User Score
8.1

Generally favorable reviews- based on 234 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Negative: 31 out of 234

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
  1. May 7, 2021
    10
    game of the year without doubt

    I really hope Square Enix give Drakengard 3 the NieR Replicant treatment
  2. May 8, 2021
    10
    Finally finished this Painful Sad Game after 53hrs

    Got all Canon Endings A to D ( Still getting Ending E ) but my Opinions will be based on the Canon Endings This game Broke me, it was a Emotional Rollercoaster maybe more Heartbreaking than Nier Automata, it is one of the best games i have played this year, The music was even better, even if it was just a pre recording from the OG
    Finally finished this Painful Sad Game after 53hrs

    Got all Canon Endings A to D ( Still getting Ending E ) but my Opinions will be based on the Canon Endings

    This game Broke me, it was a Emotional Rollercoaster maybe more Heartbreaking than Nier Automata, it is one of the best games i have played this year, The music was even better, even if it was just a pre recording from the OG Nier with a few renditions and new soundtracks ( Especially the Mermaid Episode ) but i can sense Keiichi Okabe really outdone himself on this remake , Story is so well written and so is the characters, just Yoko Taro writing at its best

    if you're a fan of Automata definitely get this if you're in for the lore on what happen at Automata , or if you're a fan of Yoko Taro's Work Definitely Get this

    The only negative on this game i can find will be on others perspective on this , The Game loops itself to get all Endings, which will turn off for some people especially from new comers trying out a Yoko Taro Game which is very common on his previous works, but if you get pass that Loops you will get one of the best narratives in gaming or JRPG / RPG in general

    I know it's a Remake or Remaster but it's my Game of the Year this 2021, It Just that Good

    ( Drakengard Remake/Remaster next please Yoko Taro huhuhu )
    Expand
  3. Apr 26, 2021
    10
    This game is awesome so far, put in a good 20 hrs its just objectively better that the one we got originally. It looks better, the rerecorded voices are better and even fantastic where they need to be. And the music that they redid is phenomenal with some much emotion just gives me goosebumps every time i hear it. The story and music are what really steals the show overall and the combatThis game is awesome so far, put in a good 20 hrs its just objectively better that the one we got originally. It looks better, the rerecorded voices are better and even fantastic where they need to be. And the music that they redid is phenomenal with some much emotion just gives me goosebumps every time i hear it. The story and music are what really steals the show overall and the combat overhaul alleviated my biggest criticism of the original and is great this time. I cant wait to get all endings again i detect another game to Platinum :D (Also cant wait for the next game in this fantastic series, and tbh i would take another Drakengaurd as well please ) Expand
  4. May 4, 2021
    10
    Finally got hands on this masterpiece, I got into Yokoverse with Automata and absolutely love it, this was my long need to play game and this version allow it, after automata depression I though i never gonna experience something like that, but this game exceeded automata in all ways. True masterpiece. And about that PC port after 60hrs ingame I never encountered any of bugs, i had lockedFinally got hands on this masterpiece, I got into Yokoverse with Automata and absolutely love it, this was my long need to play game and this version allow it, after automata depression I though i never gonna experience something like that, but this game exceeded automata in all ways. True masterpiece. And about that PC port after 60hrs ingame I never encountered any of bugs, i had locked FPS in AMD drivers. Expand
  5. Apr 24, 2021
    8
    NieR Replicant is a faithfull remaster of the original NieR Replicant that only released in Japan. Featuring brand new models, textures, lighting and the much improved combat over the original. But being a PC port, there are some very apparent issues, more on that later.

    Many will surely be disappointed with the lack of the older main protagonist from NieR Gestalt which was the western
    NieR Replicant is a faithfull remaster of the original NieR Replicant that only released in Japan. Featuring brand new models, textures, lighting and the much improved combat over the original. But being a PC port, there are some very apparent issues, more on that later.

    Many will surely be disappointed with the lack of the older main protagonist from NieR Gestalt which was the western version of Replicant. However you can get him as a skin in the game for those that feel nostalgic.

    NieR Replicant shines in it’s story. It’s a gripping tale of a brother trying to save his sister that will tug on many hearts. For those who enjoyed NieR Automata’s story and never played this one, this game is a must have. But it’s important to expect the same dull side questing that both the original and Automata had, featuring little to no in-depth story for those you help along the way.

    Now on to the state of the PC port. It’s clear that Yoko Taru’s team need to work a lot on their PC ports. With limited graphical settings and the lack of V-Sync is a constant reminder that PC is always on the backseat for this franchise. However they did better than Automata, featuring borderless-windowed mode, better mouse & keyboard support and more, it’s just unfortunate this game could end up being another modding project to smooth out the quirks.

    From sudden FPS drops down to the single digits once every hour or so, to the mouse constantly being in the center of the screen while using a controller, it’s still an enjoyable experience for those willing to keep up with it. I will however recommend to either wait for an official patch or a modders patch to fix the current issues with the port.
    Expand
  6. Jun 23, 2022
    10
    NieR: Automata was my first entry into this series (as it was for many), forever raising the bar on computer games and setting an example for how this medium can uniquely convey a message unlike any other medium.
    The Replicant remake was a fantastic way to enjoy the prequel in a contemporary quality, and all I can say is, I am very glad that I did. I can't even imagine what fantastic
    NieR: Automata was my first entry into this series (as it was for many), forever raising the bar on computer games and setting an example for how this medium can uniquely convey a message unlike any other medium.
    The Replicant remake was a fantastic way to enjoy the prequel in a contemporary quality, and all I can say is, I am very glad that I did. I can't even imagine what fantastic storytelling and emotional rollercoaster will await in the next installment of this series.
    Automata holds the crown, but don't miss out on this one if you remotely enjoyed Automata.
    Expand
  7. May 18, 2021
    10
    The story is good. But the story is only good. And the story is so tragic and sad... Why do I keep thinking of this game?
  8. May 2, 2021
    8
    Story - 8/10 (especially with the new E ending, but to be honest they should have completely removed the C route since its just unnecessary and for me it killed the pacing of the game)
    Music - 9/10 (imho Automata wins this one but the music is quite good especially for a 11 year old game)
    Gameplay - 8/10 (The sidequests are **** even for a game thats 11 years old, but some of them have
    Story - 8/10 (especially with the new E ending, but to be honest they should have completely removed the C route since its just unnecessary and for me it killed the pacing of the game)
    Music - 9/10 (imho Automata wins this one but the music is quite good especially for a 11 year old game)
    Gameplay - 8/10 (The sidequests are **** even for a game thats 11 years old, but some of them have an OK story to cover it, most of them dont. Combat is really good and fluid, on par with Automata. The Word system is also well balanced but it falls short if you play on anything other than the Hard difficulty.
    Expand
  9. Aug 28, 2021
    10
    I played Automata before playing this and even though I enjoyed Automata's combat more, I think the story in Replicant is absolutely amazing and it hits really really hard.
  10. Nov 5, 2021
    8
    This game is incredible, yet it also suffers from pacing hell. It's an enjoyable experience and i'm glad to have played it, but this game also suffers from segments that while meaningful also feel bland. I do understand that this is a faithful remaster and I also enjoyed the new content they added. I just wish they could've found a way to have players enjoy Nier Replicant's beautiful storyThis game is incredible, yet it also suffers from pacing hell. It's an enjoyable experience and i'm glad to have played it, but this game also suffers from segments that while meaningful also feel bland. I do understand that this is a faithful remaster and I also enjoyed the new content they added. I just wish they could've found a way to have players enjoy Nier Replicant's beautiful story while also ridding itself of some of it's tedium counterparts. Expand
  11. Jul 29, 2023
    8
    Story - 8/10 (especially with the new E ending, but to be honest they should have completely removed the C route since its just unnecessary and for me it killed the pacing of the game)
    Music - 9/10 (imho Automata wins this one but the music is quite good especially for a 11 year old game)
    Gameplay - 8/10 (The sidequests are **** even for a game thats 11 years old, but some of them have
    Story - 8/10 (especially with the new E ending, but to be honest they should have completely removed the C route since its just unnecessary and for me it killed the pacing of the game)
    Music - 9/10 (imho Automata wins this one but the music is quite good especially for a 11 year old game)
    Gameplay - 8/10 (The sidequests are **** even for a game thats 11 years old, but some of them have an OK story to cover it, most of them dont. Combat is really good and fluid, on par with Automata. The Word system is also well balanced but it falls short if you play on anything other than the Hard difficulty.
    Expand
  12. May 21, 2021
    8
    Nier Replicant is a slow burn. It takes some time to grow on you, but when it does, it gets better and more enjoyable. If you played Automata, you’ll feel right at home.

    Hear me out. I get that this is a remake, so obviously, a lot of its elements have received a drastic overhaul. But, here’s the thing: in my 100 hours of playtime, I couldn’t help but feel that this felt like a PS3
    Nier Replicant is a slow burn. It takes some time to grow on you, but when it does, it gets better and more enjoyable. If you played Automata, you’ll feel right at home.

    Hear me out. I get that this is a remake, so obviously, a lot of its elements have received a drastic overhaul. But, here’s the thing: in my 100 hours of playtime, I couldn’t help but feel that this felt like a PS3 game with a brand-new coat of paint slapped on. I won’t argue that movement and combat feel fluid and fantastic, but everything else still felt….archaic. Side quests were not engaging or compelling: fetch these amount of items, kill this amount of enemies, etc.; fishing and farming mechanics that felt outdated; repetitive boss fights.

    But! This game doesn’t need to pride itself on gameplay; you play for its beautiful, strange, and heart-wrenching story; you stay for its cast of characters. Sure, maybe I thought the gameplay was only good enough, but man, did I want to keep playing just to see what unfolds. There is heavy lore here, and I was engrossed. I won’t spoil too much, but it’s not over once those credits roll.

    Nier Replicant had this weird ebb and flow. At times, I thought it was good, then average, then fantastic by the end of it. Did it have its ups and downs? It did, but its flaws were not enough to hold it back from being great. Now I understand why this is a cult classic among Nier fans, and it made me a fan too. Get it and enjoy!
    Expand
  13. Jul 30, 2023
    10
    Игра великолепна, на прохождение всех концовок ушло где то 40 часов, хороший вариант ознакомиться с Replicant в новой обёртке. Музыка потрясающая и звучит эмоционально, до мурашек по коже. Сюжет и музыка — это то, что действительно продает эту игру. Боевая система стала лучше по сравнению с оригиналом но с неба звёзд не хватает. Играйте и заходите в комнату ожидания следующей игры ЙокоИгра великолепна, на прохождение всех концовок ушло где то 40 часов, хороший вариант ознакомиться с Replicant в новой обёртке. Музыка потрясающая и звучит эмоционально, до мурашек по коже. Сюжет и музыка — это то, что действительно продает эту игру. Боевая система стала лучше по сравнению с оригиналом но с неба звёзд не хватает. Играйте и заходите в комнату ожидания следующей игры Йоко Таро. Expand
  14. May 10, 2021
    10
    The original Nier was a game greater than the sum of its parts. Nier Replicant is all that, but the parts are even better and the sum even greater. One of the most unique experiences gaming can offer.
  15. Feb 26, 2022
    8
    'NIER REPLICANT VER.1.22474487139...' is an ARPG with many elements. The sci-fi worldview design also lays a layer of mystery on the narrative. The poignant music and excellent performance are very suitable for players who enjoy the story.

    Review of "NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139..."

    Graphic/Art: 8

    Music/Sounds: 9

    Narrative/Performance:8.5

    Gameplay:8

    Score:8.5 (+0.1)
  16. Sep 11, 2021
    10
    Among my favorite stories and characters in media. The aesthetic is amazing as well. The combat is really good. I can see how replaying parts of it to see the full story could be annoying for some people but I liked the game so much it didn't bother me. One of my favorite games.
  17. Sep 15, 2021
    8
    NieR Replicant is a very phenomenal game in the sense of storytelling. The way the game told its narrative was only possible through being a video game. If there were ever a movie interpretation of the game, a lot would be lost in translation. However, outside of its incredible story and characters, the game is an average action RPG. Toylogic did a fairly decent job remastering the gameNieR Replicant is a very phenomenal game in the sense of storytelling. The way the game told its narrative was only possible through being a video game. If there were ever a movie interpretation of the game, a lot would be lost in translation. However, outside of its incredible story and characters, the game is an average action RPG. Toylogic did a fairly decent job remastering the game and improving the combat but I personally feel Toylogic was limited in what they were able to change. Changing the game and/or structure could have made some story beats different although I feel it wouldn’t have taken too much away. The game forces you to replay the 2nd half of the game at least 3 times to get all the endings. It’s nice that they insert more lore and context into the story for each subsequent playthrough, but it doesn’t make playing through the exact same missions and story beats any less tedious. This also brings the issue of making it unclear which cutscenes or dialogues are ok to skip on each subsequent run. And the new contexts usually amounts to somewhere between 15 minutes to an hour of new context. As someone who doesn’t like watching the same cutscenes over and over again, this was a major personal gripe for me. Because of the tedium, it’s hard to give this game too much praise in the gameplay department. If the game had a run-of-the-mill story, I would probably give this game a fairly average score, but the story was so good that it saves what would have been a monotonous action RPG. Expand
  18. Oct 14, 2021
    10
    Tek kelimeyle efsaneydi.Müziklerinden tutun oynanışa hikayesine kadar .bu puanı hak etmiyor 100 üzerinden 100lük bir oyun.Cyberpunk gibi god of war gibi balon oyunları oynayacağınıza bunu oynayın.
  19. Sep 4, 2022
    8
    Pro
    - Solid battle system
    - Amazing music Cons - Character not enough to be too memorable. Maybe Emil is the most memorable one because of his face. - Too many VN section without any visual - Annoying mandatory side quest to be finished in first part to reach true ending. Conclusion As annoying as it is to repeat playing the same game multiple times for different ending, it's
    Pro
    - Solid battle system
    - Amazing music

    Cons
    - Character not enough to be too memorable. Maybe Emil is the most memorable one because of his face.
    - Too many VN section without any visual
    - Annoying mandatory side quest to be finished in first part to reach true ending.

    Conclusion
    As annoying as it is to repeat playing the same game multiple times for different ending, it's good story and twist is what makes me reached the end for all ending.
    Expand
  20. Dec 7, 2021
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. While it may be off putting to some, NieR Replicant manages to deliver a more compelling story, combat, and music than NieR Automata.

    The big problem with NieR Replicant are the actual quests, it involves dealing with a lot of **** just to get to your objective, at first you dont see the point of how helping a guy with his delivery letter would help you find your sister, and honestly, it doesnt make a lot of sense, the game takes a bit too much detours from its original objective, so i can definitely see why people may find the story boring, however you need to judge it by what it is, the story is pristine, it delivers a lot of great messages and meaning, the bosses have awesome story and personality, the characters are fantastic, the powers and overall backstory of each characters is amazing as well!

    The new ending for this re-release is great, you can finally play with kainé, which has been a request among the community for a while, you feel like you are actually fixing things and brings back memories from Automata, while maybe not being as impactful as Automata's E ending, but nevertheless, i dont have anything else to complain.

    The game is absolutely amazing, groundbreaking experience. definitely recommend it. and the pc port also is great.
    Expand
  21. Nov 9, 2021
    8
    Everything is cool, but even Weiss is tired of this pointless running around
  22. Jun 4, 2023
    9
    18/20. Absolutely wonderful. Devola’s music has a lot to do with it. The universe is awesome, mysterious and charming, that mix between sweetness and coldness is so good. I can see the berserk inspiration for the character design in part 2. Gameplay does the job. I definitely prefer the coldness of nier over FF warmness.
  23. Jan 8, 2023
    10
    One of it's kind game. The story is insanely well written, please play the game again or watch explanation videos to get the whole picture. This is literally one of those games with perfect stories, the music is very well done, the character designs and movement is really good. This game is definately a must play
  24. May 9, 2021
    10
    Incredible story, music, and atmosphere. It cleverly subverts video game tropes and combines different gameplay genres along the way.
    It does have problems with the reuse of areas and achieving the final ending can be a slog.
    However, it is all worth your time as this game (like automata) is just a brilliant piece of art.
  25. May 16, 2021
    8
    Just to go play it. It is excellent.

    The story is very romantic and beautiful. The characters are amazing. The sound design is fascinating. Why 8? There are many issues. Even though most of the fans say that automata is much worse than replicant, I don't agree with that. For some reason I just don't get the same chills and existential thoughts that I got after automata. The combat is
    Just to go play it. It is excellent.

    The story is very romantic and beautiful. The characters are amazing. The sound design is fascinating.

    Why 8? There are many issues. Even though most of the fans say that automata is much worse than replicant, I don't agree with that. For some reason I just don't get the same chills and existential thoughts that I got after automata. The combat is quite good, but gets a bit annoying after many hours that this game requires you to play. The backtracking and the repetitive aspects of the game are awful. At some point you really get insanely tired of the game.

    However, even though the game has different problems, overall it is still worth playing. It might give you a lot of things to reconsider.

    What Taro is doing in his games is actually making the player think about the basic things that we are all so used to. The concepts of life, love, meanings, destiny and others are actually very complex. Taro is trying to push these ideas to their limits. The game will make you think about the stuff that you think is obvious, but actually is not obvious at all. I believe that such stories are the most valuable nowadays.

    One thing I also really enjoy is that all his stories do not end well. Each quest, each characters' story, each enemy has a sad outcome. Everything in this game has a bad ending. All his stories are followed by loss, pain and death. But what Taro is doing is showing that bad is actually not that bad. We are constantly surrounded by bad things, but they are actually the only thing that makes everything else in our life matter. I think that this is the best way to show beauty. You only start valuing what you have when you lose everything else.
    Expand
  26. May 26, 2021
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. To much endings that’s make you feel boring sometimes …………………………………….. Expand
  27. Sep 5, 2021
    10
    True Masterpiece!

    I have seen pretty depressing/plot twisting medias to make my emotional receptors dull enough, this game rejuvenated those senses. At first this game looks just like any other games, as you progress, game gets darker and depressing, it's sad that you can almost sense those f*ckups but they are unavoidable as nightmares coming true. If first route was not depressing
    True Masterpiece!

    I have seen pretty depressing/plot twisting medias to make my emotional receptors dull enough, this game rejuvenated those senses. At first this game looks just like any other games, as you progress, game gets darker and depressing, it's sad that you can almost sense those f*ckups but they are unavoidable as nightmares coming true. If first route was not depressing enough, second route is just a bag of salt on wounds.
    NGL gameplay is punishing, going through same fights, same scenes, director knew what he was doing, it's like a testament for how much you crave for that extra bit of plot that can alter the whole story in a new direction. Game is different, that's what makes it unique and memorable.
    Expand
  28. Jun 19, 2022
    9
    Totally love the music and story, the battle system is ok, but the side quests are weak and the re runs to see all the endings can feel repetitive, nevertheless it is a must play
  29. Aug 6, 2023
    8
    Das Spiel ist so viel besser als ich erwartet habe!

    Jeder Soundtrack egal wie oft die sich nach und nach wiederholen ist einfach immer wieder gern anzuhören, es spielt sich wie NieR Automata mit dem extremst schnellen und präzisem Ausweichen, die Welt ist recht kompakt, hat dennoch genügend Orte und Fläche um eine großartige Story zu erzählen, die einen sehr mitnimmt und gerade die 2D
    Das Spiel ist so viel besser als ich erwartet habe!

    Jeder Soundtrack egal wie oft die sich nach und nach wiederholen ist einfach immer wieder gern anzuhören, es spielt sich wie NieR Automata mit dem extremst schnellen und präzisem Ausweichen, die Welt ist recht kompakt, hat dennoch genügend Orte und Fläche um eine großartige Story zu erzählen, die einen sehr mitnimmt und gerade die 2D Passagen wenn man in Häuser geht hat echt seinen Charme.

    Die englische Sprachausgabe ist auch wirklich großartig, da gibt´s kein Bedauern über eine fehlende deutsche. Ich bin gerade beim zweiten Ende, der Anfang davon ist erstmal ein halbes E-Book, danach wiederholt man die Main-Kämpfe und Wege dorthin und habe jetzt erstmal keine Lust mehr.
    Nach den Credits hätte Schluss sein können.
    Expand
  30. Dec 26, 2022
    10
    Replicant é meu segundo jogo favorito, perdendo apenas para o Automata.
    A trilha sonora aqui, segue sendo uma das mais marcantes que eu já ouvi na minha vida. A história é simplesmente épica, linda e cheia de desastres. Os plot twists, como de costume em NieR, são completamente insanos. Destaque para a história de Kainé.
    É uma jornada épica que justifica muitas coisas de Automata e expande
    Replicant é meu segundo jogo favorito, perdendo apenas para o Automata.
    A trilha sonora aqui, segue sendo uma das mais marcantes que eu já ouvi na minha vida. A história é simplesmente épica, linda e cheia de desastres. Os plot twists, como de costume em NieR, são completamente insanos. Destaque para a história de Kainé.
    É uma jornada épica que justifica muitas coisas de Automata e expande esse universo.
    Fiquei sem chão ao notar que antes da história da 2B e 9S, ocorreram tantas coisas nesse mundo. Chorei assim como chorei em Automata.
    Serão para sempre meus 2 jogos favoritos.
    Expand
  31. Aug 29, 2023
    8
    Positive Criticisms:

    Visual and Audio Design: The game's remastered graphics, character models, and environment designs are visually impressive. Similarly, the game's music and sound design have been praised for enhancing the atmosphere. Story and Character Development: One of the strongest aspects of the "NieR Replicant" series is its storytelling and character depth. Players can
    Positive Criticisms:

    Visual and Audio Design: The game's remastered graphics, character models, and environment designs are visually impressive. Similarly, the game's music and sound design have been praised for enhancing the atmosphere.

    Story and Character Development: One of the strongest aspects of the "NieR Replicant" series is its storytelling and character depth. Players can form an emotional connection with the main character Nier and the supporting characters.

    Combat and Gameplay Mechanics: The game's combat system and fighting mechanics offer a dynamic experience that requires players to utilize their skills. This has satisfied action RPG enthusiasts.

    Negative Criticisms:

    Lack of Modernized Gameplay: The remastered version of the game might give some critics the feeling that the original game has aged over time. The gameplay may not fully meet modern expectations and might feel clunky.

    Repetitive Sidequests: The game includes some repetitive side quests and activities. This repetition can lead to a sense of monotony in the later parts of the game.

    Navigation and Map Design: Lack of clear navigation in certain areas and complex map design can make it difficult for players to find their objectives.

    Graphical Issues: Some players have experienced performance issues and graphical glitches on both PC and console versions. These issues can negatively impact the gaming experience.

    In conclusion, "NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139..." has garnered mixed criticisms among gamers. Generally, aspects like story, character development, and atmosphere have been positively evaluated, while gameplay mechanics and technical issues have been at the forefront of some criticisms. Personal preferences, expectations, and whether players have experience with the original game play a significant role in how the game is evaluated.
    Expand
Metascore
80

Generally favorable reviews - based on 14 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 12 out of 14
  2. Negative: 0 out of 14
  1. Jul 6, 2021
    80
    NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139 is an extremely well-thought-out remaster that puts our resilience to the test, with a fantastic story and captivating characters. It does not completely let go of its origins, which at times are somewhat painful. It's a difficult love affair, it demands a lot of our time but it rewards us with one of the most curious and interesting stories of its genre.
  2. Despite the problematic PC port, NieR Replicant ver.1.22 is a great opportunity to experience the game released in 2010 with improved graphics, modern gameplay and excellent music.
  3. May 10, 2021
    75
    A solid action-RPG with a thought-provoking story and fun combat that is held back by repetitive quests and some dated gameplay elements. It is well worth a playthrough but only the most devoted will have the stamina to replay it multiple times to get the full story.