The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

 PC
User Score
9.1

Universal acclaim- based on 23035 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 20,928 out of 23035
  2. Mixed: 473 out of 23035
  3. Negative: 1,634 out of 23035
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. ALFRANCO
    Jun 21, 2020
    10
    A masterpiece, the only "complaint" that I could have is that there so many decisions that sometimes you don't even know what to do because you are afraid of what is coming.
    Good soundtrack, dialogues, gameplay and story
    It is a must buy
  2. Jaehaerys61
    Dec 25, 2019
    9
    Que dires de plus que ce qui à était dits pour ce jeux, rien à si juste rajouter les mods graphique qui améliore encore le jeux
  3. GrimmjowUK
    Feb 15, 2023
    10
    The best game ever. No game can surpass the superiority of this game. You can feel like every npc is alive in this game, that keeps this game apart from all rpgs. Story, combat and diversity of choices are excellent. Thanks CD Projeckt Red.
  4. PIPOdeclown
    Apr 18, 2018
    10
    **** great in every aspect. Its deep in every way. Impossible achievement In the quantity with that amount of quality.

    Sex on a unicorn and you can have sexy sexy time with lots of women. Tons of hours, combat, story, armor, weapons, potions, bombs, crossbow Side quests, crafting, oils apply on weapons, Stones apply on weapons and armor, mutagen for stat increase, Deep leveling menu    **** great in every aspect. Its deep in every way. Impossible achievement In the quantity with that amount of quality.

    Sex on a unicorn and you can have sexy sexy time with lots of women.

    Tons of hours, combat, story, armor, weapons, potions, bombs, crossbow Side quests, crafting, oils apply on weapons, Stones apply on weapons and armor, mutagen for stat increase, Deep leveling menu for combat magic and crafting potions/bombs. Super support for over 3 years, its crazy.    … Expand
  5. Demon2017
    Jun 10, 2022
    10
    Шедевр на все времена. Все хейтеры пусть идут нафиг, потому что лучше этого из РПГ вы не найдёте. Играть всем обязательно
  6. MrDracky
    Jan 20, 2017
    10
    O jogo vem como final de uma trilogia de jogos (The Witcher 1 e 2), e diversas partes na história falam de um assunto dos jogos anteriores, então recomendo primeiro jogar pelo menos o 2 ou ver um resumo sobre eles para não se perder na história assim como me perdi na primeira vez que fui jogar hehe. Mas enfim, vamos direto ao ponto:

    Para mim esse jogo foi simplesmente o melhor jogo RPG    O jogo vem como final de uma trilogia de jogos (The Witcher 1 e 2), e diversas partes na história falam de um assunto dos jogos anteriores, então recomendo primeiro jogar pelo menos o 2 ou ver um resumo sobre eles para não se perder na história assim como me perdi na primeira vez que fui jogar hehe. Mas enfim, vamos direto ao ponto:

    Para mim esse jogo foi simplesmente o melhor jogo RPG que já joguei na minha vida, um pouco à frente de Skyrim, pois ele reúne todas as características base parar um ótimo RPG, e traz algo que acho que muitos deviam trazer; coisas para não ser enjoativo, principalmente por ser singleplayer, essas coisas seriam, história e personagens cativantes, minigames que poderiam sozinhos já serem um jogo(principalmente Gwent, garanto que será difícil encontra um minigame melhor em outros jogos), além de você poder guiar a história do seu jeito com as suas escolhas, o que dá a sensação de você ser mesmo o Geralt (personagem principal).

    E sobre os Cons do jogo e seus problemas?

    Eu realmente acho que além dos bugs, não são tantos mas muitos incomodam um pouco, como você estar correndo igual um idiota com seu cavalo Carpeado até que bate em uma árvore e cai para um lugar bugado e vazio, mas todo o terreno onde você estava continua lá em cima, aí você precisa retornar no último save, mas não há nenhum bug que chegue a bugar seu jogo pra sempre, é só voltar no save.
    O resto serão de probleminhas que muitas vezes vão do jogador, por exemplo, eu gostaria de poder bater em todo mundo roubar tudo e poder botar fogo nas vilas (não sou nada maudoso xiu aí), mas não é possível, acredito que é porque isso poderia contradizer partes da história, mas enfim de problema mesmo são só esses bugzinhos

    Depois de muita enrolação e blá blá blá da minha convivência com o jogo, vou finalizar minha avaliação:
    Ótimo, vale muito apena comprar e jogar, garanto que você irá se divertir muito! E passar muito nervoso se colocar no Marcha da Morte (Modo Ultra Hard), se você é amante de RPGs ou já jogou os anteriores é OBRIGATÓRIO comprar isso!
    Se você ainda não conhece o mundo dos RPGs singleplayer, vale a pena comprar mesmo assim, mas acho bom pesquisar gameplays antes.    … Expand
  7. ThatUDLegacy
    Feb 24, 2017
    10
    The Best Rpg Ever Made on the Best Platform, Pure bliss!
    i Thank you CdProjectRed for not screwing over gamer's like the other giant game makers.
    240 hours played while still having more content, Thank you for such a great game.
  8. ivan4o200
    Mar 28, 2018
    10
    An outstanding experience made with love. I cant have enough of this game cause every single playthrough different things happen.
  9. Mandra
    Apr 5, 2022
    10
    This game blows my mind in every aspect. Top story, graphics, audio, great characters, rich universe, a map with a billion things to discover (will please the completionists).

    A proper classic *clap*
  10. Mitya64
    Jul 3, 2018
    10
    . Куча квестов, охот на монстров. Сюжетка просто топ. Огромный мир. Появился конь плотва. Доработанные драки В общем игра не на одно прохождение, вы заходите пройти ее еще раз, но по другому
  11. Cumdonor69
    Jun 21, 2017
    9
    (Single player only review)
    Story: 10
    Gameplay: 8 Characters: 10 World: 10 Music: 10 Graphics: 10 Optimization: 9 Value: 10 Art direction: 10 Enjoyment: 8 Overall: 9 Reason for score: What kept it from getting a 10 from me was the fact that there was actually too many things to do. Stopped playing after 20 hours or so since it took me that long to get out of the tutorial area    (Single player only review)
    Story: 10
    Gameplay: 8
    Characters: 10
    World: 10
    Music: 10
    Graphics: 10
    Optimization: 9
    Value: 10
    Art direction: 10
    Enjoyment: 8
    Overall: 9
    Reason for score: What kept it from getting a 10 from me was the fact that there was actually too many things to do. Stopped playing after 20 hours or so since it took me that long to get out of the tutorial area which was a problem for me since I do like to play other games and do other things in life. Only got back and finished it after using cheats and mods. This complain is purely subjective and if this type of game is for you, then more power to you.    … Expand
  12. SkeletonCross
    Apr 8, 2018
    10
    As a game I've put over 200 hours in I can't do anything, but recomend it to people. The main story is amazing, and gets you in the edge of your seat. The world actually feels alive, the side quests are well written, and even have story to each quest. Unlike a lot of games the developers give you just enough to know what's going on and nothing more. it's briiliant they treat you likeAs a game I've put over 200 hours in I can't do anything, but recomend it to people. The main story is amazing, and gets you in the edge of your seat. The world actually feels alive, the side quests are well written, and even have story to each quest. Unlike a lot of games the developers give you just enough to know what's going on and nothing more. it's briiliant they treat you like you've been playing the game. Not a lof of games do that anymore. The graphics are amazing, and make mosts games look like they came out in the last gen. Every tree, dog, withch, and drowner looks breath taking. The scenery, and music are epic. When I say the music is epic I MEAN EPIC. It is THE BEST soundtrack in all of gaming. From the plains of velen to the mountains of skelige everything just perfectly fits together. Even the conversations in the game fell great. I don't think I could ever give a 10 to a game, but this one deserves it and rightfully so. Thank You CDprojektRed for the best game of this decade!… Expand
  13. MetalRobot69
    Jan 31, 2022
    7
    Don't give me wrong it is a great game but it isn't for my taste. I am a very story skewed player and the story wasn't the best for me. You pass hours searching for a girl that I don't even know (because I didn't know The Witcher universe).

    Saying that the gameplay is fun, it has very cool finishing animations and a good variety of monsters, though I don't think Gerald has many combat    Don't give me wrong it is a great game but it isn't for my taste. I am a very story skewed player and the story wasn't the best for me. You pass hours searching for a girl that I don't even know (because I didn't know The Witcher universe).

    Saying that the gameplay is fun, it has very cool finishing animations and a good variety of monsters, though I don't think Gerald has many combat moves, it is just the same attack with swords, dodge, block and one of few magics, BTW spawning quen you are pretty much invincible (I did that on the hardest difficulty and for me, the game was too easy).

    I liked way more the DLC Wine and Blood, for me that was 10/10 but the main story is kinda meh.    … Expand
  14. SelimDemirci
    Apr 24, 2018
    10
    HİKAYE:
    ömrümde oynadığım en iyi seri witcher serisidir tabi ben 2. ve 3. oyunları oynadım. 3 oyunu daha 40 saat oynadım ama dolu dolu oynadım. her an her köşeye bakıyorsunuz her yerde detay fışkırıyor çevre şahane gerek şehirler olsun gerek orman ortamı olsun oyun sizi kendisine bağlıyor,her karakterin ayrı bir hikayesini duymak her an bir yerde bilinmeyen bir ek görev çıkması, iki    HİKAYE:
    ömrümde oynadığım en iyi seri witcher serisidir tabi ben 2. ve 3. oyunları oynadım. 3 oyunu daha 40 saat oynadım ama dolu dolu oynadım. her an her köşeye bakıyorsunuz her yerde detay fışkırıyor çevre şahane gerek şehirler olsun gerek orman ortamı olsun oyun sizi kendisine bağlıyor,her karakterin ayrı bir hikayesini duymak her an bir yerde bilinmeyen bir ek görev çıkması, iki insanın arasında hikayeler anlatması sizi şaşırtıyor. ben şahsen okuyabildiğin her konuşma yazılarını okumaya çalışıyorum.
    ormanda geziniyorsunuz her an karşınıza vahşi bir canavar çıkabiliyor veya bir geyik sürüsüne rastlayabiliyorsunuz, orman sanki siz yokkende yaşıyor. 4 mevsim fırtınalar yağmurlar güneşli havanın güzelliği de ayrı bir eser doğrusu;
    ayrıca ana görevler harika hazırlanmış, soluksuz oynuyorsunuz asıl güzel olan yan görevler, tek bir yan görev bile gereksiz ve saçma değil sanki yan görevler bile ana görev gibi detaylı ve hikayesi var.

    GRAFİKLER:
    ben oyunu dizüstü pc'de oynuyorum ama güçlü bir pc ve oyunu high ayarlarda oynuyorum orman ve yeşillik daha çok son bahar havasında ama fırtına efektleri ve gece ortamı karanlık oluyor, güçlü bir bilgisayarınız var ise ulatra ayarlarda çok daha iyi bir görsel alabilirsiniz ben bu konuda uzman bir fikir veremiyorum.

    OYNANABİLİRLİK:
    rpg oyunu gibi görünüyor ama aksiyon tarafı da var menüler sade ve ortalama bir kaç saatte öğreniyorsunuz, karakterinizi geliştirmek biraz kafa yoruyor. iksirler mutajenler derken biraz sorlanabiliriniz, ayrıca karakterin de geliştirilmesig erkeiyor tabi burda genelde kılıçlar ve elbiseler önemli bu kişisel eşyalar genelde yan görevlerle toplanabiliyor veya parasıyla yaptırabiliyorsunuz. yan görevleri yapın en çok ordan para geliyor haberiniz olsun. tüm eşyaları toplayıp satabileceğiniz yerler araştırın,

    SONSÖZ:
    arkadaşlar alın ve aldırın ben rpg sevmem demeyin bu oyun eğer oyun oynamayı seven bireyseniz mutlaka oynamanız gereken bir başyapıt, tek bir kusuru tek bir hatası gözüme batmadı. bitmesin diye bir çırpıda bitirmemeye çalışıyorum.    … Expand
  15. JimmyJams
    Apr 26, 2018
    9
    Good game, something everyone with the slightest interest in story driven RPGs should play.

    Nice graphics, great writing and voice acting (side quests included), fly honies with fat asses, and all round challenging and engaging combat/rpg mechanics.

    Protip, igni and quen. Igni so you never have to bum a lighter to light your blunt and quen for eternal life amen.
  16. bartcbem
    Jul 27, 2019
    10
    In my eyes one of the best game of recent years. What CD Project did is stunning example that passion, dedication and hard work can produce unforgettable gaming experience.
    I have big respect for the studio and how they approach game development and their customers.
  17. AkumaJack
    Oct 4, 2017
    10
    This is a must play for quite everyone.
    Here's a list of pro and cons and then a more "in depth" review.
    PRO: +Huge world in which you can roam around freely +Build variety is on top, you can play the game in a lot of different ways +Quest and story are good and intresting +TONS of content. I've just finished the main game and it took me around 70+ hours. I havent completed all    This is a must play for quite everyone.
    Here's a list of pro and cons and then a more "in depth" review.

    PRO:
    +Huge world in which you can roam around freely
    +Build variety is on top, you can play the game in a lot of different ways
    +Quest and story are good and intresting
    +TONS of content. I've just finished the main game and it took me around 70+ hours. I havent completed all sidequests, or contracts or the DLCs (that i heard are extremely good and long)
    +Gwent

    Cons:
    -It is too easy maybe

    So, the review.
    The Witcher 3 is an open world action rpg and it is extremely good at both.
    First the open world part: You'll get something like 3 major areas in which you can go exploring and when i say three think about each one of them like the entire map of Fallout 3 or something like that. Every area has it's own ecosystem, its enviroment and its tradition. And in this huge, good looking and realistic map you'll have ALWAYS something to do because it is litterally filled with point of interest like hidden treasures or monsters caves and so on.
    I think you could easily spend 5 hours completing the PoI just of the prologue area (that is the smaller).
    And it is quite useful to do that because you'll get loot (swords, formulas ecc.) and EXP while fighting monsters gives you something like 1xp point per kill.

    Now for the Action part:
    The game is fast paced, especially if you go for a fast attack build like i did. You'll be spamming the right click every second. It is fun, there are a lot of non human enemies and unique bosses / minibosses. The problem is it can get quite to easy if you do every sidequest/contract and level up or if you use sick combos that can brake the game.
    Also it rarely forces you to really think about what to do in fights since you usually fights the same kind of enemy in every encounter and rarely different kinds in the same fight.
    Still quite fun because you have a lot of options at your disposal: attacks (both fast and heavy), signs, bombs, potions and so on.

    And last the RPG part:
    Is fantastic. One of the best thing of the game. Almost EVERY choice you take will change something sooner or later. I completed a quest in the begging just to discover 30 hours later that i could use the ending of that quest to convince an NPC to help because i was good.
    You can help your friends in the sidequests and they will remember. It is great. just great.
    Also you can roleplay the fight style you'd like more thanks to a TONS of skills that you can pick at every level you gain.

    conclusion:
    Is one of the best Open world RPG i've ever played.    … Expand
  18. Diegochocho
    Jul 3, 2018
    10
    CD Projekt lo hace una vez mas, supera por mucho al 2, en todos los aspectos.
    Para empezar el combate de por si es hermoso, puede que a la larga te sea repetitivo pero con todos los puntos que tiene este juego se te olvidara fácilmente. Los mapas son magníficos, te perdes explorando cada rincón con NPC tan vivos que te hacen creer que estas jugando con personas reales. El contenido    CD Projekt lo hace una vez mas, supera por mucho al 2, en todos los aspectos.
    Para empezar el combate de por si es hermoso, puede que a la larga te sea repetitivo pero con todos los puntos que tiene este juego se te olvidara fácilmente. Los mapas son magníficos, te perdes explorando cada rincón con NPC tan vivos que te hacen creer que estas jugando con personas reales. El contenido secundario esta trabajado hasta el ultimo detalle, y las misiones secundarias parecen misiones principales literalmente. Y de la historia ni que hablar, me saco el sombrero ante CD Projekt.    … Expand
  19. Deaden84
    Dec 24, 2019
    7
    Good story and nice game atmosphere drops behind of bad combat mechanics and unbalanced game play. Control schematics and other things are making this game hardly bearable. Even at easiest difficulty is being pain to play. Always dodge dodge hit dodge dodge hit which is boring and provide dull game play. Also if we compare with other RPG games, this one have a very bad shapedGood story and nice game atmosphere drops behind of bad combat mechanics and unbalanced game play. Control schematics and other things are making this game hardly bearable. Even at easiest difficulty is being pain to play. Always dodge dodge hit dodge dodge hit which is boring and provide dull game play. Also if we compare with other RPG games, this one have a very bad shaped Leveling/Experience design. Even they didn't care to fix their mistake over these years. If need risk and rewards, playing easiest or hard doesn't matter because nothing is rewarding you. So, playing easiest will be best option but don't expect it as easiest difficulty. Conclusion: Be realist and don't throw your coins to give over score. 7 point is fine for this game.… Expand
  20. Sv4roG
    Feb 3, 2019
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt is the best game ever, period. Everything from graphics, main story line, side quests, character building to sound and music is amazing. As close to perfection as I've ever seen.… Expand
  21. Arkane
    Apr 23, 2018
    10
    Great game. Couldn't be a better Story driven RPG out there. The characters have a amazing feel to them. The game feels alive and the story is the best there is. Even the DLC is better then some other games out there.
  22. Greko03
    Nov 5, 2019
    10
    Me pasé este juego 5 veces con todo y expansiones, aún así no acabé de descubrir todos sus secretos, es un juego que tiene fallos en varios aspectos, pero de alguna manera, el conjunto de gameplay, gráficos, historia, sonido y diseño en general lo hacen, para mi, un juego casi perfecto, lloré reí, me emocioné, sentí coraje y nostalgia, eso, pocos juegos lo logran, y eso es un gran mérito,Me pasé este juego 5 veces con todo y expansiones, aún así no acabé de descubrir todos sus secretos, es un juego que tiene fallos en varios aspectos, pero de alguna manera, el conjunto de gameplay, gráficos, historia, sonido y diseño en general lo hacen, para mi, un juego casi perfecto, lloré reí, me emocioné, sentí coraje y nostalgia, eso, pocos juegos lo logran, y eso es un gran mérito,
  23. Rgc
    Jul 4, 2017
    10
    Well I just bought the witcher 3 because I wanted to play on pc for a better experience and without a doubt is my favorite game of the generation (I still do not play tloz breath of the wild). The best of the video game is its storyline and story that is impressive, even the side missions have a good storyline and story behind it. The soundtrack is very captivating and complements veryWell I just bought the witcher 3 because I wanted to play on pc for a better experience and without a doubt is my favorite game of the generation (I still do not play tloz breath of the wild). The best of the video game is its storyline and story that is impressive, even the side missions have a good storyline and story behind it. The soundtrack is very captivating and complements very well with the game. The gameplay is very good. The graphics look very impressive on PC but on consoles they look worse but they look great too. It is a game that I recommend to those who are lovers of the open worlds and that a videogame has an interesting, abundant and profound history.… Expand
  24. auditbadger
    Aug 5, 2019
    9
    I think that this is truly a unique game and I would recommend that if you are a fan of this type of genre then I think you should give this game a try.
  25. Sh3riff
    Sep 8, 2017
    9
    Not so often you can find so good action game (its not so much RPG as others say - except for the talking part). Story is good, details are awesome, fights are epic .. except for the wolf pack parts.
  26. Benibla124
    Feb 23, 2019
    10
    I love this game! I bought the GOTY edition on sale for 20€ and completey enjoyed it. I played the game for 130 hours and it never became boring!
  27. DickDastardly
    Dec 6, 2019
    10
    Juegazo, la edición GOTY con las 2 expansiones por menos de 10 € cuando esta de oferta es un ragalazo. Horas y horas de contenido, super recomendado,
  28. LuKi965
    Oct 17, 2017
    10
    Huge, open world. Epic story line. Memorable characters. Very good combat system.
    Maybe year 2018 will change this state but as for now it's the best RPG ever created.
  29. Archound
    Nov 16, 2017
    10
    Well, the game is not completely flawless. Red Engine apparently does not take into account wind occlusion, so Geralt hair is always moving even in in-doors (that could be hardcoded i think, like an additional property for post process volumes windIntensity=0;). UI is slow, adrenaline meter is bugged (sometimes the middle bar glow constantly). Roach is sometimes doing weird movements.Well, the game is not completely flawless. Red Engine apparently does not take into account wind occlusion, so Geralt hair is always moving even in in-doors (that could be hardcoded i think, like an additional property for post process volumes windIntensity=0;). UI is slow, adrenaline meter is bugged (sometimes the middle bar glow constantly). Roach is sometimes doing weird movements.
    APART FROM that, the game is flawless and puts the new high standard in genre. 10/10.    … Expand
  30. andreyjmco
    Oct 27, 2017
    10
    I remeber playing Witcher 2 on it's release and just giving up after 20 some hours and never touching again.
    I remeber playing Witcher 3 on it's release and just giving up after 5 hours to play Madden Ultimate Team.
    And get highly frustrated to let this masterpiece go in exchange of a pay-to-win multiplayer. At first, The Witcher 3 gets you by hand and teaches you the basics of combat.    I remeber playing Witcher 2 on it's release and just giving up after 20 some hours and never touching again.
    I remeber playing Witcher 3 on it's release and just giving up after 5 hours to play Madden Ultimate Team.
    And get highly frustrated to let this masterpiece go in exchange of a pay-to-win multiplayer.
    At first, The Witcher 3 gets you by hand and teaches you the basics of combat. During the tutorial, you suddenly see there is a lot of options in combat to use, but i kept myself in the melee style. After completing the White Orchard tutorial, it just lets you go. "Go on, do whatever you wish". This is where i got lost. Did not know how to start and started dying after trying to beat some higher leveled monsters.
    When i came back to the game, in early 2016, i decided to follow the main quest. To never regret. The socio-political tone of the story drags you into the world of The Witcher. It makes you understand why stuff happen in the game, making you feel the dimensional difference between ordinary characters you'll find in the villages and cities (lots of them) and the main characters in the game (witcher, sorcerers, monsters, etc.). It makes you accomplish amazing magical stuff like travel through dimensions and at the same time ordinary village tasks like chase a goat. I kept going on and back between these dimensional differences and it made the game feel good to play.
    Combat IS SO MUCH BETTER than it was in The Witcher 2. Can't compare. It gives you options to choose between what kind of combat you'll adhere to. You can upgrade signs and burn enemies, take control of their minds or stun them with magic. Or you can master the swordsmanship and adapt you game to a counter-attack/melee approach to the enemies. You just choose.
    The variety of weapons and armor in the game is also a great point. You'll switch between a lot of them, until the very end of the game, when you'll probably find the ones to match your combat style. Just be patient.
    Soundtrack is amazing. Makes you really feel in the medieval era and sets the tone of the game in calm, action and cutscenes. "Wolven Storm" is a beautiful original soundtrack even in different languages, just check on YouTube.
    Don't forget to play both the DLC's. They're both amazing stories by themselves, bringing much more content than you'll ever imagined.
    I played this game on main quest, new game plus, the Heart of Stone DLC and the Blood and Wine DLC in a total of 488 hours and actually got SAD it ended.
    Until i've played this, Ocarina of Time was considered to be the best game ever created (and i've played hundreds of games since 1998). It just lost it's crown to The Witcher 3. Absolute masterpiece.    … Expand
Page:

Awards & Rankings

2
#2 Best PC Game of 2015
1
#1 Most Discussed PC Game of 2015
11
#11 Most Shared PC Game of 2015

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
93

Universal acclaim - based on 32 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 32 out of 32
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 32
  3. Negative: 0 out of 32
  1. RPGamer
    Jan 28, 2016
    90
    The Witcher 3 says no to all of this - it's a great game with a fully realized setting, it's a joy to play, the business model behind it treats its customers like human beings, and it delivers a story that finally hits the tone of the books.
    Read full review
  2. PCWorld
    Jan 20, 2016
    100
    Probably the best open-world RPG ever made, but it still falls prey to some of the genre's worst traps.
    Read full review
  3. PC Invasion
    Nov 4, 2015
    80
    I've made it pretty clear that it's hardly a flawless game, but that doesn't change the fact that The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is something pretty bloody special and you should absolutely play it.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »