Middle-earth: Shadow of War

 PlayStation 4
User Score
4.9

Generally unfavorable reviews- based on 1686 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 665 out of 1686
  2. Mixed: 265 out of 1686
  3. Negative: 756 out of 1686
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. brewistmonk
    Oct 21, 2017
    0
    I did not play this game nor do I intend to. Any game with loot boxes will never be purchased or played by me.. The critics giving this game high marks are not examining the entire game. cash grabs from developers should not be tolerated and must not be allowed to dominate the future of the gaming industry. please vote with your wallet. stay away from this type of game and the loot boxesI did not play this game nor do I intend to. Any game with loot boxes will never be purchased or played by me.. The critics giving this game high marks are not examining the entire game. cash grabs from developers should not be tolerated and must not be allowed to dominate the future of the gaming industry. please vote with your wallet. stay away from this type of game and the loot boxes will eventually go away. As should the mindless critics glossing over this destructive presence in the industry.… Expand
  2. Abysswalker89
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    I've been a gamer for about 20 years and seen publishers pull a lot of crap. But gambling in videogames as "lootboxes""?! This is a new low! Monolith sold their souls. Please boycott this game.. buy it second hand.. download it.. just don't support this crap please. Don't let this become the new industry norm
  3. nicouou
    Oct 18, 2017
    0
    An otherwise good game ruined by loot-boxes, micro-transactions, pre-order bonuses and different editions. I advise anyone to boycott this game and all other games with these anti-consumer business strategies. Even just buying the game but not the scummy stuff still shows the publisher that you're okay paying for a game where it is in it, regardless of if you use it or not. They willAn otherwise good game ruined by loot-boxes, micro-transactions, pre-order bonuses and different editions. I advise anyone to boycott this game and all other games with these anti-consumer business strategies. Even just buying the game but not the scummy stuff still shows the publisher that you're okay paying for a game where it is in it, regardless of if you use it or not. They will intentionally make the game more tedious and/or difficult if you don't buy their greddy sh!!t to encourage you to buy it. Want an example? Just look at GTA V Online. While it might not seem too devastating now, If we allow this stuff to happen, it will only get worse over time. If you pay for a AAA priced game you should get the full experience, no excuses (real expansions made afterwards is an exception, of course).… Expand
  4. Developer_
    Oct 21, 2017
    0
    micro transaction in a single player game that is paid for its not even free to play
    the game contains a lot of bugs like raising dead captains and training a captain
  5. michael_clancy
    Oct 25, 2017
    10
    This game is phenomenal. As a Lord of the Rings fan, this game is a dream come true. It features cameos from Golem, (slightly sexualized) Shelob (although that didn't really bother me), and the nazgul. Playing as elf infused discount Aragorn doesn't even take the fun off. The stealth and combat is a much more polished version of Assassins Creed in every way. Although it takes a while toThis game is phenomenal. As a Lord of the Rings fan, this game is a dream come true. It features cameos from Golem, (slightly sexualized) Shelob (although that didn't really bother me), and the nazgul. Playing as elf infused discount Aragorn doesn't even take the fun off. The stealth and combat is a much more polished version of Assassins Creed in every way. Although it takes a while to get going, the nemesis system creates incredible personalized stories, the ads aren't making it up. The game is perfect in almost every way. The game does suffer from a lack of tutorials, and only being able to equip one bonus per power at a time. However, the game still has a lot to offer, and is one of the most fun games I've ever played. Now, to address the elephant in the room, the micro-transactions don't affect the game at all. I am 10-12 hours into the game, and I have not seen a single thing promoting loot boxes. They are not necessary to play the game, and only there for people who don't want to play the game. I would argue that the loot boxes are even more prevalent in Battlefield, Overwatch, and CS:GO, but no one complains about those. This game is amazing. Definitely worth the $60, and I expect to have even more fun as the game progresses. The problems are blown out of proportion by journalists. Play this game. You'll thank me.… Expand
  6. Cashmoney900000
    Dec 12, 2017
    7
    So I just completed the main storyline. Overall gameplay has expanded upon what was already in place, I enjoyed it throughly WITH a few issues. The timing doesnt always seem like line up. The enemies ability to adapt is annoying when some of them have only one weakness to begin with (i.e. shield enemies need to be vaulted over, then they adapt and you can no longer do that). The storySo I just completed the main storyline. Overall gameplay has expanded upon what was already in place, I enjoyed it throughly WITH a few issues. The timing doesnt always seem like line up. The enemies ability to adapt is annoying when some of them have only one weakness to begin with (i.e. shield enemies need to be vaulted over, then they adapt and you can no longer do that). The story line was pretty good, it surprised me. I haven't got into the lootboxes yet, but it has gotten kind of grindy. Imagine Pokemon where you can only catch a pokemon at your trainers level. The game can probably be beaten in 1 sitting. Maybe around 8 to 12 hours of storyline gameplay only. Subquest and just going around merking s*** is what makes this game fun for me. ALSO I bought it at black friday. It is not worth more than 30$ imo. Not a bad game, just not long enough, and to combat that they add extensive grinding to compensate lack of content. Fun. But has its issues. Also f*** the lootboxes, Im not with that movement, at all.… Expand
  7. goztzero
    Nov 23, 2017
    0
    Music is shallow as **** it actually makes me wanna go to sleep

    Animations especially the running one are cringe inducing Graphics are quite bad, especially everything that it's not an orc. Orc intro cinematics get old really fast. Nemesis systems gets boring/annoying after a while (orcs keep spawning all the time) Its a really good attempt but with it really needed a lot of    Music is shallow as **** it actually makes me wanna go to sleep

    Animations especially the running one are cringe inducing

    Graphics are quite bad, especially everything that it's not an orc.

    Orc intro cinematics get old really fast.

    Nemesis systems gets boring/annoying after a while (orcs keep spawning all the time)

    Its a really good attempt but with it really needed a lot of refinement this feels more like a phone game than a game itself it's not worth $60 usd    … Expand
  8. MrBrioche
    Nov 23, 2017
    0
    ok where to start... there is a lot of problem here
    1.Clumsy/unresponsive control, in a stealth/assassination game like that control is REALLY important and VERY often in this game it feels like you are trying to do something specific and the game just dont understand what you are trying to do.
    2.it feels like the nemesis system is force down your throat, sometimes you just KNOW that the    ok where to start... there is a lot of problem here
    1.Clumsy/unresponsive control, in a stealth/assassination game like that control is REALLY important and VERY often in this game it feels like you are trying to do something specific and the game just dont understand what you are trying to do.
    2.it feels like the nemesis system is force down your throat, sometimes you just KNOW that the game wanted you to die right there
    3.in the previous game the number of enemies were fix, but in this one they keep spawning all the time, so you cant ''plan'' and execute like before, overlord mission feel cheesy asf.
    4. the dmg you inflict is just to low compare to the dmg you take ex: a little grunt will take 25% of your HP per attack, the counter window is really smaller compare to the previous game, a captain CAN 1shoot you, when you are in these big fit, there is basically nothing you can do except run and even that dont usually work, feels unfair
    5.flying mechanic... my man... painful
    6.mission seems harder the first time you do it, it feel like they want to force death upon you
    7. fighting wraith is disgusting, counter window to small, they attack off screen you barely see it and so punishing and if you fight them while fighting other orc, i was dying inside
    8.i was chasing this legendary orc that was godlike and when i finally dominated him he lost some of his attribute....? wtf is going
    9.at some point i sent my epic orc on a mission, give him 2 reinforcement and for some reason my epic orc did some dmg (i think) to the 2 others and they started attacking him and they killed him ...?! this happened to me twice.... wtf AI
    10. the AI .... is really bad....
    last but not least micro transaction , i dont think it has his place in a full priced game but it wasnt intrusive but then again i cant stop thinking about how this game could have been without it

    so this game is ''good'' sometimes but the frustration you get from playing it just destroy those little moment of happiness, the only thing this game gave me, its a bad after taste in the mouth, feels bad man    … Expand
  9. devry12
    Dec 26, 2017
    10
    Game is amazing. Micro transations are no issue, just dont buy them at all, simple as that. I promise yoh wont care, dont lisfen to the people sayunb igs an issue, they clewrlh dont own this game lol.
  10. ryuujin
    Oct 19, 2017
    7
    Shadow of war takes the nemesis system from the last game and blows it out of the water. This game improves on every part of it and the combat is also much better. I bought the gold edition and got the platinum without spending any extra money and the time spent was well worth the money. While many people play a game for its story, this game has a much weaker story than the predecessor andShadow of war takes the nemesis system from the last game and blows it out of the water. This game improves on every part of it and the combat is also much better. I bought the gold edition and got the platinum without spending any extra money and the time spent was well worth the money. While many people play a game for its story, this game has a much weaker story than the predecessor and doesn't improve the relationship between Talion and Celebrimbor. Even still though, the game was fun to play the highlight was the amount of personality that the orcs had. The game is good and definitely a must buy, even if it has an iffy story and the fourth act being a slight grind.… Expand
  11. M1N5K
    Oct 25, 2017
    1
    This game is a shame. The pushing of micro-transactions is really absolutely ridiculous. This game is REALLY Pay To Win. Too bad, because the previous game was fantastic.
  12. HonzazCzech
    Dec 13, 2017
    10
    Very fun to play game i like it more than AC origins/its beautiful but boring/. Shadow of war is one of the game whenever you play feel epic!. Its take a while than you will learn combat system - army - pits - vendetas personally love it
  13. Ghoster
    May 12, 2018
    3
    This game is FUN (at least first part)! Microtransactions are not a problem because they are totally optional. But, game become boring in defense missions in act 4 (specially with Orcs talking 10 times during each mission). Further, some trophies for platinum are pointless and stupid. Fight pits are probably most stupid thing made in video games ever (in this missions you WATCH 2 NPC'sThis game is FUN (at least first part)! Microtransactions are not a problem because they are totally optional. But, game become boring in defense missions in act 4 (specially with Orcs talking 10 times during each mission). Further, some trophies for platinum are pointless and stupid. Fight pits are probably most stupid thing made in video games ever (in this missions you WATCH 2 NPC's fighting each other). So, game is really fun if you just want to play it until end of act 3. But, if you want finish act 4 or platinum trophy prepare of tones of stupid missions, trophies and a lot of grinding.… Expand
  14. ToxicJimmy
    Dec 3, 2017
    7
    First off, I understand the bad user score and overall microtransactions have really gotten out of hand. BUT, how Shadow of War implements them is not completely ruining the game. If you choose to ignore the microtransactions it makes the game a little more grindy. However due to SOW's fantastic nemesis system it kind of makes it into an OK grind and still manages to keep it as anFirst off, I understand the bad user score and overall microtransactions have really gotten out of hand. BUT, how Shadow of War implements them is not completely ruining the game. If you choose to ignore the microtransactions it makes the game a little more grindy. However due to SOW's fantastic nemesis system it kind of makes it into an OK grind and still manages to keep it as an interesting experience.

    You can still obtain orc followers, training orders and items from "regular chests" bought with in-game-gained currency which is really easy to farm on higher levels. Basically all the microtransactions do are ensure that you get a legendary item or legendary orc follower, which defeats the whole sense of purpose and accomplishment that already is present in the game if you play it normally. I don't feel forced to purchase loot boxes to enjoy the good qualities of the game.

    With that out of the way:

    Pros

    ++ Nemesis System
    ++ Movement and Combat
    + A lot of skills with many variations
    + Graphics and Performance (Played on PS4 Pro)
    + Orc Pit Fights
    + Fortress Battles (Both offline and online)
    + Some updates are free without the need of a season pass
    + No crashes (personally)
    + Voice Acting (Except Talions generic dialogue)
    + Better story boss battles than Shadow of Mordor, even though some bosses are very "copy-paste"
    + Story is interesting at times

    Cons

    -- Loot boxes
    - Obsolete gear and item system
    - The need to occasionally enter the slow and laggy market section to purchase chests for in-game currency (mainly training orders)
    - Mediocre main character
    - Some glitches (like getting stuck) may require game restart
    - Repetitive Act 4 and Nemesis missions
    - Slow and grindy progression in late-game

    I totally understand if people won't buy the game simply because of the disgusting microtransactions, it's just that they're missing out on the awesome game that lies beneath the pile of **** if they can't see past them.    … Expand
  15. Valtazarkane
    Oct 19, 2017
    5
    A strong middle-aged man. A strong middle-aged man.A strong middle-aged man.A strong middle-aged man.A strong middle-aged man.A strong middle-aged man.A strong middle-aged man.
  16. VmsCritic
    Jul 17, 2018
    8
    I'm a huge fan of Lord of the Rings saga. I've played Shadow of Mordor back in 2014 and it was one of the best PS4 games at that time, and still one of the best experiences I had in PS4. Shadow of War brings new challenges, improves in every aspect when compared with Shadow of Mordor. The biggest new gameplay feature are the Fortress/Conquest missions, the Dragons and Nazgul battles. TheI'm a huge fan of Lord of the Rings saga. I've played Shadow of Mordor back in 2014 and it was one of the best PS4 games at that time, and still one of the best experiences I had in PS4. Shadow of War brings new challenges, improves in every aspect when compared with Shadow of Mordor. The biggest new gameplay feature are the Fortress/Conquest missions, the Dragons and Nazgul battles. The cutscenes are incredible. The scenario is amazing. The endgame is absolutely amazing – great fight and astonishing history ending. However, I got tired of playing sometimes due to the repetition of missions, fights, etc. Perhaps thats me after playing a lot of other games with spetacular fights such as Nioh, HzD, GoW. I hope the next Monolith game reinvents itself more than they did in this game.… Expand
  17. Spidor
    Nov 18, 2017
    1
    This game is one half okay game, and one half infuriating grind. Once you beat the penultimate mission, suddenly the game forces you to repeat ALL your progress multiple times over (encouraging you yo purchase precious lootboxes on the way). Do not play this game as is. Wait until they realize the error of their ways and patch the second half of the game out.

    Also - fortresses are not    This game is one half okay game, and one half infuriating grind. Once you beat the penultimate mission, suddenly the game forces you to repeat ALL your progress multiple times over (encouraging you yo purchase precious lootboxes on the way). Do not play this game as is. Wait until they realize the error of their ways and patch the second half of the game out.

    Also - fortresses are not nearly as cool as the trailer. IT's not fun, it's samey, and the AI is AWFUL.    … Expand
  18. saladman67
    Nov 21, 2018
    0
    Gameplay is good but not good enough to make up for the fact that you need to pay loads of money to complete the game. ugh such bs, this could have been a good game but alas I wasted 70 bucks. Never pre ordering again unless form Rockstar.
  19. visiblelight7
    Nov 16, 2018
    9
    I got the game for 20$ expecting it to be horrible but it was quite enjoyable. It's a massive improvement on the first due to the added complexity. However, it's exactly the same game at it's core so if you were bored from the first one, you will DEFINATELY feel like you are playing the same game.

    The fun comes from upgrading your character. If you enjoy watching your kick butt and get    I got the game for 20$ expecting it to be horrible but it was quite enjoyable. It's a massive improvement on the first due to the added complexity. However, it's exactly the same game at it's core so if you were bored from the first one, you will DEFINATELY feel like you are playing the same game.

    The fun comes from upgrading your character. If you enjoy watching your kick butt and get excited over what you are able to accomplish during fights...then you will enjoy this game.

    No way this game deserves a 4/10. Clearly a smear campaign due to loot boxes(which is understandable) but now that they removed it. It deserves much higher rating. I'd say AT LEAST 6-7/10.    … Expand
  20. Topazar
    Mar 15, 2018
    9
    Долгое время не покупал игру так как был смущен ее низкими оценками среди игроков, но когда приобрел ее по скидке просто офигел насколько это недооцененная игра. Прошёл ее на одном дыхании, немезида принесла немало крутых моментов с орками командирами. Отличная графика, бодрая боёвка у кучей приемов и разнообразие командиров дает не хилое разнообразие геимплея. Я прошёл всю сюжетку неДолгое время не покупал игру так как был смущен ее низкими оценками среди игроков, но когда приобрел ее по скидке просто офигел насколько это недооцененная игра. Прошёл ее на одном дыхании, немезида принесла немало крутых моментов с орками командирами. Отличная графика, бодрая боёвка у кучей приемов и разнообразие командиров дает не хилое разнообразие геимплея. Я прошёл всю сюжетку не открыв ни одного лутбокса так что все этот крик вокруг доната простой шум людей которые даже не играли в игру. Да в игре есть недостатки, однообразные сайд квесты, немного кривое управление особенно в толпе врагов сложно выбрать нужную тебе цель для атаки, но плюсы игры перекрывают ее минусы, для меня это одна из самых недооцененных игр последних лет.… Expand
  21. Ps4player
    Nov 2, 2017
    6
    read this review of middle earth shadow of war. every single user review i have seen only talk about micro transactions and nothing else. the gameplay is good and builds up from the last game with more to do in this world. the siege of towers is a ton of fun to do and has replay value to it. the story is underwhelming overall but that was expected when i went into this game. the nemesisread this review of middle earth shadow of war. every single user review i have seen only talk about micro transactions and nothing else. the gameplay is good and builds up from the last game with more to do in this world. the siege of towers is a ton of fun to do and has replay value to it. the story is underwhelming overall but that was expected when i went into this game. the nemesis system, is still fun to use and what they added to it makes it even better. even though it has pros it still has cons. yes the micro transactions do ruin the fun of getting all the loot yourself instead of just buying it. the game has buggy issues for when it comes to combat and even just looking at your army. i would wait for a sale if i were you to get this game because right now it is not worth the full 90$ you have to pay for it i think 60$ (U.S PRICE IS FINE).… Expand
  22. GreyKaff
    Nov 17, 2017
    8
    Great game.. A little bit similar to shadow of mordor but better.. ZERO need for microtransactions. Nemesis system still impress with fort attack/defense.. For me, solid 8.
  23. ChildofDivorce
    Nov 22, 2017
    1
    I was sooo pumped about this game. LOVED SoM.
    After reading USER reviews I will not be purchasing it.
    Micro-transactions are BS, even if they aren't necessary, it just makes me sick to see them in a game like this.
    Stay classy WB.
  24. Rodrigo23
    May 17, 2018
    7
    This game really disappointed me. The world is full of useless secondary activities and stuffing to give a feeling that "there are many things to do". The mission menu is messy and confusing. The story is terribly boring, and the characters without charisma and for oblivion. The new multiplayer mode does not add much. The best thing is the nemesis system, the orcs are the only thing and the best.
  25. Kearne
    Jun 10, 2018
    0
    Lets start with that I never, ever score or even write reviews on games, movies, etc. But this.... This abomination of a game made me do it.... I've played many titles that people would call **** but this is the cherry on top of a most annoying and poorly done AAA (supposedly) video games ever made.
    I'm not gonna even describe that the graphics are bad and for me look exactly like in    Lets start with that I never, ever score or even write reviews on games, movies, etc. But this.... This abomination of a game made me do it.... I've played many titles that people would call **** but this is the cherry on top of a most annoying and poorly done AAA (supposedly) video games ever made.
    I'm not gonna even describe that the graphics are bad and for me look exactly like in Shadow of Mordor. I don't pay that much attention to it (which I did a second ago.... oh well). What pains me the most is the level of stupidity and laziness developers have shown by making it. Everything through poorly written story, strange aiming concept (during big fights you are prompt to dodge an attack from berserker and suddenly your hero tries to jump over the nearby oolog, which just grabs you and smashes into the ground) and the worst, last act: Shadow Wars.... In my wildest dreams I wouldn't come up with the idea of something as boring and tedious as perpetual siege game mechanic. First 5 stages are ok'ish. The rest is just utter garbage. Especially when attacking orcs are starting to get well ahead of you with their levels. Then the nightmare starts.... Neverending grind without any storyline. After God know how many hours sinked into the game I couldn't even make myself to finish it, not to mention doing plat.    … Expand
  26. WaspyWasp
    Apr 26, 2020
    10
    Great game. The Nemesis system is still quite remarkable and it's surprising that no other game attempted to achieve something similar. Talion and Celebrimbor are great characters, and while the story is quite nonsensical if you try to put it in line with the books, it's still incredibly enjoyable. Can't wait to see what Monolith has in store next
  27. IvanusKnight
    Jul 10, 2019
    0
    CASHCASHCASHCASH.PAY TO WIN.THIS GAME IS PICIE OF CASH,F+CK YOU WARNER BROS.
  28. NemesisBruh
    Feb 7, 2021
    0
    Imagine patenting the nemesis system, despite your game being an Assassin's Creed re-skin. Not to mention that nemesis system itself existed long before this game. The industry is built on innovating existing ideas. Everything is inspired by something that came before it. That's how games, art, music, writing, culture itself and everything else works. Patenting the nemesis system is likeImagine patenting the nemesis system, despite your game being an Assassin's Creed re-skin. Not to mention that nemesis system itself existed long before this game. The industry is built on innovating existing ideas. Everything is inspired by something that came before it. That's how games, art, music, writing, culture itself and everything else works. Patenting the nemesis system is like patenting a color blue, or like patenting an the idea of a powerful corrupting item in storytelling. WB Games needs to back down on this.… Expand
  29. Dimitris29
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    All the people are hating just cause of the microtransactions... They AREN'T required to complete the game. Stop b****ing and just enjoy the game. I've played for 5 hours so far and enjoyed every second. Story is good, gameplay is great, Nemesis system is fantastic. You complaining about the microtransactions isn't gonna change anything. Just play the game without them. Everything aboutAll the people are hating just cause of the microtransactions... They AREN'T required to complete the game. Stop b****ing and just enjoy the game. I've played for 5 hours so far and enjoyed every second. Story is good, gameplay is great, Nemesis system is fantastic. You complaining about the microtransactions isn't gonna change anything. Just play the game without them. Everything about SoW is great!… Expand
  30. Fhamil
    Oct 15, 2017
    0
    We need publishers/developers with the same mindset such as CDPR. It can be done people. Keep the faith and never support microtransactions in full priced games
  31. MrRPG
    Oct 10, 2017
    5
    The game play, soundtrack and story are all good, Improvements have been made on all the predecessors features.
    This game's biggest flaw is the greed of the studio, no single player game should have micro-transactions, this has been repeated a lot in the comments section and I have to agree with it all, we have to take a stand against these practices especially when the game play it's    The game play, soundtrack and story are all good, Improvements have been made on all the predecessors features.
    This game's biggest flaw is the greed of the studio, no single player game should have micro-transactions, this has been repeated a lot in the comments section and I have to agree with it all, we have to take a stand against these practices especially when the game play it's self pushes the player through artificial difficulty spikes in an attempt to garner micro-transactions. That said the core game is still very good.    … Expand
  32. DrEm91
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    While I was extremely excited to buy Shadow of War, having absolutely loved Shadow of Mordor, I will not buy it. I am posting this review just to express my disgust at implementing micro transactions in a full fledged game. As a gamer, I will NEVER support companies that do this. While I know, this may not be developers fault or decision. I am sure they created an awesome game, I am sad toWhile I was extremely excited to buy Shadow of War, having absolutely loved Shadow of Mordor, I will not buy it. I am posting this review just to express my disgust at implementing micro transactions in a full fledged game. As a gamer, I will NEVER support companies that do this. While I know, this may not be developers fault or decision. I am sure they created an awesome game, I am sad to see their hard work overshadowed with this controversy. Maybe I will pick it up, after a patch that lets us experience the "real" ending without having to fork out money.… Expand
  33. xavia91
    Oct 19, 2017
    3
    "You don't need lootboxes and can play through the whole game without a problem" that is if you are willing to grind your ass off with repetitive battles to slowly raise your level... The beginning is fun and progressing as expected, but after leaving Minas Tirith you are suddenly stuck with endless grinding and meaningless story missions on the side....

    Thanks to the proper early phase    "You don't need lootboxes and can play through the whole game without a problem" that is if you are willing to grind your ass off with repetitive battles to slowly raise your level... The beginning is fun and progressing as expected, but after leaving Minas Tirith you are suddenly stuck with endless grinding and meaningless story missions on the side....

    Thanks to the proper early phase it does not get ZERO points as it deserves for being a greedy ****    … Expand
  34. deathbringer
    Oct 22, 2017
    0
    Awful, awful, and again, awful. They game would be decent, if not for the disgustingly greedy decisions they made with it. The whole game is based around microtransactions. A $60 game with microtransactions...
  35. theplayer23
    Oct 15, 2017
    4
    Although the game looks very good - MT MT MT - oh and MT MT and than some more MT -
    i am blessed that waited till my friend buy this game. now I know I will never buy it.
  36. northernlad
    Oct 11, 2017
    6
    just started act two been on shadow of war most of the day my very first thought that comes to mind is disappointment the games combat is the same as the first which works fine but the start is terrible the games been filled with mindless fluff story is drivel the world seems well crafted and orks are great but i have to say as a massive fan of the first game which i still own and playjust started act two been on shadow of war most of the day my very first thought that comes to mind is disappointment the games combat is the same as the first which works fine but the start is terrible the games been filled with mindless fluff story is drivel the world seems well crafted and orks are great but i have to say as a massive fan of the first game which i still own and play this is a major step backwards graphics dont make a game and game content shoved behind microtransactions is a joke all in all a average game at best shame as i had really high hopes for this--- update it's just the same grind over and over pretty much using the fabled batman gameplay mechanic the game world feels far to light losing the dark and gritty feel of the first and anyone who thinks this story is good well each to there own first game a surprising almost a master peace in my humble opinion but this is not garbage but very average there's better games out there simple fact i'd advise anyone to wait for abit before jumping into a full price game here… Expand
  37. Manzor
    Oct 21, 2017
    3
    Big kick in the ass to the lord of the rings lore but it has some other big problems. Some of them related to microtransactions but there are problems with playability. Too much combo mechanics. It looks amazing (in some way, graphics are not amazing either) but if you play some hours you realise how boring the game is. You are just pressing buttons.

    Not a terrible game, but to me, it's    Big kick in the ass to the lord of the rings lore but it has some other big problems. Some of them related to microtransactions but there are problems with playability. Too much combo mechanics. It looks amazing (in some way, graphics are not amazing either) but if you play some hours you realise how boring the game is. You are just pressing buttons.

    Not a terrible game, but to me, it's a bad game. Not enough good to deserve playing. There are bigger fishes in the sea.    … Expand
  38. scox
    Oct 12, 2017
    10
    Game is great, you don't have to use the microtransactions if you don't want to. I fully agree that having them in is total crap, but to review bomb this game over them is a bit harsh.
  39. Mztt
    Oct 14, 2017
    9
    The game is fun but most of the people that give it a negative review never even played the game which is BS. Play the game before you judge it for something that's not affecting gameplay unless you use them. You can even get them for free if you care.
  40. tmlorfing
    Oct 31, 2017
    0
    This isn't a game, it's a 60 dollar virtual slot machine. STAY FAR AWAY from this "game", and it's time to shun all publishers who shoehorn literal gambling into videogames.
  41. whatever523
    Nov 2, 2017
    0
    Yay, lootboxes!

    You are paying for those extra profits with user ratings. I think you will find that in the long run, it's not worth it. Just ask Ubisoft.
  42. lostsol
    Nov 13, 2019
    3
    While playing the game you will find yourself forced to spend more money to finish to be able to finish it. If this isn't a d*** move, then what it is?
  43. TeeZee
    Oct 24, 2017
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Story feels forced, why not just pick up where the game left off? no reason for crappy convoluted cut scenes. no consistency with the original game. ring of power offers no new strengths? you feel weaker with a ring of power, new random unexplained magic. when story line shifts and you no longer have celembrembor with you you still retain his powers and abilities? orcs retain will of their own? domination magic is more like persuasive recruiter magic. they tried to improve on every aspect of the game but doesnt come out well. orcs talk longer and there are more of them bunched together, really makes for long pointless cut scenes during sieges every time you move in for combat, the loot system was poorly implented imo and personally miss the runes and obviously the nickle and diming you upon purchase asking for $100 for the completed game and micro transactions inside the game. i enjoy the stealthy cloak and dagger playstyle from the first game. this one is more focused on your orcs and seiges and forcing you into combat and certain playstyles… Expand
  44. dwyattallnight
    Oct 25, 2017
    0
    THERE IS NO PLACE FOR MICROTRANSACTIONS IN SINGLE PLAYER GAMES !
    This is a 60$ AAA Pay-To-Winskip halfgame (for full experience pay 100$)
    game is designed to lure players into gambling by bringing the concept of microtranactions (in the form of loot cases) into a single player game. Warner Brothers games wants to push the player into buying loot boxes on which he gambles if he may or    THERE IS NO PLACE FOR MICROTRANSACTIONS IN SINGLE PLAYER GAMES !
    This is a 60$ AAA Pay-To-Winskip halfgame (for full experience pay 100$)
    game is designed to lure players into gambling by bringing the concept of microtranactions (in the form of loot cases) into a single player game.
    Warner Brothers games wants to push the player into buying loot boxes on which he gambles if he may or may not get a loot which will be beneficial to the gameplay experience.

    WB games shameless business practice :
    1) microtransactions in a single player game
    2) gambling via Loot Cases (great for the kids !!)
    3) pay to winskip
    4) preorder DLC    … Expand
  45. Guldan666
    Oct 27, 2017
    0
    Крайне неряшливо и убого склёпанная игра.
    Система Немезис в этой части показала себя во всей "красе".
    После захвата самой первой крепости, я пошел помогать одному из своих охотиться на карагоров. Прибыв на место, вступив в бой с 4-мя карагорами, на меня напал мой бывший капитан...пришлось его убить...Спустя секунду на меня нападает второй бывший капитан...еще одного казнил...и вот тут    Крайне неряшливо и убого склёпанная игра.
    Система Немезис в этой части показала себя во всей "красе".
    После захвата самой первой крепости, я пошел помогать одному из своих охотиться на карагоров.
    Прибыв на место, вступив в бой с 4-мя карагорами, на меня напал мой бывший капитан...пришлось его убить...Спустя секунду на меня нападает второй бывший капитан...еще одного казнил...и вот тут же нападает третий....я напрягся, но и его убил...и сразу же после него, вы угадали, нападает четвертый....какая веселая и продуманная игра. Так я остался без 4-х капитанов за 10 минут. Пошел искать себе нового. Устроил на него засаду...все сложилось удачно, переманил. Отхожу от места "битвы", буквально метров на 15-20....и угадайте, кто на меня напал, с криками, вроде: "Я больше не служу тебе!"....да-да тот самый, на которого устроил засаду 10-ю секундами раньше. Это как, вообще, называется?
    Игра хоть немного тестировалась? Я не успеваю сюжетные миссии проходить, это какой-то круговорот порабощения капитанов с дальнейшим их предательством....Бл****ий цирк.
    Очень напрягает, что даже если ты всех капитанов на карте сделаешь своими... локации, все-равно будут наполнены вражески настроенными орками. Смысл отхватывать местные заставы (красные зоны на карте), если там нельзя организовать собственный перевалочный пункт, где будут лояльные тебе орки, которых можно было бы брать с собой, чтобы они помогали отхватывать другие зоны? Ну хотя, этож думать пришлось бы разработчикам...а они этого явно не делали.
    В итоге мы имеем карту, с постоянно генерящимися орками. Даже их количество не меняется.
    Сюжет оригинальностью не блещет...да и игра в основном про геймплей....чего от него требовать?
    Стоит отметить мыльную графику уровня "Мафия 3".
    Вообще во многом мне эта игра напоминает мафию... настолько неумело сделанный, однообразный, скучный, затянутый продукт еще надо постараться сделать. Я удивлен, что у этой игры положительные обзоры, а у мафии нет.
    Так же напрягает однообразность локаций, строений и замков.
    Про микротранзакции говорить не особо хочется, ибо ими не пользуюсь. Но хочется спросить...неужели, если человек задонатит, у него выпадет парочка крутых орков, он поставит их капитанами... они тоже взбунтуются, скорее рано, чем поздно??? А зачем тогда платить за то, от чего потом придется избавиться?    … Expand
  46. Koristo
    Oct 27, 2017
    0
    Shadow of War is fun until reaching the 4th and final act, which locks the ending of the game behind a monotonous and mindless grind. A baffling decision that can only be explained by the developer/publisher trying to strongarm you into buying their expensive XP boosts and Orc followers in order to get closure for the story. SHAME
  47. Buthomar
    Oct 28, 2017
    0
    Не проходите последние 10 периодов с обороной крепостей, вы офигеете от занудства и однообразности постоянно пи"""жа орков, пожалейте свои 10 часов жизни, посмотрите финальный ролик на ютубе. Финальный ролик 2 минуты и он абсолютно ни о чём.Не проходите последние 10 периодов с обороной крепостей, вы офигеете от занудства и однообразности постоянно пи"""жа орков, пожалейте свои 10 часов жизни, посмотрите финальный ролик на ютубе. Финальный ролик 2 минуты и он абсолютно ни о чём.
  48. Arteck
    Oct 28, 2017
    0
    К сожалению, игра не зашла. Всё плохо с точки зрения арт дирекшена: нет ощущения, что ты в Средиземье плюс все локации выглядят некрасиво, удались только орки - они разные и уродливые. Геймплей больше похож на мобильный фритуплей, чем на ААА игру - сюжет неинтересный, хороших миссий нет вовсе, постоянное повторение скучных действий, который сводятся к битвам с десятками и десятками орков.К сожалению, игра не зашла. Всё плохо с точки зрения арт дирекшена: нет ощущения, что ты в Средиземье плюс все локации выглядят некрасиво, удались только орки - они разные и уродливые. Геймплей больше похож на мобильный фритуплей, чем на ААА игру - сюжет неинтересный, хороших миссий нет вовсе, постоянное повторение скучных действий, который сводятся к битвам с десятками и десятками орков. Ждал захвата крепостей, но и он не оправдал ожиданий - особой тактики нет, просто орков много десятков, нужно захватит несколько точек и потом победить босса. Захват орков и их прокачка слишком репитативен и уныл как и прокачка. Куча значков на карте, но интересных занятий нет, зато есть тупой бег по карте на километры и много багов. Я в печали, по сравнению с 1 частью игра лучше не стала :(… Expand
  49. TrallOrk
    Oct 29, 2017
    0
    Po genialnej pierwszej części, która zaskoczyła systemem nemezis , powrót do dwójki to swoisty wtf, serio, twórcy zrobili coś czego nie jestem w stanie przeboleć w tej części, mianowicie jesli podbiłeś jedną twierdzę to tj byś grał już we wszystko co ta gra ma do zaoferowania ,ponieważ zawartość jest powielona do bólu, owszem system nemezis ulegl co rusz wiekszej ewolucji, teraz orkowiePo genialnej pierwszej części, która zaskoczyła systemem nemezis , powrót do dwójki to swoisty wtf, serio, twórcy zrobili coś czego nie jestem w stanie przeboleć w tej części, mianowicie jesli podbiłeś jedną twierdzę to tj byś grał już we wszystko co ta gra ma do zaoferowania ,ponieważ zawartość jest powielona do bólu, owszem system nemezis ulegl co rusz wiekszej ewolucji, teraz orkowie sprzymierzeni mogą nas zdradzać, albo tez ratować w przyplywie ostatniej szansy przed zgonem , w pierwszej części mieliśmy tj 2 fortece, tutaj mamy ich znacznie znacznie więcej ,każda z fortec to osobna mapka ,stosunkowo mały obszar różniący się topografią terenu typu wulkaniczny grafment,lodowy fragment, sloneczny lisciasty fragment, otwart swiat zostal zastapiony na wzor czegos z dragon age inkwizycji, w pierwszej części tez był taki podział z tym, że te dwa gragmenty ziemi były większe niż pare twierdz mozolnie zdobywanych jak na taśmie produkcyjnej, typu przejmuj po kolei kontrole nad armia saurona po czym jak juz uzbierasz odpowiednią ilość orków i lvl bohatera , mozesz zdobywac twierdzę , cały urok piewrszej części został wjebany pod dywan mikrotransakcji ktore co rusz uswiadamiaja ci ze bez otwierania skrzynek cien wojny bedzie mozolną wędrówką o zabarwieniu mmorpg w którym jesteś ewidentnie ciągnięty w strone marchewki , która i tak jest poza twoim zasiegiem dopóki nie ''przypakujesz''. W 1 czesci urokliwe bylo zmieżenie się z kimś o wiele potężniejszym i możliwość wygrania takiego pojedynku, tutaj ta urokliwość zosala zabudowana ścianą pay to wind bądź grind to win, ludzie mają w chuuuuuuj godzin w grze wlaśnie przez tą mozolność zdobywania kolejnych wież , jestem obecnie przy 3 i mam wrazenie ze widzialem w tej grze juz wszystko, jestem nią znudzony i wkurwiony. Do 1 części wracałem dla samego fun'u wybijania tych skurczybyków , jednak dwójka została pozbawiona tego funu, bo wszystkiego jest tak zatrzęsienie, że ulecial klimat skrytobojczego przeslizgiwania sie w zgliszczach, teraz po prostu biegne obok orkow i mam w dupie czy biegna za mna czy nie, to wlasnie ta rożnica, tytuł stracił ducha , stał się bezcelową wojną o mord, a fabuła ? coż zacząłem przewijać przerywniki , tak mnie wciągneła , zupełnie nie zależy mi na losach tych osób ani przebiegu scenariusza tak samo jak i w kolko zdobywanie fortow konczących sie z bossem w lochu ,gezeees żygam tą powtarzalnością bez serca. takie 0/10… Expand
  50. BeiNeludei
    Oct 30, 2017
    0
    Gioco fantastico fino al terzo atto. Il quarto... beh mi è passata la voglia di giocare. Magari mi guardo il finale su YouTube...non si può strutturare un atto intero in questo modo. È un pay to finale.non ho la pazienza di difendere fortezze per una settimana.

    Dilusione
  51. KelTyZed
    Oct 30, 2017
    0
    El juego entero no me lo he pasado por que el 4 acto es hacer lo mismo todo el rato, tienes que defender tus fortalezas una vez tras otra si llego a saber que esta parte del juego se hace asi no me lo compro, solo por eso hace que el juego pase de ser un buen juego a no serlo, no se que pensaron cuando lo hicieron pero vamos llevo 14 fortalezas seguidas defendidas y no pienso seguir hanEl juego entero no me lo he pasado por que el 4 acto es hacer lo mismo todo el rato, tienes que defender tus fortalezas una vez tras otra si llego a saber que esta parte del juego se hace asi no me lo compro, solo por eso hace que el juego pase de ser un buen juego a no serlo, no se que pensaron cuando lo hicieron pero vamos llevo 14 fortalezas seguidas defendidas y no pienso seguir han querido innovar con lo de capturar castillos y esta bien pero todo tiene un limite, y aqui os habeis pasado mucho.… Expand
  52. rfisha
    Nov 22, 2017
    0
    More microtransaction crap in a full price game. I agree with other reviewers that this is not good for a full price game. I cancelled my order and will be giving this one a miss.

    Such a shame, because I loved the orginal and this looks so much better.
  53. jhonba
    Oct 14, 2017
    9
    para mi este juego no merece tan odio por las micro transacciones por que no afecta la campaña en vez de eso debería quejar se cosas mas importantes los se quejan no saben jugar es el equipo sino
    el jugador
  54. Ryhelia
    Oct 21, 2017
    10
    My god...3.4 user score? 100+ people giving a 0 because of microtransactions? UGH. I wish metacritic could keep user reviews somewhat legit. I mean, one idiot wrote a whole paragraph talking about how great and addictibe the game is.....then said "but it has micro transactions so i give it a 0".

    This game is fan tastic, addictive, and by far the best game in the Tolkein universe.    My god...3.4 user score? 100+ people giving a 0 because of microtransactions? UGH. I wish metacritic could keep user reviews somewhat legit. I mean, one idiot wrote a whole paragraph talking about how great and addictibe the game is.....then said "but it has micro transactions so i give it a 0".

    This game is fan tastic, addictive, and by far the best game in the Tolkein universe. Building armies is spectacular fun. Hunting orcs is wonderful. Even the "grind" aspect is fun.

    If you don't like microtransactions transactions DONT BUY LOOT BOXES. They are unnecessary. They are for people who want to quickly breeze through the game without working for it.    … Expand
  55. miszcz2000
    Oct 16, 2017
    9
    The game is awesome! Brutal and addictive. More of the same but better and bigger. If you don't like the micro transactions then don't buy the damn loot boxes. They're quite useless anyway.
  56. RistoH
    Oct 18, 2017
    10
    Alright, most of the reviews complaining about microtransactions have simply not played the game, or at least are not good at the game. I played the first game, Shadow of Mordor through twice 100% in less than the time i've already spent on one playthrough of Shadow of War. (EDIT: I forgot to mention that i also played all of the DLC through in that time.) And frankly, i must say thatAlright, most of the reviews complaining about microtransactions have simply not played the game, or at least are not good at the game. I played the first game, Shadow of Mordor through twice 100% in less than the time i've already spent on one playthrough of Shadow of War. (EDIT: I forgot to mention that i also played all of the DLC through in that time.) And frankly, i must say that Shadow of War is better, in every way that it can be. The graphics are nice, the game runs better, there's no longer these useless or annoying sidequests, but they are replaced with actual, interesting story content. The nemesis system is better in every way, and helping your followers feels good, (even though after you've conquered all of mordor you have little connection to your followers anymore.) The game is basically just better in every way. God i loved the Nazgul fights.
    But never in those over 50 hours of gameplay did i experience an impassable paywall where i either have to grind for 50 hours or pay money to get through act4. I actually spent an hour per area, hunting for good captains, assigned warchiefs and upgraded my fortresses with the money i had gathered throughout the game, (and i spent about 50 000 miriam on lootboxes just to see what i'd get at lower levels)
    Having upgraded all my forts to a the fullest extent i could, in less than 5 hours of gaming i started playing the sieges. Oh damn, i just won, and they didn't even breach a wall. Damn well i guess it will get harder. But it never did, i just dominated orcs during the sieges always getting the max level guys i could. You get a level per siege so keeping up with the enemy isn't a problem.
    I only lost 2 sieges and those were because of my own error, and not because of the level of my fort or my followers.
    Not once in my playthrough did i face a paywall or even notice the microtransactions.
    I also saw someone complaining that their followers started dying all the time, well that's because you didn't go revive them or you just generally didn't look after them. Never was a problem for me.

    All in all the game was totally worth the money i spent on it, i will buy the expansions to the game, because i absolutely loved the experience. All of you who are complaining about the microtransactions or the paywall or what have you, have not played the game or suck very deeply.    … Expand
  57. Mortalus
    Oct 26, 2017
    7
    Let me tell you a story, Mortalus bought Shadow of War, Mortalus did not cry like a little **** about micro-transactions that are totally nonessential to the game. Mortalus on the other hand enjoyed the new upgraded nemesis system (which is now nuts), loot, running and jumping all over Mordor, collecting stuff, Mortalus died like 20 times on the hardest difficulty totally having fun. BeLet me tell you a story, Mortalus bought Shadow of War, Mortalus did not cry like a little **** about micro-transactions that are totally nonessential to the game. Mortalus on the other hand enjoyed the new upgraded nemesis system (which is now nuts), loot, running and jumping all over Mordor, collecting stuff, Mortalus died like 20 times on the hardest difficulty totally having fun. Be like Mortalus.

    Edit: As I finished the game, I must say the story was nice, but the game does not end, and that is where it all fell apart, you basicially need to achieve max level to get to the secret ending, I ended somewhere near level 50 with all my quests done, so all you are left with is killing orc captains, but I dominated all of them, so everything I was left with was shun my orcs from my army and then kill them, but it takes a lot of time, to get from level 47 to 48 you need to do 70 captain missions. It does get repetitive, it is very big grind to full level, I do not know why developers went this way, Still microtransactions are not needed, maybe those XP boosts might come in hand, to new players I might recommend gem your armor with XP gems and play on lower difficulty as you will not get extra health from green gems which you will sacrifice for the white ones, maybe this way you will be able to get extra XP from quests and actually finish the game for cut scene that lasts +- 1m30s. Overall the game was pretty fun until ACT 4.

    (I do support these micro-transactions as it is a way for developers to make some extra money for their hard effort, as far as they do not push you to buy those boxes, you do not need them at all, not a little bit.)    … Expand
  58. rodericrinehart
    Jan 2, 2018
    9
    The game is a 9/10. It improves upon the original in EVERY way, specifically combat, graphics, no QTEs, and variety of environments. The loot box outrage is ridiculous. You can absolutely beat the game and enjoy it thoroughly without spending a penny. People are going to have to get used to loot boxes in 99% of games - all multiplayer and a majority of the single player games will haveThe game is a 9/10. It improves upon the original in EVERY way, specifically combat, graphics, no QTEs, and variety of environments. The loot box outrage is ridiculous. You can absolutely beat the game and enjoy it thoroughly without spending a penny. People are going to have to get used to loot boxes in 99% of games - all multiplayer and a majority of the single player games will have them. The real test will be if they are pay-to-win, or just cosmetic and optional. The ones in Shadow of War are not cosmetic only, but they absolutely 100% are optional to beating and enjoying the game.… Expand
  59. starceph
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    Mira, sabéis que? que como le dais 0 para bajar la media pues yo le doy el 10 para subirla. Segid llorando con vuestras pamplinas y vuestros "oh vamos a quejarnos de un juego que ni siquiera tenemos" que yo me lo estoy pasando bomba con el juego
  60. mikecv434
    Oct 16, 2017
    9
    The is a great game!! There are microtansactions in Destiny 2(another great game),why isnt it getting slated too. Buy the game, play the game, enjoy the game. If you dont want to pay for the extras then dont bother.
  61. gurgen
    Oct 25, 2017
    10
    After seeing the reviews being generally negative I decided to register and leave my own. This game is by far the best RPG game I have ever played in my entire life. The Witcher 3 come really close but in a different way. There is absolutely everything in this game that anybody may ever want. INSANE amount of variety in EVERYTHING!!! Nemesis system is improved tremendously after the firstAfter seeing the reviews being generally negative I decided to register and leave my own. This game is by far the best RPG game I have ever played in my entire life. The Witcher 3 come really close but in a different way. There is absolutely everything in this game that anybody may ever want. INSANE amount of variety in EVERYTHING!!! Nemesis system is improved tremendously after the first game! I played for about 20-30 hours before I started noticing SIMILAR (NOT THE SAME) NPCs huge depth of their characters makes you feel their uniqueness within the world, and even when I pass by regular orcs I just feel obliged to rid the world from this monsters because I feel I truly fight the dark powers and really make a difference by killing them! This is the first game ever that makes me feel that way about any regular monsters that are scattered throughout the world. The danger of any orc being able to slay you and earn the respect and promotion makes you feel cautious of your every move. The variety of the surrounding area is just stunning! every single location is the size of the whole map from the first game which is pretty impressive, considering the amount of action that is packed within. Scattered artifacts and hidden memories now MAKE SENSE! I feel the desire to find out what has happen to the world and once again I feel like I really can make the difference by submerging into the atmosphere of battle between light and dark. Skills are designed to make you think about the upgrades you should use approaching any significant battle be it an assault, ambush or anything else that leads to the weakening of the Saurons army. It will take me another review to discuss the battle system. Such a variety of moves that Talion and the orcs display just stuns me every single time I engage in mortal battle for survival. Slo-mo is absolutely incredible and is always more than appropriate! I have not experienced anything like it in any game (maybe Witcher 3is coming close to that but not quite). Animation of the characters (main and regular farming material) makes me feel like those scum is actually may be an individual with a personality. The promoted orcs are just fabulous. I can't stop admiring the quality of detail and depth of the characters. I am still amazed with the orcs chit chat right before the mo fos are about to go down. Within the battle there can be numerous moments when the tide can change and the fight balance can shift either way. Several times I was unexpectedly saved by soldiers popping out of nowhere giving me a chance to survive. Just as many times I was about to slay another green beef cake as suddenly I was tackled by some giant in an ambush attempt. The variety of approaches you can take is just mind boggling to me. Loot system is not excellent but is an improvement still. Now there is at least a reason for you to "farm" the orc, although coming back to a variety of the enemies, it does not feel completely like farming, since I feel every enemy is unique and worth my time slaying the bastard. And I think the last but not least, the graphics. Stunning. The level of detail is exceptional, colors are beautiful and the textures and attention to the world is awesome! Finally, microtransactions. If you are one of those people who complete the game on easy difficulty, keep buying the chests. For those who are broke and can't afford it - beat it. You don't have to buy it. It doesn't affect you if someone buys a loot box, so wtf would you complain about someone playing the game with a little help? it's their own story! I would understand if it was an MMO and you were busted by jerks who buy 100 boxes and farm you every time.… Expand
  62. Kenmei
    Nov 28, 2017
    0
    I wanted to go into this with an open mind. All the news about the microtransactions was really disturbing to me but I wanted to give this a shot. Well, quite frankly, this game sucks. And not just because of the microtransactions. No pretty much everything in this game had very little added to it, or just flat out failed in its delivery.
    Basically imagine just the first game, with a    I wanted to go into this with an open mind. All the news about the microtransactions was really disturbing to me but I wanted to give this a shot. Well, quite frankly, this game sucks. And not just because of the microtransactions. No pretty much everything in this game had very little added to it, or just flat out failed in its delivery.
    Basically imagine just the first game, with a kinda different story and, again, the microtransactions. While the story is prob average, it suffers heavily from the 4th act being a MASSIVE leveling grind and a halt to pretty much any momentum it had gained from the previous act. The beginning of Act 4 is the point where the game starts to heavily recommend you buy loot boxes because of the sudden massive level deficiency you find yourself in. With the amount of time it would take to grind your way to the point where you are able to do those quests, hours will have gone by and I can't accept that. For how little things changed from the 1st game to this one, throwing a massive road block in there around 3/4th the way through it is a slap in the face. All the good will that Monolith built up through the first game, with alot of stolen concepts from other games, is just completely gone now. I won't play another game in the series and prob never another Monolith game. They've lost a customer by their actions here.    … Expand
  63. inverguy
    Oct 24, 2017
    0
    The golden age of gaming is behind us. This game is a pure representation of how terribly wrong it can get if the company is not interested in just taking your money but stealing it from you. But before I say more.

    Pros: there is some good content in this game. They definitely developed the story so it offers more entertainment but this is where everything positive ends. Cons: That    The golden age of gaming is behind us. This game is a pure representation of how terribly wrong it can get if the company is not interested in just taking your money but stealing it from you. But before I say more.

    Pros: there is some good content in this game. They definitely developed the story so it offers more entertainment but this is where everything positive ends.

    Cons: That entertainment seems to be limited by microtransactions. You are impacted by how much thy degraded the loot. You can easily tell that they made it so much ‘difficult’ so you invest in this already expensive game to make it enjoyable. I’m a casual gamer and never felt the need to buy any loot chests etc … but this one is just asking you for money. Yes, you can get a better loot and there are ways to guarantee it, but it ALWAYS feels like it’s few levels too late. You are actually punished for not spending even more money in a freaking single player game.

    With no respect to ppl standing behind such an awful business plan, I hope this will bite you back in the ‘behind’.

    PS: I hope you guys won’t buy this game. There are better titles… or at least wait until it’s 60% off    … Expand
  64. AcerolaOrion
    Oct 30, 2017
    0
    This is the point in time where pay to win has taken over singleplayer, pay to play games.

    The game is a horrendous grindfest. Killing Orcs doesnt give you experience. Killing captains and finishing events related to them gives A RIDICULOUSLY SMALL amount of experience. The amount of experience required to go even (and by being even on level --> able to recruit orcs and progress    This is the point in time where pay to win has taken over singleplayer, pay to play games.

    The game is a horrendous grindfest. Killing Orcs doesnt give you experience. Killing captains and finishing events related to them gives A RIDICULOUSLY SMALL amount of experience.

    The amount of experience required to go even (and by being even on level --> able to recruit orcs and progress story missions) is insane compared to what you are rewarded outside of story missions.

    Naturally you can buy experience boosters with real money! And just like for junkies, the first lootbox is always free! Making sure to catch all the people who are predisposed to spending money on being exploited like this.

    Disgusting! If you want to play this game --> steal it!    … Expand
  65. SvenL1975
    Oct 24, 2017
    0
    The first three acts are a clear 8/10, maybe even a 9. Then Act IV starts and we get a tacked on part that either takes days or weeks to finish or you can just buy loot boxes to get through it quickly. And all you get afterwards is one lousy cutscene and the end credits. If you are willing to stop playing after Act III, you'll have a great experience with this game, they improved almostThe first three acts are a clear 8/10, maybe even a 9. Then Act IV starts and we get a tacked on part that either takes days or weeks to finish or you can just buy loot boxes to get through it quickly. And all you get afterwards is one lousy cutscene and the end credits. If you are willing to stop playing after Act III, you'll have a great experience with this game, they improved almost everything since the first game. Until they fix the final act, my rating will be 0/10 however.… Expand
  66. Baluberda
    Dec 28, 2017
    0
    Micropayments, waste 10+ hours grinding or pay real money. Do not buy these kind of games to let them die
  67. christhec
    Oct 18, 2017
    0
    I have specifically created an account in order to review this game, and to voice my displeasure over the inclusion of loot boxes into offline story mode. I played the first Middle-Earth game, and like many other people, were very impressed and surprised about how good the game was. I played through the story mode several times, and recommended the game to anybody that would listen.I have specifically created an account in order to review this game, and to voice my displeasure over the inclusion of loot boxes into offline story mode. I played the first Middle-Earth game, and like many other people, were very impressed and surprised about how good the game was. I played through the story mode several times, and recommended the game to anybody that would listen. Naturally, I was hugely anticipating the sequel, Shadow of War. I eagerly read bits of information leaked over the past couple of years, and was looking forward to purchasing and enjoying the game.

    Then came loot boxes. The very late announcement that the game would include loot boxes in the offline story mode has killed any love I had for this series. It is a trend which should be completely eradicated and offers no improvement to players enjoyment of the games. The feature is purely used to suck more money out of players, it adds literally zero benefit to the game.

    People should not support this game, and should be very vocal about their displeasure of it. I will not ever be purchasing this game, not for full price, or second hand when it inevitably gets traded in and the price drops. It is a disgrace that it has been included in this game.

    I am completely appalled by the critic reviews, none of which have rated this game negatively. Perhaps if they gave the game a negative review, they fear EA would not allow them early access to future games, a direct conflict of interest for their jobs and well being. I have also read on Youtube that Youtubers that were given the game early were forced, by means of contract, to only say positive things about the title. While I have no proof if this allegation is true, considering the overwhelming response from critics, I find it very believable.

    As other users have commented, I suggest everybody boycott this game, make it a failure to send a firm message to EA that this will not be tolerated.    … Expand
  68. ConnorMak
    Oct 19, 2017
    4
    No, the low score is not because of the infamous micro transactions. It's because the game is a frustrating and boring grind. Wait until after Xmas and pick it up for under $20. $10 if you wait longer.
  69. KottarBjorn
    Oct 21, 2017
    0
    I just finished the game, and this is a soulless piece of junk. The story sucks, it does not follow the tolkien books or movies, the combat i repetitive (you can just mash 1 button the hole time and win every fight) the game tells you every time how to beat the enemy in every fight with helpboxses and messages, it requires you to buy lootboxes for the last 25% of the game, because theI just finished the game, and this is a soulless piece of junk. The story sucks, it does not follow the tolkien books or movies, the combat i repetitive (you can just mash 1 button the hole time and win every fight) the game tells you every time how to beat the enemy in every fight with helpboxses and messages, it requires you to buy lootboxes for the last 25% of the game, because the grind is not working. When 2 orcs have a fight in the pit the AI is so stupid that most of the time the units just stands there and dies. And you have to lvl up, and the only thing you can do is buying more lootboxes. So when you have paid 60 euro game, you have to add at least 20 more euro to finish the game. It is like they are taking a piss in your face when you are halfway in the game. And the game before that is not even enjoyable. It is the same assassin's creeds farming quest that says every time; go there and kill 5 guys, good job, now go here and kill 7 guys in the same way, good job, now you lvl up. And so it continues the hole game, until the microtransaction part. If you think it is weird that Critic Reviews are so much higher then the User score it is because they are to afraid to piss of EA with their bad game. Because it is. This game does not deserve any score better then it gets right now. And it comes with a lot of bugs and game crashes. In almost every mission there is some form of problem. If you know whats good for you, you spend youre cash on something good instead of this bullocks game.… Expand
  70. Squid_Guy
    Oct 29, 2017
    0
    Warner Bros greed is taking over! This glorified gambling should stop!
    These micro's ruin the experience! This is ruining the AAA industry.
    It doesn't help that it allready has multiple special editions and a season pass. Which is already pretty scummy. But to put in micro's, because this giant company says that making games is really expensive. That's rubbish, look at the indie    Warner Bros greed is taking over! This glorified gambling should stop!
    These micro's ruin the experience! This is ruining the AAA industry.
    It doesn't help that it allready has multiple special editions and a season pass. Which is already pretty scummy.
    But to put in micro's, because this giant company says that making games is really expensive.
    That's rubbish, look at the indie industry, look at Hellblade. These games were made without the funding of micro's, they aren't made by a giant company, and they turn a profit.

    These publishers are just liars!    … Expand
  71. Sceptic
    Oct 20, 2017
    5
    A genuinely excellent game marred by a lootbox system.While it's true that they are not necessary,the endgame is clearly designed to "encourage" players who have little time or patience to repetitively grind,and to purchase fast tracks to success.This is disgusting.So after spending a huge amount of time(In the pits mostly) grinding my way to 100% completion,I'll give this game a 10 forA genuinely excellent game marred by a lootbox system.While it's true that they are not necessary,the endgame is clearly designed to "encourage" players who have little time or patience to repetitively grind,and to purchase fast tracks to success.This is disgusting.So after spending a huge amount of time(In the pits mostly) grinding my way to 100% completion,I'll give this game a 10 for the first 80%,minus 5 for the insidious,predatory single player lootbox system.… Expand
  72. Tom360
    Dec 4, 2017
    2
    Man what a letdown!!! The first game was totally polished, told a coherent story, no major bugs. This one is a mess! Texture pop-in, enemies spawn right in front of you, combat feels chaotic and messy (not in a good way). I loved the first game, but this one needed to cook for a bit longer before seeing the light of day!
  73. superfields
    Nov 19, 2017
    9
    Totally unfair reviews, which is why I had to write my own review. If reviews were left to gamers like these no one would ever want to play games. I agree I hate microtransactions too, Star wars Heroes is a perfect example. But unlike that game which forces you to purchase game time, this game is entirely up to you if you want to make any further purchases. Believe me if your good at thisTotally unfair reviews, which is why I had to write my own review. If reviews were left to gamers like these no one would ever want to play games. I agree I hate microtransactions too, Star wars Heroes is a perfect example. But unlike that game which forces you to purchase game time, this game is entirely up to you if you want to make any further purchases. Believe me if your good at this game you never have too.

    Besides this game is better than the original in every aspect, so when I say its a shame how many people turned a blind eye to this game based on the losers who gave this game zero. Pretty sad, to give a zero means it has too be absolutely atrocious and this is far from it...    … Expand
  74. damien_k98
    Nov 27, 2017
    9
    You gotta love the fact that if their is one, just one little flaw with a game, then the User Score on MC has to be Unfavorable. My only flaw with the game is that the graphics feels a little......meh compared to other WB games like Batman: Arkham Knight, Injustice 2, and Shadow Of Mordor. Other than that, this game was a blast, great combat mechanics, fun story, and of course The Nemesis System.
  75. peepeetime
    Oct 23, 2017
    8
    If you are a fan of the first game then you're gonna have a good time. It builds on the first game and delivers some real fun. Minus 2 points for a weaker story and a dragged out act IV. The micro-transaction complaints are overblown but not unfounded. I personally didn't need to pay a penny for lootboxes but the fact they were shown in game so prominently is troubling.
  76. Aginagala
    Nov 13, 2017
    6
    Although the game can be buggy at times an improved story, improved combat system, improved nemesis system and a huge open world cannot take away the fact that this was a great game and thoroughly enjoyable. I finished the story to a point where I couldn't stop there and simply carried on afterwards. I found new monsters such as drakes a great implementation, and were fun to upgrade withAlthough the game can be buggy at times an improved story, improved combat system, improved nemesis system and a huge open world cannot take away the fact that this was a great game and thoroughly enjoyable. I finished the story to a point where I couldn't stop there and simply carried on afterwards. I found new monsters such as drakes a great implementation, and were fun to upgrade with the improved RPG system, giving a feeling of satisfaction when leveling and finally being able to ride one. Moreover I found the leveling system on the whole in the game extremely satisfying to unlock new move sets, and skills to aid me on my journey.

    Finding a legendary captain felt scary and when you are ambushed at the point of almost killing another captain for your army it feels very real. To build on this you see betrayals against you, betrayals against the warchiefs, seemingly a much more real and immersive feeling surrounded the game this time, as mini stories were built up within your armies and at points I felt small bonds connected to particular captains that stuck with me or helped me in situations I did not expect.

    The game built on the best bits of the former game creating a thoroughly enjoyable experience. The gigantic battles that were the sieges were perhaps the best part of this game, with huge and reasonably challenging battles, and more than enough choice to plan how you can attack. I feel the first, fight and capture part was reasonably easy however the Overlords themselves are no push over. Each with unique and tough abilities, interesting designs and never feeling samey due to lazy design, fighting them always felt like a new experience, the setting, the time taken to get there was beautifully crafted.

    However... the game is let down due to the gambling aspect of it. This game has succumbed to micro transactions, another let down of a great game. It was unnecessary and could have been completely avoided and been a fantastic game without it. Moreover due to these micro transactions the end game was a lot more grindy than enjoyable and with a lack luster ending. Moreover, the fact that the micro transaction aspect of the game is always in your face, when you're spending hours after hours grinding the same things over and over, it becomes tempting which I do not like at all, and for younger gamers I'm sure it would be more than enough to convince them to purchase something in this. However in 2017 it no longer surprises me when Triple A titles contain micro-transactions, it could have easily been left out and felt like a much more satisfying experience after grinding all your huge army up, rather than knowing that someone had skipped all that and simply bought their way into most probably a better position than you. Without these, it would have easily had a lot of better reviews and been a much more well appreciated game, it's part of what made the first game fun, the feeling that you were at the bottom and had to make your way up the ranks of orcs with no other way of simply cheating/buying your way up there. A fantastic game let down by greed..    … Expand
  77. Juel92
    Nov 15, 2017
    8
    A great game held back by occasionally repetetive gameplay and a weaker 3rd act. The game features microtransactions but I can honestly say that I never even considered using them. The Uruks are plentiful and sieges are fairly easy, especially if you dominate the Warchiefs. The game does improve and expand on the first one but it also feels a bit held back and not quite the "Greater thanA great game held back by occasionally repetetive gameplay and a weaker 3rd act. The game features microtransactions but I can honestly say that I never even considered using them. The Uruks are plentiful and sieges are fairly easy, especially if you dominate the Warchiefs. The game does improve and expand on the first one but it also feels a bit held back and not quite the "Greater than the sum of it's parts" that the first game was.
    Still a lot of fun and if you enjoyed the first one you should get this game and just ignore the MTs since they're entirely pointless.    … Expand
  78. SirPedr
    Dec 15, 2017
    8
    It's a great game, if you disregard the large amount of microtransactions. I've been playing it for hours and hours, the gameplay is a lot of fun and the world is very vast; one of the few games worth collecting collectibles and relics, for being interesting and contribute to immersion in the world of Tolkien.
    However, the story is less profound and interesting than the first game. The    It's a great game, if you disregard the large amount of microtransactions. I've been playing it for hours and hours, the gameplay is a lot of fun and the world is very vast; one of the few games worth collecting collectibles and relics, for being interesting and contribute to immersion in the world of Tolkien.
    However, the story is less profound and interesting than the first game. The idea of putting a rivalry between the main characters could have been better explored and developed throughout the plot, rather than bringing it to the surface only at the end.
    Anyway, it's still worth playing. Fun gameplay that entertains for several hours, old game systems have been improved and enhanced, and dubbing in Portuguese is fantastic.    … Expand
  79. xrichardisfast
    Dec 28, 2017
    9
    From what I've played so far of Shadow Of War (about 15 hours) I've been loving it, I was told not to buy it because of the horrible forcing of loot boxes on people and I honestly don't see it. Yes loot boxes are a thing in this game but contrast to what all the salty reviewers looking to give this game a bad name for being greedy say, the loot boxes are a big issue, and aren't needed toFrom what I've played so far of Shadow Of War (about 15 hours) I've been loving it, I was told not to buy it because of the horrible forcing of loot boxes on people and I honestly don't see it. Yes loot boxes are a thing in this game but contrast to what all the salty reviewers looking to give this game a bad name for being greedy say, the loot boxes are a big issue, and aren't needed to experience the game as a whole. Onto the gameplay: the gameplay in Shadow Of War is rather rewarding to play, and defeating orcs has been refined since the first title. it may become a little repetitive after awhile, however for someone who is looking to enjoy the game (and not trying to savagely gut it for being a micro transaction game) it is easy to overlook. As a fan of the Middle Earth universe, the most offensive thing about the game is the story. it breaks the lore in every which way and has no respect for how rings function in this world. I won't go into more detail, lest I spoil anything. Finally, I'd like to briefly talk about the graphics. The graphics of shadow of war are stunning and are a massive improvement over the first title. Even if the occasional orcs body glitches, the graphics are still amazing and the glitches are minor.

    Overall a very enjoyable experience thus far. If i had one recommendation to you it would be to ignore the salty reviewers who are only here to tear apart the game for having micro transactions and see what fun and beauty the game has to offer.    … Expand
  80. redeyedwerewolf
    May 25, 2018
    9
    DONT LISTEN TO THE HATERS,THIS IS WHAT U GET WHEN U ALWAYS LISTEN TO THE MEDIA NOT YOUR OPINION OF THE DAMN THING.THE CRITICS ARE ALWAYS TALKING ABOUT MICROTRANSACTIONS IN THIS GAME,I COMPLETED 100% OF THE GAME AND PLATNIUMED IT AND ENJOYED EVERY BIT OF IT,AMAZING GAME,I COMPLETED IT WITHOUT PAYING ANY REAL WORLD MONEY.THE ONLY NEGATIVE OF THIS GAME IS THAT IT CAN GET A LITTLE BITDONT LISTEN TO THE HATERS,THIS IS WHAT U GET WHEN U ALWAYS LISTEN TO THE MEDIA NOT YOUR OPINION OF THE DAMN THING.THE CRITICS ARE ALWAYS TALKING ABOUT MICROTRANSACTIONS IN THIS GAME,I COMPLETED 100% OF THE GAME AND PLATNIUMED IT AND ENJOYED EVERY BIT OF IT,AMAZING GAME,I COMPLETED IT WITHOUT PAYING ANY REAL WORLD MONEY.THE ONLY NEGATIVE OF THIS GAME IS THAT IT CAN GET A LITTLE BIT REPETITVE IN THE SHADOW WARS END GAME… Expand
  81. Kurxen
    Nov 23, 2019
    1
    DO NOT BUY even if it were a dollar. I play every game out there but this game is GARBAGE. One of the biggest issues is the enemy balancing. Ots just ridiculous and unplayable as you can defeat a single thing. I'm telling you even on easy mode they can still one or two shot you
  82. WeThinkHealth
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    Everyone here, aside from the fraud making multiple Metacritic accounts, knows this game is an 8, 9, or a 10. This game didn't get GOTY for nothing in its prior form, and THIS iteration is even better. Please ignore the misguided account cloner giving this great game a 0 or a 1. Be thankful these studios create these great games for us for the same price we used to pay for 8-bit cartridgesEveryone here, aside from the fraud making multiple Metacritic accounts, knows this game is an 8, 9, or a 10. This game didn't get GOTY for nothing in its prior form, and THIS iteration is even better. Please ignore the misguided account cloner giving this great game a 0 or a 1. Be thankful these studios create these great games for us for the same price we used to pay for 8-bit cartridges in the days of NES. I, for one, don't forget those days in the 80s and 90s where - if we wanted a true AAA experience - we had to insert 25 cents or 50 cents into an arcade machine to play a game that doesn't even come CLOSE to the experiences we get in today's age from the comfort of our couch in our living rooms on our very own console. We're lucky, indeed! Hopefully, Metacritic will delete these erroneous reviews.… Expand
  83. capnskillet
    Oct 11, 2017
    9
    This is an early review, but I wanted to try to help counter all the zeroes from people who didn't even play. The bad reviews are only becasue of microtransactions, which would only speed up gameplay for those who want to get an advantage. None of it is required to play and enjoy the game.

    If you enjoyed the first game, then this one is much like it just more options. More skills,    This is an early review, but I wanted to try to help counter all the zeroes from people who didn't even play. The bad reviews are only becasue of microtransactions, which would only speed up gameplay for those who want to get an advantage. None of it is required to play and enjoy the game.

    If you enjoyed the first game, then this one is much like it just more options. More skills, better loot system, more orc varieties, an enjoyable story line so far, and just all around fun. You can also set difficulty this time. Bottom line is just buy the game and avoid the microtransactions if you hate them.    … Expand
  84. Vitooc
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    I don't understand people crying about micro-transactions... You can easily finish the game without using it !! It is just a possibility if you want more epic and legendary orcs etc, but really not an obligation at any time!!
    It is definitely a great game let's be honest!!
  85. LuigiC96
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    great game ignoring micro transaction, blame WB not the devs, silly people harming the Devs for something they have no power or control over. supporting the Devs
  86. simzodom
    Oct 14, 2017
    10
    Miocro-transations, so what? It will not ruin the actual game itself. The $60 is for the base game. To all those saying that this game is similar to a mobile app, educate yourself. There are games out there where you run out of "energy points" and have to wait 5 minutes+ to continue playing. Most of which are games that actually don't even have any substance. Its literally "pay and go toMiocro-transations, so what? It will not ruin the actual game itself. The $60 is for the base game. To all those saying that this game is similar to a mobile app, educate yourself. There are games out there where you run out of "energy points" and have to wait 5 minutes+ to continue playing. Most of which are games that actually don't even have any substance. Its literally "pay and go to the next chapter, pay to get the weapon that does 5444 damage vs the sword you get in the game that does 77 damage." Those are extremes that "Shadow of War" doesn't go to. Mobile apps also rely heavily on what is referred to as a "whale". The 5% of the people who get the game for free who encompass more than half of the overall profit of. Nobody aims a gun to their head to make them pay.

    If you owned a company and could make a profit doing this, you would all do it. If you have willpower to play the game and not even look at the micro-transactions (buy the stuff with in game currency or actually earn your loot) then it would be a pleasant experience. It is NOT grindy in my opinion because it is fun to use some strategy and kill/capture the harder orcs. Also, you do not need to pay to beat the game, you do not hit a steep wall that you cannot get past unless you pay, you can enjoy it regardless. You guys are so annoying, giving this game 0/10's when it is actually an extremely fun game with plenty of things to do.

    I am willing to bet that most of you just trash the game, but then run straight to the store and buy it/enjoy it. You just want to complain for the sake of complaining. Play the game or don't review it.    … Expand
  87. Veronus
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    Haven't spent a penny on micro-transactions. This game rules them all and it's easily a 10. Such a great job making this game EPIC and addictive. Unfortunately too many people have seen that you can buy orcs and items (if you choose) and assume that it's a pay to win. Simply put that is dead wrong. Nothing is going to make this game EASIER, and while it might be nice to have some extraHaven't spent a penny on micro-transactions. This game rules them all and it's easily a 10. Such a great job making this game EPIC and addictive. Unfortunately too many people have seen that you can buy orcs and items (if you choose) and assume that it's a pay to win. Simply put that is dead wrong. Nothing is going to make this game EASIER, and while it might be nice to have some extra gear or orcs around they are not required, simple jump off the tower go recruit and don't spend $$. A great job of giving players a choice has blown back in Monolith's face because of a fickle demographic. Don't miss out on this game because of cosmetics. Trust Me.… Expand
  88. easterfields
    Oct 14, 2017
    10
    Anything less than a 9 for this masterpiece is a crime against gaming! This whole package is a masterpiece. People whining and wetting themselves over the loot feature havent even played the fantastic story mode. Buy this game and appreciate it for what it is, one of the most fun adventures (and best looking) around. Warning though! The AI, aka Nemesis System, is scary good.
  89. Thcenkdug
    Oct 17, 2017
    9
    Firstly, yes there are loot boxes, and yes, you can use real money to pay for them. You can also use in-game currency to buy the low end loot boxes. I played this game for a week which equates to about 40 hours of game play and got to level 60. I did the daily quests and earned enough online currency to buy the two starter loot boxes (Act 1 and Act 2) about 1300 coins. I received over 20Firstly, yes there are loot boxes, and yes, you can use real money to pay for them. You can also use in-game currency to buy the low end loot boxes. I played this game for a week which equates to about 40 hours of game play and got to level 60. I did the daily quests and earned enough online currency to buy the two starter loot boxes (Act 1 and Act 2) about 1300 coins. I received over 20 orcs, 8 xp boosts, and a handful of in game currency boosts. I used my XP boosts while I was playing the numerous main and side quests. Doing this I was able to skyrocket to level 60 and never feel like I was grinding, sometimes gaining two or three levels at once. Be careful though because they only last for two hours of real time, so make sure you use that time wisely. The only "grind" part was getting my orcs at a higher for the Stage Defenses of my Fortresses. This did take me about 5 hours to get all my fortresses leveled to my level. But, since then I haven't purposefully leveled a single orc, at worst during my siege defenses, I capture more powerful orcs and put them in place of the weaker ones. With all that said, the facial graphics during game play is the reason I gave this a 9. As for all the complaints about the loot boxes, I did not pay for a single one and am still having a great time.… Expand
  90. diegolavega77
    Oct 15, 2017
    10
    To all the other reviewers on about the game being pay to win ignore them, i played the whole base story in about 4 days and im through 50% of the grind without and i quote "Opening ANY lootbox" Not even a free currency lootbox nothing i have not touched it and the game is completely normal, i have been able to play normally, hell i even felt like i was in shadow of mordor for a while.JustTo all the other reviewers on about the game being pay to win ignore them, i played the whole base story in about 4 days and im through 50% of the grind without and i quote "Opening ANY lootbox" Not even a free currency lootbox nothing i have not touched it and the game is completely normal, i have been able to play normally, hell i even felt like i was in shadow of mordor for a while.Just more content and customisation. But whatever, since all these people have herd mentality opinions im just gonna leave it at this.… Expand
  91. angryjack67
    Oct 16, 2017
    9
    Everyone whining in the reviews are either complaining without playing the game first, or are trash at the game. I played throughout the game only buying one chest (tutorial). I found the game to be really fun and nearly none of my orcs die. If you are complaining about the micro transactions (which are there to HELP you, not hinder you) then just get a trainer to assist you. I don'tEveryone whining in the reviews are either complaining without playing the game first, or are trash at the game. I played throughout the game only buying one chest (tutorial). I found the game to be really fun and nearly none of my orcs die. If you are complaining about the micro transactions (which are there to HELP you, not hinder you) then just get a trainer to assist you. I don't promote cheating but its better than giving a great game terrible reviews. The only reason i give it a 9/10 is because after beating the game there is not much to do, if anything. i think that additions to the multiplayer would greatly help out.… Expand
  92. Kaioh
    Oct 10, 2017
    8
    This game is a god tier. If you liked ME:SoM - you will like this even more.
    Pls ignore buttblasted kiddies who fell for transactions meme. They're trying to ruin games score just like they did it with Deus Ex Mankind Divided.
    Ignore little kids. Buy the game and form your own opinion. You don't need p2w in this game.
  93. GoEdison
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    If you liked Shadow of Mordor, you'll LOVE Shadow of War. Period. Nothing else needs to be said...aside from the fact that everyone should ignore the 0 - 1 ratings from the same guy who's really angry about loot boxes and microtransactions - not to mention upvoting his multiple reviews with fake accounts. You have to seriously question the character of people who'll spend their dayIf you liked Shadow of Mordor, you'll LOVE Shadow of War. Period. Nothing else needs to be said...aside from the fact that everyone should ignore the 0 - 1 ratings from the same guy who's really angry about loot boxes and microtransactions - not to mention upvoting his multiple reviews with fake accounts. You have to seriously question the character of people who'll spend their day creating fake accounts to make several reviews, leave several ratings, and give their own reviews a "YES" vote. You can't fix stupid! You WILL enjoy this game, though.… Expand
  94. JoeJoeMcTwist
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    Awesome game. I've put in about 10 hours of gameplay so far and this game is absolutely amazing. The combat has been built upon and refined in every aspect since ME:SOM. It feels as fluid as ever, with new and more brutal finishers.

    The story is ok so far but the nemesis system is where this game really shines. I haven't gotten too deep into the game yet but, I'm really enjoying the    Awesome game. I've put in about 10 hours of gameplay so far and this game is absolutely amazing. The combat has been built upon and refined in every aspect since ME:SOM. It feels as fluid as ever, with new and more brutal finishers.

    The story is ok so far but the nemesis system is where this game really shines. I haven't gotten too deep into the game yet but, I'm really enjoying the challenge of the hardest difficulty.

    Graphics look amazing. If you loved the first one, you will absolutely love this game. Don't listen to all the hate about MT, they're completely optional and they don't subtract from the experience at all.    … Expand
  95. Ashur
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    This is Shadow of Mordor on steroids. An amazingly fun game. Just ignore all the cry-babies crying about the microtransactions. I have been playing for quite a while and barely ever came across the menu for the lootboxes or anything. Unless you are some money spending addict, you won't notice or care about them.
  96. Cureza
    Oct 30, 2017
    0
    If I want to experience all the game I have to pay for those dam loot boxes.
    This game os not cheap and it is not fair to make players pay so much money to get the full experience.
    Don't buy this game. i'm refunding it and if you want to save game industry, boycott it
  97. DennisN92
    Oct 14, 2017
    8
    Shadow of War the sequel to the epic game called Shadow of Mordor is a great game, and I haven't been able to put the controller away since purchasing it.

    This game is fun, but even I was skeptic towards buying the game seeing how a lot of talks were going around how the game is pay to win because of the loot boxes. That does not seem to be the case at the end of the day one can play    Shadow of War the sequel to the epic game called Shadow of Mordor is a great game, and I haven't been able to put the controller away since purchasing it.

    This game is fun, but even I was skeptic towards buying the game seeing how a lot of talks were going around how the game is pay to win because of the loot boxes. That does not seem to be the case at the end of the day one can play this game without loot boxes and enjoy it thoroughly, but purchasing them does make it easier to progress throughout the game.

    The game itself has an fantastic nemesis system that makes the game feel alive. As you are progressing through the story itself, it feels like you are creating your own story by killing orcs or making them follow you as one of your companions. They really developed the nemesis system into something great seeing how orcs that worked with you helped you capture a fortress might one day turn on you and conquer everything you worked so hard to get.

    The combat system is flawless, its pretty much the same as the previous game with a few new niches to it to make it a little bit better. Plus the new RPG elements of upgrading your hero is more in-depth and lets you form Talion and Celebrimbor into the hero of Mordor you want to be.

    The scenery is impressive, the regions are all beautiful and different, but sadly the gameplay is pretty much the same in every area except that some areas got one type of enemies with some power that isn't as usual in another province.

    I don't want to put the focus on microtransactions, they are there, and I don't like them, but I won't let them ruin my gaming experience, and I won't let them keep me away from playing a great game. If you ignore them and don't purchase them then maybe the gaming companies will stop putting them in the games, you might even boycott the game overall to make a statement towards the company group if you want to do that go for it.

    Either way, the game is much better than the first one and would probably get amazing reviews if it wasn't for the microtransactions being in there. It isn't something groundbreaking, but they took a working recipe from the first game and upgraded it into a worthy sequel.

    If you like what I read make sure to take a look at my blog for more reviews like this, just google therealzadeh and you will find it.    … Expand
  98. Thetiffer66
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    Seriously? This game is awesome. Don't like micro transactions and loot crates? Don't use them. I haven't and it hasn't effected the game for me. I loved SoM, and this one is right up there. Beautiful graphics, cool new characters. If you don't play it because of this, your loss.
  99. LRDeez
    Oct 12, 2017
    10
    Micro transactions have nothing to do with completing the game. Quit with all the whining. You are not giving a fair review and no one wins when we do this.
  100. cas514
    Nov 3, 2017
    5
    Update:

    I've been playing this for about 80 hours now and im still not done.. Great right? yea i guess but something dawn on me that made me put the game down and made me stop playing. So legendary orcs, where the **** are they? I remember at the start of the game when i was in the first map, I had an orc become legendary after coming back to in my first 5 hours of the game. Then one    Update:

    I've been playing this for about 80 hours now and im still not done.. Great right? yea i guess but something dawn on me that made me put the game down and made me stop playing. So legendary orcs, where the **** are they? I remember at the start of the game when i was in the first map, I had an orc become legendary after coming back to in my first 5 hours of the game. Then one day i came back home tired and i just wanted to get a quick kill in and I mistakenly agreed to the agreement at the start of the game which shows up every-time you boot up the game which enables the online mode and now im 80 hours in and I barely get nemesis to come back to life, and barely get legendary orcs. This is a clear indication that the ****ing loot boxes effect the balance of this game greatly. It's disgusting that it had to come to this.

    First Impression ( Will Update): First off im only maybe 4 hours into the game:

    Graphics: Look worse than the first game, textures on the orcs especially look stretched out and blurry and its especially noticeable on my 4k TV. This is probably due to the scale of the game. The open world is bigger (for no reason) so the graphics had to take a hit. It's unfortunate that dev still believe bigger maps equals better game. Talions face model looks better so does the models for the other humans.

    Gameplay: Same as the first but it doesn't feel as fluid or as responsive as the first game. The reused animation from the first game still look great but the combat doest feel like a dance like the first did. Maybe it will feel better when I unlock more skills. One skill i absolutely hate and breaks the flow the combat animation is the new Staff they force you to use. I never want to use this thing, the animation when you use it feels so clunky and unsatisfying. I hope I can turn it off later.

    Lootboxes. I did not agree to the terms in the beginning so i wont have to deal with any loot boxes or multiplayer nonsense but of course I will continue to get prompted to agree anytime I boot up the game because they really want me to use the market which I never ever will. I wont know until later in the game wether or not the loot boxes will effect the game or not so we shall see. if it does I will promptly change the score to a 0 if i feel like the game is effected. I don't mind grinding as long as its fun and progression is fair but if this starts feeling like a cell phone game im going to lose it.

    Supporting Characters: I already hate them.

    Story: Not Sure, The intro to the game did nothing for me tho. Felt poorly executed. But i will update as soon as I beat the game

    I payed $18 dollars for this game so I won't feel too bad if it disappoints me but i hope that it doesn't because Mordor is one of my favorite games of all time.    … Expand
Page:

Awards & Rankings

65
#65 Best PS4 Game of 2017
12
#12 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2017
13
#13 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2017

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
80

Generally favorable reviews - based on 69 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 53 out of 69
  2. Mixed: 16 out of 69
  3. Negative: 0 out of 69
  1. CD-Action
    Dec 19, 2017
    80
    I was annoyed by various flaws (both technical and design-related) and tedious, dragged out final stages of the campaign, but overall I enjoyed the ride. It looks like the developers wanted to stuff the game with all the best elements Middle-earth has to offer. Shadow of War’s atmosphere is terrific and watching Talion rise in power is surprisingly addictive. [12/2017, p.62]
  2. Cubed3
    Nov 26, 2017
    70
    A handful of issues, some much more annoying than others, do not negate how solid of an action RPG Middle-earth: Shadow of War is. A tremendous achievement for the team at Monolith Productions, this is an exciting, if not sometimes slow, and too often unfair, title that manages to be as impressively fun as it is big.
    Read full review
  3. Playstation Official Magazine UK
    Nov 20, 2017
    60
    Big, brutal, and - alas - bloated, Shadow of War is a disappointing follow-up, conjuring battles of grand scale and then deadening their impact through grinding repetition. [December 2017, p.79]
See all critic reviews »