OR

Email Address

Password

Forgot password?

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures | Release Date: December 16, 2016

7.6	USER SCORE Generally favorable reviews based on 3768 Ratings

USER RATING DISTRIBUTION

Watch Now

Stream On

Stream On

Buy on

Stream On

Stream On

Stream On

Expand

Review this movie

VOTE NOW

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.

Check box if your review contains spoilers

0 characters (5000 max)

User Reviews

User score By date Most helpful

9

GamingPoptartTVDec 26, 2016

I would have to say when it comes to this movie. I got everything I ever wanted. I even got the ending I wanted. Sadly this movie does suffer from a few if not nit picks in my opinion. First off when it comes to Tarkin I feel his CGI was notI would have to say when it comes to this movie. I got everything I ever wanted. I even got the ending I wanted. Sadly this movie does suffer from a few if not nit picks in my opinion. First off when it comes to Tarkin I feel his CGI was not on par with Leias which was perfect. It would have been better if you where gonna have Tarkin in such a role to constantly have his back towards people. I felt that would have been better. The other things was some poor character development. I understand that there fates why develop the characters. Yet literally the only 2 characters from the Rogue One Squadron that I can remember was K2 and Donni Yen. Then the last thing that is the only plot hole in this movie to me at least is why are the Empire looking for Kaber Crystals. It has been cannonized that the Death Star runs off one giant kaber Crystal. So what are they scouring planets for more. Just a nit pick I know. Also there is some poor editing I know it was rushed but there are some scenes where it wasn't edited well.

Other then all that I would say this movie is a 9/10 and a must see and must own on blue ray.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

homer4presidentApr 12, 2017

This is a war story, about people who discover purpose and meaning in their lives. It is a little raw, not for little kids who are looking for Jar Jar. Teens and above will appreciate that personal and ultimate sacrifice to ideals have beenThis is a war story, about people who discover purpose and meaning in their lives. It is a little raw, not for little kids who are looking for Jar Jar. Teens and above will appreciate that personal and ultimate sacrifice to ideals have been made throughout history. Thoughtful, adventurous, bitter sweet. Doubly so, with guest star appearance of Leia foretelling the next film, A New Hope, that this movie is a prequel to. Loved it.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

gjdr9876Apr 16, 2017

Great movie with great tie ins to the other star wars films. Just an awesome action packed and good feel story. I suggest you give it a second or third watch for the great little things they included

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

3

YoloSwag4DogeAug 29, 2017

I found the movie to be technically amazing as far as stunts, CGI, costumes and action scenes go. But I didn't find it very entertaining. There's so little backstory given to the main characters and their personalities just didn't reallyI found the movie to be technically amazing as far as stunts, CGI, costumes and action scenes go. But I didn't find it very entertaining. There's so little backstory given to the main characters and their personalities just didn't really stand out. They simply got ping ponged from one location to the next until all of them eventually died so as not to conflict with the rest of the movies. The dialogue shared between them is mostly related to advancing the plot as opposed to expressing who the characters really are. They seemed like copy and paste cut outs to me. The action scenes in Star Wars movies have always relied on some suspension of disbelief. But the ridiculousness was just too much for me in Rogue One. A droid casually chucking a grenade behind it's back as a gang of storm troopers round the corner. Donnie Yen one shotting a tie fighter out of the sky with a laser crossbow. A group of conveniently placed metal boxes laid out in front of the empire garrison's main door used by the rogue rebels to ambush dozens of hapless, brain dead storm troopers. And of course Donnie Yen walking across a raging battlefield without consequence muttering the same line over and over like a religious fanatic. Apparently the force is no longer needed for fighting people with it. As long as one has faith in the force they can just walk around in god-mode while the force carries out their unstoppable destiny for them. Oh, and of course there's the oft repeated trope of a main character appearing dead, only to then pop up behind the bad guy, just as the bad guy's about to shoot his gun, only to make it seem like the bad guy shot his gun, when it was in fact the good guy who shot the bad guy in the back, which is revealed to the viewer when the bad guy hits the ground dead. *Cue triumphant music* The movie was just dull and comically predictable for me. But I really wasn't that surprised. Rogue One is most likely all the franchise will ever be. A rehash of cliches, references to the original, comedic interludes and CGI simulations of scenes from the originals for nostalgia's sake. With that being said, I thoroughly enjoyed the darth vader scene at the end. That scene was **** amazing.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

Jollyjoe1000Apr 12, 2017

all though star wars episode 7 lowered my expectation when it came to a star wars movie. this movie most definitely satisfied me. It was just a little slow at the beginning, but the end was exiting. The icing on the cake was how it was theall though star wars episode 7 lowered my expectation when it came to a star wars movie. this movie most definitely satisfied me. It was just a little slow at the beginning, but the end was exiting. The icing on the cake was how it was the events that set up the first star wars movie.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

mace8704Dec 28, 2016

Dark, depressing, and mature. For better and for worse, this is arguably the least 'fun' I've had with a Star Wars film. The first entry in the anthology series creates a darker tone intended for older audiences hoping to have their nostalgiaDark, depressing, and mature. For better and for worse, this is arguably the least 'fun' I've had with a Star Wars film. The first entry in the anthology series creates a darker tone intended for older audiences hoping to have their nostalgia itch scratched as opposed to younger audiences hoping for an upbeat and fresh narrative. Personally, I'm in the camp that thinks Star Wars is currently in a state of narrative stagnation. We've seen the death star multiple times with both Lucas and Abrams. We've seen the orphan narrative with Luke, Rey, and now Erso. We've seen the comedic droid with C3P0, R2-D2, BB-8, and now K-2S0. It gave me an odd feeling of deja vu. Haven’t I seen this movie before? It’s indicative of either a concerning lack of creativity, or a fear of experimentation due to the sacred cow status of the Star Wars franchise. Rent if you’re a fan of the original trilogy. Avoid if not.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

HelenHDec 30, 2016

Good film. It adds to the previous films. And I believe it is the first time in a Star Wars film the Alliance does not consist of only heroes who won't do any wrong. Suddenly, the characters are not black and white and I think it is a reallyGood film. It adds to the previous films. And I believe it is the first time in a Star Wars film the Alliance does not consist of only heroes who won't do any wrong. Suddenly, the characters are not black and white and I think it is a really nice change.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

thoodeeDec 25, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. loved this movie! I really was invested in the characters, and even family that weren't familiar with star wars were craving more about what happens after. Of course I pointed to episode 4. The only thing that somewhat let me down was the amount of Vader screen time, however when he finally did show up you knew sh!t just got real and was fully satisfied.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

lucbevibrasilDec 30, 2016

Rogue One presents several new (and good) things in the saga. Be it the rebel extremism of Saw Guerrera, a kind of religious belief (in Force itself), and even the dramatic deepening in the relationship father and daughter of Jyn and GalenRogue One presents several new (and good) things in the saga. Be it the rebel extremism of Saw Guerrera, a kind of religious belief (in Force itself), and even the dramatic deepening in the relationship father and daughter of Jyn and Galen Erso. All this with great action scenes and a beautiful soundtrack by Michael Giacchino. But notorious is the ability of director Gareth Edwards to balance all this and still show respect for the original trilogy, putting scenes with easter-eggs and wonderful references. Oh, and there's Darth Vader. Amazing… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

jmabaDec 27, 2016

je suis agréablement surpris par la direction artistique du film. elle reprend tous les codes de l'épisode 4 de 1977 sans pour autant la rendre vieillissante. époustouflant, un tour de force. un petit bémol pour un personnage. les scènesje suis agréablement surpris par la direction artistique du film. elle reprend tous les codes de l'épisode 4 de 1977 sans pour autant la rendre vieillissante. époustouflant, un tour de force. un petit bémol pour un personnage. les scènes d'actions sont magnifiques, les plans sont enivrants, les clins d’œil aux top. sa pulse.

je reste critique sur la qualité de la VF qui n'est pas à la hauteur (qualité d'interprétation et de production).

pour la musique, je trouve qu'elle est rafraîchissante dans l'univers star wars, mais malgré un mix à la star wars, très présente, les compositions qui sont inspiré des partitions de mr JW, n'arrivent pas à imprégner le spectateur que je suis, me focalisant sur le sound design et le respect des équipes de production pour l'oeuvre originale.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

7

The3AcademySinsOct 13, 2017

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a great war film, and okay Star Wars film. My biggest problem was that we did not get to spend a whole lot of time getting to know the characters or getting emotionally attached to them. Other than that, thisRogue One: A Star Wars Story is a great war film, and okay Star Wars film. My biggest problem was that we did not get to spend a whole lot of time getting to know the characters or getting emotionally attached to them. Other than that, this movie is definitely worth a watch!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

7

JyroJyroSep 27, 2017

A near-pointless addition to the Star Wars franchise notwithstanding, this is actually a brilliantly competent action movie. Jones & Mendelsohn are great, rinsing everything they could from the rather lacking script, and the cinematography isA near-pointless addition to the Star Wars franchise notwithstanding, this is actually a brilliantly competent action movie. Jones & Mendelsohn are great, rinsing everything they could from the rather lacking script, and the cinematography is frequently stunning. Oh, and that final Darth Vader scene is a true pleasure.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

PluutozzMay 29, 2017

Very well made and entertaining Star Wars film. Rogue One is alot more bold than Force Awakens could ever be. Not perfect in any sense of course but a very good standalone movie in Star Wars Universe. Thumbs up.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

PabloBird22Jan 4, 2017

Rogue one is awesome it's simply amazing, Darth vader was awesome as usual i swear on my life that I never saw Darth vader so bloody and brutal as in the last scene, it's awesome Rogue one always gonna find a place as the best STAR WARSRogue one is awesome it's simply amazing, Darth vader was awesome as usual i swear on my life that I never saw Darth vader so bloody and brutal as in the last scene, it's awesome Rogue one always gonna find a place as the best STAR WARS prequel.

P.S: R.I.P Carri fisher for his last scene in the movie :')… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

alejandro970Dec 28, 2016

Forget what you see and knew of episodes 1-3. This one is the real prequel of SW episode of 1977; Jones and Luna moves and feels like fishes on water, and the doses of action will not dissapont the fanboys. One of best choices of current holidays.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

tbeit2May 25, 2017

I found Rogue one to be one of the best Star Wars movies yet, certainly the best since the original trilogy. What makes the film shine is the characters and story. Much like the video game Halo Reach from 2010, this is a movie that aims toI found Rogue one to be one of the best Star Wars movies yet, certainly the best since the original trilogy. What makes the film shine is the characters and story. Much like the video game Halo Reach from 2010, this is a movie that aims to make us sad with an expected plot and it works. The characters are likable, and the main character is one of my favorites in the universe now. The plot manages to also take turns despite its obvious end point.

The action is amazing as well. All of the scenes are well directed and explosive, with everything popping and being a joy to watch. The music was great as always.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

TheChosenOne7Jan 3, 2017

Pretty good movie. Would be a 10 but there are a few major plot holes and some of the writing is left wanting, but overall a fantastic movie. Far better than the SJW propaganda filled Force Awakens. Let's hope the next movie follows thisPretty good movie. Would be a 10 but there are a few major plot holes and some of the writing is left wanting, but overall a fantastic movie. Far better than the SJW propaganda filled Force Awakens. Let's hope the next movie follows this example and sticks to being entertaining and true to the franchise instead of pushing a backwards agenda.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

Bigchris27Dec 26, 2016

OK at first I almost walked out of the movie due to the fact that it was very slow paced but after the first 20 minutes or so it was fantastic fast as lightning and super fun full of adventure action and laughs was really glad with my choiceOK at first I almost walked out of the movie due to the fact that it was very slow paced but after the first 20 minutes or so it was fantastic fast as lightning and super fun full of adventure action and laughs was really glad with my choice to stay had a blast watching it a absolute must see for the holiday season good family choice as well… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

laxdrew2Dec 29, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This film got almost everything right. The plot, special effects, and dialogue are all exceptional. The one and only complaint that I had when watching this movie was that there were too many operations going on at once, and too many characters were introduced to be killed off within two hours. All in all, this is a great film, the one Star Wars fans have been waiting for.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

Dr_Shooter24Dec 26, 2016

The problem of Rogue One is not the technical part, which is compelling and incredible, but the lack of interest that produces either the plot and the characters. I understand to be amusing for those who are huge fans of the saga, but for me,The problem of Rogue One is not the technical part, which is compelling and incredible, but the lack of interest that produces either the plot and the characters. I understand to be amusing for those who are huge fans of the saga, but for me, there is no story to tell, and that, for a presigious name like Star Wars is something inadmisible. And let´s be honest, Felicity Jones doesn´t have any charisma.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

Rpk_Dec 22, 2016

I have Rogue One a 60 score and here's why:

The purposely restrained tone and dourness of Rogue One was a real drag. At two hours running time where you go in expecting a high energy action movie this is not a good thing. It felt like R1 wasI have Rogue One a 60 score and here's why:

The purposely restrained tone and dourness of Rogue One was a real drag. At two hours running time where you go in expecting a high energy action movie this is not a good thing. It felt like R1 was trying to be more Blade Runner than Star Wars, except without the intelligence, cast, and superior craftsmanship. I understand Rogue One is set during a time of war, but SW has always been able to attack serious issues without losing its lighthearted soul.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

BranagunDec 25, 2016

This was an exhilarating and emotional roller coaster - not 'fun' as such, and some of the characterisation is sketchy. However it has a surprisingly authentic war film vibe and is seemingly uncompromising by concerns of 'Disneyfication' -This was an exhilarating and emotional roller coaster - not 'fun' as such, and some of the characterisation is sketchy. However it has a surprisingly authentic war film vibe and is seemingly uncompromising by concerns of 'Disneyfication' - some of this is bold and brutal, especially the third act. This gives me hope for future standalone instalments.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

MyDistUniverseDec 26, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Star Wars: Rogue One Google Image
Rogue One is everything you would expect from the 8th instalment of the Star Wars saga.
We have incredible CGI and special effects that make this epic film larger than life. Fast paced space and ground battles with all the necessary trimmings and space troopers galore. Not to mention the funny android with an attitude problem and more personality than most humans. It is all there.
The music score is very much in line with the series, yet still unique in its own way. This only adds to the overall feeling and knowledge that this is a self contained movie.
The opening of Rogue One departs from the big score and introduction scrolling across the screen. I found this part a tiny bit disappointing - it is kind of a Star Wars thing after all. Even I know that, and admittedly I don't know much.

The Story
Set between Episode III and IV Rogue One tells the story of a band of rebels who are trying to get the plans for the Death Star. They are lead by Jyn Erso, who is the daughter of Galen Erso, the man who reluctantly developed the machine.
During the construction Galen had secretly built in a weak spot at the core, hoping that the rebellion would be able to destroy the deadly weapon before the Empire had a chance to use it.
His wish did not exactly come true, because the evil Orson Krennic uses it to destroy Jedha City in order to show its power to the Empirial Senat. This makes the task at hand all the more urgent and the rebels are prepared to sacrifice everything to complete their mission.
The final showdown happens on the planet Scarif where the plans are stored. Star Wars fans who have been with the franchise for a while will probably know or at least guess the outcome of the movie. In my opinion that does not take anything away from the glory of watching it all happen in such a spectacular fashion on the big screen in 3D.
Sequel yes / no?
Rogue One is a stand alone movie but rumours continue to linger that there may be works in the pipeline to continue the story. I guess only time will tell. It is a very profitable franchise after all, so nothing is really unthinkable.
Disney revamped the Star Wars tale with The Force Awakens in 2015. They are currently working to get the chapter of that out in 2017. If the trend continues then the next movies after that is not due until 2019, which leaves the perfect open spot in 2018 for something else. But that is just speculation on my part.

Final thoughts
I have never been a Star Wars fan. To tell the truth the first movie in the franchise I ever saw was Episode I, and that only partly. I watched it years ago and the only part I remembered is the pod race. The first Star Wars movie I consciously watched was indeed The Force Awakens last year. After watching Rogue One now I am determined to make a marathon session over Christmas out of watching the entire series in one go. I will be off work for a few days, so that will give me the perfect opportunity to do that.
There are two reasons for that. First is my newfound appreciation for the story. And secondly there is the knowledge that I am missing the overall picture. I can't really place any of the events around those two movies within the timeframe of the entire story. As I am certain, that there will be more films coming and I am also certain that I am going to watch them, I want to be able to see the whole picture when I do that.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

JarlPhiDec 27, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. For the first time since the so unloved Prelogy, when I left the theater, I had that feeling, you know, that little feeling you have when you just saw a Star Wars Movie, I loved it, I really did, let me elaborate on this.
1-The movie's purpose. I've always wondered how could a weapon as extraordinary as the death star have a flaw in it, and most importantly, how could the empire be unaware of it, Finally I have my answer.
2-The Ironic Drama, following characters and getting attached to them knowing that they will die at the end of the movie, that is so cruel, so raw, and that makes the rebellion's values so much greater, those people went on a suicide mission, they fought, they killed, and they died for something they won't be able to experience, Freedom.
3-The planets, we saw so many different environnement, so beautiful landscapes, so wonderful scenes, Visually, it was really beautiful, we experienced the diversity that defines Star Wars, the creativity that characterized Lucas'saga.
4-Darth Vader, the first scene could be considered as rubbish fan-service, but the second one, had a purpose, directly link Rogue One to Ep IV, which makes it its direct prequel, that makes sense, plus THAT SCENE WAS MARVELOUS, when I saw Vader Killing those rebels, I had an orgasm.
5-The Force as A religion, The Force is with me and I'm One With the force, replace Force by "god", and you know what Chirrut is, A Badass Priest, He believed in the force when no one else did, the way he and Baze (which on the contrary was skeptical, but chose to believe when he saw his friend die) was really touching. 6-CGI, it was nearly perfect, Grand Moff Tarkin was, and he always will be (until ep IV ..), I loved the droid, really funny, and cynical.
What I didn't like about the movie is the development of some the characters, Jyn, Andor and the relation between Galen and Krennicshould have been more developed, and I would have loved seeing General Akbar leading the fleet.
Rogue One was a good movie, and a great Star Wars. and that makes Ep VII look even worse. Ep VII could have been much better if Disney didn't force JJ to do it before 2016.
Anyway, May The Force Be With You!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

SuilenrocDec 28, 2016

Personally I thought that Rogue One was the best of all the modern Star Wars films. After watching this you will definitely want to watch A New Hope again.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

alva3901Nov 4, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One, directed by Gareth Edwards, is the first standalone film in the Star Wars saga and by far the most intriguing in the franchise. Set as a prequel to Episode 4: A New Hope, Rogue One brings in a group of unknown rebels led by Jyn Erso (played by Felicity Jones), as they travel to new worlds to find the plans to the Death Star, devised by her father Galen Erso (Mads Mikkelson). Gareth Edwards, who's other major films include 'Godzilla' and 'Monsters', brings in a new perspective into the Star Wars universe, combining characters and action so well, you'll leave the theater buzzing for more (even when you realize that it leaves you right off a New Hope). The plot to Rogue One is very simple, but it's the characters that really take this movie to new heights. The likes of Jyn, Captain Andor (Diego Luna), K-2S0 (Alan Tudyk), Chirrut Imwe (Donnie Yen) and Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) make this movie worth watching (other than it being a Star Wars film). The droid, K-2S0, was the stand-out secondary character, able to bring great sources of humour while still being of use. But the real star of the show was Jyn Erso, with Felicity Jones doing a great job as the female lead. She is tough, rebellious and reckless, making her a well-crafted character, that has a great backstory.

Though Star Wars creates great protagonists, Rogue One's main antagonist Orson Krennic is definitely up there with the best. Ben Mendelsohn is powerful, able to give you a villain that any Star Wars fan would want. The action was also spectacular, with the final climatic fight one of the best in the franchises history, which is definitely saying something. Full of wonder and delight, you never drift your eyes away from the screen, with the special effects staff deserving full recognition as they recreate some of the characters of the originals.

It seems hard to not mention Darth Vader, so I will. He has little screen-time, but for every second he is in, he steals the show. One scene in particular was very special, as we see him in action for the first time in years.

Overall, Rogue One is a Star Wars movie that really takes you on a different journey from what you would be used to. It connects itself so well to the beginning of A New Hope, you could combine both movies with no problem. The cast and crew deserve the credit for the effort they made in creating a standalone film in the biggest franchise in movie history. Though the most 'war-like' of the 8 films, it still has moments of levity spread throughout, which reminds you of the original Star Wars spirit. It stands alone in the saga, and it definitely stands high in the huge and ever-expanding universe.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

CodgerEbertJan 5, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Great movie, but where were all the Bothans? Other than that, they seamlessly folded this prequel in with A New Hope. The end of Rogue One could take place 30 minutes before Tantive IV gets boarded by Vader. The fact that most of the protagonists died was kind of refreshing in today's world of immortal, sequel-ready heroes. I rank this one 3rd out of all Star Wars Movies, behind ESB and A New Hope.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

NightscapeSep 22, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This movie reminded me I can feel feelings. Of all the Star Wars movies, this one reminds me the most of actual war. The traditional use of animatronics with conservative use of computer animation and the musical score are great. I love the cast and their connection to each other, but what I want to focus on is how it is also the best at creating emotional attachment of all the movies. In the original Star Wars and the Force Awakens, they both blow up stuff and kill people with us the audience, having little attachment to what was lost (save one scene in episode VII) - the opposite is true here. As a survivor of the Iraq War and actually losing friends, this created the most emotion for me, due to seeing the similarities to the sacrifices of war and having watched the original trilogy (I try to forget the prequels ever happened). I highly recommend watching the (de-specialized edition of the) original trilogy then this, and try not to cry while high. If I was forced to rank this, subjectively, it is my favorite after Star Wars and Empire Strikes Back. However, it has a Grave of the Fireflies feel and is hard to watch a lot like the original trilogy and episode VII.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

MonkiReviewsMay 22, 2017

This is actually a good prequal. Everything I wanted, and better. The characters are amazing and the story is almost perfect, or maybe even perfect. It is one of the best movies in the series.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

dcutlerApr 2, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. At the beginning of the movie they were switching around to different planets and I thought it was kinda a mess. But then the battle happened and everything changed. The Darth Vader scene at the End where you finally get to see Vader killing rebels is something I've wanted to see on screen forever.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

Eclaire9Apr 6, 2017

A must see film for every Star Wars fan. Not to mention of course that one scene that would be embedded on the viewer's minds. It brought us back to the reasons why he will always be a memorable one.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

Zummy1976May 14, 2017

Very good but not great. Lacks the heart and soul of TFA but it's a surprisingly uncompromising war movie sprinkled with some truly memorable moments.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

FishSauceFunkMay 25, 2017

I had absolutely no expectations of watching this and by the end of the movie I thorougly enjoyed it. The first thing that comes to mind is because of the setting, the characters have no additional "baggage" of the greater series of StarI had absolutely no expectations of watching this and by the end of the movie I thorougly enjoyed it. The first thing that comes to mind is because of the setting, the characters have no additional "baggage" of the greater series of Star Wars, this allows the characters to simply exist outside of the jedi/sith universe and are so personable, while being connected. I love the main character's story - the nuance portrayed with good people trying to do good within the Empire and showing the shadier side of the Rebel Alliance, this makes the whole Star Wars universe look more grounded. I enjoyed how you leave the movie identifying with the Alliance as a greater struggle, the lack of central character build up highlights die-hard rebel life and sacrifice, a friend called it a Star Wars "war movie" and I could see that. Last, props to the diversity of the cast, they weren't exaggerated stereotypes for the sake of racial and gender diversity but had lots of heart (e.g. Felicity Jones, Forest Whitaker, Donnie Yen). Lastly - I teared up during the last scene, guess you'll know why once you see it. Kudos Rogue One!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

mrdr4gonDec 15, 2017

Uneven in places, but this does the job for the most part. There's a few stretches were little happens that get a little irritating but the film as a whole is more or less effective. The atmosphere in the film is especially effective.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

Skipper81GerAug 12, 2017

This is a film based on the starwars story. Which is not perfect but makes much better than from episode 7, which was very limited by the age release from 12 onwards. Rogue one is dirtier, more beautiful, more demanding, stronger and moreThis is a film based on the starwars story. Which is not perfect but makes much better than from episode 7, which was very limited by the age release from 12 onwards. Rogue one is dirtier, more beautiful, more demanding, stronger and more profound in comparison to part 7.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

2

tortlreDec 22, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I really wish I could like this movie. I really do. But I couldn't understand any of the characters, let alone connect with them. They spent about 1/10th of the movie introducing 8 or so main characters, and then the rest of the movie was a wild goose chase with terrible fan service. When they all died in the end, I didn't care at all. The only reason I scored this a 2 instead of a 0 is because of Vader's scene in the end.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

3

AndyWollandJan 9, 2018

Rather disappointed, was expecting much more especially compared to the blatant re-hash that was The Force Awakens. Basically let down by a slow story line and most of all by the uninteresting 'throw away' characters.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

8

bishop04Mar 10, 2018

THIS MOVIE IS AMAZING. it is by far the best prequal we got (the prequals are still awsome) it shows us another side of the star wars universe we've never seen before. The last act is amazing its just a roller coaster of joy to watch!!!!!!THIS MOVIE IS AMAZING. it is by far the best prequal we got (the prequals are still awsome) it shows us another side of the star wars universe we've never seen before. The last act is amazing its just a roller coaster of joy to watch!!!!!! I'll never forget the experinced I had when watching this in the theater!!!!!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

3

natedeugJul 25, 2018

It's too bad the characters or their motivations don't match the stunning visuals. This looks like Star Wars. It feels like a damp rag.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

WapitikevMar 11, 2019

The best Star Wars movie by Disney-Lucasfilm by a wide margin. The scenes with Vader, though unnecessary to the film, are well done and respectful to the character. CGI Leia was pretty cringy. CGI Tarkin was acceptable. The male and femaleThe best Star Wars movie by Disney-Lucasfilm by a wide margin. The scenes with Vader, though unnecessary to the film, are well done and respectful to the character. CGI Leia was pretty cringy. CGI Tarkin was acceptable. The male and female leads are unlikable characters doing the right thing. The droid and the two priests of "The Religion of the Force" were the best parts of this movie.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

3

toughcritic1977Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I was a big fan of episodes 4,5, and 6. I loved Espisode 7; it's not my favorite, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. Rogue One is sticky, bunghole crap. The accents of the actors/actresses make it difficult to follow the dialogue and the plot. It almost feels like Disney wants to expand their audience and cater to Europeans in this film by adding accents. There is absolutely no evolution of the plot (in fact the Kyle Katarn plot is completely obliterated!) and some of the directorial choices are just plain silly (the frickin' dialogue.....lordy).

One of my biggest complaints concerns the digital dopplegangers of Grand Moff Tarkin and Princess Leia. Did anyone look at these digital incarnations..... pardon me, abominations, and maybe think they were a terrible idea. The CG version of Leia is more palatable because she is shown for such a short duration, but Tarkin is shown extensively and he looks like some awkward Japanese sex-robot trying to fool a lonely person into thinking he is real.

The plot is just a mess. The whole premise of this small group of "rogues" taking on the Empire is not in any way bravado, it just makes the Empire look they belong on the short bus. It comes across as a ridiculous suicide mission where everything goes their way. Did you really have to waste the IP Man (Donnie Yen) and make him pull that lever? Who thought that was a good idea? Overall, this a turd burglar of film. When the prequels were out a decade ago everyone pretended like they were passable when they were steaming, hot garbage. This movie belongs in the same chute. Yes it gritty, and more violent than the other Star Wars flicks, but the story is just rubbish. Gareth and Lucas should hang out and talk about more ways to attempt to ruin one of the greatest franchises ever.… Expand

9 of 28 users found this helpful919

All this user's reviews

0

oannizzleDec 16, 2016

Thank YOU Gareth Edwards !!!! from now on we have TRUST in you because you give us HOPE. George Lucas must be proud right now of what you did with his legacy.

14 of 45 users found this helpful1431

All this user's reviews

10

rsullivaDec 23, 2016

The fact that this movie is rated lower than the 'Force Awakens' disheartens the credibility of all professional critics; this movie was epic to say the least. By far the most realistic and possible the most moving Stars Wars movie everThe fact that this movie is rated lower than the 'Force Awakens' disheartens the credibility of all professional critics; this movie was epic to say the least. By far the most realistic and possible the most moving Stars Wars movie ever produced; providing an extremely well integration of the first and second trilogies. This movie had absolutely no appeal no the 'stupid humor' or 'cute' appeal often found in the other Star Wars films. After watching the film for the second time, I can state that this is probably my favorite Star Wars film ever produced; due to its new definition of the force and the unstoppable force reprimanded by the empire and specifically Darth Vader. The almost impossible feats accomplished by the rebels, reinforces the 'underdog' feel of the rebel alliance provided in the original trilogy while also explaining how the force controls the fate of the galaxy. This film also had noticeable political claims which makes stand on almost the same level of greatness as the original film 'New Hope'.… Expand

4 of 13 users found this helpful49

All this user's reviews

7

Movie1997Dec 17, 2016

As much as I wanted to love this movie, I just couldn't. Don't get me wrong, I don't find "Rouge One" to be a bad movie by any means. It is simply a film that isn't without some flaws. Say what you want about "The Force Awakens", but at leastAs much as I wanted to love this movie, I just couldn't. Don't get me wrong, I don't find "Rouge One" to be a bad movie by any means. It is simply a film that isn't without some flaws. Say what you want about "The Force Awakens", but at least there was structure behind it. It had great dialogue, great editing, clear direction and well-rounded characters. With "Rouge One" the dialogue is not always spot on, the editing is a bit jarring at times, there's not always clear direction and there is not a great sense of care of the characters. Some of the characters from Ben Mendelshon, Mads Mikkelsen, Alan Tudyk, and Donnie Yen were much more memorable than others. Even two particular old school Star Wars characters impressed the hell out of me. At the same time, I found the rest of the characters to be nowhere as interesting. The biggest problem with "Rouge One" is that it doesn't take the time to flesh out our main protagonist's. When we get to bigger moments towards the end, there is no sense of worry or care about the fate of most of these new characters. But what ultimately makes this movie an enjoyable feast for the eyes is the action. The last thrid of this movie in particular is what everyone is going to be talking about. It absolutely looks stunning. Overall, has an interesting story, but it doesn't have as many interesting/memorable characters, or great structure in storytelling. Nevertheless, there is still enjoyment to behold. I'm going to give "Rouge One: A Star Wars Story" a B!… Expand

3 of 10 users found this helpful37

All this user's reviews

4

AxeTDec 17, 2016

"The Force Awakens" though not the worst in the series was the weakest on story since it was a thinly disguised rehash, and of course story is the most important aspect of any narrative movie. This one is even worse pertaining to story. It"The Force Awakens" though not the worst in the series was the weakest on story since it was a thinly disguised rehash, and of course story is the most important aspect of any narrative movie. This one is even worse pertaining to story. It looks fantastic yeah, and has a reality to the photography that goes beyond even the last entry. That's the progression of technology. Stunning visual effects used to mean something, but now since it's a given for not only the genre but all big studio fare (and is expected particularly from this series which started the whole VFX blockbuster long running trend) what matters more than ever is the story-telling. This thing is so predictably formulaic in its telling of a small backstory alluded to in the original film, it offers practically no surprises at all. No story surprises that is. There is nothing really in this feature that one doesn't automatically intuit from the trailers. It's another connect the dots enterprise with all the little winks to fans which actually somehow shrinks the entire legacy every time they close in this vast universe by keying into every little story detail they can find from the old films. Plot beats arcane canon acknowledgments any day nerds!

How many times can we watch the same repetitive action tropes no matter what galaxy they're set in and still be thrilled? Continuous action and spectacle is not good story craft. Too much "action" equals boredom. This is a real problem for the medium in general, I understand, but it must be fought. For example, why not get bold and creative and go into some strange subplots revolving around certain characters? Go unexpected every chance! That's good story-telling. That's what "Game of Thrones" does. That's why that is far superior story-telling nowadays than "Star Wars" is. Diversity in casting is only a diversion from the real task which is all that matters, story. It's not that the casting here is a problem, it's just that it's irrelevant no matter how much attention it may get. The fact this movie has the fewest stars yet in the cast is not necessarily a problem either, but without big stars or familiar characters to pull you along and give personality to the generic proceedings it gets very dull. And most detrimental of all, this suffers from the same wretched problem the prequels and last year's reboot sequel did. In the case of the prequels, playing out mysterious and intriguing backstory by actually rendering and extending what was a couple lines in the original script into a bloated forefront has killed the magic once there. What was huge has become somehow small in so doing. By the same token with Episode VII, seeing what happens to beloved characters well into the future only serves to dampen our imaginings of them. In both cases, it only taints the original couple films from way back. Hey this is the very nature of sequels and prequels I know, so there's no solution other than to either do them so exceedingly well that they transcend this problem or don't do them at all, especially if dealing with classics or returning after prolonged periods of time. Or just keep putting out stuff like these last two movies which are good enough, sound enough productions to still make a fortune based on an overwhelmingly large and beholden fan base but in the long run will ultimately continue to harm the franchise and damage its value.

It's too bad because this is a sophisticated product with the conceit of a really good war mission story cleverly extracted from the seed planted in the original 1977 film. The tone is right, serious but light enough here and there. The problem is it's one hell of a slog through with a lot of watch checking! There are flourishes, but nothing that can come close to saving a sophisticated audience from either being bored out of their minds or lying to themselves that this was an entertaining couple of hours. Be honest with yourself. There are a couple very powerful fleeting moments. If the whole movie was on such level it would be the best! As it stands, it made me want to play the virtual reality game version instead of sitting through endlessly recycled narrative. The story has to grip more than ever these days or it's a waste of time, because we have seen it all over and over and over!
The best movies for kids are the ones that adults can also love. The first two "Star Wars" movies were that like we'd never seen before. Unfortunately the magic has never been re-captured since.… Expand

3 of 10 users found this helpful37

All this user's reviews

8

AsaZimbabweDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. overall rogue one is great. it is a fun sci-fi movie. it is a tense action movie. it is a thought-provoking war film. it is almost perfect as a star wars fill-in-the-gap story, justly expanding the star wars universe. easily better than the prequels, on many levels better than e7, and potentially up there with empire. much darker in tone and visually one of the strongest (if not the strongest) of all the star wars films to date. it does an excellent job of location, set, character & costume design. it captures, matches & improves upon the original 70’s future-long-ago look & feel; particularly compared to the prequels coming-off as too squeaky-clean and cartoony, where obvious green-screen 'sound-stage sets' clashed w/ cgi backgrounds that actually came-off as claustrophobic or making the actors seem lost-in-place, rogue one feels much more authentically 'there' and breathable, artfully integrating cgi & traditional effects with moveable characters. it even stands out compared to abram’s understandable but heavy-handed return to reliance on traditional sets & mechanics… for example, edward’s film improves & expands upon the rebel base yavin 4 locale, while keeping consistent with what you may have imagined was just off camera 40 years ago in e4; much more-so than abram’s disappointing teletubbies green hills + cement roads to simulate the rebel base in e7. many aspects of r1 kept me feeling like this was the star wars film i had been longing for, or at least adequately filling in many of the blanks the original insinuated. there is a sense of depth and history here missing from recent star wars films; diverse planets, ancient temples, exotic creatures & locales feel much more realized & alive, part of a larger universe than maz kanata’s isolated b&b cantina-remake. i’ve heard understandable complaints about the pacing, it does feel a little bit long at times, but i don't hold that against it and can't think of much i would cut. speaking of cuts, as others have noted several scenes or lines of dialogue from the trailers are missing in the final film, but mostly this is just a curiosity considering the theatrical cut is still almost 2.5 hours. there is also understandable chatter that some of the new characters are not as realized as one might ‘hope’ for. the acting and interplay between the two lead actors felicity jones & diego luna is excellent and among the best in any star wars film. if their characters leave you longing for more, it is a compliment rather than a knock, and the context of the film in the larger star wars universe perfectly justifies the amount of attention they get. my biggest complaints would be trivial: spoiler alerts: it is said that you are not supposed to notice a good movie soundtrack, but how can you say that about star wars? the fact that giacchino scored this and not williams is apparent in parts. a few times the music strikes up and you are expecting classic star wars to come belting out but it doesn’t, and feels like it falls a bit short. there are other moments though, where the soundtrack uses non-traditional instruments to provide a more other-wordy feel than previous films… it's cool that grand moff tarkin is back in a significant role, but he does look obviously cgi as others have noted. Vader has a weird, kind of glaring overhanging neck issue with his helmet which bugged me (and others), though otherwise it was great to have him back as a bad-ass post hayden era, the closing moments with Vader were great and among his best, if not short-lived & offer promise of more to come. Donnie Yen was a cool character but somewhat annoying with the overly-repetitive ‘hare-krishna’ force mantra, it was a bit ‘forced’ that he's so close to a jedi but technically not. a particular scene in jeddah surrounding an imperial 'tank' carrying kyber crystals felt especially clunky, the tank looked clumsy and out of place, that scene struck me the most as a mechanical set, seeing the tank struggling to maneuver on the ground with dozens of flying ships everywhere else was reminiscent of being stuck on the track of the bumpy indiana jones ride at disneyland. the new robot side-kick ‘K’ was mostly well-written and well-performed by tudyk and provided good, consistent comic relief. and major kudos to how many of the main characters were dead by the end of the film, that is lacking in so many movies and particularly bold of edwards, kennedy & disney. as an ‘old-head’ traditional star wars fan i found r1 to be less-than perfect, better than i expected, slightly more satisfying than e7, a huge improvement over the prequel trilogy, and ultimately excited for the future of the star wars universe being placed into the hands of new talent... ps: got to agree with AdamCM: "the best Star Wars since Empire"… Expand

13 of 44 users found this helpful1331

All this user's reviews

9

NikolayGDec 17, 2016

A great addition to the Star Wars universe, Rogue One has the best last act of any Star Wars movie (excepting the big surprise moment in Empire Strikes Back). The only downside is that the robot's jokes aren't that funny and one characterA great addition to the Star Wars universe, Rogue One has the best last act of any Star Wars movie (excepting the big surprise moment in Empire Strikes Back). The only downside is that the robot's jokes aren't that funny and one character gives up on life kind of inexplicably. He/she (not to give anything away) could have escaped danger but basically just said it wasn't worth the trouble. That was a head scratcher. Otherwise, this is a fantastic gritty take on Star Wars, with a brilliant ending. Jyn Erso is a great heroine, a bit more scrappy and relatable than perfect Rey; this movie also includes some of Vader's finest moments.… Expand

5 of 17 users found this helpful512

All this user's reviews

9

gasDec 18, 2016

Great movie compared to the most recent star wars titles.
im 42 so i grew up with the originals, which ofc are legends for me.
this tilte is more mature and realistic then all the previous titles, i liked the fact there is noGreat movie compared to the most recent star wars titles.
im 42 so i grew up with the originals, which ofc are legends for me.
this tilte is more mature and realistic then all the previous titles, i liked the fact there is no clown-characters, i liked very much the plot and many aspects of the setting which are at laest a bit more "realistic" then what was used to be in the franchise.
Dont want to spoil cause here is still on theaters... anyway i like every direcotor choice in this movie.
Its defo a great movie, i could not expect somethign better afeter seing episode VII, which was not bad but not great either..… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

8

VasotDec 18, 2016

Better from Force Awakens in my opinion and the plot is far from childish (there are no Jar Jar Binks or Ewoks or stupid kiddie stuff) this movie is way darker and dramatic and very close to "The Empire Strikes back" atmosphere. CharactersBetter from Force Awakens in my opinion and the plot is far from childish (there are no Jar Jar Binks or Ewoks or stupid kiddie stuff) this movie is way darker and dramatic and very close to "The Empire Strikes back" atmosphere. Characters are more realistic in Rogue One with their ups and downs as opposed to Force Awakens which the main protagonist there appeared as a Super-Jedi feminist that knows everything without training...… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

10

Molag-BalDec 21, 2016

Dont expect anything like the originals, but this was a damn good movie for what it is. The second part of the movie is beyond amazing and the main character she is a fun one. Her companion is boring though.

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

10

Paulo-LameirasDec 22, 2016

From the visual direction taken from the original trilogy, to the dirty environments, darker tone, interesting and varied cast of characters, and phenomenal ending, this just turned out to be my favoutite Star Wars movie since The Return ofFrom the visual direction taken from the original trilogy, to the dirty environments, darker tone, interesting and varied cast of characters, and phenomenal ending, this just turned out to be my favoutite Star Wars movie since The Return of the Jedi! While far from bad, only the soundtrack didn't 100% met my expectations.

Surprisingly good movie and even better Star Wars one. 9.5/10… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

7

TagirixDec 18, 2016

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a fan-oriented movie, to my mind. I have watched all the movies, but I disliked this one because of many reaons. First, the story is very predictive, and it is not interesting at all. I know this is a spin-off,Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a fan-oriented movie, to my mind. I have watched all the movies, but I disliked this one because of many reaons. First, the story is very predictive, and it is not interesting at all. I know this is a spin-off, but still it is not worth. Second, sometimes it was so boring that I decided to sleep. Overall, I recommend watching this movie only if you are a true fan of Star Wars.… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

8

kurotadori94Dec 23, 2016

The first half of the movie worried me a little, mostly because of the unconvincing dialogues. The second half, however, was much better, I found the debate inside the rebellion and the war scenes well structured and realistic, and the endingThe first half of the movie worried me a little, mostly because of the unconvincing dialogues. The second half, however, was much better, I found the debate inside the rebellion and the war scenes well structured and realistic, and the ending was epic. What I did not appreciate was the choice to make in digital the characters whose original actors were either dead or too old to play the role: the result was a little disturbing, with grand Moff Tarkin reminding me awkwardly of Harry Potter's Dobby, I think they just should've changed actors... But that said, I overall enjoyed very much the movie.… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

10

RandomLetters27Dec 21, 2016

What a fantastic Star Wars film. Star Wars for adults who grew up wanting to do battle in a galaxy far, far away. The characters here are some of the most interesting you'll find in Star Wars, and the villains are darkly glorious. Fathers,What a fantastic Star Wars film. Star Wars for adults who grew up wanting to do battle in a galaxy far, far away. The characters here are some of the most interesting you'll find in Star Wars, and the villains are darkly glorious. Fathers, hug your daughters; we're in for a ride.… Expand

3 of 11 users found this helpful38

All this user's reviews

10

general1109Dec 18, 2016

фильм очень хороший и интересный.Вот он на много лучше чем эпизод 7.фьмсфлджосфдшмрдфдрмфрмдшфрмсфдшрафдшрафлдоралдфралдфраодфралдфоралдфралдфафрлафафафильм очень хороший и интересный.Вот он на много лучше чем эпизод 7.фьмсфлджосфдшмрдфдрмфрмдшфрмсфдшрафдшрафлдоралдфралдфраодфралдфоралдфралдфафрлафафа

3 of 11 users found this helpful38

All this user's reviews

0

flamesofexigoDec 28, 2016

I have been watching movies in theaters for 25 years. Today, I did something that I have never done before. I walked out of a movie screening. 45 minutes in I couldn't take it anymore. The rehashed themes, pedestrian dialogue, hackneyedI have been watching movies in theaters for 25 years. Today, I did something that I have never done before. I walked out of a movie screening. 45 minutes in I couldn't take it anymore. The rehashed themes, pedestrian dialogue, hackneyed acting, ho-hum visuals, and mediocre, bombastic score. I am done with the Star Wars franchise. The last good SWs movie was Episode III, which was quite flawed in its own right.… Expand

4 of 15 users found this helpful411

All this user's reviews

10

unclebillyDec 17, 2016

As a star wars fan, not a single movie in recent history has made me as excited and amazed as rouge one has. This movie has some over extended moments that get a bit pale, and some acts may be slightly weak; but the rest makes up for it 100%.As a star wars fan, not a single movie in recent history has made me as excited and amazed as rouge one has. This movie has some over extended moments that get a bit pale, and some acts may be slightly weak; but the rest makes up for it 100%. The action, cinematography, feel of wonder is all there and better than ever. I don't think Darth Vader has ever been more Vader and I don't we have ever seen a ground battle to this scale. This isn't your regular star wars movie but definitely not in a bad way.… Expand

5 of 19 users found this helpful514

All this user's reviews

5

piercoDec 16, 2016

People who are voting this awful, boring, mishmash of a movie 10 realy need their heads examined. I now understand why the likes of Trump can manipulate people to vote for him. Whay a world of Idiocy we live in.

5 of 19 users found this helpful514

All this user's reviews

6

SpookydarrenDec 16, 2016

So, just wanted to make a point and say that some of the best bits were missing from the trailers. Jin saying "that's what I do, I rebel". She sounded like a bad ass but the character ends up being somewhat diminished imo. Also the face offSo, just wanted to make a point and say that some of the best bits were missing from the trailers. Jin saying "that's what I do, I rebel". She sounded like a bad ass but the character ends up being somewhat diminished imo. Also the face off with the tie fighter on the tower looked spectacular but was also cut. On the plus side the new droid and Vader were AWESOME. Film saved in the last five minutes. Looking forward to the Han Solo story.… Expand

9 of 36 users found this helpful927

All this user's reviews

6

TrevorsViewDec 16, 2016

Okay, so the first spinoff of the immortal Star Wars saga has finally hit theaters, but how does it compare to the rest? Well, it’s miles ahead of those embarrassing prequels (no surprise), but Rogue One: A Star Wars Story just can’t competeOkay, so the first spinoff of the immortal Star Wars saga has finally hit theaters, but how does it compare to the rest? Well, it’s miles ahead of those embarrassing prequels (no surprise), but Rogue One: A Star Wars Story just can’t compete with the originals, or The Force Awakens.

As I’m sure you’ve heard, there’s no opening crawl or John Williams score this time, just a silent view of space with a single planet. Everything else from here is an X-wing flight of an experience you’d expect from a Star Wars movie, including booming sound effects and AT-AT walkers that look as epic as ever. There’s an appropriate mix of practical sets and good CGI to create all sorts of new settings, including a tropical planet and a claustrophobic prison. It’s got all the checklist requirements to make a good Star Wars movie, but there’s something missing.

Basically, without giving anything away, the Death Star is in its finishing stages of development, and war zones land on all areas of conspiracy against the weapon, the strife of war affects the lowest of the low in the galaxy. But we are introduced to the struggle on a rock and moss planet that houses a small family of farmers. The father is forcefully invited to join the Empire, along with his wife and daughter. He is soon taken away, and the little girl manages to escape, only to be transported place to place by an Imperial prison as an adult.

Now, she ends up with the Rebel Alliance so that she can be this movie’s “feminist protagonist” in helping steal the plans to the Death Star, and also to see her father again. You know how it all goes from here.

The problem I had with this movie is not just in how we already know how it will end before it even begins, but in the excessive use of characters with so little humanity I cannot connect with a single one of them.

Think of it this way: you remember how in The Force Awakens we saw a detailed introduction to Rey that showed us what her day-to-day life on Jakku was like? Remember the clear backstory given to Finn and how that motivated his actions? Here, none of the new characters have any of that. Jyn’s not motivated enough to fight for what she has lost, as we never know what her relationship with her father was ever like. Then she starts to cry over this inner pain, and let me tell you: Felicity Jones (Like Crazy, The Theory of Everything) is not skilled in making crocodile tears. Her story just moves by too quickly to balance a feel of hope with letting us feel for her.

Everyone else around her is just a plot device. While Forest Whitaker’s (The Butler, The Last King of Scotland) new cyborg character has a sympathetic redemption story screaming to get out, the poor performance of the man behind the mask just doesn’t land. Then there’s the cameos of characters from the original trilogy. Remember how the appearances of older characters in The Force Awakens actually advanced the emotional story and improved your appreciation of the originals? This does none of that. Darth Vader does appear as epic as ever, but he just comes to explain the plot, and leaves, only to make one more brief appearance. There are a couple of others from the originals who appear, but none of them are very satisfying or necessary. Although there was one cameo that just blew my mind, making me go, “Whoa! How did the visual effects crew make that possible?!”

But there is a god, strong saving grace though: one of the new characters proves to be strong with the force, despite it being a time when the force is thought of as an ancient religion. He’s also blind, and an epic master of hand-to-hand combat. Let me tell you: he gets a moment to shine in his fight against a gaggle of Stormtroopers, and it’s the most amazing thing ever.

So is Rogue One: A Star Wars Story the spinoff to the saga we all hoped for? Not exactly. It’s a satisfactory action flick if you’re willing not to think too hard about it as high art. But if you are looking for the essential Star Wars experience that surpasses all of your expectations, you might end up disappointed.… Expand

6 of 24 users found this helpful618

All this user's reviews

10

stevegroundhogDec 18, 2016

This movie is for true Star Wars fans. It is the best movie since Empire. Perfectly ties in between Episode 3 and Episode 4. They even brought back Peter Cushing from the grave (albeit freaky and cool at the same time). There is no loveThis movie is for true Star Wars fans. It is the best movie since Empire. Perfectly ties in between Episode 3 and Episode 4. They even brought back Peter Cushing from the grave (albeit freaky and cool at the same time). There is no love story, no stupid characters like Jar Jar, no annoying little kid who loves Pod Racing, no anorexic chick named Rey who can wield the Force within three minutes, no whiny Kylo Ren with daddy issues, it is a perfect Star Wars movie. It is purely Empire vs Alliance in a Dirty Dozen type atmosphere. Go see it!… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

10

LarrynautikDec 19, 2016

I am an old fan since before the Prequel Trilogy, and this Prequel Trilogy never enjoyed me a lot. I was disappointed by Episode 7. Where was the Star Wars spirit ? And then, I saw Rogue One. For many reasons, this is an excellent Star Wars.I am an old fan since before the Prequel Trilogy, and this Prequel Trilogy never enjoyed me a lot. I was disappointed by Episode 7. Where was the Star Wars spirit ? And then, I saw Rogue One. For many reasons, this is an excellent Star Wars. The scenario is very well-written, with a lot of unexpected developments. Special effects are very satisfying excepted for two characters. It doesn't affects the global felling however. Let's say it all : there's despair, hope, glory and emotion, humor, with a lot of winks towards all the other episodes. Most of all, this episode fit between espisodes 3 and 4 is perfectly articulated and acts as a real connection. I'm fully convinced this is a real Star Wars episode and should be seen by any fan or anyone else interested in Star Wars. I really enjoyed the show and the universe depicted. It looks believable and esthetically in absolute harmony with the "old" Star Wars movies, even if new ships are shown and new heroes too. There's also this specific and so appreciated urban chaos and crowds full of aliens on multi-storied cities. But you also get a lot of urban wars and exciting space fights.

To be honest, even the end of the movie will keep your breathe until the very last second. Impressive until the end, graphically and scenaristically. That's all, just a very good Star Wars an old fan appreciated a lot. It's clearly impossible to do better than that. Great job guys ! Shall all the following episodes be done like that !… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

6

TheQuietGamerJan 9, 2017

Rogue One succeeds at showing a darker and more desperate side of the Star Wars universe. The galaxy is being crushed under the Empire's oppression, the Rebel Alliance is being forced to resort to grim tactics in order to survive, and to topRogue One succeeds at showing a darker and more desperate side of the Star Wars universe. The galaxy is being crushed under the Empire's oppression, the Rebel Alliance is being forced to resort to grim tactics in order to survive, and to top it all off the Empire is in the process of putting the finishing touches on some sort of super weapon. One rumored to have the power to destroy planets. All of this sets off a chain of events that make for the most unique Star Wars yet. One that feels more like a heist and war film, than what's come before.

One of the movie's greatest strengths is that it captures the bleak atmosphere one would expect from a Star Wars story set in this period of the series' timeline. There's a feeling of hopelessness that follows the characters around through every scenario they find themselves apart of. Nearly every planet they visit has that dirty, rundown, right in the middle of a warzone feel that sells the tone excellently. When it comes to the depiction of the state of the galaxy the movie succeeds near-perfectly.

Another area where the movie is at it's best is in it's incredible battles. These conflicts standout as the best the series has to offer. The scale is grand, the stakes are intense, and the shear amount of eye candy is stunning. The series even gets involved in some non-blaster fights that rival the series best lightsaber duels, despite not having a single Jedi in sight. When it comes to action the movie does not disappoint. Unfortunately the same thing cannot be said for it's writing and characters. Something that leaves an unfortunate sour patch in an otherwise stellar movie.

It's not that the events aren't interesting. The concept of watching a ragtag team come together to steal the plans for the freaking Death Star with all odds stacked against them is one that would excite any Star Wars fan. The problem is that early on it just sort of moves in a way that unceremoniously throws them together. It jumps around so much at the beginning it's actually a little confusing to piece together what's going on. It doesn't take long for things to click, but when they do your left with an even bigger problem; you have no way to connect with the characters, so it's impossible to care about them. The exception being Alan Tudyk's excellent K-2SO. It's not that they're unlikable characters. It's just that there's no spark or flair to them that causes them to standout as anything more than the Star Wars universe's B-team. A group of bland faces meant to carry things on here while things are being prepared for Episode VIII. Given that the popularity of the Star Wars series partly stems from the compelling nature of it's characters and plot, it's disappointing to see the series first anthology film fall short in those areas. This is primarily a movie you watch for the spectacular action. I say primarily because the movie does have a great deal of fan-service for Star Wars fans. Things like special references and even a few surprise cameos are sure to please. Especially since they feel natural to the story and not just shoehorned in. So in the end Rogue One isn't a disaster. Just more of a disappointment in some areas. There are still plenty of reasons to check it out, longtime fan or not. It's noticeable differences in things like tone have the potential to appeal to newcomers. So in the end all is not lost.

6.9/10… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

6

SmoothrunnerDec 27, 2016

Unexpectedly good movie for a Star Wars. At least I've saw it out to the end unlike previous "episode". I'm not a fanboy of this "fairy tale rubbish", but at last they've filmed something that makes sense and really reminded war to meet theUnexpectedly good movie for a Star Wars. At least I've saw it out to the end unlike previous "episode". I'm not a fanboy of this "fairy tale rubbish", but at last they've filmed something that makes sense and really reminded war to meet the movie title. Attractive Felicity Jones is a fine choice for the main role, but other staff are mediocre. Pathetic speeches are laughable and heroes behave unnaturally but still better than in most other SW "episodes". But what really bothers me is that "rebels" are as much unsympathetic as Empire is. They are depicted as bunch of zealots willing to sacrifice their own and others lives for an unclear and morally ambiguous purpose - vague illusions and dreams. They are fanatics with dubious motivation. Even religious suicide bombers have more reason and logic in their doings than SW's rebels. At least they are expecting to end up in an imaginary "paradise" and are dying for their "brothers". But all these rebels - what are they killing and dying for? As I said - they are scary zealots with irrational behaviour and no better than Imperial Stormtroopers. In fact, they are behaving utterly unrealistic. But this is SW after all.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

2

ImpeccableTasteJan 3, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Way too long for a movie this uninteresting. Dialogue is awful, and sometimes annoying (Blind Character). No Force practitioner in any of the past movies has to chant a mantra, it was just annoying. Characters are dull especially main leads, and supporting cast are wasted Mads Mikkelsen, and Forest Whitaker especially.The Rebel Alliance makes it sound like he is some really tough terrorist but that is not how Whitaker plays the part. Space battle doesn't make since, they are attacking shield for five minutes, and blowing up aircraft guns, and not until near the end of the battle do the TIE fighters come out of the shield give me a break. Darth Vader scene is the best of the movie, was hoping a Jedi would show up but no such luck. Wait for rental definitely.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

6

Burnouts3s3Dec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is an ambitious film that's constantly hindered by the Studio's interference. Gareth Edwards (Director of films such as the independent film, Monsters, and the 2014 reboot of Godzilla) emphasizes slow build-up, scale and a sense of melancholy in his works. Rogue One, for the most part, uses Gareth's natural inclinations and makes a film less like the optimistic A New Hope and more like the bleak Empire Strikes Back. The film centers on Jyn Erso, a daughter of an ex-Imperial engineer who designed the plans of the Death Star. When Jyn's father is captured by the Empire and Jyn's mother is killed, Jyn joins the Rebellion as a means of survival. Years later, Jyn grows up to a be a jaded cynic, turning herself away from the cause. However, when a hologram of her father reappears, Jyn joins up with the new Rebellion in hopes of finding her father.

Jyn joins up with a cast of rebels in order to fulfill her goal. Unfortunately, whether by mandate of the studio or Edwards himself, a majority of the cast doesn't receive the much needed character development needed to form a strong emotional connection to them. (I'm told that a prequel novel, Catalyst, details many of the backstories and origins of the side characters. As I recall, there used to be a time when movies had to stand alone and didn't require the aid of a peripheral novel to explain characters). The stand outs of the cast are Donnie Yen's Chirrut Îmwe, a believer in the Force who cannot wield it makes the people around him question his figurative and literal blind faith and Alan Tudyk's K-S2O, a reprogrammed Imperial droid that can't help but say what's on his mind. While neither character full develops, the actors imbue their roles with such personality, that when the possibility of "They will not come back from this mission" starts to sink in, you genuinely feel for their loss.

Rogue One ordered a number of reshoots during production. Unfortunately, many of the studio's re-shoots stick out. Just when I felt that Gareth Edwards was about to take the Star Wars movies in a different and original direction (such as in the peripheral media or even the now non-canon Star Wars Extended Universe, a series of tie-in novels, books and games deleted from continuity by mandate of Disney purchasing the Star Wars license), there's a random cameo or reference that feels so out of place that it literally took me out of the movie. For example, Jyn, early on, bumps into the two strangers Luke meets in Mos Eisley. While the cameo is fun, it does little to move the plot or the characters. Perhaps, it's a small universe after all.

And while I liked K-S2O's character, you can't help but feel every time he's in a scene, a humorous moment will be around the corner, effectively making him a comedic relief robot (I heard a poster refer to him as a Bazingabot).

As such, there are moments of tonal whiplash throughout the film. Just as the film is about to take a darker turn or a depressing outlook, a random cameo appears or K-S2O says something funny. Were these moments intended from the beginning or did the studio worry that the film was too bleak and ordered reshoots to make the affair lighthearted? We may never know what Gareth's original cut of the film would've differed from what we have now. That being said, the director takes bold risks and does things to the characters a lesser director wouldn't have done. That takes guts. Rogue One is enjoyable. It is worth seeing in the theater. But, when I hear audiences compare this to Empire Strikes Back, I really wish the narrative would've taken more risks and Edwards would've been free to do what he intended. As for now, I recommend seeing it at a Matinee.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

10

ColourSurroundJan 4, 2017

I came in with meager expectations and was genuinely blown away with how the film handled the story, paced the action, and played out as a whole. The acting was superb, the effects made you feel like you were watching a Star Wars film - andI came in with meager expectations and was genuinely blown away with how the film handled the story, paced the action, and played out as a whole. The acting was superb, the effects made you feel like you were watching a Star Wars film - and not some CGI mind-maze - and the story was genuinely well written. I loved all of the classic Star Wars easter eggs that were thrown in, and that the main character gave a nod to Jan Ors from the Dark Forces games of the 90s. It was original, but above all very entertaining. The critic metascore does not reflect its quality. It definitely plays out more like a war drama in a sci-fi setting than anything else, but I think it is all the better for it. Although quite different from any of its predecessors, it is a wonderful film that I feel surpasses The 'Force Awakens' in almost every facet, and can rightly take its spot with Episodes IV-VI in the Star Wars canon.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

4

norseDec 24, 2016

This movie was surprisingly bland and non-fun to watch.

For the record, I gave last years new Star Wars movie a 10/10 rating. This year, we have the same great visuals, visual design and probably the best ever story told in the time of theThis movie was surprisingly bland and non-fun to watch.

For the record, I gave last years new Star Wars movie a 10/10 rating.

This year, we have the same great visuals, visual design and probably the best ever story told in the time of the movie Franchise.

Plenty of good actors, but: while the actors were great and the story was outstanding, both the writing and the acting were sub-par. I suspect poor direction.

The movie presses way too hard on a number of Star Wars cliches (force guy, hey, let's mention the force every sentence, huge space battle for a stationary target at the end, OMG, my relationship with my Dad and foster Dad is strained, everyone who dies dies a heroic death...)

Fewer characters with more development would have helped the movie along tremendously. Terrible shame, this movie could have been the greatest one yet.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

3

DonMegaMar 26, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. TLDR: Director was lazy and didn't build the hero character up to fit with the narrative, so much so that the movie has you scratching your head and the story becomes ridiculous and forced.

The movie would have been really good if they didn't ruin the story. So the main female character's father works for the empire which makes her automatically distrusted in rebel circles due to that reputation. However, to create a strong female character they completely forgot the story they are telling and suddenly she becomes a hero without merit but for some reason the rebels in one scene all gather around her so that she can inspire them with her wisdom as they kneel and look up at her in awe. Now remember she is a nobody at this point, she was captured by the rebels literally minutes earlier and thought to work for the empire and they wanted to use her to connect to the father but here she is giving motivational speeches to rebels that are about to enter battle. The story doesn't make sense. I would understand if she did some heroic act earlier, maybe saved a couple rebels or something then that pure respect and treating her like a hero would have some merit, however she did nothing. She was captured, called an empire spy and then became a rebel hero. Now the story is drivel, it's ridiculous and seems like the director was trying to push some political narrative throughout the movie. But I still recommend watching it for one of the best star wars scenes ever. The introduction of vader to the rebels. That short scene where he fights in the hall way had me jump out of the seat a shout at the screen. It was amazing. I'm not a huge star wars fan but that single scene was the best thing I've seen out of all the movies… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

JohnWittenMay 2, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. [Excerpt from Full Review]

I will do my best to avoid the majority of spoilers, but for the most part the plot of the film is pretty straight forward and simplistic, similar to that of the original film. Whereas the original’s premise was to complete a suicide run and destroy the evil Empire’s operational battle station known as the Death Star, Rogue’s goal is to obtain the plans for said station. This film also really puts it into perspective just how close the Rebel Alliance came to failing every step of the way leading up to the destruction of the original Death Star. Rogue One puts this into the limelight in ways that the original film never seemed to seriously do, and as a result is much darker than any Star Wars movie we’ve watched to date. It may not be “killing younglings” dark, but the tone is definitely a lot more gritty and the stakes are a lot realer despite us knowing how it will ultimately end.

Although this film went the route of the prequels in having a relatively star-studded cast as opposed to unknowns in the lead roles, I think it helped for sure. Felicity Jones is phenomenal and each member of the rogue’s gallery that comprises the Rebel Alliance as well as some of the new faces of the Empire are fleshed out and portray their parts quite well. I was a bit disappointed but not altogether surprised that some of the more familiar roles and faces didn’t play as big a part as I had initially speculated that they would. Forest Whitaker plays grizzled guerilla veteran and leader Saw Gerrera (notably from the animated series), however his role seemed to be relegated to a little bit of backstory, tying the mission to Jones’ character, and tying up Gerrera’s arc in the universe as well. Despite that and despite Peter Cushing being given a little bit too much screentime and this bordering on irreverence considering he could’ve easily made his initial cameo and then the other scenes could’ve been pulled off without his appearance, my gripes are relatively few.

The characters themselves, while not necessarily so fleshed out seeing as this is a one-shot kind of one-time story for the majority of them, played their parts perfectly and seemed to mesh on-screen. I thought the melding of new and old characters was promising and worked much better than it seemed to with the original trilogy characters meeting The Force Awakens’ characters in episode seven. While I’m still curious as to what exactly Episode Eight will entail and what exactly it will be called, I cannot deny that Rogue One will be a success and admittedly deserves it. It has it flaws here and there but a simplistic story is not one of them. We knew where it was going to go based upon the time period and universe’s chronology and history, but even with that linear path set in stone and in mind, the story managed to do a lot of things that kept it fresh as well. Yes, by the end it is depressing and dark indeed, but there’s still that glimmer of faint hope on the horizon that will eventually blossom into the roaring wildfire of rebellion come Episode Six.

I was pleasantly surprised that the film actually concludes virtually with the opening scene of Episode Four, as that really put into perspective where exactly it falls in the scheme of things and also how brutally efficient the Empire is with cracking down on the Rebellion, despite never being able to train efficient Storm troopers in the art of hitting targets. I loved that the cast was as diverse and attentive to detail as it was, as well as the strong presence of Jones in the lead role, shining in more than a couple of moments in the film. I also particularly liked Donnie Yen’s character and would be interested to see some more detail and thought put into the origins of his organization- the ‘Wills’ and all that Force-related stuff has been mentioned before, just look back at Yoda and Qui-gon Jinn’s mention in Episode Three. There were plenty of memorable moments, special effects to make any fan drool, and tiny homages and moments made specifically with other moments in mind. All in all, not only is Rogue One a solid film on its own, but it is a welcome addition to the Star Wars universe and will hopefully prove that even stories outside of the main episodes and outside of the recognized or unrecognized expanded universe are welcome too.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

ThylbanusDec 21, 2016

Non-spoiler here. I have to say it was well done. Definitely a feel for the era it is set in. The plot is solid and there are MANY nods to everything in the Star Wars Universe. Sometimes you just have to listen to the background soundsNon-spoiler here. I have to say it was well done. Definitely a feel for the era it is set in. The plot is solid and there are MANY nods to everything in the Star Wars Universe. Sometimes you just have to listen to the background sounds and announcements. I love the whole way everything unfolded all the way up until the end. Then, in the last seconds, they drop a plot hole. Not a plot hole for the movie, but where it fits into the universe of Star Wars. Doesn't mean that the movie up until that point was bad. I give credit where credit is due. It just did a small bit of overreach in those last seconds. This movie hits on all the points that it should. It is one of the better movies to come from this universe. It has a hard, war edge that I see spawned the comment that it is the first movie to acknowledge that there is a war going on. While not totally accurate, the sentiment is. It is no Empire, but it certainly hits a bit better than the Force Awakens.

By the way, a lot of the scenes that ended up in the commercials are not in the movie. I don't know which is the reshoot and not, but there is a ton of scenes in those commercials that are not in the movie. This actually makes me hope for a definitive/director's cut that will be as additive as Batman v Superman. This movie needed to be just a bit longer to properly provide exposition.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

Castian77Dec 23, 2016

Over all the movie was good, but i could not handle the main heroine.
I can bet the movie could've done much better without her, she is at the center of everything, doing just exposure commentary, much like if she was not there at all.
TheOver all the movie was good, but i could not handle the main heroine.
I can bet the movie could've done much better without her, she is at the center of everything, doing just exposure commentary, much like if she was not there at all.
The better, established lore-rich characters were underdeveloped or changed to catter to this tasteless heroine.
See the movie again, imagine the scenes without her, you'll see, the movie not only does not change much, but any change is for the better.
This was more a war movie in a star wars themed world, ratehr a Star Wars classic movie, and that was good.

Gotta say, Disney sure wants to press the " Disney princesses" even to star wars to the point of nearly ruining the plot of the movies.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

7

wrath_of_khanMar 14, 2017

The first act is meandering and struggles to get you attached to the characters, but somewhere in the second act, the story transitions into something more watchable and by the third act, it's an all-out war story. Not the best Star WarsThe first act is meandering and struggles to get you attached to the characters, but somewhere in the second act, the story transitions into something more watchable and by the third act, it's an all-out war story. Not the best Star Wars outing, but it is good and very far from the worst.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

OctomortDec 24, 2016

they made 200 mill on it in first two weeks so obviously it is a good film. The only likable character who had that Star wars rebel personality of determined optimism, with that touch of charming naivety, was the droid, even Mon Mothma was athey made 200 mill on it in first two weeks so obviously it is a good film. The only likable character who had that Star wars rebel personality of determined optimism, with that touch of charming naivety, was the droid, even Mon Mothma was a whinger (yes USA it is a real word it means whiny B**** but you can say it in front of your mum). All that matters is the box office and the opinions of the corporate lovers on this site who always seem to vote a product 9 or 10, maybe an eight if it poisons their grandmother. My comments are meant to reflect the tone of the film, jaded and depressive!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

ilushkaDec 30, 2016

I do not delivered as much excitement as any other film of the saga. Good play from Galen Erso and K-2SO. Other actors was bad. Movie is good as a cameo-film, like new ghostbusters.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

RvwFromUpHereDec 30, 2016

Who: Felicity Jones, a Spanish guy, and Charles Jefferson as, Saw Gerrera
What: Another reason for butt-hurt Warcraft fans to leave their basement, wash the cheetoh dust from their hands, and trash a movie that is actually pretty great
Where:Who: Felicity Jones, a Spanish guy, and Charles Jefferson as, Saw Gerrera
What: Another reason for butt-hurt Warcraft fans to leave their basement, wash the cheetoh dust from their hands, and trash a movie that is actually pretty great
Where: A Galaxy Far, Far, Away
When (Can I watch this movie again): If you like Star Wars, any time. If you don't...you're the worst type of person.
Why: While Episode 7 was very divisive among fans, this movie stays true to the intentions of the original trilogy and delivers what it promised.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

AristMar 31, 2017

Unbelievable; great action with an in-depth drama. It was really brilliant to give lead acting to people who were not ultra stars. Very star warsy and yet very real and very deep!

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

DukeSilverJan 2, 2017

Just accept it. It's better than The Force Awakens. It maintained it's connection to the originals without beating us over the head with stupid one liners and constantly saying, "you'll love this because you loved the original movies!".

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

LockeJohnJan 21, 2017

It's an OK movie, with some great scenes. As a whole the movie is a mess, with weak story. The acting is great but the characters aren't very interesting. The villain is weak as a character, even though the acting is good.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

vonMistontDec 30, 2016

No spoilers. Rogue 1 is the true awakening of the force. While last year’s cash grab made all 6 previous movies pointless, all our favorite heroes dirty and all their sacrifices and struggle irrelevant Rogue 1 only makes original trilogyNo spoilers. Rogue 1 is the true awakening of the force. While last year’s cash grab made all 6 previous movies pointless, all our favorite heroes dirty and all their sacrifices and struggle irrelevant Rogue 1 only makes original trilogy better by explaining some important plot holes (boy how many hours did we spend with friends laughing about how stupid constructor of a Death Star must have been to build so vulnerable station – well Rogue 1 has the last laugh!). It must have been made by true fans of everything that made original Star Wars great and not by some childish pretender who can only see the surface and doesn’t understand the essence. This movie is with The Force and The Force is with the Rogue 1. Beginning may be a bit slow for some people used to today’s action movies in which plot is only an excuse for some pointless combat but I myself prefer this kind of film structure in which first you have to learn why people do things they do. Finale on the other hand has no equal. And I’m not only referring to other Star Wars movies. It was so spectacular that I couldn’t sleep that night when I came back from the cinema. When I close my eyes I see magnificent scenes from Rogue 1. I watched original trilogy dozens of times, some scenes hundreds of times , I watched flawed prequel trilogy a lot too and it also had some good scenes, and while I will maybe never watch Force Awakens again I know that I will be rewinding Rogue 1 and watching some moments over and over again.
There is nostalgia in this movie but it’s not there just to trick you into liking this movie. It’s there because it truly is real original great Star Wars movie in it’s very core, you could literally make smooth transition between last scene of Rogue 1 and first scene of New Hope and you almost wouldn’t notice that another film just started (and that’s what I’m intending to do when Rogue 1 comes out!). It’s also great standalone film. You don’t have to know anything about other Star Wars movies to enjoy it and it makes it even better for Star Wars fan. When someday I will show my child Star Wars I would now have to decide if just maybe I should start with Rogue 1.
It really pains me to watch most of action movies, as often it seems that screenwriter was the worst payed person in whole crew. In Rogue 1 I would really have to search hole in whole to attack a plot. Story was really solid and could stand on its own even if it wasn’t set in Star Wars universe. As I mentioned above movie explains some questions concerning New Hope and some quite familiar characters (one in particular), we can also see even more of how tyrannical Imperial regime really was, we learn that Rebellion also isn’t a monolith but quite interesting group of people with different approaches. Humor was well placed and paced and unconstrained. It wasn’t one liner fest. I feel that every dialogue had sense and it was there for some reason. There was even one inspiring speech which actually inspired me! Usually in moments like these are tedious, but when Jyn was delivering her speech she was making sense and her arguments were convincing.
Soundtrack was ok it did its job and I know it was there which I couldn’t really say about previous movie. For me Star Wars was literally a space Opera or rather space symphony. I was watching beautiful scenes with no dialogue enjoying music and sights. And Rogue 1 has that quality too. Sights are magnificent, when spaceship is flying, even in battle you can see it clearly, camera doesn’t fly like crazy, you can really see what’s going on. I don’t know if it was just me but I also really liked ship’s landing scenes or when the ship flies by I find it very aesthetic and majestic and Rogue 1 has plenty of this awe inspiring moments and also plenty of great fight scenes.
Actors do a very good job, I really liked main cast a lot. Forest Whitaker was a bit overplayed, but on the other how do you not overplay a madman? Diego Luna was excellent as ruthless rebel driven by revenge, Donnie Yen was adorable human Yoda and like no other he showed us The Force really exists. After watching trailers I had many doubts to Felicity Jones as her character seemed too audacious and disrespectful with all this “I rebel!” etc. and I really want my heroes to care for what they do and be afraid to die, because if they don’t care why should I? But I was wrong, she was simply great. And she wasn’t some MaRey Sue either. I also had doubts about main villain but he was just repulsive enough to be believable and not some child’s vision of how mad space nazi would behave. CGI characters could have been made better, but I my fiance who didn’t grow up with Tarkins face said she didn’t notice he was CGI character.
I can’t wait for more movies by the authors of Rogue 1 it is without a doubt the best movie of this year and I couldn’t honestly say that any of the original trilogy films is better that Rogue 1.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

ArconteDec 23, 2016

The Force Awakens was a total letdown last year but I have to say that this time Lucasfilm (Disney) did a great job. Rogue One is just amazing. Seriously go out and watch it becouse it deserve it, it's a true Star Wars movie. It's a story ofThe Force Awakens was a total letdown last year but I have to say that this time Lucasfilm (Disney) did a great job. Rogue One is just amazing. Seriously go out and watch it becouse it deserve it, it's a true Star Wars movie. It's a story of hope, a story of sacrifice for the greater good against the odds and oppression and I really loved the way the characters are well developed and plausible this time.
Also, even if there isn't (almost...) any lightsaber in it, still it shows us the force in a way that is so much better and convincing in comparison to what jj Abrams did in Episode 7, which totally broke my suspension of disbelief.
Both Visual and audio are stunning.
The ending is very climactic and the final battle (space and land)is just mind blowing.I do believe that this movie totally embrace the spirit of the Rebel Alliance. Finally!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

zappbrannigan23Jan 8, 2017

I hoped for more out of this film.

Negatives: Probably my biggest negative is the CGI for the pivotal actors faces (ones no longer with us). Their not being an actual persons face were obvious and poorly done. The first half of the movie isI hoped for more out of this film.

Negatives:
Probably my biggest negative is the CGI for the pivotal actors faces (ones no longer with us). Their not being an actual persons face were obvious and poorly done.
The first half of the movie is too slow
The character development not quite as good as it should be. 2 characters voices/words were very difficult to understand what they were saying.

Positives:
There were a lot of fun (albeit a bit simple) references and lead ins to past and future movies this one sits in between. Fans eat this stuff up and so did I.
The final 1/4 of the movie was very well done action/battle sequences in both space and ground.
The lead actress and her father were well casted and likable.
With a little more script and dialog polish this could have been much more flowing and stronger ties to the characters. I offer my revision/suggestion services to review any future movies for free.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

MD5774Dec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is easily the best movie of 2016. I don't know what movie critics saw , this movie was really good . The trash that was Force Awakens has been erased and has this has given moviegoers hope in Disney and the Star Wars franchise .JJ Adbrams should be ashamed and embarrassed the trash he put on screen last year.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

7

NigmeMar 25, 2017

Acting: 7 (thanks to Mads Mikkelsen & Forest Whitaker) Screenplay: 7
Ending: 8
My score: 7
Well-shot prequel in the universe.
Fans and ordinary viewers should appreciate the film.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

UNARMED_JORDFeb 26, 2017

A very average anthology film that is not without some fantastic sequences such as action and emotional but overall Rogue One is a good action movie but a faltering Star wars one

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

live4tantraDec 25, 2016

People are unbelievable with their ratings. Force Awakens was a joke. This movie is true to the Star Wars saga. I hope Disney keeps this Director for all future Star Wars movies. The only flaw I saw in this movie was Orson Krennic whosePeople are unbelievable with their ratings. Force Awakens was a joke. This movie is true to the Star Wars saga. I hope Disney keeps this Director for all future Star Wars movies. The only flaw I saw in this movie was Orson Krennic whose acting and speech pattern was a bit silly. Other than that, the movie was awesome!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

dlwatso15Jan 21, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I've been a huge fan of Star Wars since I was a child, since the day I saw the first installment and my mind was blown. I've loved almost all of them (I like Episode 1 and 2 but they're nowhere near as good as the rest of the films) but Rogue One is a piss poor Star Wars movie and a **** movie in general. Let me start off by saying the things I liked about the movie. - Good acting
- Great visuals and CGI
- Great settings - Ben Mendelsohn as Orson Krennic
- Alan Tudyk as K-2SO

Now here are the things I didn't like. - Boring characters outside of Orson and K-2SO
- Boring script and poor writing
- Terrible pacing throughout
- Darth Vader's cheesy joke
- Little to no mention to other films in the series
- Plays everything too safe - Not one Jedi in the film
- The actions scenes look great but nothing important really happens in them
- All of the action scenes are basically the same as the previous action scene
- Overall cheesiness throughout

Now, it's not a terrible movie but it's not good. It was so boring that my girlfriend fell asleep for the last half hour and I almost fell asleep in the middle. I don't think I've ever wanted to go to sleep during a Star Wars film to get out of it. My only suggestion is to find this movie at a Redbox or something and try it yourself but do not go into it with high expectations.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

noaccentallowedDec 20, 2016

Rogue One is a film with plenty of imperfections, but is still an outstanding Star Wars experience when taken as a whole. In this way, it is the most natural addition to the franchise since Return of the Jedi. Uneven pacing and plot holesRogue One is a film with plenty of imperfections, but is still an outstanding Star Wars experience when taken as a whole. In this way, it is the most natural addition to the franchise since Return of the Jedi. Uneven pacing and plot holes haunt the legacy of every Star Wars film (even The Empire Strikes Back), yet these stories endure because of unparalleled visual imagination and an unbreakably strong human element. Director Gareth Edwards and writers Gary Whitta and John Knoll all understood this. Combined with intense passion as both artists and Star Wars fans, they sought to create an offbeat tale within the mythos that proved that not every ounce of brand value comes from epic heroes combating the forces of evil with laser swords. In that respect and many others, the production team crushed expectations.

For the uninitiated (if there are any left), Rogue One is an ensemble war film, centered on acquiring the Death Star plans. It isn’t intended to be optimistic and colorful like a typical Star Wars movie. The atmosphere is grim, depicting a galaxy drained of hope by an oppressive fascist dictator. Here the rebels have to walk on eggshells, working from the shadows to make calculated strikes at the Empire. As a result, the scale is somewhat smaller in this adventure and significantly more personal. Dialog is sharp, carefully representing a small team at odds with themselves. However, there is a surprising amount of levity in the script to offset the otherwise bleak narrative. In particular, Alan Tudyk’s portrayal of the sarcastic droid K-2SO steals the show. Though Ben Mendelsohn as the self-absorbed Director Krennic and Diego Luna as the morally conflicted Cassian Andor also turn in memorable performances. Yet acting of any quality is no substitute for a compelling plot, which is where Rogue One occasionally loses steam. The first act of the story jumps around liberally, putting crucial details in jeopardy of being lost to all but the most attentive viewers. In the second act, the story grinds to a halt so the female lead can fulfill her arc. It is also where one or two subplots are entirely dropped, leading to unnecessary confusion about the state of a crucial character. In the final act, the story picks up again and ties up every loose end with extraordinary diligence. Rogue One has arguably the most comprehensive and satisfying finale to any Star Wars narrative, including the entire gamut of expanded canon. It is also worth noting that even if the pacing is uneven, virtually nothing is out of context. Contrary to the insultingly shallow exposition of The Force Awakens, everything in Rogue One has a substantial visual or verbal explanation. It helps reinforce the plight of the team and flesh out the world they inhabit. Also, the attention to detail ensures Rogue One will be a pleasure to watch for years to come.

To that end, there is an item in Rogue One that will serve as a discussion piece both immediately and well into the future. In the film, a certain character from the original trilogy is recreated with the use of CGI. This is not merely a cameo, he is a fully functional cast member. His likeness, mannerisms and voice were entirely reproduced to fill a role. While it has handled with the utmost taste, the actor in question has been dead for over two decades. This sets a dangerous precedent not just for Star Wars, but for the future of filmmaking. Hollywood is desperate enough to remake any film from yesteryear, though now they can also remake people. While currently a gimmick with frightening potential, these techniques could one day become a crutch to the creatively bankrupt. Hopefully Lucasfilm and Disney discourage widespread adoption of this approach.
Beyond that ethical quandary and a few missteps, Rogue One needs little improvement. A director’s cut of the film with touched up editing would address the vast majority of complaints. The first act could slow its breakneck pace and add a bit more articulation to each action sequence. Cut content could be added back into the film to minimize the confusion caused by the dead ends in subplots. Perhaps a few more establishing shots on the tropical planet of Scariff would better emphasize how visually diverse and interesting it is from other locales in the Star Wars universe. Certainly the score could be more melodic, even if Michael Giacchino did do a phenomenal job emulating John Williams. Overall, the next freelancer artists to tackle a Star Wars film need to take risks. If Rogue One is the barometer for future installments however, there is little reason to be concerned.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

BozmoDec 20, 2016

Is movie fits perfectly into the Star Wars film line. Being a prequel to A New Hope, it had a lot to live up too, the film did not disappoint. The action and CGI were amazing. The only problem I had with the movie is that some of theIs movie fits perfectly into the Star Wars film line. Being a prequel to A New Hope, it had a lot to live up too, the film did not disappoint. The action and CGI were amazing. The only problem I had with the movie is that some of the characters were not as memorable as The Force Awakens. But all the other pros make any cons seem like nothing.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

CarlosSpicyWienDec 20, 2016

A very different Star Wars film, though different doesn't mean bad. Action-packed as usual, great visuals, fantastic acting, a film you definitely won't be disappointed about.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

CraigMitchDec 20, 2016

One of the best star wars movies out there. Definitely has by far the best star wars battle of all the movies. Much better than the force awakens. Will buy on blu ray or any special edition version.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

flowirinDec 24, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Its a star wars movie. That's good. tie fighters, death stars, corellian corvettes, space battles and storm troopers. YAY
but. meh.
There's obvious symbolism. the filmatic movement from darkness to light, representing despair to hope. but belaboured, and makes the movie hard to watch for the first forever. 50 shades of, well, darkness and that's all there is to see.
Then there's the lack of gravitas. The monologues are just that little bit too long and quite frankly i didn't care enough about the boring bearded dudes to care. And the star, is it Jen? no, its Jin. or something, she's not quite got the method down pat and I dropped out of the movie world several times when she was obviously acting.
Then there's the style. The first movement is all chop chop chop, switching frantically between worlds, clumsy exposition, not feeling much like a star wars movie, more like a complex detective film noir, which then changes mood halfway though and tries to pull a thin red line, or something.
I guess it did manage to build a sense of the human (and alien) cost of the plans that luke comes across in a new hope. there's that word again. They said it enough.
Then there's the 3D. The Force Awakens nailed it, and it was brilliant. Rouge One? meh. I like to look around each scene, take in the other players, check out the scenery, the sets. In Rouge One, the focal plane is really small, so only the person that the director wants you to look at is in focus (and even then they are often obstructed by shoulders or objects). Everyone else is blurry. So i spent a lot of time looking at a blurry person, waiting for the focus to shift so i could see them properly. Not so much in the second half, but it was a real irritant for the first half. This was compounded by a constant, unnecessary, shaky cam. So 3D added a tiny bit to the movie, but took more than it gave.

And dear GOD. please never use that CGI technique for people's faces EVER AGAIN. I'll have nightmares. So BAD
the droid was good.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

aagarrisonwriteDec 28, 2016

I liked this movie.

Yes, it was 'Star Wars,' with the series' expected pros and cons. And, likewise, 'Rogue One' was a *movie,* with the expected cliches and embellishments. That said, however, this 'Star Wars' movie was, in my opinion, aI liked this movie.

Yes, it was 'Star Wars,' with the series' expected pros and cons. And, likewise, 'Rogue One' was a *movie,* with the expected cliches and embellishments. That said, however, this 'Star Wars' movie was, in my opinion, a pleasing one, both in terms of entertainment value and as an interesting, satisfying story.

Though, for me the movie's true appeal was in the wisdom that lay beneath the theater and images. That is, I felt that there was some *truth* written between the film's lines, of a rare, quality kind that carries over into the real world. For that reason, 'Rogue One' is, I believe, a "good" movie.

I don't see many film, literally just one a year (if that). As it were, 'Rogue One' was the one I saw this year, and I don't regret it.

My sincere thanks goes out to all who worked to produce this movie. I am grateful for, and have benefited from, your time and service. Keep it up!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

MaruganDec 31, 2016

The last act was the best piece of Star Wars I've ever watched. I enjoyed act 1 and 2 but the characters become great at the last 45 min. The chemistry between Jyn and Cassian was good but in that point was The Force Awakens a lot better. AllThe last act was the best piece of Star Wars I've ever watched. I enjoyed act 1 and 2 but the characters become great at the last 45 min. The chemistry between Jyn and Cassian was good but in that point was The Force Awakens a lot better. All in all is Rogue One a great movie with incredible shots, a brutal and dark atmosphere. Episode VII was a movie for children, Rogue One is a phanomenal piece of Star Wars for the one's, who are adults but in their heart still children.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

DevianAppleDec 31, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I overall liked the movie. It is a 'Star Wars Story' but it apparently became something like the normal one, as I have seen at the end. I still didn't like how they freaking killed EVERYONE at the end, and there were slightly too many fighting scenes. But overall, I'll give it a 9.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

josei1985Mar 13, 2017

Una película que hasta que no llega a su final puede llegar a resultar algo tediosa. Más orientada a seguir exprimiendo una saga mítica. Cómo enlaza los últimos minutos del filme con el episodio IV la hace interesante como prólogo a laUna película que hasta que no llega a su final puede llegar a resultar algo tediosa. Más orientada a seguir exprimiendo una saga mítica. Cómo enlaza los últimos minutos del filme con el episodio IV la hace interesante como prólogo a la primera trilogía.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

1

bradactor66Feb 10, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I am not sure what to think of this movie because I was tired when I saw it. I did not know it was a spin off. I suppose for younger viewers they would love it. My title for this is "Mixed Nuts" because of the superimposed imagery of Darth Vader, Prince Leia, and others. Again I do not remember mention of Jedi Knights. The force was mentioned and one interesting character with it. For those who liked it, que sera sera. May the blessings Be… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

nikblu1904Jan 16, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Good backstory and overall interesting, but Tarkin's face just looks too unrealistic. Also one joke of "Chirrut Imwe" is really cringy, please stop. Sadly, every main character dies in the last battle, but it makes sense.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

StormSentryMar 28, 2017

It follows the same story routine as other Star Wars movies. There are many illogical moments... or overcomplicated. It is hard to relate to the cast.
Nonetheless it is visually stunning and mildly entertaining.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

7

HPFANBOY1237Apr 8, 2017

I honestly don't get why everyone loves this movie so much? Is everyone just enamored by the visuals? I think that's the case because the visuals in this movie are amazing. And sadly that's the best part about the movie. The characters haveI honestly don't get why everyone loves this movie so much? Is everyone just enamored by the visuals? I think that's the case because the visuals in this movie are amazing. And sadly that's the best part about the movie. The characters have no personality, they just do cool stuff and they have haunting pasts that we learn little to nothing about. Need I mention the annoying cameos? It's just like, really? Did we need that? No. What we need are real characters that we can root for. Instead of that, we get huge action sequences and useless cameos. Yes, the action sequences in this film are amazing, but do we care if one of the characters dies? No. It's really sad that this film had so much potential, I mean we finally see the Rebellion for what is and not this completely good thing. But this potential goes basically nowhere because of the bland characters. If this film had good characters we would have a great film, but here we are. C+… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

prev next

Page:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

More From This Movie

65 Critic Reviews

7.6 User Reviews

Details & Credits|Trailers

Current Movie Releases

By MetascoreBy User Score

1 77 Project Hail Mary

4 72 The Sheep Detectives

SEE ALL

Essential Links

New on Amazon Prime Video

New on Netflix

Coming Soon to DVD/Blu-ray

SEE ALL