Elden Ring

 Xbox Series X
User Score
7.7

Generally favorable reviews- based on 3153 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 2,339 out of 3153
  2. Mixed: 182 out of 3153
  3. Negative: 632 out of 3153
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. AustinGamers
    Feb 28, 2022
    9
    Love it very challenging just like any action rpg game and hypixel skyblock. The open world is just diverse with different bosses with different types of attack to learn and overcome. The only flaw is the performance where it keeps dropping in demanding situation ever on series x|s and ps5. Overall best game for this type of audience/gamers
  2. Eleithir
    Apr 6, 2022
    10
    Simply the best open world game ever. Mystery behind every corner, great gameplay and beautiful world design.
  3. Idi002
    May 17, 2022
    8
    Pros: Amazing Graphics and art style, Fluid Combat with a wide array of weapons.
    Cons:, Late game difficulty spike that makes you feel like your back at Level 1(And I've beaten Dark souls 1), All of a sudden past the 35 hour mark Bosses suddenly take years to kill because of there high health pool, they have stupid fast attacks which is not a problem by itself, but those fast attacks hit    Pros: Amazing Graphics and art style, Fluid Combat with a wide array of weapons.
    Cons:, Late game difficulty spike that makes you feel like your back at Level 1(And I've beaten Dark souls 1), All of a sudden past the 35 hour mark Bosses suddenly take years to kill because of there high health pool, they have stupid fast attacks which is not a problem by itself, but those fast attacks hit for your entire health bar, what should be like is that Fast and hard to dodge attacks should hit for a little less, while easier to dodge attacks should hit for much more like it was in ds1. But the reason I don't give this game a lower score is because all these issues can be fixed by one guy with a slider tool. Just tweak some of the enemy health and damage. And this game is a solid 10/10.    … Expand
  4. RedGeneralX2
    May 29, 2022
    8
    It's a great addition to the Soulsborne series. There are some flaws, the big one being the PC stutter but it plays great most of the time regardless. My personal issues are the erroneous amount of delayed attacks and some seemingly unavoidable attacks.
  5. Faaip
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    Game journalists got it right for once. Hard game definitely but very rewarding once it starts to click. I suggest sticking around until it does. It’s worth it.
  6. yoookreker
    Jun 11, 2022
    10
    this game is one of the best souls like games ever! happy passing for everyone!
  7. jluis859
    Mar 11, 2022
    10
    Best soul I have ever played, my top:
    1. Elden ring 2. Bloodborne 3. Sekiro
    4. Dark souls series
  8. PoisonScorpion
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    this game is great lots of content lots of different enemies and bosses the world is beautiful even the underground areas looks amazing... the low reviews are from people that dont like dark souls games or never played one which is to be expected but if you want a game with lots of hours of content and playability this game is for you
  9. Admiralhackbar4
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    Fromsofts finest, feels like a culmination of the past 10+ years. The inclusion of Guard Counters and Sekiros posture system removes the jank from Dark Souls III's combat, and the world and story are the best they've ever been.
  10. Recarte360
    Feb 28, 2022
    9
    El juego es bueno, gaficos de este planeta, exelente opciones para explorar en mundo abierto, dificultad muy buena para arrancarte unos cuantos pelos. Nota: Por accidente califique el juego en la seccion de PS5, ya que la pagina entrando te recomienda el juego en dicho sis y sistema y por no fijarme cliquie ahí.
  11. Kbjjkkvv
    Feb 28, 2022
    10
    Best fromsoftware work yet. Game is perfect mix of gameplay of dark souls/bloodborne and open world like zelda:botw
  12. Inquisidor44
    Feb 28, 2022
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Desafiante
    Neblina bien utilizada Superior a bugison forbbiden west
    Mundo abierto de ensueño
    Amigable para nuevos jugadores
    Graficazos de la leche
    No es una prioridad pero si un jugazo    … Expand
  13. TiRedWarrior
    Feb 28, 2022
    8
    Environments, enemy types and mechanics of said enemies are nearly perfect. You can have so much fun just exploring the map and the process of getting just a little better every excursion is thrilling. The game falters at few key places including graphics, performance, and multiplayer decisions. The performance of the game even in performance mode is lack luster at best hovering 40-50.Environments, enemy types and mechanics of said enemies are nearly perfect. You can have so much fun just exploring the map and the process of getting just a little better every excursion is thrilling. The game falters at few key places including graphics, performance, and multiplayer decisions. The performance of the game even in performance mode is lack luster at best hovering 40-50. While this is not that bad considering the character models and some environments look like early ps4 it’s disappointing. Multiplayer could be phenomenal but is bogged down by bad design choices. One example is walls that forces you to disband group at region zones and have your friends try to get to the point where you’re at alone just so you can progress after you get past the wall. Others include mounts and summons not working. These two features are so core to the single player experience that it is baffling that they couldn’t optimize their game enough to have them included. There is a lot to like about this game and contrary to popular opinion an 8 is a worth while experience so give it a try.… Expand
  14. Galen_Marek_
    Sep 7, 2023
    10
    Hands down, Miyazaki did it again and we witnessed the best game that FromSoftware has created, deserved that award.
  15. Wickedxdream
    Apr 13, 2022
    10
    This game is amazing… I always had Witcher 3 as the best game I have ever played but finally elden ring has stolen the spot. The games world building is awesome when you just start the game your just lost in this world. I get so sidetracked form the main story because the world is just so amazing to explore. The boss fights are top notch some better then other. But this is the game whereThis game is amazing… I always had Witcher 3 as the best game I have ever played but finally elden ring has stolen the spot. The games world building is awesome when you just start the game your just lost in this world. I get so sidetracked form the main story because the world is just so amazing to explore. The boss fights are top notch some better then other. But this is the game where you dream to be something you can be it. This game is for the hardcore fans and new ones. Just if you are new just give it sometime to get used to it and I promise once you get a hang of the movement’s and fighting controls it’s rewarding. But I have put in over 200 hours in this game and still find new stuff all the time. But this game deserves the praise the best I’ve ever played.… Expand
  16. Merunes20
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    игра затягивает определённо лучшая игра 2022
  17. aristotelis123
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Amazing game and you can co op now. A masterpiece that shows the best of what open world can offer 10/10
  18. culper1776
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Dodge, block, parry perfection doesn't make a fun game. No cohesive story or characters, open world has clear boundaries, pretentious.
  19. Bandar117
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    Best Game Ever made from FromSoftware !!! I can’t believe what i seen from this game the perfect Art World and more colorful. Even the enemies and bosses everywhere
  20. Mytekke
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Just perfect. I'm on my 5th journey and it's still a lot of fun. The best release 2022.
  21. reviewaccountau
    Feb 27, 2022
    9
    9/10

    runs fine just as good as dark souls 3 on series S. servers don't work for multiplayer atm. 20 hours into the game singeplayer tho
  22. Broemenp
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    This game deserves more than 10 this game is true masterpiece best of all other games Ive played until now
  23. Lghooopp
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Such an excellent game and a true masterpiece. Game play is flawless and the world has such a beautiful atmosphere and rich lore.
  24. TheJamesBaxter_
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Ten out of Ten, absolutely amazing. The game could run better but the core game is one of the greatest of all time.
  25. nogills
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Absolutely perfect, From has once again put all other devs to shame. The open world is SO dense. Combat amazing
  26. Elxx
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Muy buen juego, mi primer juego de este tipo y la verdad me a gustado y me encanta la dificultad que no sea muy fácil pero tampoco imposible
  27. Oscarbarber
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Juegazo, más de lo que esperaba superó mis expectativas, mundo inmersivo mantiene la dificultad de los anteriores juegos del estudio y que bueno que siga así, el diseño artístico está genial, uno de mis favoritos
  28. DustyHam
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    An amazing game with the power of the Xbox series x making the world and graphics Jaw dropping
  29. Dereyno
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Enormously rewarding for any souls gamer. Lives up to the challenging nature of its predecessors
  30. Watattenchu
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    An insane amount of options to approach every aspect of the game, excellent fast paced combat and an incredible story with a cast of characters with superb voice acting. The open world is designed expertly and feels great to explore and discover secrets in.
  31. TabbyToeBeans
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    I've never played any FromSoftware games before, and I was scared coming into it. But oh my god is this game amazing. I love open worlds and this is such a refreshing experience that I can't seem to put down! Of course it's hard, but it's not impossible like every other critic believes it is; it's rewarding and beautiful. The enimies/bosses are unique, the NPCs are compelling and theI've never played any FromSoftware games before, and I was scared coming into it. But oh my god is this game amazing. I love open worlds and this is such a refreshing experience that I can't seem to put down! Of course it's hard, but it's not impossible like every other critic believes it is; it's rewarding and beautiful. The enimies/bosses are unique, the NPCs are compelling and the atmosphere puts you on edge while also giving you that 'going on a 5th grade feild trip' excitment. I'm only 30hrs into it and I know I didn't even scratched the surface. I cant wait to see what else this game has in store.… Expand
  32. Lord_Venom
    Feb 27, 2022
    9
    I've had no issues with this game on Xbox unlike PC. It's another Souls game, if you're into them then you'll probably be into this one too. I've put in multiple hours only killing one boss so far. The scenery is breath taking, the best part for me was exploring the landscape.
  33. Pokenala
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    As someone who’s only dipped their toes into the “Souls-borne” genre, I’ve got to say that this is easily one of, if not THE best games I’ve ever played. It’s so incredibly challenging, but every time you get over a hurdle you have one of the biggest feelings of satisfaction any game can give you! I have a hard time noticing frame drops, so I don’t have anything to say on that level. ButAs someone who’s only dipped their toes into the “Souls-borne” genre, I’ve got to say that this is easily one of, if not THE best games I’ve ever played. It’s so incredibly challenging, but every time you get over a hurdle you have one of the biggest feelings of satisfaction any game can give you! I have a hard time noticing frame drops, so I don’t have anything to say on that level. But this world is drop-dead GORGEOUS! With only the slightest bit of pop-in every now and then. Already at ~26 hours, and can’t wait to sink hundreds! If you like a challenge and an immersive world, check it out!… Expand
  34. NikeSnow
    Feb 27, 2022
    9
    I really hated soul games. Never could get into them. So I was never good for the challenge. This game?! Is really really good. If something is too hard I just go somewhere else and rank up and come back. Really enjoy the creativity and thoughtfulness of this game for new players. I only wish it had the classic quest menu. It would be a lot easier to track quest, but I see why it’s notI really hated soul games. Never could get into them. So I was never good for the challenge. This game?! Is really really good. If something is too hard I just go somewhere else and rank up and come back. Really enjoy the creativity and thoughtfulness of this game for new players. I only wish it had the classic quest menu. It would be a lot easier to track quest, but I see why it’s not needed for this game.… Expand
  35. Jurnte
    Feb 27, 2022
    10
    Great game ! Sucks u in from the start. The graphics could be better but it doesn't bother me while gaming. The online functions aren't working properly but be patient ppl.
  36. LauMei
    Feb 28, 2022
    10
    One of the best games of all time. Best open world in terms of freedom and exploration since Skyrim.
  37. Baldhunter
    Feb 28, 2022
    9
    I can only rate how Elden Ring is for me on the Xbox Series S. I've had no problems, no stutters, no frame drops, multiplayer works, it's running the way it supposed to. It looks exactly like it did in all the advertising and network test (if it looked bad to some why did they buy it and then complain about it?) It's also exactly what Fromsoft said it was, an open worlds souls game.I can only rate how Elden Ring is for me on the Xbox Series S. I've had no problems, no stutters, no frame drops, multiplayer works, it's running the way it supposed to. It looks exactly like it did in all the advertising and network test (if it looked bad to some why did they buy it and then complain about it?) It's also exactly what Fromsoft said it was, an open worlds souls game.
    Anyway I'm a Nintendo guy and I bought my Xbox so I could play this game and am not disappointed. It's also my first souls game since Dark Souls 1 first came out and I'm loving it, lots of dying even to the first enemy but it can be done with some time and practice. It's huge too, 40 hours in and I haven't even gotten out of the first area, too busy exploring and dying and trying to power up as much as possible, the world isn't empty, it just doesn't have a million markers on the map telling you exactly where everything is, you have to go look for it.    … Expand
  38. Shedfreak
    Feb 28, 2022
    10
    This is probably the best Action RPG I ever played so far, it's challenging, always surprising, artistically stunning, I can't really find any gameplay flaws, it's just a joy to play for hours and hours.
  39. Creten
    Feb 28, 2022
    10
    I’m only 8 hours in but…WOW! I’m enjoying every bit. This is my first dark soulsesk game and it is not disappointing me one bit. Praise elden ring !
  40. MideonNViscera
    Mar 2, 2022
    10
    I've always been looking forward to Elden Ring, but I was getting a bit worried as we got closer to release as I saw how many people were hyped for it. I was afraid with them going open world, and the apparent mainstream appeal, that it would be Baby Dark Souls.

    Well, my fears were unfounded. Going open world didn't impede this game at all, it elevated it. Almost every square inch of    I've always been looking forward to Elden Ring, but I was getting a bit worried as we got closer to release as I saw how many people were hyped for it. I was afraid with them going open world, and the apparent mainstream appeal, that it would be Baby Dark Souls.

    Well, my fears were unfounded. Going open world didn't impede this game at all, it elevated it. Almost every square inch of this game is beautiful, unique, and most importantly, full of new experiences. I feel actual joy exploring this land, when usually in an open world game I just zero in on the waypoint so I can quickly kill the enemies and finish whatever lame quest I am on.

    There have been a few additions to the Souls gameplay, such as a jump button and stealth. I was surprised to see stealth, but after playing a bit I can't really imagine getting around this world without it.

    I could probably babble on about this game for awhile, but really I'm just writing this review to spite the babies!    … Expand
  41. Fermont
    Feb 28, 2022
    10
    From Software make amazing, challenging and envolving immersive games, Elden Ring it’s incredible
  42. DarkGhost327
    Feb 28, 2022
    10
    es dark souls 2 ll

    la verdad esta demasiado bueno el juego, esta vez si se lucio from software la verdad me quede viciado a este juego.
  43. nathan0421
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    A culmination of what made every other FromSoftware souls-like amazing. From beautiful scenic views to creative original bosses and enemies, this masterpiece really has it all. The combat as always is insanely satisfying, leaving you to want to grind more and more for damage enhancements and talismans. Every corner I turn it seems like I discover another hidden dungeon in a cliff side orA culmination of what made every other FromSoftware souls-like amazing. From beautiful scenic views to creative original bosses and enemies, this masterpiece really has it all. The combat as always is insanely satisfying, leaving you to want to grind more and more for damage enhancements and talismans. Every corner I turn it seems like I discover another hidden dungeon in a cliff side or crevice, giving me another couple of hours of gameplay and areas to explore. Overall I think you know where I stand with Elden Ring, the current server troubles are being addressed and shouldn’t play into the reviews of a new release, especially from a developer and publisher who only serves the players and doesn’t implement a money hungry cash grab into their games. Thank you FromSoftware for helping keep gaming in its roots, with the player.… Expand
  44. CrashAzarel
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    Excellent game that delivers and lives up to the hype. Sadly. People will review bomb anything just cause they are haters.
  45. Talens16
    Mar 1, 2022
    9
    El juego es una culminación de todos los SoulsBorne que ha realizado FromSoftware. Eso sí, el juego presenta actualmente algunos problemas con el online y algún que otro leve problema de rendimiento mientras se está en campo abierto en el Necrolimbo. Aun así, la historia, mecánicas y exploración hacen que este juego sea claramente al GOTY de este año con muy pocas dudas.
  46. Nottommyc
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    Believe the hype. I’ve gone through and read negative reviews on this platform describing frame stuttering, crashing, input lag, what have you. In my 30 hours I’ve not had the game crash once nor frame rate stuttering, especially when a lot of mobs are on screen. It’s impressive to me how the game holds up in these moments of high stress. The art style is gorgeous. It is clear fromsoft putBelieve the hype. I’ve gone through and read negative reviews on this platform describing frame stuttering, crashing, input lag, what have you. In my 30 hours I’ve not had the game crash once nor frame rate stuttering, especially when a lot of mobs are on screen. It’s impressive to me how the game holds up in these moments of high stress. The art style is gorgeous. It is clear fromsoft put time and effort into this creation. Everything is placed in the world and has a reason for being there. It is incredible to me that they were able to create this in just over 2 years of development. This is also the most accessible soulsborne game, while also being one of the most challenging I’ve played. Keep in mind my review is solely based on my experience in my 30 hours, yes I am a fromsoft fan, so I’ve tried to avoid bias in this review, and I’ve taken off the rose colored glasses to fully experience these opening hours. Elden Ring receives a 10 from me on Xbox series X|S based the absolute zero issues or problems I have come across. Of course issues could still be there, and I will update this and my score accordingly if anything mentioned above changes over time.… Expand
  47. Jueguista
    Mar 1, 2022
    9
    The game is absolutely amazing. Sadly, on PC it performs about as well as you'll perform in battles
  48. Anto0409
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    J'adore ce jeu !! MERCI Fromsoftware de nous avoir sorti un chef-d'œuvre comme celui-ci !!!!
  49. trustypatches69
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    elden ring, the game that isn't for everyone COUGH COUGH* bad players who never got good* COUGH COUGH COUGH
    love this game the most id say, almost done beating it without summons and gotta say, its pretty easy
  50. Khanstent
    Mar 1, 2022
    9
    Honestly, first I must say that if you aren't a fan of Dark Souls and/or any previous FromSoftware game this is not going to change your mind.

    With that out of the way, let's get down to it. This game is "bare" because it wants to give you a sense of exploration. Yes, minimaps are cool, yes quest trackers are good to have, but where's the mystery if every single thing has big arrows    Honestly, first I must say that if you aren't a fan of Dark Souls and/or any previous FromSoftware game this is not going to change your mind.

    With that out of the way, let's get down to it. This game is "bare" because it wants to give you a sense of exploration. Yes, minimaps are cool, yes quest trackers are good to have, but where's the mystery if every single thing has big arrows pointed at them? The lore is there for people that want to search, but you really have to do some digging to figure things out. Though to be fair the story is not anything different, it's been the same in all games. You're some kind of chosen one that keeps coming back to life and you have to kill some gods to become the next ruler. Good enough for me let's go kick some ass, but there's still a huge world to explore, with plenty of side dungeons/bosses if you want to take a break from the main path.

    Which leads to combat, which has always been the best thing in all of the FromSoftware games. The amount of builds you can create is insane, and with new features and mechanics you can pretty much make any build viable. Want do smash things with giant hammers or swords? Go for it. Want to slice and dice with knives and daggers? Take a stab at it. Wanna stand far away and blast enemies with fireballs and magic missiles? Cast away your doubts and blast away your foes. Hell there's even a video of someone playing as Darth Maul, double-blading every enemy in their path.

    The visuals are decent, nothing mind blowing but in this day and age it's really hard to improve upon graphics. Even still, the art direction and style carry the game tenfold, so while the graphics aren't amazing you will still be in awe at how great the world looks. I'm constantly panning the camera 360 degrees just to take in all the visuals and I am constantly in awe of it all.

    Now to answer the biggest question on everybody's mind: how difficult is it? You really want to know? It's brutal. Maddening. It will make you rage with anger and weep with sorrow. You will cry for mommy and dial 911 for emergency help simultaneously. Your anus will hurt from the relentless 24/7 pounding it gives you. You will fail more than you succeed, but when you do succeed, and rest assured you will, you will feel like the god you are aiming to by the end of the game. But wait, there's more. Tired of getting your ass handed to you for the millionth time? FRET NOT YOUNG TARNISHED! You can summon other players to assist you with bosses meaning you don't have to worry about being stuck for too long.

    Overall the game is definitely a blast. I'm playing on the Xbox One X and I have not run into too many technical issues. Yes some FPS drops here and there but no crashing and no fight hindering slow downs during bosses either. The only reason it's a not a 10/10 is because the story is basically rehashed. Well, that and for a game to deserve a 10 it really does need to be superb while also bringing something new to the table. Elden Ring doesn't exactly bring anything new to the table but it definitely improves on the old formula. It's kinda like if your favorite drink is Mountain Dew and your favorite fruit is cherry and they just released Code Red. Except it can kill you twice before you even take your first sip. Yeah, something like that.    … Expand
  51. Relik78
    Mar 1, 2022
    9
    Not a fan of souls game in general but this one is awesome.
    Ignore the 'bad graphics" cry babies. If graphics were everything then most of the best games ever made would never exist. Playability and replayability are great. One of the few games out there worth the full price.
  52. Araphex
    Mar 1, 2022
    10
    First game in the past few years that has been released with minor to no bugs or issues. There was some network issues in the beginning but that was resolved in 24 hours. The game was still playable offline. Game plays as intended. Definitely game of the year nominee for sure.
  53. Terrence_01
    Aug 11, 2023
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This game is not maidenless. It is more than just being that. Its perfect and therefore is a an achievment.… Expand
  54. B22_The_ODST
    Mar 1, 2022
    9
    Me encantó, el mejor de la serie souls en mi opinión, le metido horas y horas y aún sigo encontrando cosas, a pesar de conservar cosas de juegos pasados se siente muy diferente y nuevo, me encanta. El único problema que he tenido es el tema de la optimización pero nada grave, se sienten los bajones de frames pero no llega ser injugable.
  55. TheLilly
    Mar 2, 2022
    10
    While I'm some ways off of creating my video review or even completing the game, Elden Ring has proven itself worth the hype, and despite it being my most anticipated game ever, it still somehow managed to exceed my expectations. Having spent more than 60 hours on the game, I can't put the game down, and I can't wait to get into NG+.

    The game is brutal on mistakes, but stick it out,    While I'm some ways off of creating my video review or even completing the game, Elden Ring has proven itself worth the hype, and despite it being my most anticipated game ever, it still somehow managed to exceed my expectations. Having spent more than 60 hours on the game, I can't put the game down, and I can't wait to get into NG+.

    The game is brutal on mistakes, but stick it out, because this is in my honest opinion the greatest game I have ever had the privilege of playing.

    There is an actual sense of adventure. The map does not shout at you with dozens of markers - you see something on the map resembling ruins, and you check it out because the game taps into your curiosity. Every discovery you make feels like your own and is rarely guided, with dialogue and world design that compliments the intelligence of the player, as is a staple in FromSoftware's games.

    Having spent that much time in the game, I'd say I'm more or less about 60% of the way through, and I am so happy about that. I never want this game to end.

    RECOMMENDATION: As I have always said for FromSoft games - your first playthrough should be solo, and unguided. This game is the pinnacle of that statement. Knowing where everything is from guides kills the exploration and discovery aspect of the game somewhat.    … Expand
  56. Omnisplicer
    Mar 2, 2022
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Elden Ring provides continues to refine and arguably perfect the Souls formula. Add in new gameplay mechanics, a gripping story co-written by George R.R. Martin, a gorgeous open world with caves and dungeons and an incredible selection of weapons and magic and you have what may just be an early GOTY. I am yet to complete this game, and an amendment with a 10/10 rating isn’t out of question. It’s truly a shame that this game is getting review-bombed for having the audacity to have no more than acceptable performance. Cyberpunk this definitely is not.… Expand
  57. Excal
    Mar 2, 2022
    9
    Gameplay-10
    Story-8
    World Design-10 Graphics-6 Fun Factor-10 Replay Value-10 Overall Score-9 Exploration is the strongest aspect of this game, open world games , time after time open world games have become more focused on giving you a huge sandbox world but then holding your hand throughout your whole journey out of fear of the player being frustrated or confused. (Far cry 6 or Ac    Gameplay-10
    Story-8
    World Design-10
    Graphics-6
    Fun Factor-10 Replay Value-10
    Overall Score-9 Exploration is the strongest aspect of this game, open world games , time after time open world games have become more focused on giving you a huge sandbox world but then holding your hand throughout your whole journey out of fear of the player being frustrated or confused. (Far cry 6 or Ac Valhalla as example)

    Like Zelda Botw, Elden Ring goes against this grain in that it respects the players intelligence to create their own adventure out of the sandbox world that is given. Combat while bring very similar to Dark Souls 3, is the most refined combat that we’ve seen from FromSoftware. Graphics can be seen as a weak point of this game, in that even in next gen consoles it doesn’t seem to give that wow factor as much as other games that are coming out in 2022 such as Horizon Forbidden West. Though I will say the world design of this game is so strong that it outshines the (can be) poor textures. As any Other Soulslike FromSoftware game that they’ve published, Elden Ring has Excellent Replay Value, the combat has a mastery to it as soon as you begin playing the game.It being a well executed RPG it gives the player so much variations in how they can play the game that by the time you’re finished your 1st play through, you want to begin your second journey straight away just so you experience the game as a different build instead.

    Elden Ring is must play    … Expand
  58. Benlugo113
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    Love this game, im new to the series but it has given me a level of inmersion I have not felt since rdr2. The difficulty is perfect, it makes you lear your enemies moves and weaknesses in order to beat them. People that say that its too hard they have no patience ir just dont like games that take time. Performance is the only notable issue ive heard from some people, my series x runs itLove this game, im new to the series but it has given me a level of inmersion I have not felt since rdr2. The difficulty is perfect, it makes you lear your enemies moves and weaknesses in order to beat them. People that say that its too hard they have no patience ir just dont like games that take time. Performance is the only notable issue ive heard from some people, my series x runs it great and ive not encountered a game breaking bug.… Expand
  59. NorthAJ
    Mar 2, 2022
    9
    My first souls game and it is a true test of patience and strategy. Beautiful open world with plenty to do and see. Everytime I think I'm gonna throw my controller against the wall from dying to many times I end up getting past whatever it is I'm fighting lol which makes the victory that much more sweeter. Ride on fellow tarnished.
  60. Aezrel
    Mar 7, 2022
    10
    It's an awesome game and deserves the praise and price tag. Deal with it and get good.
  61. aliassmego
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    Exactly what you've come to expect but in an open world. Enough to keep you busy for a very long time.
  62. lol12445
    Mar 2, 2022
    10
    There are a lot of people who hate this game and the hate is not justified.
  63. JSky221
    Mar 2, 2022
    10
    Fantastic game so far! Love the open world and the boss battles have been very fun and challenging.
  64. Git_gud_nub
    Mar 2, 2022
    10
    Git Gud, also good game, needs some optimization but really addictive and fun, although the margit and godric are kinda hard for being player's first boss, i know you should level up amd try again but there's no clear message and most players don't like to stand down, maybe a message after your first margit death should mention you should explore and level up and try again if you're havingGit Gud, also good game, needs some optimization but really addictive and fun, although the margit and godric are kinda hard for being player's first boss, i know you should level up amd try again but there's no clear message and most players don't like to stand down, maybe a message after your first margit death should mention you should explore and level up and try again if you're having difficulty… Expand
  65. GetAmpt
    Mar 2, 2022
    9
    The only reason it's not getting a 10 from me is because of the input lag. Other than that, it's the best souls experience you can ask for. The people giving it a bad score are either paid actors or just like to **** online about a genre they don't understand and refuse to learn. Hands down one of the greatest games ever made. No loot boxes, **** microtransactions. Just an amazing singleThe only reason it's not getting a 10 from me is because of the input lag. Other than that, it's the best souls experience you can ask for. The people giving it a bad score are either paid actors or just like to **** online about a genre they don't understand and refuse to learn. Hands down one of the greatest games ever made. No loot boxes, **** microtransactions. Just an amazing single player/coop experience.… Expand
  66. Anonweb3
    Mar 2, 2022
    10
    Literally the greatest of all time. I've been a gamer for 23 years now , I review games , I buy every single game including zanki zero , code realize etc. and games nobody's ever heard of . I've played them all . Eldin ring on my series X is The GOAT. GOTC, game of the century . I don't think I need to say more .
  67. CptnElite
    Mar 3, 2022
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Sin duda alguna es la mejor obra de From.
    Llevo aproximadamente unas 20-30 horas de juego y encuentro varias de las nuevas mecánicas sumamente entretenidas.
    Dentro de las innovaciónes, la que más me llamó la atención es la de aplicar cenizas/artes de guerra a el arma que quieras y hacer que mejoren de la forma que desees, esto abre la posibilidad de builds híbridas que anteriormente eran imposibles.
    Por ejemplo:
    Mi personaje es mago de combate pero en algunas ocasiones me encuentro con enemigos resistentes a la magia o que simplemente reciben muy poco daño, por lo tanto, requiero de un poco de daño divino, eléctrico, de fuego o un poco de buffs como curación o juramento sagrado.
    Otra mecánica que disfruto mucho es la de contraataque, esto permite a jugadores oxidados o nuevos asestar golpes de alto daño sin requerir mucha habilidad y sin exponerse tanto al enemigo.
    El sistema de mundo abierto permite una exploración sumamente amplia, así como sorpresas inesperadas como los subterráneos.
    Pero... Como todo lo bueno, también hay algunas cosas malas.
    Entre los detalles que me parecieron algo..... Desepcionantes, está la cantidad de material reciclado, entre esto se encuentran las animaciones.
    Diablillos/esclavos de lothrick.
    Avatares del arbol/Demonio del refugio.
    Caballeros superiores/caballeros de lothrick.
    "gordos de machete" /legionarios de harald y juso el borracho.
    Gargolas/Gárgolas de morne.
    Aliento diagonal de los dragones/aliento de fuego de midir.
    Basiliscos/basiliscos. Cangrejo/cangrejo. Un jefe en la aldea de los alvinos/demonio de Aries..... Por favor, incluso pusieron los perros :v. También encontré algunas estructuras (chozas y cabañas) que literalmente fueron copiadas de la hoguera de asentamiento de los no muertos. Por último, las mazmorras básicas como minas y criptas tienden a ser un poco repetitivas variando únicamente en la disposición de enemigos, nivel y algunas secciones de las mismas, siento que pudieron haber hecho un diseño único para todas y cada una de ellas. Como conclusión: el juego es extremadamente bueno, presenta varios desafíos justos y sobre todo, es divertido explorar y progresar a lo largo del mundo. Los detalles como las animaciones recicladas y lo ligeramente monótono de las mazmorras puede ser dejado de lado si uno se enfoca en divertirse e investigar el mundo    … Expand
  68. NLThomas
    Mar 3, 2022
    8
    Where to start.

    Well let's begin with all the 10/10 reviews. I do believe it is a amazing game, and I really enjoy it, but it has its flaws. Network code: not much improvement from dark souls 3 and in general, online is a bit hard to get into. Had one item activated that should summon me into other people their world when they got invaded but never happened. PC build/stable FPS:    Where to start.

    Well let's begin with all the 10/10 reviews. I do believe it is a amazing game, and I really enjoy it, but it has its flaws.

    Network code: not much improvement from dark souls 3 and in general, online is a bit hard to get into. Had one item activated that should summon me into other people their world when they got invaded but never happened.

    PC build/stable FPS: It is From Software their first open world and mistakes will be made. Where I didn't have too bad of a FPS drop on pc, I know others did. And I sure had some awful frame drops myself during certain fights. In the end, it will be patched out rather sooner then later so I do not feel like it is too far of a point to judge on.

    Open world: Their first open world and they nailed it. The moment you step out of the introduction area, you can go wherever you wish to go in a stunning looking world. Walk around and stumble upon a cave? Well it has some neat loot in it and worth a grab. By far the best open world game for me.

    Difficulty: The game can be as difficult or easy as you make it. The first boss people seem to be having issues with is Margrit, who is indeed difficult. But it teaches you to do something else. Go out and explore, level up, get stronger weapons and then return to properly fight him.

    Everything together, it is a solid 8 out of 10 for me. Not everything is perfect, but which game is? A true love letter to the fans of the dark souls series.    … Expand
  69. Slinko
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    An incredibly fun and refreshing game that I know I am going to play again. It gives me a sense of wonder and adventure that I have not felt in gaming in years.
  70. DisclosedClub
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    I'm not going to lie to you, it's pretty hard. The game lacks difficulty options, forcing players to either rise to the occasion and enjoy the rigor of fights where you dodge attack after attack performed by colossal bosses, or get mad because they can't manage to time their rolls and write a bad review on metacritic. That being said, the game does feel a bit grindy in the beginning,I'm not going to lie to you, it's pretty hard. The game lacks difficulty options, forcing players to either rise to the occasion and enjoy the rigor of fights where you dodge attack after attack performed by colossal bosses, or get mad because they can't manage to time their rolls and write a bad review on metacritic. That being said, the game does feel a bit grindy in the beginning, especially if giants scare you. It also lacks a simple main story, opting instead to give detail and plenty of backstory to its npc's and the world itself and making you the player figure things out. Your destiny won't be found nested in dialogue options, lengthy cutscenes, and a clear-cut path, it'll be what you make it. If you're up for the challenge, get Elden Ring and enjoy one of the greatest games out there.… Expand
  71. Cryptic247
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    Absolutely breathtaking beat game I have played in years and I look forward to putting 1000+ hours into it
  72. Cardsdrummer
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    This game does as much for the Souls like games as Breath of the Wild did for Zelda. And it’s amazing! If you absolutely don’t like the Souls games or have a really hard time with the combat, this may not change your mind, but if your curious it’s definitely worth checking out!
  73. Gamer_Dad
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    I love this game, im older now and dont have much time to play being a single dad so not much time to "git gud" or whatever but this game reminds me of how games are supposed to be. No slot machine lootbox bs or pay to win systems. The open world is EXTREMELY addicting and I find myself getting excited to beat enemies and bosses like I did when I was younger. Never played souls so theI love this game, im older now and dont have much time to play being a single dad so not much time to "git gud" or whatever but this game reminds me of how games are supposed to be. No slot machine lootbox bs or pay to win systems. The open world is EXTREMELY addicting and I find myself getting excited to beat enemies and bosses like I did when I was younger. Never played souls so the learning curve has been steep but not overwhelming. This is a great game. Worth your money and your time. Some people just want to moan and groan these days.… Expand
  74. Zkarface
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    Simplemente maravilloso!
    Miyazaki y su equipo han creado una definitiva obra maestra.
    Un mundo abierto despampanante, un esquema de batalla limpio y clásico, y una dificultad endiabladamente atrapante.
  75. illtana
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    Game is absolutely stunning. Runs with 0 issues on my Series S from my personal experience. Bosses are fairly challenging, regular enemies vary in difficulty, but most of all.... the game allows you to go out and explore the vast world with the only punishment being the players(yourself) lack of skill. I'm blown away with how amazing this game truly is. 10/10 in my books.
  76. Newrecier34
    Mar 3, 2022
    10
    This game is fantastic. It's a fromsoftware game; if you don't like difficulty or want the story handed to you, well then this isn't the game for you. If you like souls games then you will probably love this one. You will die a lot, the game is a challenge. The combat is grueling and takes a while to master.
  77. smitheryinke
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    It’s funny to see people who clearly haven’t played anything more challenging than mainstream bait titles zelda botw, ghost of tsushima, assassin’s creed and whatnot, complain about a game that has a 10+ year long history of having the same solid mechanics set in stone. They don’t realize that the difficulty of these games comes from THEM being a **** player because they were seasoned withIt’s funny to see people who clearly haven’t played anything more challenging than mainstream bait titles zelda botw, ghost of tsushima, assassin’s creed and whatnot, complain about a game that has a 10+ year long history of having the same solid mechanics set in stone. They don’t realize that the difficulty of these games comes from THEM being a **** player because they were seasoned with the titles stated above, titles that reward you for being a **** player. They are not used to challenges. They want quest markers, dungeon markers, npc markers on the map. They want a difficulty setting. They don’t get what “roleplaying” means in these games. You’re not playing as some killing machine that can crush every single enemy as if they were tin cans, you’re playing as a person who seeks to be that strong one day, and you DO become that strong come late game. I hate that this game became a mountain of hype. Sorry but, the souls series doesn’t deserve this treatment. I don’t know why they decided to open it up to the general, more stupid audience. If this game had the same fanbase DS3 had at its release, I guarantee you it would’ve had a fan review score of 98-99. This game is literally the closest game we’ve had to perfect in its respective genre. Sorry for the long comment, I just felt like they didn’t do justice to this masterpiece of a video game franchise.… Expand
  78. LarsMoon
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    One if the best games i ever played. Its rich in content and filled with challenges aswell as impressive art design. Very sad it got review bombed over minor stutter issues onn PC
  79. velodi
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    The Best Game of last 10 years! Project have only problems with optimization, but it not have important for emotions! Thanks for real entertaiment. Wait in VR :)
  80. TreeStump
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    This is my first time playing a souls like game. I’m not sure I could go back to the other games but it’s definitely on my to do list after I continue to play Elden Ring. I’m 40 hours in and it’s just amazing. There is so much to do and so much to explore. The game is tough but it gives you multiple ways to come back and to level up. You can even summon spirits, NPCs or other onlineThis is my first time playing a souls like game. I’m not sure I could go back to the other games but it’s definitely on my to do list after I continue to play Elden Ring. I’m 40 hours in and it’s just amazing. There is so much to do and so much to explore. The game is tough but it gives you multiple ways to come back and to level up. You can even summon spirits, NPCs or other online players to help you through an area or boss. A big thing to note going in is you are going to die, and die alotttttt. Be prepared don’t throw your control; try not to rage quit. Just leave go level up or explore. This game is beautiful and is full of life. Highly recommend. So far it’s my favorite game and I can’t put it down. I will be back to give another review months later after I finish every bit of content I can squeeze out! 10/10… Expand
  81. Temp13
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    Absolutely amazing, a real breath of fresh air after a year or so of generally disappointing games.

    A lot of the lower rated reviews are people crying about the difficulty, but to be fair, is the game difficult? Yes, extremely at times, especially if you aren't familiar with souls style combat, like I wasn't. So if you're not very patient then this isn't the game for you. However, if    Absolutely amazing, a real breath of fresh air after a year or so of generally disappointing games.

    A lot of the lower rated reviews are people crying about the difficulty, but to be fair, is the game difficult? Yes, extremely at times, especially if you aren't familiar with souls style combat, like I wasn't. So if you're not very patient then this isn't the game for you.

    However, if you commit a little bit of time to learning the combat system and to understanding the bosses move sets, you'll be recorded with what I consider to be one of the best gaming experiences I've had in a very long time.

    The boss battles are some of the most intricately designed, punishing button mashing and forcing you to beat them, not by luck, but by skill and determination. The scenery is beautiful and the open world is very, very detailed, with a trip into an unassuming shack taking you on a quest spanning multiple hours. The enemies are diverse and always keep you on your toes and every battle is a little bit different. The game allows you to play in a multitude of ways, in a very non-linear style of story telling where you have to figure things out on your own. This makes the game very rewarding and finally beating a boss which you've been beaten by 50 or so times brings unmatched satisfaction.    … Expand
  82. pablooren18
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    Definitivamente la evolucion perfecta de los juegos de From Software, en donde literalmente te puedes introducir en un mundo con miles de cosas por descubrir y colocadas estrategicamente para que tengan sentido. Si bien la nueva mecanica de andar a caballo no me termina de convencer, es sin duda, un reto mas a nuestras habilidades frente al mando.

    Realmente si piensan que es un Dark    Definitivamente la evolucion perfecta de los juegos de From Software, en donde literalmente te puedes introducir en un mundo con miles de cosas por descubrir y colocadas estrategicamente para que tengan sentido. Si bien la nueva mecanica de andar a caballo no me termina de convencer, es sin duda, un reto mas a nuestras habilidades frente al mando.

    Realmente si piensan que es un Dark souls 4 (lo cual muchas personas lo describen asi) por algunos sonidos, animaciones, npc's y entre tantas cosas. Esto es sin duda lo caracteristico de los juegos de From Software, podemos verlo en juegos como BloodBorne o Sekiro.

    La dificultad es una de esas cosas que hacen que From Software sea lo que es hoy en dia y por lo cual la comunidad se mantiene tan fiel a este tipo de aventuras.

    Sin duda la joya de la corona de los mundos abiertos. Jefes increibles, materiales interesantes, mecanicas fabulosas y excelente soundtrack.

    Recomendado totalmente! Denle la oportunidad y aunque se frustren y quieran abandonar, no se rindan y podrán entender el por que estos juegos son tan maravillosos.    … Expand
  83. Shovelfox
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    El mejor juego de la saga y probablemente del año, el mundo abierto es una pasada tomando en cuenta el diseño de personajes el arte conceptual del juego da hermosas vistas cada enemigo más fuerte q el anterior y hace una gran dificultad s te insista a explorar mejorar a tu personaje querer conocer todo en resumen el mejor juego del año
  84. Danchez313
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    I’m 31 and have been playing video games since I was 5. I’ve played probably hundreds of games, as it’s my favorite hobby. Elden Ring is one of the greatest games I’ve ever played and in my opinion one of the best video games ever made. I have no complaints. Its a masterpiece. It can be quite difficult, but that’s the type of games that FromSoftware makes. The game is gorgeous, fun,I’m 31 and have been playing video games since I was 5. I’ve played probably hundreds of games, as it’s my favorite hobby. Elden Ring is one of the greatest games I’ve ever played and in my opinion one of the best video games ever made. I have no complaints. Its a masterpiece. It can be quite difficult, but that’s the type of games that FromSoftware makes. The game is gorgeous, fun, challenging, and incredibly satisfying. I’m 52 hours in and probably only halfway done. It’s just filled to the brim with content.… Expand
  85. ReddSerPent
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    Great game been play souls games for a while got to say the best in the series
  86. ThisShepeX
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Sinceramente siento que el juego es demasiado sencillo, no entiendo el sistema de parry aún pero Esta muy bien balanceando el combate, referente a las caídas fotográficas pues es algo que con un parche se soluciona, cómo veterano de la saga souls este se lleva por bastante a los otros es mis apenas 16 horas de juego.
    No puedo creer lo sencillo que es el el patrón de golpes de los jefes, sinceramente hubiera preferido mínimo algunas segundas faces de varios jefes pero hasta ahora solo vencí a el primero jajaja Así que veamos cómo me sorprende ❤️    … Expand
  87. breadhot
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    Actually enjoyed this game. Hard to say in this day of graphics-focused game design.
  88. saadkha
    Mar 4, 2022
    10
    the best game in the history of gaming fights are so good and the map is large and beautifull you have the choice to do what ever you want in your game progress and more
  89. Bebop1002
    Mar 5, 2022
    10
    I already wrote my review under the ps5 page. Just want to boost the score after a bunch of fools tried to review bomb the game for reasons only they know. Like always with great games or great and challenging games, people show their incompetence on metacritic or other user scores, ruining sites like this completely. As if someone doesn’t buys or buys a game based on your trash reviewsI already wrote my review under the ps5 page. Just want to boost the score after a bunch of fools tried to review bomb the game for reasons only they know. Like always with great games or great and challenging games, people show their incompetence on metacritic or other user scores, ruining sites like this completely. As if someone doesn’t buys or buys a game based on your trash reviews lol. People already know that user score is invalid. So save your time and rather learn the game. Noob.… Expand
  90. kadecarlisle33
    Mar 5, 2022
    10
    Absolutely gorgeous and satisfying once conquered! Beating the game is worth it!
  91. ToastyReview
    Mar 5, 2022
    10
    Amazing achievement in game development. Maybe not for everyone but Fromsofts execution in bringing the now classic soulsbourne style to the open world is just outstanding
  92. NewPath
    Mar 5, 2022
    10
    After more than 50 hours I'm writing my review of Elden Ring. In my eyes, the game deserves a 10/10 from a Dark Souls fan perspective. About the performance itself. I play it on my XSX in 2K and the 60 fps is stable for me. Only in 4k mode it fluctuates between 45/50-60 fps. Also online works for me from 1 day without problems. It has not worked for many people who came later on theAfter more than 50 hours I'm writing my review of Elden Ring. In my eyes, the game deserves a 10/10 from a Dark Souls fan perspective. About the performance itself. I play it on my XSX in 2K and the 60 fps is stable for me. Only in 4k mode it fluctuates between 45/50-60 fps. Also online works for me from 1 day without problems. It has not worked for many people who came later on the release day because the server capacities were at capacity. From Software probably didn't expect so many players, which of course doesn't excuse it at all. However, it must also be said that this has now been fixed.

    Graphically, the game is no Horizon Forbidden West, which was never expected. It is a beautiful Dark Souls game.

    I read a lot of negative reviews here that classify the game as too hard and only got it because of the open world. If you haven't played a Souls game yet, I think you should do so first. For anyone who says it was only rated well by Souls fans, YES BECAUSE IT IS A SOULS GAME. I don't understand the negative review because the game is like Dark Souls, that's what it's supposed to be and I thank From Software for that too. From Software has not only kept its own game concept, they have also improved a lot of the negative things that bothered me about Dark Souls.

    This is not a generic mainstream sony open world game. Anyone who thinks they are getting a standard Sony open world game like Horizon, Days Gone, etc should stay away from Elden Ring.

    Anyone who is a fan of the Dark Souls series and especially the first part, this game is a must! Elden Ring is a masterpiece from From Software. They have managed to take the best of their last games and combine it with an incredibly large open world. The game has the atmosphere of Dark Souls 1 (to the point that I feel like I did the very first run of Dark Souls 1, both nostalgia and the childlike joy of exploring an unknown world), it has the movement of Dark Souls with nuances of Sekiro.

    The open world seems nice but a bit empty and the first dungeons very (that's how I felt) , the Souls feeling did not come up immediately. BUT! After 50 hours of playing I understand why this was so at the beginning. The game should go in the mainstream direction whereby newcomers should settle into the game concept in the first area. After the first boss and the first castle, the Souls feeling really kicks in and content is thrown at you. So many different beautiful worlds, secret paths, interesting quests and many many random surprises on his journey there has never been in a Souls game.

    I haven't played a game that captivated me like this in years.    … Expand
  93. MADD4Q
    Mar 5, 2022
    10
    Only issue I have with this game is the occasional performance issues or frame drops but it happens so infrequently that it barely takes away from the overall experience.
    Jaw dropping visuals, incredibly rich and deep lore, gameplay is the best the souls series has seen and the bosses are some of the most impressive ever in gaming period.
    I sometimes died because of how cool, badass or    Only issue I have with this game is the occasional performance issues or frame drops but it happens so infrequently that it barely takes away from the overall experience.
    Jaw dropping visuals, incredibly rich and deep lore, gameplay is the best the souls series has seen and the bosses are some of the most impressive ever in gaming period.
    I sometimes died because of how cool, badass or beautiful some of the bosses were and it distracted me from dodging the brutal attacks.
    This is an open world done right, not just ticking off a checklist of things all generic open world tropes but it an actual well polished and thought out world, everything in it feels like it belongs and it feels so full of life and variety that after 70hours + of playing I'm still finding surprises and I see any sign of that stopping.
    FromSoftware have out done themselves and I believe this game will have a spot among one of the greatest games ever made and has a new stepping stone of what an open world can bring pushing the genre forward but also the gaming industry as a whole.
    The bar has been raised so high and after writing this review I'm gonna go play Elden Ring some more.
    As close to perfection as any game I've play thus far.    … Expand
  94. idbethrilled
    Mar 5, 2022
    8
    Don't listen to the cult, be fully warry of the game you are about to buy. I have fully enjoyed the game but I'm about half way through and frankly, I'm burned out it's just too repetitive.

    The Critics reviews for this game, are insane. Have they lost their **** minds? This game is the definition of quantity over quality. Why is this game immune to basic critiques other games get    Don't listen to the cult, be fully warry of the game you are about to buy. I have fully enjoyed the game but I'm about half way through and frankly, I'm burned out it's just too repetitive.

    The Critics reviews for this game, are insane. Have they lost their **** minds? This game is the definition of quantity over quality.

    Why is this game immune to basic critiques other games get ROASTED for? Its open world...is bad. Pure and simple. It's big? it's open? But it's 2022 and EVERY open world has to be more than just open and big. The level design is crude and linear. Choice in design amounts to "path with traps" or "path with no traps". To much of dungeons is walking on basic rooftops with no level design whatsoever on them. It's lazy. They should have cut the game in half and focused. Dungeons and villages are copy-paste, traps are crude, there is just too much yet so little outside of the combat.

    Which would be fine, if the game weren't acting like it was anything more than just combat.

    I honestly do really enjoy this game's gameplay, but for 2022...it's pretty subpar as far as diversity of offerings and complexity of systems. I've gotten about 1/2 the way through (I've done most everything up to entering the Capital and I'm level 90ish) and I'm pretty much burned out. The story, frankly, is just lore...that's it. You've got 1 real story going on and the rest is just set dressing to explain gameplay choices that were already present in Dark Souls...aka, it's not story. There is nothing compelling here. It's just beautiful metaphorical imagery that amounts to pretty much nothing narratively other than a loose allegory for life that's so vague and lacking in substance that it's just boring. They stole the death rune? Neat...what does that mean? That we can revive...that's it. The entire plot is just telling you why you are playing a dark souls game.

    At what point does "mysterious" end up just being "vague and empty"...because my experience has been thinking something was coming, and being disappointed OVER and OVER.

    I don't want quest logs or map icons telling me where to go, but this game won't even give you enough story context to tell you the next step in a quest. They just give you a dagger and say "give it to the person who owns it"...like what the actual ???? It's like they forgot to finish the game. I have spent a vast swathe of time playing this game, doing nothing but looking up the next step because the game gave me NOTHING and I'm not gonna waste my time searching for a needle in a haystack.

    I LOVE solving puzzles, I love piecing together information, I love open story design...my favorite game of all time is Outer Wilds. This game, just frankly sucks outside of the combat (which is still dated)...deeply. The horse controls are pretty mediocre and lack in clarity, bosses are all dodge spam and lack interesting mechanics (I can name like 3 bosses that actually felt neat but 1 of them was so bad at the same time I don't even want to mention him).

    I am TOTALLY FINE with how hard this game is...if anything it's the easiest dark souls ever. It's just only a dark souls game.

    I do think, for a Souls gamer...this game is gunna be a 10/10...don't hesitate. Buy it.

    But for me, a person who has played this kind of game before...I'm just not interested in more of the same.

    Being conservative, not pushing your game franchise to be more, that's not something that should be rewarded with the amount of praise this game is getting...there is SO MUCH this game franchise could do to bring out greater gameplay complexity while maintaining its unique stamp. Being open world isn't revolutionary. Not having basic UI elements isn't revolutionary. Telling a vague story badly isn't compelling. These are problems.

    This game is deeply overhyped...period. But so are many games, such as BOTW...which was also great in many categories while mediocre in others. However, BOTW was actually innovative. It took risks. This game is a singleplayer MMO from 2004 with better combat. Thats how crude it feels to engage with the world and story and level design. That has to count for SOMETHING in the score.

    So I'm sorry but I have to dock this game...it's not perfect, it lacks so much. In a RPG game market that is deeply more complex than this title I don't really see what it is doing so right that it warrants a 10/10...it's just doing so little and pumping out a lot...so that's all games have to be now? That's just what AC is doing and everyone docks AC?...and I like this more than AC...but how is this game dodging the basic criticism the industry applies to every other similar title?

    Sifu and Hades has done more to move the Dark Souls formula forward than FromSoft has...it's bad. This isn't the next BOTW, this is just another Dark Souls title. Don't be deluded by the hype    … Expand
  95. ssaammbb
    Mar 6, 2022
    10
    Greatest game I have ever played. It has all the classic soulsbourne elements and then some, and the most detail ed open world of any game.
  96. Ick91
    Mar 6, 2022
    10
    Sad to see all the low user reviews from players who probably never made it out of Lingrave. These games may not be for everyone but this specific entry is a masterpiece in my opinion. Could not recommend this game enough.
  97. rattt
    Mar 6, 2022
    9
    Simply incredible. This is the first Soulslike game I’ve played longer than a few hours. It’s great. Combat is fun, and the art direction is top notch.
  98. Chester12
    Mar 6, 2022
    10
    Obra maestra de fronsofware 80 horas de juego y no me cansa espero que sea el nuevo goty
  99. URGAMESUCKS_
    Mar 6, 2022
    8
    Ds3+Breath of the wild . Good game exept performance and its litteraly a copy paste of ds3 gameplay wise. Performance and bugs will prob be fixed in time but gameplay cant, Def not a masterpiece but a very good game, fans of souls will like i was just hoping for more innovation. PLZ FROM GIVE US SEKIRO 2
  100. Pickymoss420
    Mar 7, 2022
    10
    If you like demon souls than you're gonna love this! Alden Ring is amazing! The world is huge with so much to discover. The game is challenging, but it gives you all the weapons you need.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best Xbox Series X Game of 2022
1
#1 Most Discussed Xbox Series X Game of 2022

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
96

Universal acclaim - based on 19 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 19 out of 19
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 19
  3. Negative: 0 out of 19
  1. The Mako Reactor
    Apr 4, 2022
    95
    Despite some annoying performance issues, Elden Ring is a masterpiece. The combat, enemy variety, exploration, music, and open world are top notch. I’ve been playing it daily across all platforms alongside other games all month, and look forward to doing that all year as I try new builds, help friends, and try to do everything I want in this triumph of a video game.
    Read full review
  2. XboxAddict
    Mar 25, 2022
    100
    Elden Ring rewards your curiosity in many ways, be it items, runes or a pathway to another area, but mostly it’s a story to tell your friends when you are sharing tales around the bonfire. It does not force feed tutorials down your throat, but instead it leans far the opposite way by not telling you much at all and lets you explore and find things out on your own. There is no true quest log, no points of interest on a map or no arrows pointing you in the right direction, so there is a good chance you’ll miss some of the best caves and areas of the game. Because of all of this, Elden Ring is forcing me to find all of that out on my own and it is one of the most rewarding games I have ever played. I will continue to explore the Land Between for many hours to come. I’m just not in a hurry.
    Read full review
  3. MondoXbox
    Mar 14, 2022
    92
    Elden Ring manages to draw the player into a fascinating world for many hours, with refined gameplay that fits perfectly with the freedom granted to the player. A sumptuous but imperfect work, which fails to completely overcome some of the historical flaws of Hidetaka Miyazaki's productions. Flaws that, however, can't diminish the scope of a masterpiece destined to leave an indelible mark on the videogame world and to set new standards for the souls-like and open-world genres.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »