NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139...

 PlayStation 4
User Score
8.6

Generally favorable reviews- based on 533 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 450 out of 533
  2. Mixed: 40 out of 533
  3. Negative: 43 out of 533
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. strangebrew123
    Aug 2, 2022
    7
    A gentle game with a great back story for Nier Automata fans. Some good humour and some very good voice acting. However, there are too may tedious side quests meaning that you easily overlevel, which detracts from the game. Great for a PS3 game, though pretty dated in gameplay for a PS4 game.
  2. Kostas_Spirou
    Jun 1, 2022
    9
    This is a very depressing game, and the story is just amazing, one of the best stories for sure.
    Very complex, deep, with subtle symbolisms, but the pacing could've been handled better.
    The main characters are very interesting and relatable in many ways, while the side characters felt bland and one-dimensional. The gameplay is great, unfortunately you unlock pretty much all the abilities    This is a very depressing game, and the story is just amazing, one of the best stories for sure.
    Very complex, deep, with subtle symbolisms, but the pacing could've been handled better.

    The main characters are very interesting and relatable in many ways, while the side characters felt bland and one-dimensional.

    The gameplay is great, unfortunately you unlock pretty much all the abilities early in the game, but they are very fun to use, and the combos are satisfying.

    The new rearranged music is incredible, better than the original, and dare I say one of the best soundtracks for sure.

    Overall it's an outstanding Remake, it does have some few outdated elements like the fact that you need to collect all the weapons in order to get the true ending, or the generic side quests, but it's still an amazing experience, and the new story additions are worth checking out.

    Final Rating: "Amazing" ~ 9/10.    … Expand
  3. Empyrea
    Mar 13, 2023
    7
    I think this game would deserve a 7'5-8 but I'm giving it a 7 because players tend to overrate this game. It took me 19 hours doing only a few quests. I might watch the extra scenes on youtube as I don't feel to play this game over and over, only to see a few new things. I continued for one hour after finishing the first game and it's not worthy to me (plus, what's with the lenght of KaineI think this game would deserve a 7'5-8 but I'm giving it a 7 because players tend to overrate this game. It took me 19 hours doing only a few quests. I might watch the extra scenes on youtube as I don't feel to play this game over and over, only to see a few new things. I continued for one hour after finishing the first game and it's not worthy to me (plus, what's with the lenght of Kaine story? Videogames are not books. It's just not the moment nor the place to do that). I also feel the influence of Evangelion on monsters, blood and drama. Not a must have game and not a game for everyone but it's a good choice if you like rpg with plenty of action. I also like to point out the good soundtrack of this game.… Expand
  4. LiamMayfair
    Aug 13, 2023
    9
    Nier Replicant is a brilliant game overall: superb lead characters, engaging story, fun combat mechanics (remade in this new release of the original title to be similar to Nier: Automata) and easily one of the best videogame soundtracks I've ever experienced. Honestly, Nier Replicant's music score alone is enough to rate this game highly, as it elevates the in-game experience toNier Replicant is a brilliant game overall: superb lead characters, engaging story, fun combat mechanics (remade in this new release of the original title to be similar to Nier: Automata) and easily one of the best videogame soundtracks I've ever experienced. Honestly, Nier Replicant's music score alone is enough to rate this game highly, as it elevates the in-game experience to incredible heights.

    Now, Nier Replicant does have some flaws, some of them owing to its age:

    - The game's quest structure is hands down its biggest problem: quests (especially secondary ones) are very repetitive and have you running pointless errands for everybody. At least, quests in the main story move the plot forward and allow you to learn more about the characters through cutscenes and dialogue among them as you play. You get hardly any of those things with secondary quests, which makes them very dull and even infuriating, as the game forces you to complete a few of them to get certain endings.
    - The environments and scenario design are rather bland
    - Outside of the group of co-protagonists, most of the characters in the game are uninteresting and generic

    If you have the patience to put up with some of Nier Replicant's dated or simply poorly designed elements, you will get in return an unforgettable, unique and thought-provoking experience, as well as a cast of main characters you will fall in love with.

    Did I mention how freaking good this game's soundtrack is, by the way? Well, I'll say it again: Nier Replicant's soundtrack is the GOAT.    … Expand
  5. galanteo94
    Aug 30, 2023
    9
    Uno de los mejores juegos de rol de acción de la PS4, si quieres vivir emociones intensas y satisfactorias este es tu juego. Estilo Bayonetta, Kingdom Hearts para adultos, nos encontramos ante una obra cumbre del género aunque está lejos de ser perfecto, hace un dueto inolvidable junto a NIER: Autómata.
  6. Timenick
    Jul 8, 2021
    9
    Pros:
    - Very good but also very sad story with a lot of twists
    - Interesting characters with a lot of backstory to uncover - Excellent writing - Wonderful music - Really good voice acting, especially by Laura Bailey - Good Hack n Slash combat - Interesting level design - Very funny humor - A lot of new things to discover that weren't in the original - Reduced loading times,    Pros:
    - Very good but also very sad story with a lot of twists
    - Interesting characters with a lot of backstory to uncover
    - Excellent writing
    - Wonderful music
    - Really good voice acting, especially by Laura Bailey
    - Good Hack n Slash combat
    - Interesting level design
    - Very funny humor
    - A lot of new things to discover that weren't in the original
    - Reduced loading times, improved graphics, stable 60fps frame rate

    Cons:
    - Some sidequests are really bad
    - The game can feel repetitive sometimes, especially on subsequent playthroughs you have to do for the full story
    - The soundtrack you get from preordering doesn't work without a separate usb device.

    Verdict: NieR:Replicant has aged really well and probably fits much better into the zeitgeist than it did in 2010. An excellent remake of an excellent game that you shouldn´t miss.    … Expand
  7. deathstramding
    Nov 8, 2022
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Masterpiece Masterpiece Masterpiece Masterpiece Masterpiece Masterpiece… Expand
  8. Solaris123
    Jun 12, 2021
    10
    Best storyline games ever made , emotional ,philosophy ,depressing drama JRPG i ever play on my life.
  9. Ragnar_san
    Mar 29, 2023
    10
    Muy buen juego que se merece que mas gente lo compre. Cuando juegas a NieR Replicant juegas a la esencia mas pura de Yoko Taro.
  10. GrannyWeed
    Mar 12, 2022
    10
    This game is a timeless classic. Epic story, masterpiece level music, and well developed characters are enough to keep you hooked for hours!
    Only small problems you'll encounter are certain sections in the game with old school text based adventure RPG sections which will tire you (unless you like that kind of storytelling) and barebones gameplay. Despite it's flaws this game is still a    This game is a timeless classic. Epic story, masterpiece level music, and well developed characters are enough to keep you hooked for hours!
    Only small problems you'll encounter are certain sections in the game with old school text based adventure RPG sections which will tire you (unless you like that kind of storytelling) and barebones gameplay. Despite it's flaws this game is still a masterpiece    … Expand
  11. Svetlendrius
    Mar 8, 2022
    9
    Отличная игра с некоторыми небольшими недостатками.
    Сюжет и лор у игры шикарный, а твисты просто моё почтение. Система концовок тоже придумана интересно и даёт переосмысление сюжета. Саундтрек тоже шикарен.
    Побочные квесты вроде простеньекие, но пропитаны какой-то душевностью. Боевка хорошая, боссы отличные и запоминающиеся. Прокачка не очень глубокая (есть ли она?). Рыбалка сделана    Отличная игра с некоторыми небольшими недостатками.
    Сюжет и лор у игры шикарный, а твисты просто моё почтение. Система концовок тоже придумана интересно и даёт переосмысление сюжета. Саундтрек тоже шикарен.
    Побочные квесты вроде простеньекие, но пропитаны какой-то душевностью. Боевка хорошая, боссы отличные и запоминающиеся. Прокачка не очень глубокая (есть ли она?). Рыбалка сделана хорошо.
    Некоторые отрицательные и спорные моменты:
    Какое-то детское знакомство персонажей.
    Моменты с повествованием через текст на черном фоне, с одной стороны ты буд-то читаешь книгу, а с другой я вообще-то в игру пришёл играть. Так что тут каждому по своему.
    Игра слишком легкая на самой высокой сложности, не то чтобы я был каким-то хард геймером, но выполняя все побочки игра не особо даёт челенджа.
    Несмотря на некоторые недостатки, основные моменты в игре сделаны на очень высоком уровне, из-за чего играть в нее очень приятно.    … Expand
  12. Vaeu
    Dec 25, 2021
    7
    It was intriguing to play the game that preceded the masterpiece that is Nier: Automata. Others that played Automata before Replicant would easily discern the story beats that both share, of which are emotionally packed - something that is lacking from games nowadays. The characters here are also interesting, we have an outcast, a shut-in, and a great older brother, the stories theseIt was intriguing to play the game that preceded the masterpiece that is Nier: Automata. Others that played Automata before Replicant would easily discern the story beats that both share, of which are emotionally packed - something that is lacking from games nowadays. The characters here are also interesting, we have an outcast, a shut-in, and a great older brother, the stories these characters have add to the emotion of the story.

    While the music is top tier and sound effects solid and the graphics and animation too, the aspect I disliked the most was the gameplay. It is understandable for an older game that this aspect wouldn't necessarily live up to modern standards with just a remaster. However, the weakness is still relevant. The combat is smooth and satisfying but despite the variety of spells and weapons to use, you are unlikely to switch often as there isn't any incentive to. The main drag about the gameplay is the mundane quests, most are simple fetch or slay quests but there are tedious and boring escort and talking quests. The story for the quests are worth paying attention to, but this is undermined by how much back and forth one needs to do which is annoying as there is no fast travel (until part 2, but the fast travel system is still rather poor) and also the long load times that will take you out of the immersion. Not to mention how some quests demand a ridiculous amount of resources that require immense grinding, but the game doesn't have a good system to allow one to without boring the player to death.

    Overall, Nier Replicant is a good game, but it is clear that the flaws Nier Automata left were done for good reason.    … Expand
  13. MFPhoenix
    Jul 7, 2021
    10
    A fantastic story, brilliant musical scores, intuitive and fun combat, this game started off slow for me but quickly grew on me. The negatives, because there are only a couple in my opinion: Fetch quests and the constant backtracking, I see the attempt to make it add to the story but it could have gone without some of it.

    But nevertheless, this game gets a rare 10 from me. The slight    A fantastic story, brilliant musical scores, intuitive and fun combat, this game started off slow for me but quickly grew on me. The negatives, because there are only a couple in my opinion: Fetch quests and the constant backtracking, I see the attempt to make it add to the story but it could have gone without some of it.

    But nevertheless, this game gets a rare 10 from me. The slight negatives weren't enough to detract a point by the ending of the game. I'd say this is a must buy for any JRPG fan.    … Expand
  14. chrisdan23
    Jan 25, 2023
    7
    NieR Replicant ist purer Fan Service at it's best. Nach dem großen Erfolg des überraschenden Nachfolgers NieR: Automata, hat Square Enix mit NieR Replicant nun eine Remaster Version des Original NieR Spiels der PS3 Ära entwickelt. Neben verbesserter Grafik und Präsentation hat Square sich hier vor allem nochmals an Steuerung und Kampfsystem gemacht, damals tatsächlich die Spielspaßkiller,NieR Replicant ist purer Fan Service at it's best. Nach dem großen Erfolg des überraschenden Nachfolgers NieR: Automata, hat Square Enix mit NieR Replicant nun eine Remaster Version des Original NieR Spiels der PS3 Ära entwickelt. Neben verbesserter Grafik und Präsentation hat Square sich hier vor allem nochmals an Steuerung und Kampfsystem gemacht, damals tatsächlich die Spielspaßkiller, und diese nahezu auf das Niveau heutiger Action Titel gebracht. NieR hat sich noch nie so gut gespielt. Wenngleich dem Spiel natürlich immer noch sein begrenztes Budget anzusehen ist und Gameplay und Spieldesign ihrer Wurzeln in der PS3 Ära nicht abschütteln können, für Fans ist das Remake von NieR sicherlich die Erfüllung eines Traums. Aber auch Spieler, die NieR erst mit dem Sequel NieR:Automata kennen gelernt haben, finden im neu aufgelegtem Original NieR bereits viele der Spieleelemente und kreative Ideen wieder, die NieR so speziell und einzigartig im Japano Action RPG Genre machen.… Expand
  15. Babushka_Zhu
    Sep 5, 2021
    10
    Вот и закончилось моё долгое приключение в этой прекрасной игре. Умирающий мир, угасающая надежда, чудесная музыка и атмосфера, эмоционально опустошающий финал. Сложно описать весь спектр эмоций, надеюсь и вы когда-нибудь решитесь пережить это незабываемое путешествие. Спасибо всем причастным к созданию данного шедевра!Вот и закончилось моё долгое приключение в этой прекрасной игре. Умирающий мир, угасающая надежда, чудесная музыка и атмосфера, эмоционально опустошающий финал. Сложно описать весь спектр эмоций, надеюсь и вы когда-нибудь решитесь пережить это незабываемое путешествие. Спасибо всем причастным к созданию данного шедевра!
  16. djdizzy
    Jul 18, 2021
    8
    This game is a solid 9 that is padded with so many time-wasting fetch quests that the score gets dropped to a 7. So I split the difference and gave it a 8.

    The game differs quite a bit from Nier Automata. The pacing is different and the combat is different. The combat is good, really good, but not as good as Automata. The story is outstanding, the deeper you get into the game the    This game is a solid 9 that is padded with so many time-wasting fetch quests that the score gets dropped to a 7. So I split the difference and gave it a 8.

    The game differs quite a bit from Nier Automata. The pacing is different and the combat is different. The combat is good, really good, but not as good as Automata. The story is outstanding, the deeper you get into the game the deeper the story gets. Lots of twists that will blew my mind. The pacing is the worst aspect of this game and that’s because of side quests and grinding for rare items.

    This game has 5 endings and you’re supposed to get them in order (Ending A, Ending B, and endings C-E). If you just want to do the first playthrough for the first ending (Ending A) then you can just do whichever side quests you feel like or none at all. What is left is a fantastic 9/10 experience.

    If you want to see the full story and get the true final ending, then you’ll have to spend many hours doing side quests where you traverse the world fetching items and taking them back and forth. Plus grinding (killing the same enemies ad nauseum) until you get the rare items you need. It’s like Chinese water torture in video game form. The payoff to this is that you experience the true depth of the story and indeed it does reward you handsomely story-wise for this trouble.

    I quit the game in frustration from the hours of fetch quests a couple times and regretted buying the game. Then I’d hit the main story and it was so good that all was forgiven.

    I highly recommend the game, it’s a gem of a game. But I recommend it with this caveat and advice: Play through the game as you see fit, doing as many or little side quests as you feel like. Get Ending A. Then decide if you want to keep going or not, doing many hours of grinding and fetch quests in exchange for the coveted Ending E.    … Expand
  17. YannySp101
    Jun 1, 2021
    9
    NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139... is the Remastered version of NIER.
    As a massive fan of NieR: Automata and as someone who didn't play the original version of this game, I was very excited to play NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139...
    I'm gonna start off from the most important part of the game; the story. While NieR: Automata's story emphasizes on it's themes, NieR Replicant's story    NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139... is the Remastered version of NIER.
    As a massive fan of NieR: Automata and as someone who didn't play the original version of this game, I was very excited to play NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139...
    I'm gonna start off from the most important part of the game; the story.
    While NieR: Automata's story emphasizes on it's themes, NieR Replicant's story emphasizes on it's characters. In NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139..., the story has been expanded with a new story arc and an additional Ending. Overall, NieR Replicant has a phenomenal story, one that brought me to tears many times; even more so than NieR: Automata's.
    The gameplay is neither as experimental nor as fluid as in NieR: Automata but the combat system is quite similar and the Sealed Verses are more interesting than the Pod Programs.
    The main characters surprised me; they're absolutely wonderful! Visually, the game isn't impressive but it looks fine and the music is incredible!
    Just like in NieR: Automata though, a single playthrough won't be enough to finish the entire story of the game. Unfortunately for NieR Replicant, you need to collect every weapon in the game in order to get the true ending of the story and it gets quite boring after a while.
    Also, the side-quests are very uninteresting and dated.

    Pros:
    + Superb narrative
    + Great gameplay
    + Awesome characters
    + Fantastic music

    Cons:
    - Tedious requirements for the true ending
    - Weak side-quests

    Narrative: 10/10
    Gameplay: 8/10
    Content: ?/10
    Characters: 9/10
    Music: 10/10
    Graphics/Audio: 8/10

    Final Rating: 9/10
    - Amazing -
    If it wasn't for the tedious requirements and some outdated elements, I would've given NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139... an even higher final rating.
    Still, this is a very special videogame experience and at the end of the day, I really wish there were more games like NieR: Automata and NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139...

    Do I recommend it?:
    Yes! Especially to the fans of the series.    … Expand
  18. Antoniods
    Apr 30, 2021
    9
    Gioco molto originale vario tipo di boss fight principali, contento dell' acquisto giocatelo più volte che ci sono mod e prospettive diverse, si sa distinguere dalla massa anche se la serie Nier Automata è la migliore.
  19. Valiefor
    May 1, 2021
    8
    One of the best main stories, insane music and good characters
    Mediocre graphic and terrible open world with side quests
  20. alextended
    May 2, 2021
    10
    Es una obra maestra en todos los sentidos este y automata representan una de las historias más avanzadas en los videojuegos mis juegos de la decada.
  21. YokoHugo
    May 6, 2021
    8
    La remasterización de una obra maestra de la época de Ps3, renovada con nuevos gráficos, modelados y un mayor rendimiento. Algo que creo que se debe aclarar es que el padre nunca fue el protagonista original, siempre fue el hermano de la versión japonesa. Algunos creen que la relación padre-hijo era mejor, pero creo que la relación entre hermanos puede ser igual o más fuerte.
    De nuevo,    La remasterización de una obra maestra de la época de Ps3, renovada con nuevos gráficos, modelados y un mayor rendimiento. Algo que creo que se debe aclarar es que el padre nunca fue el protagonista original, siempre fue el hermano de la versión japonesa. Algunos creen que la relación padre-hijo era mejor, pero creo que la relación entre hermanos puede ser igual o más fuerte.
    De nuevo, nos encontramos con un muy buen juego de la mano de Yoko Taro. Personajes complejos y entrañables, cada uno con su trasfondo (bastante tristes todos), música excepcional y un apartado gráfico que no revoluciona, pero da la talla. Un sistema de combate que se nota que no ha tenido la buena mano de platinum games pero que no molesta en lo absoluto. De nuevo, el primer final es sólo el inicio, y cada nueva ruta desgrana más historia que cada vez hace a la trama más interesante. Cometiendo el mismo error que siempre en esta saga, aunque las misiones secundarias aportan historia siguen siendo aburridas. El juego da lugar a muchas teorías y sus finales te dejan pensando, lo cual me gusta mucho. Es un juego que no puede faltar en las estanterías de los fans de la saga o de Yoko Yaro, y que tampoco dejaría de aconsejar a los recién llegados, aunque su arranque sea algo lento.    … Expand
  22. KAZEK
    May 10, 2021
    10
    Super historia dobry system walki niezwykła muzyka. Gra jedyna w swoim rodzaju
  23. Brohan
    May 14, 2021
    9
    I had a blast with this game. I know some people complain about some of the side quests, but some of the stories in this quests were enjoyable. However backtracking as well as well replaying the game multiple times to get all the endings did feel cumbersome at times. The story, combat and everything else were amazing. If you feel the game feels too easy on normal, play on hard. EnemiesI had a blast with this game. I know some people complain about some of the side quests, but some of the stories in this quests were enjoyable. However backtracking as well as well replaying the game multiple times to get all the endings did feel cumbersome at times. The story, combat and everything else were amazing. If you feel the game feels too easy on normal, play on hard. Enemies may feel like “sponges” at first but if you knock them down by parrying or using the right spell, you can finish them off easily with the circle button.… Expand
  24. Mayhem365
    May 18, 2021
    9
    I never played the original but was in love with the sequel Nier Automata. This game is a great prequel and I really hope for another game in this series.
  25. nahobino5_
    Jun 22, 2021
    10
    One of the best games for people who like gorgeous adventures with beautiful anime-style characters! The story is very deep and emotional, accompanied by one of the best gaming soundtracks ever. Nier never disappoints. Most sidequests are completely optional and so is grinding materials to max out all weapons. These two parts can get tedious, but if you're not playing the game to collectOne of the best games for people who like gorgeous adventures with beautiful anime-style characters! The story is very deep and emotional, accompanied by one of the best gaming soundtracks ever. Nier never disappoints. Most sidequests are completely optional and so is grinding materials to max out all weapons. These two parts can get tedious, but if you're not playing the game to collect trophies, it's no issue. My only wish is for the game to be longer because I enjoyed every minute playing it!… Expand
  26. Avaton
    Jul 18, 2021
    8
    Undubletly the best part of the game is the OST.
    I'm coming from Nier Automata, and I've played this Replicant only with this Remake.
    And after all I can see the OST, and a good part of the plot, as the best thing that came from this. The gameplay of course work, but I find that the Nier Automata gameplay it's still much better than this one. (and the side quests aren't always so    Undubletly the best part of the game is the OST.
    I'm coming from Nier Automata, and I've played this Replicant only with this Remake.
    And after all I can see the OST, and a good part of the plot, as the best thing that came from this.

    The gameplay of course work, but I find that the Nier Automata gameplay it's still much better than this one.
    (and the side quests aren't always so interesting to do)

    But, overall, (even with some flaws) it's always a pretty cool game anyway.    … Expand
  27. PMG-Writer
    Aug 8, 2021
    8
    Thus, the revised version "NieR Replicant" is a lot of fun. The storyline can keep you glued to the console for a long time. While the missions are good, the side quests could have used more variety. Thanks to the exciting battle system and excellent boss fights, you get a lot for the money. The graphical performance could simply have been more. In return, the reworked music tracks justThus, the revised version "NieR Replicant" is a lot of fun. The storyline can keep you glued to the console for a long time. While the missions are good, the side quests could have used more variety. Thanks to the exciting battle system and excellent boss fights, you get a lot for the money. The graphical performance could simply have been more. In return, the reworked music tracks just sound great. If you like to experience a classic on the console, you should take a look at "NieR Replicant".… Expand
  28. DartFeld
    Nov 9, 2021
    10
    a good introduction to make you a fan of nier series , with many endings to see.
  29. AntonioDS94
    Dec 13, 2021
    8
    Per me è 8 bella la trama e le quest principali la cosa più brutta sono le missioni secondarie troppo strane per il suo genere di gioco e bello il comparto sonoro.
  30. FermiAltair
    Aug 31, 2023
    9
    Excelent game, since music, landscapes, characters, lore, everything is cool, the story can be a little be better than automata, but this games came first and this is the remastered version so if you never pplayed the Nier original (like) i can assure you love this game.
  31. Ygs
    Feb 22, 2022
    9
    nier replicant may not be the same as the previous version, but it is still a great enjoyable experience that should not be missed. The gameplay is better than the version, but it has regressed in terms of visual effects.
  32. juantxisimo
    Sep 16, 2022
    10
    Well, I acknowledge that graphics are pretty outdated, but it makes up for it with the fluid gameplay. And then, the story, soundtrack, environment and characters this game has has literally changed my life
  33. nfs7379
    Sep 4, 2022
    9
    9/10.......................................................................
  34. Rhex98
    Jan 7, 2023
    9
    Una versión mejorada del Nier de ps3, mejora en todos los sentidos y la vuelve en una gran experiencia en la cual se cuenta una historia increíble y conmovedora. En donde más flaquea es en el gameplay el cual puede ser estar bien, pero es notablemente inferior al de Nier Automata, igualmente altamente recomendado para los que disfruten de obras que buscan sorprenderte.
  35. toscx_playa
    Jul 28, 2022
    9
    I really liked this game, despite the fact that I did not complete it, I put 9/10, because bosses can be difficult in some tasks.
  36. frantisekbarta
    Nov 14, 2022
    10
    I played Automata first and I liked it a lot, it is a beautiful game. But Replicant, at least in my opinion, is the real deal... Great story, writing, humor, voice acting, varying gameplay, music, and visuals - every aspect is astounding, and together they form an exceptional experience. It became one of my favourite games. I knew that Robin's excitement during "Nier 2" reveal had to basedI played Automata first and I liked it a lot, it is a beautiful game. But Replicant, at least in my opinion, is the real deal... Great story, writing, humor, voice acting, varying gameplay, music, and visuals - every aspect is astounding, and together they form an exceptional experience. It became one of my favourite games. I knew that Robin's excitement during "Nier 2" reveal had to based on something... (Check the "Nier 2 Reveal Live Reaction - Robin explodiert (NieR Automata)" video on YT).… Expand
  37. gamingdork
    Dec 14, 2022
    8
    Story ,characters are well written and it perfectly takes the combat system of nier automata and applies it to 2010's Nier Gestalt . Environment is great and characters are memorable .
    My issues with this game are that fetch quest are not as simple as that of in automata and requires a little grind and also you have to play through the game 3 times in total to get to Ending D and Ending E    Story ,characters are well written and it perfectly takes the combat system of nier automata and applies it to 2010's Nier Gestalt . Environment is great and characters are memorable .
    My issues with this game are that fetch quest are not as simple as that of in automata and requires a little grind and also you have to play through the game 3 times in total to get to Ending D and Ending E is not even hinted anywhere which is a significant portion of the game. Reason I deducted 2 points otherwise it's a fantastic Action RPG    … Expand
  38. AdoMobA
    Mar 13, 2023
    10
    Pros
    - one of the best subversive hero stories ever told
    - fantastic character writing with motivations that are understandable yet unjustifiable - a beautiful soundtrack that compliments any and every scene - one of the best ending twists ever pulled off in any media Cons - archaic side quest design that features a lot of back and forth without much payoff - while route C and D    Pros
    - one of the best subversive hero stories ever told
    - fantastic character writing with motivations that are understandable yet unjustifiable
    - a beautiful soundtrack that compliments any and every scene
    - one of the best ending twists ever pulled off in any media

    Cons
    - archaic side quest design that features a lot of back and forth without much payoff
    - while route C and D feature different endings they are nearly identical story wise when it comes to route B
    - some of the most god awful loot drops for a single player game (if you are going for the platinum and farming for specific materials - spent nearly 35 hours out of my 60 hour playthrough farming materials to get the Upgrade 33 weapons Achievement)

    Nier Replicant as a whole, serves as one of the best shining examples of a flawed masterpiece still being a masterpiece. Yes, most of the side quests are boring fetch quests. Yes it gets repetitive during route C and D. And yes the loot chances suck. But what you get in return, is an experience you won't find anywhere else.

    Replicant as a story pulls off one of the most remarkable twists I have ever seen, while not really chastising the players for that twist. It delivers a gut punch to sour the sweet taste victory while also remaining beautifully wistful and depressing throughout.

    And while I might have called the side quests mostly uninspired, there are definite standouts. Off the top of my head, the whole questline concerning the Lighthouse lady is one of my favorite moments from the game. An innocuous side quest dealing with a man conning a bunch of women from the surrounding cities expands on a main quest storyline ten hours after you've done it, making it somehow even more tragic.

    The party of adventurers is also a standout. NieR, Weiss, Kainé and Emil are my personal favorite party in gaming, as they bounce off each other amazingly, making all of their dialogue burst with personality. The rest of the cast are no slouches either, bringing up moments that made me tear up.

    All of this is underlined by the beauty of a soundtrack, allowing the story to pop off the screen in bright and beautiful color. Kainé/Salvation being my favorite, only slightly beating out Song of the Ancients. A strong OST that does not slouch at any point.

    I wholeheartedly recommend NieR Replicant as one of gaming's best stories ever told.    … Expand
  39. SebastianNovaro
    Jun 25, 2023
    9
    This game definitely have some flaws but still been a very good experience to enjoy
  40. TheBigTicket
    Jun 28, 2023
    10
    I am not sure if this game is better than Automata but the story hit me even harder, some of the endings literally had me in tears.

    Gameplay wise it is much better than the original but not on the level of Automata, the soundtrack is equally as amazing and the 3 main characters are extremely well written.
next
Page:

Awards & Rankings

11
#11 Best PS4 Game of 2021
6
#6 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2021

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
83

Generally favorable reviews - based on 91 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 84 out of 91
  2. Mixed: 7 out of 91
  3. Negative: 0 out of 91
  1. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Feb 15, 2022
    80
    Nier: Replicant is a game for true fans of action JRPGs. For those who have the patience to overcome the slow start and generic environments. And who are willing to play the game several times to fully understand what it was about. They will definitely be rewarded.
  2. CD-Action
    Nov 19, 2021
    80
    As a remake, NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139... is a bit disappointing, because in terms of graphics it only reached the level of NieR Automata, which means it doesn’t look great. The content, however, is still brilliant. It’s an amazing adventure you must experience. [06/2021, p.36]
  3. IGN Japan
    Jul 6, 2021
    90
    If anything, the amazing story of the original Nier has only become more valuable today than it already was back in the day. While many elements have received a significant update, some remain the same, but the story more than makes up for it.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »