Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

10

hawkeye766Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: a Star Wars Story is a movie far different that anything
that has ever been released under the lucasfilm name. It is completely
devoid of a crawl at the beginning for one thing; Instead it starts
with a concussive sforzando of the score, and space flashes onto the
screen, as if to say, "Here it is, what else did you expect?" I love
those bold yellow words as much as the next guy, they function as a
call to adventure, an invitation to a place far different from anything
the viewer is used to. But Rogue One is different: it's a lot less
adventurous and far more familiar than the galaxy far far away has ever
been. I mean this in the most complimentary way possible; this is a
film that puts the War in "Star Wars" in an acute fashion. Rogue One's main strength is its action. In this reviewers humble
opinion, it features the best action the franchise has to offer. Before
you cry "Blasphemy!" and slam the computer shut in rage, allow me to
explain myself. The battle of the death star in Return of the Jedi is
probably the original trilogy's best space combat. It provides a
vigorous depiction of spacial warfare, displaying the speed and chaos
of ship to ship combat. It is, however, fettered by the primitivity of
early 1980s special effects. The Force Awakens brought to the table
modern effects, but was fairly unexciting to watch due to its being a
near carbon copy of the battle in IV. The battle that serves as Rogue
One's climax is an all-new concept. Things like planetary shield gates,
message transmissions, and ramming ships are brought in the picture.
Aided by 15 or so visual effects companies Disney recruited, it looks
considerably excellent as well. Many aspects of A New Hope are also addressed. The conveniently placed
exhaust port is no longer a shoehorned plot device, but a final act of
revenge by a defecting engineer. Tarkin isn't a Grand Moff but a lowly
Governor, and we get to witness his ascension to power firsthand. Darth
Vader also plays a fairly major role in the film. Many have criticized
Edwards for his habitation of barely three scenes, but really, this
makes them special. Lack of cinematic appearance for the last 34 years
makes it that much more exciting. I struggled in containing my
excitement when I heard that mechanical rasp coming out of the pitch
black hallway of the rebel cruiser in the last scene. After all those
warnings about cell phones, I figured a boisterous scream of childlike
glee would probably be frowned upon in the establishment. When Vader's
crimson blade appeared, spreading the faces of the trembling rebel
soldiers and the hallway of that ship in rufescent, evil glow, I was
actually shaking with anticipation. Vader precedes to hurl himself upon
the hapless rebels with wieldy might. The rebels rush back, handing
off the sought after plans from man to man, as Vader slashes, chokes,
and tosses through their ranks with ease. In a moment of perfection,
the trooper hands off his precious cargo to a CG Princess Leia. "What
did they bring us?" he says. "Hope" she replies. Needless to say, I
almost cried. As I exited the theater, barely keeping my balance after listening to
Giacchino's brilliant overture, I overheard a woman talking with
dissatisfaction about the movie: "I guess it was good, it was kind of
depressing though. I mean, they all died, right?"
"WRONG!" I wanted to scream. Yes, they all die, but in a blaze of
glory. Each character receives the fitting end that I only wish Han
Solo had been given. Countless rebel giants fall, fighting for the
rebel cause. Bohdie the pilot dies wiring an antenna, Baze Malbus dies fighting with newfound acceptance of the force, and Cassian and Jyn die having passed on the death star plans. While nothing else can ever fill the place the original trilogy holds in my heart, I must admit no other Star Wars film has ever portrayed, at least this powerfully, the theme of sacrifice, and how it can pave the way for a new hope.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

10

KingofdanerdsJan 20, 2017

I just love how the directors were able to find a successful way to make a Star Wars movie taking place between Episodes III and IV. Action is amazing and this movie has a strong and supporting cast. Could not ask for more. I am one with theI just love how the directors were able to find a successful way to make a Star Wars movie taking place between Episodes III and IV. Action is amazing and this movie has a strong and supporting cast. Could not ask for more. I am one with the force the force is with me. R.I.P. Carrie Fisher. 10/10… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

9

Doomsday4766Dec 20, 2016

After watching this film I am elated. Here I am thinking that Disney ruined the originality of Star Wars for me by making the no risk, recycled, nothing new 'Farce Awakens'. To be sure, I had a bit of skepticism still when I entered theAfter watching this film I am elated. Here I am thinking that Disney ruined the originality of Star Wars for me by making the no risk, recycled, nothing new 'Farce Awakens'. To be sure, I had a bit of skepticism still when I entered the theater. Would this film cautiously retread the story about some space peasant blessed with magical abilities? Would I have to sit though a nostalgia driven plot that makes no sense? to my relief I was spared any disappointment, and was treated with one of the most originally grounded Star Wars films. The beginning of the movie I felt was the slowest, but before long I was drawn completely into the plot. Then when the action begins it really doesn't stop, right up until the closing scene.

It gets a 9 from me for being a truly self contained story, no real loose ends here, just one entertaining ride. -1 point for overdoing CGI a tad , and to all those who called out the music as a negative. At least it had some original scores, and I was able to actually hear it. Unlike in that awful 7th movie...… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

gamer1Dec 24, 2016

J'ai vraiment aimé ce film, un vrai plaisir de voir que la licence Star Wars semble enfin capable de nou faire rêver à nouveau ! De l'action comme rarement et les acteurs sont très bien aussi

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

VonSeuxMar 26, 2017

More entertaining than force awakens, font really get why this needs to be sold as a side story. Anyway, less pretentiousness more fun. The metacritc average does not translate how nice action adventure movie.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

MCotsalasFeb 22, 2017

I'm shocked that this is only rated a 65 by the critics. This was without a doubt a better told story than The Force Awakens, and the characters had much more likability than The Force Awakens. Looking forward to the next story told inI'm shocked that this is only rated a 65 by the critics. This was without a doubt a better told story than The Force Awakens, and the characters had much more likability than The Force Awakens. Looking forward to the next story told in between trilogy films. (I believe the next one is about Han Solo's origins.)… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

NostalgicDec 23, 2016

First of all all the haters out there need to stfu. How pathetic and unintelligent does a human have to be to rate this epic movie low? We are talking about the most loved franchise of all time and what these filmmakers have managed to doFirst of all all the haters out there need to stfu. How pathetic and unintelligent does a human have to be to rate this epic movie low? We are talking about the most loved franchise of all time and what these filmmakers have managed to do is nothing short of extraordinary. Go see this movie in 3d now !!! All I have to say is bacta tank !… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

7

SpangleDec 22, 2016

A step backward from The Force Awakens, the second Disney Star Wars film still retains many positive elements that continue to show why Star Wars is the only good blockbuster we have left. While this will end soon (after we get one a year forA step backward from The Force Awakens, the second Disney Star Wars film still retains many positive elements that continue to show why Star Wars is the only good blockbuster we have left. While this will end soon (after we get one a year for the next century), Rogue One keeps the good karma rolling with an entertaining and thoroughly well crafted epic space opera. Blending the action with story like few blockbusters care to do anymore, Rogue One has a sense of spectacle and wonder that these types of films should have, but few do. Beneath its CGI Peter Cushing is a beating heart that is infectious and permeates every scene in the film. Though it has its flaws, the film fulfills its goals of providing quality entertainment, but does not spare the audience in exposition and plot, nor does it compromise its serious moments with comedy. In other words, Rogue One is not like the soulless cash-ins we have seen this year such as Captain America: Civil War, Jason Bourne, The Magnificent Seven, or Doctor Strange. Instead, Rogue One has a sense of purpose and it is determined to fulfill this goal.

