The Orville

:

Season 1
  • Network: FOX , HULU
  • Series Premiere Date: Sep 10, 2017
Season #: 3, 2, 1
User Score
8.4

Universal acclaim- based on 1016 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 877 out of 1016
  2. Mixed: 46 out of 1016
  3. Negative: 93 out of 1016
Watch Now

Where To Watch

Stream On
Buy on
Stream On
Stream On
Expand

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

view
per page
  1. pchernik
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    This once again proves to me that critics are either idiots or only rate positively once they are paid off and that I should not look for shows to watch based on their reviews, and instead look at "user reviews". This show is totally opposite of "Star Trek Discovery" in that respect. It's funny and it's enjoyable. If I can't have a good serious sci-fi show I'd much rather have this. If youThis once again proves to me that critics are either idiots or only rate positively once they are paid off and that I should not look for shows to watch based on their reviews, and instead look at "user reviews". This show is totally opposite of "Star Trek Discovery" in that respect. It's funny and it's enjoyable. If I can't have a good serious sci-fi show I'd much rather have this. If you are looking for a space adventure to watch, and can't stand the Discovery garbage, look no further!… Expand
  2. pgreens
    Oct 10, 2017
    9
    i see what theyre going for here, and hope they can continue. i dont know what bug crawled up these critics asses; they probably dont like anything they cant easily categorize. the show is a solid 80% star trek. Yes, the crude jokes sometimes dont land and are odd in the prestigious sci fi setting. Yes, Norm McDonald is really shoehorned in there, probably a huge drain on the animationi see what theyre going for here, and hope they can continue. i dont know what bug crawled up these critics asses; they probably dont like anything they cant easily categorize. the show is a solid 80% star trek. Yes, the crude jokes sometimes dont land and are odd in the prestigious sci fi setting. Yes, Norm McDonald is really shoehorned in there, probably a huge drain on the animation budget for no reason. If you can forgive those two sins, which are easily ignored, you have a pretty good star trek show. its far better than nothing.… Expand
  3. ahnehnois
    Oct 10, 2017
    8
    The main surprise about the show is that there's not much humor. It doesn't need that to work, though.

    They have slavishly recreated the Star Trek aesthetic, from the recycled chords in the music to the distinctive James Conway overhead shots. The occasional gag is in there, but for the most part, the writing seems composed of rejected pitches for one of the long-gone Trek shows. Even    The main surprise about the show is that there's not much humor. It doesn't need that to work, though.

    They have slavishly recreated the Star Trek aesthetic, from the recycled chords in the music to the distinctive James Conway overhead shots. The occasional gag is in there, but for the most part, the writing seems composed of rejected pitches for one of the long-gone Trek shows. Even in a few episodes, that writing has generated some intriguing surprises, and the chemistry between the characters have grown. It works for much the same reasons a non-parodical Star Trek does: the writers, despite having to adhere to the tropes of the genre, are freer than the ones churning out regular network shows.

    It has a ways to go to get up to the impactfulness of its predecessors, but it's been good enough so far that it ought to get the chance to go on a while.    … Expand
  4. Absolon47
    Oct 10, 2017
    10
    Very nicely done. Honestly being a Star Trek fan myself, I actually enjoy this show more than the newest Star Trek series, Discovery. I don't care what the so called professional critics think (they are wrong most of the time anyways)
  5. VanGheist
    Oct 10, 2017
    9
    This show honestly impresses me. It's timing couldn't have been any better either. The Orville has everything we wished for from Star Trek: Discovery and more. The friendly banter, the Roddenberry message, and the episodic feel to the show make it very enjoyable to me and most likely any of you Trekkies out there. I give it a solid 9. Don't listen to these so called "Professional"This show honestly impresses me. It's timing couldn't have been any better either. The Orville has everything we wished for from Star Trek: Discovery and more. The friendly banter, the Roddenberry message, and the episodic feel to the show make it very enjoyable to me and most likely any of you Trekkies out there. I give it a solid 9. Don't listen to these so called "Professional" critics, they don't know what they hell they're talking about. You have a fan base now, just keep developing those characters in interesting ways and I for one, will continue to promote this show to my family and friends.… Expand
  6. BlobTheCat
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    Fantastic show in the spirit of Star Trek The Next Generation.
    You can clearly see that Seth Macfarlane is a true Star Trek-Fan. He's one of us.
    It's exactly that what i was craving for all these years. Thank you for this masterpiece of space opera!
  7. LordoftheDance
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    Its TNG meets A Million Ways to Die in the West. Some jokes fall flat or feel forced, but some are absolutely hilarious and unforgettable. Jokes aside, there has also been storytelling that is spot on Star Trek that was really well done. I've only seen 5 episodes, and so far I am absolutely pumped. It's everything you like about Star Trek with comedy thrown in.

    Also: It keeps    Its TNG meets A Million Ways to Die in the West. Some jokes fall flat or feel forced, but some are absolutely hilarious and unforgettable. Jokes aside, there has also been storytelling that is spot on Star Trek that was really well done. I've only seen 5 episodes, and so far I am absolutely pumped. It's everything you like about Star Trek with comedy thrown in.

    Also: It keeps getting better and better.    … Expand
  8. moviestalker
    Oct 9, 2017
    7
    When I was told this show was closer to Star Trek then the new ST: Discovery, I found that really hard to believe yet curiosity got the better of me. After watching the first three episodes I was pleasantly surprised with how this show turned out.

    Is the show flawless? No, it's not. There are some cringy moments now and then when the Orville tries to be funny and it's not. But I see    When I was told this show was closer to Star Trek then the new ST: Discovery, I found that really hard to believe yet curiosity got the better of me. After watching the first three episodes I was pleasantly surprised with how this show turned out.

    Is the show flawless? No, it's not. There are some cringy moments now and then when the Orville tries to be funny and it's not. But I see room for improvement and I'm more than willing to give this show a chance.

    Are people correct when they say this is the spiritual successor to star trek, that 'ST: Discovery' failed to deliver? So far, I'll say 'yes'

    Finally a personal matter:
    I never really understood why the rating system on metacritic so heavily favors the votes of the so called "experts critics". A rating of '36' is hardly justified while so many people enjoyed this show. Why not show both, the critics *and* user score as Metascore at the same time?    … Expand
  9. kushida2017
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    It really goes to show you how NOT to listen to the "professional" Critic's..
    These guys are bought and sold on there political biases, Identity tribe mind, and wrong think ideology. These people have no real understanding and out of touch with the world they live in, There the elitist, and i bet they think we of the different opinion are.... Deplorable
  10. Stormwolf
    Oct 9, 2017
    9
    Great show, these guys should have been the ones making the new Star Trek. Sure, some of the jokes are fairly flat, but it's okay when you look at the wonderful TOS/TNG style plots they have.

    This is the show for you if you like the pre-reboot Star Trek and Galaxy Quest, watch it if you haven't seen it already.
  11. slayermcgee
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    I came to this show expecting a campy riff on Star Trek, and what I have found is a lovingly crafted homage to Star Trek of old, but with new modern issues injected into the well-written story lines. I love this show, and I'm hoping to see it continue to grow!
  12. Vince_Vega
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    The Orville starts with a weak and becomes one of the strongest "Ship and Crew" shows we had in a long time.
    Personally I think the first episode doesn't do the show justice. While it is solid in it's second half, the very first impression we get of this show can leave a negative impression. it's too busy trying to explain and setup everything, while squeezing in the jokes. This flow    The Orville starts with a weak and becomes one of the strongest "Ship and Crew" shows we had in a long time.
    Personally I think the first episode doesn't do the show justice. While it is solid in it's second half, the very first impression we get of this show can leave a negative impression. it's too busy trying to explain and setup everything, while squeezing in the jokes. This flow starts to become more organic in the following episodes.
    This show delivers a high concept Sci-Fi (highlight Ep.3 here!) while delivering the comic relief other shows were missing. The bridge crew feels like people, relatable normal people working together in an office. Halfway through it's first season The Orville demonstrates great Sci-Fi story lines combined with an established chemistry of the cast.

    This is the Ship and Crew Sci-Fi adventure show that many of us have been waiting for for a long time.    … Expand
  13. PrimeSpeaker
    Oct 8, 2017
    9
    If you love star trek tng then give this one a shot. It's very similar in terms of tone with a little more direct comedy while keeping the heart, The visuals are gorgeous and the it has just been fun overall.
  14. Moilleadoir
    Oct 8, 2017
    5
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. tldr; Well-made, but mediocre.

    I created an account just because I couldn’t believe the huge amount of biased Trekhead reviews here. There has been a huge pile on, creating a spacetime anomaly that’s warping the Metacritic score.

    The biggest problem with The Orville is that it can’t seem to decide what it wants to be. It’s not really a comedy; even the comedy that’s there is often not funny. It’s far too faithful to Star Trek to be even a gentle parody, in fact you can’t help wondering if MacFarlane feels making fun of ST would be heretical. At best it’s a slightly non-serious Star Trek clone with deeply unoriginal plots.

    It really feels like Seth just wanted to do some amazingly expensive ST roleplaying.

    There is a kind of achievement I suppose in combining the worst of Star Trek—episodic plots where characters seldom develop and aliens are either never truly alien or discover that they can only truly find themselves by learning the wonders of humanity—and the worst of MacFarlane—‘jokes’ referring to themselves, cheap pop-culture references. The humour that’s there is more lazy Family Guy (or Ted) than American Dad.

    The most telling piece of ST mimicry so far was the alien race (Moclans) who are introduced as a single-sex race. They present and identify as male (which initially makes no sense) but in the second episode Bortus’ egg hatches a female. This is classic ST—introduce a difference, an alienness, and then immediately normalise it or reduce it to safely known human terms. It’s Science Fiction with all the interesting bits safely removed. At least human morality didn’t win in the subsequent plot; that’s a small difference from Star Trek.

    On the plus side, technically the show is very well made, all the FX are good and the actors do a fine job with what they’re given (which isn’t great). It may even be better acting than actual ST, but on the whole that’s not really saying a lot.

    Will I keep watching it? Probably, but after each episode I’ll still wonder why they made it. I also watched all of Deep Space Nine though, so just because I can devote myself to lost causes, doesn’t mean you should!

    At the end of the day, if you’re a Trekkie you’ll probably love it. If not and you’re a watcher of sci-fi, you might be scratching your head quite a bit. If you don’t mind unchallenging TV, you won’t mind this. Ultimately, for most people there is nothing compelling here, but it’s certainly not unwatchable (as some have claimed).

    For context, I’d give Firefly a 9, I liked Babylon 5 a lot (despite it’s flaws) and a couple of my favourite recent shows are Mr. Robot and Legion.    … Expand
  15. Robobob
    Oct 8, 2017
    9
    Did you love Star Trek: The Next Generation but were always kind of bugged that the crew never mentioned pop culture in film or TV? Did it annoy you that everyone on the Enterprise D was perfect at their job and almost always followed the rules? Did you find it a little stuffy will only a few mild attempts at humor? Well, then you will really love The Orville. This is the kind of crewDid you love Star Trek: The Next Generation but were always kind of bugged that the crew never mentioned pop culture in film or TV? Did it annoy you that everyone on the Enterprise D was perfect at their job and almost always followed the rules? Did you find it a little stuffy will only a few mild attempts at humor? Well, then you will really love The Orville. This is the kind of crew that pops in a classic episode of Seinfeld on the view screen during some down time. This is the crew most likely to get themselves blown up in the first few episodes. They are also the most likely to curse at the bad guy on screen and flip him the bird. Add on top of that the most "Trek" themed episodes seen in a sci-fi show since the glory Trek-days of the 90s. I'm waiting for the day that a member of the crew specially mentions that ancient show "Star Trek: The Next Generation" and notes the similarity in their mission. This show is so good but I'm certain as it goes on and finds it niche that it is headed for greatness.… Expand
  16. dr9188
    Oct 8, 2017
    10
    Firstly... I am dumbfounded how this has such a low "pro-critic" score compared to Star Trek Discovery... This show, in my opinion, is by far the superior show, in terms of humour and quality of storylines as well as respect it pays to the format and universe of Star Trek (more than even anything JJ Abrams managed)

    I just binge watched the first 4 episodes of The Orville... And, being a    Firstly... I am dumbfounded how this has such a low "pro-critic" score compared to Star Trek Discovery... This show, in my opinion, is by far the superior show, in terms of humour and quality of storylines as well as respect it pays to the format and universe of Star Trek (more than even anything JJ Abrams managed)

    I just binge watched the first 4 episodes of The Orville... And, being a person with an internet connection, I naturally couldn't resist the temptation to make my opinions known.

    For the uninitiated, The Orville is the latest Seth MacFarlane comedy. Immediately this may be a cause for concern, as his animation has become increasingly stale (although I was a fan of A Million Ways To Die In The West).

    And yet, within the space of its trailer, my feelings went from curious to optimistic.

    In the end, these initial episodes far exceeded my expectations, actually feeling less like a "typical" sitcom than the trailer suggests... Don't get me wrong, there are a lot of one-liners. But the structure of each episode much more closely resembles that of The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine or even Voyager. This actually works incredibly well; as the world is built throughout each episode, the jokes feel funnier as you realise these are people making funny comments in a consistent world, rather than the changing rules of MacFarlane's previous animations. The plots feel like the kind you would find on any past Trek episode, with the humour instead coming from the character's reactions. You could imagine these characters in the actual Star Trek universe, being given a ship because there's no-one else to pilot it. I mean, I'm sure even in the Federation there must be alcoholism, divorce and tension between senior staff...

    Of particular note to me was the third episode "About A Girl". Without giving too many spoilers, it surprised me how well it emulated the way Star Trek would present cultural problems... With my only issues being it was so early in the series there wasn't the chance of more character development which was maybe needed for the situation and characters to feel more relatable. Equally, I can see why an episode such as this was broadcast so early... As a signal that this was aiming to be more than a silly comedy, but to derive humour instead from how it follows (and plays with) the situations from Star Trek itself, I feel it was successful. One thing that did shock me was some discussion this episode was so-called "SJW" and pushing some kind of political message... From people who clearly know nothing about Star Trek or the kind of message that Gene Roddenberry tried to convey from his very first season.    … Expand
  17. StarzSeeker
    Oct 8, 2017
    10
    This is Star Trek TOS meets Next Generation meets Galaxy Quest. I'm 5 episodes in and the show is getting better with each passing week. I was 11 minutes into the pilot and heard myself say out loud "this is Star Trek!". The look and feel of the show is all Trek. The characters are developing quickly and that's a positive. You need the audience to care about the characters and they haveThis is Star Trek TOS meets Next Generation meets Galaxy Quest. I'm 5 episodes in and the show is getting better with each passing week. I was 11 minutes into the pilot and heard myself say out loud "this is Star Trek!". The look and feel of the show is all Trek. The characters are developing quickly and that's a positive. You need the audience to care about the characters and they have succeeded in doing so. The stories are deeper than you would expect for a season 1. It's almost as if they decided to start in season 2 or 3. Users have it at 8.1, very positive. So to all the professional critics out there who are panning the show I would recommend you reconsider your career choice. The show is a hit with the audience therefore you are obviously not seeing what the great majority is seeing. Two thumbs up, and only two because that's all I have.… Expand
  18. SirIsaacBrock
    Oct 7, 2017
    10
    WTF critics, is your only job to crap on anything that doesn't end mid sentence or have sex scenes mixed with dragons?

    Seth MacFarlane created another great show to brighten up our little world and keep us entertained an hour at a time. From the thought provoking story of episode 3 to the little accents such as Kermit the Frog being on his desk, Seth and his team has worked tirelessly    WTF critics, is your only job to crap on anything that doesn't end mid sentence or have sex scenes mixed with dragons?

    Seth MacFarlane created another great show to brighten up our little world and keep us entertained an hour at a time. From the thought provoking story of episode 3 to the little accents such as Kermit the Frog being on his desk, Seth and his team has worked tirelessly to ensure that we are kept enthralled from beginning to end with pop culture references and characters I'd like to have a beer with.

    This show may not have awesome graphics but it sure as Hell makes up for it with heart. I hope this is the beginning of a fantastic lighthearted voyage that puts all those critics that can't help hating dreamers in their places.

    Bravo Mr. MacFarlane and team, keep up the good work!    … Expand
  19. Senatic
    Oct 7, 2017
    9
    It's Star Trek The Next Generation/DS9, with a bit more humor in it. Except it's not Star Trek. That's all you need to know, if you liked Next Generation or DS9 I'm pretty sure you will like this.

    That's literally all you need to know, oh and don't listen to any of the professional reviewers. They have no clue what they are talking about. (Duh what else is new). If you want more details    It's Star Trek The Next Generation/DS9, with a bit more humor in it. Except it's not Star Trek. That's all you need to know, if you liked Next Generation or DS9 I'm pretty sure you will like this.

    That's literally all you need to know, oh and don't listen to any of the professional reviewers. They have no clue what they are talking about. (Duh what else is new). If you want more details see below but what is said above is literally all you really need to know.

    Pros:

    -It's "real" Star Trek, unlike the modern Star Trek movies and the new Star Trek Discovery, The Orville actually understands its source material and i was amazed at how much depth there was in episode three, the complexity and issues tackled are deeper and more nuanced than anything portrayed by the nonstop action crap filled with lens flares and horizontal shoots we've seen during the last 10 years.

    -Great CGI

    -Great Costumes (for the most part)

    -The show examines political and cultural aspects of our modern day by shining a light on them in this alien soap opera just like Star Trek The Next Generation did.

    -Good main cast with believable acting.

    -Action is sparse and gives way to the intellectual examination of society and societal issues.

    -The show is very self aware of the silliness and ridiculousness that sometimes goes on which makes for great additional commentary on the tropes and plot devices shows like this sometimes rely on.

    Cons:

    -The Robot crew members costume is stupid and doesn't fit the show at all.

    - Some bad acting from a few of the secondary characters.

    - The jokes in the first three episodes (What I've watched so far) are a bit hit and miss, some were pretty funny and some were totally off for me.

    Summary: I literally can't think of any more cons, though I'm sure there are some. I'm just so happy to finally have an intellectual star trek type show to watch again. Yes some of the jokes are not that funny, but it's a minor nuisance and is completely overshadowed by the feeling of pure joy as the show handles moral, societal and cultural questions with a intellectual approach. I don't want to spoil anything but episode three completely blew me away. It was so refreshing to actually have to think while watching, I had to stop and consider the points and the implications of the characters decisions and statements to examine where I stood on it all.

    Just a fantastic show so far, surely there is room for improvement and I'm sure they will find their feet as time goes on but they clearly have a perfect grasp of what made Star Trek great to begin with and that is all that matters to me.    … Expand
  20. maillard
    Oct 7, 2017
    10
    The series is fresh innovative funny, without all that PC star trek moralist rubbish, overused old characters and overrun storylines. It is not pompous and preachy, in fact, it is much like Kirks original star trek, great show, fab cast. Get over yourselves critics.
  21. gadenp
    Oct 6, 2017
    9
    This show is more Star Trek then the current Star Trek movies and Discovery. And it just seems to grow better and better every episode.

    All the things that make Star Trek what is it, you can find in Orville. The biggest one being the light of hope of a better tomorrow, of working for a better future or making one self and others better. The recent Star Trek shows keep on harping on    This show is more Star Trek then the current Star Trek movies and Discovery. And it just seems to grow better and better every episode.

    All the things that make Star Trek what is it, you can find in Orville. The biggest one being the light of hope of a better tomorrow, of working for a better future or making one self and others better.

    The recent Star Trek shows keep on harping on the darkness within, but that is not Star Trek and is a horrible disservice. On the other hand Orville is a great successor and ode to all that makes Star Trek great.    … Expand
  22. Nebadon_Adams
    Oct 6, 2017
    9
    Once again, the elitist critics are smoking crack and pissing on us commoners trying to tell us it's raining. The ORVILLE is THE NEW STAR TREK. I've only seen the first two episodes (the second directed by Voyager alum Robert Duncan McNeill) and I was THOROUGHLY entertained. Oh, and I HATE Family Guy and American Dad and all that pop-culture crap. But this show is SO GOOD! It's obviousOnce again, the elitist critics are smoking crack and pissing on us commoners trying to tell us it's raining. The ORVILLE is THE NEW STAR TREK. I've only seen the first two episodes (the second directed by Voyager alum Robert Duncan McNeill) and I was THOROUGHLY entertained. Oh, and I HATE Family Guy and American Dad and all that pop-culture crap. But this show is SO GOOD! It's obvious that McFarlane ACTUALLY likes Star Trek and not just the politics behind it.

