Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures | Release Date: December 16, 2016
7.6
USER SCORE
Generally favorable reviews based on 3768 Ratings
USER RATING DISTRIBUTION
Positive:
2,939
Mixed:
512
Negative:
317
Watch Now
Stream On
Stream On
Buy on
Stream On
Stream On
Stream On
Expand
Review this movie
VOTE NOW
 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Check box if your review contains spoilers 0 characters (5000 max)

User Reviews

User scoreBy dateMost helpful
8
madnoloJan 2, 2017
This movie was a big surprise for me, being a series fan I went in without much expectations. I had this preconception made after watching the Force Awakens, which I found to be beautiful and very well made, but largely lacking in screenplayThis movie was a big surprise for me, being a series fan I went in without much expectations. I had this preconception made after watching the Force Awakens, which I found to be beautiful and very well made, but largely lacking in screenplay and plot. Rogue One is in my opinion funnier and more captivating than any of the prequels(1,2 and 3). The music and scenario are as as well done as always. Acting from the main characters could be the only lacking feature, but the movie makes up for it with the terrific screenplay and well orchestrated pace. Definitely recommend it.… Expand
3 of 6 users found this helpful33
All this user's reviews
8
cuevaslermaJan 2, 2017
This film is for those who saw Episode IV in the theatres, only those who remember what they felt when they saw the stormtroopers, AT-AT, Star destroyers. they are the ones who really will enjoy this film, only a few will really feel chillsThis film is for those who saw Episode IV in the theatres, only those who remember what they felt when they saw the stormtroopers, AT-AT, Star destroyers. they are the ones who really will enjoy this film, only a few will really feel chills to see certain characters. Only a few will return to 1977, for the others a good sci-fi movie could be considered.… Expand
3 of 6 users found this helpful33
All this user's reviews
10
LyciusJan 30, 2017
I am old school and one of those people who rejects the special editions and the 3 prequels as a horrible departure from the first three films. I place this film solidly at the number 2 spot in my favorites, behind Empire.
3 of 6 users found this helpful33
All this user's reviews
10
NRbgjMar 23, 2017
This is how Star Wars should be, a darker, gritty, more realistic space opera. A piece of art in the movie industry by crew and cast. Excellent. Well done.
3 of 6 users found this helpful33
All this user's reviews
8
GrantD243Apr 25, 2018
Rogue One was Disney's first stab at a non-Skywalker saga film and it was a valiant first attempt. It did its job of filling the gap of time that we don't see before A New Hope starts, but it's not without its flaws. The biggest problem withRogue One was Disney's first stab at a non-Skywalker saga film and it was a valiant first attempt. It did its job of filling the gap of time that we don't see before A New Hope starts, but it's not without its flaws. The biggest problem with this film, which leads to other problems, is that we only get one movie with this cast of characters. This was something that was set in stone from the beginning, so they had to try to make us care about these characters in a pretty tight running time. And, unfortunately, they don't execute this task as well as they could have. The rest of the movie is pretty damn good. We get some classic Star Wars scenes, and some interesting plot lines. There's also some excellent comedy in this film (much better than than Diney's other two Star Wars films). But, the characters are pretty shallow as I said and it's hard to truly care about them when the movie expects us to, and as a result the film isn't as good as it could have been.… Expand
3 of 6 users found this helpful33
All this user's reviews
7
DirigiblePulpJan 5, 2017
Mostly good fun. The new characters seem interesting, but probably don't get enough depth. I like the underlying theme of the unsung heroes of the rebellion though I'm not sure if it ever really rang true in the end. It's mostly there as aMostly good fun. The new characters seem interesting, but probably don't get enough depth. I like the underlying theme of the unsung heroes of the rebellion though I'm not sure if it ever really rang true in the end. It's mostly there as a sign post and when the main characters die it feels more like a necessary act for the films that follow as opposed to any kind of inevitability about the sacrifices and futility of war.

Mikkelsen is a bit wasted and he shouldn't have been. Mendelsohn is good, though I wish he would have gotten some juicier scenes (the opening confrontation between these two is probably the best for both).

There's a bit too much fan service in this. The CGI Tarkin and Leia aren't necessary. They were distracting and are going to age extremely poorly. It was fine for them to do it, but close-ups of their faces was needless. They should have kept the shots wide and distant, and up close with their backs turned. Vader kicking ass was both cool and eye-roll inducing. I still don't know how to feel about that. Is there nothing sacred anymore?… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
10
CombinerMar 27, 2017
Great movie with all that traditional Star Wars moments , epic space battles tragic moments ! This movie has something that The Force Awaken had not ... Maybe it's much more soul in it .
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
8
dharmaJun 10, 2017
Rogue One is a bold direction for the Star Wars franchise under Disney. Sure it's a 'retelling' and prequel to the original trilogy, but it's bleakness and sombre tone is so much different than the 'Jedi oriented' main 'line'. Despite itsRogue One is a bold direction for the Star Wars franchise under Disney. Sure it's a 'retelling' and prequel to the original trilogy, but it's bleakness and sombre tone is so much different than the 'Jedi oriented' main 'line'. Despite its middling second act (a problem associated with any film by Gareth Edwards), it then proceeds to a great third act, essentially one of the best set pieces ever in a Star Wars film. A great addition to the ever expanding Star Wars universe and it shows that Disney's ability as a box office juggernaut is without comparison.… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
10
PlutarcoMar 28, 2017
This is a wonderful movie. I just want to thank the people who created this beautiful masterpiece. Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, Rogue One!!!
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
8
mp303Feb 4, 2017
The final sequence of this movie was......I can't even describe! is not a 10 for me because of the first act and lack of development for Jyn and the captain, Donnye Yen and K2 were amazing.
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
7
destinyfan1Mar 29, 2017
let me begin with, yeah you already guessed, it the beginning. Th beginning is actually the only bad thing,You get guided over the personages and in my personnal opinion it feels rushed and to much swithing from planets . Also the fun factorlet me begin with, yeah you already guessed, it the beginning. Th beginning is actually the only bad thing,You get guided over the personages and in my personnal opinion it feels rushed and to much swithing from planets . Also the fun factor wasn't that high . But after 50 min the movie gets open like a flower in the summer with great action and star wars feeling like always , espacially the last fight is very pumping , the guy that got knocked out on the tower shouldn't have came back do . But for the rest awesome movie!!!!!… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
9
TFHJan 5, 2017
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rouge One was one of my favorite Star Wars movies. I liked the characters a lot, and the new and improved armory was a nice addition. The background story on some people was a bit vague though, but only on some. Overall, a great movie.… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
9
MatteleJan 7, 2017
THIS had to be Star Wars 7, not that lazy and uninspired reboot. Given that this movie will not have a direct sequel, and given that it is a spin off, the authors finally created a really enojoyable movie. Must see.
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
10
toadvinesJan 16, 2017
Awesome job by Gareth Edwards and Lucasfilm. Honestly, ehen I heard that this was subject to re-shoots I expected the worst. Actually, I was expecting something along the lines of Suicide Squad – fragments of good material stitched togetherAwesome job by Gareth Edwards and Lucasfilm. Honestly, ehen I heard that this was subject to re-shoots I expected the worst. Actually, I was expecting something along the lines of Suicide Squad – fragments of good material stitched together to create an incoherent mess. But not so with Rogue One. The movie is entirely coherent and if the reshoots hadn’t been reported I think this would have looked like the product of a singular vision. It’s very dour. It has an authentic war feel to it. It doesn’t feel like this has been made to appeal to chil;dren, rather to adults who have grown up with Star Wars. And that’s great. Rogue One proves that Star Wars can cover many bases successfully. There are a few standout moments here, holy s*** moments that are among the best in the entire series. It starts off slow but compelling, and the film builds and builds to a mind blowing climax. The scenes on the beaches are unlike anything we’ve seen before in Star Wars and bring to mind Saving Private Ryan and the space battle is full of inventive action. This bodes well for future standalone entries.… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
10
EnderJoshJan 28, 2017
I LOVED THIS MOVIE. GO SEE IT NOW IF YOU HAVEN'T. One of the few movies I wholeheartedly give 10/10 to. Amazing on a visual level, suspense level, you name it. Every level you can think of. Sure, little kids may find it loud, hard toI LOVED THIS MOVIE. GO SEE IT NOW IF YOU HAVEN'T. One of the few movies I wholeheartedly give 10/10 to. Amazing on a visual level, suspense level, you name it. Every level you can think of. Sure, little kids may find it loud, hard to understand and enjoy, but for older viewers, it's the exact opposite. Great job, Lucasfilm, you did it again. Another outstanding Star Wars film.… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
8
TiagoGM18Mar 27, 2017
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Much better than I ever expected it would ever be. Funny, charming and badass... the only issue I have with this movie is that without most of the references and cameos, it wouldn't be as enjoyable as it is.… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
9
Phil_FantusMar 27, 2017
This movie left me conflicted. It was on one side everything I hoped that Star Wars could have been if it evolved from a child's dream in the eighties into an adult's grim reality of 2016. Go see it, it's amazeballs! The acting is fine, theThis movie left me conflicted. It was on one side everything I hoped that Star Wars could have been if it evolved from a child's dream in the eighties into an adult's grim reality of 2016. Go see it, it's amazeballs! The acting is fine, the story is sound, the effect are great. It would have been a 10 if it wasn't so grim. But it is and that I did not expect. I will say no more, lest I leave a spoiler. The lighthearted space camp from your youth is gone. Space is dark and will leave you thinking. That's the other side of the medal.… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
8
LeZeeNov 4, 2017
The episode III½.

So this is like a bridge between the original trilogy and the next three prequels. A story where the main characters from the original tale are not involved. Being a big fan of this franchise, I loved it. I did not expectThe episode III½.

So this is like a bridge between the original trilogy and the next three prequels. A story where the main characters from the original tale are not involved. Being a big fan of this franchise, I loved it. I did not expect big, so got entertained well. But pity that this wonderful characters are not going to return. This is just a one-off film. For seeing its overwhelming success, there could be a prequel, which has a very very slim chance.

The story was like that had started in a half way. That's why I wanted a prequel to tell us the Galen Erso's point of view story. When he has been taken back to the base to work for the Empire, his daughter is the only one who escapes from there. After a few years later the grown- up daughter, Jyn, end up on the rebel's side. When she hints a plan for them to strike the Empire, nobody considers it. But a rogue gang forms where they all does according to her saying. That's the story, and how it all ends are the rest.

The story was simple, but the action-adventures were good. Like what a 'Star Wars' fans want to see. The main drawback was there's no familiar faces around. Even the original franchise style of title and credit presentation was off the beat. Though there were cameos. Darth Vade, Princess Leia, R2D2 and 3PO, including a small lightsabre fight at the end, just to satisfy the fanboys. Overall a worthy film, otherwise it would have not earned one billion at the box office, making one of the top 10 of all time.

8/10… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
9
DBPirate1129Dec 24, 2017
Rogue One definitely surprised me when I first saw it in theaters. I wasn't really thrilled by The Force Awakens, but Rogue One's originality and risk-taking helped me enjoy it!

Director Gareth Edwards does a great job of making you feelRogue One definitely surprised me when I first saw it in theaters. I wasn't really thrilled by The Force Awakens, but Rogue One's originality and risk-taking helped me enjoy it!

Director Gareth Edwards does a great job of making you feel like you're back in the Original Trilogy era. The cinematography and the slightly gritty landscape of planets like Jedha and Wobani also add to that feel. Despite the little development they had, I found most of the characters in Rogue One to be extremely compelling even though we only got to see them for a brief time. My favorites were the possibly Force-sensitive Chirrut Imwe and the ambitious Imperial director and main antagonist Orson Krennic, who is played brilliantly by Ben Mendelsohn. I should also add that all of the actors in this film are great.

Rogue One does seem a little slow on the first viewing but that's mainly because the first act is built on introducing characters. Once the action starts around 30 minutes into the film (just an estimate), it really picks up. The film ends with the best space battle and perhaps the best ground battle Star Wars has seen to date. The D-Day inspired beaches of Scarif were a great pick for the final act.

Unlike The Force Awakens, which relies on nostalgic references and dramatic cameos of Original Trilogy characters, Rogue One manages to be a good film all its own. It has a strong cast of characters, interesting locations, and expands and improves the first Star Wars film in way I didn't think possible.… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
8
TheMVGMOct 6, 2017
A nice change of pace for Star Wars, coming off the awful prequels, and TFA. Easily the best since Jedi, and it's my personal favorite since Empire. The movie has some of the best cinematography, and Michael Giacchino on the score is a greatA nice change of pace for Star Wars, coming off the awful prequels, and TFA. Easily the best since Jedi, and it's my personal favorite since Empire. The movie has some of the best cinematography, and Michael Giacchino on the score is a great choice. Memorable movie, and one of the best Star Wars films… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
10
ReksoDec 16, 2017
THIS IS a real STAR WARS for the older ppl with a logical plot! Grateful!

The film was filmed clearly with a soul, beautiful battles, not tiresome dialogues as in other parts and the right end.
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
9
HyapeDec 17, 2017
In the best traditions of old movies - serious, dramatic, realistic. You believe in every scene, in every step of main characters. It's not perfect, but much better than VII and VIII episodes.
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
7
WalterKovacsDec 26, 2017
There are some definite flaws in this film but it is too harshly treated by critics. It is certainly better than any of the Star Wars films post the original trilogy. Great cast with solid performances. Gareth Edwards uses less CGI and moreThere are some definite flaws in this film but it is too harshly treated by critics. It is certainly better than any of the Star Wars films post the original trilogy. Great cast with solid performances. Gareth Edwards uses less CGI and more props which is really refreshing. This movie will stand up to the test of time far better than the others. It compliments the original films which still are far better than the new installments. A must see film any if you don't enjoy any one of the other films.… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
10
Marco97swDec 27, 2017
I love the way they connected the prequels with the original trilogy. This films shows the reasons why the empire was such a hard to beat and why the rebels were so afraid of vader
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
8
SWEEPtheLEG175Jul 7, 2018
Great to see some grunt "rebels" in action. The connection to EP IV is rad. Great ending. I think they could have done 1 more scene with Vader, just give the fans what they want, it's Star Wars, not The Godfather.
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
10
HagueJul 7, 2018
Gareth Edwards doesn't back down when it comes to delivering an action-packed thrill of a rollercoaster ride such as Rogue One. This is excitement and fantasy on a whole new level. It delivers a prequel to the 4th Movie (Star Wars: A NewGareth Edwards doesn't back down when it comes to delivering an action-packed thrill of a rollercoaster ride such as Rogue One. This is excitement and fantasy on a whole new level. It delivers a prequel to the 4th Movie (Star Wars: A New Hope) and delivers and excitingly new plot to discover in the "Star Wars" franchise. Overall, this movie is incredibly recommended for all.… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
10
ArchVaderAug 3, 2018
This is the only Star Wars Disney movie worth anything, why? Because it follows close to the canon and EU. Once again the other movies should be following the old canon and the other movies should be doing the New Jedi Order because of theThis is the only Star Wars Disney movie worth anything, why? Because it follows close to the canon and EU. Once again the other movies should be following the old canon and the other movies should be doing the New Jedi Order because of the age of the actors. They could pass the movies onto a new generation of Jedi.… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
9
tarekaliJan 22, 2020
I just rewatched Rogue One and this time round the nuances of the acting are even more poignant. The massive sacrifices by Galen Erso and his daughter Jyn, and the selflessness of every single protagonist in the mission, make the deeds of theI just rewatched Rogue One and this time round the nuances of the acting are even more poignant. The massive sacrifices by Galen Erso and his daughter Jyn, and the selflessness of every single protagonist in the mission, make the deeds of the vaunted Skywalker clan seem small in comparison. This movie doesn't miss a beat, and I appreciate it even more amidst the stale vomit of the new abomination Abrams, Kennedy and Riaan subvert expectations Johnson trilogy. Gareth Edwards should have helmed the new trilogy.… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
9
leelustigDec 16, 2016
People loved The Force Awakens but have problems with this movie? The whole world is insane. Here is a list of things this movie did better than last year's installment. - Actual establishment of the Imperials being in control, and a need forPeople loved The Force Awakens but have problems with this movie? The whole world is insane. Here is a list of things this movie did better than last year's installment. - Actual establishment of the Imperials being in control, and a need for a rebellion/resistance.
- A tentacle monster that had an actual purpose.
- Actual stakes and a genuine concern that the heroes won't make it out alive.
- Intricate exposition not being reduced to ridiculously basic confabulation.
- Dialogue that wasn't cheesier than a cheese-plate.
- Cinematography that actually shows details of aliens. - Important robot/alien characters (that speak).
- Mads Mikkelsen. - Actually having something to do with the original trilogy. I could also reduce this list to two words: Darth Vader.… Expand
13 of 27 users found this helpful1314
All this user's reviews
10
SkeptecDec 17, 2016
My favorite star wars movie to date. I absolutely loved the new characters. The monk character being my favorite by far. I honestly couldn't think of any negatives really.
8 of 17 users found this helpful89
All this user's reviews
10
DPtdrysteDec 17, 2016
Really just reviewing this a 10 to balance the critic reviews. As a casual Star Wars fan I want to say 3 quick things about this movie:

1. It is a very "efficiently" produced film. No scene seems unnecessary. 2. It is accessible for non-StarReally just reviewing this a 10 to balance the critic reviews. As a casual Star Wars fan I want to say 3 quick things about this movie:

1. It is a very "efficiently" produced film. No scene seems unnecessary.
2. It is accessible for non-Star Wars die-hards like me, and today I'm actually gonna watch 4, 5, and 6 because it has piqued my interest in the series.
3. Based on talking about this with friends, it feels like what "Reach" was to the Halo series. As Vox has put it, while a Disney movie, this is a movie about war.

I really liked this movie. It was better than the last movie I saw in theatres, Arrival, and I really liked that movie too. This movie isn't as deep and provocative, but it's better.

If you are an experienced consumer of culture stuffs like games, music, movies, and TV shows I would say that a good lens to try to see this movie from is you as a kid, watching a serious war movie. As I get older I tend to compare everything to the best entries in the entire gamut of the culture genre, but if we are just going to compare every game to The Last of Us and every show to Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones, everything is going to suck comparatively.

Rogue One is definitely worth your $15 to watch in 3D. Go with someone younger than you, I went with my niece, and she really liked it.… Expand
8 of 17 users found this helpful89
All this user's reviews
10
ManofReyDec 17, 2016
I've watched the other Star Wars films hundreds of times but I'd have to rank this in the top 3 at the least. I don't know if I can edit this later but I'm going to be brief because I want this to show. Now everyone saw there was a spaceI've watched the other Star Wars films hundreds of times but I'd have to rank this in the top 3 at the least. I don't know if I can edit this later but I'm going to be brief because I want this to show. Now everyone saw there was a space battle in the trailers but it gets much better than the trailers give it service .

This has to be the best space battle ever and every actor exceeded expectations. Felicity Jones especially. Most of the music for the film wasn't that good it seemed to try and mimic John Williams trumpets and repeated notes and that was kinda stupid. I was hoping they would mix it up a bit.… Expand
8 of 17 users found this helpful89
All this user's reviews
9
Ming120Dec 16, 2016
This might as well be my favorite Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. It was absolutely refreshing to have a story that is not focused on an overpowered force-wielding protagonist, but on characters a little bit more normal. TheThis might as well be my favorite Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. It was absolutely refreshing to have a story that is not focused on an overpowered force-wielding protagonist, but on characters a little bit more normal. The plot is a little more interesting this time around, with plenty of action to be had.… Expand
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
10
DrChocolateDec 22, 2016
Phenomenal. The Star Wars film I've been waiting for since 1983. Dark and foreboding, excellent characterization,and the hour-long battle in the second half of the film is the best in the franchise yet. A worthy achievement and highlyPhenomenal. The Star Wars film I've been waiting for since 1983. Dark and foreboding, excellent characterization,and the hour-long battle in the second half of the film is the best in the franchise yet. A worthy achievement and highly recommended for all old Star Wars fans like me.… Expand
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
9
bfoore90Dec 16, 2016
Led by a stellar cast and finalized with some pretty awesome scenes with the one and only Darth Vader, Rogue One serves as a welcomed edition to the Star Wars universe and should please any Star Wars fan, new and old.
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
10
theRobotDec 17, 2016
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. "In the grim darkness of the galaxy far, far away, there is only war."

This movie is so much different than anything you have ever seen from Star Wars. It's like guys at Disney got inspired by Game of Thrones attitude to plot armor and decided to do something similar in their movie. And the fact that their movie is 7+ didn't stop them at all.

Seriously, this movie plays with your mind by making you think it will be yet another rehash from previous parts. Once again we get an orphan, who gets adopted, who apparently is rich in force and whose relatives are kidnapped by the empire. At the begginning we get loads of miracles, stormtroopers are as inaccurate as always and we are made into thinking it will be like that for the whole movie. Except it's not - at some point the plot armor for characters starts to get worn out and falls from them, leaving them fragile and unprotected. First insignificant characters start to die. Then gradually more significant ones. Eventually we aren't even sure about the fate of main protagonists, but we are still getting hints that they might survive. And then it turns out they don't. That's when the whole tragicness of this situation hits us. They are not superheroes, not another reincarnation of Han Solo and Luke Skywalker, that will get miraciously rescued from almost every situation. They are just desperate guys with nothing to lose, doing their suicide mission. Flashbacks of them saying various stuff, that might spoil the final ending hits you like a goddamn train and you get really, really depressed. If you took away the details from this movie, you would think it's the description of some Warhammer 40k novel, because how grimdark it is. But like WH40k, it's much more than that. It's a beautiful tale about hope, fighting against all odds, sacrifice and heroism. For me it's probably the best Star Wars movie since Empire Strikes Back and who knows if not the best Star Wars movie ever.… Expand
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
10
MattzoneDec 18, 2016
Just got home from the movie. Extremely good movie, BUT be aware that this is more like a war movie with the Star Wars brand. I took my 6 year old and he was very bored (he was fine during "Force Awakens"). Noting those facts, this isJust got home from the movie. Extremely good movie, BUT be aware that this is more like a war movie with the Star Wars brand. I took my 6 year old and he was very bored (he was fine during "Force Awakens"). Noting those facts, this is perhaps one of the better movies from the Star Wars brand... great acting, sets, effects and tie in to the franchise. Perhaps think of it as Star Wars Episode 3.5! Good Work!… Expand
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
9
BarefootedjediDec 16, 2016
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Before I start I have to say I absolutely loathed Force Awakens, a movie which had no respect for the Star Wars universe, and whose writers seemed to think repetition of past plots was a demonstration of love for it. I went to this one expecting to be disappointed, though I hoped the fact it involves no Jedi might actually be its saving grace. It was. There is no character here who, without even being a Padawan, defeats a Sith master both in Jedi mind control and in a light saber duel (the excluding of this possibility is why I suspected it would be harder to stuff up this one). Also, instead of stupidly rehashing the past this instalment nicely interlocks with it (note the distinction J.J., and you critics who uncritically gushed over FA). Consistent with the fictional history, there are no Jedi in sight (since they've all been assassinated or have gone to ground like Obi Wan and Yoda), and the only light-saber you’ll see is Darth Vader's when he goes on a slaughter fest at the end which nicely dovetails with the beginning of the original movie I saw as a child and was entranced by then. In many ways this is the adult Star Wars we grown up fans of the originals have been waiting for. I only wish the writers of this could have had the making of FA instead of the fool Jar Jar Abrams. Disney, please let them complete the trilogy Abrams stuffed up. They understand what real Star Wars fans want. Something gritty and grown up, which recognises the history and mythology of the SW universe but tells its own story within that context.

Felicity Jones is a great actress, and plays a role which is both capable and sensitive. Also, as an Aussie, I'm happy to see Ben Mendelsohn as the central villain; a great actor. For martial arts fans there's the brilliant Donnie Yen, who isn't a Jedi but should be, instead playing a blind, possibly slightly crazy, worshiper of the force, who may or may not be force sensitive but regardless manages to take out a lot of storm troopers and almost magically dodge some blaster fire (and has a friend with a hugely powerful blaster to keep him alive when the odds are too much against him). Chirrut Imwe (Donnie), yes, you are one with the force, you are one with the force (you’ll get my reference once you’ve seen the movie). There is a beautifully tragic ending for the central characters too. Heroes die, as they ought to in a good war movie or tragedy.

Expect to see some slightly dodgy CGI resurrections, but only when necessary and not to too bad effect. Of course the greatest of all Star Wars villains, Darth Vader, being in his life support suit, doesn’t need this kind of treatment and is voiced as always by the inimitable James Earl Jones.

I see that this received poorer reviews from the professional reviewers than did FA, to which I can only say these guys must be either corrupt or stupid (or maybe both). Ok, I have suspected that since all the gush over FA, but this round of stupidity confirms it. I have given this 9 instead of 10 because, though it is sensible, consistent, respectful of the past but not slavishly committed to it, and well written, what I would really have loved to see is this kind of loving care lavished on the new trilogy (movies with Jedi in them!) instead of just this (appropriately Jedi free) standalone. If you are a lover of the original trilogy I strongly recommend this one. If you were disgusted by FA I am totally with you (read my review to see how much I hated it), but this one is a different beast. Give it the chance you regretted giving FA. It may not be perfect, but I think it's the best since the original trilogy (and doesn't have the vomitous cutesiness of Ewoks to mar it).

Now, where would I start with a remade Episode VII? The remnants of the empire have degenerated into an insurgency against a shakily re-established republic. They are carrying out terrorist attacks across the galaxy. The Jedi academy has been re-established by Luke, and Leia has also had some Jedi training, but perhaps has chosen not to become a full-fledged Jedi because there is so much political work to do patching together a workable galactic democracy. Perhaps Leia, in fighting against terrorists has become a little dark herself (this couldn’t reasonably happen with Luke, since he has proved himself capable of resisting the combination of Darth Vader and the Emperor in ROTJ), setting up a sibling conflict of galactic proportions. After all, real politics is a dirty business. She hasn’t become Sith but her morality is uneasily balanced. Questionable alliances have been made (think of the mess in Syria at the moment). The line between good and evil is becoming blurred. Luke, as a monk like Jedi figure, has perhaps become morally flawed in a more subtle way, by virtue of a too mystical, navel gazing perspective on right and wrong. An adult premise. Start there screenwriters. Develop.… Expand
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
10
MMBoschDec 18, 2016
Beautiful Star Wars Movie. It will fill your heart with joy and it will probably make you cry, all at the same time. Don't miss it it IMAX, it looks gorgeous.
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
8
mromalvDec 18, 2016
The first act has pacing problems, but once it gets going it's a great movie, especially the final act. I've seen it twice now and liked it more the second time, when you have a grasp of what's happening in the firs 45 minutes it's easier toThe first act has pacing problems, but once it gets going it's a great movie, especially the final act. I've seen it twice now and liked it more the second time, when you have a grasp of what's happening in the firs 45 minutes it's easier to enjoy.

Those last 30 minutes are just perfection.… Expand
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
8
EpicLadySpongeDec 16, 2016
Before you go directly to see this movie, ask yourself the following questions. Am I going to see at least one memorable Star Wars character in this film? Well, there isn't that many since this is supposed to be a spin-off. Am I going toBefore you go directly to see this movie, ask yourself the following questions. Am I going to see at least one memorable Star Wars character in this film? Well, there isn't that many since this is supposed to be a spin-off. Am I going to experience the same feeling like the previous Star Wars films? Yes, and it's pretty unusual for a spin-off. Lastly, do these new characters make me want to see this movie? If you want to exactly know what happens to these characters, then yes. We can't tell you what happened to these characters for sure as that would lead to spoilers. Rogue One takes its main base and separates everything but left the feelings of the film just for the beneficial fans. It's not near a masterpiece, but at least it's trying to be something and that something is what Rogue One should be anyways.… Expand
12 of 26 users found this helpful1214
All this user's reviews
8
originaljoelDec 16, 2016
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is a very well shot film. The CGI is without doubt some of the best I've ever seen. Seeing Vader again was awesome and not to mention Peter Cushing being brought back to life with flawless CGI.

This film also exceeded my expectations. It was original, well paced, well acted and overall a much grittier and realistic take on Star Wars.

My Rating 8.6/10… Expand
12 of 26 users found this helpful1214
All this user's reviews
10
BoombastixDec 18, 2016
Rogue One was spectacular and everything I wanted it to be. I consider this movie an apology for the abysmal Force Awakens and for this I can only say one thing: Apology accepted!
6 of 13 users found this helpful67
All this user's reviews
9
Closeremperor16Dec 17, 2016
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Holy F**K Vader!! Oh man I can only look at this movie as a massive fan and as a fan it was amazing. The story was interesting and moved quickly, the cinematography and sense of scope and scale was excellent. I absolutely loved getting to see more of the oppression of the empire and the morally grey areas of the rebellion.

I loved the fact that this felt like a war movie taking place in the star wars universe. It connected seamlessly to episode 4 and gave me some truly jaw dropping moments. The whole last half hour of the movie was amazing and the beach scenes were everything I had hoped for in the best saving private Star wars kind of way. And Vader Holy **** Vader just mercilessly chopping down the rebels in the hallway at the end may have become one of my favourite Scenes ever. All in all I ****ing loved it, I have seen some criticisms of lack of character development ect But I think for the type of single shot story that this is that the way they handled it was appropriate. All in all is it a perfect movie…no because no movies perfect. BUT I would say because of my taste for the darker side of star wars this prob slots in to place behind empire strikes back as my favourite Star Wars movie. I need to see it about 4 more times in the cinema before I set my ranking in stone but the point is want to see it many more times. This film Gave me everything I wanted and was hoping for in an incredibly satisfying package. Bravo! Job well Done!!!… Expand
6 of 13 users found this helpful67
All this user's reviews
10
VLaZzzDec 18, 2016
Rogue One is a direct prologue to the original trilogy.
It sets up the story perfectly, giving an insight into the struggle and desperation of the Rebellion, emphasising the urgency for the destruction of the Death Star.
6 of 13 users found this helpful67
All this user's reviews
9
Randall0Dec 16, 2016
So we all new going into this movie what the end result was. What we didn't know was how this story progressed into episode 4. I can honestly say this movie was amazing, the effects, the nods to the original trilogy and the effort they madeSo we all new going into this movie what the end result was. What we didn't know was how this story progressed into episode 4. I can honestly say this movie was amazing, the effects, the nods to the original trilogy and the effort they made to make the look and feel of this film fit seamlessly with the original Star Wars film. It is a movie that stays with you long after you walk out the door. I am astounded that the critics have not recognised this film with much higher ratings overall. It most certainly deserves it. Deserving of a "classic" rating and one for the collection. 9/10. Hard to find fault.… Expand
11 of 24 users found this helpful1113
All this user's reviews
9
KenwayDec 16, 2016
"Rogue-one". The movie which differs from all previous. The movie in which everything became serious. I already many times said to friends that I am not a fan of Star Wars. I had liked the seventh episode, but against the background of the"Rogue-one". The movie which differs from all previous. The movie in which everything became serious. I already many times said to friends that I am not a fan of Star Wars. I had liked the seventh episode, but against the background of the Rogue it is some other... Children's most likely. In the Rogue there is almost everything: atmosphere (she here absolutely another), drama, light humour, very interesting characters and of course ACTION! As for a story, he simple and clear. The soundtrack is weak, but there is no wonder as one composer has left, and another has succeeded only in September. A visual part of the movie very beautiful, and a sound in an IMAX format just tremendous. Also in the movie the fan service is a lot of, fans will estimate. Offensively for me only one that the movie doesn't allow to reveal to characters, even to the main character. As for her, she is a fighting little girl who never gives up. Felicity Jones has played perfectly. And here the character Mad Mikkelsen is a father of the main character, but he catastrophically isn't enough. I don't know the others and there are nothing to tell about them, but their characters interesting. Well and the most abrupt moment of fans expects in the picture final. Result: I very strongly had liked this picture. She differs from all that is in this Universe and it does well her. Someone from fans will abuse her for gravity, someone will shout that there are no Jedis and the picture a priori becomes a hogwash, someone will shout about all our favourite canon, someone will hate for something else, and someone will just enjoy the events in this picture. And I grant a camp the fan of this picture. It is clear that Disney put the franchise on the conveyor, but the main thing that there was a quality. And in the Rogue it is.… Expand
11 of 24 users found this helpful1113
All this user's reviews
10
HeavypointDec 17, 2016
This Movie is a love letter to the originals and fills the gap on why the Death Star was able to have such a weakness.

I love this movie plain and simple its a Star Wars movie done well and you must go and see it for yourself!!!This Movie is a love letter to the originals and fills the gap on why the Death Star was able to have such a weakness.

I love this movie plain and simple its a Star Wars movie done well and you must go and see it for yourself!!!

GOOOOOOOOOOOO WATCH IT ****

DO IT!… Expand
10 of 22 users found this helpful1012
All this user's reviews
9
sevenoftwoDec 17, 2016
Story/Characters

I thought that this film is very strong in it's story and characters. Nothing is held back in this film. The Rebels and Imperials are both fighting hard and dying while attempting to reach theirs goals. The tone of thisStory/Characters

I thought that this film is very strong in it's story and characters. Nothing is held back in this film. The Rebels and Imperials are both fighting hard and dying while attempting to reach theirs goals. The tone of this film is serious and thoughtful. Each protagonist, while not given a great deal of screen time, has a distinct personality and worldview that is displayed through their conversations and behavior. Visuals/Music

The visual effects and music are, in my opinion, top notch. While the visual style is different than previous Star Wars films, this is an intentional choice and it works for this film. Action sequences are easy to follow (no excessive shaky cam or wild, rapid panning) and the cinematography and framing are excellent. The sense of scale is impressive and CGI effect shots are mostly very well done. If you're able to view this movie while keeping in mind that it is new and different in some ways, I think you'll enjoy it. The music is not by John Williams, but it is clearly inspired by his work and it feels entirely appropriate for a Star Wars film. In other words, this is the best that Star Wars music can be without simply reusing existing John Williams' existing material (which would have enjoyable but truly lacking in creativity).

Overall

This may be my favorite Star Wars film and I say that as a fan of the series. It is an adult-oriented film and could be called "bittersweet". I found it powerful and emotionally moving while also still being fun and exciting. If you find joy in watching epic space combat scenes as I do, this is a Star Wars film you'll particularly enjoy.… Expand
5 of 11 users found this helpful56
All this user's reviews
10
rajeev_Dec 18, 2016
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. My review on the movie Rogue One(2016).
1.An individual can visualize and enjoy this movie in two types i. As a Normal space battle flick ii.As a star wars movie.
2.This is 2 hours of a climactic, heart-wrenching, no **** straight to the point event. Yes, I saw this movie as a star wars movie 'cause I know the story lines and characters.
3.MACHINES USED: X-wing fighters, U- wing fighters, Y- wing fighters, imperial I- class star destroyers, TIE-strikers, Resistance star destroyers,{ AT-ACT, AT-ST} walkers: cargo carriers, clone-tank.
TROOPERS USED: storm-troopers, death-troopers, shore-troopers, and sand-troopers.
4. This story is about the bunch rebellions named Jyn-Erso, Captain Cassian Andor, Chirrut Imwe, Saw Gerrera, K-2SO(actually an imperial reprogrammed machine). Bodhi Rook. named Rouge-One. these five people will make you tear up for sure, awesome char' build-up. The movie is all about stealing plans located at SCARIF(kyber crystal refining planet) from imperial and transmitting it over to rebel-alliances. If you know about the star wars- a new hope(1997), you see Princess Leia handing the death star plan Chip over to R2-D2. 5. Tone and cinematography of the movie is gorgeous, exclusively there's a char who's blind and the way camera angle is set when he senses the movement is gorgeous, even the hyperdrive chills jus chills the way fighters arrive, ships arrive, are awesomely shown.
6. There's no point in discussing the story, it's better to acknowledge the way story is executed 'cause story is straight to the point.The execution is way better, way courageous than Star Wars VII : the Force Awakens. 7. I loved this movie to the core, it's heart-breaking and hope-bringing. The third act will BLOW- YOUR MIND. 8. Darth Vader OMFG he is damn terrifying. Princess Leia is CGI of the younger version. In the end when they ask what is this ? while giving the chip.She replies HOPE. SNAP END CREDITS. GOOSEBUMPS.
VERDICT: Go, watch it, Irony I walked all the way to my home from the stop chanting " I am the force, and the force is with me" you'll get the reference after the watch. Way Way better than Star Wars VII. I loved it to the core… Expand
5 of 11 users found this helpful56
All this user's reviews
8
aurynsdadDec 16, 2016
Overall incredible. Far better than the other prequels. I liked the storyline better than the Force Awakens, which had some strange plot holes it's hard to get past. On repeat viewings, I'll be able to decide whether I like this or ForceOverall incredible. Far better than the other prequels. I liked the storyline better than the Force Awakens, which had some strange plot holes it's hard to get past. On repeat viewings, I'll be able to decide whether I like this or Force Awakens better. The third act is legendary. Strengths: the story, the feel, the acting, the writing. Weaknesses: a few spots of jarring editing, music, and CGI.… Expand
9 of 20 users found this helpful911
All this user's reviews
10
Trash_McblazesDec 16, 2016
Feel the need to rate this higher to offset the critic reviews lower than 5. This is a movie in the vein of the original trilogy. Wish the supporting players were more flesched out and thought that the beginning was paced pretty fastFeel the need to rate this higher to offset the critic reviews lower than 5. This is a movie in the vein of the original trilogy. Wish the supporting players were more flesched out and thought that the beginning was paced pretty fast otherwise this is a Star Wars story. Now, if you walked into this movie with no previous knowledge of the u iverse you would be entertained and finish off your popcorn quite quick; this is a good movie, period. Now go and enjoy yourself!… Expand
9 of 20 users found this helpful911
All this user's reviews
10
fgallindoDec 16, 2016
The TOP3 : 1 - ROGUE ONE; 2 - STAR WARS (Yes, it is! the one and only Star Wars); 3 - THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK. And the rest? WIPE THEM OUT, ALL OF THEM!
13 of 29 users found this helpful1316
All this user's reviews
10
PeterAlexanderDec 16, 2016
Rogue One is gritty, charming and exhilarating. Gareth Edwards takes considerable risks in the very first Star Wars spinoff, all to huge success. Whilst the characters are played brilliantly, and the story is thrilling from start to finish,Rogue One is gritty, charming and exhilarating. Gareth Edwards takes considerable risks in the very first Star Wars spinoff, all to huge success. Whilst the characters are played brilliantly, and the story is thrilling from start to finish, it is the action and the gorgeous look of the film that stand out.… Expand
12 of 27 users found this helpful1215
All this user's reviews
8
tonywar93Dec 17, 2016
Rogue One is a great movie with a few drops here and there. The movie flows averagely pretty well for 2h15m, from an explanatory and choppy intro to one of the most breathtaking battles the Star Wars saga has ever seen and to what could beRogue One is a great movie with a few drops here and there. The movie flows averagely pretty well for 2h15m, from an explanatory and choppy intro to one of the most breathtaking battles the Star Wars saga has ever seen and to what could be considered a true nerd-gasm in the final scenes. Lots of pleasant surprises, lots of welcome call-backs, maybe some lack of characters's depth. Non-fans will enjoy an alternative war movie; fans will thank Gareth Edwards for realizing their innest geeky dreams.… Expand
12 of 27 users found this helpful1215
All this user's reviews
10
deekanDec 17, 2016
Great.great.great! Everything I wanted, yet so much more. Some of the best war scenes in any fantasy film, let alone star wars! Edwards is one to look out for.
8 of 18 users found this helpful810
All this user's reviews
9
colilla1972Dec 16, 2016
Una buena película con uno de los mejores cierres del universo de Star Wars, -tal vez los mejores últimos 20 minutos de toda la franquicia-. Es cierto algunas cosas pudieron ser mejor pero como muestra del potencial del Universo De Star WarsUna buena película con uno de los mejores cierres del universo de Star Wars, -tal vez los mejores últimos 20 minutos de toda la franquicia-. Es cierto algunas cosas pudieron ser mejor pero como muestra del potencial del Universo De Star Wars es muy buen comienzo y la película es muy divertida.… Expand
8 of 18 users found this helpful810
All this user's reviews
10
OlrikusDec 17, 2016
-- Spoiler Free --
Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since original trilogy. Period.
Significant to say it adds weight to original trilogy and that is a worthy achievement itself. Lore of original trilogy was left intact and overall it is-- Spoiler Free --
Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since original trilogy. Period.
Significant to say it adds weight to original trilogy and that is a worthy achievement itself. Lore of original trilogy was left intact and overall it is a must see film.

Also it is a completely unusual film for Star Wars franchise and some people will dislike this film for that since it has no light saber duels and it's more focused on the heart of rebellion and it's people.… Expand
8 of 18 users found this helpful810
All this user's reviews
9
TokyochuchuDec 22, 2016
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a truly excellent entry into the franchise that even outshines the prior 'Force Awakens'. Risks are taken, new ground is covered and excitement is served up in spades. Perfectly cast and directed, Rogue OneRogue One: A Star Wars Story is a truly excellent entry into the franchise that even outshines the prior 'Force Awakens'. Risks are taken, new ground is covered and excitement is served up in spades. Perfectly cast and directed, Rogue One immediately takes it's place as one of the better Star Wars films out there.… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
9
AlexanderLuthorDec 19, 2016
Rogue One is a fitting addition to the Star Wars cannon with a story line filled with interesting characters, captivating moments, and possessing a tragic quality reminiscent of The Empire Strikes Back.
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
8
PandaFromHell05Dec 23, 2016
The first time I watched the trailer, I was like meh. After watching the movie, I was pleasantly surprised. While I feel like this is not the most epic Star Wars movie ever (I mostly like lightsaber fights when it comes to Star Wars, andThe first time I watched the trailer, I was like meh. After watching the movie, I was pleasantly surprised. While I feel like this is not the most epic Star Wars movie ever (I mostly like lightsaber fights when it comes to Star Wars, and Rogue One does not have lightsaber fights), it's certainly decent. It's a classic father-daughter story, where you come to care about the characters. The robot droid was hysterical, honestly. Also, the tribute to characters such as Grand Moff Tarkin, was believable and plain creepy that they brought an actor who's been dead since the 90's, back to life. It was a pretty fantastic movie, much better than Force Awakens.… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
10
akino3Dec 21, 2016
There is not much to say about this film other than the fact that it has exceeded all my expectations and its mediocre score. Seriously, what more could a Star Wars fan want? I can't thank the people involved in this film enough.
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
10
forumsDec 19, 2016
My favorite Star Wars movie. I love this movie because; darker and more real.
birth of Death Star. Very scary Darth Vader. very scary laser from Death Star. no happy ending. sad ending. I don't enjoy lightsaber battles, I enjoy seeingMy favorite Star Wars movie. I love this movie because; darker and more real.
birth of Death Star. Very scary Darth Vader. very scary laser from Death Star. no happy ending. sad ending. I don't enjoy lightsaber battles, I enjoy seeing people killed by Darth Vader with lightsaber. People try to survive and escape from Darth Vader. People try to survive and escape from laser from Death Star. There should be movies like this not like Star Wars 1,2,3,7. There should be Star Wars every year. I can't wait.… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
9
Armorwing01Dec 19, 2016
I liked the Force Awakens, it had likable characters like Finn, Kylo Ren, and a few others. It lacked originality and just could not grip me as well as some of the others. This movie kicked a**, so much a**, very likable characters, Vader,I liked the Force Awakens, it had likable characters like Finn, Kylo Ren, and a few others. It lacked originality and just could not grip me as well as some of the others. This movie kicked a**, so much a**, very likable characters, Vader, amazing fights, fun references, Vader, plot twists, Vader, and a logical and emotional conclusion. Cannot wait for more Star wars Spin offs.… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
9
mlebeau12Dec 17, 2016
This movie takes a long time to settle in, but a lot of that is due to the fact that so many new characters and worlds must be introduced. Once the movie settles in, it is non stop action. The third act rivals and 30 minute stretch in theThis movie takes a long time to settle in, but a lot of that is due to the fact that so many new characters and worlds must be introduced. Once the movie settles in, it is non stop action. The third act rivals and 30 minute stretch in the Star Wars saga. This movie is darker than other Star Wars films and also provides a much murkier divide between good and evil.… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
8
herewasmikeDec 17, 2016
Really enjoyed this addition to the Star Wars universe. It's a universe we're familiar with and a dark and gritty story that pays off in incredible ways at the end. There are very few movies with 3rd acts that have left me with an almostReally enjoyed this addition to the Star Wars universe. It's a universe we're familiar with and a dark and gritty story that pays off in incredible ways at the end. There are very few movies with 3rd acts that have left me with an almost immediate feeling that I needed or wanted more - and it pays off extremely well every time.

The film expands the universe to a few new planets, but what I enjoyed most about these new locations is how real they feel. They are bustling hubs, full of life and activity, a feeling that really captures how Mos Eisley felt the first time that I had seen it. Most importantly though, the Empire is everywhere. The scale of the Empire is shown off to massive degrees, and that's exactly the way it should be. There is tremendous attention to details, and you can tell these worlds were crafted with great care in mind.

The movie does seem to wear you down a bit before the 3rd act begins. Many complaints show an issue with the movie being fairly boring or snoozy, or there being problems with the dialogue. After seeing the film a couple of times, I don't think the movie snoozes as it does move from place to place briskly, but it does seem difficult for it to hold the audience's attention as we can see from other reviews. Still, this is a movie about a desperate move by the Rebellion to find out more about the Empire's super weapon, and the tone is conveyed as such. These characters are on a mission, and they have to do it quickly. The stakes are high, and because they are so high, it is what helps the final parts of this move pay off in astounding ways.

Still, the characters could have been rounded out just a touch more. The acting is all really quite good, but there's just not enough of these characters to make us root for them a bit more. It was what could have taken this film from really very good to excellent, but it's just not quite there.

But everything pays off in the final act of this film. It's a gigantic battle, and you can feel how desperate both sides are for victory. These are some of the best moments in the entire saga's history - from the beginning of the battle to the final scene. The Empire and Rebellion move like set pieces on a chess board - each strategically trying to turn the advantage, each coming up with a new surprise. Of course, there is a moment here that every Star Wars fan could not help but love, but really, the entire battle is a classic moment for Star Wars. The Battle at Scarif turns this movie from perhaps an average or dangerously below average to nearly astounding. That is how good it is. It pays off the journey to get to this point in the film, and while I didn't think it was a slog at all, I certainly appreciated the journey tremendously more so than the moments before it. Indeed, the final moments left me wanting more, almost immediately, I wanted to go back. It is can't miss stuff for any Star Wars Fan, and really, it makes the film pay off for any newcomer that might come into this universe as well. It's exciting, it's poetic, it's fan service, but it's also very fresh. Rogue One is not just a worthy addition to Star Wars - as a direct lead-in to A New Hope, it makes New Hope even more exciting in tremendous new ways. Does it have a few problems? Sure it does, but Rogue One makes up for the issues in incredible ways, and it earns its spot as one of the top films in the entire series.… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
10
bardsleynDec 20, 2016
This is such a great film. It has a slow build up but by the end I was absolutely beaming. This is not a award winning drama. It's a star wars film. Sit back, relax, and enjoy the show. It's amazing. Even my wife, who is not a star wars fan,This is such a great film. It has a slow build up but by the end I was absolutely beaming. This is not a award winning drama. It's a star wars film. Sit back, relax, and enjoy the show. It's amazing. Even my wife, who is not a star wars fan, loved it. A fan and a non-fan walking out happy? What more could you want!… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
10
tianotcDec 21, 2016
GREAT!! Star Wars fans will love every aspect of this movie, action, story, character.. but for me, the biggest achievement was the way they connect this movie with episode IV... I left the cinema with a sense of euphoria that reminded meGREAT!! Star Wars fans will love every aspect of this movie, action, story, character.. but for me, the biggest achievement was the way they connect this movie with episode IV... I left the cinema with a sense of euphoria that reminded me of childhood times!… Expand
4 of 9 users found this helpful45
All this user's reviews
8
S0LiDDec 16, 2016
Star Wars Episode VII and JJ Abrams look very ridiculous in front of Rogue One, I've really enjoyed much more watching Rogue One than the non sense Ep VII
11 of 25 users found this helpful1114
All this user's reviews
10
G3RDec 16, 2016
This movie is simply amazing. Walking out of the theater I wasn't thinking about how great it was but rather, "I have to watch this again NOW". If you were not around when episode 4 hit the screens then it would be hard to imagine how itThis movie is simply amazing. Walking out of the theater I wasn't thinking about how great it was but rather, "I have to watch this again NOW". If you were not around when episode 4 hit the screens then it would be hard to imagine how it changed our culture. People didn't ask you if you have seen Star Wars. They asked you how many times you have seen Star Wars. A feat that movie makers have not been able to accomplish since. This move IS episode 3, despite it's billing. Was it perfect? No. Good luck finding that on a screen today. If you are a fan of Scifi you will not be disappointed. If you are old you will feel again what you felt upon watching the original.… Expand
12 of 28 users found this helpful1216
All this user's reviews
8
SHORTFINGERDec 16, 2016
it was okay. lot of slow parts. far between fighting parts in the movie. but i did enjoy it. does tell us how they got the death star plans etc. did not learn much about the main people in the movie at all very little.
6 of 14 users found this helpful68
All this user's reviews
10
SpecialK916Dec 17, 2016
I mean what else do you want? For what they had to work with I think they did a fantastic job. I just got home, so maybe I'm still high off the fumes of the rebellion, but I wouldn't put up too much of a fight with anyone that says it wasI mean what else do you want? For what they had to work with I think they did a fantastic job. I just got home, so maybe I'm still high off the fumes of the rebellion, but I wouldn't put up too much of a fight with anyone that says it was better than the force awakens.… Expand
6 of 14 users found this helpful68
All this user's reviews
10
Tss5078Jan 10, 2017
The purpose of Rogue one was simple, to fix a plot hole that had bothered Star Wars fans for nearly forty years. How did the rebels get a hold of the plans for the death star and why was it so easy to destroy? At a young age, Jyn Erso'sThe purpose of Rogue one was simple, to fix a plot hole that had bothered Star Wars fans for nearly forty years. How did the rebels get a hold of the plans for the death star and why was it so easy to destroy? At a young age, Jyn Erso's (Felicity Jones), father Galen (Mads Mikkelsen) was taken by the empire, to help develop the death star. Jyn was protected by the rebels before fleeing and living on her own, until one day, the rebels receive a message from Galen, saying that his daughter is the key to everything, and if they help get her to him, he can stop the empire. What I love about Rogue one, is the fact that for this film the franchise took a step back. If you ask anybody what their favorite Star Wars movie is, inevitably you will hear A New Hope or The Empire Strikes Back, but why? It's because these films didn't have massive budgets, big name movie stars, the top directors in Hollywood, complex story lines, special characters thrown in for the kids, simply put they were the greatest space adventures of all-time. Rogue one leaves in the special effects, but the actors are not very well known, the director has only two films under his belt, the story is easy to follow, the characters are extremely likeable, (much more so than the new ones in the Force Awakens), and most import of all the story is more narrowly focused and much easier to follow. There aren't a million different things going on here, there is one objective and it is being attempted by characters you can actually get behind. Jyn Erso, very much has the Katniss Everdeen tough girl thing going for her and she is paired with Cassian (Diego Luna), who has all the charisma of a young Harrison Ford, together the pair is infectious and you can't help but like them. I didn't feel any of that with Rey and Finn, in fact, I barely remembered their names. I'd also be remiss if I didn't mention the scenery and special effects in the film, unlike in recent films, we see a multitude of planets, it isn't just all sand and sun. The planet in the final scene with the beaches and the energy shield in particular was just amazing. Finally there is the ending, I won't give anything away if you haven't seen it yet, but I will say this. While controversial, in my opinion, more perfect it could not have been. Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy and I hope J.J. Abrams took notice. This is what the future of the franchise should be. Just because you have the largest film budget in history, doesn't mean your film has to have dozens of plots, and all these random characters we don't care about. Use that money on special effects, more amazing ships, weapons, and planets, and just make Star Wars fun again in a way that Rogue One reminded us it could be.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
10
RixusDec 31, 2016
This is the Star Wars you've been waiting for. This is the Star Wars we deserve. The best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy. Its got everything you could ever want, from storm troopers and gritty combat, to space battles and aThis is the Star Wars you've been waiting for. This is the Star Wars we deserve. The best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy. Its got everything you could ever want, from storm troopers and gritty combat, to space battles and a more traditional take on faith in The Force. I want to go into detail, but I dont want to ruin the experience for anyone. Just know its a great Star Wars film, and perfectly ties into the original trilogy.

Hollywood: this is it, this is what we want. All future movies need to take their cue from Rogue One. I dont know why the critics rated this lower than Force Awakens, clearly the fans are rating this higher, and I'm right there with them.

Great, great movie. Go watch it!… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
Agent314Dec 21, 2016
This is hands down the best Star Wars movie since Empire Strikes Back. The first time I saw it I was too nervous to really catch all the nuances and finer points of story. Nervous, yes! Because I wanted sooooo bad for this movie to make meThis is hands down the best Star Wars movie since Empire Strikes Back. The first time I saw it I was too nervous to really catch all the nuances and finer points of story. Nervous, yes! Because I wanted sooooo bad for this movie to make me feel like I did when I was 10 and seeing Star Wars for the first time.

Yes, the film is a bit slow at first. No, the CGI characters are NOT distracting or uncanny. Yes, you'll long for a bit more backstory on the members of Rogue One, but YES you are supposed to want more! That's what Star Wars did for us. OMG, the clone wars? What were those? Jedi? What are you talking about? Anyway, none of that makes Rogue One less enjoyable.

The second time I saw the film I picked up on a lot more clues, and was left overjoyed. I loved the film even more. The Force Awakens was pretty good, but this is just shy of spectacular.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
8
Musicman_pamvDec 19, 2016
I was close to giving Rogue One a 10, but I am a tough grader and there were a few things that distracted me from giving it that high a rating. This is the Star Wars movie I have been waiting for since the original trilogy. Episode VII didI was close to giving Rogue One a 10, but I am a tough grader and there were a few things that distracted me from giving it that high a rating. This is the Star Wars movie I have been waiting for since the original trilogy. Episode VII did not deliver the same feel that Rogue One does. This "feels" and looks like Star Wars. Some of the recreations of settings from Ep. IV are very well done. The quibbles I have are few and mostly technical, not story or script related.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
BabinskiDec 28, 2016
This is what the Force Awakens should have been. The action sequences are incomparably better than any other in the previous movie. The story line is also way more original, showing other aspects of the rebel alliance. I only felt theThis is what the Force Awakens should have been. The action sequences are incomparably better than any other in the previous movie. The story line is also way more original, showing other aspects of the rebel alliance. I only felt the characters werent developed very well.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
7
eagleeyevikingDec 21, 2016
Despite an uneven first act that sprawls with far too many characters and locations, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story recovers with gritty action, plenty of heart, and a thrilling third act that ties the story to A New Hope well.
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
8
OllyNortonDec 21, 2016
I really enjoyed this movie. I wasn't actually motivated to see it, i found The Force Awakens to be throughly dull, but i had some time to kill and decided to go for it. Im so glad I did. The movie has some incredible visual moments, backedI really enjoyed this movie. I wasn't actually motivated to see it, i found The Force Awakens to be throughly dull, but i had some time to kill and decided to go for it. Im so glad I did. The movie has some incredible visual moments, backed by incredible action, and a likeable (if underdeveloped) cast. The music isn't up to the standards of the series, and some characters are somewhat underused, but overall this is a throughly enjoyable film that eleven both Star Wars fans and none can enjoy. (although star wars fans will get more enjoyment out of the multitude of OT references that are present).… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
bde9000Mar 7, 2017
Rogue One es un gran respiro de aire fresco a la franquicia, no tenia esperanzas después de ver el Copy-Paste que significo The Force Awakens, pero al ser este un spin-off se dieron mucho mas libertades creativas que ojala tomen en EpisodioRogue One es un gran respiro de aire fresco a la franquicia, no tenia esperanzas después de ver el Copy-Paste que significo The Force Awakens, pero al ser este un spin-off se dieron mucho mas libertades creativas que ojala tomen en Episodio VIII. Rogue One es la película con el tono mas oscuro y depresivo de la franquicia y la verdad es que le sienta muy bien, con una trama simple pero que funciona y con unos muy buenos personajes que por desgracia no tienen el suficiente tiempo en pantalla. Apesar de que la primera mitad de Rogue One se vuelve muy meeee,la batalla de Scarif es de lo mejor que alguna vez haya visto en la franquicia tal vez solo superada por Hoth. En general te puedo asegurar que si eres fan, esta película cumple en todos los aspectos y fácil puede estar entre tus 3 favoritas de la franquicia.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
Jess_HillDec 23, 2016
*Inhales deeply...*

Anticipation was very, very high with this new Star Wars offering, though I did attempt to temper my response to this much awaited film. This is an experience that is ultimately worthwhile, though the first two acts had*Inhales deeply...*

Anticipation was very, very high with this new Star Wars offering, though I did attempt to temper my response to this much awaited film. This is an experience that is ultimately worthwhile, though the first two acts had me worried at times. There is an intermittent lack of finesse, both with the CGI and the script, but the performances from Jones, Tudyk and Luna are exceptional. The cinematography is magnificent, delivering the sumptuous visuals we have come to expect from this universe, and the pacing is initially stilted but tightens considerably in the second and third acts. Taking place between the events of 'The Revenge of the Sith' and 'A New Hope', the storyline provides an engaging insight into the perils of war, with a focus on the darker realities of conflict than any other Star Wars film to date. It's in the final act that this film fulfills the heavy responsibility with which it was imbued, and in so doing provides long time fans with an unflinching journey to the heart of the rebellion. Leave the younger kids at home for this one. I am with the force, and the force is with me. 8.96/10… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
SKDDec 18, 2016
This is the Star Wars movie we wanted last year.

Instead of checking off a predetermined set of boxes tied to people’s nostalgia and following the contours of an older Star Wars movie, Rogue One focuses on an original, compelling story withThis is the Star Wars movie we wanted last year.

Instead of checking off a predetermined set of boxes tied to people’s nostalgia and following the contours of an older Star Wars movie, Rogue One focuses on an original, compelling story with the nostalgia interlaced. There were some moments where the drama feels forced (and there was enough of them that it prevented me from giving it a 10), but overall the motivations and desires of the characters are believable. Far from being omni-competent, the actions of the main characters cost them deeply by the end of the movie. I also liked how one of the characters, a droid called K-2SO, provides intelligent humor and comic relief without making a mockery out of himself (the way C-3PO does). And when the nostalgic moments came up with old characters, they feel more natural rather than tacked on.

A short note: It’s also worth pointing out that the underlying themes in movies can provide passing commentary on the times in which the creators live. The original Star Wars with its original Death Star provided a subtle commentary on weapons of mass destruction during the height of the Cold War and the nuclear weapons age. As I watched this movie and saw the scene where rebels ambushed storm troopers in the streets of a desert city, it made me immediately think of the Syrian Civil War. I don’t know if that was done on purpose, but it definitely feels like a powerful, passing commentary on the times in which we live.

Moving along, I am pleased that this film puts the ‘Wars’ back in Star Wars. You won’t see any Jedi doing back flips with lightsabers here. Instead, at the end of the movie, there is a very long and intense ground and space battle that defines what Star Wars is all about. It goes back to the Star Wars roots in a way that the Force Awakens tried to do, but fell short on.

I hope that the people making Episodes 8 and 9 take note. This may have been an anthology film, but it is hands down the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy and has set the new gold standard for what a Star Wars film should look like.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
8
GMReviewsDec 22, 2016
Rogue One delivers a newly established grit to the world of Star Wars, delivering the realism of war with stunning special effects. The story is solid in its idea and is straight to the point without being tangled in sub-plots, which alsoRogue One delivers a newly established grit to the world of Star Wars, delivering the realism of war with stunning special effects. The story is solid in its idea and is straight to the point without being tangled in sub-plots, which also produces the negative that character development is lacking, ripping some of the emotional pull from the film, which is very much needed for a Star Wars film. The heroes throughout the film are each very unique, and whilst some get more screentime than others, they all play their part in the end, which really sets the tone of teamwork well. This film is a great action/adventure blockbuster that should not be missed, especially if you’re a Star Wars fan; resulting in a good first entry to the Star Wars spinoffs. This film gets an 83% 8/10… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
CicoNutDec 22, 2016
We are now living in an era where we can look forward to a new ‘Star Wars’ movie each year. And luckily for us, the two Disney have released so far are amazing. While ‘The Force Awakens’ was light-hearted like the original, ‘Rogue One’ takesWe are now living in an era where we can look forward to a new ‘Star Wars’ movie each year. And luckily for us, the two Disney have released so far are amazing. While ‘The Force Awakens’ was light-hearted like the original, ‘Rogue One’ takes a darker turn, with a morally ambiguous lead cast and a more realistic war-like feel.

The movie follows the story of Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones), the daughter of an Imperial Scientist, who is unwillingly recruited by the Rebel Alliance to find her father and stop the Empire from unleashing their new planet-killer onto the galaxy. However, as her journey continues, she discovers the Rebel Alliance isn’t always quite as heroic as we would like to believe.

One of the things that makes Rogue One great is that it isn’t black and white. While the Empire is still clearly evil, the Rebel Alliance is also shown to not always make the right choices, and one quote that sums this up pretty well is when Jyn tells Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) “You might as well be a Storm Trooper.”

One thing that surprised me about this movie was just how great some of the performances were. Two actors I think people will be talking about are Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso and Alan Tudyk as K-2SO (the film’s main source of comic relief). While Tudyk provides plenty of laughs, Jones portrays her character’s strengths and flaws perfectly.

All right all done here bye-bye!

…

Oh wait. I forgot about the best part of the movie – Darth Vader. Not since ‘The Empire Strikes Back’ have we seen Vader this merciless and evil. His screen time is limited, but extremely powerful and satisfying (particularly the absolutely badass ending).

Rogue One is absolutely one of the best ‘Star Wars’ movies yet, with a dark story and a great cast of characters. The force is strong with this one!… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
imnamineDec 19, 2016
No, there's no lightsaber fight in this movie. But is the movie any good ? Yes, it is. It's what I call a perfect spin-off. Photography is astonishing, characters are good enough, battles and landscapes on point.
You can really feel EdwardsNo, there's no lightsaber fight in this movie. But is the movie any good ? Yes, it is. It's what I call a perfect spin-off. Photography is astonishing, characters are good enough, battles and landscapes on point.
You can really feel Edwards put his on style in the movie.
So no, this isn't a masterpiece, but it's indeed a great movie and that's what I expected from it.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
8
FierceBETTYDec 18, 2016
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Far from a perfect movie, Rogue One is an entertaining Sci-Fi action romp. The Characters are all likable and relate-able though their introductions did seem a little rushed. The biggest criticism I have is that at times it seemed that it wasn't sure what tone it wanted to have. There are moments that are dark that hit a perfect tone for the dire story of the movie and then there are times where a heroic almost joyful fanfare plays (reminiscent of the OG Trilogy) and it just feels out of place with the scene. One scene in particular was the biggest offender, When the Rebel Hammerhead cruiser sacrifices itself to take out one of the star destroyers and open the shield gate, the music is bouncy and has a twinkle to it... NO, several dozen if not hundreds of Rebel sailors just sacrificed, willingly might I add, their lives to hopefully open the shield gate. That needed to be somber or heroic. And it was not. There were a few other instances of this happening but not as dramatic as what I just wrote. Other than the tonal issues at times, I feel the direction and acting in Rogue One was exemplary. I feel it sets a good foundation for the "offshoots" of the Star Wars franchise and I'm looking forward to what Lucasfilm and Disney have to offer down the road.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
sindhurajatDec 19, 2016
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is that movie which takes even a casual viewer, who has at least viewed the cinematic flicks, deep down into the Star Wars history/mythology. Seeing Grand Moff Tarkin and Princess Leia brought back to the screen, as we first saw them in A New Hope, is such a feast for the eyes.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
thibDec 19, 2016
The best stars wars since 1983, I was realy scared after the force awakens, because lets be honnest it was more like a remake of the first movie from the 70's, But this one has a original scenario and have a great story, the fact that thereThe best stars wars since 1983, I was realy scared after the force awakens, because lets be honnest it was more like a remake of the first movie from the 70's, But this one has a original scenario and have a great story, the fact that there is no happy ending at the end make it better the movie is all about sacrifice.
it's realy make the perfect conection with the "new hope" plot great movie great star wars thanks god after the force awakens… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
8
SuplexDec 22, 2016
Well done movie with great special effects.
Loved the character design. The costumes are awesome.
Full of references of all the star wars universe.
Recommended.
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
8
sVcDec 22, 2016
This is a much darker movie than any of the other Star Wars movies. I found The Force Awakens to be slightly better than this one but I think that's only because I was so happy to see someone finally make a movie that lives up to the StarThis is a much darker movie than any of the other Star Wars movies. I found The Force Awakens to be slightly better than this one but I think that's only because I was so happy to see someone finally make a movie that lives up to the Star Wars name (I, II & III were horrible). Plus, the nostalgia factor of seeing beloved characters again. But I'll say this about Rouge One: the final 1/3 of the movie is as good...actually, better than, anything that any of the originals had done. The first and second act had enough to keep me interested, but after watching the last act, looking back now, it pales in comparison. Which is not to say I didn't thoroughly enjoy every bit of the movie. They don't go into great depth with the new characters, but just enough so that you have an understanding of who they are and that you will care for them and their fate. I liked all the references and throwbacks to the originals of course. And Darth Vader's second appearance was just simply bad ass. The one issue I had was the score. And I'm not blaming the composer, I'm sure he did a great job. I can't even say I'm that big a fan of John Williams, but after seeing 7 movies with his music, it kind of became a distraction when I heard it in the background.. All in all, if you are a fan of the originals you'll be a fan of this as well.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
10
JamesLaskosDec 29, 2016
What an astonishing film! Rogue One is not only in the second place of the best Star Wars film ever created, after Episode IV And V, but one of the most epic movies ever filmed. Long shots and beautiful shot angles that reminds PeterWhat an astonishing film! Rogue One is not only in the second place of the best Star Wars film ever created, after Episode IV And V, but one of the most epic movies ever filmed. Long shots and beautiful shot angles that reminds Peter Jackson's The Lord Of The Rings, epic music-score, fantastic battle sequences, great humor, incredible cinematography, amazing characters and a very emotional end. Rogue Ones last 5 minutes is one of the best endings in cinema history. Is a cinematic wonder that easily earns the title of the best movie of the 2016 and one of the best sci-fi/fantasy films in cinema world!… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
Captain105Jan 1, 2017
the Reason I think this star wars deserves a lot more respect is because it earns a whole new level of utterly tragic realism it used the Star Wars mythology as a background into something more turning it into an amazing Star Wars spectacle.
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
9
HappyislandsJan 9, 2017
Against all odds this turned out to be a rather bold movie.If we weren't already aware of re-shoots this would have the hallmarks of a singular vision - a gritty and uncompromised war film set in the Star Wars Universe.
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
7
awgoldenJan 17, 2017
If we're forced to compare this to the last offer from the franchise, it's simply a much better movie than Force Awakens. Better story, executed with more poignancy, than either rehashes (eg. Force Awakens) or mythology fillers (eq. I-III)If we're forced to compare this to the last offer from the franchise, it's simply a much better movie than Force Awakens. Better story, executed with more poignancy, than either rehashes (eg. Force Awakens) or mythology fillers (eq. I-III) that seem more focused on living up to ANH and Empire than trying to just make a good movie.… Expand
3 of 7 users found this helpful34
All this user's reviews
10
EmilMDec 16, 2016
Rouge One! I really like the direction and the gritty vibe this film brings to the star wars universe. It is weird to talk about a realistic feel.. but stil it has a more realistic feel to the characters than before. it has darker tone (likeRouge One! I really like the direction and the gritty vibe this film brings to the star wars universe. It is weird to talk about a realistic feel.. but stil it has a more realistic feel to the characters than before. it has darker tone (like Empire strikes back) and in my opinion it makes you invest more in the film as you watching it makes the story matter, it gives you chills down your spine as a randon cgi ship blows up... which i personally thinks is amazing! It would really like to se even more of this natural gritty and realistic vibe in the star wars universe! i dont think this film is a 10 maybe 8 or 9 but il give a 10 as i hope it might push the money-men interest in making star wars film in this deriction… Expand
8 of 19 users found this helpful811
All this user's reviews
7
Ryan_ParkinsonDec 16, 2016
Rogue One does a lot of things and does all of them well, but not well enough.

The visuals here are off-the-chart good: the effects are unparalleled (practical Star Destroyers looked jaw-dropping), the photography is gorgeous and theRogue One does a lot of things and does all of them well, but not well enough.

The visuals here are off-the-chart good: the effects are unparalleled (practical Star Destroyers looked jaw-dropping), the photography is gorgeous and the production design is ace. Director Gareth Edwards large scale, space opera moments are truly wondrous, but his smaller scale scenes, particularly dialogue exchanges, falter. There's this uncomfortable sense that his in scene direction was precise and purposeful, but his handheld camera's coverage pretty much butchers every conversation into a messy blur of words in which the basic topical beats and decisions are given no weight whatsoever. It doesn't help that not a single character is fleshed out beyond a singular facet of personality and that no actual team banter occurs, but I quite often found myself unsure of what certain exchanges were even about or why they were needed.

It's a shame, because the handheld camera looks SO great. I'm surprised that there wasn't more of a Children Of Men influence on the film. It would have been great to see civilians joining the fight so that each battlefield felt organic and truly like a galaxy at war. A greater focus on the intimate details of the Rebellion's guerrilla warfare style and teh suffering of the innocents while on Jedha could have nailed this. The score as well suffers from using the wrong theme tonally from the original trilogy to adapt. The score isn't bad, but its tonally incoherent with the film, as if Giachinno was told to make it more positive than Desplat's darker work. Building the score around a darker, lower-tempo version of William's "Imperial March" like the second trailer did would have been far more effective. It's just never ominous or rousing enough.

With all that being said, this film is a remarkable technical achievement and an enjoyable experience. Regardless of people's issues with The Force Awaken's and Rogue One, it's incredibly exciting to see Disney actually bringing real movie magic back to cinemas.… Expand
10 of 24 users found this helpful1014
All this user's reviews
10
SteelMashineDec 20, 2016
Although I am very biased attitude to Star Wars, and for me this whole saga is a favorite in the world, but still, being objective, I would say simply - it's the top !!! !!! Vader is gorgeous! The film breaks all the templates just modernAlthough I am very biased attitude to Star Wars, and for me this whole saga is a favorite in the world, but still, being objective, I would say simply - it's the top !!! !!! Vader is gorgeous! The film breaks all the templates just modern cinema, as well as sets a new quality standard for Star Wars! I tell you, as a man, very well versed in this universe - Seventh episode was excellent intonation of a new trilogy, but this film, from which there is little waiting, could overshadow the seventh episode, and I hope it will serve as a good benchmark for this movie in this universe to which the directors will seek the following episodes! Bravo! 10/10! Everyone is required to view, even if you're not a fan, because the cost to join the great saga !!!… Expand
12 of 29 users found this helpful1217
All this user's reviews
10
imthenoobDec 21, 2016
While Force Awakens played heavily on the nostalgia factor, Rogue One takes all the risks and it works out wonderful. No opening scroll so we jump right into the action. It ties up a lot of plot holes from the previous films (such as why theWhile Force Awakens played heavily on the nostalgia factor, Rogue One takes all the risks and it works out wonderful. No opening scroll so we jump right into the action. It ties up a lot of plot holes from the previous films (such as why the Death Star had it's fatal flaw), The action scenes are beautiful and the ending couldn't have been any better. They took a lot of risks with the CG (anyone who saw the film knows what I am talking about) but it paid off perfectly.

My only complaint is that they didn't use the new villain as well as they could have. Aside from that, Go and see it immediately. It blows FA out of the water imo and I loved FA.… Expand
4 of 10 users found this helpful46
All this user's reviews
10
DreadLordAvatarJan 10, 2017
absolutely the best star wars film since empire strikes back. it totally captures the Ep4 feeling, Director Gareth Edwards is a genius. glad the music isnt a rehash of john williams score, this feels refreshing and a true delight. saw itabsolutely the best star wars film since empire strikes back. it totally captures the Ep4 feeling, Director Gareth Edwards is a genius. glad the music isnt a rehash of john williams score, this feels refreshing and a true delight. saw it in 3d at the theatre. hope the bluray release includes the 3d version this time unlike the milking morons that did force awakens double dip release. i truly hope JJ Abrams studies rogue one and capitalizes on it's magic and applies it to Ep8 to make a true star wars film.… Expand
4 of 10 users found this helpful46
All this user's reviews
7
dtlDec 17, 2016
This is a good movie, but not even nearly as good as The Force Awakens. It is quite the spectacle, and a reasonably coherent story, but somewhat lacking in character development. It is also definitively the darkest Star Wars movie, but thatThis is a good movie, but not even nearly as good as The Force Awakens. It is quite the spectacle, and a reasonably coherent story, but somewhat lacking in character development. It is also definitively the darkest Star Wars movie, but that didn't really have much impact for me, perhaps do to the aforementioned lack of character development leading to a lack of caring about the stakes.

All I'll say about the plot is that it is a wholly original take on Star Wars, but a few times seems quite hemmed in by how it has to end. I wonder if they originally meant for it to be different, but were forced to change things for the sake of continuity.

The acting was mostly decent, but not great. I did think that Felicity Jones stood out in a good way in that department as Jyn Erso.… Expand
4 of 10 users found this helpful46
All this user's reviews
Page:
More From This Movie

65 Critic Reviews

7.6 User Reviews

Details & Credits|Trailers

Current Movie Releases
By MetascoreBy User Score
1 77 Project Hail Mary
2 75 Send Help
3 73 Hoppers
4 72 The Sheep Detectives
5 63 Normal
SEE ALL
Essential Links
New on Amazon Prime Video
New on Netflix
Coming Soon to DVD/Blu-ray
SEE ALL