User Score
7.8

Generally favorable reviews- based on 2739 Ratings

User score distribution:
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
  1. Mar 6, 2018
    10
    I can proudly say that I picked this up back in the PS2 days without any idea what this game was. Sat down with my girlfriend at that time and we were kind of clueless and lost - "what the hell are we supposed to do? We just wander around?". But the game was haunting, beautiful; the loneliness and the mystery made us want to remain there, in that old, forgotten, almost abandoned realm.I can proudly say that I picked this up back in the PS2 days without any idea what this game was. Sat down with my girlfriend at that time and we were kind of clueless and lost - "what the hell are we supposed to do? We just wander around?". But the game was haunting, beautiful; the loneliness and the mystery made us want to remain there, in that old, forgotten, almost abandoned realm.

    And then we found the first "giant". Or boss. Or colossus. "What the hell? Do we attack its feet?", we asked each other, while nothing seemed to happen. "Try hitting it with arrows", she said. Nothing. "What the hell are we supposed to do... climb it or something?".

    And then that was it. We were in love with that game, forever. "No way! No way!!!". We realized: the BOSS WAS THE PUZZLE. And that was it. Finding it, learning about it, outsmarting it, climbing it, finding its weak spots, killing it.

    I remember how mesmerized and shocked and amazed we were. Games were NEVER like that. We knew we had something different, so different, in our hands. And that was "Shadow of the Colossus", a timeless, unforgettable tale.

    Once it was released in the PS3 I played it again - loved and enjoyed every second of it - even though I pretty much knew everything I had to do. The game was incredible, still was. Modern, bold, fresh, perfect.

    And then... came this remake. My eyes could not believe the first trailers, once it was announced at E3. It was hard to believe, it was unreal. They were remaking this game... and what a beauty this is. The PS4 version is probably closer to Fumito Ueda's ideal version of it, since the systems back then were so limited. And I was thrilled to see that it was exactly the same game, just bigger, better, sharper, more beautiful, more haunting. But that loneliness, that solitude, that mysterious sense of visiting an abandoned realm was still there, just as I remembered. And what a joy it was to be back.

    This is one of those games that I wanted to get 2 copies. One to open and play exhaustively. Another to frame and hang in the wall. This is a masterpiece.
    Expand
  2. Mar 23, 2018
    10
    I'm not sure how many people really asked for this. I bet we all would've been fine with another HD port, but now that it's all said and done, Shadow of the Colossus Remastered is pretty damn stellar. It adds just enough to feel fresh but doesn't overstep any nostalgic boundaries. It's basically what all video game remasters should strive to be.

    The updated control scheme is probably
    I'm not sure how many people really asked for this. I bet we all would've been fine with another HD port, but now that it's all said and done, Shadow of the Colossus Remastered is pretty damn stellar. It adds just enough to feel fresh but doesn't overstep any nostalgic boundaries. It's basically what all video game remasters should strive to be.

    The updated control scheme is probably the only thing that kind of irked me, but I don't honestly see it as a bad thing. They're definitely more modernized (X is jump instead of Triangle, for example). Regardless, I prefer the original control scheme - and they tossed in the option to change either back to the original set-up OR go with a pseudo-updated set-up that's mostly the same except the roll command is mapped to Circle (whereas before it was R1+Circle). Genius.
    Expand
  3. Mar 5, 2018
    10
    To this day, no game has come anywhere close to dethroning SotC as my favorite game of all time. It has its flaws, like everything else in our vast universe, but as a total package—the awe-inspiring sense of scale, the crushing loneliness that hangs over every inch of the Forbidden Lands, the captivating yet minimalistic narrative style, the morally questionable actions of the protagonist,To this day, no game has come anywhere close to dethroning SotC as my favorite game of all time. It has its flaws, like everything else in our vast universe, but as a total package—the awe-inspiring sense of scale, the crushing loneliness that hangs over every inch of the Forbidden Lands, the captivating yet minimalistic narrative style, the morally questionable actions of the protagonist, the sheer artistic majesty—nothing compares to SotC, and I doubt anything ever will...in my lifetime, at least.

    A true classic, that can stand beside the great masterpieces from any medium (not just video games) or any era.

    The GOAT is reborn.
    Expand
  4. Jan 4, 2019
    10
    When this came out originally on the PS2 it blew me away. I considered it to be The Greatest Game Of All Time. Its elegant simplicity, incredible visuals and soundtrack and huge emotional impact left an indelible mark on me. I was so excited upon hearing it was being remastered for the PS4, and what a job they did. It's not for everyone- I daresay many would find it cumbersome and boring,When this came out originally on the PS2 it blew me away. I considered it to be The Greatest Game Of All Time. Its elegant simplicity, incredible visuals and soundtrack and huge emotional impact left an indelible mark on me. I was so excited upon hearing it was being remastered for the PS4, and what a job they did. It's not for everyone- I daresay many would find it cumbersome and boring, but for the rest of us, this is what a masterpiece looks like. Easiest 10/10 ever. Expand
  5. Feb 27, 2018
    10
    those dont like this game must be the ones like to fight minions a lot before the big boss. this game better than all zelda games combined.
  6. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    A masterpiece reborn

    Ever since i heard shadow of The colossus was getting a remake i was overjoyed. I've played it on ps2, loved the remaster and now im able to play the remake of one the best action titles ever created. I couldn't be happier that this remake happened.The graphics, sound,  everything has been remade running on a brand new game engine entirely. The colosi and
    A masterpiece reborn

    Ever since i heard shadow of The colossus was getting a remake i was overjoyed. I've played it on ps2, loved the remaster and now im able to play the remake of one the best action titles ever created. I couldn't be happier that this remake happened.The graphics, sound,  everything has been remade running on a brand new game engine entirely. The colosi and environments have been overloaded with amazing detail and the world feels very alive despite the quieting emptiness of it. With detailed texture work and lighting this game looks absolutely gorgeous. It's also butter smooth hardly ever dropping frames even when giant colossi are thrashing about. The story has been left untouched retaining the same emotional journey the original offered. No new colosi or extra story but Everything else however has been improved to the MAX. Bluepoint games did a phenomenal job of remaking this classic. ID even go as far to say this surpasses the original and is one of if not the best game remakes ever created. A masterpiece has been made even better i can't wait to see what bluepoint games does next. Absolutely incredible job. 10/10
    Expand
  7. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    This is an excellent port of an already great game. It comes with small improvements in the gameplay area that don't let us forget that success has to be earned but ultimately make the game more playable. The graphics are just beyond amazing. This is exactly how Shadow is supposed to look. There is no excuse anymore, this modern classic needs to be experienced by everyone.
  8. Feb 20, 2022
    10
    Practically a 1:1 copy of the original in a fresh sheen. BluePoint's remake magic could never get a better display.
  9. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    What can i say that everyone has not said already. This game is beyond amazing and is a timeless classic.
  10. Sep 11, 2018
    10
    9.5/10

    I couldn't play the original on PS2 as the camera was infuriatingly impossible to control but glad I revisited this game the developer Bluepoint has refined and polished it to a fine tee. Closest you're likely to get to Zelda-esque title on PS4, so satisfying to take down this huge scale Colossi and the musical score to accompany it is just breathtaking at times.

    A true masterpiece.
  11. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    One of the besy remakes of the last years!!
    Technically perfect and sublime
    Bluepoint games are a the best remake studio in the world!!
  12. Mar 28, 2018
    10
    +Hauntingly beautiful
    +Fantastic soundtrack
    +Purest sense of adventure +SOC's use of scope and scale is wonderous +Bluepoint have set the new standard for a videogame remake -Controls are clunky at times -No hand holding so objective not always clear! I had just brought my 4ktv and this was the first game I tried and in resolution mode the visuals were most impressive. HDR
    +Hauntingly beautiful
    +Fantastic soundtrack
    +Purest sense of adventure
    +SOC's use of scope and scale is wonderous
    +Bluepoint have set the new standard for a videogame remake
    -Controls are clunky at times
    -No hand holding so objective not always clear!

    I had just brought my 4ktv and this was the first game I tried and in resolution mode the visuals were most impressive. HDR highlights the wonderous haunted land accentuating the beauty in the art design. Having only played the original once round a friends on his ps2 years ago I kind of knew what to expect going in, but the experience simply blew me away on my ps4 pro.

    According to that same friend this is an accurate remake and nothing new has been added only a visual upgrade so in that regard the game has aged well in my opinion. If you are a fan of adventure games zelda etc and own ps4 then this game is essential for your collection. I kept thinking of films like Legend, Princess Mononoke and Labyrinth as I played through.
    Expand
  13. Nov 22, 2020
    10
    Not sure what the mixed scores are all about. This game is perfection in every possible way.

    Lots of people criticising the controls. Others say the story is shallow. I say poppycock. The story is precisely what it should be: a simple plot, told in the best possible way and almost without words, purely with the emotions of the player. The controls take some time getting used to, but
    Not sure what the mixed scores are all about. This game is perfection in every possible way.

    Lots of people criticising the controls. Others say the story is shallow. I say poppycock. The story is precisely what it should be: a simple plot, told in the best possible way and almost without words, purely with the emotions of the player.

    The controls take some time getting used to, but are far from the mess some of these reviews are making them out to be.

    Every 5-ish years a game comes along that might just alter your view on video games as a whole. This is one of those games. How many others even have this potential?

    Don't pass up on this.
    Expand
  14. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    Easily one of the greatest games of all time. So glad to see it in the gorgeous HD it deserves. A remaster done right. My only wish is for it to be on PC as well but beggars cant be choosers.
  15. PSz
    Feb 6, 2018
    10
    Expect this to be flooded with purist trolls that wiil make companies question if there's a reason to make remakes. THANK YOU HARDCORE GAMER NECKBEARS
  16. Feb 15, 2018
    10
    One of the best games ever made..

    Truly a work of art, the music the atmosphere and story is just incredibly well done..

    Credit to Bluepoint games for making an already timeless masterpiece get the makeover it deserves.

    10/10
  17. Dec 13, 2019
    10
    Oustanding remake of one of the best videogames ever made. Simple mechanics for the art of wonder and emotion.
  18. Feb 10, 2018
    10
    Легендарный ремейк легендарной игры. Для тех кто играл - комментарии излишни, для тех кто не играл - обязательно попробуйте.
  19. Jun 17, 2018
    10
    The original version of the game was a bit wonky, and the motion blur killed my eyes. But this remake completely fixed all of that, and now Shadow of The Colossus has become one of my favorite games of all time. Every boss is memorable and extremely sad to take down. The story was engaging and heartbreaking, and the game sounds and looks incredible. Plus the atmosphere felt so alone andThe original version of the game was a bit wonky, and the motion blur killed my eyes. But this remake completely fixed all of that, and now Shadow of The Colossus has become one of my favorite games of all time. Every boss is memorable and extremely sad to take down. The story was engaging and heartbreaking, and the game sounds and looks incredible. Plus the atmosphere felt so alone and sad, and the music is some of the best I have heard in a video game. Expand
  20. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    With Nintendo Switch Ports (which is basically all the Switch is) you pay SIXTY DOLLARS, you get a game that can barely break 720p on a cheap overpriced screen. For FORTY dollars you can get a game completely overhauled for a new generation at the reasonable price of $40.
  21. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    A timeless classic if you never played this game you owe it to yourself and if you alredy played it there is enough in this remake to fall in love all over again.
  22. Feb 9, 2018
    10
    This is the way a remaster should be done. Still one of the best and influent games in history. Now this PS4 is without doubt the best way to play this master piece.
  23. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    I haven't beat yet. it looks fantastic, one of the greatest games ever made!

    Haters go back to your Cross boxes, and dwitche pieces of plastic.. leave PS awesome games alone!
  24. Nov 9, 2022
    10
    Wasn’t going to write a review for this but never in my entire life have I seen an audience get something all so very very wrong. What am I reading and seeing here? Never have I been more disappointed in humanity than I am right now seeing all those red reviews.

    This is the greatest damn video game ever crafted with haunting themes of loss and despair. I think many people just do not have
    Wasn’t going to write a review for this but never in my entire life have I seen an audience get something all so very very wrong. What am I reading and seeing here? Never have I been more disappointed in humanity than I am right now seeing all those red reviews.

    This is the greatest damn video game ever crafted with haunting themes of loss and despair. I think many people just do not have the deep sensitivity required in order to truly appreciate the power and haunting beauty of this game. I almost do not even want to call it a game. It’s beyond that when something is able to make you feel so deeply. I cried in the end…most of these people will never be able to possess the ability to feel what the character in this game is feeling. The desire, the determination that no matter what the cost….he’d do anything necessary to bring the love of his life back from the dead.

    I will say this…the critics here are the correct ones. And thank the heavens for that. If I listened to all the idiots here I’d miss out on the greatest cinematic masterpiece I have ever experienced. And I’ve platinumed this game. I’ve spent 120 hours on it according to my ps5. It’s my most beloved and cherished video game of all time. I bought two physical special editions of the game. One for myself and my brother. This is how much this video game means to me.

    The critics didn’t review this game for the average moron that’s out there. Of course they knew most people wouldn’t understand this masterpiece. This game is made for people such as myself who admire the finer things life has to offer. Someone that smells the roses while going for walks. Admires beautiful sunsets. Listens to the birds as they fly over cascading waterfalls…..the critics reviewed this game based on what Fumito Ueda envisioned this game to be. The loneliness, the despair, the way the horse handles….every little damn detail in this game is exactly how it was intended to be. It’s not supposed to be easy to climb those colossal beasts…it’s supposed to be an agonizing task in which when you succeed you feel as if you have conquered the world.

    I’m glad the critics see this game for what it truly is. Shame on all those bad reviews but I’ve always knew this to be true. Most people on this planet are not exactly spiritual and introspective people.
    It’d be like trying to show someone with a bery corrupt mentality and view of nature why the waterfall is so beautiful and they’ll just say…but it’s just a waterfall. You either see it or you don’t. You either believe it or you don’t. I for one, am happy to say that I see what the critics see. People are going to talk to me about awful controls? Seriously? The horse controls as if I’m actually riding an actual horse. It feels like he is a separate entity to the main character and feels like it has a mind of its own. You really have to command him to stop. The horse honestly controls itself and moves freely through the corridors without much need for player control. People are just clueless or upset that this game was praised so much and rightfully so. I had no problems navigating through the game but then again this game is my cup of tea…I hate shooters and nonsensical stupid games. I like contemplative experiences like this where you just navigate through the environment without anyone holding your hand.

    This is perhaps the most misunderstood product of all time. People are just not used to this kind of game and are gonna bash something they don’t like because it’s not their conventional Zelda like game.

    This game is REAL. The creator wanted you to feel every breath of wind and every blade of grass. He wanted you to be in the footsteps of wander and boy, the final 10 minutes are some of the most emotional moments I have ever witness in a gamer.
    Expand
  25. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    Shadow of the Colossus is a masterpiece. Completely original. Artisitically perfect. Emotional. Even without the incredibly satisfying, creative, and enjoyable battles, the experience of just running around the atmospheric world on the horse is heart-swelling. I wish I could go there. The only fault is sometimes clumsy and frustrating horse controls, but even then it's for the sake ofShadow of the Colossus is a masterpiece. Completely original. Artisitically perfect. Emotional. Even without the incredibly satisfying, creative, and enjoyable battles, the experience of just running around the atmospheric world on the horse is heart-swelling. I wish I could go there. The only fault is sometimes clumsy and frustrating horse controls, but even then it's for the sake of realistic feel. Playing this beautiful game has enriched my life. I wish I could personally thank the developers. Expand
  26. Feb 17, 2019
    10
    Gameplay/Mechanics: 10
    Sound/Music: 10
    Graphics/Art: 10
    Story/Atmosphere: 10
    OVERALL: 10/10 Shadow of the Colossus is a masterpiece. One of the greats.
  27. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    It’s amazing, I played this game a first time in my life... How I can miss this game early??! Great atmosphere, great feelings of giant colosses, music, light.. Great remaster! Thank You Sony, Thank You Blue Point!!!
  28. Apr 2, 2019
    10
    You know metacritic, with this random REVIEWBOMBING, the Userscores become meaningless!!Do you care??
  29. Feb 28, 2018
    10
    Shadow of the Colossus is phenomenal; the graphics and environments are stunning, the music is beautiful, and the colossi/boss fights are massive in scale and epic. It is a simplistic open world game, with little to no dialogue and very basic core mechanics. But it is an intriguing world and atmosphere that separates this game from the rest.
  30. Feb 8, 2018
    10
    Yes; the game is short and can and will be passed by a veteran in less than 6 hours.
    Yes; it does have a lot more style than substance when compared to most any game nowadays.
    Yes; the controls suck pretty bad. But when you get past the first colossus or two and you get into the rhythm of things Shadow of the Colossus is one of the most memorable games to come out in the last 20
    Yes; the game is short and can and will be passed by a veteran in less than 6 hours.
    Yes; it does have a lot more style than substance when compared to most any game nowadays.
    Yes; the controls suck pretty bad.

    But when you get past the first colossus or two and you get into the rhythm of things Shadow of the Colossus is one of the most memorable games to come out in the last 20 years; every person who has played the game will have their favorite colossus and will carry their memories for years to come. And after two prior attempts at making this playable on previous systems (and almost succeeding on the ps3), this has got to be the definite version as it removes minor inconveniences that would annoy most any player, and adds extra tidbits for anybody wanting to spend more time with it.
    And most importantly... It actually runs at a stable framerate for once (not necessarily 1080p 60fps but it is very playable at 30 fps as it used to run at 18 fps on its original release in 2005)
    Expand
  31. Aug 4, 2021
    10
    Solid 9.5

    This is a unique game, it has a lot of soul in it, maybe the new generation won't understand it.
  32. Mar 20, 2018
    10
    As a first time player who has wanted to play this game for a long time, but just didn't know about it in the peak of the PS2 era, I just have to say. Wow. The game was short but not too short and did not overstay its welcome, I think it's the perfect length for the story it was trying to tell and the gameplay elements that they had. The visuals are amazing, as they were in the day, theyAs a first time player who has wanted to play this game for a long time, but just didn't know about it in the peak of the PS2 era, I just have to say. Wow. The game was short but not too short and did not overstay its welcome, I think it's the perfect length for the story it was trying to tell and the gameplay elements that they had. The visuals are amazing, as they were in the day, they have been given a full remake in order to do it justice in 2018 and it works. I loved the weird more cinematic camera angles that show off the landscape of this beautiful came, and there is an extreme amount of personality in the characters, despite little dialogue and showing of a lot of them. Actions speak leagues more than words.

    I don't want to spoil anything about the story, but just know it's good - its very very good, the more you think about it afterwards, the better it gets. Definitely get this game if you haven't played it yet. Also I really want an Ico remaster now.
    Expand
  33. Feb 9, 2018
    10
    Muito emocionante. Não parece um remaster e sim um jogo novo. Infelizmente não se faz jogos como antigamente.
  34. Feb 9, 2018
    10
    All these jealous Xbox fan boys rating this game a 1 or 0 need to have their reviews removed. The empty world adds to the powerful story this game paints. It is a beautiful and powerful journey and Bluepoint did an incredible job remaking the game without messing with the wild, more realistic controls ...I mean do people honestly expect you to move gracefully while climbing a 200 footAll these jealous Xbox fan boys rating this game a 1 or 0 need to have their reviews removed. The empty world adds to the powerful story this game paints. It is a beautiful and powerful journey and Bluepoint did an incredible job remaking the game without messing with the wild, more realistic controls ...I mean do people honestly expect you to move gracefully while climbing a 200 foot tall colossi that is moving. The imperfections are part of what is so appealing and the fact that is not like any other game, but I guess the people that don't like that are just happy paying $60 for the same COD game every year Expand
  35. Oct 27, 2018
    10
    кокаето гавно гавниной пахнет мелкий малолетний дебил лезет ну куда ты лезеш
  36. Jun 4, 2020
    10
    Best thing about this version of the game is there in run at 60 frames per second on PS4 Pro And the climbing mechanics have been improved, If you have not played the original then play this and after that buy a PS3 and Try out ICO
  37. Jul 13, 2021
    10
    Shadow of the colossus is a remaster of the Ps2 classic, it is without a doubt an incredible experience but in its own time the game comes with a graphical update that makes it very pleasant especially the big scenes with detailed constructions.

    However, when it comes to the gameplay it remains simple and it serves well the idea of ​​playing with a weak character in the face of its
    Shadow of the colossus is a remaster of the Ps2 classic, it is without a doubt an incredible experience but in its own time the game comes with a graphical update that makes it very pleasant especially the big scenes with detailed constructions.

    However, when it comes to the gameplay it remains simple and it serves well the idea of ​​playing with a weak character in the face of its challenges, as the controversial camera continues to have a lot of difficulty in showing the combat against colossal beings without being impossible to understand what is happening sometimes.

    Going straight to the point, there weren't any major mechanical advances in this new version of the game however if you're a fan of the original it won't matter, as what makes Shadow of the colossus unique is its incredible narrative that guides you through its contemplative scenarios and memorable songs in unique combats where the combination of these elements makes each event unique.

    If you are an old fan of the franchise this game is mandatory, however if this is your first experience, I recommend caution do not expect a big open world with thousands of side quests or something like that, but a remarkable narrative experience where not everything will be played in your face in cutscene.
    Expand
  38. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    Honestly, this is the perfect remaster. It looks amazing while feeling exactly the same as it did with a dualshock 2 in my 13 year old hands. All the visual upgrades are just outstanding (PS4 pro). The music is still phenomenal. And battling the colossi all over again makes me just as giddy as it did when I was a kid. I think it's a tad overpriced for what it is, especially as there was anHonestly, this is the perfect remaster. It looks amazing while feeling exactly the same as it did with a dualshock 2 in my 13 year old hands. All the visual upgrades are just outstanding (PS4 pro). The music is still phenomenal. And battling the colossi all over again makes me just as giddy as it did when I was a kid. I think it's a tad overpriced for what it is, especially as there was an HD upgrade on the PS3. Can we get an Ico remaster please? Expand
  39. Feb 20, 2022
    10
    Spread the message of communism by slaying the monopolistic ancients that have cursed the land
  40. Mar 18, 2018
    10
    I remember fellow gamers trying to convince me to play this game when it originally released on PS2 but at the time I was too focused on other games. Just over a decade later I've found they were absolutely right, this is a masterpiece.a fairytale-like story, with an amazing ending that is heartbreaking and beautiful. Plus now it's one of the best looking games on the PlayStation 4. A MUST HAVE.
  41. Feb 10, 2018
    10
    I just don't know if kids who were born when the original PS2 version came out 13 years ago would love this or hate it. It is technically an open world game, but the world is small and picturesque, and there is nothing but the core concept at work: use your sword and bow to kill 16 gigantic monster bosses. Other than tracking down and eliminating these beasts, which are platforming puzzlesI just don't know if kids who were born when the original PS2 version came out 13 years ago would love this or hate it. It is technically an open world game, but the world is small and picturesque, and there is nothing but the core concept at work: use your sword and bow to kill 16 gigantic monster bosses. Other than tracking down and eliminating these beasts, which are platforming puzzles unto themselves, there are no side missions, no XP, no skill tree, no NPCs to talk to, no crafting, no weapon mods...hell, there are no smaller enemies to dispatch as you traverse the beautiful landscape. The experience is lush in atmosphere and intrigue (not to mention graphics and audio) but minimalist in pretty much every other regard and hearkens back to the end of a simpler digital entertainment era where you got the whole game, up front, on the disc...and the experience was complete, polished, and innovative. I only had to play an hour to know that the rest of this game is amazing because I had the PS2 version, which I also loved, and the people who made this must've loved the 2005 original as well. One of my great shames in gaming history is reaching the last colossus in the PS2 version but never beating it. I did buy the PS3 version, which is a simple upscale/remaster job (and included ICO) but didn't have time for it when so much good current-gen stuff was coming out. But after encountering, and besting, the first monster in this newly built PS4 remake (just the same way I beat him 13 years ago on my old CRT TV), I was smiling uncontrollably. I'm playing on a stock PS4 and the graphics are amazing, the frame rate is buttery smooth, and the main character no longer feels heavy and sluggish, straining against the constraints of old hardware. Will the CoD/2K/GTA/PUBG kids get it? I don't know, but I hope they do give this a try, because it's still a piece of unique, essential gaming. Expand
  42. Jan 29, 2019
    10
    Gameplay : 10 (No enemy except bosses, and bosses are coolest things in whole universe :))
    Story : 10 ( Team ICO )
    Art : 10 ( Team ICO )

    Best game of all times tied with the witcher 3.
  43. May 16, 2018
    10
    I really loved the PS2 original and subsequent PS3 HD remaster. I consider SOTC to be a gaming classic. At the time I really loved the art, emotionally evoking story and feel to the world. I had mixed feelings about a remake on first hearing of its release. I didn't want it to be a sacrilegious, messed around with, poorly done caricature of my beloved game.

    This game is certainly not
    I really loved the PS2 original and subsequent PS3 HD remaster. I consider SOTC to be a gaming classic. At the time I really loved the art, emotionally evoking story and feel to the world. I had mixed feelings about a remake on first hearing of its release. I didn't want it to be a sacrilegious, messed around with, poorly done caricature of my beloved game.

    This game is certainly not that. It delivers a truly beautiful version, especially in 4k HDR. The game is just spectacular to look at and the game-play of the original is completely intact and unadulterated. The controls are perfectly fine as far as I'm concerned, but will probably need some getting used to for newcomers. I've tried all the new control options and they all seem to work fine to me, both old style and modern. If you've never played this game, absolutely do not let the criticism aimed at the control system put you off! Yes, they're slightly fiddly, but not at all a problem once familiarised. The incredible original soundtrack is as per the original, which certainly needs no improving.The new photo mode option is a great distraction and a welcome addition.

    I don't think there is anything lacking at all in this version whatsoever, in fact it's been great playing it again and has deepened my appreciation considerably. The game plays at a relaxing pace most of the time and I find the best way to play it is to just explore and take your time enjoying the atmosphere and amazing scenery and vistas. I find it very relaxing to play and it helps me unwind. Playing it again has made me realise how unique the game is, particularly in the modern gaming climate of fast paced action/ FPS type games, driving sims etc. It's definitely not going to appeal to everyone, but if you allow yourself to be immersed in it's atmosphere and get into the pace of the game, you'll find it an experience unlike anything else. The seemingly low key story, reveals itself to be quite an epic in its later stages.

    If any game could be described as having artistic merit (Personally, I think video games definitely have merit as being an art form), it would be this.

    *Slight changes I have noticed, to that of the originals: Dormin when speaking, has a female voice layered over the male voice. The lighting of the game is slightly different to the originals. The bloom light effects are not as pronounced. The game does not have quite the same pastoral colour pallette. None of this bothers me, the above were probably due to technical restrictions of the original hardware. I love the new look of the game entirely!
    Expand
  44. Apr 14, 2018
    10
    El trabajo de Blupoint no es más que un detalle para los amantes de este mítico juego. Su lore y su originalidad mantienen su esencia; un juego de 10 en PS2 y clásico atemporal sin duda alguna que nuevamente deja a todos rendidos ante su majestuosidad. Hermoso.
  45. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    The very best of Team Ico and one of the most astounding games ever crafted in the history of gaming. No bias here I've been a Nintendo fan and this one captures my interest in Remakes. Hopefully, soon there will be more like this specifically those titles that worthy of remakes. Kudos to Bluepoint aswell!
  46. Jun 9, 2018
    10
    The original Shadow of Colossus is one of my most favorite game of all time. The remake is probably the best gaming news in 2017. I love everything. it took the best game on PS1 and make it even better. Fantastic story, Breath-taking visual, epic boss battle. 10/10 Flawless
  47. Feb 8, 2018
    10
    This game is a real masterpiece.
    Breathtaking story,graphics and gameplay.
    Maybe one of the best I have ever played!
  48. Mar 23, 2019
    10
    As evident by the shockingly low user score compared to the original's, this game is not for everybody. The controls are wonky and the camera is all over the place. But I don't care. The controls, the camera, the horse, they don't bother me. Why not? Because everything else is goddamn beautiful. The soundtrack is beautiful, the colossi are all fun and unique (except for maybe two of them),As evident by the shockingly low user score compared to the original's, this game is not for everybody. The controls are wonky and the camera is all over the place. But I don't care. The controls, the camera, the horse, they don't bother me. Why not? Because everything else is goddamn beautiful. The soundtrack is beautiful, the colossi are all fun and unique (except for maybe two of them), the graphics are breathtaking, I've heard people complain that it takes the atmosphere away, which it doesn't at all for me. The only thing that the graphical overhaul removed was my nostalgia for the original. Which is a good thing. That ending is also one of the saddest endings I've seen in a video game. If you've never played this game, then playing it now might be a bit risky. You might end up hating it. If not, it just might be one of the best games you'll ever play. Expand
  49. Feb 1, 2020
    10
    Beautiful, poignant, contemplative, and evocative, Shadow of the Colossus is one of the strongest cases for Games as Art that I can recommend.
  50. Apr 12, 2018
    10
    This very appreciated game is the world all-time classic i can enjoy with my kids when i get old
  51. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    Quite easily the best version of SotC I can possibly find, hands down. Its remade visuals just screams godlike all over the place, I swear!

    Seriously, go buy and play this game, even if you already had PS2 original and/or the PS3 re-release!
  52. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    An outstanding game. Congratulations to Bluepoint for making an already masterpiece into a legend.
    The game remains magnificent, for the older gamers like myself it ia a must buy the graphics are brilliant and the gameplay as smooth as ever.
    You cannot imagine how good it is, i'll keep it spoiler free PLEASE GIVE IT A TRY. For the newcomers it is a game that you need to play, however
    An outstanding game. Congratulations to Bluepoint for making an already masterpiece into a legend.
    The game remains magnificent, for the older gamers like myself it ia a must buy the graphics are brilliant and the gameplay as smooth as ever.
    You cannot imagine how good it is, i'll keep it spoiler free PLEASE GIVE IT A TRY.

    For the newcomers it is a game that you need to play, however it is not for everyone it is a harsh adventure that needs time and devotion, if you expect something like GTA or Elder scrolls type of game that it is not for you. The action is limited and the environment quite empty but that is the purpose in order to put you in the situation Wander is ( the protagonist )

    Mark my words friends Shadow of the Colossus can still Shadow every game out there.
    Expand
  53. Mar 25, 2018
    10
    An actual masterpiece. When I heard they were remaking this I was worried but it is basically the same game with some modern options. Even Argo is still derpy.
  54. Feb 9, 2018
    10
    É simplesmente o melhor jogo que eu já joguei na vida. O seu minimalismo, sua direção de arte, sua trilha sonora, fazem desse jogo, uma verdadeira obra-prima!
  55. Feb 6, 2018
    10
    Joguei no ps2 e era fantástico agora fico perfeito ,um dos melhores jogos de todos os tempos
  56. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    Un juego 10/10 que no debe faltar en tu colección, excelentes gráficos, mantiene la jugabilidad de PS2, Banda sonora destacable, etc. Sinceramente. estamos ante la presencia de uno de los mejores Remake hasta la fecha, totalmente recomendado, si te gusta esta saga.
  57. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    Even though a lot of the problems that exist in the original - bad camera work, unintuitive controls - it really drove home the feeling of it being that game we all loved when we were younger. It felt the same, but better at the same time. Better graphics are obviously a huge plus. This is how the game was supposed to be made back on ps2 but was never able to be. The magnitude of theEven though a lot of the problems that exist in the original - bad camera work, unintuitive controls - it really drove home the feeling of it being that game we all loved when we were younger. It felt the same, but better at the same time. Better graphics are obviously a huge plus. This is how the game was supposed to be made back on ps2 but was never able to be. The magnitude of the colossi, the sheer size of the map, the challenging navigation through various diverse and distinct areas make this game such a pleasure to play. Furthermore the fact that there really is only “1” character makes the play through an introspection of self and really allows for the character to be connected to personally. In an age where games like Destiny 2, FFXIV, Dragon Age, Monster Hunter World etc are all about jam packing goodies and millions of things to do into it, the lack of things to do, and the main point of the game are all heightened because of that. Enjoy the scenery, which include the colossi just as much as the physical world, to the fullest extent. A true masterpiece - especially for a remake/master whatever you wanna call it. Expand
  58. Feb 7, 2018
    10
    Uma obra-prima que não envelheceu

    A Blue Point fez um remake incrivel e manteve muito bem as mecanicas do jogo original. Realmente deu pra ver o amor que a empresa usou pra refazer esse jogo unico do Fumito Ueda. Do ps2 ao ps4 ainda continua um jogo incrivel!!!
  59. Feb 8, 2018
    10
    It’s amazing, I played this game a first time in my life. Great atmosphere, great feelings of giant colossus, music, light.. Great remake
    Thank You Bluepoint
  60. Feb 8, 2018
    10
    Having never played this game before i didnt understand the hype. Now I do. My god what an amazing game!!!
  61. Feb 11, 2018
    10
    Shadow of the Colossus is the gaming equivalent of art house cinema. Therefore, this is not a game for those who do not appreciate art, nor those who do not experiment with games outside their comfort zone. I for one am in admiration of this 2018 remake of Shadow of the Colossus. A masterpiece.
  62. Feb 10, 2018
    10
    One of the best game of the year. The game has many lessons and even morality that make us think and worth learning.
  63. Feb 15, 2018
    10
    This is an absolute masterpiece. It even improved and went beyond what the original game could
  64. Feb 20, 2018
    10
    Esse jogo, para mim, e para muitos, é o melhor jogo de todos os tempos, marcou infâncias, marcou gerações, com uma gameplay praticamente que única, merece todos os créditos, como o melhor jogo, ainda mais feito por um dos caras que manja no assunto de games, realmente, esse jogo é simplesmente magnifico!!!
  65. Mar 20, 2018
    10
    Es un videojuego Exelente!
    Es un videojuego Exelente!
    Es un videojuego Exelente!
  66. Mar 21, 2018
    10
    Tudo que já era épico está presente novamente neste Remake em uma escala ainda maior e mais imersiva. Os controles foram melhorados, os gráficos estão de tirar o fôlego e a trilha sonora se mantém igualmente memorável.
  67. Mar 23, 2018
    10
    muito bom! ewreuiorywruewurewurwurywuiruwriwryuwirwrywuirywriwyriwyriwryuuwi
  68. Apr 4, 2018
    10
    old games are more different and more special than new ones after all these progress in gaming industry.hope to see such these games in future.
  69. Apr 20, 2018
    10
    Team Ico creo un gran titulo de culto que no es apto para cualquier jugador, ahora en manos de BluePoint nos llega este remake en exclusiva para PS4, en cual a pesar de dejar casi intacto el juego original (cosa que no esta del nada mal) y hace un pulido gráfico, llevando este titulo a la nueva generación y el cual luce espectacular, el gameplay esta intacto salvo que ahora esta la opciónTeam Ico creo un gran titulo de culto que no es apto para cualquier jugador, ahora en manos de BluePoint nos llega este remake en exclusiva para PS4, en cual a pesar de dejar casi intacto el juego original (cosa que no esta del nada mal) y hace un pulido gráfico, llevando este titulo a la nueva generación y el cual luce espectacular, el gameplay esta intacto salvo que ahora esta la opción de cambiar la configuracion de botones, de ahi en fuera la cámara torpe y el movimiento de nuestros personajes es la misma, sin embargo el titulo co su lavado de cara parece un juego fresco de este 2018, cabe destacar que como bien mencione es un titulo de culto y que no es para todo publico, ya que el juego no esta lleno de acción y hay muchos momentos vacíos específicos para la búsqueda de los colosos.
    Pero esto no quita que el juego sea maravilloso en su propio sentido y que esta renovación es un gran acierto por parte de Sony PlayStation ya que al fin y al cabo pone un nuevo titulo mas al amplio catalogo de la PS4.
    Expand
  70. May 7, 2018
    10
    Es mas bello aun que el eoriginal, graficos claramente superiores y me atreveria a decir que de los mejores en consola actualmente. Jugue al original cuando salio en su dia en PS2, el primer contacto fue maravilloso, y en ICO tambien se aprecia semejante calidad. Con un mundo entero que explorar, lleno de detalles y belleza, derrotar a los 16 colosos del mapa supone un reto. Ademas deEs mas bello aun que el eoriginal, graficos claramente superiores y me atreveria a decir que de los mejores en consola actualmente. Jugue al original cuando salio en su dia en PS2, el primer contacto fue maravilloso, y en ICO tambien se aprecia semejante calidad. Con un mundo entero que explorar, lleno de detalles y belleza, derrotar a los 16 colosos del mapa supone un reto. Ademas de algun que otro coleccionable, las monedas añadidas en esta versión, y un modo cámara en que hacer fotos,el juego poco ofrece respecto a su versión original. A pesar de ellos sigue siendo perfecto. Conserva los modos extra y equipamientos desbloqueables que habia en la version original, cosa que se agradece. El control sigue siendo el mismo, del cual no tengo quejas. He visto personas que se quejan porque Agro no obedece. Agro está diseñado asi a propósito, como si de un caballo real se tratara, y, en ese aspecto, su inteligencia artificial es increíble y muy realista. El movimiento del protagonista tambien sigue siendo el mismo, con unas animaciones increíbles y control fluido. Tanto si lo has jugado o no antes, merece la pena esta remasterizacion, y mucho, la historia atrapa, la jugabilidad es alucinante y los gráficos hermosos. Expand
  71. Jun 6, 2018
    10
    So, you want review? Want a game with zero grinding or annoying side quests? Want a game with almost zero dialogue? Zen out with the almost kid friendly boss-climbing masterpiece.

    When other fantasy games get you lost in some kind of narrative- SOC leaves a lot to your imagination which I found to be similar to Dark Souls. Yes there is a damsel in distress but it's no big deal. The
    So, you want review? Want a game with zero grinding or annoying side quests? Want a game with almost zero dialogue? Zen out with the almost kid friendly boss-climbing masterpiece.

    When other fantasy games get you lost in some kind of narrative- SOC leaves a lot to your imagination which I found to be similar to Dark Souls. Yes there is a damsel in distress but it's no big deal. The difficulty level on this game was not high.

    The graphics here are super. REALLY SUPER. Ride along cliff sides and peer down to the water falls below. Relax, you will never be attacked. You can fall off cliffs and die however.

    SOC provided a very memorable game experience that I will not soon forget.
    Expand
  72. Mar 14, 2020
    10
    Shadow of the Colossus is the perfect example of a remake done right. Gameplay and artwork are completely identical to the original PS2 version with minor to no changes which shows how much the original version was ahead of its time.

    The only thing that changed are the graphics which have received a major upgrade to fit the newest generation of video games and framerate is solid 30fps,
    Shadow of the Colossus is the perfect example of a remake done right. Gameplay and artwork are completely identical to the original PS2 version with minor to no changes which shows how much the original version was ahead of its time.

    The only thing that changed are the graphics which have received a major upgrade to fit the newest generation of video games and framerate is solid 30fps, making battles with the colossi look more eye-catching than ever.

    For those who experience the game for the first time, it is a completely mesmerizing game with deep and dark atmosphere, story, art direction and gameplay. It is a dark journey to the Forbidden Lands which every gamer should take. As for those who’ve played the original, do yourself a favor and play this outstanding remake. It is a downright masterpiece.
    Expand
  73. Jul 18, 2018
    10
    İts a amazing bosses and Very good Story its a game of the year i Love shadow of the cololsus
  74. Mar 26, 2023
    10
    THAT is how you do a remake! Very faithful to the original. Are you taking notes, Squeenix?
  75. Oct 22, 2018
    10
    Jogo excelente, totalmente refeito e sem perder a originalidade.
    Jogabilidade perfeita e um dos melhores graficos da atual gen
  76. Sep 16, 2018
    10
    En el Top 5 de los mejores juegos de la historia en mi opinión. Un juego único y distinto que con poca cosa te consigue transmitir muchísimo. Con este remake se disfruta aún más.
  77. Oct 8, 2019
    10
    If artistic games is your bag, Shadow of the Colossus is a must-pick title to play.
    This is it´s third time it goes trough the grinder to be remade. Debuted on PS1, remade for PS3 and now getting the high definition flavour for large TVs, and boy is it magical. But as much negativity that many remakes get or the whole concept of it at all is, this title deserves to be a little better each
    If artistic games is your bag, Shadow of the Colossus is a must-pick title to play.
    This is it´s third time it goes trough the grinder to be remade. Debuted on PS1, remade for PS3 and now getting the high definition flavour for large TVs, and boy is it magical. But as much negativity that many remakes get or the whole concept of it at all is, this title deserves to be a little better each time.

    Shadow Of The Colossus is for one an atmospheric game. Where the player are thrown into a mythical fable, a vast fantasy world, large colossi monsters and very little else. I don´t really get other reviewers comparing it to games like The Witcher, and other fantasy games. They have NOTHING in common with them. The game's philosophy and execution is not even comparable to anything. Probably The Last Guardian, but it is by the same developer.

    Bluepoint kept the basic concept and it´s main focus: You (the player) vs the Colossi´s. They did not ad much in to "fill it up", but kept the artistic integrity and the focus the original makers made it to be. There is little around you to take you away from the main story of the game. No collectibles (well a little, but totally unnecessary) or sidequests. And that takes skill to make something like this.

    Trough your whole journey, learn to suck up the amazing scenery, the sixteen epic boss fights and the story of one boy´s fight to save his sweetheart.
    Not much more to say about it. The juicy controls could be better probably, but it does not feel too troublesome.
    A true arthouse of a game and a magical classic that is very faithfully preserved in this third remake.
    Expand
  78. Jun 11, 2019
    10
    Juegazo, grandes gráficos, ambientación correcta, un remake perfecto.
    Recreando sus mejores escenas en ps4 pro Un videojuego que debes tener en tu catalago de exclusivas, o que merece ser probado en esta generación si vienes de la anterior gen.
  79. Mar 22, 2019
    10
    The best Remaster I've ever seen, this game is pure gold, the story,the graphics,the combat, the visuals, everything is perfect.
  80. Dec 8, 2018
    10
    This game is absolutely amazing and with the upgraded graphics this looks amazing! Definitely worth a purchase, especially if you haven't played the original. And if you have, its still worth the money for the amazing visual upgrade from the PS2 title.
  81. Mar 25, 2019
    10
    Not for the new age circle jerkin kids who run around aimlessly just too get shot in the back and rinse n repeat!!! I love this game along with the last guardian. It's what makes playing worth your while delivering a fantasy experience mostly movies can only capture.
  82. May 31, 2019
    10
    A true classic that definitely shines from the new remake graphics. It tells a great emotional story as you fight colossi to save your loved one. The boss fights are epic and always different. I played it for the first time on the ps4 and I really enjoyed it and it has that zelda kinda of vibe in it.
  83. Jun 29, 2019
    10
    Just breathtaking. This entire open world slows down the speed. It allows to enjoy the true moments of peace by playing this game. Visually stunning, sound just perfect and the colossi tell you how small the protagonist in fact is. A pefect 10.
  84. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    De vez en cuando aparece un juego “diferente” que nos deja huella y nos recuerda porque tenemos esta bonita afición.

    Debes jugarlo, sin mas.

    Pd: si eres del fifa, del asasin y del calofduti este juego no es para ti
  85. Jul 18, 2019
    10
    Не играл ни в оригинал, ни в переиздание на ps3, так что в первый раз прикоснулся к этому шедевру. SofC - это определенно игра не для всех. Она не про геймплей или сюжет, в отличие от большинства современных ААА-проектов, она - про атмосферу. Мир игры странным образом привлекает и затягивает, хотя является, по сути, абсолютно пустым (исключение составляют сами колоссы и парочка животных).Не играл ни в оригинал, ни в переиздание на ps3, так что в первый раз прикоснулся к этому шедевру. SofC - это определенно игра не для всех. Она не про геймплей или сюжет, в отличие от большинства современных ААА-проектов, она - про атмосферу. Мир игры странным образом привлекает и затягивает, хотя является, по сути, абсолютно пустым (исключение составляют сами колоссы и парочка животных). Яркий показатель - 70% геймплея - это скачки на лошади, и за 2,5 прохождения эти самые скачки не надоели. Про сюжет и геймплей говорить бесполезно, да и не нужно, так как в это надо попросту поиграть. Как итог, для меня лично Shadow of the Colossus полностью оправдала уже полученное звание классики и заняла очень высокое (если не первое) место в списке моих любимых игр. Expand
  86. Dec 31, 2019
    10
    Un remake praticamente perfetto, con una fedeltà pazzesca a quella che è l estetica di Ueda, magnifico.
  87. Aug 24, 2019
    10
    Esse é o melhor jogo de todos os tempos!!
    Controles bem trabalhados e obedecem muito bem os comando, história perfeita, músicas marcantes, Collosus bem elaborados e EPICO!
    Para mim, esse jogo supera o God Of War 1 e 2 fácil
    QUE JOGO PERFEITO!!
  88. Sep 8, 2019
    10
    Easily one of the best games I’ve ever played, and even though I didn’t play the original, I’m happy I finally gave this masterpiece a chance
  89. Nov 26, 2019
    10
    um dos melhores jogos de todos os tempos, esse remake ficou magnífico, adoro os trabalhos de fumito ueda e esse é com certeza o mais marcante!
  90. Dec 28, 2019
    10
    SOTC its a solid artistic masterpiece. This game is the definition of what videogames can achieve as art pieces.
    It uses all of the resources of a media that requires active engagement in a creative way to induce feelings and actions in our brains. Thus, its a piece of art.
  91. Aug 3, 2020
    10
    There is a reason why this game was released on nearly every single PlayStation Console ... it is pure greatness ...What more needs to be said one of the all time greatest games ..
  92. Dec 8, 2019
    10
    That's how a f*cking remake is done. A masterpiece with new excellent graphics.
  93. Aug 21, 2023
    10
    Definetly deserves all the praise. One of the most effective games at capturing the loneliness of an open, beautifully crafted world. Heartbreakingly sinister.

    10
  94. Dec 7, 2020
    10
    Gostar ou não de SOTC deveria ser um dos seus métodos de avaliar o caráter de outra pessoa. Clássico cult.
  95. Jan 2, 2020
    10
    "Just" the best game ever made... "apenas"o melhor jogo já feito...........
  96. Feb 28, 2020
    10
    Shadow Of The Colossus has been remade from the ground up, and it’s the best remake of all time. It stays to the original to a way I cannot stop appreciating, the graphics visuals and sound make this game feel unreal it’s so amazing. The story is the same simple amazing plot, they even made the music somehow more epic that has to appreciated even more! The bosses look so good and feel theShadow Of The Colossus has been remade from the ground up, and it’s the best remake of all time. It stays to the original to a way I cannot stop appreciating, the graphics visuals and sound make this game feel unreal it’s so amazing. The story is the same simple amazing plot, they even made the music somehow more epic that has to appreciated even more! The bosses look so good and feel the same just like how they were amazing terrifying colossi. The time trails are still here with amazing rewards, there is even a new reward for exploring the entire world and finding some orbs that adds so much replayability. Shadow Of The Colossus is a dream game it does everything well all the things are well made and feel epic and satisfying, and it deserves the title of legendary. (A Masterpiece 5/5) You Must Play It! Expand
  97. Mar 15, 2020
    10
    This great game is fun fun and deeply satisfying and touching. This game is among the best games I've played
  98. Mar 15, 2020
    10
    Simple yet powerful story, brilliant sound design, Beautiful to look at and fighting the colossi could not be funner.
  99. Mar 12, 2022
    10
    This gameplay is simply a masterpiece! To keep this short:
    Music 100/10
    World&Characters 10/10
    Controls/Gameplay 7/10
    Enjoyment 10/10
  100. Jun 19, 2020
    10
    Shadow of the Colossus proves that videogames can be art too.
    I've played the og back in the day and it was one of the best experiences I've had in my life.
    This games is the same thing but fixes (almost) all the problems that the original had.
Metascore
91

Universal acclaim - based on 100 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 97 out of 100
  2. Negative: 0 out of 100
  1. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Apr 24, 2018
    80
    Perfectly polished and improved cult game – even with better controls! Killing giant monsters has never been so much (melancholic) fun. [Issue#283]
  2. Apr 24, 2018
    90
    A tribute to the Fumito Ueda will delight the veterans of the original game same as introduce this classic to the newcomers, who are not tuned on a nostalgic note. An ideal opportunity to improve your video game education and a wonderful experience in the same time. Some clumsy controls and occasionally stubborn camera can’t ruin the great experience.
  3. CD-Action
    Apr 3, 2018
    70
    It’s a good remaster, but frankly I find it unnecessary. Those who have already played the game on PS2 or PS3 will find nothing new here, and those who didn’t have the chance to get acquainted with it probably will not understand what we saw in Shadow of the Colossus 12 years ago, when gaming reality was completely different. [03/2018, p.66]