Red Dead Redemption and Undead Nightmare

 PlayStation 4
User Score
1.7

Overwhelming dislike- based on 144 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 20 out of 144
  2. Mixed: 3 out of 144
  3. Negative: 121 out of 144

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. smil3mood
    Aug 19, 2023
    10
    works well, $50 is a little expensive, but on PS3 if you buy with DLS it costs the same $50 ((I put 10 since I play for the first time and the game is like new for me ((
  2. UncleTacitus
    Aug 20, 2023
    9
    Just masterpiece!
    The gameplay, graphics and story is still great and wonderful.
    I wish there was a remaster.
  3. Callingcascade
    Aug 18, 2023
    8
    Aside from the 30 fps lock when playing on a PS5, this is a solid port of the game. It didn't need fancy new features. The story and gameplay hold up. I was never a fan of the multiplayer when it originally released so it's not really missed for me.
  4. psmoon21
    Aug 20, 2023
    10
    Switch and PS4 players who never had the chance to play this masterpiece, now can.

    Many complain that it brings little news or the price, yes, but surely if they had done a remake or a remastering changing things there would also be complaints. The same press that did not take into account the price of some "remake" recently, now puts it as a negative of this game It's a port, a    Switch and PS4 players who never had the chance to play this masterpiece, now can.

    Many complain that it brings little news or the price, yes, but surely if they had done a remake or a remastering changing things there would also be complaints.

    The same press that did not take into account the price of some "remake" recently, now puts it as a negative of this game

    It's a port, a good port on both consoles that exactly resembles the original changing the resolution on ps4 and switch 1080p (improved on ps4 pro and ps5, 4k), shadow improvements and less blur, with some new subtitle languages ​​plus the dlc (one of the best dlc ever).

    Remember that in the case of playstation it could be free if the console was backwards compatible, sony's fault.

    The original game is a masterpiece and even with a few additions this version still is. And even with the years that have passed and taking that into account, it seems to me a much better game than current games.    … Expand
  5. Destroyer2208
    Aug 23, 2023
    9
    Although the lack of multiplayer is a bit of a sting. This is truly the best version of these games. Controls are more responsive and the game runs beautifully. As someone who still has his original Collector's Edition and has now 100% on this edition too. I was happy to pay the price for this collection. I will buy the physical copies. For both Switch and PS4. Would love a full remake oneAlthough the lack of multiplayer is a bit of a sting. This is truly the best version of these games. Controls are more responsive and the game runs beautifully. As someone who still has his original Collector's Edition and has now 100% on this edition too. I was happy to pay the price for this collection. I will buy the physical copies. For both Switch and PS4. Would love a full remake one day. Fingers Crossed, Rockstar wants my money again.… Expand
  6. RSG_Assassin
    Aug 20, 2023
    10
    Most of the poor reviews are simply people jumping on the bandwagon of hate that seems to be common with Rockstar games as of recent. A ridiculous sense of entitlement coupled with a complete inability to process their emotions without raging about it all over the internet. Whilst funny at first, it has become a bore dealing their petulance over a private company daring to release productsMost of the poor reviews are simply people jumping on the bandwagon of hate that seems to be common with Rockstar games as of recent. A ridiculous sense of entitlement coupled with a complete inability to process their emotions without raging about it all over the internet. Whilst funny at first, it has become a bore dealing their petulance over a private company daring to release products to make money.

    Now as someone who 100%'d and Platinum'd both the original Red Dead Redemption on PS3, and Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PS4, and played almost 2000 hours of Red Dead Online, I think I have a better appreciation of these games than most here.

    The story is fantastic. John is forced by the Government to hunt down his former gang mates. He travels around multiple states and Mexico and gets sucked into a whole bunch of odd situations by the weird and wacky characters that he meets on the way. I'm not joking, there are some incredibly strange people involved. If you've only ever played RDR2 then it feels a lot more like the epilogue than the main game being that you have no gang to back you up. John is a lot more interesting, not so dumb like in RDR2, and has some really insightful things to say. It might reveal why some of us still prefer John over Arthur. New Austin and West Elizabeth are both far more fleshed out than in RDR2 so there's plenty of fresh exploration to be done, plus Mexico makes an appearance which is a whole vibe in itself. There's still plenty of things to do in the world such as odd jobs and mini games alongside the main and stranger missions.

    The mechanics are definitely a step down from RDR2 being that this is an older game, but they're perfectly serviceable. Shooting feels weird if you're used to RDR2, being a tad more clunky to aim around the body when locking on, but you can also choose to play without any auto-aim if that's your preference. Melee is extremely basic compared to what was offered in RDR2.
    There is a complete lack of character maintenance which is perfect for those out there who struggle with the feeding/stamina/weight mechanics of RDR2 like one of my friends, or if you're just like me and never liked having to manage those things and just wanted to focus on the game.

    Visually the game is as stunning as ever. As a matter of fact all RAGE based R* titles are stunning. It is a wonder what rendering the game at a higher resolution will achieve with these games. Certainly some things can't be improved by a simple increase in resolution, such as facial models and textures, but they hold up well enough.
    On the PS4 Pro and thus the PS5, the game runs at native 4k at a consistent 30fps. 60fps support would have been nice even as an experimental toggle in the options, but the 30fps rarely drops so the it doesn't feel jittery at all to play.

    Finally, Undead Nightmare, one of the best DLCs I've ever played that offers a whole new story where zombies awaken on Earth and John has to deal with them, is included in this version of the game. It features a new story and a bunch of new mythological creatures to go with it.

    Some notes I have on things that people have complained about:

    UI - I would have definitely liked to have seen the UI redone to match the rest of the game in 4k. As it stands it is too low of a resolution for my liking, but it's no big deal. Having said that, however, gutting the map and menu and replacing it might have taken away the charm of those parts of the UI, so it might be a blessing in disguise that they didn't touch it.

    Multiplayer - I loved the multiplayer in the original. It was an unique experience that I would have loved to see return, much like I do for many MP games of that era, but its absence isn't the end of the world. Let's take off the nostalgic goggles for a second and remember that the primary gameplay loop was running around the map beating the same gang hideouts over and over again, and the PvP, whilst having some of the best modes I've ever played in a R* game, was completely unbalanced where getting to a certain gun spawn first almost certainly ensured a win. Amazing fun at the time in 2010, but its a whole lot of work to fix up the exploits and release it when the vast majority of people never played it anyway.
    Don't believe me? Check the trophy data for the PS3 version of RDR1. Only 26.9% of players killed someone with the Red Dead Rockstar trophy, which is so easy that it would be almost impossible to miss at it's peak. Meanwhile only 2.0% ever reached the top rank.
    It really is not a big deal to most people.

    So why did i give it a 10? Simply because I believe the OG version to be a 10 and this is the OG but better. Just because it is not a remaster or remake doesn't suddenly make the game not a 10, and certainly doesn't make it a 0.    … Expand
  7. Eldon-U
    Aug 23, 2023
    10
    Red Dead Redemption Re Released on PS4. I could tell you that I was hoping for a Remaster but, I was not. I like the fact they released it in more of the original form that was 2010 RDR1. it has way better frame rate then the 2010 PS3 release and looks a bit better as well. I think people should not "assume" they are getting what they want, when all that was not even Promised.
  8. nima1880
    Aug 25, 2023
    10
    Great storytelling!
    Great charachters!
    Good graphics
    Mexico is great
    Mini games are so good
  9. CleverPun
    Aug 26, 2023
    9
    I see a lot of people who are claiming that RockStar 'listens to your wallet' and prompting people not to buy this game because they're disappointed that a remaster was not released. Don't listen to a bunch of people on the internet who can't seem to form an opinion of their own without reading and regurgitating some angry kid on Twitter/X's opinion first. If you haven't had a chance toI see a lot of people who are claiming that RockStar 'listens to your wallet' and prompting people not to buy this game because they're disappointed that a remaster was not released. Don't listen to a bunch of people on the internet who can't seem to form an opinion of their own without reading and regurgitating some angry kid on Twitter/X's opinion first. If you haven't had a chance to play the game, or you want the game on a system that isn't rendering in 640p and possibly either buried in a garage or in your kid's room somewhere, don't hesitate. This is an incredibly solid port, and despite what others may think, it does take work to port a thirteen year old game to modern systems. It isn't lazy, it isn't bad, these people are simply miffed that they didn't get Red Dead Redemption 2: The Marston Years. It is a little disappointing that it runs at 30fps on PS4 Pro and PS5, but it's still solid for what it is. The price may seem a little daunting, and I agree, BUT these guys screaming that the Xbox version is cheaper are full of it. This version includes all of the DLC, which on Xbox is roughly $13 plus $29.99 for the base game. That brings the total to $42.99 plus tax. You're saving a whooping $7.01. I would say that genuinely isn't that big of a deal. Use reason people, make up your own minds, and don't let some angry dorks influence your decision. Do the research and trust your gut, buy it on sale if you don't want to pay the $50, because it WILL be on sale at some point. Also, RockStar and their Publishers will not 'listen to your wallet'. The problem with that logic is twofold. For one, there is going to be a whole lot of people that don't have an Xbox and have either never played the game or just don't want to drag out the old PS3 (or in some cases purchase a PS3) to play their old copy of the game. These people are going to buy and play the game, and they are not in the vocal minority complaining online because they're too busy enjoying the game. There are also people that are either Nintendo nuts that have never had a chance to play, or just want the game in portable format that are going to snatch up the Switch version in droves (I bought it day one for my Switch because I don't get a whole lot of chances to sit down in front of a TV to game, and I also bought the PS4 version because my son wants to play the game.) The second major reason that the 'wallet vote' thing is crap is because Rockstar is huge. They won't take a major hit on this one. This is doubly true when you factor in all of the people I've previously mentioned that are buying the game, alongside the fact that GTA VI will likely be out within two years and will recoup any potential losses that may (or most likely may not) occur with this port. Your collective $50 a piece is not going to hurt a multi-billion dollar company. Anyhow, I know I spoke little on the game itself. It really is a great port. I haven't had any issues, and it's wonderful to finally get to play this again without having to throw down $300-$500 for an Xbox.… Expand
  10. Graphic-Outrage
    Sep 7, 2023
    9
    It's literally the same game as it originally released, people are just pissed that it's 50 bucks. But it's a great game. Review bombers are something else...
  11. DGS14
    Sep 6, 2023
    10
    Mucho mejor que la mayoría de juegos actuales, como el aburrido Zelda por ejemplo

Awards & Rankings

7
#7 Best PS4 Game of 2023
1
#1 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2023

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
78

Generally favorable reviews - based on 11 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 7 out of 11
  2. Mixed: 4 out of 11
  3. Negative: 0 out of 11
  1. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Jan 18, 2024
    80
    Objectively, Red Dead Redemption is a true classic. Not only does it conclude the beloved story of both its successor and predecessor, but it does so with equal flourish and narrative quality. [Issue#330]
  2. PSX Extreme
    Oct 4, 2023
    80
    Red Dead Redemption as a game is still a fantastic romp that any cowboy or open world fan should experience. Meanwhile, playing it on my PS5 (via backwards compatibility) is a treat, even if it doesn’t change how the game runs or looks. It has one of the best open worlds you can ask for and a compelling story to boot. But, it’s bogged down by its lazy cash-grab nature, with the Rockstar team opting to do away with content and instead do the absolute bare minimum.
    Read full review
  3. Player 2
    Sep 30, 2023
    83
    Red Dead Redemption is an unbelievably good game, even in 2023, however the lack of effort put into elevating the game to the current day’s technical benchmarks damages its modern legacy.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »