Scott Tobias
Select another critic »For 1,915 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
46% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
51% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 3.9 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Scott Tobias' Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 62 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Sansho the Bailiff | |
| Lowest review score: | AVPR: Aliens vs Predator - Requiem | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 975 out of 1915
-
Mixed: 723 out of 1915
-
Negative: 217 out of 1915
1915
movie
reviews
-
- Scott Tobias
It’s haunting and beautiful at times, surprisingly playful at others, and like all great movies about magic, it has more than a few tricks up its sleeve.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Nebraska is one of Payne’s best films, a near-perfect amalgam of the acrid humor, great local color, and stirring resonances that run through his work.- The Dissolve
- Posted Nov 13, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though it has the dramatic apparatus of fiction, the film unfolds with a documentary-like openness to the world around it.- The Dissolve
- Posted May 22, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though conventional in many respects, it feels like no other boxing film ever made, due largely to Eastwood's unmistakable presence on both sides of the camera.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Plenty of entertaining action movies have been made since John Woo's 1992 Hard Boiled, but really, what's the point?- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It would be enough for The Babadook to get by on scares alone—the eponymous spook is eminiently franchise-able—but Kent doesn’t give the audience that kind of distance. Her agenda is more personal.- The Dissolve
- Posted Nov 26, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
McQueen speeding across the German countryside and leaping over the first of two barbed-wire fences leading into Switzerland may be the film's most iconic and enduring image. Dubious or not, it's a triumph of sorts that a tale that ends in war crimes could have such a rousing conclusion.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In spite of some thoughtful-and occasionally just bizarre-rumination on what the marvels of Chaumet really signify, Cave Of Forgotten Dreams often feels as stifling as the place it explores, rather than the sensual odyssey its evocative title suggests.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Apr 28, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Drawing on a wealth of footage from inside ACT UP meetings and protests, David France's powerful documentary How To Survive A Plague pays tribute to their courage and relentlessness, but it's even better as a record of the tactics of effective activism.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Sep 19, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
When victims and their families talk about having their lives wrecked by a sexually abusive priest in the forceful documentary Deliver Us From Evil, that destruction is as much spiritual as psychological.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Little beyond Servillo’s presence gives the film any ballast, which is both asset and liability, freeing Sorrentino to pepper the screen with wild setpieces and fits of inspiration while encouraging a certain shapelessness.- The Dissolve
- Posted Nov 13, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Arriving in the middle of the Reagan 1980s, Repo Man remains one of the few examples of revolt within the system, and it’s no surprise to learn that Cox is fond of John Carpenter’s 1988 cult classic They Live, which also weds genre mayhem to cutting political satire.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's a feisty, contentious, deliberately misshapen film, designed to challenge and frustrate audiences looking for a clean resolution. Just because it's over doesn't mean it's settled.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Sep 12, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Story has made a potent political film without having to spray viewers with a fusillade of alarming numbers to back it up. She trusts viewers to intuit their way through fascinating anecdotes and detours that gain a cumulative power, one that data alone cannot possibly express.- Variety
- Posted Nov 3, 2016
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Dardennes sustain that tension through a masterful closing drive that resembles the final third of "In The Bedroom," only without the same dreadful inevitability.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
With startling clarity and dreadful logic, Loach and Laverty make sense of every bad choice Compston makes until he runs out of options, locked into a destiny that he can't escape, mainly because his good intentions are clouded by tragic naivete.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Witnessing outreach workers intervening in these situations is inspiring enough, but their subtlety and nuance in neutralizing people of different backgrounds and temperaments is especially impressive.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jul 28, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Like its spiritual predecessor The Battle Of Algiers, Z is as much a mini-revolution as it is a movie, actively engaging in a political battle as it was unfolding.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Persona feels like an act of disclosure on Bergman’s part, with him pulling back the curtain to acknowledge the fantasy of filmmaking and global realities that linger in his mind.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film wilts under the harsh light of rationality; after all, how could anyone make sense of a heroine whose doppelgänger is both distinctly separate and inextricably connected to her? And yet these parallel lives rhyme so tunefully through the reflective cinematography and sweeping score that any confusion or disbelief tends to melt away.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Flight was commissioned by producers overseas, and it feels similarly, impeccably slight.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Damon's minimalist style is key to why the Bourne movies have become an oasis from other blockbuster action fare.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Through Brody's remarkably controlled, self-effacing performance, Polanski succeeds in making his hero an invisible man, but the sights he conjures are surprisingly artless and ordinary, familiar from a dozen other Holocaust dramas. Among the casualties in The Pianist is a great director's imagination.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film never feels entirely staid: Lu wriggles out of convention where he can, especially in the first half, and engages with history as an artist, not a hagiographer.- The A.V. Club
- Posted May 12, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The frequent outbursts of comedy help alleviate a tone that's appropriately muted and sad, and Jenkins should be credited for refusing to tack smiley-faces onto a tough, possibly lose-lose situation.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film's visceral assault extends to the sledgehammer script, an amassment of unsubtle ironies and war-is-hell clichés that often reduce it to an amateurish theatrical stunt.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- NPR
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It doesn’t matter what’s real and not real in The Rider. What matters is that it’s true.- Uproxx
- Posted Apr 12, 2018
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though frequently dazzling, Kings And Queen proves that a bunch of punchy singles don't necessarily make an album.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
No one writes for ensembles better than Apatow, and his players are all skilled at giving his work a loose, improvisational feel.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
When a director of Scorsese's caliber is working at the top of his game, it's a reminder of why we go to the movies in the first place.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Gosling excels at playing contradictory characters like this one, having kick-started his career as a Jewish neo-Nazi in "The Believer," but here, his inner turmoil rarely gets vocalized. It's a remarkably subtle performance.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Payne, the great satirist behind "Citizen Ruth" and "Election," loves to populate his films with throwaway details, which in About Schmidt accumulate into a portrait of Midwestern life that's almost chilling in its exactitude.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Asphalt Jungle would be considered a heist picture if the mood didn't dictate otherwise. The standard "honor among thieves" theme applies, but dishonor gives the film its special noir flavor.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Brilliant in flashes, thinned out as a whole, the film seems ideal for the DVD revolution, where the greatest hits can be compiled at the touch of a remote.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Pursuit Of Happyness represents a belated and calculated attempt to scrape off the glossy movie-star veneer and connect with the everyday struggles of living hand-to-mouth in the big city, but it's too late. Watching his (Smith's) performance here is a little like imagining an American version of "Rosetta" starring Julia Roberts.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Farhadi isn’t interested in judging his characters so much as comprehending them in all their complexity, and registering the consequences of their actions, particularly on children.- The Dissolve
- Posted Dec 19, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It’s odd to see a romance that commences with rough trade in an alleyway end up feeling like a spiritual descendent of Bend It Like Beckham.- The Reveal
- Posted Feb 13, 2026
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though bookended by extraordinarily powerful scenes that play off a potent religious metaphor, the middle section sinks into a morass of ill-defined relationships and uneven performances, which may be blamed in part on culture clash.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In terms of scale, The Tree Of Life recalls the mammoth ambition of Stanley Kubrick's "2001: A Space Odyssey," but it's also more intimate and personal than Malick's previous films, rooted in vivid memories of growing up in '50s Texas.- The A.V. Club
- Posted May 26, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Most of all, The Host functions as a popcorn movie par excellence, loaded with the most familiar conventions, but shot through with such conviction and visual panache that even its clichés seem invigorating.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
With the conceptual rigor and emotional directness associated with the best of Iranian cinema, Oskouei simply listens to the stories of those who have never been listened to before. Their shattering testimony, elegantly harmonized in a chorus of stolen childhood, has universal appeal.- Variety
- Posted Jan 17, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Meticulous and immersive, Meek's Cutoff feels like history in three dimensions.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Apr 7, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Like many French films of its kind, Private Property remains content to simply observe a situation without tidying up the narrative, which in this case leaves some big questions unanswered. But Lafosse knows that problems that beg for a resolution sometimes don't get one.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A singularly beautiful nostalgia piece that radiates with love and sadness, and doesn’t extract one type of feeling from another. It’s a film of aching bittersweetness, impeccably realized, past perfect.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Coogler isn’t exactly an invisible hand. He pokes and prods his audience at every turn: Neither the false moments nor the powerful ones leave much mystery about how we’re supposed to feel.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jul 11, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It may be painful at times, but Rachel Getting Married sure is one heck of a party.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's the definition of a film meant to be admired more than loved, but Desplechin's fierce intelligence and uncompromising sense of character come through, as does some of the sharp wit and stylistic flourishes left over from his last film, 2004's "Kings And Queen."- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There's none of the poetry of "For All Mankind," just visual support for a meat-and-potatoes recap of events that have already been chewed over plenty.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Quietly asserts its eccentric romanticism with an assured, matter-of-fact blend of humor and pathos.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Moonrise Kingdom is Anderson's most completely satisfying film since the one-two of "Rushmore" and "The Royal Tenenbaums," in part because it's the perfect distillation of both.- The A.V. Club
- Posted May 23, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though the story's Shakespearean underpinnings give Kagemusha the weight of classic tragedy–in this case, the tragedy of a man rendered helpless by larger historical forces–the film astonishes mostly as pure spectacle.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
While it falls short of its predecessors, the film is generally more confident and inventive than any of the non-Toy Story Pixar sequels.- The Verge
- Posted Jun 13, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Anarchy finally reigned supreme in 1932's classic Horse Feathers, which was the first Marx brothers comedy that smoothly integrated the story into the troupe's routine.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Trier doesn't allow the bleakness of the material to swamp the film in a miserablist tone, but he doesn't hold back, either, in revealing every hairline crack in Lie's fragile psyche.- The A.V. Club
- Posted May 23, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Old Joy doesn't try for too much, but its subtle victories leave plenty to savor.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Writer-director Charles Sturridge doesn't mess with the Lassie formula--he provides plenty of dog-porn shots of the collie bounding through scenery in slow motion--but the overqualified cast puts the film over the top.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Sun and Chiang strike a tricky balance between a high-stakes making-of documentary and an intimate, observational family portrait, but Maleonn is such a thoughtful, sensitive, brilliant subject that the film is compelling no matter where on the creative spectrum they find him.- Variety
- Posted Sep 10, 2020
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Even as The Quiet American loses focus and urgency, Caine's performance keeps the doomed spirit of Greene's hero intact.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
This Arthur cravenly turns Susan into a monstrous status-seeker, making her less of a human being and thus much easier for Arthur to trample over in securing a meaningful adult relationship.- NPR
- Posted Apr 7, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Bujalski's brand of stylized dialogue sounds genuinely fly-on-the-wall.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Stray Dogs evokes the whole of Tsai’s filmography, but also pays off his collaboration with Lee, who shows a side of himself that’s been hidden away for all these years.- The Dissolve
- Posted Sep 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
An inspired, original, and gracefully integrated collaboration of theater and cinema that complements not only both forms, but also the seductive, dreamlike qualities of the source material.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Shapeless and overlong, How Do You Know unfolds in a heap of unprocessed ideas and emotions, as if Brooks started production two or three drafts too early.- NPR
- Posted Dec 17, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The great Kôji Yakusho stars as a revered samurai who decides that enough is enough, and sets about assembling the assassins of the title like a men-on-a-mission movie.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jun 2, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Schumacher choose to start the movie in outer space? The opening shot epitomizes everything wrong with Phone Booth: Given the chance to stage human drama on an intimate, suffocating scale, Schumacher begins in the endless expanse of the void, tricked out with gratuitous CGI effects.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Wrong Man, an overlooked masterpiece from his greatest decade, eschews suspense for the straight-up nightmare of an innocent man dragged through the justice system.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Has an exhilarating edge. It's only when they open their mouths that the movie gets into trouble.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
So why, given its moment-to-moment surplus of visual imagination, does the film feel so hollow and unsatisfying?- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Kaufman strikes just the right balance between playfulness and sincerity, leaping freely from one absurd situation to another before pulling back on the reins.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The experience is two-thirds thrilling to one-third enervating, a winning ratio for what's essentially a tightly curated anthology film.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 6, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Secret Of The Grain stretches out at the relaxed pace of a seven-course meal, but at the end of it, Kechiche has squeezed the most he can out of percolating dramas within the family and he lets the audience get to know its members without needing to throw them all a subplot.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A tasteless, witless, mindlessly perfunctory bloodbath that has the discourtesy to take itself seriously. Pitting aliens against predators may be the height of frivolity, but God forbid anyone have fun with it.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Amen should be a powderkeg of a movie, yet the urgency and force that defined Costa-Gavras' earlier work has been drained away, along with his invigorating newsreel craft.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Making his feature debut, director Sacha Gervasi follows up his fine documentary "Anvil: The Story Of Anvil" with another story about the perils of uncompromising creative endeavor, but his Hitchcock goes only a step beyond caricature.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Nov 23, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Fantastic Mr. Fox may be his most purely pleasurable film to date, evoking the Dahl books and Rankin-Bass productions that so transported him as a kid.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Edited with an impeccable sense of timing and rhythm, with each new revelation and insight planted at just the right moment, Bus 174 examines an already gripping story from a moving and untold perspective.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Showing the best of humanity and the worst of humanity doesn’t mean denying one in favor of the other; taken together, Salgado’s photographs have the scope and perspective of someone who can genuinely say he’s seen it all.- The Dissolve
- Posted Mar 26, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It is shocking in its revelations, thrilling in its possibilities.- The Reveal
- Posted Oct 16, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though Chop Shop is an American film, it feels more like an Iranian movie or the Dardenne Brothers’ "Rosetta"; Bahrani introduces something like a plot point in the late-going, but he mostly focuses, to riveting effect, on how his young hero hustles and claws through everyday life.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
What makes Raising Victor Vargas so special, beyond its irresistible charisma, is how Sollett and his cast capture the thrill of first love.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Apart from anything else, Predators is a clinic in documentary ethics, but Osit’s intellect doesn’t mute his pain, sensitivity and outrage. It’s a film for the heart and the head.- The Reveal
- Posted Oct 2, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
To an equal extent, Project Nim shows the human capacity for cruelty and narcissism as well as compassion and selflessness.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jul 7, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film has much more sophistication than the average throwback, but the search for justice across Indian Territory is uncomplicated and righteous, and the half-contentious/half-sentimental relationship between a plucky teenager and an irascible old coot grounds it in the tried-and-true.- The Guardian
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Avatar is a weak patchwork of his other films: the leaden voiceover from "Terminator 2" here, the military/civilian conflict from "Aliens" there, even a Jack-and-Rose-style forbidden love story cued to adult-contempo soundtrack.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Morgen isn’t interested in rehashing the facts and highlights of Cobain’s life and career, or in providing chin-scratching insights via music scholars and other talking heads. He’s made an impression of Cobain, which is a much more intuitive and vital enterprise.- The Dissolve
- Posted Apr 23, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's a complex fusion of film history and personal history, filled with dazzling embellishments and unabashed sentiment about the glories of cinema.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Nov 22, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Raimi’s new film feels distinctly unburdened and fun, happily frolicking in its own pulp silliness.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Chabrol handles the upended family dynamic beautifully until the final third, when a wildly implausible sequence of events lessens the suspense just as he should be turning the screws.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's a little disappointing to see Van Sant dial back into mainstream respectability. Had he evoked Harvey Milk's life with the poetry that he did Kurt Cobain's, Milk might have been something special.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Newton has made a beautiful little film about sacrifice and redemption, and he earns it one tiny brushstroke at a time.- Variety
- Posted May 21, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Cutie And The Boxer chronicles a marriage that’s extraordinary in many ways, and ordinary in one—it’s a constant work in progress.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 15, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The issue may be polarizing, but Vera Drake resonates with such seriousness and truth that it transcends the narrow limitations of polemic.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
If nothing else, the film puts the lie to the notion that an abortion could ever be frivolous or lightly considered. On that point, everyone in Lake Of Fire agrees, whether they acknowledge the other side or not.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Kitano infects the lyrical, meditative beauty of classical Japanese cinema with the jarring, low-down savagery of Western genre pictures. What emerges is more than the sum of its parts, an original and profound statement on mortality, how rich human life can be, and how quickly it can be taken away.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film might have been more powerful, not to mention fair, if the nuns believed they were doing right; only on movie night, when McEwan sees herself in Ingrid Bergman in "The Bells Of St. Mary's," does Mullan grant her so much as the delusion of rectitude.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review