Red Dead Redemption 2

 Xbox One
User Score
8.3

Generally favorable reviews- based on 5168 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 4,181 out of 5168
  2. Mixed: 305 out of 5168
  3. Negative: 682 out of 5168
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. ravinosaurus
    Jun 6, 2019
    10
    This game might not be perfect but it deserves nothing short of 10 because it is definitely more than a 9 for me. The games slower pace is due to realism being prioritized more than gameplay in this game. I absolutely loved the slower pace but I agree that the gameplay could have been better. I don't quite understand how people expect it to have a faster pace because it really blends inThis game might not be perfect but it deserves nothing short of 10 because it is definitely more than a 9 for me. The games slower pace is due to realism being prioritized more than gameplay in this game. I absolutely loved the slower pace but I agree that the gameplay could have been better. I don't quite understand how people expect it to have a faster pace because it really blends in with the time and the setting of the game. The whole game is like watching a movie but you get really attached to the characters along the way and that makes it something really special. Arthur Morgan is so good you will forget how good of a character John Marston was. This is so far the best rockstar game I ever played and I believe its one of the all-time greats.… Expand
  2. bouncy
    Jun 20, 2019
    10
    I am genuinely angry that Fortnite got that game award over Red Dead Redemption 2. Now, I'm still only on chapter 2 however this game has been a lot of fun so far. The controls are actually pretty good with my only complaint being to match speeds you need to hold A the entire time and it isn't a toggle. The graphics are hands down the best of this generation especially in 4K. The openI am genuinely angry that Fortnite got that game award over Red Dead Redemption 2. Now, I'm still only on chapter 2 however this game has been a lot of fun so far. The controls are actually pretty good with my only complaint being to match speeds you need to hold A the entire time and it isn't a toggle. The graphics are hands down the best of this generation especially in 4K. The open world that I have explored so far has been filled with things to do and is absolutely stunning. Rockstar have outdone themselves with Red Dead Redemption 2 and if you haven't got this game already, you're missing out on what I would call a masterpiece.… Expand
  3. Dashthunderman
    Jun 22, 2019
    10
    This game is a no brainier just buy it. Gameplay is fantastic graphics are insane and it has a beautiful masterpiece of a story pieced together by rockstar. This game in my books will be timeless and a 140+ hour game of content I hope to revisit. Although I will leave the online out of this review because if you are buying this game you shouldn't be buying it for it's online.
  4. drakerain
    Jul 3, 2019
    9
    Red dead redemption 2 is unlike any game I have ever played before, I was invested in every character until the very end. My advice is to take the game slow unlike I did and savor every moment. There are some features that could be fixed there are a lot of glitches and running is a little janky. But it is still my favorite game of all time.
  5. aPandaMan
    Jul 7, 2019
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I think I can honestly say that this is the best game I have ever played. It has a masterful story that puts you in the shoes of Arthur Morgan and takes you on an emotional rollercoaster. You get to see how Dutch and the other remaining gang members deteriorate into the husk of their former selves that they are in the first game. It’s an awesome must-play!… Expand
  6. Rebelgut
    Jul 12, 2019
    10
    I have never loved playing through a game more. Rockstar does an absolutely incredible job bring the immersion of the west into a players mind. The game is so detailed and has one of the most heart wrenching stories I have ever played through. The voice acting is incredible, the game is visually so appealing, and there is just so many details that should be appreciated.
  7. Lucca_MOA
    Jul 13, 2019
    10
    This is a Rockstar masterpiece that takes the Red Dead Redemption series to a whole other level. Buy it and thank me later.
  8. W0lf_0f_Snyd3r
    Jul 14, 2019
    8
    I love Rockstar games, but they seriously need to figure out their controls. Since GTA III controls have been **** with a slight improvement.
  9. tsssssunami
    Aug 6, 2019
    8
    Red Dead Redemption 2 has something for everyone. The main story is beautifully crafted, and never seem boring. In most games, filler missions that don't move the plot are some of the most boring ones. In RDR2, getting drunk and building houses were some of my favorite memories of the whole game. Aside from the main story, you can take off and do whatever you want in the vast open map.Red Dead Redemption 2 has something for everyone. The main story is beautifully crafted, and never seem boring. In most games, filler missions that don't move the plot are some of the most boring ones. In RDR2, getting drunk and building houses were some of my favorite memories of the whole game. Aside from the main story, you can take off and do whatever you want in the vast open map. Sure, you can do regular cowboy things, rob trains, get in bar fights, do whatever you want. But in my opinion, some of the best parts of the game is making your own fun up in the mountains, fishing and hunting. Red Dead allows me to fufill my dreams of being a god damn mountain man. Thank you Rockstar… Expand
  10. v3st1az
    Aug 22, 2019
    9
    Outstanding. Great. Awesome.

    There is everything you need in the game: – huge world with beautiful nature and various animals and plants(you'll do a lot of photos I'm sure) – different activities(meeting strangers, all sort of robberies, bounty hunting, gambling, fishing/hunting, horse racing, exploring, talking around a campfire and list goes on) – good story about people, who can't    Outstanding. Great. Awesome.

    There is everything you need in the game:
    – huge world with beautiful nature and various animals and plants(you'll do a lot of photos I'm sure)
    – different activities(meeting strangers, all sort of robberies, bounty hunting, gambling, fishing/hunting, horse racing, exploring, talking around a campfire and list goes on)
    – good story about people, who can't find their place in modern society
    – plenty of Easter eggs and points of interest
    – and bunch of other stuff

    P.S.(for Russian-speaking)
    Поражают дебилы, ставящие 0 баллов, только потому, что "неудобно читать субтитры на английском" – God damn fools.    … Expand
  11. joaojoy
    Sep 12, 2019
    10
    Excelente jogo, um dos melhores que já joguei, muito bem feito, gráficos lindos, jogabilidade, história, trilha sonora, nota 10
  12. WagnerSPBH
    Sep 5, 2019
    10
    RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 foi sem dúvida o melhor jogo que joguei em toda minha vida de games. Nunca tinha jogado um game com uma história tão profunda e envolvente, uma jogabilidade excelente, diálogos memoráveis e personagens marcantes! Muitos easter eggs fantásticos! O jogo é sensacional! Merecia sim o Goty 2018!
  13. lordn3r0
    Nov 4, 2019
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2 is best of 8th generation so far. Ultımately detailed open world, very good written story and storyline, memorable characters, remarkable ost, perfect gunplay and perfect open world activities. This game is pure art. Pure. One of the best games ı've ever played.
  14. Bielks96
    Sep 7, 2019
    10
    Uma das histórias mais envolvente dos últimos tempo digo com tranquilidade que rd2 está no topo junto com as grandes obras de cinema uma história digna de Oscar.
  15. It_is_decided
    Sep 8, 2019
    9
    I love the characters and the story that the game is trying to tell; the only critique I have with the game. is specific m mechanics and how in some specific missions they carry you the whole way and tell you exactly what to do.
  16. Colty250
    Sep 16, 2019
    9
    Almost everything about this game is amazing, the story is an incredible 60 hour journey which expands on the Van Der Linde gang mentioned in the first game (the game is a prequel.) Arthur is an amazing character and a much more interesting character than John Marston, his backstory could of been touched more but perhaps that is being saved for another game or expansion. There is enoughAlmost everything about this game is amazing, the story is an incredible 60 hour journey which expands on the Van Der Linde gang mentioned in the first game (the game is a prequel.) Arthur is an amazing character and a much more interesting character than John Marston, his backstory could of been touched more but perhaps that is being saved for another game or expansion. There is enough content in this game to last over 100 hours not including the ever expanding online mode. You can fish, hunt, collect, explore and experience the immersive open world scenery and random encounters. The soundtrack is also incredible and is a perfect match for the game. The gang's characters are all interesting in their own way and give you insights into their lives in random interactions in the camp. On another note, the last few hours of the story are incredible and leave you wanting more, despite playing the game for 50+ hours already which is always something that indicated how good a game is. The only downside I could find is that the movement mechanics feel a bit dated and are similar to Grand Theft Auto V, although the gun mechanics are great.

    Played on Xbox One X (3840x2160 @ 30fps)    … Expand
  17. JohninNL
    Sep 20, 2019
    10
    Even though I do own a Nintendo Switch and Xbox One I do not consider myself only a very casual gamer, when playing a game 9/10 it will be a platformer along the lines of Mario while my Xbox One is mostly used for media consumption. This game has been peaking my interest for a while due to all the high review scores and I finally picked it up on sale a week ago and oh boy what a game thisEven though I do own a Nintendo Switch and Xbox One I do not consider myself only a very casual gamer, when playing a game 9/10 it will be a platformer along the lines of Mario while my Xbox One is mostly used for media consumption. This game has been peaking my interest for a while due to all the high review scores and I finally picked it up on sale a week ago and oh boy what a game this is. It's not to difficult but the amount of depth in here is unbelievable, it never feels like your doing the same thing twice and whether you just want to be hunter, like to go exploring the massive lands of the game or interacting with strangers that have interesting stories to tell all over the map there will be something for you here. This is why I believe this game is great for gamers and non-gamers alike. Now let me get back to my game ;)… Expand
  18. Beastside
    Sep 28, 2019
    10
    The game of the generation. Probably the greatest gaming experience I've ever had.
  19. Andizzzzy
    Jan 11, 2021
    10
    I really like the Red Dead Redemption concept.

    My only wish is that Rockstar didn't focus any of their time on the online mode, and instead went all out on the single-player. Also this game could've done with DLC.
  20. Nirico
    Oct 27, 2019
    10
    When I play a game the story is paramount for me so stepping into Red Dead Redemption 2 it has big shoes to fill. In the time since the original Red Dead Redemption released (one of my personal favorite games and stories ever made) there have been many phenomenal stories be they The Last of Us, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt or even the more recently released God of War. But I must say not onlyWhen I play a game the story is paramount for me so stepping into Red Dead Redemption 2 it has big shoes to fill. In the time since the original Red Dead Redemption released (one of my personal favorite games and stories ever made) there have been many phenomenal stories be they The Last of Us, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt or even the more recently released God of War. But I must say not only did Red Dead Redemption 2 live up to these examples, but it blew them out of the way in many regards. From the characters to the world to even your horse, everything is connected to Arthur in ways you wouldn’t expect. While the gun play isn’t top notch, the other aspects of the game more than make up for this fact. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a must play for anyone whom values storytelling and character, and it’s a game that will resonate me for as long as I live. And that’s not an exaggeration.… Expand
  21. GATOR31
    Nov 4, 2019
    10
    Awesome game, imprescindible in our collection. I played the One S version and it looks perfect on a 4K HDR TV. However in One X looks more better, but in One S is perfect with the reescaled 4K.
  22. Yoyoadel
    Nov 6, 2019
    10
    This game is a real masterpiece it is the best game I have ever played the graphics are awesome and may be the best in this generation the story is perfect and well connected to the first RDR
  23. farzad312
    Nov 6, 2019
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Still a masterpiece from Rockstar. No problem with Red Dead Redemption 2. The graphics are great. The sound is really good. The story is rich and not boring. RDR 2 deserves a score of 10.… Expand
  24. Boomerkhan
    Nov 7, 2019
    10
    Amazing game. Absolutely love it. I adore it. Best story in a video game. Definitely a must-buy
  25. Crisdeth
    May 2, 2021
    10
    excelente juego, si te pasaste el primero, es impresindible que juegues este. excelentes graficos, calidad de detalles, comunidad online activo.
  26. GordonGekkoSU
    Nov 10, 2019
    9
    Fantastic game! Best game of 2019 for sure!

    . There’s a ton of content for you to get to grips with and you will definitely not be getting bored anytime soon
  27. MasterRug75
    Nov 11, 2019
    10
    The best tittle of rockstar games with maybe the best and most human character un the videogames, Arthur Morgan
  28. SenorKoquonfaes
    Nov 16, 2019
    10
    To put it as succinctly as possible: Read Dead Redemption 2 is one of the single greatest gaming experiences I've ever played.

    It's visually astounding, it's set a new standard for storytelling and the characters are written to make you really feel strongly about them, one way or another. Arthur Morgan is going to go down as one of the greatest protagonists in video game history.    To put it as succinctly as possible: Read Dead Redemption 2 is one of the single greatest gaming experiences I've ever played.

    It's visually astounding, it's set a new standard for storytelling and the characters are written to make you really feel strongly about them, one way or another.

    Arthur Morgan is going to go down as one of the greatest protagonists in video game history.

    Full recommendation!    … Expand
  29. KKs_Grandma
    Nov 20, 2019
    10
    This is , by far, the best game I have ever played. The story is great and the game is so immersive that it's hard to stop playing. The open world is so large it takes many many hours to explore it all and there's so much to do while exploring that it adds even more hours. I love games that i can finish the story but start over because there is so much more to do. This is one of thoseThis is , by far, the best game I have ever played. The story is great and the game is so immersive that it's hard to stop playing. The open world is so large it takes many many hours to explore it all and there's so much to do while exploring that it adds even more hours. I love games that i can finish the story but start over because there is so much more to do. This is one of those games i will never get tired of.… Expand
  30. Patense
    Nov 24, 2019
    10
    Jogo espetacular, beira a perfeição.
    A história é muito boa, te prende e te surpreende.
    Os NPcs vivem e interagem de forma natural. Cada encontros aleatório tem uma história diferente. Tudo dele é realista, o mundo o diversificado, pântano, planícies, montanhas , cheio de animais. O tempo muda de forma incrível, o sol, a chuva a neve e noite estrelada. Pra quem gosta de exploração é    Jogo espetacular, beira a perfeição.
    A história é muito boa, te prende e te surpreende.
    Os NPcs vivem e interagem de forma natural.
    Cada encontros aleatório tem uma história diferente.
    Tudo dele é realista, o mundo o diversificado, pântano, planícies, montanhas , cheio de animais.
    O tempo muda de forma incrível, o sol, a chuva a neve e noite estrelada.
    Pra quem gosta de exploração é fascinante.
    Pontos negativos, animações de preparar alimentos e tirar peles animais é muito bonita, mas poderia ter opção de corte de cena.
    Vida, olhos da morte e energia,cada um poderia ter somente uma barra.    … Expand
  31. SJBailey780
    Nov 28, 2019
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2 is without a doubt the best game of this generation! It’s is also my second favorite game of all time second only to the Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. Red Dead Redemption 2 has maybe the best story in any video game ever. Red Dead Redemption 2 is one of those games that I understand if you don’t like it. It’s definitely not for everyone. RDR2 is a game you have to be veryRed Dead Redemption 2 is without a doubt the best game of this generation! It’s is also my second favorite game of all time second only to the Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. Red Dead Redemption 2 has maybe the best story in any video game ever. Red Dead Redemption 2 is one of those games that I understand if you don’t like it. It’s definitely not for everyone. RDR2 is a game you have to be very patient with. It’s a game based on realism. I love Red Dead Redemption 2 and truly think it’s a masterpiece.… Expand
  32. Soccerj22
    Nov 29, 2019
    10
    Best game must buy. Story is the best I've played, Arthur is fantastic, never was bored. Amazing!
  33. Aixra12z
    Dec 8, 2019
    10
    Very emotional game. I like this game so much.
    You will get emotional 100%.
  34. CincoZero
    Jun 27, 2020
    8
    The greatest strengths of this game are undoubtedly the history and charisma of the characters (including Arthur Morgan has become in my opinion Rockstar's greatest character) even though you already know how it will end if you have already played RDR1. The graphics are very good, the scenery is mesmerizing, the soundtrack is impeccable. The gameplay flows very well, although I wasThe greatest strengths of this game are undoubtedly the history and charisma of the characters (including Arthur Morgan has become in my opinion Rockstar's greatest character) even though you already know how it will end if you have already played RDR1. The graphics are very good, the scenery is mesmerizing, the soundtrack is impeccable. The gameplay flows very well, although I was surprised by the new targeting system that takes a short time to fire weapons accurately (probably to balance RDO).
    But the game ended up disappointing me in some points like the lack of content in a part of the map (New Austin) and the terrible state that RDO is at the moment.    … Expand
  35. Dmoney201263
    Dec 26, 2019
    8
    It is an unfortunate thing that Rockstar one of the most prolific game developers that bring us such amazing experiences give little love to the pc community. They used to make wacky goofy games and one offs that pushed the envelope in different directions and took risks but Take 2 is a disease riddle with corporate money addicted micro transaction loving soulless garbage. I love RedIt is an unfortunate thing that Rockstar one of the most prolific game developers that bring us such amazing experiences give little love to the pc community. They used to make wacky goofy games and one offs that pushed the envelope in different directions and took risks but Take 2 is a disease riddle with corporate money addicted micro transaction loving soulless garbage. I love Red Dead and put hundreds of hours into it and more on the remaster before Red Dead 2 but this is unacceptable. Why is it that the pc is an after thought that developers just throw crap at a wall and hope it sticks? The pc is what gave Rockstar it's billions of dollars from online and mod communities yet they give so little of a f$#% that it hurts their well earned reputation. Red Dead 2 is an amazing well built story with compelling characters and story beats that keep you committed and engaged throughout it's lengthy campaign. This is one of the most engrossing and beautiful experiences I have had on my Xbox one X but the pc version is a hot garbage fire that is unacceptable. You are made by your customers and destroyed by the same people who once held you in such high esteem. The years of love and childhood fond memories can only last so long before you start to get torn out of the past by just how greedy and disrespectful these devs have treated this community. There is noaccident that CDProject Red is held so high as the gold standard of how to treat your community and give them what you want yourself from a game. Once you put money above fun, exciting stories and strip single player dlc out for some boring "community" mods and games as a service nonsense you deserve everything said about you and seeing so many who loved you starting to leave. You make games for the love and enjoyment it gives you and everyone who interacts with it's world. People give their time, attention, and hard earned dollars for a product when there are so many games that they do not have to support or give you that valuable commodity. Step back and really think about how this affects your company and make a decision money or enjoyable enthralling stories that change the industry because you are almost a shell of the once great Rockstar.… Expand
  36. darkyyy
    Jan 2, 2021
    10
    This is a masterpiece! This is probably the best game I've ever played! The plot is long, but what a thrill it is. The ending that made me cry for days on end; (The gameplay, physics, graphics (even on One S) are very cool. I have no words, only emotions! 10/10
  37. 010101010100
    Dec 13, 2021
    0
    Returned it after less than 4 hours. good graphics, bad controls, bad missions, bad gameplay. The missions are basically just following someone slowly on your horse. The story mode is mediocre with online being unplayable. online is P2W, so people who just spend money in the game want to make everyone else feel like they wasted their money too. Any game that shows me on a map to OP P2WReturned it after less than 4 hours. good graphics, bad controls, bad missions, bad gameplay. The missions are basically just following someone slowly on your horse. The story mode is mediocre with online being unplayable. online is P2W, so people who just spend money in the game want to make everyone else feel like they wasted their money too. Any game that shows me on a map to OP P2W players that are trying to hunt me down is a terrible game regardless of anything else. i’d rather play a game that has no map at all. i expected more out after dropping money for the ultimate version. rockstar’s whole business model is more of a cashgrab than mobile game companies.… Expand
  38. Legrant91
    May 22, 2020
    10
    For me, this is the perfect game. I also loved the first part, but it even goes beyond that. I love Rockstar Games!
  39. KaliusMaximus
    Jun 20, 2020
    10
    Best game of all time and of this generation by far. Nothing came close to this pure masterpiece.
  40. TheFran990
    Jun 23, 2020
    10
    This is game is an absolute beauty. The story is a great journey, since the begining until the end, a rollercoaster that will stay in your hearth forever, and the gameplay is 10 out of 10 as well.
  41. GhostKill
    Jan 29, 2023
    10
    Perfect! From Undead Nightmare to traversing the plains in this game- it is the bomb! Hunting, shootouts, and even zombies- this game is incredible. Jon Marston is a great character with super dead eye abilities and it's just so much fun. Red Dead is GTA in the old west and it's a win!
  42. irai16
    Nov 7, 2020
    10
    Playing this game was a life-changing experience that opened my eyes to what video games could truly be. This is absolutely one of the best games I've ever played, and a towering achievement in graphics, design, story, and immersion. Now, I just have to try the online....
  43. Cabanboo2
    Jan 4, 2021
    10
    oque falar desse jogo

    um dos melhores mundo abertos já feitos tinha uma missão MUITO dificil de fazer o arthur morgan ter o mesmo carisma do lendário John Marston e para mim ele é melhor o jogo MAIS DETALHADO DA HISTÓRIA História/narrativa muito emocionante, profunda e complexa Trilha sonora sensacional Áudio design incrível e gráficos HIPNOTIZANTES para mim o    oque falar desse jogo

    um dos melhores mundo abertos já feitos

    tinha uma missão MUITO dificil de fazer o arthur morgan ter o mesmo carisma do lendário John Marston e para mim ele é melhor

    o jogo MAIS DETALHADO DA HISTÓRIA

    História/narrativa muito emocionante, profunda e complexa

    Trilha sonora sensacional

    Áudio design incrível

    e gráficos HIPNOTIZANTES

    para mim o melhor jogo já feito na historia    … Expand
  44. vampiredavid
    Jul 21, 2020
    10
    The greatest character in video game history. The best open-world game.Just like coming back to 1899's America.
  45. Luiscrit
    Jul 26, 2020
    9
    El juego me encanto pero si hay algunas partes de la historia que se sienten un poco flojas
  46. emoninja
    Aug 11, 2020
    0
    Online gameplay is attrocious, especially after the August 10th 1.21 update. In general, it feels as though this game's online component is neglected and underappreciated by Rockstar Games. The updates are few and far between over the past 2 years compared to Grand Theft Auto Online, Red Dead doesn't get the light of day, but Grand Theft Auto is the golden child. I've tried to advocateOnline gameplay is attrocious, especially after the August 10th 1.21 update. In general, it feels as though this game's online component is neglected and underappreciated by Rockstar Games. The updates are few and far between over the past 2 years compared to Grand Theft Auto Online, Red Dead doesn't get the light of day, but Grand Theft Auto is the golden child. I've tried to advocate for Red Dead Online, even convinced some of my friends to get an X Box so we could play together. But after this most recent patch, it's clear to me that there is no care or concern for the game by the developers. I feel like a fool for believing this was a worthwhile outlet for my time. I was wrong.… Expand
  47. PittenZak94
    Oct 7, 2020
    0
    Truly the best game I have ever played. Dialogue, sound, visuals, story, gameplay, all are great.
  48. Berellow
    Dec 1, 2020
    5
    One of my favourite games ever! The story is an absolute masterpiece!
    I recommend it 10/10.
    Although the online gameplay was full of glitches and bugs now is actually rlly better... Love this game
  49. SagIchNed
    Dec 3, 2020
    10
    This game will always be a Masterpiece!
    Graphics 10/10
    Story 10/10
    Gameplay 10/10
  50. maiconpl
    Dec 8, 2020
    6
    Os gráficos são incríveis, mas o jogo não prende. Joguei 4 horas e desisti.
  51. Scoutgoat
    Jan 13, 2021
    10
    I almost never give any games 10/10, but this game absolutely deserves it. This is as perfect as a game can get. Beautiful graphics, extremely well written story, memorable characters, amazing and diverse soundtrack, fun environments to explore, the best AI in any game, the best NPC interaction in any game, awesome physics (especially when it comes to euphoria physics), and extremelyI almost never give any games 10/10, but this game absolutely deserves it. This is as perfect as a game can get. Beautiful graphics, extremely well written story, memorable characters, amazing and diverse soundtrack, fun environments to explore, the best AI in any game, the best NPC interaction in any game, awesome physics (especially when it comes to euphoria physics), and extremely realistic animations. Most people criticize the game for being too slow, but this isn't GTA. It's not meant to be a fast paced shooter; it's meant to be a game where you take in the beauty, interact with the NPCs, and just enjoy the world. Mission design is also a thing people like to criticize for being linear, but they don't understand that they're meant to be linear. They're missions, not quests where you can go about it in 20 different ways.… Expand
  52. FadedInMN
    Dec 16, 2020
    7
    Another solid game from Rockstar, it doesn't miss many marks but online could have been a bit more fun.
  53. Ryan222
    Jan 3, 2021
    10
    One of the best stories I've experienced in any game or book or movie great game
  54. JackTheSoplica
    Jan 5, 2021
    10
    It is simply the best game that i have ever played. There are some minor shortcomings (wanted system, missions structure). Everything else is top notch, with outstanding story and characters. The world is the best of all games, with vast amount of animals and plants, beautiful landscapes and living cities. Also it runs suprisingly well on Xbox one x (native 4k, 30fps). For me Red DeadIt is simply the best game that i have ever played. There are some minor shortcomings (wanted system, missions structure). Everything else is top notch, with outstanding story and characters. The world is the best of all games, with vast amount of animals and plants, beautiful landscapes and living cities. Also it runs suprisingly well on Xbox one x (native 4k, 30fps). For me Red Dead Redemption 2 is the best game of all.… Expand
  55. Matvey1337
    Jan 9, 2021
    10
    This game is worked out to the smallest detail. The game is completely realistic and chic. Every step, the player's action has been worked out.
    The game is awesome. I'm sure this game is the best this decade, and indeed in the entire gaming industry.
    The plot is also gorgeous. Gorgeous missions, missions are unique, in some you need to think, and in some you just need to shoot. Each    This game is worked out to the smallest detail. The game is completely realistic and chic. Every step, the player's action has been worked out.
    The game is awesome. I'm sure this game is the best this decade, and indeed in the entire gaming industry.
    The plot is also gorgeous. Gorgeous missions, missions are unique, in some you need to think, and in some you just need to shoot. Each character has its own personality and amazing background stories.
    At the end I cried like a ****
    100/10    … Expand
  56. Cenkracker
    Jan 20, 2021
    10
    After Gta V i tought:
    its a wild-west game what can they add after first rdr.
    And i'm shocked it was a long emotional journey.Rockstar did their best i can tell.
    During 25 days i played rdr2 night to morning.
    I mean wow i want to hug everyone in rockstar san diego.Its my favorite video game until rokstar's new game.
  57. Yefe71
    May 17, 2021
    0
    İts not a game ,its legand

    main character:10/10
    story telling:10/10
    gameplay:10/10
    others:9.5/10
  58. BaBka_YaGGa
    May 18, 2021
    10
    Лучшая игра 2018 года, лучшая игра про Дикий Запад, с потрясающей графикой и великолепным сюжетом. Продуманны в иге тысяча тысяч мелочей, поведение животных и людей, физика всего и вся, открытый мир, полный реализм и улет. 10/10 игра шедеврЛучшая игра 2018 года, лучшая игра про Дикий Запад, с потрясающей графикой и великолепным сюжетом. Продуманны в иге тысяча тысяч мелочей, поведение животных и людей, физика всего и вся, открытый мир, полный реализм и улет. 10/10 игра шедевр
  59. Patedus
    Mar 16, 2022
    7
    Overrated. Great story but that's really all it is... a great story in a big ass open world that revolves around a game that feels linear.
  60. Azura_xv
    Jul 26, 2021
    0
    Gameplay 0/10Trash
    Most Overrated game
    Characters is okay
    Story is okay
    Soundtrack is okay
  61. Parangaritiwi
    Mar 8, 2022
    0
    Trash horse simulator, overrated garbage with critics so biased towards Rockstar studios.
  62. Salt_addict
    Feb 14, 2022
    9
    Could not stop playing from start to epilogue. Didn't touch online however.
  63. Akira47rus
    Mar 13, 2022
    0
    Идиотизм, если я из россии то хрен тебе а не игры, вот это отношение, супер!!!
  64. SocratesGoneMad
    Jul 5, 2022
    0
    I'm not a huge Rockstar fan. So it really surprised me when this ended up being one of my favorite games I've ever played. The writing is just so good, possibly the best out of any game I've played. This leads to excellent characters that make you really care about the world. Just a masterpiece.
  65. DGS14
    May 16, 2023
    10
    simplemente el mejor juego de la historia, el mejor juego que vas a jugar jamas
  66. Neelyry
    Dec 15, 2019
    5
    Slowest paced game i have ever played. Would have given it a ten if they didnt make it painfully slow. Beating this was a chore
  67. ost8fan
    Jan 16, 2022
    10
    Perfect in most ways. Story is incredible, characters memorable and impactful, the world is impressively alive and responsive. I’ll always seemingly have issues with shooting in Rockstar games, and it can be a bit overstuffed, but this game sets an incredibly high bar.
  68. hoohoo
    Jan 1, 2020
    7
    Good game, but overrated. Not even in top10. It has severe UI problems. Slow actions, auto-aiming that causes one wrong button press to fail missions (ie. you shoot the person you were supposed to help or lasso them when you were supposed to lasso the horse etc). Wolfs start chacing you. Let’s turn the camera by force towards them, so you can’t see where you are riding and inevitablyGood game, but overrated. Not even in top10. It has severe UI problems. Slow actions, auto-aiming that causes one wrong button press to fail missions (ie. you shoot the person you were supposed to help or lasso them when you were supposed to lasso the horse etc). Wolfs start chacing you. Let’s turn the camera by force towards them, so you can’t see where you are riding and inevitably crash and get killed by the wolves. Beautiful, but looks do not cover what it lacks in mechanics. Even C64 had games that were better mechanics.… Expand
  69. osprey
    Nov 30, 2022
    4
    I absolutely loved RD1 and never got tired of playing it. I was so excited to play this game and at first was struck by the beauty of the world and the quality of the voice acting. Love how real the horses are and how they behave exactly like real horses. The first game was full of fun things to do and surprises to find in the wilderness. This game has none of that. The constantI absolutely loved RD1 and never got tired of playing it. I was so excited to play this game and at first was struck by the beauty of the world and the quality of the voice acting. Love how real the horses are and how they behave exactly like real horses. The first game was full of fun things to do and surprises to find in the wilderness. This game has none of that. The constant maintenance of your character your horse and the camp are tedious beyond belief. The controls are ridiculously convoluted and you can't stay out of trouble no matter how careful you are. The game crashes or locks frequently and everything you try to do is ruined by the weakness of your character. I fail constantly and as for objectives to get a gold, forget about it. I am so sad that the game I love so much has become one I freaking hate. The four points are for the beauty of the game and the things that they did right, everything else has ruined this game for me. I will pass it on to my son and see if he can wring any fun out of it and maybe show me where the fun is. Biggest disappointment since Mafia 3. Update, my son hated it too!… Expand
  70. Cyper
    May 23, 2020
    10
    This ie best game I have played the last 15 years. I am born 1990 and I have NEVER played any game like this before.

    • The graphics is stunning with extreme details. For example, your characters pupils will dilate in darker environment. Horses balls shrinks in cold weather. Walking in snow or mud make footprints. If you hit someone, you may see them with a bandage around their head the    This ie best game I have played the last 15 years. I am born 1990 and I have NEVER played any game like this before.

    • The graphics is stunning with extreme details. For example, your characters pupils will dilate in darker environment. Horses balls shrinks in cold weather. Walking in snow or mud make footprints. If you hit someone, you may see them with a bandage around their head the day after. That kind of attention to details shines through the whole game.

    • The environment is living and breathing of life. This is not only the NPC:s. You can even see birds picking up fish, dogs playing in the mud, and even eagles hunting rabbits. The environment and the people is different depending on which state you're in.

    • The story is extremely well-written. There is indeed a few underdeveloped characters. But overall it is amazing: it is long, it is complex, and there is many ways to interact with the people in the story outside of the story itself. You really get to KNOW all the characters. The game's ending was very emotional and made me shred a tear.

    • There is lots to do outside of the storyline.

    • I was afraid that this game would become another ''responsive, accessible, fast-paced dumbed-down action game. Well it was not. The shooting mechanics and the animations are great. Not everyone's cup of tea though: this game is not the typical AA-title with fast-paced action and accessible gameplay. Shooting and movement is slower and more deliberate. You have to shave, and clean yourself if you want to look respectable. You have to clean your guns from time to time to keep them in shape. There is a lot of animations. If you have short attention span this game might not be for you.

    • The soundtrack is amazing.

    Summary: If this game does not deserve 10/10 I don't know which game that would. No game is perfect. 10/10 cannot therefore refer to perfection. There is simply NO OTHER GAME like Red Dead Redemption 2. It is innovative. It cannot be replaced. With the quality, and the fact that it is different, it will always stay close to me. This is hands down the best game i've ever played in my life.    … Expand
  71. Shartrais
    Jun 28, 2020
    9
    Es un juego brillante en muchísimas cosas, como en la narrativa, el desarrollo de personajes, la iluminación, la dirección narrativa... Pero no consigue ser una obra maestra por querer ser un juego de mundo abierto, con muchas tareas que completar y mucho relleno.
  72. tdebug
    Jun 1, 2022
    5
    Mechanics is overcomplicated with every button assigned to 4 different actions. It's like learning all the (often unneccesary) mechanics meant to be a part of the game, except is only every giving frustration. Some things are not polished and not fixed even in 2022, like missing tent on a mini-map and unability to rest in the own camp etc. But keeping in mind which button is it to pressMechanics is overcomplicated with every button assigned to 4 different actions. It's like learning all the (often unneccesary) mechanics meant to be a part of the game, except is only every giving frustration. Some things are not polished and not fixed even in 2022, like missing tent on a mini-map and unability to rest in the own camp etc. But keeping in mind which button is it to press and what will it do in this case, seems to be part of the fun, except it is not fun.… Expand
  73. Compi24
    Jul 2, 2020
    10
    All Rockstar had to do was make a follow-up to "Red Dead Redemption" that was just half as good and I'd have been adequately pleased. The 2010 opus is not only one I bought at full price and felt as though I'd underpaid for, but one of my favorite games of all time. Easy top 20, for sure. Instead, what the powers-that-be have done here is something I can only say I feel lucky to even beAll Rockstar had to do was make a follow-up to "Red Dead Redemption" that was just half as good and I'd have been adequately pleased. The 2010 opus is not only one I bought at full price and felt as though I'd underpaid for, but one of my favorite games of all time. Easy top 20, for sure. Instead, what the powers-that-be have done here is something I can only say I feel lucky to even be alive to witness. "Red Dead Redemption 2" is an unrelentingly immersive, breathtaking experience from its unassuming first few minutes to its totally satisfying conclusion. It's intense, emotional, haunting and completely addicting to play. I haven't felt this in tune with a narrative, location or cast of characters in quite some time. There are bugs, yes, and some quirks to the game's honor system, but nothing ever eclipsed the sheer joy I felt every time I popped this game on and dove into its richly textured world. The performances are all incredible. The music is evocative. I nearly cried three times at a point. I don't know what else to say. Thank you, Rockstar. Bravo.… Expand
  74. Adriaan1
    Jun 5, 2020
    9
    Amazing game, good story, great gunplay! The game is a solid entry! Horse riding is really good!
  75. Achtlos
    Dec 10, 2018
    9
    Ok so... yeah the 9/10 is because the voice acting, story, direction, art composition is second to none. And those people that worked on this game, deserve the accolades they are getting, should have been Game of the Year. Here's the negative: during story sections, the game changes it's "rules" mid game, you can then no longer snipe to a distance, or do things your way, it's ONLY the wayOk so... yeah the 9/10 is because the voice acting, story, direction, art composition is second to none. And those people that worked on this game, deserve the accolades they are getting, should have been Game of the Year. Here's the negative: during story sections, the game changes it's "rules" mid game, you can then no longer snipe to a distance, or do things your way, it's ONLY the way the game allows it, or you fail.. and there's not always a prompt on what it desperately wants you to do.. it breaks the flow and pulls you out of the moment.… Expand
  76. khabron
    Mar 7, 2019
    10
    Obra de Arte Digital, buenos gráficos, historia un poco larga, pero espectacular.
  77. Voodoo123
    Dec 14, 2022
    10
    Played and completed on Xbox series x (initially started on Xbox one x but then upgraded). Seminal visual quality locked 4k HDR visuals (albeit at 30fps). Simply industry leading quality animations, storylines, textures,lighting,soundtrack,effects work,open world map design and ai systems. The only criticism I would say is the game is unreasonably long to play through all the side contentPlayed and completed on Xbox series x (initially started on Xbox one x but then upgraded). Seminal visual quality locked 4k HDR visuals (albeit at 30fps). Simply industry leading quality animations, storylines, textures,lighting,soundtrack,effects work,open world map design and ai systems. The only criticism I would say is the game is unreasonably long to play through all the side content with main missions it's around 60-70+hrs. The game is a work of art. It saddens me the houser bros are not going to be leading the way on future rockstar games but this serves as an example of the pinnacle output of these studios (slave labor working conditions aside!!). If you like open world games and have take any pleasure in a western setting then get this game now!… Expand
  78. flesy
    Dec 1, 2019
    7
    O jogo é bom mas tem muita coisa para melhorar, depois que eu zerei, o jogo perdeu toda a graça, não tem missões secundárias de alto nível para fazer, a maioria são bem chatinhas, só tem uma cidade grande o resto não se pode chamar de cidades pois a maioria só tem 10 edifícios e acabou, parece que os criadores ficaram com preguiça de fazer um jogo melhor, pois tinha potencial,

    As    O jogo é bom mas tem muita coisa para melhorar, depois que eu zerei, o jogo perdeu toda a graça, não tem missões secundárias de alto nível para fazer, a maioria são bem chatinhas, só tem uma cidade grande o resto não se pode chamar de cidades pois a maioria só tem 10 edifícios e acabou, parece que os criadores ficaram com preguiça de fazer um jogo melhor, pois tinha potencial,

    As mecânicas do jogo merecem 10 e os gráficos tbm, mas o resto deixou a desejar.    … Expand
  79. rockon
    Mar 31, 2019
    8
    If you can get past the negatives you will have many hours of good entertainment. The best part of this game is that there is so much to do. You can choose to run through the main missions or embark on the many challenges and achievements . The graphics are incredible and the map is huge. There are many things to find and plunder on the map. There might be something valuable in everyIf you can get past the negatives you will have many hours of good entertainment. The best part of this game is that there is so much to do. You can choose to run through the main missions or embark on the many challenges and achievements . The graphics are incredible and the map is huge. There are many things to find and plunder on the map. There might be something valuable in every structure. A hidden cubby hole might have $100 worth of stuff in it. Early in Chapter 2 I had explored and plundered about every corner of the map. I was careful to loot every dead body. Occasionally that caused me to lose missions but my wallet was always fat. Arthur's stuff was all pimped out.
    When you complete the main story line there are still things to do. Bounties, achievements, legendary animals if you haven't collected them. The first game's map enables in the Epilogue. I don't know what's on it yet. Some people criticized activities that are not mandatory.
    Clothing? Didn't bother with it. Gaming? I consider the games stupid and tedious. Treasure-hunting? It's not as easy as in the first game. I got tired of falling to my death and went to Youtube.
    A big negative is lack of fast-travel options and fast-travel to self-marked vicinity as in the first game. Travel was limited to named destinations.
    Also, path-finding issues and other technical glitches. Characters getting stuck forced abandonment of missions. Charles won't put the body in the wagon and just stands there, etc. Rains Fall knocks Charles off his horse so you lose the mission, etc. Because Charles won't re-mount. Control/button issues where the option won't function. Often you have to jiggle stuff and move around to get buttons to function and game play to proceed. That wasn't just occasional-that was prevalent. One time I got Charles unstuck by running into him. You can accidentally bump some one with your horse in town and suddenly have the entire town shooting at you. And then owe a bounty if you escape. It interrupts what you're trying to do. You will spend a lot on bounties in this game unless you want a constant price on your head.
    You can lose missions in a hundred different ways. Some times by following confusing or untimely AI instructions. I found that it was important not to mess with the controls until dialogue finished because it could cause a problem. Some times you can skip useless dialogue. Too often they won't allow it. Cut-aways can interfere with the flow of the action.
    Right at the end of the main story the audio started acting up. Sounds like hoofbeats and the whistle disappeared. Segments of dialogue became inaudible. This continued in the Epilogue.
    The gun play seemed to be clumsier than the first game and the Dead Eye less accurate. Dead eye marking was definitely made harder. Annoying to shoot people in the head at close range and having them get up again. Or when some one survives being shot in the middle of the chest or back with a high-powered rifle. I think it was taking 5 shots with the Mauser to drop some people.
    The AI characters really are stupid and easy to kill if you take your time. The only thing they have in their favor is surprise. Your character will always have superior firepower. If you were any good with your shooting in the first game killing your opponents in this game will be a piece of cake. Perhaps too easy.    … Expand
  80. br_1245
    Aug 24, 2020
    10
    Enredo perfeito. Pegou uma difícil tarefa de melhorar o primeiro jogo e com seu enredo envolvente e empolgante mesmo já se sabendo o destino dos protagonista conseguiu ser uma obra prima dos games!
  81. NintenAlfa2015
    Jul 2, 2020
    10
    Increíble, no esperaba tanto de un juego. La historia es de las mejores que he podido jugar y lo vivo que es el mundo simplemente wow
  82. kyle20ellis
    Mar 17, 2022
    9
    I personally still hold that the original is the better one between the two games, but this is still a top tier gaming experience and a real treat for fans of the first game. Gorgeous graphics and environment, wonderfully engaging story and characters, another killer soundtrack and just a romping good time. I hope we'll get a Part III in the future.
  83. mohi11019
    Jun 4, 2023
    10
    after playing this masterpiece, choosing another game to play, will be difficult!
  84. DedezzeSS
    Dec 13, 2022
    9
    Отличная игра.
    Немного затянуто начало повествовния. Лично мне интересно стало часов через 5-6, но рад что перетерпел это время и по итогу насладился интересной историей.
  85. The_BlueRose
    Feb 16, 2019
    9
    Pese a su prácticamente impecable apartado técnico y una gran historia y personajes, esperaba un poco mas de Rockstar en este RDR2, sobre todo en el aspecto jugable y estructura de misiones.

    - La historia esta bastante bien, no llega a los niveles narrativos de The Witcher pero te la crees, al menos en parte. Hay ciertos momentos que pese a estar en cierta medida justificados parecen un    Pese a su prácticamente impecable apartado técnico y una gran historia y personajes, esperaba un poco mas de Rockstar en este RDR2, sobre todo en el aspecto jugable y estructura de misiones.

    - La historia esta bastante bien, no llega a los niveles narrativos de The Witcher pero te la crees, al menos en parte. Hay ciertos momentos que pese a estar en cierta medida justificados parecen un poco artificiales.
    El ejemplo mas claro seria el cambio de mentalidad de Dutch, ¿como puede ser que un lider nato pase de repente a un segundo plano? Me parece bien que se justifique mediante la influencia de Micah para crear una banda "mejor", pero no me creo que tenga peso suficiente para traicionar sus principios y a toda la gente que creyó en el. Se repite mucho la motivación del dinero, que pese a conseguir suculentos botines sigue necesitando más, sin dar ningún motivo real. Ademas es una precuela, ya sabes como va a acabar,

    Eso lleva a otro punto, la economia. De poco sirve entregar pieles si solo haciendo las misiones de historia vas a conseguir tanto dinero que al final no te lo vas ni a gastar todo. Y de este podriamos llegar a la situacion de forajidos que actuan como tal cuando le conviene al juego. Con un sistema de reputacion que no termina de funcionar.

    Arthur es un buen protagonista, pero ni de lejos uno de los mejores que se han hecho. Su estructura se basa en el clásico del chico que no le queda otro camino mas que el de robar. Esto no le hace mala persona "per se" ellos mismos reconocen que pese a ser forajidos "no son ese tipo de gente". Incluso los miembros de la banda hablan con Arthur diciéndole que no es una mala persona. Al final es en el que todos confian y este no les abandona.

    Su arco es bastante simple, cuando todo va bien sigue a Ducht, cuando este empieza a actuar de forma violenta y deja de lado a la banda, Arthur decide tomar su propio camino. Ya sea siendo bueno o malo. En una serie de misiones de reputacion que decidiran si eres buena o mala persona. Lo que hayas hecho antes importa poco vaya...

    - Jugablemente es donde tiene mas carencias: el juego ya es lento de por sí, si le incluimos gunplay realista y una falta importante de movilidad nos queda que en una situacion de tiroteo el jugador va con el pecho al descubierto, cuando seria mas conveniente que al entrar en situaciones de peligro adoptara una posicion mas agachada y menos expuesta a recibir un disparo. Ni las coberturas funcionan tan bien como deberian, funcionan peor que en la primera parte.

    - Ambientacion y apartado tecnico: aqui es donde realmente destaca el titulo. Recrea la naturaleza y la fauna como nunca antes se haya visto, con una distancia de dibujado que cuesta creer. Aqui es donde cazaras, pescaras y te pasearas por las ciudades y sus proximidades. Destacar los bien que estan hechas las tormentas, sobre todo el sonido de los truenos que es de 10.

    - Al final te quedas con el apartado tecnico y la ambientacion, jugablemente podria ser mejor, las misiones podrian estar mejor diseñadas, dando mayor libertad al jugador y la historia pese a ser buena no es de las mejores que he visto le falta profundidad. Es un juego largo y se hace aun mas largo debido a su ritmo lento, que en misiones no termina de cuajar pero cuando quieres pasearte un rato y contemplar el paisaje es fetén    … Expand
  86. DausenMoore
    Nov 18, 2020
    7
    Very overrated. I pre-ordered it for both myself and my brother and neither of us play it. It's more of a cowboy simulator than a game lol. It's very slow and it controls you too much. That fact that you're forced to walk so often, you loot so slow, you can't complete missions in creative ways, etc.

    It's not bad, and graphically it's incredible, but it's simply not very fun.
  87. AHRbro
    Jul 11, 2020
    9
    First of all: If you want this game for the Online or play it as some type of shooter or like fast paced games, don't waste your money and time in this game. You may want to give it a try and that is okay but I warn you this before my actual review.

    On my personal experience I think this game was built with love and dedication. It's pretty good if you like slow paced games. I liked this    First of all: If you want this game for the Online or play it as some type of shooter or like fast paced games, don't waste your money and time in this game. You may want to give it a try and that is okay but I warn you this before my actual review.

    On my personal experience I think this game was built with love and dedication. It's pretty good if you like slow paced games. I liked this game mainly because of the storytelling that works like a movie or a book. The narrative is the strongest pro in this game, but being honest, at some point I got bored between Chapter 1 and 2 but the story and character developments is so well done. Which is why I think it is not perfect.

    The graphics are stunning even playing it in an original Xbox One. The frame rate doesn't look too bad because the worst case scenario would be the game playing at 24-28 fps in the cutscenes which makes it look more like a movie.

    One of the main things that keeps this game from being perfect is Online which is not so compelling or attractive as GTA Online. It may seem boring at times and that is a huge letdown but I feel that Red Dead Online is more of a plus than a main feature of the game.    … Expand
  88. JowDF
    Feb 17, 2019
    10
    História cativante, o melhor protagonista que eu já vi em um jogo, o nível de detalhes é absurdo, os gráficos são lindos. Foram 120 horas de pura imersão em um jogo, excelente recomendo muito!! Parabéns a Rockstar Games por essa obra-prima.
  89. High_Ego
    Oct 31, 2020
    6
    Много насилия, крови. Удалили после ограбление поезда.
  90. Magma17
    Mar 24, 2019
    8
    Red dead redemption 2 sem dúvidas é o maior blockbuster, o jogo mais aguardado da geração, mas, será que cumpriu tudo o que prometeu?
    Red dead redemption 2 não trouxe nada de inovação, é objetivamente o GTA com uma engine melhorada em uma nova ambientação, e ouso dizer que alguns aspectos ainda parecem inferiores.
    É um jogo sem alma, rockstar não foi tão criativa para desenvolver idéias    Red dead redemption 2 sem dúvidas é o maior blockbuster, o jogo mais aguardado da geração, mas, será que cumpriu tudo o que prometeu?
    Red dead redemption 2 não trouxe nada de inovação, é objetivamente o GTA com uma engine melhorada em uma nova ambientação, e ouso dizer que alguns aspectos ainda parecem inferiores.
    É um jogo sem alma, rockstar não foi tão criativa para desenvolver idéias novas para esse título, não tem um desenvolvimento bom na história e sem sistemas que evoluem durante a jogatina, é o mesmo do início ao fim, a justificativa disso, claro, é a falta de liberdade criativa pela proposta da ambientação escolhida;
    >época tediosa, jogo tedioso.
    ''Por que devo continuar?'' eu me pegava o tempo toda fazendo essa pergunta. Como eu não joguei o primeiro, a história pouco me importava e as motivações de conquistas não existiam, tanto em game, tanto fora dele com os sistemas da Xbox live.
    Todo esse lance cinematográfico dos trailers era de fato encantador, mas e na prática?
    Bastava testar e ver, nada funcionava direito, e eu não digo em relação aos bugs, e sim de como o gun fight só é bonito e nada mais, você pode literalmente ir andando em linha reta e matar cada um com um golpe de machado e assim será, sem desafios, sem diversão.
    O que sobra?
    Sim, apenas gráficos e detalhes do ambiente, realmente muito bem construído, é um simulador de screenshots, é a única maneira desse jogo ser minimamente interessante.
    O global illumination, Draw Distance, texturas, são perfeitos.    … Expand
  91. LabiusMaximus
    Mar 6, 2019
    7
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Trivial spoilers only. Hard one to review because some aspects are clearly 9-10 and others 5-6.
    I've waited until I'm about 85% through the main quest to feel confident enough to give an opinion.
    I've played games since the mid 80s and was looking forward to this one for many years.
    An overall score of 7.5 is what I was thinking and that is the about the average score here.

    The 2nd RDR takes a darker turn in the series, noir at times. You are definitely a bad guy (who does some fishing on the side). Some of the consequences of your evil ways punctuate a general trend of failing to get "the big one" score, your team winnowed through attrition, betrayal and a feeling time is running out. You might think this storyline would be ripe for an atmosphere of tension (so necessary for the reward of relief or success), but it just fizzles out.

    This is part of a general feeling of a lack of reward in the game, which is a central aspect of gaming entertainment and psychology. (There are some real high points early on, however).
    It also lacks the irreverent humor of the 1st Red Read (eg the "films" aren't as funny, no calls such as "what have you been eatin'! or the actually funny side quests such as "flowers for a lady"). Some interactive elements (button sequences or mashing, common in the earlier Walking Dead series) seem dated and mechanistic, begging for a puzzle. The gambling side games aren't bad, but max bet is $5. That is tough when you have a 1000+ in the kitty. Again, the option for reward is limited. As said by others, you can put away a load of money, but there is not much to spend it on, so thousands end up with nowhere to go.

    SJW infused themes are unfortunately present. First, the mandatory head nod to diversity - you have a mixed black Indian, also a Hispanic in your team, the remaining white males diluted down with various women. That is in contrast to what the real mix would have looked like in the late 19th C.

    I was surprised to see blacks in the area that seems like a take on a mountain town in the north.
    Boilerplate modern media/college conceptions of racism appear in the southern area and of course it is one way street of white on black, (as per the doctrine, though so contrasting to the actual direction of discrimination and violence nowadays).

    Only one bad black guy (a bad debtor) appears as a side quest versus manifold white ones. There is also a "special person" in your crew, an unscrupulous loan/card shark. He gets off lightly. Even still, usgamer has a hit piece crying antishemitizm tropes, with the obligatory hollowcost reference. Such are the offended times we live in.
    You of course are not racist at all, just a mere mass murdering felon, which is a type of criminal lower down on the SJW totem pole than utterer of racial epithets.

    There is an absurd SJW moral moment in which you sally forth with the black Indian mesitzo to deal with some sickos who shoot bison for fun, instead of just to eat. So, of course, you murder them and social justice is served. To cap it off, at any time in the game, you can at will go shooting for shytz and giggles. That gets me thinking, has anyone tried to run down and dynamite a rabbit or coyote?

    The main story itself opens strongly then plateaus, with the odd high point, such as a bank heist, but a huge number of filler-like sequential gunfights in the middle of the game become boring through repetition and the story thusly disengaging. It is a chore at 85% completion. That said, the game is not short and it took couple of weeks of solid play and exploration to get to this point.

    The voice acting is generally of a good standard, though that of Dutch seems increasingly weak, annoying and melodramatic as the game progresses. Maybe this was intended. I swear its a fat guy doing it.

    Outstanding graphics, about a 9 and some aspects a 10. Truly beautiful at times.

    The background music is professionally engineered and contributory to immersion. Negro spirituals add a certain mood, but are disproportionate to the times and gringo folky tunes would be more apt (first such one encountered around 80% of the way through the main story).

    The design and faults in the control system detract significantly from the game, otherwise overall the game would be hard to rate under 8. The inventory wheel interferes way too much to feel properly "in the game". Often you can't take the weapons you intend to into a fight, you get the wrong one (eg varmint rifle in a shootout!, or the games overrides your choices).

    Movement is clunky and a bit buggy at times, such as getting stuck (not common), but not uncommonly comes a need to hover a number of times to correctly loot a body or cabinet.

    Despite all the carping, playing such a long game to 85% percent completion is itself an indicator of a pretty good game, which this assuredly is, but it is well short of a 10. It probably remains the best of close to best of 2018 in a sea of mediocre titles    … Expand
  92. Firepistol95
    Nov 24, 2018
    9
    Quick fire review:
    The graphics are great with such realism and detail tht is optimized for such weak hardware in todays age. So im impressed with very lil pop in tht I noticed in my playtime. Only graphical issue I noticed was shadow detail distance as ur moving about the world but its not obvious to the point of annoyance.
    The audio is beautiful and very immersive. Music choice is    Quick fire review:
    The graphics are great with such realism and detail tht is optimized for such weak hardware in todays age. So im impressed with very lil pop in tht I noticed in my playtime. Only graphical issue I noticed was shadow detail distance as ur moving about the world but its not obvious to the point of annoyance.

    The audio is beautiful and very immersive. Music choice is good, gun sounds are nice and meaty, movement, etc, etc sounds are really good.

    Story is pretty good, it reminds me of old 70s and older Western films where it concentrated on slow build up of characters, setting and scenes. Now honestly I find tht quite boring if it were a film, mostly bc of me being born in this modern time of speed, in entertainment.

    Gameplay is pretty slow, methodical and gunplay feels about almost the same as the 1st Redemption. Most of the ppl tht dont like the gameplay are just too used to fast-paced arcadey gameplay nowadays and consider this more slowpaced gameplay to "intentionally avoid the QoL of todays gaming", when tht is simply not the case. (albeit a few weird command placements on the controller) Now im not saying tht invalidates ppls criticism but it does show tht its just not the game for them. (or shuld I say dont hav the patience of learning something this complex for controller input, which is understandable) The gameplay u can get used to and it can feel a bit stiff but its still nonetheless enjoyable if ppl dont mind or enjoy the more slow, detailed gameplay.

    Edit: Forgot to mention tht it certainly isnt the best game of the year or generation. (it was overhyped) But its still definitely a solid game, from my exp and only had a few small frustrations with it.
    Not much in terms of replay value also. (grant it I dont replay many Open World games anyways, no matter how good they are)    … Expand
  93. eva3si0n
    Apr 22, 2019
    10
    Unambiguously the best game of 2018. On a game at me almost 6 months left, already painfully there was no wish to pass it all at once. And so a game very much approaches under quiet passing, it does not hurry anywhere. It is felt in everything, beginning from gay being thrilled and finishing with a plot. As for a plot - it departs from canons of Rockstar Games here. The excellent beginningUnambiguously the best game of 2018. On a game at me almost 6 months left, already painfully there was no wish to pass it all at once. And so a game very much approaches under quiet passing, it does not hurry anywhere. It is felt in everything, beginning from gay being thrilled and finishing with a plot. As for a plot - it departs from canons of Rockstar Games here. The excellent beginning and the end of the game was very frequent in their previous games, and here the middle strongly sank in respect of direction, most was also with Red Dead Redmption of 2010. In the second part a plot uniform. Graphics on Xbox One X is amazing, it is possible to carp of course at artificial HDR, but the fact that a game goes to the native 4K most part of time laudable. In general RDR2 a bright indicator that video games not just a part of the modern art, and it is rather an a leader of the industry. RDR2 looks much better than the majority of movies of a genre a western. And the most important RDR2 it is made as it is should for the mass player in difference from GTA. Here 50% of time - riding a horse and what description of the real life it are. Artur the most ordinary person. The epilog very competently underlines that the sense of a game is simple and it is not necessary to show any great things or acts of heroes to make the best game of the current generation of consoles. It is possible to refer to minuses only management. It here з and just stronger reduces the rate of a game. 10 of 10, the best game of the last 5 years. Such strong emotions for the last 5-6 years gave me earlier only Uncharted 4 and TLOU.… Expand
  94. AliHakami
    Aug 11, 2020
    9
    .............loooooooooooooooool.........................................................
  95. Dragonfly44
    Dec 10, 2018
    8
    Spectacular story. Amazing graphics. Good sountrack, but the rest doesn’t realyl fall into place all that well. My experience with the game - although i haven’t really heard the same about it - has been mostly dissapointing. Too often it takes a ridiculous amount of time to load and once or twice the frame rate has dropped insidiously low for a more than a minute. I want to love this gameSpectacular story. Amazing graphics. Good sountrack, but the rest doesn’t realyl fall into place all that well. My experience with the game - although i haven’t really heard the same about it - has been mostly dissapointing. Too often it takes a ridiculous amount of time to load and once or twice the frame rate has dropped insidiously low for a more than a minute. I want to love this game but its really hard to do so. Rating - 83%… Expand
  96. Armywild
    Dec 9, 2018
    8
    MEXICO, gamertag ALFONSPARTAN: +Mi calificacion es solo para el modo campaña, despues de jugar unas cuantas horas y pasar los dos primeros capitulos, puedl comentar que es asombroso. Las mecanicas de juego e interaccion con el entorno, son muy buenas, es normal existan algunas pequeñas fallas en la IA , pero vamos, es un juegazo muy bien ambientado del viejo oeste. Sin duda es un juego queMEXICO, gamertag ALFONSPARTAN: +Mi calificacion es solo para el modo campaña, despues de jugar unas cuantas horas y pasar los dos primeros capitulos, puedl comentar que es asombroso. Las mecanicas de juego e interaccion con el entorno, son muy buenas, es normal existan algunas pequeñas fallas en la IA , pero vamos, es un juegazo muy bien ambientado del viejo oeste. Sin duda es un juego que debe tenerse en la coleccion. Rockstar lo ha hecho de nuevo. Actualizare mi calificacion promedio al jugar al online, que al ver los demas comentarios, tambien esta para mejorar pero esta a la altura del juego.… Expand
  97. KasaethaN
    Jun 30, 2020
    10
    People usually don't understand this game. This is not a game to finish in a couple of weeks, it can take months. Take your time, explore, do the challenges, find the treasures and secrets... you can spend hours just fishing legendary fish. It is a game to be along with for a long time and enjoy it throughout. Amazing masterpiece.
  98. FEARLESSSSSSSSS
    Mar 12, 2019
    10
    Ещё один шедевр в копилку Рокстар.
    Красный Мертвый Выкуп 2 постепенно начинает набирать обороты в красоте и эпичности миссий. Красивые пейзажы, интересные побочные миссии и конечно же ограбления банков присутствуют.
    Играть обязательно!    Ещё один шедевр в копилку Рокстар.
    Красный Мертвый Выкуп 2 постепенно начинает набирать обороты в красоте и эпичности миссий. Красивые пейзажы, интересные побочные миссии и конечно же ограбления банков присутствуют.
    Играть обязательно!
  99. Spoarmach
    Jun 29, 2020
    10
    While it has some notable but minor flaws, it's hard to argue that Red Dead Redemption 2 is not a masterpiece. The end result of the meticulous detail, wonderful writing and stunning looks is an open world that sets a new bar for believability, and a time and place I can't stop thinking about or wanting to be a part of.
  100. zwireqq
    Oct 31, 2020
    5
    After 3 tries to finish this game I quit. I quit saying to myself this game is something extraordinary and worth finishing.
    This beautiful yet boring game Is nothing really revolutionary. Stale, repetitive missions, weak, spaghetti like main plot, dull characters and clunky rockstarlike gun play and controls.
    I'm really disappointed because visually this game is stunning but just bad    After 3 tries to finish this game I quit. I quit saying to myself this game is something extraordinary and worth finishing.
    This beautiful yet boring game Is nothing really revolutionary. Stale, repetitive missions, weak, spaghetti like main plot, dull characters and clunky rockstarlike gun play and controls.
    I'm really disappointed because visually this game is stunning but just bad experience with everything else aside visuals make me dont want to play it instantly.    … Expand
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best Xbox One Game of 2018
1
#1 Most Discussed Xbox One Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Shared Xbox One Game of 2018

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
97

Universal acclaim - based on 33 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 33 out of 33
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 33
  3. Negative: 0 out of 33
  1. Official Xbox Magazine UK
    Dec 18, 2018
    100
    Unquestionably 2018's best game, and an all-time open-world masterpiece. [Christmas 2018, p.89]
  2. BaziCenter
    Nov 2, 2018
    100
    It doesn’t matter if you are gamer, a human being, or an alien from another planet; Red Dead Redemption 2 is a title that you just can’t miss. The bar set by RDR2 is so high that even Rockstar itself will probably have a hard time raising it. One of the best releases in the history of digital entertainment.
    Read full review
  3. The Sydney Morning Herald
    Oct 29, 2018
    90
    While it has some notable but minor flaws, it's hard to argue that Red Dead Redemption 2 is not a masterpiece. The end result of the meticulous detail, wonderful writing and stunning looks is an open world that sets a new bar for believability, and a time and place I can't stop thinking about or wanting to be a part of.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »