Middle-earth: Shadow of War

 PlayStation 4
User Score
4.9

Generally unfavorable reviews- based on 1686 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 665 out of 1686
  2. Mixed: 265 out of 1686
  3. Negative: 756 out of 1686
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. FewFew
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    Shadow of Mordor on steroids.

    Great game; these review bombing people haven't even touched the game which shows how immature the gaming community truly has become.

    Get it, worth a buy at full price. Don't buy the MTX's if you don't want to as they are NOT needed.
  2. alijarchiie
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    Guys i got this game 2 days ago and i found it great in every aspect so why zero everything improved i love the story . I love to be like a commander as commander Shepherd in mass effect and guide my army it feels good . maybe some fighting mechanic in the first chapter was better but it is great as a final
  3. saturday_youth
    Mar 29, 2018
    1
    So i bought the game with good will after reading a few reviews and thought to myself, man it can't be that bad. And of course it isn't at the beginning. It starts with a strong atmosphere that quickly shoots itself in the food with the terrible fan fiction approach to the tolkien universe. Spider transforms into women? New "the one Ring"? Ok so far so bad, i can get behind that. GameplaySo i bought the game with good will after reading a few reviews and thought to myself, man it can't be that bad. And of course it isn't at the beginning. It starts with a strong atmosphere that quickly shoots itself in the food with the terrible fan fiction approach to the tolkien universe. Spider transforms into women? New "the one Ring"? Ok so far so bad, i can get behind that. Gameplay counts in the end. The Combat delivers imo, so does the nemesis system. So far so good. But than it get's to the tokens that u use to buy the "LootBoxes", terribly designed, they float in the air like coins in a f2p running game. Full immersion break right there in your face. Same goes for the jewels (which will buff your weapons) and armor. Picking them up locks you in a terrible animation that takes way to long. Well designed? Not really.
    The Menus are even worse. They are uninspired and completely designed without the world of LotR in Mind. Easy to navigate? Yes but just not fun to look at. Besides this, it is fun to play but i've only played a few hours and the music already starts to get annoying. Then there are the "elven Soul arrows" who make annoying sounds which can't be turned off unlike the music and are nearly everywhere.

    So the game has everything it needed to succeed but somewhere along the line of development, something must have happened. Something bad that influenced gameplay and design. But let's end this on a good note: The World is beautifully designed.    … Expand
  4. samadhi2016
    Oct 18, 2017
    9
    I consider that metacritic should take urgent action against people who put zero (0) to a game causing great damage, many will be haters and other terrorist companies, a game is a play and however bad it may be may lead a 4 or 5 of note, but zero ?, I hope metacritic take this orientation pages as 3d games and are taking with the people hater, this game is a good game, in history,I consider that metacritic should take urgent action against people who put zero (0) to a game causing great damage, many will be haters and other terrorist companies, a game is a play and however bad it may be may lead a 4 or 5 of note, but zero ?, I hope metacritic take this orientation pages as 3d games and are taking with the people hater, this game is a good game, in history, playability and fulfills its mission… Expand
  5. axel64701
    Oct 19, 2017
    0
    Wow , this is like a ubisoft game, it's so boring,so repetitive ,so grindy..and ACT 4 is a disgrace to us all, just to take some bucks from microtransactions... very very low game, we have to discourage this type of games.
  6. INgUSRune
    Jan 11, 2019
    9
    9 of 10, why? 60+ hours of great gameplay - that's why! Seriously, I'm Tolkien fan, not so many thing in game lore arrange me, but storyline forged amazingly!
  7. PeterAlexander
    May 29, 2018
    9
    Shadow of War is an exciting and engaging sequel to the masterpiece that was the original. It expands the world and improves on the nemesis system.
  8. Kamarr
    Oct 24, 2017
    5
    This game is nowhere near a 10 nor is it a 0 pretty dumb how the gaming community is fighting between these two scores. So here is a real review.

    This game is an overhaul of the first game if you liked the first game then you will LOVE this one pretty much same controls and the game is fluid at times. I thoroughly enjoy the rag doll effects that happen sometimes really releases the    This game is nowhere near a 10 nor is it a 0 pretty dumb how the gaming community is fighting between these two scores. So here is a real review.

    This game is an overhaul of the first game if you liked the first game then you will LOVE this one pretty much same controls and the game is fluid at times. I thoroughly enjoy the rag doll effects that happen sometimes really releases the stress when fighting tons of enemies.
    The Nemesis system has been improved dramatically but the RNG of seeing descent orcs is very icky which tries to capture you into paying real money to get them quick Epic/Legendary Orcs.(I'll go more into that later.)
    They dubbed down the graphics engine but easily understandable as there are usually 15-25 orcs at a time on screen so better performance. There are some minor issues I have with some of the clunky controls like lets say I try to roll dodge away from an enemy instead I try to roll over an enemy that has vault breaker(can't roll over these orcs). Another thing is how great it is to climb just about anything now it does get lame at times cause more times than not as you chase some enemies it will cause you to climb a wall as you run through like an underpass which is ANNOYING as Im chasing an orc not trying to climb to Mt.Everest. The game seems to be crazy grindy once you hit lvl 45ish+ which is ok as the game is a lot longer than the first but the story is very short and usually only grants about 15lvls through all of them.

    Now to talk about End game and if you need super strong orcs for the last part of the game. The answer for it is no a good player can easily make a difference in how easy the game is and setting up proper equipment can help you out dramatically. Like I carry 3 different swords all aiming for a different thing. Same with Daggers and Chest piece. Also if you can get the lvl 20-30 cloak to drop that restores ALL health on stealth atk keep it forever!! As it doesn't drop at higher lvls. Now the whole idea buying orcs cause the RNG of orcs appearing in rarity is utter trash and it really kills the game for me but I managed to make common orcs work as long as they have only 2 weakness or just 1 cause it happens and they can be a great addition to the team if you don't wanna spend $$. Now spending $$ to get the high lvl orcs for ranked play is bs to heres an example. I spend 20usd and get an legendary orc army then go attack someone on Ranked play during the battle an orc you just BOUGHT dies there goes 5usd lost. They really need to fix this issue as its not ok to sell push to win buttons in a Single player game. But just about everything else this game hits silver for me. Seeing my Nemesis form the previous game was really worth it as he kicked my butt so much and my warchief that joined was AMAZING!!

    Now would I recommend buying this? Yes I would but I would stray away from Micro Transactions unless you do the daily quests and earn them that way. They really could have high 8-10 scores with this game but I feel they worked so painfully hard on the Micro Transactions they missed an amazing opportunity.    … Expand
  9. holiday_hawk
    Oct 18, 2017
    6
    I'd like to start by saying that micro-transactions have almost no affect on the game. I'm one trophy away from beating the game while platinuming it on PS4 and have not spent a cent on the game. If today's gaming community is foolish enough to buy them then I can't blame the developers for putting them in. With that said, Shadow of War is one of the most frustrating experiences I've hadI'd like to start by saying that micro-transactions have almost no affect on the game. I'm one trophy away from beating the game while platinuming it on PS4 and have not spent a cent on the game. If today's gaming community is foolish enough to buy them then I can't blame the developers for putting them in. With that said, Shadow of War is one of the most frustrating experiences I've had in a while. I had such high hopes going into to it after absolutely loving the first one (getting a platinum trophy on the regular and GOTY edition). Parts of SoW are really good, almost 9/10 good, but these parts are surrounded by a couple dozen hours of what is essentially frustrating time killer missions. There are far too many collectables, far too many missions for each faction, and the end-game fortress capture is horrible. I can't believe that when this game was playtested (and it's polished enough that I know it was well playtested) no one said "doing the same type of mission four times isn't fun, how about making fewer, but more memorable missions." If you're doing Gondor missions, be prepared to untie lots of soldiers, if you're doing Carnan missions be prepared to destroy lots of necromancer totems, and so on and so on. Without spoiling why, I'll just say that the final chapter of the game requires to defend your forts over and over again, each fort multiple times. This mechanic goes from amazing to beyond annoying so quickly. I found myself tired of it before the final act. The controls still need work, and this is unacceptable. The studio straight lifted the controls from Assassins' Creed, so they really only needed to fine tune AC's wonky controls. Instead, we're still left with controls that will have you climbing up walls when you don't want to, not climbing up walls when you want to, draining an orc off screen rather than the broken captain, and more. The worst part of all this is that buried in the middle of this tedious borefest is a great game. Some really fun, memorable missions are hidden in here. The new features such as pit fights and fort attacks are really fun at first too. It's only with an insane amount of repetition that they become aggravating. If you go into this game with a completionist mentality you're going to have a bad time. If you go into it thinking you'll just hit up the main story quest then it would be a really fun game. The developers should have left it a short, fun romp leaving you wanting more instead of a long, drawn out process leaving you wishing it was over.… Expand
  10. shiftyman
    Oct 27, 2017
    5
    Just on 20 hours in and it’s the most boring, repetitive game of 2017, there’s hardly any difference to the first one. The story is c grade trash. Zzzzzzzzz.
  11. Tsamblala
    Oct 22, 2017
    8
    The game is an ok improvement from the previous version. Most annoying thing in battle is to find an orc to drain or look for that damn elf shot.
    The Nemesis-system is not as amazing as they made it look. You cannot make friends with the orcs or make a choice between saving a follower or killing your nemesis, as was advertised.
    Overall an ok game but I personally expected much more.    The game is an ok improvement from the previous version. Most annoying thing in battle is to find an orc to drain or look for that damn elf shot.
    The Nemesis-system is not as amazing as they made it look. You cannot make friends with the orcs or make a choice between saving a follower or killing your nemesis, as was advertised.
    Overall an ok game but I personally expected much more.
    About the microtransactions, they aren't a necessity. I completed the game in 2 days and didn't even consider to buy anything. I don't like the MT but they didn't bother me because I was able to finish the game without them.    … Expand
  12. stash55
    Oct 25, 2017
    2
    I'm going to be blunt. If the market that's a critical component of the game is not bug-free, then don't release the game. I've given this game a 2 instead of 0 because in all fairness it's not easy to make a game, especially an open world game. As a gold edition purchaser I'm having issues with not receiving included content. Also, my market is bugged and breaks very frequently andI'm going to be blunt. If the market that's a critical component of the game is not bug-free, then don't release the game. I've given this game a 2 instead of 0 because in all fairness it's not easy to make a game, especially an open world game. As a gold edition purchaser I'm having issues with not receiving included content. Also, my market is bugged and breaks very frequently and randomly. Unless I restart the game, I don't have access of any kind to the market (server error). As you know, this means I can't deploy units in the army menu, which is a critical part of the game especially later on. I also don't receive gold after completing challenges ie I get notified that I've been awarded but the coins don't show up in the market. Hopefully these bugs are fixed soon but I can't change the rating here, it's just not acceptable to release a game in this condition.… Expand
  13. Gorka
    Mar 24, 2018
    0
    Nobody should buy this game, it is dreadful. Endless battles that are equal to the previous one. Go spend your money on a game that's worth it: Horizon: Zero Dawn. And I actually bought a ps4 to get the sequel to Shadow of Mordor. It ain't worth it.
  14. MeleeM
    Feb 24, 2020
    0
    Avoid PS4 version of this game. Hopelessly broken in Act II and cannot proceed with first fortress assault mission "The Etten". WBGames support is useless.
  15. JAX85
    Oct 11, 2017
    9
    Best 2017 open world action adventure game! Best story , best offline mode (i love story offline mode) best upgrading system , best graphic and best environment. If you love lord of rongs , you love Middle -Earth and you should buy this game! ❤
  16. Plopp00
    Oct 13, 2017
    9
    To all people giving this game 0/10 because of the microtransactions.

    Shut up and play the game before you give it a **** review. The microtransactions only helps you finnish the game earlier. You say that the critics says that evrything is great because they get paid to do it. But what if you took the time to actually analyze the games mechanics, gameplay and story. Then maybe    To all people giving this game 0/10 because of the microtransactions.

    Shut up and play the game before you give it a **** review.

    The microtransactions only helps you finnish the game earlier.

    You say that the critics says that evrything is great because they get paid to do it.
    But what if you took the time to actually analyze the games mechanics, gameplay and story. Then maybe you would pay them extra because the game is great with the nemesis system and the diffrent open-worlds you can explore.

    For you hating on the story for changing some of the lore to fit the story: THE GAMES AND THE STORYS ARE NOT CANON!!!!!!!!!!    … Expand
  17. logangood
    Oct 11, 2017
    9
    Don't listen to the people giving this a 1-5 or around that. I guarantee they they didn't even play the game. The game is a lot of fun especially if you liked the first one. The end game is not locked behind a paywall and the loot boxes you can get just by actually playing the game. The game doesn't even pressure you into buying any. Need gear? Kill some captains or do some vendetta andDon't listen to the people giving this a 1-5 or around that. I guarantee they they didn't even play the game. The game is a lot of fun especially if you liked the first one. The end game is not locked behind a paywall and the loot boxes you can get just by actually playing the game. The game doesn't even pressure you into buying any. Need gear? Kill some captains or do some vendetta and capture fortresses. The microtransactions don't even make a difference in the game.… Expand
  18. CastielX87
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    If you crying Wahhh Wahhh microtransactions blahh blahhh have not played the game you #Merica Reviews are not Valid. Trolls pff

    I love the game so far after 10hrs and have not needed your precious microtransactions. btw this is not the only game that has microtransactions. So i don't get all the Fake Reviews with 0's on them. It has been said by many legit reviews that you don't    If you crying Wahhh Wahhh microtransactions blahh blahhh have not played the game you #Merica Reviews are not Valid. Trolls pff

    I love the game so far after 10hrs and have not needed your precious microtransactions.

    btw this is not the only game that has microtransactions. So i don't get all the Fake Reviews with 0's on them.

    It has been said by many legit reviews that you don't need microtransactions to complete the game. Only if ur losers.
    And stop mimic youtube users that hate microtransactions    … Expand
  19. TheNpV
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    Dont even read guys who write about, loot-case and microtransaction system, u can play even without this stuff, u need it ONLY if u wanna finish game faster possible, no more. Microtransaction system is Unobtrusive, u can finish game easily without even opening "shop" window. I do rly respect the creators of this game, couse they fixed all problems from previous game, even some littleDont even read guys who write about, loot-case and microtransaction system, u can play even without this stuff, u need it ONLY if u wanna finish game faster possible, no more. Microtransaction system is Unobtrusive, u can finish game easily without even opening "shop" window. I do rly respect the creators of this game, couse they fixed all problems from previous game, even some little moments like parkour mechanics. You dont even need to grind much to finish game, like some one said previously. This game is damn great, even more then just great, its perfect, if u played Shadow of Mordor, and thinking to buy this part - u must do it!
    Sorry for my bad English.
    If u play this game, u will enjoy it, only guys who didnt played, saying something about microtransaction.    … Expand
  20. KaptainKrunch
    Oct 17, 2017
    9
    To be honest I have no idea what game these people with negative reviews are playing. I'm about 608 hours in and I have yet to even visit the micro transaction marketplace. ALSO, I have yet to hit a single grind wall where i can't level.

    Even if I play for an hour or so I usually go up at least one level and receive 3-5 pieces of good loot. Micro transactions in this game are like a    To be honest I have no idea what game these people with negative reviews are playing. I'm about 608 hours in and I have yet to even visit the micro transaction marketplace. ALSO, I have yet to hit a single grind wall where i can't level.

    Even if I play for an hour or so I usually go up at least one level and receive 3-5 pieces of good loot. Micro transactions in this game are like a bottle of ketchup on the table of a steakhouse; its really there to be considerate, no one actually expects you to use it.

    If you are re-considering playing this game I IMPLORE you to drown out the negative user reviews. I've been both a gamer and LOTR fan for 10+ years and I absolutely love this game. 10/10 would recommend, 10/10 will be playing for dozens of hours in the coming weeks. (only gave 9/10 because I don't believe in perfection)    … Expand
  21. MG05
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    I am not in habbit of writting long reviews but I just mention few points below.
    - The game is worth playing at least this year's best game and surely proved that as well in terms of all aspects, graphics ,story and gameplay.
    - For lootboxes which has became apple of discord for masses without any major reason as it does not effected the gameplay from any prespective as you can play    I am not in habbit of writting long reviews but I just mention few points below.
    - The game is worth playing at least this year's best game and surely proved that as well in terms of all aspects, graphics ,story and gameplay.
    - For lootboxes which has became apple of discord for masses without any major reason as it does not effected the gameplay from any prespective as you can play offline.
    - In the end go ahead dont just unllike the game beacuse of loot box thing.    … Expand
  22. Cherryleaf
    Oct 12, 2017
    8
    This is by no mean a perfect game, and I personally despise the very thought of Microtransaction's, but that does not make this game a bad one - cause this is by far no Pay-to-Win (not once have I felt compelled to buy anything for real money).

    Since seems that, not all of them, but many of those who gave the 0-3 score (and wow, there are a whole lot of them) and bash on the game in    This is by no mean a perfect game, and I personally despise the very thought of Microtransaction's, but that does not make this game a bad one - cause this is by far no Pay-to-Win (not once have I felt compelled to buy anything for real money).

    Since seems that, not all of them, but many of those who gave the 0-3 score (and wow, there are a whole lot of them) and bash on the game in their reviews, only lifts "Microtransactions" as their issue. Well, I can say this much - I got so much Mirian already early on, that I could easily spend a whole lot of it, and yet never feeling poor - cause like in other game’s with systems like this, the paid storefront here, feels less predatory and actually more like an unnecessary addition. The only difference (as I see it) is that the better and expensive chests just hands guaranteed better loot, but I personally rather get that in-game anyway.

    The GFX is gorgeous and the enviroments is stunning, as is the details on the Orc Generals/Officers, armor and weapons. The Nemesis system feels both familiar and improved since the first. The Skill-tree has some nice and awesomely helpful abilities, while others just feel "MEHH!!". Still there is variety enough that early on they matters, but later on you'll most likely have covered them all. Even though the Armor & Weapons looks neat and cool, but their abilities doesnt hand the same variety and awesomeness, also it becomes a tedious task to always be in need to un-lock their bonus abilities as soon as you get a better piece.

    The story is not all that compelling, but it doesn't bother me all that much since there is so many other things to do (some of the stuffs can after a while feel bit repetative). At its core it is a great experience, and for me personally, this game is a brilliant game that gives me more flesh and insight to one of the many untold stories in Middle Earth.    … Expand
  23. klaviernista
    Oct 10, 2017
    8
    Played a bit last night. Seems like Middle Earth, Shado of Mordor on steroids, which is a good thing IMO.

    For those of you bemoaning microtransactions in the game - there is a simple solution. Don't buy them. You don't need them to complete the game, and no one is forcing you to buy them. Its kind of like drugs. They are out there for sale, but no one is forcing you to seek them    Played a bit last night. Seems like Middle Earth, Shado of Mordor on steroids, which is a good thing IMO.

    For those of you bemoaning microtransactions in the game - there is a simple solution. Don't buy them. You don't need them to complete the game, and no one is forcing you to buy them. Its kind of like drugs. They are out there for sale, but no one is forcing you to seek them out and buy them. Panning an otherwise good game for the inclusion of microtransactions that are not required and aren't being implemented in a way to distract from gameplay is just stupid.    … Expand
  24. Prekkan
    Oct 11, 2017
    8
    All this negativity for microtransactions Is starting to get old. I personally don't care If you can buy yourself a legendary army from minute 1 or not. As long as It doesn't make the game impossible to complete without, It's not an issue. It's a option If you want to purchase the boxes or not. But onto the review!

    For the few hours I've played, I absolutely love It. All the new skills,    All this negativity for microtransactions Is starting to get old. I personally don't care If you can buy yourself a legendary army from minute 1 or not. As long as It doesn't make the game impossible to complete without, It's not an issue. It's a option If you want to purchase the boxes or not. But onto the review!

    For the few hours I've played, I absolutely love It. All the new skills, equipment's and mechanics for the captains Is just so much fun. New various puzzle solving makes you interact more with the collectables. Even added quotes from the books that you have to solve! If you liked Shadow of Mordor, you're gonna love Shadow of War. It's the same idea with a lot more content. Worth all the money.    … Expand
  25. bcdserra
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    I'm having a lot of fun with this game, MT's or not. Gameplay, locations, atmosphere, graphics, I'm having a blast ! There have been more games with hard grinds to get endgame stuff this year, this one just gives you the choice to pay for it or not. I won't. I've grinded out Nier's true ending and +8 chips, I've grinded out Zelda's lvl 4 armors, I've grinded out Nioh's max level divineI'm having a lot of fun with this game, MT's or not. Gameplay, locations, atmosphere, graphics, I'm having a blast ! There have been more games with hard grinds to get endgame stuff this year, this one just gives you the choice to pay for it or not. I won't. I've grinded out Nier's true ending and +8 chips, I've grinded out Zelda's lvl 4 armors, I've grinded out Nioh's max level divine weapons. None of those gave me the option to pay for them. I do it because I like it. The option being there does not bother me one bit. I'll just work hard to get the best gear and max lvl orcs and if someone else wants to pay to have that it's their problem.… Expand
  26. BatmansLavaLamp
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    With the short amount of time I've been able to play Shadow of War I'm already blown away- Compared to the first game, the visuals are a masterpiece. The opening cinematic is fantastic, with a style that could be mistaken for an animation feature film. This is probably because the first game had to be ported for PS3 as well as PS4, so the graphics on PS4 had to be sacrificed.
    The gameplay    With the short amount of time I've been able to play Shadow of War I'm already blown away- Compared to the first game, the visuals are a masterpiece. The opening cinematic is fantastic, with a style that could be mistaken for an animation feature film. This is probably because the first game had to be ported for PS3 as well as PS4, so the graphics on PS4 had to be sacrificed.
    The gameplay and animations feel so much more fluid than Shadow of Mordor. Don't get me wrong, SOM had incredible gameplay, but it always felt like it was lacking in variety, with only a couple different animations for each combo. SOW has outdone itself in terms of gameplay mechanics.
    Also, when you think of games like Destiny (for comparison, no bias), the sequel was very good in its own right, but it wasn't that much of an improvement from the first game. Shadow of War, however, has absolutely smashed this sequel out of the park. The map is massive, with the in-menu world map being 3D rendered. New mechanics, combat moves, Uruk variation, enemy types and environment settings. It has a much more flushed out nemesis system, and RPG elements never before seen in SOM. The progression feels perfectly paced, with the story starting a little while after the events of SOM.
    As for the story, I cannot say, as I have not played anywhere near enough of it. But just from the opening few missions, I can already say that it is going to be one to remember.
    In terms of accuracy in the LOTR universe, the names of places, the placement and map generation, and even time- they're all perfectly flushed out and thought about carefully. As a massive LOTR fan, I am not disappointed by how they have portrayed the game.
    In conclusion, this game has definitely been worth my money and time, and I cannot wait to play more of it. WB and Monolith have not failed to impress, as always.    … Expand
  27. aory
    Oct 10, 2017
    8
    This is a great game, all the loot box whiners haven't got a clue. Play the game, play the quests, follow the story and side quests and there isn't much to complain about. Its no 10/10 but it is overall pretty good.

    Loot boxes are pretty fail, but not necessary. As usual, they are for the lazy gamer, just like all the garbage reviews.
  28. PsychoNinja69
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    This game is amazing. People spamming 0 and 1 star reviews are just mad because they aren't good enough at the game to enjoy it. If you enjoyed the first game or The Witcher 3 than you will love this game.
  29. knightwhosaysni
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    Ok let me just say one thing here: If you don't want to have the end be so grindy and **** like people are **** about, then don't power through the game. And for **** sake, would you all just shut up about the **** microtransactions. I don't like them either, which is why I AM NOT BUYING ANY **** LOOTBOXES, Besides everything I have read about them says that if you actually invest timeOk let me just say one thing here: If you don't want to have the end be so grindy and **** like people are **** about, then don't power through the game. And for **** sake, would you all just shut up about the **** microtransactions. I don't like them either, which is why I AM NOT BUYING ANY **** LOOTBOXES, Besides everything I have read about them says that if you actually invest time into the game then the lootboxes are completely unnecessary.

    Now that that is out of the way: I **** love this game already. I've defeated a **** ton of captains already and each and every one was unique and fun to fight against, required different tactics, and had different personalities.

    The combat is pretty much the same as the first game, but that's a very good thing here. The first game had amazing combat and this is no different. Its very similar to games like Assassins Creed or Batman: Arkham Asylum. One thing I love that Monolith has added to the game is dismembering enemies. It happens at random but man does it look cool when it happens.

    I like all the RPG elements that were added also. Captains, and warchiefs now drop loot that you can add to Talion to customize him as you see fit. They are also able to be broken down into Mirian, the games in game currency to buy things like gem slots for your gear.

    I haven't made it out of the first area yet, but that's because it is just jam packed with things to do and also because i want to level up my character so he isn't underpowered later on in the game. One of such things is clearing out all of the captains from the army screen. I like to think of it as sowing chaos among the ranks of Orcs, because whats an army without its captains?

    All in all, I am having a fantastic time with this game. I'll be giving an update later in the game though to see if my feelings changed.    … Expand
  30. GamerFLAG12
    Oct 11, 2017
    9
    TL;DR, unless you want to read an honest review. High five at the end.

    For everyone going through looking at reviews, please ignore these Metacritic user reviews giving the game a 0 score. All of them are people complaining about microtransactions, without even playing the actual game and reviewing it based on what it's worth. ($60, same as every other game out there) Having played    TL;DR, unless you want to read an honest review. High five at the end.

    For everyone going through looking at reviews, please ignore these Metacritic user reviews giving the game a 0 score. All of them are people complaining about microtransactions, without even playing the actual game and reviewing it based on what it's worth. ($60, same as every other game out there)

    Having played nearly 15 hours of the game already, I've been having a blast. I was a big fan of the original, and this game was an on-the-fence buy for me due to time, but honestly, do not regret buying it at all. More than enough content and nowhere near the end still, also I've only explored two regions to this point, imagine all that I have left to do and explore.

    Microtransactions play such a small part in the game; you can probably get 60 hours of game time without even considering or looking at them, according to most people that have put in that amount of time since getting their early copies. The only benefit you get from them is getting higher ranked orcs, which you can do in the game yourself, better-ranked gear, which you can get in the game, and some XP/loot bonuses, which you can't get in the game, but don't make it that game breaking.

    The gameplay has been thoughtfully tweaked from the first game, based on player feedback over the past years, making the combat system more fluid and diverse. You can have different combat styles now, ranging from assassin to warrior to archer to a mix of all three and more. (personal favorite is Mount Rider, love my Caragors) All skills benefit from so many new additions or tweaks that it plays like the previous iteration while bringing in a whole new truckload of options. (i.e., Poisoning Grog Barrels from afar, then shooting them to cause an explosion, resulting in a poison-proof captain cheating death and hunting me down)

    The story is going to be either a hit or miss for some people, it is genuinely exciting and brings new lore to LoTR, people saying there is no lore or story are incredibly wrong and probably lazy enough to skip all the conversations and lore items found throughout the world. I have barely done some of the story missions and have found myself immersed in the game's story and it drives me to continue. Obviously, there are going to be sure things that don't make sense at first *cough* Shelob *cough* but give them time to explain it in the story, and it falls in place making it all the more entertaining.

    Graphics are a step up from the first game, some of the reviews on here have said they are awful and the reduced resolution. I have played both the PS4, PS4 Pro and Xbox One versions (PS4 being my main copy) and on all three consoles, it looked great, with some apparent advantages on PS4 Pro for textures and the overall fps rate. Someone on here went as far as to say the original games graphics were better, which is entirely crazy. Apparently, this user had both games playing side by side to make this comparison, because from what I've seen they are a definite improvement over the original.

    Grinding is another big thing people are complaining on. Most of these players don't care for having to grind; they are just using it to bolster further their hate of microtransactions, which once again are not necessary and you can ignore entirely. If you are playing a game in this day and age without some grinding, then I'd like to know what it is because most games (good ones at that) have grinding implemented in some way. (i.e., Borderlands, MGSV, Diablo, Overwatch, Dark Souls, Witcher, Nioh and much more) For most of the people complaining about grinding, please do understand that RPG/ARPG video games that have endgame content or open worlds aren't going to give you a never-ending story unless you plan to pay them. ("DLC! Oh no I have to spend money for more! Unthinkable!" -Most of the Negative Reviewers) Now, this is where the loot and nemesis systems and oodles of side missions come in, to give players a goal to get better loot and keep coming back to take on stronger enemies. If you don't like those systems, then you shouldn't be playing games built mainly for looting or open-world adventure, which is done exceptionally well in this game.

    See I haven't gotten to the end quite yet, but friends and professional reviewers I know have gotten to the end have not complained about a single thing, other than a lack of a stellar ending. So people complaining about all these issues are either nitpicky gamers expecting $60 to be a lifetimes worth of gaming in 2017 or plain crazy.

    Make your own opinions, buy the game and play it, because it honestly is a great game. Most people complaining about microtransactions are merely doing so because they feel compelled to buy these to compete with other players, who do this as well.

    Will be playing this for the next couple of weeks or months.

    Thanks for reading, hope it helps, here is your high five ( O.O)/    … Expand
  31. ptea
    Oct 12, 2017
    9
    I would want to be strong when it comes to microtransactions and I am not going to go for even a dime extra. It's enough to pay 60€ for a game and it should be if we are reasonable. Still even if these things make me angry, it's a fact that this is a great game. If you loved the first one, you are going to love this one also. I hope that game publishing would change to normal and thisI would want to be strong when it comes to microtransactions and I am not going to go for even a dime extra. It's enough to pay 60€ for a game and it should be if we are reasonable. Still even if these things make me angry, it's a fact that this is a great game. If you loved the first one, you are going to love this one also. I hope that game publishing would change to normal and this greed would stop. I think that only way to do that is to rebel against it. I could not rebel in a way that I would leave this game from ny collection but I wont buy anything but the normal version of this game. Stop buying anything extra, make developers and publishers know that you are angry. Still no reason to hate this game for it's contents without the greed it has lots to offer… Expand
  32. work_hard
    Oct 18, 2017
    10
    sim o jogo é bom, pessoal está hateando o jogo pelo fato de microtransações, vale a pena a compra, principalmente se você gostou do primeiro e este é uma continuação perfeita, pois está tudo melhorado, o sistema nemesis , muito mais horas de jogo, a história melhorou na minha opinião, quem gosta do universo do senhor dos anéis vai amar, alguns pontos pode não gostar se for um fã muitosim o jogo é bom, pessoal está hateando o jogo pelo fato de microtransações, vale a pena a compra, principalmente se você gostou do primeiro e este é uma continuação perfeita, pois está tudo melhorado, o sistema nemesis , muito mais horas de jogo, a história melhorou na minha opinião, quem gosta do universo do senhor dos anéis vai amar, alguns pontos pode não gostar se for um fã muito exigente , mas sim sombras da guerra é um excelente jogo e espero mais jogos dessa franquia.… Expand
  33. GReviews
    May 2, 2018
    9
    Overall I would say this game is a real gem. If you liked the original you should play this game. If you like Lord of the Rings you should play this game. If you like Assassin's Creed or Arkham Asylum you should play this game. Basically, you should play this game.
  34. Azula-1994
    Oct 12, 2017
    7
    Shadow of War...

    Gameplay: The gameplay in Shadow of War is brilliant, I never get tired of killing orcs, Uruk's and other enemies, there are so many different combat options you can use to take down your foe. Graphics: The Graphics aren't terrible but I don't really see any improvement compared to Shadow of Mordor. Story: The story is way over the top and as much as they tried to    Shadow of War...

    Gameplay: The gameplay in Shadow of War is brilliant, I never get tired of killing orcs, Uruk's and other enemies, there are so many different combat options you can use to take down your foe.

    Graphics: The Graphics aren't terrible but I don't really see any improvement compared to Shadow of Mordor.

    Story: The story is way over the top and as much as they tried to tie into the trilogy it just doesn't make much sense.

    Do the Microtransactions take anything away from the game? the answer is yes and no. The game overall is solid, but the microtransactions and loot-crates are in the game and are very noticeable. The biggest issue is the end game where the ending is locked behind tedious grinding defending all of your forts successfully or you can fast track that by buying legendary orcs/uruks/trolls... overall at its core it is a great game that has lost part of its soul by corporate greed.    … Expand
  35. Tru3_Canad1an
    Feb 6, 2021
    0
    **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games **** you WB games
  36. Steve4500
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    For anyone with a genuine interest in this game it is worth noting straight away that you do NOT need to buy micro transactions in this game. For people who play the game how its supposed to be played (not powering through it and trying to complete in 15 hours) then your character and orc army will be more than capable to get through the final few acts.
  37. Lord_V
    Oct 13, 2017
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Middle-Earth: Shadow of War is not just the best Lord of the Rings game, it is one of the best games ever made. Easily GOTY 2017.
    It takes what made previous game, Shadow of Mordor, so great and doubles everything, at minimum. It does everything better.

    Story follows Talion (Troy Baker ) and Celebrimbor (Alistair Duncan), after the events of first game. They create new ring and aim to conquer all of Mordor. Same time, Dark Lord's forces gather all around them preparing for the final battle, that will decide the fate of whole of MIddle-Earth.

    Story is very well written and has several absolutely fantastic twist on the way to end. There are several absolutely marvelous characters and atmosphere is just what it should be.

    This is also pretty long game, but it is not too long or repetitive. Certain basic gameplay elements are there whole time. Nemesis system is the big deal and orcs come in so many diffrent shapes and skills. Combat does not get boring, it is very engaging, thanks to one of the best combat mechanics ever created. It is easy to learn but difficult to master.

    There is also so many those little things that really make this game that good. There is so many lore in there to be found. Many artifacts have story of their own and many very famous characters also have so much more story in them.
    I must say that the first time Witch-King of Angmar emerged from the shadows, was absolutely fantastic moment and boss battle is one of the best ever in so many ways. One thing I would change thou is the fact that his weapons are not that good. Sure, it is loyal to the source material, but I would have added a sword for him and made his weapon look more different from Saurons (like in the movie).

    To point out few of the worst things in game, first that comes to mind is pit fights. Those are so bad and boring. To a certain point those are not even that difficult but champion level is brutal and that is the point when you are furious when you see how incompetent those orcs are. They do not do what they are suppose to do.
    Also, micro transactions, cancer of gaming. It is there, but you do not have to use it. Sure, its makes the game easier but I managed very well without it.
    Also, there is certain community points in game, but I really do not care about those and paid little to no attention to it.

    There is so much I could comment about the game but the best way is to experience it yourself. This is masterpiece, nothing less. I got myself Gold version just to get all DLC Expansions. I am huge LotR fan and this game delivers so much.

    + Combat mechanic
    + Nemesis system
    + Story
    + Atmosphere
    + Talion / Troy Baker

    - Some minor details

    95/100

    Masterpiece    … Expand
  38. Caruat
    Oct 20, 2017
    10
    Do not read the negative reviews of users. They are devoid of arousal and are thrown against a play masterpiece only for unnecessary and completely optional microtransmissions! But do you realize that by doing so, you just do not mind a great single player game? This is a masterpiece game and a possible candidate at GOTY 2017. 10 full and praise.
  39. medv4380
    Oct 20, 2017
    10
    This is a Pay-to-Cheat game. Not unusual if you remember the 80's gaming 1-900 hint lines. This is not a Pay-to-Win but depending on how you play may have that appearance. Once I unlocked the primary areas and could control an Army I started clearing out all the little collectible and side quests. While I did this it did seems like maybe there would be an intense grind in a few areas thatThis is a Pay-to-Cheat game. Not unusual if you remember the 80's gaming 1-900 hint lines. This is not a Pay-to-Win but depending on how you play may have that appearance. Once I unlocked the primary areas and could control an Army I started clearing out all the little collectible and side quests. While I did this it did seems like maybe there would be an intense grind in a few areas that seemed like I just wasn't strong enough. However, once I got back onto the primary quest line it leads me back into the area that I hadn't concerned that was more level appropriate and not grindy at all. If you are too aggressive and Kill the captains on the quests instead of recruiting you could easily turn it into a nasty grind. For those who only want to kill captains and not play the game as intended this could be seen as a Pay-to-Win, but you just need to use the Free in game currency to repopulate the dead captains. Even the Legendary Loot boxes are possible if you complete the Online Revenge quests to get the higher tier currency for FREE. You could also allow yourself to be killed to quickly repopulate if you find yourself low on currency, but I've not had this problem.

    Because of my play style the games very enjoyable, and won't require any additional purchases past the original game purchase. Though I'll probably consider future DLC expansions.    … Expand
  40. ryanjolly1
    Oct 13, 2017
    7
    People giving this a 0 because there's microtransactions. If they actually played the game they would know they are absolutely unnecessary and you don't have to buy crates to win, it's not pay to win, it's pay to get stronger.
    The story is fantastic, which is obviously expected from one of the biggest franchises in modern history. The combat is still in my opinion the best combat out    People giving this a 0 because there's microtransactions. If they actually played the game they would know they are absolutely unnecessary and you don't have to buy crates to win, it's not pay to win, it's pay to get stronger.
    The story is fantastic, which is obviously expected from one of the biggest franchises in modern history. The combat is still in my opinion the best combat out there in gaming, very fast, very slick. The loot change was needed in my opinion from the first one. Where you just got runes to upgrade your gear, you now drop new weapons and armour, along with upgrades and runes to make them more powerful.
    The reason I gave this an 7 and not a 10 is simply because of it's price tag, yes, microtransactions and bugs. $60 for a single player game with very small multiplayer implementations, and that's only the base game. You'll need to fork out extra for expansions if you didn't buy the higher editions of the game. It's wrong to have microtransactions, but, they aren't something you need to buy to beat the game, yes you need to grind for better gear to be able to finish the game, but overall, it's something to give you a boost, nothing more. BUT, having said that, WB are a disgrace, and being a multi billion dollar publisher, it's very wrong to ask for MORE money like they are, especially when you have 3 editions of your game.
    So, to the people giving this game a 0 simply because of MT's, you're idiots who simply haven't even played the game, who're following the crowd because it's not "cool" to hate on video games without even using the brain you was given.    … Expand
  41. louco_por_games
    Oct 18, 2017
    10
    microtransações gerou um hater pesado, não acho legal ter microtransações em um jogo, isso deve ser criticado, mas o jogo está excelente, não merece tanta negativo assim pelos users, o jogo não tem bugs que atrapalhem a jogatina, está fluindo legal, combate melhorado, adições boas para a continuação , vale a pena compra se você gostou do primeiro jogo sim.
  42. Munka48
    Oct 18, 2017
    9
    While I agree the loot boxes are annoying, you can easily earn Mirian in game by destroying old weapons that you will no longer use. THIS IS NOT an excuse, but the silver loot boxes can be bought this way alleviating the grind.

    THIS ASIDE, the game is good, the game is actually great! The story may branch off the LOTR lore and story, but the story is fun! I liked it as much flak as it    While I agree the loot boxes are annoying, you can easily earn Mirian in game by destroying old weapons that you will no longer use. THIS IS NOT an excuse, but the silver loot boxes can be bought this way alleviating the grind.

    THIS ASIDE, the game is good, the game is actually great! The story may branch off the LOTR lore and story, but the story is fun! I liked it as much flak as it gets for being cheesy. The new nemesis system is awesome and feels scripted with how specific and detailed the dialogue can be, that is a good thing! Overlords are cool and very difficult but the fortress sieges can be a little easy to rush through. You literally just walk into a point and hit down on the d pad.
    That aside though the game does a good job in making you feel powerful but also challenged. The regions are appropriately sized and add flavor to the selection. The clear focus here is game play and mechanics, so if you like games that are very video gamey you should enjoy this.    … Expand
  43. bprotond
    Oct 17, 2017
    8
    Every single reviewer here has not played the game and is just complaining about the loot boxes. The game can be played and finished without the use of the lootboxes, all they give you is better gear and some legendary lords to build an army with. Although I dislike the idea of the lootboxes, people are blowing this out of proportion.
    i just completed on nemesis difficulty without ever    Every single reviewer here has not played the game and is just complaining about the loot boxes. The game can be played and finished without the use of the lootboxes, all they give you is better gear and some legendary lords to build an army with. Although I dislike the idea of the lootboxes, people are blowing this out of proportion.
    i just completed on nemesis difficulty without ever putting any extra money into the game and the "grinding" is not necessary, playing the game normally had me at lvl 43 at the final zone where the recommended level was 40.
    The game is pretty much a copy of the previous one with many improvements. Every single upgrade you get when leveling has 3 subcategories to improve the skill. Killing captains now drops gear instead of runes (runes have been simplified and are dropped by regular orcs), 5 regions compared to the 2 of the previous game.
    The game is really fun and as a LotR fan i thoroughly enjoyed it, even if the story doesn't really follow actual LotR lore.    … Expand
  44. nicden70
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    The game is amazing. Haven't touched a loot box. Have like 9000 mirian saved up. Not necessary to use. Like the first game but with cleaner gameplay. The story is fantastic. Lord of the Rings fan dream come true.
  45. c9sasza
    Oct 14, 2017
    9
    I just finished the game and won the platinum trophy in less than 40 hours, the box system is useless and pushed to the force do not understand the complaints and criticism, I do not support it but this system is not intrusive, this is the best game in the universe of Tolkien.
  46. Ethn94
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    Don’t listen too all the hate because of micro transactions, they are seriously OPTIONAL. If you loved the first game then you will love this one even Moore.
  47. coku09
    Nov 2, 2017
    10
    Top nice! Really like it, I understand why people are frustrated with the in game purchases but i don't mind spending a few euros on the microtransactions for a better time :)
  48. TheGamerKnight
    Oct 23, 2017
    9
    Is this a good game? Yes. It's fantastic. If you loved Shadow of Mordor, you won't be disappointed. If you played The Witcher, you won't be disappointed.

    So what's with all of the negative reviews? Well, it's because of the microtransactions. It's just losers review-bombing the game as an act of protest. It's stupid and shouldn't be allowed. Take a look at all of the reviews. Not ONE of    Is this a good game? Yes. It's fantastic. If you loved Shadow of Mordor, you won't be disappointed. If you played The Witcher, you won't be disappointed.

    So what's with all of the negative reviews? Well, it's because of the microtransactions. It's just losers review-bombing the game as an act of protest. It's stupid and shouldn't be allowed. Take a look at all of the reviews. Not ONE of them has a legitimate reason for rating the game poorly (maybe a couple do, but the others are ALL because of microtransactions). Just look at some of these: "Loot boxes are not allowed in the 60$ game!" "Game ruined by microtransactions." "Microtransactions." It's all bullcrap. You should absolutely buy this game. The gameplay is highly addicting, it's loads of fun...I'm not gonna lie, the story is pretty lacking, but other than that, the game is fantastic. Don't listen to those tools review-bombing this game because of the microtransactions. Don't want them? Just don't buy them.    … Expand
  49. Gouldfish44
    Oct 12, 2017
    10
    LOL my review was deleted because I called out all the ass hats giving this a 0.

    Behold! My 10/10 score has been restored! The game is better than the first, the microtransactions are in the background and not forced at you, and you certainly do not need them to beat the game. People are just following the crowd. Play it for yourself before posting a 0 just for the sake of it.
  50. PULKEMONTHE
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    the good: big game a very open world very interesting story great gameplay and unforgettable game mechanics
    the bad: microtransactions that ruin the expreriencia for those who acquire it and bitter those who can afford it
  51. Superman311288
    Nov 5, 2017
    9
    Great game with epic gameplay and nemesis system.. only annoying is the microtransactions in the game. I was not present in the previous game .. now its only about season pass and microtransaction.
  52. lolifofo
    Nov 22, 2017
    6
    Having played and loved Shadow of Mordor, I was very disappointed in this sequel, mainly due to the campaign, which is so short and fragmented, it is practically non-existent. The game-play is fun like in the original game, and with a few new added elements, but it is not enough to make up for the lackluster narrative. Another huge flaw is the last act in the campaign, which is theHaving played and loved Shadow of Mordor, I was very disappointed in this sequel, mainly due to the campaign, which is so short and fragmented, it is practically non-existent. The game-play is fun like in the original game, and with a few new added elements, but it is not enough to make up for the lackluster narrative. Another huge flaw is the last act in the campaign, which is the grindiest portion I've played in any video game, regardless of whether or not you purchase loot boxes with real money. I didn't, and it didn't affect my experience whatsoever because you collect enough in-game currency as you play to get those loot boxes. You certainly don't need to spend real money. For those who played Shadow of Mordor; don't get Shadow of War unless you REALLY love brutally killing orcs because that's all you're getting here. It lacks the epic and fun experience and novelty of the original. For those who haven't played the original yet, just go get it and skip this one.… Expand
  53. Nubosis
    Nov 17, 2017
    9
    This game is very addictive, it builds up from its great predecessor (Shadow of Mordor) and adds a lot of content and gimmicks along, its better than the first one and it's very enjoyable, it gets old the tribe-oriented theme, maybe it gets better with the dlcs, maybe not, it's worth the full price and more if you like (maybe not if you are hardcore fan) LOTR.
  54. notlaw
    Nov 8, 2017
    7
    shadow of war loot box arrrhhh score 0-0-0-0- haha I dont play online say I can happily say I didn't encounter any of it. The game itself is more or less just as good as the last the orcs themselves dont look quite as polished but with alot more variety it doesn't really matter. the story is abit of a hit and a miss but so was the last one. Shame about the massive grind wall at the endshadow of war loot box arrrhhh score 0-0-0-0- haha I dont play online say I can happily say I didn't encounter any of it. The game itself is more or less just as good as the last the orcs themselves dont look quite as polished but with alot more variety it doesn't really matter. the story is abit of a hit and a miss but so was the last one. Shame about the massive grind wall at the end that is what made me give it a 7 and not higher. Making you either pay or grind is really a poor decision by the developers but does it make this game a zero? Nah.… Expand
  55. Hemp316
    Nov 16, 2017
    9
    People on here are complete and utter idiots!This game is extremely fun and innovative and all people can talk about is Loot Boxes which in no way is necessary to play the game.Every zero I see lends me to believe most of these people have never even played the game.For once the Critics are correct and the people have absolutely no idea what hell they are talking about!
  56. Hectik
    Nov 12, 2017
    8
    In my opinion, this is a big improvement from Shadow of Mordor.

    Amassing a large army and assaulting fortresses and very challienging and defending them every now and then is also very fun. New enemies and allies like the Olog Hais and Drakes to fly through the landscapes. Combat is more polished and the Nemesis system has a couple of surprises like being saved by a rogue Orc when    In my opinion, this is a big improvement from Shadow of Mordor.

    Amassing a large army and assaulting fortresses and very challienging and defending them every now and then is also very fun.

    New enemies and allies like the Olog Hais and Drakes to fly through the landscapes.

    Combat is more polished and the Nemesis system has a couple of surprises like being saved by a rogue Orc when you're about to be finished off by the Captain (that rogue orc sometimes kills your would be killer).

    The micro transactions are there but I haven't played long enough for it to be an issue so far. I've been getting Legendary and Epic followers so far without buying them.

    The story is still not very interesting but the human version of Shelob is a welcome change to her portrayal on the LOTR movies. Too bad it was too short.

    Still a great game. Don't be turned off on all the 0s from idiots who probably haven't played the game to completion and just complain about the microtransactions being there.    … Expand
  57. Kevan
    Nov 7, 2017
    9
    yes, canon lore is totally subverted. yes, it's grindy at the last act. yes, there are some graphical glitches. Still, great graphics, great gameplay, clever nemesis system. and nope, microtransactions are worthless, actually nobody asks you money. don't miss it, it's definitely 9/10 and a goty
  58. Bob_Paulson
    Nov 9, 2017
    7
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I'm very happy with this game except for 2 very distinct reasons:

    The Captain and War Chief endless speeches become very annoying. There needs to be a way to disable this "feature". A little bit is fine, but some of these bosses go on FOREVER.

    The second issue I have and is a huge let down for me is Act 4: Shadow Wars. It's just a series of defending your territories over and over and over again. This is just plain STUPID. If you want to play a never ending campaign of defending your castles, that's fine. Add it as an option. But to be part of the actual story line is a huge let down for an otherwise fantastic game. I feel like this was just added as filler and has no real purpose nor adds any value to the game itself. If the story is essentially ended after Act 3, then why add this? It really makes no logical sense.

    Honestly, the micro transactions really don't mean anything to me. I really don't care if it's there or not. I'm not going to spend any additional money on this game and I really don't have to pay attention to it if I want. I do spend the in game Miriin to add new Captains to my armies. But that's it.

    This game started out with a fantastic premise and has a great story line to continue the tale of Talion. But in the end I feel it falls way short of the original game Shadow of Mordor. I feel that scoring it as a 7 is a bit generous, but the overall game play is every bit as fantastic as the first game and what story there is, is also very well done. No game is perfect, but what's odd here is the game designers gave us too much of a good thing. For me the game is equal parts over the top good and over the top bad. In this case, a little bit less of both would have made a much better overall game.    … Expand
  59. Nycore
    Nov 21, 2017
    10
    This is the best Lord of the Ring game you do not need to buy any loot boxes to obtain stuff more quickley. **** the haterssssssssssssssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  60. Poonishar
    Nov 23, 2017
    8
    Quality game. I enjoyed the first games ideas, but found it too long to get going- this game does not waste any time and thrusts you straight into the fun which is awesome, I found it hard to put the pad down, it feels like a revenge game to start with due to the need to hunt down the last Orc that took you down, feels great once you then get your revenge. Missions are also good andQuality game. I enjoyed the first games ideas, but found it too long to get going- this game does not waste any time and thrusts you straight into the fun which is awesome, I found it hard to put the pad down, it feels like a revenge game to start with due to the need to hunt down the last Orc that took you down, feels great once you then get your revenge. Missions are also good and there's been some hate for the micro transactions but they are totally avoidable so pay no attention to that and don't let it put you off either from what is a supremely fun game. Solid 8/10… Expand
  61. Hokyshirt
    Nov 19, 2017
    6
    Overall great game, but just skip act 4 and watch the 'true' ending on youtube, because it's not worth the grindfest. Acts 1-3? FANTASTIC. Act 44? I mean, if you have nothing better to play for the next four months, go for it. It's still the same keep seiges and defenses as before, but you can only do the same thing in the same 4 areas so many time before it just gets dull, and the endingOverall great game, but just skip act 4 and watch the 'true' ending on youtube, because it's not worth the grindfest. Acts 1-3? FANTASTIC. Act 44? I mean, if you have nothing better to play for the next four months, go for it. It's still the same keep seiges and defenses as before, but you can only do the same thing in the same 4 areas so many time before it just gets dull, and the ending you get from all that work is just not worth it.
    This isn't a terrible game, but Act 4 almost ruins all the awesome stuff about the rest of it. Without act 4, I'd give it a 9. With Act 4, I'd give it a 6.    … Expand
  62. CaptainPuGDoG
    Nov 16, 2017
    7
    Loot boxes,Loot boxes,Loot boxes,Loot boxes,Loot boxes,Loot boxes,or Grinding Grinding Grinding Grinding Grinding Grinding
    But this game have interesting story 8,and beautiful animation 8,and this fight animation only one,because of this, it is time to spend on Grinding
    World 5 all game design so primitive and unremarkable
  63. Targayrean
    Oct 12, 2017
    7
    It's such a good game it's such a shame they would cheapen it with micro transactions... It could be a 10/10 it nicely develops from the last game but I am almost ashamed myself for supporting such a cheap cash crab. I am glad people are taking a stand but I've now put a couple of hours in and I don't see a reason why it's needed- I would play with out them for a great game.
  64. mikepatyaev
    Dec 21, 2022
    4
    Experience an epic open world brought to life by the Nemesis System. Forge a new Ring of Power, conquer Fortresses in massive battles and dominate Mordor with your personal orc army in Middle-earth: Shadow of War
  65. Dog3117
    Nov 6, 2017
    5
    Short and sweet
    -Horrible Story with characters that range from horrible to somewhat promising
    -smooth and initially enjoyable gameplay, which unfortunately personally grew dull rather fast -Microtransactions in a singeplayer game that directly relate and effect the core mechanic of the game -is a sad excuse to be part of LOTR universe (Feels like its only LOTR for brand recognition)    Short and sweet
    -Horrible Story with characters that range from horrible to somewhat promising
    -smooth and initially enjoyable gameplay, which unfortunately personally grew dull rather fast
    -Microtransactions in a singeplayer game that directly relate and effect the core mechanic of the game
    -is a sad excuse to be part of LOTR universe (Feels like its only LOTR for brand recognition)
    +core mechanic of nemesis system is a unique and impressive feature that makes all players experience somewhat unique and personal
    -Ratbag shoulda **** died in the first one bruh, thats BS

    Anyone who disagrees with my score, either thinking it should be lower or higher probably has some valid points, respect y'alls opinions either way    … Expand
  66. Zekeriah03
    Nov 3, 2017
    8
    I really do enjoy this game. The nemesis system has been refined and the interactions with the orcs are one of the best things about the game. One thing that disappointed me was the story. The orcs in the game had far more of a personality than any humans that you would run into. The Balrog fight is disappointing as well because all I was doing was dodging his attacks and shooting him inI really do enjoy this game. The nemesis system has been refined and the interactions with the orcs are one of the best things about the game. One thing that disappointed me was the story. The orcs in the game had far more of a personality than any humans that you would run into. The Balrog fight is disappointing as well because all I was doing was dodging his attacks and shooting him in his gigantic weak spot. It felt as though someone was holding my hand throughout the fight. Some of the fights with the orcs in the game were way harder than that. The sieges in the game were amazing to watch though. The main parts of the siege are not focused on surviving but making sure that the captains you brought with you don't die. The fights with the overlords were quite difficult and it would occasionally take me several tries to defeat them. Unlike Shadow of Mordor, the ending to this game is really cool. I did not go through with the countless siege defenses to finish the game and I may edit my review after that but the boss fights are not quick time events, the story takes a major twist, and the story somewhat fits in with the movies. Taking all this into consideration, the nemesis system is probably the best thing in the game. The story is bland up to the end but that doesn't make it a bad game. It does a good job of wrapping up the story of Talion and Celebrimbor. One thing that I want to know from the other reviews for the game is "why do you harbor such a deep hatred for the game?" I ask this because all I am seeing are people bashing the microtransactions. I do admit that I do not like them either but it does not break the game. I understand some of the reviews with like 4s and 5s saying that the story is boring or something else was wrong. But the low scores on the microtransaction alone is kind of arrogant. Why rate the game so low if all you have to say about it is one thing? Try something a bit more constructive.… Expand
  67. Reed618
    Nov 10, 2017
    10
    This is really more of an 8/10 because of the unskippable orc intros (so annoying at times), some of the poor questlines (carnan in particular) and the fighting pits (occasionally very entertaining but often a massive pain... I hate it when my orc just stands around doing nothing until it dies)
    However I can't agree with a 3.6 so i'm trying to upvote it. There's tons to love about this    This is really more of an 8/10 because of the unskippable orc intros (so annoying at times), some of the poor questlines (carnan in particular) and the fighting pits (occasionally very entertaining but often a massive pain... I hate it when my orc just stands around doing nothing until it dies)
    However I can't agree with a 3.6 so i'm trying to upvote it. There's tons to love about this game. Huge areas to explore with lots of missions and sidequests. There's not that much narrative drive throughout but the gameplay is really fun and i like some of the twists and turns even if it did kind of crap all over the lore.
    I've finished the first 4 stages of the shadow wars end game (there are ten stages in total) and it's surprisingly fun. it's just siege missions (either defence or attack) which can be repetitive but at the same time the sieges are one of the best parts of the game so i'm spacing this part out and taking my time with it.
    All in all I can see why people are disappointed but this isn't andromeda, it's still a really good game which is a lot of fun. It's just also quite flawed in areas. I'd say pick it up on sale and give it a go. You'll probably enjoy it but don't buy loot boxes because they really aren't necessary. You can just recruit orcs during the siege missions of shadow wars, there's no need to buy them.    … Expand
  68. Kaisermena
    Oct 16, 2017
    5
    El juego en su campaña en solitario sigue siendo tan bueno como el anterior, o aún mejor, de eso no tengo queja. Pero en cuanto al multijugador y a los micropagos y las cajitas aleatorias, creo que era algo totalmente innecesario en este tipo de juegos. Un gran trabajo dañado por la avaricia y las políticas abusivas. Sigan así Warner Entertainment que van por buen camino
  69. spaghetti-cop
    Nov 7, 2017
    7
    Shadow of War is filled with a lot of great moments. Sadly there aren't enough of these to make the game reach the highs of it's predecessor. I was hoping more compelling campaign this time around with interesting characters, but instead it's more of the same cliches we got the first time around. To be fair, the plot has a couple interesting twists that were good enough to motivate me toShadow of War is filled with a lot of great moments. Sadly there aren't enough of these to make the game reach the highs of it's predecessor. I was hoping more compelling campaign this time around with interesting characters, but instead it's more of the same cliches we got the first time around. To be fair, the plot has a couple interesting twists that were good enough to motivate me to complete it, but it's the orcs that make this game worth playing; nothing else really. Once you finish each NPCs arc and complete the final mission, you'll get that familiar "that's it?" feeling that commonly plagues open world games like this one.

    The game just never finds its stride. Buffing Talion to god level and manipulating the story lines and progression of your orcs is a lot of fun, but it's a shame that the game cheapens this in its final act by turning orcs into stats to be purchased instead of characters to remember. Every strength the game has is marred by a weakness.

    The combat this time around is very one-note. It's just chaos with berserkers, defenders, ologs always overwhelming you and the game devolves into spamming overpowered skills like chain consume and headshots. The first game had tighter encounters with more balance put into each one. The game ramped up its difficulty organically. Shadow or War just throws it all into the blender and makes combat feel like a mess. I think that's how I feel about it in general. It's a very tangled game that does a lot right and a lot wrong.    … Expand
  70. achillesares
    Nov 26, 2017
    8
    I am against microtransactions in games if you need it to beat the game. That being said this is not the case for this game. People say it’s hard but I find it challenging which is what I look for in a game.

    This game has significantly improved since the first game. The nemesis system and the smooth combat make it worth playing. The story is better than the first one but I few this is    I am against microtransactions in games if you need it to beat the game. That being said this is not the case for this game. People say it’s hard but I find it challenging which is what I look for in a game.

    This game has significantly improved since the first game. The nemesis system and the smooth combat make it worth playing. The story is better than the first one but I few this is where it’s downfall is. I enjoy a good engaging story where character are around for awhile and you get to know them. Character development falls short.

    In my opinion if you enjoyed the first one this is a must play game. You don’t NEED to purchase any loot boxes to beat this game. They offer multiple upgrades and I’m unsure why they are even there except for people who just like to have every item in a game.    … Expand
  71. boris_out
    Mar 7, 2018
    6
    Больше - не значит лучше.

    К сожалению, именно эта мысль приходит в голову при прохождении Shadow Of War. Да, хваленная система Nemesis стала разнообразнее, количество сюжетных вставок возросло, общая режиссура слегка подняла свою плану - но стала ли игра от этого НАМНОГО качественнее? Единственное, за что хочется хвалить Тени Войны, скрыто в осаде и обороне крепостей, доступ к    Больше - не значит лучше.

    К сожалению, именно эта мысль приходит в голову при прохождении Shadow Of War. Да, хваленная система Nemesis стала разнообразнее, количество сюжетных вставок возросло, общая режиссура слегка подняла свою плану - но стала ли игра от этого НАМНОГО качественнее?

    Единственное, за что хочется хвалить Тени Войны, скрыто в осаде и обороне крепостей, доступ к которым открывается лишь спустя 3-5 часов игры. Именно благодаря масштабу и эпичности данных сражений хочется проходить скучные сюжетные квесты. И именно этот аспект игровой механики вытягивает творение Монолитов на 6 баллов из 10.

    Если вам понравилась первая часть - можно смело продолжать рубить орков и тут, но если вы равнодушны к миру Толкина и однообразному геймплею, то следует однозначно проходить мимо очередной ААА-игры с микротранзакциями.

    P.S.
    Ах да, спустя полгода после выхода баги все также встречаются на просторах Средиземья - будьте к этому готовы.    … Expand
  72. Tokoo
    Oct 11, 2017
    5
    Love how all the critic's that reviewed this game giving it 80+ rating, all say the same thing. Oh its a great copy of the 1st game. That's nice so they polished it, added loot boxes, expanded the nemesis system, made a lack luster story, and also locked the anticlimactic ending behind ether grinding, or buying loot boxes/ Such a shame, loot boxes in a 60 usd game is retarded, but forcingLove how all the critic's that reviewed this game giving it 80+ rating, all say the same thing. Oh its a great copy of the 1st game. That's nice so they polished it, added loot boxes, expanded the nemesis system, made a lack luster story, and also locked the anticlimactic ending behind ether grinding, or buying loot boxes/ Such a shame, loot boxes in a 60 usd game is retarded, but forcing people to do the multiplayer system whether they want to or not just to make extra money is appalling, and if a critic can give you a score of 80+ after that then shame on them as well.… Expand
  73. ryxerg
    Oct 19, 2017
    7
    All the microtransactions are LIES! you can purchase every item in the game via daily mission, and the grinding system are Middle-Earth WAY, if you don't like it just don't buy the game!
    The story are a little bit linear but its good anyway, the main reason you want to buy this game is about the gameplay not the story.
    The gameplay looks nice, but the control of the main char are not too    All the microtransactions are LIES! you can purchase every item in the game via daily mission, and the grinding system are Middle-Earth WAY, if you don't like it just don't buy the game!
    The story are a little bit linear but its good anyway, the main reason you want to buy this game is about the gameplay not the story.
    The gameplay looks nice, but the control of the main char are not too good, i play it on my ps4 slim and the main char sometimes do something that i don't want him to do.
    Overall the game is good but need some improvement at graphic and controlling    … Expand
  74. OmgitsJackYp
    Oct 31, 2017
    8
    How dare they put microtransactions into a SP game. Especially into a good game. This game could've been game of the year but no Warner brothers has to kill it with microtransactions.
  75. manningn15
    Aug 18, 2019
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This is my favorite video game of 2017 and my 2nd favorite video game of all time. The visual and graphics are phenomenal, beautiful, creepy, and cool especially the characters, the drakes, the caragors, the graugs, and Ghûls. I loved how real the people looked. The different areas were really real looking and looked so much like the scenery in the movies. The gameplay was remarkable especially the fighting, the drake riding, and the missions. The story and writing are terrific. I love to ride drakes and kill captains. The enemies are awesome. The voice over performances are fantastic especially the ones for Talion and Shelob. I loved all of the different weapons and the armour you can get. I love this game so much and it is a A+ game.… Expand
  76. Sidious58
    Apr 14, 2018
    6
    Un gioco che inizialmente sembrava ottimo,ma poi la trama si è rivelata assurda,priva di senso e totalmente incoerente con l'universo di Tolkien. Aggiungo ambientazioni abbastanza scarne e una parte finale allungata sino allo schifo a dir poco orrenda
  77. AlbertoBuzz
    Mar 27, 2018
    7
    Es un buen juego en el que las criticas están exageradas, no necesitas pagar para pasarte la historia cómodamente, y todos los orcos se pueden conseguir jugando y subiéndolos de nivel tu mismo. Me parece un buen juego que mejora a el primer shadow of mordor.

    It is a good game in which the critics are exaggerated, you do not need to pay to spend the story comfortably, and all the Orcs    Es un buen juego en el que las criticas están exageradas, no necesitas pagar para pasarte la historia cómodamente, y todos los orcos se pueden conseguir jugando y subiéndolos de nivel tu mismo. Me parece un buen juego que mejora a el primer shadow of mordor.

    It is a good game in which the critics are exaggerated, you do not need to pay to spend the story comfortably, and all the Orcs can be achieved by playing and by uploading them level yourself. I think it's a good game that improves the first shadow of Mordor.    … Expand
  78. Arnitxe
    Sep 8, 2020
    9
    This is what I call a good sequel.
    WB Games did a good job with this game. The graphics are not as good as other 2017 games but I liked it anyway. The game is so much longer then the first one but it's funnier and has a lot of side stories as well. Easy platinum in my collection :)
  79. Tilerphy
    May 5, 2019
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. It is a perfect game now as the micro-transactions had been deleted.
    I have fall in love with the middle-earth story. I even want to buy all the books about middle-earth after I finished the game.

    even thought the Orcs are similar, but it cannot decrease the fun.    … Expand
  80. SomethingSquid
    May 26, 2019
    10
    I have no idea why people are complaining about this amazing game. I haven’t seen one micro transaction in my 9.8 hours of playing beside the dlc. This is one of the best games I have ever played.
  81. MazrimTaim14
    Oct 14, 2019
    3
    Question: How do you f up a great, fresh and innovative game in Shadow of Mordor?

    Answer: Make everything grindier to earn freaking microtransaction.

    It only affects the endgame if you want to see the "true" ending. But its better to watch it instead on youtube.

    The award "Could have been a Contender" goes to this steaming pile of
  82. Watcher-o-Roads
    Feb 12, 2020
    1
    Wasted Opportunity
    Batman Arkham like gameplay with addition of Nemessis system which was cool. Lamest final boss fight and unreliable story which ruin both the game and the Lord of the Rings experience.
  83. Weeklythrower58
    Mar 27, 2020
    1
    This is trash on ps4 play it on Xbox the game is just broken and ai is ****
  84. JoKeR_AlexS
    Jun 24, 2020
    4
    Este comentário é universal nas minhas reviews. Apenas quero dar nota aos jogos e caso queiram saber mais alguma coisa sobre o jogo, aconselho a ver outras reviews ou até mesmo a experimentar o jogo.
  85. SPodvohom
    Feb 15, 2021
    0
    Патентую траханье рта издателей этой параши.
  86. gmzstation
    Aug 26, 2020
    9
    Big fan of this game it must play on my opinion it has new things no other games has
  87. ion87
    Dec 9, 2022
    9
    Great follow up to a fantastic series. Gameplay is smooth and the characters are intriguing.
  88. mr3kler
    Nov 28, 2020
    10
    One of the best game i have ever played. Now it doesn't have any loot boxes for real money.
  89. Oleksandr_
    Feb 10, 2021
    0
    Patenting the nemesis system, despite your game being created base on others' ideas. The industry is built on innovating of existing ideas.
  90. pharagonesia
    Oct 10, 2020
    3
    It is very evident the developers didn't play their own game. Try climbing a wall and the game can't determine whether the 'X' button indicates a command to roll or a command to climb. This regression in mechanics was evident right away. The skill upgrade menus are another downgrade from Shadow of Mordor. While the environments in the game look better than the predecessor, the charactersIt is very evident the developers didn't play their own game. Try climbing a wall and the game can't determine whether the 'X' button indicates a command to roll or a command to climb. This regression in mechanics was evident right away. The skill upgrade menus are another downgrade from Shadow of Mordor. While the environments in the game look better than the predecessor, the characters themselves appear more plastic. Orc Captain cut scenes seem to run longer and there is no way to bypass the nonsense dialogue. Arrows no longer need to be manually picked up, but good luck finding them. If you have aim assist turned on, good luck because the feature is mostly broken. Then there's the matter of having to find some bizarre combination of left/right to reveal secrets. The concept sounds cool at face value, but the implementation is rage inducing. And finally - my biggest complaint - is the unresolved input lag that was well documented with Shadow of Mordor. Sometimes the character will just sit there taking hits, not responding to input because, well, apparently the developers don't play their own product. The only improvement in the game was the decision to eliminate plant hunting for health regeneration, but even that doesn't resolve the issue of a fundamentally broken character health system.… Expand
  91. Hoplita
    Dec 5, 2020
    4
    Got it for free with PS Plus. Event after the end of the highly criticized micro-transactions, it's still a bad game. Only three years in of its release, this game clearly has not aged well. The movement is bad. The combat mechanics are repetitive. The enemies are dumb (stealth mechanic is a joke). The graphics could be better. The story is boring. It's a sloppy game. Perhaps theGot it for free with PS Plus. Event after the end of the highly criticized micro-transactions, it's still a bad game. Only three years in of its release, this game clearly has not aged well. The movement is bad. The combat mechanics are repetitive. The enemies are dumb (stealth mechanic is a joke). The graphics could be better. The story is boring. It's a sloppy game. Perhaps the developers thought they could provide anything to the players since it's a LOTR game and its predecessor was a success (indeed, the first game was pretty good). Unfortunately, this a game made not with love, but with greed.… Expand
  92. Mo_obaid
    Nov 23, 2020
    1
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. It’s not worth playing random fighting random mechanics the story line is not good the basics of the game are the worst I spent my time for no thing… Expand
  93. LesandroBonucci
    Jun 12, 2021
    2
    one of the worst games i ever played
    just presing one button to kill those orks
    soon all games is gonna be like this
  94. TheTeaMKiLLer69
    Jun 1, 2021
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Boring to death.
    Terrible voice acting.
    Boring quest design.
    Horrible gameplay design.    … Expand
  95. Nalpa
    Apr 13, 2021
    0
    Really bad input latency both on PS4 and PS5. Not playable. I loved the first game and the nemesis system is pretty genius but come on patch that mess!
  96. Chrislzrks
    Apr 7, 2021
    3
    Most uninspired, generic game of the recent years.. There's Nothing "Tolkienish" in this game. Mediocre graphics, meeh gameplay, uninspired world and atmosphere as like quests and storyline...
    A crime against Tolkien and Lord of the rings franchise..
    Abort...
  97. dasse666
    Jan 4, 2022
    10
    With the microtransactions gone the game gets put in the light it should have from the beginning. Much has happened sinne Shadow of mordor, the new Shadow of war has a bygger world, better mechanics and depper detail in combat. The voice acting is stunning as an example.
  98. ripear
    May 10, 2023
    0
    This is not what i was expecting. Having played the original game, this is totally different. The main characters are the same, but it's just a loot game, there's no caching story and the gameplay feels repetitive and borign. It's a shame, as the world and magic of Tolkien has a lot more to offer than this. Don't waste your money on this game.
  99. Reedsnees
    Jul 8, 2022
    3
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Loot boxes are bad, but unlike most games you can get the same loot by just obtaining it. The story sucks but gollum in it so yeah good game… Expand
  100. gamer664
    May 5, 2023
    0
    Don't bother with this games. It's the exact same as the first one. WB also patented the Nemesis system, which prevents other studios from improving upon the concept.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

65
#65 Best PS4 Game of 2017
12
#12 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2017
13
#13 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2017

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
80

Generally favorable reviews - based on 69 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 53 out of 69
  2. Mixed: 16 out of 69
  3. Negative: 0 out of 69
  1. CD-Action
    Dec 19, 2017
    80
    I was annoyed by various flaws (both technical and design-related) and tedious, dragged out final stages of the campaign, but overall I enjoyed the ride. It looks like the developers wanted to stuff the game with all the best elements Middle-earth has to offer. Shadow of War’s atmosphere is terrific and watching Talion rise in power is surprisingly addictive. [12/2017, p.62]
  2. Cubed3
    Nov 26, 2017
    70
    A handful of issues, some much more annoying than others, do not negate how solid of an action RPG Middle-earth: Shadow of War is. A tremendous achievement for the team at Monolith Productions, this is an exciting, if not sometimes slow, and too often unfair, title that manages to be as impressively fun as it is big.
    Read full review
  3. Playstation Official Magazine UK
    Nov 20, 2017
    60
    Big, brutal, and - alas - bloated, Shadow of War is a disappointing follow-up, conjuring battles of grand scale and then deadening their impact through grinding repetition. [December 2017, p.79]
See all critic reviews »