Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

6

Thatonenerd2187Dec 21, 2016

Star wars rouge one to me is dissipating, not as a film, but as a star wars movie. The special effects, action scenes, and overall filmmaking is solid. The one problem with this movie is the characters. Their not that memorable and don't haveStar wars rouge one to me is dissipating, not as a film, but as a star wars movie. The special effects, action scenes, and overall filmmaking is solid. The one problem with this movie is the characters. Their not that memorable and don't have much development. Plus the acting isn't bad, it's just o.k.… Expand

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

7

awgoldenJan 17, 2017

If we're forced to compare this to the last offer from the franchise, it's simply a much better movie than Force Awakens. Better story, executed with more poignancy, than either rehashes (eg. Force Awakens) or mythology fillers (eq. I-III)If we're forced to compare this to the last offer from the franchise, it's simply a much better movie than Force Awakens. Better story, executed with more poignancy, than either rehashes (eg. Force Awakens) or mythology fillers (eq. I-III) that seem more focused on living up to ANH and Empire than trying to just make a good movie.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

delete013Jan 16, 2017

A slow, clumsy start perhaps, it slowly accelerates towards a dramatic ending. At first fractioned story parts collide just before the final act to perform a crescendo of visual and emotional enjoyment.

One just must admire the timing, careA slow, clumsy start perhaps, it slowly accelerates towards a dramatic ending. At first fractioned story parts collide just before the final act to perform a crescendo of visual and emotional enjoyment.

One just must admire the timing, care and precision, accompanied by great acting, especially on behalf of the Imperial side. No candy for children or primitive nonsense for teenagers, just gritty, glorious fight against the odds. And when the movie seems to reach the finish line, there follows a phantastic insidious ending. A triumph of cinema!

I it simply amazing that a story with heavyweight background of the Star Wars would be done in such a bold manner. I cannot think of a better gift for fans of a good fantasy cinema.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

10

toadvinesJan 16, 2017

Awesome job by Gareth Edwards and Lucasfilm. Honestly, ehen I heard that this was subject to re-shoots I expected the worst. Actually, I was expecting something along the lines of Suicide Squad – fragments of good material stitched togetherAwesome job by Gareth Edwards and Lucasfilm. Honestly, ehen I heard that this was subject to re-shoots I expected the worst. Actually, I was expecting something along the lines of Suicide Squad – fragments of good material stitched together to create an incoherent mess. But not so with Rogue One. The movie is entirely coherent and if the reshoots hadn’t been reported I think this would have looked like the product of a singular vision. It’s very dour. It has an authentic war feel to it. It doesn’t feel like this has been made to appeal to chil;dren, rather to adults who have grown up with Star Wars. And that’s great. Rogue One proves that Star Wars can cover many bases successfully. There are a few standout moments here, holy s*** moments that are among the best in the entire series. It starts off slow but compelling, and the film builds and builds to a mind blowing climax. The scenes on the beaches are unlike anything we’ve seen before in Star Wars and bring to mind Saving Private Ryan and the space battle is full of inventive action. This bodes well for future standalone entries.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

6

Captain_ChaosJan 15, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A visually amazing film with many, many treats for long-time fans of Star Wars, with a grittier, more human cast of characters marred by an unsatisfying conclusion. Killing off most of your principle cast is not good writing.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

6

JoeCoolJan 2, 2017

I'm going to go with a 6 for this one, since I feel a 7 would just be too generous, even being a pretty big Star Wars fan. I had some doubts about the whole 'Star Wars Story' thing at first, but the movie managed to get the looks of the StarI'm going to go with a 6 for this one, since I feel a 7 would just be too generous, even being a pretty big Star Wars fan. I had some doubts about the whole 'Star Wars Story' thing at first, but the movie managed to get the looks of the Star Wars universe right, but the feeling was off from the get go. The grittiness of it all and the throw-away characters spoiled the fun quite a bit. The CGI was great, and there was no shortage of action near the end, but I still wonder why this movie was created at all. It doesn't fit with the Star Wars feeling except maybe for the space battle at the end which is great, but not enough to completely save this otherwise really bad movie. If this is the direction these Star Wars stories are going to take then they might as well call it a day right now.… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

6

paychickJan 15, 2017

Bad CGI. I just can't get past (or forgive) that. Do not, I repeat, do not attempt to bring back actors from the dead by giving them dead-eyed impostors. Ug.

The movie might have been fantastic had it been released before "The ForceBad CGI. I just can't get past (or forgive) that. Do not, I repeat, do not attempt to bring back actors from the dead by giving them dead-eyed impostors. Ug.

The movie might have been fantastic had it been released before "The Force Awakens" but I'm so tired of the Death Star that it felt stale and a rip off of itself.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

6

berserkoidJan 15, 2017

Well in a nutshell I thought the first half of the movie was boring and unnecessary. The new characters were not very captivating, especially that re-programmed Imperial droid. It got interesting for me from when they proceeded to land on theWell in a nutshell I thought the first half of the movie was boring and unnecessary. The new characters were not very captivating, especially that re-programmed Imperial droid. It got interesting for me from when they proceeded to land on the tropical moon to get the plans, although that whole deal was incredibly similar the Endor landing scenes from Return of the Jedi. I was almost waiting for new-age tropical Ewoks to appear and help the rebels - glad that didn't happen! I did like how the very end tied-in to right before A New Hope begins. Much better than Force Awakens. 6.5 out of 10 for me.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

7

KeithDowJan 14, 2017

Rogue One is a fun ride and the end sequence is a genuine thrill. While only the fourth or fifth best film in the series, it still does justice to the reinvigorated franchise.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

4

night4Jan 14, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Here's a bunch of characters you won't care about!

Aaaaaand they're all dead. The end.

That's the movie. You know what's funny? I JUST watched it not 3 hours ago and I literally couldn't tell you the name of a SINGLE character in it, even if my life depended on it.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

blowme44Jan 12, 2017

For Star Wars Fans, this is what we've been waiting for,"a perfect blend of old and new with spectacular special effects." With a little poetic license this film rivals our fond memories of Empire and New Hope.

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

6

JorgeLestreJan 12, 2017

Although it has great visuals and a very amusing new android, Rogue One doesn't quite achieve the instant connection to the main characters, even though fans will enjoy the visual bonanza.

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

JonNajemJan 12, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Even though this is a prequel to Star Wars (1977), it maybe the best standalone movie ive ever seen. Every character has their own quirks and importance within the roles they play which make each and every one of them likable for different reasons. The slow start just allows the movie to climb to infinite heights. Great acting all around from both the Rebel and Empire core cast. most people complain about the CGI Peter Cushing, but I honestly thought he was still alive cause the CGI was so convincing overall (Leia...maybe not so much, slightly more noticeable). The action was dirty, yet strategic, like the space battles back in Return of the Jedi or The Battle of Hoth in Empire Strikes Back. Made it feel just like a classic star wars movie, even more so than The Force Awakens did. Though the first act may chug a little on first viewing, it has a much less severe effect on second viewing. All in all, this is a damn good film.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

7

PipeCJan 11, 2017

A Standalone But Autochthonous Rebellion

Ten years after the terminal insertion into film cosmos begot by George Lucas, settled down the first usufruct of Disney's shrewd acquisition when it purchased Lucasfilm. "The Force Awakens" was theA Standalone But Autochthonous Rebellion

Ten years after the terminal insertion into film cosmos begot by George Lucas, settled down the first usufruct of Disney's shrewd acquisition when it purchased Lucasfilm. "The Force Awakens" was the channel Abrams applied to flourish the torpid force in the warsies' heart after the futile prequels. Starting with this one, Disney took it upon itself to purvey an annual movie within litigating film release schedule. Kathleen Kennedy and formidable crew of the factory covet with making an empirical universe about the preternatural galaxy far, far away; and to achieve this, they have concluded to try its luck with Edwards' war experiment in order to elucidate whether it is beneficial to create a line of independent events out of the Skywalker family. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" opens by far a feasible wave of dissimilar films of a galactic anthology while focusing and securing its strongest point in the director's fervent declaration: war film which does not drink neither George Lucas' nor J. J. Abrams' lymph for manufacturing a deferential, nostalgic, cogitative, and sometimes dispiriting extension in Star Wars mythology.

Its narrative component emulates the scale clichés of the original trilogy: a princess, a robot, a misanthrope, a strife between the dark side and the light side and of course display of spaceships assailing each other. Conversely, this compact design takes risks as for inquiring into primitive and uncommon perspectives, which foster a fortification of a deeper concept around mythology. And although as a last resort is a war celluloid more than remarkable—in spite of it merely sketches certain characteristics and focuses its plausible references in "The Dirty Dozen" (1967) by Robert Aldrich—does not manage to be a corporeal Star Wars movie since it's constantly held on by fan service and generates a quite primary treatment to the development. A prime look to unfamiliar areas from a standpoint's as ordinary as opposed, a wit tinged of tribulation and grief and one of the most honorable final thirds in a blockbuster in recent times are the unforeseen top ambitions by the filmmaker.

It takes place before the events of "Episode IV," "Rogue One" came up from a shallow idea of visual effects supervisor and CCO at Industrial Light & Magic John Knoll, which consisted in clarifying the time- space around what was the itinerary of the Death Star plans until being in Princess Leia Organa's hands , route somewhat named in "A New Hope". So this is the story of those ordinary beings who achieved the extraordinary. Innocent Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones) opens with a retrospective scene about her girlhood, underlined by tragedy and misfortune. Thereon, it introduces her as a redeemed prisoner who is moved to a Rebel Alliance HQ. There, a transcendental mission has commended her in order to make contact with his fading father for locating and discovering the nature and the place of a substantially powerful weapon. Ordinary people clan gradually takes form, finding its cardinal mover into the force. Although the fabled team bounces from a planet to another for terminating its commission, we figured out exiguous details about the crew captained by Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) —who made me very proud;—likewise, most fans clamor for more background in Saw Gerrera's story, the leader of the Onderon rebels. Despite the fact that the depth was an authentic reverb, character designs and performances are what many fans were waiting for. Displaying a heterogeneous and multicultural acting cast, which delves into each contemporary civilization, the film takes advantage of the cultural range to generate a vast human-racial universe inside its world, in the same way, each performer gets its moment of glory before the decisive and evocative ending. Their performances made the audience proud, so much so that was ineluctable not yell in the credits of the motion picture.

More suitable for adults than infants, more suitable for warsies than mass audiences. If it were action and conflagration scenes, the near-perfect third act would lead the film to the sublime, sadly, its burning and high-octane last forty minutes aren't enough to keep afloat lack of enthusiasm and the multiplicity of the beginning and exposition, opportunities lacking in momentum and vigor that exclusively are notable for performances and special effects. In time record, Giacchino composed an entrancing, nostalgic and fortifying soundtrack, which is assembled with the dark tone of each frame, also it testifies him as the first author in breaking John Williams' musical canon. "Rogue One" is more a war product, in where its spectacular music, sparkling performances, and nearly excellent action sequences invade unexplored lands and nothing irreverent in Star Wars world, also, the film gives a message of hope and encourages all us, who this year lost a great woman: imposing Carrie Fisher. RIP my Princess Leia.… Expand

6 of 9 users found this helpful63

All this user's reviews

6

tigerskin84Jan 11, 2017

Despues del desastre que fue the force awakens, una copia horrenda del episodio 4 recibimos rogue one, el film que nadie pidio(como el proximo de han solo), no me malinterpretes la pelicula no es tan mala pero tiene demasiados personajes y noDespues del desastre que fue the force awakens, una copia horrenda del episodio 4 recibimos rogue one, el film que nadie pidio(como el proximo de han solo), no me malinterpretes la pelicula no es tan mala pero tiene demasiados personajes y no profundiza nada en ellos por lo tanto es dificil sentirse apegado a ellos cuando llega el final.Otro problema con esta pelicula es que ya sabemos que es lo que va a pasar por lo tanto tiene 0 factor sorpresa y tambien quiero mencionar la obsesion de disney con las death stars y la ya trillada trama de alguien que viene con un mensaje importante y vital y los problemas entre padre e hijos, ya cansan... espero que el episodio 8 sea buena o adios a esta gran saga de peliculas.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

9

KayVen17Jan 11, 2017

Deutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt dasDeutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt das einen User Score von 8. Bei 86 einen von Userscore von 9. Falls eine 85 kommt entscheide ich ob ich es eher positiv oder negativ nehme. Regeln verstanden?
Dann sind hier meine Punkte.

Mein persönlicher Score = 90/100
Mein User Score = 9/10… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

10

Tss5078Jan 10, 2017

The purpose of Rogue one was simple, to fix a plot hole that had bothered Star Wars fans for nearly forty years. How did the rebels get a hold of the plans for the death star and why was it so easy to destroy? At a young age, Jyn Erso'sThe purpose of Rogue one was simple, to fix a plot hole that had bothered Star Wars fans for nearly forty years. How did the rebels get a hold of the plans for the death star and why was it so easy to destroy? At a young age, Jyn Erso's (Felicity Jones), father Galen (Mads Mikkelsen) was taken by the empire, to help develop the death star. Jyn was protected by the rebels before fleeing and living on her own, until one day, the rebels receive a message from Galen, saying that his daughter is the key to everything, and if they help get her to him, he can stop the empire. What I love about Rogue one, is the fact that for this film the franchise took a step back. If you ask anybody what their favorite Star Wars movie is, inevitably you will hear A New Hope or The Empire Strikes Back, but why? It's because these films didn't have massive budgets, big name movie stars, the top directors in Hollywood, complex story lines, special characters thrown in for the kids, simply put they were the greatest space adventures of all-time. Rogue one leaves in the special effects, but the actors are not very well known, the director has only two films under his belt, the story is easy to follow, the characters are extremely likeable, (much more so than the new ones in the Force Awakens), and most import of all the story is more narrowly focused and much easier to follow. There aren't a million different things going on here, there is one objective and it is being attempted by characters you can actually get behind. Jyn Erso, very much has the Katniss Everdeen tough girl thing going for her and she is paired with Cassian (Diego Luna), who has all the charisma of a young Harrison Ford, together the pair is infectious and you can't help but like them. I didn't feel any of that with Rey and Finn, in fact, I barely remembered their names. I'd also be remiss if I didn't mention the scenery and special effects in the film, unlike in recent films, we see a multitude of planets, it isn't just all sand and sun. The planet in the final scene with the beaches and the energy shield in particular was just amazing. Finally there is the ending, I won't give anything away if you haven't seen it yet, but I will say this. While controversial, in my opinion, more perfect it could not have been. Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy and I hope J.J. Abrams took notice. This is what the future of the franchise should be. Just because you have the largest film budget in history, doesn't mean your film has to have dozens of plots, and all these random characters we don't care about. Use that money on special effects, more amazing ships, weapons, and planets, and just make Star Wars fun again in a way that Rogue One reminded us it could be.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

krikaoliJan 10, 2017

Wow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make aWow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make a movie much better than Star Wars VIII. Very impressive plot, actors, etc.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

DreadLordAvatarJan 10, 2017

absolutely the best star wars film since empire strikes back. it totally captures the Ep4 feeling, Director Gareth Edwards is a genius. glad the music isnt a rehash of john williams score, this feels refreshing and a true delight. saw itabsolutely the best star wars film since empire strikes back. it totally captures the Ep4 feeling, Director Gareth Edwards is a genius. glad the music isnt a rehash of john williams score, this feels refreshing and a true delight. saw it in 3d at the theatre. hope the bluray release includes the 3d version this time unlike the milking morons that did force awakens double dip release. i truly hope JJ Abrams studies rogue one and capitalizes on it's magic and applies it to Ep8 to make a true star wars film.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

10

anthonymurphy29Jan 10, 2017

Rogue One features spectacular visual effects, from action-packed sequences to the CGI-assisted return of classic characters from the original Star Wars (Episode IV: A New Hope, 1977). Gareth Edwards managed to pay tribute in a subtle way andRogue One features spectacular visual effects, from action-packed sequences to the CGI-assisted return of classic characters from the original Star Wars (Episode IV: A New Hope, 1977). Gareth Edwards managed to pay tribute in a subtle way and at the same time gift us with groundbreaking storytelling. Rogue One is an excellent addition to the Star Wars universe (although it isn't part of the main saga episodes), further bridging the gap between Revenge of the Sith (Episode III, 2005) and A New Hope.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

9

HappyislandsJan 9, 2017

Against all odds this turned out to be a rather bold movie.If we weren't already aware of re-shoots this would have the hallmarks of a singular vision - a gritty and uncompromised war film set in the Star Wars Universe.

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

6

TheQuietGamerJan 9, 2017

Rogue One succeeds at showing a darker and more desperate side of the Star Wars universe. The galaxy is being crushed under the Empire's oppression, the Rebel Alliance is being forced to resort to grim tactics in order to survive, and to topRogue One succeeds at showing a darker and more desperate side of the Star Wars universe. The galaxy is being crushed under the Empire's oppression, the Rebel Alliance is being forced to resort to grim tactics in order to survive, and to top it all off the Empire is in the process of putting the finishing touches on some sort of super weapon. One rumored to have the power to destroy planets. All of this sets off a chain of events that make for the most unique Star Wars yet. One that feels more like a heist and war film, than what's come before.

One of the movie's greatest strengths is that it captures the bleak atmosphere one would expect from a Star Wars story set in this period of the series' timeline. There's a feeling of hopelessness that follows the characters around through every scenario they find themselves apart of. Nearly every planet they visit has that dirty, rundown, right in the middle of a warzone feel that sells the tone excellently. When it comes to the depiction of the state of the galaxy the movie succeeds near-perfectly.

Another area where the movie is at it's best is in it's incredible battles. These conflicts standout as the best the series has to offer. The scale is grand, the stakes are intense, and the shear amount of eye candy is stunning. The series even gets involved in some non-blaster fights that rival the series best lightsaber duels, despite not having a single Jedi in sight. When it comes to action the movie does not disappoint. Unfortunately the same thing cannot be said for it's writing and characters. Something that leaves an unfortunate sour patch in an otherwise stellar movie.

It's not that the events aren't interesting. The concept of watching a ragtag team come together to steal the plans for the freaking Death Star with all odds stacked against them is one that would excite any Star Wars fan. The problem is that early on it just sort of moves in a way that unceremoniously throws them together. It jumps around so much at the beginning it's actually a little confusing to piece together what's going on. It doesn't take long for things to click, but when they do your left with an even bigger problem; you have no way to connect with the characters, so it's impossible to care about them. The exception being Alan Tudyk's excellent K-2SO. It's not that they're unlikable characters. It's just that there's no spark or flair to them that causes them to standout as anything more than the Star Wars universe's B-team. A group of bland faces meant to carry things on here while things are being prepared for Episode VIII. Given that the popularity of the Star Wars series partly stems from the compelling nature of it's characters and plot, it's disappointing to see the series first anthology film fall short in those areas. This is primarily a movie you watch for the spectacular action. I say primarily because the movie does have a great deal of fan-service for Star Wars fans. Things like special references and even a few surprise cameos are sure to please. Especially since they feel natural to the story and not just shoehorned in. So in the end Rogue One isn't a disaster. Just more of a disappointment in some areas. There are still plenty of reasons to check it out, longtime fan or not. It's noticeable differences in things like tone have the potential to appeal to newcomers. So in the end all is not lost.

6.9/10… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

6

sensorglitchJan 9, 2017

This was a good movie. However, when I compare it to other movies in the franchise I can't help but think of it as maybe the 6th best movie in the franchise? It's hard to give a movie a high rating based on that.

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

0

Alvin_PinsberryJan 9, 2017

Goddamn this was an endless, joyless slog of a movie. The characters were bland and uninteresting. No-one had any kind of arc. The story-line, despite basically nothing happening, took 2 and a half hours to get through.

And there's thisGoddamn this was an endless, joyless slog of a movie. The characters were bland and uninteresting. No-one had any kind of arc. The story-line, despite basically nothing happening, took 2 and a half hours to get through.

And there's this scene when they're all standing around the table where the main character says "We have to do this" or something, and everyone's nodding behind her, and it's the most cheesy embarrassing moment in all of Star Wars.

Awful.… Expand

3 of 14 users found this helpful311

All this user's reviews

10

RealmOfTheEnderJan 9, 2017

I'm likely not the kind of person to look to for reviews, but I found this film to be absolutely amazing. I'll go ahead and write here:

-Did it feel like Star Wars? =Yes, absolutely. It was perfect. The atmosphere, the characters, theI'm likely not the kind of person to look to for reviews, but I found this film to be absolutely amazing. I'll go ahead and write here:

-Did it feel like Star Wars?
=Yes, absolutely. It was perfect. The atmosphere, the characters, the planets, everything felt like how a Star Wars movie should.

-How about dat Darth Vader tho?
=It was...okay, I guess. He could've been better used, but the way he's used still makes up for it. -Was it the best Star Wars eva?
=I'd say 3rd best, behind A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back.

Overall, I believe this was a really good Star Wars film, and a good film in general.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

9

TimW001Jan 9, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This was a very enjoyable film. Here is a list of its best feature:
-Forest Whitaker's character
-The Tense Third Act -Giant Space Battle
-Hammerhead cruiser making two Imperial capital ship crash
-1970's grit.
-Direct connection to the 1970's movies
-Darth Vader, and Darth Vader's rampage

It was a far darker and grittier film than The Force Awakens. Great movie, a must see.… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

10

Jason117Jan 8, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Well, this film actually turn me into a Star war fan. When the force awaken came out I was like meh, I was a half fan of star wars and I think im gonna keep it that way cause I wasn't watching much of epic Star wars before. I never actually get into the movie but this time, I'm touched by the film and I'm seriously mean it. I truely wish Jyn and Cassian can make it out and I can see them again in the up-coming films in the future but it's ok if they didn't. She will be remain as my favorite character in my momery.… Expand

5 of 7 users found this helpful52

All this user's reviews

8

hassallDec 25, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. When i saw this movie i kept getting goosebumps, the cgi is this is good,I was a bit disappointing that all the main characters dies in this movie but hey its still a good movie.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

6

zappbrannigan23Jan 8, 2017

I hoped for more out of this film.

Negatives: Probably my biggest negative is the CGI for the pivotal actors faces (ones no longer with us). Their not being an actual persons face were obvious and poorly done. The first half of the movie isI hoped for more out of this film.

Negatives:
Probably my biggest negative is the CGI for the pivotal actors faces (ones no longer with us). Their not being an actual persons face were obvious and poorly done.
The first half of the movie is too slow
The character development not quite as good as it should be. 2 characters voices/words were very difficult to understand what they were saying.

Positives:
There were a lot of fun (albeit a bit simple) references and lead ins to past and future movies this one sits in between. Fans eat this stuff up and so did I.
The final 1/4 of the movie was very well done action/battle sequences in both space and ground.
The lead actress and her father were well casted and likable.
With a little more script and dialog polish this could have been much more flowing and stronger ties to the characters. I offer my revision/suggestion services to review any future movies for free.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

MatteleJan 7, 2017

THIS had to be Star Wars 7, not that lazy and uninspired reboot. Given that this movie will not have a direct sequel, and given that it is a spin off, the authors finally created a really enojoyable movie. Must see.

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

8

mromalvDec 18, 2016

The first act has pacing problems, but once it gets going it's a great movie, especially the final act. I've seen it twice now and liked it more the second time, when you have a grasp of what's happening in the firs 45 minutes it's easier toThe first act has pacing problems, but once it gets going it's a great movie, especially the final act. I've seen it twice now and liked it more the second time, when you have a grasp of what's happening in the firs 45 minutes it's easier to enjoy.

Those last 30 minutes are just perfection.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

10

aliciabrookssJan 7, 2017

Finally, a Star Wars movie which one can call near perfect. From the brilliant plot to the constant action, it is truly tough pinpoint what makes "Rogue One" such an epic film, and I mean EPIC. For once, a star wars film that is not based onFinally, a Star Wars movie which one can call near perfect. From the brilliant plot to the constant action, it is truly tough pinpoint what makes "Rogue One" such an epic film, and I mean EPIC. For once, a star wars film that is not based on comical relief and cliches, this darker movie is just what Star Wars fans had been looking for. I leave this review to a minimum, as one can only judge once they've seen it, and i definitely urge you all to see it. All that I will say is that, as my father said upon leaving the theatre "That is the best Star Wars film I've ever seen". Well done Gareth Edwards.

(P.S for those comparing Rogue One to TFA, Rogue One makes TFA look like absolute garbage and it is almost unfair to compare the two)… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

4

bkristmanJan 6, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A very ordinary 'b' film with a larger budget that has a lead character pretty much indistinguishable from the last star wars one and just as serious,boring and vanilla.
The cinematography and effects were very blase and the 3D was almost non-existent .
The nearly powerless jedi they added to the film was some kind of primitive mentally disturbed man who kept yelling about the force to himself throughout and he did a disservice to the Star Wars legacy. The droid had the only bit of humour in the film but i'm not sure why the had to pay Tudyk to do it because the voice was indistinguishable.
All in all a poor 'by the numbers' effort without personality.
Throughout this film i just came to realize how good an actor Harrison Ford was ,not technically,but how just his appearance could have lit up a film like this .… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

8

sVcDec 22, 2016

This is a much darker movie than any of the other Star Wars movies. I found The Force Awakens to be slightly better than this one but I think that's only because I was so happy to see someone finally make a movie that lives up to the StarThis is a much darker movie than any of the other Star Wars movies. I found The Force Awakens to be slightly better than this one but I think that's only because I was so happy to see someone finally make a movie that lives up to the Star Wars name (I, II & III were horrible). Plus, the nostalgia factor of seeing beloved characters again. But I'll say this about Rouge One: the final 1/3 of the movie is as good...actually, better than, anything that any of the originals had done. The first and second act had enough to keep me interested, but after watching the last act, looking back now, it pales in comparison. Which is not to say I didn't thoroughly enjoy every bit of the movie. They don't go into great depth with the new characters, but just enough so that you have an understanding of who they are and that you will care for them and their fate. I liked all the references and throwbacks to the originals of course. And Darth Vader's second appearance was just simply bad ass. The one issue I had was the score. And I'm not blaming the composer, I'm sure he did a great job. I can't even say I'm that big a fan of John Williams, but after seeing 7 movies with his music, it kind of became a distraction when I heard it in the background.. All in all, if you are a fan of the originals you'll be a fan of this as well.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

6

indigobeastJan 6, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I was disappointed by this movie because the story was poorly written because I was very confused with what was actually going on so thinks were randomly happening to make the movie progress. Most of the characters were forgettable and didn't have anything special about them. The final sequence is what saved this movie in my opinion because the quality and imagination really shows here like this is when i started getting engaged in the movie. The only bad thing about the battle was the random deaths of all the big characters they happened too quickly between each other. Only see this movie if you're a die hard star wars fan as they would pretty much love this movie either way.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

7

DirigiblePulpJan 5, 2017

Mostly good fun. The new characters seem interesting, but probably don't get enough depth. I like the underlying theme of the unsung heroes of the rebellion though I'm not sure if it ever really rang true in the end. It's mostly there as aMostly good fun. The new characters seem interesting, but probably don't get enough depth. I like the underlying theme of the unsung heroes of the rebellion though I'm not sure if it ever really rang true in the end. It's mostly there as a sign post and when the main characters die it feels more like a necessary act for the films that follow as opposed to any kind of inevitability about the sacrifices and futility of war.

Mikkelsen is a bit wasted and he shouldn't have been. Mendelsohn is good, though I wish he would have gotten some juicier scenes (the opening confrontation between these two is probably the best for both).

There's a bit too much fan service in this. The CGI Tarkin and Leia aren't necessary. They were distracting and are going to age extremely poorly. It was fine for them to do it, but close-ups of their faces was needless. They should have kept the shots wide and distant, and up close with their backs turned. Vader kicking ass was both cool and eye-roll inducing. I still don't know how to feel about that. Is there nothing sacred anymore?… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

9

TFHJan 5, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rouge One was one of my favorite Star Wars movies. I liked the characters a lot, and the new and improved armory was a nice addition. The background story on some people was a bit vague though, but only on some. Overall, a great movie.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

7

sinadoomJan 5, 2017

An excellent stand-alone story set in the Star Wars universe. It's one of those extremely forumalaic kind of films but done right. You can definitely tell that it's had a lot of money spent on it, with breathtaking effects and visualsAn excellent stand-alone story set in the Star Wars universe. It's one of those extremely forumalaic kind of films but done right. You can definitely tell that it's had a lot of money spent on it, with breathtaking effects and visuals throughout. The start of the film feels quite messy and jumbled but it all ties together nicely after the first half an hour or so. Characters aren't as well-developed as they could've been but are passable, and the story is nothing special but overall, the experience is greater than the sum of its parts. Would recommend.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

CodgerEbertJan 5, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Great movie, but where were all the Bothans? Other than that, they seamlessly folded this prequel in with A New Hope. The end of Rogue One could take place 30 minutes before Tantive IV gets boarded by Vader. The fact that most of the protagonists died was kind of refreshing in today's world of immortal, sequel-ready heroes. I rank this one 3rd out of all Star Wars Movies, behind ESB and A New Hope.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

IxamJan 5, 2017

It's a standard action film set in the Star War's universe. If that sounds like your cup of tea, then go see it and enjoy. A team of underdeveloped characters team up to accomplish a mission, this time with tie fighters and x-wings! The filmIt's a standard action film set in the Star War's universe. If that sounds like your cup of tea, then go see it and enjoy. A team of underdeveloped characters team up to accomplish a mission, this time with tie fighters and x-wings! The film lacks the charm of the better action films (and the original trilogy), and outside of the action sequences was pretty dull. The action sequences were pretty phenomenal, and redeem the movie to an extent. I hope Disney learns from their mistakes and includes more compelling/likeable characters in following films.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

PabloBird22Jan 4, 2017

Rogue one is awesome it's simply amazing, Darth vader was awesome as usual i swear on my life that I never saw Darth vader so bloody and brutal as in the last scene, it's awesome Rogue one always gonna find a place as the best STAR WARSRogue one is awesome it's simply amazing, Darth vader was awesome as usual i swear on my life that I never saw Darth vader so bloody and brutal as in the last scene, it's awesome Rogue one always gonna find a place as the best STAR WARS prequel.

P.S: R.I.P Carri fisher for his last scene in the movie :')… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

Mando44646Jan 4, 2017

This movie was much better than Episode 7. No giant idiotic plot choices like Starkiller Base and they didn't forget to do world building either. It greatly enriches Episode 4 and Star Wars in general, though I do wish we had more time withThis movie was much better than Episode 7. No giant idiotic plot choices like Starkiller Base and they didn't forget to do world building either. It greatly enriches Episode 4 and Star Wars in general, though I do wish we had more time with many of the characters.

Best Star Wars movie since Episode 6, in my opinion. I cannot recommend it enough.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

7

BIOHAZARD-R-USJan 4, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. There was a lot this movie did right, mainly the humor and the action sequences. Laughter was frequent while watching this movie, and the action sequences were carefully constructed and perfectly executed, with the hits and punches all coming in heavy and every now and then making you call out "Yes!" when one lands brutally. K-2 was the absolute definite highlight of the movie, with much of the humor coming from his dialogue. The scene with Darth Vader comes in at the very end, like last 2 minutes and only lasts as long. Some of the shots in the trailer from this scene were cut, but the scene is so badass and so intense, it easily becomes the best scene of the movie. The movie does not have an opening crawl, and that is for two reasons: 1) this is not part of any of the trilogies, and ends quite conclusively for the main characters, and 2) this movie is actually a visual portrayal of the events detailed in the opening crawl from A New Hope. Thus, giving an opening crawl to this movie would've been redundant. The story is pretty simple, only meant to bridge the gap between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope. Rogue One tells the tale of Jyn, her father who was forced to build the Death Star, his secret fault he built in the reactor, and the Rebellion attempting to get the plans for the Death Star in order to launch an attack on it. If you've seen Episode IV, then you'll know how this movie ends.

Now, for what this movie does bad. And it does quite a lot, though surprisingly it doesn't really detract from the experience too much. First of all, the CGI characters, specifically Grand Tarkin and Young Princess Lea. Obviously they couldn't physically recast Peter Cushing, and Carrie Fisher aged almost 40 years. So the choice was made to use CGI character representations of them, and man was it bad. Not only did Tarkin move like a chimp from the new Planet of the Apes movies, but he had a very video game-like stilt to his movements, and his imagery looked like they tried to go hyper-realistic and overdid it. And his voice, every time Tarkin spoke, it pissed me off, because it sounds NOTHING like Peter Cushing or the way he sounded in Episode IV. Princess Lea looked really good on the other hand, but her animation was so stiff, they could've just used a post-added still frame of her from A New Hope and it would've looked about the same. The other thing this movie did badly, and this is what drops my score the most, is the character arcs and development. Cassian's arc starts out starts out kind of like a Han Solo rugged guy, then is revealed to be part of the Rebellion, then is made out to be a bad guy by getting and agreeing to follow orders that directly conflict with Jyn, then him not following the orders, to him becoming a true ally to Jyn, to becoming a love interest to her. His arc is so all over the place, it looks like they were just checking off character traits and found they were short a few for the movie, so they packed them all into him. For being the main character, Jyn hardly does anything, except for kill a few Storm Troopers on Jedah and help find where in the Archives the Death Star plans are. Saw Gerrera is played by Forest Whitaker, and is hyped up to be a badass warrior with a long war torn history, and yet is shown only for a couple minutes near the beginning and is immediately killed off. Baze and Chirrut were a fun duo, and besides K-2SO, these guys are the only other ones providing humor. The Defector Pilot also kinda does too, but besides these 4 characters, no one else is likeable.

You definitely need to see this movie if you've seen the other Star Wars movies, and it is quite fun to watch, with good humor and solid action throughout, but a few big flaws detract this movie from being as good as it could've been.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

ColourSurroundJan 4, 2017

I came in with meager expectations and was genuinely blown away with how the film handled the story, paced the action, and played out as a whole. The acting was superb, the effects made you feel like you were watching a Star Wars film - andI came in with meager expectations and was genuinely blown away with how the film handled the story, paced the action, and played out as a whole. The acting was superb, the effects made you feel like you were watching a Star Wars film - and not some CGI mind-maze - and the story was genuinely well written. I loved all of the classic Star Wars easter eggs that were thrown in, and that the main character gave a nod to Jan Ors from the Dark Forces games of the 90s. It was original, but above all very entertaining. The critic metascore does not reflect its quality. It definitely plays out more like a war drama in a sci-fi setting than anything else, but I think it is all the better for it. Although quite different from any of its predecessors, it is a wonderful film that I feel surpasses The 'Force Awakens' in almost every facet, and can rightly take its spot with Episodes IV-VI in the Star Wars canon.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

7

Ryzoft_StipeJan 4, 2017

A good refreshment after the disaster called "The Force Awakens." The difference between this movie and the latter is the sole fact that this one doesn't rely on stealing plots. Gareth Edwards has had courage to include characters and openlyA good refreshment after the disaster called "The Force Awakens." The difference between this movie and the latter is the sole fact that this one doesn't rely on stealing plots. Gareth Edwards has had courage to include characters and openly mention the Clone Wars without being scared like some directors who are led to believe that the prequel trilogy is bad. All in all, this movie is great. 7/10… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

TheChosenOne7Jan 3, 2017

Pretty good movie. Would be a 10 but there are a few major plot holes and some of the writing is left wanting, but overall a fantastic movie. Far better than the SJW propaganda filled Force Awakens. Let's hope the next movie follows thisPretty good movie. Would be a 10 but there are a few major plot holes and some of the writing is left wanting, but overall a fantastic movie. Far better than the SJW propaganda filled Force Awakens. Let's hope the next movie follows this example and sticks to being entertaining and true to the franchise instead of pushing a backwards agenda.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

4

kdedrickJan 3, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Being a life-long Star Wars fan, I had high hopes upon entering this film. Unfortunately, I left disappointed. The first 10 mins of the movie is constant shifting between different locations without establishing what purpose they have. They end up just being names on the screen with no meaning.
Characters are incredibly underdeveloped and the movie just expects you to feel for them.
Forest Whitaker's character was completely pointless.
Some sort of mind-control alien was introduced and then completely ignored after.
The main villain Krennic had a lot of potential but that is never realized.
The main character Jyn, is suddenly overcome with a sense of duty to complete this mission, despite having spent her entire life avoiding responsibility.
The chinese characters decide to just join the group because plot demands it?
I thought the Grand Moff Tarkin revival was appropriate and well done, I dont think the complaints are merited. Galen Erso was my favorite character and more of this movie should have been spent on him and his relationship with Krennic.
Vader's final scene was the best of the film. The character should have been featured more prominently.
The CGI of the film was great. Locations were gorgeous.
Unfortunately the lame plot and characters are too much to ignore and over weigh the few positives.
If you are a Star Wars fan, you will obviously go see it, otherwise dont bother.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

saintandrewsfalJan 3, 2017

Good film overall with some missteps. Acting, story, and action, were all tight. No problems there. The issues come up with cliched moments, a small lull in the second act, and an average ending.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

6

tobisanJan 3, 2017

I have mixed feelings with this movie. Love the way it connects to the original trilogy and it had great action sequences, but the characters were poorly developed and it seems to be an unnecesary story to tell.

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

4

AbsozeroJan 3, 2017

This was a C movie at best. Poorly written, too much fan service. A letdown like The Force Awakens was. I don't think Disney has the magic to make a good Star Wars movie.

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

6

dspratlinJan 3, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. What's it about?

It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire. During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire's ultimate weapon, the DEATH STAR, an armored space station with enough power to destroy an entire planet. This is their story. What did I think?

Where Return of the Jedi was a let-down due to "alleged" toy company requirements, Rogue One seems a let-down by a meddling committee. Too many cooks dilute a terrific premise and muddy great characters thanks to an overly-convoluted introduction and dollops of unnecessary spoon-feeding.

But make sure you see it on the big screen for the final battle sequence - it's basically a 21st-century version of the ROTJ final act.

Epilogue: If you recall, we all loved Star Wars for George's ground-breaking "used universe" and the mythical unanswered questions (Jedi, Clone Wars, why there is no underwear in space). Edwards delivers a gloriously dirty reality, but the committee let the movie down by interrupting him and providing us with too many answers to questions we didn't ask. A Star Wars movie doesn't require title cards to tell the audience where we are, that's part of the charm. Drop us in and let us swim!… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

2

ImpeccableTasteJan 3, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Way too long for a movie this uninteresting. Dialogue is awful, and sometimes annoying (Blind Character). No Force practitioner in any of the past movies has to chant a mantra, it was just annoying. Characters are dull especially main leads, and supporting cast are wasted Mads Mikkelsen, and Forest Whitaker especially.The Rebel Alliance makes it sound like he is some really tough terrorist but that is not how Whitaker plays the part. Space battle doesn't make since, they are attacking shield for five minutes, and blowing up aircraft guns, and not until near the end of the battle do the TIE fighters come out of the shield give me a break. Darth Vader scene is the best of the movie, was hoping a Jedi would show up but no such luck. Wait for rental definitely.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

10

moheetoJan 3, 2017

Unexpectedly Awesome Star Wars movie - the start has received criticism for jumping around too much but I didn't feel that at all - I felt it introduced the new characters efficiently. And then we have a bit of story genius that explains theUnexpectedly Awesome Star Wars movie - the start has received criticism for jumping around too much but I didn't feel that at all - I felt it introduced the new characters efficiently. And then we have a bit of story genius that explains the Death Stars weakness. It loses momentum during the middle section which lagged a bit in my opinion. But that's soon forgotten as the action ramps up in the third act for some majorly exhilarating s***. I'm up off my chair in the last 2 minutes as you know who turns up. And the whole cinema cheers at the end.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

9

DukeSilverJan 2, 2017

Just accept it. It's better than The Force Awakens. It maintained it's connection to the originals without beating us over the head with stupid one liners and constantly saying, "you'll love this because you loved the original movies!".

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

cuevaslermaJan 2, 2017

This film is for those who saw Episode IV in the theatres, only those who remember what they felt when they saw the stormtroopers, AT-AT, Star destroyers. they are the ones who really will enjoy this film, only a few will really feel chillsThis film is for those who saw Episode IV in the theatres, only those who remember what they felt when they saw the stormtroopers, AT-AT, Star destroyers. they are the ones who really will enjoy this film, only a few will really feel chills to see certain characters. Only a few will return to 1977, for the others a good sci-fi movie could be considered.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

madnoloJan 2, 2017

This movie was a big surprise for me, being a series fan I went in without much expectations. I had this preconception made after watching the Force Awakens, which I found to be beautiful and very well made, but largely lacking in screenplayThis movie was a big surprise for me, being a series fan I went in without much expectations. I had this preconception made after watching the Force Awakens, which I found to be beautiful and very well made, but largely lacking in screenplay and plot. Rogue One is in my opinion funnier and more captivating than any of the prequels(1,2 and 3). The music and scenario are as as well done as always. Acting from the main characters could be the only lacking feature, but the movie makes up for it with the terrific screenplay and well orchestrated pace. Definitely recommend it.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

AvalordJan 2, 2017

First I have to state: I disliked, even despised "A Force Awakens", a movie without a single original thought, badly executed. Rogue One is no less than the best Star Wars Movie ever made. The characters are great, the pacing is just right.First I have to state: I disliked, even despised "A Force Awakens", a movie without a single original thought, badly executed. Rogue One is no less than the best Star Wars Movie ever made. The characters are great, the pacing is just right. With Protagonists that matter to you, you want to spend some time with, before you descend into the slaughterhouse together.
All those who criticise the slow start of the film I have to tell: Just wait for the next Star Wars Movie (VIII). You'll get your soul/mindless J.J.Abrams opus soon enough!… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

fashion_policeJan 2, 2017

The movie is really good I recommend it. The Star Wars feel is here, there is character development and it is not cliché. The last hour is particularly good. Only downside is that it would have been cool to have more lightsaber fights.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

SomePersonaJan 1, 2017

I actually really enjoyed this movie, and that is coming from a person that is not much of a Star Wars fan. It's also coming from a person that thinks The Force Awakens is one of the most overrated flicks of all time.

My favorite parts ofI actually really enjoyed this movie, and that is coming from a person that is not much of a Star Wars fan. It's also coming from a person that thinks The Force Awakens is one of the most overrated flicks of all time.

My favorite parts of this movie was basically anything with CGI Tarkin and another character that is recreated with CGI (no spoilers (: ) and the entire final sequence of stealing the Death Star plans.

You know what? I'm going to spoil it. They steal the Death Star plans and give them to Princess Leia. She gives them to the rebels and they destroy the Death Star! There, I just spoiled everything for you! LOL… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

kamikaz3kittenJan 1, 2017

A beautiful looking movie, proving that a stand alone movie set in this universe can succeed and do it with style. Its action packed leaving me wanting more.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

6

DemoraseJan 1, 2017

I don't know how to describe Rogue One for the first hour and half other than I was utterly bored out of my mind. However, the last thirty minutes were full and engrossing enough to salvage this troubled movie. But surely you can do betterI don't know how to describe Rogue One for the first hour and half other than I was utterly bored out of my mind. However, the last thirty minutes were full and engrossing enough to salvage this troubled movie. But surely you can do better than that, Disney.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

0

ClearviewDec 31, 2016

It is most boring movie! Music is unbearable and annoying! Everything in this movie is boring and much worse than original star wars. Actor's play is so bad, can't stay it. After watching this, I think I will never watch new star wars.

3 of 42 users found this helpful339

All this user's reviews

5

FortifierDec 31, 2016

This edition to the Star Wars cinematic universe felt a lot to me like "Suicide Squad"; great fan service and cool cast, but is ultimately empty due to undeveloped story and characters. Most Star Wars films begin with two protagonists, thenThis edition to the Star Wars cinematic universe felt a lot to me like "Suicide Squad"; great fan service and cool cast, but is ultimately empty due to undeveloped story and characters. Most Star Wars films begin with two protagonists, then as they journey throughout the galaxy we learn more about them as well as the world around them and the story itself. Then eventually the "torch" is passed down to two new characters who we follow as the story continues.

In short, the previous Star Wars films accomplished beautiful character, plot and world development at the exact same time. In "Rogue One", however, the "torch" is thrown around rapidly as the characters sit in a circle like a game of "hot potato". There is little to no character development, we're thrown around all over the place in the Star Wars universe, and the writers leave absolutely no time for its audience to emotionally invest in the story or characters (which is extremely disappointing for not only a Star Wars film, but for a film that is over TWO HOURS LONG).

This is what its like for the first two-thirds of the film; while there is a lot of fan service to go around (which is expected from this film), the story and character development is simply atrocious. The third and final act, however, is what saves this movie from being an utter waste of time. This is when the action and threat becomes real and the characters finally come to life. If this film was just the final 40 minutes I would actually give this film a much higher rating.

In conclusion, this series relies far more on fan-service of an already established Star Wars universe to please its audience rather than an actual (never mind "original") story. Believe me when I say that, unless you are an absolute die-hard fan of the Star Wars franchise, you're better off simply re-watching the Original Trilogy if you want to watch Star Wars again.

5/10… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

10

RixusDec 31, 2016

This is the Star Wars you've been waiting for. This is the Star Wars we deserve. The best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy. Its got everything you could ever want, from storm troopers and gritty combat, to space battles and aThis is the Star Wars you've been waiting for. This is the Star Wars we deserve. The best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy. Its got everything you could ever want, from storm troopers and gritty combat, to space battles and a more traditional take on faith in The Force. I want to go into detail, but I dont want to ruin the experience for anyone. Just know its a great Star Wars film, and perfectly ties into the original trilogy.

Hollywood: this is it, this is what we want. All future movies need to take their cue from Rogue One. I dont know why the critics rated this lower than Force Awakens, clearly the fans are rating this higher, and I'm right there with them.

Great, great movie. Go watch it!… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

AreganDec 31, 2016

This is the Star Wars movie I've been waiting for.

My All time favorite movie is A New Hope and since then, I always wanted to see more rebel action and plot. This movie delivers just that. We can all agree that some scenes are too long, orThis is the Star Wars movie I've been waiting for.

My All time favorite movie is A New Hope and since then, I always wanted to see more rebel action and plot.
This movie delivers just that.

We can all agree that some scenes are too long, or hurt the course of the movie.
But overall, it has everything a movie needs to be a GOOD Star Wars.

Aliens, original world, space battles (and what a space battle...), land battle...
And this movie is dark. I mean, "The end justifies the mean" could be used to describe the rebel moves...
The ties to the ep III and IV are well made. The use of the CGI was unexpeted but welcomed.

All in all, this movie is a must for a Star Wars fan.
For non fan, compare it the Saving the Private Ryan with lasers :)… Expand

18 of 34 users found this helpful1816

All this user's reviews

9

DevianAppleDec 31, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I overall liked the movie. It is a 'Star Wars Story' but it apparently became something like the normal one, as I have seen at the end. I still didn't like how they freaking killed EVERYONE at the end, and there were slightly too many fighting scenes. But overall, I'll give it a 9.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

MaruganDec 31, 2016

The last act was the best piece of Star Wars I've ever watched. I enjoyed act 1 and 2 but the characters become great at the last 45 min. The chemistry between Jyn and Cassian was good but in that point was The Force Awakens a lot better. AllThe last act was the best piece of Star Wars I've ever watched. I enjoyed act 1 and 2 but the characters become great at the last 45 min. The chemistry between Jyn and Cassian was good but in that point was The Force Awakens a lot better. All in all is Rogue One a great movie with incredible shots, a brutal and dark atmosphere. Episode VII was a movie for children, Rogue One is a phanomenal piece of Star Wars for the one's, who are adults but in their heart still children.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

7

DukeJonDec 31, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Film was ok. Quite a lot of characters, shame they didn't get enough backstory for you to care about them before the end. Nice world war 2 battle scenes at the end. Main female character was "meh"; first half of film she doesn't care and the second half she's making rousing speeches about hope. Great scene with Vader doing his evil thing on the rebel flagship at the very end. CGI Peter Cushing somewhat creepy, and probably not in the way that was intended. I am still waiting for the Star Wars film where the empire troops behave like the "gene-built trained from birth to be natural killing machine super-soldiers" that they are supposed to be. But here we have another film where they flap comically about before lining up to be shot. I think the reprogrammed droid took out a platoon just on his own.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

3lusiveDec 31, 2016

Probably the best Star Wars film I've ever seen and the best film I've watched this year. Bold, engrossing, tense, and very well put together. Light-years ahead of what I thought it would be. Acting from all main characters is strong, storyProbably the best Star Wars film I've ever seen and the best film I've watched this year. Bold, engrossing, tense, and very well put together. Light-years ahead of what I thought it would be. Acting from all main characters is strong, story is generally well thought out and paced. The humour parts are subtle and not overdone or childish.

The villains are exceptional and Darth Vader in particular is genuinely 'scary', his limited screen time is still very effective.

Overall Rogue One has a serious tone to it which suits the film and franchise very well (as opposed to childish crap that plagues some previous ones). You genuinely care for their fate and the task at hand (to get the Death Star files which expose its critical weaknesses). At no point during the film did I feel bored or wanting it to hurry up, in fact I could have sat for at least another hour! Very well balanced and paced.

The film is leaps and bounds ahead of The Force Awakens and previous recent star wars films.

I rarely write reviews but felt this one deserved it.

More please.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

8

chesaroDec 30, 2016

It is a good movie, but by no means a great one, or better than episode VII, it does what it pointed to do. The only thing i really hated was the CG characters... They just looked fake.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

RvwFromUpHereDec 30, 2016

Who: Felicity Jones, a Spanish guy, and Charles Jefferson as, Saw Gerrera
What: Another reason for butt-hurt Warcraft fans to leave their basement, wash the cheetoh dust from their hands, and trash a movie that is actually pretty great
Where:Who: Felicity Jones, a Spanish guy, and Charles Jefferson as, Saw Gerrera
What: Another reason for butt-hurt Warcraft fans to leave their basement, wash the cheetoh dust from their hands, and trash a movie that is actually pretty great
Where: A Galaxy Far, Far, Away
When (Can I watch this movie again): If you like Star Wars, any time. If you don't...you're the worst type of person.
Why: While Episode 7 was very divisive among fans, this movie stays true to the intentions of the original trilogy and delivers what it promised.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

7

AuthorityDec 30, 2016

This movie wants to be a more serious character driven movie (for the first 1/2 to 2/3), but without any memorable characters except one sidekick with not enough screen time. Being a prequel also saps some of the potential drama. You knowThis movie wants to be a more serious character driven movie (for the first 1/2 to 2/3), but without any memorable characters except one sidekick with not enough screen time. Being a prequel also saps some of the potential drama. You know mostly how things will end up. The action at the end saves the movie, pushing it into watchable territory, but without the emotional payoff it was trying so hard to achieve. The only reason you care about any of it is because of the knowledge of the better movies that come after. Rogue One seems to accept this, and is liberally sprinkled with references to those movies as a substitute to fleshing out its own plot or characters.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

7

jarvatarDec 30, 2016

The Star Wars backdrop make this movie far more interesting than the writing. Ultimately this move is a C- at best but if you're a sci-fi/star wars fan it's almost a must see. The droid dialogue alone is worth the view.

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

10

kagreelDec 30, 2016

Best Star Wars movie ever! Story moved so smoothly, beautifully shot, great surprises, phenomenal action sequences, and an overall exceptional cast! Story was the best yet of the Star Wars franchise, being so simple yet complex at the same time.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

0

Bo33yDec 30, 2016

The film was pointless. It has got to be the most pointless film in the history of pointless films.

Hey guys we already knew that the plans were stolen, and where they were stolen from, and we also already knew what happened to the stolenThe film was pointless. It has got to be the most pointless film in the history of pointless films.

Hey guys we already knew that the plans were stolen, and where they were stolen from, and we also already knew what happened to the stolen plans and even to the people stealing those plans. It was how the original films kicked off, and it was all rather self explanatory.

But I suppose there is some kind of a starwars geek somewhere else in that other galaxy far far and away who needed another explanation into that rather simple explanation. I suppose you'd really think so? After thinking, hey guys why haven't they got any starwars diversity, because with a galaxy full of alien factions and races you'd think there would be more than just some other token humanoids bringing to life the cartoon version, but they didn't did they?… Expand

5 of 12 users found this helpful57

All this user's reviews

5

ilushkaDec 30, 2016

I do not delivered as much excitement as any other film of the saga. Good play from Galen Erso and K-2SO. Other actors was bad. Movie is good as a cameo-film, like new ghostbusters.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

lucbevibrasilDec 30, 2016

Rogue One presents several new (and good) things in the saga. Be it the rebel extremism of Saw Guerrera, a kind of religious belief (in Force itself), and even the dramatic deepening in the relationship father and daughter of Jyn and GalenRogue One presents several new (and good) things in the saga. Be it the rebel extremism of Saw Guerrera, a kind of religious belief (in Force itself), and even the dramatic deepening in the relationship father and daughter of Jyn and Galen Erso. All this with great action scenes and a beautiful soundtrack by Michael Giacchino. But notorious is the ability of director Gareth Edwards to balance all this and still show respect for the original trilogy, putting scenes with easter-eggs and wonderful references. Oh, and there's Darth Vader. Amazing… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

vonMistontDec 30, 2016

No spoilers. Rogue 1 is the true awakening of the force. While last year’s cash grab made all 6 previous movies pointless, all our favorite heroes dirty and all their sacrifices and struggle irrelevant Rogue 1 only makes original trilogyNo spoilers. Rogue 1 is the true awakening of the force. While last year’s cash grab made all 6 previous movies pointless, all our favorite heroes dirty and all their sacrifices and struggle irrelevant Rogue 1 only makes original trilogy better by explaining some important plot holes (boy how many hours did we spend with friends laughing about how stupid constructor of a Death Star must have been to build so vulnerable station – well Rogue 1 has the last laugh!). It must have been made by true fans of everything that made original Star Wars great and not by some childish pretender who can only see the surface and doesn’t understand the essence. This movie is with The Force and The Force is with the Rogue 1. Beginning may be a bit slow for some people used to today’s action movies in which plot is only an excuse for some pointless combat but I myself prefer this kind of film structure in which first you have to learn why people do things they do. Finale on the other hand has no equal. And I’m not only referring to other Star Wars movies. It was so spectacular that I couldn’t sleep that night when I came back from the cinema. When I close my eyes I see magnificent scenes from Rogue 1. I watched original trilogy dozens of times, some scenes hundreds of times , I watched flawed prequel trilogy a lot too and it also had some good scenes, and while I will maybe never watch Force Awakens again I know that I will be rewinding Rogue 1 and watching some moments over and over again.
There is nostalgia in this movie but it’s not there just to trick you into liking this movie. It’s there because it truly is real original great Star Wars movie in it’s very core, you could literally make smooth transition between last scene of Rogue 1 and first scene of New Hope and you almost wouldn’t notice that another film just started (and that’s what I’m intending to do when Rogue 1 comes out!). It’s also great standalone film. You don’t have to know anything about other Star Wars movies to enjoy it and it makes it even better for Star Wars fan. When someday I will show my child Star Wars I would now have to decide if just maybe I should start with Rogue 1.
It really pains me to watch most of action movies, as often it seems that screenwriter was the worst payed person in whole crew. In Rogue 1 I would really have to search hole in whole to attack a plot. Story was really solid and could stand on its own even if it wasn’t set in Star Wars universe. As I mentioned above movie explains some questions concerning New Hope and some quite familiar characters (one in particular), we can also see even more of how tyrannical Imperial regime really was, we learn that Rebellion also isn’t a monolith but quite interesting group of people with different approaches. Humor was well placed and paced and unconstrained. It wasn’t one liner fest. I feel that every dialogue had sense and it was there for some reason. There was even one inspiring speech which actually inspired me! Usually in moments like these are tedious, but when Jyn was delivering her speech she was making sense and her arguments were convincing.
Soundtrack was ok it did its job and I know it was there which I couldn’t really say about previous movie. For me Star Wars was literally a space Opera or rather space symphony. I was watching beautiful scenes with no dialogue enjoying music and sights. And Rogue 1 has that quality too. Sights are magnificent, when spaceship is flying, even in battle you can see it clearly, camera doesn’t fly like crazy, you can really see what’s going on. I don’t know if it was just me but I also really liked ship’s landing scenes or when the ship flies by I find it very aesthetic and majestic and Rogue 1 has plenty of this awe inspiring moments and also plenty of great fight scenes.
Actors do a very good job, I really liked main cast a lot. Forest Whitaker was a bit overplayed, but on the other how do you not overplay a madman? Diego Luna was excellent as ruthless rebel driven by revenge, Donnie Yen was adorable human Yoda and like no other he showed us The Force really exists. After watching trailers I had many doubts to Felicity Jones as her character seemed too audacious and disrespectful with all this “I rebel!” etc. and I really want my heroes to care for what they do and be afraid to die, because if they don’t care why should I? But I was wrong, she was simply great. And she wasn’t some MaRey Sue either. I also had doubts about main villain but he was just repulsive enough to be believable and not some child’s vision of how mad space nazi would behave. CGI characters could have been made better, but I my fiance who didn’t grow up with Tarkins face said she didn’t notice he was CGI character.
I can’t wait for more movies by the authors of Rogue 1 it is without a doubt the best movie of this year and I couldn’t honestly say that any of the original trilogy films is better that Rogue 1.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

3

DaigoustDec 30, 2016

O filme supera somente os episódios 1, 2 e 3, mas nao se iguala aos episódios seguintes. Alguns personagens foram mau desenvolvidos. Mimimimimimimimimimimimimi

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

8

HelenHDec 30, 2016

Good film. It adds to the previous films. And I believe it is the first time in a Star Wars film the Alliance does not consist of only heroes who won't do any wrong. Suddenly, the characters are not black and white and I think it is a reallyGood film. It adds to the previous films. And I believe it is the first time in a Star Wars film the Alliance does not consist of only heroes who won't do any wrong. Suddenly, the characters are not black and white and I think it is a really nice change.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

JamesLaskosDec 29, 2016

What an astonishing film! Rogue One is not only in the second place of the best Star Wars film ever created, after Episode IV And V, but one of the most epic movies ever filmed. Long shots and beautiful shot angles that reminds PeterWhat an astonishing film! Rogue One is not only in the second place of the best Star Wars film ever created, after Episode IV And V, but one of the most epic movies ever filmed. Long shots and beautiful shot angles that reminds Peter Jackson's The Lord Of The Rings, epic music-score, fantastic battle sequences, great humor, incredible cinematography, amazing characters and a very emotional end. Rogue Ones last 5 minutes is one of the best endings in cinema history. Is a cinematic wonder that easily earns the title of the best movie of the 2016 and one of the best sci-fi/fantasy films in cinema world!… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

laxdrew2Dec 29, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This film got almost everything right. The plot, special effects, and dialogue are all exceptional. The one and only complaint that I had when watching this movie was that there were too many operations going on at once, and too many characters were introduced to be killed off within two hours. All in all, this is a great film, the one Star Wars fans have been waiting for.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

SuilenrocDec 28, 2016

Personally I thought that Rogue One was the best of all the modern Star Wars films. After watching this you will definitely want to watch A New Hope again.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

DarthVadereviewDec 28, 2016

This is a Star Wars Movie that shows the true power of the Dark Side of the Force!This is a Star Wars Movie that shows the true power of the Dark Side of the Force! -lORD vADER… Expand

1 of 8 users found this helpful17

All this user's reviews

9

aagarrisonwriteDec 28, 2016

I liked this movie.

Yes, it was 'Star Wars,' with the series' expected pros and cons. And, likewise, 'Rogue One' was a *movie,* with the expected cliches and embellishments. That said, however, this 'Star Wars' movie was, in my opinion, aI liked this movie.

Yes, it was 'Star Wars,' with the series' expected pros and cons. And, likewise, 'Rogue One' was a *movie,* with the expected cliches and embellishments. That said, however, this 'Star Wars' movie was, in my opinion, a pleasing one, both in terms of entertainment value and as an interesting, satisfying story.

Though, for me the movie's true appeal was in the wisdom that lay beneath the theater and images. That is, I felt that there was some *truth* written between the film's lines, of a rare, quality kind that carries over into the real world. For that reason, 'Rogue One' is, I believe, a "good" movie.

I don't see many film, literally just one a year (if that). As it were, 'Rogue One' was the one I saw this year, and I don't regret it.

My sincere thanks goes out to all who worked to produce this movie. I am grateful for, and have benefited from, your time and service. Keep it up!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

nahtan1244Dec 28, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Warning MAJOR SPOILERS TURN BACK IF YOU MUST. I was VERY excited to see Rouge one as I am with any star wars movie. Star wars is a very Exciting franchise and each movie leaves you in anticipation of what may hold in the newest movie. Did Rouge one disappoint me? No It had some really good moments and some flaws too. After reading critic reviews and audience reviews alike I feel I am the only one brave enough to give this a 6. Let's get down to the bottom of this review shall we? So first of all I really liked the character of Jyn Erso. Her character was not only well fleshed out but we care about her as a person and her fight for justice after we witness her father die as he turns his back on the empire. The actor who played her father was fantastic as well as the person who played mother. Gareth Edwards perfectly balanced nostalgia and really good cgi. He and his team of animators did very well at replacing passed away characters with new actors who played their part very well such as General Tarkin. Characters such as Darth Vader and Carrie fisher were replaced with CGI models and voice archives of that character to fit the timeline as this took place around the same time a new hope did. The Robot K-2SO was probably my most favorite chacter he was so sassy, funny and all around liable and was clearly the comic relief and it worked very well. The last scene with Darth Vader as everyone has been making a big fuss about is as good as everyone has been making it out too be. The final battle was brilliant and added a sort of world war 2 vibe too it However this is were the positives end. First the person who plays Riz Ahmed is probably the weakest actor out of the bunch. Also the character of Saw Guerrera was kinda pointless and did not add much to his character or the story. You remember how we got a great backstory to make us care about the lead. Well that is nowhere too be found in the heroes pals. Donnie yen a blind solider who is part of Jyn's team of resistance fighters is fun too watch but he and Cassian are supposed to be friends but no good backstory is given to any of the characters except jyn which makes it hard for me too care about them when everyone expect jyn dies at the end. Which brings me to my next point. Nothing in this movie will surprise you. Now you may be thinking the robot never got any backstory why are you not giving him a hard time. The way the characters are set up the rebel fighters backstory is important as they are risking their lives to save humanity. They are not here too play the comic relief and are the main point of the story the robot is more of a side character. All in all their are many things too like about rouge one but the problems the plague it from being a great movie really keep it from being near perfect and are crucial if they wanted this to be a near perfect film.… Expand

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

7

TGFY_BoomerangDec 28, 2016

I do think, this prequel for the original movies is much better than the recent sequel. The story actually feels worth to tell, and that is something not a lot of prequels can offer. The action and the characters hold their ground for a 2I do think, this prequel for the original movies is much better than the recent sequel. The story actually feels worth to tell, and that is something not a lot of prequels can offer. The action and the characters hold their ground for a 2 hours long movie, which (Spoiler) will have no direct sequel. But especially the end felt much to forced and kind of teinted the movie.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

alejandro970Dec 28, 2016

Forget what you see and knew of episodes 1-3. This one is the real prequel of SW episode of 1977; Jones and Luna moves and feels like fishes on water, and the doses of action will not dissapont the fanboys. One of best choices of current holidays.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

BabinskiDec 28, 2016

This is what the Force Awakens should have been. The action sequences are incomparably better than any other in the previous movie. The story line is also way more original, showing other aspects of the rebel alliance. I only felt theThis is what the Force Awakens should have been. The action sequences are incomparably better than any other in the previous movie. The story line is also way more original, showing other aspects of the rebel alliance. I only felt the characters werent developed very well.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

6

ericrosarDec 28, 2016

While the movie has great visual effects, cinematography, and fan service (a lot), all these replaced character depth and a compelling story. Even episode VII had more relateable new characters. These were here just to advance a plot (aWhile the movie has great visual effects, cinematography, and fan service (a lot), all these replaced character depth and a compelling story. Even episode VII had more relateable new characters. These were here just to advance a plot (a simple plot). The first 30 to 45 mins is pretty slow (and I don't mind slow if character depth is being provided/not the case), then we get to some great action which overstays its welcome by 20 mins.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

0

flamesofexigoDec 28, 2016

I have been watching movies in theaters for 25 years. Today, I did something that I have never done before. I walked out of a movie screening. 45 minutes in I couldn't take it anymore. The rehashed themes, pedestrian dialogue, hackneyedI have been watching movies in theaters for 25 years. Today, I did something that I have never done before. I walked out of a movie screening. 45 minutes in I couldn't take it anymore. The rehashed themes, pedestrian dialogue, hackneyed acting, ho-hum visuals, and mediocre, bombastic score. I am done with the Star Wars franchise. The last good SWs movie was Episode III, which was quite flawed in its own right.… Expand

4 of 15 users found this helpful411

All this user's reviews

10

joyalexandreDec 28, 2016

This is a good Star Wars. A refreshing look at the franchise. It patch a lot of the faults in the old trilogy. I like the more mature look at the characters as well.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

BostonterrierDec 28, 2016

Tied with my 2nd favorite star wars film (a new hope). Empire strikes back is still my fav. Anyway, this movie is nearly flawless, but most its cast is forgettable/serviceable. The only two stand-out performances were a robot and Chirrut ImweTied with my 2nd favorite star wars film (a new hope). Empire strikes back is still my fav. Anyway, this movie is nearly flawless, but most its cast is forgettable/serviceable. The only two stand-out performances were a robot and Chirrut Imwe (as portrayed by the fantastic Donnie Yen). Definitely a great movie.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

5

mace8704Dec 28, 2016

Dark, depressing, and mature. For better and for worse, this is arguably the least 'fun' I've had with a Star Wars film. The first entry in the anthology series creates a darker tone intended for older audiences hoping to have their nostalgiaDark, depressing, and mature. For better and for worse, this is arguably the least 'fun' I've had with a Star Wars film. The first entry in the anthology series creates a darker tone intended for older audiences hoping to have their nostalgia itch scratched as opposed to younger audiences hoping for an upbeat and fresh narrative. Personally, I'm in the camp that thinks Star Wars is currently in a state of narrative stagnation. We've seen the death star multiple times with both Lucas and Abrams. We've seen the orphan narrative with Luke, Rey, and now Erso. We've seen the comedic droid with C3P0, R2-D2, BB-8, and now K-2S0. It gave me an odd feeling of deja vu. Haven’t I seen this movie before? It’s indicative of either a concerning lack of creativity, or a fear of experimentation due to the sacred cow status of the Star Wars franchise. Rent if you’re a fan of the original trilogy. Avoid if not.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

Mantis10Dec 28, 2016

This movie was exactly what I thought, nothing more nothing less. Nothing remotely interesting or clever about it. Just a long drawn out plot that probably could have been a really neat 1 hour short story. Zero attachment to the charactersThis movie was exactly what I thought, nothing more nothing less. Nothing remotely interesting or clever about it. Just a long drawn out plot that probably could have been a really neat 1 hour short story. Zero attachment to the characters and generally uninteresting people... Though Chirrut was sort of neat. That being said the movie looked good, plot holes were filled nicely, and the little bit of comedy was fun. Again, probably would have loved it if it was a 1 hour short created only to feed into A New Hope.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

5

jonnxDec 28, 2016

Great visuals, sound and all that, but if you are not a Star Wars fan, what does it offers? Unfortunately not much. To me, it felt like Disney milking another franchise. It was too long and boring at moments, acting not great, story not thatGreat visuals, sound and all that, but if you are not a Star Wars fan, what does it offers? Unfortunately not much. To me, it felt like Disney milking another franchise. It was too long and boring at moments, acting not great, story not that interesting etc.

I would very much prefer some modern adaptation, without the classic costumes, props and sets. That would be much harder and riskier to make, but there would be chance of making actually great movie.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

8

Gamed2longDec 28, 2016

Star Wars is in a strange place. The prequel trilogy are objectively worse movies than the original trilogy. But they do feel cut from the same cloth. The Force Awakens and Rogue One are better movies than the prequels, but feel cut from aStar Wars is in a strange place. The prequel trilogy are objectively worse movies than the original trilogy. But they do feel cut from the same cloth. The Force Awakens and Rogue One are better movies than the prequels, but feel cut from a different cloth. I found Rogue One to be a thoroughly enjoyable flick. The plot made sense and didn't step on the original films. I liked the diverse imperial bases. The film has minor flaws, such as some of the acting talent being wasted. Forest Whitaker and Mads Mikkelsen can do more/better! It seemed like K2SO got all the good comedic lines. Also a couple of times (minor spoiler) a character appears where the original actor has aged substantially or passed on. The approach taken to that seemed a little uncanny valley to me. Ultimately though the film lacks much of an underlying theme. Which makes it a flick, even though its a good one. Finally RIP Carrie Fisher.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

Jan_FetzerDec 27, 2016

I don't get how the critic consensus only gives this film 65%. IMO, this is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. It ties into Episode IV perfectly, everything makes sense (for once) and the film even goes as far as to explainI don't get how the critic consensus only gives this film 65%. IMO, this is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. It ties into Episode IV perfectly, everything makes sense (for once) and the film even goes as far as to explain one of the biggest plot holes of A New Hope.

In some ways, I even like Rogue One more than any other Star Wars film. For the first time, it's not a black vs. white fairytale, where the Rebellion is good and the Empire is bad (simply because the audience is told so). The characters in this film are more complex and nuanced than in any other SW film before. This is the modern re-boot of the amazing franchise we've all been waiting for.

The only thing missing is the iconic Star Wars sound track. I don't know why they didn't use some of the original musical themes but if they had, I would give this film a perfect 10.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

6

SmoothrunnerDec 27, 2016

Unexpectedly good movie for a Star Wars. At least I've saw it out to the end unlike previous "episode". I'm not a fanboy of this "fairy tale rubbish", but at last they've filmed something that makes sense and really reminded war to meet theUnexpectedly good movie for a Star Wars. At least I've saw it out to the end unlike previous "episode". I'm not a fanboy of this "fairy tale rubbish", but at last they've filmed something that makes sense and really reminded war to meet the movie title. Attractive Felicity Jones is a fine choice for the main role, but other staff are mediocre. Pathetic speeches are laughable and heroes behave unnaturally but still better than in most other SW "episodes". But what really bothers me is that "rebels" are as much unsympathetic as Empire is. They are depicted as bunch of zealots willing to sacrifice their own and others lives for an unclear and morally ambiguous purpose - vague illusions and dreams. They are fanatics with dubious motivation. Even religious suicide bombers have more reason and logic in their doings than SW's rebels. At least they are expecting to end up in an imaginary "paradise" and are dying for their "brothers". But all these rebels - what are they killing and dying for? As I said - they are scary zealots with irrational behaviour and no better than Imperial Stormtroopers. In fact, they are behaving utterly unrealistic. But this is SW after all.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

3

pardogatoDec 27, 2016

Rogue One is what you get when you get a good script for one 5-minutes special DVD additional backstory special, and producers stretch it just enough to fit a full length film. The fact that the whole plot can be described (with details!) inRogue One is what you get when you get a good script for one 5-minutes special DVD additional backstory special, and producers stretch it just enough to fit a full length film. The fact that the whole plot can be described (with details!) in a single sentence is enough proof of its lack of substance. Fans will not care and cinemas will love it.… Expand

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

User Reviews