MLB 15: The Show

 PlayStation 4
User Score
7.7

Generally favorable reviews- based on 199 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 144 out of 199
  2. Mixed: 28 out of 199
  3. Negative: 27 out of 199
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. darkmuk
    Apr 6, 2015
    10
    I've never played last series of the show before, also i'm not a big baseball fan. but I can tell you this, so addictive and fun. I bet you will love this game, even if you have no interest in baseball like me. I can't stop playing the show 15!
  2. WVUSHEP5884
    Apr 22, 2015
    9
    The Show is an amazing game!! Very realistic to actual baseball. The dynamic difficulty is great and the graphics are superb! Not to mention the gameplay is great as well! Go Cards!!!!
  3. skrill3d
    May 11, 2015
    10
    Easily the greatest baseball game I've ever played. It's incredibly realistic and the games feel and play out like you'd expect in real baseball. Definitely worth picking up.
  4. xbeefsupreme27x
    Apr 21, 2015
    9
    Since '08, The Show has been the best (now only) baseball sim on the console market. Each year there are subtle tweaks that edge it closer to perfection. The player models, however, are beginning to show their age. Give or take a few framerate hiccups, this game in motion is something to behold. Unless you're still clinging to a modded MVP 2005 or High Heat, this is the way to go for baseball.
  5. Rell
    Apr 10, 2015
    9
    Featuring a bunch of improvements over last year, with the much anticipated licensed gear, it's definitely worth the price of admission. Graphics and lighting has gone up a notch, and animations are more lifelike. I've played several games online and in diamond dynasty with absolutely no lag, maybe a hiccup during camera cuts but not any during gameplay.

    If you like baseball, this game    Featuring a bunch of improvements over last year, with the much anticipated licensed gear, it's definitely worth the price of admission. Graphics and lighting has gone up a notch, and animations are more lifelike. I've played several games online and in diamond dynasty with absolutely no lag, maybe a hiccup during camera cuts but not any during gameplay.

    If you like baseball, this game is a must. If you don't, you should still consider this great sports sim. Varied umpire calls, dirt that kicks up along with grass from a ground ball, to the hot dog guy screaming "hot dogs!".. This game is the real deal    … Expand
  6. GRaider
    Apr 8, 2015
    8
    Another fantastic rendition of MLB. The game is finally beginning to look like a next gen title with updated graphics, physics etc. The loading times are VASTLY improved which makes a huge difference if you play RTTS. There are still legacy issues like no closed dome options, sloppy uniform details etc but if you love baseball you can go no wrong with this.

    For next year though I'd like    Another fantastic rendition of MLB. The game is finally beginning to look like a next gen title with updated graphics, physics etc. The loading times are VASTLY improved which makes a huge difference if you play RTTS. There are still legacy issues like no closed dome options, sloppy uniform details etc but if you love baseball you can go no wrong with this.

    For next year though I'd like to see, closed/retractable roofs. Much better uniforms like vests, correct material textures, correct logo scaling and just pay attention to the details more (twins missing stripe, wrong A's road batting helmet, white stripes missing from road jays uniform all need fixed just to name a few)    … Expand
  7. JohnsonStJonson
    Jun 16, 2015
    9
    THE HOOK!!! gotcha sucker. My relationship with this game started off on rocky terms as it was not the game I intended to buy. I must have gotten the football/fútbol translation mixed up, but it's all good because I came out with a gem. The Franchise mode for the game is simple, yet sensual. The online play is my favorite part, but I still can't seem to find my favorite team to play with.THE HOOK!!! gotcha sucker. My relationship with this game started off on rocky terms as it was not the game I intended to buy. I must have gotten the football/fútbol translation mixed up, but it's all good because I came out with a gem. The Franchise mode for the game is simple, yet sensual. The online play is my favorite part, but I still can't seem to find my favorite team to play with. I guess putting Manchester United in the game would've been an unfair advantage against the other teams. In Summation, I get a tingly feeling in my clavicle when I get a hit, so 9/10. Would've been 10/10 if the Marlins had those Latina cheerleaders.… Expand
  8. dajuand23
    Mar 31, 2015
    10
    MLB 15: The Show proves once again why it is the crowned jewel of baseball simulation. With a ton of new features, including General Manager mode, this game packs a punch. The gameplay style is very similar to last year but I am a firm believer in the saying, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." If you are looking for a huge leap in this department do not bother as you will be disappointedMLB 15: The Show proves once again why it is the crowned jewel of baseball simulation. With a ton of new features, including General Manager mode, this game packs a punch. The gameplay style is very similar to last year but I am a firm believer in the saying, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." If you are looking for a huge leap in this department do not bother as you will be disappointed but if you love it, then you will be super excited and will be able to pick up right where you left off. If you are a diehard fan of Road to the Show mode, which is my personal favorite, you will love the ability to carry your saved game over from last years game and continue on your quest to being a future Hall of Fame player. If you are a baseball fan, you have to give this game a try!… Expand
  9. polishwonder
    Apr 1, 2015
    10
    I've played Baseball all my life from High school, college then pros (AAA) and this is the best and most true Baseball game I have ever played. OH and people saying the graphics are not good, Please play a night game in any stadium like Baltimore and tell my the lighting is not awesome!! There people even on there Balconies watching the game in the back drops!! Game is amazing!!
  10. kjstap64
    Apr 3, 2015
    9
    Big fan of the MLB the Show series. This years rendition is a major improvement over previous years versions, without question. Not sure what others are playing who render a sub 5 rating. Sony has corrected many flaws that were present last year: poor bunting mechanics, ball to bat contact sounds etc. Fielding, hitting is much more fluid. Menus are reorganized and are more user friendly.Big fan of the MLB the Show series. This years rendition is a major improvement over previous years versions, without question. Not sure what others are playing who render a sub 5 rating. Sony has corrected many flaws that were present last year: poor bunting mechanics, ball to bat contact sounds etc. Fielding, hitting is much more fluid. Menus are reorganized and are more user friendly. Crowd effect is more lively and visually the game is stunning. Nice step up from 2014. On par with EA's MVP Baseball which says a lot. Card packs, Diamond Dynasty etc are pluses. Wish there were throwback stadiums in PS4 bur there's always next year. Thanks Sony for a fun game of Baseball-you've captured the true essence of the Game.… Expand
  11. Cracker03
    Apr 3, 2015
    9
    The guy giving this a zero is a tool. I've played every year, last years being the worst, this years it's more fluid, faster load times, new modes, all kinds of gear, those saying its wonky don't hold the darn joystick hard, it makes it possible to have errors, in past years u could hold the joystick left or right and never move, when u accomplish something u feel great about it, hittingThe guy giving this a zero is a tool. I've played every year, last years being the worst, this years it's more fluid, faster load times, new modes, all kinds of gear, those saying its wonky don't hold the darn joystick hard, it makes it possible to have errors, in past years u could hold the joystick left or right and never move, when u accomplish something u feel great about it, hitting the perfect accuracy on a pitch and striking a due out is epic, I mean mccutchens cologne before a game come on now!… Expand
  12. TheMarine316
    Apr 8, 2015
    10
    I find it funny how jaded and well flat out stupid some reviewers can be these days when dealing with franchises that have been around a while, especially sports games, it's as if it doesn't bring some new mechanic that completely changes the experience then people cry about how it's just a re-pasted version of the previous game.... the reason I bring this up is because my first experienceI find it funny how jaded and well flat out stupid some reviewers can be these days when dealing with franchises that have been around a while, especially sports games, it's as if it doesn't bring some new mechanic that completely changes the experience then people cry about how it's just a re-pasted version of the previous game.... the reason I bring this up is because my first experience with this franchise was MLB 09: The show and it hooked me right off the Bat (No pun intended) I've played every game in the series since then and every years the game only improves each and every year but you wouldn't know it from reviews, previous versions of this game like the 09 version and 2010 version got 9's across the board yet this years version struggles to get 8's, this makes no sense to me especially considering it's more or less the same game as the 09 or 2010 version that were getting massive praise but with added features and even more unbelievable realism, that's why I feel with these repeat sports games people are just jaded or stupid, The MLB games are the most realistic sports games i've ever played, sometimes you need to do a double take to make sure it's a video game and not an actual live game on TV.... as I said this franchise only gets better and it baffles me how a franchise that used to get near perfect scores in the past struggles now and gets a lot of 7's and 8's now when it gets vastly better year single year, it's not exactly a 10, i'd give it a 9.5 but since this scale doesn't don't .5's i'll give it a 10 because it deserves better love from reviewers then it's been getting.… Expand
  13. killab1984
    Apr 5, 2015
    10
    5 games into my franchise season and its becoming pretty clear I'll be playing this edition of the show for some time to come. Fluid animations and better lighting are prolly the 2 biggest changes and while that might not sound like a lot it really makes a difference. I'm using the pure analog pitching setting and it is siiiick. You may have to change some settings on ur tv to eliminate a5 games into my franchise season and its becoming pretty clear I'll be playing this edition of the show for some time to come. Fluid animations and better lighting are prolly the 2 biggest changes and while that might not sound like a lot it really makes a difference. I'm using the pure analog pitching setting and it is siiiick. You may have to change some settings on ur tv to eliminate a black border on the screen set ur tv settings to 16:9 and you'll be using every inch of ur screen. In conclusion its early yet but A-rods leading the league in hrs after 5 games and Tanka has 20+ strikeouts in 2 games. So go Yankees and go Sony you hit it outta the park.… Expand
  14. StealthyK1LLs
    Apr 6, 2015
    9
    Hey, like I always say, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. More of the same, but it's still the best sports game right now. Saying it's bad because it's the same as the last one is like saying the new Lamborghini is bad because it has the same horsepower as the last one. Great game.
  15. PipeLn
    Mar 31, 2015
    10
    Difficult to explore every feature in a single day but I can say this is hands down the best baseball game I have played in forever. Lots of options, graphics are a 10, sounds are pretty awesome, crowd is dynamic, player stances and how they carry themselves 10, fun factor is a 12 so far. If there are only minor changes from last year then I have to say the poor reviews are just the 10%Difficult to explore every feature in a single day but I can say this is hands down the best baseball game I have played in forever. Lots of options, graphics are a 10, sounds are pretty awesome, crowd is dynamic, player stances and how they carry themselves 10, fun factor is a 12 so far. If there are only minor changes from last year then I have to say the poor reviews are just the 10% never happy crowd. There are no competitors to this game in the current market and it was well worth my $69.99 for the complete version.

