Read Positive User Reviews for Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

8

TheApplegnomeDec 16, 2016

This is rebellion on a whole new (epic) level. It's a fun and more grittier adventure to the galaxy far, far away.

Rogue One; like all the SW-premieres are always a fun event to experience. Fans and non-fans alike collectively get togetherThis is rebellion on a whole new (epic) level. It's a fun and more grittier adventure to the galaxy far, far away.

Rogue One; like all the SW-premieres are always a fun event to experience. Fans and non-fans alike collectively get together once again for this space adventure. It's visually a big upgrade from the prequels, and it does to a certain point manage to embrace the original film's charisma. Fun, bright and enjoyable characters is a big trace -- and forget romance! This is a pure war film where companionship is everything. We follow 'Jyn Erso' and the main story is greatly focused on her, but a major letdown is the underdeveloped side-characters. They are all well presented and we get some inside to their personalities; but there's no major background nor development to characters like 'Cassian Andor'. Our main antagonist 'Orson Krennic' is very much the same. But there are some deeper layers to him, but sadly not enough to be considered a complex nor memorable villain. Because of this lack of greater depth to characters; the few emotional moments that does exist could have been even greater, because there are some great ones. The great one-liners from K-2SO is on the other hand very much appreciated, it's great that they really understand the importance of humor in the SW universe.

The story that takes place is full of action, as expected -- but more importantly; the characters are the major players here. A great character-filled first act, a more passive & calmer second act, to a stunning and perhaps too massive third act -- that's Rogue One. There're many characters and places involved in this story. All of this made some of the story uneven. It kept going, from places to places, characters to characters and so on; it became an experience that's a bit too far- stretched. It lost that "wow-factor". The second act takes a step back and didn't impress me on a personal level. It's okay but nothing really impressive got to me. But I am confident enough to say to all the big SW-fans out there that you will definitely love this film, and yes there are some really impressive action pieces -- but I never got many "wow moments". It drags on and lacks a greater long-term stamina when it comes to action. When looking at the CGI; it's a major technological achievement, except for two major CGI characters that look all other than alive. They are impressive to look at; much details, but the way they interact and talk is so fake. Add a non- Williams score that's underwhelming, well the flick got flaws. But other than that I really enjoyed it!

It's a good Star Wars movie. Not the best nor the worst. It got its flaws concerning the uneven storytelling and undeveloped side-characters, and some flaws are more serious than other. It's a beautiful story that's partially gritty and it got a stunning visualization of Vader. Add a darker tone, a very satisfying finale and an ending that manages to wrap everything together! That's Rogue One. It's the pure definition of rebellion.

*psst don't enter this film expecting much Vader.

Personal rating: 82/100 Critical rating: 70/100… Expand

48 of 73 users found this helpful4825

All this user's reviews

8

RobBob99Dec 17, 2016

Black Hawk Down meets Star Wars, that is what it's like watching Rogue One and it truly delivers on the action. This has some of the absolute best action sequences in any Star Wars film and it actually has what many of the films have lacked,Black Hawk Down meets Star Wars, that is what it's like watching Rogue One and it truly delivers on the action. This has some of the absolute best action sequences in any Star Wars film and it actually has what many of the films have lacked, stakes. Through good characters and terrific acting, Rogue One manages to succeed what most prequels fail to do, enhance the impact of later films. I see myself watching A New Hope through a new point of view and I have to say, Gareth Edwards made a Star Wars movie that stands on its own. Yes it's not a perfect movie, but it's a really good movie with minor flaws.… Expand

20 of 31 users found this helpful2011

All this user's reviews

9

MrMovieBuffDec 17, 2016

The last time the "Star Wars" franchise decided it wanted to make prequels... we got outraged fans who lost faith in the iconic franchise. Luckily, Gareth Edwards directs 'Rogue One: A Star Wars Story', a title that might put-off some fans,The last time the "Star Wars" franchise decided it wanted to make prequels... we got outraged fans who lost faith in the iconic franchise. Luckily, Gareth Edwards directs 'Rogue One: A Star Wars Story', a title that might put-off some fans, but the movie itself is definitely worth a watch. We meet a young girl named Jyn (Felicity Jones) who had to escape after her father, Galen (Mads Mikkelsen) is informed by Director Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) forces Galen to work on the crafting of the Death Star. After some decade and a half, Jyn meets Rebel Officer Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) and she is informed about the Death Star.

She also meets a droid named K-2SO (a very funny Alan Tudyk) whose mannerisms and personality seem unusual, but helpful. They travel from planet to planet to find more clues on how to get the plans to destroy the Death Star, and they also find more characters to come and help. There is so much of this movie to talk about, but a "Star Wars" review can be easily spoiled, so I'm just going to summarize my thoughts on the movie. This is a really steady paced, dark and thrilling movie. The third act is one of the best third acts in any "Star Wars" movie, ever. The war battle that rages reminded me of the opening battle scene in 'Saving Private Ryan' (1998), obviously not that violent, but for this franchise's standards, it is. There are many familiar faces that return in this movie, most notably, Darth Vader (reprising the voice of James Earl Jones), who only makes two small appearances in this movie. But, they are so great, I cannot elaborate further without spoiling it, so I'll leave it there. This movie, which takes place before the events of 'Star Wars: A New Hope' (1977), really relies mostly on story as opposed to character. You get to know a lot about Jyn, a little bit about Cassian and K-2SO... but the rest are kind of glossed over as far as development goes. Director Gareth Edwards did a capable job of actually making this feel like a "War" movie, whereas the other movies were a space-opera spectacle. The first two acts are a little pacey here and there... but that third act is truly one of the best highlights for this entire franchise.… Expand

19 of 30 users found this helpful1911

All this user's reviews

10

Mad_MonkDec 16, 2016

Loved it. Was a much better Star Wars movie than "the force awakens". This is the Star Wars movie many of us have been waiting for. Darker and more real. Will definitely see it again at the movies. 10/10

57 of 91 users found this helpful5734

All this user's reviews

7

triple_coDec 16, 2016

This is a grittier, darker Star Wars film than the main saga. The battle's feel more real, gravitated and weighted. Visually, the film is absolutely stunning and deserves full marks. Some of the scenes in Rogue One are some of the best I'veThis is a grittier, darker Star Wars film than the main saga. The battle's feel more real, gravitated and weighted. Visually, the film is absolutely stunning and deserves full marks. Some of the scenes in Rogue One are some of the best I've ever seen in a Star Wars film. The beginning of the movie however, is muddled and lacks focus. There are too many characters with not enough development, and too many things happening to really get your teeth into. While the second half of the film will blow audiences away, the first feels a little clunky and the re-shooting seems obvious as you watch.

Although it has a shaky start, the film is definitely worth watching, especially for Star Wars fans. There is much to enjoy here but it comes with some flaws. If you forgive it for it's pacing and character misfires, this is a solid entry in the franchise.… Expand

20 of 32 users found this helpful2012

All this user's reviews

10

LerritsnowDec 17, 2016

Unexpectedly bold and brilliant. This was not the neutered,Disney version of Star Wars I was expecting. In fact this was a very ballsy movie that made a lot of uncompromising creative decisions. There were moments that called to mindUnexpectedly bold and brilliant. This was not the neutered,Disney version of Star Wars I was expecting. In fact this was a very ballsy movie that made a lot of uncompromising creative decisions. There were moments that called to mind Apocalypse Now, Saving Private Ryan and Full Metal Jacket in that last act. And in some key ways it goes evenue further than those films. Hands up - I was not expecting this to be this good.… Expand

31 of 50 users found this helpful3119

All this user's reviews

10

NaxDec 17, 2016

I was 7 when I watched my first Star Wars movie "A New Hope" it was the year 1987. I guess I can say that I prefer old movies above all else, maybe because of that I hated every frame of it. Before I was going to ROGIU ONE I honestly had noI was 7 when I watched my first Star Wars movie "A New Hope" it was the year 1987. I guess I can say that I prefer old movies above all else, maybe because of that I hated every frame of it. Before I was going to ROGIU ONE I honestly had no expectations, NO HOPE at all.

My GOD. I was gonna cry in the end. That was the movie I was waiting for since "Empire Strikes Back". Visually the movie is a masterpiece, way and way better then "Episode VII". Battles are breath taking, I dont wanna spoil it that is why I cant go into detail. THIS MOVIE DESCRIBES THE "WAR" in STAR WARS. A real war, where everyone SUFFERS, where darkness looms, innocent & evil die, this story shows what we have never seen before.

And such an ending, thanks to Gareth Edwards, really I can die in peace now, this movie is the one and one only that almost made me cry, smile, laugh, made me sit on the edge of my seat on the second part.

I GUARANTEE YOU, if you love EPISODE 4-5-6 the most, THIS IS THE MOVIE YOU HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR.… Expand

26 of 42 users found this helpful2616

All this user's reviews

10

BoabDreepsDec 16, 2016

I was 12 when the last decent Star Wars movie came out.
I've been burned ever since: Special Editions, Prequels, Force Awakens (sorry, it sucks).
So the bar was pretty low going in to the midnight screening. 10 minutes in and I rememberI was 12 when the last decent Star Wars movie came out.
I've been burned ever since: Special Editions, Prequels, Force Awakens (sorry, it sucks).
So the bar was pretty low going in to the midnight screening.
10 minutes in and I remember turning to my friend (another 70's child) and saying "I don't know about you, but I'm f**kin lovin this already".
By the end I couldn't get out of the seat. I was an emotional wreck. I had another emotional breakdown in the car on the way home.

To everyone involved in making this film:
Thank you for making Star Was awesome again

I'm going again tonight, just to make sure I didn't dream this.… Expand

51 of 84 users found this helpful5133

All this user's reviews

9

NiikopolDec 17, 2016

The movie has bit too quick of a start. You are jumping from one planet to another in span of few minutes and can get lost there. However, with second act of the movie this is gone and third one is probably best epic space fight we saw inThe movie has bit too quick of a start. You are jumping from one planet to another in span of few minutes and can get lost there. However, with second act of the movie this is gone and third one is probably best epic space fight we saw in Star Wars universe ever. The movie does a lot of fanservice, obvious to any SW fan, but which non-fans and first timers would probably didnt even notice (Hammerhead class ship from KoToR), however is funny, quick paced, the plot gets it together in second act and ties up really great at the end, the acting was very well done (especially Donnie Yen). Great movie, go watch, 6.5/10 average by "professional" critics is absurd.… Expand

17 of 28 users found this helpful1711

All this user's reviews

10

Stroker_289Dec 16, 2016

Some of you are giving this movie an outstanding write-up review with a score of 0, make sure you give it a score along with a write-up. This movie is one-off star wars movie, one of the best in the franchise, far superior to episode 7 inSome of you are giving this movie an outstanding write-up review with a score of 0, make sure you give it a score along with a write-up. This movie is one-off star wars movie, one of the best in the franchise, far superior to episode 7 in every way possible. Everyone involved in this movie should be involved in every star wars movie from here on.… Expand

41 of 68 users found this helpful4127

All this user's reviews

9

lupaf5Dec 17, 2016

Amazing star wars movie, it has his problems but at least is something different, the prequel we deserve, now i have a lot of fait in this new anthology movies. (please check the negative reviews, its incredible how people can be so stupid, iAmazing star wars movie, it has his problems but at least is something different, the prequel we deserve, now i have a lot of fait in this new anthology movies. (please check the negative reviews, its incredible how people can be so stupid, i mean i know its their opinion but damn alot of them didnt even know what movie they were watching)… Expand

15 of 25 users found this helpful1510

All this user's reviews

8

lsteeleDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. With only a few cheesy fan service moments and a long, exposition-filled first act, Rogue One makes up for nearly all mistakes with a beautiful final act and a thrilling final scene that kept me on the edge of my seat. If you are a Star Wars fan, this movie is a must see. If you're not, see it anyways.… Expand

15 of 25 users found this helpful1510

All this user's reviews

8

oDjentoDec 16, 2016

Rogue One isn’t perfect, but it is a great breath of fresh air for the Star Wars Franchise. The direction feels very different at first, feeling more handheld at not super Star Wars-esque because of its grittier more grounded style, but thisRogue One isn’t perfect, but it is a great breath of fresh air for the Star Wars Franchise. The direction feels very different at first, feeling more handheld at not super Star Wars-esque because of its grittier more grounded style, but this is great and works for the film. It ends up making it feel like a real war and struggle for the rebellion and it ends up changing later towards the end in tonal shift and direction to blend into A New Hope.
Pacing is a little odd at first, but the first section is interesting enough to keep you very invested, especially with all the character introductions. The second act is a littler quieter and a bit of a lull but still has enough going on and differs itself from the rest of the film to keep it fresh. The last section is an intense all out action masterpiece, and really gives a space feeling of something similar to the end battle of Saving Private Ryan. Characters are well enough written for you to enjoy and like them all, however they are a little underdeveloped for the most part and you end up wanting more from them. This ends up not hindering the film too much since the film is a standalone. This film does carry itself well, it knows when to be dark without over doing it and changes location at a nice rate with a clear understanding of where and what folk are doing.
This also the first film where Darth Vader is actually fully terrifying, he is almost like an insanely powerful sci fi MikeMyers. Even thoug he isn’t in it much, his presence is palpable.
The good thing about Rogue One also is that it doesn’t try to keep using nostalgia to interest its viewers (which TFA did a lot) but does have plenty of nice little easter eggs.
The droid K2SO in the film is also the comic relief of it, but whilst a few jokes hit the mark a lot are unnecessary and too forced in, and there is (like TFA) a lot of cheesy 2016 throwaway jokes just put in there. Disney need to learn to restrain themselves from certain jokes, and when they do put them in they need to understand when to end the joke and how to fully have them come across.
Last two complaints, the new score for the film is cheesy and doesn’t fit the film at all, and really takes away from it as a whole sadly. Dubbing John Williams over it would be very cheap, but to be honest it would probably make the film feel more epic and fit more. There is also some questionable CGI characters in the film which just look unnatural in the film but still don’t ruin it too much.
Overall, this film diverges enough away from Star Wars to make it feel fresh but also very nicely connects itself to the original trilogy. Action is awesome yet characters are a little underdeveloped, special effects are gorgeous but score is disappointing. It is a tragic war film set in the Star Wars universe, and Gareth Edwards did something brave with what he had.
Bravo to you sir.
8/10… Expand

16 of 27 users found this helpful1611

All this user's reviews

7

dkminusDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is an amazing movie, but it takes some time to become it. It has an uneven, and somewhat uninteresting beginning, a fun but rather incongruous middle, and a spectacular end. Along the way, it both suffers and benefits from the worldRogue One is an amazing movie, but it takes some time to become it. It has an uneven, and somewhat uninteresting beginning, a fun but rather incongruous middle, and a spectacular end. Along the way, it both suffers and benefits from the world in which it's set.

Rogue One is a unique journey through a very familiar world. It has everything you'd hope to see in a Star Wars movie - space battles, stormtroopers, new alien races, lovable droids, rogues turned heroes. Yet it still manages to feel fresh and different from the rest. I personally felt that this was one of the film's strengths, that it was something different. However, the film also pays a little too much homage to Star Wars: A New Hope, its immediate successor in the Star Wars chronology. There are several character from the original film who appear in Rogue One, a couple of whom are digitally rendered. It doesn't work. At all. It's rather unsettling to look at, and I'd much prefer they just recast those roles if they're set on using those characters.

Once the film builds momentum, it's delightful to watch. The humor is great, the action is thrilling, and there are some genuinely real character moments. Sadly, the film is also punctuated throughout with heavy-handed attempts to inspire (you've never heard the word "hope" used so many times in a single screenplay). And there is an evil lair which is laughably on the nose. It couldn't get more stereotypically cartoonish.

Despite its faults, Rogue One is a great time. It's definitely worth seeing in the theaters, but be aware: it might be a little intense for young kids.… Expand

29 of 49 users found this helpful2920

All this user's reviews

8

ReginthornDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is the best Star Wars movie since 1980. The general consensus of last years Force Awakens was that the spirit of the original trilogy returned. However, the problem with Episode VII is in how the spirit is captured identically. InRogue One is the best Star Wars movie since 1980. The general consensus of last years Force Awakens was that the spirit of the original trilogy returned. However, the problem with Episode VII is in how the spirit is captured identically. In having returned so reverently, the franchise needed to display a willingness to tinker. Enter the newest cinematic addition to Star Wars. Rogue One is a balanced movie of hope and despair. The last Star Wars movie to find this magical balance in tone is The Empire Strikes Back. Likewise, Rogue One finds a unique synergy between old and new. The first anthology Star Wars movie works in its inevitable lead-in to an almost forty-year-old classic with a sense of invigoration. The movie smartly covers up modern filmmaking conventions with amazing throwbacks to the original trilogy. Seventies style facial hair can still be found on the Rebel pilots while a few smart cameos make the Star Wars initiated feel at home. The amount of Star Warsness to the film allows director Gareth Edwards to comfortably recton A New Hope. A problem with Rogue One is how the film can only be best enjoyed by a Star Wars fan. Rogue One is a decent enough war movie. The dogfights are exciting. The characters are charming and funny enough. The overall plot can’t be fully enjoyed without having seen A New Hope. In addition, the cinematic impact the film has on the future of this storied franchise also can't be appreciated by an outsider. Rogue One features the most diverse cast of any Star Wars movie... as well as the franchises more intense scenes. The mentioned scenes make up some of the best moments in a Star Wars movie to date. Rest assured the future of the franchise is in the very capable hands of Disney. Rouge One is how a franchise should make the old relevant.… Expand

30 of 51 users found this helpful3021

All this user's reviews

9

FarhanFirozDec 16, 2016

Rogue one is a dark, gritty and the most realistic movie in the Franchise. A Fascinating Story with Stand-out performances and a Mind blowing 3rd act. Gareth Edwards direction with the Action scenes and VFX is ground-breaking. The only issueRogue one is a dark, gritty and the most realistic movie in the Franchise. A Fascinating Story with Stand-out performances and a Mind blowing 3rd act. Gareth Edwards direction with the Action scenes and VFX is ground-breaking. The only issue with the movie is the 2nd act wasn't structured well.… Expand

17 of 29 users found this helpful1712

All this user's reviews

9

blahblahblah69Dec 17, 2016

After seeing Kevin Smith's reaction to the movie I immediately went and saw it opening day. What a rewarding experience it turned out to be. While watching the movie I felt somewhat skeptical as to the direction everything was going, but theAfter seeing Kevin Smith's reaction to the movie I immediately went and saw it opening day. What a rewarding experience it turned out to be. While watching the movie I felt somewhat skeptical as to the direction everything was going, but the third act is a breath taking edge of your seat roller coaster ride that delivers on so many levels and ended on such a high note. Totally recommend. Righteous prequel to A New Hope. Do yourself a favor, see this movie in theaters and share the experience with as many people as you know. This movie will be more and more revered for its place in star wars cinematographic entries as time goes on.… Expand

17 of 29 users found this helpful1712

All this user's reviews

10

kendrickdkDec 16, 2016

Love this movie so much. Great story, great acting, great pacing, great plot. The ending was epic. Going to see it again tomorrow. The movie starts of slow but builds to a hectic tempo by the end.

22 of 38 users found this helpful2216

All this user's reviews

8

Jack97Dec 16, 2016

Rogue One kicks off the Star Wars spin-offs in great fashion. While it lacks compelling characters, it makes up for it with exhilarating action, spectacular visuals, great performances from it's cast and a third act that is none stop edge ofRogue One kicks off the Star Wars spin-offs in great fashion. While it lacks compelling characters, it makes up for it with exhilarating action, spectacular visuals, great performances from it's cast and a third act that is none stop edge of your seat excitement and intensity. It also leads into "A New Hope" perfectly without feeling forced. This is a Star Wars Story worth telling and worth experiencing on the big screen!… Expand

22 of 38 users found this helpful2216

All this user's reviews

7

ezhikovDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I've waited to see a 5/10 movie, so i decided to count plusses and minuses.
Main male character is -
Main female character is +-
Grand Moff Tarkin is +++
Lack of normal Imperial March when Vader enters the room is -
Blind monk with heavy friend is +
Two boring inspirational speaks is --
Three in time jokes is ++
Couple of off time jokes is -
The End is +
New robot is - (except for final part +)

7 total.… Expand

15 of 26 users found this helpful1511

All this user's reviews

9

DefinitelyMaybDec 17, 2016

Rogue one is perhaps one of the greatest Star Wars film ever made -but not a great film in itself. I agree character and pacing is a bit off, but I think people forget that Star Wars never really had great character development to begin withRogue one is perhaps one of the greatest Star Wars film ever made -but not a great film in itself. I agree character and pacing is a bit off, but I think people forget that Star Wars never really had great character development to begin with but rather great actors giving a really good performance (ie Harrison Ford's lines a lot of his one-liners were ad lib). My personal gripe with this film is probably that a lot of the characters felt a bit tagged on - like the blind dude etc, and some of the choices they do (ie in the ending) feels forced and illogical -and could have been written better in terms of what happens to them. The ending is rather unambiguous and a certain CGI character appears too much and does something at the end for no reason (only to ensure there won't be a sequel). Also Gareth Edwards could've shot some of the action scenes better and give some character's a proper arc which was lacking. Lack of a crawl and insistence of using location cards were a bit off-putting.

However Rogue One has the best world building, plot development, costume design, lighting and story flow out of the other Star Wars films. The film doesnt rely on wipes to get to one place to another which is great. Rogue one also have amazing action sequences and impeccable sound design. All the locations feel like real worlds compared to Force Awaken (which felt like small set designs). Although the score lacked more distinguishable motifs, I thought it flowed really well with the action o the films - and more of the traditional motifs were integrated well. Overall I thought Rogue One was a better Star Wars film than TFA and maybe even ROTJ, only because the world building and action was impeccable.… Expand

19 of 33 users found this helpful1914

All this user's reviews

10

allthingsnerdyDec 16, 2016

So, I saw "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" last night and I was actually very impressed. I read a lot of reviews before I actually went and saw this film. So while reading these reviews I was beginning to become skeptical myself, they rantedSo, I saw "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" last night and I was actually very impressed. I read a lot of reviews before I actually went and saw this film. So while reading these reviews I was beginning to become skeptical myself, they ranted and raved about how the Disney keeps introducing planets and characters that they want us to fall in love with or force upon us and have never heard of. This is a side story all on it's own, so we are going to meet characters that we don't know, we are going to see planets that we haven't seen before, and that is ok.

"Rogue One" is probably the best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back", it leaves us right where it is supposed to chronologically in the saga. It has you pulling and falling in love with all the characters for the most part. The little cameos that we see here and there are well placed to give you that little nostalgia feeling.

If we all remember in "Episode IV: A New Hope" where the leader of the Rebel Alliance Mon Mothma says that a lot of people had lost their lives to recover these plans. Well "Rogue One" is the story behind what she was talking about.

Jyn Erso the daughter of Galen Erso, was played by Felicity Jones, an English actress known for playing the role of Jane Hawking in the film "The Theory of Everything" in 2014. I am sure now she will be known as the actress who starred in "Rogue One". She played the role with poise and gumption, bringing the character to life with the strength that her character stood for in the saga. We first meet her character at an adult age when she has already been captured by Imperials and is then "liberated" by members of the Rebel Alliance. Those Rebels would be Cassian Andor and K-2SO played by Diego Luna and the delightful Alan Tudyk. Diego Luna plays a rough around the edges and very secretive scoundrel role in this film, where you don't know if he is good guy or bad guy, while Alan Tudyk plays his sarcastic and very blunt comedic sidekick that is sure to leave you laughing and begging for more.

If you are going to go see this film, keep an open mind that this is a story that we knew little of, and that Disney did a great job bringing this story to life and giving us more of an insight on what the Rebel Alliance went through to overcome the great evil that was the Empire.

This movie isn't meant to be compared to any of the other episodes that we have seen in previous years. It is to tell the prequel story of the most beloved Trilogy of all time. So don't go to this film with doubts, go to see this film with the hopes to catch a glimpse of something you have never seen before, there are no preconceptions of what to think, because this is a whole brand new story, so you can take it for what it is for, a wonderfully filmed movie, with characters you can connect with for the first and (spoiler alert) the last time.

The film has everything, AT-AT's, AT-ST's, sarcastic droids, Dog Fights, real plot lines and a grand finish! A must see in theaters, don't wait to Redbox this movie, you need to go see it in theaters to appreciate it's full value.

I hope this review was helpful, and I hope you enjoy the film as much as I did.

Vader is still a beast!

-Devin of All Things Nerdy… Expand

19 of 33 users found this helpful1914

All this user's reviews

9

judahjsnDec 16, 2016

Just incredible. Reminded me of things that were great about the originals that I had forgotten. This is a masterful star wars film full of feeling and incredibly choreographed battle scenes. It makes the Force Awakens seem bloodless andJust incredible. Reminded me of things that were great about the originals that I had forgotten. This is a masterful star wars film full of feeling and incredibly choreographed battle scenes. It makes the Force Awakens seem bloodless and airless in comparison. The cqi recreations of old actors is the only fly in the ointment. Terrible, terrible decision. Would have been flawless without that.… Expand

27 of 47 users found this helpful2720

All this user's reviews

10

TryASummersaultDec 16, 2016

10/10 I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE, AND THE FORCE IS WITH ME! I'm absolutely stunned and thrilled right now because I just witnessed the most authentic and truest representation of a Star Wars film since the original classic trilogy. This was10/10 I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE, AND THE FORCE IS WITH ME! I'm absolutely stunned and thrilled right now because I just witnessed the most authentic and truest representation of a Star Wars film since the original classic trilogy. This was nothing short of phenomenal and executed every single aspect of the galaxy/franchise in flawless fashion. From the gargantuan scale of the vastly magnificently planet scapes and ships to the wild variation of the characters, this might be the greatest film in the franchise yet. The action scenes are plenty and are amazingly set up on the ground and in the air. The cgi is the best I've seen in any film ever and the grand scale is masterful. The story was easily the most adventurous and well told than any in the franchise. The score was brilliant and captured the Star Wars feel beautifully. Gareth Edwards will now be known as one of the best new directors around after crafting this masterpiece. I was going to wait to see but couldn't hold my excitement and I would recommend everyone see this in the theatre for all It's glory.… Expand

39 of 68 users found this helpful3929

All this user's reviews

8

BrianMcCriticDec 16, 2016

This film is so much fun even with its few flaws. My favorite part of the film is the third act which is terrifically shot with a lot of emotion and great action. The lead up, the setting up of the team is put together fairly fast whichThis film is so much fun even with its few flaws. My favorite part of the film is the third act which is terrifically shot with a lot of emotion and great action. The lead up, the setting up of the team is put together fairly fast which doesn't allow for much character development. Also I felt some of the cameos were forced just to get a fan reaction instead of writing them in with more thought. Overall this is my fifth favorite Star Wars film behind the original trilogy and TFA. A-… Expand

16 of 28 users found this helpful1612

All this user's reviews

10

ChopperGunnerNLDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Star Wars Rogue One was personally one of my favorite Star Wars movies. The movie takes a while to get the viewer's attention, but after that the movie became very interessting. CGI was well done, casting and acting was good and storyline was well written and unpredictable. (SPOILER ALERT): This is also one of the few action movies and the only Star Wars movie were they main characters die.… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

DeathSladeDec 16, 2016

In my opinion this is one of the best star wars movies ever. It's gritty, grounded, has a lot of action and callbacks to the original trilogy, and overall great. Most of the characters also have great development and i am actually sympatheticIn my opinion this is one of the best star wars movies ever. It's gritty, grounded, has a lot of action and callbacks to the original trilogy, and overall great. Most of the characters also have great development and i am actually sympathetic for the villain. Vader in this movie is so satisfying and all the scenes that he's in is amazing, it really shows what Vader really is. The only negative that i have with this movie is probably the characters with the CGI face which doesn't work as seamlessly as it could be.… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

Trent2012Dec 16, 2016

This was an excellent movie that fits in well with the Star Wars Saga. It is a far better movie than the horrible episode 4 remake known as The Force Awakens!

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

KaktusmiesDec 16, 2016

If you love Star Wars, you will love this! In my opinion even better than Force Awakens! If you didn't like Force Awakens go see this! Now! So many nostalgic things and oh, the emotions I experienced during this movie! 10/10 I will probablyIf you love Star Wars, you will love this! In my opinion even better than Force Awakens! If you didn't like Force Awakens go see this! Now! So many nostalgic things and oh, the emotions I experienced during this movie! 10/10 I will probably go watch this one again!
I love space fighting and this movie has lots of it!… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

dannytran555Dec 17, 2016

**** the critic that all i can say. This film is pure gold with great visual and story telling. star wars rogue one is perfect link between ep 3 and 4 also there so many good character in flim with marvel sense of humor . If u wonder should**** the critic that all i can say. This film is pure gold with great visual and story telling. star wars rogue one is perfect link between ep 3 and 4 also there so many good character in flim with marvel sense of humor . If u wonder should you watch this then the answer is yes… Expand

23 of 41 users found this helpful2318

All this user's reviews

9

GameAnalyzerDec 16, 2016

Rogue One manages to stay as a faithful chapter from the Star Wars franchise on its own league serving as a rightful prequel to the fourth episode. The creators right from the start had promised to bring something new to the table and theyRogue One manages to stay as a faithful chapter from the Star Wars franchise on its own league serving as a rightful prequel to the fourth episode. The creators right from the start had promised to bring something new to the table and they did deliver. The casting was perfect. The CGI has been remarkable with lots of surprise elements in offer for long time fans of the franchise from the 70s. Although the film delivers in the long run with all Stars Wars action elements ranging from stormtroopers to the AT act walkers against the rebellion units , there are minor issues with general pacing as the story progresses around with its Death Star plot at instances with poorly timed execution of the characters related to it, bogging it down for viewers. The Force Awakens had an USP with great character execution but on the other hand the action sequences in Rogue One struck the right chord several notches above TFA for the prequel story. It deserves a solid 9.… Expand

24 of 43 users found this helpful2419

All this user's reviews

10

ProsmoothDec 16, 2016

This is a guy's Star Wars movie that stars a chick in the lead. Trust me--if you owned all the toys when you were 11 years old, you are going to go bonkers over this thing. It's The Dirty Dozen in space with Darth Vader and AT ATs. During theThis is a guy's Star Wars movie that stars a chick in the lead. Trust me--if you owned all the toys when you were 11 years old, you are going to go bonkers over this thing. It's The Dirty Dozen in space with Darth Vader and AT ATs. During the last third of this thing I felt like I could take on the whole Empire myself. It's a flawed masterpiece. Weakest part is the music and some pacing problems in the first act--but it's not weak enough to affect my score.… Expand

85 of 153 users found this helpful8568

All this user's reviews

10

HasskthugDec 16, 2016

Everything ever wanted from a Star Wars movie. I'm rooting for both the bad guys and the good guys. Funny, exhilarating and tragic. It adds deeper meaning to Episode IV. Thank you Gareth Edwards

25 of 45 users found this helpful2520

All this user's reviews

10

saleen2k3Dec 16, 2016

I thought the movie was amazing, the characters, the set pieces, and the emotional aspects of the movie. I was really pulled in and did not let up until the end. 10/10

17 of 31 users found this helpful1714

All this user's reviews

9

MasterRileyDec 17, 2016

Rogue One is the epic story that follows a small group of rebels that steal the plans to the death star. I really liked the cinematography, special effects, action, and overall scope of this film. It is one of if not the most beautifulRogue One is the epic story that follows a small group of rebels that steal the plans to the death star. I really liked the cinematography, special effects, action, and overall scope of this film. It is one of if not the most beautiful looking Star Wars movies. Most of the new characters are really good as well and the performances provided by the various actors. The characters that stood out the most for me are Krennic, K2SO, and Chirrut. I wasn't a huge fan of Saw Gerrera and felt like some of the other characters weren't as memorable as I hoped they'd be. But after thinking about it I think thats the point of the story. This group of rebels ended up risking their lives for the greater good of the galaxy, and sometimes not being remembered after the fact is what happens in war. I only have one other main gripe with the film, and it has to do with a CGI character. I liked the writing and performance of the character I am just unsure that it feels organic enough to fit into the story. Overall these few nitpicks aren't really enough for me to feel the film is flawed because it is amazing in every other front. Especially the final act, oh man was it ever worth it. This is the prequel you are looking for.… Expand

29 of 54 users found this helpful2925

All this user's reviews

7

BertoflyingfoxDec 16, 2016

It was always going to have a predictable outcome, but a decent flick nonetheless. Just good enough to stay in "go watch it eventually" status.

The beginning of the movie planet-hops a bit too much, some characters feel underdeveloped, andIt was always going to have a predictable outcome, but a decent flick nonetheless. Just good enough to stay in "go watch it eventually" status.

The beginning of the movie planet-hops a bit too much, some characters feel underdeveloped, and the action scenes could've been more interesting.

Really fun third act though. Special mention for Donnie Yen and Jiang Wen, they did a great job playing their characters.… Expand

16 of 30 users found this helpful1614

All this user's reviews

10

AreganDec 31, 2016

This is the Star Wars movie I've been waiting for.

My All time favorite movie is A New Hope and since then, I always wanted to see more rebel action and plot. This movie delivers just that. We can all agree that some scenes are too long, orThis is the Star Wars movie I've been waiting for.

My All time favorite movie is A New Hope and since then, I always wanted to see more rebel action and plot.
This movie delivers just that.

We can all agree that some scenes are too long, or hurt the course of the movie.
But overall, it has everything a movie needs to be a GOOD Star Wars.

Aliens, original world, space battles (and what a space battle...), land battle...
And this movie is dark. I mean, "The end justifies the mean" could be used to describe the rebel moves...
The ties to the ep III and IV are well made. The use of the CGI was unexpeted but welcomed.

All in all, this movie is a must for a Star Wars fan.
For non fan, compare it the Saving the Private Ryan with lasers :)… Expand

18 of 34 users found this helpful1816

All this user's reviews

10

AdamCMDec 16, 2016

The best Star Wars since Empire. Everything worked. The action was fantastic. The creative score was incredible. The characters were fun. It was just a fun movie!

34 of 65 users found this helpful3431

All this user's reviews

10

Can7onaLegendDec 16, 2016

The Greatest movie since sliced bread and various other bread based thing's. like egg's and car's. wanna find out how the death star blew up? this is the movie for moviegoers!

23 of 44 users found this helpful2321

All this user's reviews

10

rumburDec 16, 2016

Great movie, with nice story, and a lot better feeling than so called "episode seven". The only flaw is soundtrack, which is variation of the original SW music. But the ending was great, and the movie really tie-in with episode 4. TommorowGreat movie, with nice story, and a lot better feeling than so called "episode seven". The only flaw is soundtrack, which is variation of the original SW music. But the ending was great, and the movie really tie-in with episode 4. Tommorow i'm going again. It's the best Star Wars movie since "Return of the Jedi".… Expand

26 of 52 users found this helpful2626

All this user's reviews

10

Moviereviewer15Dec 16, 2016

Little note: my review will be spoiler-free

HOLY S--T! What I just saw blew me away. What I came out of was "Star Wars" at it's best. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is, IMHO, now the TRUE best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back".Little note: my review will be spoiler-free

HOLY S--T! What I just saw blew me away. What I came out of was "Star Wars" at it's best. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is, IMHO, now the TRUE best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back". Set before the original "Star Wars" from 1977, this film shows us a true WAR in "Star Wars" by having spies of the Rebel Alliance go up against the evil Galactic Empire to steal the plans to their original Death Star. And, since Gareth Edwards, the director of this movie, really wanted to deliver a war film set in the Star Wars universe, akin to "Saving Private Ryan" and "Black Hawk Down", he was telling the truth coming out of what I saw. It really feels like a Star Wars movie in a whole new way. I will admit that I enjoyed "The Force Awakens", but, after a while, I've come to realize that while it is watchable, it feels safe in some ways. This one, really showed how original, different and new it was while being familiar when it knew too and it payed off big time in what I consider it's most serious, if not darkest, Star Wars ever. The entire cast of this movie shines. Felicity Jones plays Jyn Erso, our lead hero with strong brashness but such vulnerability you can't help but feel bad for her when you see how things play out for her in the film, especially with her father Galen (played by the always devious yet charming Mads Mikkelsen). Diego Luna puts effort into his role as Cassian Andor and makes it as memorable as his character's arc in the film is. Riz Ahmed really shows how conflicted his character, Bodhi Rook, is as he delivers playing a former Imperial cargo worker now struggling to redeem himself. Donnie Yen," and Jiang Wen are awesome as the pair of Force-believing warrior Chirrut Imwe and trigger-happy gun-wielding Baze Malbus. And, Alan Tudyk as the sarcastic reprogrammed droid K-2SO rounds out the cast to help make this movie work in their best way and they all get moments to shine in such iconic ways. Ben Mendohlson really showed his determination playing Orson Krennic in a different kind of villain for "Star Wars" to show. Darth Vader when he shows up really shows in this time where the film is set, he really is the Vader everyone grew up with. But, I cannot get off the hook without saying how impressed I am by Forest Whitaker's performance of my most anticipated character from this movie, Saw Gerrera from "Star Wars: The Clone Wars". While he was in this movie for more or less of what I expected, Forest Whitaker REALLY got into character as Saw and portrayed him in all the ways he was portrayed when we first saw him in "The Clone Wars". Also, if you generational Star Wars fans are hoping for ties to the Prequel Trilogy instead of just the Originals, well you're in luck, as we get appearances of not just characters and actors from the Prequels but also planets from the Prequels as well. We also visit new planets that help expand many parts of the Star Wars mythology such as where people stand in believing the Force and what it took to build the Death Star. Plus, be on the lookout for appearances and mentions of certain characters and ships from "Star Wars Rebels", which you can watch on Disney XD, when it returns with new episodes in January. Also, two important characters from the Original Trilogy make a return in some of the most well-made VFX ever put to film. I'm not spoiling who they are, so, you'll just have to watch for yourself. And, you'll feel like you're part of the action especially once you get to the epic space battle in the climax of the movie. Finally, Michael Giacchino really delivered with his score for this movie that really brings out the action and emotional development these characters go through to complete their mission as well as bringing something new to score in "Star Wars" while sprinkling familiar scores when needed. Overall, if you're looking for a phenomenal "Star Wars" film, "Rogue One" is that. It truly delivers on taking huge risks, like abandoning the traditional opening crawl, and finding its place into the "Star Wars" universe while remaining a standalone movie that really doesn't need to setup anything for the future of "Star Wars". And, that's good. I hope this movie is successful enough to do more riskier Star Wars spinoffs, especially if Episode IX is the last of the core Star Wars saga. I hope you all love this film, because I most certainly did. This film is for all generations of Star Wars fans. Go see it. You'll be glad you did. 5 stars. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
10/10… Expand

27 of 55 users found this helpful2728

All this user's reviews

10

RookeyFeb 3, 2020

So much better than the new trilogy. Definetly worth watching, especially as a fan.

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

8

WiedzemirFeb 3, 2020

The best Disney Star Wars so far. The well-written story, believable characters. Both sides of the conflict are shown to be competent and driven by reasonable motivations. Decent CGI, Tarkin looks almost real.

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

10

Passionate_RedJan 17, 2023

Perfect... kinda. It's certainly my favourite Star Wars movie. Didn't really like Cassian.

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

7

Fixer84Mar 15, 2023

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a Star Wars movie that couldn't be more Star Wars. Set aside the Jedi and focused on the component of the Rebellion (finally!) the film does what it has to do. And it does it well. Maybe some characters could be handled well and the supporting characters are only needed to do one thing, die. But not all stories have to have a happy ending.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

9

andyviciusDec 29, 2017

this is a great star wars movie. for me, it's up there with empire strikes back. yep, that good.

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

10

Jason117Jan 8, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Well, this film actually turn me into a Star war fan. When the force awaken came out I was like meh, I was a half fan of star wars and I think im gonna keep it that way cause I wasn't watching much of epic Star wars before. I never actually get into the movie but this time, I'm touched by the film and I'm seriously mean it. I truely wish Jyn and Cassian can make it out and I can see them again in the up-coming films in the future but it's ok if they didn't. She will be remain as my favorite character in my momery.… Expand

5 of 7 users found this helpful52

All this user's reviews

9

SchroederRockDec 18, 2016

After a ho-hum Episode 7 that rehashes the plot of Episode 4, I wasn't sure I had much faith left in Disney's ability to resurrect this franchise and push it forward. Rogue One has completely changed my mind on that. One can make a case thatAfter a ho-hum Episode 7 that rehashes the plot of Episode 4, I wasn't sure I had much faith left in Disney's ability to resurrect this franchise and push it forward. Rogue One has completely changed my mind on that. One can make a case that the first 30 minutes of the movie are a bit forgettable but ultimately they create the groundwork for the rest of the film, which connects phenomenally with Episode 4's first moments. Where Rogue One succeeds over Episode 7 is the visceral feel of the film. This is absolutely a space epic with futuristic technology and tons of gloss but somehow it all comes off with a little grit and loads more adventure than last year's Episode 7. Rogue One shows that there are stories worth telling in between the major events seen in each Episode film. Even if you're not an avid Star Wars fan, you can appreciate what Rogue One is, but tuned-in fans will love seeing several familiar faces of the early Rebellion. Whatever the next Star Wars film is, bring it one!… Expand

13 of 19 users found this helpful136

All this user's reviews

7

PipeCJan 11, 2017

A Standalone But Autochthonous Rebellion

Ten years after the terminal insertion into film cosmos begot by George Lucas, settled down the first usufruct of Disney's shrewd acquisition when it purchased Lucasfilm. "The Force Awakens" was theA Standalone But Autochthonous Rebellion

Ten years after the terminal insertion into film cosmos begot by George Lucas, settled down the first usufruct of Disney's shrewd acquisition when it purchased Lucasfilm. "The Force Awakens" was the channel Abrams applied to flourish the torpid force in the warsies' heart after the futile prequels. Starting with this one, Disney took it upon itself to purvey an annual movie within litigating film release schedule. Kathleen Kennedy and formidable crew of the factory covet with making an empirical universe about the preternatural galaxy far, far away; and to achieve this, they have concluded to try its luck with Edwards' war experiment in order to elucidate whether it is beneficial to create a line of independent events out of the Skywalker family. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" opens by far a feasible wave of dissimilar films of a galactic anthology while focusing and securing its strongest point in the director's fervent declaration: war film which does not drink neither George Lucas' nor J. J. Abrams' lymph for manufacturing a deferential, nostalgic, cogitative, and sometimes dispiriting extension in Star Wars mythology.

Its narrative component emulates the scale clichés of the original trilogy: a princess, a robot, a misanthrope, a strife between the dark side and the light side and of course display of spaceships assailing each other. Conversely, this compact design takes risks as for inquiring into primitive and uncommon perspectives, which foster a fortification of a deeper concept around mythology. And although as a last resort is a war celluloid more than remarkable—in spite of it merely sketches certain characteristics and focuses its plausible references in "The Dirty Dozen" (1967) by Robert Aldrich—does not manage to be a corporeal Star Wars movie since it's constantly held on by fan service and generates a quite primary treatment to the development. A prime look to unfamiliar areas from a standpoint's as ordinary as opposed, a wit tinged of tribulation and grief and one of the most honorable final thirds in a blockbuster in recent times are the unforeseen top ambitions by the filmmaker.

It takes place before the events of "Episode IV," "Rogue One" came up from a shallow idea of visual effects supervisor and CCO at Industrial Light & Magic John Knoll, which consisted in clarifying the time- space around what was the itinerary of the Death Star plans until being in Princess Leia Organa's hands , route somewhat named in "A New Hope". So this is the story of those ordinary beings who achieved the extraordinary. Innocent Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones) opens with a retrospective scene about her girlhood, underlined by tragedy and misfortune. Thereon, it introduces her as a redeemed prisoner who is moved to a Rebel Alliance HQ. There, a transcendental mission has commended her in order to make contact with his fading father for locating and discovering the nature and the place of a substantially powerful weapon. Ordinary people clan gradually takes form, finding its cardinal mover into the force. Although the fabled team bounces from a planet to another for terminating its commission, we figured out exiguous details about the crew captained by Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) —who made me very proud;—likewise, most fans clamor for more background in Saw Gerrera's story, the leader of the Onderon rebels. Despite the fact that the depth was an authentic reverb, character designs and performances are what many fans were waiting for. Displaying a heterogeneous and multicultural acting cast, which delves into each contemporary civilization, the film takes advantage of the cultural range to generate a vast human-racial universe inside its world, in the same way, each performer gets its moment of glory before the decisive and evocative ending. Their performances made the audience proud, so much so that was ineluctable not yell in the credits of the motion picture.

More suitable for adults than infants, more suitable for warsies than mass audiences. If it were action and conflagration scenes, the near-perfect third act would lead the film to the sublime, sadly, its burning and high-octane last forty minutes aren't enough to keep afloat lack of enthusiasm and the multiplicity of the beginning and exposition, opportunities lacking in momentum and vigor that exclusively are notable for performances and special effects. In time record, Giacchino composed an entrancing, nostalgic and fortifying soundtrack, which is assembled with the dark tone of each frame, also it testifies him as the first author in breaking John Williams' musical canon. "Rogue One" is more a war product, in where its spectacular music, sparkling performances, and nearly excellent action sequences invade unexplored lands and nothing irreverent in Star Wars world, also, the film gives a message of hope and encourages all us, who this year lost a great woman: imposing Carrie Fisher. RIP my Princess Leia.… Expand

6 of 9 users found this helpful63

All this user's reviews

8

SarumanWiseDec 31, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Like many people, I went to rewatch this after being let down by The Last Jedi, and boy, did I forget how much I enjoyed this film. It's basically a war movie set in the Star Wars universe, and as such isn't limited by the trappings of a Star Wars movie (no opening scrawl! No Jedi or lightsaber battles - the closing scene is an exception, but more on that later) and I remember thinking this film represented so much potential for the Star Wars license now out of Lucas's restrictive hands - imagine, an entire universe of Star Wars stories being told on the big screen without being tied down by the restrictions of a main "Star Wars" Episode. Rogue One is a great start to this Anthology universe.

Spoilers abound!

THE GOOD: Yes, there are a lot of characters, and some have criticised that we don't have time to get to know them before they all die horribly and hence the deaths aren't emotional for us - but I didn't feel that way. I thought the characters worked - Jyn was a strong female protagonist who clearly had chemistry with her father Galen, Cassian served his purpose, and Chirrut and Baze were standouts to me (even though a great many stormtroopers had to play into the stereotype and die stupidly to establish Chirrut's awesomeness). I fell for K2SO - he grew on me and his end was tragic (perhaps biased by my fondness for Alan Tudyk and his character's equally tragic end on 'Serenity'). The crew's deaths worked for me, because I felt I grew to know them enough over the course of the movie to care about them - I know this wasn't the case for everyone. When Cassian tells Bodhi the pilot "You're our only way out of here" before the final battle on Scarif, I thought this was going to be another happy-ending no-stakes Rebel tale - didn't see the grim ending coming until K-2SO took a blaster bolt to the chest.

Darth Vader in the hallway at the end - sweet Christmas. I swear there was a mass orgasm in the cinema when that scene happened, and I'm not ashamed to admit I was part of it. Yes, shameless fan service - but it worked very, very well. The OG stormtroopers, Imperial sets and the Death Star also scratched many nostalgia itches for me.

Original Trilogy cameos - I felt these were more than fan service since Rogue One was supposed to be a prequel to A New Hope. I'll admit I'm big on nostalgia so all the cameos worked for me - I was overjoyed at Grand Moff Tarkin and even loved Dr Evazan and Ponda Baba (more poignant as Dr Evazan's actor passed away shortly after my viewing).

Finally, the cinematography in this film was amazing (one of The Last Jedi's strongest points as well). The wide shots of the Star Destroyer over Jedha City, the Scarif beach, the Death Star ominously peeking over the horizon, the view of Scarif from space through the Rebel flagship's floor, the space battle itself - I found it all breathtaking.

THE BAD:
Krennic as a villain served his purpose, but I felt he was underused. In the iTunes extras, director Gareth Edwards explains he couldn't make Vader or Tarkin the villain because they had plot armour and clearly survive the movie - this is probably why they had to cook Krennic up. Mendelsohn does a good job but is clearly upstaged by Vader and Tarkin whenever they are onscreen.

Forest Whitaker was wasted as Saw Guerrera, I feel - this character has a far more interesting arc in the Clone Wars and Rebels animated series, which explores his fanaticism and his hatred for what the Empire did to his sister. In this film he was a plot device.

I'm all for diversity in film - but while watching this film I could tell that the diversity was inserted on purpose. Not a bad thing, but it felt a little forced.

As with all Star Wars films, suspension of disbelief is required - stormtroopers still can't shoot for nuts, a whole battalion of them are defeated by a blind man with a stick in the beginning but by the end of the film they are a credible threat to a well-armed band of Rebels.

THE VERDICT: A thoroughly enjoyable film, and well worth Disney buying the franchise in my opinion (The Last Jedi notwithstanding). Spells a lot of potential for future Star Wars Anthology films - here's hoping Solo lives up to the mark.… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

8

MacsMusicDec 29, 2017

This is a pretty legit sci-fi action movie set as a prelude to A New Hope. The side characters are interesting - the blind guy, the robot, and the big guy with the gun. The main characters are less interesting, but don't hurt the movie tooThis is a pretty legit sci-fi action movie set as a prelude to A New Hope. The side characters are interesting - the blind guy, the robot, and the big guy with the gun. The main characters are less interesting, but don't hurt the movie too badly. The humor and action in this movie are great, and the plot is always moving and consistently interesting. What really makes this movie shine is how it really feels like a classic Star Wars movie - just watch the ending and try not to love it.… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

7

KonlinerJul 16, 2018

Weak on dialogue, but saved by the brilliant set design and action scenes. The climax and ending part are very well executed, while the beginning to the middle part (before they headed to Schariff) are bland. It seems the director wasWeak on dialogue, but saved by the brilliant set design and action scenes. The climax and ending part are very well executed, while the beginning to the middle part (before they headed to Schariff) are bland. It seems the director was focusing too much on the climax and ending that he didn't pay much attention to the rest of the part. I also think the movie is weak when it comes to trying to deliver a sad emotion. It's too overdone.… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

9

varmadmcgooDec 23, 2016

I had low expectations after the cash-grab disappointment that was The Force Awakens, but Rogue One was a very pleasant surprise.

Jyn Erso was wonderful, a true hero. Rogue One proves you don’t need much lightsaber action at all to make aI had low expectations after the cash-grab disappointment that was The Force Awakens, but Rogue One was a very pleasant surprise.

Jyn Erso was wonderful, a true hero.

Rogue One proves you don’t need much lightsaber action at all to make a standout Star Wars movie.

The most impressive thing about this film was how real it made the war feel. We saw sacrifices being made over and over for the sake of the Rebellion. This is why people are calling this a “dark” movie. It’s too optimistic, the rebels too successful, for the movie to be called dark; it’s weighty. The successes are earned at incredible cost. Such is war.

One notable disappointment here was the musical score. It felt largely repurposed from John Williams’ previous work — and sometimes, that was enough, but it felt like a timid mimicry of greatness. Were there any new musical themes introduced? I don’t recall any. It’s fine, even necessary, to use the Imperial March when Vader shows up, but there needs to be more, too.

We met so many delightful characters — all human except for K-2, whose brand of humor was most welcome, and which stands in stark contrast to the dumb dad-jokes C-3PO made in the latter prequels. No, this was smarter humor, which felt (again) more “earned.”

Here’s hoping future Star Wars films will be more Rogue One and less The Force Awakens!… Expand

13 of 20 users found this helpful137

All this user's reviews

9

3lusiveDec 31, 2016

Probably the best Star Wars film I've ever seen and the best film I've watched this year. Bold, engrossing, tense, and very well put together. Light-years ahead of what I thought it would be. Acting from all main characters is strong, storyProbably the best Star Wars film I've ever seen and the best film I've watched this year. Bold, engrossing, tense, and very well put together. Light-years ahead of what I thought it would be. Acting from all main characters is strong, story is generally well thought out and paced. The humour parts are subtle and not overdone or childish.

The villains are exceptional and Darth Vader in particular is genuinely 'scary', his limited screen time is still very effective.

Overall Rogue One has a serious tone to it which suits the film and franchise very well (as opposed to childish crap that plagues some previous ones). You genuinely care for their fate and the task at hand (to get the Death Star files which expose its critical weaknesses). At no point during the film did I feel bored or wanting it to hurry up, in fact I could have sat for at least another hour! Very well balanced and paced.

The film is leaps and bounds ahead of The Force Awakens and previous recent star wars films.

I rarely write reviews but felt this one deserved it.

More please.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

8

43in2014Dec 23, 2016

Related media: The three prequels have been quite soulless, as the actors had to act opposite green screens most of the time, while The Force Awakens (TFA) was a great disappointment as it heavily ripped off A New Hope (ANH). Check out myRelated media: The three prequels have been quite soulless, as the actors had to act opposite green screens most of the time, while The Force Awakens (TFA) was a great disappointment as it heavily ripped off A New Hope (ANH). Check out my review of the latter, if you can find it.
>
What's Rogue One (RO) like?: Story-wise, it's like other past films where the protagonists had to risk their lives to infiltrate the opposite side so as to steal something, except that here, there are also spaceships and lasers... It was better than TFA, but it also has several problems. >
Pros: >
1. TFA broke many of the conventions and principles behind how The Force works and how things work in general! For no apparent reason, Rey knew how to pilot a complex spaceship and how to fight with a lightsaber without having been trained on either task beforehand. (This is all down to JJ Abrams. On Star Trek (2009) it was inspiring, but Into Darkness and TFA just made me question his destructive creativity. His earlier films were also quite unruly. I've decided to never watch his films again.) RO avoids this by not invoking the use of the force that often. Most events made sense. This film is a fitting addition to the Star Wars Expanded Universe.
>
2. The battle scene on Scarif was nice. >
Cons:
>
1. RO is only slightly better than TFA. The story is less contrived than in TFA. However, it was still rather ridiculous that our heroes need to travel to so many places and to go through so many hoops to get the jobs done. Some parts seemed drawn out. >
2. Apart from Jyn, the other main characters were not developed sufficiently, in the rush to show the action scenes. >
3. The actor playing Commander Krennic seemed to be over-acting, all the time. He was unnecessarily angry and devilish all of the time.
>
4. The CGI in this film has some significant flaws. The Star Destroyers look like Lego pieces when in front of a bright background, while the fully computer-generated Grand Moff Tarkin looked... computer-generated. The eyes! You have to sort out the problem with the static eyes! The production had $200m and these problems were not solved?
>
5. I thought the destruction of Alderaan in ANH was the first time the Death Star fired its main laser and destroyed a planet? In ANH, Grand Moff Tarkin said, “Princess Leia, before your execution, I’d like you to join me for a ceremony that will make this battle station operational… In a way, you have determined the choice of the planet that is to be destroyed FIRST. Since you are reluctant to provide us with the location of the Rebel base, I have chosen to test this station's destructive power on your home planet of Alderaan.” Furthermore, Obi-Wan only felt the pain from the destruction of Alderaan and not from any moon or planet before that. The firing of the main laser in RO was not mere a test. Has this film created a continuity error? >
6. The new musical score was a strange and horrible choice. The score rises to a crescendo in a haphazard way and then abruptly drops and goes all over the place. Which inexperienced composer was hired to do this? A Golden Raspberry Award is coming up.
> 7. There was no need to show Leia at the end of RO. (It is not a spoiler that she's coming up next in ANH.) The CGI was inadequate and the scene should have been left out.
>
How would the different age groups rate it?
Children: Excellent
Teenagers: Excellent
Young adults: Excellent
Medium age adults: Good
Old adults: Average.
My rating: 4/5 (no half scores). It's worth it pay to watch it in the cinemas.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

10

delete013Jan 16, 2017

A slow, clumsy start perhaps, it slowly accelerates towards a dramatic ending. At first fractioned story parts collide just before the final act to perform a crescendo of visual and emotional enjoyment.

One just must admire the timing, careA slow, clumsy start perhaps, it slowly accelerates towards a dramatic ending. At first fractioned story parts collide just before the final act to perform a crescendo of visual and emotional enjoyment.

One just must admire the timing, care and precision, accompanied by great acting, especially on behalf of the Imperial side. No candy for children or primitive nonsense for teenagers, just gritty, glorious fight against the odds. And when the movie seems to reach the finish line, there follows a phantastic insidious ending. A triumph of cinema!

I it simply amazing that a story with heavyweight background of the Star Wars would be done in such a bold manner. I cannot think of a better gift for fans of a good fantasy cinema.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

8

Seymour_MoviesDec 24, 2016

As a self-titled moderate Star Wars fan (I enjoy watching the movies, but am not an expert in Star Wars at all) I enjoyed the film. I think that this works as a stand alone film, that isn't going to change anyones life, but it isAs a self-titled moderate Star Wars fan (I enjoy watching the movies, but am not an expert in Star Wars at all) I enjoyed the film. I think that this works as a stand alone film, that isn't going to change anyones life, but it is entertaining. As a member of the Star Wars family, it felt like a nice change of pace, was much grittier than usual, and had some good easter eggs. I say at the very least, this is a good movie to get you out of the house and get you a break from family during this holiday season.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

10

blowme44Jan 12, 2017

For Star Wars Fans, this is what we've been waiting for,"a perfect blend of old and new with spectacular special effects." With a little poetic license this film rivals our fond memories of Empire and New Hope.

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

10

anthonymurphy29Jan 10, 2017

Rogue One features spectacular visual effects, from action-packed sequences to the CGI-assisted return of classic characters from the original Star Wars (Episode IV: A New Hope, 1977). Gareth Edwards managed to pay tribute in a subtle way andRogue One features spectacular visual effects, from action-packed sequences to the CGI-assisted return of classic characters from the original Star Wars (Episode IV: A New Hope, 1977). Gareth Edwards managed to pay tribute in a subtle way and at the same time gift us with groundbreaking storytelling. Rogue One is an excellent addition to the Star Wars universe (although it isn't part of the main saga episodes), further bridging the gap between Revenge of the Sith (Episode III, 2005) and A New Hope.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

7

Chazd3Dec 16, 2016

CG/special effects are marvelous. This interstitial Star Wars Saga is a perfect insert that adds dramatic guidance to the entire Stars Wars labyrinth. Other than the somewhat overwrought and at times confusing space battles, well done.

13 of 21 users found this helpful138

All this user's reviews

7

MaxsonDec 17, 2016

I really want to give this movie a higher score but I just can't. I'll list the good things about this movie first. This one in my opinion has the best space battles, visually stunning and action packed. It's more of a war film compared toI really want to give this movie a higher score but I just can't. I'll list the good things about this movie first. This one in my opinion has the best space battles, visually stunning and action packed. It's more of a war film compared to the other star wars movies. Some of the new characters were pretty cool, their performances were actually good. Well acted, but not amazing. My biggest issue with the film would have to be character's backstory. I'm not going to count the female protagonist,because the movie did a good job explaining her past, but what about the other guys? Some of the good guys were put in without a backstory, so the entire time while I was watching the movie, I was wondering about their backgrounds. My second issue is the the second act, it felt a bit slow because the pacing. The third act was very good, well executed and definitely worth watching just for the third act in this film.… Expand

14 of 23 users found this helpful149

All this user's reviews

7

the12blackDec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One does a lot of things right, but tallies up a few missteps along the way.
The good: Well-acted; great special effects that enhanced but did not distract; and solid action.
The Bad: Music added nothing to the story/was completely forgettable; plot was more complex than in needed to be.
The Ugly: ZERO emotional attachment to any character, good or bad.

Should be a 6 but threw in an extra bone for the Vader action towards the end.… Expand

12 of 20 users found this helpful128

All this user's reviews

8

ShermosDec 23, 2016

The only reason I'm not giving Rogue One a 10/10 score is because it does have a some minor flaws in the plot and could have done a better job with character building. Overall however, this film is awesome, and I haven't enjoyed a Star WarsThe only reason I'm not giving Rogue One a 10/10 score is because it does have a some minor flaws in the plot and could have done a better job with character building. Overall however, this film is awesome, and I haven't enjoyed a Star Wars film so much since The Empire Strikes Back. It might even be the best overall. I certainly enjoyed it more than the Force Awakens.… Expand

12 of 20 users found this helpful128

All this user's reviews

9

TimW001Jan 9, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This was a very enjoyable film. Here is a list of its best feature:
-Forest Whitaker's character
-The Tense Third Act -Giant Space Battle
-Hammerhead cruiser making two Imperial capital ship crash
-1970's grit.
-Direct connection to the 1970's movies
-Darth Vader, and Darth Vader's rampage

It was a far darker and grittier film than The Force Awakens. Great movie, a must see.… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

9

ThomoriDec 17, 2016

Für mich einer der besten SW-Filme,weit vor Ep7.
Grandiose Kameraperspektiven (z.B. der Sternenzerstörer über der Tempelstadt).
Die Imps treffen zwar immer noch nicht präzise,aber wenigstens besser als in den anderen Teilen :-P Was für einFür mich einer der besten SW-Filme,weit vor Ep7.
Grandiose Kameraperspektiven (z.B. der Sternenzerstörer über der Tempelstadt).
Die Imps treffen zwar immer noch nicht präzise,aber wenigstens besser als in den anderen Teilen :-P
Was für ein Schlachtengetümmel und Vader,Tarkin und Leia wiederzusehen war es allein schon wert :-)… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

10

kushtopiaMar 27, 2017

It is the best Star Wars movie. I have personally gone to the theaters 3 times to see it. The violence is tough and gritty. The story was incredible and it contains my personal favorite star wars scene of all time.

4 of 7 users found this helpful43

All this user's reviews

9

ArdiffDec 18, 2016

Well, I'm really waiting for this movie. I waited a very dark and adult story. And I get it. Yes, the first half of the movie is too much boring and tighten but then the narrative accelerates twice and actions happened is too fast. And ofWell, I'm really waiting for this movie. I waited a very dark and adult story. And I get it. Yes, the first half of the movie is too much boring and tighten but then the narrative accelerates twice and actions happened is too fast. And of course about battles. It a one of the massive battles in Star Wars saga, I enjoying of every single minute.… Expand

13 of 23 users found this helpful1310

All this user's reviews

7

dc127Dec 19, 2016

I will preface this by stating that I did not like TFA at all. I thought it was a complete retread of previous movies. I went into Rouge One with low expectations. I was pleasantly surprised. Most of the story is quite predictable, you canI will preface this by stating that I did not like TFA at all. I thought it was a complete retread of previous movies. I went into Rouge One with low expectations. I was pleasantly surprised. Most of the story is quite predictable, you can see almost all of the twists and turns coming from a mile away. The characters are ok, but not great. This is both a plus and a minus to the movie. Part of the reason I did not like TFA is that the characters were overly dominant to the movie. If you didn't like Finn or Rey the movie was hard to watch. None of the Rogue One characters stand out either way. No one really bothered me, but I also didn't care about any of them in any significant way. The movie is almost a paint by numbers remake of a half dozen WWII movies. I however liked this to a certain degree. I left thinking the movie did its job. It told a one off story that was engaging but not over the top. It gave me some space battles and ground fights that I could enjoy without setting up a series of other new movies (boo TFA).… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

9

familyguyDec 18, 2016

Awesome is only word i can use to describe this masterpiece. It basically a war movie with star wars look. awesome character , great visual effecf and story telling. This movie is prefect missing link between ep 3 and 4. also they add aAwesome is only word i can use to describe this masterpiece. It basically a war movie with star wars look. awesome character , great visual effecf and story telling. This movie is prefect missing link between ep 3 and 4. also they add a little of Marvel sense of humor make it ez to watch for new audience . And last but not least Darth Vader super badass in this film. just go to theater and watch it u won't be disappoint… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

10

TJAWApr 22, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. In the same way that The Force Awakens grew on me, Rogue One has really grown on me too, which is why I'm upgrading my score for this film from 4/10 to 7/10. No, it's not as good as The Force Awakens - its characters are kind of flat and it's nowhere near as fun. But after giving it a second viewing, Rogue One is honestly pretty good to me now. It's far from perfect, but it's a decent enough Star Wars experience with very strong visuals, great action scenes and a dark tone. What it lacks, unfortunately, is the colourful spark and charm that TFA provided. Too many scenes from Rogue One feel like a soap opera and it can come across as miserable and boring at times. So, for anyone who disliked it the first time, give it one or two more viewings and it may grow on you.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

10

JonNajemJan 12, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Even though this is a prequel to Star Wars (1977), it maybe the best standalone movie ive ever seen. Every character has their own quirks and importance within the roles they play which make each and every one of them likable for different reasons. The slow start just allows the movie to climb to infinite heights. Great acting all around from both the Rebel and Empire core cast. most people complain about the CGI Peter Cushing, but I honestly thought he was still alive cause the CGI was so convincing overall (Leia...maybe not so much, slightly more noticeable). The action was dirty, yet strategic, like the space battles back in Return of the Jedi or The Battle of Hoth in Empire Strikes Back. Made it feel just like a classic star wars movie, even more so than The Force Awakens did. Though the first act may chug a little on first viewing, it has a much less severe effect on second viewing. All in all, this is a damn good film.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

8

AndrewLambertJan 22, 2017

Rogue One continues Disney's spectacular resurgence of the legendary saga, enriching the series' mythology by exploring hidden depths of the Star Wars universe in ways never seen before.

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

8

hassallDec 25, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. When i saw this movie i kept getting goosebumps, the cgi is this is good,I was a bit disappointing that all the main characters dies in this movie but hey its still a good movie.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

10

RealmOfTheEnderJan 9, 2017

I'm likely not the kind of person to look to for reviews, but I found this film to be absolutely amazing. I'll go ahead and write here:

-Did it feel like Star Wars? =Yes, absolutely. It was perfect. The atmosphere, the characters, theI'm likely not the kind of person to look to for reviews, but I found this film to be absolutely amazing. I'll go ahead and write here:

-Did it feel like Star Wars?
=Yes, absolutely. It was perfect. The atmosphere, the characters, the planets, everything felt like how a Star Wars movie should.

-How about dat Darth Vader tho?
=It was...okay, I guess. He could've been better used, but the way he's used still makes up for it. -Was it the best Star Wars eva?
=I'd say 3rd best, behind A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back.

Overall, I believe this was a really good Star Wars film, and a good film in general.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

7

iampattyjackDec 19, 2016

In five years I will appreciate Rogue One more than I do today.

This is the first Star Wars movie with a major departure from the formula that viewers have come to expect from the franchise and it is instantly noticeable. These majorIn five years I will appreciate Rogue One more than I do today.

This is the first Star Wars movie with a major departure from the formula that viewers have come to expect from the franchise and it is instantly noticeable.

These major departures have both a positive and negative impact on the movie as a whole.

Throughout the film you will find yourself comfortable in the world of Star Wars for a moment, then the movie will make it aware you are watching the creation of someone else with their own ideas.

Watching this movie in the theater I felt conflicted as these new ideas were meddling with something that I have grown up with for years.

However after a night to sleep on the matter, I came to the conclusion that some of my perceived flaws in the movie will become all too important in the coming years.

Those who are a die hard Star Wars fan will notice this instantly.

The opening of the movie is drastically different than what you would expect from anything in the Star Wars universe. It delves straight into a frantic affair rather than the slow crawl of subtext that appear throughout the series.

There is a lack of screen wipes during scene changes, this might sound like a small detail, but in the grand scheme of Star Wars movies, this has always been a staple that felt extremely jarring for a first time viewing.

It’s these small details that don’t feel familiar which will have people annoyed or at least scratching their heads.

Also Darth Vader makes a pun. No, that should never happen again.

That being said, I appreciate the movie nonetheless.

This movie is not afraid to take risks and I greatly respect that.

While the previous filming decisions seem a bit jarring, many of the other changes to the Star Wars formula feel like a welcome addition to the universe.

The Rebel Alliance is shown to be something other than an angelic being to rid the galaxy of the big bad guys.

They make deals with extremists, fight guerrilla wars and hide within civilian populations. I love the expansion of ideals and it even warrants the idea that some were even content or happy with the empire in comparison.

The agents and main characters aren’t necessarily the good guys, they are just fighting for what they believe in. Many of them even fight for what the viewer may perceive as the wrong reasons, but the right cause.

There is so much in this movie that makes the conflict and galaxy feel more real than the main series.

Especially the third act, which is hands down the best part of the movie.

The final battle was magnificent from beginning to end, it felt like watching the Vietnam War in space. That is about the best thing I could ever imagine.

I could have had the entire movie be the story be about some random soldiers on this battlefield and it might have actually been a better film.

Unfortunately because of the highs of the third act it makes the first two acts look weak in comparison.

The film has some major pacing issues in the first act. Nothing quite seemed to flow properly and getting all the information before the film moved along to the next scene was challenging.

It feels like first portions of the movie were solely there to get towards the final act. That inherently makes it less fun to experience.

The film needed a couple more relaxed moments for the characters to build who they were for each other. They never quite felt like they cared for each other which in a movie about a squad of characters is really needed. The best comparison I can make is to Guardians of The Galaxy. The characters never had that moment of interaction that made them bond together through exploits which Guardians of The Galaxy pulled off with flying colors. This movie needed that to really put the exclamation point on the third act. In summary, I enjoyed the hell out of Rogue One despite some pacing issues and lack of character empathy. If you didn’t enjoy The Force Awakens because it felt like a retread of the original film, this will likely be a much more enjoyable affair. As a movie, it feels like a fresh take on the Star Wars universe. While that doesn’t always work the way intended, it sets up the ability for other directors and filmmakers in the future to do the same. I greatly respect that idea and look forward to see what is next. View the video version of this review here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGi71YjuxQA… Expand

6 of 11 users found this helpful65

All this user's reviews

10

olivermetaDec 16, 2016

Loved it. Felicity Jones was the true heroine/ hero and I fell in love. I also felt like the other major characters played their parts well. Also loved the blind guy (Chirrut). A True star wars movie!! Didn't just feel like an attemptedLoved it. Felicity Jones was the true heroine/ hero and I fell in love. I also felt like the other major characters played their parts well. Also loved the blind guy (Chirrut). A True star wars movie!! Didn't just feel like an attempted nostalgia trip.… Expand

11 of 21 users found this helpful1110

All this user's reviews

10

lsdfmksldfmlsDec 17, 2016

This movie is worth it just for that one scene that everyone is talking about. Overall a fun movie but for fans of the series, it is a great bridge to explaining what happens in the background of Episode 4

11 of 21 users found this helpful1110

All this user's reviews

9

RathaelDec 17, 2016

ROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force! Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore byROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force!

Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore by doing so, and introducing us to many new and reminding us of a quite a few old characters, in different scopes of screen time, some important to the plot, others more of fan service, letting us know they do exist in this ever expanding universe.

Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso, Alan Tyduk as K2S0 and Forest Whitaker as Saw Gerrera steal the show. Yes that is that Saw Gerrera to who ever watched Clone Wars animated series. Felicity Jones carries the entire movie with her conviction and fearlessness. K-2SO provides the most of the part of the comic relief but not in a way that anyone has seen before, think of him as of more cynical version of C-3PO, that way I do not go into much details or spoil much of his character. Forest Whitaker is fantastic as war grizzled Saw Gerrera that shows us just exactly how much war can change anyone, regardless of what side you are on.

Another big surprise in this movie was just how much screen-time was dedicated to the Empire and its characters with Ben Mendelsohn as Commander Krennic, puts a real face to the Empire, and how the people behind it, were as divided and human as any of the other rebel characters. That is probably partially true, as he's one of the only real Imperial characters really developed on screen other than Vader/Palpatine before, and it was very interesting to see that side of the war as well. This is where the movie really shines as well, as it shows that even Imperial officers like him, have their own agendas and dreams.

Rest of the cast is very very capable as well with Mads Mikellsen leading the cast as the imperial science officer, and Donnie Yen (Yeah!) as a blind staff wielding warrior, and its Donnie Yen in Star Wars movie, that's all that really needs to be said about that! Rest of the cast is also very capable and the charisma and the connection between these characters is very well established.

Gareth Edwards manages to make an adult version of Star Wars not saying the others were not adult oriented movies, but this one is not really relying on humor but establishing the true struggle that rebellion had to do against the Empire. And Edwards manages to do so, without making the movie dreary all the way, managing levity just enough to keep the story fun and exciting.

Another big departure here is that this is the first Star Wars movie not composed by John Williams but Michael Giacchino whose music fits to the feel of this movie, even though there are some famous Star Wars beats in the movie, most of this soundtrack feels very original, and he has put his stamp on the Star Wars universe, which is an amazing accomplishment.

Everything about this movie feels authentic, and its really the small things from the aesthetic feel of the movie and how certain shots were framed and how certain sequences were established is done very well, almost as a painting at some points, and there was that scene that was scene with a Star Destroyer, that I believe was shown in trailers, that scene gives you goosebumps.

Overall this movie does what a very very few movies can succeed at and that is take established universe, remove most of the main characters from that universe and make a compelling movie, make the universe feel more lived in. Manage to expand on the known universe in such a way that is meaningful, introduce us to some of the new characters that we can cheer for: Either Rebel or Imperial, and as I could believe this is first time that both Rebel Alliance hierarchy is kind of explained, and that adds to their plight. And this last statement I am going to probably catch a lot of crap for, but I believe it to be true. This movie managed to do an impossible, make an original trilogy even better movies.

4 out of 4 stars.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

9

Dirk2112Dec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Genuinely perplexed by the negative reviews because this is a well-cast, expertly designed, well performed film that also happens to have been stylishly directed and cleverly written. It’s actually so well directed and performed that on the few occasions its script hits a bump, the momentum of its performances plus direction rolls right over them. No, it doesn't drip with easy charm and charism of Force Awakens but then again, it shouldn't. [Mild Spoiler!] You couldn’t watch this story unfold onto Ridley and Boyega. It's the Guns of Navarone of Star Wars films in the best possible ways.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

10

commanderclauDec 20, 2016

You are going to cry, but you are going to be happy about it. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story it's one of the best Star Wars' movies (maybe the best one).

7 of 14 users found this helpful77

All this user's reviews

9

ason313Dec 17, 2016

This is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old filmsThis is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old films without feeling derivative of them. Might also be the darkest Star Wars film to date, showing why a new hope was really needed. A great way to start off the side films.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

10

easterfieldsDec 19, 2016

I loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sellI loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sell this story and they are perhaps one of the most interesting motley crews in Star Wars history. It was so fascinating to see how everything fit together just prior to A New Hope and this film actually answers several questions fans have had for nearly 40 years. It really does fit in nicely with the Star Wars mythos and it's exciting to watch! Some have criticized it for being too dark. Well keep in mind that this time period was the peak of the Empire's dominance. The Rebel Alliance had to make a huge stand to start any kind of challenge against it's tyrannical grip over the universe. Thus war was inevitable. This movie does an amazing job of conveying the dark period in which everything was set and it does an even better job of showing how even the smallest sacrifices during such a period can cause huge effects. People die. That is part of war. What really shocked me about Rogue One is that there really is no Force, no Skywalkers, no Jedi, and yet it feels more true to the original films than the last 4 have. It breaks every rule of a Star Wars film and yet managed to do everything right in the process. There are so many pleasant surprises in watching this that every fan should be smiling ear to ear by the time it's over. Yes there are sad moments, but this isn't supposed to be the feel-good movie of the holidays. It's supposed to fill in a spot that existed prior to the very first time Star Wars was introduced to us. Not only is it successful in this regard, but it introduces characters that will long go down in the history books of how the Empire crumbled. Don't miss it!… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

DCharlesDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A fun, exhilarating Disney space adventure. The film works on almost all levels, particularly the CGI created Peter Cushing, Princess Leia, a fantastic final battle and an unforgettable scene with Darth Vader.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

vertiqsDec 17, 2016

After the pretty enjoyable, but still just a copy*multiply+add_old_heroes formula of 'Force Awakens' - looks like we got back on track with this Star Wars Story, though a bit darker, then one may expect.

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

KayVen17Jan 11, 2017

Deutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt dasDeutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt das einen User Score von 8. Bei 86 einen von Userscore von 9. Falls eine 85 kommt entscheide ich ob ich es eher positiv oder negativ nehme. Regeln verstanden?
Dann sind hier meine Punkte.

Mein persönlicher Score = 90/100
Mein User Score = 9/10… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

9

UdrakanDec 17, 2016

SPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darkerSPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darker events. Yes, this isn't some happy story, this is a WAR story in Star WARS and it's absolutely amazing. It has all what I wanted from Star Wars: Space Battles, The Force, cool lovable robots, lasers and explosions, deep characters. The Rebelion is shown from a different perspective - they are good guys, but sometimes they do shady and sad stuff to keep them selves alive. This enriches SW universe, where rebels are mostly shown as only good people. The models and CGI are absolutely amazing. I had shivers going down my spine when I realized just how big Star Destroyer is and then they show Death Star behind it. I was in awe. Skirmishes are clever and Storm troopers are more dangerous and actualy hit people, especialy the elite back ones. Music on-par with movie quality. Darth Vader is scary again! The scene with him is so epic and intimidating! I don't give this 10/10 for 2 reasons: 1)Weak start - first 15 minutes of film are not as good as the rest, It starts slowly with a remote family story, whcih I would rate 6/10. 2) A little bit of cliche stuff. Although amazingly well done, its another Death Star plot, and I had enough of Death star plot in SW. Even Force Awakens was enough. People in market agressively bumping character's shoulder and then shouting at them-I saw this in so many films, it's a small one, but I noticed it, among other nit-picks. Overall it's an amazing Star Wars film and even amazing film on it's own. I totaly recommend it. My final verdict is 9/10 - It's a must see.… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

9

MattyiceDec 21, 2016

Rogue One feels more like an exhilarating war film than a Star Wars film, but this is obviously a good thing. The new characters and recognizable cameos are fantastic, the action scenes are top notch, and it is shot extremely well. The film'sRogue One feels more like an exhilarating war film than a Star Wars film, but this is obviously a good thing. The new characters and recognizable cameos are fantastic, the action scenes are top notch, and it is shot extremely well. The film's first third drags a bit and Gareth Edwards' directorial flaws peek in and out, but the rest of the film's pros make up for it. A great addition to the Star Wars mythos and I hope they make more films like this in the future of a galaxy far far away.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

JackalJan 18, 2017

I am 51, I have seen each film as they came out from 1977...I played as the characters (I didnt have a cellphone)...this story was a great missing piece to the puzzle even more so for a glimpse of the great Darth Vader. Excellent film. I cantI am 51, I have seen each film as they came out from 1977...I played as the characters (I didnt have a cellphone)...this story was a great missing piece to the puzzle even more so for a glimpse of the great Darth Vader. Excellent film. I cant believe it would have any rating below 10.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

krikaoliJan 10, 2017

Wow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make aWow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make a movie much better than Star Wars VIII. Very impressive plot, actors, etc.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

anichelsJan 24, 2017

I did not expect much coming into the theater, being disappointed with the logic of the story line of TFA. This movie is brilliantly written, and nicely plugs the only plot holes in the original series. There is obvious CGI that I immediatelyI did not expect much coming into the theater, being disappointed with the logic of the story line of TFA. This movie is brilliantly written, and nicely plugs the only plot holes in the original series. There is obvious CGI that I immediately noticed, but I'm still giving it a 10.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

MmkkJan 21, 2017

A fantastic film that has raised the bar for all the next Star Wars films. It may drag a bit in the beginning, but it makes up for it towards the end. A must see for any Star Wars fan.

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

moheetoJan 3, 2017

Unexpectedly Awesome Star Wars movie - the start has received criticism for jumping around too much but I didn't feel that at all - I felt it introduced the new characters efficiently. And then we have a bit of story genius that explains theUnexpectedly Awesome Star Wars movie - the start has received criticism for jumping around too much but I didn't feel that at all - I felt it introduced the new characters efficiently. And then we have a bit of story genius that explains the Death Stars weakness. It loses momentum during the middle section which lagged a bit in my opinion. But that's soon forgotten as the action ramps up in the third act for some majorly exhilarating s***. I'm up off my chair in the last 2 minutes as you know who turns up. And the whole cinema cheers at the end.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

abydosMar 25, 2017

Excellent Star Wars movie. Light years better than Force Awakens. This movie is a give new story of the Star Wars universe, a very good and very exciting story.