Scott Tobias
Select another critic »For 1,915 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
46% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
51% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 3.9 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Scott Tobias' Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 62 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Sansho the Bailiff | |
| Lowest review score: | AVPR: Aliens vs Predator - Requiem | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 975 out of 1915
-
Mixed: 723 out of 1915
-
Negative: 217 out of 1915
1915
movie
reviews
-
- Scott Tobias
In an era full of auteur-driven turbulence in Hollywood, The Sting stands out as a model of old-school craft, a richly appointed studio production with big stars and a premium on efficiency and pace.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Herzog also finds extraordinary beauty in what Dorrington is trying to accomplish: Like Jean-Jacques Rousseau in his boat, Dorrington wants to float around the natural world in a reverie, and when he finally does, he experiences a connection with Plage that's genuinely transcendent.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Mitchell’s deft handling of the relationships in It Follows gets threaded into an ingenious and exceedingly skillful creepshow.- The Dissolve
- Posted Mar 9, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Ballard makes a simple, deeply affecting emotional associations between Amy, her father, the geese, and the absent mothers and cinematographer Caleb Deschanel bathes the action in an appropriately magisterial beauty.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Witherspoon's broad, obsessive comic performance is bound to get the most attention, but Broderick does the best work of his career, finding an affecting spot between the all-purpose defiance of Ferris Bueller and the put-upon foil of his recent work.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It takes enormous skill to pull off such a high-wire act without diminishing the gravity of the situation, but Bong and his first-rate cast are up to the task.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
At times, Goldsworthy's philosophy edges into fuzzy New Age-isms, but with an ever-widening gulf separating humans from their environment, his work demonstrates the enlightening pleasures of reconnecting.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Viewers can walk away with something more precious than factoids: an emotional, aesthetically striking experience that cuts more deeply than words. And if they crave more information, that’s what the Internet is for.- The Dissolve
- Posted Oct 29, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A sampler of novella-length films set in three different time periods and starring the same two actors, Hou Hsiao-hsien's Three Times resembles one of those delicate trios served at fine restaurants, each a fresh interpretation of a common ingredient.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Worse still, all that introspection adds up to a disappointingly shallow accumulation of regrets and life lessons, none of them surprising. After the adrenaline rush, 127 Hours turns to vapor.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Nov 4, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There's a suffocating air to The Deep Blue Sea that makes it harder to access than other period romances of its kind, but Davies aligns himself wholly with Hester.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Mar 21, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Handsomely produced and photographed, which alone distinguishes it from the guerrilla standards of its cut-rate peers, Enron succeeds most by simply making a complex situation graspable, a tall order when the perpetrators are masters of grand-scale deception.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Remove all the crime-movie trappings—and there aren't that many, once Altman gets through with them—and the film would still endure for its surface alone, capturing the Depression-era South with brushstrokes of language, décor, and radio-plays on the soundtrack.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The cheetah is the star in Duma, and no one directs animals more convincingly than Ballard, who knows better than anyone how to integrate patchwork nature shots into narrative action. Too bad the two-legged talking animals aren't as compelling this time out.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Fiennes is the perfect John Le Carré hero: reserved and sophisticated, possessing the driest of wits, yet deceptively passionate in a way that people never really anticipate from him.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Since the focus is on the track, the filmmakers aren't out to reinvent the wheel, but for such a simple piece of formula storytelling, they do a remarkably poor job of dotting I's and crossing T's.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The simplified, handheld camerawork and the idea of “cutting for emotion” rather than continuity gets the most out of his actors, who are free to clash and improvise within a scene without worrying about hitting their marks.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Settles into pleasant monotony and repetition, without any narrative arc or purpose. Seasoned bird-watchers, however, may find that the sensory overload leaves them close to spiritual nirvana.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though Rebels Of The Neon God is missing the austerity and discipline that would make Tsai’s master-shot style so effective—and funny—its relatively conventional approach (including a recurring musical theme!) doesn’t obscure the beautiful, enigmatic tone that’s long set him apart.- The Dissolve
- Posted Apr 8, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though tagged as the director's bid for commercial success, School Of Rock is as philosophical in its own way as "Slacker" or "Waking Life." It was made by people who not only know the music well enough to create magnificent flowcharts around it, but also understand how a simple, soul-stirring rock song can seem revolutionary.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Provides one of the rare glimpses of the upper class to come out of recent Iranian cinema--the last one in memory was 1996's exquisite, Ibsen-esque melodrama "Leila"--and director Jafar Panahi (The Circle) captures it vividly through his hero's wounded obsession.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
With shades of Carrie, Harry's magical powers and adolescent angst make a combustible fusion, taking on frightening, vengeful implications that Cuarón honors by refusing to airbrush the shadowy regions of fantasy.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
This is not some nostalgia-soaked throwback to the noir of old, but a rude, shit-kicking thriller that co-opts - and merrily defiles - a classic like "Double Indemnity." Whatever its shortcomings, at least they're never failures of nerve.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jul 25, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Even in its rougher patches, The Spectacular Now has a disarming earnestness that keeps it on the level, helped along by two superb lead performances that add up to more than their sum.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 1, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
At its heart, Touching The Void contends with the physical and spiritual dilemma of facing the unknown and overcoming paralyzing fear in order to emerge reborn on the other side. But the film's appeal is even more fundamental than that: It's just one of those stories that catches the breath, no matter how often it's told.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Kaurismäki has a narrow vision, disarming and sweet, yet utterly predictable, and there's little distinction between the films he's directing today and the films he directed 30 years ago. They have the wrong kind of timelessness.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Oct 19, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's a hilariously half-baked scheme, one that quickly turns them from hunters to hunted, but the strength of The Hunting Party is its shaggy-dog quality.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In its dramatic shift from the real to the allegorical, the ending of Andrey Zvyagintsev's auspicious debut feature The Return is likely to leave many viewers scratching their heads.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Much of the observational brilliance of Approaching The Elephant comes from how closely form relates to content: Out of chaos comes order, both at Teddy McArdle and in the film, which brings the personalities and conflicts into sharper focus as it goes along.- The Dissolve
- Posted Feb 17, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
If the role brings her more recognition and work, all the better, but Leo certainly isn't lobbying for it. She doesn't show off. She just does what she's always done: Reveals a character for who she is, nothing more, nothing less.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A daring and immediate debut feature for Koshashvili, Late Marriage could lead two likeminded people to opposite conclusions, and that may be its greatest strength.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though its heroine's mysterious seizures and blackouts are terrifying in the way they undermine her quest for self-determination, Requiem isn't a horror movie so much as a thwarted coming-of-age story, like "Carrie" without the bloody reckoning.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Fly movies could be a metaphor for sequels: Always go for the real article, not the freakishly mutated copy one telepod over.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Whatever lizard-brain fun might have been had in watching Johnson do battle against a drug cartel is weakened by the occasional hard tug at the social conscience. The film winds up divided against itself.- NPR
- Posted Feb 22, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It might be fair to argue that the resonances of Upstream Color are too obscure and internal — many viewers have and will be baffled by it — but it’s the type of art that inspires curiosity and obsession, like some beautiful object whose meaning remains tantalizingly out of reach.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Apr 3, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The body means different things for each of them, and Ceylan's mesmerizing existential drama takes its time establishing the players and bringing their inner lives into focus. It's cinema as autopsy.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jan 4, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Even when the plot kicks in and the stakes get raised, there’s a casualness to Guiraudie’s approach that’s singular and admirably defiant of genre expectations. He’s setting a scene. Tension insinuates itself later.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jan 22, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
An impeccable minimalist drama that's tailored specifically to Devos' expressive capabilities, which say more than the sparse dialogue.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Abortion, incest, infidelity, revenge, and hockey collide at a fever pitch, juxtaposed with such frantic energy that they're pushed to the level of high comedy, funniest at its most dramatic.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Searching for originality in an addiction narrative like Animals is a problem, because these stories of decline and degradation tend to sound the same. So the limited time frame is the film’s strongest asset, because it’s only paying attention to the final hours.- The Dissolve
- Posted May 13, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film's greatest achievement is transforming his supposed acts of deviancy into disease-of-the-week uplift, not to mention a moving love story, an irreverent black comedy, and an intellectually compelling study of an artist at work.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
George Washington is a mood piece first, and its triumph is in bottling up the intense feeling of early adolescence, and watching how tragedy transforms it.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
At once too real for escapism and too ridiculous for a credible espionage thriller, The Sum Of All Fears unfolds like a cruel joke and treats imagined human tragedy as the punchline.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It’s easier to tell the story of a smashing success or an utter failure, because there’s drama inherent to either scenario, but what Hansen-Løve accomplishes with Eden is trickier, a feeling of being adrift in a scene where people are already invited to lose themselves to dance.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jun 17, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Stunning you-are-there account of a grand swindle in the making. Were the coup not such an outrageous and chilling affront to democracy, their documentary would be a gut-busting comedy along the lines of Woody Allen's "Bananas."- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Meaney’s Flintstone-ian brute makes a terrific foil to Sheen’s prissy arrogance, but the other supporting players don’t make much of an impression. Ditto for this slice of history itself, though mileage may vary for soccer fans.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It takes less than a minute of watching Duel, Steven Spielberg's feature-length debut, to realize you're in the hands of a master director.- The Guardian
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In keeping with his concept that the mind and the body are inseparable, Sade builds to an extraordinarily powerful centerpiece when the two come together, fusing fear and desire, pleasure and pain, innocence and enlightenment.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It comes off as calculatedly irreverent at times, and its Wes Anderson-isms are too precious by half, but its sweetness is genuine and next-to-impossible to resist.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Cianfrance and his actors, Michelle Williams and Ryan Gosling, have not made a cold or schematic film. They aim instead for raw emotional experience, one that's full of insight into the ways a relationship can go astray, but mostly feels like a slow-motion punch to the gut.- NPR
- Posted Dec 28, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
On a production of this magnitude, few actors have the presence to assert themselves above the cacophony, but Crowe carries the film with the rare combination of charisma and brute masculinity that has made him a star.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Those schooled in Eastern European history may have better luck deciphering it, but what keeps it compelling throughout is Loznitsa's direction, which favors sophisticated long takes and particularly suspenseful use of foreground and background action. His next film should be a doozy.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Sep 28, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Denis brings it all together for a genuinely shocking finale, unexpected, yet in keeping with the film's consuming madness.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Dec 14, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film feels oddly slack and inert, livened only by testimony better suited to another forum.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Doing some of his best work in years, Ewan McGregor plays Mills' alter ego as a prickly, not altogether noble loner in his late 30s who initially doesn't take the news of his father's coming-out well.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jun 2, 2011
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
More than merely offering a backstage pass to history, Larraín draws us into the utter uniqueness of a situation where personal loss and national duty collided so violently.- NPR
- Posted Dec 20, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In light of Apichatpong Weerasethakul's young career, it's fitting that his beguiling, transfixing romantic fable Tropical Malady splits down the middle into two radically different halves.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Through Sorrentino's lens, Andreotti's chief lieutenants are made to look like Reservoir Dogs, with Andreotti as a calm, tight-lipped, upper-crust analog to Lawrence Tierney.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Touring his father's magnificent structures, Nathaniel shows signs of coming around to his mother's point of view, and of realizing that Kahn's towering contributions to art and humanity perhaps exceed (if not altogether excuse) his shortcomings as a father, a husband, and a lover.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A clever, exceedingly wonky procedural about a undercover cop (Dragos Bucur) who quietly refuses to do what he's told.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In an unusually subtle performance by a child actor, Kacey Mottet Klein stars as a crafty ragamuffin.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Oct 3, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Little about [Östlund’s] work is simple-minded or cut-and-dried. His films marinate in viewer discomfort.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jan 15, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The two halves of Closed Curtain complement each other, but the first is more compelling than the second, partly because the mysteries of construction trump the grind of deconstruction, and partly because Panahi channeled his anguish more directly and affectingly with This Is Not A Film.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jul 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Leon isn't a flashy director, but he has an excellent sense of proportion. Gimme the Loot unfolds in a series of loose, funny, naturalistic scenes, but they never trail off into improvisational vapors.- NPR
- Posted Mar 21, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A hypnotic 80-minute drift through nocturnal New Orleans that seeks more to pick up on bits of culture and atmosphere than to tell any stories. They blow up the conventions of documentary realism to capture the city's soul, a much more abstract, elusive undertaking.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Dec 5, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
As director Dominique Benicheti invites the audience to contemplate this way of life—and that’s all the film seeks to accomplish, which is plenty—he reveals the virtues of simplicity, routine, and quietly communing with the natural world.- The Dissolve
- Posted Nov 26, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A caustic, witty, regretful elegy for a place so transformed that it's virtually unrecognizable.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The grand concept is really just a vehicle for a more intimate study of depression and its dangerous, shifting polarities.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Nov 9, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
You, The Living, if only by virtue of a more intimate scale than Songs, benefits from a lightness of touch and even a thin sliver of optimism in some sequences.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though the film is too slick and heavy-handed in its pro-integration sloganeering, and it's burdened by Travolta's ill-conceived star turn, its infectious high spirits and catchy tunes still pack one hell of a sugar rush.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film is memorable mainly for attractive people sailing and smooching against an attractive backdrop. There's no urgency behind all the preening.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The latest bloom from the flourishing garden that is Romanian cinema, Radu Muntean's Tuesday, After Christmas chronicles the emotional fallout from a classic love triangle, but it unfolds with the agonizing tension of a suspense film.- NPR
- Posted Jun 1, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
District 9 fuses science fiction mayhem and biting social commentary as well as any film since "Starship Troopers." It’s the rare alien invasion story that has the aliens running scared.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There aren't many laughs in this vaudevillian gambit, and fewer still in the fish-out-of-water comedy of Madea hosting a rich white family that's chiefly concerned with yoga, wi-fi, and their carb intakes. Still, Perry remains a true outsider artist-nobody makes movies like his. (And please don't try.)- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jun 29, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In accounting for Almodóvar's identity as an artist and a man, Bad Education comes together like a bold and far-reaching summation of his career to date.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
One of the big reasons Flight is so satisfying is that it moves with the no-frills, meat-and-potatoes conventions of a first-rate procedural while being awash in ambiguity.- NPR
- Posted Nov 1, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's the perfect material for Russell, who not only deals perceptively with the dizzying swings of manic depression, but makes it the fabric of a big, generous, happy-making ensemble comedy.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Nov 14, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Norte is the rare film where the characters seem simpler the longer we spend time with them. They’re humans that evolve into types.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jun 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A sort of distracted, freewheeling form of inquiry and observation drives Encounters At The End Of The World, a loosely constructed documentary that seems to have been made on a whim.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Turin Horse has a burnished beauty that's awe-inspiring, like a clear window into a faraway world as it dangles, and then falls, off the precipice.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Feb 8, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
As usual with the Knives Out series, Johnson stays well out ahead of his audience, and Craig gets more than one delightful drawing-room moment when he pulls together the elusive facts of the case.- The Reveal
- Posted Nov 26, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Having the dog around raises the emotional stakes tenfold, and develops a kinship with Vittorio De Sica's Italian neo-realist classic "Umberto D.," which also revealed societal ills through a poignant dog-owner relationship- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The Testament of Ann Lee suggests a bigger story than Fastvold has the time or resources to tell, but it stays close to Seyfried’s hip and allows the purity of Ann’s vision to carry the day.- The Reveal
- Posted Dec 30, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though The Train is a marvel of old-fashioned action craft, from invisible dolly shots of breathtaking sophistication to the careful staging of massive railway catastrophes, it’s not a thoughtless adventure by any means.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Concerns feelings that can't be expressed, relationships that can't flower, and connections that are impossible to bridge.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film sprawls across two decades and 127 minutes, but there isn't a memorable image in it.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A canny piece of autobiography that looks at the man behind the legend and the legend behind the man.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The true audacity of The Mastermind may be Reichardt’s conception of J.B. himself, who not only lacks nobility or competence, but possesses a compelling vacancy that’s harder to unpack.- The Reveal
- Posted Oct 16, 2025
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The tough urban realism Lumet perfected in cop dramas like Serpico, Q&A, and Prince Of The City has been reflected in first-rate TV shows like Homicide: Life On The Street, The Wire, and The Shield. But those shows had multiple seasons to draw out the breadth of institutional corruption, while Lumet miraculously covers this territory in 167 minutes.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There’s a promotional bent to Mad As Hell that whiffs more of branding than rigorous documentary filmmaking.- The Dissolve
- Posted Feb 3, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Greenfield's refusal to pass judgment on the Siegels lends her subjects and their marriage unexpected complexity and depth - especially Jackie, a true force of nature.- NPR
- Posted Jul 20, 2012
- Read full review