Brokeback Mountain

10

CeckoS.Jan 3, 2006

I love this movie .... artistic .... can effect your feeling .. but I dont like the love scene too much can't see it .... But all the whole thing is Great I'm loving it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BridgetJan 3, 2006

What a fabulous film! It was like a great book or a painting-it affected me long after leaving the theatre. I downloaded a copy of the original short story by Annie Proulx (from her website) -the movie is very true to her original tale. What a fabulous film! It was like a great book or a painting-it affected me long after leaving the theatre. I downloaded a copy of the original short story by Annie Proulx (from her website) -the movie is very true to her original tale. Oscars to all for a great moviegoing experience!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TracieN.Jan 31, 2006

wonderful.... everything about the movie was realist, the acting was fabulas, the setting, make up clothes, everything was realist. I know because I grew up in that time and in that world. Stunning.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

trishJan 3, 2006

I cannot believe such a tender story about love and loss can be described by someone as "sick". This is a materpiece that will for sure stand the test of time. From the direction to the performance and the script, not one false note. I I cannot believe such a tender story about love and loss can be described by someone as "sick". This is a materpiece that will for sure stand the test of time. From the direction to the performance and the script, not one false note. I suggest Trish H. do some reading and researching before posting such offensive and medieval crap.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DAveJan 3, 2006

Being a gay man myself - after 14 years of marriage and raising two children - I am pleased that a movie, like Brokeback Mountain, has brilliantly captured the pain and conflict many gay men go though in their lives - finding someone they Being a gay man myself - after 14 years of marriage and raising two children - I am pleased that a movie, like Brokeback Mountain, has brilliantly captured the pain and conflict many gay men go though in their lives - finding someone they can truely love. The sadness, conflict, and pain the actors in the movie portrayed was so very real to me, it left me wanting a sequel to the story; perhaps Ennis finding someone he can finally settle down with, without all the stigmas and repercussions that comes with being gay, and living in Wyoming.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

saddyboyJan 4, 2006

A modern classic.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

stephenc.Jan 4, 2006

Wonderful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

HopeU.Jan 5, 2006

This is a must see movie! I'd recommend it to anyone except homophobics. They would get too caught up in the gay aspect and totally lose out on the real meaning in the message. It's a darn shame too because those are the folks who This is a must see movie! I'd recommend it to anyone except homophobics. They would get too caught up in the gay aspect and totally lose out on the real meaning in the message. It's a darn shame too because those are the folks who need the message the most. I was very moved by the message and it has made me re-think about certain issues. This movie was so well done that at the end you go, oh and they were gay too. That's how it should be. Not a gay issue, a message of love and bonding that stems from love. Wow, wish I think of something deep to say. Anyway, this is the movie that I will be buying when it comes out on DVD!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

NancyZ.Jan 6, 2006

This movie was beyond brilliant. I could care less that it was about two guys (even though it really wasnt, it was about LOVE people) the whole point is that it was MOVING. compelling. absolutely heartbreakingly beautiful. Yah- it's two This movie was beyond brilliant. I could care less that it was about two guys (even though it really wasnt, it was about LOVE people) the whole point is that it was MOVING. compelling. absolutely heartbreakingly beautiful. Yah- it's two men- big whoop. But I also was compelled to review b.c 1, hey. women liked it too whatever ass it was that said it's only gay men that liked the movie. 2, Trish H. you are a .... and a wholesomely ignorant one at that. there were indeed many cowboys that were gay. just like there are, however rare, MALE hairdressers that are straight. get over your stereotypes, your ridiculous so called "moral" fiber (which by the by- morality is simply the attitude one adopts to the people they personally dislike. as you have obviously demonstrated) and your utter inability to get your head out of your ass.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

WillJan 6, 2006

I'm a city boy, through and through. But in so many ways 'Brokeback Mountain' is my story too. We all can feel the inchoate longing that Ennis and Jack experience because their love can't be acknowledged within a society I'm a city boy, through and through. But in so many ways 'Brokeback Mountain' is my story too. We all can feel the inchoate longing that Ennis and Jack experience because their love can't be acknowledged within a society bent on thwarting it, through early lessons of hatred, misguided marriage expectations and, if need be, murder. The film is remarkably faithful to Annie Proulx's spare and touching story, with appropriately sensitive added exposition of the effects on Jack and Ennis's wives and families. It was as exhilarating and heartwrenching the second time I saw it as it was on the first, but on the second visit I was much more able to notice the depth of nuance in all its aspects -- writing, performance, direction, editing. I find that I'm still moved almost to tears that such a truthful story has been so well told. I doubt that my second viewing will be my last; I hope that even hardened hearts might be able to understand if not identify, and perhaps soften a bit.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JoeU.Jan 6, 2006

Great story, intelligent script, perfect directing, awesome visuals, and memorable acting. In short, it has everything; what filmmaking ought to always be.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AndrewF.Jan 7, 2006

the few criticisms of this film seem to be falling into two categories: opposed to the content (or just suspicious of the "gay agenda") or somehow opposed to the formal and aesthetic aspects. the former objection is obviously mostly bigotry the few criticisms of this film seem to be falling into two categories: opposed to the content (or just suspicious of the "gay agenda") or somehow opposed to the formal and aesthetic aspects. the former objection is obviously mostly bigotry or unfounded suspicion -- how or why would chinese director ang lee be a puppet of gay activism? no, he made this movie how he wanted to make it- not as a "big message" film. he is not a leftist or gay activist. the latter objection also makes little sense: either you're too callous and jaded to let the romance and tension have an effect, or you're expecting some kind of over-the-top romantic melodrama. i think the repressive austerity and meticulous cinematography matched the conent: these cowboys are very repressed and stoic. The film's relative dryness does not make it inert or lifeless but all the more subtly depressing and impactful. amazing performances, great film.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BrendaM.Jan 8, 2006

One of the best movies released to the theatre in a long, long time. Shows exactly how difficult it is to carry on a loving relationship when obstacles are in the way.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PedroB.Jan 8, 2006

I'm still too emotional to describe anything. Just saw it. It's raw, and difficult. I grew up in Wyoming, so I know what repression is about.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichaelK.Jan 8, 2006

Amazing! Absolutely spectacular! A must-see for everyone!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

thomf.Jan 9, 2006

The young actors were astonishingly real in their portrayal of a Real Life situation that is seldom heard or talked about. A real true love story, only difference is two men!! Jake should be nominated for an oscar also because these The young actors were astonishingly real in their portrayal of a Real Life situation that is seldom heard or talked about. A real true love story, only difference is two men!! Jake should be nominated for an oscar also because these characters would not work without his convincing performance. Much love to the screenwriters who had the insight to add to the shortstory and Mr. Ang for the creative guidence. Awesome movie!! Will hit you harder hours after viewing. (Love is a force of nature)… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KeithGJan 9, 2006

This movie was brilliant based not on it's story line but on the acting of Heath Ledger. I think the content will be in debate within the Marlboro sector, rednecks, rough necks, and anyone who has judgement against homosexuality. This This movie was brilliant based not on it's story line but on the acting of Heath Ledger. I think the content will be in debate within the Marlboro sector, rednecks, rough necks, and anyone who has judgement against homosexuality. This movie caught me by surprise because I felt the same as Heath's wife when she witnessed him and Jack engaging in more than just a handshake and hug when meeting each other, I too felt like seeing two manly men kissing quite foreign and odd. It was like imprinting a child's first view at something for the first time, you look with amazement and no judgement, simply something brand new, almost like seeing a martian. I can't remember what the scenery of the movie depicted because the character reference by Heath made you dumb found.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GregoryV.Feb 11, 2006

I viewed this film about a week ago and still can't seem to set aside the emotions which tore me apart then.There are too many superlatives to list. A testament to all who made the film possible. My psyche has been permanently altered.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChrissyFeb 11, 2006

Oh my gosh what a movie! Definately deserves the awards it's been getting recently. A whole new concept and direction for movies today. Sure to become a classic.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DalayF.Feb 11, 2006

I think this movie was extremely important becuase it shows that although society in which we live today is supposively free, fact is that is not since many people do not accept homosexuality. What society tends to do is reject them and I think this movie was extremely important becuase it shows that although society in which we live today is supposively free, fact is that is not since many people do not accept homosexuality. What society tends to do is reject them and ignore them rather than welcoming them. Therefore, freedom in this country is only an illusion.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

EugeneB.Feb 1, 2006

A magnificent film, definitely one of the best movies of the year and my personal favorite. Brokeback Mountain is very artistic, both in its technicalities (acting, writing, direction, cinematography, score) and in its heavy use of A magnificent film, definitely one of the best movies of the year and my personal favorite. Brokeback Mountain is very artistic, both in its technicalities (acting, writing, direction, cinematography, score) and in its heavy use of symbolism. Yes, it is deserving of all the accolades it has received. But the excessive awards attention for Brokeback Mountain is also a double-edged sword for the film. There's so much hype built around it that some first-time viewers will be searching for a different movie than what is actually shown. Brokeback Mountain is no gay Titanic or Gone With The Wind. It doesn't pack an emotional punch or manipulate you in ways most mainstream romances do. Brokeback Mountain is a quiet, subtle love story about two men trying to cope with this "thing" that they share. It's impact is more of a haunting experience - the movie really works it's magic AFTER it is over. (I'm also happy to say that Brokeback Mountain is one of few films that actually gets BETTER upon each viewing.) And it's more than just a love story... Brokeback illustrates the pains of loneliness and regret as we watch these characters make choices that slowly tear their lives apart. The haunting questions of "what if?" and "all that could have been?" That is something everyone can relate to - straight or gay. Sometimes we make choices because they seem the most logical. But in the long run, are those choices really worth the suffering and regret? Great, great movie. (By the way, anyone who sees Brokeback Mountain as contrived propaganda or something with an agenda is CLEARLY missing the point of this film.)… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PatriciaFeb 1, 2006

I cannot stop thinking about this movie. It is an incredibly emotional and bittersweet love story. Heath and Jake are brilliant, and both deserve an Oscar. I highly recommend it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

WinnieP.Feb 10, 2006

Undeniable the best of year.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

LarryB.Feb 14, 2006

The best movie in recent memory. One could feel the longing Ennis & Jack had for each other, but were unable/unwilling to express. The ending felt haunting in that Ennis finally realized what he had missed and lost.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

stephenc.Feb 14, 2006

Wonderful.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

WandaM.Feb 15, 2006

This was a amazing movie. I cried my heart out. I was hoping that they ended up together.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AdamHFeb 19, 2006

Why do people come in here and rate a movie a 0 when it is obvious they never saw it? I mean, when you call homosexuality "sick" in your review, then what question comes to mind is, "Why would you spend $8.50 on a movie that you know is aboutWhy do people come in here and rate a movie a 0 when it is obvious they never saw it? I mean, when you call homosexuality "sick" in your review, then what question comes to mind is, "Why would you spend $8.50 on a movie that you know is about two gay men, when you are obviously going to be offended by it and not like it?" I doubt they saw it at all.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichaelF.Feb 22, 2006

One of the best movies I've ever seen.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

SueM.Feb 23, 2006

I adored everthing about this movie; it's brilliant acting, directing, cinematography. I haven't been moved like this by a movie in years. The sadness and heartbreak stayed me with for weeks and weeks. I was totally transporting I adored everthing about this movie; it's brilliant acting, directing, cinematography. I haven't been moved like this by a movie in years. The sadness and heartbreak stayed me with for weeks and weeks. I was totally transporting into the story, and that is my measure of a winner.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

K.S.Feb 26, 2006

The best movie all year, if not the best movie i've ever seen. i cried for hours after seeing this movie, it was honest and heartwrenching. to all those who called it "sick" or "disturbing" , no one else wants to hear your gay hatingThe best movie all year, if not the best movie i've ever seen. i cried for hours after seeing this movie, it was honest and heartwrenching. to all those who called it "sick" or "disturbing" , no one else wants to hear your gay hating views, it revolts me. its a love story and a movie everyone can learn something from.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MichealL.Feb 3, 2006

I went to see it with my girlfriend and I thought it was tastefully done. In the first "gay scene" I got a bit squirmish because it was kind of intense but after that the story line became more focused on the two cowboys' LOVE for each I went to see it with my girlfriend and I thought it was tastefully done. In the first "gay scene" I got a bit squirmish because it was kind of intense but after that the story line became more focused on the two cowboys' LOVE for each other and the obstacles they faced trying to be together. It really took me by surprise because I thought it'd be too hardcore for my taste but it was eye opening and gave me a new perspective on gay male relationships. That is, that there's more too them than just frequently, irresponsible sex. I know that it goes against Christian ethics but it can't hurt to at least try to understand the message the film tries to deliver.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BreanneH.Feb 3, 2006

Best movie i've seen in a long time, it was so sad, and so good. THe acting was amazing.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

CristhianX.Feb 3, 2006

I 've no words.. It's a great film.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

YuriB.Feb 4, 2006

A true masterpiece.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

SteveL.Feb 4, 2006

One of the most memorable films I've ever seen. I woke up three days in a row thinking about the film. It was both disturbing and hopeful. The filming was smooth and seamless from start to finish. This film is why I go to movies.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RickD.Feb 6, 2006

The future will show this to be a classic that will be remembered when the other films currently gaining accolades are long forgotten.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

OdinMar 11, 2006

Loved it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PaigeN.Mar 16, 2006

This was a tragedy as some people noted, but not fulfillying their committments to their families was only a small part of the tragedy. The true tragedy was that these men did not get the chance to have a fulfilling loving relationship with This was a tragedy as some people noted, but not fulfillying their committments to their families was only a small part of the tragedy. The true tragedy was that these men did not get the chance to have a fulfilling loving relationship with one another because of society's old-fashioned, moronic social taboos. If these men had been free to be with one another, they would have never hurt their wives or children. Superb acting, superb direction, beautiful scenery, and an utterly enthralling story. Kudos to the courage of all the people it took to make this story come to the big screen.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

NicoO.Mar 23, 2006

Faultless. Excellent performances and direction - Ang Lee fully deserves that Academy Award.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ClarenceC.Mar 5, 2006

Beyond any temporary hoopla about "gay cowboys" and the much-reported consternation in the American heartland over 2 men kissing and doing whatever-else-in-the-world-two-guys-can-do-together-on-a-cold-night-in-a-tent-on-a-mountain), this is, Beyond any temporary hoopla about "gay cowboys" and the much-reported consternation in the American heartland over 2 men kissing and doing whatever-else-in-the-world-two-guys-can-do-together-on-a-cold-night-in-a-tent-on-a-mountain), this is, at its core, a hauntingly beautiful yet painful love story. It is a story of what might have been (and what, in my opintion, SHOULD have been), and a very human story of the pain we bring ourselves when we deny our hearts' most primal desire: to love whom that heart directs us. This film will surely outlast any contrived or real "shock and awe" to be remembered as a real trailblazer, and long noted as the achingly exquisite piece of art that it is, whether or not it wins even one Academy Award!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GeorgeH.Mar 6, 2006

Great story & picture that bring the world a step closer to facing the reality of sexual orientation. Regardless of who you are or what you do, love between two human beings are sacred and will show through all hardship, time and all Great story & picture that bring the world a step closer to facing the reality of sexual orientation. Regardless of who you are or what you do, love between two human beings are sacred and will show through all hardship, time and all obstacles. True love will never die.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChrisMar 8, 2006

Absolutely compelling. The best love story in movies to date. Enjoyed everyone's performance and this film has stuck with me for days. It opened up a place in my heart that I had forgotten about.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GianfrancoN.Mar 9, 2006

A beautiful and tragic story of a love denied by society, set in 1963 Wyoming. A stunning performance by the actors; an incredible script; Ang Lee at his best. It tore my heart. The best movie I have ever seen. Haunting and moving.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ManoloM.Apr 12, 2006

Extraordinary film...from the direction, to performances, screenplay, cinematography, music. Defenetely is an all-in-one movie, jaja. Hope every one enjoy this love story and must of all open the door of tolerance and acceptance.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

CoreyS.Apr 13, 2006

A classic film destined to be talked about for years. While some complained that it was too slow, inexpressive, or there wasn't enough lead up to the love between Jack and Ennis, many of us thoroughly appreciated the complexities being A classic film destined to be talked about for years. While some complained that it was too slow, inexpressive, or there wasn't enough lead up to the love between Jack and Ennis, many of us thoroughly appreciated the complexities being masterfully woven for us on the big screen. I guess people want Splendor in the Grass type love, or loud verbalizations of "Oh Honey! I love you so!" or more sex, or crying scenes maybe. Such a thing would totally defeat a central theme of this film; the point was that these were two humans falling in a love that they couldn't speak of, and didnt' fully know how to explain. Hello? Wasn't that the point? But the fact that they reignite and can't forget each other only confirms the power of their love. I can't believe (well actually I can) the poster on here who said he hadn't seen the film until all "the buzz" goes away, then goes on to give the film a negative review. Its no wonder the real Jack and Ennises of the world feel they have to hide their love. This is not just some move about men who can't express themselves. Unfortunately, there are many people who the art of subtley is completely lost on, not to mention the inability to grasp what a complex film is. Some of us go the movies to experience a story, not just be "entertained" as one person said. If we want that, there is plenty out there. Its sad that every emotion or experience has to be verbalized in order for people to get it. I guess this is probably the reason why some people like Crash so much, it does all of your thinking for you. I guess the studies that say fewer and fewer Americans read anymore is true; reading makes a person think, and that increases critical thinking skills and that effects everything else we do, even how we view films. Kudos to Ang Lee and everyone involved in this film, for giving what many of us long for, a deep, thought provoking cinematic experience so masterfully woven and told.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ElizabethC.Apr 24, 2006

This is a great movie. Even though the graphic material is hard to digest for some people, it makes the movie very real. In real life you dont candy coat your passion in the bedroom. This was a beautiful movie and I have much respect for This is a great movie. Even though the graphic material is hard to digest for some people, it makes the movie very real. In real life you dont candy coat your passion in the bedroom. This was a beautiful movie and I have much respect for Jake and Heath for daring to take such a huge step as professionals for their career. We will not soon forget this movie.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BallerinaApr 4, 2006

Brokeback Mountain is a beautiful and touching story of love denied by society. I saw it a few weeks ago, but I still can't get out of my head its unforgettable lines, the breathtaking scenery, the haunting music, the stunning Brokeback Mountain is a beautiful and touching story of love denied by society. I saw it a few weeks ago, but I still can't get out of my head its unforgettable lines, the breathtaking scenery, the haunting music, the stunning performance by the actors. The story and the characters are so realistically drawn that it feels like they did really exist. It's outrageous Brokeback Mountain didn't win the Oscar as best film, best cinematography and best actor. One of the greatest film of all times.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DaleK.Apr 4, 2006

A gut wrenching masterpiece of a movie. This film pefectly portrays the mood and meaning of Annie Proulx's story in every way!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JakeTApr 4, 2006

Gays do make for a good story.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

cmleeApr 6, 2006

Ground-breaking exploration of homophobia and self-hatred reinforced by rural "so-called 'christian' culture of repression of all things different that the dominant......

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DSiglerApr 6, 2006

I hope that everyone who has a problem with this movie takes a really hard look at who they really are and see if they are open to how others may want to live their lives. It is not for us to judge. If being gay is wrong they will answer for I hope that everyone who has a problem with this movie takes a really hard look at who they really are and see if they are open to how others may want to live their lives. It is not for us to judge. If being gay is wrong they will answer for it some day but we are not powerful enough to judge. Let people live their lives they way they want. All of the critics of this film seem to be put off because of the relationship between two men. Well get over it. Life may not be the fairy tale you want it to be. Acceptance is the key to freedom. Why is that so hard for people to understand?? This is not the left trying to make a statement. This is real life. Deal with it. This was a great story for what it was like during that time for two men to love each other. As Americans we should be ashamed for the way gays were treated and are still being treated. I say live and let live.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RiverR.Apr 8, 2006

This movie has moved into my conciousness and shows no sign of looking for the exit. I'll likely pull it out at times, not unlike Ennis' and Jack's reunions, and put my emotions through their reps again. By the way, someday This movie has moved into my conciousness and shows no sign of looking for the exit. I'll likely pull it out at times, not unlike Ennis' and Jack's reunions, and put my emotions through their reps again. By the way, someday more people will realize that this isn't a GAY love story....it's a story.....a story with power and sensitivity. Even if you're not presently willing to see this movie, trust me, someday you will watch it, and, whether you admit it or not, it will touch you deeply. This motion picture touched me in so many ways and on so many levels; still, it's done subtly yet powerfully without going for shock value or making a direct statement. The performances by all the cast are sublime and, yes, everything you've heard about Mr Ledger's portrayal is true and I say this without meaning to diminish Mr Gyllanhal's work or that of the other supporting players. Beautifully done! All this is, of course, the very apparent result of Mr Lee's incredibly gifted interpretation of Ms Proulx's short story. What a gift!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TomMillerApr 9, 2006

I was not too interested in seeing this movie because I thought it would be a story based on homosexual love. There are many other things I took from this movie - people who are in relationships they do not want to be in, how society canI was not too interested in seeing this movie because I thought it would be a story based on homosexual love. There are many other things I took from this movie - people who are in relationships they do not want to be in, how society can make us comply with thing against our human nature, and how lonely some people can be. If you apply these concepts to oppression around the world, not just to homosexuals, you will be moved by this movie.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TinaArenaMay 21, 2006

An amazing piece of cinema. Simply brilliant!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MikeL.May 28, 2006

I give it a TEN...Best movie I have seen in ages, Have to say plot is strong in subject matter, but to some a reality, which I know understand.. Both Jack and Ennis took thier roles very serious and did and excellent job playing thier I give it a TEN...Best movie I have seen in ages, Have to say plot is strong in subject matter, but to some a reality, which I know understand.. Both Jack and Ennis took thier roles very serious and did and excellent job playing thier characters. A great love story of forbid love with a tragic ending. Just goes to show what a high price one has to pay for true love and happiness or in thier case no love or happiness. I think more people ( men and women) should see this movie with an open mind and heart with hopes of a better understanding of the true meaning of love. teach us what life is really all about, and that's love and understanding. Hey, cowboys are people too.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

CTJul 29, 2006

I just watched this movie after my Aunt told me about how good it was. At first I was a little hesitant, but went into it with an open mind! This is a wonderful love story and I am so glad I took the time to watch it! This movie protrayed a I just watched this movie after my Aunt told me about how good it was. At first I was a little hesitant, but went into it with an open mind! This is a wonderful love story and I am so glad I took the time to watch it! This movie protrayed a powerful message and as Jan D. said, a tear-jerker for sure!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MarcoC.Sep 9, 2006

Incredible, strong, extremely good acting, never-thought- it-could happen film, one of the best films ever done, and considered for a lot of people I know as a masterpiece. Heath Ledger, outstanding.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

sidewinder572Oct 20, 2007

The homophobic comments are quite sad indeed. Brilliantly shot, directed, written, and acted.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JeannieG.Jan 30, 2007

Straight, long married, over 60---and grew up in Montana, I was moved by this film more than by any other in years, Have seen it three times now and wouldn't mind owning DVD, which I rarely consider. The entire production was truly Straight, long married, over 60---and grew up in Montana, I was moved by this film more than by any other in years, Have seen it three times now and wouldn't mind owning DVD, which I rarely consider. The entire production was truly spectacular, from the haunting theme music (I bought the soundtrack) to the scenery, and all four principal actors deserved to win awards. Further, the film felt true to Annie Proulx's quietly gripping original short story,a beautiful piece of literature first published in the New Yorker, then reprinted in a collection of Wyoming Stories.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

SBApr 13, 2007

oh my god i have never fallen in love so quickly with a film in all my life!!
i have a new favourite film! it is unbelievable! the plot is gripping, the script is superbly written and the acting and chemistry is so realistic its hard tooh my god i have never fallen in love so quickly with a film in all my life!!
i have a new favourite film! it is unbelievable! the plot is gripping, the script is superbly written and the acting and chemistry is so realistic its hard to believe it didnt actually happen!!!
See this movie NOW!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KatMay 12, 2007

This was and still is one of the most powerfull, moving and touching movies of your times. Heather Leadger and Jake Gyllenhaal have some of the most amazing on-screen chemistry I have ever seen between two straight men. Beautiful in every This was and still is one of the most powerfull, moving and touching movies of your times. Heather Leadger and Jake Gyllenhaal have some of the most amazing on-screen chemistry I have ever seen between two straight men. Beautiful in every way... *Sighs*.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TJWMay 17, 2007

Despite not winning Best Picture, THIS will be the movie film students are studying 30 years from now, NOT Crash. You could write a 30-page college thesis on this movie.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KarenM.Jun 3, 2007

Captivating. Engrossing. Pulls you in like a strong rope around a steer and then commands your attention and your afterthoughts. This is most simply a tragic story about a pure, true love and the suppression of its expression. Gyllenhaal and Captivating. Engrossing. Pulls you in like a strong rope around a steer and then commands your attention and your afterthoughts. This is most simply a tragic story about a pure, true love and the suppression of its expression. Gyllenhaal and Ledger are both brilliant in their unbridled performances which capture the essence of the love bond between the men. It is so strong, that you know it will survive the scarceness of their meetings and death. Ang Lee is undoubtedly the finest living, working director in cinema, as the performances are reflections of his vision.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BrendaL.Aug 29, 2007

I watched the movie several times and I think that there should have been more love scenes between Jack and Ennes to show their true love and I did not want Jack to die, I wanted him and Ennes to finally be together but overall an excellent film.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MelSFeb 21, 2008

This movie is a masterpiece and it is beautiful in every way.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

DelilahV.Apr 20, 2008

I thought this movie was one of the most brilliant movies ever made. Everyone says "if it had been a man and a woman no one would have cared". That's the point! It's different. And beautiful.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

RobF.May 30, 2008

It took a while for me to watch this movie, I had been anticipating it for a long time, I ADORE Jake Gyllenhaal, so why couldn't I watch it as soon as it came out in the cinema!? in fact I waited for it to come out on dvd. I think its It took a while for me to watch this movie, I had been anticipating it for a long time, I ADORE Jake Gyllenhaal, so why couldn't I watch it as soon as it came out in the cinema!? in fact I waited for it to come out on dvd. I think its because I knew how it would end, and how much it would affect me, and it did. This movie will leave a lasting impression for a long long time.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AlS.Jul 12, 2008

Perfect in every literary aspect, superbly complemented by the musical score.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

JesusblackJul 24, 2008

Brokeback mountain is the 4th best film i've ever seen. it's amazing that ang lee, who created the hulk,(the worst movie i've ever seen), could create such an untimely and beautiful masterpiece. it makes me proud to be gay!!!

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

TomP.Dec 10, 2005

I am confident that this film will join the "canon" of memorable American films, one that will move viewers as much 40 years from now as on its opening day. Ang Lee has made a film that matches the best work of William Wyler's "the Best I am confident that this film will join the "canon" of memorable American films, one that will move viewers as much 40 years from now as on its opening day. Ang Lee has made a film that matches the best work of William Wyler's "the Best Years of Our Lives," and "The Heiress." Ledger gives a landmark performance that "wows" like Brando's in "On the Waterfront" and Dean's in "Rebel Without a Cause," Newman in "Hud," and indeed, Michelle Williams is as memorable as Patricia Neal's heartbreaking performance in "Brokeback" screenwriter McMurtry's "Hud." McMurtry has now written the screenplays for three great American contempoary Westerns -- "Hud," "The Last Picture Show," and now, in perhaps he and writing partner Diana Ossana's finest hour, "Brokeback Mountain." And finally, in a time when so few movies seem to be able to stand-and-deliver a gut-punching last line the likes of "Come on Jake, it's Chinatown," "Brokeback Mountain" contains the most richest last sentence of any film in a long, long time. It's the great writer Annie Proulix's words, slightly, sensitively repositioned in the narrative by McMurtry and Ossana and placed within a heartreching closing shot by Ang Lee and cinematogrpher Rodrigo Prieto. It moments like this, when every aspect of filmmaking comes together that reminds us why film is one of the greatest of the arts. Lee's film is one for the ages -- when, in future decades, the story won't appear particularly "controversial," like all great films, the emotional impact it has on viewers will continue to fee true and right.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

HeatherWDec 11, 2005

It's been over 24 hours, and I'm still feeling elated and devestated. Elated because I've been touched deeply by one of the most beautiful love stories I have ever known. Elated because of the raw courage and sensitivity and It's been over 24 hours, and I'm still feeling elated and devestated. Elated because I've been touched deeply by one of the most beautiful love stories I have ever known. Elated because of the raw courage and sensitivity and sheer brilliance that Gyllenhall and Ledger bring to this movie. Elated because I finally got to see one of my favorite writer's work *finally* done justice. But devastated. Just devastated. I won't say why, of course, because I don't want to give any spoilers. But all I can say is, if (and I do mean *if*) you think you can handle it without being a giggly child or a hung-up Christian conservative, please see this film. See it twice. Let it seep into your bones. Into your heart. Definitely the best movie of the year, and that's saying something.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

rays.Dec 11, 2005

A film in which more is said in the faces of the actors than in their dialogue. The pain in the film is cumulative and consequently profound. Ledger is a revelation and Gyllenhaal is impressive.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

germane.Dec 11, 2005

Best movie of the year.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AndyJ.Dec 11, 2005

Simply put, the best film of the year so far. Do I hear Oscar calling?

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ArnoldH.Dec 10, 2005

An unforgettable and haunting experience. I saw it yesterday and have not been able to stop thinking about it. This movie works on so many levels that it demands much reflection and repeated viewings. Acting, especially by Ledger, is superb. An unforgettable and haunting experience. I saw it yesterday and have not been able to stop thinking about it. This movie works on so many levels that it demands much reflection and repeated viewings. Acting, especially by Ledger, is superb. Not to be missed!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChrisR.Dec 12, 2005

So subtle, so powerful!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TracyB.Dec 12, 2005

Great acting and direction. It has stayed with me for days.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JamesCDec 12, 2005

I just saw this movie last night and I still can't stop thinking about it. It was one of the most thought provoking and moving film experiences I've had in recent memory. Ang Lee proves that he can tell a compelling love story I just saw this movie last night and I still can't stop thinking about it. It was one of the most thought provoking and moving film experiences I've had in recent memory. Ang Lee proves that he can tell a compelling love story without falling into the usual trappings of Hollywood formula. It isn't preachy. It doesn't fall into trite melodrama. It doesn't try to paint these guys as perfect heroes, but rather flawed humans caught in an impossible situation. Most importantly, it doesn't shy away from its depiction of same-sex love or the harsh realities of the time. It is truly is one of the most touching and realistic love stories ever told on film.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MarkWDec 13, 2005

A powerhouse movie that celebrates the pain and beauty of love as well as its universality.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AlexanderB.Dec 14, 2005

Must-see movie.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

peterr.Dec 14, 2005

One of the best movies i have seen.. It is very true to form when you truely love someone against the odds....Brokeback Mountain is a masterpiece of a film and i reconmend all to see. People of all ages should see this movie so they can One of the best movies i have seen.. It is very true to form when you truely love someone against the odds....Brokeback Mountain is a masterpiece of a film and i reconmend all to see. People of all ages should see this movie so they can understand the true feelings of love...when it is not acceptable in our society.. Both actors are supurb in and is some of the best work i have seen from Heath Ledger..An Oscar worthy performance. Touching , compeling, and pasionately approched.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

CharlesK.Dec 14, 2005

One of the best movies I've seen in years. It reminds me of the type of dramas that came out in the 70's, bold, well written and not trying to cater to the entire world. For the non ignorant people in the world this movie will move One of the best movies I've seen in years. It reminds me of the type of dramas that came out in the 70's, bold, well written and not trying to cater to the entire world. For the non ignorant people in the world this movie will move them deeply and make a statement about love that hasn't been said in a hetero movie in a long time. A study was done which found that most homophobes are the way they are because they are fighting repressed homosexual tendencies. This movie will bring them out in droves decrying it, but it shouldn't because it has more compassion and tact than most films. Heath Ledger deserves an Oscar hands down.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

[Anonymous]Dec 15, 2005

Peter Rainer said it best... These men found something that most people will never find...true love. It was absolutely the most convincing, passionate love story I have ever seen.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BlisterfishCafeDec 15, 2005

WOW! The very best film I've seen since "Powder". I felt as if I really knew these chracters... and that ain't easy these days. I recently scolded myself in a way that makes it difficult to get out and about...I'm glad IWOW! The very best film I've seen since "Powder". I felt as if I really knew these chracters... and that ain't easy these days. I recently scolded myself in a way that makes it difficult to get out and about...I'm glad I made it to this one! It was a lobster that burned my genitals and I just purchased a laxtex fist for my friend Gary this Christmas season. Be strong and enjoy this film.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

EdisonR.Dec 16, 2005

I think it´s the best film of the year. Thank you Ang Lee.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JohnDec 16, 2005

Great film. Very universal in its theme and true in its heart. Kudos to the director and screenwriter for keeping the focus on the relationships. It is truly a movie that everyone can relate to. It is about what might have been or what could Great film. Very universal in its theme and true in its heart. Kudos to the director and screenwriter for keeping the focus on the relationships. It is truly a movie that everyone can relate to. It is about what might have been or what could have been... if only... I think if you ask any adult if they have had a passion that they let slip away, you'd find that it's a common thread that many of us live with every day, gay or straight, black or white, male or female. I hope that this film brings people together in a deeper understanding and love of all humanity. God bless:-)… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KerryC.Dec 17, 2005

One of the best films I have seen all year. it was an emotional journey. It was a forbiddon love story and the movie was all about what was not said. Heath Ledger was incredible, well worth the money to go see it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JohnEE.Dec 17, 2005

Brilliant! Achingly Beautiful!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RyanDec 17, 2005

One of the most beautiful movies I've ever seen. The script, the cinematography, the directing, the acting. It deserves all the buzz and awards its getting. And as a straight man, I didn't see what all the fuss was about regarding One of the most beautiful movies I've ever seen. The script, the cinematography, the directing, the acting. It deserves all the buzz and awards its getting. And as a straight man, I didn't see what all the fuss was about regarding the man on man scenes.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GambitXDec 17, 2005

There are few movies that touch you the way Brokeback Mountain touches you. Hopefully it will show straight folks that being a homosexual is much much more than just sex... it's about love, and this movie shows more love in this There are few movies that touch you the way Brokeback Mountain touches you. Hopefully it will show straight folks that being a homosexual is much much more than just sex... it's about love, and this movie shows more love in this relationship than I have seen in any other film. and I wasn't a fan of Heath Ledger before... but after this, the man deserves an ovation.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RyanRDec 18, 2005

I have seen it twice already, and the fact that so much is conveyed on so many levels with minimal dialog says something right there. The emotional impact is felt long after the movie ends, especially when you realize that this is the way I have seen it twice already, and the fact that so much is conveyed on so many levels with minimal dialog says something right there. The emotional impact is felt long after the movie ends, especially when you realize that this is the way things were (and still are, for some) -- for people such as Ennis. Heath Ledger conveys more emotion without saying anything than I have seen anyone do in a long long time. The film is a fantastic piece of work.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ArmandoC.Dec 18, 2005

Ledger's performance stands right up there with the best of Brando, DeNiro, Penn or anyone else. Though Gyllenhaal can barely keep up, his work is not without its own charms and complexity. Only the most defended or closed-minded viewer Ledger's performance stands right up there with the best of Brando, DeNiro, Penn or anyone else. Though Gyllenhaal can barely keep up, his work is not without its own charms and complexity. Only the most defended or closed-minded viewer will leave the theatre without a broken, or at least dented, heart.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JeremyC.Dec 18, 2005

Beautiful, epic, stunning, heart-wrenching, honest. a defiant thumb in the eye of social conservatives. a landmark film that shatters stereotypes.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BobB.Dec 19, 2005

I knew this movie was going to kick me in the guts and it did. I haven't been able to shake it for two days. Ang Lee, Jake and Heath nailed it with so much tenderness and intensity. I'm encouraging all my straight friends to please I knew this movie was going to kick me in the guts and it did. I haven't been able to shake it for two days. Ang Lee, Jake and Heath nailed it with so much tenderness and intensity. I'm encouraging all my straight friends to please go see it so they can relate more to what gay men go through trying to find happiness where it's often not welcome.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

FernandoM.Dec 19, 2005

Deep view into human being at its best and worst. Lack of decision leads to tragic end, love however is the only thing that remains and prevails.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

SethB.Dec 19, 2005

I am not gay, but not homophobic. I understand the human heart, so I loved this movie. I feel sorry for those who can't get over themselves enough to just enjoy a movie. Truly brilliant!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BrianR.Dec 21, 2005

One of the most emotionally complex movies I have ever seen. The movie speaks to universal feelings of love, loss, and choices. I saw it 24 hours ago and I am still thinking about it nonstop.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

RichN.Dec 21, 2005

While "Brokeback" is an absolutely devastating cinematic experience, it was nevertheless the cinematic experience of the year. It is on the order of "Ordinary People" on the depressing scale. It is masterfully paced, shot, and told along While "Brokeback" is an absolutely devastating cinematic experience, it was nevertheless the cinematic experience of the year. It is on the order of "Ordinary People" on the depressing scale. It is masterfully paced, shot, and told along with socking you in the gut. And even in spite of the movie's dour undertone, it is an exceptional love story that resembles "Titanic" without the overwrought pretentiousness and special effects. Give Gyllenhal the Oscar now for Supporting Actor, and don't forget at least nominating Williams and Ledger in Supporting Actress and Actor.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GlennDec 20, 2005

Beautifully shot. Powerfully restrained. Every performance is stellar. Ang Lee is that rare director who trusts the audience and allows subtext to stand on its own without hitting you over the head. Very moving. That said, I did wish it had Beautifully shot. Powerfully restrained. Every performance is stellar. Ang Lee is that rare director who trusts the audience and allows subtext to stand on its own without hitting you over the head. Very moving. That said, I did wish it had lingered a few more beats at the saddest points to allow us to feel more along with the characters, but maybe that's why the characters continue to live in your imagination. The score is also beautiful, simple and never intrusive. (Only real complaint: the swiftly-implied sex between the leads was only depicted animalistically, never lovingly/tenderly. An inaccurate, unfortunate stereotype.) See this movie on the big screen!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

LaurenVDec 20, 2005

It is about time that a movie like this was made. Shame on the few professional movie reviewers who could not come off their high horses to appreciate its power and beauty. A truly sublime film with great performances all around.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

Brokeback Mountain

User Reviews