    I come here and read reviews and noticed the bad ones here. "I have to say it, someone has to. It's basically the same game as last years! I was so angry around 1am. I thought "omg it's the same game again, what lies!" The stupid editions are not worthy of an upgrade. Pitching is the same, hitting is the same except now there's directional batting....stupid!."

    Why? a 2? what gives because last year was the best baseball hands down too and no one thinks changing a good thing too much is better. I give this reviewer a 1!!!    … Expand
  16. jdd1369
    Apr 1, 2015
    10
    Best baseball sim I have ever played, the fielding the fields alone make the game worth buying, best looking game I have played graphically, diamond dynasty adds a new fun to it. New directional hitting, pitching and more this game is worth it!
  17. Weedfly
    Apr 1, 2015
    9
    Most complete sports game, only miss an online road to the show mode for perfection. Great presentation, smooth gameplay, Dynamic hitting and pitching are great too. I love it.
  18. Habbsinator
    Apr 1, 2015
    10
    By far the best version of The Show, been playing since '08 and they've really smoothed out all the camera movements. Online play has zero lag that Ive encountered in around 20 games, and the changes to some of the Franchise and Diamond Dynasty modes are welcome additions to this gem of a series. If you're on the fence whether its worth the upgrade, 100% YES it is... the Online playBy far the best version of The Show, been playing since '08 and they've really smoothed out all the camera movements. Online play has zero lag that Ive encountered in around 20 games, and the changes to some of the Franchise and Diamond Dynasty modes are welcome additions to this gem of a series. If you're on the fence whether its worth the upgrade, 100% YES it is... the Online play alone is worth it since '14 sucked the big one with glitches and lag galore no matter your connection.… Expand
  19. jg7884
    Apr 1, 2015
    9
    I was hesitant to buy this game because of how awful last years game for PS4 was. However, I wasn't let down this time. The graphics are noticeably better, unlike last years ps3 port. The pitching interface is way better than the past couple years. It's almost like mvp baseball again. There is new audio commentary which helps a lot and different animations. The stadiums look insanely real.I was hesitant to buy this game because of how awful last years game for PS4 was. However, I wasn't let down this time. The graphics are noticeably better, unlike last years ps3 port. The pitching interface is way better than the past couple years. It's almost like mvp baseball again. There is new audio commentary which helps a lot and different animations. The stadiums look insanely real. Most importantly you can challenge your friends to online head to head matches with ease. online play is as smooth as nba2k which is a big plus considering how awful last years was overall. Much improved. Worth buying… Expand
  20. patchez_sanrick
    Apr 1, 2015
    10
    Last year, Online play was choppy, poor, horrible. This year has been very promising so far. I have played a couple of online games now and they were smooth and flawless. Offline play is gorgeous as usual.
  21. baseballben
    Mar 31, 2015
    10
    The best sports franchise returns again for another home run! Gameplay, graphics, simulation realism, all top-notch. As a hardcore player of franchise mode, I couldn't be more thrilled about edit-able contracts and the addition of trade finder. The menus look a lot better than last year's, and it's overall just a better game.
  22. boynamedluke
    Mar 31, 2015
    10
    The Show is INCREDIBLE!! I'll be honest, the last baseball game I played is Bases Loaded on NES... but for a guy that plays everything but sports games, I'm having a blast. Looks great, feels empowering.
  23. stryderHD
    Mar 31, 2015
    9
    Much of the same great gameplay and additions of new lightiing, time of day and directional batting, adding a new splash of features helps and give us a very solid MLB gaming experience. I just wish they'd change the same commentators we have had for what seems 5+ years now.
  24. sudsy17
    Apr 1, 2015
    10
    Absolutely loving it this year! The fielding is much nicer and the online plays so much smoother than in previous games. Diamond Dynasty is fantastic, very addictive fun. The only drawback here is I couldn't put my team up against my friends team (may be able to and I just cant figure it out). The new hitting is easily the biggest improvement in my eyes and allows me to actually moveAbsolutely loving it this year! The fielding is much nicer and the online plays so much smoother than in previous games. Diamond Dynasty is fantastic, very addictive fun. The only drawback here is I couldn't put my team up against my friends team (may be able to and I just cant figure it out). The new hitting is easily the biggest improvement in my eyes and allows me to actually move runners over and hit the ball in the direction that I want if I wait for the right pitch. The new equipment is an alright addition but doesn't add much imo. The trophies are MUCH better this year and for once it will be fun to actually trophy hunt as I play the show series which extends the game IMO. Overall I'm loving this one.… Expand
  25. Hotnhealthy
    Apr 1, 2015
    10
    I love this game. I liked MLB 14 for PS4. This new game fixes everything that I hate about last years version of MLB The Show. MLB 15 improves the PS4 load times. I would get so board waiting for 14 to load. I would wait as the diamond
  26. ps4lover
    Mar 31, 2015
    10
    wow this game is amazing. Graphic, gameplay, real time seasonal sun and shadows are excellent. Fielding improved much better. pitching mechanic improved pretty much better than 14
  27. Trimdeezy
    Apr 1, 2015
    8
    First off?

    Anyone who'd take time out of their life - stop to leave a 0 for this game - THE SHOW, as their 2nd review ever - and taking even more time out of their life to review R.B.I. baseball (and gave it a 10, truly, one of the worst games I've ever played, in general), is in DESPERATE need of a hooker. I mean, I get it - It's common knowledge when a trick run out of **** to do,    First off?

    Anyone who'd take time out of their life - stop to leave a 0 for this game - THE SHOW, as their 2nd review ever - and taking even more time out of their life to review R.B.I. baseball (and gave it a 10, truly, one of the worst games I've ever played, in general), is in DESPERATE need of a hooker. I mean, I get it - It's common knowledge when a trick run out of **** to do, they get behind a keyboard and take out their tantrums on the video game system they don't like.

    BUT DAMN Hcliffed!?! I mean, it was hard enough to say "video game systems he didnt like" without shaking my head - but it's damn near heartbreaking when you realize how close to the truth I am. Trust me son; Life gets better - and one day, you'll look back and remember a time when you didn't find significance in fighting a video game war (lol SEE? Read it back to me. "Video game war." You get any medals for that? lol)

    On to the beef: I can tell you how much you'll like MLB The Show 15 by you asnwering one question;

    Did you own MLB The Show 13 and still LOVE & ADORE MLB The Show 14? Yes? Then you'll more than likely LOVE MLB 15.

    Were you disappointed with 14? Then, guess what? You run the gambit - Probably 50% chance you may be slightly to moderately disappointed with MLB15 - unless you're really looking out for subtle improvements - of which, there are plenty.

    For me? Those subtleties? They add up - so skipping to the end - My conclusion is, it's a GREAT game (what an "8" really should be) and I'll be playing it all damn summer.

    Now...

    Is it ground breaking? No.

    Is it an improvement? Oh yeah. How much? Depends on what you wanted.

    If you asked me - Is The Show 15 the best baseball game on the planet? No question, yes - will be my answer - especially with the new logo editors and community content that we always get (OFSM - you KNOW what it is - cant wait for that OFSM to drop).

    Was I disappointed on some levels? Yes. No doubt.

    1. No sounds of the show (LOVED Sounds of The Show for PS3; Loved having fat ass Griffey Junior coming out to NBN - That said? I'm quite sure we can blame Sony Music Unlimited; this is due to a PS4 hardware issue for lack of native mp3 support - nothing SD Studios could do about it sadly - still, I was hoping THEY'd of spurred change on behalf of SCEA).

    2. Not as much equipment as I was looking for - Also, with real equipment? I was hoping for real stadium ad's billboards and restaurant names. Still swing and a miss

    3. Lastly? I DO understand the complaint about the commentary. First of all; most people have NO idea how much it costs to pay for play by play commentary in A BASEBALL GAME. This aint Golf, Trick; But... Anyone who's been a fan of any team who had a truly great announcer (Dave Niehaus for me) knows how much personality it can give the sport. For me? I have just as much wonderful memories of baseball just listening to the radio call as I do watching it on TV. It can mean a lot - and yes! It's VERY expensive to voice a baseball game... but were not asking for every year, here. To me, I've felt like it's been the exact same for over 3 years. I know thats not %100 true; but if it's giving me that impression? They aren't doing enough to mix it up. You dont need a full new track every year but Im hoping they figure this out eventually. Inject more variety; even if you have to add to it bit by bit, every year.

    There are a few more disappointments, but all relatively minor.

    Otherwise? Its the Show 14; but faster, smoother, tighter, crisper, visually more impressive; Directional hitting? Love it pulling the ball on the right pitch inside; A real cut off man that AI runner will react to??? YES PLEASE. The ambiance? Is even better, and Im still not sure how its possible - and HOLY CRAP I can play online without desync in the 2nd inning?!?! Maybe I should give it a 9 for that alone (Did you FINALLY learn your lesson SCEA?)

    But like many; my expectations were pretty high. Largely? They were met - I cant see this being any more than a 9; or any less than a 7, again depending on reasonable expectation, your objectivity and love of baseball. Could be higher - could be lower

    A zero? A two? And you've never had to settle with 2k13 or RBI Baseball.

    Now... If you've never had the show before? And say you LOVE baseball as much as the rest of us do?

    Jesus... Boy, I WISH I was you - because if you jump into the show now? With MLB 15 being your first time? Your head is going to explode.

    The rest of us? You already know what you're getting here. It's like.... the Show 11 was a birthday cake - and you know you can add a bit more icing, some sparkly candles - you can cut it however you want... it's still cake.

    And it tastes better than last years cake.

    Go pick it up - I promise you this, it's worth a try - not any less than eharmony is worth a shot to a console fanboy's chances of finally getting lai    … Expand
  28. whiteuncledrew
    Mar 31, 2015
    9
    The game is no where near the same as last year... Of course some of the gameplay is going to feel the same because the gameplay has been near perfect for years now... why change it? A fully revamped Diamond Dynasty which actually has my attention now as opposed to last years, a ton of new additions and improvements to the franchise and LICENSED EQUIPMENT FINALLY. This game is no whereThe game is no where near the same as last year... Of course some of the gameplay is going to feel the same because the gameplay has been near perfect for years now... why change it? A fully revamped Diamond Dynasty which actually has my attention now as opposed to last years, a ton of new additions and improvements to the franchise and LICENSED EQUIPMENT FINALLY. This game is no where near the same as last year and is definitely worth your money if you're a baseball fan or a fan of sports in general. Unlike other sport games that just try to lure you into buying 100 of dollars worth of packs for ultimate team; The show really focuses on its core gameplay first and foremost and then focuses on the other stuff. A must buy.… Expand
  29. scottysauce
    Apr 5, 2015
    10
    Ok so I'm 41 years old and I've been playing all sorts of games over the years in all sorts of forms. So I've made it an effort to stay clear of any baseball games on all platforms because it's just so darn slow and tedious. Since getting a PS4 I've been bored with the selection of great games and I needed a break from Bloodborne so I picked this up and I'm so glad I did. Like I said I'veOk so I'm 41 years old and I've been playing all sorts of games over the years in all sorts of forms. So I've made it an effort to stay clear of any baseball games on all platforms because it's just so darn slow and tedious. Since getting a PS4 I've been bored with the selection of great games and I needed a break from Bloodborne so I picked this up and I'm so glad I did. Like I said I've been so over these games for years but I'm frigging loving this game. There is so much to do and so much improvement all over the board it's simply stunning. Love this!! Get this!! Wow!!! More legends please in dlc!… Expand
  30. LolzGames
    Apr 3, 2015
    10
    TONS of new features are now in the game. The radio show and sponsorships adds a realistic edge to the game. Gm Contracts adds tough a challenge thats a very fun addition. The game is one of the best MLB the show games and baseball games ever.
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

59
#59 Best PS4 Game of 2015
53
#53 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2015

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
80

Generally favorable reviews - based on 44 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 38 out of 44
  2. Mixed: 6 out of 44
  3. Negative: 0 out of 44
  1. Sporting News
    Mar 2, 2016
    80
    For someone playing the series for the first time the commentary will sound pretty good. However those who do so year after year are sick and tired of hearing the same things and not having the emotion from the announcers to match the big moments. It's well past time for SCEA to make a change in this area.
    Read full review
  2. CD-Action
    Jul 4, 2015
    75
    Baseball simulation became even better but I still think it’s not the best sport to turn into a video game. There are just too many nuances – how you grip the bat, how your wrist works etc. – that are impossible to recreate. [07/2015, p.61]
  3. GameOver.gr
    Jun 2, 2015
    80
    With enough updates to keep you going for the next year, superb graphics and the ability to import your saves from the previous versions, The Show 15 probably is the best baseball game out there.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »