Scott Tobias
Select another critic »For 1,915 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
46% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
51% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 3.9 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Scott Tobias' Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 62 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Sansho the Bailiff | |
| Lowest review score: | AVPR: Aliens vs Predator - Requiem | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 975 out of 1915
-
Mixed: 723 out of 1915
-
Negative: 217 out of 1915
1915
movie
reviews
-
- Scott Tobias
Compared to the CGI chaos that tends to engulf DCEU and MCU movies, especially in crossover teamups, the clean zip of Pixar animation feels exhilaratingly rare, like a lost language rediscovered.- The Guardian
- Posted Jun 12, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A beautiful, mysterious, beguiling cinematic doodle, and an absolute master class in mise-en-scène, unfolding in odd, fragmented frames and precisely choreographed movement within those frames.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Steinbauer's eagerness to draw information--and, let's face it, exclusive new clips--out of his recalcitrant subject borders on exploitation at times, but the smart, cagey Rebney has an agenda of his own that Steinbauer can't entirely control or define. The documentary gives him a forum to be his funny, irreducible self, which is a luxury the accidentally famous are rarely afforded.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Savage Grace should have the force of Greek tragedy, but Kalin's chamber drama feels curiously stifling and flat, and Moore's volatile turn isn't enough to quicken its pulse.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
With this rueful, cantankerous yet hugely charismatic figure at its center, Tony Stone’s beautiful documentary reveals the twin burdens of working the farm alone while beating back an encroaching inner darkness.- Variety
- Posted Sep 8, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Boss Of It All, though clever as a piece of genre deconstruction, isn't terribly funny.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Can't help but be deeply engrossing, as it taps into a highly charged atmosphere that one parent dubs "a different form of child abuse."- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
ts small achievement is in trying to understand the life-and-death choices of two people who aren’t as certain about what they’re doing as they initially appear.- The Dissolve
- Posted Mar 10, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Benson and Moorhead have made a horror film for jaded aficionados, deconstructing and reconstructing tired elements into a gnarled, distinctive Frankenstein's monster. This monster might ransack a village, but it would have to think about it first.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jan 23, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Few directors are capable of marrying ideas and entertainment—one is often sacrificed for the other—but Spielberg peppers one gripping action setpiece after another with trenchant details about a near-future robbed of the most basic freedoms and privacy.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
After all, the documentary itself stands as a thrilling testament to the fact that art is — and should be — open to interpretation.- NPR
- Posted Mar 28, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film is a true torchbearer of the French New Wave—playful, restless, full of invention, and born of an overwhelming discontent for the status quo.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Zelker’s three-ring circus of digital and social-media content needs a compelling main event, and this movie seems unlikely to inspire many to check out the supplementary materials.- Variety
- Posted Apr 3, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Kudlácek rounds up a who's-who of experimental filmmakers, Haitian artists, dance choreographers, archivists, and programmers, all of whom reflect intelligently (though dryly) on Deren's importance in underground cinema.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The tiger footage in Two Brothers would make for a solid nature documentary, but because the animals are shoehorned into a narrative, they've been anthropomorphized to death.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Clouds Of Sils Maria is a great midlife crisis film, in other words, and, like Irma Vep, it’s also a great meta-commentary on contemporary moviemaking, with Assayas making keen observations about modern celebrity, screen-devouring blockbusters, Internet gossip culture, and the next generation of actresses, represented here by Kristen Stewart and Chloë Grace Moretz.- The Dissolve
- Posted Apr 7, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Eternity And A Day occasionally lapses into navel-gazing ennui, and Ganz's reluctant kinship with the adorable moppet courts cliché, but Angelopoulos strings together so many haunting, exquisitely choreographed sequences that even his worst ideas are emotionally resonant.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There are times when the title is more a wish than an action - because just as cocaine addicts are forever chasing that first high, there's always the hunger to recapture a lost feeling again, even for those who have spent years in recovery. Pity those who fall off the wagon.- NPR
- Posted Apr 19, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film is less about people or this specific herding ritual than about the majesty of the landscape and the interplay between these animals, their keepers, and the dictates of nature itself.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jul 9, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Trobisch has made a drama of tragic accommodation — limited not to one woman’s sexual assault, but to the everyday interactions that all women must navigate carefully.- The New York Times
- Posted Jun 6, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It may not have been what the producers had in mind, but they asked for a Paul Schrader movie, and that's exactly what he delivered.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Watching Rocky Balboa go through the usual paces does trigger a few helpless waves of nostalgia, especially once Bill Conti's famed score kicks in and Stallone sticks it to a few sides of beef. But audiences needn't be responsible for helping an over-the-hill actor through his midlife crisis.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
For most of the way, right up until a hastily contrived and deeply unsatisfying ending, the film perceptively sketches a fractured identity, a man who enters a new life carrying painful remnants of the old.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Oct 10, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A viscerally punishing study of repression and masochism, carried out with the utmost discretion and chilling reserve.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Beyond The Hills has a rich understanding of the appeals and perils of religious values that provide structure and meaning to some while seeming cruel and irrational to outsiders. It’s a world within a world, and Mungiu peers from a clear window.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Mar 6, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In a sense, Oasis is an unabashed tearjerker, but Lee keeps knocking the melodrama off-balance, making all the big emotional payoffs a little discomforting, because they're not that far removed from something really disturbing.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There are times when even its subtleties seem predictable, when it questions dramatic conventions that indie films have already questioned, like the temperament of movie-parents whose children fear coming out of the closet. Yet the film has an abiding sweetness that's ultimately irresistible.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Dec 29, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Rwandan genocide was one of the most shameful marks on Bill Clinton's presidency, but for all the film's powerful images, George stops short of the forceful political statement that Rusesabagina's story demands.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Shot on three mobile phones, Fazili’s Midnight Traveler is a documentary that feels like a modern-day message in a bottle, an urgent appeal for help from a family that’s still searching for a home.- Variety
- Posted Apr 18, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's a powerful idea in the abstract, the culmination of three acts that cover a 25-year catastrophe with a time-lapse breathlessness. It just never leaves the abstract and becomes flesh.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 9, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
For a film about man who spent half his life defying staid convention, Kinsey remains as timid as a choirboy.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film is a powerful reminder never to underestimate the historical evils that have been, and could again be, unleashed.- Variety
- Posted Sep 23, 2021
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In Chéreau's hands, Gabrielle has an operatic quality that throws the repressive environment into sharp relief; the film works like a pressure cooker, seething with bottled passions that intermittently burst through with startling cruelty and violence.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Christophers is a slippery customer, an ingenious and twisty two-hander that shifts in tone as Lori and Julian get their hooks into each other. Coel and McKellen prove to be a combustible pair, two actors of contrasting generations, genders, and race who parry in darkly funny sessions that morph in complexity as their characters continue to try to outflank each other.- The Reveal
- Posted Apr 10, 2026
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film deftly sketches a sibling relationship complicated by obligation, guilt, mistrust, and, not least, an abiding love.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Perhaps because the present-day characters are such insufferable twits -- especially the brooding Penn, who's given to tossing around stanzas by Yeats and Dylan Thomas -- the modern story feels like a device, a flimsy entrée into events that would be better accessed directly.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
What begins as a sophisticated meditation on the meaning of heroism gradually slumps into leaden repetition in the second half, as the point gets watered down and belabored. After such provocative beginnings, the film finally, dutifully raises its hand in salute.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Like many debut features, Reprise is a foremost a statement of purpose, and in that respect, at least, Trier shows limitless promise.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Under his (McElwee's) watch, the possibilities of a documentary seem to expand by the minute, incorporating not only journalistic truths, but also personal insights and philosophy, unique regional textures, and unexposed pockets of humanity.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
If The Winslow Boy has a flaw, it's that Mamet's style is impeccable to a fault, too cool and remote to have much of an emotional payoff. But since few directors can even approach his level of precision, that's a very minor complaint.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Tsai's latest, What Time Is It There?, runs his usual themes and obsessions through a whimsical premise worthy of Wong Kar-Wai, striking such an exquisite balance between humor and despair that the moods comfortably coexist, just as they do in real life.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film satisfies in much the same way Allen's movie-a-year comedies used to satisfy.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film is little more than an exercise in style, but it's dazzling and mythic, a testament to the fundamental appeal of fast cars, dangerous men, and tension that squeezes like a hand to the throat.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Sep 14, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Past the novelty of its conceit and casting, and the animating intelligence of its first-time director, Henry Hobson, Maggie is a bit of a drag.- The Dissolve
- Posted May 6, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Bale's live-wire performance typifies the many major and minor elements that elevate The Fighter from the deeply conventional sports movie it might have been into the endearingly offbeat sports movie it turns out to be.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Dec 9, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Polinger tracks the escalation of danger and violence with startling intensity—the first third of Full Metal Jacket also appears to be an influence—but there’s nuance to the way Ben chooses to handle this situation.- The Reveal
- Posted Dec 30, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Don’t Think I’ve Forgotten could stand to be a tighter, punchier assemblage of music and talking heads, but Pirozzi has gathered an impressive array of surviving musicians and family members willing to talk about the targeting of artists for propaganda and death.- The Dissolve
- Posted Apr 21, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Director Jon Favreau, who dipped profitably into family entertainment with 2003's "Elf," effectively recreates the illustrative universe of a good children's book, but he's stuck with a story that noisily grinds its gears.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
At bottom, Silent Light is less about faith than matters of the heart, and in Reygadas' hands, the ache is bone-deep.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Only Lovers Left Alive accomplishes the neat trick of reinventing a moribund genre as a distinctly Jarmuschian hangout movie.- The Dissolve
- Posted Apr 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Doesn't function nearly as well as a standalone piece, mainly because it's stuck with the thankless task of mopping up after the other two.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Channels Toback in his purest form, which will probably be a treat for auteurists and a headache for just about everyone else.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film is often a rough, searching, unfocused piece of work, but at a minimum, it affirms Bell as a talent to watch both as an actress and a writer-director, one with a strong, developing comedic sensibility.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 8, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
DuVernay stages well-known public events like the “Bloody Sunday” march with scrupulousness, scope, and a gut-wrenching visceral power. But Selma’s true success is as a chamber piece, not a thundering historical epic.- The Dissolve
- Posted Dec 22, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Make no mistake: Poltergeist is a Spielberg film, no matter what the credits say. His stylistic fingerprints are all over the movie, never more so than in the opening third, which turns a suburban haunting into an occasion for Spielbergian movie magic before the ghosts get down to business.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Like other great pastiche artists, Gomes has created a time machine to a cinematic era that never quite existed, so it feels simultaneously borrowed and new.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Dec 27, 2012
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Schrader has always been better as a writer and a critic than as a dramatist, which is why his most successful work has either been published in film journals or directed by Martin Scorsese. His flat, awkward staging diminishes some good performances -- particularly those of Nolte and a welcome Sissy Spacek.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Miss Bala toes a delicate line between exploitation movie and movie about exploitation, but that's part of what gives the film its charge - this isn't some flaccid docudrama about how the cartels are poisoning the country, it's a lively, white-knuckle thriller where any such proselytizing is reduced to implication.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jan 25, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It’s an ideal showcase for the four leads, who are given the latitude to create fully human characters.- Variety
- Posted Feb 28, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Throughout Keane, there's an unnerving feeling that Lewis is capable of anything, from harming himself to assaulting anyone around him.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film does coast along smoothly to the inevitable, which is a credit to the always-game Reese Witherspoon, who's courteous enough to pretend she doesn't know what's coming, then make it look like a huge surprise.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A documentary that focuses rigorously on process and atmosphere at the expense of context and engagement.- NPR
- Posted Aug 12, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Zodiac is the rare serial-killer movie in which the psychosis stems as much from the pursuers (and the filmmaker) as the pursued.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Coming after the inspired trifecta of "Dracula: Pages From A Virgin's Diary," "Cowards Bend The Knee," and "The Saddest Music In The World," Brand feels a little like boilerplate Maddin rather than a fresh burst of inspiration.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Smith delights in these offbeat personalities and their jerry-rigged accoutrements, but the real joy in the film comes from the happy interaction between the subjects and their creations.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Morris’ film does everything it can to make Hawking’s thinking accessible to a wider audience, and reveal how A Brief History Of Time is as much its author’s story as it is the story of the universe.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The secondhand guilt that comes from watching a conscientious woman reckon with her role in an institutional sin is immense and it’s a credit to Jude that he’s so willing to make his audience uncomfortable.- The Reveal
- Posted Mar 27, 2026
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film ends so beautifully that it's easy to forgive the dead passages that preceded it and hope it carries over into his next movie.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Under Fresnadillo's assured direction, 28 Weeks Later blurs the line between genre entertainment and a photojournalist's shots of the next urban catastrophe.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Nolan reverses the emphasis -- no surprise from the director of a plot-driven film like "Memento" -- but achieves the same end, bringing Hollywood noir under the harsh glare of permanent daylight.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Like many French films of its kind, Private Property remains content to simply observe a situation without tidying up the narrative, which in this case leaves some big questions unanswered. But Lafosse knows that problems that beg for a resolution sometimes don't get one.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It’s only fitting that a series that began with the concept of linking the digestive tracts of three people would end by feasting on its own shit.- The Dissolve
- Posted May 19, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Plenty of entertaining action movies have been made since John Woo's 1992 Hard Boiled, but really, what's the point?- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A romantic comedy with jagged edges, Fatih Akin's exhilarating Head-On paves the road to love through miles of prickly thatch.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The hits outnumber the misses well enough in Airplane!, especially in the first half, when the Zucker-Abrahams-Zucker team (writer-directors David Zucker, Jim Abrahams, and Jerry Zucker) are layering jokes in the foreground and background. There are parodies of popular favorites like Jaws and Saturday Night Fever, wacky stock footage on back-screen projection, slapstick violence against various religious solicitors, and plenty of silly wordplay.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It’s a fascinating time capsule, catching a new, empowered Democratic machine in its infancy.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Like a lot of scenes in Funny Ha Ha, the commonplace somehow seems invigoratingly original.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In the scope of things, Ohwon's story is a route into the larger story of an uncertain and tumultuous period in Korea, and it's here that Chi-hwa-seon loses its grip.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A little of this stuff goes a long way with Cattet and Forzani, who have always seemed more immersed in image-making than in the tedious business of telling a story with a mind toward pace and characterization. To experience their films is to toggle between exhilaration and enervation, and hope the balance tips the right way in the end, which it ultimately does with Reflection in a Dead Diamond.- The Reveal
- Posted Dec 5, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The vibrant rap drama Hustle & Flow wraps the authentic around the inauthentic, telling an underdog story that sticks to formula, yet resonates with an undeniably real energy and texture.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Malick's powerful intermingling of brutality and beauty, his signature cutaways to indigenous flora and fauna, and the gentle lyricism of his disjunctive narration and painterly images are too rich to fully register in a single viewing.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Despite a too-neat resolution, the characters in Results haven’t figured themselves out, much less their relationships, and Bujalski is perfectly comfortable sorting through their confusion.- The Dissolve
- Posted May 28, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The miracle of Nolan's Batman trilogy is the way it imprints those myths with the dread-soaked tenor of the times.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jul 18, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The true puzzle here is grief, that nebulous process where there’s no clear answer or road map, just behaviors and rituals that feel distinctly removed from the flow of everyday life. Petzold and his cast spend time in that stream, and it’s an alluring feeling to drift along with them.- The Reveal
- Posted Mar 27, 2026
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Like Blood Simple, Blue Ruin deals in crimes of passion, carried out by human beings who are flawed yet tragically relatable—one is about mopping up the blood, the other about the impossibility of stanching the flow.- The Dissolve
- Posted Apr 24, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
While there are surely gags and references that are for-fans-only in the film, which exists in part to pay off longstanding support, Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie is shambling and sweet, loaded with hilarious standalone bits that are held together by the duo’s warm camaraderie and intimate connection to the city of Toronto.- The Reveal
- Posted Feb 20, 2026
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The result is a powerfully visceral experience that justifies itself almost entirely on surface chops, with striking color composition and a complex sound design that elevates the story to an operatic scale.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
If there’s anything worth extrapolating from The Tribe, it isn’t the deaf experience so much as recognizing our own tendencies to conform to certain unspoken laws. The more insular a society, the more severe the consequences of rebellion.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jun 16, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Morvern Callar not only attempts to reveal an interior life, usually the province of novels, but also focuses on the interior life of a woman who refuses to open up to anyone.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The clipped tough-guy language, Juan Ruiz Anchía's rich chiaroscuro lighting, the layers of "short cons" and larger deceptions—they're all elements of a genre whose time had passed, but that Mamet was able to revive with effortless aplomb.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Given their reputations as feminist provocateurs, the coming together of Breillat and Argento seems natural, even inevitable, and The Last Mistress gets a charge from their feisty, uncompromising spirit.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Maddin films have a higher rate of invention per frame than the majority of his peers can muster.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Debut features are rarely this confident and accomplished, much less such a perfect blueprint of what to expect from a filmmaker down the line.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Without the landscape or the heroine expressing themselves particularly sharply, Tracks is just a taciturn young woman wandering through the desert for months. In other words, a slog.- The Dissolve
- Posted Sep 19, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Portraits of maternal ambivalence are rare in cinema and Bronstein pushes it to the limit, turning motherhood into a white-knuckle experience with the highest of stakes.- The Reveal
- Posted Oct 16, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
These images and reports have stirred consciences without quite stirring decisive action, and an earnest indie doc like this one seems like another cry in the wilderness.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though narrower in scope and lacking the first-person angle, Waste Land resembles Agnès Varda's great 2000 documentary "The Gleaners & I," particularly in its awe of tough, creative, hard-working people who live on the margins.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Oct 28, 2010
- Read full review