    TL;DR: I have found my NEW STAR TREK, and it is ORVILLE.    … Expand
  23. EludiumQ36
    Oct 6, 2017
    3
    "Pria" is my "jump the shark" episode. Charlize Theron, an A-list film actress, on this show, this early in season 1, kissing and in bed with Seth. Really?! And I still can't accept - just can't - Seth MacFarlane in a dramatic role, it's just too foreign, and too forced. And it just seems like he played a trump card to get this high production value series, like he was "I've always wanted"Pria" is my "jump the shark" episode. Charlize Theron, an A-list film actress, on this show, this early in season 1, kissing and in bed with Seth. Really?! And I still can't accept - just can't - Seth MacFarlane in a dramatic role, it's just too foreign, and too forced. And it just seems like he played a trump card to get this high production value series, like he was "I've always wanted to be a starship captain on television and you guys owe me." Again, love the production values, but the cast just is wrong for this series. It's like they don't measure up to the potential that the production offers. It's like putting goofy teenagers in a Rolls Royce - nothing good can come from that. This show just isn't engaging and I think it's because Seth doesn't have the charisma that past starship captains have had. His immaturity poisons the structure of the show. And worse, I don't see a path to improvement without a near 100% cast turnover, and that's not happening. So, I'm out at this point. I think this show should die quietly at season's end, but I'm sure Seth has a guaranteed 2 or even 3 yr deal, but no show should survive with a ratings share under 3.… Expand
  24. bassoon821
    Oct 6, 2017
    10
    From the trailer, I thought this was going to be a good comedy show, but it turns out to have great story and characters, too. It's currently the show I look forward the most every week!
  25. Dubeau
    Oct 6, 2017
    8
    Orville is a good show that pay homage to Star Trek and some real classic sci-fi episodes that aired on TV. It isn't your sci-fi flick that puts you in a dark political place, like Galactica or Discovery. Instead you get some nice classical stories branded in a more modern style. Even the music pays homage to classic pieces with variations on themes. Yes, the actors or the humour is notOrville is a good show that pay homage to Star Trek and some real classic sci-fi episodes that aired on TV. It isn't your sci-fi flick that puts you in a dark political place, like Galactica or Discovery. Instead you get some nice classical stories branded in a more modern style. Even the music pays homage to classic pieces with variations on themes. Yes, the actors or the humour is not always good...but overall you still get entertainment. Orville was made for fan of classic scifi and should be appreciated has such. I give it a 75%. Note: Don't give in to the critics that want to bash on McFarland and give the show a fair chance of seducing you by it's light tone and respect to old fiction.… Expand
  26. teebizzoo
    Oct 6, 2017
    10
    I have never written a review here before, but given the reactions of the critics, I felt I had to now. I had low expectations of "The Orville." I had feared a kind of low-level humor would prevail, with very little attention to the heart and soul that most shows set in a Star Trek universe possess. Fortunately, I was wrong. I love this show. The characters are lovable, and the humor isI have never written a review here before, but given the reactions of the critics, I felt I had to now. I had low expectations of "The Orville." I had feared a kind of low-level humor would prevail, with very little attention to the heart and soul that most shows set in a Star Trek universe possess. Fortunately, I was wrong. I love this show. The characters are lovable, and the humor is well-balanced with the story lines. The humor also is a terrific balance of the expected and unexpected, and the writers honor both the spirit of the original Star Trek and all of the spoof humor that has been inspired by it. It has just the right combination of reverence and irreverence. I don't know what the critics want from this show, but whatever it is they've got it all wrong. They're either misunderstanding what this show is supposed to be, or they never liked shows like Star Trek in the first place. I think The Orville is charming, entertaining, engaging, and well-written. Even more than that, it's lighthearted and fun, something we all need more of right now. I hope it's on for years to come.… Expand
  27. zohrn
    Oct 6, 2017
    9
    After five episodes, my summary is 4:1 positive. Ep .1-2 were at least nice/decent on an unexpected high level, Ep. 3 was very good (despite being serious), Ep. 4 sadly uninspired, and Ep. 5 very good again. The always present comedy may not work for everyone (like me or most critics), but the sense of Trek clearly works for the audience. My 9 rating may be a bit overdrawn, but for now,After five episodes, my summary is 4:1 positive. Ep .1-2 were at least nice/decent on an unexpected high level, Ep. 3 was very good (despite being serious), Ep. 4 sadly uninspired, and Ep. 5 very good again. The always present comedy may not work for everyone (like me or most critics), but the sense of Trek clearly works for the audience. My 9 rating may be a bit overdrawn, but for now, it's what I feel.… Expand
  28. suaviant
    Oct 6, 2017
    10
    Critics are wrong. I am a lifelong Star Trek fan, even enjoyed the first of the Abrams reboots somewhat but this, this feels like the most Star Trek thing since Star Trek Enterprise. It is funny not always in a laugh out loud way, and it never feels stupid. The drama so far is decent enough. The characters are believable. This is good. I signed up because this show deserves another voiceCritics are wrong. I am a lifelong Star Trek fan, even enjoyed the first of the Abrams reboots somewhat but this, this feels like the most Star Trek thing since Star Trek Enterprise. It is funny not always in a laugh out loud way, and it never feels stupid. The drama so far is decent enough. The characters are believable. This is good. I signed up because this show deserves another voice telling you to support it and check it out. I truly hope this show continues for some time to come and if it gets better then we are all in for a treat :-)… Expand
  29. golibethesda
    Oct 6, 2017
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This show is surprisingly good. They are copying other ST series in many ways but they're doing a good job and it's not a straight copy/paste. It also doesn't have as many stupidities as STD and characters are likeable. First episode was so-so but I liked the second one (Sage is great in her role and the character she plays is convincing and not stupid), third wasn't bad either (the defence strategy by showing how stupid the pilot is cracked me up) and fourth was actually good and felt like Star Trek (and how cool is that they've included a generation ship?). It's ironic that without much effort they've done a much better job than STD creators/writers where everything is ****… Expand
  30. jim_taltontish
    Oct 5, 2017
    9
    Five episodes in and I'm loving it. For all the critics saying this is derivative, of course it's derivative--it's a spoof on ST:TNG. I thought the first episode was pretty weak, but eps two through five are right up there with good eps of their inspiration. There's certainly more drama and plot than humor. It has enough wiggle room to inject silly gags, yet it takes itself seriouslyFive episodes in and I'm loving it. For all the critics saying this is derivative, of course it's derivative--it's a spoof on ST:TNG. I thought the first episode was pretty weak, but eps two through five are right up there with good eps of their inspiration. There's certainly more drama and plot than humor. It has enough wiggle room to inject silly gags, yet it takes itself seriously enough to tell satisfying stories. Live long and prosper, Orville!… Expand
  31. Mark1791
    Oct 5, 2017
    9
    The Orville is totally a Star Trek clone with comedy that manages to tap into what made Star Trek good. The humor is light and plays like a Star Trek episode if normal people were the crew rather than folks who always do the right thing because it's the 24th century. Some of the story lines aren't trivial either (Episode 3 About a Girl was a surprise) and really, really feels like oldThe Orville is totally a Star Trek clone with comedy that manages to tap into what made Star Trek good. The humor is light and plays like a Star Trek episode if normal people were the crew rather than folks who always do the right thing because it's the 24th century. Some of the story lines aren't trivial either (Episode 3 About a Girl was a surprise) and really, really feels like old school Star Trek. A surprising and refreshing breath of fresh air in an era where this type of show is seen as not being popular. I have no idea why the critics have bashed this when the audience ratings are so far off.… Expand
  32. SGAShepp
    Oct 5, 2017
    10
    This show surprised the crap out of me. I was going in expecting "Ted in space" but by was I wrong, and boy an I glad I was.
    This show actually has a pretty delicate balance between seriousness and humour. I'll sink into the drama the suddenly a character will need to use the bathroom. Then It'll all come back to me that it's comedy too!
    All I have to say is that ANYONE who likes    This show surprised the crap out of me. I was going in expecting "Ted in space" but by was I wrong, and boy an I glad I was.
    This show actually has a pretty delicate balance between seriousness and humour. I'll sink into the drama the suddenly a character will need to use the bathroom. Then It'll all come back to me that it's comedy too!
    All I have to say is that ANYONE who likes anything of the star trek series, likes anything Seth MacFarlane has done and wants a fresh spin on the star trek feel. Then please give this a try!    … Expand
  33. jcastlouis
    Oct 4, 2017
    1
    The Orville is so derivative that they literally have to explain in interviews why their legal team thinks CBS won't sue them for violating the Star Trek intellectual property rights. The first show is shallow and full of plot holes and the writing is sophomoric at best. And then the "humor." If your idea of funny is dick jokes and double entendres, then this show has plenty.. but theyThe Orville is so derivative that they literally have to explain in interviews why their legal team thinks CBS won't sue them for violating the Star Trek intellectual property rights. The first show is shallow and full of plot holes and the writing is sophomoric at best. And then the "humor." If your idea of funny is dick jokes and double entendres, then this show has plenty.. but they still aren't funny. And that's kind of the problem. The show is trying to be a serious science fiction entry -- which could be funny IF the writers focused the humor on parodying true sci fi. But the humor is all dick jokes and an alien blob sexually harassing the doctor (now in 50% of the episodes so far). That sort of thing might be mindlessly humorous if it wasn't in a show that takes place in the future where everything is supposed to be better and brighter. It's Star Trek Lite, which is fine for people who just want the comfort and familiarity of The Next Generation back. But Captain Picard never had to explain dick jokes on the bridge of the Enterprise.… Expand
  34. neverthehero
    Oct 4, 2017
    8
    This show is entertaining and funny. Seth MacFarlane stars as Ed Mercer, an officer in the Planetary Union's line of exploratory space cruisers who is given the Orville as his first command, only to discover that his ex-wife, Kelly Grayson (Adrianne Palicki), has been assigned to be his First Officer. The two seem to be a good fit for the show as well as the others who are cast. WhileThis show is entertaining and funny. Seth MacFarlane stars as Ed Mercer, an officer in the Planetary Union's line of exploratory space cruisers who is given the Orville as his first command, only to discover that his ex-wife, Kelly Grayson (Adrianne Palicki), has been assigned to be his First Officer. The two seem to be a good fit for the show as well as the others who are cast. While the writing is good, there is room for improvement for comedy but I suspect this will happen if the show is picked up for another season. I have to say, this is a very entertaining show and would recommend it to anyone who is or isn't a fan of the Star Trek series.… Expand
  35. Cosmic_Hound
    Oct 4, 2017
    9
    This show fills in that slot that has been left vacant since the end of the "The next generation" era Star Trek. It innovates in its own way, swapping technobabble for humour and campyness for self-awareness. The characters are interesting and diverse, there is conflict without unprofessional emotional outbursts on the bridge and while command style is laid back discipline is respected andThis show fills in that slot that has been left vacant since the end of the "The next generation" era Star Trek. It innovates in its own way, swapping technobabble for humour and campyness for self-awareness. The characters are interesting and diverse, there is conflict without unprofessional emotional outbursts on the bridge and while command style is laid back discipline is respected and the crew work together towards their goal. The starship is properly lit and up to modern future technology, with interesting and consistent designs for human and extrasolar spacecrafts and stations. The social commentary is open to more than a single interpretation and not partisan. The musical theme is very good, not as bombastic as the old ones but still delivering the idea of space adventure.
    While I am a fan of grimdark, I prefer "The Orville: the third generation" to "Star Trek Gothic".    … Expand
  36. TheThinker1958
    Oct 4, 2017
    10
    The ORVILLE is more than a space comedy. There are really funny jokes but the entire show is really good. The characters are all unique and strong. The CGI is some of the best I've ever seen (Star Trek: Discovery looks really dark and the story line is just war). The stories so far have been all good. I've been able to watch each episode 8 times without getting a bit tired of them. ThatThe ORVILLE is more than a space comedy. There are really funny jokes but the entire show is really good. The characters are all unique and strong. The CGI is some of the best I've ever seen (Star Trek: Discovery looks really dark and the story line is just war). The stories so far have been all good. I've been able to watch each episode 8 times without getting a bit tired of them. That has to be a plus for any show. In contrast, ST Discovery didn't motivate me to watch it again. The story line is very simple... and no jokes.… Expand
  37. MK500
    Oct 3, 2017
    9
    This show is weirdly true to Gene Rodenberry‘s Star Trek. Yes it often makes fun of Star Trek; but that’s OK (and I’m a huge Trekkie). It is well written and amusing; but it’s not just a comedy. The traditional exploration and moral conflicts that make Star Trek great are there; and you feel good at the end of each episode. It’s also a light hearted take on the future that doesn’t make youThis show is weirdly true to Gene Rodenberry‘s Star Trek. Yes it often makes fun of Star Trek; but that’s OK (and I’m a huge Trekkie). It is well written and amusing; but it’s not just a comedy. The traditional exploration and moral conflicts that make Star Trek great are there; and you feel good at the end of each episode. It’s also a light hearted take on the future that doesn’t make you depressed about where we are headed as a species. It’s so much better than the dark depressing abomination CBS is attempting to call Star Trek!… Expand
  38. abm0
    Oct 3, 2017
    8
    And once again the critics are out of their minds, bashing a show that, while a bit confusing at first, has actually managed to bring us far more believable and enjoyable Star Trek (featuring some actual space-trekking for a change!) than the official/"serious" CBS production, which has been an incoherent, self-important, cliche-ridden overly-violent mess so far.
  39. ulissesmt
    Oct 3, 2017
    10
    Really great show! Remember me of the pre JJ Abrams Start Trek movies. There is a really classic, TNG fell. I hope the guys get going for far more seasons.
  40. Palanthemion
    Oct 3, 2017
    9
    Currently the closest series to Star Trek. Classic story telling, so far good character development. It remains to be seen whether the Orville can create a living and breathing universe. Looking forward to it.
  41. Daniel_Campbell
    Oct 2, 2017
    2
    The Orville...I don't think it's going to hook me. A self indulgent, unfunny mess. It kind of feels like someone took a mediocre sitcom and removed the laugh track. The show isn't funny enough to be a comedy, not smart enough to be good science fiction, and not well written enough to be a good drama. It's just so...bleh.
  42. Bulk88
    Oct 2, 2017
    10
    The critics are totally off on this one. This show carries the spirit of Gene Rodenberry forward than any other show out now. The characters are both interesting and believable, plot lines are engaging and thought provoking, and the feel of the show is inspirational. Seriously, this show needs to be on the must see list for any Trekkie.
  43. QACritic
    Oct 2, 2017
    9
    Watched the first 4 episodes and this is more Star Trek (TOS and TNG) than Family Guy and it is a fun lighthearted show instead of the typical doom and gloom that is available now although it does tackle some controversial issues. Ignore the critics and give it a chance it has potential, most of the characters are likable and they have personalities that are realistic with a sense of humorWatched the first 4 episodes and this is more Star Trek (TOS and TNG) than Family Guy and it is a fun lighthearted show instead of the typical doom and gloom that is available now although it does tackle some controversial issues. Ignore the critics and give it a chance it has potential, most of the characters are likable and they have personalities that are realistic with a sense of humor even if it does not work sometimes. All of them are competent at their jobs with typical human flaws and characteristic. I am wandering how long before they get hit by lawsuit from Star Trek considering the similarities.… Expand
  44. Ricochetv1
    Oct 2, 2017
    8
    They're going after some hard issues, Ep 3 especially, and showing that things don't always have to play out in some kind of picture-perfect way, as usually happened in Star Trek. It's easy to get caught up in the drama, but then you're quickly reminded this is a comedy, though I think the better genre for this would be "Dramedy". I do feel that some of the humor is forced, and feels aThey're going after some hard issues, Ep 3 especially, and showing that things don't always have to play out in some kind of picture-perfect way, as usually happened in Star Trek. It's easy to get caught up in the drama, but then you're quickly reminded this is a comedy, though I think the better genre for this would be "Dramedy". I do feel that some of the humor is forced, and feels a little awkward at times, but I'm enjoying the series too much to really care.… Expand
  45. NotchFilter
    Oct 2, 2017
    5
    This show is like chewing-gum for the mind. There's not a lot of depth to it, but it's fun to watch.

    At least parts of it are. Other parts are drawn out to be much longer than they should be. The episodes where the show tries to tackle deep issues (such the episode with as the female baby), well, the show's weak writing foundation crumples under the load of what it is trying to    This show is like chewing-gum for the mind. There's not a lot of depth to it, but it's fun to watch.

    At least parts of it are. Other parts are drawn out to be much longer than they should be.

    The episodes where the show tries to tackle deep issues (such the episode with as the female baby), well, the show's weak writing foundation crumples under the load of what it is trying to say.

    This is a fun show. Mr. MacFarlane's Captain is more reminiscent of Kirk than Picard. If only the writing were on a par with the graphics, I'd probably give the show an 8 or 9.

    The stories seem to be too familiar, it is the "don't take yourself seriously" style of this show that helps it to stand out from the rest of the pack.

    But it does not stand out too far.    … Expand
  46. Hemp316
    Oct 2, 2017
    9
    From what I have seen of the Series so far,I really like The Orville and am extremely excited to see it succeed.For all these Critics giving it such A hard time they obviously are way off base with the rest of us.I happen to think that the Orville is A very faithful,clever and funny homage to Star Trek,yet at the same time goes to great strides to convey the Drama of A Star Trek SeriesFrom what I have seen of the Series so far,I really like The Orville and am extremely excited to see it succeed.For all these Critics giving it such A hard time they obviously are way off base with the rest of us.I happen to think that the Orville is A very faithful,clever and funny homage to Star Trek,yet at the same time goes to great strides to convey the Drama of A Star Trek Series without disrespecting it in anyway,shape or form.Seth McFarlane has always been quite talented and I have enjoyed his
    involvement in anything he's ever been in and he really stands out in A positive way on this show.

    The rest of the Cast is talented,well casted and overall great at their particular roles.The guest stars are part of the show I really enjoy the most as most so far have been from either the various Star Trek Series or involvement with voice overs from Family Guy,American Dad or one of many Seth McFarlane's Movies he's been involved in.They are also well casted and I get really excited seeing them every single Week!

    Overall,I think FOX and Critics are doing everything they can to find An excuse to cancel this show as they do with so many other show that are gone before their time and I have to say it's unfair and way off base when most common people I have seen have had nothing but rave reviews about the show,I would suggest those who support the show do everything they can to spread the word to others.Hopefully,there this show will go on and there will be A season two,because from what I have seen so far there is every indication that Orville has the success it so rightfully deserves.    … Expand
  47. keklolgloat
    Oct 1, 2017
    10
    As a 30-year-old growing up in Canada on cold snowy nights curling up and watching Trek with my family was a highlight growing up. Orville hits this ooey-gooey feeling right on the nose, it just feels; Trek.

    Also: interesting disparity between the critic reviews and the user reviews; gee wizz, could the critics be *GASP* wrong?
  48. Trokil
    Oct 1, 2017
    10
    In the Orville Seth MacFarlane shows, that he knows why people liked Star Trek. This is a show in love with the sci-fi shows of the 80’s and 90’s and why so many people were becoming fans for life. It is a homage to classic TV and is fun to watch while the crew deals every week with funny, interesting and important topics. But nothing feels so heavy handed like in Discovery, it is stillIn the Orville Seth MacFarlane shows, that he knows why people liked Star Trek. This is a show in love with the sci-fi shows of the 80’s and 90’s and why so many people were becoming fans for life. It is a homage to classic TV and is fun to watch while the crew deals every week with funny, interesting and important topics. But nothing feels so heavy handed like in Discovery, it is still good-hearted in its core. There is still this optimism towards the future we loved in shows like TNG. A wonderful show for all fans who are done with all those gritty reboots of their favorite sci-fi franchises.… Expand
  49. Cron0s69
    Sep 30, 2017
    8
    Sorry for my bad english
    Star Trek is Star Trek , The Orville Is The orville ,comparing Star Trek to The orville, do not make sense ,Is need the time for the new serie , oh the episode 4 be drawn from the novel Oprhans of the sky by Robert Heinlein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orphans_of_the_Sky
  50. PandaFromHell05
    Sep 30, 2017
    10
    First off, don't listen to the critics on this one. As always, THEY ARE WRONG.

    At first, hearing about Seth MacFarlane coming out with a Galaxy Quest style TV show intrigued me. If anyone knows Seth MacFarlane, you must know that he's a Star Trek fan. He's provided audio commentary on the "Cause and Effect" episode on the Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 5 Blu-Ray, and he    First off, don't listen to the critics on this one. As always, THEY ARE WRONG.

    At first, hearing about Seth MacFarlane coming out with a Galaxy Quest style TV show intrigued me. If anyone knows Seth MacFarlane, you must know that he's a Star Trek fan. He's provided audio commentary on the "Cause and Effect" episode on the Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 5 Blu-Ray, and he guest-starred in 2 Star Trek: Enterprise episodes. Between appreciating his humor style in shows like Family Guy and in movies like Ted and A Million Ways to Die in the West, I decided to give this show a shot.

    I admit, I was a little skeptical after the pilot. It could either go really well or really bad. Fortunately, after watching episodes 2, 3, and 4, I have decided that I like this show so much that I will purchase it on BluRay when it comes out.

    In a nutshell, this is basically Star Trek: The Next Generation with Seth MacFarlane's humor. It goes hand-in-hand. It even belongs in the Star Trek universe by replacing words like "Enterprise" to "Orville", "cutting beam" to "phaser beam", and "Federation" to "Union". Look at the uniforms..very similar to Trek. This is also a good opportunity for amazing directors from the Trek franchise, like Brannon Braga and Jonathan Frakes to prosper by directing episodes. I feel if Leonard Nimoy were alive, he'd give this a try as well.

    If you like Family Guy and like Star Trek, give this a shot. You won't be disappointed. I give this a 10/10. Perfection and amazing re-watchability in my book. Excited for a Season 2!    … Expand
  51. Kyle999
    Sep 30, 2017
    10
    What the hell do critics know! This is the Star Trek we've been waiting for! A plot/character driven sci-fi show that tackles social issues of the day. Discovery sucks compared to The Orville. I'm willing to bet this show has a lot more staying power than the critics think. If you love mindless explosions go watch the new Star Trek. If you want people and stories you are going toWhat the hell do critics know! This is the Star Trek we've been waiting for! A plot/character driven sci-fi show that tackles social issues of the day. Discovery sucks compared to The Orville. I'm willing to bet this show has a lot more staying power than the critics think. If you love mindless explosions go watch the new Star Trek. If you want people and stories you are going to care about, than the Orville is for you!… Expand
  52. thanatopsis
    Sep 30, 2017
    8
    It plays it a bit safe, and the jokes often fall flat, but it isn't so much funny as it is witty. It isn't perfect, but the critics don't give it enough credit. I didn't care for the first two shows, but the last two were much better. If you generally like Star Trek and/or Seth, give it a try, more than a few episodes.
    It is more Star Trek-like than the last few Star Trek movies with    It plays it a bit safe, and the jokes often fall flat, but it isn't so much funny as it is witty. It isn't perfect, but the critics don't give it enough credit. I didn't care for the first two shows, but the last two were much better. If you generally like Star Trek and/or Seth, give it a try, more than a few episodes.
    It is more Star Trek-like than the last few Star Trek movies with their dumbed-down plots and heavy use of action. I'll happily take some good and bad jokes in place of pointless action sequences.    … Expand
  53. SebastianP
    Sep 30, 2017
    10
    Its the Star Trek i missed since TNG.
    I love the design, positive attitude and storytelling. I also love the fact it deals with philosphical questions again. The jokes are funny and not annoying at all. Everything Star Trek did wrong the last years is done right here. No need for lens flare, war, social competition and actioncam, just good old storytelling in a great sympathical way. I    Its the Star Trek i missed since TNG.
    I love the design, positive attitude and storytelling. I also love the fact it deals with philosphical questions again. The jokes are funny and not annoying at all. Everything Star Trek did wrong the last years is done right here. No need for lens flare, war, social competition and actioncam, just good old storytelling in a great sympathical way. I really hope this Series gets bigger! Thank you Seth!    … Expand
  54. juan_pueblo
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    La verdad, que no se quienes son los que opinan y por ende tampoco que es lo que buscan. La verdad que se trata de una serie de ciencia ficción, que homenajea a otras como Star Trek, pero ante las situaciones problemas buscan presentar la solución de una persona normal y no el de un ser superior miembro de una sociedad utópica. No entiendo el tipo de personas que mira padre de familia oLa verdad, que no se quienes son los que opinan y por ende tampoco que es lo que buscan. La verdad que se trata de una serie de ciencia ficción, que homenajea a otras como Star Trek, pero ante las situaciones problemas buscan presentar la solución de una persona normal y no el de un ser superior miembro de una sociedad utópica. No entiendo el tipo de personas que mira padre de familia o similares o una peli de james franco y seth rogen y se rasgan las vestiduras porque no les suena a shakespeare, es pedir peras al olmo. Como dice el refrán al pan, pan y al vino, vino, no pretendan buscar las cinco patas al gato, ni generar grandes expectativas, cuando claramente el show apunta hacia otra dirección. Señores críticones (no críticos) si no les gusta, cambien de canal, miren otra cosa o filmen su propia serie. Hay mucha gente contenta con esta serie, feliz de contar al aire actualmente con dos programas de tales características (me refiero a la nueva de star trek), vivan y dejen vivir a los demás, no estamos obligados a compartir sus gustos, como tampoco ustedes los nuestros. Existe algo llamado control remoto, úsenlo.… Expand
  55. AuraBoyX
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    AWESOME SHOW!!! A bit of camp and a whole lot of the true soul of Star Trek! I am so glad this show wasn't what I expected it to be (a Family Guy style comedy in space). Screw Discovery - this show is great!
  56. 123movie
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    LOVED it...... Quite simply it is fun! I´ve watched the first four episodes and crave more. It´s character driven... I already am rooting for several of them!
    I watched Star Trek Discovery and was bored to death... Klingons have been a snooze fest since the beginning of time. The Orville is a lot more interesting, fun and thoroughly enjoyable. May it Live Long and bring Prosperity to    LOVED it...... Quite simply it is fun! I´ve watched the first four episodes and crave more. It´s character driven... I already am rooting for several of them!
    I watched Star Trek Discovery and was bored to death... Klingons have been a snooze fest since the beginning of time. The Orville is a lot more interesting, fun and thoroughly enjoyable. May it Live Long and bring Prosperity to its sponsors so that it gets picked up for a second season and more... Love it!    … Expand
  57. TwiTu
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    I didnt know what to expect. I read some peoples opinion that this is more Star Trek than Discovery will ever be, but I had my doubts, because I fell for mainstream critics, whose completely biased and even more false "reviews" you can see here. I was actually hooked from the first episode.

    As I said, I had my doubts, I thought it would be a full blown parody of Star Trek, which I    I didnt know what to expect. I read some peoples opinion that this is more Star Trek than Discovery will ever be, but I had my doubts, because I fell for mainstream critics, whose completely biased and even more false "reviews" you can see here. I was actually hooked from the first episode.

    As I said, I had my doubts, I thought it would be a full blown parody of Star Trek, which I wouldnt have cared for much, but its far far FAR from that.
    What would best describe it? Star Trek. But massively expanded on its humor. But no parody at all. Maybe here and there a few puns, but nothing that would make the show look ridiculous. It actually has very serious topics in its episodes, which bring tears to my eyes due to laughter (seriously, some of the best jokes and situational comedy I have ever seen) and due to being such a contrast to the propaganda that is Discovery and blowing it out of Star Trek waters, which is ultimately why it gets a 10 and not a 9 from me.

    You love every single character instantly. Yes, every single one of them. They are original, they are diverse, they are good actors, they all fit together well, the dialogs are witty, intelligent, funny and even as deep as Star Trek on its best day. The chemistry is simply amazing.

    With Discovery, Star Trek has been raped by the neoliberal ideology to unrecognizability, but this is a more than worthy successor! And thats also why I am not surprised at all, that those very neoliberal "critics" are trashing it that much. They know exactly its 1000 times better than Discovery, but doesnt offer any propaganda value for their side, in fact exposes it.

    I can only recommend to watch it yourself instead of trusting these paid demagogues. You will laugh, and you will recognize Star Trek in it.    … Expand
  58. afngary
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    Was really impressed by this Star Trek clone. Thought it was going to be so so with the light humor, but found that it really updated it with the times. It's as if you added 10% Family Guy with 90% true Star Trek format. Really liked it and really glad to finally have a science fiction show to watch since the late 90's.
  59. weinishao
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    This show is great. I hope it goes for 10 seasons. A mix of pure Star Trek Nostalgia, cultural references, character development and Farlane's humor, makes it relevant for today's audience. Don't listen to the critics, watch it. Four episodes in and it even better, character development has an incredible well paced timing, and it gives you that " I what the next episode now" feeling fromThis show is great. I hope it goes for 10 seasons. A mix of pure Star Trek Nostalgia, cultural references, character development and Farlane's humor, makes it relevant for today's audience. Don't listen to the critics, watch it. Four episodes in and it even better, character development has an incredible well paced timing, and it gives you that " I what the next episode now" feeling from the Star Trek of old.… Expand
  60. Semtex_Steve
    Sep 29, 2017
    8
    This show is very enjoyable and, like everyone else is saying, it has a bit of a Next Generation style in the way it presents dilemma and conflict. The comedy aspect is often very basic, but it can raise the odd chuckle and the characters are interesting. I really look forward to seeing what this show can become in the future and hope that it is given a fair chance to grow.

    It's not a    This show is very enjoyable and, like everyone else is saying, it has a bit of a Next Generation style in the way it presents dilemma and conflict. The comedy aspect is often very basic, but it can raise the odd chuckle and the characters are interesting. I really look forward to seeing what this show can become in the future and hope that it is given a fair chance to grow.

    It's not a straight-up comedy, or drama, or techno-babble sci-fi, but a mix of all three that is actually really difficult to describe. The closest thing I can compare it to is Galaxy Quest, mixed with Next Generation, mixed with Red Dwarf - but with Seth MacFarlane's sense of humor. I would certainly recommend people see the first few episodes for themselves and make their own judgment - because the critics seem really confused about this show.    … Expand
  61. Dudleyk2
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    I am amazed at how badly this was reviewed by the professional critics on this site. So many of the new Sci Fi shows as in Star Trek Discovery displays our future as one homogenized politically correct society. The characters in Orville are evolved and also show the same insecurity’s and weaknesses inherent in being human.
    Oh yeah and it is really entertaining
  62. ppstudent
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    As a Trek long time fan, I'm impressed in the way the first four episodes went. Star Trek Orville has a strong cast, a strong story line, and a lot of humor (both flat and funny). They continue to get better every week while maintaining the humor (a mix of funny and flat jokes). You get a 10 score!
  63. Voodoo123
    Sep 29, 2017
    10
    +Great visual homage to Star Trek TNG
    +Exceptional cast
    +Excellent soundtrack +Like galaxy quest/Red Dwarf, when orville uses parody it really understands the material from which it is derived +Dramatic / ethical debates within story like classic star trek -Seth Macfarlane This show exceeded my expectations massively. As a fan of star trek I got a lot of enjoyment from this. Only    +Great visual homage to Star Trek TNG
    +Exceptional cast
    +Excellent soundtrack
    +Like galaxy quest/Red Dwarf, when orville uses parody it really understands the material from which it is derived
    +Dramatic / ethical debates within story like classic star trek
    -Seth Macfarlane

    This show exceeded my expectations massively. As a fan of star trek I got a lot of enjoyment from this. Only two episodes in and I already feel engaged with the world building and find the humour is not played at detriment to telling a good story. Pretty much my only gripe is that Seth Macfarlane is so recognisable it sort of takes me out of the show a bit although I am warming up to his and the rest of his cast's excellent performance here. I will definitely be watching more of The Orville!    … Expand
  64. Boreas
    Sep 29, 2017
    7
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I just watched episode 4 and the show is starting to hit it's stride, it feels so much like TNG but also has elements of the original Star Trek. In particular episode 4 bares more the a passing relationship with 'For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky' TOS S03E08. It also nods to Asimov's 'Nightfall'.

    The blend of humour and drama still feels uneven, to be honest at times I just wished they'd drop the joke and play it straight.

    The show isn't perfect and still has some rough edges but if it's given time it will grow into something really good.    … Expand
  65. Jester27
    Sep 28, 2017
    10
    Pre-viewing impressions led me to believe that "The Orville" was going to be a pile of space junk, via most of the reviews left by critics. Sure it's not none stop belly laughs, & at times can be quite serious, nonetheless it is entertaining. I don't think it was intended to be a full blown comedy anyhow - just a Sci-Fi show with a little humour thrown in for good measure, just like otherPre-viewing impressions led me to believe that "The Orville" was going to be a pile of space junk, via most of the reviews left by critics. Sure it's not none stop belly laughs, & at times can be quite serious, nonetheless it is entertaining. I don't think it was intended to be a full blown comedy anyhow - just a Sci-Fi show with a little humour thrown in for good measure, just like other shows of this genre. There's obvious elements taken from past Sci-Fi shows, such as Star Trek, Star Wars & Babylon 5, but that's what makes it likable. I've been a "Trekkie" since I was old enough to understand the storylines & quite frankly I would favour this over the new CBS effort - Star Trek Discovery, having watched both. Give it a chance & ignore the critics, you won't regret it unless you're a big stick in the mud!… Expand
  66. Alvin_Pinsberry
    Sep 28, 2017
    8
    I think it's fashionable to hate on Seth MacFarlane shows. It certainly seems to be that way amongst critics. It's almost pathological, to the point that they'll prematurely write-off shows that he's in or involved with before even bothering to watch them.

    That's the only explanation I can think of for why this show was so critically panned, because it's solid. It's not perfect, by any    I think it's fashionable to hate on Seth MacFarlane shows. It certainly seems to be that way amongst critics. It's almost pathological, to the point that they'll prematurely write-off shows that he's in or involved with before even bothering to watch them.

    That's the only explanation I can think of for why this show was so critically panned, because it's solid. It's not perfect, by any stretch, but the three episodes I've seen were consistently good (episode 3 might even be great), and were definitely of high enough quality to warrant sticking with the show for at least the rest of the season.

    If, for whatever reason, you're still deciding whether or not to watch this show by the time you see this review, then I fully recommend that you do.    … Expand
  67. CalvinWheatley
    Sep 28, 2017
    9
    What I really love about this show is that it is a FUN take from Star Trek among other Sci-Fi shows. Its refreshing to see a comedy that's fun but serious enough to be believable. For years we've had the unbelievable premises and often untouchable or unrepeatable morality assumptions of what we expect our future brethren to become. Shows that give us characters of quality and morals thatWhat I really love about this show is that it is a FUN take from Star Trek among other Sci-Fi shows. Its refreshing to see a comedy that's fun but serious enough to be believable. For years we've had the unbelievable premises and often untouchable or unrepeatable morality assumptions of what we expect our future brethren to become. Shows that give us characters of quality and morals that seem impossible (at least considering today's mentality) are unachievable. Who can forget the Star Trek episodes that put the notions of "God", "racial and gender tensions, "meat-eaters and killing", "war and violence" or even "emotions" as notions that were primitive concepts only to find later that the show contradicts itself because too many religious folk were offended by the "lack of God" or too many racists were offended by ideas like Kirk and Uhura kissing, or even the rarity of men in the background of ST/TNG wearing mini-skirts. Episodes of the crew of the Enterprise finding the notion of eating mean repulsive only in later episodes to celebrate Thanksgiving with what would be assumed to be the corpse of a bird, even if it were tofu. The notion that animal consumption was repulsive was just not believable to our sensibilities.

    Here we have in The Orville a show that while obviously one would like to believe the characters are so evolved they are more human than most humans are (especially under the Trump regime). The show takes what could be considered as serious concepts (cheating spouses, single sex species, transgendered issues, etc.) along with notions of war, alien species, galactic treaties, not to mention awesome special effects and using the comedic talent of Seth MacFarlane have taken these very serious topics and made them fun and funny and at the same time have made them believable.

    Who could imagine a Captain's spouse cheating the Deep Space Nine? Who could imagine a Same-Sex couple on the Original Star Trek? Saurian Brandy? Yes but who could imagine a navigator drinking beer at 10 AM while excited to see his new ship? Or Hologram designers putting such twists in their games as to make their computer generated opponents Mexican criminals (as our President like to think of them) and instead of making them shoot the gamers, challenge them to a dance off?

    The special effects, the make up and costumes, the story lines, IT'S ALL FUN PEOPLE!! Where and what are these critics watching? We always were taught that human kind in the future would be better, non-racist, non-sexist, non-violent but we have all learned (especially in the last year) that our world and human kind can be an awful species and indeed racist, and sexist, and violent, all we have to do is observe our President and his words and actions and we will see these horrible traits from the people we imagine would one day take us to a magical world like the Star Trek series. The Orville gives us that magical world but in a way that I believe humans (and aliens) might truly act, especially given in the wake of Nazi soldiers on American streets.

    I LOVE "The Orville" and I hope that these few "professional critics" heed the word on the "Popular Vote". Look at the numbers above... 290 Positive 21 Mixed 43 Negative and yes I know these will change but imagine the critics and naysayers being our Electoral College and look who they chose for us.

    I hope that people will look at this show with an open mind and laugh and think "How much fun would that be" instead of the (even though I love the series) unbendable and often contradictory world of Star Trek.

    Anyway I give this show a rating of a 9 even though it really deserves a 10. I hope we give this show a chance.    … Expand
  68. toenisk
    Sep 28, 2017
    10
    Love the new series. It's nice to have a show that is fun and not campy and at the same time fills the void until The Expanse returns. The future is not all doom and gloom.
  69. pjosephson
    Sep 28, 2017
    3
    You know around the 6th season of a once good series the episodes seem to loose that magic they once had, characters leave the show and are replaced by new less interesting characters and episodes seem to repeat plots they did several seasons previously. Well surprise, that is the feeling you get just from watching the first few episodes of The Orville. It felt old a used up. Not thatYou know around the 6th season of a once good series the episodes seem to loose that magic they once had, characters leave the show and are replaced by new less interesting characters and episodes seem to repeat plots they did several seasons previously. Well surprise, that is the feeling you get just from watching the first few episodes of The Orville. It felt old a used up. Not that this series will last six seasons. I be surprised if it lasted one. This series blatantly rips of STNG and embarrassingly so. The characters and scripts are wooden. The acting is meh... especially once again MacFarlane. Don't get me wrong MacFarlane is talented man, just that acting is not one of those talents.

    The main problem is it can't decide if it is a bad comedy or misplaced action sci-fi. Neither work as The Orville is setup now. The comedy is often misplaced. In fact this may be the one show that a laugh track might help to let us know they were trying to be funny. Unlike the rip off of those other Sci-Fi trek shows (whoops, I mean homage to Sci-Fi trek shows) wherein the humor was strong banter between to characters and humor was in such a way it was added to accentuate the characters we care about. The Orville takes a strange approach with it's comedy. It is not exactly crude but definitely not light, it continuously references 20th century knowledge in it's humor, but, the banter is off perhaps a little arrogant. Perhaps they should decide to either be one or the other. Either be like Galaxy Quest (a true homage) that was a comedy about misfits with some drama. Or be like all the other Star Treks be a serious sci-fi show, honest and caring to the subject matter but with those little light humorous moments. As it stands now The Orville does the comedy badly and the Sci-Fi drama with no purpose other than to preach. It just awkward and rudderless.    … Expand
  70. Ulflander
    Sep 28, 2017
    10
    The Critics are way off on this way. Orville is an awesome homage to Star Trek in all the best ways. The ship designs are really cool, and so far the plots have been decent.
    I hope FOX doesn't pull a firefly and cancel this, because It really is enjoyable.
  71. scifinerd215
    Sep 27, 2017
    10
    I thought this show was going to be terrible, Guess what I loved it. It really reminded me of my childhood watching TNG. They really captured the essence of Star Trek a feat the new Star Trek movies and TV show cant seem to do. There are just the right amount of jokes and it doesn't kill the show. The ensemble cast is good. My only gripe would be, I wish Seth McFarlane wasn't in it. I knowI thought this show was going to be terrible, Guess what I loved it. It really reminded me of my childhood watching TNG. They really captured the essence of Star Trek a feat the new Star Trek movies and TV show cant seem to do. There are just the right amount of jokes and it doesn't kill the show. The ensemble cast is good. My only gripe would be, I wish Seth McFarlane wasn't in it. I know we have him to thank for it, but he's a bit unlikable and detracts from the show. Other than that the show is great. Good job guys..… Expand
  72. xcontractx
    Sep 27, 2017
    0
    Seth should stick to the crude humor of 2004 and leave the scifi to others.

    I didn't know how little I needed this show until they aired it, and now I know.
  73. drmagnumwolf
    Sep 27, 2017
    10
    this is what Star Trek: Discovery was supposed to be. This is Star Trek in all its forms, it also has hilarious moments, granted, some fall a bit short, but it is a great TV show!
  74. ulukay
    Sep 27, 2017
    10
    did not went in with much expectation ... but apart from some obvious macfarlane humor, it almost feels like a natural extension of Star Trek TNG.
    It has reasonable good CGI, some cool characters, does the whole "exporation" part of Star Trek, AND is funny.
  75. Al5421
    Sep 26, 2017
    9
    I've watched two episodes of 'The Orville' and I found the series very entertaining .... a pleasant surprise ... I expected something different.

    The series is decently written ... with some imaginative space adventures ... the Orville's crew, human and alien interact well between themselves with some cheeky humour here and there ... and the special effects remind me of that used during    I've watched two episodes of 'The Orville' and I found the series very entertaining .... a pleasant surprise ... I expected something different.

    The series is decently written ... with some imaginative space adventures ... the Orville's crew, human and alien interact well between themselves with some cheeky humour here and there ... and the special effects remind me of that used during the 1960's ... the show itself reminds me very much of Star Trek s 'Original Series' ... however the Orville is a kind of parody / drama of 'OS' ... a series that just does not take itself too seriously.

    I found I was interested in the characters and their adventures ... and strangely I actually prefer it to the new Star Trek 'Discovery' show ... I also watched two episodes of 'Discovery'.

    I'll give 'The Orville' a 9 ...    … Expand
  76. flowbeus
    Sep 26, 2017
    9
    I wasn't expecting much here but I was surprised how good this was. I watched the first 3 episodes and was really impressed. For me Star Trek is all about morality, ethics, culture, humanity, politics, etc, the best elements of science fiction mixed with an optimistic vision of the future.

    I've been very disappointed in the direction Star Trek has been going over the years, opting for    I wasn't expecting much here but I was surprised how good this was. I watched the first 3 episodes and was really impressed. For me Star Trek is all about morality, ethics, culture, humanity, politics, etc, the best elements of science fiction mixed with an optimistic vision of the future.

    I've been very disappointed in the direction Star Trek has been going over the years, opting for more space battles and special effects rather than thought-provoking dilemmas and focusing on the wonders of the cosmos.

    The Orville seems to be filling in the dark hole that the absence of Star Trek has left in us. There is humor in the show, but it's not the main focus, and the show is dabbling in serious issues like the ethics of sex-change operations and cultural/racial elitism.

    We can forgive the show for trying to find its footing and establish the right balance between comedy and drama. This is normal for a show that's just starting out. But there is a lot to love so far, and the show's heart is in the right place for a fantastic series. Fox please don't Firefly this one...    … Expand
  77. ginberryblue
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    The Orville is the Star Trek I've been wishing for for years. The heart of Trek is (or was!) optimism, a thoughtful exploration of human society, and *humor*. The Orville delivers at warp 11. I don't know what show those idiot critics were watching. If you want a show that makes you think and laugh at the same time, The Orville is for you.
  78. flik221
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    This show has it all. Humor, adventure, fun characters, and blows Star Trek Discovery out of the water. Amazing show that if there is any justice in the universe will be around for many years.
  79. EdmundF
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    Its sad to say but the Orville as a parody of Star Trek actually does a better job filling the Star Trek gap than the current Star Trek Reboot. Beyond that it is independently funny and the characters are surprisingly well crafted. The critics as usual have no idea what is good.
  80. Jesp1
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    Refreshing! Feels like the Star Trek of TNG yore. Definitely gave me nostalgia tickle vibes. And interestingly is safe enough for the younger ones without being too inappropriate. Definitely going to give it a chance!
  81. xeron
    Sep 25, 2017
    8
    Great, refreshing, representative mil command, bright special effects can only be growing and critical reason for like, better effects than Galaxy Quest. Star Trek no compare. Re-watched several times. Storyline good enough to support special effects and science, storyline can be like long running Simpsons and South Park. "a Science show!"
  82. BarkingPumpkin
    Sep 25, 2017
    4
    Not funny enough, not smarmy enough, it's almost interesting enough simply because we're familiar with vaguely similar older TV shows, but in the end it's just not worth the time.
  83. sanchopancho
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    The critics are smoking crack and totally missed the mark. The Orville is what Star Trek-like scifi is supposed to be about: exploration, entertainment, and escapism. Having watched it back to back with the new Star Trek Discovery, I know which show I will be following.
  84. Dracology
    Sep 25, 2017
    8
    The Orville is a breath of fresh air in a sea of SciFi shows dedicated to showing how grim and dark the future might be. While it has room for improvement in 3 episodes it's already shown more heart and brought more joy than most recent series in the genre and proven it can tackle complicated issues without resorting to demonizing parts of the argument.

    It carries with it the spirit of    The Orville is a breath of fresh air in a sea of SciFi shows dedicated to showing how grim and dark the future might be. While it has room for improvement in 3 episodes it's already shown more heart and brought more joy than most recent series in the genre and proven it can tackle complicated issues without resorting to demonizing parts of the argument.

    It carries with it the spirit of Trek, and I'm eager to watch even more in the future.    … Expand
  85. Ehkzu
    Sep 25, 2017
    7
    My wife & I watched Star Trek: Discover with my brother, two other couples and one of their kids (12 y.o.). My wife & I have seen all of the Star Trek franches—TV shows & the movies. The other couples, less so.

    Afterwards we watched The Orville pilot. All 8 of liked The Orville better, and my wife and I both thought The Orville was, against all odds, truer to Roddenberry’s vision than    My wife & I watched Star Trek: Discover with my brother, two other couples and one of their kids (12 y.o.). My wife & I have seen all of the Star Trek franches—TV shows & the movies. The other couples, less so.

    Afterwards we watched The Orville pilot. All 8 of liked The Orville better, and my wife and I both thought The Orville was, against all odds, truer to Roddenberry’s vision than the official heir to the franchise throne.
    Less pretentious, funnier, more thoughtful, with more engaging characters—including the Krill baddies.

    We found Discovery less believable, despite the cartoony/spoofy elements of The Orville. We found Discovery to be more full of itself, and more straining to achieve its desired results. In Hawaiian Pidgin you’d say “Tryin’, brah?”

    Discover wasn’t actively bad, but as other reviewers here have said, it bears the Curse of Abrams—embracing the outward aspects of Trek without the heart and soul of Roddenberry’s vision.

    How ironic that the creator of Family Guy and a practising Sinatra-style lounge singer would star in a more Trek-hearted show than the official version.

    I’ve also seen The Orville’s episodes 2 and 3 and it gets better as it goes along—less of the 13 year old boy humor bits, more substance. Episode three takes today’s transgender controversies and goes where no man has gone before—with poignant, thoughtful ending to a show that had almost no “action” but was full of ideas and character development instead. Roddenberry lives.

    Now if sci fi shows could go where no show but 2001 and Firefly/Serenity have gone, and realize that space ships don't go Whoosh! as they pass you in space...    … Expand
  86. Augen76
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    Embodies much of what makes Star Trek great, with a lighter feel. Some of the jokes fall flat, but the characters are likable and the stories engaging. This is not a parody akin to Spaceballs, its a love letter to Star Trek with some modern humor. The sets, models, effects, and make up are all spot on giving the series a welcoming feel and surprisingly high production value. The alienEmbodies much of what makes Star Trek great, with a lighter feel. Some of the jokes fall flat, but the characters are likable and the stories engaging. This is not a parody akin to Spaceballs, its a love letter to Star Trek with some modern humor. The sets, models, effects, and make up are all spot on giving the series a welcoming feel and surprisingly high production value. The alien designs and concepts thus far have been diverse and fascinating. Using this as a back drop we get character and philosophical episodes that don't play out the way I expected which is refreshing. Score - 10/10 I haven't been this excited about a new television series in years because it really comes across as a passion project than a soulless money making product. It may take time to find its stride, but early on I am sold on The Orville.… Expand
  87. Pastafarian
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    Best new show of 2017. It feels like star trek but with a lot of humor. Good actors and funny aliens make a good team. They also tackle moral issue's without taking its self to serious.
  88. Shermos
    Sep 24, 2017
    9
    I have only seen the first episode. I will edit this review upon completion of the season. No spoilers.

    Ignore the critics. If you miss old school Star Trek and are sick of dark sci-fi, you will likely enjoy Orville. It is very clearly a love letter to the kind of Star Trek which came out before 2009. The show is trying to be a bit like Mash with a very healthy dose of Star Trek    I have only seen the first episode. I will edit this review upon completion of the season. No spoilers.

    Ignore the critics. If you miss old school Star Trek and are sick of dark sci-fi, you will likely enjoy Orville. It is very clearly a love letter to the kind of Star Trek which came out before 2009.

    The show is trying to be a bit like Mash with a very healthy dose of Star Trek thrown in. It's a comedy which also deals with serious subjects from time to time. Most of the characters (especially the aliens) are interesting and I look forward to learning more about them and their backstories as the show progresses.

    The show is also interesting because it's not showcasing the best and brightest humanity has to offer. The Orville is a mid level ship and the crew is not perfect, just doing the best they can with what they have.

    I expect upon completion of the season, my rating will go up.    … Expand
  89. RCDVOK
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    I wanted to see Star Trek Discovery first before I wrote a review to see which is better. I can say that The Orville is way better hands down. It does get silly at times but as a true Star Trek fan for over 30 years and faithful to every series this is more inline with Star Trek then Discovery. I was hoping I would be following Discovery because I thought it had a bigger budget and stuffI wanted to see Star Trek Discovery first before I wrote a review to see which is better. I can say that The Orville is way better hands down. It does get silly at times but as a true Star Trek fan for over 30 years and faithful to every series this is more inline with Star Trek then Discovery. I was hoping I would be following Discovery because I thought it had a bigger budget and stuff but I was wrong.

    Until they realize and either change Discovery (which I know the over paid Exec at CBS won't admit they scewed up and change) or cancel which they won't do till forced to, I will watch Discovery. It's fun light and uplifting like TNG AND TOS. To bad so sad for Discovery.    … Expand
  90. PeteyFlip
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    I love this show! I seriously hope it makes it for the long haul. It's a great Star Trek homage, along with basically the typical Seth MacFalane humor. I'm really enjoying it. The storyline is really good. I've seen homages to Star Trek and the Twilight Zone both so far along with hitting on real life issues here and there. Really a wonderful show.
  91. Ariadne
    Sep 24, 2017
    6
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I looked forward to this all summer. I wanted it to be so much. It didn't have to be Star Trek or Family Guy, but a nice mix was just fine. However, what I didn't expect was to be preached at.

    The first episode was about keeping weapons in 'our safe hands' and out of the hands of our enemies. Actually, the pilot was it's best show, so far.

    The second episode was about the evils of zoos and the third, well, I just don't even know which social message they were going for... was it the feminist story or was it a transgender story. Heck was it just a nod to the pro-circumcision people? Maybe it was a re-imagining of the futility of putting an (innocent) black person on trial during the 40s, because the tribunal, which was badly written, and badly argued, was stacked with a prejudiced jury who were somehow expected to 'see the light'... and didn't. It was unsatisfying at best.

    I wanted so much more for this show. Leave the politics and social commentary at home. just write some good stories or I think the Orville will have a short run.    … Expand
  92. stevegroundhog
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    The Orville is a fantastic fresh take on a the bleak and dark Star Trek franchise. It is essentially Star Trek, but better. By giving us a dramedy set in the style of Next Generation, this show has the bright future to break out at least more seasons than Star Trek the orignal series.

    No doubt the mainstream critics were paid off to bash it due to Discovery debuting. Discovery will be a    The Orville is a fantastic fresh take on a the bleak and dark Star Trek franchise. It is essentially Star Trek, but better. By giving us a dramedy set in the style of Next Generation, this show has the bright future to break out at least more seasons than Star Trek the orignal series.

    No doubt the mainstream critics were paid off to bash it due to Discovery debuting. Discovery will be a bland, dark, bleak, piece of SJW crap from a show that has lost it's way. Do yourself a favor, if you want to go back to the way Star Trek is supposed to be then watch this show.

    Also.... FOX do not screw us over.    … Expand
  93. Opinionated75
    Sep 24, 2017
    9
    A genuinely witty antidote for the overwrought and cheerless barrage of space programs. Not quite Galaxy Quest in quality, but good enough for free TV.
  94. LucaRanieri
    Sep 24, 2017
    1
    From my impressions of the first episode,Garbage. total disappointment.
    Not god, very disappointment tv show ever.
    there is nothing original in this series
    I would like to clear the memory of my mind, really realy really really bad.
    I hope they will cancel it soon.
  95. Akilax
    Sep 24, 2017
    3
    My impression after having seen the first three episodes and some snippets from previews:

    "I must be watching a different show than all those users who praise it here." Usually I find myself siding more with the user score on metacritic, but on this one the critics are right. The only positive quality about this show to me were the visuals. There was a real effort made to make    My impression after having seen the first three episodes and some snippets from previews:

    "I must be watching a different show than all those users who praise it here."

    Usually I find myself siding more with the user score on metacritic, but on this one the critics are right.

    The only positive quality about this show to me were the visuals. There was a real effort made to make this show look convincingly like a "Star Trek" spin-off (not that it claims to be). The CGI is of good quality and many elements seem as though they were taken straight out of the "Star Trek" universe. Elements like the uniforms and their color coding system were almost copied, the computer consoles and ship designs have a lot of similarities and the technology presented so far reminds me a lot of many of the "Star Trek" episodes I have seen. Unfortunately this is where the similarities end.

    Considering the characters, their quirks and how they play together, the show is a complete disaster. Almost everything comes out of the blue, which may be understandable for a fresh show, but for those remembering the "Star Trek" series, character development was gradual, comprehensible and often happened in interesting interactions or events.
    Not so with "The Orville". Usually a change of mind that gets explained through a joke, makes a character do something they otherwise wouldn't have done, but it often feels more like an excuse for having no explanation at all. Deeply rooted convictions get thrown aside and if you ask how this makes any sense you have to accept that another "moment of comedy" just made it so and therefore it does not have to follow logic or be compelling.
    No, from the point of view of characters, this show fails severely.

    Considering the actual plot of the episodes, there is more disappointment to be had.
    I will not go into the perceived pushing of political views (that the show does consistently) too much, but I want to say that I found it to be very annoying despite not even disagreeing or having a stake in most views expressed. It was just done in such a bad way, it almost felt as though they wanted to break the 4th wall by intention at times. It came across as really bad storytelling.
    Otherwise the plot is quite stale. Leaving the political aspects out of it there are no interesting storylines. The show seems very episodic at the moment with little meta-plot developing between episodes. Any surprises or even plot holes get covered by "humor" and events do not have to follow logic, so you are left just passively consuming something with no intellectual engagement. Star Trek was quite a different experience for me.

    Now some may feel like I expected "Star Trek" and got disappointed, but that would be wrong. I expected comedy and got none, so I looked at what was left and saw Sci-Fi pretending to be similar to "Star Trek" and even failing at that. That is why I compare it.

    You could also take "Firefly" as a comparison. That show was truly funny with great characters and it was consistent in its own world following logical consequences within that world. "Firefly" did manage to combine Comedy with Drama in a Sci-Fi setting in its own charming way.

    "The Orville" fails, because it does not sprinkle comedy into a good story with some drama, but rather tries to save bad stories with the excuse of comical events that only exist to make the story go on somehow and aren't even funny themselves.

    I hope Seth MacFarlane will find a way to change this show in a way he can actually get his strengths to work in synergy with it. Unfortunately, the talents I have seen from him in the past do not show here at all and the huge effort put into this show seems wasted so far.    … Expand
  96. suelyntorg
    Sep 23, 2017
    3
    Succeeds at no level. I assume they are going for a mild Star Trek spoof with light-hearted comedy laid over an interesting SciFi plot with characters who grow over time. It does not succeed. The jokes are 21st century Family Guy, would be inappropriate/antiquated in the future and fall flat even in the present. As soon as I heard 'dude' and 'bite me' a few times, I knew it wasn't forSucceeds at no level. I assume they are going for a mild Star Trek spoof with light-hearted comedy laid over an interesting SciFi plot with characters who grow over time. It does not succeed. The jokes are 21st century Family Guy, would be inappropriate/antiquated in the future and fall flat even in the present. As soon as I heard 'dude' and 'bite me' a few times, I knew it wasn't for me. I agree it has great special effects. It's such a Star Trek rip-off, it should be a copy-right violation. The characters are blatant rip-offs. But viewers of Family Guy humor may love it. It makes all the mistakes of Star Trek with none of its redeeming qualities. It tries to be Galaxy Quest with none of it's humor or class.… Expand
  97. morgan234
    Sep 23, 2017
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. THE ORVILLE. NEGATIVE 5

    To whom it may concern:

    I am 71, an avid Science Fiction fan, and have never, ever written in to comment about any TV show ever before in my life, so you can judge this letter from that fact.
    Also I am not a sexist. I thoroughly enjoyed the show Voyager and enjoyed seeing a woman as captain. I liked Captain Janeway. I gave that show an overall rating of about 7 out of 10, the same rating I gave Star Trek TNG.

    The Orville deserves a negative rating. -5 would be about right. That's a negative five, below zero. I would rank it lower but the production values bring the score up.

    I watched the first show and was thoroughly with the basic premise.
    If I understand it correctly the premise is this: No matter how much a woman cheats and betrays a man he should forgive her because it is all his fault, anyway, because he didn't pay her enough attention.
    Imagine Scotty telling Kirk “You fired me because I sabotaged the engines, but, Capitan, it was your fault because you wouldn't give me the raise I wanted. Oh, by the way, I've pulled some strings and I'm now your second in command.” And Kirk saying, “You're absolutely right, Scotty. It's all my fault. Welcome back aboard, trustworthy crew member!”

    The problem with the captain: He is portrayed as an easy-going mild mannered milksop. If a woman's betrayal could send the character as portrayed into such a descent then he's not captain material in the first place. When he caved in and accepted the untrustworthy ex-wife as his Second that demonstrated his lack of character and of his incompetence.
    We have a woman who has already betrayed him once, and he accepts her into a position where he has to trust her absolutely. No way should you grant trust to anyone who has already shown their untrustworthiness. The way this man caved to the demand that he accept her in this position demonstrates his emasculation. This is not the personality required of a captain of any vessel, let alone one of starfleet's.

    How did the woman in question get to this position? Nepotism and secret manipulating. Sure, she says she's doing the poor jerk a favor, but she is secretly tinkering with his life, and has connived a position for herself where she can be there in person to watch the fool dance to her tune.

    This man is supposed to put his absolute trust in a backstabbing, cheating, behind-the-scenes manipulating ex-spouse. The Afghan's have stoning pits in every village just for women like this. However in the Orville's world, untrustworthy personalities are promoted to positions of authority.

    This script panders to the new Feminism ideal of the emasculated Omega male who accepts, with smiles, all the crap a woman feels like dumping on him because it's actually his fault all along because he was unaware of the female's unspoken “needs”. The message that, sure she cheated on him, but it was really his fault because he didn't pay enough attention to her is absurd. This is pandering to the “New Feminism.” Bring back Captain Janeway; She was honest and you knew where you stood with her.

    This script reeks of “Feminist” input. It has “New Feminism” “values” smeared all over it, and the stink comes across overwhelmingly on the screen.

    The basic premise that backstabbing, manipulating women are are really at heart nice people and all their faults betrayals, and secret connivings should be overlooked because... well, because they're women. . And if any male doesn't, then he's a sexist. This is the message I take away from this show. You folks can fold up your message and wipe it where the sun don't shine.
    .
    The Orville sucks big time. Not only will I not watch this turkey, but I hate this show so much I am embarking on a letter writing campaign to have it canceled. This show sends all the wrong messages.

    You can make this show watchable if you do two things: Ditch the manipulating b---h immediately and give the Captain some balls. Then, maybe, you can something with this turkey. I will refuse to watch this show again until the backstabbing b---h is written out of the series.
    A suggestion: Kill the ex-wife off in such a way the the Captain gets resolve and grows a pair.

    I refuse to watch this show again. I accidentally came across the second episode while channel surfing. The alien strong girl was in command. thought, “This is a good character. Great, they already eliminated the two repellent personalities that stink up this show.” the show was enjoyable until the scene cut to the captain and his cheating ex-wife back in their old apartment. I switched channels at that point.

    I rate The Orville an F---! (That's eff minus minus minus, not the swear word, though that certainly fits.)

    Sincerely,
    James Morgan    … Expand
  98. dfdfdf
    Sep 23, 2017
    10
    decent show. critics are idiots. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  99. palaemon
    Sep 23, 2017
    10
    This borrows from Star Trek of old. That's okay - they're now using it anytime soon. They've moved on to Battlestar Galactica-esque stories and Kelvin-timeline visuals.

    The first episode has weak moments, but overall it was fun. The second ep got even more character development. I think so far, Seth is the weakest link - but by episode 3, it started balancing the humor and deeper story    This borrows from Star Trek of old. That's okay - they're now using it anytime soon. They've moved on to Battlestar Galactica-esque stories and Kelvin-timeline visuals.

    The first episode has weak moments, but overall it was fun. The second ep got even more character development. I think so far, Seth is the weakest link - but by episode 3, it started balancing the humor and deeper story meanings. It's not even close to perfect - but watch Encounter at Farpoint - it's not the best. It's okay - but you also (now) know where it went and how good it got. The Orville needs time. I hope it's allowed to grow and develop into an even more balanced show, focusing on character humor and situations.    … Expand
  100. Sjbakerphdddddd
    Sep 22, 2017
    10
    This reminds me of the original Star Trek. It is wonderfully quirky. I hope it makes it. It focuses on content rather than explosions and special effects.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

2
#2 Most Discussed TV Season of 2017
47
#47 Most Shared TV Season of 2017

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
36

Generally unfavorable reviews - based on 21 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 0 out of 21
  2. Mixed: 11 out of 21
  3. Negative: 10 out of 21
  1. New York Post
    Reviewed by: Michael Starr
    Sep 21, 2017
    50
    It’s got top-notch special effects and terrific makeup (for its space-alien characters). But it just doesn’t quite gel. At least not yet, anyway.
    Read full review
  2. TV Guide Magazine
    Reviewed by: Matt Roush
    Sep 14, 2017
    50
    The show's smirky tone, embodied in MacFarlane's smug frat-boy demeanor as the captain, never quite gels with the universal humanism the episode is aiming for. [18 Sep - 1 Oct 2017, p.27]
  3. Yahoo TV
    Reviewed by: Ken Tucker
    Sep 11, 2017
    30
    Except for Norm Macdonald as the voice of an alien made of what looked like quivering gelatin, I didn’t find much that was amusing about The Orville’s space odyssey. ... From its opening scene with Victor Garber assigning Ed his ship to the final, unsuspenseful shootout with alien enemies, The Orville moved from one lull to another.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »