Watchmen (2019)

10

KajeKiDec 12, 2019

A once in a decade kind of show. HBO does it again - they are pushing the envelope like they did with West World. Just the decisions they made for the story, the ideas, the ridiculousness, the genre defying plot lines. And I do appreciateA once in a decade kind of show. HBO does it again - they are pushing the envelope like they did with West World. Just the decisions they made for the story, the ideas, the ridiculousness, the genre defying plot lines. And I do appreciate them bringing the racial Tensions to the forefront. I mean, this is something that - like it or not - we as citizens of the United States are struggling with. I mean you can tell from the comments, a lot of people want a show that doesn't challenge them. This is a challenging show but can be especially challenging for conservatives and those that have trouble sympathizing with the plight African Americans. However, that adide, it's just a fantastic and original story. There's absolutely no way this is a 0 or like 5. This show is a 9 minimum. But because of all the haters on this site based solely on the politics (reality!) of the history and conflicts in the show, I need to give this an absolute 10. This is engaging sci-fi with an intense black female lead. It's not heavy handed at all, they just had one major scene regarding the historical massacre of a black community in Tulsa. That doesn't make this show a 0. It's not sjw it's not any of that crap. It's just a phenomenonal show!… Expand

10 of 22 users found this helpful1012

All this user's reviews

0

HammerOfThoriumDec 12, 2019

Abysmal. A stain on the name of Watchmen. The writer's bigotry shines through in every scene.

10 of 27 users found this helpful1017

All this user's reviews

3

SoulLoveDec 11, 2019

I had high hopes. Turns out to be full of new age revolutionary symbolism pushing the subconscious towards a wack society. Brainwashes the normal person to believe it is okay to kill others based on their beliefs (taking it a step furtherI had high hopes. Turns out to be full of new age revolutionary symbolism pushing the subconscious towards a wack society. Brainwashes the normal person to believe it is okay to kill others based on their beliefs (taking it a step further than anti free speech, to anti free thought). Afraid for what Hollywood is trying to push us towards as a society. Literally disgusting.… Expand

8 of 25 users found this helpful817

All this user's reviews

1

Mendax89Dec 10, 2019

A crime against comics. The showrunner took the Watchmen IP and created a joke. Nothing good about this show.

13 of 30 users found this helpful1317

All this user's reviews

10

JoesDec 10, 2019

Excelente serie mucho mejor que la película de snyder, recomendado si eres fan

10 of 21 users found this helpful1011

All this user's reviews

10

TrillcosbeyDec 9, 2019

Fantastic Treatment, this is a definite intrusion into the DC universe and the super hero troupe, that challenges and intrigues rather than some terrible carnival ride that has become the genre. Side note.(I like to do a little experiment toFantastic Treatment, this is a definite intrusion into the DC universe and the super hero troupe, that challenges and intrigues rather than some terrible carnival ride that has become the genre. Side note.(I like to do a little experiment to see if I can trust the people on this platform if you find they give rambo last blood and transformers a 10 its a pretty good bet they have the taste and brains of a cat fish.)… Expand

9 of 17 users found this helpful98

All this user's reviews

10

Proteus7xDec 8, 2019

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Don't listen to people who know nothing of Watchmen's (1986) themes and measure this as a sequel to the movie (most of these negative reviews are far off the mark)...

This show is incredibly well acted, produced, and written.

While some people have complained about it not relating to the source material, I don't think those comments have much merit. The original takes place in New York while this show takes place 30 years in the future of the graphic novel in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Some have complained that the show is too political, anti-conservative, and too racial. I wonder if those individuals ever really read the comic, as it was very political for its time too. The writer of the graphic novel, Alan Moore, even started that he wrote the story to be anti-Reaganism, and Reagan is essentially THE template for modern day conservatives. Moore also stated that he was making conscious decisions to make people uncomfortable regarding the themes presented.

Moore also said, "Our intention was to show how superheroes could deform the world just by being there, not that they'd have to take it over, just their presence there would make the difference... From the point where Dr. Manhattan appears, it slowly starts to go downhill from there - everything starts to change. He doesn't take over the country or make people subservient to him, but just his presence there makes everything begin to change. Yet on another level, if you equate Dr. Manhattan with the atom bomb, the atom bomb doesn't take over the world, but by being there it changes everything."

So in that spirit, HBO's Watchmen is on target with the tone and general themes of the original Watchmen. Some reviews have lamented Rosarch's depiction as a white supremacist. He's NOT. His journal being left out in the wild sans the author leaves behind a world that interprets his writings in their own way. By introducing the truth into the world without the author, the readers have gone in their own direction with it. And it goes wrong... just like Alan Moore stated things do in the original Watchmen.

I don't really understand people who complain about accurate depictions of racism or politics in comic book adjacent media, especially alleged comic books fans. Complaints about "woke" culture and "SJWs" seems silly when we've had characters and stories that have ALWAYS addressed these kinds of themes. Would these same reviewers hate the X-Men because the story is allegorical to racism and/or disenfranchisement of people in society who aren't WASPs? Would they hate Marvel's original Civil War now because it calls out fascism?

At any rate, the show is phenomenal and has been an absolute joy as so much is introduced but not explained as of yet. It is engaging and enthralling and the callbacks and Easter eggs to the graphic novel are liberally sprinkled throughout. Shed the "woe is me" mindset of some white viewers (and honestly, unless you're a white supremacist, there's no reason to feel attacked while you watch) and enjoy! Yes, there are actual horrific historic events that are shown, but how is that any different from X-Men showing young Magneto during the holocaust? Those who are triggered these days by hearing stories told from other groups besides white people really should grow up and realize the World is complex and varied. This is what makes comics so great!

I've been inspired to re-read the graphic novel as a result of the show and I really can't recommend it enough!

10/10 to balance out the insecure, biased, unmerited reviews that keep popping up (reviews are opinion, so it is nice when someone like myself offers a challenge based upon accuracy rather than isolated perspective).… Expand

12 of 27 users found this helpful1215

All this user's reviews

0

LmaoPlotHoleDec 8, 2019

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Dr Manhattan came back to Earth because he was lonely and disguised himself as human so he could love again. Crazy racists have some kinda portal to catch him with despite living in shantytowns. They plan to put a real bad guy in the white house if not turn him into another Manhattan with their tech.
The book was about blurred lines between good and evil. Everything in this show is completely binary. 1 or 0. Black or white. Imagine that...the guy who wrote Lost gave us another convoluted plot that goes nowhere and HBO once again fails to get a show to the finish line.… Expand

12 of 28 users found this helpful1216

All this user's reviews

0

AnonymousVDec 6, 2019

It's propaganda with the sole intent to be divisive and have all us bottom feeders and consumers fighting amongst ourselves. It touches on subjects in a way that it knows the reaction it will get. Be smarter than this people. We all need toIt's propaganda with the sole intent to be divisive and have all us bottom feeders and consumers fighting amongst ourselves. It touches on subjects in a way that it knows the reaction it will get. Be smarter than this people. We all need to start standing together. Otherwise, those in control will continue to use race/left-right/gender/sexuality/nationality etc. to continue to control and keep us divided, fighting amongst ourselves whilst we are slaves to a system that continues to abuse humanity and the planet. The greatest oppressors are those in plain sight yet are never seen to be the focus of our hate or held accountable for all the suffering they perpetuate for their own selfish gain. I wonder why. Watchmen>HBO>Warner Media>AT&T>$170.7billion revenue in 2108. A monopoly company that owns and controls more media than any other company on the planet. They control minds, are incredibly and excessively lucrative and their influence in our lives in incomprehensible. Is it a coincedence they are at least indirectly responsible for this type of content? Does it not really help them? Subterfuge, anyone? Then again, Metacritic>CBS Interactive>ViacomCBS>National Amusements>Redstones - isn't much better or trustworthy.… Expand

11 of 32 users found this helpful1121

All this user's reviews

10

tjriz91Dec 3, 2019

I feel sorry for the people who got caught up on the white supremacy aspect of this show, and decided to either tune out completely after a couple episodes, or continued watching but in the process completely overlooked everything amazingI feel sorry for the people who got caught up on the white supremacy aspect of this show, and decided to either tune out completely after a couple episodes, or continued watching but in the process completely overlooked everything amazing this show has to offer because their preconceived notions prevented them from TRULY experiencing the narrative. Yes, white supremacy is a threat within the show and a major theme that the creator purposely intertwined within the narrative. He wants to evoke emotion within the viewer, and he uses hyperbole to do so. But by shutting your brain off because of it, you are doing yourself a disservice. If you interpret the show as being one-sided political propaganda, you obviously didn't watch past the first couple episodes, or you are simply being close-minded and completely misinterpreting everything. I just finished episode 7 and the show has only gotten better and better in my mind. A slow-cooking intrigue...amazingly crafted, yet cryptic and quirky with science fiction/alternative history themes underlying the whole thing. And one of the most amazing original soundtracks of any television show I've watched to date.

And to the people who are upset that it is "nothing" like the comic...how it ties into the original comic becomes more clear as time goes on. It was never meant to be a direct adaptation, and that was made clear before the show even aired. And even as a fan of the original comic series, I'm extremely glad it's not a direct adaptation, as I think that would have been fairly status quo and boring. If you continue watching it past the first couple episodes you come to find how it ties to the comics in an unconventional, yet smart way.

To each their own, and I respect anyone who has differing opinions on shows that I personally enjoy. That type of thing is highly subjective. But I do find it a little immature to pass this particular show off as liberal propaganda, or a useless piece of trash because of it not being a DIRECT adaptation. Again this show is a slow-burner, but you are rewarded as time goes on, especially if you are a true fan of science fiction.… Expand

14 of 26 users found this helpful1412

All this user's reviews

9

SHough610Dec 4, 2019

Lindelof does a great job of remaining true to the spirit of the original Watchmen while telling an original story. It's a logical extension of the ideas that Moore and Gibbons touched on in the original.

If I have one criticism it's thatLindelof does a great job of remaining true to the spirit of the original Watchmen while telling an original story. It's a logical extension of the ideas that Moore and Gibbons touched on in the original.

If I have one criticism it's that the series lacks some of the subtlety of the original. But it's visually beautiful and the music is amazing.… Expand

10 of 21 users found this helpful1011

All this user's reviews

8

notor12Dec 4, 2019

I'm now 7 episodes into the season.

The show has improved a lot from my original review. It's still nowhere near the quality of Alan Moore's work, but it is reasonably fun television compared to what else is out there. The elements thatI'm now 7 episodes into the season.

The show has improved a lot from my original review. It's still nowhere near the quality of Alan Moore's work, but it is reasonably fun television compared to what else is out there. The elements that were added to or borrowed from the original work are the weakest parts of the show still. But the story isn't bad on its own. I'm genuinely interested to see where it is going and unlike with Lindelof's previous work I don't think he will totally screw his audience this time. He didn't totally screw this one up. I'd still like to see an authentic Watchmen port that does true justice to the original, but that just isn't going to happen because it isn't accessible to mainstream audiences. The Watchmen motion comic was the best I think we're going to get. As far as tv goes, this is still not really truly the Watchmen but it's a passable alternative.

8/10… Expand

10 of 20 users found this helpful1010

All this user's reviews

2

BigbenhowardNov 30, 2019

I'm going to do a spoiler free review, and as such, it's going to be very short and general.

Somewhere in there, there's possibly a good story. But that's not earning anyone any points here when they had such a legendary story to springboardI'm going to do a spoiler free review, and as such, it's going to be very short and general.

Somewhere in there, there's possibly a good story. But that's not earning anyone any points here when they had such a legendary story to springboard off of. Instead, it's absolutely polluted with the writer's inability to resist submerging the entire show in his extremist ideology. The writing suffers for it, the plot suffers for it, and the characters, more than anything else, suffer for it.… Expand

14 of 31 users found this helpful1417

All this user's reviews

2

psyberdelicNov 29, 2019

WTF??? How did this get made? I watched the first three episodes and there might have been one good moment but for the most part it was incomprehensible. Even if you were a Watchmen groupie it's hard to see it making any sense at all.WTF??? How did this get made? I watched the first three episodes and there might have been one good moment but for the most part it was incomprehensible. Even if you were a Watchmen groupie it's hard to see it making any sense at all. Terrible story telling.… Expand

14 of 32 users found this helpful1418

All this user's reviews

10

PsychicSquidNov 28, 2019

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This show is no more political than the original graphic novel. As I read the negative reviews for this show, it becomes apparent that either the trolls didn't read the original, or they were too stupid to understand the political subtext. The show is faithful to the mood and plot of the original novel. If you are a true fan, you will probably love seeing what became of the watchmen universe twenty years after the events of the original. The acting is superb, and all of the characters are there in some way. The political points aren't one sided, but the show does deal with white supremacists, as did the graphic novel. And, anyone who thinks a woman shouldn't be able to kick ass needs to challenge Rhonda Rousey to a fight.… Expand

12 of 25 users found this helpful1213

All this user's reviews

1

TeemuerNov 27, 2019

Was a fan of the movie. Not have read the comics.. i am 5 episodes in now and can not go on with this bs. I mean... it tries to tell that racism is baaaad but at the same time is the most racist show i've ever seen (russian stereotypes, howWas a fan of the movie. Not have read the comics.. i am 5 episodes in now and can not go on with this bs. I mean... it tries to tell that racism is baaaad but at the same time is the most racist show i've ever seen (russian stereotypes, how every white person belongs to KKK or is just simply a bad guy... i could go on...). Don't get me wrong racism is an ok theme but when everything is built around that it gets annoying. Maybe it's an american thing... .
Bad:
1. This show is all about racism and ironically the show is racist as hell.
2. Story is a mess and all around the place. Hard to follow. .
Good:
1. Cinematography is great, i mean the show looks good. .
.
2. The cast is good.

Greets from Finland.… Expand

14 of 31 users found this helpful1417

All this user's reviews

9

AscosporeNov 4, 2019

A genius sequel to novel. Watchmen for here and now. Intricate and faithful interpretation of the limited series with awesome new credentials. Many butthurt rushed to tear Lindelof a new one. Now they secretly watching and loving his work.

24 of 51 users found this helpful2427

All this user's reviews

6

empeNov 25, 2019

I had high hopes for this one, but after 5 episodes I'm sure they're leeching out of original Watchmen popularity. I mean, the show is sometimes surprising and make you curious what happens next, but not in a sense that you care about it.I had high hopes for this one, but after 5 episodes I'm sure they're leeching out of original Watchmen popularity. I mean, the show is sometimes surprising and make you curious what happens next, but not in a sense that you care about it. Good for killing time but you wouldn't notice if it suddenly ends.… Expand

4 of 11 users found this helpful47

All this user's reviews

10

QuiscustodietNov 22, 2019

So yes, this series isn't a rehash of the graphic novel, but as it progresses a lot of mythos pops up. But if that's a reason to give it a 0, I'm surprised those people had all together enough brains to apreciate Alan Moore's original work inSo yes, this series isn't a rehash of the graphic novel, but as it progresses a lot of mythos pops up. But if that's a reason to give it a 0, I'm surprised those people had all together enough brains to apreciate Alan Moore's original work in the first place. And so what if it also sends a message that's anti-racism? If that's a bad thing these days, then the semi-apocalyptic world portrayed in the series is much closer then we might realize. That being said, I think the show is great. I can go into detail why, but that has been covered by other reviewers. Just wanted to come out here to give it a 10/10 to show my support in reaction to these prejudiced wannabe-fanboys.… Expand

13 of 28 users found this helpful1315

All this user's reviews

10

Mellownisty727Oct 26, 2019

This show is amazing so far. lindeloff has a great track record, and I bet this will be even better than his last great show, The Leftovers. Don't listen to the people review bombing this with zeroes because they think everything is pc and aThis show is amazing so far. lindeloff has a great track record, and I bet this will be even better than his last great show, The Leftovers. Don't listen to the people review bombing this with zeroes because they think everything is pc and a personal attack against them. These are the kind of people that hate any media that has any perspective of people of color. I guarantee you most of them haven't watched past the pilot episode if they even watched it at all. The only 'provocative' or 'radical leftist' theme here is just the brief portrayal of white supremacist militias; I don't know what it says about you if you're offended when anyone says white supremacy is wrong, destructive, or just a problem we are dealing with. This is not an attack on you unless you identify as a white supremacist in a militia. The masked militia in this show is just one set-piece of many in this show. Race plays a minor role. Also what idiot thinks the Watchmen comic wasn't political? Hate to break it to you, but Alan rickman is very left field, even left of Jeremy Corbyn who he publicly supports.
Anyways, so far, i love the lead actors and the story setup. Looking forward to the rest of the season and how this show will expand on its mystery.… Expand

20 of 45 users found this helpful2025

All this user's reviews

10

TiffanyStarrxxxNov 20, 2019

A lot of the people down voting this seem to be focusing on one thing and that's having their world view challenged. I see a lot of white nationalists posting in here who are upset that black and LGBT people get to be on screen. Well I'm hereA lot of the people down voting this seem to be focusing on one thing and that's having their world view challenged. I see a lot of white nationalists posting in here who are upset that black and LGBT people get to be on screen. Well I'm here to tell you the show is great and if you're not a racist homophobe you'll find some enjoyment.… Expand

20 of 36 users found this helpful2016

All this user's reviews

1

RyanhoffmanNov 18, 2019

Propaganda. Tired of a bunch of millionaires with private security escorts that live in walled communities pushing their ideology on the rest of us REAL people.

17 of 44 users found this helpful1727

All this user's reviews

10

LavishSumDreadNov 18, 2019

Wow the alt-right is truly the whiniest group of people. Show is great. Loved the comic, not so much the movie where al the characters were insanely strong and Kung-fu masters. The show is akin to the book in tone and world building.Wow the alt-right is truly the whiniest group of people. Show is great. Loved the comic, not so much the movie where al the characters were insanely strong and Kung-fu masters. The show is akin to the book in tone and world building. Absolutely love it.… Expand

22 of 38 users found this helpful2216

All this user's reviews

10

hydrogenNov 17, 2019

I am not a watchmen comic loyalist and am watching to show indecently of the comic. It is a very intriguing story. The political hints dull as the story unfolds into something much larger.

17 of 32 users found this helpful1715

All this user's reviews

10

PurpleCrayon4UNov 17, 2019

If you needed a reason to watch Watchmen, to binge Watchmen,
to immerse yourself into Watchmen,
Episode Little Fear of Lightning is your calling. This season of Watchmen has been like the intrepidness of riding a rollercoaster: You get on andIf you needed a reason to watch Watchmen, to binge Watchmen,
to immerse yourself into Watchmen,
Episode Little Fear of Lightning is your calling. This season of Watchmen has been like the intrepidness of riding a
rollercoaster: You get on and fasten in, the car slowly makes its way
down the route(speeding up a bit, slowing a bit, bumpy slow turns),
then you begin to elevate while your anticipation escalates as you
look around and take in the totality of what you’re about to endure
-not really capturing the big picture....until the bottom drops out
from under you as you white-knuckle the safety bar
-Watchmen has engulfed you, has taken you in, and you will not
stop until Watchmen has decided to be done with you.… Expand

12 of 26 users found this helpful1214

All this user's reviews

1

Nile3Nov 17, 2019

An addition to the now pervasive postmodern political narrative of the media.

I really enjoyed the movie and the comic book, but this series is unlike both of them. It is spectacularly odd. The quality of the filming is good, the actors areAn addition to the now pervasive postmodern political narrative of the media.

I really enjoyed the movie and the comic book, but this series is unlike both of them. It is spectacularly odd. The quality of the filming is good, the actors are not bad, but the story never seem to hold together.

So, if you must know, they turned Rorshack's mask into a symbol of white supremacy, they masked the police officers with yellow band because they're scared of the people in Rorshack masks and then a nun with a son comes to the rescue. The comedian is the producer making us watch this garbage laughing all the way to the bank.… Expand

11 of 33 users found this helpful1122

All this user's reviews

4

a_scott_aNov 16, 2019

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. very mild spoilers - ignore all the "political" complaints. On the other hand, this production hangs heavily off of interest and knowledge in the original comic/2009 movie plot. It does not stand on its own. Far from starting on the street with understandable characters and gradually getting into layers of meaning, you start with a subplot of one character trapped in some kind of alice in wonderland world that simply fills up 10 minutes of each episode with disjointed chatter. The main character is supposedly a batman type figure with a secret lair... right in the middle of downtown and on a policeman's salary. Married with kids with an army of anti-masks and very poorly hidden identity. Motivation? All sorts of people unexpectedly turn to the camera and say "tic toc". The richest person in the world comes knocking on someone's door at bedtime for no apparent reason, they say - your that billionaire! the response all catty - actually, I'm a trillionaire *smug little smirk*. More interesting visually than most things going, but some unwatchable moments and not much story if you get beyond the references to the original. What if there was a universe took the Tulsa Riots seriously? That's an interesting question - but in the watchman universe, they're still cleaning up after a squid attack that made 9/11 look like a sneeze, so, that reparation is the only thing that makes any sense in the universe where we're suppose to be.… Expand

4 of 13 users found this helpful49

All this user's reviews

3

hellpittNov 12, 2019

was this watchmen or blacklightning? this is watchmen in name only guys...a hard pass

9 of 25 users found this helpful916

All this user's reviews

8

whatsthatagainNov 12, 2019

The original Watchmen comic book series was intended as an anti-violent message about the dangers of masculine far right ideology or in today's lexicon "woke" propaganda. This series does a good job of making that point crystal clear. WhichThe original Watchmen comic book series was intended as an anti-violent message about the dangers of masculine far right ideology or in today's lexicon "woke" propaganda. This series does a good job of making that point crystal clear. Which is good because many people seemed to have missed the point of the comic book series. Moore intended Rorschach to be the bad guy people.… Expand

12 of 26 users found this helpful1214

All this user's reviews

0

Karma_policeNov 11, 2019

If i wanted propaganda down my throat i would just go to a Democrat debate, this is not the Watchmen we love, i don't understand the urge to take established universes and franchises and inject their politics into them, it's like they knowIf i wanted propaganda down my throat i would just go to a Democrat debate, this is not the Watchmen we love, i don't understand the urge to take established universes and franchises and inject their politics into them, it's like they know their ideas are **** and the only way they can push them is masquerading them into franchises people love, this is not only extremely dishonest but disrespectful to the source material and the fandom.… Expand

9 of 31 users found this helpful922

All this user's reviews

10

peabottiNov 11, 2019

I have honestly never written a review online in my life (I find them usually filled with trolls). However, I love this show so much I felt compelled to write a review to contradict all of the haters giving this show a zero. Two simpleI have honestly never written a review online in my life (I find them usually filled with trolls). However, I love this show so much I felt compelled to write a review to contradict all of the haters giving this show a zero. Two simple things. First, this is not a freaking political debate, this is a sci-fi fantasy show so relax with all of the correlation to racism and our history in America. Second, every single person giving this show a bad review clearly cannot follow the plot or dialogue. The show has 100 different ties to the graphic novel (mostly subtle) but a true fan of the novel would recognize them. I am sorry if the users writing reviews are too dense to understand all of the nuances but the creators of the this show are not going to hold your hand and walk you through explanations. They expect you to know the lore, and expect you to be smart enough to keep up. If you hate this show, then this show is simply over your head. Go watch something easy to understand on basic cable TV instead. This show is brilliant.… Expand

19 of 36 users found this helpful1917

All this user's reviews

10

memm12Nov 10, 2019

Exceptionally well done with cinematography and acting, and a story that draws you in.
Set in the Watchmen universe but little relationship to the original comic, interesting to see how the metacritic comments are brigaded by a combination ofExceptionally well done with cinematography and acting, and a story that draws you in.
Set in the Watchmen universe but little relationship to the original comic, interesting to see how the metacritic comments are brigaded by a combination of supremacist and racist users along with a few comic purists. The show must be threatening to a few groups with extremist ideas and beliefs, and that in and of itself is a reason to see what this show has to say and to give it a chance. Really enjoying it so far.… Expand

16 of 30 users found this helpful1614

All this user's reviews

0

BlanasNov 10, 2019

This movie is below any levels of stupidity. This is not even propaganda, because no propaganda can be so stupid, because it will bring the reverse effect to the intended. The only explanation is that this movie was made by white supremacistsThis movie is below any levels of stupidity. This is not even propaganda, because no propaganda can be so stupid, because it will bring the reverse effect to the intended. The only explanation is that this movie was made by white supremacists to ridicule racial justice.… Expand

12 of 32 users found this helpful1220

All this user's reviews

10

CrimsonFlushNov 10, 2019

Oh, dear, people are unhappy about their comics being too left-leaning again.

The CW’s Batwoman was initially getting review bombed by a bunch of people (because … women and gays? Not in my Gotham!) and now that trend has continued withOh, dear, people are unhappy about their comics being too left-leaning again.

The CW’s Batwoman was initially getting review bombed by a bunch of people (because … women and gays? Not in my Gotham!) and now that trend has continued with HBO’s Watchmen series, which premiered this weekend. According to CBR, the show has a 93% Fresh rating from critics but is scored at 49% by audiences. Of course, there are those with legitimate criticism of the series—as I have my own—but many other complaints are about the show’s perceived “politically correct” narrative and it being “too woke,” upset that this new series has a very political stance.

Except that, you know, the original comic by Alan Moore is super political, left-leaning, and was created to mock a lot of things. But you know, people don’t actually like to think about it, especially when it comes to one character in particular: Rorschach, Ted Cruz’s favorite.

In the show, there is a white supremacist group called the “Seventh Kavalry” in Tulsa that has taken to Rorschach’s black-and-white mask, and they are acting up in response to President Robert Redford’s push to implement reparations to those affected by past racial injustices. That absolutely makes sense, since Rorschach, in the comics, is outwardly (checks the list) racist, homophobic, sexist, and a total and complete fascist. Alan Moore literally wrote him to make fun of The Question, Mr. A, and a bunch of other Steve Ditko comic characters that the artist/writer used to promote his Ayn Randian ideals.

Watchmen has always been about taking the idea of superheroes to its natural conclusion with the events in world history. That’s why, at least from my perspective, the issue of reparations makes sense in this context. For the first time in a long time, that is a serious topic of debate, and with the presidency something you can do for unlimited terms in the world of Watchmen, a president, especially a popular one, could tackle that kind of legislation. In a place like Tulsa, which has always had a racial divide and dark history of white inhabitants being antagonistic when their Black counterparts make it, this just seems like the natural conclusion—especially when Rorschach’s journals were shared with the equivalent of Breitbart News.

These white supremacists are the logical conclusion to his rhetoric.

Does that mean you’re a white supremacist if that was your favorite character in the comics? No … unless you actually are a white supremacist. Rorschach is an interesting character because Alan Moore is a good writer and knows how to teach without preaching. His work is layered and thoughtful but also filled with clear intent. From what I have watched of the show, while it isn’t perfect, I’m willing to give Damon Lindelof room to tell the story as long as he does the same. Well, as much room as you can give a former Lost showrunner, but that’s a whole different kettle of alien squid.

Still, more than anything, I wish that audience reviews stopped being a way for people to drag something for being “too woke,” because it creates bad faith for everyone. We are allowed to have different tastes and have our political leaning affect out taste, but that doesn’t mean we can’t be fair.… Expand

23 of 40 users found this helpful2317

All this user's reviews

0

skdurshNov 8, 2019

Racist trash. Sick of "woke" Hollywood and their absolutely corrupt BS. If you like this show, you're part of the problem.

14 of 35 users found this helpful1421

All this user's reviews

0

LaSh4wn328Nov 8, 2019

Who botches the Watchmen?

Absolutely terrible show. I am sick to death of Hollywood crap about how whitey is de debbil and needs to get viciously beaten and tortured by snarling brown people for his sins. It's such a tedious cliche, butWho botches the Watchmen?

Absolutely terrible show. I am sick to death of Hollywood crap about how whitey is de debbil and needs to get viciously beaten and tortured by snarling brown people for his sins. It's such a tedious cliche, but that's clown world for you. Makes me glad I don't actually pay to watch HBO shows, if you know what I mean.

In the original (good) Watchmen story, something like this would be used as an insert to show the kind of cheap propaganda being used to manipulate the masses. Now there was a story that actually had a brain.… Expand

13 of 34 users found this helpful1321

All this user's reviews

0

GuapoGrandeNov 8, 2019

The original Watchmen was a brilliant and morally complex story that tried to seriously examine how superheroes would affect the real world, including geopolitics. This show is a stupid race-baiting fantasy that has nothing to do withThe original Watchmen was a brilliant and morally complex story that tried to seriously examine how superheroes would affect the real world, including geopolitics. This show is a stupid race-baiting fantasy that has nothing to do with anything remotely real.

It was infuriating to seen Damon Lindelof babbling in an interview about how, as a (((fellow white person))) he wanted to make a show about attacking white privilege. Sure Lindelof, you're white. Sure you are.

Skip this show, it's trash and a spiteful insult to Alan Moore… Expand

14 of 32 users found this helpful1418

All this user's reviews

10

ScroccoNov 8, 2019

The series is amazing and it creates a mix and refresh of stories and themes which were part of the original comic. I'm a huge fan of Trent Reznor and his Nine Inch Nails and watching such wonderful series with his music makes the wholeThe series is amazing and it creates a mix and refresh of stories and themes which were part of the original comic. I'm a huge fan of Trent Reznor and his Nine Inch Nails and watching such wonderful series with his music makes the whole experience even more amazing. Despite that, is curious to see that a series so vocal against white suprematism receives so many negative reviews – especially because from their comment they sound like properly racist people. This makes me love this series even more :)… Expand

14 of 29 users found this helpful1415

All this user's reviews

0

BarronOfDuneNov 8, 2019

Revolting that they were able to call this Watchmen. It's just more grating "whites are evil, angry black people are saints" from Hollywood, which is always eager to crap on normal white people even as their own ranks are full of WeinsteinsRevolting that they were able to call this Watchmen. It's just more grating "whites are evil, angry black people are saints" from Hollywood, which is always eager to crap on normal white people even as their own ranks are full of Weinsteins and Epsteins.

FYI the Tulsa race riots did happen, but they were nothing like the 4 color cartoon shown here. The actual details of who started it (both whites and blacks were killing each other, it wasn't a 1-way affair) and how many died are very vague today, but that doesn't stop Hollywood from trying to turn it in to a cheap and fake morality play to pander to SJW audiences.… Expand

15 of 34 users found this helpful1519

All this user's reviews

0

MahbubAli92Nov 8, 2019

Just more woke (i.e. unrealistic and obnoxious) trash that tries to co-opt a popular and established brand to smuggle in very cheesy and on-the-nose leftist politics, like practically every other show these days.

Watched one episode and wasJust more woke (i.e. unrealistic and obnoxious) trash that tries to co-opt a popular and established brand to smuggle in very cheesy and on-the-nose leftist politics, like practically every other show these days.

Watched one episode and was disgusted to see them pandering to identity politics-obsessed snowflakes while wearing the skin of Alan Moore's creative genius.… Expand

14 of 33 users found this helpful1419

All this user's reviews

3

zeeo92Nov 8, 2019

Another "progressive" trash for leftists. Don't watch it if you have some self respect.

15 of 39 users found this helpful1524

All this user's reviews

3

GravewaxNov 8, 2019

3 episodes in, it has 1 more left before I ditch this steaming pile. The story, plot and well just about everything is all over the place. They had a heap of source material to draw from and this is the crap they came up with.

18 of 39 users found this helpful1821

All this user's reviews

0

theeliteOct 31, 2019

These so called professional critic's should be fired.Or the need to be honest about the illegal drugs they are on.
This is not the watchmen.

19 of 43 users found this helpful1924

All this user's reviews

10

JeffreyWhitmoreNov 7, 2019

I was an avid reader of the series back when it came out, and I am always wary of all the crap DC has pulled, and I hate comic book TV series in general (The Boys was good!) and I was NOT looking forward to HBO ruining it.
I'm also very waryI was an avid reader of the series back when it came out, and I am always wary of all the crap DC has pulled, and I hate comic book TV series in general (The Boys was good!) and I was NOT looking forward to HBO ruining it.
I'm also very wary of PC and Woke stuff that Hollywood puts out...
But this is amazing. If you don't like you were probably cheering on the Tulsa massacre yet realized what was up after 30 minutes, and started stewing because You Had Been Had.
So much right wing Trump supporting crybabies here.
Good. Keep crying like little girls.
I loved Chappelle, I loved the Joker, and there is somewhat of a viewer/reviewer disparity - I realize that Metacritics has some weird biasing going on - but don't you dare try to paint this with the same brush.
Highly recommended. This is Great TV.
Ignore the alt right brigading and see for yourself.… Expand

14 of 31 users found this helpful1417

All this user's reviews

2

Modnar99Nov 6, 2019

The political criticism is valid, but worse, the show is, well, kind of boring. As you might expect from Lindelof, it's like if the Leftovers was about super heroes. Politically, it seems designed to push the "dangerous rise of whiteThe political criticism is valid, but worse, the show is, well, kind of boring. As you might expect from Lindelof, it's like if the Leftovers was about super heroes. Politically, it seems designed to push the "dangerous rise of white supremacy" narrative. The trailer park scene is so shamelessly stereotypical, it never would have been allowed if it was about any other group. I'm not a comic fan, so I'm able to enjoy it in a so-bad-it's-funny way.… Expand

15 of 38 users found this helpful1523

All this user's reviews

0

Alucard11Nov 5, 2019

It's just too bad and destroys Alan Moore's masterpiece, and the behavior, attitude and thinking of the characters don't match those shown in the graphic novel.
Sure is one of the worst tv series ever made

14 of 33 users found this helpful1419

All this user's reviews

0

JJorgNov 5, 2019

This show is just awful. Worse than awful! I call my parents awful, but I'll still interact with them occasionally. But this show, no, I just can't.
I read the Watchmen graphic novel years ago after I saw V for Vendetta. Alan Moore is aThis show is just awful. Worse than awful! I call my parents awful, but I'll still interact with them occasionally. But this show, no, I just can't.
I read the Watchmen graphic novel years ago after I saw V for Vendetta. Alan Moore is a genius and I imagine if he were dead and was made aware of this abomination, he would be doing somersaults in his grave. And I don't mean somersaults of joy, I mean the kind you would do to get away from the pile of puke puddling around your head. But you can't find relief because your grave is starting to fill up with copious amounts of vomit that this horrible show induces.
Serious question: who the hell signed off on making this show?… Expand

14 of 35 users found this helpful1421

All this user's reviews

1

DanimusRexNov 4, 2019

An unenthusiastic "meh" overall. I renewed my HBO sub for this one, only to be disappointed beyond measure. I was expecting something to top "the boys", but there's no life in this cobbled together nonsense. It seems to me that the writersAn unenthusiastic "meh" overall. I renewed my HBO sub for this one, only to be disappointed beyond measure. I was expecting something to top "the boys", but there's no life in this cobbled together nonsense. It seems to me that the writers had a coherent story put together until the director/ producers decided they could make more money by slapping the watchmen label on it. Don't waste your time.… Expand

19 of 47 users found this helpful1928

All this user's reviews

0

BarnyNov 4, 2019

watchmen in name only... the whole show is just garbage pandering to modern politics to the point where I believe it has to be a competition between all these woke writers to produce simultaneously the most despised product by their consumerswatchmen in name only... the whole show is just garbage pandering to modern politics to the point where I believe it has to be a competition between all these woke writers to produce simultaneously the most despised product by their consumers and the most revered by the critics. Someone would have to remind them the basics of customer service: the customer is right, if the customer does not get what the customer wants, the customer is not the problem, the product is the problem. Full fat zero.… Expand

13 of 32 users found this helpful1319

All this user's reviews

10

WolfguardNov 4, 2019

The story is told intriguingly without giving away everything at once. The cinematography is great, and there's generally a solid performance from the actors. It's not a show for impatient people and the Marvel/DC segment, though. I'm threeThe story is told intriguingly without giving away everything at once. The cinematography is great, and there's generally a solid performance from the actors. It's not a show for impatient people and the Marvel/DC segment, though. I'm three episodes in and I'm captivated!… Expand

14 of 33 users found this helpful1419

All this user's reviews

9

MadDrDreamNov 4, 2019

Realy great for those who will discover the universe of Watchmen. Splendid for all the fan of the graphic novel, despite what Alan Moore himself told.

The first episode is quite slow and maybe boring for those who expect somethin like "TheRealy great for those who will discover the universe of Watchmen. Splendid for all the fan of the graphic novel, despite what Alan Moore himself told.

The first episode is quite slow and maybe boring for those who expect somethin like "The Boys" but it become more and more powerfull and intersting with time. With the episode 2 and more with episode 3 it becomes more clear and intelligent, with less "boring" moment.

I really expect that more the tv show advanced and more it will be interesting. Really great show !… Expand

15 of 36 users found this helpful1521

All this user's reviews

0

BenderIsGreatNov 3, 2019

There’s nothing political or racial about my opinion. The show is terrible .

21 of 41 users found this helpful2120

All this user's reviews

3

alihefendiNov 3, 2019

Watchmen TV Series appear as a sequel of ground-breaking comic book with same name, but from my point of view it isn't possible to say that, it created same impression with first sights as comic book did. Important racial issues took hugeWatchmen TV Series appear as a sequel of ground-breaking comic book with same name, but from my point of view it isn't possible to say that, it created same impression with first sights as comic book did. Important racial issues took huge place in serie's plot, but creators dealt those with really burdensome method. There are no deep sides of characters, and no several situations which could appear after the final of comic book. However, this abortive expression couldn't effect audience, and expectations are going to become horrible disappoint.… Expand

17 of 39 users found this helpful1722

All this user's reviews

1

MarstandoonOct 31, 2019

A more vapid and blatant political show I've never seen. Once again, Hollywood takes a cherished franchise and runs it into the ground by inserting their poorly articulated opinions EVERYWHERE.

16 of 38 users found this helpful1622

All this user's reviews

0

SoulshockerOct 31, 2019

The movie was interesting so I was excited for this, but turns out it's complete unwatchable garbage. It's despicable how anti-white the show is, very political. I'm not white and I don't care for this nonsense.

14 of 34 users found this helpful1420

All this user's reviews

0

carlestormOct 31, 2019

more race **** they should call it strong independenant black woman beating up white males, because that is what it is. its certainly not watchmen. seriusly what even is the point of theese shows? that white people are all evil but they likemore race **** they should call it strong independenant black woman beating up white males, because that is what it is. its certainly not watchmen. seriusly what even is the point of theese shows? that white people are all evil but they like african american hip-hop? **** the only thing that makes sense is if the majority of HBO's viewers are black americans brainwashed by their own culture and HBO only cares for money even though they promote racism.… Expand

17 of 39 users found this helpful1722

All this user's reviews

1

skepticckOct 30, 2019

This is not Watchmen, this is in your face,preachy political propaganda, this is racist (anti-white) trash. If not liking trash like this or Batwoman makes me a "...ist", then sure call me that and will wear that title proudly.

24 of 48 users found this helpful2424

All this user's reviews

0

WhiskyliverOct 30, 2019

Nothing to see here. Just more progressive “woke” garbage. Like we needed anymore.

39 of 69 users found this helpful3930

All this user's reviews

0

OlivierPielOct 28, 2019

I waited until episode 2 to make a judgement as I expected that episode 1 was written to subvert our expectations. How was I deceived! The writing is indeed simplistic nonsense. Cue: The German WWI propaganda leaflet to demoralize blackI waited until episode 2 to make a judgement as I expected that episode 1 was written to subvert our expectations. How was I deceived! The writing is indeed simplistic nonsense. Cue: The German WWI propaganda leaflet to demoralize black American troops is kept as a cherished relic by the character played by Lou Gosset Jr., as if it had a talismanic value...and as if anybody (black or not) could be so daft to take it at face-value.
Not only it is insulting to viewers with a modicum of historical knowledge but, very much to the intelligence of black troops at the time.
It's funny how a show both patronizes and insults a group of people ("blacks") at the same time!!!!

At least we can see now that Lindelof is truly a fraud, and that Lost anf Leftovers should be discounted as sophomoric pseudo-philosophical nonsense.… Expand

22 of 44 users found this helpful2222

All this user's reviews

3

RabidprimateOct 27, 2019

Watchmen in name only. If your not part of the Cult of Woke its just strange and boring.

21 of 44 users found this helpful2123

All this user's reviews

8

pjntOct 27, 2019

Good start. Reviews suggest anti-white implications, however, I am not American and do not come to this conclusion. I see shows today overwhelmingly have LGBT characters, white villains and female lead roles. In the 80's the mainstreamGood start. Reviews suggest anti-white implications, however, I am not American and do not come to this conclusion. I see shows today overwhelmingly have LGBT characters, white villains and female lead roles. In the 80's the mainstream entertainment industry always had their 'comic relief' black dude. It is the social evolution being put to screen. Watchmen has great acting, great effects and a story that is engaging. Looking forward to ep. 2.… Expand

14 of 36 users found this helpful1422

All this user's reviews

9

Agent007BKOct 27, 2019

The way the Tusla Race Massacre was covered in the first episode captivated me. Definitely a fan, and I can't wait to see the way the rest of the season pans out. Not surprised by the low ratings though. Anytime Black and Brown people talkThe way the Tusla Race Massacre was covered in the first episode captivated me. Definitely a fan, and I can't wait to see the way the rest of the season pans out. Not surprised by the low ratings though. Anytime Black and Brown people talk about things of the past that have shaped their lives, there's a certain sect of people that are always triggered. Funny how that works. You can tell they also have limited knowledge on the subject matter because they've completely forgotten the political nature of The Watchmen comics being that the beginning of the comics has to deal with the Cold War between the US and Russia. Comics ALWAYS have different runs, and this is no different. Don't let the haters deter you. Challenge yourself if you're not fragile.… Expand

15 of 41 users found this helpful1526

All this user's reviews

8

timmytimeOct 27, 2019

Amazing show that is doing the same thing the comic did in the 80s for today. As a fan I'm astounded by how well they've captured the spirit of the comic while still offering something fresh and more than just fanservice. It does a better jobAmazing show that is doing the same thing the comic did in the 80s for today. As a fan I'm astounded by how well they've captured the spirit of the comic while still offering something fresh and more than just fanservice. It does a better job of capturing the tone of the comic than the movie… Expand

15 of 38 users found this helpful1523

All this user's reviews

0

JayGeeWiseOct 26, 2019

Identity politics trying portray the antifa like left and excuse their excessive use of violence. Women are beating up men to comical extents. Where is the complexity of characters like Rorschach and the comedian? One dimensional charactersIdentity politics trying portray the antifa like left and excuse their excessive use of violence. Women are beating up men to comical extents. Where is the complexity of characters like Rorschach and the comedian? One dimensional characters that, are at this point, a tired trope. Sad to see a beloved novel of mine be disrespected to further Hollywood’s unpopular politics.… Expand

23 of 48 users found this helpful2325

All this user's reviews

0

insicknessOct 25, 2019

Hey, I have an idea. Let's take a beloved franchise that had nothing to do with race and make it all about race and racism. Let's make something that will satiate my white-as-evil-incarnate fantasy.

27 of 51 users found this helpful2724

All this user's reviews

1

blaatenatorOct 25, 2019

The pilot was a piece of sh**t: no introduction to the universe, incoherent storyline and 'straiht-in-your-face pretentious' mumbo-jumble conversations. For some reason it reminded me of Star Wars: The Last Jedi, where they also tried toThe pilot was a piece of sh**t: no introduction to the universe, incoherent storyline and 'straiht-in-your-face pretentious' mumbo-jumble conversations. For some reason it reminded me of Star Wars: The Last Jedi, where they also tried to shove some ideology through the viewers throath (though with a different focus).… Expand

25 of 52 users found this helpful2527

All this user's reviews

0

FGPTOct 25, 2019

I can't believe they did this to the source material! Who is HBO trying to please? Twitter activists? What about the fandom, The people that actually enjoy the art? Such a waste! The production value is amazing, the directing is great. But itI can't believe they did this to the source material! Who is HBO trying to please? Twitter activists? What about the fandom, The people that actually enjoy the art? Such a waste! The production value is amazing, the directing is great. But it all falls to the ground because the story is terrible.… Expand

28 of 58 users found this helpful2830

All this user's reviews

10

FoxDogOct 25, 2019

Since I am grown adult who doesn't have a fragile ego I loved this show. Its pretty telling that people see racism as a personal attack. That being said the show is amazing. Great acting, good story telling and the promise to be a great series.

20 of 48 users found this helpful2028

All this user's reviews

0

AthanasiosTOct 24, 2019

I've read the comic, saw the movie and expected something in the general direction of those two. Unfortunately, the TV show is just a well directed anti-racist drama, in an alternative 2019, with a predictable and overplayed scenario. NotI've read the comic, saw the movie and expected something in the general direction of those two. Unfortunately, the TV show is just a well directed anti-racist drama, in an alternative 2019, with a predictable and overplayed scenario. Not interesting at all, it won't keep me past the first episode.… Expand

20 of 44 users found this helpful2024

All this user's reviews

1

RubberfactsOct 24, 2019

This is just another attempt to co-opt an established franchise to trojan horse regressive corporate approved politics. They've replaced the wry cynicism of the original comic with aggressively boring fear mongering and identity politicsThis is just another attempt to co-opt an established franchise to trojan horse regressive corporate approved politics. They've replaced the wry cynicism of the original comic with aggressively boring fear mongering and identity politics which I think everyone is tired of at this point, after being force fed them by nearly everyone in the media and entertainment industry for the last couple years.… Expand

47 of 78 users found this helpful4731

All this user's reviews

1

FranciscoBoniOct 24, 2019

Damon Lindelof is a butcher. This is just a random TV show that happens to be named "Watchmen" with hysterical over the top politics. It has little to do with the source material and it's core message.

27 of 56 users found this helpful2729

All this user's reviews

0

ThayerConradOct 24, 2019

Watch "Watchmen" only if you are so convinced that all people of European descent are pure evil that you like to see "alternate future" fiction that portrays white people as cartoonish villains and non-whites as their noble and sufferingWatch "Watchmen" only if you are so convinced that all people of European descent are pure evil that you like to see "alternate future" fiction that portrays white people as cartoonish villains and non-whites as their noble and suffering victims, always and everywhere, even in timelines that don't really exist… Expand

43 of 73 users found this helpful4330

All this user's reviews

2

viroodiemOct 23, 2019

Terrible premier for a show nobody asked for.

It takes a huge steaming, splattery dump all over the franchise by ignoring the source material, creating its own story line and mythos to suit its narrative agenda. Aside from its clearlyTerrible premier for a show nobody asked for.

It takes a huge steaming, splattery dump all over the franchise by ignoring the source material, creating its own story line and mythos to suit its narrative agenda.

Aside from its clearly politically motivated direction that has nothing to do with the franchise in any capacity at all, it commits the worst sin any form of entertainment can make. Its boring as watching paint dry. The cast is filled with mid range actors and has beens that lack any strong chemistry together.

I paused the show 6 times within 48 minutes and by this point I was wondering why I kept turning it back on.

This is a shame because so much could have been done here and instead of making what was advertised, they used the watchmen IP as a vehicle to tell white men how evil they are.

Gave the thing a 2 out of 10 for no other reason than appreciating the Reznor/Ross soundtrack. Beyond this everything else in it is offensive and intolerant propaganda.… Expand

28 of 55 users found this helpful2827

All this user's reviews

0

robben1234Oct 23, 2019

Just some woke propaganda. Using Watchmen as a bait, has nothing to do with it.

43 of 77 users found this helpful4334

All this user's reviews

4

DoubledoorOct 23, 2019

This show could have been decent, if they had done two things: Cut out all the social commentary, seriously, "cop brutality is bad" and "racism is bad" is something we all know. It gets pushed into our faces every single day, and we don'tThis show could have been decent, if they had done two things: Cut out all the social commentary, seriously, "cop brutality is bad" and "racism is bad" is something we all know. It gets pushed into our faces every single day, and we don't need any more of that. IMO they should also have at least 1 character from the movie in the first episode, even if it's just a TV interview. This would connect it to the movie universe, which is something this movie badly needs. Some kind of connection to something we already know.

If I had to say something good about the show so far, I'd say the acting is pretty great.… Expand

24 of 42 users found this helpful2418

All this user's reviews

0

JrtlaktalkOct 23, 2019

I am not certain what the purpose of movies and shows these days are by going out of its way to sacrifice story and narrative just to vilify a certain demographic, but this is another one of those, so if you are tired of that, you can skipI am not certain what the purpose of movies and shows these days are by going out of its way to sacrifice story and narrative just to vilify a certain demographic, but this is another one of those, so if you are tired of that, you can skip this.

Also, Regina King was not a good cast, and her portrayal feels odd, she does an angry mom character better. Despite how much I dislike Jada Pinkett Smith, she would actually have been a good cast here. She wouldn't even have needed to "act" very hard to pull it off.

The fact that it doesn't feel like the book, isn't saying much these days, seeing as almost every origin story, character, and narrative is being wokered for the purpose of... because. This show screws up Rorschach for that purpose, other things as well, but that is the most notable screw up.… Expand

29 of 60 users found this helpful2931

All this user's reviews

0

HellioWOct 22, 2019

People who think The Last Jedi, Star Trek Discovery and Prometheus are masterpieces will enjoy the first episode. For my part I think it's so bad it's bizarre. There's not a single redeeming feature, everything is terrible, even the musicalPeople who think The Last Jedi, Star Trek Discovery and Prometheus are masterpieces will enjoy the first episode. For my part I think it's so bad it's bizarre. There's not a single redeeming feature, everything is terrible, even the musical score. The masked vigilantes would be at home in Kick-Ass (seriously). Lot's of obvious and cringe worthy JJ Abrams style self-references.… Expand

26 of 55 users found this helpful2629

All this user's reviews

0

iagosoares95Oct 22, 2019

The original history wasn'y respected, transforming Rorschard in a white supremacist

43 of 75 users found this helpful4332

All this user's reviews

9

tgm0Oct 22, 2019

I knew nothing about Watchmen, but I really enjoyed the first episode of this new series. Looking forward to see more...

17 of 50 users found this helpful1733

All this user's reviews

1

goust24Oct 22, 2019

This is not Watchmen. This is bad political propaganda. Thanks, I'm not hungry. One point for music.

46 of 82 users found this helpful4636

All this user's reviews

0

MrnapalmOct 22, 2019

Unfortunately this TV series has nothing to do with the watchmen, and it's sad. :(

37 of 69 users found this helpful3732

All this user's reviews

4

DanielGOct 21, 2019

This is some artsy fartsy yuppies wet dream to take a solid franchise and integrate some awful identity politics into a franchise that has nothing to do with that. The pilot was extremely weak and boring almost the entire way through. It keptThis is some artsy fartsy yuppies wet dream to take a solid franchise and integrate some awful identity politics into a franchise that has nothing to do with that. The pilot was extremely weak and boring almost the entire way through. It kept some original watchmen fans interested with mere nano seconds of well known characters from the original franchise. Mixed along with the boring plot line and terrible pacing that will put you to sleep. They did a fab job with the trailers, I'll give them that. Too bad its going to be a one season let down show. If you are looking for your next series time sink. This isn't going to be one of them.… Expand

31 of 53 users found this helpful3122

All this user's reviews

10

AryamanOct 21, 2019

An amazing premiere highlighted by Regina King's performance and a wonderful score!

20 of 56 users found this helpful2036

All this user's reviews

8

MFTOct 21, 2019

Not an American and i don't really care about American politics either. I didn't find any "liberal propaganda". Music is very good, some actors are excellent, plot is ridiculous and setting is fitting for the current state of the world. It'sNot an American and i don't really care about American politics either. I didn't find any "liberal propaganda". Music is very good, some actors are excellent, plot is ridiculous and setting is fitting for the current state of the world. It's a good superhero/antisuperhero tv show, similar to Umbrella Academy and Doom Patrol. Just watch it and decide for yourself.… Expand

21 of 57 users found this helpful2136

All this user's reviews

3

ScienceAdvisorOct 21, 2019

This is Watchmen in name only. This first epsiode is boring, incoherent, breaks continuity (if you believe it is a sequel not a reboot) and full of 'member berries. The only other thing it does is pound home that "Racism & Police Brutality"This is Watchmen in name only. This first epsiode is boring, incoherent, breaks continuity (if you believe it is a sequel not a reboot) and full of 'member berries. The only other thing it does is pound home that "Racism & Police Brutality" bad, except we are the choir and know that already. How this made it to series is beyond comprehension.… Expand

56 of 90 users found this helpful5634

All this user's reviews

3

mortendynamoOct 21, 2019

This has nothing to do with the original Watchmen. It should never have been made into a series.

60 of 92 users found this helpful6032

All this user's reviews

0

chestnutmountOct 21, 2019

Old stupid tropes and a network playing it safe so it doesn't offend anyone. The whole premise is based on laughable villains, boring heroes, and an entire police force that's completely useless. Pacing is also all over the place as well asOld stupid tropes and a network playing it safe so it doesn't offend anyone. The whole premise is based on laughable villains, boring heroes, and an entire police force that's completely useless. Pacing is also all over the place as well as the story telling. If you want yet another show that shows a 105 lb woman beating everyone's ass in hand to hand combat then this show is for you. Alan Moore (creator of Watchmen) particularly hates Hollywood. This time they've finally given him a legit reason for his grievances.… Expand

46 of 75 users found this helpful4629

All this user's reviews

0

llagrokOct 21, 2019

Absolute drivel compared to its predecessor.
Completely devoid of nuance and void of interesting characters or plot points.

45 of 78 users found this helpful4533

All this user's reviews

10

DeeziedeetzOct 21, 2019

An excellent show. Very well written. Visually spectacular. Good job HBO and DC.

17 of 54 users found this helpful1737

All this user's reviews

0

Catolic_GamerOct 21, 2019

If they put political ideology aside, it could be much better! Watchmen deserve more!

44 of 76 users found this helpful4432

All this user's reviews

10

IcksapelOct 21, 2019

Well written. Def one of the best shows this year. The actors are all brilliant and the pacing is real good. HBO found a winner with this one.

17 of 55 users found this helpful1738

All this user's reviews

7

arunscriptOct 21, 2019

I’ll begin with a few disclaimers. I am not an American. I won’t go out of my way to like or dislike anything because the main protagonist is black or a woman or white or brown or man or any combinations of these. Also, I believe that theI’ll begin with a few disclaimers. I am not an American. I won’t go out of my way to like or dislike anything because the main protagonist is black or a woman or white or brown or man or any combinations of these. Also, I believe that the Watchmen books are infinitely better than the Zack Snyder hyper-stylized movie adaptation. Don’t get me wrong. The movie is fun but it misses the point.

I also don’t agree with Alan Moore’s general tendency to thumb down any attempt to turn his books into another medium - movies or television. That said, here’s what I think about the TV series (one episode in).

PROS
- Good setup overall with the background story and the current state that the world is in. Good suspense and story.
- “Superhero” selection is very interesting and very human (no “powers” - yet)
- Decent suspense; pretty decent story
- Good background music / score

CONS
- Action sequences aren’t top-notch (they’re not bad either)
- Overall, everything is “good” not “great”

I want to give this a 6.5/10... am giving it a 7/10. How the story develops will be interesting (will update the rating accordingly).… Expand

20 of 55 users found this helpful2035

All this user's reviews

9

PhoenixxlOct 21, 2019

The alternate history setting is probably hard on people who aren't used to encountering the concept in science fiction. They will see "political".

Why 9 and not 10.. Even though there's only 1 of them, I'm dead tired of the whole superheroThe alternate history setting is probably hard on people who aren't used to encountering the concept in science fiction. They will see "political".

Why 9 and not 10.. Even though there's only 1 of them, I'm dead tired of the whole superhero FANTASY shtick. Not because I want to prohibit other people enjoying the genre but because I am a science fiction fan and it's gobbling up all the allotted time and money production companies set aside for the genre as a whole. That being said, there are a few novel concepts introduced in this series which I would like to get to the bottom of.… Expand

21 of 56 users found this helpful2135

All this user's reviews

10

JohnRoflsOct 20, 2019

Complex storyline that intertwines new mythos into an existing universe while touching on a very real potential distopian world in a cautionary tale that spends little time directly preaching. Rather, the story forces the audience into theComplex storyline that intertwines new mythos into an existing universe while touching on a very real potential distopian world in a cautionary tale that spends little time directly preaching. Rather, the story forces the audience into the alternate history that began within the text of Watchmen. Absolutely brilliant cinematography ties everything together.… Expand

37 of 105 users found this helpful3768

All this user's reviews

0

PrettyboyfloydOct 20, 2019

Not Alan Moore's Watchmen, but Lindehoff's attempt off making Black Panther. And there's only one reason he needs to inject his idea's into some one else's franchise, because he's too much of a hack to create his own.

54 of 88 users found this helpful5434

All this user's reviews

Watchmen (2019)

User Reviews