Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

9

ArdiffDec 18, 2016

Well, I'm really waiting for this movie. I waited a very dark and adult story. And I get it. Yes, the first half of the movie is too much boring and tighten but then the narrative accelerates twice and actions happened is too fast. And ofWell, I'm really waiting for this movie. I waited a very dark and adult story. And I get it. Yes, the first half of the movie is too much boring and tighten but then the narrative accelerates twice and actions happened is too fast. And of course about battles. It a one of the massive battles in Star Wars saga, I enjoying of every single minute.… Expand

13 of 23 users found this helpful1310

All this user's reviews

9

3lusiveDec 31, 2016

Probably the best Star Wars film I've ever seen and the best film I've watched this year. Bold, engrossing, tense, and very well put together. Light-years ahead of what I thought it would be. Acting from all main characters is strong, storyProbably the best Star Wars film I've ever seen and the best film I've watched this year. Bold, engrossing, tense, and very well put together. Light-years ahead of what I thought it would be. Acting from all main characters is strong, story is generally well thought out and paced. The humour parts are subtle and not overdone or childish.

The villains are exceptional and Darth Vader in particular is genuinely 'scary', his limited screen time is still very effective.

Overall Rogue One has a serious tone to it which suits the film and franchise very well (as opposed to childish crap that plagues some previous ones). You genuinely care for their fate and the task at hand (to get the Death Star files which expose its critical weaknesses). At no point during the film did I feel bored or wanting it to hurry up, in fact I could have sat for at least another hour! Very well balanced and paced.

The film is leaps and bounds ahead of The Force Awakens and previous recent star wars films.

I rarely write reviews but felt this one deserved it.

More please.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

9

Doomsday4766Dec 20, 2016

After watching this film I am elated. Here I am thinking that Disney ruined the originality of Star Wars for me by making the no risk, recycled, nothing new 'Farce Awakens'. To be sure, I had a bit of skepticism still when I entered theAfter watching this film I am elated. Here I am thinking that Disney ruined the originality of Star Wars for me by making the no risk, recycled, nothing new 'Farce Awakens'. To be sure, I had a bit of skepticism still when I entered the theater. Would this film cautiously retread the story about some space peasant blessed with magical abilities? Would I have to sit though a nostalgia driven plot that makes no sense? to my relief I was spared any disappointment, and was treated with one of the most originally grounded Star Wars films. The beginning of the movie I felt was the slowest, but before long I was drawn completely into the plot. Then when the action begins it really doesn't stop, right up until the closing scene.

It gets a 9 from me for being a truly self contained story, no real loose ends here, just one entertaining ride. -1 point for overdoing CGI a tad , and to all those who called out the music as a negative. At least it had some original scores, and I was able to actually hear it. Unlike in that awful 7th movie...… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

gamer1Dec 24, 2016

J'ai vraiment aimé ce film, un vrai plaisir de voir que la licence Star Wars semble enfin capable de nou faire rêver à nouveau ! De l'action comme rarement et les acteurs sont très bien aussi

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

judahjsnDec 16, 2016

Just incredible. Reminded me of things that were great about the originals that I had forgotten. This is a masterful star wars film full of feeling and incredibly choreographed battle scenes. It makes the Force Awakens seem bloodless andJust incredible. Reminded me of things that were great about the originals that I had forgotten. This is a masterful star wars film full of feeling and incredibly choreographed battle scenes. It makes the Force Awakens seem bloodless and airless in comparison. The cqi recreations of old actors is the only fly in the ointment. Terrible, terrible decision. Would have been flawless without that.… Expand

27 of 47 users found this helpful2720

All this user's reviews

9

jonasionDec 16, 2016

Look, I'm a massive Star Wars fan, but I've been nothing but disappointed since the mid-eighties really. Episode 7 was somewhat okay for me, but it left a lot of **** in its wake. Rogue One goes about explaining some key things that have leftLook, I'm a massive Star Wars fan, but I've been nothing but disappointed since the mid-eighties really. Episode 7 was somewhat okay for me, but it left a lot of **** in its wake. Rogue One goes about explaining some key things that have left the nerd-verse puzzled about the original Star Wars - Episode IV - A New Hope (as it was later dubbed). Rogue One goes about explaining that and it does so really well and it takes no prisoners.… Expand

7 of 19 users found this helpful712

All this user's reviews

9

MattyiceDec 21, 2016

Rogue One feels more like an exhilarating war film than a Star Wars film, but this is obviously a good thing. The new characters and recognizable cameos are fantastic, the action scenes are top notch, and it is shot extremely well. The film'sRogue One feels more like an exhilarating war film than a Star Wars film, but this is obviously a good thing. The new characters and recognizable cameos are fantastic, the action scenes are top notch, and it is shot extremely well. The film's first third drags a bit and Gareth Edwards' directorial flaws peek in and out, but the rest of the film's pros make up for it. A great addition to the Star Wars mythos and I hope they make more films like this in the future of a galaxy far far away.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

9

warren-troubleDec 17, 2017

I loved this movie! I think that some the criticism of this movie are valid, we don't spend enough time getting to know the characters and some of the best scenes from the trailer were cut from the movie, but I am overwhelmed with joy by theI loved this movie! I think that some the criticism of this movie are valid, we don't spend enough time getting to know the characters and some of the best scenes from the trailer were cut from the movie, but I am overwhelmed with joy by the look and feel of this movie! The worlds, the clothing, the creatures! There are moments during and afterwards that probably dont make sense if you spend any amount of time thinking about it but everything about this movie is undeniably Star Wars before special editions and prequels.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

NikolayGDec 17, 2016

A great addition to the Star Wars universe, Rogue One has the best last act of any Star Wars movie (excepting the big surprise moment in Empire Strikes Back). The only downside is that the robot's jokes aren't that funny and one characterA great addition to the Star Wars universe, Rogue One has the best last act of any Star Wars movie (excepting the big surprise moment in Empire Strikes Back). The only downside is that the robot's jokes aren't that funny and one character gives up on life kind of inexplicably. He/she (not to give anything away) could have escaped danger but basically just said it wasn't worth the trouble. That was a head scratcher. Otherwise, this is a fantastic gritty take on Star Wars, with a brilliant ending. Jyn Erso is a great heroine, a bit more scrappy and relatable than perfect Rey; this movie also includes some of Vader's finest moments.… Expand

5 of 17 users found this helpful512

All this user's reviews

9

MCotsalasFeb 22, 2017

I'm shocked that this is only rated a 65 by the critics. This was without a doubt a better told story than The Force Awakens, and the characters had much more likability than The Force Awakens. Looking forward to the next story told inI'm shocked that this is only rated a 65 by the critics. This was without a doubt a better told story than The Force Awakens, and the characters had much more likability than The Force Awakens. Looking forward to the next story told in between trilogy films. (I believe the next one is about Han Solo's origins.)… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

tr1cky1Dec 29, 2016

Hands downthe best standalone Star Wars Movie. The pure action may have been better in Ep 3, the best light saber battle is Ep 1, but those 2 movies were absolute trash.

Writing and dialogue are clearly the best out of all the series inHands downthe best standalone Star Wars Movie. The pure action may have been better in Ep 3, the best light saber battle is Ep 1, but those 2 movies were absolute trash.

Writing and dialogue are clearly the best out of all the series in Rogue One. One addition by subtraction is a different reliance on the Force compared to the other films, turning it into a grittier movie and less of a battle of super-beings. Most importantly, I've now got a new favorite droid. I kinda wonder what Lucas thinks of all this.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

Iky009Apr 15, 2017

The surreal scenarios are just a part of the visual delight, and technical brilliance of every film, here we see another very well constructed plot, full of great characters and unrestrained action. Rogue One does not leave its origins aside,The surreal scenarios are just a part of the visual delight, and technical brilliance of every film, here we see another very well constructed plot, full of great characters and unrestrained action. Rogue One does not leave its origins aside, but still, it can escape the essence of the saga, and tread its own way ...… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

colilla1972Dec 16, 2016

Una buena película con uno de los mejores cierres del universo de Star Wars, -tal vez los mejores últimos 20 minutos de toda la franquicia-. Es cierto algunas cosas pudieron ser mejor pero como muestra del potencial del Universo De Star WarsUna buena película con uno de los mejores cierres del universo de Star Wars, -tal vez los mejores últimos 20 minutos de toda la franquicia-. Es cierto algunas cosas pudieron ser mejor pero como muestra del potencial del Universo De Star Wars es muy buen comienzo y la película es muy divertida.… Expand

8 of 18 users found this helpful810

All this user's reviews

9

Agent314Dec 21, 2016

This is hands down the best Star Wars movie since Empire Strikes Back. The first time I saw it I was too nervous to really catch all the nuances and finer points of story. Nervous, yes! Because I wanted sooooo bad for this movie to make meThis is hands down the best Star Wars movie since Empire Strikes Back. The first time I saw it I was too nervous to really catch all the nuances and finer points of story. Nervous, yes! Because I wanted sooooo bad for this movie to make me feel like I did when I was 10 and seeing Star Wars for the first time.

Yes, the film is a bit slow at first. No, the CGI characters are NOT distracting or uncanny. Yes, you'll long for a bit more backstory on the members of Rogue One, but YES you are supposed to want more! That's what Star Wars did for us. OMG, the clone wars? What were those? Jedi? What are you talking about? Anyway, none of that makes Rogue One less enjoyable.

The second time I saw the film I picked up on a lot more clues, and was left overjoyed. I loved the film even more. The Force Awakens was pretty good, but this is just shy of spectacular.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

GameAnalyzerDec 16, 2016

Rogue One manages to stay as a faithful chapter from the Star Wars franchise on its own league serving as a rightful prequel to the fourth episode. The creators right from the start had promised to bring something new to the table and theyRogue One manages to stay as a faithful chapter from the Star Wars franchise on its own league serving as a rightful prequel to the fourth episode. The creators right from the start had promised to bring something new to the table and they did deliver. The casting was perfect. The CGI has been remarkable with lots of surprise elements in offer for long time fans of the franchise from the 70s. Although the film delivers in the long run with all Stars Wars action elements ranging from stormtroopers to the AT act walkers against the rebellion units , there are minor issues with general pacing as the story progresses around with its Death Star plot at instances with poorly timed execution of the characters related to it, bogging it down for viewers. The Force Awakens had an USP with great character execution but on the other hand the action sequences in Rogue One struck the right chord several notches above TFA for the prequel story. It deserves a solid 9.… Expand

24 of 43 users found this helpful2419

All this user's reviews

9

TimW001Jan 9, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This was a very enjoyable film. Here is a list of its best feature:
-Forest Whitaker's character
-The Tense Third Act -Giant Space Battle
-Hammerhead cruiser making two Imperial capital ship crash
-1970's grit.
-Direct connection to the 1970's movies
-Darth Vader, and Darth Vader's rampage

It was a far darker and grittier film than The Force Awakens. Great movie, a must see.… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

9

deckMay 25, 2017

Rogue One lends itself convincingly to episodes three and four by dispensing with comic(episode 7) and focusing on the classic features of the Lucas films.
Star Wars fans may be annoyed with the fact that Kyle Katarn's story is obsolete, butRogue One lends itself convincingly to episodes three and four by dispensing with comic(episode 7) and focusing on the classic features of the Lucas films.
Star Wars fans may be annoyed with the fact that Kyle Katarn's story is obsolete, but they get the first Star Wars movie of the 21st century, which can meet the expectations of a modern Star Wars.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

AlexanderLuthorDec 19, 2016

Rogue One is a fitting addition to the Star Wars cannon with a story line filled with interesting characters, captivating moments, and possessing a tragic quality reminiscent of The Empire Strikes Back.

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

9

gracjanskiMay 23, 2022

I dont know why this movie doesnt have much better reviews. I like this one: The story fits perfectly into the time between Episode 3 and 4, especially the connections with the costumes and the characters are obvious. The visual effects areI dont know why this movie doesnt have much better reviews. I like this one: The story fits perfectly into the time between Episode 3 and 4, especially the connections with the costumes and the characters are obvious. The visual effects are also great and the action scenes are very good. The ending is good, something different than in many other movies. In addition the movie feels a lot like a Star Wars movie.

Only the characters could have been more interesting, and some political correct elements are obvious.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

sciteachJun 8, 2018

Every time I watch this movie, I enjoy it even more than the last. This has quickly risen to the top of my best SW movies list in the post-original trilogy. It is so powerful, and speaks to me about the horrors of war. What is good? What isEvery time I watch this movie, I enjoy it even more than the last. This has quickly risen to the top of my best SW movies list in the post-original trilogy. It is so powerful, and speaks to me about the horrors of war. What is good? What is evil? What decisions must be made to "do the right thing?" The last 30 minutes of this movie are cinematic genius, and leave you feeling that the rebellions chances were only a just barely given to them.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

NecroMnemicJan 4, 2020

Great Movie! Likeable characters, very well embedded into the original franchise without mindlessly copying it (like episode 7 and 9).

This is the best StarWars Movie since Episode 6 released.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

BabinskiDec 28, 2016

This is what the Force Awakens should have been. The action sequences are incomparably better than any other in the previous movie. The story line is also way more original, showing other aspects of the rebel alliance. I only felt theThis is what the Force Awakens should have been. The action sequences are incomparably better than any other in the previous movie. The story line is also way more original, showing other aspects of the rebel alliance. I only felt the characters werent developed very well.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

bfoore90Dec 16, 2016

Led by a stellar cast and finalized with some pretty awesome scenes with the one and only Darth Vader, Rogue One serves as a welcomed edition to the Star Wars universe and should please any Star Wars fan, new and old.

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

9

BigDegs29Dec 21, 2016

8.5/10 (Metacritic doesn't let you do decimals)

This is my second favorite Star Wars after Empire. The worst part of the movie is the beginning, and it progressively gets better from there until it's firing on all cylinders by the end. The8.5/10 (Metacritic doesn't let you do decimals)

This is my second favorite Star Wars after Empire. The worst part of the movie is the beginning, and it progressively gets better from there until it's firing on all cylinders by the end. The final act is spectacular! Probably the best space battle excepting Jedi, and the best ground fight in any Star Wars.

The story is great, and even goes so far to correct a 40-year-old plot hole in A New Hope (I won't explain that further for fear of spoilers).

The weak point is the character development. The two mains, Jyn and Cassian, have decent character arcs. Chirrut and Baze play two characters that are pretty much cliche at this point, but still enjoyable. Bodhi is forgettable. K-2SO is pretty awesome and carries almost all of the comedic relief on his shoulders, and not in the cheesy way the prequels treated C-3PO. Saw Gerrera played by Whitaker has only a small role in the movie and is involved in probably the weakest scene of the entire thing.

There is a lot of fan service in this movie. Without going into spoilers, some of it works really well and some had me rolling my eyes.

They used CGI to bring back two characters from the original trilogy. One gets a lot of screen time and suffers for it, entering into the uncanny valley. The other gets limited screen time and works a lot better.

I take it by now everyone knows Vader is in the film. And let me tell you, Rogue One has the best Vader scene in all of Star Wars IMO. They humanized him in Jedi, but they bring back the menace full on here!

I consider this a must-see. If you're like me, the first 15-20 minutes will leave you pessimistic about the result of the movie, but it'll win you over shortly after that!… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

ThomoriDec 17, 2016

Für mich einer der besten SW-Filme,weit vor Ep7.
Grandiose Kameraperspektiven (z.B. der Sternenzerstörer über der Tempelstadt).
Die Imps treffen zwar immer noch nicht präzise,aber wenigstens besser als in den anderen Teilen :-P Was für einFür mich einer der besten SW-Filme,weit vor Ep7.
Grandiose Kameraperspektiven (z.B. der Sternenzerstörer über der Tempelstadt).
Die Imps treffen zwar immer noch nicht präzise,aber wenigstens besser als in den anderen Teilen :-P
Was für ein Schlachtengetümmel und Vader,Tarkin und Leia wiederzusehen war es allein schon wert :-)… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

9

familyguyDec 18, 2016

Awesome is only word i can use to describe this masterpiece. It basically a war movie with star wars look. awesome character , great visual effecf and story telling. This movie is prefect missing link between ep 3 and 4. also they add aAwesome is only word i can use to describe this masterpiece. It basically a war movie with star wars look. awesome character , great visual effecf and story telling. This movie is prefect missing link between ep 3 and 4. also they add a little of Marvel sense of humor make it ez to watch for new audience . And last but not least Darth Vader super badass in this film. just go to theater and watch it u won't be disappoint… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

9

ason313Dec 17, 2016

This is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old filmsThis is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old films without feeling derivative of them. Might also be the darkest Star Wars film to date, showing why a new hope was really needed. A great way to start off the side films.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

Closeremperor16Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Holy F**K Vader!! Oh man I can only look at this movie as a massive fan and as a fan it was amazing. The story was interesting and moved quickly, the cinematography and sense of scope and scale was excellent. I absolutely loved getting to see more of the oppression of the empire and the morally grey areas of the rebellion.

I loved the fact that this felt like a war movie taking place in the star wars universe. It connected seamlessly to episode 4 and gave me some truly jaw dropping moments. The whole last half hour of the movie was amazing and the beach scenes were everything I had hoped for in the best saving private Star wars kind of way. And Vader Holy **** Vader just mercilessly chopping down the rebels in the hallway at the end may have become one of my favourite Scenes ever. All in all I ****ing loved it, I have seen some criticisms of lack of character development ect But I think for the type of single shot story that this is that the way they handled it was appropriate. All in all is it a perfect movie…no because no movies perfect. BUT I would say because of my taste for the darker side of star wars this prob slots in to place behind empire strikes back as my favourite Star Wars movie. I need to see it about 4 more times in the cinema before I set my ranking in stone but the point is want to see it many more times. This film Gave me everything I wanted and was hoping for in an incredibly satisfying package. Bravo! Job well Done!!!… Expand

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

9

lupaf5Dec 17, 2016

Amazing star wars movie, it has his problems but at least is something different, the prequel we deserve, now i have a lot of fait in this new anthology movies. (please check the negative reviews, its incredible how people can be so stupid, iAmazing star wars movie, it has his problems but at least is something different, the prequel we deserve, now i have a lot of fait in this new anthology movies. (please check the negative reviews, its incredible how people can be so stupid, i mean i know its their opinion but damn alot of them didnt even know what movie they were watching)… Expand

15 of 25 users found this helpful1510

All this user's reviews

9

MiracSpectacJan 7, 2018

Rogue One surpassed all my expectations by a mile, providing what may be one of my favorite Star Wars films to date. As a standalone, I only expected a few vanilla characters, but it somehow managed to establish some characters that meet theRogue One surpassed all my expectations by a mile, providing what may be one of my favorite Star Wars films to date. As a standalone, I only expected a few vanilla characters, but it somehow managed to establish some characters that meet the standards of main entries. Though still a little vanilla, the quality is there. It was honestly just a fantastic drama, and that's what I expect from Star Wars.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

Kai82Feb 9, 2020

While it is slow at the beginning it has the best and most intense final battle in all Star Wars movies. When you think that Darth Vader made only a cameo you get the most badass scene you can imagine. You see the fear in his enemies eyes asWhile it is slow at the beginning it has the best and most intense final battle in all Star Wars movies. When you think that Darth Vader made only a cameo you get the most badass scene you can imagine. You see the fear in his enemies eyes as they recognize that they are screwed. But lets start at the beginning. It was planned as spin off with the premise to be a war movie. “Good guys do horrible things in wars” was a quote of the director. There were massive reshoots and rumors about the movie. You can see it it the trailers. There are many scenes that are not in the movie. The cast is relativly good. Felicity Jones is the lead as Jyn Erso. She carries her role and burdens. Diego Luna as Cassian Andor is a rebel that does the dirty work for the Alliance that has to be done. He is not evil, more the kind of guy that sacrifices his soul for the sake of the greater good / others. The secret stars are Donnie Yen as Chirrut Inwe and Jiang Wen as Baze Malbus. The two are an awesome duo and so enjoyable to watch. Riz Ahmed delivers his role as imperial defector who seeks redemption. K-2SO a droid and former enforcer is also a highlight. I must mention that the Star Wars movies create a lot of good droid characters. For the villains: Ben Mendelson as Orsen Krennic is a perfect power hungry plotter and high ranking imperial (I think there is a huge overlap or there is even no difference). Then there is Darth Vader and an iconic character that returns (Wont spoil). Forest Whitaker as Saw Gerrera is more a good bad guy or anti hero and underused. He is the kind of rebel that does all that is necessary no mater the causalities or morality. He is also someone who would never abandon a friend or break his own code of honor (He could have become the Che Guevara of Star Wars). The story starts slow and got better as the movie progresses. The final is just awesome. It is the spirit of the rebellion. The people that wont give up no matter the odds push forward on a suicide mission just to keep hope / the rebellion alive. They are outnumbered and have only the surprise attack and distraction advantage on their side. The Empire soldiers outnumber them at least 100 to 1, have superior weapon and can call for even more reinforcements. Its so good and immersive that I consider giving 10/10 for it alone and forget that the set up to get there is not worth this rating. Also the ending. I never thought that they have courage to pull this off. It gives the characters even more meaning. There are of cause the issues with the CGI. Some familiar characters look really weird. This is not that serious for me but I must admit that it is an issue that can hurt the experience for some. Overall the final safes this movie. It would be unremarkable but no failure without it. I will praise the characters and want to see more. I also want to see the original movie before the reshoots but don't think it is possible.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

DBPirate1129Dec 24, 2017

Rogue One definitely surprised me when I first saw it in theaters. I wasn't really thrilled by The Force Awakens, but Rogue One's originality and risk-taking helped me enjoy it!

Director Gareth Edwards does a great job of making you feelRogue One definitely surprised me when I first saw it in theaters. I wasn't really thrilled by The Force Awakens, but Rogue One's originality and risk-taking helped me enjoy it!

Director Gareth Edwards does a great job of making you feel like you're back in the Original Trilogy era. The cinematography and the slightly gritty landscape of planets like Jedha and Wobani also add to that feel. Despite the little development they had, I found most of the characters in Rogue One to be extremely compelling even though we only got to see them for a brief time. My favorites were the possibly Force-sensitive Chirrut Imwe and the ambitious Imperial director and main antagonist Orson Krennic, who is played brilliantly by Ben Mendelsohn. I should also add that all of the actors in this film are great.

Rogue One does seem a little slow on the first viewing but that's mainly because the first act is built on introducing characters. Once the action starts around 30 minutes into the film (just an estimate), it really picks up. The film ends with the best space battle and perhaps the best ground battle Star Wars has seen to date. The D-Day inspired beaches of Scarif were a great pick for the final act.

Unlike The Force Awakens, which relies on nostalgic references and dramatic cameos of Original Trilogy characters, Rogue One manages to be a good film all its own. It has a strong cast of characters, interesting locations, and expands and improves the first Star Wars film in way I didn't think possible.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

9

GamingPoptartTVDec 26, 2016

I would have to say when it comes to this movie. I got everything I ever wanted. I even got the ending I wanted. Sadly this movie does suffer from a few if not nit picks in my opinion. First off when it comes to Tarkin I feel his CGI was notI would have to say when it comes to this movie. I got everything I ever wanted. I even got the ending I wanted. Sadly this movie does suffer from a few if not nit picks in my opinion. First off when it comes to Tarkin I feel his CGI was not on par with Leias which was perfect. It would have been better if you where gonna have Tarkin in such a role to constantly have his back towards people. I felt that would have been better. The other things was some poor character development. I understand that there fates why develop the characters. Yet literally the only 2 characters from the Rogue One Squadron that I can remember was K2 and Donni Yen. Then the last thing that is the only plot hole in this movie to me at least is why are the Empire looking for Kaber Crystals. It has been cannonized that the Death Star runs off one giant kaber Crystal. So what are they scouring planets for more. Just a nit pick I know. Also there is some poor editing I know it was rushed but there are some scenes where it wasn't edited well.

Other then all that I would say this movie is a 9/10 and a must see and must own on blue ray.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

MrMovieBuffDec 17, 2016

The last time the "Star Wars" franchise decided it wanted to make prequels... we got outraged fans who lost faith in the iconic franchise. Luckily, Gareth Edwards directs 'Rogue One: A Star Wars Story', a title that might put-off some fans,The last time the "Star Wars" franchise decided it wanted to make prequels... we got outraged fans who lost faith in the iconic franchise. Luckily, Gareth Edwards directs 'Rogue One: A Star Wars Story', a title that might put-off some fans, but the movie itself is definitely worth a watch. We meet a young girl named Jyn (Felicity Jones) who had to escape after her father, Galen (Mads Mikkelsen) is informed by Director Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) forces Galen to work on the crafting of the Death Star. After some decade and a half, Jyn meets Rebel Officer Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) and she is informed about the Death Star.

She also meets a droid named K-2SO (a very funny Alan Tudyk) whose mannerisms and personality seem unusual, but helpful. They travel from planet to planet to find more clues on how to get the plans to destroy the Death Star, and they also find more characters to come and help. There is so much of this movie to talk about, but a "Star Wars" review can be easily spoiled, so I'm just going to summarize my thoughts on the movie. This is a really steady paced, dark and thrilling movie. The third act is one of the best third acts in any "Star Wars" movie, ever. The war battle that rages reminded me of the opening battle scene in 'Saving Private Ryan' (1998), obviously not that violent, but for this franchise's standards, it is. There are many familiar faces that return in this movie, most notably, Darth Vader (reprising the voice of James Earl Jones), who only makes two small appearances in this movie. But, they are so great, I cannot elaborate further without spoiling it, so I'll leave it there. This movie, which takes place before the events of 'Star Wars: A New Hope' (1977), really relies mostly on story as opposed to character. You get to know a lot about Jyn, a little bit about Cassian and K-2SO... but the rest are kind of glossed over as far as development goes. Director Gareth Edwards did a capable job of actually making this feel like a "War" movie, whereas the other movies were a space-opera spectacle. The first two acts are a little pacey here and there... but that third act is truly one of the best highlights for this entire franchise.… Expand

19 of 30 users found this helpful1911

All this user's reviews

9

bde9000Mar 7, 2017

Rogue One es un gran respiro de aire fresco a la franquicia, no tenia esperanzas después de ver el Copy-Paste que significo The Force Awakens, pero al ser este un spin-off se dieron mucho mas libertades creativas que ojala tomen en EpisodioRogue One es un gran respiro de aire fresco a la franquicia, no tenia esperanzas después de ver el Copy-Paste que significo The Force Awakens, pero al ser este un spin-off se dieron mucho mas libertades creativas que ojala tomen en Episodio VIII. Rogue One es la película con el tono mas oscuro y depresivo de la franquicia y la verdad es que le sienta muy bien, con una trama simple pero que funciona y con unos muy buenos personajes que por desgracia no tienen el suficiente tiempo en pantalla. Apesar de que la primera mitad de Rogue One se vuelve muy meeee,la batalla de Scarif es de lo mejor que alguna vez haya visto en la franquicia tal vez solo superada por Hoth. En general te puedo asegurar que si eres fan, esta película cumple en todos los aspectos y fácil puede estar entre tus 3 favoritas de la franquicia.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

FarhanFirozDec 16, 2016

Rogue one is a dark, gritty and the most realistic movie in the Franchise. A Fascinating Story with Stand-out performances and a Mind blowing 3rd act. Gareth Edwards direction with the Action scenes and VFX is ground-breaking. The only issueRogue one is a dark, gritty and the most realistic movie in the Franchise. A Fascinating Story with Stand-out performances and a Mind blowing 3rd act. Gareth Edwards direction with the Action scenes and VFX is ground-breaking. The only issue with the movie is the 2nd act wasn't structured well.… Expand

17 of 29 users found this helpful1712

All this user's reviews

9

gjdr9876Apr 16, 2017

Great movie with great tie ins to the other star wars films. Just an awesome action packed and good feel story. I suggest you give it a second or third watch for the great little things they included

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

Jess_HillDec 23, 2016

*Inhales deeply...*

Anticipation was very, very high with this new Star Wars offering, though I did attempt to temper my response to this much awaited film. This is an experience that is ultimately worthwhile, though the first two acts had*Inhales deeply...*

Anticipation was very, very high with this new Star Wars offering, though I did attempt to temper my response to this much awaited film. This is an experience that is ultimately worthwhile, though the first two acts had me worried at times. There is an intermittent lack of finesse, both with the CGI and the script, but the performances from Jones, Tudyk and Luna are exceptional. The cinematography is magnificent, delivering the sumptuous visuals we have come to expect from this universe, and the pacing is initially stilted but tightens considerably in the second and third acts. Taking place between the events of 'The Revenge of the Sith' and 'A New Hope', the storyline provides an engaging insight into the perils of war, with a focus on the darker realities of conflict than any other Star Wars film to date. It's in the final act that this film fulfills the heavy responsibility with which it was imbued, and in so doing provides long time fans with an unflinching journey to the heart of the rebellion. Leave the younger kids at home for this one. I am with the force, and the force is with me. 8.96/10… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

RvwFromUpHereDec 30, 2016

Who: Felicity Jones, a Spanish guy, and Charles Jefferson as, Saw Gerrera
What: Another reason for butt-hurt Warcraft fans to leave their basement, wash the cheetoh dust from their hands, and trash a movie that is actually pretty great
Where:Who: Felicity Jones, a Spanish guy, and Charles Jefferson as, Saw Gerrera
What: Another reason for butt-hurt Warcraft fans to leave their basement, wash the cheetoh dust from their hands, and trash a movie that is actually pretty great
Where: A Galaxy Far, Far, Away
When (Can I watch this movie again): If you like Star Wars, any time. If you don't...you're the worst type of person.
Why: While Episode 7 was very divisive among fans, this movie stays true to the intentions of the original trilogy and delivers what it promised.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

ElebrilDec 20, 2019

This is hands down the most valuable addition to the Star Wars series since Disney took over - a great addition. The film features probably the best space combat scenes out of all the movies and for that alone it is worth seeing, it staysThis is hands down the most valuable addition to the Star Wars series since Disney took over - a great addition. The film features probably the best space combat scenes out of all the movies and for that alone it is worth seeing, it stays true to the SW lore (if you can live through the fact that Kyle Katarn was the one who stole the Death Star plans according to the old lore). It is the only new film worth having on blue-ray, one that is far superior to The horrible Force Awakens, Last Jedi, or Rise of the Skywalker.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

leelustigDec 16, 2016

People loved The Force Awakens but have problems with this movie? The whole world is insane. Here is a list of things this movie did better than last year's installment. - Actual establishment of the Imperials being in control, and a need forPeople loved The Force Awakens but have problems with this movie? The whole world is insane. Here is a list of things this movie did better than last year's installment. - Actual establishment of the Imperials being in control, and a need for a rebellion/resistance.
- A tentacle monster that had an actual purpose.
- Actual stakes and a genuine concern that the heroes won't make it out alive.
- Intricate exposition not being reduced to ridiculously basic confabulation.
- Dialogue that wasn't cheesier than a cheese-plate.
- Cinematography that actually shows details of aliens. - Important robot/alien characters (that speak).
- Mads Mikkelsen. - Actually having something to do with the original trilogy. I could also reduce this list to two words: Darth Vader.… Expand

13 of 27 users found this helpful1314

All this user's reviews

9

DukeSilverJan 2, 2017

Just accept it. It's better than The Force Awakens. It maintained it's connection to the originals without beating us over the head with stupid one liners and constantly saying, "you'll love this because you loved the original movies!".

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

FLaaVEnAug 11, 2020

The best star wars movie that disney has produced. It ties in so well into "a new hope".

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

DCharlesDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A fun, exhilarating Disney space adventure. The film works on almost all levels, particularly the CGI created Peter Cushing, Princess Leia, a fantastic final battle and an unforgettable scene with Darth Vader.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

SKDDec 18, 2016

This is the Star Wars movie we wanted last year.

Instead of checking off a predetermined set of boxes tied to people’s nostalgia and following the contours of an older Star Wars movie, Rogue One focuses on an original, compelling story withThis is the Star Wars movie we wanted last year.

Instead of checking off a predetermined set of boxes tied to people’s nostalgia and following the contours of an older Star Wars movie, Rogue One focuses on an original, compelling story with the nostalgia interlaced. There were some moments where the drama feels forced (and there was enough of them that it prevented me from giving it a 10), but overall the motivations and desires of the characters are believable. Far from being omni-competent, the actions of the main characters cost them deeply by the end of the movie. I also liked how one of the characters, a droid called K-2SO, provides intelligent humor and comic relief without making a mockery out of himself (the way C-3PO does). And when the nostalgic moments came up with old characters, they feel more natural rather than tacked on.

A short note: It’s also worth pointing out that the underlying themes in movies can provide passing commentary on the times in which the creators live. The original Star Wars with its original Death Star provided a subtle commentary on weapons of mass destruction during the height of the Cold War and the nuclear weapons age. As I watched this movie and saw the scene where rebels ambushed storm troopers in the streets of a desert city, it made me immediately think of the Syrian Civil War. I don’t know if that was done on purpose, but it definitely feels like a powerful, passing commentary on the times in which we live.

Moving along, I am pleased that this film puts the ‘Wars’ back in Star Wars. You won’t see any Jedi doing back flips with lightsabers here. Instead, at the end of the movie, there is a very long and intense ground and space battle that defines what Star Wars is all about. It goes back to the Star Wars roots in a way that the Force Awakens tried to do, but fell short on.

I hope that the people making Episodes 8 and 9 take note. This may have been an anthology film, but it is hands down the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy and has set the new gold standard for what a Star Wars film should look like.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

yoshi8869May 23, 2017

Wow. Ok. This is one of the best Star Wars films I've ever seen. I've been a Star Wars fan since I was 8 years old. I've obsessed and obsessed over the franchise through my teenage years and into early adulthood. This movie, better than ForceWow. Ok. This is one of the best Star Wars films I've ever seen. I've been a Star Wars fan since I was 8 years old. I've obsessed and obsessed over the franchise through my teenage years and into early adulthood. This movie, better than Force Awakens, encapsulates everything I loved about the original trilogy. The story and characters are fresh. The space battle is the single best in the Star Wars saga. The new villain is one of the best. I've fallen in love with Star Wars yet again.

FULL SCORE:

Production: 26/30
--Acting: 7/10
--Direction: 9/10
--Crew/Effects: 10/10

Story: 21/30
--Plot: 8/10
--Characters: 7/10
--Theme: 7/10

Immersion: 29/30
--Soundtrack: 9/10
--Visuals: 10/10
--Style/Vibe: 10/10

Personal Enjoyment: 9.7/10

Analytical Score: 86.7% A

(S: 96-100
A: 85-94
B: 75-84
C: 65-74
D: 55-64
F: 0-54

10/10=Excellent
9/10=Great
8/10=Very Good
7/10=Good
6/10=Decent
5/10=Neither Good nor Bad
4/10=Weak
3/10=Bad
2/10=Very Bad
1/10=Appalling
0/10=The Worst)… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

BarefootedjediDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Before I start I have to say I absolutely loathed Force Awakens, a movie which had no respect for the Star Wars universe, and whose writers seemed to think repetition of past plots was a demonstration of love for it. I went to this one expecting to be disappointed, though I hoped the fact it involves no Jedi might actually be its saving grace. It was. There is no character here who, without even being a Padawan, defeats a Sith master both in Jedi mind control and in a light saber duel (the excluding of this possibility is why I suspected it would be harder to stuff up this one). Also, instead of stupidly rehashing the past this instalment nicely interlocks with it (note the distinction J.J., and you critics who uncritically gushed over FA). Consistent with the fictional history, there are no Jedi in sight (since they've all been assassinated or have gone to ground like Obi Wan and Yoda), and the only light-saber you’ll see is Darth Vader's when he goes on a slaughter fest at the end which nicely dovetails with the beginning of the original movie I saw as a child and was entranced by then. In many ways this is the adult Star Wars we grown up fans of the originals have been waiting for. I only wish the writers of this could have had the making of FA instead of the fool Jar Jar Abrams. Disney, please let them complete the trilogy Abrams stuffed up. They understand what real Star Wars fans want. Something gritty and grown up, which recognises the history and mythology of the SW universe but tells its own story within that context.

Felicity Jones is a great actress, and plays a role which is both capable and sensitive. Also, as an Aussie, I'm happy to see Ben Mendelsohn as the central villain; a great actor. For martial arts fans there's the brilliant Donnie Yen, who isn't a Jedi but should be, instead playing a blind, possibly slightly crazy, worshiper of the force, who may or may not be force sensitive but regardless manages to take out a lot of storm troopers and almost magically dodge some blaster fire (and has a friend with a hugely powerful blaster to keep him alive when the odds are too much against him). Chirrut Imwe (Donnie), yes, you are one with the force, you are one with the force (you’ll get my reference once you’ve seen the movie). There is a beautifully tragic ending for the central characters too. Heroes die, as they ought to in a good war movie or tragedy.

Expect to see some slightly dodgy CGI resurrections, but only when necessary and not to too bad effect. Of course the greatest of all Star Wars villains, Darth Vader, being in his life support suit, doesn’t need this kind of treatment and is voiced as always by the inimitable James Earl Jones.

I see that this received poorer reviews from the professional reviewers than did FA, to which I can only say these guys must be either corrupt or stupid (or maybe both). Ok, I have suspected that since all the gush over FA, but this round of stupidity confirms it. I have given this 9 instead of 10 because, though it is sensible, consistent, respectful of the past but not slavishly committed to it, and well written, what I would really have loved to see is this kind of loving care lavished on the new trilogy (movies with Jedi in them!) instead of just this (appropriately Jedi free) standalone. If you are a lover of the original trilogy I strongly recommend this one. If you were disgusted by FA I am totally with you (read my review to see how much I hated it), but this one is a different beast. Give it the chance you regretted giving FA. It may not be perfect, but I think it's the best since the original trilogy (and doesn't have the vomitous cutesiness of Ewoks to mar it).

Now, where would I start with a remade Episode VII? The remnants of the empire have degenerated into an insurgency against a shakily re-established republic. They are carrying out terrorist attacks across the galaxy. The Jedi academy has been re-established by Luke, and Leia has also had some Jedi training, but perhaps has chosen not to become a full-fledged Jedi because there is so much political work to do patching together a workable galactic democracy. Perhaps Leia, in fighting against terrorists has become a little dark herself (this couldn’t reasonably happen with Luke, since he has proved himself capable of resisting the combination of Darth Vader and the Emperor in ROTJ), setting up a sibling conflict of galactic proportions. After all, real politics is a dirty business. She hasn’t become Sith but her morality is uneasily balanced. Questionable alliances have been made (think of the mess in Syria at the moment). The line between good and evil is becoming blurred. Luke, as a monk like Jedi figure, has perhaps become morally flawed in a more subtle way, by virtue of a too mystical, navel gazing perspective on right and wrong. An adult premise. Start there screenwriters. Develop.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

9

BorgorosJan 11, 2020

Solid all the way! Gritty and dirty, with shady charaters that does all they can to redeem them selves for the greater good. Absolutely awesome final 30 minutes that explodes on the screen. I love it!

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

MD5774Dec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is easily the best movie of 2016. I don't know what movie critics saw , this movie was really good . The trash that was Force Awakens has been erased and has this has given moviegoers hope in Disney and the Star Wars franchise .JJ Adbrams should be ashamed and embarrassed the trash he put on screen last year.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

Armorwing01Dec 19, 2016

I liked the Force Awakens, it had likable characters like Finn, Kylo Ren, and a few others. It lacked originality and just could not grip me as well as some of the others. This movie kicked a**, so much a**, very likable characters, Vader,I liked the Force Awakens, it had likable characters like Finn, Kylo Ren, and a few others. It lacked originality and just could not grip me as well as some of the others. This movie kicked a**, so much a**, very likable characters, Vader, amazing fights, fun references, Vader, plot twists, Vader, and a logical and emotional conclusion. Cannot wait for more Star wars Spin offs.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

9

DefinitelyMaybDec 17, 2016

Rogue one is perhaps one of the greatest Star Wars film ever made -but not a great film in itself. I agree character and pacing is a bit off, but I think people forget that Star Wars never really had great character development to begin withRogue one is perhaps one of the greatest Star Wars film ever made -but not a great film in itself. I agree character and pacing is a bit off, but I think people forget that Star Wars never really had great character development to begin with but rather great actors giving a really good performance (ie Harrison Ford's lines a lot of his one-liners were ad lib). My personal gripe with this film is probably that a lot of the characters felt a bit tagged on - like the blind dude etc, and some of the choices they do (ie in the ending) feels forced and illogical -and could have been written better in terms of what happens to them. The ending is rather unambiguous and a certain CGI character appears too much and does something at the end for no reason (only to ensure there won't be a sequel). Also Gareth Edwards could've shot some of the action scenes better and give some character's a proper arc which was lacking. Lack of a crawl and insistence of using location cards were a bit off-putting.

However Rogue One has the best world building, plot development, costume design, lighting and story flow out of the other Star Wars films. The film doesnt rely on wipes to get to one place to another which is great. Rogue one also have amazing action sequences and impeccable sound design. All the locations feel like real worlds compared to Force Awaken (which felt like small set designs). Although the score lacked more distinguishable motifs, I thought it flowed really well with the action o the films - and more of the traditional motifs were integrated well. Overall I thought Rogue One was a better Star Wars film than TFA and maybe even ROTJ, only because the world building and action was impeccable.… Expand

19 of 33 users found this helpful1914

All this user's reviews

9

SBNDec 18, 2016

The Force Awakens was not the sequel expected by the "original trilogy generation", but it is still a great movie and I love it. Actually, now we are learning that every new trilogy is built for a new generation. My seven years old son lovesThe Force Awakens was not the sequel expected by the "original trilogy generation", but it is still a great movie and I love it. Actually, now we are learning that every new trilogy is built for a new generation. My seven years old son loves TFA much more than any other SW movie. Like prequels were the best ones for the kids that grew up with them. Some are better, some worse, so subjective in some cases, all them are Star Wars, I just enjoy it.
Rogue One is really a new paradigm. It's a branch in a new direction, in a wider angle.
I enjoyed Rogue One in a new level, different. It's so fresh as classic, so funny as heartbreaking, so old as new. It's awesome. Tasty. I love every character from this movie. It's a story about the real war of the stars, the war of the people who dies for the cause. It was necessary to explain Star Wars from this point of view.
To me, Rogue one is 9/10 as a movie.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

mrushing02Dec 16, 2016

“It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire.

During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire’s ultimate weapon, the“It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire.

During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire’s ultimate weapon, the DEATH STAR, an armored space station with enough power to destroy an entire planet.”

These words are the first thing that anyone ever saw of Star Wars as the film opened in 1977 and now Gareth Edwards has imbued them fully in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story.

Hope Anew

The Rebellion’s struggle just got worse, as it learns that the Empire has created a world-killing weapon named the Death Star. The Rebellion finds itself on the knife’s edge between hope and despair. The council of the Rebellion cannot decide what to do. Do they risk it all by trying to steal the plans, or do they resign themselves to defeat and despair? Jyn challenges the council, “What chance do we have? The question is what choice”. She implores the council to remember that if they do nothing then they’ve sealed the fate of the galaxy and that evil this great cannot go unopposed. It brings to mind Edmund Burke’s famous saying, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” She encourages them with a refrain Cassian Andor said to her earlier in the movie, “Rebellions are built on hope”. Hope changes everything, it reminds people that the way it is, is not how it has to be. Hope is the spark that, if kindled, creates the fire of change. Change is possible, but it takes sacrifice, determination and some times, lives to see it come about.

The beauty of the film is that hope is not just a figment of the heroes imaginations. The Force seems quite active, even without the Jedi. It’s moving in mysterious ways and bringing people together that can make a difference. This band of rogues does the impossible, one chance at a time, succeeding in their goal and setting in motion something that will see the end of the Empire.

The Movie

Gareth Edwards made a Star Wars movie that feels completely different and yet utterly familiar, all at the same time. Like The Clone Wars, Edwards uses cinematic inspirations to pull in the war movie genre and make it a Star Wars movie, emphasis on the war. The nods to great war films of the past are all there and they work perfectly. On top of that you feel the “Star Wars” seeping out of every single frame. The Ghost from Star Wars Rebels can be seen at least 4 times, Cham Sydulla is called for over the coms at Yavin 4, the sets feel like they came out of a lost arc of The Clone Wars, Saw Gerrera has an important role and so much more. The point here is that Edwards lovingly knits together the history of the Prequel and the Original trilogy and it’s seamless.

Star Wars, when it’s at it’s best, is stretching what it means to be Star Wars by taking other genres and telling a story in the Star Wars universe that aligns with the themes of the saga. Edwards achievement is nothing short of incredible, the movie feels like the Maker’s fingerprints are all over it and it’s the highest compliment that could be paid to the movie.

The characters are outstanding. K-2so is the best new droid since R2 and Jyn, Cassian, Chirrut, Baze and Bhodi are all welcome additions to the Star Wars canon. Darth Vader’s scenes are chilling (and let’s stop here and just geek out completely that Vader’s castle is finally on screen!) and perfectly played, just enough to leave you wanting more.

The music by Giacchino feels like a welcome addition to the Star Wars franchise, it’s much like The Clone Wars music and only references familiar themes in snippets yet that’s a good thing. The movie needed it’s own identity and the themes he created feel familiar and distinct, perfectly matching the spirit of the movie.

I’ll get personal, this movie is everything I wanted a new Star Wars movie to be. Pushing the boundaries of what it means to be Star Wars while at the same time respecting the history and the franchise as a whole. Here’s to hoping the rumors of Edwards wanting to direct a Kenobi movie are true. Rogue One is rated 4.5 upside down Death Stars out of 5.… Expand

7 of 19 users found this helpful712

All this user's reviews

9

ViharTancosJan 2, 2018

They can do this good quality with colorful characters and interesting story. Please keep this team to do the other films and fired a rest of them.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

KayVen17Jan 11, 2017

Deutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt dasDeutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt das einen User Score von 8. Bei 86 einen von Userscore von 9. Falls eine 85 kommt entscheide ich ob ich es eher positiv oder negativ nehme. Regeln verstanden?
Dann sind hier meine Punkte.

Mein persönlicher Score = 90/100
Mein User Score = 9/10… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

9

SpottedLaughterDec 24, 2016

Absolutely in the top five Star Wars Movies ever made and a joy to watch from beginning to end.

While yes, there are issues with the movie, some of the CGI can be a bit in the uncanny valley the first time you see it and some of theAbsolutely in the top five Star Wars Movies ever made and a joy to watch from beginning to end.

While yes, there are issues with the movie, some of the CGI can be a bit in the uncanny valley the first time you see it and some of the characters are under developed, I don't feel they impact the movie too seriously. The movie ties perfectly into the start of 'A New Hope' and helps to fill in plenty of holes that were in the original movie, such as why Luke becomes 'Red 5', why the Death Star has such an odd weakness and how Vader can be so certain that Leia isn't on a diplomatic mission as she claims.

Also, the fact that the Rebellion isn't depicted right out as the good guys in the film, is a massive relief! In all of the original trilogy, the Rebels are shown as the moral right, good guys against an evil empire. But not in Rogue One. Here we see a Rebellion that is on the verge of breaking, taking desperate measures to keep themselves hidden and accomplish their goals in the face of overwhelming odds, where many of their missions are win or die trying.

For any Star Wars fans, this is highly recommended that you see it!… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

blahblahblah69Dec 17, 2016

After seeing Kevin Smith's reaction to the movie I immediately went and saw it opening day. What a rewarding experience it turned out to be. While watching the movie I felt somewhat skeptical as to the direction everything was going, but theAfter seeing Kevin Smith's reaction to the movie I immediately went and saw it opening day. What a rewarding experience it turned out to be. While watching the movie I felt somewhat skeptical as to the direction everything was going, but the third act is a breath taking edge of your seat roller coaster ride that delivers on so many levels and ended on such a high note. Totally recommend. Righteous prequel to A New Hope. Do yourself a favor, see this movie in theaters and share the experience with as many people as you know. This movie will be more and more revered for its place in star wars cinematographic entries as time goes on.… Expand

17 of 29 users found this helpful1712

All this user's reviews

9

UdrakanDec 17, 2016

SPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darkerSPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darker events. Yes, this isn't some happy story, this is a WAR story in Star WARS and it's absolutely amazing. It has all what I wanted from Star Wars: Space Battles, The Force, cool lovable robots, lasers and explosions, deep characters. The Rebelion is shown from a different perspective - they are good guys, but sometimes they do shady and sad stuff to keep them selves alive. This enriches SW universe, where rebels are mostly shown as only good people. The models and CGI are absolutely amazing. I had shivers going down my spine when I realized just how big Star Destroyer is and then they show Death Star behind it. I was in awe. Skirmishes are clever and Storm troopers are more dangerous and actualy hit people, especialy the elite back ones. Music on-par with movie quality. Darth Vader is scary again! The scene with him is so epic and intimidating! I don't give this 10/10 for 2 reasons: 1)Weak start - first 15 minutes of film are not as good as the rest, It starts slowly with a remote family story, whcih I would rate 6/10. 2) A little bit of cliche stuff. Although amazingly well done, its another Death Star plot, and I had enough of Death star plot in SW. Even Force Awakens was enough. People in market agressively bumping character's shoulder and then shouting at them-I saw this in so many films, it's a small one, but I noticed it, among other nit-picks. Overall it's an amazing Star Wars film and even amazing film on it's own. I totaly recommend it. My final verdict is 9/10 - It's a must see.… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

9

FingoldfinDec 21, 2016

Fantástica, lo único que flojea para mi es la banda sonora pues en algunos momentos no cuadra con lo que esta ocurriendo, por el resto es simplemente maravillosa.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

COOLQUINN17Mar 3, 2017

Have you ever wonder how the rebels stole the Death Star plans? It did say that they did stole it in the opening credits of A New Hope but nobody ever knew how they did it. Well, almost 40 years later, we FINALLY know how they stole the DeathHave you ever wonder how the rebels stole the Death Star plans? It did say that they did stole it in the opening credits of A New Hope but nobody ever knew how they did it. Well, almost 40 years later, we FINALLY know how they stole the Death Star plans. This is another Star Wars Prequel that you will ACTUALLY enjoy. The action was very incredible, the Darth Vader hallway scene and the final battle were the best action scenes. The characters are likable, even though not memorable. The CGI was awesome and they knew when to put it in there and not to put it in there. Speaking of CGI, they did pretty good with the CG Tarkin and the actor that did the motion capture and the voice for him did a good job impersonating Peter Cushing, who played Tarkin in A New Hope. Peter Cushing passed away in 1994 but Tarkin was a major player in the creation of the Death star and they knew they needed Tarkin. They also did a great job with the CG Leia, it really looked like she was there. They didn’t need to hire a person to do the voice because they used archive recordings from A New Hope for her voice. There is a sad moment in the movie but i won’t spoil it or anything. It’s obvious that this isn’t the best Star Wars movie and they can never beat the first two Star Wars movies but it’s still a great Star Wars movie. Go ahead and watch it, you’ll have an epic time.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

MasterRileyDec 17, 2016

Rogue One is the epic story that follows a small group of rebels that steal the plans to the death star. I really liked the cinematography, special effects, action, and overall scope of this film. It is one of if not the most beautifulRogue One is the epic story that follows a small group of rebels that steal the plans to the death star. I really liked the cinematography, special effects, action, and overall scope of this film. It is one of if not the most beautiful looking Star Wars movies. Most of the new characters are really good as well and the performances provided by the various actors. The characters that stood out the most for me are Krennic, K2SO, and Chirrut. I wasn't a huge fan of Saw Gerrera and felt like some of the other characters weren't as memorable as I hoped they'd be. But after thinking about it I think thats the point of the story. This group of rebels ended up risking their lives for the greater good of the galaxy, and sometimes not being remembered after the fact is what happens in war. I only have one other main gripe with the film, and it has to do with a CGI character. I liked the writing and performance of the character I am just unsure that it feels organic enough to fit into the story. Overall these few nitpicks aren't really enough for me to feel the film is flawed because it is amazing in every other front. Especially the final act, oh man was it ever worth it. This is the prequel you are looking for.… Expand

29 of 54 users found this helpful2925

All this user's reviews

9

vertiqsDec 17, 2016

After the pretty enjoyable, but still just a copy*multiply+add_old_heroes formula of 'Force Awakens' - looks like we got back on track with this Star Wars Story, though a bit darker, then one may expect.

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

RathaelDec 17, 2016

ROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force! Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore byROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force!

Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore by doing so, and introducing us to many new and reminding us of a quite a few old characters, in different scopes of screen time, some important to the plot, others more of fan service, letting us know they do exist in this ever expanding universe.

Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso, Alan Tyduk as K2S0 and Forest Whitaker as Saw Gerrera steal the show. Yes that is that Saw Gerrera to who ever watched Clone Wars animated series. Felicity Jones carries the entire movie with her conviction and fearlessness. K-2SO provides the most of the part of the comic relief but not in a way that anyone has seen before, think of him as of more cynical version of C-3PO, that way I do not go into much details or spoil much of his character. Forest Whitaker is fantastic as war grizzled Saw Gerrera that shows us just exactly how much war can change anyone, regardless of what side you are on.

Another big surprise in this movie was just how much screen-time was dedicated to the Empire and its characters with Ben Mendelsohn as Commander Krennic, puts a real face to the Empire, and how the people behind it, were as divided and human as any of the other rebel characters. That is probably partially true, as he's one of the only real Imperial characters really developed on screen other than Vader/Palpatine before, and it was very interesting to see that side of the war as well. This is where the movie really shines as well, as it shows that even Imperial officers like him, have their own agendas and dreams.

Rest of the cast is very very capable as well with Mads Mikellsen leading the cast as the imperial science officer, and Donnie Yen (Yeah!) as a blind staff wielding warrior, and its Donnie Yen in Star Wars movie, that's all that really needs to be said about that! Rest of the cast is also very capable and the charisma and the connection between these characters is very well established.

Gareth Edwards manages to make an adult version of Star Wars not saying the others were not adult oriented movies, but this one is not really relying on humor but establishing the true struggle that rebellion had to do against the Empire. And Edwards manages to do so, without making the movie dreary all the way, managing levity just enough to keep the story fun and exciting.

Another big departure here is that this is the first Star Wars movie not composed by John Williams but Michael Giacchino whose music fits to the feel of this movie, even though there are some famous Star Wars beats in the movie, most of this soundtrack feels very original, and he has put his stamp on the Star Wars universe, which is an amazing accomplishment.

Everything about this movie feels authentic, and its really the small things from the aesthetic feel of the movie and how certain shots were framed and how certain sequences were established is done very well, almost as a painting at some points, and there was that scene that was scene with a Star Destroyer, that I believe was shown in trailers, that scene gives you goosebumps.

Overall this movie does what a very very few movies can succeed at and that is take established universe, remove most of the main characters from that universe and make a compelling movie, make the universe feel more lived in. Manage to expand on the known universe in such a way that is meaningful, introduce us to some of the new characters that we can cheer for: Either Rebel or Imperial, and as I could believe this is first time that both Rebel Alliance hierarchy is kind of explained, and that adds to their plight. And this last statement I am going to probably catch a lot of crap for, but I believe it to be true. This movie managed to do an impossible, make an original trilogy even better movies.

4 out of 4 stars.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

9

RavarathSep 6, 2017

As a BIG fan of OLD Star Wars universe I have to say this movie is FAR superior than Force Awakens. The story is great (I might have lowered standards after Force Awakens) with some plot holes, but hey it's unavoidable. Character developmentAs a BIG fan of OLD Star Wars universe I have to say this movie is FAR superior than Force Awakens. The story is great (I might have lowered standards after Force Awakens) with some plot holes, but hey it's unavoidable. Character development is fine (as for stand off movie not trilogy) but the biggest pro is the ambiance. We can feel the gravity of events that we are about to witness (in comparison Force Awakens - meh whatever) and they will define the whole galaxy! This is THE good old Star Wars universe as we used to know dark but yet heroic and not some colorful, happy and cringy fairy tale.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

tbeit2May 25, 2017

I found Rogue one to be one of the best Star Wars movies yet, certainly the best since the original trilogy. What makes the film shine is the characters and story. Much like the video game Halo Reach from 2010, this is a movie that aims toI found Rogue one to be one of the best Star Wars movies yet, certainly the best since the original trilogy. What makes the film shine is the characters and story. Much like the video game Halo Reach from 2010, this is a movie that aims to make us sad with an expected plot and it works. The characters are likable, and the main character is one of my favorites in the universe now. The plot manages to also take turns despite its obvious end point.

The action is amazing as well. All of the scenes are well directed and explosive, with everything popping and being a joy to watch. The music was great as always.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

TheChosenOne7Jan 3, 2017

Pretty good movie. Would be a 10 but there are a few major plot holes and some of the writing is left wanting, but overall a fantastic movie. Far better than the SJW propaganda filled Force Awakens. Let's hope the next movie follows thisPretty good movie. Would be a 10 but there are a few major plot holes and some of the writing is left wanting, but overall a fantastic movie. Far better than the SJW propaganda filled Force Awakens. Let's hope the next movie follows this example and sticks to being entertaining and true to the franchise instead of pushing a backwards agenda.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

daviddelnorte23Apr 13, 2017

Tenía muchisimas ganas de ver esta película. De volver al universo 'Star Wars' después del episodio VII el cual me parecío un poco regular, pero tremendamente entretenida. 'Rogue One' me pasa lo contrario me encanta la historia y me pareceTenía muchisimas ganas de ver esta película. De volver al universo 'Star Wars' después del episodio VII el cual me parecío un poco regular, pero tremendamente entretenida. 'Rogue One' me pasa lo contrario me encanta la historia y me parece que encaja mejor dentro de la mítica saga de las galaxias y la otorga más sentido aún a esta. Con guiños durante varias fases de la película que me pusieron la piel de gallina a mí que no soy un fiel seguidor de la saga.

En cuanto a los personajes, en esta si que me gustan todos empezando por el personaje de F. Jones, Diego Luna o el asiático. En contrapunto con el Ep. VII donde casi nadie me gustaba. Creo que estos personajes aparte de estar mejor escritos son mucho más interesantes y, por supuesto, más carismáticos.

La película a nivel visual es fantástica, esta muy bien escrita desarrollando muy bien a los personajes y cociendo toda la trama a fuego lento desde el minuto 1 de metraje y a pesar de ser la menos 'Star Wars' de todas, es tremendamente fiel a la misma.

En resumen, me encantó 'Rogue One' y, además, me parece un peliculón. Lo único malo, por poner un pero, es que no incluyesen los famosos créditos iniciales. Es un 'pero' menor. La doy 9 (dentro de lo que es, una película de 'Star Wars'...).… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

9

laxdrew2Dec 29, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This film got almost everything right. The plot, special effects, and dialogue are all exceptional. The one and only complaint that I had when watching this movie was that there were too many operations going on at once, and too many characters were introduced to be killed off within two hours. All in all, this is a great film, the one Star Wars fans have been waiting for.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

CicoNutDec 22, 2016

We are now living in an era where we can look forward to a new ‘Star Wars’ movie each year. And luckily for us, the two Disney have released so far are amazing. While ‘The Force Awakens’ was light-hearted like the original, ‘Rogue One’ takesWe are now living in an era where we can look forward to a new ‘Star Wars’ movie each year. And luckily for us, the two Disney have released so far are amazing. While ‘The Force Awakens’ was light-hearted like the original, ‘Rogue One’ takes a darker turn, with a morally ambiguous lead cast and a more realistic war-like feel.

The movie follows the story of Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones), the daughter of an Imperial Scientist, who is unwillingly recruited by the Rebel Alliance to find her father and stop the Empire from unleashing their new planet-killer onto the galaxy. However, as her journey continues, she discovers the Rebel Alliance isn’t always quite as heroic as we would like to believe.

One of the things that makes Rogue One great is that it isn’t black and white. While the Empire is still clearly evil, the Rebel Alliance is also shown to not always make the right choices, and one quote that sums this up pretty well is when Jyn tells Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) “You might as well be a Storm Trooper.”

One thing that surprised me about this movie was just how great some of the performances were. Two actors I think people will be talking about are Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso and Alan Tudyk as K-2SO (the film’s main source of comic relief). While Tudyk provides plenty of laughs, Jones portrays her character’s strengths and flaws perfectly.

All right all done here bye-bye!

…

Oh wait. I forgot about the best part of the movie – Darth Vader. Not since ‘The Empire Strikes Back’ have we seen Vader this merciless and evil. His screen time is limited, but extremely powerful and satisfying (particularly the absolutely badass ending).

Rogue One is absolutely one of the best ‘Star Wars’ movies yet, with a dark story and a great cast of characters. The force is strong with this one!… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

noaccentallowedDec 20, 2016

Rogue One is a film with plenty of imperfections, but is still an outstanding Star Wars experience when taken as a whole. In this way, it is the most natural addition to the franchise since Return of the Jedi. Uneven pacing and plot holesRogue One is a film with plenty of imperfections, but is still an outstanding Star Wars experience when taken as a whole. In this way, it is the most natural addition to the franchise since Return of the Jedi. Uneven pacing and plot holes haunt the legacy of every Star Wars film (even The Empire Strikes Back), yet these stories endure because of unparalleled visual imagination and an unbreakably strong human element. Director Gareth Edwards and writers Gary Whitta and John Knoll all understood this. Combined with intense passion as both artists and Star Wars fans, they sought to create an offbeat tale within the mythos that proved that not every ounce of brand value comes from epic heroes combating the forces of evil with laser swords. In that respect and many others, the production team crushed expectations.

For the uninitiated (if there are any left), Rogue One is an ensemble war film, centered on acquiring the Death Star plans. It isn’t intended to be optimistic and colorful like a typical Star Wars movie. The atmosphere is grim, depicting a galaxy drained of hope by an oppressive fascist dictator. Here the rebels have to walk on eggshells, working from the shadows to make calculated strikes at the Empire. As a result, the scale is somewhat smaller in this adventure and significantly more personal. Dialog is sharp, carefully representing a small team at odds with themselves. However, there is a surprising amount of levity in the script to offset the otherwise bleak narrative. In particular, Alan Tudyk’s portrayal of the sarcastic droid K-2SO steals the show. Though Ben Mendelsohn as the self-absorbed Director Krennic and Diego Luna as the morally conflicted Cassian Andor also turn in memorable performances. Yet acting of any quality is no substitute for a compelling plot, which is where Rogue One occasionally loses steam. The first act of the story jumps around liberally, putting crucial details in jeopardy of being lost to all but the most attentive viewers. In the second act, the story grinds to a halt so the female lead can fulfill her arc. It is also where one or two subplots are entirely dropped, leading to unnecessary confusion about the state of a crucial character. In the final act, the story picks up again and ties up every loose end with extraordinary diligence. Rogue One has arguably the most comprehensive and satisfying finale to any Star Wars narrative, including the entire gamut of expanded canon. It is also worth noting that even if the pacing is uneven, virtually nothing is out of context. Contrary to the insultingly shallow exposition of The Force Awakens, everything in Rogue One has a substantial visual or verbal explanation. It helps reinforce the plight of the team and flesh out the world they inhabit. Also, the attention to detail ensures Rogue One will be a pleasure to watch for years to come.

To that end, there is an item in Rogue One that will serve as a discussion piece both immediately and well into the future. In the film, a certain character from the original trilogy is recreated with the use of CGI. This is not merely a cameo, he is a fully functional cast member. His likeness, mannerisms and voice were entirely reproduced to fill a role. While it has handled with the utmost taste, the actor in question has been dead for over two decades. This sets a dangerous precedent not just for Star Wars, but for the future of filmmaking. Hollywood is desperate enough to remake any film from yesteryear, though now they can also remake people. While currently a gimmick with frightening potential, these techniques could one day become a crutch to the creatively bankrupt. Hopefully Lucasfilm and Disney discourage widespread adoption of this approach.
Beyond that ethical quandary and a few missteps, Rogue One needs little improvement. A director’s cut of the film with touched up editing would address the vast majority of complaints. The first act could slow its breakneck pace and add a bit more articulation to each action sequence. Cut content could be added back into the film to minimize the confusion caused by the dead ends in subplots. Perhaps a few more establishing shots on the tropical planet of Scariff would better emphasize how visually diverse and interesting it is from other locales in the Star Wars universe. Certainly the score could be more melodic, even if Michael Giacchino did do a phenomenal job emulating John Williams. Overall, the next freelancer artists to tackle a Star Wars film need to take risks. If Rogue One is the barometer for future installments however, there is little reason to be concerned.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

Randall0Dec 16, 2016

So we all new going into this movie what the end result was. What we didn't know was how this story progressed into episode 4. I can honestly say this movie was amazing, the effects, the nods to the original trilogy and the effort they madeSo we all new going into this movie what the end result was. What we didn't know was how this story progressed into episode 4. I can honestly say this movie was amazing, the effects, the nods to the original trilogy and the effort they made to make the look and feel of this film fit seamlessly with the original Star Wars film. It is a movie that stays with you long after you walk out the door. I am astounded that the critics have not recognised this film with much higher ratings overall. It most certainly deserves it. Deserving of a "classic" rating and one for the collection. 9/10. Hard to find fault.… Expand

11 of 24 users found this helpful1113

All this user's reviews

9

KenwayDec 16, 2016

"Rogue-one". The movie which differs from all previous. The movie in which everything became serious. I already many times said to friends that I am not a fan of Star Wars. I had liked the seventh episode, but against the background of the"Rogue-one". The movie which differs from all previous. The movie in which everything became serious. I already many times said to friends that I am not a fan of Star Wars. I had liked the seventh episode, but against the background of the Rogue it is some other... Children's most likely. In the Rogue there is almost everything: atmosphere (she here absolutely another), drama, light humour, very interesting characters and of course ACTION! As for a story, he simple and clear. The soundtrack is weak, but there is no wonder as one composer has left, and another has succeeded only in September. A visual part of the movie very beautiful, and a sound in an IMAX format just tremendous. Also in the movie the fan service is a lot of, fans will estimate. Offensively for me only one that the movie doesn't allow to reveal to characters, even to the main character. As for her, she is a fighting little girl who never gives up. Felicity Jones has played perfectly. And here the character Mad Mikkelsen is a father of the main character, but he catastrophically isn't enough. I don't know the others and there are nothing to tell about them, but their characters interesting. Well and the most abrupt moment of fans expects in the picture final. Result: I very strongly had liked this picture. She differs from all that is in this Universe and it does well her. Someone from fans will abuse her for gravity, someone will shout that there are no Jedis and the picture a priori becomes a hogwash, someone will shout about all our favourite canon, someone will hate for something else, and someone will just enjoy the events in this picture. And I grant a camp the fan of this picture. It is clear that Disney put the franchise on the conveyor, but the main thing that there was a quality. And in the Rogue it is.… Expand

11 of 24 users found this helpful1113

All this user's reviews

9

Dirk2112Dec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Genuinely perplexed by the negative reviews because this is a well-cast, expertly designed, well performed film that also happens to have been stylishly directed and cleverly written. It’s actually so well directed and performed that on the few occasions its script hits a bump, the momentum of its performances plus direction rolls right over them. No, it doesn't drip with easy charm and charism of Force Awakens but then again, it shouldn't. [Mild Spoiler!] You couldn’t watch this story unfold onto Ridley and Boyega. It's the Guns of Navarone of Star Wars films in the best possible ways.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

9

NiikopolDec 17, 2016

The movie has bit too quick of a start. You are jumping from one planet to another in span of few minutes and can get lost there. However, with second act of the movie this is gone and third one is probably best epic space fight we saw inThe movie has bit too quick of a start. You are jumping from one planet to another in span of few minutes and can get lost there. However, with second act of the movie this is gone and third one is probably best epic space fight we saw in Star Wars universe ever. The movie does a lot of fanservice, obvious to any SW fan, but which non-fans and first timers would probably didnt even notice (Hammerhead class ship from KoToR), however is funny, quick paced, the plot gets it together in second act and ties up really great at the end, the acting was very well done (especially Donnie Yen). Great movie, go watch, 6.5/10 average by "professional" critics is absurd.… Expand

17 of 28 users found this helpful1711

All this user's reviews

9

sevenoftwoDec 17, 2016

Story/Characters

I thought that this film is very strong in it's story and characters. Nothing is held back in this film. The Rebels and Imperials are both fighting hard and dying while attempting to reach theirs goals. The tone of thisStory/Characters

I thought that this film is very strong in it's story and characters. Nothing is held back in this film. The Rebels and Imperials are both fighting hard and dying while attempting to reach theirs goals. The tone of this film is serious and thoughtful. Each protagonist, while not given a great deal of screen time, has a distinct personality and worldview that is displayed through their conversations and behavior. Visuals/Music

The visual effects and music are, in my opinion, top notch. While the visual style is different than previous Star Wars films, this is an intentional choice and it works for this film. Action sequences are easy to follow (no excessive shaky cam or wild, rapid panning) and the cinematography and framing are excellent. The sense of scale is impressive and CGI effect shots are mostly very well done. If you're able to view this movie while keeping in mind that it is new and different in some ways, I think you'll enjoy it. The music is not by John Williams, but it is clearly inspired by his work and it feels entirely appropriate for a Star Wars film. In other words, this is the best that Star Wars music can be without simply reusing existing John Williams' existing material (which would have enjoyable but truly lacking in creativity).

Overall

This may be my favorite Star Wars film and I say that as a fan of the series. It is an adult-oriented film and could be called "bittersweet". I found it powerful and emotionally moving while also still being fun and exciting. If you find joy in watching epic space combat scenes as I do, this is a Star Wars film you'll particularly enjoy.… Expand

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

9

mlebeau12Dec 17, 2016

This movie takes a long time to settle in, but a lot of that is due to the fact that so many new characters and worlds must be introduced. Once the movie settles in, it is non stop action. The third act rivals and 30 minute stretch in theThis movie takes a long time to settle in, but a lot of that is due to the fact that so many new characters and worlds must be introduced. Once the movie settles in, it is non stop action. The third act rivals and 30 minute stretch in the Star Wars saga. This movie is darker than other Star Wars films and also provides a much murkier divide between good and evil.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

9

imnamineDec 19, 2016

No, there's no lightsaber fight in this movie. But is the movie any good ? Yes, it is. It's what I call a perfect spin-off. Photography is astonishing, characters are good enough, battles and landscapes on point.
You can really feel EdwardsNo, there's no lightsaber fight in this movie. But is the movie any good ? Yes, it is. It's what I call a perfect spin-off. Photography is astonishing, characters are good enough, battles and landscapes on point.
You can really feel Edwards put his on style in the movie.
So no, this isn't a masterpiece, but it's indeed a great movie and that's what I expected from it.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

sindhurajatDec 19, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is that movie which takes even a casual viewer, who has at least viewed the cinematic flicks, deep down into the Star Wars history/mythology. Seeing Grand Moff Tarkin and Princess Leia brought back to the screen, as we first saw them in A New Hope, is such a feast for the eyes.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

thibDec 19, 2016

The best stars wars since 1983, I was realy scared after the force awakens, because lets be honnest it was more like a remake of the first movie from the 70's, But this one has a original scenario and have a great story, the fact that thereThe best stars wars since 1983, I was realy scared after the force awakens, because lets be honnest it was more like a remake of the first movie from the 70's, But this one has a original scenario and have a great story, the fact that there is no happy ending at the end make it better the movie is all about sacrifice.
it's realy make the perfect conection with the "new hope" plot great movie great star wars thanks god after the force awakens… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

BozmoDec 20, 2016

Is movie fits perfectly into the Star Wars film line. Being a prequel to A New Hope, it had a lot to live up too, the film did not disappoint. The action and CGI were amazing. The only problem I had with the movie is that some of theIs movie fits perfectly into the Star Wars film line. Being a prequel to A New Hope, it had a lot to live up too, the film did not disappoint. The action and CGI were amazing. The only problem I had with the movie is that some of the characters were not as memorable as The Force Awakens. But all the other pros make any cons seem like nothing.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

CraigMitchDec 20, 2016

One of the best star wars movies out there. Definitely has by far the best star wars battle of all the movies. Much better than the force awakens. Will buy on blu ray or any special edition version.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

varmadmcgooDec 23, 2016

I had low expectations after the cash-grab disappointment that was The Force Awakens, but Rogue One was a very pleasant surprise.

Jyn Erso was wonderful, a true hero. Rogue One proves you don’t need much lightsaber action at all to make aI had low expectations after the cash-grab disappointment that was The Force Awakens, but Rogue One was a very pleasant surprise.

Jyn Erso was wonderful, a true hero.

Rogue One proves you don’t need much lightsaber action at all to make a standout Star Wars movie.

The most impressive thing about this film was how real it made the war feel. We saw sacrifices being made over and over for the sake of the Rebellion. This is why people are calling this a “dark” movie. It’s too optimistic, the rebels too successful, for the movie to be called dark; it’s weighty. The successes are earned at incredible cost. Such is war.

One notable disappointment here was the musical score. It felt largely repurposed from John Williams’ previous work — and sometimes, that was enough, but it felt like a timid mimicry of greatness. Were there any new musical themes introduced? I don’t recall any. It’s fine, even necessary, to use the Imperial March when Vader shows up, but there needs to be more, too.

We met so many delightful characters — all human except for K-2, whose brand of humor was most welcome, and which stands in stark contrast to the dumb dad-jokes C-3PO made in the latter prequels. No, this was smarter humor, which felt (again) more “earned.”

Here’s hoping future Star Wars films will be more Rogue One and less The Force Awakens!… Expand

13 of 20 users found this helpful137

All this user's reviews

9

BostonterrierDec 28, 2016

Tied with my 2nd favorite star wars film (a new hope). Empire strikes back is still my fav. Anyway, this movie is nearly flawless, but most its cast is forgettable/serviceable. The only two stand-out performances were a robot and Chirrut ImweTied with my 2nd favorite star wars film (a new hope). Empire strikes back is still my fav. Anyway, this movie is nearly flawless, but most its cast is forgettable/serviceable. The only two stand-out performances were a robot and Chirrut Imwe (as portrayed by the fantastic Donnie Yen). Definitely a great movie.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

BranagunDec 25, 2016

This was an exhilarating and emotional roller coaster - not 'fun' as such, and some of the characterisation is sketchy. However it has a surprisingly authentic war film vibe and is seemingly uncompromising by concerns of 'Disneyfication' -This was an exhilarating and emotional roller coaster - not 'fun' as such, and some of the characterisation is sketchy. However it has a surprisingly authentic war film vibe and is seemingly uncompromising by concerns of 'Disneyfication' - some of this is bold and brutal, especially the third act. This gives me hope for future standalone instalments.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

MyDistUniverseDec 26, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Star Wars: Rogue One Google Image
Rogue One is everything you would expect from the 8th instalment of the Star Wars saga.
We have incredible CGI and special effects that make this epic film larger than life. Fast paced space and ground battles with all the necessary trimmings and space troopers galore. Not to mention the funny android with an attitude problem and more personality than most humans. It is all there.
The music score is very much in line with the series, yet still unique in its own way. This only adds to the overall feeling and knowledge that this is a self contained movie.
The opening of Rogue One departs from the big score and introduction scrolling across the screen. I found this part a tiny bit disappointing - it is kind of a Star Wars thing after all. Even I know that, and admittedly I don't know much.

The Story
Set between Episode III and IV Rogue One tells the story of a band of rebels who are trying to get the plans for the Death Star. They are lead by Jyn Erso, who is the daughter of Galen Erso, the man who reluctantly developed the machine.
During the construction Galen had secretly built in a weak spot at the core, hoping that the rebellion would be able to destroy the deadly weapon before the Empire had a chance to use it.
His wish did not exactly come true, because the evil Orson Krennic uses it to destroy Jedha City in order to show its power to the Empirial Senat. This makes the task at hand all the more urgent and the rebels are prepared to sacrifice everything to complete their mission.
The final showdown happens on the planet Scarif where the plans are stored. Star Wars fans who have been with the franchise for a while will probably know or at least guess the outcome of the movie. In my opinion that does not take anything away from the glory of watching it all happen in such a spectacular fashion on the big screen in 3D.
Sequel yes / no?
Rogue One is a stand alone movie but rumours continue to linger that there may be works in the pipeline to continue the story. I guess only time will tell. It is a very profitable franchise after all, so nothing is really unthinkable.
Disney revamped the Star Wars tale with The Force Awakens in 2015. They are currently working to get the chapter of that out in 2017. If the trend continues then the next movies after that is not due until 2019, which leaves the perfect open spot in 2018 for something else. But that is just speculation on my part.

Final thoughts
I have never been a Star Wars fan. To tell the truth the first movie in the franchise I ever saw was Episode I, and that only partly. I watched it years ago and the only part I remembered is the pod race. The first Star Wars movie I consciously watched was indeed The Force Awakens last year. After watching Rogue One now I am determined to make a marathon session over Christmas out of watching the entire series in one go. I will be off work for a few days, so that will give me the perfect opportunity to do that.
There are two reasons for that. First is my newfound appreciation for the story. And secondly there is the knowledge that I am missing the overall picture. I can't really place any of the events around those two movies within the timeframe of the entire story. As I am certain, that there will be more films coming and I am also certain that I am going to watch them, I want to be able to see the whole picture when I do that.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

Jan_FetzerDec 27, 2016

I don't get how the critic consensus only gives this film 65%. IMO, this is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. It ties into Episode IV perfectly, everything makes sense (for once) and the film even goes as far as to explainI don't get how the critic consensus only gives this film 65%. IMO, this is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. It ties into Episode IV perfectly, everything makes sense (for once) and the film even goes as far as to explain one of the biggest plot holes of A New Hope.

In some ways, I even like Rogue One more than any other Star Wars film. For the first time, it's not a black vs. white fairytale, where the Rebellion is good and the Empire is bad (simply because the audience is told so). The characters in this film are more complex and nuanced than in any other SW film before. This is the modern re-boot of the amazing franchise we've all been waiting for.

The only thing missing is the iconic Star Wars sound track. I don't know why they didn't use some of the original musical themes but if they had, I would give this film a perfect 10.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

aagarrisonwriteDec 28, 2016

I liked this movie.

Yes, it was 'Star Wars,' with the series' expected pros and cons. And, likewise, 'Rogue One' was a *movie,* with the expected cliches and embellishments. That said, however, this 'Star Wars' movie was, in my opinion, aI liked this movie.

Yes, it was 'Star Wars,' with the series' expected pros and cons. And, likewise, 'Rogue One' was a *movie,* with the expected cliches and embellishments. That said, however, this 'Star Wars' movie was, in my opinion, a pleasing one, both in terms of entertainment value and as an interesting, satisfying story.

Though, for me the movie's true appeal was in the wisdom that lay beneath the theater and images. That is, I felt that there was some *truth* written between the film's lines, of a rare, quality kind that carries over into the real world. For that reason, 'Rogue One' is, I believe, a "good" movie.

I don't see many film, literally just one a year (if that). As it were, 'Rogue One' was the one I saw this year, and I don't regret it.

My sincere thanks goes out to all who worked to produce this movie. I am grateful for, and have benefited from, your time and service. Keep it up!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

SuilenrocDec 28, 2016

Personally I thought that Rogue One was the best of all the modern Star Wars films. After watching this you will definitely want to watch A New Hope again.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

MaruganDec 31, 2016

The last act was the best piece of Star Wars I've ever watched. I enjoyed act 1 and 2 but the characters become great at the last 45 min. The chemistry between Jyn and Cassian was good but in that point was The Force Awakens a lot better. AllThe last act was the best piece of Star Wars I've ever watched. I enjoyed act 1 and 2 but the characters become great at the last 45 min. The chemistry between Jyn and Cassian was good but in that point was The Force Awakens a lot better. All in all is Rogue One a great movie with incredible shots, a brutal and dark atmosphere. Episode VII was a movie for children, Rogue One is a phanomenal piece of Star Wars for the one's, who are adults but in their heart still children.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

DevianAppleDec 31, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I overall liked the movie. It is a 'Star Wars Story' but it apparently became something like the normal one, as I have seen at the end. I still didn't like how they freaking killed EVERYONE at the end, and there were slightly too many fighting scenes. But overall, I'll give it a 9.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

Captain105Jan 1, 2017

the Reason I think this star wars deserves a lot more respect is because it earns a whole new level of utterly tragic realism it used the Star Wars mythology as a background into something more turning it into an amazing Star Wars spectacle.

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

CodgerEbertJan 5, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Great movie, but where were all the Bothans? Other than that, they seamlessly folded this prequel in with A New Hope. The end of Rogue One could take place 30 minutes before Tantive IV gets boarded by Vader. The fact that most of the protagonists died was kind of refreshing in today's world of immortal, sequel-ready heroes. I rank this one 3rd out of all Star Wars Movies, behind ESB and A New Hope.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

TFHJan 5, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rouge One was one of my favorite Star Wars movies. I liked the characters a lot, and the new and improved armory was a nice addition. The background story on some people was a bit vague though, but only on some. Overall, a great movie.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

9

MatteleJan 7, 2017

THIS had to be Star Wars 7, not that lazy and uninspired reboot. Given that this movie will not have a direct sequel, and given that it is a spin off, the authors finally created a really enojoyable movie. Must see.

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

9

HappyislandsJan 9, 2017

Against all odds this turned out to be a rather bold movie.If we weren't already aware of re-shoots this would have the hallmarks of a singular vision - a gritty and uncompromised war film set in the Star Wars Universe.

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

9

NightscapeSep 22, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This movie reminded me I can feel feelings. Of all the Star Wars movies, this one reminds me the most of actual war. The traditional use of animatronics with conservative use of computer animation and the musical score are great. I love the cast and their connection to each other, but what I want to focus on is how it is also the best at creating emotional attachment of all the movies. In the original Star Wars and the Force Awakens, they both blow up stuff and kill people with us the audience, having little attachment to what was lost (save one scene in episode VII) - the opposite is true here. As a survivor of the Iraq War and actually losing friends, this created the most emotion for me, due to seeing the similarities to the sacrifices of war and having watched the original trilogy (I try to forget the prequels ever happened). I highly recommend watching the (de-specialized edition of the) original trilogy then this, and try not to cry while high. If I was forced to rank this, subjectively, it is my favorite after Star Wars and Empire Strikes Back. However, it has a Grave of the Fireflies feel and is hard to watch a lot like the original trilogy and episode VII.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

BionicMattJul 3, 2019

A darker Star War film, without ever feeling gritty or edgy. With Disney at the helm, a film like this should never have existed, and yet I'm so glad it does.

For the first time, the heroes are the 'expendables', and their suicide missionA darker Star War film, without ever feeling gritty or edgy. With Disney at the helm, a film like this should never have existed, and yet I'm so glad it does.

For the first time, the heroes are the 'expendables', and their suicide mission carries real risk. That single line delivered by Leia in IV now has so much more weight.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

addabisMay 27, 2018

Rogue One is a great movie to watch. It depicts Empire in it's later stages and gives a background to Episode IV which follows in order. The overall tone is darker and more "realistic", especially in the second half. In contrast to EpisodeRogue One is a great movie to watch. It depicts Empire in it's later stages and gives a background to Episode IV which follows in order. The overall tone is darker and more "realistic", especially in the second half. In contrast to Episode VIII, this was fun to watch several times.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

Phil_FantusMar 27, 2017

This movie left me conflicted. It was on one side everything I hoped that Star Wars could have been if it evolved from a child's dream in the eighties into an adult's grim reality of 2016. Go see it, it's amazeballs! The acting is fine, theThis movie left me conflicted. It was on one side everything I hoped that Star Wars could have been if it evolved from a child's dream in the eighties into an adult's grim reality of 2016. Go see it, it's amazeballs! The acting is fine, the story is sound, the effect are great. It would have been a 10 if it wasn't so grim. But it is and that I did not expect. I will say no more, lest I leave a spoiler. The lighthearted space camp from your youth is gone. Space is dark and will leave you thinking. That's the other side of the medal.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

9

dcutlerApr 2, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. At the beginning of the movie they were switching around to different planets and I thought it was kinda a mess. But then the battle happened and everything changed. The Darth Vader scene at the End where you finally get to see Vader killing rebels is something I've wanted to see on screen forever.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

User Reviews