Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

9

BozmoDec 20, 2016

Is movie fits perfectly into the Star Wars film line. Being a prequel to A New Hope, it had a lot to live up too, the film did not disappoint. The action and CGI were amazing. The only problem I had with the movie is that some of theIs movie fits perfectly into the Star Wars film line. Being a prequel to A New Hope, it had a lot to live up too, the film did not disappoint. The action and CGI were amazing. The only problem I had with the movie is that some of the characters were not as memorable as The Force Awakens. But all the other pros make any cons seem like nothing.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

holeemcDec 20, 2016

As a massive Star Wars fan, and a fan of traditional war films, this one was a slam-dunk for me. Seemingly uncompromised by the reshoots, this was a slow build that leads to an exhilarating final act that reaches an almost orgasmic crescendo.

2 of 10 users found this helpful28

All this user's reviews

6

Rebecca31Dec 20, 2016

So here's a Star Wars movie that's not really a Star Wars movie. You get a whole bunch of new and dispensable characters most of which I've completely forgotten, a story that's missing the wow factor, a great soundtrack and a decent cast.So here's a Star Wars movie that's not really a Star Wars movie. You get a whole bunch of new and dispensable characters most of which I've completely forgotten, a story that's missing the wow factor, a great soundtrack and a decent cast. Don't get me wrong I didn't hate this movie, there was some scenes I thoroughly enjoyed and honestly most of them were towards the end. Yet overall I was a little underwhelmed but can take comfort in the fact that this is not the worst Star Wars movie you could watch.
However, let us not forget what this movie really is...a cash grab. A filler movie with some nice little bits of nostalgia to remind you that oh yes this IS a Star Wars movie. The inevitability of Disney owning Star Wars is we'll get a new movie every year and that might sound like a dream come true now but in the year 2040 with the 32nd Star Wars movie you'll wish you never heard the words Disney and Star Wars together. I'll recommend this because it's worth a watch once but if you're a Star Wars fan you'll go see this no matter what anyone says.… Expand

9 of 17 users found this helpful98

All this user's reviews

9

Doomsday4766Dec 20, 2016

After watching this film I am elated. Here I am thinking that Disney ruined the originality of Star Wars for me by making the no risk, recycled, nothing new 'Farce Awakens'. To be sure, I had a bit of skepticism still when I entered theAfter watching this film I am elated. Here I am thinking that Disney ruined the originality of Star Wars for me by making the no risk, recycled, nothing new 'Farce Awakens'. To be sure, I had a bit of skepticism still when I entered the theater. Would this film cautiously retread the story about some space peasant blessed with magical abilities? Would I have to sit though a nostalgia driven plot that makes no sense? to my relief I was spared any disappointment, and was treated with one of the most originally grounded Star Wars films. The beginning of the movie I felt was the slowest, but before long I was drawn completely into the plot. Then when the action begins it really doesn't stop, right up until the closing scene.

It gets a 9 from me for being a truly self contained story, no real loose ends here, just one entertaining ride. -1 point for overdoing CGI a tad , and to all those who called out the music as a negative. At least it had some original scores, and I was able to actually hear it. Unlike in that awful 7th movie...… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

6

TVJerryDec 20, 2016

As action flicks go, this one is too slow and talky, but does have a decent final battle. As Star Wars flicks go, it's a standalone with little of the legacy characters, a story that's tangential to the originals and no scrolling text at theAs action flicks go, this one is too slow and talky, but does have a decent final battle. As Star Wars flicks go, it's a standalone with little of the legacy characters, a story that's tangential to the originals and no scrolling text at the beginning. A group of rebels sets out to steal the plans to the Death Star before it can destroy planets. The expected cool locations, technology and creatures dance around the edges, but there are no breakthru visuals or individuals to make this one stand out. The drama that dominates the first 90 minutes isn't especially compelling or interesting. Overall, it continues the legacy without bringing much new or exciting to its inheritance.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

commanderclauDec 20, 2016

You are going to cry, but you are going to be happy about it. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story it's one of the best Star Wars' movies (maybe the best one).

7 of 14 users found this helpful77

All this user's reviews

3

NooogieDec 19, 2016

I feel asleep for about a half an hour watching this. It was missing something for me and the fact the main protagonist was basically a midget kind of took me out the the immersion. When it gets right down for it I only popped for about 5I feel asleep for about a half an hour watching this. It was missing something for me and the fact the main protagonist was basically a midget kind of took me out the the immersion. When it gets right down for it I only popped for about 5 mins of the movie. And we all know what that was.… Expand

8 of 17 users found this helpful89

All this user's reviews

7

iampattyjackDec 19, 2016

In five years I will appreciate Rogue One more than I do today.

This is the first Star Wars movie with a major departure from the formula that viewers have come to expect from the franchise and it is instantly noticeable. These majorIn five years I will appreciate Rogue One more than I do today.

This is the first Star Wars movie with a major departure from the formula that viewers have come to expect from the franchise and it is instantly noticeable.

These major departures have both a positive and negative impact on the movie as a whole.

Throughout the film you will find yourself comfortable in the world of Star Wars for a moment, then the movie will make it aware you are watching the creation of someone else with their own ideas.

Watching this movie in the theater I felt conflicted as these new ideas were meddling with something that I have grown up with for years.

However after a night to sleep on the matter, I came to the conclusion that some of my perceived flaws in the movie will become all too important in the coming years.

Those who are a die hard Star Wars fan will notice this instantly.

The opening of the movie is drastically different than what you would expect from anything in the Star Wars universe. It delves straight into a frantic affair rather than the slow crawl of subtext that appear throughout the series.

There is a lack of screen wipes during scene changes, this might sound like a small detail, but in the grand scheme of Star Wars movies, this has always been a staple that felt extremely jarring for a first time viewing.

It’s these small details that don’t feel familiar which will have people annoyed or at least scratching their heads.

Also Darth Vader makes a pun. No, that should never happen again.

That being said, I appreciate the movie nonetheless.

This movie is not afraid to take risks and I greatly respect that.

While the previous filming decisions seem a bit jarring, many of the other changes to the Star Wars formula feel like a welcome addition to the universe.

The Rebel Alliance is shown to be something other than an angelic being to rid the galaxy of the big bad guys.

They make deals with extremists, fight guerrilla wars and hide within civilian populations. I love the expansion of ideals and it even warrants the idea that some were even content or happy with the empire in comparison.

The agents and main characters aren’t necessarily the good guys, they are just fighting for what they believe in. Many of them even fight for what the viewer may perceive as the wrong reasons, but the right cause.

There is so much in this movie that makes the conflict and galaxy feel more real than the main series.

Especially the third act, which is hands down the best part of the movie.

The final battle was magnificent from beginning to end, it felt like watching the Vietnam War in space. That is about the best thing I could ever imagine.

I could have had the entire movie be the story be about some random soldiers on this battlefield and it might have actually been a better film.

Unfortunately because of the highs of the third act it makes the first two acts look weak in comparison.

The film has some major pacing issues in the first act. Nothing quite seemed to flow properly and getting all the information before the film moved along to the next scene was challenging.

It feels like first portions of the movie were solely there to get towards the final act. That inherently makes it less fun to experience.

The film needed a couple more relaxed moments for the characters to build who they were for each other. They never quite felt like they cared for each other which in a movie about a squad of characters is really needed. The best comparison I can make is to Guardians of The Galaxy. The characters never had that moment of interaction that made them bond together through exploits which Guardians of The Galaxy pulled off with flying colors. This movie needed that to really put the exclamation point on the third act. In summary, I enjoyed the hell out of Rogue One despite some pacing issues and lack of character empathy. If you didn’t enjoy The Force Awakens because it felt like a retread of the original film, this will likely be a much more enjoyable affair. As a movie, it feels like a fresh take on the Star Wars universe. While that doesn’t always work the way intended, it sets up the ability for other directors and filmmakers in the future to do the same. I greatly respect that idea and look forward to see what is next. View the video version of this review here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGi71YjuxQA… Expand

6 of 11 users found this helpful65

All this user's reviews

9

Armorwing01Dec 19, 2016

I liked the Force Awakens, it had likable characters like Finn, Kylo Ren, and a few others. It lacked originality and just could not grip me as well as some of the others. This movie kicked a**, so much a**, very likable characters, Vader,I liked the Force Awakens, it had likable characters like Finn, Kylo Ren, and a few others. It lacked originality and just could not grip me as well as some of the others. This movie kicked a**, so much a**, very likable characters, Vader, amazing fights, fun references, Vader, plot twists, Vader, and a logical and emotional conclusion. Cannot wait for more Star wars Spin offs.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

1

iceman994Dec 19, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. So I already know that the whole movie will do the same like the previous Disney creation and I had true on that. So what was the problem again. The story switching scenes so fast. Ununderstandable characters. Why are the characters sometimes know nothing then know everything. Why Disney killed the Force real franchise now anybody can use Force. Which is a joke. Are we getting a good movie ever by Disney or Star Wars will be the most challanging movie for others except Lucas. Lucas was the god of Star Wars nobody can remake them ever. Thats the truth. Anybody who blame me think about the mood of the Lucas version Star Wars movies. Then watch Disney one. They have so much difference. There are many kind of people in the world. I can understand who loves crap movie. I am not the person who watch anything and say it was good. No critics need to blame the person to make a movie which worth to watch. I hate Hollywood right now killing old franchise. Same DC Universe do. Also Marvel with Spiderman or X-Men. How easy to ruin something but how hard to make something new and perfect. Thats why we can easily destroy anything it is the easiest thing. Because we built it and we can destroy.… Expand

10 of 22 users found this helpful1012

All this user's reviews

10

LarrynautikDec 19, 2016

I am an old fan since before the Prequel Trilogy, and this Prequel Trilogy never enjoyed me a lot. I was disappointed by Episode 7. Where was the Star Wars spirit ? And then, I saw Rogue One. For many reasons, this is an excellent Star Wars.I am an old fan since before the Prequel Trilogy, and this Prequel Trilogy never enjoyed me a lot. I was disappointed by Episode 7. Where was the Star Wars spirit ? And then, I saw Rogue One. For many reasons, this is an excellent Star Wars. The scenario is very well-written, with a lot of unexpected developments. Special effects are very satisfying excepted for two characters. It doesn't affects the global felling however. Let's say it all : there's despair, hope, glory and emotion, humor, with a lot of winks towards all the other episodes. Most of all, this episode fit between espisodes 3 and 4 is perfectly articulated and acts as a real connection. I'm fully convinced this is a real Star Wars episode and should be seen by any fan or anyone else interested in Star Wars. I really enjoyed the show and the universe depicted. It looks believable and esthetically in absolute harmony with the "old" Star Wars movies, even if new ships are shown and new heroes too. There's also this specific and so appreciated urban chaos and crowds full of aliens on multi-storied cities. But you also get a lot of urban wars and exciting space fights.

To be honest, even the end of the movie will keep your breathe until the very last second. Impressive until the end, graphically and scenaristically. That's all, just a very good Star Wars an old fan appreciated a lot. It's clearly impossible to do better than that. Great job guys ! Shall all the following episodes be done like that !… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

10

SumwhenDec 19, 2016

Personally I was quite shocked out how things panned out in this - kudos to Disney and LFL for making a gutsy and uncompromising war movie. And although the character development wasn't it's strong point, the characters were all at leastPersonally I was quite shocked out how things panned out in this - kudos to Disney and LFL for making a gutsy and uncompromising war movie. And although the character development wasn't it's strong point, the characters were all at least likeable and Chirrut and Baze were genuinely great. Really ballsy given the circumstances.
AND DARTH VADER THOUGH!!!!!!… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

5

mintloDec 19, 2016

I didn't like it. I enjoyed Star Wars 7, and the original three. It seems like they were in a rush to make a Star Wars movie and just slapped a script together. Also too loud, way too much score and not enough pauses without music to takeI didn't like it. I enjoyed Star Wars 7, and the original three. It seems like they were in a rush to make a Star Wars movie and just slapped a script together. Also too loud, way too much score and not enough pauses without music to take in the subtle star wars sounds. Too much exposition as well. I get this was targeted at the kids but even though the original Star Wars is more mature I loved it as a kid. Disney, please don't be in such a rush to recoup your 4 billion dollars that you release sub par Star Wars films.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

easterfieldsDec 19, 2016

I loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sellI loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sell this story and they are perhaps one of the most interesting motley crews in Star Wars history. It was so fascinating to see how everything fit together just prior to A New Hope and this film actually answers several questions fans have had for nearly 40 years. It really does fit in nicely with the Star Wars mythos and it's exciting to watch! Some have criticized it for being too dark. Well keep in mind that this time period was the peak of the Empire's dominance. The Rebel Alliance had to make a huge stand to start any kind of challenge against it's tyrannical grip over the universe. Thus war was inevitable. This movie does an amazing job of conveying the dark period in which everything was set and it does an even better job of showing how even the smallest sacrifices during such a period can cause huge effects. People die. That is part of war. What really shocked me about Rogue One is that there really is no Force, no Skywalkers, no Jedi, and yet it feels more true to the original films than the last 4 have. It breaks every rule of a Star Wars film and yet managed to do everything right in the process. There are so many pleasant surprises in watching this that every fan should be smiling ear to ear by the time it's over. Yes there are sad moments, but this isn't supposed to be the feel-good movie of the holidays. It's supposed to fill in a spot that existed prior to the very first time Star Wars was introduced to us. Not only is it successful in this regard, but it introduces characters that will long go down in the history books of how the Empire crumbled. Don't miss it!… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

5

nukachuDec 19, 2016

The movie is full of super effects and tons of fighting scenes, this is normal for typical science-fiction film. I like the fact that, director doesn't try to promote the movie using sexual scenes, and this is not kind of "heroes shouldThe movie is full of super effects and tons of fighting scenes, this is normal for typical science-fiction film. I like the fact that, director doesn't try to promote the movie using sexual scenes, and this is not kind of "heroes should survive", but I didn't find this movie interesting, there are funny moments in the movie though.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

1

namelessDec 19, 2016

No heart, nothing that made you love the series to begin with. It is just talking, then a gun fight, more talking, another gun fight, repeat, repeat, repeat. I fell asleep at one point. I don't know whether the screenwriters are that bad, theNo heart, nothing that made you love the series to begin with. It is just talking, then a gun fight, more talking, another gun fight, repeat, repeat, repeat. I fell asleep at one point. I don't know whether the screenwriters are that bad, the director butchered what they gave him, or the producer doesn't care except to deliver a product. Disney should be paying you to watch. See it on TV. The production values are excellent but it is emotionally vacant except for some cliches. Believe it or not it is even worse than the Lucas Star Wars films of the 90s and I thought nothing could go that low again. If you have never seen a Star Wars movie and are 12 years old or yonger then this movie is OK. What I couldn't figure out was why does Rey act like a boy for the whole movie? She dressed like a boy, talked like a boy, and acted like boy. Are we now ashamed of being a woman? Also two major plot holes. The first one is 3 minutes in which is a terrible sign that they think the audience is stupid.… Expand

17 of 48 users found this helpful1731

All this user's reviews

4

KaptenVideoDec 19, 2016

I have never truly enjoyed any of the "Star Wars" movies. Seen all of them except "Force Awakens" – which I tried to watch on a flight and got so bored after about eight minutes that switched to something else. Not that it was badly done. II have never truly enjoyed any of the "Star Wars" movies. Seen all of them except "Force Awakens" – which I tried to watch on a flight and got so bored after about eight minutes that switched to something else. Not that it was badly done. I just couldn't find anything to care about.

But I can dig why many people like or even love the Lucas seminal creation. It's the same reason why many still love Elvis Presley, The Beatles or, say, Frank Sinatra. When the first "SW" came out in 1977, it was phenomenal cultural event in a sense that today's cinema lovers can't quite fathom.

The age of blockbuster movies had barely begun, the sci-fi movies in general had never been mass friendly – it was a dry, intellectual or just downright trashy field, and always geek-oriented. And the wider audience had never had a chance to experience such a big-scale, detail-rich, lovingly crafted made up universe. Sure, the screenplays have always been mediocre. Even "SW" creator George Lucas has freely admitted that he was not a good writer. But fans were happy to satisfy with style and quantity because these movies sure do have lot to offer to the eyes: places, characters, action, design, details... Don't forget that blockbuster movies were still a new thing. The next trilogy, released from 1999 to 2005, never received the same amount of love because people were much more used to screen spectacles than in 1977-1983. They still admired the visuals and Lucas's team's world creating skills. But it just wasn't the same.

And that may be the reason why I never cared about "SW". I stepped on Lucas's train so late that I had already my firm beliefs about what good story means. I had seen seen many big screen extravaganzas already and acquired a taste for more depth than usual blockbusters are prepared to offer.

Still, I decided to give "Rogue One" a go. The reviewers have already praised the fresh approach where we have a strong female hero and how there's no clear line between good and evil side before and how plays out like a war movie, etc.

But watching it myself, I instantly remembered why I don't care about "SW": * new faces on screen but the same style of wooden acting and dialogue that feels like characters just reciting their lines instead of really talking to each other

* characters have almost zero depth so there's no really argument for being interested in them, if you are not "SW" fan which makes you interested already

* I didn't acquire a cohesive sense of time and place, just a series of scenes which don't always connect to a greater whole and often don't even have a proper flow. * For most of the time, "Rogue One" felt like a bunch a short movies that are connected by faces and places. Like a picture book where you have to concentrate only on one or two pages at a time. And many of those pages are not even exciting, maybe due to hammy acting and depthless characters.

* The only part that feels like more than a series of loosely connected scenes is the rebel attack which can really be compared to war movie in its own right.

What I liked about "Rogue One" was this female hero everyone's talking about who never plays on the gender card but acts like a soldier on the battlefield as everybody else. And the visuals are cool as always, all these pictoresque places, interesting details, awe-inducing battles. And, of course, the war movie part. And the heartfelt prologue. So for me, as a person who doesn't swallow "SW" hype easily, there is maybe an hour of adventure interesting enough for watching and another hour and ten minutes just enduring and hoping it will not get too boring.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

5

KeithAJohnstonDec 19, 2016

This film generates mixed feelings. On the good side the visuals excel, the ending is superb and there are some wonderful moments. It adds significantly to the impact of Star Wars: A New Hope by focusing on the sacrifices made to get theThis film generates mixed feelings. On the good side the visuals excel, the ending is superb and there are some wonderful moments. It adds significantly to the impact of Star Wars: A New Hope by focusing on the sacrifices made to get the plans to Leia.

On the downside the film fails to generate an emotional connection with the characters, which is its major sin. The main character is poorly done, the story is complex and unconvincing and its overlong and boring at times. A missed opportunity.… Expand

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

9

thibDec 19, 2016

The best stars wars since 1983, I was realy scared after the force awakens, because lets be honnest it was more like a remake of the first movie from the 70's, But this one has a original scenario and have a great story, the fact that thereThe best stars wars since 1983, I was realy scared after the force awakens, because lets be honnest it was more like a remake of the first movie from the 70's, But this one has a original scenario and have a great story, the fact that there is no happy ending at the end make it better the movie is all about sacrifice.
it's realy make the perfect conection with the "new hope" plot great movie great star wars thanks god after the force awakens… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

8

Musicman_pamvDec 19, 2016

I was close to giving Rogue One a 10, but I am a tough grader and there were a few things that distracted me from giving it that high a rating. This is the Star Wars movie I have been waiting for since the original trilogy. Episode VII didI was close to giving Rogue One a 10, but I am a tough grader and there were a few things that distracted me from giving it that high a rating. This is the Star Wars movie I have been waiting for since the original trilogy. Episode VII did not deliver the same feel that Rogue One does. This "feels" and looks like Star Wars. Some of the recreations of settings from Ep. IV are very well done. The quibbles I have are few and mostly technical, not story or script related.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

4

Luckypaddy_Dec 19, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Me: Good fan fiction. Fanboy: It is official!
Me: Oh boy. It is fan service from beginning to end. The characters seem interesting, but I don't know I haven't had time to know them. Except that robot. He didn't take **** from anyone and was a straight shooter. I liked that.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

7

Theone789Dec 19, 2016

It was a story that did not need to told. If you watch episode four you know the rebellion got the plans at a great loss. The grafics that were used to to bring people from episode four back were terrible. The story line did show the darkIt was a story that did not need to told. If you watch episode four you know the rebellion got the plans at a great loss. The grafics that were used to to bring people from episode four back were terrible. The story line did show the dark side of the rebellion so I can respect that since there is always a dark side to any side of any war. ingrew up on this and credit the Star Wars movies to a part that made me want to be a soldier and to be apart of something greater then myself so to the rogue one story line thank you for showing that average people with great courage can accomplish great things.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

7

dc127Dec 19, 2016

I will preface this by stating that I did not like TFA at all. I thought it was a complete retread of previous movies. I went into Rouge One with low expectations. I was pleasantly surprised. Most of the story is quite predictable, you canI will preface this by stating that I did not like TFA at all. I thought it was a complete retread of previous movies. I went into Rouge One with low expectations. I was pleasantly surprised. Most of the story is quite predictable, you can see almost all of the twists and turns coming from a mile away. The characters are ok, but not great. This is both a plus and a minus to the movie. Part of the reason I did not like TFA is that the characters were overly dominant to the movie. If you didn't like Finn or Rey the movie was hard to watch. None of the Rogue One characters stand out either way. No one really bothered me, but I also didn't care about any of them in any significant way. The movie is almost a paint by numbers remake of a half dozen WWII movies. I however liked this to a certain degree. I left thinking the movie did its job. It told a one off story that was engaging but not over the top. It gave me some space battles and ground fights that I could enjoy without setting up a series of other new movies (boo TFA).… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

0

GOJIRIUMDec 19, 2016

I grew up with Star Wars... I'm a huge fan, and I enjoyed this movie like a little kid. It has a proper vibe! This a perfect transition for a new generation of fans!

10 of 43 users found this helpful1033

All this user's reviews

10

BitmouseDec 19, 2016

I really enjoyed the movie.

However, the movie doesn't contribute to the canon in any meaningful way.

150 characters long dong sing-a-long song. Yeap

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

10

twall3Dec 19, 2016

I didn't care for the director's "Godzilla" movie (too much serious dialogue from characters I didn't care about), so I wondered how likeable this would be. I didn't like Rogue One ... I LOVED it (and the characters)! While it started on theI didn't care for the director's "Godzilla" movie (too much serious dialogue from characters I didn't care about), so I wondered how likeable this would be. I didn't like Rogue One ... I LOVED it (and the characters)! While it started on the slower end of things, by the time the movie ended and the credits rolled, my mind was blown. I knew it took place somewhere between SW3 and SW4, but what they did, how they handled it - hard to describe. Something like this: you go to the zoo to see a Lion, but before you leave, you've got your head in it's mouth looking down it's throat - unexpected up close view. Wow.… Expand

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

10

CommonsenseDec 19, 2016

Critics are pretty wrong on this one. Characters could have been developed a little more, but the tension, cinematography and, overall story didn't disappoint. No one in my theater seemed unhappy and many even clapped an cheered and this wasCritics are pretty wrong on this one. Characters could have been developed a little more, but the tension, cinematography and, overall story didn't disappoint. No one in my theater seemed unhappy and many even clapped an cheered and this was 2 days after the premier on a 6:30 showing.… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

9

sindhurajatDec 19, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is that movie which takes even a casual viewer, who has at least viewed the cinematic flicks, deep down into the Star Wars history/mythology. Seeing Grand Moff Tarkin and Princess Leia brought back to the screen, as we first saw them in A New Hope, is such a feast for the eyes.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

imnamineDec 19, 2016

No, there's no lightsaber fight in this movie. But is the movie any good ? Yes, it is. It's what I call a perfect spin-off. Photography is astonishing, characters are good enough, battles and landscapes on point.
You can really feel EdwardsNo, there's no lightsaber fight in this movie. But is the movie any good ? Yes, it is. It's what I call a perfect spin-off. Photography is astonishing, characters are good enough, battles and landscapes on point.
You can really feel Edwards put his on style in the movie.
So no, this isn't a masterpiece, but it's indeed a great movie and that's what I expected from it.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

forumsDec 19, 2016

My favorite Star Wars movie. I love this movie because; darker and more real.
birth of Death Star. Very scary Darth Vader. very scary laser from Death Star. no happy ending. sad ending. I don't enjoy lightsaber battles, I enjoy seeingMy favorite Star Wars movie. I love this movie because; darker and more real.
birth of Death Star. Very scary Darth Vader. very scary laser from Death Star. no happy ending. sad ending. I don't enjoy lightsaber battles, I enjoy seeing people killed by Darth Vader with lightsaber. People try to survive and escape from Darth Vader. People try to survive and escape from laser from Death Star. There should be movies like this not like Star Wars 1,2,3,7. There should be Star Wars every year. I can't wait.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

7

McOtzDec 19, 2016

Es una buena pelicula con el problema de que tira continuamente de fanservice para que el espectador, preferiblemente fan, no note lo mas mínimo las carencias de la película.

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

3

mondainaiDec 19, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. - Too many obvious Easter eggs. Gareth and the writers think we enjoy these. We don’t. Star Wars had ZERO references to other SW movies, so you don’t need them. You think you are being clever or cute, you are not. They are annoying and make me cringe. - Rolled my eyes constantly, I don’t need to see the morons from the Cantina scene who picked a fight with luke. 1) It takes me out of the movie as I realize immediately you are waving a giant easter egg in my face. 2) This is stupid as was this tatoonine? Am I to assume the drunk degenerates where smart enough to leave on time? - Death Start plans on a single removable hard drive, far away from armed guards in a tower that just so also happens to have a communications tower that can upload assumingly a non imperial encrypted code? What drugs was Mr. Weizz taking? - Too many clichés, the bad guy shows up at the end and is about to shoot the heroine when someone off screen shoots him, seriously this happens in like 30 other movies, can you think of something more original? Obviously not. - Main Character isn’t remotely likeable. Our first impression of the grown up version of her? She punches the people who save her. Seriously? Who does that who is likeable? Nobody. The likeable hero, would have had a chance to escape, but risked herself to save a child on board. Yeah, a bit of a cliché, but considering the movie is full of them, one more wouldn’t have been so bad. - The Forest Whitaker Character is pointless. He is paranoid of spies coming to kill him, but when sees obvious danger, he decides to stand and face the CG wall of sand death? Lame… - They should have snuck on board the death star to get the plans. The blind guy should have turned out to be a Jedi and fought Darth Vader, movie would have been 10x better on that alone. - I am every bit as big of a Fan as the next person and as a real star wars fan and not some bot who gave it a 10. If Disney keeps trying to stuff their politics and lecture us rather than entertain us, then they are going to lose us and ruin one of the best franchises ever made. For what? It is almost as if the teenage humanity majoring older sister who hated hearing her younger brother play with his star wars toys went and got a job in the lucas film story department, just so she could get revenge. Please for the love of all that is good and decent, stop ruining this franchise or I am going to become rich and buy the rights to “The Notebook” and everything else you care about and do remakes to exact revenge!!… Expand

6 of 14 users found this helpful68

All this user's reviews

9

SchroederRockDec 18, 2016

After a ho-hum Episode 7 that rehashes the plot of Episode 4, I wasn't sure I had much faith left in Disney's ability to resurrect this franchise and push it forward. Rogue One has completely changed my mind on that. One can make a case thatAfter a ho-hum Episode 7 that rehashes the plot of Episode 4, I wasn't sure I had much faith left in Disney's ability to resurrect this franchise and push it forward. Rogue One has completely changed my mind on that. One can make a case that the first 30 minutes of the movie are a bit forgettable but ultimately they create the groundwork for the rest of the film, which connects phenomenally with Episode 4's first moments. Where Rogue One succeeds over Episode 7 is the visceral feel of the film. This is absolutely a space epic with futuristic technology and tons of gloss but somehow it all comes off with a little grit and loads more adventure than last year's Episode 7. Rogue One shows that there are stories worth telling in between the major events seen in each Episode film. Even if you're not an avid Star Wars fan, you can appreciate what Rogue One is, but tuned-in fans will love seeing several familiar faces of the early Rebellion. Whatever the next Star Wars film is, bring it one!… Expand

13 of 19 users found this helpful136

All this user's reviews

7

the12blackDec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One does a lot of things right, but tallies up a few missteps along the way.
The good: Well-acted; great special effects that enhanced but did not distract; and solid action.
The Bad: Music added nothing to the story/was completely forgettable; plot was more complex than in needed to be.
The Ugly: ZERO emotional attachment to any character, good or bad.

Should be a 6 but threw in an extra bone for the Vader action towards the end.… Expand

12 of 20 users found this helpful128

All this user's reviews

8

FierceBETTYDec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Far from a perfect movie, Rogue One is an entertaining Sci-Fi action romp. The Characters are all likable and relate-able though their introductions did seem a little rushed. The biggest criticism I have is that at times it seemed that it wasn't sure what tone it wanted to have. There are moments that are dark that hit a perfect tone for the dire story of the movie and then there are times where a heroic almost joyful fanfare plays (reminiscent of the OG Trilogy) and it just feels out of place with the scene. One scene in particular was the biggest offender, When the Rebel Hammerhead cruiser sacrifices itself to take out one of the star destroyers and open the shield gate, the music is bouncy and has a twinkle to it... NO, several dozen if not hundreds of Rebel sailors just sacrificed, willingly might I add, their lives to hopefully open the shield gate. That needed to be somber or heroic. And it was not. There were a few other instances of this happening but not as dramatic as what I just wrote. Other than the tonal issues at times, I feel the direction and acting in Rogue One was exemplary. I feel it sets a good foundation for the "offshoots" of the Star Wars franchise and I'm looking forward to what Lucasfilm and Disney have to offer down the road.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

6

johnny5aliveDec 18, 2016

Not good. Lazy and overdone fan service. Vader casting was bad as he's not big/imposing enough. Tried to shoehorn diversity for the sake of making marketing people at Disney happy. The score was meh. The actual story/screenplay was justNot good. Lazy and overdone fan service. Vader casting was bad as he's not big/imposing enough. Tried to shoehorn diversity for the sake of making marketing people at Disney happy. The score was meh. The actual story/screenplay was just boring with poor banter and acting. The CGI for Tarkin and Leia was bad. Just stop. No need for that Leia scene. No excuse for them to not just cast a look alike. Locations jumped around way too much in the beginning. Zero chance a stormtrooper could not track Jyn to the rock inside the cave seeing as the ground is dirt and her footprints would have literally led them to her. This is a movie a Marvel fanboy eats up. Loud, bright colors, corny one-liners. I'm going to obviously watch it a second time and it's possible it might improve. Highly doubtful though. If so, a 7 is the highest I could go.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

10

Monkey_NutzDec 18, 2016

If you're an original trilogy purest this movie will hit you in the gut and hold you enthralled for just over two hours. THIS is the Star Wars movie we've been waiting for since 1985.

While not perfect, it is the perfect antidote to the lastIf you're an original trilogy purest this movie will hit you in the gut and hold you enthralled for just over two hours. THIS is the Star Wars movie we've been waiting for since 1985.

While not perfect, it is the perfect antidote to the last four weaksauce episodes (yeah, I'm talking to you too Force Awakens). I cheered, I cried, my mouth dropped in awe. I fell in love with Star Wars all over again, something I'd written off as impossible. As a previously bitter fan, this one movie has instilled within me the driving theme of this wonderful film, hope.… Expand

4 of 11 users found this helpful47

All this user's reviews

9

MD5774Dec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is easily the best movie of 2016. I don't know what movie critics saw , this movie was really good . The trash that was Force Awakens has been erased and has this has given moviegoers hope in Disney and the Star Wars franchise .JJ Adbrams should be ashamed and embarrassed the trash he put on screen last year.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

stevegroundhogDec 18, 2016

This movie is for true Star Wars fans. It is the best movie since Empire. Perfectly ties in between Episode 3 and Episode 4. They even brought back Peter Cushing from the grave (albeit freaky and cool at the same time). There is no loveThis movie is for true Star Wars fans. It is the best movie since Empire. Perfectly ties in between Episode 3 and Episode 4. They even brought back Peter Cushing from the grave (albeit freaky and cool at the same time). There is no love story, no stupid characters like Jar Jar, no annoying little kid who loves Pod Racing, no anorexic chick named Rey who can wield the Force within three minutes, no whiny Kylo Ren with daddy issues, it is a perfect Star Wars movie. It is purely Empire vs Alliance in a Dirty Dozen type atmosphere. Go see it!… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

9

SKDDec 18, 2016

This is the Star Wars movie we wanted last year.

Instead of checking off a predetermined set of boxes tied to people’s nostalgia and following the contours of an older Star Wars movie, Rogue One focuses on an original, compelling story withThis is the Star Wars movie we wanted last year.

Instead of checking off a predetermined set of boxes tied to people’s nostalgia and following the contours of an older Star Wars movie, Rogue One focuses on an original, compelling story with the nostalgia interlaced. There were some moments where the drama feels forced (and there was enough of them that it prevented me from giving it a 10), but overall the motivations and desires of the characters are believable. Far from being omni-competent, the actions of the main characters cost them deeply by the end of the movie. I also liked how one of the characters, a droid called K-2SO, provides intelligent humor and comic relief without making a mockery out of himself (the way C-3PO does). And when the nostalgic moments came up with old characters, they feel more natural rather than tacked on.

A short note: It’s also worth pointing out that the underlying themes in movies can provide passing commentary on the times in which the creators live. The original Star Wars with its original Death Star provided a subtle commentary on weapons of mass destruction during the height of the Cold War and the nuclear weapons age. As I watched this movie and saw the scene where rebels ambushed storm troopers in the streets of a desert city, it made me immediately think of the Syrian Civil War. I don’t know if that was done on purpose, but it definitely feels like a powerful, passing commentary on the times in which we live.

Moving along, I am pleased that this film puts the ‘Wars’ back in Star Wars. You won’t see any Jedi doing back flips with lightsabers here. Instead, at the end of the movie, there is a very long and intense ground and space battle that defines what Star Wars is all about. It goes back to the Star Wars roots in a way that the Force Awakens tried to do, but fell short on.

I hope that the people making Episodes 8 and 9 take note. This may have been an anthology film, but it is hands down the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy and has set the new gold standard for what a Star Wars film should look like.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

2

crazyjackelDec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a massive disappointment. It's only saving grace is the advanced cgi that really adds a touch of beauty, but besides from that i absolutely hated it and feel like there is something i don't get that makes this movie a 7.8. In the theater, i clapped at the end when the main characters die, good riddance. I feel that most of the good reviews are based on it's star-wariness, but it is practically an abomination composed of various scenes that already exist in star wars, except for the slug mind-rape scene, that scene was pretty god damn original, great way to make the movie exciting. Also killing off all the characters does not make them interesting. But hey Disney, keep making more of these, if anything this movie has proven that we will consume anything from Disney, no questions asked, including some f-ing meth, cause meth makes you intelligent.… Expand

9 of 19 users found this helpful910

All this user's reviews

10

VLaZzzDec 18, 2016

Rogue One is a direct prologue to the original trilogy.
It sets up the story perfectly, giving an insight into the struggle and desperation of the Rebellion, emphasising the urgency for the destruction of the Death Star.

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

7

SammifxDec 18, 2016

Does a lot of things right, and some crtical ones wrong. The biggest negatives 1) score and music editing (timing of music with whats happening on screen is completely offputting and doesnt help in setting the tone
2) first half introductionsDoes a lot of things right, and some crtical ones wrong. The biggest negatives 1) score and music editing (timing of music with whats happening on screen is completely offputting and doesnt help in setting the tone
2) first half introductions and character motivations were eehhh.
3) inspiration speeches from people we just met 4) cgi tarkin,(other character from new hope) and vaders voice.
5) didnt' really care for the characters apart from the main trio (madds included).

Positives
the second half .. and the environmental/battle/ship graphics- wow. just wow. see this in imax if possible just for the visuals. also, the nice connection at the end to the new hope. all in all id have given this an 8.5 if it had been scored well . still, heaps better than VII… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

MattzoneDec 18, 2016

Just got home from the movie. Extremely good movie, BUT be aware that this is more like a war movie with the Star Wars brand. I took my 6 year old and he was very bored (he was fine during "Force Awakens"). Noting those facts, this isJust got home from the movie. Extremely good movie, BUT be aware that this is more like a war movie with the Star Wars brand. I took my 6 year old and he was very bored (he was fine during "Force Awakens"). Noting those facts, this is perhaps one of the better movies from the Star Wars brand... great acting, sets, effects and tie in to the franchise. Perhaps think of it as Star Wars Episode 3.5! Good Work!… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

0

Iserlohn14Dec 18, 2016

I really wanted to like it, but instead I'm really starting to hate Disney for what they're doing to this series. They bend over backwards to try to make everything LOOK like Star Wars, but the original sense of adventure, discovery, andI really wanted to like it, but instead I'm really starting to hate Disney for what they're doing to this series. They bend over backwards to try to make everything LOOK like Star Wars, but the original sense of adventure, discovery, and magic is gone. Do you really think kids 30 years from now will fondly recall how amazing it was watching the adventures of "Jin Erso" or "Saul Gerrera" with his mind-reading CGI slug? Cramming Vader in there was the worst of all. I mean sure he looked cool, but there was no point. It's all just very cynical and offputting. I bet Disney's going to sell a ton of merch though!… Expand

12 of 30 users found this helpful1218

All this user's reviews

0

BarronOfDuneDec 18, 2016

Way too many main characters (I guess they wanted to sell a bunch of action figures) but you never care about any of them. Same with the big final battle: it felt like an excuse to have a million different kinds of toys. Decent spectacle IWay too many main characters (I guess they wanted to sell a bunch of action figures) but you never care about any of them. Same with the big final battle: it felt like an excuse to have a million different kinds of toys. Decent spectacle I guess, but it leaves no impression and I was already forgetting the details by the time I got to the parking lot. What a letdown.… Expand

13 of 29 users found this helpful1316

All this user's reviews

10

general1109Dec 18, 2016

фильм очень хороший и интересный.Вот он на много лучше чем эпизод 7.фьмсфлджосфдшмрдфдрмфрмдшфрмсфдшрафдшрафлдоралдфралдфраодфралдфоралдфралдфафрлафафафильм очень хороший и интересный.Вот он на много лучше чем эпизод 7.фьмсфлджосфдшмрдфдрмфрмдшфрмсфдшрафдшрафлдоралдфралдфраодфралдфоралдфралдфафрлафафа

3 of 11 users found this helpful38

All this user's reviews

4

Brent_MarchantDec 18, 2016

Wow...another "Star Wars" movie...zzzzzz. Despite a somewhat promising beginning and some dazzling special effects throughout, this latest offering in the franchise quickly degenerates into yet another tired, predictable slog that goes on farWow...another "Star Wars" movie...zzzzzz. Despite a somewhat promising beginning and some dazzling special effects throughout, this latest offering in the franchise quickly degenerates into yet another tired, predictable slog that goes on far too long, provides no particularly new insights into the mythology and has an ending that's already known from the outset. Unless you're an uber fan and can't live without seeing absolutely everything in the "Star Wars" mythos, don't waste your time on this underwhelming, half-hearted effort.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

9

ArdiffDec 18, 2016

Well, I'm really waiting for this movie. I waited a very dark and adult story. And I get it. Yes, the first half of the movie is too much boring and tighten but then the narrative accelerates twice and actions happened is too fast. And ofWell, I'm really waiting for this movie. I waited a very dark and adult story. And I get it. Yes, the first half of the movie is too much boring and tighten but then the narrative accelerates twice and actions happened is too fast. And of course about battles. It a one of the massive battles in Star Wars saga, I enjoying of every single minute.… Expand

13 of 23 users found this helpful1310

All this user's reviews

10

MMBoschDec 18, 2016

Beautiful Star Wars Movie. It will fill your heart with joy and it will probably make you cry, all at the same time. Don't miss it it IMAX, it looks gorgeous.

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

1

DetharDec 18, 2016

"Rebbelions are built on hope." My hope for Disney's Star Wars died (again). Movie is slow, bland and just doesn't feel like Star Wars. Characters are shallow and are poorly developed.

There are too many stupid moments. Remember AT-ATs in"Rebbelions are built on hope." My hope for Disney's Star Wars died (again). Movie is slow, bland and just doesn't feel like Star Wars. Characters are shallow and are poorly developed.

There are too many stupid moments. Remember AT-ATs in Battle of Hoth? "That armor is too strong for blasters!" Yeah right, Galen must have tinkered with them too, because lazors are now destroying those AT-ATs effortlessly without hitting weak spots. Even ordinary blaster is enough to damage their legs. And that's just one example of many. WHAT THE #*@# GUYS?! The Empire is depicted as incompetent bunch of fools. I started to feel bad and sorry for them, not for oppressed rebbellion. Trained, regular army with unlimited funds is just clueless on battlefield (just like Disney).

The only bright side is that the movie is not as bad as "The Force Awakens". Very close though.… Expand

11 of 24 users found this helpful1113

All this user's reviews

9

gasDec 18, 2016

Great movie compared to the most recent star wars titles.
im 42 so i grew up with the originals, which ofc are legends for me.
this tilte is more mature and realistic then all the previous titles, i liked the fact there is noGreat movie compared to the most recent star wars titles.
im 42 so i grew up with the originals, which ofc are legends for me.
this tilte is more mature and realistic then all the previous titles, i liked the fact there is no clown-characters, i liked very much the plot and many aspects of the setting which are at laest a bit more "realistic" then what was used to be in the franchise.
Dont want to spoil cause here is still on theaters... anyway i like every direcotor choice in this movie.
Its defo a great movie, i could not expect somethign better afeter seing episode VII, which was not bad but not great either..… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

6

Burnouts3s3Dec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is an ambitious film that's constantly hindered by the Studio's interference. Gareth Edwards (Director of films such as the independent film, Monsters, and the 2014 reboot of Godzilla) emphasizes slow build-up, scale and a sense of melancholy in his works. Rogue One, for the most part, uses Gareth's natural inclinations and makes a film less like the optimistic A New Hope and more like the bleak Empire Strikes Back. The film centers on Jyn Erso, a daughter of an ex-Imperial engineer who designed the plans of the Death Star. When Jyn's father is captured by the Empire and Jyn's mother is killed, Jyn joins the Rebellion as a means of survival. Years later, Jyn grows up to a be a jaded cynic, turning herself away from the cause. However, when a hologram of her father reappears, Jyn joins up with the new Rebellion in hopes of finding her father.

Jyn joins up with a cast of rebels in order to fulfill her goal. Unfortunately, whether by mandate of the studio or Edwards himself, a majority of the cast doesn't receive the much needed character development needed to form a strong emotional connection to them. (I'm told that a prequel novel, Catalyst, details many of the backstories and origins of the side characters. As I recall, there used to be a time when movies had to stand alone and didn't require the aid of a peripheral novel to explain characters). The stand outs of the cast are Donnie Yen's Chirrut Îmwe, a believer in the Force who cannot wield it makes the people around him question his figurative and literal blind faith and Alan Tudyk's K-S2O, a reprogrammed Imperial droid that can't help but say what's on his mind. While neither character full develops, the actors imbue their roles with such personality, that when the possibility of "They will not come back from this mission" starts to sink in, you genuinely feel for their loss.

Rogue One ordered a number of reshoots during production. Unfortunately, many of the studio's re-shoots stick out. Just when I felt that Gareth Edwards was about to take the Star Wars movies in a different and original direction (such as in the peripheral media or even the now non-canon Star Wars Extended Universe, a series of tie-in novels, books and games deleted from continuity by mandate of Disney purchasing the Star Wars license), there's a random cameo or reference that feels so out of place that it literally took me out of the movie. For example, Jyn, early on, bumps into the two strangers Luke meets in Mos Eisley. While the cameo is fun, it does little to move the plot or the characters. Perhaps, it's a small universe after all.

And while I liked K-S2O's character, you can't help but feel every time he's in a scene, a humorous moment will be around the corner, effectively making him a comedic relief robot (I heard a poster refer to him as a Bazingabot).

As such, there are moments of tonal whiplash throughout the film. Just as the film is about to take a darker turn or a depressing outlook, a random cameo appears or K-S2O says something funny. Were these moments intended from the beginning or did the studio worry that the film was too bleak and ordered reshoots to make the affair lighthearted? We may never know what Gareth's original cut of the film would've differed from what we have now. That being said, the director takes bold risks and does things to the characters a lesser director wouldn't have done. That takes guts. Rogue One is enjoyable. It is worth seeing in the theater. But, when I hear audiences compare this to Empire Strikes Back, I really wish the narrative would've taken more risks and Edwards would've been free to do what he intended. As for now, I recommend seeing it at a Matinee.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

0

Lsherman3Dec 18, 2016

I don't know how this movie has gotten such good reviews. It was simply terrible, and I really wanted to like it. But it was just so bad on so many levels. Most notable was how Boring and predictable the story was, like a 12 year old wroteI don't know how this movie has gotten such good reviews. It was simply terrible, and I really wanted to like it. But it was just so bad on so many levels. Most notable was how Boring and predictable the story was, like a 12 year old wrote it. There are a bunch of new characters that you never get to really know or care about. The plot is just like trudging through mud. It was like watching someone play a video game. The film makers seemed to enjoy themselves while we are hanging around not at all engaged. Recreating old characters like Grand Moff Tarkin out of special effects was just dreadfully creepy. Once these digital recreations start talking the special effects reveal that your watching a digital puppet show. Its pretty bad.

I wonder if the Disney machine is hiring people to write positive reviews because this movie is just so awful to have to sit through.… Expand

11 of 28 users found this helpful1117

All this user's reviews

10

rajeev_Dec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. My review on the movie Rogue One(2016).
1.An individual can visualize and enjoy this movie in two types i. As a Normal space battle flick ii.As a star wars movie.
2.This is 2 hours of a climactic, heart-wrenching, no **** straight to the point event. Yes, I saw this movie as a star wars movie 'cause I know the story lines and characters.
3.MACHINES USED: X-wing fighters, U- wing fighters, Y- wing fighters, imperial I- class star destroyers, TIE-strikers, Resistance star destroyers,{ AT-ACT, AT-ST} walkers: cargo carriers, clone-tank.
TROOPERS USED: storm-troopers, death-troopers, shore-troopers, and sand-troopers.
4. This story is about the bunch rebellions named Jyn-Erso, Captain Cassian Andor, Chirrut Imwe, Saw Gerrera, K-2SO(actually an imperial reprogrammed machine). Bodhi Rook. named Rouge-One. these five people will make you tear up for sure, awesome char' build-up. The movie is all about stealing plans located at SCARIF(kyber crystal refining planet) from imperial and transmitting it over to rebel-alliances. If you know about the star wars- a new hope(1997), you see Princess Leia handing the death star plan Chip over to R2-D2. 5. Tone and cinematography of the movie is gorgeous, exclusively there's a char who's blind and the way camera angle is set when he senses the movement is gorgeous, even the hyperdrive chills jus chills the way fighters arrive, ships arrive, are awesomely shown.
6. There's no point in discussing the story, it's better to acknowledge the way story is executed 'cause story is straight to the point.The execution is way better, way courageous than Star Wars VII : the Force Awakens. 7. I loved this movie to the core, it's heart-breaking and hope-bringing. The third act will BLOW- YOUR MIND. 8. Darth Vader OMFG he is damn terrifying. Princess Leia is CGI of the younger version. In the end when they ask what is this ? while giving the chip.She replies HOPE. SNAP END CREDITS. GOOSEBUMPS.
VERDICT: Go, watch it, Irony I walked all the way to my home from the stop chanting " I am the force, and the force is with me" you'll get the reference after the watch. Way Way better than Star Wars VII. I loved it to the core… Expand

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

7

TagirixDec 18, 2016

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a fan-oriented movie, to my mind. I have watched all the movies, but I disliked this one because of many reaons. First, the story is very predictive, and it is not interesting at all. I know this is a spin-off,Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a fan-oriented movie, to my mind. I have watched all the movies, but I disliked this one because of many reaons. First, the story is very predictive, and it is not interesting at all. I know this is a spin-off, but still it is not worth. Second, sometimes it was so boring that I decided to sleep. Overall, I recommend watching this movie only if you are a true fan of Star Wars.… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

6

Biggs364Dec 18, 2016

Stars Wars fanatic since summer of 77, with a few disappointments along the way. (Episodes 1 &7) This one gives me mixed feelings. On the bad side: No crawl. No John Williams except a few 8 bar licks pasted in here and there. The beginningStars Wars fanatic since summer of 77, with a few disappointments along the way. (Episodes 1 &7) This one gives me mixed feelings. On the bad side: No crawl. No John Williams except a few 8 bar licks pasted in here and there. The beginning compresses about 5 minutes worth of plot into 90 minutes and despite the intermittent heavy duty action sequences, seemed somewhat boring. My bored-o-meter is usually rated on how many times I look at my watch during the film- more than once and its a dog, but I actually fell asleep (worse than looking at my watch) for about 90 seconds about 1 hour into this one! I didn't miss much.
Now for the good: Fundamentally, this movie is based on one line from what we now call "A New Hope". DV: "Several transmissions were beamed to this ship by rebel spies." The last 45 minutes gets around to this and it is a real thrill ride, ending with the perfect segue into Episode 4. Amidst the drama/action there are all the usual Star Wars things we have come to love- desperate space battles, impenetrable shields, storm troopers, AT-ATs, the Death Star, Vader at his darkest, and Episode 4 cameos left and right. I was totally satisfied with this ending. Too bad the beginning was so tedious.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

3

adamfillenzDec 18, 2016

The movie has a few nice moments of course, but when we realize that the droid K-2SO is the most memorable character (with no facial expressions) of the whole film it's a bit saddening. Of course the visuals are nicely done, but the actionThe movie has a few nice moments of course, but when we realize that the droid K-2SO is the most memorable character (with no facial expressions) of the whole film it's a bit saddening. Of course the visuals are nicely done, but the action scenes are long and boring as well as the scenes based on dialogs between them. Director Krennic is well played but very one dimensional. Chirrut Imwe's character repeating the same sentence all over again becomes really annoying after a while. There's an important Jedi temple in the movie and we don't get any information of it. We don't even see it from inside and I guess that would have been quite important for most of the fans... So all togeather I have to say it was a disappointment.… Expand

49 of 115 users found this helpful4966

All this user's reviews

4

lemonademazDec 18, 2016

The last 30 minutes or so are pretty great. The rest of the movie is mind-numbingly boring, though. Cool space battle, bad characters and writing. The Vader scene is okay aswell.

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

8

Magic84Dec 18, 2016

Weak character development is overshadowed by an original plot with an amazing third act. First act of the movie is a choppy mess, but the rest of the film over delivers.

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

8

VasotDec 18, 2016

Better from Force Awakens in my opinion and the plot is far from childish (there are no Jar Jar Binks or Ewoks or stupid kiddie stuff) this movie is way darker and dramatic and very close to "The Empire Strikes back" atmosphere. CharactersBetter from Force Awakens in my opinion and the plot is far from childish (there are no Jar Jar Binks or Ewoks or stupid kiddie stuff) this movie is way darker and dramatic and very close to "The Empire Strikes back" atmosphere. Characters are more realistic in Rogue One with their ups and downs as opposed to Force Awakens which the main protagonist there appeared as a Super-Jedi feminist that knows everything without training...… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

8

fluxmulderDec 18, 2016

Good movie. I enjoyed it much more than the Force Awakens, which felt like a rehash of A New Hope. Finally we get a fresh Star Wars movie that makes use of the best elements of the SW universe while also giving us new things to discover andGood movie. I enjoyed it much more than the Force Awakens, which felt like a rehash of A New Hope. Finally we get a fresh Star Wars movie that makes use of the best elements of the SW universe while also giving us new things to discover and enjoy. I enjoyed the ensemble cast, and as usual the visual effects and battle scenes are top notch. Some of the dialogue was too exposition heavy though, and the cutting to so many different locations got confusing. Overall though, solid movie, and a good direction for the SW movies to be moving in.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

10

BoombastixDec 18, 2016

Rogue One was spectacular and everything I wanted it to be. I consider this movie an apology for the abysmal Force Awakens and for this I can only say one thing: Apology accepted!

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

9

familyguyDec 18, 2016

Awesome is only word i can use to describe this masterpiece. It basically a war movie with star wars look. awesome character , great visual effecf and story telling. This movie is prefect missing link between ep 3 and 4. also they add aAwesome is only word i can use to describe this masterpiece. It basically a war movie with star wars look. awesome character , great visual effecf and story telling. This movie is prefect missing link between ep 3 and 4. also they add a little of Marvel sense of humor make it ez to watch for new audience . And last but not least Darth Vader super badass in this film. just go to theater and watch it u won't be disappoint… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

6

sciencehedgeDec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I have been a big fan of the Star Wars movies over the past several decades. Rogue One definitely excelled on the action side; however, the characters were flat and most of the performances quite boring---especially Felicity Jones and Diego Luna. Although I was rooting for their success in getting the plans for the death star, I felt almost no kinship or sympathy for them as characters. I would say that Rogue One was a good action movie without a soul and without the magic that most of the Star Wars movie had. The force was not with Rogue One.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

3

dpaudiophileDec 17, 2016

action is B, maybe B+ being generous. Characters are forgettable and underdeveloped. The tone would be better off if it was a mix of dark/action packed and fun/fantasy driven, but it's all dark/action packed, and especially going into Newaction is B, maybe B+ being generous. Characters are forgettable and underdeveloped. The tone would be better off if it was a mix of dark/action packed and fun/fantasy driven, but it's all dark/action packed, and especially going into New Hope, it really feels like an awkward transition.… Expand

8 of 19 users found this helpful811

All this user's reviews

10

ManofReyDec 17, 2016

I've watched the other Star Wars films hundreds of times but I'd have to rank this in the top 3 at the least. I don't know if I can edit this later but I'm going to be brief because I want this to show. Now everyone saw there was a spaceI've watched the other Star Wars films hundreds of times but I'd have to rank this in the top 3 at the least. I don't know if I can edit this later but I'm going to be brief because I want this to show. Now everyone saw there was a space battle in the trailers but it gets much better than the trailers give it service .

This has to be the best space battle ever and every actor exceeded expectations. Felicity Jones especially. Most of the music for the film wasn't that good it seemed to try and mimic John Williams trumpets and repeated notes and that was kinda stupid. I was hoping they would mix it up a bit.… Expand

8 of 17 users found this helpful89

All this user's reviews

10

SpecialK916Dec 17, 2016

I mean what else do you want? For what they had to work with I think they did a fantastic job. I just got home, so maybe I'm still high off the fumes of the rebellion, but I wouldn't put up too much of a fight with anyone that says it wasI mean what else do you want? For what they had to work with I think they did a fantastic job. I just got home, so maybe I'm still high off the fumes of the rebellion, but I wouldn't put up too much of a fight with anyone that says it was better than the force awakens.… Expand

6 of 14 users found this helpful68

All this user's reviews

7

Movie1997Dec 17, 2016

As much as I wanted to love this movie, I just couldn't. Don't get me wrong, I don't find "Rouge One" to be a bad movie by any means. It is simply a film that isn't without some flaws. Say what you want about "The Force Awakens", but at leastAs much as I wanted to love this movie, I just couldn't. Don't get me wrong, I don't find "Rouge One" to be a bad movie by any means. It is simply a film that isn't without some flaws. Say what you want about "The Force Awakens", but at least there was structure behind it. It had great dialogue, great editing, clear direction and well-rounded characters. With "Rouge One" the dialogue is not always spot on, the editing is a bit jarring at times, there's not always clear direction and there is not a great sense of care of the characters. Some of the characters from Ben Mendelshon, Mads Mikkelsen, Alan Tudyk, and Donnie Yen were much more memorable than others. Even two particular old school Star Wars characters impressed the hell out of me. At the same time, I found the rest of the characters to be nowhere as interesting. The biggest problem with "Rouge One" is that it doesn't take the time to flesh out our main protagonist's. When we get to bigger moments towards the end, there is no sense of worry or care about the fate of most of these new characters. But what ultimately makes this movie an enjoyable feast for the eyes is the action. The last thrid of this movie in particular is what everyone is going to be talking about. It absolutely looks stunning. Overall, has an interesting story, but it doesn't have as many interesting/memorable characters, or great structure in storytelling. Nevertheless, there is still enjoyment to behold. I'm going to give "Rouge One: A Star Wars Story" a B!… Expand

3 of 10 users found this helpful37

All this user's reviews

8

moebius_risingDec 17, 2016

Thoroughly a great ride.

Unless you're a repressed homosexual red-pill MRA, alt-right type, then there's no pleasing you anyway. They'll have you believe there's some communist marxist conspiracy hidden between the lines of dialogue becauseThoroughly a great ride.

Unless you're a repressed homosexual red-pill MRA, alt-right type, then there's no pleasing you anyway.

They'll have you believe there's some communist marxist conspiracy hidden between the lines of dialogue because they're mom-hating weaboo spackers and secret sexual deviants.

Remember folks, anyone that far to the right usually has something unsavory to hide and clearly a lot of time on their hands to put up fake reviews with 20 different aliases.

This is how they make themselves useful to the universe.… Expand

1 of 9 users found this helpful18

All this user's reviews

7

doroutDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One was definitely a decent movie. Far better than the force awakens. There were some loopholes, but a big one was a main core of the rebellion followed someone who had absolutely no tactical experience, no war time experience, nothing. Not even a dash of experience at all really; and any of the people who followed Jyn could have easily filled the leader role. I just didn't understand that at all. Jyn assuming command realistically and practically makes no sense what-so-ever. Don't get me wrong. I honestly don't give a F about a bad @ss female leadership role, like Lieutenant Ripley(Alien+), Selene(Underworld), Kerry Mathison (Homeland), etc. Just do it right and I have no problem.

Another issue was the rebel commander (the woman in all white, whoever she is). In the original Star Wars she was not in-charge. Princess/Senator Leia was and she was the inspiration that the rebels needed, not Jyn. Moreover, the plans for the Death Star were not transmitted, they were hand given to Leia and she hid them within R2D2.

I can go on, but people just need to watch this for themselves. I do recommend watching Rogue One despite the issues I have listed, and did not list.

Side note: I was ecstatic that there was no PC/SJW BS. Some of the screen writers were talking white supremacy so don't expect anything risible and moronic as that.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

7

GuccimayneDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I thought it was a solid movie, 7/10. The pacing was a bit too fast in the beginning, then suddenly drags in the middle, but the third act really sells the show. This makes it hard to give it above a 7, but all in all the movie was a meaningful, unique story within the confines of the star wars universe that I enjoyed. In fact I'd say this movie was executed much better than Episode 7. TFA was heavy on the nostalgia pandering but left me guessing about WAY too much relevant plot information because they were saved for the books and future movies. Unlike TFA, I didn't HAVE to watch Clone Wars/Rebels or read the novelization to understand what was going on in Rogue One. It's cool for backstory but it didn't detract from the plot of the movie in front of me. The cast was amazing and although I didn't come to "care" for all of the characters' fates because there were a lot of them, I believe they each contributed something to the mission and overall movie. They weren't just on screen cracking jokes while getting their butts handed to them (Finn). Donnie and the Droid were especially show stealers, but by far my favorite character has to be Krennic. I might just rewatch the movie just to see Darth Vader going nuts on those dudes in the corridor, ha. Lastly, I loved how they filmed the Death Star beautifully looming in the sky before vaporizing everything. The cinematography in those scenes was fantastic. Really emphasizes the psychological warfare of seeing the Death Star hanging out over your planet.

Admittedly I was concerned about the quality of the stand alone Star Wars movies since I am quite upset with how TFA turned out, but if this is how things are going to look in the future, I may continue watching Disney's Star Wars.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

kivayugimotoDec 17, 2016

Good movie; thoroughly enjoyed it! It is worth seeing it in a movie theater. Favorite character is the robot; it's dialogue responses just added to make it a fun action movie.

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

0

PrimitivePersonDec 17, 2016

Rouge One is boring kiddie garbage. "Please note that the Empire is a white supremacist organization, Opposed by a multicultural group led by brave women,” says Gary Whitta Star Wars writer, notice the complete disregard of plausibility andRouge One is boring kiddie garbage. "Please note that the Empire is a white supremacist organization, Opposed by a multicultural group led by brave women,” says Gary Whitta Star Wars writer, notice the complete disregard of plausibility and demographics. Disney can't think of anything better to do with their expensive new franchise than rehash the old and fill it with propaganda, Force Awakens was a horrible kiddy movie. So boring even all the prequels were better. Its amazing that grown adults enjoy this crap, mostly through nostalgia. Boycott Star Wars, send Hollywood a message. “I sold them (Star Wars) to the white slavers that takes these things, and…,” - George Lucas.… Expand

11 of 28 users found this helpful1117

All this user's reviews

2

BobbyBDec 17, 2016

I just walked out on this sophomoric movie. The plot line was quite weak. The CGI was good. But the writers are unequipped as far as originality is concerned. It's a tired plot with no thought other than for the action sequences which areI just walked out on this sophomoric movie. The plot line was quite weak. The CGI was good. But the writers are unequipped as far as originality is concerned. It's a tired plot with no thought other than for the action sequences which are predictable.… Expand

11 of 24 users found this helpful1113

All this user's reviews

9

MasterRileyDec 17, 2016

Rogue One is the epic story that follows a small group of rebels that steal the plans to the death star. I really liked the cinematography, special effects, action, and overall scope of this film. It is one of if not the most beautifulRogue One is the epic story that follows a small group of rebels that steal the plans to the death star. I really liked the cinematography, special effects, action, and overall scope of this film. It is one of if not the most beautiful looking Star Wars movies. Most of the new characters are really good as well and the performances provided by the various actors. The characters that stood out the most for me are Krennic, K2SO, and Chirrut. I wasn't a huge fan of Saw Gerrera and felt like some of the other characters weren't as memorable as I hoped they'd be. But after thinking about it I think thats the point of the story. This group of rebels ended up risking their lives for the greater good of the galaxy, and sometimes not being remembered after the fact is what happens in war. I only have one other main gripe with the film, and it has to do with a CGI character. I liked the writing and performance of the character I am just unsure that it feels organic enough to fit into the story. Overall these few nitpicks aren't really enough for me to feel the film is flawed because it is amazing in every other front. Especially the final act, oh man was it ever worth it. This is the prequel you are looking for.… Expand

29 of 54 users found this helpful2925

All this user's reviews

10

hawkeye766Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: a Star Wars Story is a movie far different that anything
that has ever been released under the lucasfilm name. It is completely
devoid of a crawl at the beginning for one thing; Instead it starts
with a concussive sforzando of the score, and space flashes onto the
screen, as if to say, "Here it is, what else did you expect?" I love
those bold yellow words as much as the next guy, they function as a
call to adventure, an invitation to a place far different from anything
the viewer is used to. But Rogue One is different: it's a lot less
adventurous and far more familiar than the galaxy far far away has ever
been. I mean this in the most complimentary way possible; this is a
film that puts the War in "Star Wars" in an acute fashion. Rogue One's main strength is its action. In this reviewers humble
opinion, it features the best action the franchise has to offer. Before
you cry "Blasphemy!" and slam the computer shut in rage, allow me to
explain myself. The battle of the death star in Return of the Jedi is
probably the original trilogy's best space combat. It provides a
vigorous depiction of spacial warfare, displaying the speed and chaos
of ship to ship combat. It is, however, fettered by the primitivity of
early 1980s special effects. The Force Awakens brought to the table
modern effects, but was fairly unexciting to watch due to its being a
near carbon copy of the battle in IV. The battle that serves as Rogue
One's climax is an all-new concept. Things like planetary shield gates,
message transmissions, and ramming ships are brought in the picture.
Aided by 15 or so visual effects companies Disney recruited, it looks
considerably excellent as well. Many aspects of A New Hope are also addressed. The conveniently placed
exhaust port is no longer a shoehorned plot device, but a final act of
revenge by a defecting engineer. Tarkin isn't a Grand Moff but a lowly
Governor, and we get to witness his ascension to power firsthand. Darth
Vader also plays a fairly major role in the film. Many have criticized
Edwards for his habitation of barely three scenes, but really, this
makes them special. Lack of cinematic appearance for the last 34 years
makes it that much more exciting. I struggled in containing my
excitement when I heard that mechanical rasp coming out of the pitch
black hallway of the rebel cruiser in the last scene. After all those
warnings about cell phones, I figured a boisterous scream of childlike
glee would probably be frowned upon in the establishment. When Vader's
crimson blade appeared, spreading the faces of the trembling rebel
soldiers and the hallway of that ship in rufescent, evil glow, I was
actually shaking with anticipation. Vader precedes to hurl himself upon
the hapless rebels with wieldy might. The rebels rush back, handing
off the sought after plans from man to man, as Vader slashes, chokes,
and tosses through their ranks with ease. In a moment of perfection,
the trooper hands off his precious cargo to a CG Princess Leia. "What
did they bring us?" he says. "Hope" she replies. Needless to say, I
almost cried. As I exited the theater, barely keeping my balance after listening to
Giacchino's brilliant overture, I overheard a woman talking with
dissatisfaction about the movie: "I guess it was good, it was kind of
depressing though. I mean, they all died, right?"
"WRONG!" I wanted to scream. Yes, they all die, but in a blaze of
glory. Each character receives the fitting end that I only wish Han
Solo had been given. Countless rebel giants fall, fighting for the
rebel cause. Bohdie the pilot dies wiring an antenna, Baze Malbus dies fighting with newfound acceptance of the force, and Cassian and Jyn die having passed on the death star plans. While nothing else can ever fill the place the original trilogy holds in my heart, I must admit no other Star Wars film has ever portrayed, at least this powerfully, the theme of sacrifice, and how it can pave the way for a new hope.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

9

ason313Dec 17, 2016

This is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old filmsThis is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old films without feeling derivative of them. Might also be the darkest Star Wars film to date, showing why a new hope was really needed. A great way to start off the side films.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

8

lsteeleDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. With only a few cheesy fan service moments and a long, exposition-filled first act, Rogue One makes up for nearly all mistakes with a beautiful final act and a thrilling final scene that kept me on the edge of my seat. If you are a Star Wars fan, this movie is a must see. If you're not, see it anyways.… Expand

15 of 25 users found this helpful1510

All this user's reviews

8

Muskrat147Dec 17, 2016

(In-Depth) Rating - 8.2/10

Rogue One, A Star Wars Story, tells the story of how the Rebellion captured the plans for the original Death Star. The film, which is filled to the brim with brilliant action and wonderful CGI, is a great film for(In-Depth) Rating - 8.2/10

Rogue One, A Star Wars Story, tells the story of how the Rebellion captured the plans for the original Death Star. The film, which is filled to the brim with brilliant action and wonderful CGI, is a great film for fans and film-goers alike.

Almost all of the performances in the film are well executed. The characters that these actors portray, however, are somewhat flat and lack emotional depth. Felicity Jones, who plays the character of Jyn Erso, is a wonderful addition to the many talents on screen. The character of Jyn Erso, however, is extremely weak and one-dimensional, considering that she is the main character of the film. Through flashbacks, we learn about her tragic past, and how her father was taken from her. You can't fully care about this character though, even with her backstory, and just resort to rooting for her simply because she is working with the rebellion. This happens with all of the other characters in the film as well.

Michael Giacchino's score for Rogue One (which he composed in all of roughly 4 weeks, mind you) is the main reason why this film is good. It's magnificent blend between original score and pre-existing themes (most notably, Darth Vader's iconic theme) helps make the film slightly emotional, and truly shines during the action sequences, which are impressive even without the music.

The CGI that encompasses Rogue One is arguably the best of the year. Everything from the glorious ground and space battles over Scarif to the endless amount of sets and and locations, the CGI blends almost perfectly with the live footage. However, arguably the most controversial aspect of Rogue One, is the inevitable inclusion of two motion-capture characters (no spoilers). Personally, I found these characters to be perfectly fine, minus a few (glaring) imperfections. All in all, Rogue One is not a perfect film (by any means), and definitely not as polished as last years' The Force Awakens. But the film is good (great, even), and will make for lots of fun and enjoyment.… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

10

SkeptecDec 17, 2016

My favorite star wars movie to date. I absolutely loved the new characters. The monk character being my favorite by far. I honestly couldn't think of any negatives really.

8 of 17 users found this helpful89

All this user's reviews

9

UdrakanDec 17, 2016

SPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darkerSPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darker events. Yes, this isn't some happy story, this is a WAR story in Star WARS and it's absolutely amazing. It has all what I wanted from Star Wars: Space Battles, The Force, cool lovable robots, lasers and explosions, deep characters. The Rebelion is shown from a different perspective - they are good guys, but sometimes they do shady and sad stuff to keep them selves alive. This enriches SW universe, where rebels are mostly shown as only good people. The models and CGI are absolutely amazing. I had shivers going down my spine when I realized just how big Star Destroyer is and then they show Death Star behind it. I was in awe. Skirmishes are clever and Storm troopers are more dangerous and actualy hit people, especialy the elite back ones. Music on-par with movie quality. Darth Vader is scary again! The scene with him is so epic and intimidating! I don't give this 10/10 for 2 reasons: 1)Weak start - first 15 minutes of film are not as good as the rest, It starts slowly with a remote family story, whcih I would rate 6/10. 2) A little bit of cliche stuff. Although amazingly well done, its another Death Star plot, and I had enough of Death star plot in SW. Even Force Awakens was enough. People in market agressively bumping character's shoulder and then shouting at them-I saw this in so many films, it's a small one, but I noticed it, among other nit-picks. Overall it's an amazing Star Wars film and even amazing film on it's own. I totaly recommend it. My final verdict is 9/10 - It's a must see.… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

9

ThomoriDec 17, 2016

Für mich einer der besten SW-Filme,weit vor Ep7.
Grandiose Kameraperspektiven (z.B. der Sternenzerstörer über der Tempelstadt).
Die Imps treffen zwar immer noch nicht präzise,aber wenigstens besser als in den anderen Teilen :-P Was für einFür mich einer der besten SW-Filme,weit vor Ep7.
Grandiose Kameraperspektiven (z.B. der Sternenzerstörer über der Tempelstadt).
Die Imps treffen zwar immer noch nicht präzise,aber wenigstens besser als in den anderen Teilen :-P
Was für ein Schlachtengetümmel und Vader,Tarkin und Leia wiederzusehen war es allein schon wert :-)… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

7

dtlDec 17, 2016

This is a good movie, but not even nearly as good as The Force Awakens. It is quite the spectacle, and a reasonably coherent story, but somewhat lacking in character development. It is also definitively the darkest Star Wars movie, but thatThis is a good movie, but not even nearly as good as The Force Awakens. It is quite the spectacle, and a reasonably coherent story, but somewhat lacking in character development. It is also definitively the darkest Star Wars movie, but that didn't really have much impact for me, perhaps do to the aforementioned lack of character development leading to a lack of caring about the stakes.

All I'll say about the plot is that it is a wholly original take on Star Wars, but a few times seems quite hemmed in by how it has to end. I wonder if they originally meant for it to be different, but were forced to change things for the sake of continuity.

The acting was mostly decent, but not great. I did think that Felicity Jones stood out in a good way in that department as Jyn Erso.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

10

unclebillyDec 17, 2016

As a star wars fan, not a single movie in recent history has made me as excited and amazed as rouge one has. This movie has some over extended moments that get a bit pale, and some acts may be slightly weak; but the rest makes up for it 100%.As a star wars fan, not a single movie in recent history has made me as excited and amazed as rouge one has. This movie has some over extended moments that get a bit pale, and some acts may be slightly weak; but the rest makes up for it 100%. The action, cinematography, feel of wonder is all there and better than ever. I don't think Darth Vader has ever been more Vader and I don't we have ever seen a ground battle to this scale. This isn't your regular star wars movie but definitely not in a bad way.… Expand

5 of 19 users found this helpful514

All this user's reviews

8

herewasmikeDec 17, 2016

Really enjoyed this addition to the Star Wars universe. It's a universe we're familiar with and a dark and gritty story that pays off in incredible ways at the end. There are very few movies with 3rd acts that have left me with an almostReally enjoyed this addition to the Star Wars universe. It's a universe we're familiar with and a dark and gritty story that pays off in incredible ways at the end. There are very few movies with 3rd acts that have left me with an almost immediate feeling that I needed or wanted more - and it pays off extremely well every time.

The film expands the universe to a few new planets, but what I enjoyed most about these new locations is how real they feel. They are bustling hubs, full of life and activity, a feeling that really captures how Mos Eisley felt the first time that I had seen it. Most importantly though, the Empire is everywhere. The scale of the Empire is shown off to massive degrees, and that's exactly the way it should be. There is tremendous attention to details, and you can tell these worlds were crafted with great care in mind.

The movie does seem to wear you down a bit before the 3rd act begins. Many complaints show an issue with the movie being fairly boring or snoozy, or there being problems with the dialogue. After seeing the film a couple of times, I don't think the movie snoozes as it does move from place to place briskly, but it does seem difficult for it to hold the audience's attention as we can see from other reviews. Still, this is a movie about a desperate move by the Rebellion to find out more about the Empire's super weapon, and the tone is conveyed as such. These characters are on a mission, and they have to do it quickly. The stakes are high, and because they are so high, it is what helps the final parts of this move pay off in astounding ways.

Still, the characters could have been rounded out just a touch more. The acting is all really quite good, but there's just not enough of these characters to make us root for them a bit more. It was what could have taken this film from really very good to excellent, but it's just not quite there.

But everything pays off in the final act of this film. It's a gigantic battle, and you can feel how desperate both sides are for victory. These are some of the best moments in the entire saga's history - from the beginning of the battle to the final scene. The Empire and Rebellion move like set pieces on a chess board - each strategically trying to turn the advantage, each coming up with a new surprise. Of course, there is a moment here that every Star Wars fan could not help but love, but really, the entire battle is a classic moment for Star Wars. The Battle at Scarif turns this movie from perhaps an average or dangerously below average to nearly astounding. That is how good it is. It pays off the journey to get to this point in the film, and while I didn't think it was a slog at all, I certainly appreciated the journey tremendously more so than the moments before it. Indeed, the final moments left me wanting more, almost immediately, I wanted to go back. It is can't miss stuff for any Star Wars Fan, and really, it makes the film pay off for any newcomer that might come into this universe as well. It's exciting, it's poetic, it's fan service, but it's also very fresh. Rogue One is not just a worthy addition to Star Wars - as a direct lead-in to A New Hope, it makes New Hope even more exciting in tremendous new ways. Does it have a few problems? Sure it does, but Rogue One makes up for the issues in incredible ways, and it earns its spot as one of the top films in the entire series.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

10

LerritsnowDec 17, 2016

Unexpectedly bold and brilliant. This was not the neutered,Disney version of Star Wars I was expecting. In fact this was a very ballsy movie that made a lot of uncompromising creative decisions. There were moments that called to mindUnexpectedly bold and brilliant. This was not the neutered,Disney version of Star Wars I was expecting. In fact this was a very ballsy movie that made a lot of uncompromising creative decisions. There were moments that called to mind Apocalypse Now, Saving Private Ryan and Full Metal Jacket in that last act. And in some key ways it goes evenue further than those films. Hands up - I was not expecting this to be this good.… Expand

31 of 50 users found this helpful3119

All this user's reviews

9

vertiqsDec 17, 2016

After the pretty enjoyable, but still just a copy*multiply+add_old_heroes formula of 'Force Awakens' - looks like we got back on track with this Star Wars Story, though a bit darker, then one may expect.

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

3

toughcritic1977Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I was a big fan of episodes 4,5, and 6. I loved Espisode 7; it's not my favorite, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. Rogue One is sticky, bunghole crap. The accents of the actors/actresses make it difficult to follow the dialogue and the plot. It almost feels like Disney wants to expand their audience and cater to Europeans in this film by adding accents. There is absolutely no evolution of the plot (in fact the Kyle Katarn plot is completely obliterated!) and some of the directorial choices are just plain silly (the frickin' dialogue.....lordy).

One of my biggest complaints concerns the digital dopplegangers of Grand Moff Tarkin and Princess Leia. Did anyone look at these digital incarnations..... pardon me, abominations, and maybe think they were a terrible idea. The CG version of Leia is more palatable because she is shown for such a short duration, but Tarkin is shown extensively and he looks like some awkward Japanese sex-robot trying to fool a lonely person into thinking he is real.

The plot is just a mess. The whole premise of this small group of "rogues" taking on the Empire is not in any way bravado, it just makes the Empire look they belong on the short bus. It comes across as a ridiculous suicide mission where everything goes their way. Did you really have to waste the IP Man (Donnie Yen) and make him pull that lever? Who thought that was a good idea? Overall, this a turd burglar of film. When the prequels were out a decade ago everyone pretended like they were passable when they were steaming, hot garbage. This movie belongs in the same chute. Yes it gritty, and more violent than the other Star Wars flicks, but the story is just rubbish. Gareth and Lucas should hang out and talk about more ways to attempt to ruin one of the greatest franchises ever.… Expand

9 of 28 users found this helpful919

All this user's reviews

10

deekanDec 17, 2016

Great.great.great! Everything I wanted, yet so much more. Some of the best war scenes in any fantasy film, let alone star wars! Edwards is one to look out for.

8 of 18 users found this helpful810

All this user's reviews

9

DCharlesDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A fun, exhilarating Disney space adventure. The film works on almost all levels, particularly the CGI created Peter Cushing, Princess Leia, a fantastic final battle and an unforgettable scene with Darth Vader.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

4

AxeTDec 17, 2016

"The Force Awakens" though not the worst in the series was the weakest on story since it was a thinly disguised rehash, and of course story is the most important aspect of any narrative movie. This one is even worse pertaining to story. It"The Force Awakens" though not the worst in the series was the weakest on story since it was a thinly disguised rehash, and of course story is the most important aspect of any narrative movie. This one is even worse pertaining to story. It looks fantastic yeah, and has a reality to the photography that goes beyond even the last entry. That's the progression of technology. Stunning visual effects used to mean something, but now since it's a given for not only the genre but all big studio fare (and is expected particularly from this series which started the whole VFX blockbuster long running trend) what matters more than ever is the story-telling. This thing is so predictably formulaic in its telling of a small backstory alluded to in the original film, it offers practically no surprises at all. No story surprises that is. There is nothing really in this feature that one doesn't automatically intuit from the trailers. It's another connect the dots enterprise with all the little winks to fans which actually somehow shrinks the entire legacy every time they close in this vast universe by keying into every little story detail they can find from the old films. Plot beats arcane canon acknowledgments any day nerds!

How many times can we watch the same repetitive action tropes no matter what galaxy they're set in and still be thrilled? Continuous action and spectacle is not good story craft. Too much "action" equals boredom. This is a real problem for the medium in general, I understand, but it must be fought. For example, why not get bold and creative and go into some strange subplots revolving around certain characters? Go unexpected every chance! That's good story-telling. That's what "Game of Thrones" does. That's why that is far superior story-telling nowadays than "Star Wars" is. Diversity in casting is only a diversion from the real task which is all that matters, story. It's not that the casting here is a problem, it's just that it's irrelevant no matter how much attention it may get. The fact this movie has the fewest stars yet in the cast is not necessarily a problem either, but without big stars or familiar characters to pull you along and give personality to the generic proceedings it gets very dull. And most detrimental of all, this suffers from the same wretched problem the prequels and last year's reboot sequel did. In the case of the prequels, playing out mysterious and intriguing backstory by actually rendering and extending what was a couple lines in the original script into a bloated forefront has killed the magic once there. What was huge has become somehow small in so doing. By the same token with Episode VII, seeing what happens to beloved characters well into the future only serves to dampen our imaginings of them. In both cases, it only taints the original couple films from way back. Hey this is the very nature of sequels and prequels I know, so there's no solution other than to either do them so exceedingly well that they transcend this problem or don't do them at all, especially if dealing with classics or returning after prolonged periods of time. Or just keep putting out stuff like these last two movies which are good enough, sound enough productions to still make a fortune based on an overwhelmingly large and beholden fan base but in the long run will ultimately continue to harm the franchise and damage its value.

It's too bad because this is a sophisticated product with the conceit of a really good war mission story cleverly extracted from the seed planted in the original 1977 film. The tone is right, serious but light enough here and there. The problem is it's one hell of a slog through with a lot of watch checking! There are flourishes, but nothing that can come close to saving a sophisticated audience from either being bored out of their minds or lying to themselves that this was an entertaining couple of hours. Be honest with yourself. There are a couple very powerful fleeting moments. If the whole movie was on such level it would be the best! As it stands, it made me want to play the virtual reality game version instead of sitting through endlessly recycled narrative. The story has to grip more than ever these days or it's a waste of time, because we have seen it all over and over and over!
The best movies for kids are the ones that adults can also love. The first two "Star Wars" movies were that like we'd never seen before. Unfortunately the magic has never been re-captured since.… Expand

3 of 10 users found this helpful37

All this user's reviews

9

mlebeau12Dec 17, 2016

This movie takes a long time to settle in, but a lot of that is due to the fact that so many new characters and worlds must be introduced. Once the movie settles in, it is non stop action. The third act rivals and 30 minute stretch in theThis movie takes a long time to settle in, but a lot of that is due to the fact that so many new characters and worlds must be introduced. Once the movie settles in, it is non stop action. The third act rivals and 30 minute stretch in the Star Wars saga. This movie is darker than other Star Wars films and also provides a much murkier divide between good and evil.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

10

theRobotDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. "In the grim darkness of the galaxy far, far away, there is only war."

This movie is so much different than anything you have ever seen from Star Wars. It's like guys at Disney got inspired by Game of Thrones attitude to plot armor and decided to do something similar in their movie. And the fact that their movie is 7+ didn't stop them at all.

Seriously, this movie plays with your mind by making you think it will be yet another rehash from previous parts. Once again we get an orphan, who gets adopted, who apparently is rich in force and whose relatives are kidnapped by the empire. At the begginning we get loads of miracles, stormtroopers are as inaccurate as always and we are made into thinking it will be like that for the whole movie. Except it's not - at some point the plot armor for characters starts to get worn out and falls from them, leaving them fragile and unprotected. First insignificant characters start to die. Then gradually more significant ones. Eventually we aren't even sure about the fate of main protagonists, but we are still getting hints that they might survive. And then it turns out they don't. That's when the whole tragicness of this situation hits us. They are not superheroes, not another reincarnation of Han Solo and Luke Skywalker, that will get miraciously rescued from almost every situation. They are just desperate guys with nothing to lose, doing their suicide mission. Flashbacks of them saying various stuff, that might spoil the final ending hits you like a goddamn train and you get really, really depressed. If you took away the details from this movie, you would think it's the description of some Warhammer 40k novel, because how grimdark it is. But like WH40k, it's much more than that. It's a beautiful tale about hope, fighting against all odds, sacrifice and heroism. For me it's probably the best Star Wars movie since Empire Strikes Back and who knows if not the best Star Wars movie ever.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

3

wet_pigeonDec 17, 2016

Movie jumps around in the beginning, establishes no emotional connection, does a lot of "telling" instead of "showing".

By the time the action picks up pace you have no reason to care about any of these people. It should have been a simpleMovie jumps around in the beginning, establishes no emotional connection, does a lot of "telling" instead of "showing".

By the time the action picks up pace you have no reason to care about any of these people. It should have been a simple story, but they found a way to **** it up.… Expand

14 of 33 users found this helpful1419

All this user's reviews

10

theexarDec 17, 2016

After the disappointment from the Force Awakens I went to the cinema with very low expectations for Rogue One. However, the movie far surpassed them. I expected cheesy moments, hollow motivational speeches, badly adapted setting. It was noneAfter the disappointment from the Force Awakens I went to the cinema with very low expectations for Rogue One. However, the movie far surpassed them. I expected cheesy moments, hollow motivational speeches, badly adapted setting. It was none of these. Apart from an unconvincing martial arts character, everything in Rogue One was Star Wars from the beginning to the end. Great humor, memorable cameos and references, intensive action scenes and all of this - without overdoing it. Awesome work!… Expand

6 of 16 users found this helpful610

All this user's reviews

9

sevenoftwoDec 17, 2016

Story/Characters

I thought that this film is very strong in it's story and characters. Nothing is held back in this film. The Rebels and Imperials are both fighting hard and dying while attempting to reach theirs goals. The tone of thisStory/Characters

I thought that this film is very strong in it's story and characters. Nothing is held back in this film. The Rebels and Imperials are both fighting hard and dying while attempting to reach theirs goals. The tone of this film is serious and thoughtful. Each protagonist, while not given a great deal of screen time, has a distinct personality and worldview that is displayed through their conversations and behavior. Visuals/Music

The visual effects and music are, in my opinion, top notch. While the visual style is different than previous Star Wars films, this is an intentional choice and it works for this film. Action sequences are easy to follow (no excessive shaky cam or wild, rapid panning) and the cinematography and framing are excellent. The sense of scale is impressive and CGI effect shots are mostly very well done. If you're able to view this movie while keeping in mind that it is new and different in some ways, I think you'll enjoy it. The music is not by John Williams, but it is clearly inspired by his work and it feels entirely appropriate for a Star Wars film. In other words, this is the best that Star Wars music can be without simply reusing existing John Williams' existing material (which would have enjoyable but truly lacking in creativity).

Overall

This may be my favorite Star Wars film and I say that as a fan of the series. It is an adult-oriented film and could be called "bittersweet". I found it powerful and emotionally moving while also still being fun and exciting. If you find joy in watching epic space combat scenes as I do, this is a Star Wars film you'll particularly enjoy.… Expand

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

6

LamontRaymondDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. It's a relatively fun movie, especially as a nostalgia fix if you liked the original three films (like I did), but one element REALLY annoyed me - the CGI-created faces of Grand Moff Tarkin and Princess Leia. I mean, great attempt, and fun. But they simply don't look real! I mean, if they could pull this sort of thing off in Avatar and hundreds of other "animated" movies, why was this such a tough ask? They don't even get near the uncanny valley. Highly off-putting, but it didn't ruin the movie for me. I also don't think Felicity Jones can handle the lead role. Even the "young" version of herself was a stronger actress. What made the movie was Alan T. as the new droid and the cast of supporting actors including Diego Luna and the blind force-believer (who is amazing).… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

10

KzArashiDec 17, 2016

Rogue One is the prequel Star Wars deserves.
And a thing to note is that the original trilogy has a tone of ingenuity. On the other hand, for Rogue One the tone align to a struggling new found hope. And that is what make Rogue OneRogue One is the prequel Star Wars deserves.
And a thing to note is that the original trilogy has a tone of ingenuity. On the other hand, for Rogue One the tone align to a struggling new found hope. And that is what make Rogue One exceptional. That filme shows the fight and the struggle to build the ground from where the NEW HOPE could flourish, through a boy ingenuity in Episode IV.
The heroes in Rogue One are much like the soldiers who fought and died in the beachs of Normand to build the ground for the Alied campain and victory against the nazis in WWII.… Expand

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

7

MaxsonDec 17, 2016

I really want to give this movie a higher score but I just can't. I'll list the good things about this movie first. This one in my opinion has the best space battles, visually stunning and action packed. It's more of a war film compared toI really want to give this movie a higher score but I just can't. I'll list the good things about this movie first. This one in my opinion has the best space battles, visually stunning and action packed. It's more of a war film compared to the other star wars movies. Some of the new characters were pretty cool, their performances were actually good. Well acted, but not amazing. My biggest issue with the film would have to be character's backstory. I'm not going to count the female protagonist,because the movie did a good job explaining her past, but what about the other guys? Some of the good guys were put in without a backstory, so the entire time while I was watching the movie, I was wondering about their backgrounds. My second issue is the the second act, it felt a bit slow because the pacing. The third act was very good, well executed and definitely worth watching just for the third act in this film.… Expand

14 of 23 users found this helpful149

All this user's reviews

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

User Reviews