Red Dead Redemption 2

 PC
User Score
6.8

Mixed or average reviews- based on 5614 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3,639 out of 5614
  2. Mixed: 316 out of 5614
  3. Negative: 1,659 out of 5614

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. animaltree
    Mar 31, 2020
    9
    Wow. This is the best game I have played so far in my life. Open world and story driven games are my favourite games so of course I'm going to love this. If you don't enjoy story games then you wont like this. Because - The story - AMAZING, long and detailed. The acting - AMAZING (and i dont say that often, i can pick up a **** actor on tv etc instantly and they often ruin it for me) TheWow. This is the best game I have played so far in my life. Open world and story driven games are my favourite games so of course I'm going to love this. If you don't enjoy story games then you wont like this. Because - The story - AMAZING, long and detailed. The acting - AMAZING (and i dont say that often, i can pick up a **** actor on tv etc instantly and they often ruin it for me) The graphics AMAZING and even the movements and facial expressions of Arthur, your horse and the other characters (even NPCs and wild animals too) are fantastic. The hunting system is great, its difficult to kill some tiny animals with a bloody bow and arrow but it makes it fun, so if you dont fancy doing some missions for a bit you can go hunting or do some challenges. The cooking/crafting system was strange at first but it makes sense and is quite simple really and quite enjoyable.
    This game is so realistic. It can be a very hard learning curve at the start and to be honest i nearly gave up this game after the first hour it really got on my nerves, specially when riding through towns and i kept knocking people over and getting bounties and witnesses to minor crimes (that was the most annoying bit throughout the game in all honesty) however i persevered and after a day or 2 i had learnt all the controls and nuances and I'm so glad I did.
    The missions are most of the time, different, and unexpected things happen in them. They can also be really long. The last few took me a week to complete, in fact I've been playing this game for the last 7 months, pretty much every other day with maybe the odd week break and that is how long its taken me to complete it - ive not got 100% im at 86.5 or something but ive done all the stranger and side missions that i have found, got all but the last legendary animal, done around half the challenges and explored the total map.
    Storywise - Arthur has been the best character I have seen in any video game. Theres so many funny lines that he says throughout the game aswell - he is a sarcastic lovable character. I think the most fun mission for me in this game is the one in the bar in Valentine with Lennie. After the game ended I had to watch this again.
    Yes it has some negatives, i think overall its an easy game to beat and maybe some difficulty settings would have been better here. Also the wanted system is very annoying, especially when committing train robberies - you have a bag over your head in a long underground train tunnel yet no lawmen are there and they somehow know its you before they even arrive. Nearly every time I have tried a train robbery my bounty was more than what I earned from it. This game is ABOUT a gang of criminals and the game makes it totally difficult to commit any crimes at all, if not even trying to steer you away from doing that. I suppose it makes sense given the various endings though but still.
    As a female I would have liked MORE FEMALE LEAD characters having a bigger role. Yeh its set in the late 1700’s and yes women were left behind in that era however the game was made in 2018. I thought Sadie was a great character and would have loved a bit more of that. Not even many stranger missions or encounters were from females. Apart from the ones that always needed saving, so Rockstar this would have been more ideal.
    Lack of fast travel for the most part of this game was quite annoying too - and made the game take so long. Only near the end of the game (i bought it 2nd hand) Rockstar introduced the fast travel (and photo mode which is fun too) it should have been in the game from the start. The auto equipping of weapons is annoying too. I would put some guns on my back ready for something, id get off the horse because i would come across someone that needs saving, id get there then i would have no guns on me! The game takes them off you for some reason if your still sat on your horse. Its similar for missions too and loads you up with random ones and not the ones you want. Another main annoyance is that half of the map is un-explorable until the main story ends and there is only one stranger mission that I have encountered here and I’ve ran around everywhere on this side of the map. Bit of a waste really and 3 legendary animals are on this side aswell which seems pointless as you can make trinkets out of them but don’t really have any use of them for many missions. A very minor thing that I would have liked is that Arthurs hair doesn't have a length limit! Why does it when everything else in the game is so detailed. even your horse has different hair lengths and colours to choose from lol
    In conclusion, Despite the negatives I'm really sad that I have finished the game now i wish it would carry on and on and on haha. Well done to Rockstar for this game, PLEASE make your next one as good as this - storywise especially. Arthur will always have a special place in my heart hahahah    … Expand
  2. OostAs
    Mar 29, 2020
    10
    My friends, this is the pinnacle of gaming. All these frustrations at the start of the pc port are not relevant anymore. Game runs perfectly (I'm on Vulkan).
    I've never played a game where you can feel the love, care and attention more than in Red Dead redemption 2 (only equaled by The Witcher 3). It's a WORLD, human, warm, bitter, exiting, calming, tense and immersive.
    Just play it.    My friends, this is the pinnacle of gaming. All these frustrations at the start of the pc port are not relevant anymore. Game runs perfectly (I'm on Vulkan).
    I've never played a game where you can feel the love, care and attention more than in Red Dead redemption 2 (only equaled by The Witcher 3). It's a WORLD, human, warm, bitter, exiting, calming, tense and immersive.
    Just play it.
    Only concern I have is that it's really hard to go back to the average quality level of most other games out there.    … Expand
  3. MaxGamer
    Mar 25, 2020
    3
    The single player story is good but online is total garbage. Just like GTA V Online, try to do anything without getting greifed by another player with an aim bot or mod is not possible. Apparently the parley system is easily bypassed.

    Skip the irritation of multiplayer grief by PK for no reason other than to run you off the server.

    Single Player Story line: Excellent
    Multiplayer : Garbage
  4. Foonch
    Mar 24, 2020
    1
    Fix the goddamn Hacker problem already Rockstar! How about letting us make private servers if you're too lazy to fix anything!?
  5. arielm
    Mar 24, 2020
    10
    Performance wise: My PC is not high end (a lenovo Y50 laptop with gtx 860 gpu) and Im not a fan of westerns. I have managed to run the game on mostly low settings with some twitches for the textures to set them to high it runs on 30-50 fps depending on the area and its more than enough.

    Gameplay wise: The experience you get is actually living in the world of the game, nothing I have yet    Performance wise: My PC is not high end (a lenovo Y50 laptop with gtx 860 gpu) and Im not a fan of westerns. I have managed to run the game on mostly low settings with some twitches for the textures to set them to high it runs on 30-50 fps depending on the area and its more than enough.

    Gameplay wise: The experience you get is actually living in the world of the game, nothing I have yet experienced in any video game. Not in the amazing Witcher 3 not in any TES/Fallout game and definitely not in other Rockstar games.

    Especially in days like this when most of us are on quarantine RDR 2 is the best way to escape this reality.    … Expand
  6. skthegreat
    Mar 24, 2020
    10
    When I was a kid, this is what I imagined games in the future would look like. What's truly wonderful about RDR2 is that is is alive. It is dynamic from its story, to the game-play, to the world.
  7. Viking706
    Mar 22, 2020
    1
    I have to force myself to finish this game as it feels like a chore. The controls are extremely clunky. The game play is quite boring barring a few set pieces for which I gave these 2 stars. The game has innumerable glitches and the main campaign is ruined with worthless filler. The whole experience feels like watching a mundane interactive movie rather than playing an actual video game.I have to force myself to finish this game as it feels like a chore. The controls are extremely clunky. The game play is quite boring barring a few set pieces for which I gave these 2 stars. The game has innumerable glitches and the main campaign is ruined with worthless filler. The whole experience feels like watching a mundane interactive movie rather than playing an actual video game. The online game locks story missions behind purchasable property which can only be unlocked by gold bars. One can either spend some more real money or grind numerous boring missions in order to gain these gold bars. This is perfectly in line with the micro transaction formula seen in grand theft auto online.… Expand
  8. bagpussonacid
    Mar 22, 2020
    1
    Mind numbing dullness. Nothing but riding along slowly for hours listening to hellishly dull dialgue. Very little action, and if you fail you have to go riding listening to the same often unskippable tedious dialogue for another 20 mins there and 20 mins back. Savegame system is a disaster and rare checkpoints add to the utter tedium of this overhyped garbage. Complete waste of money.
  9. escknx
    Mar 18, 2020
    3
    Great graphics, but horrible input lag and consolish controls. Couldn't finish this game, became boring AF playing with that console input lag. In 2007 Gaben was right when talking about PS3 evelopment cycle, after console you have to redo the game from scratch. 3 for art design, 0 for wasted potential. Glad you made you money on console adepts.
  10. dabyd1304
    Mar 14, 2020
    8
    Si hay un juego que en los últimos años, con toda seguridad, iba a estar en mi lista de aquellos que mas me han marcado, y que recordaré cuando piense en ese año concreto de su salida, ese sin duda iba a ser Red Dead Redemption 2.

    Viene de quien viene, siendo secuela y tercer título de la saga. Y en parte estaba asegurada cierta calidad, desde que se declaró sus intenciones y se disipó    Si hay un juego que en los últimos años, con toda seguridad, iba a estar en mi lista de aquellos que mas me han marcado, y que recordaré cuando piense en ese año concreto de su salida, ese sin duda iba a ser Red Dead Redemption 2.

    Viene de quien viene, siendo secuela y tercer título de la saga. Y en parte estaba asegurada cierta calidad, desde que se declaró sus intenciones y se disipó cualquier duda de que fuera a pertenecer a algún género de moda entre adolescentes y gente muy letrada del ocio online. Si es que alguna vez hubo esa duda.

    Y creo que eso precisamente es lo que nos dejaba claro a los que ibamos a ir de cabeza a por él, que nos ibamos a encontrar con algo a nuestro gusto. Y así ha sido.

    Hay miles de análisis por la red. Asi que solo quiero dejar puesto porque no le pongo un 10 y si un 8.

    Le bajo un punto por algunos problemas con el guión. No por su ritmo (como mucha gente con gran conocimiento y gusto afirma sobre que es aburrido), si no por incoherencias entre la narración y su jugabilidad. Es un problema de casi todos los juegos que intentan ser realistas en personajes y sucesos y luego pierden cualquier noción de la realidad cuando hay que apretar el gatillo. Muchos lo tienen, si. Pero eso no significa que no haya que darle una collejita en este caso.

    Por otro lado, el control hace de las suyas en muchas ocasiones, siendo ortopédico y desesperante en sus momentos más guionizados. Siendo estos momentos, a su vez, demasiado encorsetados y mal resueltos, con la posibilidad de fracasar por causas ajenas a nosotros y casi siempre que ver con su mal control.

    Aparte de estos apartados que considero errores de diseño, le quito ese último punto que le deja en el 8 final a sus problemas técnicos de lanzamiento, sobre todo con respecto a crasheos e incapacidades, en ocasiones, si quiera de jugar. Todo esto como así lo indica el resto de compañeros que han puesto un análisis, en el que con buen juicio y poca vergüenza se han creado una cuenta solo para sacar su bilis puntuando al juego con un cero porque no les arranca.

    Bienvenido a mi lista de juegos para recordar RDR 2.    … Expand
  11. MichaelViet
    Mar 14, 2020
    10
    Я вас не понимаю. Вы купили Red dead Redemption 2, она у вас на аккаунте. Игра была не очень оптимизирована и с багами. Ни одна видеокарта не могла ее запустить, но Rockstar выпустили патчи и пофиксили все. Теперь игра идет даже на core i3 2120 + rx580 на средних настройках с ультра текстурами и высокими тенями в стабильных 30 fps с Vsync 50%, без него 60 fps в лесах и полях, а в городахЯ вас не понимаю. Вы купили Red dead Redemption 2, она у вас на аккаунте. Игра была не очень оптимизирована и с багами. Ни одна видеокарта не могла ее запустить, но Rockstar выпустили патчи и пофиксили все. Теперь игра идет даже на core i3 2120 + rx580 на средних настройках с ультра текстурами и высокими тенями в стабильных 30 fps с Vsync 50%, без него 60 fps в лесах и полях, а в городах ниже 25 не проседает. Игра забивает все ядра и потоки процессора на 100, это очень хорошо поймите же. Сюжет игры интересен и медитативен. Если вы смогли поигратт или посмотреть полностью прохождение Death Stranding то RDR2 будет казаться быстрее чем раньше когда все играли в нее на PS4 и не допроходили до конца. Эта игра заслуживает 10/10, она по всем параметрам обходит все игры мира уже вышедших. Не будьте злыми, оцените игру правильно не смотря на разные ошибки на ваших ПК, я уверен что проблема в том что вы пытаетесь запустить игру на стареньких видеокартах или сборках в общем. Конечно игра не запуститься. На этом все. Всем добра… Expand
  12. di4ch1
    Mar 11, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. не, ну тут всё ясно, артур памрет и на ето спс. А на самом деле, игра ахуенна тем, что тут есть артур))0)0)… Expand
  13. OMM
    Mar 9, 2020
    2
    Fist off, this is a messy port. The controls weren't remapped and are just bad. Want to read a note? Ok, take it out, next read which shows unreadable handwriting, so now click read AGAIN. Next page go back and do it all over again for each page.. Next I was unable to begin any of the missions, as I was not able to select "accept" to kick them off. This happen on all of the online stuff.Fist off, this is a messy port. The controls weren't remapped and are just bad. Want to read a note? Ok, take it out, next read which shows unreadable handwriting, so now click read AGAIN. Next page go back and do it all over again for each page.. Next I was unable to begin any of the missions, as I was not able to select "accept" to kick them off. This happen on all of the online stuff. Next I was unable to buy gold, as this is needed to get licenses that allow you to be a bounty hunter. Its just our good old friend micro-transactions dressed as a pig in lipstick.
    Stay away, wait for Cyberpunk, from a PC developer that actually wants your business.    … Expand
  14. ahmetaslan
    Mar 6, 2020
    0
    BOK GİBİ OYUN BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK BOK
  15. JJRambo
    Mar 6, 2020
    10
    one of my favorite games of all time, amazing story and attention to detail. Looks gorgeous and plays just fine. The complexity is punishing on the hardware for sure but it's a living world.
  16. Lizarino
    Feb 29, 2020
    5
    Amazing graphics and attention to detail but if you want good gameplay and fluid controls, you probably won't like this.

    This has the best graphics I've ever seen in a game and it doesn't run tooo badly with that in mind. A mix of ultra and medium settings I get 70 to 110 fps on 1440p with a RTX 2080. Sound design is great (although there is a lack of audio settings), user interface is    Amazing graphics and attention to detail but if you want good gameplay and fluid controls, you probably won't like this.

    This has the best graphics I've ever seen in a game and it doesn't run tooo badly with that in mind. A mix of ultra and medium settings I get 70 to 110 fps on 1440p with a RTX 2080.
    Sound design is great (although there is a lack of audio settings), user interface is terrible if you want to use your mouse as well as the map at least in my opinion has a lot to be desired.
    Controls and movement, just like in GTA V, only worse, are incredibly clunky and annoying to use. You will constantly get stuck, jump onto things you walk near, walk too far or walk too slowly.

    This game may be great if you can over all the incredibly annoying things about this game but I would not recommend it, especially at full price. (Also only buy the standard edition)    … Expand
  17. mnylen
    Feb 29, 2020
    2
    Beautiful game, good story, but unfortunately the game is not stable. I'm experiencing crashes frequently enough that I'm going to shelve the game until the crashes are fixed. Which probably won't happen from the looks of it. The crashes combined with the game's save system are especially frustrating, because if you crash during a mission, you need to start the whole mission again fromBeautiful game, good story, but unfortunately the game is not stable. I'm experiencing crashes frequently enough that I'm going to shelve the game until the crashes are fixed. Which probably won't happen from the looks of it. The crashes combined with the game's save system are especially frustrating, because if you crash during a mission, you need to start the whole mission again from beginning.

    The performance is not so great either, even on top-spec PC. I have 2080 Ti and 16-core 3950X and can play at high settings in 1440p at 60 fps, but going ultra results in some dips below. 4K at 60 fps just not possible.    … Expand
  18. showt
    Feb 28, 2020
    10
    1. Сюжет - 10.
    2. Графика - 10.
    3. Атмосфера - 10.
    4. Музыка, озвучка - 10.
    5. Второстепенный контент - 10.
    6. Геймплей - 10.
    7. Отимизация. теч. часть - 10.
    8. Управление - 10.
  19. redfred
    Feb 28, 2020
    8
    Didn't check here before buying...my mistake. Game has a lot of promise...not really playable as is. NVidia says run it full screen 1070GTX...you can't and still be able to use the onscreen choices. It seems to run OK in borderless windowed mode...but not the best graphics.

    This game will drive you around the bend as you play...while there are hints as far as keys to push...there is    Didn't check here before buying...my mistake. Game has a lot of promise...not really playable as is. NVidia says run it full screen 1070GTX...you can't and still be able to use the onscreen choices. It seems to run OK in borderless windowed mode...but not the best graphics.

    This game will drive you around the bend as you play...while there are hints as far as keys to push...there is no page with a list of controls...you learn as you go. If you are trying to play in full screen and things don't work you are in for some misery. I rolled 3 characters before I got the "card thing" to work.

    The Online mode is much like checking yourself into a prison where everyone carries a shiv.. Some players will kill you for your horse and can also kill you for your camp. This can be two on one. They won't just do this in a town...also out in the boonies.

    So I ended up living on game and herbs and riding the poor grey nag. I will only play the Online mode if PvP is able to be shutoff. The PvE stuff in Online is difficult enough. There is NO MOTIVATION to improve your outfit and position when everything can be stolen. And at any time when you meet another player your are tempted to just blow them away to protect what little you have.

    This said...the play in Online mode is interesting and complex...too bad about the play because it could be fun. I enjoyed the hunting, horse, and survival play.

    I'll play the Story mode in windowed mode for now.

    *UPDATE After a 3G update I can now play in full screen mode using Nvidia's settings. I think.

    My reco? For the online mode...start off EASY...don't get trigger-happy. What you deal with in the game depends on your rep...get a bad rep and a lot of bad stuff comes your way. There are many temptations that will come your way. I'd avoid most. You do need to take on various tasks for $....but don't try to get rich quick? Start with the player vs game tasks for $ and avoid interacting with other players until you get some experience...it's too easy to go down the rabbit hole with an itchy finger.

    My modus operandi is to just learn to hunt and deal with my horse...cooking/crafting and so forth. When you get used to the game and the controls...then you might branch out...but if you go the outlaw way you will be a lookin' at trouble pardner..

    When the controls wouldn't let me interact with the guy at the PO..I started shooting the place up...thus my rep took a hit. Plus the controls are still a bit wonky..kind of a bummer when you hit a key and punch out your own horse...mine kicks back. Tried to interact with a woman at a house and I punched her.

    I'm rating this at 8 now. Good for me...    … Expand
  20. Elmax
    Feb 28, 2020
    0
    Even months after release, i can't play more than 1 hour on this game before it crashes for "memory issues" even though, I have all the latest drivers, and recommanded specifications to run the game.
    Also, the game is to be honest boring, but maybe, if I could play it without interruption, my review wouldn't be the same. This game is a shame due to the crashes, lost 60$.
  21. RollingStone6oi
    Feb 27, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Only now has this masterpiece passed. I am extremely grateful to rockstar studio for the magnificent history and its implementation at the highest level. The game is just fantastic. Before buying, I doubted “is it worth my attention?”, I asked myself. Having spent about 60 hours, I never regretted neither time nor money. The game is in no hurry to throw you in the thick of things, it shows you life. Harsh, with its events and more. A sad story that encourages one to think about the right life path. In this game I liked absolutely everything. Arthur Morgan was a cruel man, but he was with a good heart. RIP Arthur Morgan.
    Thanks to everyone who was involved in the creation of this masterpiece of the gaming industry.
    Love u all!
    ___________________________________RU_____________________________________
    Только сейчас прошел сей шедевр. Я крайне благодарен студии rockstar за великолепную историю и ее реализацию на высшем уровне. Игра просто фантастическая. Перед покупкой я сомневался «а стоит ли она моего внимания?», спрашивал я себя. Потратив порядка 60 часов я ни разу по пожалел ни времени, ни денег. Игра не спешит бросать тебя в гущу событий, она показывает тебе жизнь. Суровую, со своими событиями и прочим. Печальная история, которая подталкивает и самому задуматься о правильном жизненном пути. В этой игре мне понравилось абсолютно все. Артур Морган был человеком хоть и жестоким, но он был с добрым сердцем. RIP Артур Морган.
    Спасибо всем, кто был причастен к созданию данного шедевра игровой индустрии. Люблю вас всех!    … Expand
  22. 0235
    Feb 26, 2020
    5
    A gem of a game that refuses to allow you to control the main character in any way. You will start to find yourself lost in this game, drawn in, thrilled by what it has to offer. Then the horrific control system kicks in and you are reminded very very harshly that you are just playing a video game. couple that with a ridiculously outdated save system from PS1 times, any and all hiccups onA gem of a game that refuses to allow you to control the main character in any way. You will start to find yourself lost in this game, drawn in, thrilled by what it has to offer. Then the horrific control system kicks in and you are reminded very very harshly that you are just playing a video game. couple that with a ridiculously outdated save system from PS1 times, any and all hiccups on account of the game are magnified tenfold due to the backtracking needed to be done.

    You are constantly fighting the game just to play the game. How any of the professional reviewers overlooked this HUGE blemish on the game is beyond me. it is your connection to the game, your physical connection through the keyboard and controller. Every time the character decides to do something different to what you expect (as the past 20 times you pressed that button it did one thing) it rips your right out of any immersion you may have.

    Here are some examples:

    1) The button to "untie hostage" and "kick hostage to death" is the same button relevant to how close to the target you are.
    2) the game will SOMETIMES aim a weapon when left trigger is pulled, SOMETIMES it will request you also them press the right trigger to aim a weapon.
    3) Auto aim will prefer to target characters you can speak to, not characters you can shoot.
    4) At one point "X" accepts an offer and "B" rejects it, then just minutes later with the same character "X" becomes reject, and "B" becomes accept.

    The game is a Ferrari with no wheels. yeah, you have a Ferrari but you cant do anything with it except leave it out of gear and rev the engine while its still inside your garage.    … Expand
  23. Lordderon
    Feb 24, 2020
    10
    Just awesome game. Awesome. Yes, the optimization failed, but the game itself does not deserve 0 points. Play and enjoy
  24. D_man12
    Feb 24, 2020
    10
    I've created an account to give props to this game. Yes it has had a rough start, but the game is amazing. Granted the controls are convoluted (but I have it on good authority that the control scheme for the consoles was just as bad). Some folks are having issues with graphics that are causing crashes, but this may be fixed with the latest version of drivers and/or moving away from usingI've created an account to give props to this game. Yes it has had a rough start, but the game is amazing. Granted the controls are convoluted (but I have it on good authority that the control scheme for the consoles was just as bad). Some folks are having issues with graphics that are causing crashes, but this may be fixed with the latest version of drivers and/or moving away from using the vulcan graphics. I don't expect the control scheme to change, but the other issues are all fixable and I personally haven't had any of those problems and my computer isn't the greatest.

    What I love about the game is the immersion, I feel as though I"m actually out there in the world. It feels like the world continues on even when I'm not around. The missions are a blast. There are so many little details and unique encounters in the world that, I feel like Rockstar is giving me a little wink when I experience them.

    This game is so much fun and well worth the price of admission. If you have to wait for the technical issues to be resolved then do so, but don't miss out on this game. It's amazing, easily one of my all time favorites.    … Expand
  25. TerAnYu
    Feb 23, 2020
    2
    A very weak network component, normal only for a single campaign. There are a lot of texture issues in single player and online campaigns where you can easily get stuck.
  26. Nexta-
    Feb 22, 2020
    0
    Плюсов много.Но из-за оптимизации я не могу ими насладиться. Сама игра нравится, но прощать наплевательское отношение к игровому сообществу я не собираюсь. Если рокстар предало фанатов пк, то пускай и остаются на своей консоли. Нам такой пофигизм не нужен. А сюжет возможно в пиратке пройду. Обычно там и оптимизация игр намного лучше. Правда подумаю. Но рокстар нельзя простить. ТолькоПлюсов много.Но из-за оптимизации я не могу ими насладиться. Сама игра нравится, но прощать наплевательское отношение к игровому сообществу я не собираюсь. Если рокстар предало фанатов пк, то пускай и остаются на своей консоли. Нам такой пофигизм не нужен. А сюжет возможно в пиратке пройду. Обычно там и оптимизация игр намного лучше. Правда подумаю. Но рокстар нельзя простить. Только наказание. Ибо они на все игры на пк начнут плевать… Expand
  27. M3son
    Nov 8, 2019
    0
    the game closes itself several times, it stops working, it often can't launch the launcher, always crashes and asks for safe mode, just like GTA V did, it's poorly optimized, extremely heavy, and doesn't recognize all GPU memory even with new drivers, extremely bugged on PC version
  28. g1ml3r
    Feb 17, 2020
    8
    Looks like perfect, but...

    Positive moments: 1) Wide beautifull world; 2) Many random events when u a playing; 3) interesting missions. really good acting; 4) Nice graphic, diamond wild nature; 5) Really long gameplay. Negative moments: 1) Some times u a really get to be bored by gamelplay. Too much time just for.... TRAVELING! 2) Missions have no autosave so if u get crashed    Looks like perfect, but...

    Positive moments:
    1) Wide beautifull world;
    2) Many random events when u a playing;
    3) interesting missions. really good acting;
    4) Nice graphic, diamond wild nature;
    5) Really long gameplay.

    Negative moments:
    1) Some times u a really get to be bored by gamelplay. Too much time just for.... TRAVELING!
    2) Missions have no autosave so if u get crashed - start mission from the begining;
    3) Lot of bugs on the PC version. Lagging, crashing and other - the worst PC-adaptation I ever saw!
    4) The plot is poorly worked out! A lot of inconsistencies. The characters are drawn well, but their logic and motivation are often unclear. Separately, all the stories are very good, but as a single canvas - everything is bad.

    8/10
    But crashing and lagging....    … Expand
  29. Saggitarius
    Feb 16, 2020
    10
    Лучшая во всех отношениях игра.
    сюжет - 10/10
    Музыка - 9.5/10
    Геймплей 8/10 (иногда однообразные перестрелки достают, а также я не люблю стелс, но это вкусовщина)
    На моем i3 8100 + rx 480 + 8gb оперативки вылетов не было.
  30. Gekslee
    Feb 16, 2020
    10
    Удалось запустить игру после следующих манипуляций: отключил RAMDisk, установил файл подкачки по выбору системы, сделал чистую переустановку свежих драйверов NVIDIA вручную, дополнительно запустил все установочные файлы в папке игры Redistributables. То ли это игра, то ли лаунчер, но очень капризна к программной среде. Приходится помучиться, чтобы запустить этот шедевр, причем каждомуУдалось запустить игру после следующих манипуляций: отключил RAMDisk, установил файл подкачки по выбору системы, сделал чистую переустановку свежих драйверов NVIDIA вручную, дополнительно запустил все установочные файлы в папке игры Redistributables. То ли это игра, то ли лаунчер, но очень капризна к программной среде. Приходится помучиться, чтобы запустить этот шедевр, причем каждому (судя по куче бесполезных гайдов в нете) по-своему. Наиграл пока 14 часов на почти максималках с 1 вылетом на vulkan, пробую directx. Игра отличная, атмосферная. Не понравилось, что очень быстро течет время в игре, не успеваешь насладиться видами как темнеет (ночь пролетает ещё быстрее).… Expand
  31. PowerGamer
    Feb 13, 2020
    7
    I was looking forward to the PC version of this game.
    It ended up being disappointing in some ways.
    Over all pretty fun, epic in scope story driven game. Still I expected a GTA5 quality in both gameplay, graphics, etc., and it's just not there in this game. Pros: 1) Unique Wild West theme. Probably the #1 Western game series of all time. 2) High media quality. Great graphics, great    I was looking forward to the PC version of this game.
    It ended up being disappointing in some ways.
    Over all pretty fun, epic in scope story driven game.
    Still I expected a GTA5 quality in both gameplay, graphics, etc., and it's just not there in this game.

    Pros:
    1) Unique Wild West theme. Probably the #1 Western game series of all time.
    2) High media quality. Great graphics, great audio, etc.
    3) Long, detailed story driven.

    Cons:
    1) Crashes a lot. The immersion of the game is broken since you have to constantly manually save.
    Can't count how many times I had to do a 30min plus mission over again because the game crashed in the middle. And it isn't just me, other family members on different PCs have the same problem.
    2) The loading performance is bad. Maybe it's just a symptom of having a complex detailed world, but the game takes way to long to load on a high end PC with an M2 drive unlike most other games I play.
    3) The pace of the game is way to slow for me. I like that it is story driven but a lot of it just moves too slow. The game often kicks into movie mode where basically the game takes over and you are watching a movie. Some of these movies are very slow and drawn out. A lot of time it's just a video of you riding a horse and you can't individually skip these parts.
    I get they are trying to set a mood, but mine turns to boredom. Instead of a skip button, maybe a speed up option would be nicer, like a 1.25, 1.5, 2x speed would have been great.
    4) Has an unusual, perhaps console based, save system where you can only save when you are out of a mission. Some of these missions can be very long so you either have to play it all through to the end, or restart it when you reenter the game. On top of that when you restore a save it puts you in some random spot and under a different context. Like if you save in front of a random encounter and then load the game the encounter is not there.
    It's as if the game developer is trying to punish players..    … Expand
  32. feepfeep
    Feb 12, 2020
    0
    I can't even get past how incredibly bad the Rockstar Launcher is. I will never buy another Rockstar game again. It wouldn't matter if this game was the best ever made I still won't enjoy it because of that invasive, buggy hunk of garbage.

