Middle-earth: Shadow of War

 PlayStation 4
User Score
4.9

Generally unfavorable reviews- based on 1686 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 665 out of 1686
  2. Mixed: 265 out of 1686
  3. Negative: 756 out of 1686
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. RistoH
    Oct 18, 2017
    10
    Alright, most of the reviews complaining about microtransactions have simply not played the game, or at least are not good at the game. I played the first game, Shadow of Mordor through twice 100% in less than the time i've already spent on one playthrough of Shadow of War. (EDIT: I forgot to mention that i also played all of the DLC through in that time.) And frankly, i must say thatAlright, most of the reviews complaining about microtransactions have simply not played the game, or at least are not good at the game. I played the first game, Shadow of Mordor through twice 100% in less than the time i've already spent on one playthrough of Shadow of War. (EDIT: I forgot to mention that i also played all of the DLC through in that time.) And frankly, i must say that Shadow of War is better, in every way that it can be. The graphics are nice, the game runs better, there's no longer these useless or annoying sidequests, but they are replaced with actual, interesting story content. The nemesis system is better in every way, and helping your followers feels good, (even though after you've conquered all of mordor you have little connection to your followers anymore.) The game is basically just better in every way. God i loved the Nazgul fights.
    But never in those over 50 hours of gameplay did i experience an impassable paywall where i either have to grind for 50 hours or pay money to get through act4. I actually spent an hour per area, hunting for good captains, assigned warchiefs and upgraded my fortresses with the money i had gathered throughout the game, (and i spent about 50 000 miriam on lootboxes just to see what i'd get at lower levels)
    Having upgraded all my forts to a the fullest extent i could, in less than 5 hours of gaming i started playing the sieges. Oh damn, i just won, and they didn't even breach a wall. Damn well i guess it will get harder. But it never did, i just dominated orcs during the sieges always getting the max level guys i could. You get a level per siege so keeping up with the enemy isn't a problem.
    I only lost 2 sieges and those were because of my own error, and not because of the level of my fort or my followers.
    Not once in my playthrough did i face a paywall or even notice the microtransactions.
    I also saw someone complaining that their followers started dying all the time, well that's because you didn't go revive them or you just generally didn't look after them. Never was a problem for me.

    All in all the game was totally worth the money i spent on it, i will buy the expansions to the game, because i absolutely loved the experience. All of you who are complaining about the microtransactions or the paywall or what have you, have not played the game or suck very deeply.    … Expand
  2. GoddamnVictor
    Oct 17, 2017
    0
    A sad thing about this game is that the lootbox controversy is completely taking attention away from how much this game is lacking in creativity as a sequel, the story is great for Tolkien fans but there is just SO MUCH GRIND to go thru, and there are so little improvements to core gameplay, graphics look the same, menus are still ugly as hell (I think they are the same of the past gameA sad thing about this game is that the lootbox controversy is completely taking attention away from how much this game is lacking in creativity as a sequel, the story is great for Tolkien fans but there is just SO MUCH GRIND to go thru, and there are so little improvements to core gameplay, graphics look the same, menus are still ugly as hell (I think they are the same of the past game even).

    The game deserves a hall of fame place on how little improvement they have made, it is the laziest sequel I have played ever and would really like my TIME back    … Expand
  3. Gamingking007
    Oct 17, 2017
    10
    So I take it that everyone complaining are extremely lazy gamers or bad gamers! The micro transactions are only for people who want to finish the game very quickly! If you play the game By completing all the side quests. Then you will have no need for micro transactions. The forts is in the single player game is extremely simple to take over. The only reason I would ever need to buy theSo I take it that everyone complaining are extremely lazy gamers or bad gamers! The micro transactions are only for people who want to finish the game very quickly! If you play the game By completing all the side quests. Then you will have no need for micro transactions. The forts is in the single player game is extremely simple to take over. The only reason I would ever need to buy the micro transactions is if you want all your orcs to say legendary on their name tags but other than that no need I got my army to level 326 and took down the fort easily which was like level 150 and this was in a more difficult region. So everyone complaining about the Micro transactions are either very lazy they’re not very good games. I understand that micro transactions can be frustrating if it hinders you from playing the game the way it was intended to be pLayed but there is no reason to complain about this game about that. If micro transactions Hinder you then I agree that it is totally corrupt especially if you’re buying a new game but that is not true with this game!This game is honestly not difficult ! This is one of the most amazing games ever created especially if you’re a massive Tolkien fan! Easily at this moment the greatest rpg of the year.… Expand
  4. Raistx
    Oct 17, 2017
    8
    I am writing this review while I am at about 1/3 completed. I am enjoying my experience very much. I love the latest version of the Nemesis system and having orcs going in great troubles to insult me. The fortress assaults are also quite enjoyable. I appreciate the storyline and the amount of LoTR lore in the game. There is a big fuss about the microtransaction element of the game, which II am writing this review while I am at about 1/3 completed. I am enjoying my experience very much. I love the latest version of the Nemesis system and having orcs going in great troubles to insult me. The fortress assaults are also quite enjoyable. I appreciate the storyline and the amount of LoTR lore in the game. There is a big fuss about the microtransaction element of the game, which I just completely ignore (I never pay microtransactions as a matter of principle).
    I now have to play the game in smaller amount to decrease my stress level due to these intense fights.    … Expand
  5. Thcenkdug
    Oct 17, 2017
    9
    Firstly, yes there are loot boxes, and yes, you can use real money to pay for them. You can also use in-game currency to buy the low end loot boxes. I played this game for a week which equates to about 40 hours of game play and got to level 60. I did the daily quests and earned enough online currency to buy the two starter loot boxes (Act 1 and Act 2) about 1300 coins. I received over 20Firstly, yes there are loot boxes, and yes, you can use real money to pay for them. You can also use in-game currency to buy the low end loot boxes. I played this game for a week which equates to about 40 hours of game play and got to level 60. I did the daily quests and earned enough online currency to buy the two starter loot boxes (Act 1 and Act 2) about 1300 coins. I received over 20 orcs, 8 xp boosts, and a handful of in game currency boosts. I used my XP boosts while I was playing the numerous main and side quests. Doing this I was able to skyrocket to level 60 and never feel like I was grinding, sometimes gaining two or three levels at once. Be careful though because they only last for two hours of real time, so make sure you use that time wisely. The only "grind" part was getting my orcs at a higher for the Stage Defenses of my Fortresses. This did take me about 5 hours to get all my fortresses leveled to my level. But, since then I haven't purposefully leveled a single orc, at worst during my siege defenses, I capture more powerful orcs and put them in place of the weaker ones. With all that said, the facial graphics during game play is the reason I gave this a 9. As for all the complaints about the loot boxes, I did not pay for a single one and am still having a great time.… Expand
  6. Goo4you
    Oct 17, 2017
    3
    While I've read the endless posts about microtransactions, these have seemed to lose all meaning in today's gaming ecosystem. Developers/publishers don't seem to care about the public outcry. In truth though, you don't need the boxes nor do you have to do anything but complete the content to beat the game and get through the narrative.

    What is god awful here is the thing everybody    While I've read the endless posts about microtransactions, these have seemed to lose all meaning in today's gaming ecosystem. Developers/publishers don't seem to care about the public outcry. In truth though, you don't need the boxes nor do you have to do anything but complete the content to beat the game and get through the narrative.

    What is god awful here is the thing everybody adored in the 1st title: The nemesis system. I personally found it a novelty in the 1st game, but here it is so overdone that it ruins the entire experience. Fine, hunt down a captain, that's good. He kills you and gets stronger, ok. Hunt him down for revenge, that's great. Have 6 captains "MAGICALLY appear" on top of that vengeance target and be all varying levels (I was level 2, that got killed by a lvl 9, then lvl10 and then was surrounded by 6 Lvl 5-15 captains). Not only that, but each, and, every, one, had, to, wax, poetic, about, how, they, were, going, to, kill, me. And yea this is an option you can turn off, but really I didn't think 6 FREAKING CAPTAINS WOULD JUST POP ON TOP OF ME!

    The menus are another unmitigated mess. They are so convoluted I honestly think the designer and programmer were drinking buddies and worked on them through all-night drunken binges. It's astonishingly bad. My eyes hurt fiddling around in them.

    You can take narrative liberties from time to time, but Shelob is the most ham-fisted insertion to grace this series. The time scale for events are just completely out of sync with the LOTR. Minas Ithil is long gone by the time of the war of the ring. The argument could be made that well, we are at those events. Well then, explain Gollum being in Mordor from the 1st title! He wouldn't have been there! Hell, he'd still be wallowing in a freakin cave under Moria!!

    The worst part of all of this..is the entirety of the game...is just boring. You are doing the same handful of things over and over and over and OVER! It's just one giant collect-O-thon within the confines of the map, and really silly online "vendetta" targets for some reason. You get gear....but....it's just gear. Nothing about this is needed, it's just PADDING!

    Bloat, bloat and lazy programming with a shamble of a writer's team make up this title. Couple that with a ridiculous terms of service agreement (Forced Arbitration with an option to opt out in 30 days) and the fact if you don't accept the terms of service, you can't play the game and you can't return the game (because you opened it). It's a damn catch 22 and it's gotta be illegal!

    Pass on this, pass on this hard. If I can avoid it, I will steer clear of ANY WB game in the future.    … Expand
  7. basicbic
    Oct 17, 2017
    0
    Full of predatory forced in-game purchases. This game developer lacks the integrity required to get your business. Avoid this game and any other game released by Warner Bros. at all costs.
  8. DeadlyLemming
    Oct 17, 2017
    4
    Amazing underlying gameplay which makes it all the more heartbreaking that they leave a large amount of fun items and orcs exclusively for people who pay extra real money. Its like they tried to make the normal game as underwhelming as possible (for a game with such potential) so that you would have to buy golden/mithril chests just to have unique loot with any amount of flair. Sadly theAmazing underlying gameplay which makes it all the more heartbreaking that they leave a large amount of fun items and orcs exclusively for people who pay extra real money. Its like they tried to make the normal game as underwhelming as possible (for a game with such potential) so that you would have to buy golden/mithril chests just to have unique loot with any amount of flair. Sadly the loot/market system itself is also so cumbersome it is undoubted the game would be better off without it.… Expand
  9. KaptainKrunch
    Oct 17, 2017
    9
    To be honest I have no idea what game these people with negative reviews are playing. I'm about 608 hours in and I have yet to even visit the micro transaction marketplace. ALSO, I have yet to hit a single grind wall where i can't level.

    Even if I play for an hour or so I usually go up at least one level and receive 3-5 pieces of good loot. Micro transactions in this game are like a    To be honest I have no idea what game these people with negative reviews are playing. I'm about 608 hours in and I have yet to even visit the micro transaction marketplace. ALSO, I have yet to hit a single grind wall where i can't level.

    Even if I play for an hour or so I usually go up at least one level and receive 3-5 pieces of good loot. Micro transactions in this game are like a bottle of ketchup on the table of a steakhouse; its really there to be considerate, no one actually expects you to use it.

    If you are re-considering playing this game I IMPLORE you to drown out the negative user reviews. I've been both a gamer and LOTR fan for 10+ years and I absolutely love this game. 10/10 would recommend, 10/10 will be playing for dozens of hours in the coming weeks. (only gave 9/10 because I don't believe in perfection)    … Expand
  10. bprotond
    Oct 17, 2017
    8
    Every single reviewer here has not played the game and is just complaining about the loot boxes. The game can be played and finished without the use of the lootboxes, all they give you is better gear and some legendary lords to build an army with. Although I dislike the idea of the lootboxes, people are blowing this out of proportion.
    i just completed on nemesis difficulty without ever    Every single reviewer here has not played the game and is just complaining about the loot boxes. The game can be played and finished without the use of the lootboxes, all they give you is better gear and some legendary lords to build an army with. Although I dislike the idea of the lootboxes, people are blowing this out of proportion.
    i just completed on nemesis difficulty without ever putting any extra money into the game and the "grinding" is not necessary, playing the game normally had me at lvl 43 at the final zone where the recommended level was 40.
    The game is pretty much a copy of the previous one with many improvements. Every single upgrade you get when leveling has 3 subcategories to improve the skill. Killing captains now drops gear instead of runes (runes have been simplified and are dropped by regular orcs), 5 regions compared to the 2 of the previous game.
    The game is really fun and as a LotR fan i thoroughly enjoyed it, even if the story doesn't really follow actual LotR lore.    … Expand
  11. Asaliah
    Oct 17, 2017
    4
    Huge fan of the first one, I bought this one day one.

    It was a huge mistake: -It's exactly the same game -It's full of bugs (character stuck, bugged quests,...) -It's super repetitive -90% of skills are useless -Can't skip Orcs' speech (trust me after several hours you CAN'T stand it anymore) -Graphics are very meh -I'm ok with lore "twists" but here the story is super basic and    Huge fan of the first one, I bought this one day one.

    It was a huge mistake:
    -It's exactly the same game
    -It's full of bugs (character stuck, bugged quests,...)
    -It's super repetitive
    -90% of skills are useless
    -Can't skip Orcs' speech (trust me after several hours you CAN'T stand it anymore)
    -Graphics are very meh
    -I'm ok with lore "twists" but here the story is super basic and poorly written
    -And the cherry on the cake: microtransactions, it's totally UNACCEPTABLE
    -Secondary characters are super cliche

    If you don't pay, either use a cheat engine to finish it or stop midway and watch the real end on youtube. It's litteraly dozens of hours of grinding.    … Expand
  12. Kaisermena
    Oct 16, 2017
    5
    El juego en su campaña en solitario sigue siendo tan bueno como el anterior, o aún mejor, de eso no tengo queja. Pero en cuanto al multijugador y a los micropagos y las cajitas aleatorias, creo que era algo totalmente innecesario en este tipo de juegos. Un gran trabajo dañado por la avaricia y las políticas abusivas. Sigan así Warner Entertainment que van por buen camino
  13. miszcz2000
    Oct 16, 2017
    9
    The game is awesome! Brutal and addictive. More of the same but better and bigger. If you don't like the micro transactions then don't buy the damn loot boxes. They're quite useless anyway.
  14. Toren95
    Oct 16, 2017
    0
    Pre-order canceled when i found out about the loot boxes, gonna wait for a used game in gamestop.
    Grind are heavily increased because of this, the "true" ending is sort of locked behind a paywall, because you have to spend alot of time grinding for legendary armies
    #NoMoreMicrotransactions
  15. Veronus
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    Haven't spent a penny on micro-transactions. This game rules them all and it's easily a 10. Such a great job making this game EPIC and addictive. Unfortunately too many people have seen that you can buy orcs and items (if you choose) and assume that it's a pay to win. Simply put that is dead wrong. Nothing is going to make this game EASIER, and while it might be nice to have some extraHaven't spent a penny on micro-transactions. This game rules them all and it's easily a 10. Such a great job making this game EPIC and addictive. Unfortunately too many people have seen that you can buy orcs and items (if you choose) and assume that it's a pay to win. Simply put that is dead wrong. Nothing is going to make this game EASIER, and while it might be nice to have some extra gear or orcs around they are not required, simple jump off the tower go recruit and don't spend $$. A great job of giving players a choice has blown back in Monolith's face because of a fickle demographic. Don't miss out on this game because of cosmetics. Trust Me.… Expand
  16. mako34
    Oct 16, 2017
    0
    Od dawna bylo wiadomo, ze gra bedzie miala mikrotransakcje, ale jesli nie mozna jej bez nich przejsc, to znak, ze czas cos z tym zrobic. To jest absolutnie paskudne.
  17. roundtablegamer
    Oct 16, 2017
    6
    Talion is back in a continuing adventure in the land of Mordor. Following the events of Shadow of Mordor, Monolith Productions and Warner Brothers brings us Shadow of War. Does Shadow of war rule middle earth or should it have been burned and destroyed along with the rings? Let us find out.

    Story: The story picks up right from the events of Shadow of Mordor you are back playing as    Talion is back in a continuing adventure in the land of Mordor. Following the events of Shadow of Mordor, Monolith Productions and Warner Brothers brings us Shadow of War. Does Shadow of war rule middle earth or should it have been burned and destroyed along with the rings? Let us find out.

    Story: The story picks up right from the events of Shadow of Mordor you are back playing as Talion and Celebrimbor. In the very beginning of the game, we see them making a new ring to fight against Sauron and the Azgul. There is a war happening in middle earth in this installment of the series between the Orcs, Uruks and Olacs and the Minas Ithil. You take sides with Minas Ithil to help them win the war; however, down the line you find out there is a traitor in the Minas Ithil. In the story, we run in to new characters that have an effect in the story like Shelob, a woman who can turn in to a big spider, which is cool in my opinion. She takes Celebrimbor as a hostage in exchange for the ring you created, so that she can take on Sauron herself. As the story continues, it became more confusing because there was so much going on with all the different characters and became less interesting as I progressed through it. There are four different acts throughout the story the second being by far the longest.

    Game play: The game play in Shadow of War is pretty much the same as the first one but with more RPG elements. However, it adds a few things as well; we still have the fighting style that we have seen in the Batman series. One thing I really enjoyed and found very annoying at the same time was the fortress raids. In order to progress through some of the story you need to take over these fortresses to clear the region. While doing some of these missions you feel like your weapons are never strong enough to defeat all the captains at one check point, but luckily I was able to beat this game without using the micro transactions. Throughout the game, you will brawl, use stealth, manipulate and climb your way through Gondor. Another feature I found in this game that was a bit tedious was building your own army. How you do this is by recruiting captains after you weaken them and they help you when it is time to do a fortress raid and take on the overlord of the fortress. This is not mandatory but it helps when it comes to difficulty but I just found it tedious. Game play design is not great in this case and unfortunately is one of my biggest pet peeves when it comes to games. When you clear a camp, it should remain cleared and not have the enemies re-spawn. As you progress through the story you will run in to a fair bit of collectibles like artifacts and memories which are words that go to a poem that unlocks a door and behind that door is a high level armor or weapon.

    Conclusion: Shadow of War is a fun game but by the time, I hit the Twelve-hour mark I felt it became very lack luster, and I just wanted to be finished. It has lot of new additions to compare to the first one, but does not feel as polished. The story is far less interesting and has a lot going on with it between the characters and your character that is becomes hard to follow. With some game play flaws that are very noticeable it becomes very lack luster just a few hours in to the game I struggled just to finish it but the pay off at the end of the game was worth it.

    Shadow of War 6/10 Average    … Expand
  18. angryjack67
    Oct 16, 2017
    9
    Everyone whining in the reviews are either complaining without playing the game first, or are trash at the game. I played throughout the game only buying one chest (tutorial). I found the game to be really fun and nearly none of my orcs die. If you are complaining about the micro transactions (which are there to HELP you, not hinder you) then just get a trainer to assist you. I don'tEveryone whining in the reviews are either complaining without playing the game first, or are trash at the game. I played throughout the game only buying one chest (tutorial). I found the game to be really fun and nearly none of my orcs die. If you are complaining about the micro transactions (which are there to HELP you, not hinder you) then just get a trainer to assist you. I don't promote cheating but its better than giving a great game terrible reviews. The only reason i give it a 9/10 is because after beating the game there is not much to do, if anything. i think that additions to the multiplayer would greatly help out.… Expand
  19. Gittoplo
    Oct 16, 2017
    9
    The last time I played the game as religiously as this one was...the last Shadow of Mordor. I want to go back. I had the same feeling with Skyrim. I have only been playing for 3 days but I can already note that:

    a) The game is fun, the nemesis system has been improved. b) The graphics are amazing. Ok I am using HDR mode on LG Oled but on basic PS4. When I switched from game mode to    The last time I played the game as religiously as this one was...the last Shadow of Mordor. I want to go back. I had the same feeling with Skyrim. I have only been playing for 3 days but I can already note that:

    a) The game is fun, the nemesis system has been improved.
    b) The graphics are amazing. Ok I am using HDR mode on LG Oled but on basic PS4. When I switched from game mode to HDR, I was blown away. It looks good.
    c) The inventory menu is ok. Too small and unnecessarily complicated.
    d) Control system should be better. Sometimes I want to jump off and end up grabbing every wall in town while being hit by Tark hating scum. I mean come on.
    e) The story is solid and as an avid reader of all Tolkien books, I can do not mind them branching out. Tolkien is no Jesus. Calm down. It is all for fun and doesn't affect canon.
    f) Cannot make any comment yet on MTS as I have about 7000 Miriam and I still haven't bought any loot boxes. People say it is a grind in the end. Hell, I still haven't stormed first fortress and it is already a grind and I love it. Enjoy every boring mission.

    I have waited for so long for this game and I am not disappointed at all. I almost got put off by bad reviews but then I decided to make my own mind up and let's be honest, I was gonna buy it anyway. Who am I kidding? Buy and enjoy.    … Expand
  20. starceph
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    Mira, sabéis que? que como le dais 0 para bajar la media pues yo le doy el 10 para subirla. Segid llorando con vuestras pamplinas y vuestros "oh vamos a quejarnos de un juego que ni siquiera tenemos" que yo me lo estoy pasando bomba con el juego
  21. nicden70
    Oct 16, 2017
    10
    The game is amazing. Haven't touched a loot box. Have like 9000 mirian saved up. Not necessary to use. Like the first game but with cleaner gameplay. The story is fantastic. Lord of the Rings fan dream come true.
  22. mikecv434
    Oct 16, 2017
    9
    The is a great game!! There are microtansactions in Destiny 2(another great game),why isnt it getting slated too. Buy the game, play the game, enjoy the game. If you dont want to pay for the extras then dont bother.
  23. cristipvp
    Oct 16, 2017
    0
    This game dosent worth its money, bought it and played it, i mean it is decent, until the part that your followers dying like crazy, then u have to do more grinding to get new ones, the whole game is made so that u are forced to buy loot boxes with real money, that's the whole idea of the game, thats what make's it terrible. Talion control is very good but. Game content is very small....This game dosent worth its money, bought it and played it, i mean it is decent, until the part that your followers dying like crazy, then u have to do more grinding to get new ones, the whole game is made so that u are forced to buy loot boxes with real money, that's the whole idea of the game, thats what make's it terrible. Talion control is very good but. Game content is very small.... only thing that can make you play the game more hours after u finish it its the boring grinding… Expand
  24. Allthat
    Oct 16, 2017
    0
    First of all, you have to pay real money to see the games proper ending. What kind of game does that? WB is probably one of the stupidest publishers out there. This is a great game and had micro-transactions not been present, everyone would have bought it and the developers and WB would have made lots of money. Instead the decision to add micro-transactions gave the game tons of bad repFirst of all, you have to pay real money to see the games proper ending. What kind of game does that? WB is probably one of the stupidest publishers out there. This is a great game and had micro-transactions not been present, everyone would have bought it and the developers and WB would have made lots of money. Instead the decision to add micro-transactions gave the game tons of bad rep and it really hurt sales of this game. I hope some serious lessons were learnt from this.… Expand
  25. Bjaxe7
    Oct 15, 2017
    10
    This game is an absolute joy to play it has an amazing story and the game-play and especially the Nemesis System is Incredibly great those writing awful reviews clearly have no idea what this game is and have not played it , i personally haven't been able to put the game down since release day and i'm still enjoying the game after completing it. 10/10
  26. Dman32
    Oct 15, 2017
    0
    Ahem, earlier submission was a mistake. I was going to say... I just made this account to declare how much of a disappointment this game was. Bottom line is... the original gameplay would have been far better. As for the Nemesis system? I have seen absolutely no counts of there being any friendship between orc and Talion.
  27. Zortrax
    Oct 15, 2017
    0
    Loot boxed in a singleplayer game?? If the game was free I could agree with it.
    These stupid tactics to get all our money should forever be banned. I can only give a zero for this game.
  28. Unicus
    Oct 15, 2017
    1
    So much of this game is based on the first part, even the sounds have been taken over. It's like I'm playing the predecessor (which I have played A LOT), just with additional features. Once you get bored of the old game, do you really want to play the all new game, which is the same as the old? Apart from that, I feel like everything is overpriced, especially considering that so much hasSo much of this game is based on the first part, even the sounds have been taken over. It's like I'm playing the predecessor (which I have played A LOT), just with additional features. Once you get bored of the old game, do you really want to play the all new game, which is the same as the old? Apart from that, I feel like everything is overpriced, especially considering that so much has been taken from the previous version. The game itself (which can cost up to 100 USD, for the Gold edition), the all new buy in the single player game stuff, to show off to your not online friends... I have also played the game on Android, you can see the same overpriced "boost packages" there as well.… Expand
  29. noirfx
    Oct 15, 2017
    0
    The game is ok, just remove microtransaction and everybody will be happy. Gamers are not stupid, you can't put loot crates into 60$ single player game.
  30. theplayer23
    Oct 15, 2017
    4
    Although the game looks very good - MT MT MT - oh and MT MT and than some more MT -
    i am blessed that waited till my friend buy this game. now I know I will never buy it.
  31. Fhamil
    Oct 15, 2017
    0
    We need publishers/developers with the same mindset such as CDPR. It can be done people. Keep the faith and never support microtransactions in full priced games
  32. diegolavega77
    Oct 15, 2017
    10
    To all the other reviewers on about the game being pay to win ignore them, i played the whole base story in about 4 days and im through 50% of the grind without and i quote "Opening ANY lootbox" Not even a free currency lootbox nothing i have not touched it and the game is completely normal, i have been able to play normally, hell i even felt like i was in shadow of mordor for a while.JustTo all the other reviewers on about the game being pay to win ignore them, i played the whole base story in about 4 days and im through 50% of the grind without and i quote "Opening ANY lootbox" Not even a free currency lootbox nothing i have not touched it and the game is completely normal, i have been able to play normally, hell i even felt like i was in shadow of mordor for a while.Just more content and customisation. But whatever, since all these people have herd mentality opinions im just gonna leave it at this.… Expand
  33. Abdul701
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    I don't normally write reviews, but I think this has to be said: don't buy this game. If you buy this game, you are supporting one of the largest anti-consumer companies I've ever seen. I'd say that at this point, WB Games is even worse than EA.

    The only reward for the grind is more grind, lootboxes are unnescessary. Also microtranactions for loot things really?
  34. badgerryan19
    Oct 14, 2017
    9
    What a great game. They build on the first game and make it bigger and better. The nemesis system is more expanded and I love the different regions you can go to. The addition to the fort conquers and defends are great and some of the higher points of the game. The game has a more cohesive story was great as well, even though some of the lore isn't exactly right. The combat is more of theWhat a great game. They build on the first game and make it bigger and better. The nemesis system is more expanded and I love the different regions you can go to. The addition to the fort conquers and defends are great and some of the higher points of the game. The game has a more cohesive story was great as well, even though some of the lore isn't exactly right. The combat is more of the same, but it's great already. The upgrade level system is a little too much though. There is a lot going on and the menus can get a little confusing. Also the the gear is really awesome and it adds a little character to Talion. Now the whole thing about micro transactions. Don't buy them. All you get is orcs and that will beat the entire point of the game, so I understand the complains, but just do not buy them. If you liked the first go buy it.… Expand
  35. Hak
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    Game would be more enjoyable except for a microtransaction system integral to viewing the "true" ending of the game. Either grind the same things for 30 hours, or pay extra money. As a full priced, single player game, microtransactions are simply unforgivable.
  36. Chronos1
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    Not acceptable to make a awesome game and then load it up with greedy MT and lootcrates.. sure you don't have to buy them but it was clear they made the game extremely grindy towards the end in order to try to get lazy people to pay $$ for lootcrates.. this is why your game fails and guess what?? BF II will fail also because you **** never learn.
  37. jhonba
    Oct 14, 2017
    9
    para mi este juego no merece tan odio por las micro transacciones por que no afecta la campaña en vez de eso debería quejar se cosas mas importantes los se quejan no saben jugar es el equipo sino
    el jugador
  38. Mztt
    Oct 14, 2017
    9
    The game is fun but most of the people that give it a negative review never even played the game which is BS. Play the game before you judge it for something that's not affecting gameplay unless you use them. You can even get them for free if you care.
  39. Abysswalker89
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    I've been a gamer for about 20 years and seen publishers pull a lot of crap. But gambling in videogames as "lootboxes""?! This is a new low! Monolith sold their souls. Please boycott this game.. buy it second hand.. download it.. just don't support this crap please. Don't let this become the new industry norm
  40. Lunaheal
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    60 Euro for singleplayer game with microtransactions. Nuff said. We don't need microtransactions in singleplayer game. I hope Warner Bros. will understand it.
  41. c9sasza
    Oct 14, 2017
    9
    I just finished the game and won the platinum trophy in less than 40 hours, the box system is useless and pushed to the force do not understand the complaints and criticism, I do not support it but this system is not intrusive, this is the best game in the universe of Tolkien.
  42. easterfields
    Oct 14, 2017
    10
    Anything less than a 9 for this masterpiece is a crime against gaming! This whole package is a masterpiece. People whining and wetting themselves over the loot feature havent even played the fantastic story mode. Buy this game and appreciate it for what it is, one of the most fun adventures (and best looking) around. Warning though! The AI, aka Nemesis System, is scary good.
  43. javironcho
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    The game would be an enjoyable one if the ending wasnt behind a 50 hour boring grind or like $50, i quite enjoyed the first chapters, but reaching the end after pure useless grind is not worth it to me, i just returned it and i sugest not buying this until this microtransaction stuff is fixed or when the goty edition is at a really reduced price.
  44. bellerophon
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    Nothing interesting here, if you are a Tolkien fan the story is not canon and is not well narrated, the gameplay is 95% the same as ShadowOfModor from 2014, the graphics are even worse this time, which is a real shame, considering the powerful PC we can have these days. The microtransaction system (for a SP game, WTF ?) ends up burying the whole...
  45. gun21000
    Oct 14, 2017
    3
    Now, dear reader, do not get me wrong, I really loved this game in the beginning. From the get-go this game amazes everyone: the different type of Uruks that forces you to think more strategically, the new-and-improved Nemesis system that helps the player shape his/hers own storylines, and even though the main story might be slow and uninteresting in the beginning of the game, it doesNow, dear reader, do not get me wrong, I really loved this game in the beginning. From the get-go this game amazes everyone: the different type of Uruks that forces you to think more strategically, the new-and-improved Nemesis system that helps the player shape his/hers own storylines, and even though the main story might be slow and uninteresting in the beginning of the game, it does excite you and makes you want continue the story in the long run. However, when you reach Act IV, the joy that you felt quickly goes away when you come across what may be on of the most laziest design choice in the history of video games, and this is where those lootboxes that you heard so much about come into the play.
    Act IV is basically you defending the forts that you captured throughout the game. Now, it does not sound that bad, but when you realize that all the Uruk captains that you dominated are severely under leveled, that the attacking captains have a million strengths and maybe a few (or worse - just one) weaknesses, and the enemy forces can and will wipe the floor with your allies, the merriment that you once had will slowly fade away. Now, you may be saying: "Hey, it's just a difficulty spike at the end of the game, it doesn't sound that bad". No, you are wrong, and even after you defend all of the forts, guess what, YOU HAVE TO DEFEND THOSE FIVE FORTS ALL OVER AGAIN, AND THIS TIME, THE ENEMY CAPTAINS ARE EVEN TRIPLE THE LEVEL THAT YOUR CAPTAINS ARE. I didn't mention the best part: to acquire Uruks who are high enough level, you have to grind the **** out of the game, or JUST BUY OUR LOOTBOXES AND PRAY THAT YOU GET AN URUK THAT IS STRONG ENOUGH. So, this is why I think this game deserves a three, and I do not think I will be finishing this game.    … Expand
  46. GuerillaTaktics
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    Can we stop with the microtransactions already? This is a single player only game and they still managed to throw in a loot box mechanic, the only games where microtransactions are a good thing is when they are purely cosmetic.
  47. DennisN92
    Oct 14, 2017
    8
    Shadow of War the sequel to the epic game called Shadow of Mordor is a great game, and I haven't been able to put the controller away since purchasing it.

    This game is fun, but even I was skeptic towards buying the game seeing how a lot of talks were going around how the game is pay to win because of the loot boxes. That does not seem to be the case at the end of the day one can play    Shadow of War the sequel to the epic game called Shadow of Mordor is a great game, and I haven't been able to put the controller away since purchasing it.

    This game is fun, but even I was skeptic towards buying the game seeing how a lot of talks were going around how the game is pay to win because of the loot boxes. That does not seem to be the case at the end of the day one can play this game without loot boxes and enjoy it thoroughly, but purchasing them does make it easier to progress throughout the game.

    The game itself has an fantastic nemesis system that makes the game feel alive. As you are progressing through the story itself, it feels like you are creating your own story by killing orcs or making them follow you as one of your companions. They really developed the nemesis system into something great seeing how orcs that worked with you helped you capture a fortress might one day turn on you and conquer everything you worked so hard to get.

    The combat system is flawless, its pretty much the same as the previous game with a few new niches to it to make it a little bit better. Plus the new RPG elements of upgrading your hero is more in-depth and lets you form Talion and Celebrimbor into the hero of Mordor you want to be.

    The scenery is impressive, the regions are all beautiful and different, but sadly the gameplay is pretty much the same in every area except that some areas got one type of enemies with some power that isn't as usual in another province.

    I don't want to put the focus on microtransactions, they are there, and I don't like them, but I won't let them ruin my gaming experience, and I won't let them keep me away from playing a great game. If you ignore them and don't purchase them then maybe the gaming companies will stop putting them in the games, you might even boycott the game overall to make a statement towards the company group if you want to do that go for it.

    Either way, the game is much better than the first one and would probably get amazing reviews if it wasn't for the microtransactions being in there. It isn't something groundbreaking, but they took a working recipe from the first game and upgraded it into a worthy sequel.

    If you like what I read make sure to take a look at my blog for more reviews like this, just google therealzadeh and you will find it.    … Expand
  48. theomegamaster9
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    This game could have been great, but we should not judge based on potential. I loved the first game and i really felt that the nemisis system could become something truly unique and amazing after a bit of improving. Unfortunately, greed on an unbelievable scale ruined the experience completely. Call me whiner, but i truky believe that we need to take a stand here. This is not acceptable.This game could have been great, but we should not judge based on potential. I loved the first game and i really felt that the nemisis system could become something truly unique and amazing after a bit of improving. Unfortunately, greed on an unbelievable scale ruined the experience completely. Call me whiner, but i truky believe that we need to take a stand here. This is not acceptable. Locking the ending away behind a wall of pay-or-grind is absloutely dispicaple and taints the whole experience. I am sad that a series like this had to be the one to take the fall for the industry's growing greed but someone has to. This needs to stop.… Expand
  49. Trinisca
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    This game truly has all of the atrocious user-hostile and money grabbing features, which the game industry so pride themselves on. They have pushed it one nudge further in Shadow of War, and if you don't vote with your wallet and say no, they will continue this downwards trend.
  50. PsychedelicRA
    Oct 14, 2017
    0
    Shame Shame Shame ! I'm very disappointed. Down with the micro-transactions !!! This is a real shame. I wait so long to get this money starving machine.
  51. simzodom
    Oct 14, 2017
    10
    Miocro-transations, so what? It will not ruin the actual game itself. The $60 is for the base game. To all those saying that this game is similar to a mobile app, educate yourself. There are games out there where you run out of "energy points" and have to wait 5 minutes+ to continue playing. Most of which are games that actually don't even have any substance. Its literally "pay and go toMiocro-transations, so what? It will not ruin the actual game itself. The $60 is for the base game. To all those saying that this game is similar to a mobile app, educate yourself. There are games out there where you run out of "energy points" and have to wait 5 minutes+ to continue playing. Most of which are games that actually don't even have any substance. Its literally "pay and go to the next chapter, pay to get the weapon that does 5444 damage vs the sword you get in the game that does 77 damage." Those are extremes that "Shadow of War" doesn't go to. Mobile apps also rely heavily on what is referred to as a "whale". The 5% of the people who get the game for free who encompass more than half of the overall profit of. Nobody aims a gun to their head to make them pay.

    If you owned a company and could make a profit doing this, you would all do it. If you have willpower to play the game and not even look at the micro-transactions (buy the stuff with in game currency or actually earn your loot) then it would be a pleasant experience. It is NOT grindy in my opinion because it is fun to use some strategy and kill/capture the harder orcs. Also, you do not need to pay to beat the game, you do not hit a steep wall that you cannot get past unless you pay, you can enjoy it regardless. You guys are so annoying, giving this game 0/10's when it is actually an extremely fun game with plenty of things to do.

    I am willing to bet that most of you just trash the game, but then run straight to the store and buy it/enjoy it. You just want to complain for the sake of complaining. Play the game or don't review it.    … Expand
  52. Dimitris29
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    All the people are hating just cause of the microtransactions... They AREN'T required to complete the game. Stop b****ing and just enjoy the game. I've played for 5 hours so far and enjoyed every second. Story is good, gameplay is great, Nemesis system is fantastic. You complaining about the microtransactions isn't gonna change anything. Just play the game without them. Everything aboutAll the people are hating just cause of the microtransactions... They AREN'T required to complete the game. Stop b****ing and just enjoy the game. I've played for 5 hours so far and enjoyed every second. Story is good, gameplay is great, Nemesis system is fantastic. You complaining about the microtransactions isn't gonna change anything. Just play the game without them. Everything about SoW is great!… Expand
  53. Wallasuko
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    "I'm starvin. We aint had nothin' but maggoty fans for three stinking years!"
    "Mmmyeah! why cant we haves some money!... what about microtransactions? they're fresh!"
    "THEY ARE NOT FOR SELLING!"
    "What about loot boxes? they need those! Aww they look tasty!"

    "LOOKS LIKE SCAMS BACK ON THE MENU BOYS! RAAAAAHHHHH!"
  54. zkg03mjmk
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    I was looking forward to this game. I got the platinum trophy of shadow of Mordor on Ps4.
    But I won't buy this one. I say NO to MT and loot box on a single player AAA game, which is already $60.
  55. Lord_V
    Oct 13, 2017
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Middle-Earth: Shadow of War is not just the best Lord of the Rings game, it is one of the best games ever made. Easily GOTY 2017.
    It takes what made previous game, Shadow of Mordor, so great and doubles everything, at minimum. It does everything better.

    Story follows Talion (Troy Baker ) and Celebrimbor (Alistair Duncan), after the events of first game. They create new ring and aim to conquer all of Mordor. Same time, Dark Lord's forces gather all around them preparing for the final battle, that will decide the fate of whole of MIddle-Earth.

    Story is very well written and has several absolutely fantastic twist on the way to end. There are several absolutely marvelous characters and atmosphere is just what it should be.

    This is also pretty long game, but it is not too long or repetitive. Certain basic gameplay elements are there whole time. Nemesis system is the big deal and orcs come in so many diffrent shapes and skills. Combat does not get boring, it is very engaging, thanks to one of the best combat mechanics ever created. It is easy to learn but difficult to master.

    There is also so many those little things that really make this game that good. There is so many lore in there to be found. Many artifacts have story of their own and many very famous characters also have so much more story in them.
    I must say that the first time Witch-King of Angmar emerged from the shadows, was absolutely fantastic moment and boss battle is one of the best ever in so many ways. One thing I would change thou is the fact that his weapons are not that good. Sure, it is loyal to the source material, but I would have added a sword for him and made his weapon look more different from Saurons (like in the movie).

    To point out few of the worst things in game, first that comes to mind is pit fights. Those are so bad and boring. To a certain point those are not even that difficult but champion level is brutal and that is the point when you are furious when you see how incompetent those orcs are. They do not do what they are suppose to do.
    Also, micro transactions, cancer of gaming. It is there, but you do not have to use it. Sure, its makes the game easier but I managed very well without it.
    Also, there is certain community points in game, but I really do not care about those and paid little to no attention to it.

    There is so much I could comment about the game but the best way is to experience it yourself. This is masterpiece, nothing less. I got myself Gold version just to get all DLC Expansions. I am huge LotR fan and this game delivers so much.

    + Combat mechanic
    + Nemesis system
    + Story
    + Atmosphere
    + Talion / Troy Baker

    - Some minor details

    95/100

    Masterpiece    … Expand
  56. Jethalex
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    Don't be sheeps!! Bare some teeth and fight against a blatant and disgusting business practice. Don't let the industry ruin your hobby! Micro transaction like this is not okay!
  57. ArchibaldDuke
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    Micro-transactions in $60 single player games. $60 single player games with premium editions. With gold editions. With.. well, you understand. The greed obviously knows no limits.
  58. fredhorrigan
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    Because making a generic AssCreed clone with all of the flaws and none of the (few) strengths wasn't bad enough, now we need to put in a slot machine mechanic into a single player game and also profit from a dude's death.

    Cancer. Absolute cancer.
  59. ryanjolly1
    Oct 13, 2017
    7
    People giving this a 0 because there's microtransactions. If they actually played the game they would know they are absolutely unnecessary and you don't have to buy crates to win, it's not pay to win, it's pay to get stronger.
    The story is fantastic, which is obviously expected from one of the biggest franchises in modern history. The combat is still in my opinion the best combat out    People giving this a 0 because there's microtransactions. If they actually played the game they would know they are absolutely unnecessary and you don't have to buy crates to win, it's not pay to win, it's pay to get stronger.
    The story is fantastic, which is obviously expected from one of the biggest franchises in modern history. The combat is still in my opinion the best combat out there in gaming, very fast, very slick. The loot change was needed in my opinion from the first one. Where you just got runes to upgrade your gear, you now drop new weapons and armour, along with upgrades and runes to make them more powerful.
    The reason I gave this an 7 and not a 10 is simply because of it's price tag, yes, microtransactions and bugs. $60 for a single player game with very small multiplayer implementations, and that's only the base game. You'll need to fork out extra for expansions if you didn't buy the higher editions of the game. It's wrong to have microtransactions, but, they aren't something you need to buy to beat the game, yes you need to grind for better gear to be able to finish the game, but overall, it's something to give you a boost, nothing more. BUT, having said that, WB are a disgrace, and being a multi billion dollar publisher, it's very wrong to ask for MORE money like they are, especially when you have 3 editions of your game.
    So, to the people giving this game a 0 simply because of MT's, you're idiots who simply haven't even played the game, who're following the crowd because it's not "cool" to hate on video games without even using the brain you was given.    … Expand
  60. alijarchiie
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    Guys i got this game 2 days ago and i found it great in every aspect so why zero everything improved i love the story . I love to be like a commander as commander Shepherd in mass effect and guide my army it feels good . maybe some fighting mechanic in the first chapter was better but it is great as a final
  61. Leenat40
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    Cancer cancer cancer cancer! Loot boxes are cancer and this game is cancer. Please do not buy it, if you don't want to support trash like this. We need to put a foot down and say: NO.
  62. DrEm91
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    While I was extremely excited to buy Shadow of War, having absolutely loved Shadow of Mordor, I will not buy it. I am posting this review just to express my disgust at implementing micro transactions in a full fledged game. As a gamer, I will NEVER support companies that do this. While I know, this may not be developers fault or decision. I am sure they created an awesome game, I am sad toWhile I was extremely excited to buy Shadow of War, having absolutely loved Shadow of Mordor, I will not buy it. I am posting this review just to express my disgust at implementing micro transactions in a full fledged game. As a gamer, I will NEVER support companies that do this. While I know, this may not be developers fault or decision. I am sure they created an awesome game, I am sad to see their hard work overshadowed with this controversy. Maybe I will pick it up, after a patch that lets us experience the "real" ending without having to fork out money.… Expand
  63. Steve4500
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    For anyone with a genuine interest in this game it is worth noting straight away that you do NOT need to buy micro transactions in this game. For people who play the game how its supposed to be played (not powering through it and trying to complete in 15 hours) then your character and orc army will be more than capable to get through the final few acts.
  64. JoeJoeMcTwist
    Oct 13, 2017
    10
    Awesome game. I've put in about 10 hours of gameplay so far and this game is absolutely amazing. The combat has been built upon and refined in every aspect since ME:SOM. It feels as fluid as ever, with new and more brutal finishers.

    The story is ok so far but the nemesis system is where this game really shines. I haven't gotten too deep into the game yet but, I'm really enjoying the    Awesome game. I've put in about 10 hours of gameplay so far and this game is absolutely amazing. The combat has been built upon and refined in every aspect since ME:SOM. It feels as fluid as ever, with new and more brutal finishers.

    The story is ok so far but the nemesis system is where this game really shines. I haven't gotten too deep into the game yet but, I'm really enjoying the challenge of the hardest difficulty.

    Graphics look amazing. If you loved the first one, you will absolutely love this game. Don't listen to all the hate about MT, they're completely optional and they don't subtract from the experience at all.    … Expand
  65. nowisek
    Oct 13, 2017
    0
    Single player game for 60euro and microtransactions in it. Don't buy it. Not worth it. Pay to win. Games should be hard... But not in of way wasting time for grind. Boring repeating things.
  66. Plopp00
    Oct 13, 2017
    9
    To all people giving this game 0/10 because of the microtransactions.

    Shut up and play the game before you give it a **** review. The microtransactions only helps you finnish the game earlier. You say that the critics says that evrything is great because they get paid to do it. But what if you took the time to actually analyze the games mechanics, gameplay and story. Then maybe    To all people giving this game 0/10 because of the microtransactions.

    Shut up and play the game before you give it a **** review.

    The microtransactions only helps you finnish the game earlier.

    You say that the critics says that evrything is great because they get paid to do it.
    But what if you took the time to actually analyze the games mechanics, gameplay and story. Then maybe you would pay them extra because the game is great with the nemesis system and the diffrent open-worlds you can explore.

    For you hating on the story for changing some of the lore to fit the story: THE GAMES AND THE STORYS ARE NOT CANON!!!!!!!!!!    … Expand
  67. Borat
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    This game is a pile of garbage. I can't enjoy the main game because of the loot boxes. Having a random system that dictates what you get that pushes you towards paying real money is unacceptable! Don't buy this game unless you enjoy wasting money.

    The graphics are decent. That's it.

    Selling my copy as soon as possible.
  68. Celestinos
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    they finished the game doing these microtransactions to be able to continue in the history, this is a shame! the gamer community has to come together for this kind of thing not to invade the consoles.
    shame, shame, shame!
  69. CccyrussS
    Oct 12, 2017
    1
    I don't dislike this game because of microtransactions. I hate this game because I hate the stupid Orcs jabbering at you for 5 minutes before and after you get killed by them. I just can't stand it. Also the fighting is ridiculous dumb compared to something like Dark Souls. I just got the game yesterday and I'm bored to Tears by it and I almost threw my controller at my TV to try to getI don't dislike this game because of microtransactions. I hate this game because I hate the stupid Orcs jabbering at you for 5 minutes before and after you get killed by them. I just can't stand it. Also the fighting is ridiculous dumb compared to something like Dark Souls. I just got the game yesterday and I'm bored to Tears by it and I almost threw my controller at my TV to try to get the Orcs to shut up and that's not a good sign.… Expand
  70. scox
    Oct 12, 2017
    10
    Game is great, you don't have to use the microtransactions if you don't want to. I fully agree that having them in is total crap, but to review bomb this game over them is a bit harsh.
  71. Targayrean
    Oct 12, 2017
    7
    It's such a good game it's such a shame they would cheapen it with micro transactions... It could be a 10/10 it nicely develops from the last game but I am almost ashamed myself for supporting such a cheap cash crab. I am glad people are taking a stand but I've now put a couple of hours in and I don't see a reason why it's needed- I would play with out them for a great game.
  72. ptea
    Oct 12, 2017
    9
    I would want to be strong when it comes to microtransactions and I am not going to go for even a dime extra. It's enough to pay 60€ for a game and it should be if we are reasonable. Still even if these things make me angry, it's a fact that this is a great game. If you loved the first one, you are going to love this one also. I hope that game publishing would change to normal and thisI would want to be strong when it comes to microtransactions and I am not going to go for even a dime extra. It's enough to pay 60€ for a game and it should be if we are reasonable. Still even if these things make me angry, it's a fact that this is a great game. If you loved the first one, you are going to love this one also. I hope that game publishing would change to normal and this greed would stop. I think that only way to do that is to rebel against it. I could not rebel in a way that I would leave this game from ny collection but I wont buy anything but the normal version of this game. Stop buying anything extra, make developers and publishers know that you are angry. Still no reason to hate this game for it's contents without the greed it has lots to offer… Expand
  73. Bumpster
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    GAMERS, We need to stop saying "discusted with the gaming industry", this is NOT all developers. Lots of fantastic developers out there that understand the microtransaction issue. But like you i am angry, disappointed with Warner Bros and Monolith (was a big fan of Monoliths games). This is really unfortunate that a game that is so good is hampered, held back intentionally because theyGAMERS, We need to stop saying "discusted with the gaming industry", this is NOT all developers. Lots of fantastic developers out there that understand the microtransaction issue. But like you i am angry, disappointed with Warner Bros and Monolith (was a big fan of Monoliths games). This is really unfortunate that a game that is so good is hampered, held back intentionally because they want you to pony up $$$ and buy loot boxes. They intentionally give you crappy orcs etc so you have to buy loot boxes or play stupid fetch quests for hours that intentionally lul you into submission...so you'll buy loot boxes. They've made a great game but hamstrung it so you can't progress without more $$$$. So glad I was able to play this with a friend before i bought it. So disappointed, I thought I'd be rushing to the store to pick this up but the more we played, the more we saw through the money grab scheme. I won't be purchasing this or any Warner Bros/Monolith games in the future. We need to stop this now. Please do not support this game, it's going to kill our favorite past time.… Expand
  74. LRDeez
    Oct 12, 2017
    10
    Micro transactions have nothing to do with completing the game. Quit with all the whining. You are not giving a fair review and no one wins when we do this.
  75. BeetrootBaron
    Oct 12, 2017
    4
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The combat mechanics and the nemesis system are the only reason that this is getting a 4 from me, they have been greatly improved since shadow of mordor. The story on the other hand is absolutely rotten, as a massive fan of Tolkiens work it sickens me to see his lore broken to such a degree that it actually bothers me more than the microtransactions (we'll get to them shortly). The way they portrayed shelob as some sort of shape shifting psychic is just so immersion breaking. same goes for the ringwraiths, to make isildur and helm hammerhand ringwraiths is a spit in the face to Tolkien and its constantly on my mind while trying to get through the monotonous grind. Now as for the microtransactions, I haven't felt the need or urge to purchase any lootboxes because I would rather earn my gear and orcs but to put them in a fully priced singleplayer game is an unnecessary distraction that takes away from the experience, it is always subtly leading you to the marketplace shoving them in you're face. It also affects the balance substantially towards the end with you having to constantly defend your strongholds in order to get the true ending, the grind at this stage is so tedious that it would force a lot of people to just spend their money to get through it, either that or if you're like me it will force you to quit the game and watch the ending on youtube. This game would have been so much more interesting and enjoyable if they used the lore that Tolkien had written and if they hadn't included the balance breaking microtransactions.… Expand
  76. RoosterJuice
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    Microtransactions in an $60 single player game is like buying a nice car and then after driving it for 1 year, a message pops up on the dashboard saying you can only drive a maximum of 40 mph unless you purchase more "credits".

    Unacceptable filthy greed.
  77. Azula-1994
    Oct 12, 2017
    7
    Shadow of War...

    Gameplay: The gameplay in Shadow of War is brilliant, I never get tired of killing orcs, Uruk's and other enemies, there are so many different combat options you can use to take down your foe. Graphics: The Graphics aren't terrible but I don't really see any improvement compared to Shadow of Mordor. Story: The story is way over the top and as much as they tried to    Shadow of War...

    Gameplay: The gameplay in Shadow of War is brilliant, I never get tired of killing orcs, Uruk's and other enemies, there are so many different combat options you can use to take down your foe.

    Graphics: The Graphics aren't terrible but I don't really see any improvement compared to Shadow of Mordor.

    Story: The story is way over the top and as much as they tried to tie into the trilogy it just doesn't make much sense.

    Do the Microtransactions take anything away from the game? the answer is yes and no. The game overall is solid, but the microtransactions and loot-crates are in the game and are very noticeable. The biggest issue is the end game where the ending is locked behind tedious grinding defending all of your forts successfully or you can fast track that by buying legendary orcs/uruks/trolls... overall at its core it is a great game that has lost part of its soul by corporate greed.    … Expand
  78. Rand77
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    Micro transactions shoudnt be in game for 60$! That nonsense completely ruined game for me. That and stupid story plus almost same gameplay. Without micro transactions would be 7-8, with it for sure just 0.
  79. damman
    Oct 12, 2017
    1
    All can type is don't purchase this game new if possible due to the loot boxes and weeks of grinding to see a lame final cut scene. If you want to buy ( support Titian Fall 2 which has not micro-transaction) wait to it's on a deep sale or better yet do not purchase and support WB and Monolith who used a dead man sickness to profit for DLC or giving countless gambling loot crates that willAll can type is don't purchase this game new if possible due to the loot boxes and weeks of grinding to see a lame final cut scene. If you want to buy ( support Titian Fall 2 which has not micro-transaction) wait to it's on a deep sale or better yet do not purchase and support WB and Monolith who used a dead man sickness to profit for DLC or giving countless gambling loot crates that will give you OP over others. Please do not buy this game and stop supporting gaming devs like this one who are greedy SOBs. The game is a $$$ grab do your research first. Lets teach these gaming companies to stop slicing up games and selling it as DLC and season passes. We are the gamer who make these companies rich but we get nothing in return but pointless loot boxes and dlc that was originally cut from the real game. Bottom line it's a shell game. They know which shell has the ball but they hide if from the customer. Not going to fall for this tactic again. I work to hard for my money and I demand a full game and no DLC season pass BS and grind feast. By the way I am a black man who believes in unity for all. I say lets apply the same to the gaming industry and stop fighting each other while these fools count our money. There will be a day where the gamer control what content for the next season go AAA games. Lets get these devs to give use more not less for under 59.99. We can change the industry over night if we stop supporting these games and band together. Trust me. One love peace.… Expand
  80. DonMega
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    Pay $85 in my country for this game only to pay for loot boxes in a single player game. Sure you can beat this game without loot boxes but the game literally kills you in the last act of the game because you are forced to grind for 20+ hours to get the legendary orcs you need to finish the game or pay for loot boxes in a single player game to reduce the grind time. Just the lowest of thePay $85 in my country for this game only to pay for loot boxes in a single player game. Sure you can beat this game without loot boxes but the game literally kills you in the last act of the game because you are forced to grind for 20+ hours to get the legendary orcs you need to finish the game or pay for loot boxes in a single player game to reduce the grind time. Just the lowest of the low by a developer. Shame because the first game was great although boring and repetitive at times.… Expand
  81. igit
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    This microtransaction crap has to stop. For God's sake. It's a 60$ singleplayer game. We already paid for the game. If you buy this, you encourage the companies to put more of this crap into next games. And don't tell me this **** "you don't have to pay for microtransactions" Are you really so naive thinking that the game won't be designed in a specific way to make you pay for it sooner orThis microtransaction crap has to stop. For God's sake. It's a 60$ singleplayer game. We already paid for the game. If you buy this, you encourage the companies to put more of this crap into next games. And don't tell me this **** "you don't have to pay for microtransactions" Are you really so naive thinking that the game won't be designed in a specific way to make you pay for it sooner or later? Endless grind and other ****? No, thanks. DON"T BUY THIS.… Expand
  82. epistm87
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    making a giant spider a sex figure for wea2boos.
    Microtransactions in single game.
    this is not cheapy mobile game.
    dont buy this game in full price .
  83. Radm2000
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    Microtransactions, don't waste your time . end game all about buying loot box . suddenly you feel it turned to mobile game where you have buy to progress
  84. efkiss
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    0/10 BURN you greedy bastards. The ending is tedious AF! I regret buying and it's already cracked... Should just watched it on youtube. Don't get it why people review it at 10, maybe they are paid, but let me tell you, if you want future of micro-transactions in single-player and gamble just to finish the game then support it, rate 10 and so on, I don't want it. MT's break the game no0/10 BURN you greedy bastards. The ending is tedious AF! I regret buying and it's already cracked... Should just watched it on youtube. Don't get it why people review it at 10, maybe they are paid, but let me tell you, if you want future of micro-transactions in single-player and gamble just to finish the game then support it, rate 10 and so on, I don't want it. MT's break the game no matter how good the game is, World of Warcraft is best MMO for a reason.… Expand
  85. zerathsilver
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    Hmm lets see
    -Encouraging kids to gambling
    -Micro-transactions in an already AAA priced game
    -Recycling same content from the first game
    Buying this game should be illegal.
  86. Gouldfish44
    Oct 12, 2017
    10
    LOL my review was deleted because I called out all the ass hats giving this a 0.

    Behold! My 10/10 score has been restored! The game is better than the first, the microtransactions are in the background and not forced at you, and you certainly do not need them to beat the game. People are just following the crowd. Play it for yourself before posting a 0 just for the sake of it.
  87. DeaconFrost
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    Microtransactions in a single player game ? Are you kidding me ? Luckily I watched the review from Angry Joe before buying this game. This has to stop. NOW !
  88. Wald_OST
    Oct 12, 2017
    0
    Loot boxes are not allowed in the 60$ game! We need to fight back now, otherwise tomorrow we will be offered 60$ for the game, then for 80$ for Season pass and for 100$ to open 5-6 boxes in which the entire content of the game will be found. If the WB gets away with it, then this is the future that awaits us all.
  89. Cherryleaf
    Oct 12, 2017
    8
    This is by no mean a perfect game, and I personally despise the very thought of Microtransaction's, but that does not make this game a bad one - cause this is by far no Pay-to-Win (not once have I felt compelled to buy anything for real money).

    Since seems that, not all of them, but many of those who gave the 0-3 score (and wow, there are a whole lot of them) and bash on the game in    This is by no mean a perfect game, and I personally despise the very thought of Microtransaction's, but that does not make this game a bad one - cause this is by far no Pay-to-Win (not once have I felt compelled to buy anything for real money).

    Since seems that, not all of them, but many of those who gave the 0-3 score (and wow, there are a whole lot of them) and bash on the game in their reviews, only lifts "Microtransactions" as their issue. Well, I can say this much - I got so much Mirian already early on, that I could easily spend a whole lot of it, and yet never feeling poor - cause like in other game’s with systems like this, the paid storefront here, feels less predatory and actually more like an unnecessary addition. The only difference (as I see it) is that the better and expensive chests just hands guaranteed better loot, but I personally rather get that in-game anyway.

    The GFX is gorgeous and the enviroments is stunning, as is the details on the Orc Generals/Officers, armor and weapons. The Nemesis system feels both familiar and improved since the first. The Skill-tree has some nice and awesomely helpful abilities, while others just feel "MEHH!!". Still there is variety enough that early on they matters, but later on you'll most likely have covered them all. Even though the Armor & Weapons looks neat and cool, but their abilities doesnt hand the same variety and awesomeness, also it becomes a tedious task to always be in need to un-lock their bonus abilities as soon as you get a better piece.

    The story is not all that compelling, but it doesn't bother me all that much since there is so many other things to do (some of the stuffs can after a while feel bit repetative). At its core it is a great experience, and for me personally, this game is a brilliant game that gives me more flesh and insight to one of the many untold stories in Middle Earth.    … Expand
  90. northernlad
    Oct 11, 2017
    6
    just started act two been on shadow of war most of the day my very first thought that comes to mind is disappointment the games combat is the same as the first which works fine but the start is terrible the games been filled with mindless fluff story is drivel the world seems well crafted and orks are great but i have to say as a massive fan of the first game which i still own and playjust started act two been on shadow of war most of the day my very first thought that comes to mind is disappointment the games combat is the same as the first which works fine but the start is terrible the games been filled with mindless fluff story is drivel the world seems well crafted and orks are great but i have to say as a massive fan of the first game which i still own and play this is a major step backwards graphics dont make a game and game content shoved behind microtransactions is a joke all in all a average game at best shame as i had really high hopes for this--- update it's just the same grind over and over pretty much using the fabled batman gameplay mechanic the game world feels far to light losing the dark and gritty feel of the first and anyone who thinks this story is good well each to there own first game a surprising almost a master peace in my humble opinion but this is not garbage but very average there's better games out there simple fact i'd advise anyone to wait for abit before jumping into a full price game here… Expand
  91. Dex1911
    Oct 11, 2017
    4
    The game is very confusing you have to hold a two run but if you want to turn your camera you have to stop running then turn the camera then sprint again what the **** The health regen system is retarded and very confusing. And if you are in the middle of a Battle and your health is low you have to run and find an orc to drain to get your health back. This is a very bad game
  92. Typh
    Oct 11, 2017
    0
    Absolutely brilliant gameplay! So addictive, and I’m probably shooting myself in the foot for saying this, but best game I’ve played since I could remember. They’ve made improvements to literally everything that made Shadow of Mordor shine, which I thought would be impossible. This will surely resonate in me for future nostalgia. Rating it a 0 however, because it hasAbsolutely brilliant gameplay! So addictive, and I’m probably shooting myself in the foot for saying this, but best game I’ve played since I could remember. They’ve made improvements to literally everything that made Shadow of Mordor shine, which I thought would be impossible. This will surely resonate in me for future nostalgia. Rating it a 0 however, because it has microtransactions…still not sure what they are, but apparently they make a game unplayable I’ve heard.… Expand
  93. ArchSeeker
    Oct 11, 2017
    2
    Best thing about this game is its combat and Nemesis system just like in Shadow of Mordor. Like its predecessor though, the game fails terribly at storytelling, character development, and variety in activities. Let's also not forget that someone thought it would be a good idea to put microtransactions in the game. I know that there are many who don't care but this game's anti-consumerBest thing about this game is its combat and Nemesis system just like in Shadow of Mordor. Like its predecessor though, the game fails terribly at storytelling, character development, and variety in activities. Let's also not forget that someone thought it would be a good idea to put microtransactions in the game. I know that there are many who don't care but this game's anti-consumer business model goes to show how much companies care now. You can't even get the true ending unless you have legendary orc followers. This was clearly made to make the loot boxes more appealing due to the tedious grind you'd have to do in order to get them. Vote with your wallet folks, avoid buying this game or wait untill the price drops to at least half of the $60 price tag.… Expand
  94. lowerclassbrats
    Oct 11, 2017
    0
    Game ruined by microtransactions. This game is getting good scores from the legacy gaming media because they never have and never will look out for the consumer. If a publisher wants to ruin their game by putting gambling via microtransactions in at the cost of quality then they must accept the poor review scores from the consumer.
  95. Lilahkiz
    Oct 11, 2017
    0
    Grind for weeks for the endgame or Spend a couple of bucks on lootboxes to finish the game which you gonna choose?
    People should not support microtransactions don't believe us go look at dreamcastguy review kids
  96. Ethn94
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    Don’t listen too all the hate because of micro transactions, they are seriously OPTIONAL. If you loved the first game then you will love this one even Moore.
  97. CastielX87
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    If you crying Wahhh Wahhh microtransactions blahh blahhh have not played the game you #Merica Reviews are not Valid. Trolls pff

    I love the game so far after 10hrs and have not needed your precious microtransactions. btw this is not the only game that has microtransactions. So i don't get all the Fake Reviews with 0's on them. It has been said by many legit reviews that you don't    If you crying Wahhh Wahhh microtransactions blahh blahhh have not played the game you #Merica Reviews are not Valid. Trolls pff

    I love the game so far after 10hrs and have not needed your precious microtransactions.

    btw this is not the only game that has microtransactions. So i don't get all the Fake Reviews with 0's on them.

    It has been said by many legit reviews that you don't need microtransactions to complete the game. Only if ur losers.
    And stop mimic youtube users that hate microtransactions    … Expand
  98. logangood
    Oct 11, 2017
    9
    Don't listen to the people giving this a 1-5 or around that. I guarantee they they didn't even play the game. The game is a lot of fun especially if you liked the first one. The end game is not locked behind a paywall and the loot boxes you can get just by actually playing the game. The game doesn't even pressure you into buying any. Need gear? Kill some captains or do some vendetta andDon't listen to the people giving this a 1-5 or around that. I guarantee they they didn't even play the game. The game is a lot of fun especially if you liked the first one. The end game is not locked behind a paywall and the loot boxes you can get just by actually playing the game. The game doesn't even pressure you into buying any. Need gear? Kill some captains or do some vendetta and capture fortresses. The microtransactions don't even make a difference in the game.… Expand
  99. PULKEMONTHE
    Oct 11, 2017
    10
    the good: big game a very open world very interesting story great gameplay and unforgettable game mechanics
    the bad: microtransactions that ruin the expreriencia for those who acquire it and bitter those who can afford it
  100. Galgotit
    Oct 11, 2017
    0
    Loot boxes with a grind wall in single player. Only sort of game where its morally justifiable to pirate. I cannot honestly recommend any one buy this game and forget those shills that say otherwise.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

65
#65 Best PS4 Game of 2017
12
#12 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2017
13
#13 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2017

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
80

Generally favorable reviews - based on 69 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 53 out of 69
  2. Mixed: 16 out of 69
  3. Negative: 0 out of 69
  1. CD-Action
    Dec 19, 2017
    80
    I was annoyed by various flaws (both technical and design-related) and tedious, dragged out final stages of the campaign, but overall I enjoyed the ride. It looks like the developers wanted to stuff the game with all the best elements Middle-earth has to offer. Shadow of War’s atmosphere is terrific and watching Talion rise in power is surprisingly addictive. [12/2017, p.62]
  2. Cubed3
    Nov 26, 2017
    70
    A handful of issues, some much more annoying than others, do not negate how solid of an action RPG Middle-earth: Shadow of War is. A tremendous achievement for the team at Monolith Productions, this is an exciting, if not sometimes slow, and too often unfair, title that manages to be as impressively fun as it is big.
    Read full review
  3. Playstation Official Magazine UK
    Nov 20, 2017
    60
    Big, brutal, and - alas - bloated, Shadow of War is a disappointing follow-up, conjuring battles of grand scale and then deadening their impact through grinding repetition. [December 2017, p.79]
See all critic reviews »