Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

10

lsdfmksldfmlsDec 17, 2016

This movie is worth it just for that one scene that everyone is talking about. Overall a fun movie but for fans of the series, it is a great bridge to explaining what happens in the background of Episode 4

11 of 21 users found this helpful1110

All this user's reviews

2

EdoMcSwagApr 22, 2017

i cant differentiate the characters from cardboard boxes. i only remember Jins name because i like the alchohol. 310

9 of 18 users found this helpful99

All this user's reviews

9

RathaelDec 17, 2016

ROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force! Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore byROGUE ONE REVIEW

Star Wars is back and Star Wars is now real force!

Where to begin reviewing this movie. It achieves so much within its simplicity and a rather narrow scope of a mission, but manages to expand on the known Star wars Lore by doing so, and introducing us to many new and reminding us of a quite a few old characters, in different scopes of screen time, some important to the plot, others more of fan service, letting us know they do exist in this ever expanding universe.

Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso, Alan Tyduk as K2S0 and Forest Whitaker as Saw Gerrera steal the show. Yes that is that Saw Gerrera to who ever watched Clone Wars animated series. Felicity Jones carries the entire movie with her conviction and fearlessness. K-2SO provides the most of the part of the comic relief but not in a way that anyone has seen before, think of him as of more cynical version of C-3PO, that way I do not go into much details or spoil much of his character. Forest Whitaker is fantastic as war grizzled Saw Gerrera that shows us just exactly how much war can change anyone, regardless of what side you are on.

Another big surprise in this movie was just how much screen-time was dedicated to the Empire and its characters with Ben Mendelsohn as Commander Krennic, puts a real face to the Empire, and how the people behind it, were as divided and human as any of the other rebel characters. That is probably partially true, as he's one of the only real Imperial characters really developed on screen other than Vader/Palpatine before, and it was very interesting to see that side of the war as well. This is where the movie really shines as well, as it shows that even Imperial officers like him, have their own agendas and dreams.

Rest of the cast is very very capable as well with Mads Mikellsen leading the cast as the imperial science officer, and Donnie Yen (Yeah!) as a blind staff wielding warrior, and its Donnie Yen in Star Wars movie, that's all that really needs to be said about that! Rest of the cast is also very capable and the charisma and the connection between these characters is very well established.

Gareth Edwards manages to make an adult version of Star Wars not saying the others were not adult oriented movies, but this one is not really relying on humor but establishing the true struggle that rebellion had to do against the Empire. And Edwards manages to do so, without making the movie dreary all the way, managing levity just enough to keep the story fun and exciting.

Another big departure here is that this is the first Star Wars movie not composed by John Williams but Michael Giacchino whose music fits to the feel of this movie, even though there are some famous Star Wars beats in the movie, most of this soundtrack feels very original, and he has put his stamp on the Star Wars universe, which is an amazing accomplishment.

Everything about this movie feels authentic, and its really the small things from the aesthetic feel of the movie and how certain shots were framed and how certain sequences were established is done very well, almost as a painting at some points, and there was that scene that was scene with a Star Destroyer, that I believe was shown in trailers, that scene gives you goosebumps.

Overall this movie does what a very very few movies can succeed at and that is take established universe, remove most of the main characters from that universe and make a compelling movie, make the universe feel more lived in. Manage to expand on the known universe in such a way that is meaningful, introduce us to some of the new characters that we can cheer for: Either Rebel or Imperial, and as I could believe this is first time that both Rebel Alliance hierarchy is kind of explained, and that adds to their plight. And this last statement I am going to probably catch a lot of crap for, but I believe it to be true. This movie managed to do an impossible, make an original trilogy even better movies.

4 out of 4 stars.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

9

Dirk2112Dec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Genuinely perplexed by the negative reviews because this is a well-cast, expertly designed, well performed film that also happens to have been stylishly directed and cleverly written. It’s actually so well directed and performed that on the few occasions its script hits a bump, the momentum of its performances plus direction rolls right over them. No, it doesn't drip with easy charm and charism of Force Awakens but then again, it shouldn't. [Mild Spoiler!] You couldn’t watch this story unfold onto Ridley and Boyega. It's the Guns of Navarone of Star Wars films in the best possible ways.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

2

watcher76May 10, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The movie is slow to start. It was boring and too militaristic.

The lead actress is pretty with bright eyes, but she lacks charisma. There was a chance for character development when she turns from a young girl into a woman, but this wasn't shown. The black guy helped her after her mom died, but then he just disappears. We do not get to see the girl grow up or form any connection with him. She just turns into a woman in an imperial jail cell.

The action picks up when she meets the chinese guy who is blind. He can still fight like how the Daredevil fights.

Darth Vader shows up for like 1 minute, and then it gets boring again with all this rebel planning. The jokes fall flat.

The rebel ships are on a mission to steal data about the Death Star. They arrive at a planet with islands and palm trees. They start fighting. That was interesting. But then all the crew members die except for 1 guy and the girl.
She manages to use the satellite to send the information about the Death Star to the rebels, but then the Death Star itself arrives and sets off what looks like a nuclear bomb on the planet. The girl hugs the guy and then dies, so this movie was a tragedy.

Then there's this short scene where Darth Vader uses his light saber to kill some rebels.

I give the movie 1 star for the lasers and explosions and another star for the action sequences. It has a simple plot without any twists or turns. The dialogue is uninspiring. It still has a Star Wars flavor, so fans of the older movies may enjoy this more than I did.… Expand

8 of 16 users found this helpful88

All this user's reviews

10

commanderclauDec 20, 2016

You are going to cry, but you are going to be happy about it. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story it's one of the best Star Wars' movies (maybe the best one).

7 of 14 users found this helpful77

All this user's reviews

9

ason313Dec 17, 2016

This is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old filmsThis is the first time Star Wars really felt like war. By focusing on single mission and battle the stakes of the entire world feel greater in retrospect. Star Wars fans will not be disappointed; it revels in the ambiance of the old films without feeling derivative of them. Might also be the darkest Star Wars film to date, showing why a new hope was really needed. A great way to start off the side films.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

10

easterfieldsDec 19, 2016

I loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sellI loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sell this story and they are perhaps one of the most interesting motley crews in Star Wars history. It was so fascinating to see how everything fit together just prior to A New Hope and this film actually answers several questions fans have had for nearly 40 years. It really does fit in nicely with the Star Wars mythos and it's exciting to watch! Some have criticized it for being too dark. Well keep in mind that this time period was the peak of the Empire's dominance. The Rebel Alliance had to make a huge stand to start any kind of challenge against it's tyrannical grip over the universe. Thus war was inevitable. This movie does an amazing job of conveying the dark period in which everything was set and it does an even better job of showing how even the smallest sacrifices during such a period can cause huge effects. People die. That is part of war. What really shocked me about Rogue One is that there really is no Force, no Skywalkers, no Jedi, and yet it feels more true to the original films than the last 4 have. It breaks every rule of a Star Wars film and yet managed to do everything right in the process. There are so many pleasant surprises in watching this that every fan should be smiling ear to ear by the time it's over. Yes there are sad moments, but this isn't supposed to be the feel-good movie of the holidays. It's supposed to fill in a spot that existed prior to the very first time Star Wars was introduced to us. Not only is it successful in this regard, but it introduces characters that will long go down in the history books of how the Empire crumbled. Don't miss it!… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

DCharlesDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A fun, exhilarating Disney space adventure. The film works on almost all levels, particularly the CGI created Peter Cushing, Princess Leia, a fantastic final battle and an unforgettable scene with Darth Vader.… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

9

vertiqsDec 17, 2016

After the pretty enjoyable, but still just a copy*multiply+add_old_heroes formula of 'Force Awakens' - looks like we got back on track with this Star Wars Story, though a bit darker, then one may expect.

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

5

FortifierDec 31, 2016

This edition to the Star Wars cinematic universe felt a lot to me like "Suicide Squad"; great fan service and cool cast, but is ultimately empty due to undeveloped story and characters. Most Star Wars films begin with two protagonists, thenThis edition to the Star Wars cinematic universe felt a lot to me like "Suicide Squad"; great fan service and cool cast, but is ultimately empty due to undeveloped story and characters. Most Star Wars films begin with two protagonists, then as they journey throughout the galaxy we learn more about them as well as the world around them and the story itself. Then eventually the "torch" is passed down to two new characters who we follow as the story continues.

In short, the previous Star Wars films accomplished beautiful character, plot and world development at the exact same time. In "Rogue One", however, the "torch" is thrown around rapidly as the characters sit in a circle like a game of "hot potato". There is little to no character development, we're thrown around all over the place in the Star Wars universe, and the writers leave absolutely no time for its audience to emotionally invest in the story or characters (which is extremely disappointing for not only a Star Wars film, but for a film that is over TWO HOURS LONG).

This is what its like for the first two-thirds of the film; while there is a lot of fan service to go around (which is expected from this film), the story and character development is simply atrocious. The third and final act, however, is what saves this movie from being an utter waste of time. This is when the action and threat becomes real and the characters finally come to life. If this film was just the final 40 minutes I would actually give this film a much higher rating.

In conclusion, this series relies far more on fan-service of an already established Star Wars universe to please its audience rather than an actual (never mind "original") story. Believe me when I say that, unless you are an absolute die-hard fan of the Star Wars franchise, you're better off simply re-watching the Original Trilogy if you want to watch Star Wars again.

5/10… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

2

ZenzukaiJul 18, 2017

I Liked baze and chirrut. Really boring though, nothing interesting in the movie to bring home. Was just Disney's attempt at making more money on the new logo they bought.

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

9

KayVen17Jan 11, 2017

Deutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt dasDeutsche Review - Kritik

Der folgende Test ist in 5 Kategorien zusammengefasst. Diese 5 Kartegorien ergeben die Gesamtpunktzahl von 0 - 100 Punkten. Um einen passenden Userscore zu geben wird auf oder abgerundet. Bei 84 Punkten ergibt das einen User Score von 8. Bei 86 einen von Userscore von 9. Falls eine 85 kommt entscheide ich ob ich es eher positiv oder negativ nehme. Regeln verstanden?
Dann sind hier meine Punkte.

Mein persönlicher Score = 90/100
Mein User Score = 9/10… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

3

RyanTheN3RDJul 23, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Here is my reasoning for giving it a 3/10. The first act is boring, uninteresting beyond the fact it's Star Wars, and I don't care about anyone. The second act, is terribly written, characters don't make sense, but there's some good lines and some tension purely based on me liking Mads Mikkelsen as an actor and not wanting him to die because most other actors are doing a bad job. The third act is pretty good, everyone dies which is predictable and bad because the only character I liked was the robot, so I was sad when he died but nobody else mattered. Had to google Chirrut's friends name because I literally didn't know it from this movie because his character didn't mattered. The vader scene is cool, and all around good visuals. Here's the conclusion. I only liked one of the three acts, and I didn't love it, but the visuals were good all around so I can't give it higher than like a 33%. Literally almost fell asleep during this.… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

9

UdrakanDec 17, 2016

SPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darkerSPOILER-FREE REVIEW A movie from Star Wars universe. Recommended whether you saw any previous SW movies or not. This movie starts a bit weaker but it becomes an absolute masteripiece by the end! Disney wasn't afraid to go into darker events. Yes, this isn't some happy story, this is a WAR story in Star WARS and it's absolutely amazing. It has all what I wanted from Star Wars: Space Battles, The Force, cool lovable robots, lasers and explosions, deep characters. The Rebelion is shown from a different perspective - they are good guys, but sometimes they do shady and sad stuff to keep them selves alive. This enriches SW universe, where rebels are mostly shown as only good people. The models and CGI are absolutely amazing. I had shivers going down my spine when I realized just how big Star Destroyer is and then they show Death Star behind it. I was in awe. Skirmishes are clever and Storm troopers are more dangerous and actualy hit people, especialy the elite back ones. Music on-par with movie quality. Darth Vader is scary again! The scene with him is so epic and intimidating! I don't give this 10/10 for 2 reasons: 1)Weak start - first 15 minutes of film are not as good as the rest, It starts slowly with a remote family story, whcih I would rate 6/10. 2) A little bit of cliche stuff. Although amazingly well done, its another Death Star plot, and I had enough of Death star plot in SW. Even Force Awakens was enough. People in market agressively bumping character's shoulder and then shouting at them-I saw this in so many films, it's a small one, but I noticed it, among other nit-picks. Overall it's an amazing Star Wars film and even amazing film on it's own. I totaly recommend it. My final verdict is 9/10 - It's a must see.… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

3

BroyaxApr 14, 2017

Voilà, c'est acté : Disney va traire la grosse vache moribonde Star Wars jusqu'à l'indigestion ! vous en aurez un par an voire deux durant les années bissextiles et les anniversaires ! vous allez bouffer du Star Wars à en crever la gueuleVoilà, c'est acté : Disney va traire la grosse vache moribonde Star Wars jusqu'à l'indigestion ! vous en aurez un par an voire deux durant les années bissextiles et les anniversaires ! vous allez bouffer du Star Wars à en crever la gueule ouverte et... que la "force" soit avec vous, car vous en aurez grand besoin.

Le "Réveil de la Force" ne m'avait pas vraiment réveillé mais pour un premier essai de la part de Disney, ç'aurait pu être pire... Avec ce "Rogue One", on a franchi une étape cependant : on est passé de moyen à mauvais, car Rogue bidule est mauvais, pas nul à chier non, mais bien mauvais !

Pourtant, il s'agissait de broder quelque chose autour de la fin que l'on connaît déjà : voler les plans de l'étoile de la mort et la petite Princesse y faisait déjà allusion dans l'épisode VI (euh... c'est bien le 6 ? j'ai un doute maintenant, enfin, le Star Wars initial de 77, vous voyez...) ; elle mentionnait les immenses sacrifices et donc de là à imaginer une mission-suicide, pourquoi pas, moi je dis banco !

Seulement voilà, les scénaristes chez Disney écrivent avec leur fion, sans doute parce qu'ils ont la tronche pleine de coke qu'ils reniflent avec des billets de 100 dollars. Du coup, c'est juste n'importe quoi au sous-niveau de cette sous-histoire dont les personnages sont tous aussi nazes les uns que les autres. Deux ou trois stars viennent se ridiculiser là-dedans en pensant que ça fera bien dans leur curriculum vitae tandis que les autres branques, des inconnus au bataillon, sont payés au smic et jouent comme des pauvres tanches.

En fait, c'est tellement mal foutu dans la "Rébellion" qu'on dirait des manouches qui font un raid à la fête foraine avec leurs grosses caravanes, soit au bout d'1h25 environ, quand ça commence (enfin) à péter vraiment.

Et là, les combats spatiaux et au sol envoient du bois et les effets spéciaux se déchaînent. Mieux vaut tard que jamais comme on dit. Puis la fin arrive éventuellement, assez grotesque et au milieu de laquelle les deux ronds de flanc se réunissent : c'est d'un pathétique ! la musique se met à couiner, essayant de nous faire ressentir... quoi ? de l'émotion peut-être ? non, on éprouve tout au plus une gentille commisération, à moins que ce ne soit de la pitié en fait.

Et avant cela, on a une brochette de brèles de cette descente de tocards qui veulent nous la jouer "7 mercenaires" ! on aimerait pouvoir en rire si ce n'était aussi minable, vraiment. Sans compter ces deux personnages de la trilogie originale recyclés ici en images de synthèse, ils doivent se retourner dans leur tombe.

Cette douche froide en tout cas, moi je dis respect ! je suis bien réveillé maintenant.… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

0

GrungleMay 27, 2017

This film is a farce of a Star Wars film. The characters are flat, and any good character is painfully underused. The writing makes you cringe with utter disgust that paid writers actually made this trash.

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

6

DemoraseJan 1, 2017

I don't know how to describe Rogue One for the first hour and half other than I was utterly bored out of my mind. However, the last thirty minutes were full and engrossing enough to salvage this troubled movie. But surely you can do betterI don't know how to describe Rogue One for the first hour and half other than I was utterly bored out of my mind. However, the last thirty minutes were full and engrossing enough to salvage this troubled movie. But surely you can do better than that, Disney.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

9

MattyiceDec 21, 2016

Rogue One feels more like an exhilarating war film than a Star Wars film, but this is obviously a good thing. The new characters and recognizable cameos are fantastic, the action scenes are top notch, and it is shot extremely well. The film'sRogue One feels more like an exhilarating war film than a Star Wars film, but this is obviously a good thing. The new characters and recognizable cameos are fantastic, the action scenes are top notch, and it is shot extremely well. The film's first third drags a bit and Gareth Edwards' directorial flaws peek in and out, but the rest of the film's pros make up for it. A great addition to the Star Wars mythos and I hope they make more films like this in the future of a galaxy far far away.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

JackalJan 18, 2017

I am 51, I have seen each film as they came out from 1977...I played as the characters (I didnt have a cellphone)...this story was a great missing piece to the puzzle even more so for a glimpse of the great Darth Vader. Excellent film. I cantI am 51, I have seen each film as they came out from 1977...I played as the characters (I didnt have a cellphone)...this story was a great missing piece to the puzzle even more so for a glimpse of the great Darth Vader. Excellent film. I cant believe it would have any rating below 10.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

3

TragicShowNov 21, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Absolute garbage, even worse than the Phantom Menace. Every character is a cliche mess of terrible and cringey overacting. The only good part of the movie is the Vader scene at the end and when all the crappy characters die. The ending is the most cliche **** garbage I've ever seen. It's as if the writers read a book about the most overused movie endings in history and used every example they could. The main villain corners the hero, pointing his blaster at her. But instead of shooting her, he decides to give this long monologue first, and the moment before he pulls the trigger, a character who you assumed died (unfortunately he didn't) magically appears and shoots the villain, saving the hero. Instead of finishing him off, they instead walk off into the sunset while the villain is killed by his own creation. Also the last two living characters suddenly make out as they escape despite the fact of having zero chemistry or the slightest hint of attraction to each other throughout the movie. I know Disney likes to pander to children, but please don't use them to write your **** script.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

krikaoliJan 10, 2017

Wow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make aWow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make a movie much better than Star Wars VIII. Very impressive plot, actors, etc.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

anichelsJan 24, 2017

I did not expect much coming into the theater, being disappointed with the logic of the story line of TFA. This movie is brilliantly written, and nicely plugs the only plot holes in the original series. There is obvious CGI that I immediatelyI did not expect much coming into the theater, being disappointed with the logic of the story line of TFA. This movie is brilliantly written, and nicely plugs the only plot holes in the original series. There is obvious CGI that I immediately noticed, but I'm still giving it a 10.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

MmkkJan 21, 2017

A fantastic film that has raised the bar for all the next Star Wars films. It may drag a bit in the beginning, but it makes up for it towards the end. A must see for any Star Wars fan.

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

moheetoJan 3, 2017

Unexpectedly Awesome Star Wars movie - the start has received criticism for jumping around too much but I didn't feel that at all - I felt it introduced the new characters efficiently. And then we have a bit of story genius that explains theUnexpectedly Awesome Star Wars movie - the start has received criticism for jumping around too much but I didn't feel that at all - I felt it introduced the new characters efficiently. And then we have a bit of story genius that explains the Death Stars weakness. It loses momentum during the middle section which lagged a bit in my opinion. But that's soon forgotten as the action ramps up in the third act for some majorly exhilarating s***. I'm up off my chair in the last 2 minutes as you know who turns up. And the whole cinema cheers at the end.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

6

Benkoko11Feb 23, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Watching Darth Vadar massacre a couple dozen rebel soldiers was a hugely satisfying moment of badassery in what was otherwise a jumble of safely clichéd and predictable mediocrity.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

abydosMar 25, 2017

Excellent Star Wars movie. Light years better than Force Awakens. This movie is a give new story of the Star Wars universe, a very good and very exciting story.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

0

KAsapDec 29, 2017

at very first scene, Why did they park their spaceship too far and walked that long?
Also It was too boring that I never finished without sleeping. I can watch only halfway of the movie than fall a sleep. I gave a try 3 times, but I couldn`t make it.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

NIntendoFan94Feb 25, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. this movie blows you away! It was actually different than any star wars movie. Most of all, its worth checking out! Visual Effects has done well, The cast was good. It was a true prequel to A New Hope.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

kamikaz3kittenJan 1, 2017

A beautiful looking movie, proving that a stand alone movie set in this universe can succeed and do it with style. Its action packed leaving me wanting more.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

AvalordJan 2, 2017

First I have to state: I disliked, even despised "A Force Awakens", a movie without a single original thought, badly executed. Rogue One is no less than the best Star Wars Movie ever made. The characters are great, the pacing is just right.First I have to state: I disliked, even despised "A Force Awakens", a movie without a single original thought, badly executed. Rogue One is no less than the best Star Wars Movie ever made. The characters are great, the pacing is just right. With Protagonists that matter to you, you want to spend some time with, before you descend into the slaughterhouse together.
All those who criticise the slow start of the film I have to tell: Just wait for the next Star Wars Movie (VIII). You'll get your soul/mindless J.J.Abrams opus soon enough!… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

7

KleverViperDec 22, 2016

Overall a good film. After the first scene the film jumps around a bit and does seem confusing but it gets better in the second half with a very strong ending. Obviously a must watch for Star Wars fans but even if you aren't it's still veryOverall a good film. After the first scene the film jumps around a bit and does seem confusing but it gets better in the second half with a very strong ending. Obviously a must watch for Star Wars fans but even if you aren't it's still very entertaining.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

fashion_policeJan 2, 2017

The movie is really good I recommend it. The Star Wars feel is here, there is character development and it is not cliché. The last hour is particularly good. Only downside is that it would have been cool to have more lightsaber fights.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

7

KeithDowJan 14, 2017

Rogue One is a fun ride and the end sequence is a genuine thrill. While only the fourth or fifth best film in the series, it still does justice to the reinvigorated franchise.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

SomePersonaJan 1, 2017

I actually really enjoyed this movie, and that is coming from a person that is not much of a Star Wars fan. It's also coming from a person that thinks The Force Awakens is one of the most overrated flicks of all time.

My favorite parts ofI actually really enjoyed this movie, and that is coming from a person that is not much of a Star Wars fan. It's also coming from a person that thinks The Force Awakens is one of the most overrated flicks of all time.

My favorite parts of this movie was basically anything with CGI Tarkin and another character that is recreated with CGI (no spoilers (: ) and the entire final sequence of stealing the Death Star plans.

You know what? I'm going to spoil it. They steal the Death Star plans and give them to Princess Leia. She gives them to the rebels and they destroy the Death Star! There, I just spoiled everything for you! LOL… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

madnoloJan 2, 2017

This movie was a big surprise for me, being a series fan I went in without much expectations. I had this preconception made after watching the Force Awakens, which I found to be beautiful and very well made, but largely lacking in screenplayThis movie was a big surprise for me, being a series fan I went in without much expectations. I had this preconception made after watching the Force Awakens, which I found to be beautiful and very well made, but largely lacking in screenplay and plot. Rogue One is in my opinion funnier and more captivating than any of the prequels(1,2 and 3). The music and scenario are as as well done as always. Acting from the main characters could be the only lacking feature, but the movie makes up for it with the terrific screenplay and well orchestrated pace. Definitely recommend it.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

cuevaslermaJan 2, 2017

This film is for those who saw Episode IV in the theatres, only those who remember what they felt when they saw the stormtroopers, AT-AT, Star destroyers. they are the ones who really will enjoy this film, only a few will really feel chillsThis film is for those who saw Episode IV in the theatres, only those who remember what they felt when they saw the stormtroopers, AT-AT, Star destroyers. they are the ones who really will enjoy this film, only a few will really feel chills to see certain characters. Only a few will return to 1977, for the others a good sci-fi movie could be considered.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

LyciusJan 30, 2017

I am old school and one of those people who rejects the special editions and the 3 prequels as a horrible departure from the first three films. I place this film solidly at the number 2 spot in my favorites, behind Empire.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

NRbgjMar 23, 2017

This is how Star Wars should be, a darker, gritty, more realistic space opera. A piece of art in the movie industry by crew and cast. Excellent. Well done.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

4

RetrodoxMar 28, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. These next gen star wars movies cant hit it for me but first what I'll say about this movie is that the tone is consistent and the action is admirable also its the first aesthetic star wars film but other than that Felicity Jones need not be given a lead role ever again her acting is nothing short but cringy she had only one good scene and I happened to hate that scene I thought that forest Whitaker's scene was poorly directed and odd to be honest.For about 50 mins It seemed like the movie couldn't get off the ground and had little direction.Also I hate "lovable robots"… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

8

GrantD243Apr 25, 2018

Rogue One was Disney's first stab at a non-Skywalker saga film and it was a valiant first attempt. It did its job of filling the gap of time that we don't see before A New Hope starts, but it's not without its flaws. The biggest problem withRogue One was Disney's first stab at a non-Skywalker saga film and it was a valiant first attempt. It did its job of filling the gap of time that we don't see before A New Hope starts, but it's not without its flaws. The biggest problem with this film, which leads to other problems, is that we only get one movie with this cast of characters. This was something that was set in stone from the beginning, so they had to try to make us care about these characters in a pretty tight running time. And, unfortunately, they don't execute this task as well as they could have. The rest of the movie is pretty damn good. We get some classic Star Wars scenes, and some interesting plot lines. There's also some excellent comedy in this film (much better than than Diney's other two Star Wars films). But, the characters are pretty shallow as I said and it's hard to truly care about them when the movie expects us to, and as a result the film isn't as good as it could have been.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

7

DirigiblePulpJan 5, 2017

Mostly good fun. The new characters seem interesting, but probably don't get enough depth. I like the underlying theme of the unsung heroes of the rebellion though I'm not sure if it ever really rang true in the end. It's mostly there as aMostly good fun. The new characters seem interesting, but probably don't get enough depth. I like the underlying theme of the unsung heroes of the rebellion though I'm not sure if it ever really rang true in the end. It's mostly there as a sign post and when the main characters die it feels more like a necessary act for the films that follow as opposed to any kind of inevitability about the sacrifices and futility of war.

Mikkelsen is a bit wasted and he shouldn't have been. Mendelsohn is good, though I wish he would have gotten some juicier scenes (the opening confrontation between these two is probably the best for both).

There's a bit too much fan service in this. The CGI Tarkin and Leia aren't necessary. They were distracting and are going to age extremely poorly. It was fine for them to do it, but close-ups of their faces was needless. They should have kept the shots wide and distant, and up close with their backs turned. Vader kicking ass was both cool and eye-roll inducing. I still don't know how to feel about that. Is there nothing sacred anymore?… Expand