The Orville

:

Season 1
  • Network: FOX , HULU
  • Series Premiere Date: Sep 10, 2017
Season #: 3, 2, 1
User Score
8.4

Universal acclaim- based on 1016 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 877 out of 1016
  2. Mixed: 46 out of 1016
  3. Negative: 93 out of 1016
Watch Now

Where To Watch

Stream On
Buy on
Stream On
Stream On
Expand

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

view
per page
  1. pchernik
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    This once again proves to me that critics are either idiots or only rate positively once they are paid off and that I should not look for shows to watch based on their reviews, and instead look at "user reviews". This show is totally opposite of "Star Trek Discovery" in that respect. It's funny and it's enjoyable. If I can't have a good serious sci-fi show I'd much rather have this. If youThis once again proves to me that critics are either idiots or only rate positively once they are paid off and that I should not look for shows to watch based on their reviews, and instead look at "user reviews". This show is totally opposite of "Star Trek Discovery" in that respect. It's funny and it's enjoyable. If I can't have a good serious sci-fi show I'd much rather have this. If you are looking for a space adventure to watch, and can't stand the Discovery garbage, look no further!… Expand
  2. auriStar
    Sep 10, 2017
    9
    From my impressions of the first episode, and the previews of episodes to come, I'm seeing a fairly bright future in this. And it's a shame, really, to see the critical misunderstanding most reviewers have had about the show. This is *not* a straight comedy show. It is, at its core, a spiritual successor to Star Trek, while at the same time poking fun at the series, as well as sci fi inFrom my impressions of the first episode, and the previews of episodes to come, I'm seeing a fairly bright future in this. And it's a shame, really, to see the critical misunderstanding most reviewers have had about the show. This is *not* a straight comedy show. It is, at its core, a spiritual successor to Star Trek, while at the same time poking fun at the series, as well as sci fi in general. Many critics seem to be complaining that the show was not consistently funny. This would be a fair complaint if the show had many jokes, most of which fell flat. However, the fact is that the show has a handfull of jokes sprinkled throughout the episode, most of which are chuckle-worthy throwaway lines, and character-building moments.

    However, misunderstandings don't warrant a 9/10 on metacritic. What is actually worth watching about this show?

    The Characters:
    Each character presented in this is fairly well defined and has remarkably interesting synergy with each other. The writing is snappy enough to be interesting while distinct between characters as to not seem as if it's grasping for quotable lines. While the writing is nowhere near on-par with the likes of Xavier, it helps carry the story along fairly nicely, and retains that genuine charm which Star Trek performed so distinctly and prominently in its formative years.

    The Production:
    The show, simply put, looks like Star Trek. It is clear that the editors and effects artists put great thought into making it look authentically like a Star Trek show. Everything from the shots to the lighting evokes the classic style of Star Trek to a tee (though perhaps more DS9 than TNG). While by no means do visuals save or doom a show, the effort put into the aesthetics of the show demonstrate the care which went into it. This work is all in service of portraying a familiar, yet distinct and genuine science fiction world, with meshes of old and new imagery.

    The Plot:
    Though little has been shown as to the overarching narrative, and whether or not the show is serialized, episodic, or a mix of the two, the pacing and content of the plot in this show is strangely compelling. You'd think from what is ostensibly a parody show that the writing plays the whole thing fairly loosey goosey, but in practice, the narrative actually has some stakes. The characters are likeable enough as to where you want to see them make it through to the end, and it is made clear from the offset that characters can and will die if something goes wrong. The only issue I found in the story was that the enemy alien race, The Krill (?), seemed a bit too grunt-y to be considered an actual threat. They're quickly dispatched by the main cast, which is by no means filled with combatants. However, given the glimpses we've seen of the future episodes, this is by no means the biggest threat planned for the cast.

    Overall, I'd say the show is enjoyable so far. I may amend the score in future if the quality declines. However, in a time where we haven't seen anything really interesting come of Star Trek in decades, seeing something like this which tastefully and respectfully evokes the charm of the old show is, perplexingly, a breath of fresh air. Definitely give it a go for yourself.    … Expand
  3. Fiestykitten
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    This show is bright, optimistic and a real breath of fresh air in a genre that has gone dark, serious and gritty - whether we wanted it to or not. If it cuts back on the forced gags, let's the humour flow more naturally and concentrates on sci-fi, it could become a real gem. Good luck Seth. I applaud the vision and critics be damned.
  4. rokweiller
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    This show did its intended job ... it was funny & entertaining. The cast, set, and story line were spot on. The "pro critics" should either get new jobs or stop reviewing shows of the genre. Generally speaking, pro critics know nothing about entertainment. Fire them all.
  5. cellophanity
    Sep 10, 2017
    10
    I find the critic reviews unfair and based on FOX making it seem like a spoof parody that was gonna be hilarious satire and nothing more. This is a light hearted sci-fi comedy drama reminiscent of Star Trek TNG, with comedic moments but actual storylines and plots and character development. This is the Trek show that is not a Trek show but more like the Trek show a lot of us wanted to seeI find the critic reviews unfair and based on FOX making it seem like a spoof parody that was gonna be hilarious satire and nothing more. This is a light hearted sci-fi comedy drama reminiscent of Star Trek TNG, with comedic moments but actual storylines and plots and character development. This is the Trek show that is not a Trek show but more like the Trek show a lot of us wanted to see than the one we will actually get later this month. If you miss the positive hopeful Trek of the 90's and wish it would come back, bad news... its not going to.. ever. The good news is that you will love this show! The Orville is the show for you!… Expand
  6. guilly
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    Absolutely loved it. Just another example of the disconnect between critics and audiences. These days it seems like unless you have a gritty, serious 10 episode cable/streaming style character driven drama the critics take a dump on it. I love sci-fi, and I love shows that make me laugh and don't take themselves too seriously. The first episode checks all the boxes, will update if it goesAbsolutely loved it. Just another example of the disconnect between critics and audiences. These days it seems like unless you have a gritty, serious 10 episode cable/streaming style character driven drama the critics take a dump on it. I love sci-fi, and I love shows that make me laugh and don't take themselves too seriously. The first episode checks all the boxes, will update if it goes downhill.… Expand
  7. Shermos
    Sep 24, 2017
    9
    I have only seen the first episode. I will edit this review upon completion of the season. No spoilers.

    Ignore the critics. If you miss old school Star Trek and are sick of dark sci-fi, you will likely enjoy Orville. It is very clearly a love letter to the kind of Star Trek which came out before 2009. The show is trying to be a bit like Mash with a very healthy dose of Star Trek    I have only seen the first episode. I will edit this review upon completion of the season. No spoilers.

    Ignore the critics. If you miss old school Star Trek and are sick of dark sci-fi, you will likely enjoy Orville. It is very clearly a love letter to the kind of Star Trek which came out before 2009.

    The show is trying to be a bit like Mash with a very healthy dose of Star Trek thrown in. It's a comedy which also deals with serious subjects from time to time. Most of the characters (especially the aliens) are interesting and I look forward to learning more about them and their backstories as the show progresses.

    The show is also interesting because it's not showcasing the best and brightest humanity has to offer. The Orville is a mid level ship and the crew is not perfect, just doing the best they can with what they have.

    I expect upon completion of the season, my rating will go up.    … Expand
  8. ArchangelXv1
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    I think it's obvious that there's a disconnect between Critics and the target audience. It's why I have stopped even caring what they think.

    I really enjoyed this first episode. It felt real, unlike how Star Trek comes across sometimes . I mean there are times during serious situations where you just have to make a joke to relieve the tension. This is exactly how this show felt.    I think it's obvious that there's a disconnect between Critics and the target audience. It's why I have stopped even caring what they think.

    I really enjoyed this first episode. It felt real, unlike how Star Trek comes across sometimes . I mean there are times during serious situations where you just have to make a joke to relieve the tension. This is exactly how this show felt.

    Special effects were pretty good and the characters were believable and you could tell they had a good rapport. The alien designs are also very good. I love that blob in the hallway. And the Ogre? The actors already have great chemistry (especially the helmsman and navigator) and the dynamic Ed and his wife is hilarious and yet heartfelt at the end. I'm very pleased and look forward to the coming season.    … Expand
  9. Ripandread
    Oct 12, 2017
    8
    The special effects were great ! The story lines are getting better each week. One has to appreciate Seth McFarlane's sense of humor in order to enjoy this program.
  10. Jarek23
    Sep 11, 2017
    8
    I really hope this show is successful, it made me feel like a kid again, like I was watching TNG in my parents living room. I miss this feeling. The critics had me worried for a second, but only for a second. Once I started watching I felt that I was going to like it, and by the end I really did like it. It's not amazing, no, but it's very fun. I like the cast well enough, the crew wellI really hope this show is successful, it made me feel like a kid again, like I was watching TNG in my parents living room. I miss this feeling. The critics had me worried for a second, but only for a second. Once I started watching I felt that I was going to like it, and by the end I really did like it. It's not amazing, no, but it's very fun. I like the cast well enough, the crew well enough, the visuals, the music, everything felt like it fit together and meshed really well. Here's hoping it maintains it's course.… Expand
  11. Snookrc
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    I really enjoyed The Orville. I was worried it was going to be non-stop puns and one-liners, I enjoy that in cartoons, but find it hard to watch actors do it non-stop. The Orville actually tries to be a space exploration TV show with some humor thrown in.
  12. grampp1
    Sep 11, 2017
    8
    The Orville wasn't exactly what I expected from a Seth MacFarlane project, but it was nonetheless fun and enjoyable. I think if you approach the show expecting it to be the slap-stick, edgy comedy from beginning to end, you might be disappointed... although, there were several funny bits with the Seth MacFarlane-esque delivery. If you approach it as any other premiere, and you appreciateThe Orville wasn't exactly what I expected from a Seth MacFarlane project, but it was nonetheless fun and enjoyable. I think if you approach the show expecting it to be the slap-stick, edgy comedy from beginning to end, you might be disappointed... although, there were several funny bits with the Seth MacFarlane-esque delivery. If you approach it as any other premiere, and you appreciate some amount of sci-fi, I think it's enjoyable. Not sure just yet whether it has strong "staying-power", but I do hope that Fox gives it the chance to develop before pulling any plugs. Imagine the Orville crew comparing themselves to the crew of the more elite or renowned Enterprise, or implying that they are getting some of the glory that the Orville deserves. i think some of that material could be endless... and quite funny!!I Anyhow, I think it's a bit obvious that the user/viewer reviews are far more telling (and encouraging) than the critic reviews. ... isn't that sort of what happened with "The Family Guy"? ... Critics hated it, viewers loved it and petitioned for it to come back and now it's about to start it's 16th season! I don't think this was the strongest showing for the premiere, but I'm open-minded that it might have some endurance as it develops further.… Expand
  13. zebedee104
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    An enjoyable first episode, that is very reminiscent of Star Trek: The Next Generation and it's bright, shiny view of the future. The cast is rounded out and there aren't any duff notes there.

    I'd agree with those saying that Fox has pitched the programme wrong by making it out to be a Sitcom - it's not, it's a drama with some comedy (which isn't always very successful and fails to hit    An enjoyable first episode, that is very reminiscent of Star Trek: The Next Generation and it's bright, shiny view of the future. The cast is rounded out and there aren't any duff notes there.

    I'd agree with those saying that Fox has pitched the programme wrong by making it out to be a Sitcom - it's not, it's a drama with some comedy (which isn't always very successful and fails to hit the mark) and it's certainly looking a lot more Star Trek-like than Discovery seems like it's going to be.

    I'm hoping that we get more than the first batch of episodes and that it doesn't end up facing the cancellation bear so early, always the risk if viewers side with the critics and decide not to watch based on their opinions.    … Expand
  14. XelaNreddam
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    Absolueteky loved the show. A true homage to Next Generation from an obvious Star Trek fan boy. The characters, set design, titles, music, camera work, everything had influences and nostalgic references. All brought up to date with first class effects. It was blended with McFarlane's college humour very well, a little juvenile but not crass or childish. I doubt it will appeal to everyoneAbsolueteky loved the show. A true homage to Next Generation from an obvious Star Trek fan boy. The characters, set design, titles, music, camera work, everything had influences and nostalgic references. All brought up to date with first class effects. It was blended with McFarlane's college humour very well, a little juvenile but not crass or childish. I doubt it will appeal to everyone but I know one very happy family eager for much more of this.… Expand
  15. Donnazen1
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    I loved it! I thought it was well done and so fresh. Actually, it was pretty cool. I needed to get my outer space on. i have watched Babylon 5 - 3 times in the past year and am now watching all 79 of the Star Treks again, plus the original first pilot just came today (in VHS) The Cage, I just ordered Deep Space 9. I am looking forward to hopefully years and years of - The Orville. ThankI loved it! I thought it was well done and so fresh. Actually, it was pretty cool. I needed to get my outer space on. i have watched Babylon 5 - 3 times in the past year and am now watching all 79 of the Star Treks again, plus the original first pilot just came today (in VHS) The Cage, I just ordered Deep Space 9. I am looking forward to hopefully years and years of - The Orville. Thank goodness I recorded it so I can sit down tonight and watch it again!… Expand
  16. elsrtomato
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    The show is fun, optimistic, and it has the potential to become great sci-fi. Most critics claim it's a Star Trek ripoff, and while it certainly has many TNG elements, it's casual dialogues and character interactions reminded me of Stargate SG1. I hope it goes on, as with just one episode you can tell it's going to get great.
  17. Landee
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    The critics seem too be biased... I found the show to be a good mix of drama and comedy with it leaning more towards drama. It is definitely inspired by star trek and does it justice. I really enjoyed the way they handled the science with a pretty good attention to detail. There were only a few things I noticed that were used that seemed a little far fetched or didn't make sense. Over allThe critics seem too be biased... I found the show to be a good mix of drama and comedy with it leaning more towards drama. It is definitely inspired by star trek and does it justice. I really enjoyed the way they handled the science with a pretty good attention to detail. There were only a few things I noticed that were used that seemed a little far fetched or didn't make sense. Over all I really enjoyed the show!… Expand
  18. benengland
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    Thie first episode was superb - my family and I loved it. We will watch every episode guaranteed. Thanks so much to everyone involved in making it - I've missed this style of show SO much since Star Trek went off the air.
  19. Hugshug
    Sep 11, 2017
    8
    A Science Fiction/Comedy. Light on the Comedy, light on the Science, but good never the less. Make up your own mind, watch it and decide for yourself.
  20. ToolPackinMama
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    I am one of the original Trekkies. I have been a faithful fan of Star Trek since the 1960's. I also enjoy Star Wars. I also enjoyed Galaxy Quest. I like Sci Fi. I like humor. I loved Ep 1 of The Orville and am ready for more of the same. Beautiful looking show that is genuinely entertaining.
  21. Chris_T_Hill
    Sep 12, 2017
    10
    Honestly I’m baffled by the harsh reviews from critics the Orville is great!

    What I will agree with the critics, is the Orville isn’t Galaxy Quest, it’s not a laugh out loud, laugh a minute silly comedy; to my surprise, it’s very, much Star Trek: The Next Generation, with a bit of light relief. This is the Star Trek show I’ve long been waiting for.
  22. jc203
    Sep 11, 2017
    0
    Tough to understand how anyone could rate this show favorably! The humor is not humorous, the adventure is not adventurous, the story line is just plain dumb, and the acting is at the level of a junior high school production. The special effects are the best part. That probably explains why so much of the footage features exterior views of the Orville gliding through space. Overall, aTough to understand how anyone could rate this show favorably! The humor is not humorous, the adventure is not adventurous, the story line is just plain dumb, and the acting is at the level of a junior high school production. The special effects are the best part. That probably explains why so much of the footage features exterior views of the Orville gliding through space. Overall, a colossal waste of money...… Expand
  23. FabiusPolis
    Mar 21, 2019
    5
    There are nice ideas, but most of the plots are identical with episodes from Star Trek TNG. The jokes are slippery but beyond as funny as in "Married... with Children" and is more disturbing than entertaining. The stories suffer from the shows uncertainty if its a real sci-fi or just a Star Trek (fandom) parody. The lack of creativity (the Borg, the Klingons...all appear in one form) makesThere are nice ideas, but most of the plots are identical with episodes from Star Trek TNG. The jokes are slippery but beyond as funny as in "Married... with Children" and is more disturbing than entertaining. The stories suffer from the shows uncertainty if its a real sci-fi or just a Star Trek (fandom) parody. The lack of creativity (the Borg, the Klingons...all appear in one form) makes it worse. Average show, worth to watch episode once, but never twice or more.… Expand
  24. Rakshall
    Feb 16, 2019
    3
    Has potential ... but unfortunately its completely destroyed by frequent unfunny and embarrassing toilet-level "gags". They have no real purpose other than shatter any viewer immersion in the world. Its really hard to watch. Its a shame because under this cesspool there is occasional good and deeper story, but one has to be really immune to poor "humor" to see it.
  25. frankthetank420
    Jan 28, 2019
    10
    Don't listen to the bought and paid critics, fans from all around love this show. It really pays homage to classic Trek, and any TNG fans out there will definitely enjoy this. I'm tired of critics trying to steer us away from great work based on their politics, we know STD sucks but thats no reason to give this a poor review. This show is fantastic and doesn't take itself too seriously,Don't listen to the bought and paid critics, fans from all around love this show. It really pays homage to classic Trek, and any TNG fans out there will definitely enjoy this. I'm tired of critics trying to steer us away from great work based on their politics, we know STD sucks but thats no reason to give this a poor review. This show is fantastic and doesn't take itself too seriously, give it a shot!… Expand
  26. BronzeCentipede
    Jan 20, 2018
    10
    Intelligent SF with likeable characters, and lacking the mean-spiritedness of so much modern science-fiction. It is also, incidentally, the closest things we've had to Star Trek in decades. Some of the jokes are laugh out loud, many of them are just irritating. But it is as thoughtful drama that The Orville truly shines, without ever getting preachy.
  27. Robobob
    Oct 8, 2017
    9
    Did you love Star Trek: The Next Generation but were always kind of bugged that the crew never mentioned pop culture in film or TV? Did it annoy you that everyone on the Enterprise D was perfect at their job and almost always followed the rules? Did you find it a little stuffy will only a few mild attempts at humor? Well, then you will really love The Orville. This is the kind of crewDid you love Star Trek: The Next Generation but were always kind of bugged that the crew never mentioned pop culture in film or TV? Did it annoy you that everyone on the Enterprise D was perfect at their job and almost always followed the rules? Did you find it a little stuffy will only a few mild attempts at humor? Well, then you will really love The Orville. This is the kind of crew that pops in a classic episode of Seinfeld on the view screen during some down time. This is the crew most likely to get themselves blown up in the first few episodes. They are also the most likely to curse at the bad guy on screen and flip him the bird. Add on top of that the most "Trek" themed episodes seen in a sci-fi show since the glory Trek-days of the 90s. I'm waiting for the day that a member of the crew specially mentions that ancient show "Star Trek: The Next Generation" and notes the similarity in their mission. This show is so good but I'm certain as it goes on and finds it niche that it is headed for greatness.… Expand
  28. PrimeSpeaker
    Oct 8, 2017
    9
    If you love star trek tng then give this one a shot. It's very similar in terms of tone with a little more direct comedy while keeping the heart, The visuals are gorgeous and the it has just been fun overall.
  29. SirIsaacBrock
    Oct 7, 2017
    10
    WTF critics, is your only job to crap on anything that doesn't end mid sentence or have sex scenes mixed with dragons?

    Seth MacFarlane created another great show to brighten up our little world and keep us entertained an hour at a time. From the thought provoking story of episode 3 to the little accents such as Kermit the Frog being on his desk, Seth and his team has worked tirelessly    WTF critics, is your only job to crap on anything that doesn't end mid sentence or have sex scenes mixed with dragons?

    Seth MacFarlane created another great show to brighten up our little world and keep us entertained an hour at a time. From the thought provoking story of episode 3 to the little accents such as Kermit the Frog being on his desk, Seth and his team has worked tirelessly to ensure that we are kept enthralled from beginning to end with pop culture references and characters I'd like to have a beer with.

    This show may not have awesome graphics but it sure as Hell makes up for it with heart. I hope this is the beginning of a fantastic lighthearted voyage that puts all those critics that can't help hating dreamers in their places.

    Bravo Mr. MacFarlane and team, keep up the good work!    … Expand
  30. Vince_Vega
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    The Orville starts with a weak and becomes one of the strongest "Ship and Crew" shows we had in a long time.
    Personally I think the first episode doesn't do the show justice. While it is solid in it's second half, the very first impression we get of this show can leave a negative impression. it's too busy trying to explain and setup everything, while squeezing in the jokes. This flow    The Orville starts with a weak and becomes one of the strongest "Ship and Crew" shows we had in a long time.
    Personally I think the first episode doesn't do the show justice. While it is solid in it's second half, the very first impression we get of this show can leave a negative impression. it's too busy trying to explain and setup everything, while squeezing in the jokes. This flow starts to become more organic in the following episodes.
    This show delivers a high concept Sci-Fi (highlight Ep.3 here!) while delivering the comic relief other shows were missing. The bridge crew feels like people, relatable normal people working together in an office. Halfway through it's first season The Orville demonstrates great Sci-Fi story lines combined with an established chemistry of the cast.

    This is the Ship and Crew Sci-Fi adventure show that many of us have been waiting for for a long time.    … Expand
  31. VanGheist
    Oct 10, 2017
    9
    This show honestly impresses me. It's timing couldn't have been any better either. The Orville has everything we wished for from Star Trek: Discovery and more. The friendly banter, the Roddenberry message, and the episodic feel to the show make it very enjoyable to me and most likely any of you Trekkies out there. I give it a solid 9. Don't listen to these so called "Professional"This show honestly impresses me. It's timing couldn't have been any better either. The Orville has everything we wished for from Star Trek: Discovery and more. The friendly banter, the Roddenberry message, and the episodic feel to the show make it very enjoyable to me and most likely any of you Trekkies out there. I give it a solid 9. Don't listen to these so called "Professional" critics, they don't know what they hell they're talking about. You have a fan base now, just keep developing those characters in interesting ways and I for one, will continue to promote this show to my family and friends.… Expand
  32. allquixotic
    Oct 17, 2017
    10
    It was easy for me to get over the comedy being a little cringeworthy and just enjoy this show for what it is. It's a huge homage to Star Trek in a positive way (not a parody), and it's much more of a Star Trek show than Star Trek Discovery or JJ Trek. The episodes are engaging, thoughtful, and puristic. I really hope they keep this show alive -- the critics slamming this show isIt was easy for me to get over the comedy being a little cringeworthy and just enjoy this show for what it is. It's a huge homage to Star Trek in a positive way (not a parody), and it's much more of a Star Trek show than Star Trek Discovery or JJ Trek. The episodes are engaging, thoughtful, and puristic. I really hope they keep this show alive -- the critics slamming this show is absolutely appalling to me.… Expand
  33. JadenFrost
    Sep 14, 2017
    10
    Loved it. I find some of seths stuff hit and miss, Don't like Ted but love family guy. This was an extremely fun show if you like spoofy stuff. If you liked galaxy quest you'll probably like this.
  34. dnyl
    Oct 21, 2017
    10
    Finally, a series that captures some of the freshness of the original Star Trek. The critics are simply wrong on this one and while I usually agree with them I think they missed the point or do not know the Trek series going back 50 years.

    Granted, as an old man I have lived out the series and I do not mean just by watching reruns. I recall the particular interest in this series in    Finally, a series that captures some of the freshness of the original Star Trek. The critics are simply wrong on this one and while I usually agree with them I think they missed the point or do not know the Trek series going back 50 years.

    Granted, as an old man I have lived out the series and I do not mean just by watching reruns. I recall the particular interest in this series in the 60's and how people felt about it. And while I did not comprehend it well as a 12 year old I did know and do remember that it generated a different feel than the last few Trek series.

    Yes, that is subjective, but MacFarlane has captured that optimism and given it back with humor to an audience weary of dark vistas, explosions, and substituting Wild West stories for a plot in the last Trek films and TV shows. And, yes, I like Westerns.

    In The Orville, however, the first six episodes alone the big questions present themselves as much to the viewer than anything in most of the recent Trek films.

    The critics do not like MacFarlane's humor but this is a mistake. Using humor to show the light aspects as well as pointing out human flaws even through deliberate weak humor occasionally is welcome in a franchise run, apparently, by people who think that Trek fans are "really" just an action genre audience.

    So my assessment is that this is as good right now as both TOS and The Next Generation. I'm even hoping that MacFarlane and his bullpen of writers will come up with an episode of a meeting with the 1920's surrealists, something you would never see in the last four Trek series.

    So without being a part of the Trek franchise, The Orville out-Treks the recent installments both on the screen and on TV.

    Thank God for Seth MacFarlane. I know he will appreciate the irony of that statement.    … Expand
  35. Chanet
    Oct 27, 2017
    10
    I totally don't understand why the critics are giving this show a low score. The Orville is fun to watch and is like a light hearted Star Trek. The story line is good and I wait everyweek to watch the new episodes. I think anyone who enjoys Star Trek will enjoy this show also. The critics should be more open minded instead of being only critical.
  36. JJRaybould
    Oct 28, 2017
    9
    The simplest way to describe this show is as follows: It is like watching one of the episodic, 90s, Star Trek Shows, like Next Generation, while ramping down some of the seriousness and gravitas, while increasing the humor. The show does not take itself too seriously and yet at the same time still has interesting and thought provoking episodes in the same mold as Star Trek. TheThe simplest way to describe this show is as follows: It is like watching one of the episodic, 90s, Star Trek Shows, like Next Generation, while ramping down some of the seriousness and gravitas, while increasing the humor. The show does not take itself too seriously and yet at the same time still has interesting and thought provoking episodes in the same mold as Star Trek. The CGI/effects are pretty good for a TV, comedy knock off of the Star Trek franchise. This show is definitely worth the time to watch because it takes an "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" approach to the Star Trek model of the 90s.

    One final point. In the Trump era we find ourselves in, the massive disparity between the "professional critics" score and the average viewer review score is very telling. It once again demonstrates the disconnect between the out of touch people in the professional classes, the political class, and the media class, and the ordinary person. Do yourself a favor, ignore the critic reviews and jump straight to the real person reviews, then watch the show and enjoy.    … Expand
  37. rf2
    Jan 26, 2019
    10
    What MacFarlane uniquely understands that the critics do not is that exploring brave new worlds will be surreal and awkward and unintentionally comical. The unimaginably alien will be juxtaposed with the everyday human condition which will sometimes be dramatic and sometimes absurdly funny. Flawed characters don't have to be the unrealistically dark, dour tropes all too common today ( asWhat MacFarlane uniquely understands that the critics do not is that exploring brave new worlds will be surreal and awkward and unintentionally comical. The unimaginably alien will be juxtaposed with the everyday human condition which will sometimes be dramatic and sometimes absurdly funny. Flawed characters don't have to be the unrealistically dark, dour tropes all too common today ( as in Discovery)… Expand
  38. Burklan
    Mar 2, 2019
    10
    This show continues to improve every episode. It started out slightly above average and after watching Season 2, Identity Parts 1 and 2, I'm amazed. This is an Emmy worthy performance. The space battle is one of the best ever for TV. Seth, please keep The Orville going for years to come!!!
  39. LordoftheDance
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    Its TNG meets A Million Ways to Die in the West. Some jokes fall flat or feel forced, but some are absolutely hilarious and unforgettable. Jokes aside, there has also been storytelling that is spot on Star Trek that was really well done. I've only seen 5 episodes, and so far I am absolutely pumped. It's everything you like about Star Trek with comedy thrown in.

    Also: It keeps    Its TNG meets A Million Ways to Die in the West. Some jokes fall flat or feel forced, but some are absolutely hilarious and unforgettable. Jokes aside, there has also been storytelling that is spot on Star Trek that was really well done. I've only seen 5 episodes, and so far I am absolutely pumped. It's everything you like about Star Trek with comedy thrown in.

    Also: It keeps getting better and better.    … Expand
  40. toadofsteel
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    The Orville is everything I wanted in a Star Trek series. As someone who grew up watching The Next Generation, I was hooked on this show by episode 3.

    Given the choice between a show with the soul of Trek but not set in the franchise continutity (this show), versus the other way around (Discovery), give me Orville any day.
  41. kushida2017
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    It really goes to show you how NOT to listen to the "professional" Critic's..
    These guys are bought and sold on there political biases, Identity tribe mind, and wrong think ideology. These people have no real understanding and out of touch with the world they live in, There the elitist, and i bet they think we of the different opinion are.... Deplorable
  42. BlobTheCat
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    Fantastic show in the spirit of Star Trek The Next Generation.
    You can clearly see that Seth Macfarlane is a true Star Trek-Fan. He's one of us.
    It's exactly that what i was craving for all these years. Thank you for this masterpiece of space opera!
  43. garhent
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    The Orville does Star Trek better than Star Trek has done it recently. Good cast, interesting stories. Things don't end up happy. McFarlane put out a really good show.
  44. dr9188
    Oct 8, 2017
    10
    Firstly... I am dumbfounded how this has such a low "pro-critic" score compared to Star Trek Discovery... This show, in my opinion, is by far the superior show, in terms of humour and quality of storylines as well as respect it pays to the format and universe of Star Trek (more than even anything JJ Abrams managed)

    I just binge watched the first 4 episodes of The Orville... And, being a    Firstly... I am dumbfounded how this has such a low "pro-critic" score compared to Star Trek Discovery... This show, in my opinion, is by far the superior show, in terms of humour and quality of storylines as well as respect it pays to the format and universe of Star Trek (more than even anything JJ Abrams managed)

    I just binge watched the first 4 episodes of The Orville... And, being a person with an internet connection, I naturally couldn't resist the temptation to make my opinions known.

    For the uninitiated, The Orville is the latest Seth MacFarlane comedy. Immediately this may be a cause for concern, as his animation has become increasingly stale (although I was a fan of A Million Ways To Die In The West).

    And yet, within the space of its trailer, my feelings went from curious to optimistic.

    In the end, these initial episodes far exceeded my expectations, actually feeling less like a "typical" sitcom than the trailer suggests... Don't get me wrong, there are a lot of one-liners. But the structure of each episode much more closely resembles that of The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine or even Voyager. This actually works incredibly well; as the world is built throughout each episode, the jokes feel funnier as you realise these are people making funny comments in a consistent world, rather than the changing rules of MacFarlane's previous animations. The plots feel like the kind you would find on any past Trek episode, with the humour instead coming from the character's reactions. You could imagine these characters in the actual Star Trek universe, being given a ship because there's no-one else to pilot it. I mean, I'm sure even in the Federation there must be alcoholism, divorce and tension between senior staff...

    Of particular note to me was the third episode "About A Girl". Without giving too many spoilers, it surprised me how well it emulated the way Star Trek would present cultural problems... With my only issues being it was so early in the series there wasn't the chance of more character development which was maybe needed for the situation and characters to feel more relatable. Equally, I can see why an episode such as this was broadcast so early... As a signal that this was aiming to be more than a silly comedy, but to derive humour instead from how it follows (and plays with) the situations from Star Trek itself, I feel it was successful. One thing that did shock me was some discussion this episode was so-called "SJW" and pushing some kind of political message... From people who clearly know nothing about Star Trek or the kind of message that Gene Roddenberry tried to convey from his very first season.    … Expand
  45. Presumptuous
    Sep 12, 2017
    8
    Was it as bad as the Critics seemed to make out? hell no... was it like the Trailer Fox put out? eh no. Was it entertaining and at the very least a good hour of sci-fi... Yes.

    As a long time (30+ years) fan of Star Trek and sci-fi in general, I enjoyed it warts and all and hope it gets to see at the very least a second season, preferably more. Now that its hit the ground running it can    Was it as bad as the Critics seemed to make out? hell no... was it like the Trailer Fox put out? eh no. Was it entertaining and at the very least a good hour of sci-fi... Yes.

    As a long time (30+ years) fan of Star Trek and sci-fi in general, I enjoyed it warts and all and hope it gets to see at the very least a second season, preferably more. Now that its hit the ground running it can only really go up from here *Fingers Crossed*.

    Honestly... what the hell did the critics watch?    … Expand
  46. Stevoli
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    It reminds me why I loved Star Trek: TNG so much, this show captures the very essence of one of my favorite shows.

    I'm not sure why the "critics" are giving it such a low score.
  47. Josh93945
    Sep 19, 2017
    9
    As someone who has seen almost every Star Trek episode (except TOS), I actually really enjoy this so far. I have no idea why it's being hammered by critics. The hour long format is perfect, and allows slightly more involved stories. I never took Star Trek seriously enough to go to a convention or measure the physical aspects of the ship, but appreciated the interesting sci-fi plotAs someone who has seen almost every Star Trek episode (except TOS), I actually really enjoy this so far. I have no idea why it's being hammered by critics. The hour long format is perfect, and allows slightly more involved stories. I never took Star Trek seriously enough to go to a convention or measure the physical aspects of the ship, but appreciated the interesting sci-fi plot situations, characters, and philosophical approach. The two episodes of this show so far beat out the reboot movies for me. I'm not the biggest McFarlane-show fan, but the jokes aren't machine gunned down our throats like his others and I actually did laugh more often than not. If you're expecting a McFarlane comedy, you'll be disappointed. If you're expecting "serious" Star Trek, you'll be disappointed. But if you want something that straddles that line and pays comedic homage while being intriguing and having the "curious wonder" aspect of Star Trek, you should really enjoy it.… Expand
  48. sanchopancho
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    The critics are smoking crack and totally missed the mark. The Orville is what Star Trek-like scifi is supposed to be about: exploration, entertainment, and escapism. Having watched it back to back with the new Star Trek Discovery, I know which show I will be following.
  49. Jester27
    Sep 28, 2017
    10
    Pre-viewing impressions led me to believe that "The Orville" was going to be a pile of space junk, via most of the reviews left by critics. Sure it's not none stop belly laughs, & at times can be quite serious, nonetheless it is entertaining. I don't think it was intended to be a full blown comedy anyhow - just a Sci-Fi show with a little humour thrown in for good measure, just like otherPre-viewing impressions led me to believe that "The Orville" was going to be a pile of space junk, via most of the reviews left by critics. Sure it's not none stop belly laughs, & at times can be quite serious, nonetheless it is entertaining. I don't think it was intended to be a full blown comedy anyhow - just a Sci-Fi show with a little humour thrown in for good measure, just like other shows of this genre. There's obvious elements taken from past Sci-Fi shows, such as Star Trek, Star Wars & Babylon 5, but that's what makes it likable. I've been a "Trekkie" since I was old enough to understand the storylines & quite frankly I would favour this over the new CBS effort - Star Trek Discovery, having watched both. Give it a chance & ignore the critics, you won't regret it unless you're a big stick in the mud!… Expand
  50. Absolon47
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    Very nicely done. Honestly being a Star Trek fan myself, I actually enjoy this show more than the newest Star Trek series, Discovery. I don't care what the so called professional critics think (they are wrong most of the time anyways)
  51. RCDVOK
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    I wanted to see Star Trek Discovery first before I wrote a review to see which is better. I can say that The Orville is way better hands down. It does get silly at times but as a true Star Trek fan for over 30 years and faithful to every series this is more inline with Star Trek then Discovery. I was hoping I would be following Discovery because I thought it had a bigger budget and stuffI wanted to see Star Trek Discovery first before I wrote a review to see which is better. I can say that The Orville is way better hands down. It does get silly at times but as a true Star Trek fan for over 30 years and faithful to every series this is more inline with Star Trek then Discovery. I was hoping I would be following Discovery because I thought it had a bigger budget and stuff but I was wrong.

    Until they realize and either change Discovery (which I know the over paid Exec at CBS won't admit they scewed up and change) or cancel which they won't do till forced to, I will watch Discovery. It's fun light and uplifting like TNG AND TOS. To bad so sad for Discovery.    … Expand
  52. flik221
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    This show has it all. Humor, adventure, fun characters, and blows Star Trek Discovery out of the water. Amazing show that if there is any justice in the universe will be around for many years.
  53. tiaga
    Feb 3, 2018
    10
    Holy crap this show is entertaining! Not so much funny, and there is a lot of poop level joke, but it's also not politically correct. I hate shows that are politically motivated (star trek discovery) which defines character XYZ's personality(sexual preference, gender, etc). Many mainstream shows in recent years have new rules that try to appease a progressive audience so as to not feelHoly crap this show is entertaining! Not so much funny, and there is a lot of poop level joke, but it's also not politically correct. I hate shows that are politically motivated (star trek discovery) which defines character XYZ's personality(sexual preference, gender, etc). Many mainstream shows in recent years have new rules that try to appease a progressive audience so as to not feel left out (nicely putting it). Yes, there is politics in the show. However, they make character XYZ an alien so there is more room to talk about the subject and bend the rules. I love the way Seth tries to work around said rules so he can focus on jokes and keeping the atmosphere light. Finally, while it is not star trek I do feel a hint of excitement and joy when they make a new discovery. It's the same joy I felt when I was a tiny lad watching Voyager and deep space nine. The feeling isn't as strong as it used to be, but it's still there, however faint. In my book this show is the new continuation in the Star Trek timeline.… Expand
  54. Musashi
    Jan 16, 2018
    9
    Watching The Orville is like settling back into your favourite old comfy chair that's had a bunch of modern innovations strapped on. It absolutely recreates the feel of TNG, and so delivers a welcome nostalgia kick - but more than that, it capture the _soul_ of Star Trek.

    Clearly written by fans of the show and Sci-Fi, it pokes fun at the genre tropes in an affectionate, laugh-with-you    Watching The Orville is like settling back into your favourite old comfy chair that's had a bunch of modern innovations strapped on. It absolutely recreates the feel of TNG, and so delivers a welcome nostalgia kick - but more than that, it capture the _soul_ of Star Trek.

    Clearly written by fans of the show and Sci-Fi, it pokes fun at the genre tropes in an affectionate, laugh-with-you manner as well as dealing with more serious social commentary - and thankfully without the turgid drama that certain elements of society feel they need to hammer you on the head with.

    And, most critically, the story and character have real heart. The importance of this appears to have been completely missed by the writers of ST:D, who have been out-Star Trekked by The Orville.    … Expand
  55. night4
    Sep 18, 2017
    7
    It's good, but it's certainly NOT what the promos made it out to be. It is not a comedy. It is not a Seth McFarlane comedy, as the humor is rather tame. It's Star Trek: The Next Generation, remade. That might be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on the viewer.

    I think it's a good thing, overall. I got some hardcore TNG nostalgia watching the first episode, from the music in    It's good, but it's certainly NOT what the promos made it out to be. It is not a comedy. It is not a Seth McFarlane comedy, as the humor is rather tame. It's Star Trek: The Next Generation, remade. That might be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on the viewer.

    I think it's a good thing, overall. I got some hardcore TNG nostalgia watching the first episode, from the music in particular. It's about as close as it possibly could be without violating copyright.

    If you're not a TNG fan, you'll probably want to skip it.    … Expand
  56. primetimerob
    Oct 27, 2017
    9
    This show does a better job at capturing the spirit of Star Trek than Discovery. It has the campiness and lighthearted humor of The Next Generation, and a good mix of science and action.

    I'm surprised that this show was so universally **** on by critics. I haven't been a big fan of Seth McFarlane in the past but this show is too much fun.
  57. incollectio
    Jan 16, 2018
    9
    For a fan of Star Trek (especially TOS and TNG), this show is a breath of fresh air in the current scheme of serials. I cannot fathom how the critics cannot see what I see. There simply isn't anything like this on TV: a current, delightfully lighthearted, and smart episodic social criticism with a refreshingly warmhearted touch amidst all the uptight politics of today. When all the worldFor a fan of Star Trek (especially TOS and TNG), this show is a breath of fresh air in the current scheme of serials. I cannot fathom how the critics cannot see what I see. There simply isn't anything like this on TV: a current, delightfully lighthearted, and smart episodic social criticism with a refreshingly warmhearted touch amidst all the uptight politics of today. When all the world seems to be burying each other on social media, this show – in the true spirit of Star Trek – reminds us of our commonalities and the chance of a world of unity, while tackling current issues in the way only a proper episodic sci-fi can. There was a desperate need for something like this in the world, and The Orville delivered. The only small minus is due to it taking a couple of episodes in the beginning of the season before The Orville finally hit the right note balancing it's comedic aspects. It only kept bettering itself throughout the season, towards an even more Trek-like feel, and I have high expectations for the second one. Truly a gem in these times, and highly recommended for a modern day catharsis.… Expand
  58. Phoojoe
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    A Trek-inspired show clearly made with love by huge Trek fans. If you love TNG then you most likely will enjoy this show. While there some poor jokes here and there that may last too long, it is heavily outweighed by the chemistry of the cast and the influence of classic-era Trek. Optimistic and funny, really looking forward to more!
  59. SodaPopinski
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    Based on the Star Trek reddit, if you're a Trek fan, you'll probably like the show a lot. It's a great homage, which is why it's not super original. it's suppose to be derivative of Star Trek in addition to being satire. Those are my guesses why critics don't like the show.

    Many critics, and negative reviews here are complaining the show doesn't know if it's a comedy or a drama. Does    Based on the Star Trek reddit, if you're a Trek fan, you'll probably like the show a lot. It's a great homage, which is why it's not super original. it's suppose to be derivative of Star Trek in addition to being satire. Those are my guesses why critics don't like the show.

    Many critics, and negative reviews here are complaining the show doesn't know if it's a comedy or a drama. Does it have to fit in neatly into one genre? Another reviewer compared it to M*A*S*H, blending comedy and drama. I think it's a fair comparison (minus the laugh track).

    he characters act or at least think more like real people around today than the culturally evolved Roddenberry Star Trek TNG characters. That seems to irk a lot of people, but who's to say human's are suppose to act that way in the future. Sure, they're a bit too quick with the humor to be realistic, but it's still comedic TV.

    The plot of the pilot isn't super original, but the point of the pilot isn't the plot, but as an introduction to the show. It's arguably better than TNG's pilot episode.

    Many feel the jokes fall flat, which is subjective. I don't enjoy Family Guy, but laughed at about half the jokes in this show. Others really loved it.

    People who don't like the "dated" look of the show with it's non-gritty bright design aren't getting the Star Trek TNG roots of the show.

    In summary, it's not super serious, but should be enjoyed by sci-fi fans, and Trek fans in particular.    … Expand
  60. gbestwick
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    The Orville is both a delicate and ham fisted nod/extension/continuation/something to the Star Trek TNG universe.

    The first episode is a little slow going, and some of the characters seem to lack depth, but that is not important. This series is headed towards filling a universe. The plot of the first episode is basically what everyone would expect from a first episode. A lot of    The Orville is both a delicate and ham fisted nod/extension/continuation/something to the Star Trek TNG universe.

    The first episode is a little slow going, and some of the characters seem to lack depth, but that is not important. This series is headed towards filling a universe.

    The plot of the first episode is basically what everyone would expect from a first episode. A lot of exposition on who the characters are, they establish the relationships, they introduce the bad guys, etc. Understandably the first episode is a little slow and weirdly paces. We get to meet the bad guys (The Krill), and we get to meet many of the players.

    If you are a Trek fan you'll feel like this belongs in your ST:TNG universe. The color pallet, the ship designs, the rooms, everything just feels like home. Just, maybe newer. It's apparent that this isn't some cheap knock off of the TNG universe, but it is a well crafted love song from someone who deeply cares for it.

    This series may not be for everyone. The jokes are a little out of place for the series. The pacing was off, and the characters feel forced. However, if you watch Season 1 of TNG or pretty much any show you can say the same thing. The Orville will become a staple of everyones evening viewing as soon as they find their pace. I think that will happen before the end of season 1.

    If you don't watch this, you'll have a Firefly experience all over again!    … Expand
  61. rrrdj
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    I didn't expect anything from this show and the first episode really surprised me. I thought it was great. It is a little rough around the edges but it made me laugh a bunch of times and i was really entertained. I'm definitely going to stick with it this season!
  62. SeanMatt
    Sep 11, 2017
    9
    I think the critics may have missed the mark a little bit - this isn't a slapstick comedy - it's mostly a drama that is a bit funny at times. The special effects are top notch, the acting seems decent for a start and overall the premier was enjoyable.
  63. mrasco
    Sep 14, 2017
    8
    This is a solid Sci fi show and Star Trek TNG homage, with excellent production values. I felt some of the jokes fell a bit flat and the initial interaction between the two helmsmen felt awkward. Otherwise, I thought it was really enjoyable and worth the time watching it and it was very enjoyable. Will watch again!
  64. ahnehnois
    Oct 10, 2017
    8
    The main surprise about the show is that there's not much humor. It doesn't need that to work, though.

