie done well and you must go and see it for yourself!!!

GOOOOOOOOOOOO WATCH IT ****

DO IT!… Expand

10 of 22 users found this helpful1012

All this user's reviews

10

lsdfmksldfmlsDec 17, 2016

This movie is worth it just for that one scene that everyone is talking about. Overall a fun movie but for fans of the series, it is a great bridge to explaining what happens in the background of Episode 4

11 of 21 users found this helpful1110

All this user's reviews

9

Closeremperor16Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Holy F**K Vader!! Oh man I can only look at this movie as a massive fan and as a fan it was amazing. The story was interesting and moved quickly, the cinematography and sense of scope and scale was excellent. I absolutely loved getting to see more of the oppression of the empire and the morally grey areas of the rebellion.

I loved the fact that this felt like a war movie taking place in the star wars universe. It connected seamlessly to episode 4 and gave me some truly jaw dropping moments. The whole last half hour of the movie was amazing and the beach scenes were everything I had hoped for in the best saving private Star wars kind of way. And Vader Holy **** Vader just mercilessly chopping down the rebels in the hallway at the end may have become one of my favourite Scenes ever. All in all I ****ing loved it, I have seen some criticisms of lack of character development ect But I think for the type of single shot story that this is that the way they handled it was appropriate. All in all is it a perfect movie…no because no movies perfect. BUT I would say because of my taste for the darker side of star wars this prob slots in to place behind empire strikes back as my favourite Star Wars movie. I need to see it about 4 more times in the cinema before I set my ranking in stone but the point is want to see it many more times. This film Gave me everything I wanted and was hoping for in an incredibly satisfying package. Bravo! Job well Done!!!… Expand

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

10

saleen2k3Dec 16, 2016

I thought the movie was amazing, the characters, the set pieces, and the emotional aspects of the movie. I was really pulled in and did not let up until the end. 10/10

17 of 31 users found this helpful1714

All this user's reviews

0

idoicuDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. If you have never seen, nor know anything what-so-ever about any Star Wars movie then you might have liked it. On the other hand if you know about previous Star War movies, characters, plots...then it left you scratching your head. When the 8th installment of a movie series comes out and you have to introduce 98% of the characters as new, then kill all of them off, it add ZERO to the series. To give it some Star Wars cred they had cameos of 4 or 5 characters seen before in other Star War movies. These were true cameos and if left out would not have been missed in the least. I also have a hard time calling a movie without a single JEDI in it a Star Wars movie. It appears that the director tried very hard to disconnect Rogue One with all the other Star Wars movies to the point that they had to list the names of all the planets and who controlled them for the first 10 minutes of the film. I have seen all the other films and I was totally lost for the first half of the movie about who was trying to do what to who. Take my advice and ALL STAR WAR FANS SHOULD STAY AWAY, you will be much happier if you do not see this one, I promise.… Expand

12 of 30 users found this helpful1218

All this user's reviews

9

FarhanFirozDec 16, 2016

Rogue one is a dark, gritty and the most realistic movie in the Franchise. A Fascinating Story with Stand-out performances and a Mind blowing 3rd act. Gareth Edwards direction with the Action scenes and VFX is ground-breaking. The only issueRogue one is a dark, gritty and the most realistic movie in the Franchise. A Fascinating Story with Stand-out performances and a Mind blowing 3rd act. Gareth Edwards direction with the Action scenes and VFX is ground-breaking. The only issue with the movie is the 2nd act wasn't structured well.… Expand

17 of 29 users found this helpful1712

All this user's reviews

10

allthingsnerdyDec 16, 2016

So, I saw "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" last night and I was actually very impressed. I read a lot of reviews before I actually went and saw this film. So while reading these reviews I was beginning to become skeptical myself, they rantedSo, I saw "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" last night and I was actually very impressed. I read a lot of reviews before I actually went and saw this film. So while reading these reviews I was beginning to become skeptical myself, they ranted and raved about how the Disney keeps introducing planets and characters that they want us to fall in love with or force upon us and have never heard of. This is a side story all on it's own, so we are going to meet characters that we don't know, we are going to see planets that we haven't seen before, and that is ok.

"Rogue One" is probably the best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back", it leaves us right where it is supposed to chronologically in the saga. It has you pulling and falling in love with all the characters for the most part. The little cameos that we see here and there are well placed to give you that little nostalgia feeling.

If we all remember in "Episode IV: A New Hope" where the leader of the Rebel Alliance Mon Mothma says that a lot of people had lost their lives to recover these plans. Well "Rogue One" is the story behind what she was talking about.

Jyn Erso the daughter of Galen Erso, was played by Felicity Jones, an English actress known for playing the role of Jane Hawking in the film "The Theory of Everything" in 2014. I am sure now she will be known as the actress who starred in "Rogue One". She played the role with poise and gumption, bringing the character to life with the strength that her character stood for in the saga. We first meet her character at an adult age when she has already been captured by Imperials and is then "liberated" by members of the Rebel Alliance. Those Rebels would be Cassian Andor and K-2SO played by Diego Luna and the delightful Alan Tudyk. Diego Luna plays a rough around the edges and very secretive scoundrel role in this film, where you don't know if he is good guy or bad guy, while Alan Tudyk plays his sarcastic and very blunt comedic sidekick that is sure to leave you laughing and begging for more.

If you are going to go see this film, keep an open mind that this is a story that we knew little of, and that Disney did a great job bringing this story to life and giving us more of an insight on what the Rebel Alliance went through to overcome the great evil that was the Empire.

This movie isn't meant to be compared to any of the other episodes that we have seen in previous years. It is to tell the prequel story of the most beloved Trilogy of all time. So don't go to this film with doubts, go to see this film with the hopes to catch a glimpse of something you have never seen before, there are no preconceptions of what to think, because this is a whole brand new story, so you can take it for what it is for, a wonderfully filmed movie, with characters you can connect with for the first and (spoiler alert) the last time.

The film has everything, AT-AT's, AT-ST's, sarcastic droids, Dog Fights, real plot lines and a grand finish! A must see in theaters, don't wait to Redbox this movie, you need to go see it in theaters to appreciate it's full value.

I hope this review was helpful, and I hope you enjoy the film as much as I did.

Vader is still a beast!

-Devin of All Things Nerdy… Expand

19 of 33 users found this helpful1914

All this user's reviews

8

SHORTFINGERDec 16, 2016

it was okay. lot of slow parts. far between fighting parts in the movie. but i did enjoy it. does tell us how they got the death star plans etc. did not learn much about the main people in the movie at all very little.

6 of 14 users found this helpful68

All this user's reviews

10

oraborsaDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Cuesta escribir una critica objetiva siendo fan de la saga SW, pero cumple con todas las expectativas y las supera. La película, llena de guiños a episodio IV transforma a la doctrina jedi y "la fuerza" en portadora de fe.… Expand

6 of 18 users found this helpful612

All this user's reviews

10

DeathSladeDec 16, 2016

In my opinion this is one of the best star wars movies ever. It's gritty, grounded, has a lot of action and callbacks to the original trilogy, and overall great. Most of the characters also have great development and i am actually sympatheticIn my opinion this is one of the best star wars movies ever. It's gritty, grounded, has a lot of action and callbacks to the original trilogy, and overall great. Most of the characters also have great development and i am actually sympathetic for the villain. Vader in this movie is so satisfying and all the scenes that he's in is amazing, it really shows what Vader really is. The only negative that i have with this movie is probably the characters with the CGI face which doesn't work as seamlessly as it could be.… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

4

masamunerikuDec 16, 2016

Rogue one isn't a bad movie yet it is somehow tedious to watch. The characters, especially Jyn, are bland and uncaptivating. In TFA at least Rey and Kylo are fun enough to watch. The core plot is actually decent, the execution however is suchRogue one isn't a bad movie yet it is somehow tedious to watch. The characters, especially Jyn, are bland and uncaptivating. In TFA at least Rey and Kylo are fun enough to watch. The core plot is actually decent, the execution however is such a mess that it never got me interested in what was going on.

The star wars franchise has always been great at creating new worlds. In rogue one however half of the movie is in a place called Jedha which has a middle eastern setting. The name itself would tell that it is a homophone of Jeddah. It is so unoriginal that the actual Jedha might as well be somewhere in middle east. How lazy are the writers to not come up with a more interesting setting?

The events in Scarif are decent. The stormtroopers are still fodders as per tradition and the empire is so incompetent that you wonder why the resistance lost to such army. The battles are at least (barely) believable. Also the characters are not protected by the invincible plot armor worn by the main characters in TFA which makes it a lot more interesting.

The whole movie might be worth watching just for the Vader scenes. Those scenes remind me why star wars were so good and why rouge one isn't. A movie wthout jedis, siths, lightsabers and the force is not Star Wars.… Expand

12 of 26 users found this helpful1214

All this user's reviews

10

kendrickdkDec 16, 2016

Love this movie so much. Great story, great acting, great pacing, great plot. The ending was epic. Going to see it again tomorrow. The movie starts of slow but builds to a hectic tempo by the end.

22 of 38 users found this helpful2216

All this user's reviews

0

IvanSDec 16, 2016

Film is **** I wouldn't say it's bad. It does fall into place well as the backstory of A New Hope. But I'd probably only recommend to people with a good attention span....there's a LOT of dialog delivered with that one-note 'what I'm sayingFilm is **** I wouldn't say it's bad. It does fall into place well as the backstory of A New Hope. But I'd probably only recommend to people with a good attention span....there's a LOT of dialog delivered with that one-note 'what I'm saying is IMPORTANT' tone. I liked Felicity Jones in A Theory Of Everything (basically the wife who gets dumped for being boring), but her character is pretty boring here too & always had the same 'scowl with a mouth full of walnuts' look. Maybe everyone was directed that way & she nailed it....after all no character was anyone you'd want to have a beer with.… Expand

9 of 37 users found this helpful928

All this user's reviews

7

Chazd3Dec 16, 2016

CG/special effects are marvelous. This interstitial Star Wars Saga is a perfect insert that adds dramatic guidance to the entire Stars Wars labyrinth. Other than the somewhat overwrought and at times confusing space battles, well done.

13 of 21 users found this helpful138

All this user's reviews

10

Trent2012Dec 16, 2016

This was an excellent movie that fits in well with the Star Wars Saga. It is a far better movie than the horrible episode 4 remake known as The Force Awakens!

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

9

bfoore90Dec 16, 2016

Led by a stellar cast and finalized with some pretty awesome scenes with the one and only Darth Vader, Rogue One serves as a welcomed edition to the Star Wars universe and should please any Star Wars fan, new and old.

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

9

BarefootedjediDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Before I start I have to say I absolutely loathed Force Awakens, a movie which had no respect for the Star Wars universe, and whose writers seemed to think repetition of past plots was a demonstration of love for it. I went to this one expecting to be disappointed, though I hoped the fact it involves no Jedi might actually be its saving grace. It was. There is no character here who, without even being a Padawan, defeats a Sith master both in Jedi mind control and in a light saber duel (the excluding of this possibility is why I suspected it would be harder to stuff up this one). Also, instead of stupidly rehashing the past this instalment nicely interlocks with it (note the distinction J.J., and you critics who uncritically gushed over FA). Consistent with the fictional history, there are no Jedi in sight (since they've all been assassinated or have gone to ground like Obi Wan and Yoda), and the only light-saber you’ll see is Darth Vader's when he goes on a slaughter fest at the end which nicely dovetails with the beginning of the original movie I saw as a child and was entranced by then. In many ways this is the adult Star Wars we grown up fans of the originals have been waiting for. I only wish the writers of this could have had the making of FA instead of the fool Jar Jar Abrams. Disney, please let them complete the trilogy Abrams stuffed up. They understand what real Star Wars fans want. Something gritty and grown up, which recognises the history and mythology of the SW universe but tells its own story within that context.

Felicity Jones is a great actress, and plays a role which is both capable and sensitive. Also, as an Aussie, I'm happy to see Ben Mendelsohn as the central villain; a great actor. For martial arts fans there's the brilliant Donnie Yen, who isn't a Jedi but should be, instead playing a blind, possibly slightly crazy, worshiper of the force, who may or may not be force sensitive but regardless manages to take out a lot of storm troopers and almost magically dodge some blaster fire (and has a friend with a hugely powerful blaster to keep him alive when the odds are too much against him). Chirrut Imwe (Donnie), yes, you are one with the force, you are one with the force (you’ll get my reference once you’ve seen the movie). There is a beautifully tragic ending for the central characters too. Heroes die, as they ought to in a good war movie or tragedy.

Expect to see some slightly dodgy CGI resurrections, but only when necessary and not to too bad effect. Of course the greatest of all Star Wars villains, Darth Vader, being in his life support suit, doesn’t need this kind of treatment and is voiced as always by the inimitable James Earl Jones.

I see that this received poorer reviews from the professional reviewers than did FA, to which I can only say these guys must be either corrupt or stupid (or maybe both). Ok, I have suspected that since all the gush over FA, but this round of stupidity confirms it. I have given this 9 instead of 10 because, though it is sensible, consistent, respectful of the past but not slavishly committed to it, and well written, what I would really have loved to see is this kind of loving care lavished on the new trilogy (movies with Jedi in them!) instead of just this (appropriately Jedi free) standalone. If you are a lover of the original trilogy I strongly recommend this one. If you were disgusted by FA I am totally with you (read my review to see how much I hated it), but this one is a different beast. Give it the chance you regretted giving FA. It may not be perfect, but I think it's the best since the original trilogy (and doesn't have the vomitous cutesiness of Ewoks to mar it).

Now, where would I start with a remade Episode VII? The remnants of the empire have degenerated into an insurgency against a shakily re-established republic. They are carrying out terrorist attacks across the galaxy. The Jedi academy has been re-established by Luke, and Leia has also had some Jedi training, but perhaps has chosen not to become a full-fledged Jedi because there is so much political work to do patching together a workable galactic democracy. Perhaps Leia, in fighting against terrorists has become a little dark herself (this couldn’t reasonably happen with Luke, since he has proved himself capable of resisting the combination of Darth Vader and the Emperor in ROTJ), setting up a sibling conflict of galactic proportions. After all, real politics is a dirty business. She hasn’t become Sith but her morality is uneasily balanced. Questionable alliances have been made (think of the mess in Syria at the moment). The line between good and evil is becoming blurred. Luke, as a monk like Jedi figure, has perhaps become morally flawed in a more subtle way, by virtue of a too mystical, navel gazing perspective on right and wrong. An adult premise. Start there screenwriters. Develop.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

3

ResuaicataDec 16, 2016

Movie is LOONG and boring, you will literally be sitting in the theater for an hour and a half before the movie starts picking up and getting decent. I will say this about the actual movie, I'm not going to include spoilers. The charactersMovie is LOONG and boring, you will literally be sitting in the theater for an hour and a half before the movie starts picking up and getting decent. I will say this about the actual movie, I'm not going to include spoilers. The characters aren't going to grow on you, this is not an "Epic tale", you probably won't remember the character's names a month from now after seeing this movie. This is not Starwars,this is not the franchise we grew up on. And thats why I'm giving this movie a bad review, I'm not going to give it a "Free pass" just because it's starwars. Also with that being said, most of the people that I know personally that like the movie are pure George Lucas haters, they hate everything George Lucas did, and love everything he didn't do. They couldn't name one thing they really loved about the movie other than the action towards the end/the ending. I can't name a single thing I personally liked other than the action, so Hence the 3/10 score. FAIL

As a side note I will say this is how I personally rank the SWs movies. 1-8 1 being the best
1.) A New Hope 2.) The Empire Strikes back
3.) Return of the Jedi
4.)Revenge of the Sith
5.)The Force Awakens
6.)The Phantom Menace
7.)Star Wars Rogue One
8.)The Clone Wars

I am an avid Starwars fan, and to be honest Rogue on had less going for it than Clone Wars. The characters were that bad and they just couldn't convince me enough through poor acting (With a few major exceptions), and a poor/poorly written plot to care about them. I mean this is my personal opinion, I'm not telling you to not watch the movie, you should just lower your expectations so you won't be disappointed, or you might even like it more than you expected you would, the action scenes are great, but lets be real here if thats all it takes to make a good movie Taken 1/2 would be 8-9/10s.… Expand

25 of 72 users found this helpful2547

All this user's reviews

5

hcliffedDec 16, 2016

Not good, not horrible. Episode III.9 basically; filler with characters no one ever gets to know well enough to get attached to, I felt this movie was slow and emotionless.

Michael Giaccino kinda spit all over Williams with his sub-par score, too.

12 of 26 users found this helpful1214

All this user's reviews

5

piercoDec 16, 2016

People who are voting this awful, boring, mishmash of a movie 10 realy need their heads examined. I now understand why the likes of Trump can manipulate people to vote for him. Whay a world of Idiocy we live in.

5 of 19 users found this helpful514

All this user's reviews

9

Ming120Dec 16, 2016

This might as well be my favorite Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. It was absolutely refreshing to have a story that is not focused on an overpowered force-wielding protagonist, but on characters a little bit more normal. TheThis might as well be my favorite Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. It was absolutely refreshing to have a story that is not focused on an overpowered force-wielding protagonist, but on characters a little bit more normal. The plot is a little more interesting this time around, with plenty of action to be had.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

10

KaktusmiesDec 16, 2016

If you love Star Wars, you will love this! In my opinion even better than Force Awakens! If you didn't like Force Awakens go see this! Now! So many nostalgic things and oh, the emotions I experienced during this movie! 10/10 I will probablyIf you love Star Wars, you will love this! In my opinion even better than Force Awakens! If you didn't like Force Awakens go see this! Now! So many nostalgic things and oh, the emotions I experienced during this movie! 10/10 I will probably go watch this one again!
I love space fighting and this movie has lots of it!… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

Trash_McblazesDec 16, 2016

Feel the need to rate this higher to offset the critic reviews lower than 5. This is a movie in the vein of the original trilogy. Wish the supporting players were more flesched out and thought that the beginning was paced pretty fastFeel the need to rate this higher to offset the critic reviews lower than 5. This is a movie in the vein of the original trilogy. Wish the supporting players were more flesched out and thought that the beginning was paced pretty fast otherwise this is a Star Wars story. Now, if you walked into this movie with no previous knowledge of the u iverse you would be entertained and finish off your popcorn quite quick; this is a good movie, period. Now go and enjoy yourself!… Expand

9 of 20 users found this helpful911

All this user's reviews

5

my02Dec 16, 2016

I kept thinking "did THIS many people have 19th century British accents in all the other films....the other accents all being European?". My friend & I had trouble staying awake just like many others have mentioned....& yes the end wasI kept thinking "did THIS many people have 19th century British accents in all the other films....the other accents all being European?". My friend & I had trouble staying awake just like many others have mentioned....& yes the end was colorful & exciting (especially Darth Vader 'sashaying' through....all I'm sayin').
I barely knew what was going on half the time, dialog sounded like those royalty history movies, just with intergalactic subject matter (but how would Luke, Leah & Han EVER hang out with these people"?).
I sort've plan on seeing it again, hopefully I'll piece the story together better the 2nd time.
I wouldn't say it's bad. It does fall into place well as the backstory of A New Hope. But I'd probably only recommend to people with a good attention span....there's a LOT of dialog delivered with that one-note 'what I'm saying is IMPORTANT' tone. I liked Felicity Jones in A Theory Of Everything (basically the wife who gets dumped for being boring), but her character is pretty boring here too & always had the same 'scowl with a mouth full of walnuts' look. Maybe everyone was directed that way & she nailed it....after all no character was anyone you'd want to have a beer with.
Maybe the robot.… Expand

9 of 19 users found this helpful910

All this user's reviews

10

EmilMDec 16, 2016

Rouge One! I really like the direction and the gritty vibe this film brings to the star wars universe. It is weird to talk about a realistic feel.. but stil it has a more realistic feel to the characters than before. it has darker tone (likeRouge One! I really like the direction and the gritty vibe this film brings to the star wars universe. It is weird to talk about a realistic feel.. but stil it has a more realistic feel to the characters than before. it has darker tone (like Empire strikes back) and in my opinion it makes you invest more in the film as you watching it makes the story matter, it gives you chills down your spine as a randon cgi ship blows up... which i personally thinks is amazing! It would really like to se even more of this natural gritty and realistic vibe in the star wars universe! i dont think this film is a 10 maybe 8 or 9 but il give a 10 as i hope it might push the money-men interest in making star wars film in this deriction… Expand

8 of 19 users found this helpful811

All this user's reviews

3

Davidtang1974Dec 16, 2016

Dreadfully disappointing. Spammy,amateurish acting; unwieldy structured plot; interminably drawn out sequences; tepid, inscrutable dialogue fit for a UN boardroom. Its a clock watcher. To further prevent one from immersing into fantasy, theDreadfully disappointing. Spammy,amateurish acting; unwieldy structured plot; interminably drawn out sequences; tepid, inscrutable dialogue fit for a UN boardroom. Its a clock watcher. To further prevent one from immersing into fantasy, the oddly rendered CGI characters distracted the mind towards the glitchy, strangeness of their appearance, and movement. Also bears the worst acting I think I've ever witnessed. The actor playing Cassian - could he emote, and commit to a scene more anaemically? The characters were so one dimensional, that I just didn't care about them or their mission. Cue boredom. Given how great were the rest of the special effects, and set production that's saying something. Worst one of the lot. So glad it's over.… Expand

30 of 74 users found this helpful3044

All this user's reviews

10

Mad_MonkDec 16, 2016

Loved it. Was a much better Star Wars movie than "the force awakens". This is the Star Wars movie many of us have been waiting for. Darker and more real. Will definitely see it again at the movies. 10/10

57 of 91 users found this helpful5734

All this user's reviews

3

GreatMartinDec 16, 2016

All Star Wars die hard fans please don't read any further because this review of "Star Wars: A Star Wars Story" will make you very mad!! "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is loud, noisy, boring and, except for 4-5 lines that are funny, not atAll Star Wars die hard fans please don't read any further because this review of "Star Wars: A Star Wars Story" will make you very mad!! "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is loud, noisy, boring and, except for 4-5 lines that are funny, not at all original. Anyone with even a rudimentary knowledge of the series will know where it is heading from the introduction of Felicity Jones, as Jyn Erso who is the daughter of scientist Galen played, by Mads Mikkelsen. Without giving away any plot if the daughter had listened to the father about a mistake he made on purpose the picture would have been only an hour instead of the 2 hour 13 minute running time.

The movie has more wars than all the Star Wars pictures combined plus one of the loudest soundtracks heard in a long time. The CGI effects are out of this world, no pun intended, and in some cases amazing as an actor who has been dead over 22 years is very much alive, another looks 40 years younger and another who is in their 80s sounds like a teenager! They are the set up for the very first Star Wars movie ever made though the ending leaves nothing in doubt.

I wasn't familiar with many of the leading actors but I was impressed with Donnie Yen as a blind monk, Wen Jiang as a warrior, Riz Ahmed a pilot and Diego Luna as one of the leading rebels. Oh yes, a nod of the head to Alan Tudyk for the wisecracking 7-8 foot droid K-2SO. Forest Whitaker is wasted in a cameo which really has nothing to do with what the screenplay by Chris Weitz and Tony Gilroy is heading for and director Gareth Edwards is all over the screen in the action scenes and only hits the warmer minutes towards the end of the film.

Oh I forgot to mention Ben Mendelsohn's villain maybe because he is forgettable?

I am not a fan of Star Wars or sci-fi films and told Allen he is on his own for future Star Wars films.

Unless you are a fanatical fan of the series or a couple of CGI effects regarding people I would suggest staying away.… Expand

34 of 85 users found this helpful3451

All this user's reviews

10

olivermetaDec 16, 2016

Loved it. Felicity Jones was the true heroine/ hero and I fell in love. I also felt like the other major characters played their parts well. Also loved the blind guy (Chirrut). A True star wars movie!! Didn't just feel like an attemptedLoved it. Felicity Jones was the true heroine/ hero and I fell in love. I also felt like the other major characters played their parts well. Also loved the blind guy (Chirrut). A True star wars movie!! Didn't just feel like an attempted nostalgia trip.… Expand

11 of 21 users found this helpful1110

All this user's reviews

9

Dirk2112Dec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Genuinely perplexed by the negative reviews because this is a well-cast, expertly designed, well performed film that also happens to have been stylishly directed and cleverly written. It’s actually so well directed and performed that on the few occasions its script hits a bump, the momentum of its performances plus direction rolls right over them. No, it doesn't drip with easy charm and charism of Force Awakens but then again, it shouldn't. [Mild Spoiler!] You couldn’t watch this story unfold onto Ridley and Boyega. It's the Guns of Navarone of Star Wars films in the best possible ways.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

8

oDjentoDec 16, 2016

Rogue One isn’t perfect, but it is a great breath of fresh air for the Star Wars Franchise. The direction feels very different at first, feeling more handheld at not super Star Wars-esque because of its grittier more grounded style, but thisRogue One isn’t perfect, but it is a great breath of fresh air for the Star Wars Franchise. The direction feels very different at first, feeling more handheld at not super Star Wars-esque because of its grittier more grounded style, but this is great and works for the film. It ends up making it feel like a real war and struggle for the rebellion and it ends up changing later towards the end in tonal shift and direction to blend into A New Hope.
Pacing is a little odd at first, but the first section is interesting enough to keep you very invested, especially with all the character introductions. The second act is a littler quieter and a bit of a lull but still has enough going on and differs itself from the rest of the film to keep it fresh. The last section is an intense all out action masterpiece, and really gives a space feeling of something similar to the end battle of Saving Private Ryan. Characters are well enough written for you to enjoy and like them all, however they are a little underdeveloped for the most part and you end up wanting more from them. This ends up not hindering the film too much since the film is a standalone. This film does carry itself well, it knows when to be dark without over doing it and changes location at a nice rate with a clear understanding of where and what folk are doing.
This also the first film where Darth Vader is actually fully terrifying, he is almost like an insanely powerful sci fi MikeMyers. Even thoug he isn’t in it much, his presence is palpable.
The good thing about Rogue One also is that it doesn’t try to keep using nostalgia to interest its viewers (which TFA did a lot) but does have plenty of nice little easter eggs.
The droid K2SO in the film is also the comic relief of it, but whilst a few jokes hit the mark a lot are unnecessary and too forced in, and there is (like TFA) a lot of cheesy 2016 throwaway jokes just put in there. Disney need to learn to restrain themselves from certain jokes, and when they do put them in they need to understand when to end the joke and how to fully have them come across.
Last two complaints, the new score for the film is cheesy and doesn’t fit the film at all, and really takes away from it as a whole sadly. Dubbing John Williams over it would be very cheap, but to be honest it would probably make the film feel more epic and fit more. There is also some questionable CGI characters in the film which just look unnatural in the film but still don’t ruin it too much.
Overall, this film diverges enough away from Star Wars to make it feel fresh but also very nicely connects itself to the original trilogy. Action is awesome yet characters are a little underdeveloped, special effects are gorgeous but score is disappointing. It is a tragic war film set in the Star Wars universe, and Gareth Edwards did something brave with what he had.
Bravo to you sir.
8/10… Expand

16 of 27 users found this helpful1611

All this user's reviews

0

nugness123Dec 16, 2016

Movie **** sucked. Jesus christ what a bland, cold-hearted, depressing movie. Every character felt like a robot with no emotions or sex drive, unreal. Not as bad as episode 7.

13 of 35 users found this helpful1322

All this user's reviews

10

TryASummersaultDec 16, 2016

10/10 I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE, AND THE FORCE IS WITH ME! I'm absolutely stunned and thrilled right now because I just witnessed the most authentic and truest representation of a Star Wars film since the original classic trilogy. This was10/10 I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE, AND THE FORCE IS WITH ME! I'm absolutely stunned and thrilled right now because I just witnessed the most authentic and truest representation of a Star Wars film since the original classic trilogy. This was nothing short of phenomenal and executed every single aspect of the galaxy/franchise in flawless fashion. From the gargantuan scale of the vastly magnificently planet scapes and ships to the wild variation of the characters, this might be the greatest film in the franchise yet. The action scenes are plenty and are amazingly set up on the ground and in the air. The cgi is the best I've seen in any film ever and the grand scale is masterful. The story was easily the most adventurous and well told than any in the franchise. The score was brilliant and captured the Star Wars feel beautifully. Gareth Edwards will now be known as one of the best new directors around after crafting this masterpiece. I was going to wait to see but couldn't hold my excitement and I would recommend everyone see this in the theatre for all It's glory.… Expand

39 of 68 users found this helpful3929

All this user's reviews

6

ayarlettDec 16, 2016

Stars wars has become the Terminator franchise. First two movies were good but every one since has been average at best. This one was ok again. Nothing mind blowing and the robot K2 was the best actor. That says it all. I even thought theStars wars has become the Terminator franchise. First two movies were good but every one since has been average at best. This one was ok again. Nothing mind blowing and the robot K2 was the best actor. That says it all. I even thought the mexican guy was french until someone pointed out he was hispanic the next day. Anyway it wasnt bad but was just about average-ish. last 30 mins was the best part.… Expand

3 of 15 users found this helpful312

All this user's reviews

1

rensyphonDec 16, 2016

You're going to be bored 90% of the film. The lead female, male, and villain all lack charisma; you won't care about any of them. The plotlines and conflicts are bafflingly disjointed. For instance, a conflict will be set up, then end upYou're going to be bored 90% of the film. The lead female, male, and villain all lack charisma; you won't care about any of them. The plotlines and conflicts are bafflingly disjointed. For instance, a conflict will be set up, then end up going no where, and it was a weird place for conflict to arise from to begin with.

The side characters are fun, but underused.… Expand

32 of 78 users found this helpful3246

All this user's reviews

2

CriticalBenDec 16, 2016

Star Wars: Rogue one is most likely the worst movie of the year. I would of given it a higher score except it does not deserve anything higher than 2 stars(1 Star for Nostalgia, 1 Star to prop up all the zeroes this movie will get). please doStar Wars: Rogue one is most likely the worst movie of the year. I would of given it a higher score except it does not deserve anything higher than 2 stars(1 Star for Nostalgia, 1 Star to prop up all the zeroes this movie will get). please do not see this movie or take ones that you love to see this disaster.… Expand

26 of 73 users found this helpful2647

All this user's reviews

7

ezhikovDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I've waited to see a 5/10 movie, so i decided to count plusses and minuses.
Main male character is -
Main female character is +-
Grand Moff Tarkin is +++
Lack of normal Imperial March when Vader enters the room is -
Blind monk with heavy friend is +
Two boring inspirational speaks is --
Three in time jokes is ++
Couple of off time jokes is -
The End is +
New robot is - (except for final part +)

7 total.… Expand

15 of 26 users found this helpful1511

All this user's reviews

0

oannizzleDec 16, 2016

Thank YOU Gareth Edwards !!!! from now on we have TRUST in you because you give us HOPE. George Lucas must be proud right now of what you did with his legacy.

14 of 45 users found this helpful1431

All this user's reviews

6

TrevorsViewDec 16, 2016

Okay, so the first spinoff of the immortal Star Wars saga has finally hit theaters, but how does it compare to the rest? Well, it’s miles ahead of those embarrassing prequels (no surprise), but Rogue One: A Star Wars Story just can’t competeOkay, so the first spinoff of the immortal Star Wars saga has finally hit theaters, but how does it compare to the rest? Well, it’s miles ahead of those embarrassing prequels (no surprise), but Rogue One: A Star Wars Story just can’t compete with the originals, or The Force Awakens.

As I’m sure you’ve heard, there’s no opening crawl or John Williams score this time, just a silent view of space with a single planet. Everything else from here is an X-wing flight of an experience you’d expect from a Star Wars movie, including booming sound effects and AT-AT walkers that look as epic as ever. There’s an appropriate mix of practical sets and good CGI to create all sorts of new settings, including a tropical planet and a claustrophobic prison. It’s got all the checklist requirements to make a good Star Wars movie, but there’s something missing.

Basically, without giving anything away, the Death Star is in its finishing stages of development, and war zones land on all areas of conspiracy against the weapon, the strife of war affects the lowest of the low in the galaxy. But we are introduced to the struggle on a rock and moss planet that houses a small family of farmers. The father is forcefully invited to join the Empire, along with his wife and daughter. He is soon taken away, and the little girl manages to escape, only to be transported place to place by an Imperial prison as an adult.

Now, she ends up with the Rebel Alliance so that she can be this movie’s “feminist protagonist” in helping steal the plans to the Death Star, and also to see her father again. You know how it all goes from here.

The problem I had with this movie is not just in how we already know how it will end before it even begins, but in the excessive use of characters with so little humanity I cannot connect with a single one of them.

Think of it this way: you remember how in The Force Awakens we saw a detailed introduction to Rey that showed us what her day-to-day life on Jakku was like? Remember the clear backstory given to Finn and how that motivated his actions? Here, none of the new characters have any of that. Jyn’s not motivated enough to fight for what she has lost, as we never know what her relationship with her father was ever like. Then she starts to cry over this inner pain, and let me tell you: Felicity Jones (Like Crazy, The Theory of Everything) is not skilled in making crocodile tears. Her story just moves by too quickly to balance a feel of hope with letting us feel for her.

Everyone else around her is just a plot device. While Forest Whitaker’s (The Butler, The Last King of Scotland) new cyborg character has a sympathetic redemption story screaming to get out, the poor performance of the man behind the mask just doesn’t land. Then there’s the cameos of characters from the original trilogy. Remember how the appearances of older characters in The Force Awakens actually advanced the emotional story and improved your appreciation of the originals? This does none of that. Darth Vader does appear as epic as ever, but he just comes to explain the plot, and leaves, only to make one more brief appearance. There are a couple of others from the originals who appear, but none of them are very satisfying or necessary. Although there was one cameo that just blew my mind, making me go, “Whoa! How did the visual effects crew make that possible?!”

But there is a god, strong saving grace though: one of the new characters proves to be strong with the force, despite it being a time when the force is thought of as an ancient religion. He’s also blind, and an epic master of hand-to-hand combat. Let me tell you: he gets a moment to shine in his fight against a gaggle of Stormtroopers, and it’s the most amazing thing ever.

So is Rogue One: A Star Wars Story the spinoff to the saga we all hoped for? Not exactly. It’s a satisfactory action flick if you’re willing not to think too hard about it as high art. But if you are looking for the essential Star Wars experience that surpasses all of your expectations, you might end up disappointed.… Expand

6 of 24 users found this helpful618

All this user's reviews

6

IsotopesamDec 16, 2016

Its not until the second half that you realize the importance of the story in the Star Wars world. I wish they had built it up better in the first half. But poor character development turns this movie. Second half is great and a treat for theIts not until the second half that you realize the importance of the story in the Star Wars world. I wish they had built it up better in the first half. But poor character development turns this movie. Second half is great and a treat for the eyes but the overall story was just rushed. It was disappointing that they didn't start with the Star Wars theme either. You can wait to watch it on bluray or stream it.… Expand

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

9

judahjsnDec 16, 2016

Just incredible. Reminded me of things that were great about the originals that I had forgotten. This is a masterful star wars film full of feeling and incredibly choreographed battle scenes. It makes the Force Awakens seem bloodless andJust incredible. Reminded me of things that were great about the originals that I had forgotten. This is a masterful star wars film full of feeling and incredibly choreographed battle scenes. It makes the Force Awakens seem bloodless and airless in comparison. The cqi recreations of old actors is the only fly in the ointment. Terrible, terrible decision. Would have been flawless without that.… Expand

27 of 47 users found this helpful2720

All this user's reviews

3

Jedi49Dec 16, 2016

Went to see last night and in one word disappointing.
Have been a Star Wars fanatic since I was 10,It just didn't grab me like The Force Awakens did.
I hate to say it but I found Rogue One boring. Not that it was a bad movie but I felt thatWent to see last night and in one word disappointing.
Have been a Star Wars fanatic since I was 10,It just didn't grab me like The Force Awakens did.
I hate to say it but I found Rogue One boring.
Not that it was a bad movie but I felt that for a Star Wars movie it fell well short of my expectations.
I would give it a 2 out of 5.
Might go and see it again but I am not in a hurry to do so… Expand

13 of 38 users found this helpful1325

All this user's reviews

4

bulbrookDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Tale of two movies. First half terrible - confusing, poor character development, dark and not enjoyable to watch. Then it is like the director was told to stop making a bad movie. The characters lightened up as did the tone, and the pacing and action became a star wars movie. The second half of the movie takes place in space and on a cool planet with a palm tree filled beach. It has as a bit of Return of the Jedi feel with the story switching back and forth. Overall rent this movie and skip ahead to the very beginning of the beach scene, and you will have an enjoyable 45 min long film.… Expand

9 of 23 users found this helpful914

All this user's reviews

1

Tyger44Dec 16, 2016

After the heartbreaking disappointment that was episode 7, Rogue One does very little to get Star Wars back on track. Rogue One fails on every level with the exception of a few cool action scenes.
Just like how Force Awakens is a rehash of AAfter the heartbreaking disappointment that was episode 7, Rogue One does very little to get Star Wars back on track. Rogue One fails on every level with the exception of a few cool action scenes.
Just like how Force Awakens is a rehash of A New Hope and Legacy of the Force, with Rey and Kylo Ren acting as the replacements for Jacen and Jaina Solo, Rogue One is just a rehash of Dark Forces, with Felicity Jones and Diego Luna being replacements for Kyle Katarn and Jan Ors, just nowhere near as likable or endearing as the originals. In addition, the premise itself is predictable and uninspiring, and the movie doesn't add anything to the overall mythos.
Do yourself a favor,and just don't watch this movie. It is not worth it. If anything, this movie is confirmation that no matter what we want, we are being given one thing, and that's what they're telling we want. This movie will leave you with this crushing sense of inevitability, like the fans don't matter. Because ultimately, with Disney in charge of Lucasfilm, they don't matter.… Expand

27 of 76 users found this helpful2749

All this user's reviews

10

Stroker_289Dec 16, 2016

Some of you are giving this movie an outstanding write-up review with a score of 0, make sure you give it a score along with a write-up. This movie is one-off star wars movie, one of the best in the franchise, far superior to episode 7 inSome of you are giving this movie an outstanding write-up review with a score of 0, make sure you give it a score along with a write-up. This movie is one-off star wars movie, one of the best in the franchise, far superior to episode 7 in every way possible. Everyone involved in this movie should be involved in every star wars movie from here on.… Expand

41 of 68 users found this helpful4127

All this user's reviews

10

Can7onaLegendDec 16, 2016

The Greatest movie since sliced bread and various other bread based thing's. like egg's and car's. wanna find out how the death star blew up? this is the movie for moviegoers!

23 of 44 users found this helpful2321

All this user's reviews

9

GameAnalyzerDec 16, 2016

Rogue One manages to stay as a faithful chapter from the Star Wars franchise on its own league serving as a rightful prequel to the fourth episode. The creators right from the start had promised to bring something new to the table and theyRogue One manages to stay as a faithful chapter from the Star Wars franchise on its own league serving as a rightful prequel to the fourth episode. The creators right from the start had promised to bring something new to the table and they did deliver. The casting was perfect. The CGI has been remarkable with lots of surprise elements in offer for long time fans of the franchise from the 70s. Although the film delivers in the long run with all Stars Wars action elements ranging from stormtroopers to the AT act walkers against the rebellion units , there are minor issues with general pacing as the story progresses around with its Death Star plot at instances with poorly timed execution of the characters related to it, bogging it down for viewers. The Force Awakens had an USP with great character execution but on the other hand the action sequences in Rogue One struck the right chord several notches above TFA for the prequel story. It deserves a solid 9.… Expand

24 of 43 users found this helpful2419

All this user's reviews

8

BrianMcCriticDec 16, 2016

This film is so much fun even with its few flaws. My favorite part of the film is the third act which is terrifically shot with a lot of emotion and great action. The lead up, the setting up of the team is put together fairly fast whichThis film is so much fun even with its few flaws. My favorite part of the film is the third act which is terrifically shot with a lot of emotion and great action. The lead up, the setting up of the team is put together fairly fast which doesn't allow for much character development. Also I felt some of the cameos were forced just to get a fan reaction instead of writing them in with more thought. Overall this is my fifth favorite Star Wars film behind the original trilogy and TFA. A-… Expand

16 of 28 users found this helpful1612

All this user's reviews

8

aurynsdadDec 16, 2016

Overall incredible. Far better than the other prequels. I liked the storyline better than the Force Awakens, which had some strange plot holes it's hard to get past. On repeat viewings, I'll be able to decide whether I like this or ForceOverall incredible. Far better than the other prequels. I liked the storyline better than the Force Awakens, which had some strange plot holes it's hard to get past. On repeat viewings, I'll be able to decide whether I like this or Force Awakens better. The third act is legendary. Strengths: the story, the feel, the acting, the writing. Weaknesses: a few spots of jarring editing, music, and CGI.… Expand

9 of 20 users found this helpful911

All this user's reviews

8

ReginthornDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is the best Star Wars movie since 1980. The general consensus of last years Force Awakens was that the spirit of the original trilogy returned. However, the problem with Episode VII is in how the spirit is captured identically. InRogue One is the best Star Wars movie since 1980. The general consensus of last years Force Awakens was that the spirit of the original trilogy returned. However, the problem with Episode VII is in how the spirit is captured identically. In having returned so reverently, the franchise needed to display a willingness to tinker. Enter the newest cinematic addition to Star Wars. Rogue One is a balanced movie of hope and despair. The last Star Wars movie to find this magical balance in tone is The Empire Strikes Back. Likewise, Rogue One finds a unique synergy between old and new. The first anthology Star Wars movie works in its inevitable lead-in to an almost forty-year-old classic with a sense of invigoration. The movie smartly covers up modern filmmaking conventions with amazing throwbacks to the original trilogy. Seventies style facial hair can still be found on the Rebel pilots while a few smart cameos make the Star Wars initiated feel at home. The amount of Star Warsness to the film allows director Gareth Edwards to comfortably recton A New Hope. A problem with Rogue One is how the film can only be best enjoyed by a Star Wars fan. Rogue One is a decent enough war movie. The dogfights are exciting. The characters are charming and funny enough. The overall plot can’t be fully enjoyed without having seen A New Hope. In addition, the cinematic impact the film has on the future of this storied franchise also can't be appreciated by an outsider. Rogue One features the most diverse cast of any Star Wars movie... as well as the franchises more intense scenes. The mentioned scenes make up some of the best moments in a Star Wars movie to date. Rest assured the future of the franchise is in the very capable hands of Disney. Rouge One is how a franchise should make the old relevant.… Expand

30 of 51 users found this helpful3021

All this user's reviews

8

Jack97Dec 16, 2016

Rogue One kicks off the Star Wars spin-offs in great fashion. While it lacks compelling characters, it makes up for it with exhilarating action, spectacular visuals, great performances from it's cast and a third act that is none stop edge ofRogue One kicks off the Star Wars spin-offs in great fashion. While it lacks compelling characters, it makes up for it with exhilarating action, spectacular visuals, great performances from it's cast and a third act that is none stop edge of your seat excitement and intensity. It also leads into "A New Hope" perfectly without feeling forced. This is a Star Wars Story worth telling and worth experiencing on the big screen!… Expand

22 of 38 users found this helpful2216

All this user's reviews

6

SpookydarrenDec 16, 2016

So, just wanted to make a point and say that some of the best bits were missing from the trailers. Jin saying "that's what I do, I rebel". She sounded like a bad ass but the character ends up being somewhat diminished imo. Also the face offSo, just wanted to make a point and say that some of the best bits were missing from the trailers. Jin saying "that's what I do, I rebel". She sounded like a bad ass but the character ends up being somewhat diminished imo. Also the face off with the tie fighter on the tower looked spectacular but was also cut. On the plus side the new droid and Vader were AWESOME. Film saved in the last five minutes. Looking forward to the Han Solo story.… Expand

9 of 36 users found this helpful927

All this user's reviews

10

jc18241Dec 16, 2016

It was the best in the franchise right behind Empire Strikes Back. The cast was amazing. The story was amazing. The cameos were awesome. This movie is so damn good on so many levels. The only complaints I have are the slow opening and theIt was the best in the franchise right behind Empire Strikes Back. The cast was amazing. The story was amazing. The cameos were awesome. This movie is so damn good on so many levels. The only complaints I have are the slow opening and the movies score. Music could have been better. Nothing more to complain about after that.… Expand

10 of 27 users found this helpful1017

All this user's reviews

10

Moviereviewer15Dec 16, 2016

Little note: my review will be spoiler-free

HOLY S--T! What I just saw blew me away. What I came out of was "Star Wars" at it's best. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is, IMHO, now the TRUE best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back".Little note: my review will be spoiler-free

HOLY S--T! What I just saw blew me away. What I came out of was "Star Wars" at it's best. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is, IMHO, now the TRUE best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back". Set before the original "Star Wars" from 1977, this film shows us a true WAR in "Star Wars" by having spies of the Rebel Alliance go up against the evil Galactic Empire to steal the plans to their original Death Star. And, since Gareth Edwards, the director of this movie, really wanted to deliver a war film set in the Star Wars universe, akin to "Saving Private Ryan" and "Black Hawk Down", he was telling the truth coming out of what I saw. It really feels like a Star Wars movie in a whole new way. I will admit that I enjoyed "The Force Awakens", but, after a while, I've come to realize that while it is watchable, it feels safe in some ways. This one, really showed how original, different and new it was while being familiar when it knew too and it payed off big time in what I consider it's most serious, if not darkest, Star Wars ever. The entire cast of this movie shines. Felicity Jones plays Jyn Erso, our lead hero with strong brashness but such vulnerability you can't help but feel bad for her when you see how things play out for her in the film, especially with her father Galen (played by the always devious yet charming Mads Mikkelsen). Diego Luna puts effort into his role as Cassian Andor and makes it as memorable as his character's arc in the film is. Riz Ahmed really shows how conflicted his character, Bodhi Rook, is as he delivers playing a former Imperial cargo worker now struggling to redeem himself. Donnie Yen," and Jiang Wen are awesome as the pair of Force-believing warrior Chirrut Imwe and trigger-happy gun-wielding Baze Malbus. And, Alan Tudyk as the sarcastic reprogrammed droid K-2SO rounds out the cast to help make this movie work in their best way and they all get moments to shine in such iconic ways. Ben Mendohlson really showed his determination playing Orson Krennic in a different kind of villain for "Star Wars" to show. Darth Vader when he shows up really shows in this time where the film is set, he really is the Vader everyone grew up with. But, I cannot get off the hook without saying how impressed I am by Forest Whitaker's performance of my most anticipated character from this movie, Saw Gerrera from "Star Wars: The Clone Wars". While he was in this movie for more or less of what I expected, Forest Whitaker REALLY got into character as Saw and portrayed him in all the ways he was portrayed when we first saw him in "The Clone Wars". Also, if you generational Star Wars fans are hoping for ties to the Prequel Trilogy instead of just the Originals, well you're in luck, as we get appearances of not just characters and actors from the Prequels but also planets from the Prequels as well. We also visit new planets that help expand many parts of the Star Wars mythology such as where people stand in believing the Force and what it took to build the Death Star. Plus, be on the lookout for appearances and mentions of certain characters and ships from "Star Wars Rebels", which you can watch on Disney XD, when it returns with new episodes in January. Also, two important characters from the Original Trilogy make a return in some of the most well-made VFX ever put to film. I'm not spoiling who they are, so, you'll just have to watch for yourself. And, you'll feel like you're part of the action especially once you get to the epic space battle in the climax of the movie. Finally, Michael Giacchino really delivered with his score for this movie that really brings out the action and emotional development these characters go through to complete their mission as well as bringing something new to score in "Star Wars" while sprinkling familiar scores when needed. Overall, if you're looking for a phenomenal "Star Wars" film, "Rogue One" is that. It truly delivers on taking huge risks, like abandoning the traditional opening crawl, and finding its place into the "Star Wars" universe while remaining a standalone movie that really doesn't need to setup anything for the future of "Star Wars". And, that's good. I hope this movie is successful enough to do more riskier Star Wars spinoffs, especially if Episode IX is the last of the core Star Wars saga. I hope you all love this film, because I most certainly did. This film is for all generations of Star Wars fans. Go see it. You'll be glad you did. 5 stars. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
10/10… Expand

27 of 55 users found this helpful2728

All this user's reviews

9

colilla1972Dec 16, 2016

Una buena película con uno de los mejores cierres del universo de Star Wars, -tal vez los mejores últimos 20 minutos de toda la franquicia-. Es cierto algunas cosas pudieron ser mejor pero como muestra del potencial del Universo De Star WarsUna buena película con uno de los mejores cierres del universo de Star Wars, -tal vez los mejores últimos 20 minutos de toda la franquicia-. Es cierto algunas cosas pudieron ser mejor pero como muestra del potencial del Universo De Star Wars es muy buen comienzo y la película es muy divertida.… Expand

8 of 18 users found this helpful810

All this user's reviews

9

mrushing02Dec 16, 2016

“It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire.

During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire’s ultimate weapon, the“It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire.

During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire’s ultimate weapon, the DEATH STAR, an armored space station with enough power to destroy an entire planet.”

These words are the first thing that anyone ever saw of Star Wars as the film opened in 1977 and now Gareth Edwards has imbued them fully in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story.

Hope Anew

The Rebellion’s struggle just got worse, as it learns that the Empire has created a world-killing weapon named the Death Star. The Rebellion finds itself on the knife’s edge between hope and despair. The council of the Rebellion cannot decide what to do. Do they risk it all by trying to steal the plans, or do they resign themselves to defeat and despair? Jyn challenges the council, “What chance do we have? The question is what choice”. She implores the council to remember that if they do nothing then they’ve sealed the fate of the galaxy and that evil this great cannot go unopposed. It brings to mind Edmund Burke’s famous saying, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” She encourages them with a refrain Cassian Andor said to her earlier in the movie, “Rebellions are built on hope”. Hope changes everything, it reminds people that the way it is, is not how it has to be. Hope is the spark that, if kindled, creates the fire of change. Change is possible, but it takes sacrifice, determination and some times, lives to see it come about.

The beauty of the film is that hope is not just a figment of the heroes imaginations. The Force seems quite active, even without the Jedi. It’s moving in mysterious ways and bringing people together that can make a difference. This band of rogues does the impossible, one chance at a time, succeeding in their goal and setting in motion something that will see the end of the Empire.

The Movie

Gareth Edwards made a Star Wars movie that feels completely different and yet utterly familiar, all at the same time. Like The Clone Wars, Edwards uses cinematic inspirations to pull in the war movie genre and make it a Star Wars movie, emphasis on the war. The nods to great war films of the past are all there and they work perfectly. On top of that you feel the “Star Wars” seeping out of every single frame. The Ghost from Star Wars Rebels can be seen at least 4 times, Cham Sydulla is called for over the coms at Yavin 4, the sets feel like they came out of a lost arc of The Clone Wars, Saw Gerrera has an important role and so much more. The point here is that Edwards lovingly knits together the history of the Prequel and the Original trilogy and it’s seamless.

Star Wars, when it’s at it’s best, is stretching what it means to be Star Wars by taking other genres and telling a story in the Star Wars universe that aligns with the themes of the saga. Edwards achievement is nothing short of incredible, the movie feels like the Maker’s fingerprints are all over it and it’s the highest compliment that could be paid to the movie.

The characters are outstanding. K-2so is the best new droid since R2 and Jyn, Cassian, Chirrut, Baze and Bhodi are all welcome additions to the Star Wars canon. Darth Vader’s scenes are chilling (and let’s stop here and just geek out completely that Vader’s castle is finally on screen!) and perfectly played, just enough to leave you wanting more.

The music by Giacchino feels like a welcome addition to the Star Wars franchise, it’s much like The Clone Wars music and only references familiar themes in snippets yet that’s a good thing. The movie needed it’s own identity and the themes he created feel familiar and distinct, perfectly matching the spirit of the movie.

I’ll get personal, this movie is everything I wanted a new Star Wars movie to be. Pushing the boundaries of what it means to be Star Wars while at the same time respecting the history and the franchise as a whole. Here’s to hoping the rumors of Edwards wanting to direct a Kenobi movie are true. Rogue One is rated 4.5 upside down Death Stars out of 5.… Expand

7 of 19 users found this helpful712

All this user's reviews

10

G3RDec 16, 2016

This movie is simply amazing. Walking out of the theater I wasn't thinking about how great it was but rather, "I have to watch this again NOW". If you were not around when episode 4 hit the screens then it would be hard to imagine how itThis movie is simply amazing. Walking out of the theater I wasn't thinking about how great it was but rather, "I have to watch this again NOW". If you were not around when episode 4 hit the screens then it would be hard to imagine how it changed our culture. People didn't ask you if you have seen Star Wars. They asked you how many times you have seen Star Wars. A feat that movie makers have not been able to accomplish since. This move IS episode 3, despite it's billing. Was it perfect? No. Good luck finding that on a screen today. If you are a fan of Scifi you will not be disappointed. If you are old you will feel again what you felt upon watching the original.… Expand

12 of 28 users found this helpful1216

All this user's reviews

0

MAGA_ManDec 16, 2016

Hugely disappointing. Disney isn't even pretending anymore that this whole project isn't just a cash grab on their part (why cast 2 famous Chinese actors and barely use them? Gotta get that foreign box office!). The story adds little ifHugely disappointing. Disney isn't even pretending anymore that this whole project isn't just a cash grab on their part (why cast 2 famous Chinese actors and barely use them? Gotta get that foreign box office!). The story adds little if anything to the universe, frankly it clashes badly with the tone and themes of the original trilogy. The action is dull and same-y; I never really felt worried about what would happen next, even when characters were actually getting killed. Above all it's virtually impossible to invest in the characters or care what happens to them, partly because they're bland and poorly developed, and especially because we've all seen this stock lineup of Hollywood-diverse plucky underdogs a million times before (fighting white male Space Nazis of course. Whether Marvel or Star Wars or whatever, these days the enemy must always be white male Nazis) and it's beyond a cliche at this point. Note how even positive reviewers all admit that the most likeable character was the droid. Felicity Jones was especially awful, a scowling, frigid blank slate light-years away from the feisty, vivacious Princess Leia of the original movies. She gives pop culture heroines a bad name.

The bit at the end about struggling to get a signal and transmit a file was especially embarrassing. So cliched you half expect it's about to turn into a Verizon ad.

I think the NY Times said it best: "the only force here is force of habit". The whole reason Disney bought this franchise (because apparently "Star Wars" is now something you can just buy like an old couch on Craigslist) is because they know people are so addicted to the brand that they'll line up at the theater even if their new movies are mediocre. They're going to keep cranking this crap out until everyone is sick to death of Star Wars. I don't see how anyone can be OK with that and still call themselves a fan of the series.… Expand

39 of 102 users found this helpful3963

All this user's reviews

10

PeterAlexanderDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is gritty, charming and exhilarating. Gareth Edwards takes considerable risks in the very first Star Wars spinoff, all to huge success. Whilst the characters are played brilliantly, and the story is thrilling from start to finish,Rogue One is gritty, charming and exhilarating. Gareth Edwards takes considerable risks in the very first Star Wars spinoff, all to huge success. Whilst the characters are played brilliantly, and the story is thrilling from start to finish, it is the action and the gorgeous look of the film that stand out.… Expand

12 of 27 users found this helpful1215

All this user's reviews

3

KaneRobotDec 16, 2016

Almost fell asleep halfway though. The ending was a nice nostalgia payoff, but I'm wondering why I spent 2 hours and five minutes to get to it.

A film you could skip completely and it wouldn't matter one bit. I wasn't a big fan of TFA, butAlmost fell asleep halfway though. The ending was a nice nostalgia payoff, but I'm wondering why I spent 2 hours and five minutes to get to it.

A film you could skip completely and it wouldn't matter one bit. I wasn't a big fan of TFA, but I'd rather sit through that twice back to back than this once more. Just a "nothing" movie.… Expand

40 of 110 users found this helpful4070

All this user's reviews

0

tzkoliDec 16, 2016

So where to start ? This isn't some new era Female leads an incompetent bunch of male protagonists. This is films smarter than that, this is a tired rebel intelligence officer leading a rag tag band of rebels from to try and achieve aSo where to start ? This isn't some new era Female leads an incompetent bunch of male protagonists. This is films smarter than that, this is a tired rebel intelligence officer leading a rag tag band of rebels from to try and achieve a specific mission from most the film. This Film is an amazing star-wars movie if not a little heavy for some viewers eg young kid. This isn't a kids movie this is a movie for grown ass Starwars fans that might understand the complexities of war.… Expand

9 of 45 users found this helpful936

All this user's reviews

8

AfNinoDec 16, 2016

The first half of the movie seemed a bit weirdly edited and all over the place, but the last act is amazing. Truly gives you a perspective of war that no other Star Wars movie has ever done. A great time at the cinema overall.

8 of 21 users found this helpful813

All this user's reviews

10

AdamCMDec 16, 2016

The best Star Wars since Empire. Everything worked. The action was fantastic. The creative score was incredible. The characters were fun. It was just a fun movie!

34 of 65 users found this helpful3431

All this user's reviews

10

HasskthugDec 16, 2016

Everything ever wanted from a Star Wars movie. I'm rooting for both the bad guys and the good guys. Funny, exhilarating and tragic. It adds deeper meaning to Episode IV. Thank you Gareth Edwards

25 of 45 users found this helpful2520

All this user's reviews

10

rumburDec 16, 2016

Great movie, with nice story, and a lot better feeling than so called "episode seven". The only flaw is soundtrack, which is variation of the original SW music. But the ending was great, and the movie really tie-in with episode 4. TommorowGreat movie, with nice story, and a lot better feeling than so called "episode seven". The only flaw is soundtrack, which is variation of the original SW music. But the ending was great, and the movie really tie-in with episode 4. Tommorow i'm going again. It's the best Star Wars movie since "Return of the Jedi".… Expand

26 of 52 users found this helpful2626

All this user's reviews

10

fgallindoDec 16, 2016

The TOP3 : 1 - ROGUE ONE; 2 - STAR WARS (Yes, it is! the one and only Star Wars); 3 - THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK. And the rest? WIPE THEM OUT, ALL OF THEM!

13 of 29 users found this helpful1316

All this user's reviews

8

S0LiDDec 16, 2016

Star Wars Episode VII and JJ Abrams look very ridiculous in front of Rogue One, I've really enjoyed much more watching Rogue One than the non sense Ep VII

11 of 25 users found this helpful1114

All this user's reviews

9

leelustigDec 16, 2016

People loved The Force Awakens but have problems with this movie? The whole world is insane. Here is a list of things this movie did better than last year's installment. - Actual establishment of the Imperials being in control, and a need forPeople loved The Force Awakens but have problems with this movie? The whole world is insane. Here is a list of things this movie did better than last year's installment. - Actual establishment of the Imperials being in control, and a need for a rebellion/resistance.
- A tentacle monster that had an actual purpose.
- Actual stakes and a genuine concern that the heroes won't make it out alive.
- Intricate exposition not being reduced to ridiculously basic confabulation.
- Dialogue that wasn't cheesier than a cheese-plate.
- Cinematography that actually shows details of aliens. - Important robot/alien characters (that speak).
- Mads Mikkelsen. - Actually having something to do with the original trilogy. I could also reduce this list to two words: Darth Vader.… Expand

13 of 27 users found this helpful1314

All this user's reviews

0

AnonymousNoNameDec 16, 2016

Disney is letting garbage writers further destroy starwars by pushing their own agendas and fan-fictions. I also love the content theft from Legacy material.

Garbage.

44 of 125 users found this helpful4481

All this user's reviews

8

originaljoelDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is a very well shot film. The CGI is without doubt some of the best I've ever seen. Seeing Vader again was awesome and not to mention Peter Cushing being brought back to life with flawless CGI.

This film also exceeded my expectations. It was original, well paced, well acted and overall a much grittier and realistic take on Star Wars.

My Rating 8.6/10… Expand

12 of 26 users found this helpful1214

All this user's reviews

9

Randall0Dec 16, 2016

So we all new going into this movie what the end result was. What we didn't know was how this story progressed into episode 4. I can honestly say this movie was amazing, the effects, the nods to the original trilogy and the effort they madeSo we all new going into this movie what the end result was. What we didn't know was how this story progressed into episode 4. I can honestly say this movie was amazing, the effects, the nods to the original trilogy and the effort they made to make the look and feel of this film fit seamlessly with the original Star Wars film. It is a movie that stays with you long after you walk out the door. I am astounded that the critics have not recognised this film with much higher ratings overall. It most certainly deserves it. Deserving of a "classic" rating and one for the collection. 9/10. Hard to find fault.… Expand

11 of 24 users found this helpful1113

All this user's reviews

7

Ryan_ParkinsonDec 16, 2016

Rogue One does a lot of things and does all of them well, but not well enough.

The visuals here are off-the-chart good: the effects are unparalleled (practical Star Destroyers looked jaw-dropping), the photography is gorgeous and theRogue One does a lot of things and does all of them well, but not well enough.

The visuals here are off-the-chart good: the effects are unparalleled (practical Star Destroyers looked jaw-dropping), the photography is gorgeous and the production design is ace. Director Gareth Edwards large scale, space opera moments are truly wondrous, but his smaller scale scenes, particularly dialogue exchanges, falter. There's this uncomfortable sense that his in scene direction was precise and purposeful, but his handheld camera's coverage pretty much butchers every conversation into a messy blur of words in which the basic topical beats and decisions are given no weight whatsoever. It doesn't help that not a single character is fleshed out beyond a singular facet of personality and that no actual team banter occurs, but I quite often found myself unsure of what certain exchanges were even about or why they were needed.

It's a shame, because the handheld camera looks SO great. I'm surprised that there wasn't more of a Children Of Men influence on the film. It would have been great to see civilians joining the fight so that each battlefield felt organic and truly like a galaxy at war. A greater focus on the intimate details of the Rebellion's guerrilla warfare style and teh suffering of the innocents while on Jedha could have nailed this. The score as well suffers from using the wrong theme tonally from the original trilogy to adapt. The score isn't bad, but its tonally incoherent with the film, as if Giachinno was told to make it more positive than Desplat's darker work. Building the score around a darker, lower-tempo version of William's "Imperial March" like the second trailer did would have been far more effective. It's just never ominous or rousing enough.

With all that being said, this film is a remarkable technical achievement and an enjoyable experience. Regardless of people's issues with The Force Awaken's and Rogue One, it's incredibly exciting to see Disney actually bringing real movie magic back to cinemas.… Expand

10 of 24 users found this helpful1014

All this user's reviews

7

triple_coDec 16, 2016

This is a grittier, darker Star Wars film than the main saga. The battle's feel more real, gravitated and weighted. Visually, the film is absolutely stunning and deserves full marks. Some of the scenes in Rogue One are some of the best I'veThis is a grittier, darker Star Wars film than the main saga. The battle's feel more real, gravitated and weighted. Visually, the film is absolutely stunning and deserves full marks. Some of the scenes in Rogue One are some of the best I've ever seen in a Star Wars film. The beginning of the movie however, is muddled and lacks focus. There are too many characters with not enough development, and too many things happening to really get your teeth into. While the second half of the film will blow audiences away, the first feels a little clunky and the re-shooting seems obvious as you watch.

Although it has a shaky start, the film is definitely worth watching, especially for Star Wars fans. There is much to enjoy here but it comes with some flaws. If you forgive it for it's pacing and character misfires, this is a solid entry in the franchise.… Expand

20 of 32 users found this helpful2012

All this user's reviews

7

dkminusDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is an amazing movie, but it takes some time to become it. It has an uneven, and somewhat uninteresting beginning, a fun but rather incongruous middle, and a spectacular end. Along the way, it both suffers and benefits from the worldRogue One is an amazing movie, but it takes some time to become it. It has an uneven, and somewhat uninteresting beginning, a fun but rather incongruous middle, and a spectacular end. Along the way, it both suffers and benefits from the world in which it's set.

Rogue One is a unique journey through a very familiar world. It has everything you'd hope to see in a Star Wars movie - space battles, stormtroopers, new alien races, lovable droids, rogues turned heroes. Yet it still manages to feel fresh and different from the rest. I personally felt that this was one of the film's strengths, that it was something different. However, the film also pays a little too much homage to Star Wars: A New Hope, its immediate successor in the Star Wars chronology. There are several character from the original film who appear in Rogue One, a couple of whom are digitally rendered. It doesn't work. At all. It's rather unsettling to look at, and I'd much prefer they just recast those roles if they're set on using those characters.

Once the film builds momentum, it's delightful to watch. The humor is great, the action is thrilling, and there are some genuinely real character moments. Sadly, the film is also punctuated throughout with heavy-handed attempts to inspire (you've never heard the word "hope" used so many times in a single screenplay). And there is an evil lair which is laughably on the nose. It couldn't get more stereotypically cartoonish.

Despite its faults, Rogue One is a great time. It's definitely worth seeing in the theaters, but be aware: it might be a little intense for young kids.… Expand

29 of 49 users found this helpful2920

All this user's reviews

10

jamiejoyceDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is, quite frankly, MAGNIFICENT. Disney deserve praise for not shying away from allowing the filmmakers to apply some bold story decisions in the third act. This isn’t some neutered, watered down version of Star Wars – this is StarRogue One is, quite frankly, MAGNIFICENT. Disney deserve praise for not shying away from allowing the filmmakers to apply some bold story decisions in the third act. This isn’t some neutered, watered down version of Star Wars – this is Star Wars at its most uncompromised. Thrilling, beautiful and occasionally surprising, this is the prequel the fans deserve.… Expand

12 of 32 users found this helpful1220

All this user's reviews

9

jonasionDec 16, 2016

Look, I'm a massive Star Wars fan, but I've been nothing but disappointed since the mid-eighties really. Episode 7 was somewhat okay for me, but it left a lot of **** in its wake. Rogue One goes about explaining some key things that have leftLook, I'm a massive Star Wars fan, but I've been nothing but disappointed since the mid-eighties really. Episode 7 was somewhat okay for me, but it left a lot of **** in its wake. Rogue One goes about explaining some key things that have left the nerd-verse puzzled about the original Star Wars - Episode IV - A New Hope (as it was later dubbed). Rogue One goes about explaining that and it does so really well and it takes no prisoners.… Expand

7 of 19 users found this helpful712

All this user's reviews

10

BoabDreepsDec 16, 2016

I was 12 when the last decent Star Wars movie came out.
I've been burned ever since: Special Editions, Prequels, Force Awakens (sorry, it sucks).
So the bar was pretty low going in to the midnight screening. 10 minutes in and I rememberI was 12 when the last decent Star Wars movie came out.
I've been burned ever since: Special Editions, Prequels, Force Awakens (sorry, it sucks).
So the bar was pretty low going in to the midnight screening.
10 minutes in and I remember turning to my friend (another 70's child) and saying "I don't know about you, but I'm f**kin lovin this already".
By the end I couldn't get out of the seat. I was an emotional wreck. I had another emotional breakdown in the car on the way home.

To everyone involved in making this film:
Thank you for making Star Was awesome again

I'm going again tonight, just to make sure I didn't dream this.… Expand

51 of 84 users found this helpful5133

All this user's reviews

0

TgcDec 16, 2016

AFAIK Kyle Katarn stole the first Death Star plans, there is no mention of that fact. This movie doesn't fallow Star Wars continuity at all, it is just a Disney fantasy.

23 of 68 users found this helpful2345

All this user's reviews

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

User Reviews