Brokeback Mountain

10

AlinaLMar 11, 2006

I think that it was a beautiful movie.Incredibly well written although its not everyone's cup of tea. i -loved it anyhow.its a movie about the message of love ,no matter who it is between and is a mirror of the society of that existed inI think that it was a beautiful movie.Incredibly well written although its not everyone's cup of tea. i -loved it anyhow.its a movie about the message of love ,no matter who it is between and is a mirror of the society of that existed in the 60's as opposed to how free it is now. deals with an extremely important issue. A must-see!!!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

OdinMar 11, 2006

Loved it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

2

JonD.Mar 9, 2006

This is one of those Love or HATE movies... its a love story, not a bad plot because its almost the same story as all love stories except one thing. It was about gay men in the west. Also too long and too boring for people that like to go to This is one of those Love or HATE movies... its a love story, not a bad plot because its almost the same story as all love stories except one thing. It was about gay men in the west. Also too long and too boring for people that like to go to the movies to be entertained or amazed.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

GianfrancoN.Mar 9, 2006

A beautiful and tragic story of a love denied by society, set in 1963 Wyoming. A stunning performance by the actors; an incredible script; Ang Lee at his best. It tore my heart. The best movie I have ever seen. Haunting and moving.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AnneT.Mar 9, 2006

I saw the movie about a month ago and I just could not wait to see it again that I went to see again the following day. After a month, I am still shaken by this story and the incredible performance of Heath Ledger. Can't wait for the DVD.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChrisMar 8, 2006

Absolutely compelling. The best love story in movies to date. Enjoyed everyone's performance and this film has stuck with me for days. It opened up a place in my heart that I had forgotten about.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

K.BrownMar 8, 2006

a movie about love, that happens to have two gays as its central characters. all the more powerful because ang lee approaches sans an agenda . understated yet overwhelming. props to lee.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

SteveS.Mar 7, 2006

For those who think the movie is "slow" or "boring", I suggest that you stop hitting the next button on your iPod and try reading a book or doing something that may force you to actually use some patience. For those who think the movie For those who think the movie is "slow" or "boring", I suggest that you stop hitting the next button on your iPod and try reading a book or doing something that may force you to actually use some patience. For those who think the movie wouldn't be praised "if the love story was about a man and a woman", you're completely missing the point. There are similarities, but major differences/consequences/reactions/problems between gay and straight relationships. For those who thought Jack & Ennis were "selfish" and that the film ignored how they hurt the women in their lives by ... did you even see the film? Did you not see Michelle Williams in tears, talking about how she knew Ennis never went fishing? Did you not see Linda Cardellini in tears, telling Ennis that "girls don't fall in love with fun"? The movie deals with the hurt the women end up with. Ennis and Jack's love can't be expressed because of the stigma of being gay where they are and the circumstances of their lives. After all, if you thought that revealing your love for somebody could get you beaten or killed... you might keep it a secret too.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JeffMar 7, 2006

Ok, let us all get past that the movie was based on Gay Love, this was not a movie about how it affected the wives, I guess you would have to be either Gay or bisexual to truley understand why they could not give themselves fully to one Ok, let us all get past that the movie was based on Gay Love, this was not a movie about how it affected the wives, I guess you would have to be either Gay or bisexual to truley understand why they could not give themselves fully to one another, and yes the movie did lack a certain passion, but as a breakthrough movie, it was not about cheating on their wife, come on, Love between a man and a woman is different, you do not have to hise it, but in 1963 , do you really think they could of been together and lived a life with peace?, Now to the movie itself, Good acting, I even believed their Love, Truley can not compare to a man woman affair. Let us PLEASE get past that they were cheating on thier wife, in their hearts they were not cheating, they loved each other and in a different time and place, they would not of tried to get married and "Be Strieght", they would of just been together and not went on with a fake cover up life. OK, I am getting to emotional talking about it.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GeorgeH.Mar 6, 2006

Great story & picture that bring the world a step closer to facing the reality of sexual orientation. Regardless of who you are or what you do, love between two human beings are sacred and will show through all hardship, time and all Great story & picture that bring the world a step closer to facing the reality of sexual orientation. Regardless of who you are or what you do, love between two human beings are sacred and will show through all hardship, time and all obstacles. True love will never die.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

MylesPeraltaMar 6, 2006

for god's sakes. Why does anyone care about this movie? Its about two cowboys who are like "this town ain't big enough for the both of us; so lets go into the mountains and have sex!" just because Heath Ledger and Jake Gillenhalfor god's sakes. Why does anyone care about this movie? Its about two cowboys who are like "this town ain't big enough for the both of us; so lets go into the mountains and have sex!" just because Heath Ledger and Jake Gillenhal wanna become boofers, doesnt mean its an academy award winner! seriously...… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful

10

RajaS.Mar 6, 2006

Much has been said about Brokeback Mountain. It has been described, mostly gushingly, as a gay cowboy movie; a monumental film about homosexuality; and a crusade shattering gay stereotypes in mainstream Hollywood. Most of these

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ClarenceC.Mar 5, 2006

Beyond any temporary hoopla about "gay cowboys" and the much-reported consternation in the American heartland over 2 men kissing and doing whatever-else-in-the-world-two-guys-can-do-together-on-a-cold-night-in-a-tent-on-a-mountain), this is, Beyond any temporary hoopla about "gay cowboys" and the much-reported consternation in the American heartland over 2 men kissing and doing whatever-else-in-the-world-two-guys-can-do-together-on-a-cold-night-in-a-tent-on-a-mountain), this is, at its core, a hauntingly beautiful yet painful love story. It is a story of what might have been (and what, in my opintion, SHOULD have been), and a very human story of the pain we bring ourselves when we deny our hearts' most primal desire: to love whom that heart directs us. This film will surely outlast any contrived or real "shock and awe" to be remembered as a real trailblazer, and long noted as the achingly exquisite piece of art that it is, whether or not it wins even one Academy Award!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

1

SophieS.Mar 4, 2006

Hopelessly melodramatic. If this had been a film about a man and a woman, the critics would not be "emotionally affected" by the heartbreaking story of two people in love- they would be condemning the selfish nature of their affair and the Hopelessly melodramatic. If this had been a film about a man and a woman, the critics would not be "emotionally affected" by the heartbreaking story of two people in love- they would be condemning the selfish nature of their affair and the impact this would have on their families (wives/husbands and children). Because this has gay characters (and played by two straight actors i might add...since when were REAL gay actors unemployable in Hollywood???) all of a sudden it's a masterpiece. For heaven's sake let's all get a grip! Not once has anyone stopped to think of the emotional pain and hurt inflicted on those wives in this film..that's the most reprehensible thing about it. The film focuses on the cowboys' love and ignores the pain, betrayal and grotesque selfishness exemlpified by the two leading guys on thier wives and children. Grotesque. Horrible. Awful. Since when was infidelity, cheating and betrayal noteworthy? Everyone makes choices...all this film showed was that these two guys were not MAN enough to make their choices and live by them. Their guilt and depression are clearly attributed to their pathetic sense of themselves. NO sympathy for those characters...only the women who yet again...seem to have been left by the wayside. It looks like soon homosexual rights will outdo womens' rights. What a sham.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

RogerMar 4, 2006

A masterpiece of film. This one is going to be talked about for a hundred years.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

AnonymousMCMar 4, 2006

Propaganda Film *********************************************

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=49036 ************************************************************ The book "'The Marketing of Evil" explains howPropaganda Film *********************************************

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=49036
************************************************************
The book "'The Marketing of Evil" explains how the far left media strikes again and explains why everyone votes so high.

"The Marketing of Evil" has been almost alone among news media voices to expose "Brokeback" for what it actually is … Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful

10

TerryP.Mar 4, 2006

Exquisitely crafted film; its crux is poignantly encapsuled in the last frame with the closet on the left and the window showing the wide open spaces of West on the right - the difference between self-suppresion and living life to the fullest.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

3

RebeccaH.Mar 3, 2006

Other than the acting, this movie has no appeal. The story is of two immature men who fall in love, but not to the point where they would have cared to do much about it. Sure they met up quite a few times, but I can't get beyond how Other than the acting, this movie has no appeal. The story is of two immature men who fall in love, but not to the point where they would have cared to do much about it. Sure they met up quite a few times, but I can't get beyond how pathetic they seemed with being completely unable to give themselves to one another while breaking the hearts and shattering the lives of the women who they pretended to care about. The only emotions I felt during the entire movie were for Michelle Williams' character.… Expand

0 of 5 users found this helpful

10

AmandaD.Mar 3, 2006

This is a beautiful love story that is tragic and captivating. But I hear a lot of people saying it is universal, that it can be compared to Romeo and Juliet. I believe that to be very untrue. Romeo and Juliet never hated the fact that they This is a beautiful love story that is tragic and captivating. But I hear a lot of people saying it is universal, that it can be compared to Romeo and Juliet. I believe that to be very untrue. Romeo and Juliet never hated the fact that they were together. But Heath's character did. [***Spoilers***] In the movie his father showed him a dead rancher that had been killed because he lived on the ranch with another guy. This made Heath's character scared to give into his feelings. I thought that it stayed very true to the feelings and the hardships that gay couples have to face. I am glad someone wasn't afraid to make and movie that showed such amazing passion between people of the same sex. Hopefully this is a step towards intolerance.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

FrancescaMar 2, 2006

If I had rated this right after seeing it, it would have been a 7 -- but this movie sneaks up on you, gets in the cracks, and before you know it you realize it's one of the best movies you've seen in a loong time. I left theIf I had rated this right after seeing it, it would have been a 7 -- but this movie sneaks up on you, gets in the cracks, and before you know it you realize it's one of the best movies you've seen in a loong time. I left the theatre a bit underwhelmed despite the FANTASTIC cinematography and scenery (I grew up in the Rocky Mountain west, and it made me incredibly homesick). The reason I was underwhelmed was probably because the film is so understated: at times I found myself doubting what Jack and Ennis saw in each other, or if, indeed, any of the characters had much passion for anything at all. In hindsight, all the little things that have sat in my mind add up -- statements like "We've got no reins on this one" and "How do I quit you?" (paraphrasing); the quiet and wholly affecting despair of the wives, Ennis' in particular; etc. And in fact, part of the theme is precisely about living a life with the passion leached out of it -- which not only Jack and Ennis were forced to do, but their wives and even, apparently, Jack's parents; grinding poverty can be limiting just as homophobia can. For such a mild-seeming film (on the surface), it wrestles with the deepest emotions amazingly well -- despair and pain and passion and love and hope and fear. And, mostly, it's just about a society that warps everyone trapped in it, with characters that you sympathize with totally even as you want to scream at them and the situation they are stuck in. You can only watch, heart pounding, as the movie veers towards its inevitable conclusion. It's definitely a good movie on first viewing, but becomes truly great in the emotional resonances it sets up long after you left the theatre.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TerryMMar 1, 2006

This film is shot so well, it actually transports the viewer to that period and location. The performances by Ledger and Gyllenhaal are so genuine for that generation in which the film is shot. However, this is a drama. It requires aThis film is shot so well, it actually transports the viewer to that period and location. The performances by Ledger and Gyllenhaal are so genuine for that generation in which the film is shot. However, this is a drama. It requires a mature audience. If you are looking for special effects or lots of laughs, this movie isn't for you. This film is an insight into the lives of two men that are coping with the demands of their society, their beliefs and their love for each other. I thought this movie had a very real feel to it. The end very sad. This is one of the most memorable movies I have ever seen. I would recomend it to almost anyone.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

MrWonkaMar 1, 2006

Poofta Mountain, the magical place where all the little oomfa loomfa's come to gather at the chocolate waterfalls. They are quite a happy little folk, who love to frolic through the daffodils, and chase butterflys over the rainbow, andPoofta Mountain, the magical place where all the little oomfa loomfa's come to gather at the chocolate waterfalls. They are quite a happy little folk, who love to frolic through the daffodils, and chase butterflys over the rainbow, and have tea parties everyday in the afternoon. Sometimes these happy little folk even like to dance to disco music with glitter balls, and shiny sequin outfits. They also like to play cowboys and indians with each other. What a happy gay little folk they are.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful

9

EfrenT.Feb 27, 2006

simply beautiful, complelling, hauntyingly poignant.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

ElaineThompsonFeb 27, 2006

This movie was awful. I went into openminded, seeking for some artistic value. There was none. The only critical acclaim was that it took two actors who thought they were performing breakthrough roles, and really, it was just Sodom &This movie was awful. I went into openminded, seeking for some artistic value. There was none. The only critical acclaim was that it took two actors who thought they were performing breakthrough roles, and really, it was just Sodom & Gomorrah the sequel. There was no artistic value, there was no story, there was no goodness, there was no epic quality, it was just bad. Michelle Williams deserves some credit for playing a tormented woman. But where in this world are movies going if this gets marks above decent movies like Crash, or Walk the Line, or Cinderella Man. Movies that actually leave you feeling somewhat replenished instead of drained, dirty, and depressed.
Don't waste your time or your money on this joke of an Ang Lee film. From Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon to Crouching Cowboys HIdden Agenda.… Expand

0 of 5 users found this helpful

1

JasonF.Feb 26, 2006

As a gay man, I'm giving this movie a 1 for cinematography and thats it. I left this movie feeling numb, bored and uninspired except to go home a take a bottle of prozac. I realize everybody doesn't live happily ever after, and it As a gay man, I'm giving this movie a 1 for cinematography and thats it. I left this movie feeling numb, bored and uninspired except to go home a take a bottle of prozac. I realize everybody doesn't live happily ever after, and it enraged me more than anything really. There was nothing but repression, betrayal, self hate, misery and emptyness to this movie. What kind of story has ALL of it's characters miserable - with absolutely no bright side? Not a moive I would recommend to ANYONE.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

8

RodneyW.Feb 26, 2006

Intense, watchable, and increasingly likable, despite a key flaw: no chemistry between Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal. What you respond to is the fact that these romantic leads had the guts to do the movie, but there's no real spark. Intense, watchable, and increasingly likable, despite a key flaw: no chemistry between Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal. What you respond to is the fact that these romantic leads had the guts to do the movie, but there's no real spark. Between the two, Gyllenhaal aquits himself better. I never really bought Ledger's Gary Cooper act, or the fact that he never aged. He didn't look much older than his supposed 19-year-old daughter. Within these limits, still a compelling story.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

K.S.Feb 26, 2006

The best movie all year, if not the best movie i've ever seen. i cried for hours after seeing this movie, it was honest and heartwrenching. to all those who called it "sick" or "disturbing" , no one else wants to hear your gay hatingThe best movie all year, if not the best movie i've ever seen. i cried for hours after seeing this movie, it was honest and heartwrenching. to all those who called it "sick" or "disturbing" , no one else wants to hear your gay hating views, it revolts me. its a love story and a movie everyone can learn something from.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

Timothys.Feb 26, 2006

This film has been dubbed the gay cowboy movie, yet neither of the two said cowboys concider themselves gay. and even in a climatic emotional fit where one asks the other why he doesnt leave him, the other still does not offer any This film has been dubbed the gay cowboy movie, yet neither of the two said cowboys concider themselves gay. and even in a climatic emotional fit where one asks the other why he doesnt leave him, the other still does not offer any affirmation of love (to the dismay of many viewers). this film is a tragedy for every reason; for the untangible hopeless relationship that the men found in eachother as well as the complex and unsatisfying relationships formed with the wives and the childern. The slow unfolding of the film, i found, offers the viewer to really get lost within the storyline, and I was pleased that the near nonexistant sex scenes did not isolate the viewer to any serious degree. How anyone could have left the cinema untouched is simply beyond me. I saw it again the very next day to crosscheck my viewpoint. aside from very minor unexplained moments in the film, I would concider it near perfect.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

2

EricS.Feb 25, 2006

[***SPOILER***] Under normal circumstances, I would say this movie is OK. Given the hype, critical acclaim, and the numerous award nominations, I have to say this film is a fraud. Don't believe the hype. The cinematography is good and [***SPOILER***] Under normal circumstances, I would say this movie is OK. Given the hype, critical acclaim, and the numerous award nominations, I have to say this film is a fraud. Don't believe the hype. The cinematography is good and that's about it. Given that this story is about two men and given the length of the film, I was surprised that the primary characters are not even well-developed. When one dies, you don't even care b/c there's no heartfelt interest in him. Heath Ledger as best actor??? I couldn't believe how bad he was, unless you think talking without moving your lips is difficult. I had to stop myself from laughing out loud at his acting during one dramatic, emotional scene. I could not wait for this movie to be over ... it is soooo boring. After seeing the movie, I do believe a few that I've heard opine that this film's critical success is due to a liberal political agenda. That's the only thing that makes sense, b/c it's not that good. OK at best.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

BillFeb 24, 2006

Slow-building (in a good way), deeply believable, with characters that end up feeling not like characters but real people you've come to know, even friends, which makes the ending all the more devastating. I've seen it three times Slow-building (in a good way), deeply believable, with characters that end up feeling not like characters but real people you've come to know, even friends, which makes the ending all the more devastating. I've seen it three times and gotten different things from it each time. I imagine as I see it again in years to come, it will continue to reveal itself, as the best art does.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

HeroGreenFeb 24, 2006

BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN AN IMPOSIBLE LOVE
Before I saw the movie, I thought that homosexual people were weird and disgusting. When I heard about this movie and all the awards, I went to see it with my mom (AND I THOUGHT IT WOULD BE bad). ThisBROKEBACK MOUNTAIN AN IMPOSIBLE LOVE
Before I saw the movie, I thought that homosexual people were weird and disgusting. When I heard about this movie and all the awards, I went to see it with my mom (AND I THOUGHT IT WOULD BE bad). This movie that only costed 11 million $ comparing to King Kong with 209 millon $ was great. From the cinematography...to the way they treat the story. Ang Lee is a Great Director (Crouching Tigger, Hidden Dragon), and after making a bad movie (Hulk), he continued the good road. Gylleenhaal used to be a bad actor (The day After Tomorrow) But in THIS movie...
The Simple and short story was simply wonderful and the rest of the cast LEDGER, WILLIAMS & HATHAWAY (used to be a bad actress to ''Princess Diaries 1&2). Even thow i havent seen Crash, Capote, Good Night and good luck or Munich yet, I hope this little BUT GREAT independent picture will win the top price, best director, best screenplay, actor (lead & Sup), Actress (sup), music (even thow I loved THE CONSTANT GARDENER'S music & The PRIDE & PREJUDICE piano pieces) & Cinematography… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

MattB.Feb 24, 2006

"Brokeback Mountain" is one of those movies that stick in your mind and, no matter how much you want it to, it never leaves. Top-notch performances, stylish directing, and one of the most sincere and pure love stories of cinema make this "Brokeback Mountain" is one of those movies that stick in your mind and, no matter how much you want it to, it never leaves. Top-notch performances, stylish directing, and one of the most sincere and pure love stories of cinema make this beautiful movie the best one of 2005.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

LucyH.Feb 24, 2006

Absolutely an inspiring movie. Ubelievably moving and just touches the Heart Strings. Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal are two amazing actors who have portrayed two fabulous characters...how true the story is in reality. I just Loved the Absolutely an inspiring movie. Ubelievably moving and just touches the Heart Strings. Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal are two amazing actors who have portrayed two fabulous characters...how true the story is in reality. I just Loved the Movie!!!! Heath Ledger is one of my favorites!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

SueM.Feb 23, 2006

I adored everthing about this movie; it's brilliant acting, directing, cinematography. I haven't been moved like this by a movie in years. The sadness and heartbreak stayed me with for weeks and weeks. I was totally transporting I adored everthing about this movie; it's brilliant acting, directing, cinematography. I haven't been moved like this by a movie in years. The sadness and heartbreak stayed me with for weeks and weeks. I was totally transporting into the story, and that is my measure of a winner.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichaelF.Feb 22, 2006

One of the best movies I've ever seen.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

KrisS.Feb 22, 2006

This movie is absurdly sick. The very moral fiber of our country is deteriorating. I grew up ranching and, trust me, any real self respecting cowboy would not appreciate this. Homosexuality is not part of being a cowboy and has no place in aThis movie is absurdly sick. The very moral fiber of our country is deteriorating. I grew up ranching and, trust me, any real self respecting cowboy would not appreciate this. Homosexuality is not part of being a cowboy and has no place in a western movie. Get real people, wake up! You're being misguided by Hollywood and don't even realize it.… Expand

0 of 7 users found this helpful

3

MooFeb 21, 2006

awful...it was boring. i wanted to walk out of the movies, but i stayed in hope that the movie had not yet hit the climax, but the movie continued in boredom until, aslas, the climax was hit...the movie ended.

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

JoséFeb 20, 2006

Very sad. As a gay man it's easy to relate to one of the two. Mine was Dennis... until I came out. And I was so happy then. Still, it's not fair to frame this movie within its sex tendencies. It's a great movie no matter what. Very sad. As a gay man it's easy to relate to one of the two. Mine was Dennis... until I came out. And I was so happy then. Still, it's not fair to frame this movie within its sex tendencies. It's a great movie no matter what. It's a supreme cry to all those who waste golden chances that may never show up again. We have to grab love where we find it. It's one of those movies that make you want to jump right inside and rescue the main character from his fatal lonely destiny. And like him, I swear, if I could do it, perhaps I would never jump out.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TomS.Feb 20, 2006

This movie left me deeply despressed and I awoke early this morning thinking about it. I can not pin point all the ways it disturbed my until then contented love and life. I am not sure my love for mate is strong enough, I am not sure I can This movie left me deeply despressed and I awoke early this morning thinking about it. I can not pin point all the ways it disturbed my until then contented love and life. I am not sure my love for mate is strong enough, I am not sure I can handle aging and the loss of romantic, passion filled love as it seems to ebb away over time. I have few of the obstacles these men faced in living my love, but their tragedy somehow upset the hold I felt I had on my relationship and life. I hope this leaks away soon and I hope in time I figure out is how and why it made me feel this way.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

VirginiaR.Feb 19, 2006

Sensitive, gorgeous, heartbreaking, this movie is a dignified and graceful telling of what happens to dreams denied. The pace, the tenderness of the camera, the quality of the light, reveal the most humble places, people, and moments as Sensitive, gorgeous, heartbreaking, this movie is a dignified and graceful telling of what happens to dreams denied. The pace, the tenderness of the camera, the quality of the light, reveal the most humble places, people, and moments as sacred. The touch of fabric your lover once wore. The desperation of daughters for distant daddies. A dirt-poor life of deprivation so complete that a man never expects to get what he wants. Masculinity and the tradeoffs men have to make: if you've got a wife and the appearance of heterosexuality, it's okay to use a carving knife. If you get accused of being queer, you have to pull someone out of his truck and start pounding away until it's your head in the asphalt. I am not sure what I think about the Mexico part. But an almost perfect movie. Thank you.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AdamHFeb 19, 2006

Why do people come in here and rate a movie a 0 when it is obvious they never saw it? I mean, when you call homosexuality "sick" in your review, then what question comes to mind is, "Why would you spend $8.50 on a movie that you know is aboutWhy do people come in here and rate a movie a 0 when it is obvious they never saw it? I mean, when you call homosexuality "sick" in your review, then what question comes to mind is, "Why would you spend $8.50 on a movie that you know is about two gay men, when you are obviously going to be offended by it and not like it?" I doubt they saw it at all.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RonN.Feb 17, 2006

Too bad some critics are still homophobic! Great love story, direction and acting!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

7

VahidM.Feb 16, 2006

something new for me, but, love is universal.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DaveFeb 16, 2006

Incredible movie. The end hit me like a punch that knocks the wind out of you. I'm very open minded and have many gay friends, but was still a bit nervous about seeing this movie. If you love good film and are still haven't seenIncredible movie. The end hit me like a punch that knocks the wind out of you. I'm very open minded and have many gay friends, but was still a bit nervous about seeing this movie. If you love good film and are still haven't seen this movie, see it! The romantic scenes are very tastefully done and well acted. After a while you practically forget this movie is about two guys falling in love.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

FredJ.Feb 16, 2006

A really great movie.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

WandaM.Feb 15, 2006

This was a amazing movie. I cried my heart out. I was hoping that they ended up together.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

paulFeb 15, 2006

This film still haunts me after seeing it for the second time. Beautiful and tragic, what an experience in film making and viewing. The best movie experience I have ever had.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MalcolmH.Feb 15, 2006

Simultaneously epic and intimate. An almost perfectly realized film. But I must remind the naysayers - the aging in the film shouldn't be an issue, don't forget at the end of the movie Jack and Ennis are still only 39 to 40! Simultaneously epic and intimate. An almost perfectly realized film. But I must remind the naysayers - the aging in the film shouldn't be an issue, don't forget at the end of the movie Jack and Ennis are still only 39 to 40! Wrinkles, paunches and arthritis are not required at 40 years old. One of still fairly youthful.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

LarryB.Feb 14, 2006

The best movie in recent memory. One could feel the longing Ennis & Jack had for each other, but were unable/unwilling to express. The ending felt haunting in that Ennis finally realized what he had missed and lost.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

stephenc.Feb 14, 2006

Wonderful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

XiaodongT.Feb 13, 2006

the movie just showed what the true world shall be.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

6

OliverC.Feb 12, 2006

The people who like this movie the most are the people who never saw it. I dont get what all the fuss is about, there is basically no love or romance in a romantic drama. It drags on a lot towards the end and i left the theater frowning. O The people who like this movie the most are the people who never saw it. I dont get what all the fuss is about, there is basically no love or romance in a romantic drama. It drags on a lot towards the end and i left the theater frowning. O and Omg what a predictable ending, honestly like i've never seen that before? You should probably go see it because people make it sound great and then u can come back and agree with me.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

BillFeb 12, 2006

Yet another of Hollywood's attempts to indoctrinate immorality into the common culture and pretend that homosexuality is normal. The idea of co-mingling with a sweaty cowboy with a saddle chapped behind after a long day's workYet another of Hollywood's attempts to indoctrinate immorality into the common culture and pretend that homosexuality is normal. The idea of co-mingling with a sweaty cowboy with a saddle chapped behind after a long day's work somehow isn't appealing. Gives new credence to Willie Nelson's song "Mama, don't let your children grow up to be fag cowboys"… Expand

0 of 5 users found this helpful

9

DerekG.Feb 11, 2006

Great. The only thing keeping me from giving it a 10 is the aging of the characters. They look the same until almost the very end, when all of a sudden they're supposed to be 20 years older. Even then, Heath Ledger does not look Great. The only thing keeping me from giving it a 10 is the aging of the characters. They look the same until almost the very end, when all of a sudden they're supposed to be 20 years older. Even then, Heath Ledger does not look anywhere near as old as he should.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DalayF.Feb 11, 2006

I think this movie was extremely important becuase it shows that although society in which we live today is supposively free, fact is that is not since many people do not accept homosexuality. What society tends to do is reject them and I think this movie was extremely important becuase it shows that although society in which we live today is supposively free, fact is that is not since many people do not accept homosexuality. What society tends to do is reject them and ignore them rather than welcoming them. Therefore, freedom in this country is only an illusion.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChrissyFeb 11, 2006

Oh my gosh what a movie! Definately deserves the awards it's been getting recently. A whole new concept and direction for movies today. Sure to become a classic.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GregoryV.Feb 11, 2006

I viewed this film about a week ago and still can't seem to set aside the emotions which tore me apart then.There are too many superlatives to list. A testament to all who made the film possible. My psyche has been permanently altered.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

nicktrusovFeb 11, 2006

funny how the only movies that ever get good ratings from any of you so called movie reviewers are movies about gay love, or oppressed ghetto high school basketball teams winning a game.
truth check...
If we throw a little realism infunny how the only movies that ever get good ratings from any of you so called movie reviewers are movies about gay love, or oppressed ghetto high school basketball teams winning a game.
truth check...
If we throw a little realism in there what will we see... dicks going in man asses, aids, and little kids selling crack, killing each other over a pair of addidas. The glorification and ammount of truth kept hidden in these films is no less than that of old war flicks.
You have got to be kidding me.… Expand

0 of 5 users found this helpful

10

WinnieP.Feb 10, 2006

Undeniable the best of year.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

JudyH.Feb 10, 2006

Poignant best describes this film...a love story that touches your soul and yet makes you feel the pain that unforbidden love brings...and isn't that a shame....

0 of 0 users found this helpful

6

DanV.Feb 10, 2006

It was a pretty good movie but way overrated. The aging techniques were way unbelievable. After promising to leave myself and a guest rocked with weeping we were just happy to be done with it and leaving the theatre. Music was not memorable It was a pretty good movie but way overrated. The aging techniques were way unbelievable. After promising to leave myself and a guest rocked with weeping we were just happy to be done with it and leaving the theatre. Music was not memorable other than that one signature guitar, melodramatic, signature guitar riff.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

SergeS.Feb 10, 2006

Subtle and heartbreaking example of the existence of rampant forces beyond conscious and voluntary choices. Unforgettable.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TimT.Feb 10, 2006

Very well written and preformed by all the actors involved. Would love to see the director turn the book The Front Runner by Patricia Warren into his next big screen movie. I enjoyed the book in 1974 and still do today. you go guys.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

NikolaS.Feb 10, 2006

This film, the story, the deeply real characters and the compelling portrayal from the wonderful actors in it have really moved me. I was not expecting the film to live up to the media build up but its graceful growth and the raw honest This film, the story, the deeply real characters and the compelling portrayal from the wonderful actors in it have really moved me. I was not expecting the film to live up to the media build up but its graceful growth and the raw honest emotion carries you away. Heath Ledger's performance was surely his best yet and I think he gave the film a lot of integrity.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

5

LizzyQFeb 9, 2006

I think this movie was way over-rated. The animal abuse was almost too much to bear. The cinematography was beautiful, I think because the scenery was beautiful. I was not impressed.

0 of 1 users found this helpful

8

KateP.Feb 9, 2006

Really good film, but slow... but i think that trying to get across that its over a ong period of time.. worth viewing.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ColinY.Feb 9, 2006

How can I put in words my response to this film: superb, brilliant, terrifyingly true, sad, beautiful. I came out of the movie speechless and emotionally exhausted. The honest portrayal of all the characters is laudable, but Heath How can I put in words my response to this film: superb, brilliant, terrifyingly true, sad, beautiful. I came out of the movie speechless and emotionally exhausted. The honest portrayal of all the characters is laudable, but Heath Ledger's performance throughout is truly staggering. In future years this film will come to be seen as one of the greatest of all time.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

VictoriaK.Feb 7, 2006

This is one of the most heart felt movies I have ever seen. It defines enduring and caring love beyond gender. The sadness of this story, the inability of these two people to simply live a loving life together, overwhelmed me. The acting is This is one of the most heart felt movies I have ever seen. It defines enduring and caring love beyond gender. The sadness of this story, the inability of these two people to simply live a loving life together, overwhelmed me. The acting is incredible, full of heart and feeling. I hope this film will create some flicker of compassion and understanding in the homophobic community.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RickD.Feb 6, 2006

The future will show this to be a classic that will be remembered when the other films currently gaining accolades are long forgotten.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

JimT.Feb 6, 2006

I am very glad the movie was made. And in the end it did what at least a great story should do - change your life or the way you act. Since seeing it I have looked into giving to the Matthew Shepard Foundation (the gay student who was killed I am very glad the movie was made. And in the end it did what at least a great story should do - change your life or the way you act. Since seeing it I have looked into giving to the Matthew Shepard Foundation (the gay student who was killed in Laramie in 98). But it was not the film itself that moved me - it was the story. The exception to that for me was Heath Ledger's acting. He did more than what Ms Proulx's story could do - show on the big screen the face, body and emotions of a man showing all his colors: of rage, restraint, love and grief.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JoeA.Feb 5, 2006

If you liked 'Bridges of Madison County', you will like this movie. While similar in the basic premise of forbidden love vs. moral and 'right' committments, the subtext for Brokeback ends up being as much if not more If you liked 'Bridges of Madison County', you will like this movie. While similar in the basic premise of forbidden love vs. moral and 'right' committments, the subtext for Brokeback ends up being as much if not more powerful than the main story. And as an aside, you don't have to be gay to enjoy the movie (and I've heard it hasn't turned anyone gay . . . yet). So, if you're skipping out on this movie 'cause you've got an uncomfortable streak w/ the story, I suggest you get over it and check your homophobia at the ticket window; otherwise, you're gonna miss out on a captivating movie. My other half gets kind of uncomfortable seeing men together, but even she liked the movie. (and I'm still straight the last time I checked -- crossing my fingers).… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

YiZ.Feb 5, 2006

I think this movie is great. heath's such an actor and the contrast between wild open natural scene and stifling oppressive human society. you do need some guts to be different, even just to be yourself. it's a comfort for peopleI think this movie is great. heath's such an actor and the contrast between wild open natural scene and stifling oppressive human society. you do need some guts to be different, even just to be yourself. it's a comfort for people like these two poor ones.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

SteveL.Feb 4, 2006

One of the most memorable films I've ever seen. I woke up three days in a row thinking about the film. It was both disturbing and hopeful. The filming was smooth and seamless from start to finish. This film is why I go to movies.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RichardW.Feb 4, 2006

My wife and I were able to see Brokeback when it first opened in NYC. It is a haunting love story that says a lot more than the relationship of two loner type men. It gets to the heart of so many of our simmering up tight relationships in the USA.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichaelM.Feb 4, 2006

It touched my heart I can't get it out of my mind. Best I've seen in many years.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

SamD.Feb 4, 2006

One of the best movies i've ever seen. loved it from beginning to end, especially the end. i nearly forgot that they were gay for a while and saw them as just to people in love. after all, that's what they were.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

YuriB.Feb 4, 2006

A true masterpiece.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PabloR.Feb 4, 2006

With this kind of movies i feel alive, free and more than a spend money machine.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JackS.Feb 3, 2006

The perfect movie to educate human compassion.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

CristhianX.Feb 3, 2006

I 've no words.. It's a great film.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BreanneH.Feb 3, 2006

Best movie i've seen in a long time, it was so sad, and so good. THe acting was amazing.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichealL.Feb 3, 2006

I went to see it with my girlfriend and I thought it was tastefully done. In the first "gay scene" I got a bit squirmish because it was kind of intense but after that the story line became more focused on the two cowboys' LOVE for each I went to see it with my girlfriend and I thought it was tastefully done. In the first "gay scene" I got a bit squirmish because it was kind of intense but after that the story line became more focused on the two cowboys' LOVE for each other and the obstacles they faced trying to be together. It really took me by surprise because I thought it'd be too hardcore for my taste but it was eye opening and gave me a new perspective on gay male relationships. That is, that there's more too them than just frequently, irresponsible sex. I know that it goes against Christian ethics but it can't hurt to at least try to understand the message the film tries to deliver.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

F.PicanoFeb 3, 2006

The last ten minutes are almost unbearable in their sadness and beauty. When is the last time a movie made you feel like this? It's a great American poem in moving pictures.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MoviegoerGeekFeb 3, 2006

It didn't hit me in the guts the way "Bridges of Madison County" did , but that´s a whole another kind of story anyway.The "Marlboro postcards" are there to show us the surreal beauty of the place in question; somewhere you can It didn't hit me in the guts the way "Bridges of Madison County" did , but that´s a whole another kind of story anyway.The "Marlboro postcards" are there to show us the surreal beauty of the place in question; somewhere you can always go back to, but what the heck, it's in your imagination! Concerning the slo pace, I think BM is character-driven, so the movie follows the aching, dubious, incredulous and often contemplative mood of it's main protagonist: Ennis Del Mar. Gay Western my balls!! This movie is a lot about subtext. ANYONE can relate to: 1) Commiting or suffering iInfidelities 2) wealth differences in a relationship 3) mad, obsessive search for the impossible 4) dealing with the authority when you have everything to lose (remember Jack's father in law) 5) the slow descent into lowdown when your object of passion can't give you what you want 6) consequences of not being able to say what you feel (regret) 7) fear of the payback 8) fear of everything else and last, and more imposrtantly, OPPORTUNITIES LOST (regret again). Can you relate to some of this? BM hast it's little flaws (yes, it's a bit too long) and it's memorable, magical moments (when Ennis whispers n impossibly tender lullaby in Jack's ears your heart just breaks out of nowhere) This is a movie you just need to watch leaving all of your prejudices, labels and high expectations in the box office.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichaelM.Feb 2, 2006

It is funny that all the negative comments on this board are from the tiny minds of people who either haven't seen this film or those who cannot understand the power of love in this world. I'm just like everyone else here who wasIt is funny that all the negative comments on this board are from the tiny minds of people who either haven't seen this film or those who cannot understand the power of love in this world. I'm just like everyone else here who was blown away by a unique film with great acting. Bravo Brokeback Mountain!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ZackFeb 2, 2006

This movie touched me beyond words. I was barely able to make it out of the theatre and into my car without breaking down. I woke the next day, depressed and beyond tears. Brokeback Mountain had a profound effect on me and one that will not This movie touched me beyond words. I was barely able to make it out of the theatre and into my car without breaking down. I woke the next day, depressed and beyond tears. Brokeback Mountain had a profound effect on me and one that will not soon be forgotten. It has been over a week since I viewed the movie and not a day has gone by that it hasn't been in my thoughts. PLEASE go see this movie. Unless you are a homophobe or a card carrying member of the religious right, you will love the movie and be extremely touched. Only homophobes and haters give this movie a 0. I see probably roughly 25 movies a year and it's the best and most touching movie I've seen in YEARS. Both male actors deserve every award that can be given to them for doing an excellent job in telling the story of Jack and Ennis. The last few minutes will take your breath away. I sat in my chair for 10 minutes after the film ended before I was able to go to my car. I am not an emotional guy....especially in public...and this is the first movie I've ever cried at. I cannot say enough good about this moive. I loved it and if you are a kind and open hearted person, you'll love it too.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

6

JakeFeb 2, 2006

an okay movie in it's own right, a little bit dull. It's beautiful to look at, but it just didn't have the emotional effect on me that everyone else seems to be having. Even though the two leads happen to be men (and I thought an okay movie in it's own right, a little bit dull. It's beautiful to look at, but it just didn't have the emotional effect on me that everyone else seems to be having. Even though the two leads happen to be men (and I thought they both did a terrific job acting) the story about forrbiden love and its destructive results seems to be rehashed. Was it a good movie? Yes. Great? No. Does it deserve an Oscar? No. Other films like Crash and Capote and even Munich are much more worthy of the honor, but will most likely not get it only because this film is so contrversial, which is a pity, because the title "Best Film" implies just that, and Brokeback was definatley not the Best Film of 2005 by any means.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AmandaR.Feb 2, 2006

This is one of the best, most moving movies EVER made. I can't stop thinking about it and how great the actors were in the movie. It was amazing. Go see it, you won't be sorry.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BobGrimesFeb 1, 2006

I saw Brokeback Mountain about a month ago and it still haunts me. I'm pretty obsessed by it and I read everything I can about it.
All the people here with the 10s have such a reverence for the movie that it's almost like aI saw Brokeback Mountain about a month ago and it still haunts me. I'm pretty obsessed by it and I read everything I can about it.
All the people here with the 10s have such a reverence for the movie that it's almost like a religious eperience we've all shared. That would make the bigot and the homophobes that hate everybody and everything the anti-christ. Which reminds me of a letter somebody wrote to the editor not long ago saying that when all those things were written in the bible that everybody believed the world was flat.
The movie has had such an effect on me that I now have a new respect for the whole human race. And every one I see I can detect has a flame within and is searching for someone to love and be loved by. It's turned into a whole new and happier world for me.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PatriciaFeb 1, 2006

I cannot stop thinking about this movie. It is an incredibly emotional and bittersweet love story. Heath and Jake are brilliant, and both deserve an Oscar. I highly recommend it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

EugeneB.Feb 1, 2006

A magnificent film, definitely one of the best movies of the year and my personal favorite. Brokeback Mountain is very artistic, both in its technicalities (acting, writing, direction, cinematography, score) and in its heavy use of A magnificent film, definitely one of the best movies of the year and my personal favorite. Brokeback Mountain is very artistic, both in its technicalities (acting, writing, direction, cinematography, score) and in its heavy use of symbolism. Yes, it is deserving of all the accolades it has received. But the excessive awards attention for Brokeback Mountain is also a double-edged sword for the film. There's so much hype built around it that some first-time viewers will be searching for a different movie than what is actually shown. Brokeback Mountain is no gay Titanic or Gone With The Wind. It doesn't pack an emotional punch or manipulate you in ways most mainstream romances do. Brokeback Mountain is a quiet, subtle love story about two men trying to cope with this "thing" that they share. It's impact is more of a haunting experience - the movie really works it's magic AFTER it is over. (I'm also happy to say that Brokeback Mountain is one of few films that actually gets BETTER upon each viewing.) And it's more than just a love story... Brokeback illustrates the pains of loneliness and regret as we watch these characters make choices that slowly tear their lives apart. The haunting questions of "what if?" and "all that could have been?" That is something everyone can relate to - straight or gay. Sometimes we make choices because they seem the most logical. But in the long run, are those choices really worth the suffering and regret? Great, great movie. (By the way, anyone who sees Brokeback Mountain as contrived propaganda or something with an agenda is CLEARLY missing the point of this film.)… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

yaleeyaleeFeb 1, 2006

what is so heartbreaking about this story is the realization of two human beings find unconditionally love in one another, yet it was this love that makes them powerless and ultimately, lost. my visios blurs everytime i think about this what is so heartbreaking about this story is the realization of two human beings find unconditionally love in one another, yet it was this love that makes them powerless and ultimately, lost. my visios blurs everytime i think about this film. one of the very best i have seen in the past 10 years, easily.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JenWPFeb 1, 2006

A truly breathtaking masterpiece. Ledger's performance as the inarticulate and eternally stifled Ennis is definitely Oscar-worthy. Rodrigo Prieto's amazing cinematography combined with the haunting musical score by Gustavo A truly breathtaking masterpiece. Ledger's performance as the inarticulate and eternally stifled Ennis is definitely Oscar-worthy. Rodrigo Prieto's amazing cinematography combined with the haunting musical score by Gustavo Santaolalla make this a true feast for the senses.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

1

OscarL.Feb 1, 2006

Teh first half of the movie is a Marlboro commercial. I was expecting the "Come to where the flavor is" voice. The second half is a failed gay compassion provoking video. We all know to be gay is ok, it is something normal to love. So, Teh first half of the movie is a Marlboro commercial. I was expecting the "Come to where the flavor is" voice. The second half is a failed gay compassion provoking video. We all know to be gay is ok, it is something normal to love. So, another love soap opera with a west side cowboys scenario was uneccessary.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

9

JessFeb 1, 2006

This movie leaves an ache in your heart even after you leave the theater. Ledger has surprisingly come up with his best performance. But i think the most pleasant surprise was Michelle Williams. I didn't know she could act!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

MarcoM.Feb 1, 2006

I loved this film. The relationship between Gyllenhaal and Ledger is powerful, amazing and unique. Slightly overrated, the

0 of 0 users found this helpful

7

DavidFeb 1, 2006

Looked great, great script, excellent sound track, but I just did not believe that Heath Ledger was into it. I didn't believe the love story/20 year grand passion worked - so it didn't really work for me.

0 of 1 users found this helpful

9

TonyB.Jan 31, 2006

Although not a tear jerker in the traditional sense, "Brokeback Mountain" tells an extremely sad story so well that it is likely to linger in many viewers' minds long after they leave the theater. Heath Ledger and Jake Gylenhaal, giving Although not a tear jerker in the traditional sense, "Brokeback Mountain" tells an extremely sad story so well that it is likely to linger in many viewers' minds long after they leave the theater. Heath Ledger and Jake Gylenhaal, giving two of the year's best performances that are way beyond anything they have ever done, are both overwhelmng and heartbreaking as they try to come to terms with the hand that life has dealt them. Because in doing so, they cause havoc to those who love them as well as to themselves, they do not emerge as heroic figures, but all too human ones. A top notch supporting cast complements their outstanding work.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TracieN.Jan 31, 2006

wonderful.... everything about the movie was realist, the acting was fabulas, the setting, make up clothes, everything was realist. I know because I grew up in that time and in that world. Stunning.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

JeffC.Jan 31, 2006

Please...Just a political movie that Hollywood and the left are ramming down our throat. We have the courts back and WE will do something about the moral decay of this country...sorry the movie was bad. I think I slept thru most of it. BAD MOVIE!!!

0 of 3 users found this helpful

Brokeback Mountain

User Reviews