The end result of Rogue One is simple: deliver the Death Star plans to CGI Princess Leia. I know it is the last scene, but it is not a spoiler in the least since that is literally the plot. Along the way, we meet Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones) and a bunch of other people including a surprise Mexican (as a half-Latino who saw this with 8 other family members, this caused a great amount of shock) and some other people. Jyn is the daughter of Galen Erso (Mads Mikkelsen), who is working on the Death Star against his will as an engineer. After Galen sends a message out that informs the rebels as to the existence of the Death Star and how to defeat it, Jyn is brought in to help find Saw Gerrera (Forest Whitaker). A criminal, Jyn was adopted by Saw after her mother was killed and her father kidnapped by the Empire. A rebel himself, Saw Gerrera is an extremist and rejected by the rebellion. Following this, the film continues to build up to Jyn and her band of misfits working towards delivering the plans to Princess Leia. Admittedly, the character development is really bad. I understand the argument that this a one-off film, but this is hardly an excuse. Everybody here - including Jyn - is disposable. That said, some of these characters are seriously great, especially Chirrut Imwe (Donnie Yen). A blind man who wishes he was a jedi, Chirrut is actively a believer in the force and depends upon it for survival on more than one occasion. Of all the new characters, Chirrut is the easiest to root for and emphasizes the connections that can be made between the force/jedis and religion. Whenever he is on the screen, the scene is guaranteed to be incredibly powerful. Yet, while the film lacks character development, it does a good job making them likable. At all turns, the characters are endearing and, as a result, it makes the ending incredibly powerful and momentous, rather than easy to forget.

In terms of the acting, Rogue One is far better than anything the original trilogy offered. Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, and Harrison Ford, were and are horrifically bad actors. Though they improved throughout the original trilogy (Hamill stayed the same or got worse though and age has not helped this; honestly, Hayden Christensen is better in the prequels than Hamill in any original trilogy film), the acting was always sub-par. Here, the actors are all up to the task. There are some awkward deliveries along the way from Diego Luna, but nothing to knock him down a peg. Otherwise, the rest of the cast brought their B+ game, which is acceptable for a film of this type. The only exception here is Forest Whitaker who was inexplicably bad. It sounded like each word had to escape from his mouth as he tried to keep it down. Just speak and not with some raspy voice that sounds fake.

Plot-wise, there has been a lot of criticism towards the first two acts. Though incredibly slow and hardly as effective as the final act, the first two acts tie in so many prequel elements and original trilogy elements in order to tie them together beautifully, it cannot be ignored. Yes, a lot of it is fan service. However, the film needed to serve as a bridge between Episodes III and IV and it accomplishes this in the first two acts. Here, we see the terror on average families, learn about the Death Star, and are introduced to the rebellion, its indecisiveness, and issues it faces. Though slower than the huge finish, the first two acts are valuable and thoroughly engrossing all the same.

That said though, the final act is impeccable. Building the film to a fever pitch, Gareth Edwards spills his toy box over with a truly fun ending. With Darth Vader exuding the terror he did in the original films and a powerful conclusion for the heroes of Rogue One, this film defines its unique status amongst modern blockbusters here in this final act.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

tr1cky1Dec 29, 2016

Hands downthe best standalone Star Wars Movie. The pure action may have been better in Ep 3, the best light saber battle is Ep 1, but those 2 movies were absolute trash.

Writing and dialogue are clearly the best out of all the series inHands downthe best standalone Star Wars Movie. The pure action may have been better in Ep 3, the best light saber battle is Ep 1, but those 2 movies were absolute trash.

Writing and dialogue are clearly the best out of all the series in Rogue One. One addition by subtraction is a different reliance on the Force compared to the other films, turning it into a grittier movie and less of a battle of super-beings. Most importantly, I've now got a new favorite droid. I kinda wonder what Lucas thinks of all this.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

Gamed2longDec 28, 2016

Star Wars is in a strange place. The prequel trilogy are objectively worse movies than the original trilogy. But they do feel cut from the same cloth. The Force Awakens and Rogue One are better movies than the prequels, but feel cut from aStar Wars is in a strange place. The prequel trilogy are objectively worse movies than the original trilogy. But they do feel cut from the same cloth. The Force Awakens and Rogue One are better movies than the prequels, but feel cut from a different cloth. I found Rogue One to be a thoroughly enjoyable flick. The plot made sense and didn't step on the original films. I liked the diverse imperial bases. The film has minor flaws, such as some of the acting talent being wasted. Forest Whitaker and Mads Mikkelsen can do more/better! It seemed like K2SO got all the good comedic lines. Also a couple of times (minor spoiler) a character appears where the original actor has aged substantially or passed on. The approach taken to that seemed a little uncanny valley to me. Ultimately though the film lacks much of an underlying theme. Which makes it a flick, even though its a good one. Finally RIP Carrie Fisher.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

MeritCobaJan 28, 2017

Rogue One is a movie that sets the focus low. The heroes are not Jedi or members of some ruling elite. Rogue one's cast has more in common with Han Solo than with a Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia. The message of the movie: little acts ofRogue One is a movie that sets the focus low. The heroes are not Jedi or members of some ruling elite. Rogue one's cast has more in common with Han Solo than with a Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia. The message of the movie: little acts of bravery can have important consequences.

The MacGuffin that makes the movie go is to find the weakness of that big death star moon build by the father of Jen. Find the father, find the weakness. A message from dad reaches the rebels in the form of a pilot and so Jen has to be found as to gain access to dad by way of Saw Gerrera, a rebel so extreme that even the Rebel Alliance frowns on him. Since he happens to be Jen's surrogate father it might be that he listens to her instead of pulling the trigger.

Does that sound overtly complex? Well, it does, but if you just tag along with the movie it is just one of points in the tale that you get dragged along. And tag along is the only thing that you can do as the movie does not let go. I would say, it keeps almost the same frantic pace as that crazy movie Fury Road. And that is the main weakness of this movie. Despite interesting characters there are too many of them and not enough time for any of them. The upshot is that you don't care if someone sacrifices his life, which happens a lot in this movie. They join up and they get killed. Next! Even when there is an important emotional moment in the movie it quickly gets trampled over in a desire to keep the pace. Without some dwelling on emotions heroes become two dimensional figures and their sacrifices have no emotional impact.

Still, Rogue One one is one of the better Star Wars movies in my opinion. It would have been better if there had been some more time spend on character development and less on jumping from one place to the next out of fear that some moments of reflection will scare the audience out of the theater. A pity because the essence of this movie: little people can bring hope loses a lot of its emotional currency.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

VendonJun 22, 2017

Anyone rating this movie below a 7 is a troll. The user reviews on this website make it cancerous, they should remove user reviews because most people come here to give BS ratings. The movie was great, down with the trolls.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

BigDegs29Dec 21, 2016

8.5/10 (Metacritic doesn't let you do decimals)

This is my second favorite Star Wars after Empire. The worst part of the movie is the beginning, and it progressively gets better from there until it's firing on all cylinders by the end. The8.5/10 (Metacritic doesn't let you do decimals)

This is my second favorite Star Wars after Empire. The worst part of the movie is the beginning, and it progressively gets better from there until it's firing on all cylinders by the end. The final act is spectacular! Probably the best space battle excepting Jedi, and the best ground fight in any Star Wars.

The story is great, and even goes so far to correct a 40-year-old plot hole in A New Hope (I won't explain that further for fear of spoilers).

The weak point is the character development. The two mains, Jyn and Cassian, have decent character arcs. Chirrut and Baze play two characters that are pretty much cliche at this point, but still enjoyable. Bodhi is forgettable. K-2SO is pretty awesome and carries almost all of the comedic relief on his shoulders, and not in the cheesy way the prequels treated C-3PO. Saw Gerrera played by Whitaker has only a small role in the movie and is involved in probably the weakest scene of the entire thing.

There is a lot of fan service in this movie. Without going into spoilers, some of it works really well and some had me rolling my eyes.

They used CGI to bring back two characters from the original trilogy. One gets a lot of screen time and suffers for it, entering into the uncanny valley. The other gets limited screen time and works a lot better.

I take it by now everyone knows Vader is in the film. And let me tell you, Rogue One has the best Vader scene in all of Star Wars IMO. They humanized him in Jedi, but they bring back the menace full on here!

I consider this a must-see. If you're like me, the first 15-20 minutes will leave you pessimistic about the result of the movie, but it'll win you over shortly after that!… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

Voodoo123Oct 12, 2017

+superior fan fiction tells a new story in the cracks between episode 3-4
+excellent pacing / cast / direction improves on repeat viewings
+chessy fun times had here -CG tarkin (if only they kept as reflection only...) Seriously grinning+superior fan fiction tells a new story in the cracks between episode 3-4
+excellent pacing / cast / direction improves on repeat viewings
+chessy fun times had here
-CG tarkin (if only they kept as reflection only...)

Seriously grinning from ear to ear with all the little references and easter eggs. Genuinely impressed. This gave me new hope for star wars films yet to be that maybe can fill the gap left by the absence of George Lucas genius ....… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

joyalexandreDec 28, 2016

This is a good Star Wars. A refreshing look at the franchise. It patch a lot of the faults in the old trilogy. I like the more mature look at the characters as well.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

7

badgerryan19May 19, 2017

A good movie. I was a little skeptical on how the movie was gonna turn out. With a good cast and everyone does a good job, but it seemed like no one really out shined anyone. The characterization of the film was the biggest flaw in the movieA good movie. I was a little skeptical on how the movie was gonna turn out. With a good cast and everyone does a good job, but it seemed like no one really out shined anyone. The characterization of the film was the biggest flaw in the movie with almost none. Felicity Jones's character got the most backstory and it was enough to make you care about her. Gareth Edwards does a great job on showing the whole scope and scale of everything just like in his Godzilla movie. The practical effects, CGI, and costume design as usual is top notch. I am a little disappointed that Vader was only in the movie for about 5 minutes. But I am ultimately happy he was in it. The movie does a spectacular job on leading right up to the beginning of Episode 4.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

LuhterJun 17, 2017

It's great and how should a SW side story be. The story is solid and logical when compared to the mess ep7 was. Visually it looks great. Score the same. The lead character is not a soulless perfect hero like Rey so is interesting to watch,It's great and how should a SW side story be. The story is solid and logical when compared to the mess ep7 was. Visually it looks great. Score the same. The lead character is not a soulless perfect hero like Rey so is interesting to watch, and the supporting cast was nice even though a little more moments with them would've been nice. Overall a good movie.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

7

GuccimayneDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I thought it was a solid movie, 7/10. The pacing was a bit too fast in the beginning, then suddenly drags in the middle, but the third act really sells the show. This makes it hard to give it above a 7, but all in all the movie was a meaningful, unique story within the confines of the star wars universe that I enjoyed. In fact I'd say this movie was executed much better than Episode 7. TFA was heavy on the nostalgia pandering but left me guessing about WAY too much relevant plot information because they were saved for the books and future movies. Unlike TFA, I didn't HAVE to watch Clone Wars/Rebels or read the novelization to understand what was going on in Rogue One. It's cool for backstory but it didn't detract from the plot of the movie in front of me. The cast was amazing and although I didn't come to "care" for all of the characters' fates because there were a lot of them, I believe they each contributed something to the mission and overall movie. They weren't just on screen cracking jokes while getting their butts handed to them (Finn). Donnie and the Droid were especially show stealers, but by far my favorite character has to be Krennic. I might just rewatch the movie just to see Darth Vader going nuts on those dudes in the corridor, ha. Lastly, I loved how they filmed the Death Star beautifully looming in the sky before vaporizing everything. The cinematography in those scenes was fantastic. Really emphasizes the psychological warfare of seeing the Death Star hanging out over your planet.

Admittedly I was concerned about the quality of the stand alone Star Wars movies since I am quite upset with how TFA turned out, but if this is how things are going to look in the future, I may continue watching Disney's Star Wars.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

saintandrewsfalJan 3, 2017

Good film overall with some missteps. Acting, story, and action, were all tight. No problems there. The issues come up with cliched moments, a small lull in the second act, and an average ending.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

SpottedLaughterDec 24, 2016

Absolutely in the top five Star Wars Movies ever made and a joy to watch from beginning to end.

While yes, there are issues with the movie, some of the CGI can be a bit in the uncanny valley the first time you see it and some of theAbsolutely in the top five Star Wars Movies ever made and a joy to watch from beginning to end.

While yes, there are issues with the movie, some of the CGI can be a bit in the uncanny valley the first time you see it and some of the characters are under developed, I don't feel they impact the movie too seriously. The movie ties perfectly into the start of 'A New Hope' and helps to fill in plenty of holes that were in the original movie, such as why Luke becomes 'Red 5', why the Death Star has such an odd weakness and how Vader can be so certain that Leia isn't on a diplomatic mission as she claims.

Also, the fact that the Rebellion isn't depicted right out as the good guys in the film, is a massive relief! In all of the original trilogy, the Rebels are shown as the moral right, good guys against an evil empire. But not in Rogue One. Here we see a Rebellion that is on the verge of breaking, taking desperate measures to keep themselves hidden and accomplish their goals in the face of overwhelming odds, where many of their missions are win or die trying.

For any Star Wars fans, this is highly recommended that you see it!… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

joost-013Mar 5, 2017

A solid star wars spin-off. The characters are generally a little more flat than those in episode VII but it's still pretty good. As an action movie this movie is top notch though, even furfilling some long awaited fan service scenarios.A solid star wars spin-off. The characters are generally a little more flat than those in episode VII but it's still pretty good. As an action movie this movie is top notch though, even furfilling some long awaited fan service scenarios. Concluded, a good star wars movie and a great action movie.

*Note, the spectacle is a big part of the experience of this movie. So when you (still) have the chance to see it in theaters, or at least on a big screen you can add a point to the score.*… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

FingoldfinDec 21, 2016

Fantástica, lo único que flojea para mi es la banda sonora pues en algunos momentos no cuadra con lo que esta ocurriendo, por el resto es simplemente maravillosa.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

COOLQUINN17Mar 3, 2017

Have you ever wonder how the rebels stole the Death Star plans? It did say that they did stole it in the opening credits of A New Hope but nobody ever knew how they did it. Well, almost 40 years later, we FINALLY know how they stole the DeathHave you ever wonder how the rebels stole the Death Star plans? It did say that they did stole it in the opening credits of A New Hope but nobody ever knew how they did it. Well, almost 40 years later, we FINALLY know how they stole the Death Star plans. This is another Star Wars Prequel that you will ACTUALLY enjoy. The action was very incredible, the Darth Vader hallway scene and the final battle were the best action scenes. The characters are likable, even though not memorable. The CGI was awesome and they knew when to put it in there and not to put it in there. Speaking of CGI, they did pretty good with the CG Tarkin and the actor that did the motion capture and the voice for him did a good job impersonating Peter Cushing, who played Tarkin in A New Hope. Peter Cushing passed away in 1994 but Tarkin was a major player in the creation of the Death star and they knew they needed Tarkin. They also did a great job with the CG Leia, it really looked like she was there. They didn’t need to hire a person to do the voice because they used archive recordings from A New Hope for her voice. There is a sad moment in the movie but i won’t spoil it or anything. It’s obvious that this isn’t the best Star Wars movie and they can never beat the first two Star Wars movies but it’s still a great Star Wars movie. Go ahead and watch it, you’ll have an epic time.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

RavarathSep 6, 2017

As a BIG fan of OLD Star Wars universe I have to say this movie is FAR superior than Force Awakens. The story is great (I might have lowered standards after Force Awakens) with some plot holes, but hey it's unavoidable. Character developmentAs a BIG fan of OLD Star Wars universe I have to say this movie is FAR superior than Force Awakens. The story is great (I might have lowered standards after Force Awakens) with some plot holes, but hey it's unavoidable. Character development is fine (as for stand off movie not trilogy) but the biggest pro is the ambiance. We can feel the gravity of events that we are about to witness (in comparison Force Awakens - meh whatever) and they will define the whole galaxy! This is THE good old Star Wars universe as we used to know dark but yet heroic and not some colorful, happy and cringy fairy tale.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

BostonterrierDec 28, 2016

Tied with my 2nd favorite star wars film (a new hope). Empire strikes back is still my fav. Anyway, this movie is nearly flawless, but most its cast is forgettable/serviceable. The only two stand-out performances were a robot and Chirrut ImweTied with my 2nd favorite star wars film (a new hope). Empire strikes back is still my fav. Anyway, this movie is nearly flawless, but most its cast is forgettable/serviceable. The only two stand-out performances were a robot and Chirrut Imwe (as portrayed by the fantastic Donnie Yen). Definitely a great movie.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

AMcLMDec 23, 2016

Even though we already knew how it would end, this movie had me on the edge of my seat the whole time. There are parts that will make you laugh and parts that will make you cry and scenes that will leave you in awe. It is truly one of theEven though we already knew how it would end, this movie had me on the edge of my seat the whole time. There are parts that will make you laugh and parts that will make you cry and scenes that will leave you in awe. It is truly one of the most captivating movies I have ever seen. Whilst it does have you asking "why did they do that?" a few times, it does little to detract from the enjoyment of the film and I am sure that if one put a little thought into these decisions they could be justified. Overall, a great film that I would highly recommend even if you have somehow not watched any of the other Star Wars films.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

PatraxaDec 25, 2016

When I went into episode 7, with high hopes of a new star wars trilogy being great, my hopes were ruined. The movie was bland, the characters;boring and unoriginal, and there was a constant use of pointless nostalgia. It was awful, so goingWhen I went into episode 7, with high hopes of a new star wars trilogy being great, my hopes were ruined. The movie was bland, the characters;boring and unoriginal, and there was a constant use of pointless nostalgia. It was awful, so going into this film my expectations were set low. However the movie had good characters, amazing scenes, a fantastic plot, amazing moments, and it was a star wars movie through and through. For that alone it could easily get 7 stars, but the ending was astonishing, and for that superb ending it is a must see.
Now let us all hope that episode 8 will follow this and not the joke that was episode 7.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

hotesforclodDec 26, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Finally, a new Star Wars with dialogue! Great cast and balance of special effects. SPOILER: its both light-hearted and deeply dark; at times has the feel of episode V. Appearances by Vader will pull at your hidden dark side. I'll probably never watch The Force Awakens again, but this I'll rewatch forever...… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

Jan_FetzerDec 27, 2016

I don't get how the critic consensus only gives this film 65%. IMO, this is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. It ties into Episode IV perfectly, everything makes sense (for once) and the film even goes as far as to explainI don't get how the critic consensus only gives this film 65%. IMO, this is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. It ties into Episode IV perfectly, everything makes sense (for once) and the film even goes as far as to explain one of the biggest plot holes of A New Hope.

In some ways, I even like Rogue One more than any other Star Wars film. For the first time, it's not a black vs. white fairytale, where the Rebellion is good and the Empire is bad (simply because the audience is told so). The characters in this film are more complex and nuanced than in any other SW film before. This is the modern re-boot of the amazing franchise we've all been waiting for.

The only thing missing is the iconic Star Wars sound track. I don't know why they didn't use some of the original musical themes but if they had, I would give this film a perfect 10.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

kagreelDec 30, 2016

Best Star Wars movie ever! Story moved so smoothly, beautifully shot, great surprises, phenomenal action sequences, and an overall exceptional cast! Story was the best yet of the Star Wars franchise, being so simple yet complex at the same time.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

aliciabrookssJan 7, 2017

Finally, a Star Wars movie which one can call near perfect. From the brilliant plot to the constant action, it is truly tough pinpoint what makes "Rogue One" such an epic film, and I mean EPIC. For once, a star wars film that is not based onFinally, a Star Wars movie which one can call near perfect. From the brilliant plot to the constant action, it is truly tough pinpoint what makes "Rogue One" such an epic film, and I mean EPIC. For once, a star wars film that is not based on comical relief and cliches, this darker movie is just what Star Wars fans had been looking for. I leave this review to a minimum, as one can only judge once they've seen it, and i definitely urge you all to see it. All that I will say is that, as my father said upon leaving the theatre "That is the best Star Wars film I've ever seen". Well done Gareth Edwards.

(P.S for those comparing Rogue One to TFA, Rogue One makes TFA look like absolute garbage and it is almost unfair to compare the two)… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

LaskeudeungJan 27, 2017

Ya memang ga aneh, kalau rating critics di Meta ini cuma 65. Rogue One memang tetap memiliki kesan franchise Star Wars. Tapi ... tidak akan bisa lepas dari tokoh - tokoh utamanya yang di sini hanya muncul sebagai Cameo2 ...

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

ZerpnosMar 5, 2017

Disney gerçekten harika işler çıkarmaya devam ediyor.. Karşımıza Spin:off bir filmle çıkan Disney beklenilenin üstüne çıkıyor ve Star Wars IV'ün hemen öncesini konu alıyor. Bu konuyu mükemmel bir şekilde işleyen ve bize tekrar Vader'ıDisney gerçekten harika işler çıkarmaya devam ediyor.. Karşımıza Spin:off bir filmle çıkan Disney beklenilenin üstüne çıkıyor ve Star Wars IV'ün hemen öncesini konu alıyor. Bu konuyu mükemmel bir şekilde işleyen ve bize tekrar Vader'ı gösteren film harika bir sonla bitişini de gerçekleştiriyor. Her şeyiyle gerçekten özlediğimiz Star Wars filmlerine doymamızı sağlıyor fakat hala açız ve bir sürü Star Wars filmi istiyoruz!… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

Viking171986Mar 28, 2017

I would like to state that I grew up with Star wars, I didn't watch disney (Ironic since Disney now owns star wars) I was in the Army for 10 years and the attention to detail in the tactics that the Rebel soldiers and Storm Troopers wereI would like to state that I grew up with Star wars, I didn't watch disney (Ironic since Disney now owns star wars) I was in the Army for 10 years and the attention to detail in the tactics that the Rebel soldiers and Storm Troopers were amazing and not horrible. Daisy Ridley should take note because this is what a strong Female lead looks like, She had an actual heroes journey. Mother was murdered only to be raised by a terrorist as a child soldier and then turns into a hero. the Plot dragged in some places and killed the flow halfway through the movie but the final act alone made the movie amazing. I can only hope that The Last Jedi can be as good as this. Death Troopers FTW.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

Mac2311Jun 20, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Disney's acquisition of the Star Wars franchise was looked at with skepticism when I first heard it happened but first Episode VII and now this? yeah I'm on board. Though the pacing could have been handled better I feel the story was well put together and was realized as it should that there wasn't going to be a happy ending by the end of this movie. They did a great job of not pulling any punches and can't wait for the next one to come out!… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

kivayugimotoDec 17, 2016

Good movie; thoroughly enjoyed it! It is worth seeing it in a movie theater. Favorite character is the robot; it's dialogue responses just added to make it a fun action movie.

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

10

twall3Dec 19, 2016

I didn't care for the director's "Godzilla" movie (too much serious dialogue from characters I didn't care about), so I wondered how likeable this would be. I didn't like Rogue One ... I LOVED it (and the characters)! While it started on theI didn't care for the director's "Godzilla" movie (too much serious dialogue from characters I didn't care about), so I wondered how likeable this would be. I didn't like Rogue One ... I LOVED it (and the characters)! While it started on the slower end of things, by the time the movie ended and the credits rolled, my mind was blown. I knew it took place somewhere between SW3 and SW4, but what they did, how they handled it - hard to describe. Something like this: you go to the zoo to see a Lion, but before you leave, you've got your head in it's mouth looking down it's throat - unexpected up close view. Wow.… Expand

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

10

KzArashiDec 17, 2016

Rogue One is the prequel Star Wars deserves.
And a thing to note is that the original trilogy has a tone of ingenuity. On the other hand, for Rogue One the tone align to a struggling new found hope. And that is what make Rogue OneRogue One is the prequel Star Wars deserves.
And a thing to note is that the original trilogy has a tone of ingenuity. On the other hand, for Rogue One the tone align to a struggling new found hope. And that is what make Rogue One exceptional. That filme shows the fight and the struggle to build the ground from where the NEW HOPE could flourish, through a boy ingenuity in Episode IV.
The heroes in Rogue One are much like the soldiers who fought and died in the beachs of Normand to build the ground for the Alied campain and victory against the nazis in WWII.… Expand

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

8

AfNinoDec 16, 2016

The first half of the movie seemed a bit weirdly edited and all over the place, but the last act is amazing. Truly gives you a perspective of war that no other Star Wars movie has ever done. A great time at the cinema overall.

8 of 21 users found this helpful813

All this user's reviews

10

jamiejoyceDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is, quite frankly, MAGNIFICENT. Disney deserve praise for not shying away from allowing the filmmakers to apply some bold story decisions in the third act. This isn’t some neutered, watered down version of Star Wars – this is StarRogue One is, quite frankly, MAGNIFICENT. Disney deserve praise for not shying away from allowing the filmmakers to apply some bold story decisions in the third act. This isn’t some neutered, watered down version of Star Wars – this is Star Wars at its most uncompromised. Thrilling, beautiful and occasionally surprising, this is the prequel the fans deserve.… Expand

12 of 32 users found this helpful1220

All this user's reviews

10

theexarDec 17, 2016

After the disappointment from the Force Awakens I went to the cinema with very low expectations for Rogue One. However, the movie far surpassed them. I expected cheesy moments, hollow motivational speeches, badly adapted setting. It was noneAfter the disappointment from the Force Awakens I went to the cinema with very low expectations for Rogue One. However, the movie far surpassed them. I expected cheesy moments, hollow motivational speeches, badly adapted setting. It was none of these. Apart from an unconvincing martial arts character, everything in Rogue One was Star Wars from the beginning to the end. Great humor, memorable cameos and references, intensive action scenes and all of this - without overdoing it. Awesome work!… Expand

6 of 16 users found this helpful610

All this user's reviews

10

drrealitycheckDec 26, 2016

Best Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. This was a return to the very first two movies back in the 70s, a tribute to the best of this franchise and the kind of Star Wars saga we all came to love. A host of new characters was quiteBest Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. This was a return to the very first two movies back in the 70s, a tribute to the best of this franchise and the kind of Star Wars saga we all came to love. A host of new characters was quite successful and the humor wasn't left out either. It also fills in a lot of gaps from the original films. Oh, and your favorite all time villain, complete with the voice of James Earl Jones, makes a few appearances.Those who didn't give this event top end reviews are in immediate need of CPR.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

8

Magic84Dec 18, 2016

Weak character development is overshadowed by an original plot with an amazing third act. First act of the movie is a choppy mess, but the rest of the film over delivers.

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

10

jc18241Dec 16, 2016

It was the best in the franchise right behind Empire Strikes Back. The cast was amazing. The story was amazing. The cameos were awesome. This movie is so damn good on so many levels. The only complaints I have are the slow opening and theIt was the best in the franchise right behind Empire Strikes Back. The cast was amazing. The story was amazing. The cameos were awesome. This movie is so damn good on so many levels. The only complaints I have are the slow opening and the movies score. Music could have been better. Nothing more to complain about after that.… Expand

10 of 27 users found this helpful1017

All this user's reviews

9

jonasionDec 16, 2016

Look, I'm a massive Star Wars fan, but I've been nothing but disappointed since the mid-eighties really. Episode 7 was somewhat okay for me, but it left a lot of **** in its wake. Rogue One goes about explaining some key things that have leftLook, I'm a massive Star Wars fan, but I've been nothing but disappointed since the mid-eighties really. Episode 7 was somewhat okay for me, but it left a lot of **** in its wake. Rogue One goes about explaining some key things that have left the nerd-verse puzzled about the original Star Wars - Episode IV - A New Hope (as it was later dubbed). Rogue One goes about explaining that and it does so really well and it takes no prisoners.… Expand

7 of 19 users found this helpful712

All this user's reviews

9

mrushing02Dec 16, 2016

“It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire.

During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire’s ultimate weapon, the“It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire.

During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire’s ultimate weapon, the DEATH STAR, an armored space station with enough power to destroy an entire planet.”

These words are the first thing that anyone ever saw of Star Wars as the film opened in 1977 and now Gareth Edwards has imbued them fully in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story.

Hope Anew

The Rebellion’s struggle just got worse, as it learns that the Empire has created a world-killing weapon named the Death Star. The Rebellion finds itself on the knife’s edge between hope and despair. The council of the Rebellion cannot decide what to do. Do they risk it all by trying to steal the plans, or do they resign themselves to defeat and despair? Jyn challenges the council, “What chance do we have? The question is what choice”. She implores the council to remember that if they do nothing then they’ve sealed the fate of the galaxy and that evil this great cannot go unopposed. It brings to mind Edmund Burke’s famous saying, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” She encourages them with a refrain Cassian Andor said to her earlier in the movie, “Rebellions are built on hope”. Hope changes everything, it reminds people that the way it is, is not how it has to be. Hope is the spark that, if kindled, creates the fire of change. Change is possible, but it takes sacrifice, determination and some times, lives to see it come about.

The beauty of the film is that hope is not just a figment of the heroes imaginations. The Force seems quite active, even without the Jedi. It’s moving in mysterious ways and bringing people together that can make a difference. This band of rogues does the impossible, one chance at a time, succeeding in their goal and setting in motion something that will see the end of the Empire.

The Movie

Gareth Edwards made a Star Wars movie that feels completely different and yet utterly familiar, all at the same time. Like The Clone Wars, Edwards uses cinematic inspirations to pull in the war movie genre and make it a Star Wars movie, emphasis on the war. The nods to great war films of the past are all there and they work perfectly. On top of that you feel the “Star Wars” seeping out of every single frame. The Ghost from Star Wars Rebels can be seen at least 4 times, Cham Sydulla is called for over the coms at Yavin 4, the sets feel like they came out of a lost arc of The Clone Wars, Saw Gerrera has an important role and so much more. The point here is that Edwards lovingly knits together the history of the Prequel and the Original trilogy and it’s seamless.

Star Wars, when it’s at it’s best, is stretching what it means to be Star Wars by taking other genres and telling a story in the Star Wars universe that aligns with the themes of the saga. Edwards achievement is nothing short of incredible, the movie feels like the Maker’s fingerprints are all over it and it’s the highest compliment that could be paid to the movie.

The characters are outstanding. K-2so is the best new droid since R2 and Jyn, Cassian, Chirrut, Baze and Bhodi are all welcome additions to the Star Wars canon. Darth Vader’s scenes are chilling (and let’s stop here and just geek out completely that Vader’s castle is finally on screen!) and perfectly played, just enough to leave you wanting more.

The music by Giacchino feels like a welcome addition to the Star Wars franchise, it’s much like The Clone Wars music and only references familiar themes in snippets yet that’s a good thing. The movie needed it’s own identity and the themes he created feel familiar and distinct, perfectly matching the spirit of the movie.

I’ll get personal, this movie is everything I wanted a new Star Wars movie to be. Pushing the boundaries of what it means to be Star Wars while at the same time respecting the history and the franchise as a whole. Here’s to hoping the rumors of Edwards wanting to direct a Kenobi movie are true. Rogue One is rated 4.5 upside down Death Stars out of 5.… Expand

7 of 19 users found this helpful712

All this user's reviews

10

Monkey_NutzDec 18, 2016

If you're an original trilogy purest this movie will hit you in the gut and hold you enthralled for just over two hours. THIS is the Star Wars movie we've been waiting for since 1985.

While not perfect, it is the perfect antidote to the lastIf you're an original trilogy purest this movie will hit you in the gut and hold you enthralled for just over two hours. THIS is the Star Wars movie we've been waiting for since 1985.

While not perfect, it is the perfect antidote to the last four weaksauce episodes (yeah, I'm talking to you too Force Awakens). I cheered, I cried, my mouth dropped in awe. I fell in love with Star Wars all over again, something I'd written off as impossible. As a previously bitter fan, this one movie has instilled within me the driving theme of this wonderful film, hope.… Expand

4 of 11 users found this helpful47

All this user's reviews

10

PrivataDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A clever , deep and intellectual movie full of StarWars lore.
The best movie of the year , in 50 years we will still be talking about the wonders of R1… Expand

7 of 21 users found this helpful714

All this user's reviews

10

oraborsaDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Cuesta escribir una critica objetiva siendo fan de la saga SW, pero cumple con todas las expectativas y las supera. La película, llena de guiños a episodio IV transforma a la doctrina jedi y "la fuerza" en portadora de fe.… Expand

6 of 18 users found this helpful612

All this user's reviews

10

CommonsenseDec 19, 2016

Critics are pretty wrong on this one. Characters could have been developed a little more, but the tension, cinematography and, overall story didn't disappoint. No one in my theater seemed unhappy and many even clapped an cheered and this wasCritics are pretty wrong on this one. Characters could have been developed a little more, but the tension, cinematography and, overall story didn't disappoint. No one in my theater seemed unhappy and many even clapped an cheered and this was 2 days after the premier on a 6:30 showing.… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

10

SumwhenDec 19, 2016

Personally I was quite shocked out how things panned out in this - kudos to Disney and LFL for making a gutsy and uncompromising war movie. And although the character development wasn't it's strong point, the characters were all at leastPersonally I was quite shocked out how things panned out in this - kudos to Disney and LFL for making a gutsy and uncompromising war movie. And although the character development wasn't it's strong point, the characters were all at least likeable and Chirrut and Baze were genuinely great. Really ballsy given the circumstances.
AND DARTH VADER THOUGH!!!!!!… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

8

jenglish451Dec 17, 2016

Rogue One is thankfully another admirable Hollywood film that sincerely honors sacrifice, persistence, and hope. Of the Star Wars films, it's probably the best since the original three, and it links fairly well to the first.

It would be niceRogue One is thankfully another admirable Hollywood film that sincerely honors sacrifice, persistence, and hope. Of the Star Wars films, it's probably the best since the original three, and it links fairly well to the first.

It would be nice to know more about some of the characters, to sense even more deeply what they've suffered, but the film's focus on the story of the ensemble and how it miraculously comes together leads to another fascinating point: Arguably its handling of the idea of the Force or of a force behind the force may be more suggestive of a beneficent divine Providence, and thus closer to the Judeo-Christian God, than in the original three films which seemed to say that the Force requires balance--the light side requires a dark side, and so on (e.g. any victory of the good side is always only temporary, to be followed by the ascendancy of the dark side due to the purported balanced nature of the Force). The new film's seeming shift is a positive development. That notion of balance, of equal eternal opposition of good and evil, failed (even in the fictional world) to adequately or helpfully distinguish between good and evil so as to recognize good as higher than or better than or transcendent over evil. One could even argue from this development that the original films involved untrustworthy narration that is only now being revealed. Perhaps full investment in the themes stated above required this development. Hope would be unfounded without it.

And in its more unmitigated sense of a beneficent divine Providence watching over, superintending events, it feels reminiscent of the divine Providence and Creator (Eru Iluvitar) behind the scenes in The Lord of the Rings. But I guess time will tell if Star Wars really moves in this direction.… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

8

FuturedirectorDec 18, 2016

Well-acted, smartly written and surprisngly blessed by an all-new story-telling that shares with the audience a truly unsatisfying story that perfectly works with the original saga.

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

8

Muskrat147Dec 17, 2016

(In-Depth) Rating - 8.2/10

Rogue One, A Star Wars Story, tells the story of how the Rebellion captured the plans for the original Death Star. The film, which is filled to the brim with brilliant action and wonderful CGI, is a great film for(In-Depth) Rating - 8.2/10

Rogue One, A Star Wars Story, tells the story of how the Rebellion captured the plans for the original Death Star. The film, which is filled to the brim with brilliant action and wonderful CGI, is a great film for fans and film-goers alike.

Almost all of the performances in the film are well executed. The characters that these actors portray, however, are somewhat flat and lack emotional depth. Felicity Jones, who plays the character of Jyn Erso, is a wonderful addition to the many talents on screen. The character of Jyn Erso, however, is extremely weak and one-dimensional, considering that she is the main character of the film. Through flashbacks, we learn about her tragic past, and how her father was taken from her. You can't fully care about this character though, even with her backstory, and just resort to rooting for her simply because she is working with the rebellion. This happens with all of the other characters in the film as well.

Michael Giacchino's score for Rogue One (which he composed in all of roughly 4 weeks, mind you) is the main reason why this film is good. It's magnificent blend between original score and pre-existing themes (most notably, Darth Vader's iconic theme) helps make the film slightly emotional, and truly shines during the action sequences, which are impressive even without the music.

The CGI that encompasses Rogue One is arguably the best of the year. Everything from the glorious ground and space battles over Scarif to the endless amount of sets and and locations, the CGI blends almost perfectly with the live footage. However, arguably the most controversial aspect of Rogue One, is the inevitable inclusion of two motion-capture characters (no spoilers). Personally, I found these characters to be perfectly fine, minus a few (glaring) imperfections. All in all, Rogue One is not a perfect film (by any means), and definitely not as polished as last years' The Force Awakens. But the film is good (great, even), and will make for lots of fun and enjoyment.… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

7

BikerjamesDec 20, 2016

I enjoyed Rogue One despite its flaws. The first half hour is somewhat complicated as you are trying to decipher who is who and what is going on. Then you realize that most of the characters have the exact same personality and temperament.I enjoyed Rogue One despite its flaws. The first half hour is somewhat complicated as you are trying to decipher who is who and what is going on. Then you realize that most of the characters have the exact same personality and temperament. I think there is supposed to be chemistry between the two leads (Jyn and Cassian) but since they both have the same personality it fails. A new robot (K-2SO) is introduced to bring some MUCH needed humor into the movie, but not enough to compare to the original three movies made by Lucas in the 1970s. It seems recent directors forget how much humor was in the original films, part of what makes them so special. Also, the last two films are not very original. There aren't many scenes that we haven't seen before in other Star Wars Films. A good soundtrack should emphasize the mood of the scene - you should not be constantly aware of it. What saves this film are the action sequences and spectacular CGI images. The CGI of the two characters from the first trilogy are pretty amazing overall, but you can tell something is a little "off". I also applaud the ending which is not the typical Hollywood happy ending. There is enough good in the film to satisfy the typical Star Wars fan until the next installment, but don't expect perfection.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

Twist_Of_FateDec 24, 2016

They left the best movie of the year for last wow!.Incredible cast and relateable characters and atmosphere was definitely a step up and proves what Disney can do,haven't seen it? go see it NOW!,seen it? go see it again to relive what anThey left the best movie of the year for last wow!.Incredible cast and relateable characters and atmosphere was definitely a step up and proves what Disney can do,haven't seen it? go see it NOW!,seen it? go see it again to relive what an impressive,outstanding movie this is.Legendary… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

7

SammifxDec 18, 2016

Does a lot of things right, and some crtical ones wrong. The biggest negatives 1) score and music editing (timing of music with whats happening on screen is completely offputting and doesnt help in setting the tone
2) first half introductionsDoes a lot of things right, and some crtical ones wrong. The biggest negatives 1) score and music editing (timing of music with whats happening on screen is completely offputting and doesnt help in setting the tone
2) first half introductions and character motivations were eehhh.
3) inspiration speeches from people we just met 4) cgi tarkin,(other character from new hope) and vaders voice.
5) didnt' really care for the characters apart from the main trio (madds included).

Positives
the second half .. and the environmental/battle/ship graphics- wow. just wow. see this in imax if possible just for the visuals. also, the nice connection at the end to the new hope. all in all id have given this an 8.5 if it had been scored well . still, heaps better than VII… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

8

Jim222001Jun 15, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A gloomy and probably unnecessary StarWars story it is. However the film is so well acted and well done that it's definitely not bad. While there's some pretty bad ass Vader appearances. Which makes us forget the disappointing last time we saw Vader on the big screen in 2005. He gets way cooler lines than "Where's Padme ?" and "Noooooo!" ”
I also liked how they used to bring back dead actors from the original or to make certain actors from the original look younger. They should make a First Order film leading into Force Awakens and use that effect. My complaint is something that hit me after the film. This a big spoiler: Just that after anyone part of the Rogue One team does their part of the mission, then they're expendable like right after. Time for them to die. Which happens one by one after each character has done what they were supposed to. I didn't expect any survivors from the start but the way it was done was some-what lazy.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

7

shoulderoforionJan 22, 2017

Passable addition to the Star Wars canon. This movie was so "busy" with locations & characters you couldn't really sink your teeth into any of them before they flew by (pun). I'd rewatch when it comes out on stream. Did not care forPassable addition to the Star Wars canon. This movie was so "busy" with locations & characters you couldn't really sink your teeth into any of them before they flew by (pun). I'd rewatch when it comes out on stream. Did not care for the'droid at all.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

7

jbrown8989May 17, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Storyline was interesting and I liked the tie in at the end of the movie leading up to the original films. I don't consider myself a big Star Wars fan yet I enjoyed it.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

8

CineAutoctonoDec 21, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. "Star Wars: Rogue One" was an exciting film, the story was well created, the script was very good, but maybe it was not better than episode 7, I felt identified with the protagonists, the cameos are impresive, and without Doubt was one of my favorites of the saga.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

Mike_ZmekeDec 24, 2016

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story BEST Star wars since original trilogy.
It's fresh brith in all star wars franchise!
Don't believe the stupid surveys of journalists and be sure to go to this beautiful film

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

LeoZamprognoDec 22, 2016

One of the best StarWars Movie and one of the best movies I've seen in my life! And I am a big star wars fan. If you don't like, you are not a fan, sorry...

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

7

Theone789Dec 19, 2016

It was a story that did not need to told. If you watch episode four you know the rebellion got the plans at a great loss. The grafics that were used to to bring people from episode four back were terrible. The story line did show the darkIt was a story that did not need to told. If you watch episode four you know the rebellion got the plans at a great loss. The grafics that were used to to bring people from episode four back were terrible. The story line did show the dark side of the rebellion so I can respect that since there is always a dark side to any side of any war. ingrew up on this and credit the Star Wars movies to a part that made me want to be a soldier and to be apart of something greater then myself so to the rogue one story line thank you for showing that average people with great courage can accomplish great things.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

8

Jk9785Feb 23, 2017

In Disney's second cinematic outing in the Star Wars universe, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is an excellent, albeit flawed film. Though the action scenes are edge-of-your-seat fun, the characters aren't really developed enough for the viewerIn Disney's second cinematic outing in the Star Wars universe, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is an excellent, albeit flawed film. Though the action scenes are edge-of-your-seat fun, the characters aren't really developed enough for the viewer to care about them. Ben Mendelsohn as the sinister Director Krennic, along with Felicity Jones as Jyn really steal the show in this film. With this film, Disney has officially gained my trust after the fantastic film that was Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

SiiFeb 26, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Mit Jyn, Krennic und Galen hat man hier 3 perfekte Charaktere geschaffen, die in einem perfekt geschriebenen Drehbuch wunderbar zusammen funktionieren. Felicity Jones lieferte hier als Jyn Erso die beste weibliche Hauptrollen-Performance des Jahres 2016 ab. Die Schwachstelle des Todessterns wird optimal begründet und die Darstellung der Brutalität des Imperiums und der enormen Umstände, die die Rebellen mit ihrem eigenen Blut gelassen haben, um an die Pläne des Todessterns zu kommen, wurden ebenfalls optimal dargestellt. Die Endszene ist einfach episch göttlich und als solche ein absoluter Reminder an den Film. Diese Szene wird man auf ewig im Kopf behalten. Auf das Drehbuch zurückkehrend: Wie man das Ende gestaltet hat rundet den Film perfekt ab und lässt keinen einzigen negativen Raum mehr offen. Das Drehbuch ist einfach perfekt geschrieben. Dazu hat Rogue One im Jahre 2016 das mit Abstand beste Produktionsdesign, da kommt nichts auch nur ansatzweise ran. Insgesamt ist Rogue One ein weiterer perfekter Star Wars Film, der die Magie in dieses Franchise zurückbrachte und der mit Abstand beste Film 2016 war.
*****
10/10… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

9

Mando44646Jan 4, 2017

This movie was much better than Episode 7. No giant idiotic plot choices like Starkiller Base and they didn't forget to do world building either. It greatly enriches Episode 4 and Star Wars in general, though I do wish we had more time withThis movie was much better than Episode 7. No giant idiotic plot choices like Starkiller Base and they didn't forget to do world building either. It greatly enriches Episode 4 and Star Wars in general, though I do wish we had more time with many of the characters.

Best Star Wars movie since Episode 6, in my opinion. I cannot recommend it enough.… Expand