    They have slavishly recreated the Star Trek aesthetic, from the recycled chords in the music to the distinctive James Conway overhead shots. The occasional gag is in there, but for the most part, the writing seems composed of rejected pitches for one of the long-gone Trek shows. Even    The main surprise about the show is that there's not much humor. It doesn't need that to work, though.

    They have slavishly recreated the Star Trek aesthetic, from the recycled chords in the music to the distinctive James Conway overhead shots. The occasional gag is in there, but for the most part, the writing seems composed of rejected pitches for one of the long-gone Trek shows. Even in a few episodes, that writing has generated some intriguing surprises, and the chemistry between the characters have grown. It works for much the same reasons a non-parodical Star Trek does: the writers, despite having to adhere to the tropes of the genre, are freer than the ones churning out regular network shows.

    It has a ways to go to get up to the impactfulness of its predecessors, but it's been good enough so far that it ought to get the chance to go on a while.    … Expand
  65. Alvin_Pinsberry
    Sep 28, 2017
    8
    I think it's fashionable to hate on Seth MacFarlane shows. It certainly seems to be that way amongst critics. It's almost pathological, to the point that they'll prematurely write-off shows that he's in or involved with before even bothering to watch them.

    That's the only explanation I can think of for why this show was so critically panned, because it's solid. It's not perfect, by any    I think it's fashionable to hate on Seth MacFarlane shows. It certainly seems to be that way amongst critics. It's almost pathological, to the point that they'll prematurely write-off shows that he's in or involved with before even bothering to watch them.

    That's the only explanation I can think of for why this show was so critically panned, because it's solid. It's not perfect, by any stretch, but the three episodes I've seen were consistently good (episode 3 might even be great), and were definitely of high enough quality to warrant sticking with the show for at least the rest of the season.

    If, for whatever reason, you're still deciding whether or not to watch this show by the time you see this review, then I fully recommend that you do.    … Expand
  66. abm0
    Oct 3, 2017
    8
    And once again the critics are out of their minds, bashing a show that, while a bit confusing at first, has actually managed to bring us far more believable and enjoyable Star Trek (featuring some actual space-trekking for a change!) than the official/"serious" CBS production, which has been an incoherent, self-important, cliche-ridden overly-violent mess so far.
  67. Dracology
    Sep 25, 2017
    8
    The Orville is a breath of fresh air in a sea of SciFi shows dedicated to showing how grim and dark the future might be. While it has room for improvement in 3 episodes it's already shown more heart and brought more joy than most recent series in the genre and proven it can tackle complicated issues without resorting to demonizing parts of the argument.

    It carries with it the spirit of    The Orville is a breath of fresh air in a sea of SciFi shows dedicated to showing how grim and dark the future might be. While it has room for improvement in 3 episodes it's already shown more heart and brought more joy than most recent series in the genre and proven it can tackle complicated issues without resorting to demonizing parts of the argument.

    It carries with it the spirit of Trek, and I'm eager to watch even more in the future.    … Expand
  68. Kyle999
    Sep 30, 2017
    10
    What the hell do critics know! This is the Star Trek we've been waiting for! A plot/character driven sci-fi show that tackles social issues of the day. Discovery sucks compared to The Orville. I'm willing to bet this show has a lot more staying power than the critics think. If you love mindless explosions go watch the new Star Trek. If you want people and stories you are going toWhat the hell do critics know! This is the Star Trek we've been waiting for! A plot/character driven sci-fi show that tackles social issues of the day. Discovery sucks compared to The Orville. I'm willing to bet this show has a lot more staying power than the critics think. If you love mindless explosions go watch the new Star Trek. If you want people and stories you are going to care about, than the Orville is for you!… Expand
  69. Ricochetv1
    Oct 2, 2017
    8
    They're going after some hard issues, Ep 3 especially, and showing that things don't always have to play out in some kind of picture-perfect way, as usually happened in Star Trek. It's easy to get caught up in the drama, but then you're quickly reminded this is a comedy, though I think the better genre for this would be "Dramedy". I do feel that some of the humor is forced, and feels aThey're going after some hard issues, Ep 3 especially, and showing that things don't always have to play out in some kind of picture-perfect way, as usually happened in Star Trek. It's easy to get caught up in the drama, but then you're quickly reminded this is a comedy, though I think the better genre for this would be "Dramedy". I do feel that some of the humor is forced, and feels a little awkward at times, but I'm enjoying the series too much to really care.… Expand
  70. xwiseguyx
    Sep 12, 2017
    10
    I came into watching this thinking it was going to be horrible based on the reviews I read, but was happily surprised by how engaging the first episode was. For some reason people were expecting this to be like Angie Tribeca in outer space or something, but it was actually a fun mix of drama and humor. My other half typically hates sci-fi and never watched an episode of Star Trek andI came into watching this thinking it was going to be horrible based on the reviews I read, but was happily surprised by how engaging the first episode was. For some reason people were expecting this to be like Angie Tribeca in outer space or something, but it was actually a fun mix of drama and humor. My other half typically hates sci-fi and never watched an episode of Star Trek and enjoyed this as well. I really hope that the negative hype doesn't translate to the ratings. Glad to know at least one new show has made my DVR season pass list.… Expand
  71. CrispyMyth
    Sep 11, 2017
    8
    I wasn't super impressed with the pilot, but it kept my attention throughout and I can definitely see the potential. Good acting, good characters, great effects, okay story. Let's see what Macfarlane does with it going forward. I am cautiously optimistic after the first episode.
  72. Pastafarian
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    Best new show of 2017. It feels like star trek but with a lot of humor. Good actors and funny aliens make a good team. They also tackle moral issue's without taking its self to serious.
  73. dmartin6
    Sep 14, 2017
    10
    Classic case of professional critics having no sense of humor and being way too serious. This show is a remarkably good, lighthearted poke at the whole of the Star Trek franchise. It does not in any way denigrate, but in fact, pays homage to the franchise while providing nice, escapism, off beat humor that is quite enjoyable. IGNORE THE CRITICS ON THIS ONE!!
  74. ginberryblue
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    The Orville is the Star Trek I've been wishing for for years. The heart of Trek is (or was!) optimism, a thoughtful exploration of human society, and *humor*. The Orville delivers at warp 11. I don't know what show those idiot critics were watching. If you want a show that makes you think and laugh at the same time, The Orville is for you.
  75. GeekyGarden
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    I loved it. It was funny and family-friendly. It hearkened back to a more noble time in television. Television today needs to loosen up and get away from gritty realism. BSG and "New" Trek is fun, but it's time for something different. ... Happy Arbor Day!
  76. LesterTJester
    Sep 11, 2017
    10
    What a refreshing pilot! Seth does a great job of bringing fun back to Star Trek.

    The effects are stellar. The cast has good chemistry. The plot of the pilot was simple and yet innovative. The manage to subvert classic tropes without having to go abouts hanging a lampshade on them. I'm excited to see where they go with this. There wasn't weak link character in the bunch. I    What a refreshing pilot! Seth does a great job of bringing fun back to Star Trek.

    The effects are stellar. The cast has good chemistry. The plot of the pilot was simple and yet innovative. The manage to subvert classic tropes without having to go abouts hanging a lampshade on them.

    I'm excited to see where they go with this. There wasn't weak link character in the bunch.

    I can see how all the hack critics are going to slam this show for it not being parody like Family Guy, but actually being a spiritual successor to Gene Roddenberry's Star Trek, something we haven't seen in a very long time.

    Do yourself a favor and check out this show. If you are a fan of Star Trek, this might be just what you're looking for.    … Expand
  77. YossaBlackMage
    Sep 12, 2017
    9
    Seth McFarlane is clearly a Star Trek fan. Him and the other creative people behind the show really get what the original Star Trek (up to and including Voyager) was really about. There is a feeling of optimism, hope and exuberance tempered with a touch of seriousness in the attitudes of the characters - not because of any cynical, edgy 'darkness' that has crept into Star Trek thisSeth McFarlane is clearly a Star Trek fan. Him and the other creative people behind the show really get what the original Star Trek (up to and including Voyager) was really about. There is a feeling of optimism, hope and exuberance tempered with a touch of seriousness in the attitudes of the characters - not because of any cynical, edgy 'darkness' that has crept into Star Trek this millenium - but because they understand the gravity of their mission.

    This show captured the true essence of Star Trek so well in fact that, if you remove the gags, it could easily have been an episode of Star Trek. But it wasn't and that is kind of a shame. The gags are very funny in places but fell flat at other times. It seemed as though McFarlane created a Star Trek homage and then shoe-horned in a few jokes. At times when watching I found myself hoping there wouldn't be another joke anytime soon. Not because they weren't funny, but because I didn't want my immersion broken. The story in this episode is simple but there is a spark of inspiration in how it unfolded that gives me hope for the series.

    Most of the main characters were set up well and I found them all intriguing to varying degrees. Some have alot of potential and I feel it will make or break the show how well they are written and performed in the season ahead. MacFarlane's Captain and his ex-wife first officer aren't part of that list as I thought they came off a bit bland, though I was impressed with both the actors when they needed shift gear to a more dramatic tone. Rather, it's the supporting cast I speak of here.

    For what the show is, it is done really well so I'm giving it a 9. The jokes didn't always land and at times jarred with the main plot but it made me laugh and felt like a quality parody that really embraced it's source material with a clear passion.    … Expand
  78. molbal
    Sep 13, 2017
    9
    Perfect mix of funny and serious scenes. Captures the Star Trek feel very well, but jokes are a bit forced sometimes. I'm looking forward to the rest of the show
  79. SimoneRenee
    Sep 19, 2017
    8
    I have honestly never really felt compelled to write a review before, but I think this deserves one! Because I honestly think the critics are wrong! I've only seen the two episodes to air so far, and they're funny, cute, and have a lot of heart. Yeah you probably have to like Seth Macfarlane and cheesy syfy to enjoy the show, but I do, and so do a lot of people. The feel is a little likeI have honestly never really felt compelled to write a review before, but I think this deserves one! Because I honestly think the critics are wrong! I've only seen the two episodes to air so far, and they're funny, cute, and have a lot of heart. Yeah you probably have to like Seth Macfarlane and cheesy syfy to enjoy the show, but I do, and so do a lot of people. The feel is a little like star trek, but to me it also feels a lot like Firefly. It's not a spoof, but it also doesn't take itself too seriously. There's some comedy, and some action. It's a fun show with a fun cast, and I hope it sticks around.… Expand
  80. suaviant
    Oct 6, 2017
    10
    Critics are wrong. I am a lifelong Star Trek fan, even enjoyed the first of the Abrams reboots somewhat but this, this feels like the most Star Trek thing since Star Trek Enterprise. It is funny not always in a laugh out loud way, and it never feels stupid. The drama so far is decent enough. The characters are believable. This is good. I signed up because this show deserves another voiceCritics are wrong. I am a lifelong Star Trek fan, even enjoyed the first of the Abrams reboots somewhat but this, this feels like the most Star Trek thing since Star Trek Enterprise. It is funny not always in a laugh out loud way, and it never feels stupid. The drama so far is decent enough. The characters are believable. This is good. I signed up because this show deserves another voice telling you to support it and check it out. I truly hope this show continues for some time to come and if it gets better then we are all in for a treat :-)… Expand
  81. maillard
    Oct 7, 2017
    10
    The series is fresh innovative funny, without all that PC star trek moralist rubbish, overused old characters and overrun storylines. It is not pompous and preachy, in fact, it is much like Kirks original star trek, great show, fab cast. Get over yourselves critics.
  82. StarzSeeker
    Oct 8, 2017
    10
    This is Star Trek TOS meets Next Generation meets Galaxy Quest. I'm 5 episodes in and the show is getting better with each passing week. I was 11 minutes into the pilot and heard myself say out loud "this is Star Trek!". The look and feel of the show is all Trek. The characters are developing quickly and that's a positive. You need the audience to care about the characters and they haveThis is Star Trek TOS meets Next Generation meets Galaxy Quest. I'm 5 episodes in and the show is getting better with each passing week. I was 11 minutes into the pilot and heard myself say out loud "this is Star Trek!". The look and feel of the show is all Trek. The characters are developing quickly and that's a positive. You need the audience to care about the characters and they have succeeded in doing so. The stories are deeper than you would expect for a season 1. It's almost as if they decided to start in season 2 or 3. Users have it at 8.1, very positive. So to all the professional critics out there who are panning the show I would recommend you reconsider your career choice. The show is a hit with the audience therefore you are obviously not seeing what the great majority is seeing. Two thumbs up, and only two because that's all I have.… Expand
  83. routier1642
    Oct 12, 2017
    10
    Star Trek with the dialogue of Guardians of the Galaxy! It works. The characters are likable & believable, and despite the humour, the situations are serious and the plots and actions of the characters actually make sense. (unlike that other show)
    I don't know that's wrong with the "pro critics". Perhaps they can't classify this show. They should relax & just enjoy it.
  84. Stercrazy
    Oct 15, 2017
    10
    This show is amazing. I feel like this is the show that fans of Star Trek have been waiting for. Watching the show is like putting on an old pair of shoes. There's just something comforting and familiar about it. Do not go into this show expecting Family Guy. This is a serious sci fi show with comedic elements, not a comedy with sci fi elements. Think of this show as TNG if the showThis show is amazing. I feel like this is the show that fans of Star Trek have been waiting for. Watching the show is like putting on an old pair of shoes. There's just something comforting and familiar about it. Do not go into this show expecting Family Guy. This is a serious sci fi show with comedic elements, not a comedy with sci fi elements. Think of this show as TNG if the show followed a crew of run-of-the-mill folks on an average ship instead of an exceptional crew on a top-of-the-line ship. The show deals with complicated issues in the same way that TNG used to but it lightens things up by letting the audience see that people are still people, no matter how advanced the society gets. All that being said, I feel like the best thing this show has going for it is that isn't bogged down with Star Trek's baggage. It gets to do all the fun stuff from Trek and the stuff the fans love, but it doesn't have to worry about violating decades of canon. If you are a fan of Trek, you should REALLY give this show a watch. You won't regret it.… Expand
  85. norse
    Dec 30, 2017
    10
    This show is amazingly good.

    I expected a comedy, and was hoping it might be a bit like Galaxy Quest. It's not as outright comedic, the humor is more underhanded and the scripts are actually better than typical Trek or Star Wars. I am binge watching the series right now, and the topics are pretty heavy handed but handled lightly. It's hard to describe, but it's some of the best    This show is amazingly good.

    I expected a comedy, and was hoping it might be a bit like Galaxy Quest. It's not as outright comedic, the humor is more underhanded and the scripts are actually better than typical Trek or Star Wars.

    I am binge watching the series right now, and the topics are pretty heavy handed but handled lightly. It's hard to describe, but it's some of the best writing I've seen on television, and it's in a science fiction show. Go figure.

    Other than that, really fine acting, the graphics are top notch, and the scoring is really good - it's used sparingly and therefore is more impactful.

    Highly recommended. It's so good that I expect Fox to cancel it any minute.    … Expand
  86. Jesp1
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    Refreshing! Feels like the Star Trek of TNG yore. Definitely gave me nostalgia tickle vibes. And interestingly is safe enough for the younger ones without being too inappropriate. Definitely going to give it a chance!
  87. stevegroundhog
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    The Orville is a fantastic fresh take on a the bleak and dark Star Trek franchise. It is essentially Star Trek, but better. By giving us a dramedy set in the style of Next Generation, this show has the bright future to break out at least more seasons than Star Trek the orignal series.

    No doubt the mainstream critics were paid off to bash it due to Discovery debuting. Discovery will be a    The Orville is a fantastic fresh take on a the bleak and dark Star Trek franchise. It is essentially Star Trek, but better. By giving us a dramedy set in the style of Next Generation, this show has the bright future to break out at least more seasons than Star Trek the orignal series.

    No doubt the mainstream critics were paid off to bash it due to Discovery debuting. Discovery will be a bland, dark, bleak, piece of SJW crap from a show that has lost it's way. Do yourself a favor, if you want to go back to the way Star Trek is supposed to be then watch this show.

    Also.... FOX do not screw us over.    … Expand
  88. Stormwolf
    Oct 9, 2017
    9
    Great show, these guys should have been the ones making the new Star Trek. Sure, some of the jokes are fairly flat, but it's okay when you look at the wonderful TOS/TNG style plots they have.

    This is the show for you if you like the pre-reboot Star Trek and Galaxy Quest, watch it if you haven't seen it already.
  89. iargue
    Nov 25, 2017
    10
    Please do nott pay any attention to the critic reviews. The critic appears to have their head far too up their own ass to even have given the show a chance. They even go as far as attacking the show as being a "rip off" of star trek, despite the fact that it is literally a star trek tv show.

    The show is a fantastic show, that introduces you to the Star Trek universe without all of the    Please do nott pay any attention to the critic reviews. The critic appears to have their head far too up their own ass to even have given the show a chance. They even go as far as attacking the show as being a "rip off" of star trek, despite the fact that it is literally a star trek tv show.

    The show is a fantastic show, that introduces you to the Star Trek universe without all of the pompous **** that surround the name. Rather then being on a flagship, a vessel of hope for all of humanity, they are on a middle class ship. The ship is smaller, the people less important, but their lives and stories they have are way richer because of this.

    This is a breath of fresh air,with odd humor and the touch of situational comedy, it presents a world where you can actually connect with. Just a bunch of people doing their jobs and having funny interactions, all while set in space.

    The show deserves a thousand times better then the rating the critics provided.    … Expand
  90. Thermalzombie
    Sep 12, 2017
    7
    Enjoyed this new series. The jokes were not great but the atmosphere and cast as well as production quality made up for any lack of humor. The universe is interesting and I would like to see more looking forward to the next episode. One of the best pilot episodes of a new series I have seen.
  91. MK500
    Oct 3, 2017
    9
    This show is weirdly true to Gene Rodenberry‘s Star Trek. Yes it often makes fun of Star Trek; but that’s OK (and I’m a huge Trekkie). It is well written and amusing; but it’s not just a comedy. The traditional exploration and moral conflicts that make Star Trek great are there; and you feel good at the end of each episode. It’s also a light hearted take on the future that doesn’t make youThis show is weirdly true to Gene Rodenberry‘s Star Trek. Yes it often makes fun of Star Trek; but that’s OK (and I’m a huge Trekkie). It is well written and amusing; but it’s not just a comedy. The traditional exploration and moral conflicts that make Star Trek great are there; and you feel good at the end of each episode. It’s also a light hearted take on the future that doesn’t make you depressed about where we are headed as a species. It’s so much better than the dark depressing abomination CBS is attempting to call Star Trek!… Expand
  92. flowbeus
    Sep 26, 2017
    9
    I wasn't expecting much here but I was surprised how good this was. I watched the first 3 episodes and was really impressed. For me Star Trek is all about morality, ethics, culture, humanity, politics, etc, the best elements of science fiction mixed with an optimistic vision of the future.

    I've been very disappointed in the direction Star Trek has been going over the years, opting for    I wasn't expecting much here but I was surprised how good this was. I watched the first 3 episodes and was really impressed. For me Star Trek is all about morality, ethics, culture, humanity, politics, etc, the best elements of science fiction mixed with an optimistic vision of the future.

    I've been very disappointed in the direction Star Trek has been going over the years, opting for more space battles and special effects rather than thought-provoking dilemmas and focusing on the wonders of the cosmos.

    The Orville seems to be filling in the dark hole that the absence of Star Trek has left in us. There is humor in the show, but it's not the main focus, and the show is dabbling in serious issues like the ethics of sex-change operations and cultural/racial elitism.

    We can forgive the show for trying to find its footing and establish the right balance between comedy and drama. This is normal for a show that's just starting out. But there is a lot to love so far, and the show's heart is in the right place for a fantastic series. Fox please don't Firefly this one...    … Expand
  93. Armitas
    Nov 4, 2017
    9
    Another good example of why professional critics, especially in television and movie media, are a complete waste of our time.

    This show is basically a full fledged Star Trek with good clean comedy. I found some of the episodes to be better than Star Trek TNG. So if you want a Star Trek show but don't want to go to CBS silly side venture here you go, and as a bonus you will get quite a    Another good example of why professional critics, especially in television and movie media, are a complete waste of our time.

    This show is basically a full fledged Star Trek with good clean comedy. I found some of the episodes to be better than Star Trek TNG. So if you want a Star Trek show but don't want to go to CBS silly side venture here you go, and as a bonus you will get quite a few solid chuckles seamlessly woven in.

    THIS IS NOT FAMILY GUY!. if you are hesitant to watch this because of what Seth MacFarlane normally puts out you have nothing to fear. The comedy here is geared toward adults but it's not gross, disturbing, or crude. At worst it dips into the first rung of PG-13, but so did Start Trek TNG. If your kids are stay-at-home adults or in their teens you might even be able to watch it as a family. Don't let the name "Seth MacFarlane" scare you away from this one. It is a really good show. Seth is revealing an incredible amount of positive talent here, and I hope he continues to show the world this side of him.    … Expand
  94. Frydaddy15
    Sep 18, 2017
    9
    Looked at critic reviews, they must be some turds who watched the show. It's well-written, well produced, and above all fun. Now if you're expecting non stop laughs or deep intellectual sci fi, yeah don't bother. But it hits all the notes it needs to, it's something anyone can watch and get a kick out of. Jokes are hit or miss, but the actors and writers care about it, and that makes itLooked at critic reviews, they must be some turds who watched the show. It's well-written, well produced, and above all fun. Now if you're expecting non stop laughs or deep intellectual sci fi, yeah don't bother. But it hits all the notes it needs to, it's something anyone can watch and get a kick out of. Jokes are hit or miss, but the actors and writers care about it, and that makes it worth watching. Hope it lasts long enough to earn a few seasons.… Expand
  95. weinishao
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    This show is great. I hope it goes for 10 seasons. A mix of pure Star Trek Nostalgia, cultural references, character development and Farlane's humor, makes it relevant for today's audience. Don't listen to the critics, watch it. Four episodes in and it even better, character development has an incredible well paced timing, and it gives you that " I what the next episode now" feeling fromThis show is great. I hope it goes for 10 seasons. A mix of pure Star Trek Nostalgia, cultural references, character development and Farlane's humor, makes it relevant for today's audience. Don't listen to the critics, watch it. Four episodes in and it even better, character development has an incredible well paced timing, and it gives you that " I what the next episode now" feeling from the Star Trek of old.… Expand
  96. afngary
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    Was really impressed by this Star Trek clone. Thought it was going to be so so with the light humor, but found that it really updated it with the times. It's as if you added 10% Family Guy with 90% true Star Trek format. Really liked it and really glad to finally have a science fiction show to watch since the late 90's.
  97. AuraBoyX
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    AWESOME SHOW!!! A bit of camp and a whole lot of the true soul of Star Trek! I am so glad this show wasn't what I expected it to be (a Family Guy style comedy in space). Screw Discovery - this show is great!
  98. Cron0s69
    Sep 30, 2017
    8
    Sorry for my bad english
    Star Trek is Star Trek , The Orville Is The orville ,comparing Star Trek to The orville, do not make sense ,Is need the time for the new serie , oh the episode 4 be drawn from the novel Oprhans of the sky by Robert Heinlein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orphans_of_the_Sky
  99. Trokil
    Oct 1, 2017
    10
    In the Orville Seth MacFarlane shows, that he knows why people liked Star Trek. This is a show in love with the sci-fi shows of the 80’s and 90’s and why so many people were becoming fans for life. It is a homage to classic TV and is fun to watch while the crew deals every week with funny, interesting and important topics. But nothing feels so heavy handed like in Discovery, it is stillIn the Orville Seth MacFarlane shows, that he knows why people liked Star Trek. This is a show in love with the sci-fi shows of the 80’s and 90’s and why so many people were becoming fans for life. It is a homage to classic TV and is fun to watch while the crew deals every week with funny, interesting and important topics. But nothing feels so heavy handed like in Discovery, it is still good-hearted in its core. There is still this optimism towards the future we loved in shows like TNG. A wonderful show for all fans who are done with all those gritty reboots of their favorite sci-fi franchises.… Expand
  100. Cosmic_Hound
    Oct 4, 2017
    9
    This show fills in that slot that has been left vacant since the end of the "The next generation" era Star Trek. It innovates in its own way, swapping technobabble for humour and campyness for self-awareness. The characters are interesting and diverse, there is conflict without unprofessional emotional outbursts on the bridge and while command style is laid back discipline is respected andThis show fills in that slot that has been left vacant since the end of the "The next generation" era Star Trek. It innovates in its own way, swapping technobabble for humour and campyness for self-awareness. The characters are interesting and diverse, there is conflict without unprofessional emotional outbursts on the bridge and while command style is laid back discipline is respected and the crew work together towards their goal. The starship is properly lit and up to modern future technology, with interesting and consistent designs for human and extrasolar spacecrafts and stations. The social commentary is open to more than a single interpretation and not partisan. The musical theme is very good, not as bombastic as the old ones but still delivering the idea of space adventure.
    While I am a fan of grimdark, I prefer "The Orville: the third generation" to "Star Trek Gothic".    … Expand
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

2
#2 Most Discussed TV Season of 2017
47
#47 Most Shared TV Season of 2017

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
36

Generally unfavorable reviews - based on 21 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 0 out of 21
  2. Mixed: 11 out of 21
  3. Negative: 10 out of 21
  1. New York Post
    Reviewed by: Michael Starr
    Sep 21, 2017
    50
    It’s got top-notch special effects and terrific makeup (for its space-alien characters). But it just doesn’t quite gel. At least not yet, anyway.
    Read full review
  2. TV Guide Magazine
    Reviewed by: Matt Roush
    Sep 14, 2017
    50
    The show's smirky tone, embodied in MacFarlane's smug frat-boy demeanor as the captain, never quite gels with the universal humanism the episode is aiming for. [18 Sep - 1 Oct 2017, p.27]
  3. Yahoo TV
    Reviewed by: Ken Tucker
    Sep 11, 2017
    30
    Except for Norm Macdonald as the voice of an alien made of what looked like quivering gelatin, I didn’t find much that was amusing about The Orville’s space odyssey. ... From its opening scene with Victor Garber assigning Ed his ship to the final, unsuspenseful shootout with alien enemies, The Orville moved from one lull to another.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »