Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

9

JPKJun 13, 2019

Really Damn Good Star Wars Film
Rogue One is a great prequel to A New Hope that is intense, heart wrenching, emotional, and beautiful looking.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

FishSauceFunkMay 25, 2017

I had absolutely no expectations of watching this and by the end of the movie I thorougly enjoyed it. The first thing that comes to mind is because of the setting, the characters have no additional "baggage" of the greater series of StarI had absolutely no expectations of watching this and by the end of the movie I thorougly enjoyed it. The first thing that comes to mind is because of the setting, the characters have no additional "baggage" of the greater series of Star Wars, this allows the characters to simply exist outside of the jedi/sith universe and are so personable, while being connected. I love the main character's story - the nuance portrayed with good people trying to do good within the Empire and showing the shadier side of the Rebel Alliance, this makes the whole Star Wars universe look more grounded. I enjoyed how you leave the movie identifying with the Alliance as a greater struggle, the lack of central character build up highlights die-hard rebel life and sacrifice, a friend called it a Star Wars "war movie" and I could see that. Last, props to the diversity of the cast, they weren't exaggerated stereotypes for the sake of racial and gender diversity but had lots of heart (e.g. Felicity Jones, Forest Whitaker, Donnie Yen). Lastly - I teared up during the last scene, guess you'll know why once you see it. Kudos Rogue One!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

KelvinSelimorNov 28, 2022

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story. For the sake of which everything that was in "A New Hope" happened. Star Wars has managed to create a truly dramatic and dark story. Great cast of actors and soundtrack perfectly complemented the whole picture. IRogue One: A Star Wars Story. For the sake of which everything that was in "A New Hope" happened. Star Wars has managed to create a truly dramatic and dark story. Great cast of actors and soundtrack perfectly complemented the whole picture. I would love to see more dark Star Wars like this. Also, the creators did not stint on a couple of nostalgic moments, showing us old and beloved characters. From a small minus, you can cancel a slightly bad attempt to return to the screens of characters whose actors have already left this world, which is why these computer faces and all their facial expressions are very striking.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

manningn15Jan 20, 2019

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A great movie that gives a amazing back story to the how Princess Leia and the resistance got the plans of the Death Star so that the could destroy it. I love this movie and is one of my favorite movies I've seen in awhile. The performances from Felicity Jones and Diego Luna were spectacular. The visual effects and action scenes were fantastic. I loved the new robot K-2SO he was hilarious. The story and screenplay were great. Michael Giacchino's musical score was very good to. Also the cinematography was done well.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

samtheman34Dec 15, 2017

Really good overall movie. Vader steals every scene he is in. Good intake on how the Empire functions, would of loved to see an Emperor cameo. Top 5 Star Wars movie!

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

slee77Dec 23, 2017

This is by far one of my favorite Star Wars films. It understands the heart and soul of what a Star Wars film is without being entwined in Jedi lore the whole film. It certainly made every piece fit and gave us a very nice connector betweenThis is by far one of my favorite Star Wars films. It understands the heart and soul of what a Star Wars film is without being entwined in Jedi lore the whole film. It certainly made every piece fit and gave us a very nice connector between Episodes 3 & 4. It may be in my top 3 Star Wars films and it is the way I hope the franchise goes with the tone and overall look of future films. Great work Edwards!… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

loumexJun 14, 2022

This is a proper SW movie, well written, a great cast, an amazing hero's journey outline, well directed and damn enjoyable. This was the proper SW we deserved after the prequels.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

igobyandyJan 16, 2018

Rogue One quickly became a top 3 Star Wars film for me a long time super fan. The overall story was refreshing and felt as Star Wars as you could get. Jyn Erso i a great addition to the lineup of incredible characters and her role does notRogue One quickly became a top 3 Star Wars film for me a long time super fan. The overall story was refreshing and felt as Star Wars as you could get. Jyn Erso i a great addition to the lineup of incredible characters and her role does not seem forced. However, Forest Whittaker's portrayal of Saw Guererra was a travesty. Overacted to the point of hilarity.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

EvgenSDec 17, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Watch out for little Spoiler ahead!

No epic heroes, no happy endings. I enjoyed this serious and solid movie. Especially if compare with Force Awaken and Last jedi plots.
Rewatching it was also enjoying. Solid addition to SW film series. While Last trilogy so suck… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

HyapeDec 17, 2017

In the best traditions of old movies - serious, dramatic, realistic. You believe in every scene, in every step of main characters. It's not perfect, but much better than VII and VIII episodes.

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

9

myneeshDec 20, 2017

This is the best Star Wars movie since the originals and ROTS. Fits perfectly into the Star Wars universe and the Darth Vader scene at the end is just wow. Make you appreciate why Vader is VADER!

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

IMAJNEDec 22, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is an amazing film. Its not perfect, but it is as close to perfect as one could ever expect.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

andyviciusDec 29, 2017

this is a great star wars movie. for me, it's up there with empire strikes back. yep, that good.

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

9

Popcorn55Jan 6, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Absolutely brilliant choice of storyline, taking one or two lines from the original 1977 film and hooking in an entire film so that it segues seamlessly directly into the beginning of the original -- this film ends apparently only a few hours before the opening scene of the first "Star Wars". And that, very powerfully, gives us the feeling of having come "full circle" after forty years, after this Odyssey of disappointing sequels and prequels, here we are again -- back at the beginning! The real thing! Rogue One may well be the most magnificent prequel ever made, and it's the only "true" Star Wars prequel.

It gets off to a somewhat shaky start, and some of the side characters and subplots are half-hearted and unnecessary. If only those had been trimmed and tightened up, this would be a towering masterpiece like the original film.

NEVERTHELESS - once we get to the main event, and the battle drama unfolds in all its glory, all these minor concerns are swept away in a grand finale of wondrous spectacle, with a final sequence of utter genius.

The heroine's exit would have been more dramatic if she died wounded on the tower right after completing the transmission of the plans -- laughing defiance in the face of the Death Star commander on the screen just before they fired and blew her away. That's how I would have done it, haha!… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

Xenon_54Jan 7, 2018

Awesome coherent and in itself complete Star Wars Story. The first half lacks a little more character development though.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

joobyMay 27, 2018

Rogue One has aged very well in my memory as a film that does a good job of exploring the grittier and more exotic parts of the Star Wars universe. Taken together with Solo, these spinoff films feel vital and help to reinvigorate the StarRogue One has aged very well in my memory as a film that does a good job of exploring the grittier and more exotic parts of the Star Wars universe. Taken together with Solo, these spinoff films feel vital and help to reinvigorate the Star Wars universe with some new ideas and interesting characters while still be true to the Star Wars we know and love. Of the new Star Wars films, Rogue One and Solo have proven to be better than the sequel trilogy in all the ways that matter.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

weastsideJan 28, 2018

I saw this movie on opening night in 3D Imax and a total of 3 times. If you didn't see this film in this format, then you truly missed out big time. It was absolutely visual stunning. Nostalgia galore!!! Well written and cast. StrongI saw this movie on opening night in 3D Imax and a total of 3 times. If you didn't see this film in this format, then you truly missed out big time. It was absolutely visual stunning. Nostalgia galore!!! Well written and cast. Strong acting performances all around. Action scenes that brought a sense of realism to the screen. Great use of practical effects and top tier CGI work. I loved how this film brought back the mystery of the force that was so prevalent in the originals.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

merijnjFeb 21, 2018

(88/100)
A movie that we didn't even deserve made so great deserves a place in my top 5 Star Wars movies (for now).

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

AKthaBeastMar 19, 2018

A great **** movie told in more of a darker serious tone compared to the lighter bubblier versions of the Skywalker movies.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

NolanLundgaardMay 11, 2018

Rogue One did not feel like Star Wars for the first half of the movie, which is why I deducted a point. Instead it was overly violent with seemingly no purpose to that violence. The end/second half of the film definitely redeemed it. IRogue One did not feel like Star Wars for the first half of the movie, which is why I deducted a point. Instead it was overly violent with seemingly no purpose to that violence. The end/second half of the film definitely redeemed it. I recommend this, because it provides a brilliant tie from The Revenge of the Sith to A New Hope.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

NarlinsMay 27, 2018

This is one of the best Star Wars movies made, falling between 3 and 4 in sequence. We are awarded with a great new staff and the story is really blends and fits perfectly after all the years since these the 3rd & 4th movies.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

Flashp0int37Jun 11, 2018

Intense, heroic with dozens of Star Wars Expanded Universe references; Rogue One is an homage to Star Wars. Gareth Edwards directed a diverse and surprising group of scoundrels who become the heroes enabling the very existence of Star WarsIntense, heroic with dozens of Star Wars Expanded Universe references; Rogue One is an homage to Star Wars. Gareth Edwards directed a diverse and surprising group of scoundrels who become the heroes enabling the very existence of Star Wars New Hope.

A great prequel that transitions with breath-taking scenes to the first movie of the franchise.

It is certainly amongst the darker movies, like Empire Strikes Back. But doing so it defines what values are worth dying for and redefines heroic.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

ThatOneNerdyGuyOct 2, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Back in 2016 i thought this would be terrible, was it? HAHA no. Rogue one had to be one of the most underrated star wars movies and one of the most underrated movies of 2016. great action, AMAZING cgi as well, its what you would want from a star wars movie. But there is 1 issue, the characters aren't developed (except for jyn) like in other installments in the series. i can understand if you don't like that. But that's not the point of it, they weren't meant to be in any other movie, it makes sense *spoilers* that they all die, for a heroic sacrifice to the rebellion, but the gritty and dark theme of the movie plays out perfectly.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

JaysographyAug 28, 2019

Rouge One: A Star Wars story takes what true fans of the SWU have been waiting for. A Star Wars story, brought from the depths of George Lucas.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

LotsOfLoreDec 18, 2018

This right here is what I consider the best example of what I want Star Wars to be. When I fell in love with the original movies I was a kid, so I fell in love with them like a 12 year old would. I am not looking for that "magic" and I don'tThis right here is what I consider the best example of what I want Star Wars to be. When I fell in love with the original movies I was a kid, so I fell in love with them like a 12 year old would. I am not looking for that "magic" and I don't think you shoud too. I don't care at all for the new shallow interpretations of the story presented in episodes VII and VIII. This story, the story so brilliantly told and acted in this movie is EXACTLY what I can fall in love with now that I am older. I wish THIS was the continuation of my beloved franchise and I can only hope somebody continues on this track.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

RoyledesmaDec 22, 2018

Una de las mejores películas de star wars. La esperanza de la saga renacio con estos spinoffs.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

eshtazakiMar 21, 2019

Very decent star wars movie, loved the plot, the main character was very interesting, acting on good level (at least for me). From all the "New" star wars movies, this is the best by far, millions of light years ahead. it fills the story thatVery decent star wars movie, loved the plot, the main character was very interesting, acting on good level (at least for me). From all the "New" star wars movies, this is the best by far, millions of light years ahead. it fills the story that i missed, what connected episode III and IV.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

JohnMastrioniMar 8, 2019

This movie got a little too much hate, for me. I thought the story was good and acting was great. The ending was, come on, superb! For me, it was the last Star Wars film I can say I really enjoyed. Last Jedi and Solo left SO much to beThis movie got a little too much hate, for me. I thought the story was good and acting was great. The ending was, come on, superb! For me, it was the last Star Wars film I can say I really enjoyed. Last Jedi and Solo left SO much to be desired, primarily because of Disney's need to inject politics into their films now. It just doesn't work for me. Nor does hiring an actor or actress for a lead roll who runs their mouth during interviews for the film about everything else other than the film they should be talking about. Sorry Disney but people are voting with their wallets now. Rogue one was a great film and I hope IX can bring back the fans.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

Filmix16Jun 12, 2019

La surprenente apparition de Darth Vador m’a donner les plus gros frisson de ma vie. L’idée de la fin est bonne. J’ai adoré voir l’étoile de la mort dans sais promier teste. J’ai aussi bien aimer revoir le scénateur Organa et aussi de revoirLa surprenente apparition de Darth Vador m’a donner les plus gros frisson de ma vie. L’idée de la fin est bonne. J’ai adoré voir l’étoile de la mort dans sais promier teste. J’ai aussi bien aimer revoir le scénateur Organa et aussi de revoir la prinssece Leia. L’histoire quand à elle est bien réussi et très détailler. Le puissent réalisateur de Godzila revien avec un film de guerre encore plus réussit.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

signum88Sep 29, 2019

Fantastic bridge between episodes III and IV. It also introduces some very memorable characters.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

JeffJeffyDec 12, 2020

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I love how they made such a great movie about the opening from episode 4. Nobody really needed this movie, we knew what would happen but the characters, especially erso and andor are so well written and played that the movie is still really really good. Visuals and music are of course amazing as always and this movie has the best darth vader action in all of the movies.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

arian_snakeSep 29, 2020

It was like a classic Star Wars game and it's great
The characterization was great too

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

tarekaliJan 22, 2020

I just rewatched Rogue One and this time round the nuances of the acting are even more poignant. The massive sacrifices by Galen Erso and his daughter Jyn, and the selflessness of every single protagonist in the mission, make the deeds of theI just rewatched Rogue One and this time round the nuances of the acting are even more poignant. The massive sacrifices by Galen Erso and his daughter Jyn, and the selflessness of every single protagonist in the mission, make the deeds of the vaunted Skywalker clan seem small in comparison. This movie doesn't miss a beat, and I appreciate it even more amidst the stale vomit of the new abomination Abrams, Kennedy and Riaan subvert expectations Johnson trilogy. Gareth Edwards should have helmed the new trilogy.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

9

WuffinatorOct 30, 2019

This is easily the best Big Screen Star Wars Movie to come out since the prequels, muhc muhc better then the new trilogy.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

elena94Dec 4, 2020

The best star wars movie of all 5 new ones by far. This is how a star wars movie should be

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

Dostoyevsky3May 8, 2020

Rogue One focuses on intriguing and underrated characters we never thought we would see in an emotionally driven part of the saga's mythology that brings more depth and nuance to this franchise by going for a more serious and bittersweetRogue One focuses on intriguing and underrated characters we never thought we would see in an emotionally driven part of the saga's mythology that brings more depth and nuance to this franchise by going for a more serious and bittersweet journey not seen in other Star Wars films.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

AvaldezMay 6, 2020

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A well done movie that is compelling and captivating. While there are tiny cheesy call backs and fan service, overall it does a good job establishing new characters, flushing out minor characters from the original movie, and tying together with a new hope. Sometimes big battle speeches do more showing then telling but the ultimate battle conveys what it means to sacrifice for a cause bigger than yourself.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

orodri1Jun 29, 2020

Best movie of the recent Star wars saga, by far. Interesting and simple way to tell us about an important event of the entire story.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

aw22jdJun 24, 2020

I loved this movie from beginning to end. Great Star Wars story, great acting and great action, what more could I want?

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

DarrenIslerJun 24, 2020

Rogue One, in my humble opinion, is the best Star Wars movie ever made. Because it is the most literary, in that it contained intelligent commentary on deep ideas, and it was the most beautiful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

GioRgipJul 25, 2020

2 после мандалорца творение Диснея, замечательный фильм, добавляющий много всего в лор. Замечательная идея с показанием другой стороны войны без джедаев и т.д..2 после мандалорца творение Диснея, замечательный фильм, добавляющий много всего в лор. Замечательная идея с показанием другой стороны войны без джедаев и т.д..

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

Xolt3cSep 5, 2020

By war film, I mean something gritty. Something filled with rebel soldiers, spies, and hardware. With X-wings, Death Troopers, Imperial Walkers, untold Rebel Troopers, no Jedi Knights, British talking Imperials, and the Death Star. AndBy war film, I mean something gritty. Something filled with rebel soldiers, spies, and hardware. With X-wings, Death Troopers, Imperial Walkers, untold Rebel Troopers, no Jedi Knights, British talking Imperials, and the Death Star. And something where people we learn to love die. That’s a Star Wars movie!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

FuilerDec 17, 2020

เป็นมหากาพย์ภาพยนตร์จาก Star Wars ที่ทำออกมาได้สมกับที่เป็นภายนตร์ของ Star Wars ที่ดียิ่งกว่าภาคหลักภาค 7-9 เสียด้วยซ้ำเป็นมหากาพย์ภาพยนตร์จาก Star Wars ที่ทำออกมาได้สมกับที่เป็นภายนตร์ของ Star Wars ที่ดียิ่งกว่าภาคหลักภาค 7-9 เสียด้วยซ้ำ

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

OSRedditor_Dec 29, 2020

Watched it last night and i think i will probably watch it again but anyway characters are great and i f*cking love the end. Watch it it's great and if ur a star wars fan WATCH IT.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

AJ_13Sep 21, 2022

THE GOOD: Great cast and great chemistry between them, especially Jyn and Andor. The script is better than the ones from Episodes VII-VIII-IX combined. At the 90 minute mark I thought that this was a decent SW film but... what a third act!,THE GOOD: Great cast and great chemistry between them, especially Jyn and Andor. The script is better than the ones from Episodes VII-VIII-IX combined. At the 90 minute mark I thought that this was a decent SW film but... what a third act!, peak Star Wars. Directly to my Top 2. And Lord Vader? AMAZING staging, Gareth Edwards showed him to us as what he is: the greatest villain ever.

THE BAD: Maybe a bit of a slow beginning. Not every character is engaging.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

HeroicAge616Oct 25, 2021

Far from feeling like a cashgrab, Rogue One is an exciting side story that has the guts to tell a deeply moving story of sacrifice.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

AmadouIraklidisOct 5, 2022

After rewatching the entire franchise, it was a bit stunning to realize that Rogue One is the best movie in Star Wars lore. It's gritty, in a way that is fundamentally different from the other films, yet still contains enough levity for it toAfter rewatching the entire franchise, it was a bit stunning to realize that Rogue One is the best movie in Star Wars lore. It's gritty, in a way that is fundamentally different from the other films, yet still contains enough levity for it to feel like a crowd pleaser. How it tied together the other films is the work of someone on the level of Michelangelo, how it presented characters, new and old, are exciting, honest, and perfectly executed.

One of the greatest standalone movies in any franchise. A true treat to have watched this movie.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

8

VasotDec 18, 2016

Better from Force Awakens in my opinion and the plot is far from childish (there are no Jar Jar Binks or Ewoks or stupid kiddie stuff) this movie is way darker and dramatic and very close to "The Empire Strikes back" atmosphere. CharactersBetter from Force Awakens in my opinion and the plot is far from childish (there are no Jar Jar Binks or Ewoks or stupid kiddie stuff) this movie is way darker and dramatic and very close to "The Empire Strikes back" atmosphere. Characters are more realistic in Rogue One with their ups and downs as opposed to Force Awakens which the main protagonist there appeared as a Super-Jedi feminist that knows everything without training...… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

8

jenglish451Dec 17, 2016

Rogue One is thankfully another admirable Hollywood film that sincerely honors sacrifice, persistence, and hope. Of the Star Wars films, it's probably the best since the original three, and it links fairly well to the first.

It would be niceRogue One is thankfully another admirable Hollywood film that sincerely honors sacrifice, persistence, and hope. Of the Star Wars films, it's probably the best since the original three, and it links fairly well to the first.

It would be nice to know more about some of the characters, to sense even more deeply what they've suffered, but the film's focus on the story of the ensemble and how it miraculously comes together leads to another fascinating point: Arguably its handling of the idea of the Force or of a force behind the force may be more suggestive of a beneficent divine Providence, and thus closer to the Judeo-Christian God, than in the original three films which seemed to say that the Force requires balance--the light side requires a dark side, and so on (e.g. any victory of the good side is always only temporary, to be followed by the ascendancy of the dark side due to the purported balanced nature of the Force). The new film's seeming shift is a positive development. That notion of balance, of equal eternal opposition of good and evil, failed (even in the fictional world) to adequately or helpfully distinguish between good and evil so as to recognize good as higher than or better than or transcendent over evil. One could even argue from this development that the original films involved untrustworthy narration that is only now being revealed. Perhaps full investment in the themes stated above required this development. Hope would be unfounded without it.

And in its more unmitigated sense of a beneficent divine Providence watching over, superintending events, it feels reminiscent of the divine Providence and Creator (Eru Iluvitar) behind the scenes in The Lord of the Rings. But I guess time will tell if Star Wars really moves in this direction.… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

8

CrusaderDec 22, 2019

I loved this movie except for some parts. For one, it's too dark and gritty. Star Wars is a fairy tale. It's fantasy, not a dark Sci-Fi drama. Showing the dark side of the rebels and having them kill good people in a dirty war does not belongI loved this movie except for some parts. For one, it's too dark and gritty. Star Wars is a fairy tale. It's fantasy, not a dark Sci-Fi drama. Showing the dark side of the rebels and having them kill good people in a dirty war does not belong in a black and white story about light versus dark, good versus evil.
There's also the ending that felt forced. Like they had to find a way for it to end that way. And in some ways it doesn't make sense.
It is however still really good and worth seeing.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

ReginthornDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is the best Star Wars movie since 1980. The general consensus of last years Force Awakens was that the spirit of the original trilogy returned. However, the problem with Episode VII is in how the spirit is captured identically. InRogue One is the best Star Wars movie since 1980. The general consensus of last years Force Awakens was that the spirit of the original trilogy returned. However, the problem with Episode VII is in how the spirit is captured identically. In having returned so reverently, the franchise needed to display a willingness to tinker. Enter the newest cinematic addition to Star Wars. Rogue One is a balanced movie of hope and despair. The last Star Wars movie to find this magical balance in tone is The Empire Strikes Back. Likewise, Rogue One finds a unique synergy between old and new. The first anthology Star Wars movie works in its inevitable lead-in to an almost forty-year-old classic with a sense of invigoration. The movie smartly covers up modern filmmaking conventions with amazing throwbacks to the original trilogy. Seventies style facial hair can still be found on the Rebel pilots while a few smart cameos make the Star Wars initiated feel at home. The amount of Star Warsness to the film allows director Gareth Edwards to comfortably recton A New Hope. A problem with Rogue One is how the film can only be best enjoyed by a Star Wars fan. Rogue One is a decent enough war movie. The dogfights are exciting. The characters are charming and funny enough. The overall plot can’t be fully enjoyed without having seen A New Hope. In addition, the cinematic impact the film has on the future of this storied franchise also can't be appreciated by an outsider. Rogue One features the most diverse cast of any Star Wars movie... as well as the franchises more intense scenes. The mentioned scenes make up some of the best moments in a Star Wars movie to date. Rest assured the future of the franchise is in the very capable hands of Disney. Rouge One is how a franchise should make the old relevant.… Expand

30 of 51 users found this helpful3021

All this user's reviews

8

JSX117Sep 6, 2022

A Stunning masterpiece, which frankly comes as a massive shock following Disney's previous entries in the franchise. This film manages to rewrite the canon is a satisfying way that up to this point was inconceivable from modern Star Wars. TheA Stunning masterpiece, which frankly comes as a massive shock following Disney's previous entries in the franchise. This film manages to rewrite the canon is a satisfying way that up to this point was inconceivable from modern Star Wars. The casting is great, the acting is on-point, the effects are generally phenomenal, and the use of practical effects really grounds it in the OT Era. Even the CGI de-aging while imperfect is satisfying enough.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

8

dharmaJun 10, 2017

Rogue One is a bold direction for the Star Wars franchise under Disney. Sure it's a 'retelling' and prequel to the original trilogy, but it's bleakness and sombre tone is so much different than the 'Jedi oriented' main 'line'. Despite itsRogue One is a bold direction for the Star Wars franchise under Disney. Sure it's a 'retelling' and prequel to the original trilogy, but it's bleakness and sombre tone is so much different than the 'Jedi oriented' main 'line'. Despite its middling second act (a problem associated with any film by Gareth Edwards), it then proceeds to a great third act, essentially one of the best set pieces ever in a Star Wars film. A great addition to the ever expanding Star Wars universe and it shows that Disney's ability as a box office juggernaut is without comparison.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

8

ShermosDec 23, 2016

The only reason I'm not giving Rogue One a 10/10 score is because it does have a some minor flaws in the plot and could have done a better job with character building. Overall however, this film is awesome, and I haven't enjoyed a Star WarsThe only reason I'm not giving Rogue One a 10/10 score is because it does have a some minor flaws in the plot and could have done a better job with character building. Overall however, this film is awesome, and I haven't enjoyed a Star Wars film so much since The Empire Strikes Back. It might even be the best overall. I certainly enjoyed it more than the Force Awakens.… Expand

12 of 20 users found this helpful128

All this user's reviews

8

fluxmulderDec 18, 2016

Good movie. I enjoyed it much more than the Force Awakens, which felt like a rehash of A New Hope. Finally we get a fresh Star Wars movie that makes use of the best elements of the SW universe while also giving us new things to discover andGood movie. I enjoyed it much more than the Force Awakens, which felt like a rehash of A New Hope. Finally we get a fresh Star Wars movie that makes use of the best elements of the SW universe while also giving us new things to discover and enjoy. I enjoyed the ensemble cast, and as usual the visual effects and battle scenes are top notch. Some of the dialogue was too exposition heavy though, and the cutting to so many different locations got confusing. Overall though, solid movie, and a good direction for the SW movies to be moving in.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

8

VonSeuxMar 26, 2017

More entertaining than force awakens, font really get why this needs to be sold as a side story. Anyway, less pretentiousness more fun. The metacritc average does not translate how nice action adventure movie.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

NIntendoFan94Feb 25, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. this movie blows you away! It was actually different than any star wars movie. Most of all, its worth checking out! Visual Effects has done well, The cast was good. It was a true prequel to A New Hope.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

Gamed2longDec 28, 2016

Star Wars is in a strange place. The prequel trilogy are objectively worse movies than the original trilogy. But they do feel cut from the same cloth. The Force Awakens and Rogue One are better movies than the prequels, but feel cut from aStar Wars is in a strange place. The prequel trilogy are objectively worse movies than the original trilogy. But they do feel cut from the same cloth. The Force Awakens and Rogue One are better movies than the prequels, but feel cut from a different cloth. I found Rogue One to be a thoroughly enjoyable flick. The plot made sense and didn't step on the original films. I liked the diverse imperial bases. The film has minor flaws, such as some of the acting talent being wasted. Forest Whitaker and Mads Mikkelsen can do more/better! It seemed like K2SO got all the good comedic lines. Also a couple of times (minor spoiler) a character appears where the original actor has aged substantially or passed on. The approach taken to that seemed a little uncanny valley to me. Ultimately though the film lacks much of an underlying theme. Which makes it a flick, even though its a good one. Finally RIP Carrie Fisher.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

DexEngineerAug 11, 2020

Enjoyable Star Wars game. I would expect a bit better quality of storytelling, but overall nice experience. Fantastic robot role :)

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

Jack97Dec 16, 2016

Rogue One kicks off the Star Wars spin-offs in great fashion. While it lacks compelling characters, it makes up for it with exhilarating action, spectacular visuals, great performances from it's cast and a third act that is none stop edge ofRogue One kicks off the Star Wars spin-offs in great fashion. While it lacks compelling characters, it makes up for it with exhilarating action, spectacular visuals, great performances from it's cast and a third act that is none stop edge of your seat excitement and intensity. It also leads into "A New Hope" perfectly without feeling forced. This is a Star Wars Story worth telling and worth experiencing on the big screen!… Expand

22 of 38 users found this helpful2216

All this user's reviews

8

kamikaz3kittenJan 1, 2017

A beautiful looking movie, proving that a stand alone movie set in this universe can succeed and do it with style. Its action packed leaving me wanting more.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

Musicman_pamvDec 19, 2016

I was close to giving Rogue One a 10, but I am a tough grader and there were a few things that distracted me from giving it that high a rating. This is the Star Wars movie I have been waiting for since the original trilogy. Episode VII didI was close to giving Rogue One a 10, but I am a tough grader and there were a few things that distracted me from giving it that high a rating. This is the Star Wars movie I have been waiting for since the original trilogy. Episode VII did not deliver the same feel that Rogue One does. This "feels" and looks like Star Wars. Some of the recreations of settings from Ep. IV are very well done. The quibbles I have are few and mostly technical, not story or script related.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

8

LeZeeNov 4, 2017

The episode III½.

So this is like a bridge between the original trilogy and the next three prequels. A story where the main characters from the original tale are not involved. Being a big fan of this franchise, I loved it. I did not expectThe episode III½.

So this is like a bridge between the original trilogy and the next three prequels. A story where the main characters from the original tale are not involved. Being a big fan of this franchise, I loved it. I did not expect big, so got entertained well. But pity that this wonderful characters are not going to return. This is just a one-off film. For seeing its overwhelming success, there could be a prequel, which has a very very slim chance.

The story was like that had started in a half way. That's why I wanted a prequel to tell us the Galen Erso's point of view story. When he has been taken back to the base to work for the Empire, his daughter is the only one who escapes from there. After a few years later the grown- up daughter, Jyn, end up on the rebel's side. When she hints a plan for them to strike the Empire, nobody considers it. But a rogue gang forms where they all does according to her saying. That's the story, and how it all ends are the rest.

The story was simple, but the action-adventures were good. Like what a 'Star Wars' fans want to see. The main drawback was there's no familiar faces around. Even the original franchise style of title and credit presentation was off the beat. Though there were cameos. Darth Vade, Princess Leia, R2D2 and 3PO, including a small lightsabre fight at the end, just to satisfy the fanboys. Overall a worthy film, otherwise it would have not earned one billion at the box office, making one of the top 10 of all time.

8/10… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

8

MeritCobaJan 28, 2017

Rogue One is a movie that sets the focus low. The heroes are not Jedi or members of some ruling elite. Rogue one's cast has more in common with Han Solo than with a Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia. The message of the movie: little acts ofRogue One is a movie that sets the focus low. The heroes are not Jedi or members of some ruling elite. Rogue one's cast has more in common with Han Solo than with a Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia. The message of the movie: little acts of bravery can have important consequences.

The MacGuffin that makes the movie go is to find the weakness of that big death star moon build by the father of Jen. Find the father, find the weakness. A message from dad reaches the rebels in the form of a pilot and so Jen has to be found as to gain access to dad by way of Saw Gerrera, a rebel so extreme that even the Rebel Alliance frowns on him. Since he happens to be Jen's surrogate father it might be that he listens to her instead of pulling the trigger.

Does that sound overtly complex? Well, it does, but if you just tag along with the movie it is just one of points in the tale that you get dragged along. And tag along is the only thing that you can do as the movie does not let go. I would say, it keeps almost the same frantic pace as that crazy movie Fury Road. And that is the main weakness of this movie. Despite interesting characters there are too many of them and not enough time for any of them. The upshot is that you don't care if someone sacrifices his life, which happens a lot in this movie. They join up and they get killed. Next! Even when there is an important emotional moment in the movie it quickly gets trampled over in a desire to keep the pace. Without some dwelling on emotions heroes become two dimensional figures and their sacrifices have no emotional impact.

Still, Rogue One one is one of the better Star Wars movies in my opinion. It would have been better if there had been some more time spend on character development and less on jumping from one place to the next out of fear that some moments of reflection will scare the audience out of the theater. A pity because the essence of this movie: little people can bring hope loses a lot of its emotional currency.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

BrianMcCriticDec 16, 2016

This film is so much fun even with its few flaws. My favorite part of the film is the third act which is terrifically shot with a lot of emotion and great action. The lead up, the setting up of the team is put together fairly fast whichThis film is so much fun even with its few flaws. My favorite part of the film is the third act which is terrifically shot with a lot of emotion and great action. The lead up, the setting up of the team is put together fairly fast which doesn't allow for much character development. Also I felt some of the cameos were forced just to get a fan reaction instead of writing them in with more thought. Overall this is my fifth favorite Star Wars film behind the original trilogy and TFA. A-… Expand

16 of 28 users found this helpful1612

All this user's reviews

8

JohnWittenMay 2, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. [Excerpt from Full Review]

I will do my best to avoid the majority of spoilers, but for the most part the plot of the film is pretty straight forward and simplistic, similar to that of the original film. Whereas the original’s premise was to complete a suicide run and destroy the evil Empire’s operational battle station known as the Death Star, Rogue’s goal is to obtain the plans for said station. This film also really puts it into perspective just how close the Rebel Alliance came to failing every step of the way leading up to the destruction of the original Death Star. Rogue One puts this into the limelight in ways that the original film never seemed to seriously do, and as a result is much darker than any Star Wars movie we’ve watched to date. It may not be “killing younglings” dark, but the tone is definitely a lot more gritty and the stakes are a lot realer despite us knowing how it will ultimately end.

Although this film went the route of the prequels in having a relatively star-studded cast as opposed to unknowns in the lead roles, I think it helped for sure. Felicity Jones is phenomenal and each member of the rogue’s gallery that comprises the Rebel Alliance as well as some of the new faces of the Empire are fleshed out and portray their parts quite well. I was a bit disappointed but not altogether surprised that some of the more familiar roles and faces didn’t play as big a part as I had initially speculated that they would. Forest Whitaker plays grizzled guerilla veteran and leader Saw Gerrera (notably from the animated series), however his role seemed to be relegated to a little bit of backstory, tying the mission to Jones’ character, and tying up Gerrera’s arc in the universe as well. Despite that and despite Peter Cushing being given a little bit too much screentime and this bordering on irreverence considering he could’ve easily made his initial cameo and then the other scenes could’ve been pulled off without his appearance, my gripes are relatively few.

The characters themselves, while not necessarily so fleshed out seeing as this is a one-shot kind of one-time story for the majority of them, played their parts perfectly and seemed to mesh on-screen. I thought the melding of new and old characters was promising and worked much better than it seemed to with the original trilogy characters meeting The Force Awakens’ characters in episode seven. While I’m still curious as to what exactly Episode Eight will entail and what exactly it will be called, I cannot deny that Rogue One will be a success and admittedly deserves it. It has it flaws here and there but a simplistic story is not one of them. We knew where it was going to go based upon the time period and universe’s chronology and history, but even with that linear path set in stone and in mind, the story managed to do a lot of things that kept it fresh as well. Yes, by the end it is depressing and dark indeed, but there’s still that glimmer of faint hope on the horizon that will eventually blossom into the roaring wildfire of rebellion come Episode Six.

I was pleasantly surprised that the film actually concludes virtually with the opening scene of Episode Four, as that really put into perspective where exactly it falls in the scheme of things and also how brutally efficient the Empire is with cracking down on the Rebellion, despite never being able to train efficient Storm troopers in the art of hitting targets. I loved that the cast was as diverse and attentive to detail as it was, as well as the strong presence of Jones in the lead role, shining in more than a couple of moments in the film. I also particularly liked Donnie Yen’s character and would be interested to see some more detail and thought put into the origins of his organization- the ‘Wills’ and all that Force-related stuff has been mentioned before, just look back at Yoda and Qui-gon Jinn’s mention in Episode Three. There were plenty of memorable moments, special effects to make any fan drool, and tiny homages and moments made specifically with other moments in mind. All in all, not only is Rogue One a solid film on its own, but it is a welcome addition to the Star Wars universe and will hopefully prove that even stories outside of the main episodes and outside of the recognized or unrecognized expanded universe are welcome too.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

ThylbanusDec 21, 2016

Non-spoiler here. I have to say it was well done. Definitely a feel for the era it is set in. The plot is solid and there are MANY nods to everything in the Star Wars Universe. Sometimes you just have to listen to the background soundsNon-spoiler here. I have to say it was well done. Definitely a feel for the era it is set in. The plot is solid and there are MANY nods to everything in the Star Wars Universe. Sometimes you just have to listen to the background sounds and announcements. I love the whole way everything unfolded all the way up until the end. Then, in the last seconds, they drop a plot hole. Not a plot hole for the movie, but where it fits into the universe of Star Wars. Doesn't mean that the movie up until that point was bad. I give credit where credit is due. It just did a small bit of overreach in those last seconds. This movie hits on all the points that it should. It is one of the better movies to come from this universe. It has a hard, war edge that I see spawned the comment that it is the first movie to acknowledge that there is a war going on. While not totally accurate, the sentiment is. It is no Empire, but it certainly hits a bit better than the Force Awakens.

By the way, a lot of the scenes that ended up in the commercials are not in the movie. I don't know which is the reshoot and not, but there is a ton of scenes in those commercials that are not in the movie. This actually makes me hope for a definitive/director's cut that will be as additive as Batman v Superman. This movie needed to be just a bit longer to properly provide exposition.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

paulraisedFeb 3, 2019

A vision of what the real SW universe should look like. In realistic KOTOR fashion this movie presents a serious take on SW, the plot makes sense, the characters have depth. Felicity Jones and Diego Luna deliver excellent performances. TheA vision of what the real SW universe should look like. In realistic KOTOR fashion this movie presents a serious take on SW, the plot makes sense, the characters have depth. Felicity Jones and Diego Luna deliver excellent performances. The Leia CGI was not good, but easily one of my top three SW movies.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

8

TheApplegnomeDec 16, 2016

This is rebellion on a whole new (epic) level. It's a fun and more grittier adventure to the galaxy far, far away.

Rogue One; like all the SW-premieres are always a fun event to experience. Fans and non-fans alike collectively get togetherThis is rebellion on a whole new (epic) level. It's a fun and more grittier adventure to the galaxy far, far away.

Rogue One; like all the SW-premieres are always a fun event to experience. Fans and non-fans alike collectively get together once again for this space adventure. It's visually a big upgrade from the prequels, and it does to a certain point manage to embrace the original film's charisma. Fun, bright and enjoyable characters is a big trace -- and forget romance! This is a pure war film where companionship is everything. We follow 'Jyn Erso' and the main story is greatly focused on her, but a major letdown is the underdeveloped side-characters. They are all well presented and we get some inside to their personalities; but there's no major background nor development to characters like 'Cassian Andor'. Our main antagonist 'Orson Krennic' is very much the same. But there are some deeper layers to him, but sadly not enough to be considered a complex nor memorable villain. Because of this lack of greater depth to characters; the few emotional moments that does exist could have been even greater, because there are some great ones. The great one-liners from K-2SO is on the other hand very much appreciated, it's great that they really understand the importance of humor in the SW universe.

The story that takes place is full of action, as expected -- but more importantly; the characters are the major players here. A great character-filled first act, a more passive & calmer second act, to a stunning and perhaps too massive third act -- that's Rogue One. There're many characters and places involved in this story. All of this made some of the story uneven. It kept going, from places to places, characters to characters and so on; it became an experience that's a bit too far- stretched. It lost that "wow-factor". The second act takes a step back and didn't impress me on a personal level. It's okay but nothing really impressive got to me. But I am confident enough to say to all the big SW-fans out there that you will definitely love this film, and yes there are some really impressive action pieces -- but I never got many "wow moments". It drags on and lacks a greater long-term stamina when it comes to action. When looking at the CGI; it's a major technological achievement, except for two major CGI characters that look all other than alive. They are impressive to look at; much details, but the way they interact and talk is so fake. Add a non- Williams score that's underwhelming, well the flick got flaws. But other than that I really enjoyed it!

It's a good Star Wars movie. Not the best nor the worst. It got its flaws concerning the uneven storytelling and undeveloped side-characters, and some flaws are more serious than other. It's a beautiful story that's partially gritty and it got a stunning visualization of Vader. Add a darker tone, a very satisfying finale and an ending that manages to wrap everything together! That's Rogue One. It's the pure definition of rebellion.

*psst don't enter this film expecting much Vader.

Personal rating: 82/100 Critical rating: 70/100… Expand

48 of 73 users found this helpful4825

All this user's reviews

8

aurynsdadDec 16, 2016

Overall incredible. Far better than the other prequels. I liked the storyline better than the Force Awakens, which had some strange plot holes it's hard to get past. On repeat viewings, I'll be able to decide whether I like this or ForceOverall incredible. Far better than the other prequels. I liked the storyline better than the Force Awakens, which had some strange plot holes it's hard to get past. On repeat viewings, I'll be able to decide whether I like this or Force Awakens better. The third act is legendary. Strengths: the story, the feel, the acting, the writing. Weaknesses: a few spots of jarring editing, music, and CGI.… Expand

9 of 20 users found this helpful911

All this user's reviews

8

artardmosheaDec 16, 2019

Easily the best Star Wars movie since RotJ.

Cool story, great characters, great action.

Almost zero cringy stuff that plagues the other recent movies.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

8

OllyNortonDec 21, 2016

I really enjoyed this movie. I wasn't actually motivated to see it, i found The Force Awakens to be throughly dull, but i had some time to kill and decided to go for it. Im so glad I did. The movie has some incredible visual moments, backedI really enjoyed this movie. I wasn't actually motivated to see it, i found The Force Awakens to be throughly dull, but i had some time to kill and decided to go for it. Im so glad I did. The movie has some incredible visual moments, backed by incredible action, and a likeable (if underdeveloped) cast. The music isn't up to the standards of the series, and some characters are somewhat underused, but overall this is a throughly enjoyable film that eleven both Star Wars fans and none can enjoy. (although star wars fans will get more enjoyment out of the multitude of OT references that are present).… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

8

oDjentoDec 16, 2016

Rogue One isn’t perfect, but it is a great breath of fresh air for the Star Wars Franchise. The direction feels very different at first, feeling more handheld at not super Star Wars-esque because of its grittier more grounded style, but thisRogue One isn’t perfect, but it is a great breath of fresh air for the Star Wars Franchise. The direction feels very different at first, feeling more handheld at not super Star Wars-esque because of its grittier more grounded style, but this is great and works for the film. It ends up making it feel like a real war and struggle for the rebellion and it ends up changing later towards the end in tonal shift and direction to blend into A New Hope.
Pacing is a little odd at first, but the first section is interesting enough to keep you very invested, especially with all the character introductions. The second act is a littler quieter and a bit of a lull but still has enough going on and differs itself from the rest of the film to keep it fresh. The last section is an intense all out action masterpiece, and really gives a space feeling of something similar to the end battle of Saving Private Ryan. Characters are well enough written for you to enjoy and like them all, however they are a little underdeveloped for the most part and you end up wanting more from them. This ends up not hindering the film too much since the film is a standalone. This film does carry itself well, it knows when to be dark without over doing it and changes location at a nice rate with a clear understanding of where and what folk are doing.
This also the first film where Darth Vader is actually fully terrifying, he is almost like an insanely powerful sci fi MikeMyers. Even thoug he isn’t in it much, his presence is palpable.
The good thing about Rogue One also is that it doesn’t try to keep using nostalgia to interest its viewers (which TFA did a lot) but does have plenty of nice little easter eggs.
The droid K2SO in the film is also the comic relief of it, but whilst a few jokes hit the mark a lot are unnecessary and too forced in, and there is (like TFA) a lot of cheesy 2016 throwaway jokes just put in there. Disney need to learn to restrain themselves from certain jokes, and when they do put them in they need to understand when to end the joke and how to fully have them come across.
Last two complaints, the new score for the film is cheesy and doesn’t fit the film at all, and really takes away from it as a whole sadly. Dubbing John Williams over it would be very cheap, but to be honest it would probably make the film feel more epic and fit more. There is also some questionable CGI characters in the film which just look unnatural in the film but still don’t ruin it too much.
Overall, this film diverges enough away from Star Wars to make it feel fresh but also very nicely connects itself to the original trilogy. Action is awesome yet characters are a little underdeveloped, special effects are gorgeous but score is disappointing. It is a tragic war film set in the Star Wars universe, and Gareth Edwards did something brave with what he had.
Bravo to you sir.
8/10… Expand

16 of 27 users found this helpful1611

All this user's reviews

8

Voodoo123Oct 12, 2017

+superior fan fiction tells a new story in the cracks between episode 3-4
+excellent pacing / cast / direction improves on repeat viewings
+chessy fun times had here -CG tarkin (if only they kept as reflection only...) Seriously grinning+superior fan fiction tells a new story in the cracks between episode 3-4
+excellent pacing / cast / direction improves on repeat viewings
+chessy fun times had here
-CG tarkin (if only they kept as reflection only...)

Seriously grinning from ear to ear with all the little references and easter eggs. Genuinely impressed. This gave me new hope for star wars films yet to be that maybe can fill the gap left by the absence of George Lucas genius ....… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

Meth-dudeApr 9, 2017

As far Star Wars movies go, this one is one of the best. The acting, the visuals, the special effects and the story were all solid, the characters were interesting and the ending was very good. It definitely exceeded my expectations.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

PandaFromHell05Dec 23, 2016

The first time I watched the trailer, I was like meh. After watching the movie, I was pleasantly surprised. While I feel like this is not the most epic Star Wars movie ever (I mostly like lightsaber fights when it comes to Star Wars, andThe first time I watched the trailer, I was like meh. After watching the movie, I was pleasantly surprised. While I feel like this is not the most epic Star Wars movie ever (I mostly like lightsaber fights when it comes to Star Wars, and Rogue One does not have lightsaber fights), it's certainly decent. It's a classic father-daughter story, where you come to care about the characters. The robot droid was hysterical, honestly. Also, the tribute to characters such as Grand Moff Tarkin, was believable and plain creepy that they brought an actor who's been dead since the 90's, back to life. It was a pretty fantastic movie, much better than Force Awakens.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

8

ukrScorpionMay 1, 2018

Best film in new Star Wars film series.
Good story, Epic battles all that is missing in the main new series.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

SHORTFINGERDec 16, 2016

it was okay. lot of slow parts. far between fighting parts in the movie. but i did enjoy it. does tell us how they got the death star plans etc. did not learn much about the main people in the movie at all very little.

6 of 14 users found this helpful68

All this user's reviews

8

43in2014Dec 23, 2016

Related media: The three prequels have been quite soulless, as the actors had to act opposite green screens most of the time, while The Force Awakens (TFA) was a great disappointment as it heavily ripped off A New Hope (ANH). Check out myRelated media: The three prequels have been quite soulless, as the actors had to act opposite green screens most of the time, while The Force Awakens (TFA) was a great disappointment as it heavily ripped off A New Hope (ANH). Check out my review of the latter, if you can find it.
>
What's Rogue One (RO) like?: Story-wise, it's like other past films where the protagonists had to risk their lives to infiltrate the opposite side so as to steal something, except that here, there are also spaceships and lasers... It was better than TFA, but it also has several problems. >
Pros: >
1. TFA broke many of the conventions and principles behind how The Force works and how things work in general! For no apparent reason, Rey knew how to pilot a complex spaceship and how to fight with a lightsaber without having been trained on either task beforehand. (This is all down to JJ Abrams. On Star Trek (2009) it was inspiring, but Into Darkness and TFA just made me question his destructive creativity. His earlier films were also quite unruly. I've decided to never watch his films again.) RO avoids this by not invoking the use of the force that often. Most events made sense. This film is a fitting addition to the Star Wars Expanded Universe.
>
2. The battle scene on Scarif was nice. >
Cons:
>
1. RO is only slightly better than TFA. The story is less contrived than in TFA. However, it was still rather ridiculous that our heroes need to travel to so many places and to go through so many hoops to get the jobs done. Some parts seemed drawn out. >
2. Apart from Jyn, the other main characters were not developed sufficiently, in the rush to show the action scenes. >
3. The actor playing Commander Krennic seemed to be over-acting, all the time. He was unnecessarily angry and devilish all of the time.
>
4. The CGI in this film has some significant flaws. The Star Destroyers look like Lego pieces when in front of a bright background, while the fully computer-generated Grand Moff Tarkin looked... computer-generated. The eyes! You have to sort out the problem with the static eyes! The production had $200m and these problems were not solved?
>
5. I thought the destruction of Alderaan in ANH was the first time the Death Star fired its main laser and destroyed a planet? In ANH, Grand Moff Tarkin said, “Princess Leia, before your execution, I’d like you to join me for a ceremony that will make this battle station operational… In a way, you have determined the choice of the planet that is to be destroyed FIRST. Since you are reluctant to provide us with the location of the Rebel base, I have chosen to test this station's destructive power on your home planet of Alderaan.” Furthermore, Obi-Wan only felt the pain from the destruction of Alderaan and not from any moon or planet before that. The firing of the main laser in RO was not mere a test. Has this film created a continuity error? >
6. The new musical score was a strange and horrible choice. The score rises to a crescendo in a haphazard way and then abruptly drops and goes all over the place. Which inexperienced composer was hired to do this? A Golden Raspberry Award is coming up.
> 7. There was no need to show Leia at the end of RO. (It is not a spoiler that she's coming up next in ANH.) The CGI was inadequate and the scene should have been left out.
>
How would the different age groups rate it?
Children: Excellent
Teenagers: Excellent
Young adults: Excellent
Medium age adults: Good
Old adults: Average.
My rating: 4/5 (no half scores). It's worth it pay to watch it in the cinemas.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

8

chesaroDec 30, 2016

It is a good movie, but by no means a great one, or better than episode VII, it does what it pointed to do. The only thing i really hated was the CG characters... They just looked fake.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

potatoman222Jul 21, 2017

Um ano após o aclamadíssimos Star Wars - O Despertar da Força, chega aos cinemas o primeiro - de muitos - sping off da saga. Que serviu para re-afirmar o que já sabíamos: A Disney não está para brincadeira. No longa acompanhamos a históriaUm ano após o aclamadíssimos Star Wars - O Despertar da Força, chega aos cinemas o primeiro - de muitos - sping off da saga. Que serviu para re-afirmar o que já sabíamos: A Disney não está para brincadeira. No longa acompanhamos a história de Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones) a filha de Galen Erso (Mads Mikkelsen), um dos maiores responsáveis pela criação da maior arma de destruição em massa do império galáctico, a Estrela Da Morte. Após anos, a aliança rebelde toma conhecimento dessa arma e precisa urgentemente fazer algo em relação a isso. Então, Jyn é solicitada para partir em uma missão que envolve seu pai, e a última esperança da galáxia.
Aqui vemos claramente o trabalho de um fã feito para fãs. Diversos Fan Services estão escondidos, alguns muito bem ou nem tanto. Mas isso não significa que o longa funciona apenas para um público alvo. Qualquer pessoa não familiarizada com a saga pode ir sem receios para o cinema, pois o espetáculo visual é garantido. Gareth Edward dirige o longa com mestria, o diretor que possui poucos filmes em seu currículo, se saiu muito bem aqui. Há cenas impressionantes e de tirar o folego em decorrência de sua direção sempre corrida e doses certeiras de ação. O filme também acerta ao combinar efeitos visuais com efeitos práticos., os efeitos práticos aqui não são tão recorrentes como em O Despertar Da Força, mas ainda sim se fazem presentes e ajudam a dar vida ao universo palpável de Star Wars. Outro grande mérito do filmes são suas cenas externas e seu visual impecável, o trabalho de arte visto aqui é um dos melhores do ano. Com cenas visualmente impressionantes somos abençoados com a visão de um eclipse da estrela da morte. Sem contar o show de efeitos visuais, que como sempre em Star Wars, foram perfeitos.
No que diz respeito a atuação, o filme segue com exito. Felicity Jones dá continuidade a série de personagens femininas fortes da franquia Star Wars com Jyn Erso, uma rebelde criada por Saw Gerrera vivido por Forest Whitaker. Também temos Diego Luna na pelo de Cassian, um guerreiro da aliança rebelde que embarca na missão com Jyn em busca dos planos da Estrela Da Morte. Entre os destaques temos Dinnie Yen e o próprio Mads Mikkelsen. Entretanto, por mais que bem representados, os personagens de Rogue One não são cativantes como os que estamos acostumados na franquia. Jyn é péssima ao exercer o papel da líder que precisa passar confiança aos seus companheiros. Basicamente não há química como vimos entre Finn e Rey no longa. O que chama atenção aqui é a história e todo o contexto em que os personagens estão envolvidos, de certa forma isso é até bom, pois nos mostra que toda a situação e a luta contra o império está muito acima destes personagens.
Um espetáculo nos é exibido no final e melhor ato do filme. Cenas eletrizantes com Stromtroopers e AT-AT Walkers em um planeta tropical são uma das cenas que ficaram para sempre na mente dos fãs da saga de George Lucas, sem comentar a conexão no final entre o filme e o Episódio IV - Uma nova Esperança, que é realizada com tanto êxito que me dá arrepios só de lembrar. Entre erros e acertos, Rogue One mostra que a franquia Star Wars está viva e apenas começando, com o longa apostas são abertas para futuros filmes, e nós, fãs. Aguardamos ansiosamente para isso.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

Jim222001Jun 15, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A gloomy and probably unnecessary StarWars story it is. However the film is so well acted and well done that it's definitely not bad. While there's some pretty bad ass Vader appearances. Which makes us forget the disappointing last time we saw Vader on the big screen in 2005. He gets way cooler lines than "Where's Padme ?" and "Noooooo!" ”
I also liked how they used to bring back dead actors from the original or to make certain actors from the original look younger. They should make a First Order film leading into Force Awakens and use that effect. My complaint is something that hit me after the film. This a big spoiler: Just that after anyone part of the Rogue One team does their part of the mission, then they're expendable like right after. Time for them to die. Which happens one by one after each character has done what they were supposed to. I didn't expect any survivors from the start but the way it was done was some-what lazy.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

8

LatinCritic13Jul 29, 2017

Seeing a Star Wars spinoff like Rogue One is a pure delight for all sci-fi fans to enjoy. Everything ranging from the dazzling visual effects all the way to the story structure is just spectacular to watch. Although, there are some hiccupsSeeing a Star Wars spinoff like Rogue One is a pure delight for all sci-fi fans to enjoy. Everything ranging from the dazzling visual effects all the way to the story structure is just spectacular to watch. Although, there are some hiccups that people might encounter when it comes to narrative structure, overall it's acceptable. Felicity Jones, Diego Luna, Mads Mikkelsen, Riz Ahmed, and the cast did a fine damn job setting up the tone that captures the real force that's true to Star Wars.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

8

zaftgunApr 8, 2017

I started with negative expectations and was left impressed. It turned out to be much better than I thought. Certainly better than the last star wars movie. Good fighting, decent story. Its a fine movie as long as you dont go in nitpicking.I started with negative expectations and was left impressed. It turned out to be much better than I thought. Certainly better than the last star wars movie. Good fighting, decent story. Its a fine movie as long as you dont go in nitpicking. Movies are to be enjoyed, so just relax and enjoy, let go of minor things and you'll be happier.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

homer4presidentApr 12, 2017

This is a war story, about people who discover purpose and meaning in their lives. It is a little raw, not for little kids who are looking for Jar Jar. Teens and above will appreciate that personal and ultimate sacrifice to ideals have beenThis is a war story, about people who discover purpose and meaning in their lives. It is a little raw, not for little kids who are looking for Jar Jar. Teens and above will appreciate that personal and ultimate sacrifice to ideals have been made throughout history. Thoughtful, adventurous, bitter sweet. Doubly so, with guest star appearance of Leia foretelling the next film, A New Hope, that this movie is a prequel to. Loved it.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

WiedzemirFeb 3, 2020

The best Disney Star Wars so far. The well-written story, believable characters. Both sides of the conflict are shown to be competent and driven by reasonable motivations. Decent CGI, Tarkin looks almost real.

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

8

CineAutoctonoDec 21, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. "Star Wars: Rogue One" was an exciting film, the story was well created, the script was very good, but maybe it was not better than episode 7, I felt identified with the protagonists, the cameos are impresive, and without Doubt was one of my favorites of the saga.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

8

AsaZimbabweDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. overall rogue one is great. it is a fun sci-fi movie. it is a tense action movie. it is a thought-provoking war film. it is almost perfect as a star wars fill-in-the-gap story, justly expanding the star wars universe. easily better than the prequels, on many levels better than e7, and potentially up there with empire. much darker in tone and visually one of the strongest (if not the strongest) of all the star wars films to date. it does an excellent job of location, set, character & costume design. it captures, matches & improves upon the original 70’s future-long-ago look & feel; particularly compared to the prequels coming-off as too squeaky-clean and cartoony, where obvious green-screen 'sound-stage sets' clashed w/ cgi backgrounds that actually came-off as claustrophobic or making the actors seem lost-in-place, rogue one feels much more authentically 'there' and breathable, artfully integrating cgi & traditional effects with moveable characters. it even stands out compared to abram’s understandable but heavy-handed return to reliance on traditional sets & mechanics… for example, edward’s film improves & expands upon the rebel base yavin 4 locale, while keeping consistent with what you may have imagined was just off camera 40 years ago in e4; much more-so than abram’s disappointing teletubbies green hills + cement roads to simulate the rebel base in e7. many aspects of r1 kept me feeling like this was the star wars film i had been longing for, or at least adequately filling in many of the blanks the original insinuated. there is a sense of depth and history here missing from recent star wars films; diverse planets, ancient temples, exotic creatures & locales feel much more realized & alive, part of a larger universe than maz kanata’s isolated b&b cantina-remake. i’ve heard understandable complaints about the pacing, it does feel a little bit long at times, but i don't hold that against it and can't think of much i would cut. speaking of cuts, as others have noted several scenes or lines of dialogue from the trailers are missing in the final film, but mostly this is just a curiosity considering the theatrical cut is still almost 2.5 hours. there is also understandable chatter that some of the new characters are not as realized as one might ‘hope’ for. the acting and interplay between the two lead actors felicity jones & diego luna is excellent and among the best in any star wars film. if their characters leave you longing for more, it is a compliment rather than a knock, and the context of the film in the larger star wars universe perfectly justifies the amount of attention they get. my biggest complaints would be trivial: spoiler alerts: it is said that you are not supposed to notice a good movie soundtrack, but how can you say that about star wars? the fact that giacchino scored this and not williams is apparent in parts. a few times the music strikes up and you are expecting classic star wars to come belting out but it doesn’t, and feels like it falls a bit short. there are other moments though, where the soundtrack uses non-traditional instruments to provide a more other-wordy feel than previous films… it's cool that grand moff tarkin is back in a significant role, but he does look obviously cgi as others have noted. Vader has a weird, kind of glaring overhanging neck issue with his helmet which bugged me (and others), though otherwise it was great to have him back as a bad-ass post hayden era, the closing moments with Vader were great and among his best, if not short-lived & offer promise of more to come. Donnie Yen was a cool character but somewhat annoying with the overly-repetitive ‘hare-krishna’ force mantra, it was a bit ‘forced’ that he's so close to a jedi but technically not. a particular scene in jeddah surrounding an imperial 'tank' carrying kyber crystals felt especially clunky, the tank looked clumsy and out of place, that scene struck me the most as a mechanical set, seeing the tank struggling to maneuver on the ground with dozens of flying ships everywhere else was reminiscent of being stuck on the track of the bumpy indiana jones ride at disneyland. the new robot side-kick ‘K’ was mostly well-written and well-performed by tudyk and provided good, consistent comic relief. and major kudos to how many of the main characters were dead by the end of the film, that is lacking in so many movies and particularly bold of edwards, kennedy & disney. as an ‘old-head’ traditional star wars fan i found r1 to be less-than perfect, better than i expected, slightly more satisfying than e7, a huge improvement over the prequel trilogy, and ultimately excited for the future of the star wars universe being placed into the hands of new talent... ps: got to agree with AdamCM: "the best Star Wars since Empire"… Expand

13 of 44 users found this helpful1331

All this user's reviews

8

Jollyjoe1000Apr 12, 2017

all though star wars episode 7 lowered my expectation when it came to a star wars movie. this movie most definitely satisfied me. It was just a little slow at the beginning, but the end was exiting. The icing on the cake was how it was theall though star wars episode 7 lowered my expectation when it came to a star wars movie. this movie most definitely satisfied me. It was just a little slow at the beginning, but the end was exiting. The icing on the cake was how it was the events that set up the first star wars movie.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

RobBob99Dec 17, 2016

Black Hawk Down meets Star Wars, that is what it's like watching Rogue One and it truly delivers on the action. This has some of the absolute best action sequences in any Star Wars film and it actually has what many of the films have lacked,Black Hawk Down meets Star Wars, that is what it's like watching Rogue One and it truly delivers on the action. This has some of the absolute best action sequences in any Star Wars film and it actually has what many of the films have lacked, stakes. Through good characters and terrific acting, Rogue One manages to succeed what most prequels fail to do, enhance the impact of later films. I see myself watching A New Hope through a new point of view and I have to say, Gareth Edwards made a Star Wars movie that stands on its own. Yes it's not a perfect movie, but it's a really good movie with minor flaws.… Expand

20 of 31 users found this helpful2011

All this user's reviews

8

tonywar93Dec 17, 2016

Rogue One is a great movie with a few drops here and there. The movie flows averagely pretty well for 2h15m, from an explanatory and choppy intro to one of the most breathtaking battles the Star Wars saga has ever seen and to what could beRogue One is a great movie with a few drops here and there. The movie flows averagely pretty well for 2h15m, from an explanatory and choppy intro to one of the most breathtaking battles the Star Wars saga has ever seen and to what could be considered a true nerd-gasm in the final scenes. Lots of pleasant surprises, lots of welcome call-backs, maybe some lack of characters's depth. Non-fans will enjoy an alternative war movie; fans will thank Gareth Edwards for realizing their innest geeky dreams.… Expand

12 of 27 users found this helpful1215

All this user's reviews

8

LuhterJun 17, 2017

It's great and how should a SW side story be. The story is solid and logical when compared to the mess ep7 was. Visually it looks great. Score the same. The lead character is not a soulless perfect hero like Rey so is interesting to watch,It's great and how should a SW side story be. The story is solid and logical when compared to the mess ep7 was. Visually it looks great. Score the same. The lead character is not a soulless perfect hero like Rey so is interesting to watch, and the supporting cast was nice even though a little more moments with them would've been nice. Overall a good movie.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

EpicLadySpongeDec 16, 2016

Before you go directly to see this movie, ask yourself the following questions. Am I going to see at least one memorable Star Wars character in this film? Well, there isn't that many since this is supposed to be a spin-off. Am I going toBefore you go directly to see this movie, ask yourself the following questions. Am I going to see at least one memorable Star Wars character in this film? Well, there isn't that many since this is supposed to be a spin-off. Am I going to experience the same feeling like the previous Star Wars films? Yes, and it's pretty unusual for a spin-off. Lastly, do these new characters make me want to see this movie? If you want to exactly know what happens to these characters, then yes. We can't tell you what happened to these characters for sure as that would lead to spoilers. Rogue One takes its main base and separates everything but left the feelings of the film just for the beneficial fans. It's not near a masterpiece, but at least it's trying to be something and that something is what Rogue One should be anyways.… Expand

12 of 26 users found this helpful1214

All this user's reviews

8

HelenHDec 30, 2016

Good film. It adds to the previous films. And I believe it is the first time in a Star Wars film the Alliance does not consist of only heroes who won't do any wrong. Suddenly, the characters are not black and white and I think it is a reallyGood film. It adds to the previous films. And I believe it is the first time in a Star Wars film the Alliance does not consist of only heroes who won't do any wrong. Suddenly, the characters are not black and white and I think it is a really nice change.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

saintandrewsfalJan 3, 2017

Good film overall with some missteps. Acting, story, and action, were all tight. No problems there. The issues come up with cliched moments, a small lull in the second act, and an average ending.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

8

meta_kingNov 9, 2022

Cool! What? Only 75 letters? Oh sooooooooo! I cant do it! I can do it! 75? 75?!!!!!!

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

8

AndrewLambertJan 22, 2017

Rogue One continues Disney's spectacular resurgence of the legendary saga, enriching the series' mythology by exploring hidden depths of the Star Wars universe in ways never seen before.

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

8

FuturedirectorDec 18, 2016

Well-acted, smartly written and surprisngly blessed by an all-new story-telling that shares with the audience a truly unsatisfying story that perfectly works with the original saga.

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

8

SrPepeNov 28, 2017

La verdad que la película esta muy buena y cumplió con todas mis expectativas como seguidor de la saga. Los personajes son entrañables y los efectos especiales de lo mejor.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

thoodeeDec 25, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. loved this movie! I really was invested in the characters, and even family that weren't familiar with star wars were craving more about what happens after. Of course I pointed to episode 4. The only thing that somewhat let me down was the amount of Vader screen time, however when he finally did show up you knew sh!t just got real and was fully satisfied.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

User Reviews