    Also, not being able to play while offline is complete garbage. Rockstar has become the worst company in gaming.
  33. DemirKipi
    Feb 12, 2020
    10
    Oyun tarihinin en iyi oyunlarından biri olabilir. Size vermek istediği ne varsa tam anlamıyla veriyor. Hakkıyla verdiği grafikler, ana ve yan hikaye detaylarıyla yaklaşık 100 saatimin hakkını veren ender oyunlardan.
  34. KeshAndrew
    Feb 12, 2020
    10
    World - vast, vibrant and alive with breathtaking views and a draw distance never seen, unseen before details and lighting come in play too.
    Story - although boring at the beginning, it has its purpose, to introduce and create connections between the major character, it ties perfectly with the first RDR and Arthur Morgan is the best game character ever developed - 10/10
    Gameplay - lack    World - vast, vibrant and alive with breathtaking views and a draw distance never seen, unseen before details and lighting come in play too.
    Story - although boring at the beginning, it has its purpose, to introduce and create connections between the major character, it ties perfectly with the first RDR and Arthur Morgan is the best game character ever developed - 10/10
    Gameplay - lack of fast travel might make it boring although there is an option for automated travel, every move and control feels realistic and helps the immersion 9/10
    RDR Online - Economy is a joke, grindfest to the teeth (more grindy than even GTA online), if you are not in it for the items and just for a bit of fun and roleplay then it's alright, 6/10

    Giving the 10/10 mostly for the single player and also to boost the rating as I feel that this game doesn't deserve a 4.9 (although it seems to be from bugs, crashes etc. that Rockstar probably fixed by now, but those peeps will not change their ratings)    … Expand
  35. Beardiniyaz
    Feb 11, 2020
    10
    I am hater of GTA series, I really couldn't understent why people so love it but rdr2 is different, world is living, characters have layers, shooter mechanic are good. Best game I have played for 10 years, it's a big game in all conditions grafics is amazing, story amazing, game design is amazing etc

    In the end I cryed, it was amazing experience
  36. Grievous
    Feb 11, 2020
    2
    RDR online and GTA online = Читерская помойка, бесконечный grind, баги сервера, бесконечные загрузки. Самое главное что ни кто ни хочет ничего предпринимать чтоб хоть как то это исправить, но хотят чтоб вы покупали золотые слитки. Rockstar Games устала продавать копии игр и решила присосаться к сиське доната. Похоже очень на то что следующая игра от RG проходит мимо.RDR online and GTA online = Читерская помойка, бесконечный grind, баги сервера, бесконечные загрузки. Самое главное что ни кто ни хочет ничего предпринимать чтоб хоть как то это исправить, но хотят чтоб вы покупали золотые слитки. Rockstar Games устала продавать копии игр и решила присосаться к сиське доната. Похоже очень на то что следующая игра от RG проходит мимо.
  37. TripleBeam
    Feb 11, 2020
    6
    After (not?) playing this for a month, I'll give everybody the lowdown. The game ran fine for me on a 10 yr old EVGA SR-2, looked great, ran in 2K off the bat and is a fine immersive sim.

    .... however The combat is soo poor, the AI undeveloped, online empty and boring story not worth replaying. Enemies randomly spawn closer depending on skill; a cheap mechanic pulled from the    After (not?) playing this for a month, I'll give everybody the lowdown. The game ran fine for me on a 10 yr old EVGA SR-2, looked great, ran in 2K off the bat and is a fine immersive sim.

    .... however

    The combat is soo poor, the AI undeveloped, online empty and boring story not worth replaying.
    Enemies randomly spawn closer depending on skill; a cheap mechanic pulled from the 'magnet' style pathing of gta AI. Admittedly the first two verticle slices were great, after then it all falls apart. The scripting gets lazy, the quests repetitive and rushed. All aspects of the programming and subsequent de-bugging feel fatigued. 6 @ best. Hate to say it, I think I'm done with Rockstar... seriously - Kingdom Come was better, just like Mafia 1 is still better than all GTA's.    … Expand
  38. Distrik
    Feb 10, 2020
    10
    Прекрасная игра. Первый раз проходил на ps4, был впечатлен. В январе 2020 года, ппиобрел steam-версию игры, все работает отлично на ультра настройках, безо всяких багов, о которых пишут многие полтзователи. Все работает как надо, грузится быстрее, чем на приставке, плюс графика лучше. Может, надо запускать игру не на ведре, чтобы потом не плакаиь?Прекрасная игра. Первый раз проходил на ps4, был впечатлен. В январе 2020 года, ппиобрел steam-версию игры, все работает отлично на ультра настройках, безо всяких багов, о которых пишут многие полтзователи. Все работает как надо, грузится быстрее, чем на приставке, плюс графика лучше. Может, надо запускать игру не на ведре, чтобы потом не плакаиь?
  39. Oliverxll
    Feb 9, 2020
    10
    Amazing story.
    Amazing character development.
    Amazing visuals/graphics.
    Amazing soundtrack.
    Amazing level/world design.
    Amazing level of detail, like how everything you do affects the world and characters around you.
    R* has truly poured all their passion into this ambitious project, and has delivered on every part of it. I thank you for this experience. A true masterpiece.
  40. bugor92
    Dec 22, 2019
    10
    Рокстар просто браво!!! Да, не без проблем порт, но это пк, здесь по другому не бывает. Игра невероятная. Я так не орал от восторга со времен прохождения третьего Ведьмака в 2016. Вы - те немногие кто двигает игровую индустрию вперёд. Снимаю шляпу!Рокстар просто браво!!! Да, не без проблем порт, но это пк, здесь по другому не бывает. Игра невероятная. Я так не орал от восторга со времен прохождения третьего Ведьмака в 2016. Вы - те немногие кто двигает игровую индустрию вперёд. Снимаю шляпу!
  41. KOSTYAN200411
    Feb 7, 2020
    10
    Игра очень атмосферная,я не пожалел что купил данную игру.
  42. spiderobert
    Feb 7, 2020
    9
    I'm looking at other reviews and I just don't understand. A lot of people are complaining about rampant bugs, but when I started the game in late December of 2019, I didn't experience any issues whatsoever in the story. Never once crashed or even had a slow down. Loading screens take longer than I'd like, but only on startup, in-game loading screens are pretty quick. I'm running on a 2ndI'm looking at other reviews and I just don't understand. A lot of people are complaining about rampant bugs, but when I started the game in late December of 2019, I didn't experience any issues whatsoever in the story. Never once crashed or even had a slow down. Loading screens take longer than I'd like, but only on startup, in-game loading screens are pretty quick. I'm running on a 2nd gen i7 and a GTX 1080.

    Online was different, but that can be attributed mostly to lack of dedicated servers and occasionally nefarious players wanting to ruin someone's day by DDOSing them.    … Expand
  43. LeDocteurGonzo
    Feb 6, 2020
    0
    Red dead 2 Online est basiquement vide. C'est répétitif et aliénant.
    Cripps : livraison
    Distillerie : Livraison (ça rapporte moins de monnaie et c'est punitif au point que si une roue sort de la route, on perd automatiquement une bouteille) Collectionneur : Gameplay "Balade" et "découverte" ... ennuyeux à mourir. Chasseur de prime : ça c'est cool mais c'est à l'image du jeux : Vide et    Red dead 2 Online est basiquement vide. C'est répétitif et aliénant.
    Cripps : livraison
    Distillerie : Livraison (ça rapporte moins de monnaie et c'est punitif au point que si une roue sort de la route, on perd automatiquement une bouteille)
    Collectionneur : Gameplay "Balade" et "découverte" ... ennuyeux à mourir.
    Chasseur de prime : ça c'est cool mais c'est à l'image du jeux : Vide et sans interet. La prime des bounty n'est pas annoncé avant et on gagne pas plus de 15 dollars par bounty. D'ailleurs, ceux-ci ne sont pas palpitant (se rendre à un endroit, tuer tout le monde sauf la prime, repartir, livrer la prime)

    Ce que nous voulons dans le Online c'est des missions scénarisé d' Attaques de Diligence en groupe de 7-8, des attaques de trains en groupe, des attaques de banques.

    Pour l'instant le jeux est vide et répétitif. ET SURTOUT IL EST REMPLI DE BUG !
    Cheval ; buggé
    Campement : Buggé
    Animaux : Buggé
    Missions : Buggé
    Etc etc etc    … Expand
  44. NelchaelSS
    Feb 5, 2020
    7
    A pretty good game, but it could be A LOT better:
    -On PC, on launch performance was garbage, now it's somewhat fixed;
    -Story in the first few acts is downright BORING
    -So god damn linear. You can't complete a mission/quest unless you do it EXACTLY how R* wants
    -Do I even need to mention the cash grab that the MP part is?
  45. SomeOne28i
    Feb 4, 2020
    6
    Вчера купил игру в эпик гейм сторе за скидку + купон. Подумал, что за 2 месяца после релиза всё починили. Солидная скидка внушала, что игра всё таки будет стоить своих денег. Разумеется это не так.
    Проблемы:
    1) Графика. Просто ужасная. Хуже чем в гта 5. Моя ртх 2060 не способна показать не то что бы красивую, но хотя бы не отталкивающую картинку. 2) Невозможно целиться. Движения мышкой    Вчера купил игру в эпик гейм сторе за скидку + купон. Подумал, что за 2 месяца после релиза всё починили. Солидная скидка внушала, что игра всё таки будет стоить своих денег. Разумеется это не так.
    Проблемы:
    1) Графика. Просто ужасная. Хуже чем в гта 5. Моя ртх 2060 не способна показать не то что бы красивую, но хотя бы не отталкивающую картинку.
    2) Невозможно целиться. Движения мышкой какие то хаотичные. То слишком медленные, то наоборот быстрые. Думаю это связанно с тем, что портировали заточенную под стики игру.
    3) Быги. Часто и много. Мыло повсюду, мыло везде.
    4) Жесткочайший клон гта про дикий запад. Новых игровых сетингов нет.    … Expand
  46. sander732
    Feb 4, 2020
    9
    good game some bugs online to much pay to win amazing Graphics offline worth you'er monney
  47. 4edurahka
    Feb 4, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Игра идеальная. … Expand
  48. Caelestiel
    Feb 3, 2020
    4
    The game is amazing, but you have to play it to enjoy it. unfortunately you can`t play on pc. It crashes, you have bad performance and when the game doesn`t crash it is the Rockstar`s launcher that crashes and closes the game as well.
  49. HeyMarce
    Feb 3, 2020
    10
    Best graphics never made.

    Nice history , action, laughs

    I videogame perfect at all

    2020
  50. Soyuz
    Feb 3, 2020
    8
    4770 + GTX960 2Gb - 22FPS
    Сама игра отличная! Видна большая работа команды разрабов
  51. Rinatt
    Feb 3, 2020
    10
    одна из лучших игр несомненно, оправдала все ожидание и не только
  52. mizhak
    Feb 3, 2020
    6
    Игра прикольная, но меня бесит "меткий глаз". если убрать эту читерскую фигню, добавить крафт, недвижимость(не тот лагерь из рухляти), интересные квесты, рейды, было бы интересней.
  53. Leodeath
    Feb 2, 2020
    0
    Does greed pay? It probably does in most things nowadays but when you screw your community over and over it will come back at you. GTA5 online has been crashing for months without fixes, so you might think they were probably putting all their resources on RDR2, and once released you find out it won't start for most people, it's full of bugs and poorly optimized. After months from theDoes greed pay? It probably does in most things nowadays but when you screw your community over and over it will come back at you. GTA5 online has been crashing for months without fixes, so you might think they were probably putting all their resources on RDR2, and once released you find out it won't start for most people, it's full of bugs and poorly optimized. After months from the release an incredible amount of people still struggle to even play the game. Personally I have the tree shaking bug if I play with DX12 and crashed every 15/20 min if I play with Vulkan. Like they are doing for GTA, rather than fixing the game they add more online content hoping for players to spend more money. Aren't they making enough money to understand that this will not pay off? That it's worth earning a bit less to keep your community satisfied with the products?
    It's a shame because, obviously, the game could be great. 9/10 to the game, 0/10 to Rockstar.    … Expand
  54. Gme
    Feb 2, 2020
    9
    I did not think any game could be a worthy successor to Red Dead Redemption 1, a game which I consider to be one of the best games of that console generation. But they did it. Extremely rewarding and lengthy experience (I came in a just over 100 hours played after finishing the campaign).

    If you like a more slower paced methodical western epic, buy ASAP. If you have the attention span    I did not think any game could be a worthy successor to Red Dead Redemption 1, a game which I consider to be one of the best games of that console generation. But they did it. Extremely rewarding and lengthy experience (I came in a just over 100 hours played after finishing the campaign).

    If you like a more slower paced methodical western epic, buy ASAP. If you have the attention span of a goldfish maybe stay away.

    The game also ran fine on my aging machine (I5 4670, 8GB ram, GTX10606GB). Some slowdown in large campaign shootouts and a total of 3 crashes during missions but other than that no problems.    … Expand
  55. aideseubulus
    Feb 2, 2020
    0
    Made an account just to review this **** Unbelievable... unplayable pile of garbage. Like an indie early access, too bad it comes for 70 bucks and it's from Rocstar **** Games! This **** should NEVER happen. It is just a scam.
  56. Lone_Wolf_Sones
    Feb 2, 2020
    8
    Red Dead Redemption 2 has finally come to Steam. After being delayed for the mediocre EPIC store, has the wait been worth it? Sadly the answer is yes and no. The game itself is just as fantastic as it was on PS4 when I played it to completion there. However...the Steam release appears to be just as rough as it's initial PC release. In essence Rockstar have now flubbed two launches of theRed Dead Redemption 2 has finally come to Steam. After being delayed for the mediocre EPIC store, has the wait been worth it? Sadly the answer is yes and no. The game itself is just as fantastic as it was on PS4 when I played it to completion there. However...the Steam release appears to be just as rough as it's initial PC release. In essence Rockstar have now flubbed two launches of the same game.

    Now personally? I have not run into issues that others have, but that isn't to say those folks who are having issues are wrong. I can only comment on my own experience and feel it's worth noting that my specs exceed the recommended specs. My GTX 1070 is a step above the 1060 the recommended calls for for instance. I have been able to run the game between 40-50 fps with a mix of mostly ultra and some high settings at 1080p.

    As noted others have issues which may be in part to the Rockstar launcher (which shouldn't even be needed to be honest.) Yes we knew this was coming and they pulled this with GTAV despite the fact many had already bought it on Steam and were now subject to yet another needless launcher/client. Some have noted that the game hard crashes but that this may be due to having a controller. If this occurs try disconnecting your controller and reconnecting it after the game has launched. I have also had hard crashes myself in game without a controller connected.

    ____________________

    With the technical issues out of the way let's talk about the actual game.

    Red Dead Redemption 2 is a story driven game telling the story of the taming of the old west and how the Dutch Van Der Linde Gang and protagonist Arthur Morgan deal with the encroaching civilization.

    There is an obsessive attention to detail with luxurious animations for almost everything. The characters are well voice acted. Due to this it makes them feel real and driven by their own desires/motivations which makes the interplay between them interesting to watch.

    A wide variety of content exists for you to engage with. Collect plants, etc. Fill out your compendium of wildlife and craft new clothing and accessories from hunting them.

    The customization as I touched on just above, is robust. You can customize your horse, outfit, and yes even your guns.

    If there is one Achilles heel of Red Dead 2? It's it's lack of an efficient fast travel system. Be prepared to spend a lot of time riding your horse to get to where you want to go. I could understand if they wanted you to see the scenery, but once you've visited a town? You should be able to fast travel from a sign post akin to Witcher 3. Because of this? There are moments where the game feels like it doesn't respect your time.

    One of the problems on PS4 was you might inadvertently hit the wrong button or due to the contextual nature of some interactions? Maybe you haul off and slug someone when what you really wanted to do mount your horse or something. This is a problem here as well due to some actions being context sensitive.

    Is Red Dead 2 a game worth buying? Yes, absolutely...but just be aware that you may have to contend with some bugs.    … Expand
  57. Felizius
    Feb 2, 2020
    10
    rockstar сделали самую технологичную, красивую(по атмосфере и постановки света), игру в истории человечества, вы можете ненавидеть сеттинг, медлительность, и т.д. но почему игра виновата в том что она в таком сеттинге и из за него она не может быть быстрой и она в трейлерах, и в других медиа структурах говорит о её сеттинге и то что она медленная. Вы не можете судить игру по этимrockstar сделали самую технологичную, красивую(по атмосфере и постановки света), игру в истории человечества, вы можете ненавидеть сеттинг, медлительность, и т.д. но почему игра виновата в том что она в таком сеттинге и из за него она не может быть быстрой и она в трейлерах, и в других медиа структурах говорит о её сеттинге и то что она медленная. Вы не можете судить игру по этим параметрам и ставить ей низкие оценки из-за этих факторов, это сравнимо с тем что вы бы зашли в пиццерию и ругали бы заведение за то что у них такое себе кофе, или же зайдя в майнкрафт вы бы ставили её плохие оценки из-за графики. а то что ваша печка не тянет игру в 60fps и 4k то это игра не виновата а ваша маломощная картошка на которой вы её запускаете, хоть кто-то ругал настолько crysis 3 из-за того что она не запускается на пк в 60fps на ультрах на топовых компьютерах на то время когда она вышла, нет её никто не ругал за это а к rockstar у нас как выяснилось другое отношение, это как-то не правильно.… Expand
  58. danlamachine
    Feb 2, 2020
    9
    One of the best games I've ever played,

    1 point shy of max 10/10 because there are some gameplay issues (like controls etc.)
  59. RAZ_RU
    Feb 2, 2020
    8
    I know it's late, but I want to tell you. The game is very good, but after Kojima's vacation, it's pretty cool. I will not tell you anything about the game, but if you have a PS4, then buy it. The game is worth it, but be vigilant. The game is for those who like to work, but work in games, slowly and carefully. Minus a point for a too long story, and another minus point for some flaws in the plot.
  60. soci0path
    Feb 2, 2020
    9
    Купил игру после всех патчей и исправлений, в целом доволен. Впечетлил интересный сюжет на который у меня ушло более 60 часов, занятный геймплей, доп квесты и большой живой мир.
  61. Romulok7
    Feb 2, 2020
    9
    this is a beautiful piece of **** .... It seems that whoever had the idea of ​​doing the project thought: everything is going very well, time to do **** ..... Same text
  62. FlippyFlop
    Feb 2, 2020
    0
    This game plays like an early access game. Totally unacceptable. Rockstar is doing nothing to fix this piece of garbage. The game crashes just at the end of missions, so you have to restart the entire mission, or a character gets stuck somewhere so, once again, you have to restart. I hope Rockstar will get a big hit in terms of PC customers on their next game. Not only do they take fullThis game plays like an early access game. Totally unacceptable. Rockstar is doing nothing to fix this piece of garbage. The game crashes just at the end of missions, so you have to restart the entire mission, or a character gets stuck somewhere so, once again, you have to restart. I hope Rockstar will get a big hit in terms of PC customers on their next game. Not only do they take full price for a game which came out on consoles a year ago, they don't even take the time to fix it and make it playable. Wish i could review it badly multiple times on here and on Steam, because with this game, Rockstar has shown themselves to be a contender to the worst gaming company alongside EA. Totally shameful and disgusting.… Expand
  63. mrarsss
    Feb 1, 2020
    7
    Поставил бы 10, но больше половины побочных заданий скучные.
  64. DrSpaceman1337
    Feb 1, 2020
    2
    I am giving this game a 2/10 because it is a beautiful and immersive game when you can play, however, you're more likely to become an actual rockstar than finish story mode. It was completely unplayable for nearly 2 weeks after release and now, months later and 44% through the single player campaign, it is again completely unplayable.

    I was enjoying the game normally on a Tuesday night,    I am giving this game a 2/10 because it is a beautiful and immersive game when you can play, however, you're more likely to become an actual rockstar than finish story mode. It was completely unplayable for nearly 2 weeks after release and now, months later and 44% through the single player campaign, it is again completely unplayable.

    I was enjoying the game normally on a Tuesday night, but I took a break to hit the gym and go to work the next morning anticipating another night of play on Wednesday. Wednesday night came and I found that my autosave crashed to desktop.

    There is no way to access your manual saves from the start menu. Seriously, that isn't hyperbole, you literally can't load a game from the menu. To load a manual save you must load into an autosave OR into multiplayer. Great.

    So I started multiplayer and, as soon as it loaded in, I attempted to load ALL of my saves one at a time. The autosave continues to crash the game to desktop and ALL other saves load indefinitely, never starting the game.

    I followed all of Rockstar's canned "fixes" and none of them have done a thing to resolve this issue. I submitted a ticket, set to be responded to in 24 hours, and received zero response.

    Finally, as I have invested time and money into the game, I attempted to start a new game from the beginning. This is also NOT possible from the menu. You must load into an autosave or online server to access the story menu. Except I still cannot start a new game, even after loading into online mode. The menu says "New Game is unavailable at this time" or something along those lines.

    I assume that if I sat through the opening tutorial of online play that I would be able to finally get back to the game I want to play, but I am fed up.

    Do not buy this game.    … Expand
  65. metaAccName
    Feb 1, 2020
    3
    Messing around online with friends is fine and all and the story had promise. However, this game is mostly riddled with repetitive fetch quests, lack of options, and time gating elements. First couple hours of story mode is pretty solid if you can grab this game for free or something.
  66. Carrier1988
    Feb 1, 2020
    2
    Single Player: My playing was almost with no problems at all... some minor bugs, some bugged progress where I needed to load older saves, but nothing major.
    Multiplayer: Main reason why I rate so low. Constant R* server disconnects, constant infinite loading screens combined with extremely long loading (AMD 2700X, Samsung EVO 970, RTX2080Ti), neverending bugs in MP Story, bugs which    Single Player: My playing was almost with no problems at all... some minor bugs, some bugged progress where I needed to load older saves, but nothing major.
    Multiplayer: Main reason why I rate so low. Constant R* server disconnects, constant infinite loading screens combined with extremely long loading (AMD 2700X, Samsung EVO 970, RTX2080Ti), neverending bugs in MP Story, bugs which prevent friends joining to your Posse without you completely restarting the game, no animals to hunt on the too populate servers or simply broken spawns... Multiplayer experience cut to basic free roaming and role exping with free events... And please, don't even want me to start on Camp bugs... And if happened you're disconnect for some reason to main lobby, don't bother to go in game, just restart it or you gona have infinite loading bug almost for sure.

    This game has huge potentional, but R* probably decided to ignor all community complaints and play dead bug. Looks like all major game developers last few years have same goals - to be worse then the other company.    … Expand
  67. ConiclaKarma114
    Feb 1, 2020
    10
    a very cool and realistic game, the plot is at the highest level, at first boring, but then it becomes more interesting
  68. Warin
    Feb 1, 2020
    0
    Worst port I've ever experienced. It's always 4 hours of fiddling reinstalling EVERY day I want to play this game. It's really crap that it's still this unstable so many MONTHS after release!. Unacceptable.
  69. Skylordishere
    Feb 1, 2020
    6
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Interesting game and fun to play. Just rockstar launcher act weird sometimes.… Expand
  70. landodnal
    Feb 1, 2020
    7
    I personally really enjoy this game. I would say the game is a pretty flawless Grand Theft Auto Cowboy game with amazing graphics. Unfortunately, it does not run flawlessly, and hasn't since launch. It runs and I can play it, but having a 1 second freeze every 10 minutes or some little bug breaks the immersion constantly. The PC version seems to look worse every patch, as if they areI personally really enjoy this game. I would say the game is a pretty flawless Grand Theft Auto Cowboy game with amazing graphics. Unfortunately, it does not run flawlessly, and hasn't since launch. It runs and I can play it, but having a 1 second freeze every 10 minutes or some little bug breaks the immersion constantly. The PC version seems to look worse every patch, as if they are downgrading the graphics, even though my settings don't change.… Expand
  71. jake93ss
    Jan 31, 2020
    3
    I was super excited for this game, i played a fair bit of it on the PS4 but stopped because I didn't want to ruin the experience for me with the consoles horrible graphics and having to use a controller. Honestly the 2nd time through i couldn't get through the tutorial mission. The game is so buggy and slow, it was a slog the first time playing through it and the 2nd was putting me toI was super excited for this game, i played a fair bit of it on the PS4 but stopped because I didn't want to ruin the experience for me with the consoles horrible graphics and having to use a controller. Honestly the 2nd time through i couldn't get through the tutorial mission. The game is so buggy and slow, it was a slog the first time playing through it and the 2nd was putting me to sleep. It's the first game i've ever done so, how boring does a game have to be to make you nod off? apparently rockstar is capable of such a feat… Expand
  72. Ilgiz222
    Jan 31, 2020
    10
    Наверное лучшая игра за все время. Необычный сюжет, отличные главные герои, хорошая графика, реалистичность
  73. Reserton
    Jan 31, 2020
    10
    Шедевральная игра, веха десятилетия. С релиза всё хорошо работало, а с патчами стало ещё лучше! 10 револьвертов из 10
  74. Roadwind
    Jan 31, 2020
    8
    Well. VERY bad port from consoles. But still VERY good game. Looks like Rockstar just don't like PC )
  75. Yury_Vashurin
    Jan 31, 2020
    10
    The PC port isn't perfect, at its release it suffered from numerous problems (including waiting forever for the game to download and install on Steam). But since when we pay so much attention to such small matters? You really think it's OK to give 0 scores to a brilliant masterpiece just because of some technical problems? That's ridiculous!
  76. Reverze
    Jan 30, 2020
    0
    Я ставлю единицу за дрочь, за дрочь который я пережил! Рокстар иди на хер, за скотское отношение к игрокам. я никогда не куплю у тебя игры!

    я купил алтимейт версию. за неделю до релиза. это 3200 для ПК. Я играл на ПС4, да игра крутая, мне понравилась, не будем говорить о её плюсах. скажу сразу с чего у меня горит зад. Постоянные краши во время миссий,. После релиза, было много багов    Я ставлю единицу за дрочь, за дрочь который я пережил! Рокстар иди на хер, за скотское отношение к игрокам. я никогда не куплю у тебя игры!

    я купил алтимейт версию. за неделю до релиза. это 3200 для ПК.
    Я играл на ПС4, да игра крутая, мне понравилась, не будем говорить о её плюсах. скажу сразу с чего у меня горит зад.
    Постоянные краши во время миссий,.
    После релиза, было много багов и вылетов, да я потерпел неделю, понимаю. Но б*** нахера вы выпустили сырой продукт?
    13 декабря, вышел мод самогонщика, и тут то я хапнул сполна.
    Я заходил в игру и в течении часа пытался зайти в игровую сессию. С**а! Бесконечный загрузочный экран, после нескольких минут игры гребанные вылеты с ошибкой!
    Сука, я купил игру за такие бабки, она должна быть идеальна. Перед тем как поиграть я проверял игру на целостность, но это нихера не помогало. рокстар говорит, что проблема на стороне пользователей и рекомендуют сделать банальные вещи, которые логически нихера не помогут проблеме!
    Я пытался позвонить в рокстар и сообщить о том, что они ублюдки, но увы. Абонент не абонент.
    За 3200 я взял себя в руки и пошел решать проблему! сука, чтобы поиграть РДР2 я потратил 3200 и свои силы для решения проблемы.
    Хочу вернуть себе деньги за эту игру, но похоже поезд ушел.
    Я не потерплю к себе неуважение и скотское отношение, которое я увидел в свою сторону от рокстар.
    И своими гребанными тониками вы не задобрите меня.

    Я не могу передать мою ярость в этом отзыве. Рокстар, просто, иди на хер!
    Одним словом подонки..

    рдр код ошибки 21001001 и ему подобное. ( ругается на сервер)
    а знаете как решил? я подключил интернет напрямую в комп. без роутера. ( я не знаю причину ошибки, возможно старые протоколы в роутерах или еще что-то. Теперь когда я сажусь играть, приходится выключать роутер.)
    Надеюсь это поможет игрокам.    … Expand
  77. Angrymillenial
    Jan 30, 2020
    5
    Очень часто бывает скучно в игре. Заходить в неё не хочется. И ресурсы компьютера жрет как не в себя. На этом минусы закончились. Плюсы: самая красивая игра на данный момент, можно даже частично простить минус про ресурсы. Да и вообще очень хорошая игра, но вот не тянет в не играть...Очень часто бывает скучно в игре. Заходить в неё не хочется. И ресурсы компьютера жрет как не в себя. На этом минусы закончились. Плюсы: самая красивая игра на данный момент, можно даже частично простить минус про ресурсы. Да и вообще очень хорошая игра, но вот не тянет в не играть...
  78. Renaigse
    Jan 30, 2020
    9
    Шикарная физика,графика,атмосфера,персонажи,сюжет( хотя многим может не зайти его затянутость, но я не считаю ее лишней т.к. вся игра заточена под реализм). Очень бесит то, что 2-4 бандита разваливают по 40 охотников за головами и законников, при этом даже ранения не получая, и весь этот бред длится до Сен-Дени, где уже начинается нормальный замес. Ну и эпилог максимально уныл, хотя опятьШикарная физика,графика,атмосфера,персонажи,сюжет( хотя многим может не зайти его затянутость, но я не считаю ее лишней т.к. вся игра заточена под реализм). Очень бесит то, что 2-4 бандита разваливают по 40 охотников за головами и законников, при этом даже ранения не получая, и весь этот бред длится до Сен-Дени, где уже начинается нормальный замес. Ну и эпилог максимально уныл, хотя опять же, я понимаю почему они сделали так, как сделали. Игра не для всех, если вы любитель фортнайта или танков, или прочих шедевров для 0 IQ челиков, то вам тут делать нечего. Тем не менее, это одна из лучших игр ever, она правда очень хороша, с очень проработанными мелочами и механиками, с отличным саундом и сеттингом. Огромнейший минус - это оптимизация и вылеты, ибо 50-60 фпс на фулл ультрах, с просадками до 40 на 2070 s, это ну вообще такое себе. Ну и онлайн составляющее получилось так себе, цены слишком завышены, за задания получаешь копейки, пвп уныло из-за "меткого глаза" ( в нем просто 0 смысла лол), лица персонажей в любом случае получаются всрато + они немые.… Expand
  79. Kashmir0
    Jan 30, 2020
    9
    Tiene una gran historia, las misiones son muy variadas y no paran de sorprender.
  80. Ananisapta
    Jan 30, 2020
    0
    One of the most beautiful and realistic games I've played, and at the same time one of the ugliest and most frustrating. After playing for more than a week, I was unable to endure the moral depravity of the story. After reading the plot description in Wikipedia, I concluded that there is no redemption in this game.

    I make these remarks as a veteran of numerous RPGs over the past two    One of the most beautiful and realistic games I've played, and at the same time one of the ugliest and most frustrating. After playing for more than a week, I was unable to endure the moral depravity of the story. After reading the plot description in Wikipedia, I concluded that there is no redemption in this game.

    I make these remarks as a veteran of numerous RPGs over the past two decades. I've never minded that there is a path of evil intent in such games; most give me good options as well as bad ones. RDR2 is not an RPG, it's a walk down the mean streets of human nature. There's no escape, no way to accomplish objectives without gunning down innocent bystanders, no way to triumph over temptation and choose the high road.

    America doesn't need "art" like this. I hope the developers will use their wealth for better purposes in future.    … Expand
  81. GregTheSlav
    Jan 29, 2020
    8
    Red Dead Redemption 2 has a very good story with a very bad way to end the campaign.
    The epilogue feels like a quick and boring way to end the whole story.
    The gameplay is very glitchy and has even worse controls, especially when your horse is always agitated for no reason. The challenges are a complete waste of time and grindy. All in all, decent story with quite a few flaws in the    Red Dead Redemption 2 has a very good story with a very bad way to end the campaign.
    The epilogue feels like a quick and boring way to end the whole story.
    The gameplay is very glitchy and has even worse controls, especially when your horse is always agitated for no reason. The challenges are a complete waste of time and grindy.
    All in all, decent story with quite a few flaws in the gameplay department.    … Expand
  82. Vlad101
    Jan 29, 2020
    10
    Пк игроки как всегда токсичат на ошибки которые исправляют спустя неделю.
    Что сказать: пк сасать!
  83. byzyn4ik
    Jan 29, 2020
    10
    Bought this game on the end of November 2019 after stability improvment patch got released. Played on vega 64 on 4k with ultra textures and mid-high settings with scaling 0.9 and fxaa. The game looks really amazing, and this is the best game I've ever played on PC. But after finishing mainline game becoming so boring, but online mode is so fun.
  84. Diosuke
    Jan 28, 2020
    4
    Rendimiento pobre solo eso, podría haber sido un gran lanzamiento, pero 2k games apresuró el port una pena
  85. Whoster69
    Jan 27, 2020
    0
    I'm not even sure where to begin. There are just so many things wrong with this game. I guess I will start with the positive. The graphics are gorgeous. The single-player game seems to work OK, but I only played it for a few minutes. I bought this for the co-op multiplayer, which is a steaming pile of garbage. It is too bad too because this game has so much potential.

    Where to begin    I'm not even sure where to begin. There are just so many things wrong with this game. I guess I will start with the positive. The graphics are gorgeous. The single-player game seems to work OK, but I only played it for a few minutes. I bought this for the co-op multiplayer, which is a steaming pile of garbage. It is too bad too because this game has so much potential.

    Where to begin with the negatives. I'm only going to go into the top few. There are just too many to count. First, the interface is horrible. One of the poorest designs I have seen in my life and I've been playing PC games since the mid-1980s. It is just a confusing mess that makes no sense. And there is no guide to help you learn things. Worse still is the networking code. It is some of the buggiest pre-alpha code I have ever come across. Good luck getting it to work. My three friends and I all have problems constantly. About to finish a mission and reap rewards? Not any longer! You'll get dropped at the last second and get nothing for all your effort. Sometimes, you won't even get dropped, you'll just not get any rewards with no explanation. Lastly, there is no system built into the game to stop hackers. It is a cheaters paradise. Jerks constantly do stupid things that mess up your game (when the buggy networking code isn't, which is rare).

    I was so excited to see this game when it came out and so disappointed when it arrived. It has been out now for several months and there have been several patches, but it really hasn't improved. It is still a buggy mess that is plagued by constant cheating.    … Expand
  86. QuplGex
    Jan 24, 2020
    1
    Отличная игра с отвратительной оптимизацией на ПК.
  87. don_strapon
    Jan 24, 2020
    8
    В игру стоит поиграть, очень много проработанных моменто, шикарная графика. Но эти пострелушки в миссиях... Господи, как же я "зае я хочу на Бали" убивать по 50-60 противников за любую перестрелку. Просто всё впечатление портит эта казуальность. Сюжет не затягивает, но впечатление оставляет сильные. Поиграйте, игра одна из лучших за последние 10 лет.В игру стоит поиграть, очень много проработанных моменто, шикарная графика. Но эти пострелушки в миссиях... Господи, как же я "зае я хочу на Бали" убивать по 50-60 противников за любую перестрелку. Просто всё впечатление портит эта казуальность. Сюжет не затягивает, но впечатление оставляет сильные. Поиграйте, игра одна из лучших за последние 10 лет.
  88. zephearmin
    Jan 24, 2020
    1
    3 crashes in 90 mins on a very high-end PC from the ultimate version bought on steam. This PC port is a joke. Don't buy it.
  89. Gor80hd
    Jan 23, 2020
    10
    10 из 10, этим все сказано. В этой игре идеально всё: сюжет, графика, проработанность мира. Игра явно заслуживает звание игры десятилетия
  90. muertefx
    Jan 21, 2020
    10
    Best experience only on PlayStation, always was, always will be. Great game. PC players, hope you like rockstar launcher.
  91. MangaDude
    Jan 21, 2020
    10
    Seems that I am one of the lucky ones, when reading the reviews here. I get around 40 fps in 4k running a couple of settings on ultra and most on high. 40 frames is fine for me since I tend not to notice much of a difference compared to higher rates. A few of the very resource intensive options turned off but it looks fantastic and I don't experience any issue with the graphics. I basedSeems that I am one of the lucky ones, when reading the reviews here. I get around 40 fps in 4k running a couple of settings on ultra and most on high. 40 frames is fine for me since I tend not to notice much of a difference compared to higher rates. A few of the very resource intensive options turned off but it looks fantastic and I don't experience any issue with the graphics. I based the settings on some of the advice that various guides make available online. Also, it launches from the Rockstar launcher.
    I love the game itself and it is the best looking game I've played on PC. My system is pretty good but absolutely not a top of the line setup so I am happy that I can get it to the level that I have. My GPU is a Sapphire Radeon RX VEGA 64 Nitro+ and my CPU is a RYZEN 7 2700X, 16 GB ram and I run it off a Samsung SSD.    … Expand
  92. Izzles
    Jan 20, 2020
    9
    i5 2500k @4.2ghz 16gb 1600 mhz 980ti

    Runs between 40-60 fps with TAA high, all low impact settings are set to ultra and most impact on medium. Can dip below in busy towns but still playable. Looks draw dropping. Clunky controls with a mouse and keyboard but its the price to pay for immersive perfection (realistic animations etc). It was designed for a controller and it shows,    i5 2500k @4.2ghz 16gb 1600 mhz 980ti

    Runs between 40-60 fps with TAA high, all low impact settings are set to ultra and most impact on medium. Can dip below in busy towns but still playable. Looks draw dropping.

    Clunky controls with a mouse and keyboard but its the price to pay for immersive perfection (realistic animations etc). It was designed for a controller and it shows, multiple actions bound to one button is annoying.

    A very rare experience when it comes to entertainment. Story and characters are pretty interesting. Not really into story much but rockstar always makes them work in some way.    … Expand
  93. ozzless
    Jan 20, 2020
    6
    I don't know what drugs the critics who gave this 93 are using, but it's clear that they didn't play this game on PC.

    The good: 1 - World feels alive, a lot of scripted encounters and events. 2 - Really high level of detalization. The snow and mud are gorgeous. The voice acting has some nice little details, like starting shouting when your buddies are far away from you, or resuming    I don't know what drugs the critics who gave this 93 are using, but it's clear that they didn't play this game on PC.

    The good:
    1 - World feels alive, a lot of scripted encounters and events.
    2 - Really high level of detalization. The snow and mud are gorgeous. The voice acting has some nice little details, like starting shouting when your buddies are far away from you, or resuming the discussing from the place where you stopped due to some ingame event.
    3 - Quests are mostly interesting and not repetitious.
    4 - Runs pretty good now, 2 months after release, compared to what it was on the release. The game crashed maybe 3 times for me, and there are not a lot of bugs.

    The bad:
    1 - Absolutely horrible controls for PC. Maybe for PS4 they are good, but having to guess a correct button for every action is really annoying. Why is context action sometimes executed by 'F', sometimes by 'R' and sometimes by the mouse buttons ? WTF...
    2 - No normal saves. If you die - enjoy watching a cutscene for the 5-th time. (Yes, it can be skipped by pressing F, i mean R, i mean Space)
    3 - The game is really slow. There is hardly any fast travel available, and even where it is, you are shown the same cutscene for like 30 seconds.
    4 - Enjoy riding your horse for about 30% of your gameplay time. Just to talk to some dude and then ride half the map back.
    5 - As an open world game, the plot is too straightforward. You can not influence anything by your own choices.
    6 - Soundtrack is not memorable

    Overall, if not for the absolutely horrible controls, i could give it a 8. But having to watch the right bottom side for the clue of which button i should press in every situation just kills it for me. 6/10.
    And watching as somebody compared this to Witcher 3 - lol ! I really hoped this game could achieve a half of what The Witcher 3 did, but they are just different leagues.    … Expand
  94. Mr_Impulsive
    Jan 19, 2020
    10
    i5 6400 2.7Ghz quad core / 16GB DDR4 2666Mhz / GTX 1070 8G Gaming.

    Not sure what problems people are having but I have this machine and have no issues running the game, I'm running 1080p locked in @ 60fps with vsync. All settings on high & ultra except reflections and shadows are on medium. I get frame drops down to 45-50 or so temporarily for a few seconds after entering a town.    i5 6400 2.7Ghz quad core / 16GB DDR4 2666Mhz / GTX 1070 8G Gaming.

    Not sure what problems people are having but I have this machine and have no issues running the game, I'm running 1080p locked in @ 60fps with vsync. All settings on high & ultra except reflections and shadows are on medium. I get frame drops down to 45-50 or so temporarily for a few seconds after entering a town. Other than that I have no issues running the game, I'm not making this review to smash it in people's faces but it's not affecting everyone is what i'm saying.

    Now onto the review of Single player:

    This game is hands down one of the most detailed content loaded games I have seen in a long time, everything just comes together and creates an amazing immersive experience. No DLC is planned for SP and now after playing around 40+ hours I know why, it's loaded down with a huge amount of content in all areas. Hunting & fishing was well designed and fun to do and rewarding, there are a ton of different fish and animal species you can hunt and fish along with those rare legendary critters as well.

    Ridiculous amount of species in this game, from small frogs to giant bears I was very impressed by the amount of detail in the animals and horses. Rockstar has a good way of slowly introducing the game to you and unlocking and progressing in such a realistic and immersive way. The characters are very alive and you can really identify their moods and personality to where the player can create a bond with these characters easily.

    The graphics are stunning, utterly amazing. The original Red Dead was gorgeous, this game surpasses that in every way. The game world is extremely detailed and very polished, best looking most realistic game world I have ever seen guys. It's literally alive around you hearing the birds chirping over head, small and large game squeaking through the woods grazing about and easily getting spooked. Just stand back and observe the game world...it's breathtaking.

    Weapons, gear, tack, ammo, provisions, tools, all of these make a huge comeback form the original. Lots more variants of hunting and fishing gear, and yes you get to fully customize your weapons now which is a fantastic addition. Not to mention customizing your horse now as well.

    Overall I don't give games a 10/10, this game deserves it.

    Sorry to hear about all of the players having technical difficulties starting and playing the game. I run a very lean pc, everything runs off of an NVMe M.2 SSD and that may be why I run so well dunno. But it's just games and my OS that's it. No weirdo programs running in the background. Hopefully people can get this issue resolved cause this a great effing game.    … Expand
  95. LemmeC
    Jan 19, 2020
    0
    Waited for a long time to play this on PC because Rockstar likes to treat the PC users that made them succesful in the first place like second class-customers. Finally came out on Steam, bought it, and when I launched it for the first time the widely disliked Social Club launcher, automatically and for reasons I still don't understand, linked the game to an email adress I hadn't used forWaited for a long time to play this on PC because Rockstar likes to treat the PC users that made them succesful in the first place like second class-customers. Finally came out on Steam, bought it, and when I launched it for the first time the widely disliked Social Club launcher, automatically and for reasons I still don't understand, linked the game to an email adress I hadn't used for years and that does not even exist anymore. Contacted Rockstar Support about this and they replied with a looooong list off all sorts of hoops I had to jump through, even to the point where I would have to scan and send a copy of my ID, for the game to be linked to the email I actually use AND bought the game with. I'm not going to be Rockstars trained little **** performing tricks until they feel like I can play the game I already paid for, so I took the Steam Refund and bought myself RE2 and The Master Chief Collection instead. I do not regret anything. Thank god some companies still appreciate their clients. They will continue to receive my money. See you never Rockstar.… Expand
  96. jefac
    Jan 19, 2020
    10
    I signed up for Metacritic to leave this review. . This is the best game I've ever played
  97. VirtusN
    Jan 18, 2020
    0
    Hey, Rockstar, I've created account here just to say that your game is a pile of garbage.
    Don't know about the story, narrative etc... But optimization is non existent in this game!!!
    I5 4690k, 16 GB RAM, gtx 1050 ti 4GB and the game is UNPLAYABLE, 10-15 fps. Wonderful! I'm not asking for ultra graphics, just for a game that I can play. Especially because according the specs you have    Hey, Rockstar, I've created account here just to say that your game is a pile of garbage.
    Don't know about the story, narrative etc... But optimization is non existent in this game!!!
    I5 4690k, 16 GB RAM, gtx 1050 ti 4GB and the game is UNPLAYABLE, 10-15 fps. Wonderful!

    I'm not asking for ultra graphics, just for a game that I can play. Especially because according the specs you have published, game should run fine on my computer. But guess what?! It does not!

    Though thanks for a lesson learned the hard way-never pre order your games again.    … Expand
  98. RMDsilva
    Jan 18, 2020
    7
    There's a lot to like in RDR2.
    The story takes a while to warm up, but it gets to you, as it changes from wild west superficial shooter to an existencial crisis.
    The world is beautiful and feels alive, with animals scurrying about and settlements with people wandering around, plenty of random interactions. It is fun to spend a lot of this time running around with our horse, shooting and    There's a lot to like in RDR2.
    The story takes a while to warm up, but it gets to you, as it changes from wild west superficial shooter to an existencial crisis.
    The world is beautiful and feels alive, with animals scurrying about and settlements with people wandering around, plenty of random interactions.
    It is fun to spend a lot of this time running around with our horse, shooting and lassoing people.

    But...

    Gameplay is really not amazing. Maybe I'm getting old, but shooting just felt clunky. And the whole mechanics of it were OFF. Sure, it's not the game to be hyper realistic, but it made shooting be a race for headshots rather than a proper competition between you and other gunslingers. You can take at least 20 times more shots than all your other enemies, yet you're always outnumbered 1 to 20, 30, 40...
    Which honestly makes it feel like a super hero game, rather than a wild west shooter. If you have less than 10 enemies, it's even possible to knock them all out just using punches. At least that made it a challenge.

    Then, horse riding and hunting is kinda fun... for 5 minutes. Then hunting is apparently just a decoration with no real use. And horse riding, well, since that's your main means of transport in a region with sparse fast travel points... It becomes a chore.

    Then, what another reviewer pointed out nicely, the missions are mostly crap. Not only because of the shooting, but really the flow is always the same: get to some place, get attacked by 50 people, run away and kill some more on the way out.

    What is really a shame for me is that the story would be enough for me to keep playing (I did finish it!) - so it's really a waste of potential to not go deeper into ALL the characters. They all had so many interactions between each other and hanging out at camp... so why not have more missions with them, where something meaningful might or not happen?
    Why not give them more leading roles in the story?

    And above all, I'd really appreciate a tiny bit more realism - less mass genocide would go a long way in both gameplay, story and missions.    … Expand
  99. Dark_D3s7r0y3r
    Jan 18, 2020
    3
    I really wish I could give this game a higher score. The story is amazing, the gunplay is snappy and satisfying with keyboard and mouse, and the world is so expansive and has so much content that it takes hundreds of hours to see and do everything the game has to offer.

    The problem is that this game is so goddamn buggy that you can hardly go five meters without some new game-breaking    I really wish I could give this game a higher score. The story is amazing, the gunplay is snappy and satisfying with keyboard and mouse, and the world is so expansive and has so much content that it takes hundreds of hours to see and do everything the game has to offer.

    The problem is that this game is so goddamn buggy that you can hardly go five meters without some new game-breaking glitch popping up and forcing a reload. Enemies getting full auto bottomless mags when entering dead eye, the clumsy cover system locking you to the exposed side of cover instead of the side you were approaching, infinite loading screens, dialogue going silent suddenly and randomly, AI spawning in the most secluded corner of the map just to witness you roping the last guy who spawned into the middle of nowhere just to witness you roping the last guy who spawned into the middle of nowhere just to witness you roping the last guy who... etc, etc.

    The controls are clumsy and every button has like five different actions attached to it and selected weapons are never saved and frequently go back to your horse for no reason, so something as simple as PULLING OUT YOUR GUN is made into a huge mess where, unless you manually go into your weapon wheel and select the weapon you want to use, chances are you'll just stand there like an idiot staring at the dude pumping you full of lead. Animations for looting and skinning are excessive, to put it lightly, and are obligatory time sinks that exist solely to build immersion, which is promptly broken when some guy just starts endlessly walking into a chair because his pathfinding is broken.

    Online is a joke. You'll be staring at "ALERT: You have been disconnected from Red Dead Online due to a fault in Rockstar game services. [Error: 0x20010006]" more often than you play it, and the experience is so disgustingly obviously set up to gouge as much money out of you to buy gold as possible.

    Framerate is terrible for visuals that look pretty average, all things considered.

    This is all compounded by a total lack of communication regarding these issues from Rockstar. They seem to just want to brush all of this under the rug while advertising new content that does nothing but break all the existing content even further.

    Avoid this game until they fix it. The story is really good, and the gunplay is really fun, and there's tons of content, but it's all brought down by just an utter lack of care. They simply didn't care about actually being able to play the game, they just wanted to spend all their time putting in all of these little details instead of building a playable game.

    Edit: I'm actually going to LOWER my score for this game from a 6 to a 3. More and more bugs are made apparent the more the game is played, and as I'm playing more of the online mode, the more I feel the online actively detracts from the whole experience. Like, you can only have 10 horse slots, character customization (as woefully basic as it is,) and exclusive horses in the online mode, but online is so painful to subject yourself to that the extra enjoyment is vastly outweighed by the extra frustration. They could have implemented all of this "free DLC" as a tie-in to the single player mode, which at the very least has a fantastic story and character lineup. And please, with the limited story-based content in the online mode, hire some voice actors for the player characters and overhaul the cutscenes to accommodate this. Being a mute is such a lazy excuse for a company with as many resources as Rockstar.    … Expand
  100. Shardkiht
    Jan 17, 2020
    10
    就但看线下，满分，毕竟不要对R星的线上有太高的期望。
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best PC Game of 2019
1
#1 Most Discussed PC Game of 2019

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
93

Universal acclaim - based on 44 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 44 out of 44
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 44
  3. Negative: 0 out of 44
  1. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Feb 28, 2020
    100
    An absorbing tale that will test your machine and tear ducts. A game that did not suffer from being brought to PC. RDR2 is worth overcoming all the shortcomings, since it is one of the best games of the decade. [Issue#300]
  2. PLAY! Zine
    Dec 30, 2019
    90
    Victory of gaming as an art and the pinnacle of creativity in the gaming industry. A true, impeccably-polished masterpiece that will set standards for a decade to come.
    Read full review
  3. Game Revolution
    Dec 17, 2019
    100
    My biggest warning to anyone considering purchasing RDR2 on PC is that you need to have patience when you set it up. Take the time to go through each graphics option, compare your performance on Vulkan vs. DirectX 12, and tailor the game to your specs. Once you have the game tuned, there’s no better way to experience it than on PC.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »