Brokeback Mountain

10

MaryM.Jan 14, 2006

A testament to the human spirit in the great expanse of nature portrayed by genuine, heartfelt performances.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

WarrenCharlesW.Jan 14, 2006

People who call this a"gay cowboy movie" are missing the point and need to rethink their sensibilities, critics who say this are simply charlatons and quite frankly simple. This is a story about love, any love, without borders or labels, and People who call this a"gay cowboy movie" are missing the point and need to rethink their sensibilities, critics who say this are simply charlatons and quite frankly simple. This is a story about love, any love, without borders or labels, and how it can trasform us at our deepest level.Beutiful, simply truthful acting by Gyllenthaal,Ledger,Williams and Hathaway.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DonH.Jan 14, 2006

I am 62yrs. young and I have waited all my life for this very excellent gripping love story between two macho men to be on the big screen. It was long over due.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JamesH.Jan 14, 2006

this is one of the best films i have ever seen. it is breathtaking leaving in shock and pain of the conclusion. everyone in it are amazing with no sub-standard performance and it should get best film at the oscars. it has broken the mold this is one of the best films i have ever seen. it is breathtaking leaving in shock and pain of the conclusion. everyone in it are amazing with no sub-standard performance and it should get best film at the oscars. it has broken the mold with the desperately sad story set with some of the most beautiful landscape in the world. a story about the bleakest and upsetting love that just happens to be two men.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AlexC.Jan 14, 2006

Powerful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PresW.Jan 13, 2006

Have to admit that I always thought the story was unfilmable - sparse words being so vital to it's charm. When I attended an advance screening, I was prepared to be disappointed, partly due to repeated viewings of the trailer that, IHave to admit that I always thought the story was unfilmable - sparse words being so vital to it's charm. When I attended an advance screening, I was prepared to be disappointed, partly due to repeated viewings of the trailer that, I admit, left me in tears. While I did find the pacing of the near silent first scenes awkward on first viewing, made worse by poor sound in the theatre, I was quickly swept into the picture and transported. As the closing credits rolled I felt that I had just witnessed something politically important and cinematically poetic. The stunned silence of my fellow viewers led me to suspect that I might be right. Ang Lee has made a movie that refuses to capitulate to trend in any way. No bombast, no gratuity. McMurtry and Ossana beautifully fleshed out the tale just enough to capture the spirit and soul of these people trapped in a hell worthy of Sartre. Ledger is stunning - made more so by his virtual disposable mainstream performances prior to this - as his every utterance seems an effort to express something while giving away nothing. Gyllenhaal builds upon the stride forward witnessed in "Jarhead" and leaves us curious as to what comes next. Michelle Williams' performance puts her embryonic years at the Creek behind her - finely balancing a role that could have easily become unsympathetic. Hathaway slips beautifully out of her fluffy tiara persona into a crown of thorn - her young Texas spitfire turning brittle from the deprivation of a storybook ending daddy's little girl thought she deserved. I'm surprised to see some online reviewers focusing on this film as one that glorifies lies and adultery and I have to wonder if we saw the same movie. What I saw was a cautionary tale of the pain and chaos created when one is unable or refuses to reconcile with what they face in the mirror - a glorification of nothing. This is not a "gay cowboy" movie nor is it a "gay" anything movie. It's a spiritual movie about everyone's need to find their place in the world. Whether you choose to do it with an evangelical theory of God or with any other equally important reference is part of that journey.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

L.S.Jan 13, 2006

This was one of the best movies I have seen in years. The emotional depth of the script and wonderful acting made seeing this movie more than just an entertaining experience. It trully touched me.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RhiannonA.Jan 13, 2006

This was a lovely movie that was realistic for the time it's set in and quite artfully done. If you're looking for a homosexual pornography, this is not it, and it was all the better for it. Emotional, sometimes humorous, and This was a lovely movie that was realistic for the time it's set in and quite artfully done. If you're looking for a homosexual pornography, this is not it, and it was all the better for it. Emotional, sometimes humorous, and leaving quite an impression, I do suggest this film to anyone who has an attention span longer than a goldfish and doesn't mind a good plot.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

StefanorJan 13, 2006

The most beautiful, melancholy film I've ever seen. Heath and Jake are wonderful. The scene with Ennis and the shirt made me weep.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

JoeWilsonJan 13, 2006

this movie is front for teh homosapiem agenda. that is why my church is boycoting it. the bible says its Adma and Eve not Adam and STEVE. what all you peopl dont undrstand is that teh bibel cannot lie because that is what God said. that isthis movie is front for teh homosapiem agenda. that is why my church is boycoting it. the bible says its Adma and Eve not Adam and STEVE. what all you peopl dont undrstand is that teh bibel cannot lie because that is what God said. that is why the LORD our God in HEavn smoked Sadam & Gommorhea. btw, 4 all you "strait" peopl giving it 10, maybe YOU are the homosapiem.… Expand

0 of 8 users found this helpful

10

TaraK.Jan 13, 2006

Very Profound & the most moving film I have seen in years- A definite American classic. Ledger is truly astounding. Finally a film that equals or even surpasses its written source material. I still can't get this out of my head weeks later...

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RocksJan 13, 2006

I was in suspense the entire movie, wondering what would become of the relationship!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

1

KatieT.Jan 13, 2006

This movie was so unfathomably boring I almost fell asleep. I kept waiting for something to happen, but the plot was very dul. This is supposed to be a love story, but, not only was love never mentioned, there didn't seem to be any real This movie was so unfathomably boring I almost fell asleep. I kept waiting for something to happen, but the plot was very dul. This is supposed to be a love story, but, not only was love never mentioned, there didn't seem to be any real passion between any of the characters. I was terribly dissapointed because the reviews of this movie were so good, and in reality, it is very bad. This movie somehow makes me believe that critics are playing a joke on American society to see how many suckers they can get to sit through this terribly dull film.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

ZiffD.Jan 13, 2006

Exceptional movie. Very nicely paced. I was impressed by the particularly adept acting of Heath Ledger and Michelle Williams. Drama and a bit of humor at times (the harmonica jokes), etc. Tragic. People with souls will like this movie. Exceptional movie. Very nicely paced. I was impressed by the particularly adept acting of Heath Ledger and Michelle Williams. Drama and a bit of humor at times (the harmonica jokes), etc. Tragic. People with souls will like this movie. People with hearts will like this movie. As a straight male and a devout Christian, I can honestly say that my wife and I loved this movie and plan to go with friends to see it again this weekend. I agree with whoever wrote "This movie was beyond brilliant." Love is a force of nature and of God. Those who disparrage any of God's children are in urgent need of His grace and have some soul searching to do themselves to determine why their concerns lie so much outside of themselves. We should all remember that "God looked at everything he had made, and he found it very good."… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

1

KevinB.Jan 13, 2006

Gotta give credit for the actors to pull off the characters, but other than that

0 of 4 users found this helpful

10

KenR.Jan 13, 2006

Excellent film.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

NickBristolJan 13, 2006

i saw this film two days ago and have not been able to concentrate on anything else. i keep telling myself its just a film but it has moved me in a way like no other thing i have ever seen. it is the most beautiful masterpiece i have everi saw this film two days ago and have not been able to concentrate on anything else. i keep telling myself its just a film but it has moved me in a way like no other thing i have ever seen. it is the most beautiful masterpiece i have ever seen and probably will ever see. it broke my heart and i left the cinema wanting a different ending but knowing it would not have been the film it was without the ending it had. everyone should see this and i believe that jake and heath should win awards for these performances… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

NathanD.Jan 12, 2006

This movie had such a profound effect on me, I was myself amazed. After leaving the theater, I could not stop thinking or talking about it. It is, without a doubt, a masterpiece. Never before have I seen true love portrayed so well, and This movie had such a profound effect on me, I was myself amazed. After leaving the theater, I could not stop thinking or talking about it. It is, without a doubt, a masterpiece. Never before have I seen true love portrayed so well, and forbidden love in such a heartbreaking way, whether it was a gay or straight love story. Heath Ledger was simply captivating in this film, finally proving to everyone that doubted his abilities as an actor that they were wrong. Ang Lee has never been better, at times surpassing even his best work from Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Not a single note was missed with this film, and it is, simply put, the best film of 2005 and one of the best films in recent years.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AndrewG.Jan 12, 2006

A testament to persue your passion (or become a shell?). This could have been a melodrama, but rolled out as a serene meditation of longing and loss with a live nerve threaded through.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

1

BobL.Jan 12, 2006

Politically correct and absurd. Hollywood's version of reality.

0 of 2 users found this helpful

10

csJan 12, 2006

Beautiful. Sad. Real. I sobbed leaving the cinema. I can't stop thinking about it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

timb.Jan 11, 2006

This movie is a masterpiece i have not seen a movie made this well in a looong time. The actors were supurb and should be awarded for their performances. i don't think that Ang lee could have picked better actors to pull of this amazing This movie is a masterpiece i have not seen a movie made this well in a looong time. The actors were supurb and should be awarded for their performances. i don't think that Ang lee could have picked better actors to pull of this amazing story. Thank you Ang Lee for taking this project and making it a wonderful piece of film history. you must see this movie you will be touched by the love of these characters gay or straight.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

KaylaA.Jan 11, 2006

I did not like the movie one bit!!! It really disgust me!!

0 of 2 users found this helpful

10

EthanP.Jan 11, 2006

The most profound movie I've ever seen. I felt like I was watching the debut of Romeo and Juliet--and not because of superficial similarities. It haunts people because it's archetypical and so very, very truthful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

emilywJan 11, 2006

If Ben is so against homosexuals, then why did he go and see this movie? Personally, I don't think that he really did see it, and is just a far-right bigot posting a negative review of this film because he can't accept someone If Ben is so against homosexuals, then why did he go and see this movie? Personally, I don't think that he really did see it, and is just a far-right bigot posting a negative review of this film because he can't accept someone wanting to have a different lifestyle than his. Anyone with a slightly open mind, and good taste in movies (and that's actually seen the movie) can attest to the fact that Brokeback Mountain is one of the most powerful movies of the year. Ben, just stick to reading your bible in Idaho or wherever the hell you are from; the rest of us will continue to enjoy brilliant and insightful filmmaking.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KeithJan 11, 2006

One of the most moving films I've seen in years. A fine example of what wonderful writing can produce. The more I thought about the film, days after, weeks after seeing it, the more I loved it. The two lead characters haunted me, One of the most moving films I've seen in years. A fine example of what wonderful writing can produce. The more I thought about the film, days after, weeks after seeing it, the more I loved it. The two lead characters haunted me, particularly Ennis, who broke my heart. Ultimately, the story works almost more as his tragedy, what is wrought when a life is lived beneath the weight of self-loathing and denial. I'd be interested to know if the few people so strident in their criticism actually saw the film. While they cast the movie as some agenda piece of far left Hollywood, they make their own agendas all too apparent. It is important to remember that this film took 7 years to get made. Studios and directors didn't want to touch it because of its subject matter, despite the script having the reputation as the best unmade movie floating around. Why must every movie or work of art having to do with gay characters automatically be labled as having an agenda? Why can't it just be what it is - a work of art? Judge it on those mertis, not on outside forces that have nothing to do with the film. The reason this film works as well as it does is because its only agenda and allegience is to these two characters. And these two men come so painfully alive, that their tragedy sears the heart and mind. In the end, for me, it is a classic love story, maybe the best modern love story to be made in some time, because it utilizes all the hallmarks of tragic love with wonderful restraint and sincerity.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

KirkJan 11, 2006

I think that this movie is incredible. I agree that Heath Ledger did an amazing job in his role but I really believe that Jake Gyllenhaal deserves some major kudos for his superb performance as well. There is a lot of meaning and symbolism I think that this movie is incredible. I agree that Heath Ledger did an amazing job in his role but I really believe that Jake Gyllenhaal deserves some major kudos for his superb performance as well. There is a lot of meaning and symbolism that you don't catch the first time through. I recommend that everyone sees the film a second time. You will be amazed at how much you missed the first time you watched it.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

shannont.Jan 10, 2006

This movie was amazing. I loved the story line and I hope that other people can be open-minded enough to give it a chance.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

EnnisD.Jan 10, 2006

If you want to see an elegantly developing movie filmed in devastatingly beautiful locations with a strong plot and gut-wrenching, authentic performances, go see Brokeback Mountain.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JennMMJan 10, 2006

Undeniably genuine in it's presentation. Ledger and Gyllenhaal give painfully affecting performances that are still haunting me.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GrahamM.Jan 10, 2006

Such a brilliant, beautiful film. This is a film about 2 lovers that are forced to deny their passion and be whom others want them to be.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JakeL.Jan 10, 2006

Amazing film.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KeithGJan 9, 2006

This movie was brilliant based not on it's story line but on the acting of Heath Ledger. I think the content will be in debate within the Marlboro sector, rednecks, rough necks, and anyone who has judgement against homosexuality. This This movie was brilliant based not on it's story line but on the acting of Heath Ledger. I think the content will be in debate within the Marlboro sector, rednecks, rough necks, and anyone who has judgement against homosexuality. This movie caught me by surprise because I felt the same as Heath's wife when she witnessed him and Jack engaging in more than just a handshake and hug when meeting each other, I too felt like seeing two manly men kissing quite foreign and odd. It was like imprinting a child's first view at something for the first time, you look with amazement and no judgement, simply something brand new, almost like seeing a martian. I can't remember what the scenery of the movie depicted because the character reference by Heath made you dumb found.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

BenJan 9, 2006

Honestly, just for any of you that read these reviews and think " Wow, all the reviews are really good, this movie must be great!" The only reason they are all great is because most of the posts are put up by people that support Honestly, just for any of you that read these reviews and think " Wow, all the reviews are really good, this movie must be great!" The only reason they are all great is because most of the posts are put up by people that support homosexuality or are themselves. I think most americans have spoken with saying that this movie wasn't worth giving even 20 million dollars to in almost a month. I mean syriana ( spelling?) did better than that in opening weekend than this movie did in a whole month. And that movie wasn't really that big at all. I just saw the critics awards and of course there going to give this movie the best picture. They are a small group of people that only are pushing their horribley mislead ideas of whats right and truly good. They carry the views of a very small percentage of americans, and it shows that most americans don't buy into the garbage hollywood sells. The movie was horrible.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

thomf.Jan 9, 2006

The young actors were astonishingly real in their portrayal of a Real Life situation that is seldom heard or talked about. A real true love story, only difference is two men!! Jake should be nominated for an oscar also because these The young actors were astonishingly real in their portrayal of a Real Life situation that is seldom heard or talked about. A real true love story, only difference is two men!! Jake should be nominated for an oscar also because these characters would not work without his convincing performance. Much love to the screenwriters who had the insight to add to the shortstory and Mr. Ang for the creative guidence. Awesome movie!! Will hit you harder hours after viewing. (Love is a force of nature)… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

matta.Jan 9, 2006

Very impressive. Lee's being a little too deliberate with some scenes, and it does go about 15 minutes too long, but there are small gripes about an otherwise excellent movie. Gyllenhall and WIlliams (I still really can't take Very impressive. Lee's being a little too deliberate with some scenes, and it does go about 15 minutes too long, but there are small gripes about an otherwise excellent movie. Gyllenhall and WIlliams (I still really can't take Hathaway all that seriously so it's a good thing that her role was small) but it's Ledger's performance that is the stuff of Hollywood legend. The only other person this year that comes even remotely close is Philip Seymour Hoffman, but Ledger exclipses even him and turns in one of the most honest, powerful performances I've ever seen. Definitely worth seeing if you know anything about great movies.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

MarkB.Jan 9, 2006

In addition to its many, many genuine excellences, Ang Lee's so-called "gay cowboy" movie is also notable for providing me with the most simultaneously entertaining and disturbing time I've had watching a movie preview trailer In addition to its many, many genuine excellences, Ang Lee's so-called "gay cowboy" movie is also notable for providing me with the most simultaneously entertaining and disturbing time I've had watching a movie preview trailer since junior high school. The preview came on just before Syriana (a movie which, blaming as it does all the world's evils on American oil cartels, you'd hardly label as one especially attractive to a "red-state" audience) and when it became apparent that Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger) and Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal) were going to share more than a can of beans, about twenty-five people in the audience, almost as one, simultaneously responded with a loud, high-pitched cry of "Eeeee-YEW!!!" Imagine that: a movie NOT dealing with horror or torture whose trailer reduces a group of seemingly intelligent, well-mannered adults to a bunch of 7-year-old girls reacting to a waterbug skittering across the basement floor at their Brownie meeting! Despite this and the recent news of a Utah multiplex suddenly yanking it despite the fact that it was making money there as everywhere (one word to their management staff: IDIOTS!) this film, despite its instant status as a Jay Leno punchline, is affecting and moving people all over the country who are willing to give it a chance, and it's doing so for several very simple, basic reasons: it's a beautifully written and directed, spectacularly shot, superbly acted piece of great storytelling that stays with you no matter what your political, religious or sexual persuasion. (Even conservative critic Michael Medved praised it, although part of this may stem from his awareness that his attempts to sabotage Million Dollar Baby last year by revealing its secrets in print and on TV might just have "tipped it" enough to win it several Oscars last year, and he's not making THAT mistake again.) Quentin Tarantino said at Cannes that he liked Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11 not because he agreed with its stance but because he found it supremely entertaining, and regardless of your views on homosexuality, Brokeback Mountain works as a classic, old fashioned star-crossed and circumstance-separated lovers' "weeper" in the tradition of Back Street, Waterloo Bridge and many other movies familiar to your grandparents and those who like to tape Turner Classic Movies at 3 in the morning. (A more recent film parallel? Well, perhaps 2004's The Notebook...up to a point.) Writers Annie Proulx, Diana Ossana and Larry McMurtry (whose Lonesome Dove is undoubtedly much loved by some of the very same people who want nothing to do with his latest effort) may have specific viewpoints, but they're not doctrinaire: I think it's extremely possible for Brokeback Mountain to speak as strongly to conservative Christians as it does to gay activists. Keep in mind that the tragedy of Ennis's and Jack's long-running, clandestine affair extends to their wives and loved ones, and that nobody in the movie is patronized or caricatured. (Jack's wife, played by Anne Hathaway as a different kind of "princess" than she did in a pair of Disney movies, comes closest, but this is negated in a poignant, self-aware monologue near the end; Michelle Williams and Linda Cardellini as women in Ennis's life are simply heartbreaking.) It can also be argued that ranch boss Joe Aguirre (Randy Quaid), who hired Ennis and Jack to protect grazing sheep from wolf attacks, fires them not only because of their affair, but because they weren't doing their job--and that if the two cowboys had actually followed their hearts once down from Brokeback, Ennis's terrific, immensely sympathetic daughter (Kate Mara) would never have existed. Brokeback Mountain works superbly not only as an offbeat love story but as a powerful meditation of how entire lives are permanently altered by one impulsive action. Robert Frost's famous poem "The Road Not Taken" comes to mind not just in light of what would've happened if Jack and Ennis had become full-time lovers, but alternately (and in light of the turns everybody's lives end up taking) what the results would've been if the two guys hadn't reacted to boredom, loneliness, horniness and That Indescribable Something Else...and each of them had stayed on his side of the tent.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

JamesC.Jan 9, 2006

Gets right to the heart of the matter...love in a world not possible to express based on era, environment, circumstances - especially when love & respect with your children at stake.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RannD.Jan 9, 2006

Great movie and acting!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KeithB.Jan 9, 2006

I think that I may need to watch this movie once more. I think that a lot of viewers are unaware of the paradigms established by small, isolated towns in the Western United States, so I think on some levels the film was trying to dissiminate I think that I may need to watch this movie once more. I think that a lot of viewers are unaware of the paradigms established by small, isolated towns in the Western United States, so I think on some levels the film was trying to dissiminate that. Regardless, I thought the movie as a whole was poignant and touching; I expected the love sequences to be more romantic and sensual, but I thought that the delicacy portrayed by the characters was appropriate. I think the thing that really stuck with me for the movie was the dynamic development of Ennis from a taciturn individual to one who learns how to emote. It's a sad story and I left the theatre with a sense of resentment and heartbreak. The movie ended with Ennis looking at the postcard and Jack's clothes---I believe that the transformation of Ennis's love into something which made him human was endearing. I don't know whether this serves as a warning to people who live risqué and latent lives or more of an exposé about homosexuality in small town America, but it's certainly worth a watch.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JeffL.Jan 8, 2006

For months I've been listening to everybody from comedians to coworkers smirking about the "gay cowboy movie." I guess that's not an entirely incorrect description of Brokeback Mountain, but it's also insultingly reductive and For months I've been listening to everybody from comedians to coworkers smirking about the "gay cowboy movie." I guess that's not an entirely incorrect description of Brokeback Mountain, but it's also insultingly reductive and simpleminded; nobody's referring to Munich as "the dead athlete movie" or The Passion of the Christ as "the crucified Jew movie." Other ways to more accurately describe Ang Lee's extraordinary new movie: haunting, sad, profound, compassionate, artful, and entertaining. For about five years now, Heath Ledger has seemingly been perched to become The Next Big Thing, but nothing he has done to date - mostly small roles in good movies and big roles in bad ones - remotely prepares you for his astonishing work here as the stoic, inarticulate Wyoming ranch hand circa 1963 who shares a night of passion with a kindred soul (Jake Gyllenhaal) that turns into a deeper love that manages to survive marriages (Michelle Williams and Anne Hathaway are terrific as the wives), societal pressures that barely allow them to admit to themselves who they really are, and the long months and years they sometimes have to wait to see each other. The screenplay by Diana Ossana and the great Larry McMurtry (The Last Picture Show, Lonesome Dove), based on a short story by E. Annie Proulx, is purposefully spare and understated, while the stunning outdoor cinematography of Rodrigo Prieto is of distinctly Oscar caliber. Forget the controversy, forget the jokes, forget whatever reservations or prejudices you may have: this is a great piece of filmmaking, and a story I suspect will stick with you long after leaving the theatre.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichaelK.Jan 8, 2006

Amazing! Absolutely spectacular! A must-see for everyone!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JGJan 8, 2006

Hit me deep in my soul. Very powerful and hard hitting.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PedroB.Jan 8, 2006

I'm still too emotional to describe anything. Just saw it. It's raw, and difficult. I grew up in Wyoming, so I know what repression is about.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BrendaM.Jan 8, 2006

One of the best movies released to the theatre in a long, long time. Shows exactly how difficult it is to carry on a loving relationship when obstacles are in the way.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

gracen.Jan 8, 2006

Such a brilliant rare movie. jake gyllenhaal was amazing!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

5

DianeB.Jan 8, 2006

I haven't read Proulx's short story but I think I am a minority voice on the movie. I found Brokeback Mountain trite and frustrating, often boring, using more gay stereotypes than I like to see: punitive fathers, wives who suffer I haven't read Proulx's short story but I think I am a minority voice on the movie. I found Brokeback Mountain trite and frustrating, often boring, using more gay stereotypes than I like to see: punitive fathers, wives who suffer in silence (until they blow), alcoholism, self-hatred and denial, violent death by homophobes (I know, I know, stereotypes are often rooted in reality!) and many cinematic stereotypes as well - long shots of snow-capped mountains, full moons, empty decaying towns blowing in the wind, etc. I was never quite convinced by the "love" between these two - (sexual attraction, yes, but I couldn't figure out what else) or the motivation for Jack and Ennis enduring 20 mostly miserable years during a period of great national change. On some levels I found this an anti-gay movie (emphasis on depression, punishment and deprivation) rather than a sensitive portrayal of a loving, though doomed, relationship. I did like the scenes of the sheep being moved.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

CliffO.Jan 8, 2006

This is the best portrayal ever of life in small western towns. Undoubtedly the gay relationship between the two cowboys is much more common than country people like to admit. This movie will be enoyed by all people, gay or straight, who This is the best portrayal ever of life in small western towns. Undoubtedly the gay relationship between the two cowboys is much more common than country people like to admit. This movie will be enoyed by all people, gay or straight, who have still have a heart and can feel for the sadness and frustration felt by these guys. Also: great settings: the natural beauty of western mountains and rivers.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AlanA.Jan 8, 2006

An amazing film. This one is worthy of Oscars on all fronts: actors, cinematography, director, screenwriting, music, and more. And way overdue. The far right is just gonna have to get used to it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BrianneJan 8, 2006

Fantastic-- strong, meaningful and so real. Perfect movie.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

3

C.ChaversJan 7, 2006

This film is a huge disappointment from many levels. the most noticeable part of the film is it's drawn out length. this film could have been done in 15 minutes instead of 2 hours and 30 minutes. the themes are so overdone in gayThis film is a huge disappointment from many levels. the most noticeable part of the film is it's drawn out length. this film could have been done in 15 minutes instead of 2 hours and 30 minutes. the themes are so overdone in gay literature and film and this not only gives straight people an inadequate perception of gay people but it also works to give gay people a distorted and dismal perspective of themselves. for example, why are all gay relationships tragic and end in death??? why is this theme so repeated and overdone. all gay relationships do not end this way but sure, in the literature and this film totally colors within these lines. this film if anything gives the message to not be gay or you will be murdered or end up in a dead end relationship that can't work. (thx matthew shephard rip off storyline) . there is nothing inspirational or motivating about this film. as a gay man this film leaves me with a huge feeling of disgust at the overused and offensive stereotypes (while the limp wrist lisping type is totally avoided, you still have closeted tragic love and a relationship based on carnal proximity and no spiritual or real communication oriented committments) this is a horrible film overall. 3 points just because it's gay themed and "hollywood" everything else that basically matters in this film is absent and it's found lacking.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

StephenDJan 7, 2006

Being a straight male, I can say this is one of the most beautiful, heart-wrenching movies I have ever seen in my life. It was also just as beautiful to see a huge mix of young and old, men and women and the movie theater.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BruceJan 7, 2006

Best film of 2005. Hands down. This movie needed to be made.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AndrewF.Jan 7, 2006

the few criticisms of this film seem to be falling into two categories: opposed to the content (or just suspicious of the "gay agenda") or somehow opposed to the formal and aesthetic aspects. the former objection is obviously mostly bigotry the few criticisms of this film seem to be falling into two categories: opposed to the content (or just suspicious of the "gay agenda") or somehow opposed to the formal and aesthetic aspects. the former objection is obviously mostly bigotry or unfounded suspicion -- how or why would chinese director ang lee be a puppet of gay activism? no, he made this movie how he wanted to make it- not as a "big message" film. he is not a leftist or gay activist. the latter objection also makes little sense: either you're too callous and jaded to let the romance and tension have an effect, or you're expecting some kind of over-the-top romantic melodrama. i think the repressive austerity and meticulous cinematography matched the conent: these cowboys are very repressed and stoic. The film's relative dryness does not make it inert or lifeless but all the more subtly depressing and impactful. amazing performances, great film.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

4

SuzanneSJan 7, 2006

Guess I missed the "part" about love....between any of the characters. Although the scenery was beautiful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

EricHJan 7, 2006

Hauntingly nuanced performances, faithful adaptation of an achy story.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AndrewR.Jan 7, 2006

Some (though not all) of the criticism I have read of this film serve as a startling reminder that ignorance, prejudice and hatred are still out there (which, in a way, only further justifies the point of this film). In 2006 there are still Some (though not all) of the criticism I have read of this film serve as a startling reminder that ignorance, prejudice and hatred are still out there (which, in a way, only further justifies the point of this film). In 2006 there are still people who would exclaim, "This movie is sick! Why do most movies in this day and age have to be about homosexuality? Is nothing sacred anymore? What's next lesbian nuns?" Or, "Sick and twisted. If you are a heterosexual male, save your money for anything else." Only the inherent cliches and ignorance inherent in those opinions ensures they are not to be taken too seriously. It's sad. But it does something else: it reminds me that, whilst we may rightly proclaim the universality of this story and how accessible it is to everyone, it IS still an important film for gay people at this time in history. I found Brokeback Mountain to be a starkly frightening film in it's intelligence about the dangerous contexts (always implicit, nothing more is needed) in which such love would have existed. It leaves the viewer with so much to think about. all in the details and inferences, which will make it worth seeing again. In it's profound belief in the universality and power of love, though, it is also uplifting and extraordinary. I don't think the film is about something to applaud so much as it is about something worth believing in and worth fighting for.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

BradJ.Jan 7, 2006

Fantastic movie, not at all preachy though it has a point. The story could easily be compared to "Romeo and Juliet", and Ang Lee proves that dispite the Hulk he is an excellent director. I went to watch the movie simply to thumb my nose at Fantastic movie, not at all preachy though it has a point. The story could easily be compared to "Romeo and Juliet", and Ang Lee proves that dispite the Hulk he is an excellent director. I went to watch the movie simply to thumb my nose at the bigots who opposed it because of the homosexuality, and it surprised me by being one of the best movies I've seen in a long time. Like Napolian Dynomite it relies on no special effects and is shot in a stark, almost documentary style that will only work if the story is worthwhile. The story is worthwhile.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

BillyS.Jan 6, 2006

It would be impossible to go see this movie without knowing it is the "Gay Cowboy" movie, all the pre-release media blitz has made that obviously clear to everyone on the planet and beyond, that's o.k., it's good for business. The It would be impossible to go see this movie without knowing it is the "Gay Cowboy" movie, all the pre-release media blitz has made that obviously clear to everyone on the planet and beyond, that's o.k., it's good for business. The genius of this film, however, is that after 15 minutes it becomes a plain & simple love story about wanting and longing between two people who can't be together for their own reasons, be it denial or fear or even shame. Everything about this film is extraordinary! Rodrigo Prieto's camera work is epic, the simple guitar score is haunting and the acting, oh my the acting. Michelle Williams gives the same small, understated performance that won an Oscar for Beatrice Straight in Network, Jake Gyllenhaal, on the heels of Jarhead and Proof, shows enough talent here to make him not only an a-list actor but an Oscar nominee as well. But the true find of Brokeback Mountain is none other than teen heartthrob Heath Ledger, who gives a performance so achingly beautiful I really think he will give Philip Seymour Hoffman a run for this years Best Actor Oscar! He emerges from this film the way Johnny Depp did in Ed Wood. Its simply a miraculous piece of work. The only reason I did not give this film a 10 is the last 15 minutes of the film. When Jack gets the postcard returned to him, it might as well have been stamped "Wrap It Up" Other than that, it's as near a masterpiece as it can be and, to me, seems unbeatable for the Best Picture and Best Director Oscar come March. Bravo, Mr. Lee!!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KimJ.Jan 6, 2006

I grew up on the High Plains during 1950s and 1960s. This film captures that period of time and the dread and fear of being exposed as gay or lesbian. My heart breaks watching the anguish or lives never allowed to come to fullness.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

LynnJan 6, 2006

Very sad but very good.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JoeU.Jan 6, 2006

Great story, intelligent script, perfect directing, awesome visuals, and memorable acting. In short, it has everything; what filmmaking ought to always be.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

WillJan 6, 2006

I'm a city boy, through and through. But in so many ways 'Brokeback Mountain' is my story too. We all can feel the inchoate longing that Ennis and Jack experience because their love can't be acknowledged within a society I'm a city boy, through and through. But in so many ways 'Brokeback Mountain' is my story too. We all can feel the inchoate longing that Ennis and Jack experience because their love can't be acknowledged within a society bent on thwarting it, through early lessons of hatred, misguided marriage expectations and, if need be, murder. The film is remarkably faithful to Annie Proulx's spare and touching story, with appropriately sensitive added exposition of the effects on Jack and Ennis's wives and families. It was as exhilarating and heartwrenching the second time I saw it as it was on the first, but on the second visit I was much more able to notice the depth of nuance in all its aspects -- writing, performance, direction, editing. I find that I'm still moved almost to tears that such a truthful story has been so well told. I doubt that my second viewing will be my last; I hope that even hardened hearts might be able to understand if not identify, and perhaps soften a bit.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

NancyZ.Jan 6, 2006

This movie was beyond brilliant. I could care less that it was about two guys (even though it really wasnt, it was about LOVE people) the whole point is that it was MOVING. compelling. absolutely heartbreakingly beautiful. Yah- it's two This movie was beyond brilliant. I could care less that it was about two guys (even though it really wasnt, it was about LOVE people) the whole point is that it was MOVING. compelling. absolutely heartbreakingly beautiful. Yah- it's two men- big whoop. But I also was compelled to review b.c 1, hey. women liked it too whatever ass it was that said it's only gay men that liked the movie. 2, Trish H. you are a .... and a wholesomely ignorant one at that. there were indeed many cowboys that were gay. just like there are, however rare, MALE hairdressers that are straight. get over your stereotypes, your ridiculous so called "moral" fiber (which by the by- morality is simply the attitude one adopts to the people they personally dislike. as you have obviously demonstrated) and your utter inability to get your head out of your ass.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

6

ChrisP.Jan 6, 2006

A forbiden love story that was extremely well acted. The wyoming mountain scenes were as stunning and desolate as they are in person. The problem I had was this movie lacked the hook or climactic ending to this sad love affair. Sorry to all A forbiden love story that was extremely well acted. The wyoming mountain scenes were as stunning and desolate as they are in person. The problem I had was this movie lacked the hook or climactic ending to this sad love affair. Sorry to all those who are in love with this movie because its different or was hyped harder and longer than any other film this year, but BrokeBack...its a yawner.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

MikeG.Jan 6, 2006

Very good, but I have to agree with the "overrated" crowd - if this was a movie about a man and a woman, it wouldn't be getting this kind of buzz. Still, for a story of starcrossed lovers, it's a very strong story. As much as the Very good, but I have to agree with the "overrated" crowd - if this was a movie about a man and a woman, it wouldn't be getting this kind of buzz. Still, for a story of starcrossed lovers, it's a very strong story. As much as the performances are being lauded, it's the writing that makes the performances strong, and Ang Lee's tremendous direction that prevents this movie from getting bogged down or too slow. Definitely enjoyable and worth the money. Just not the best film of 2005, let alone of the last five or ten years.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MeganH.Jan 6, 2006

I LOVED this movie. I thought it showed the lifestyles of some men because of the world today. Hopefully it will open people's minds.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JosephN.Jan 6, 2006

all of america should see this movie. and all the troops in iraq, too. it's about hatred as well as love and it's a very important film. well done ang lee.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

9

JacquelineJan 6, 2006

This movie was intense and very emotional. For those who label it as 'the gay cowboy movie' they should really rexamine themselves. This movie tells the story of love and can be compared to anyone, and any relationship. I loved This movie was intense and very emotional. For those who label it as 'the gay cowboy movie' they should really rexamine themselves. This movie tells the story of love and can be compared to anyone, and any relationship. I loved this movie. The only reason I give it a 9 and not a tell is because it was a tad long and I'm not a fan for long movies. The acting was wonderful, as was the directing and every aspect of the story.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

2

ShgreK.Jan 6, 2006

Another attempt by the 'liberal intelectuals' and 'I- am-proud-to-be-morally-neutral' film-makers to impose upon society in a cunning and subtle way the concept of gay 'love' as perfectly normal.

0 of 3 users found this helpful

10

ThomasC.Jan 6, 2006

One of the best movies I have ever seen. What is not said or off the screen is as powerful as what is said or on the screen.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

PhyllisH.Jan 6, 2006

Acting superb, storyline disappointing. Cinematography was amazing.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

C.houserJan 5, 2006

Great and beautiful. Wonderful cinematic scenes. A long time coming, wish there would be more films of equal quality to this one. Not cheesy or cliche. Go see it yourself!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

CregT.Jan 5, 2006

Substitute a female for one of the male leads and taglines containing the words: 'predictable,' 'trite,' 'sentimental,' and 'saccharine' would be the order of the day, but no because this film Substitute a female for one of the male leads and taglines containing the words: 'predictable,' 'trite,' 'sentimental,' and 'saccharine' would be the order of the day, but no because this film supposedly challenges social mores and love against the odds (or whatever) it's suddenly a 'masterpiece.' Is there nothing that will end Hollywood's love affair with these grinding behemoths released at the end of each year as a means to garner awards from judges who are blindsided by anything that seems even remotely 'epic,' 'arthouse,' or 'daring,' and to redeem actors at the 12th hour after they have trudged through a year of less-than-spectacular roles as jive-speaking knights from the middle ages and crossdressing undercover cops? I find nothing heroic or ennobling about these characters. It's not just because the central relationship itself immediately alienates anyone whose buttons aren't pressed by watching two rustic types fondle each other in the prairie, but because their lack of control over their carnal whims and consequent adultery (compounded by cooly calculated deception) makes them morally repugnant. It's not hard to divine the propagandistic intent behind this preduction - after all, it's not the first time for Lee - but I really do think that adapting a pamphlet on 'Homosexaulity and Tolerance' would have made for a more engaging film; it certainly wouldn't have been any more disposable.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

9

PeteT.Jan 5, 2006

I plan to see this movie again. Just because I loved the story and may have missed something (the sound went out at my theater). I really did like the movie. I read the reviews of the others and to those whe rated it 2 and below-you didnt I plan to see this movie again. Just because I loved the story and may have missed something (the sound went out at my theater). I really did like the movie. I read the reviews of the others and to those whe rated it 2 and below-you didnt see the movie!. How can you rate something that you haven't seen? The story is as old as time itself-society as a whole preventing a couple from expressing themselves without fear.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

7

SubanD.Jan 5, 2006

This is not a bad movie. It is, however, a very over-rated film. It is praised for its subject matter not its quality. The film is restrained to the point where it's difficult to connect with the characters. I saw it two times to make This is not a bad movie. It is, however, a very over-rated film. It is praised for its subject matter not its quality. The film is restrained to the point where it's difficult to connect with the characters. I saw it two times to make sure I felt the same way about the film. I was left emotionally empty both times...trust me, I love films so its not me! The film is simply not moving enough even though the performance, visuals, etc were wonderful.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

HopeU.Jan 5, 2006

This is a must see movie! I'd recommend it to anyone except homophobics. They would get too caught up in the gay aspect and totally lose out on the real meaning in the message. It's a darn shame too because those are the folks who This is a must see movie! I'd recommend it to anyone except homophobics. They would get too caught up in the gay aspect and totally lose out on the real meaning in the message. It's a darn shame too because those are the folks who need the message the most. I was very moved by the message and it has made me re-think about certain issues. This movie was so well done that at the end you go, oh and they were gay too. That's how it should be. Not a gay issue, a message of love and bonding that stems from love. Wow, wish I think of something deep to say. Anyway, this is the movie that I will be buying when it comes out on DVD!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

MikeJ.Jan 5, 2006

Really a great movie..maybe slow at times for guys, straight or gay who like action vs love stories. But really pretty moving stuff. I can understand if someone doesnt like it and gives it a 5 or 6 or whatever.. but really anyone who gives Really a great movie..maybe slow at times for guys, straight or gay who like action vs love stories. But really pretty moving stuff. I can understand if someone doesnt like it and gives it a 5 or 6 or whatever.. but really anyone who gives it a 0 just has an issue with a gay theme and no matter what the movie would give it a 0. Its like me going to see a chick flick with my wife.. I didnt like the movie because it wasnt my style.. but I wouldnt give it a 0...the folks who give out zeros.. and if you read their posts just have other issues... Go see it it...… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ThomasE.Jan 5, 2006

Virtually a perfect movie.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

AnthJan 5, 2006

Anyone who would give this movie a zero (Trish H.) because of its homosexual content missed the entire part about LOVE. You would do well to take some of your "moral fiber" and try to be a little more regular.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

KatrielJan 4, 2006

I loved this movie. It was so close to the story, and kept the audience very involved.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

Renee'D.Jan 4, 2006

This movie brought out so much emotion in me, the clearest of emotion being the longing for something as beautiful as they had. The undeniable passion for someone and knowing they feel the same about you. Priceless!!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

stephenc.Jan 4, 2006

Wonderful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

saddyboyJan 4, 2006

A modern classic.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

DaveJan 4, 2006

There was not a sound in the theater during the entire movie which is a sign people were moved by the performance.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

JackJan 4, 2006

Isn't it interesting that most of the 10's came from men. This movie has been overly hyped and crammed down our throats from day one. It isn't a shock that Hollywood critics liked it. The majority of them are gay. This Isn't it interesting that most of the 10's came from men. This movie has been overly hyped and crammed down our throats from day one. It isn't a shock that Hollywood critics liked it. The majority of them are gay. This isn't about a love story. This is about pushing homosexuality one more step closer to acceptance. If it was a man and a women it would not have recieved these marks. What is the next movie going to be - boy meets dog?… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful

10

DAveJan 3, 2006

Being a gay man myself - after 14 years of marriage and raising two children - I am pleased that a movie, like Brokeback Mountain, has brilliantly captured the pain and conflict many gay men go though in their lives - finding someone they Being a gay man myself - after 14 years of marriage and raising two children - I am pleased that a movie, like Brokeback Mountain, has brilliantly captured the pain and conflict many gay men go though in their lives - finding someone they can truely love. The sadness, conflict, and pain the actors in the movie portrayed was so very real to me, it left me wanting a sequel to the story; perhaps Ennis finding someone he can finally settle down with, without all the stigmas and repercussions that comes with being gay, and living in Wyoming.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

trishJan 3, 2006

I cannot believe such a tender story about love and loss can be described by someone as "sick". This is a materpiece that will for sure stand the test of time. From the direction to the performance and the script, not one false note. I I cannot believe such a tender story about love and loss can be described by someone as "sick". This is a materpiece that will for sure stand the test of time. From the direction to the performance and the script, not one false note. I suggest Trish H. do some reading and researching before posting such offensive and medieval crap.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

5

FrankTJan 3, 2006

Professionally executed in every way, but antiseptic. i'm amazed that people actually respond to this film. i was not engaged. couldn't buy into the romance. didn't feel the chemistry. didn't feel the love. neither did Professionally executed in every way, but antiseptic. i'm amazed that people actually respond to this film. i was not engaged. couldn't buy into the romance. didn't feel the chemistry. didn't feel the love. neither did any of the 4 people i've spoken to who also felt disappointed and cold. wildly overrated.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

3

jonnoJan 3, 2006

Yawn! Why is being gay still such a big deal? Who cares? and why does anyone who disagrees with the content of this movie or questions the endless obession with gay themes in hollywood and TV get labelled as homophobic? Boring movie anyway Yawn! Why is being gay still such a big deal? Who cares? and why does anyone who disagrees with the content of this movie or questions the endless obession with gay themes in hollywood and TV get labelled as homophobic? Boring movie anyway but is the usual sentimental crap that gets oscars. Desite that solid acting from the two leads.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

8

DaveS.Jan 3, 2006

Nice movie, but nothing too ground breaking. Glad to see there are only a handful of homophobic posts.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BridgetJan 3, 2006

What a fabulous film! It was like a great book or a painting-it affected me long after leaving the theatre. I downloaded a copy of the original short story by Annie Proulx (from her website) -the movie is very true to her original tale. What a fabulous film! It was like a great book or a painting-it affected me long after leaving the theatre. I downloaded a copy of the original short story by Annie Proulx (from her website) -the movie is very true to her original tale. Oscars to all for a great moviegoing experience!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

CeckoS.Jan 3, 2006

I love this movie .... artistic .... can effect your feeling .. but I dont like the love scene too much can't see it .... But all the whole thing is Great I'm loving it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PhilG.Jan 3, 2006

This movie is a full-bodied love story of two people. It shows how both of them have been torn from each other due to society's pull, and every moment is captured in the eyes of the two men. It shows how much pain each of them go This movie is a full-bodied love story of two people. It shows how both of them have been torn from each other due to society's pull, and every moment is captured in the eyes of the two men. It shows how much pain each of them go through with each passing year and the undeniable fire betwixt, keeping them together. This movie is a far cry from pornography and a rich jubilation of a love story; it is definitely worth seeing multiple times.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

6

S.GoldJan 2, 2006

Not bad, but faulted, very hollywood. They're clearly giving themselves a pat on the back I can see why someone would love the film, but I don't get it. Great performance by Heath Ledger though and beautifully filmed landscape.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KenR.Jan 2, 2006

Excellent film.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

TrishH.Jan 2, 2006

This movie is sick! Why do most movies in this day and age have to be about homosexuality? Is nothing sacred anymore? What's next lesbian nuns? Real Cowboy's are what made this country what it is today. This movie destroys the This movie is sick! Why do most movies in this day and age have to be about homosexuality? Is nothing sacred anymore? What's next lesbian nuns? Real Cowboy's are what made this country what it is today. This movie destroys the moral fiber that a real Cowboy believes in.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful

10

GeorgeJan 2, 2006

EXCELLENT...a simple, yet very moving love story. Not to be missed. It will open the door ro mony regarding their thoughts of same-sex love.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DavidC.Jan 2, 2006

Wonderful movie !

0 of 0 users found this helpful

6

JamesR.Jan 2, 2006

Beautiful cinematography, and the relationship is heartfelt, but the movie just drags too much to be great. Who knew that being gay in Wyoming meant spending 80% of your time staring wordlessly at the landscape?

0 of 0 users found this helpful

Brokeback Mountain

User Reviews