The Witcher

:

Season 1
  • Network: Netflix
  • Series Premiere Date: Dec 20, 2019
Season #: 4, 3.5, 3, 2, 1
User Score
7.5

Generally favorable reviews- based on 2682 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 2,028 out of 2682
  2. Mixed: 201 out of 2682
  3. Negative: 453 out of 2682

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

view
per page
  1. Angar
    Aug 3, 2023
    1
    I was too dumb to understand plot, please dumb it down more. +1 point because of Henry Cavill still beeing Geralt.
  2. Rethar
    Nov 3, 2022
    0
    Horrible parasitism on books. Some canonical stories are just for show. The Queen wishes everyone beer and terribly ridicule the ambassadors. Humor gave way to a huge amount of pathos. Yen Mary Sue, Ciri Imba, for which you do not worry... There are many logical inconsistencies even for the original work.
  3. RichSpider
    Dec 22, 2021
    0
    This is the key for me. If you are going to adapt award-winning source material that's beloved by many fans, whatever changes you make better have either A) a great reason behind it or B) improve the story.

    So far I've watched The Expanse incredibly faithfully adapt the novels to TV as best as they can and why is that show so beloved? The quality of the story is extremely high. For the    This is the key for me. If you are going to adapt award-winning source material that's beloved by many fans, whatever changes you make better have either A) a great reason behind it or B) improve the story.

    So far I've watched The Expanse incredibly faithfully adapt the novels to TV as best as they can and why is that show so beloved? The quality of the story is extremely high. For the non-book readers that in of itself is great. But for the book readers, they know the quality is so damn high because the quality of the novels is so damn high and so the showrunner and writers room (including the book's authors) faithfully adapted it to preserve that high-quality storytelling. I have also watched Game of Thrones in earlier seasons where they were largely faithful adaptations of award-winning novels and how beloved were they? Intensely. Even Dune recently was made highly faithfully and the book readers have loved it.

    I haven't finished this season yet (almost there) but I'm scared seeing how many are saying the last two episodes are the worst of all. But so far, as someone who has read the books twice, loved them but isn't above adaptations taking a different spin (if it improves the story) I am really disappointed. Not by the visuals, the acting, or anything like that. It is entirely due to the showrunner and writer's decision to make changes needlessly that make the story WORSE, not better. Why do they feel the need to add their twists and their own touch? Likely fear or ego. They don't feel creatively excited about translating a story from one medium to another they want to make it "their own." The hubris of that when the source material is award-winning and they're just TV writers is incredible.

    It sucks because I could overlook some shakey acting here and there or a bad costume or average CGI, but when the story is what I have a problem with and it's a story that requires certain things in order to result in other things down the line, it makes watching the show so tough. I end up just feeling bad for Henry who considering what he's said in multiple interviews, just wishes the show was a faithful adaptation from the novels to the screen like The Expanse has been.    … Expand
  4. JavaSquirt
    Dec 20, 2021
    0
    Ждал сериал про вселенную ведьмака, получил киноиспражнение про лгбт, негров эльфов, негров дриад(с арбалетами, дриады, сука, с арбалетами, черные), нереально страшные актрисы, ЙЕн индуска, Трисс негр. Обычные славяне в деревнях тоже негры кста.Ждал сериал про вселенную ведьмака, получил киноиспражнение про лгбт, негров эльфов, негров дриад(с арбалетами, дриады, сука, с арбалетами, черные), нереально страшные актрисы, ЙЕн индуска, Трисс негр. Обычные славяне в деревнях тоже негры кста.
  5. jautja
    Dec 20, 2021
    2
    Просто отвратительно. На оригинал плевать, декорации - крашеный картон, доспехи ведьмака убожество (нильфгардские доспехи из первого сезона курят), эльфы - люди бомжи, все смешано в одну кучу, цири стала БОТЕКСНОЙ дурой, Весемир тупой и т.д.

    It's just disgusting. Don't care about the original, the decorations are painted cardboard, the witcher's armor is squalor (Nilfgard armor from the    Просто отвратительно. На оригинал плевать, декорации - крашеный картон, доспехи ведьмака убожество (нильфгардские доспехи из первого сезона курят), эльфы - люди бомжи, все смешано в одну кучу, цири стала БОТЕКСНОЙ дурой, Весемир тупой и т.д.

    It's just disgusting. Don't care about the original, the decorations are painted cardboard, the witcher's armor is squalor (Nilfgard armor from the first season is smoking), the elves are homeless people, everything is mixed in one heap, ciri has become a BOTEX fool, Vesemir is stupid, etc.    … Expand
  6. tehJo
    Dec 18, 2021
    3
    Yet another atrocity. They really loosely used books. Changing the meaning of stories, added more and more. The script is really bad, dialogs are horrible, characters are butchered. Season one was really bad and due to changes made to the story, they are going deeper and deeper into the world of terrible confusion and at the same time feeding us horrible experiences. Dialogs are writtenYet another atrocity. They really loosely used books. Changing the meaning of stories, added more and more. The script is really bad, dialogs are horrible, characters are butchered. Season one was really bad and due to changes made to the story, they are going deeper and deeper into the world of terrible confusion and at the same time feeding us horrible experiences. Dialogs are written once in the tones of fantasy and in other times modern talk. The political correctness that changed the plot and characters in season one now just makes it unwatchable. The story of Ciri was a story of a child and clearly here she is a woman. I do not see redemption for this series. I like Henry but he should know better not to be part of this atrocity.… Expand
  7. metacritiqueur
    Sep 2, 2020
    0
    Redhead lives matter ! That cast... seriously Netflix, throw away your political agenda for God sake.
  8. belchegors
    Jun 14, 2020
    0
    A spit on european / slavic folklore and culture. It's all cheap, battles are terrible. Horrible cast and storytelling itself. It's an insult to fans. Just a badly written fanfiction with some book stuff sprinkled here and there. It's not worth your time if you are a fan of the books and you want a loyal adaptation.
    Henry is great. Unfortunately, that is not enough. Looks like Netflix    A spit on european / slavic folklore and culture. It's all cheap, battles are terrible. Horrible cast and storytelling itself. It's an insult to fans. Just a badly written fanfiction with some book stuff sprinkled here and there. It's not worth your time if you are a fan of the books and you want a loyal adaptation.
    Henry is great. Unfortunately, that is not enough. Looks like Netflix plans to destroy the magnificent story.    … Expand
  9. FreeAndCritical
    May 15, 2020
    2
    All the fantasy and sci-fi TV series from recent years that I've tried watching during the COVID-19 lock-down have suffered from the same thing: misandry. Yup, the elephant in the room. This is making them very predictable and therefore boring. It's as though they're all being written using the same formula of stereotyping, one-way physical and verbal abuse etc to the point where you canAll the fantasy and sci-fi TV series from recent years that I've tried watching during the COVID-19 lock-down have suffered from the same thing: misandry. Yup, the elephant in the room. This is making them very predictable and therefore boring. It's as though they're all being written using the same formula of stereotyping, one-way physical and verbal abuse etc to the point where you can predict the outcome of a scene based on the genders involved.

    Andrzej Sapkowski's books are, for better or worse, classic sword-and-sorcery fare but the TV series is very much a feminist take on them. The Witcher isn't among the worst - I was very surprised to see Geralt head butt a woman - but it's still enough to make it a predictable tick-box yawnfest. Non-cannon music and contemporary phrases really don't help the immersion either.

    Related to immersion, the source material (in which I include the video games) draws heavily on Polish and other European folklore. I have to be careful here, but imagine a fantasy series based on African folklore (which would be awesome!) with 'Caucasian' actors throughout. It would feel jarringly 'off'. Some of the casting choices, including Yennefer, Triss and the bard I think of as Dandelion, feel way off after the excellently portrayed characters of the video games.

    Not popular opinions, I know, but it would be nice to see these TV series' mix it up a bit. This one, sadly, doesn't stand out from the crowd for me.    … Expand
  10. PowerfullPlayer
    May 15, 2020
    0
    Black villagers? Black elves? OMFG I just imagine that this **** doesn't exist.
  11. wayrez
    May 14, 2020
    2
    The only positive thing about this series is the actors' game. This series is suitable only for those who are not familiar with the universe of the Witcher. The writers just didn't care about the original source. The biggest disappointment of the year for me :/
  12. Ivanchik
    Jan 21, 2020
    0
    Пофиг на актеров. Пофиг на толерастию. Но сюжета ноль. Съемка рваная. Диалогов вообще нет, просто базар вокзал не о чём. Декорации дешёвые какие то. Общих планов съемки нет. Вообще не объясняют кто такой ведьмак. Я играл во все части и потом прочитал Книги. А вот сериал как будто сделан учениками киношколы, которые прогуливают занятия. Если сравнивать с другими сериалами, то этот всегдаПофиг на актеров. Пофиг на толерастию. Но сюжета ноль. Съемка рваная. Диалогов вообще нет, просто базар вокзал не о чём. Декорации дешёвые какие то. Общих планов съемки нет. Вообще не объясняют кто такой ведьмак. Я играл во все части и потом прочитал Книги. А вот сериал как будто сделан учениками киношколы, которые прогуливают занятия. Если сравнивать с другими сериалами, то этот всегда будет позади, с каким не сравни.… Expand
  13. Scroodjke
    Jan 13, 2020
    1
    Terrible work, absolutely revolting.
    -.Misscasting
    - Not canonical
    This show does not deserve a 2nd season.
  14. Frek
    Jan 12, 2020
    2
    My background knowledge going into this was that i played the first chapter of Witcher 3. I didn't make it through episode 5 when I lost all interest. My 3 biggest complaints:
    - Why is this called "The Witcher"? Clearly the main character is Yennifer.
    - What is going on? One minute queen lady is dead, the next shes talking to the Witcher. - Unpopular opinion: Most of the sexualized    My background knowledge going into this was that i played the first chapter of Witcher 3. I didn't make it through episode 5 when I lost all interest. My 3 biggest complaints:
    - Why is this called "The Witcher"? Clearly the main character is Yennifer.
    - What is going on? One minute queen lady is dead, the next shes talking to the Witcher.
    - Unpopular opinion: Most of the sexualized content was just there for the sake of "hey we have boobies in our show and it makes us edgy and cool".

    What I did like:
    - the combat scene in episode 1, there should be more of that
    - the character development of Yennifer, (I have no idea why the Witcher didn't get the same treatment from the get go)
    - I like the epic setting but this clearly is not made for people that aren't experts in the lore.    … Expand
  15. Tiberiy
    Jan 9, 2020
    3
    The series average. A lot of empty chatter about the unfortunate elves, the palette of the world is very gray, the graphics are not always at the level. One of the advantages of good fight scenes. Who played the game will be disappointed. But that's only in the first two series.
    However, by the middle of the series accelerates and becomes not bad.
  16. Yurchik
    Jan 7, 2020
    0
    I didn't read books or play games. I decided to watch the show... I didn't understand anything! Even the final season of Game of Thrones didn't upset me as much as - the Witcher!
  17. sub-madara
    Jan 2, 2020
    3
    Okay so I give it a 3 because near the end or in the end its a little fixed, I hope they improve. You know game of thrones had a bad ending, hope this one( witcher) starts bad ends good. But no enviroment and no atmosphere. Two persons I liked was jaskier and tissaia. Geralt was meh.
  18. ICETouch
    Jan 2, 2020
    1
    Too goddamn much of colored washing. there is position what fit in story. but much of blacks and yellows in the European Medieval fantasy? How dare you? just let whites's-story be as it followed from origin. also yellows's-story or blacks's and the other something like's too.
    World being messed up by ugly PC's twisted idea. we should stop. stop the mud competition and find own color and    Too goddamn much of colored washing. there is position what fit in story. but much of blacks and yellows in the European Medieval fantasy? How dare you? just let whites's-story be as it followed from origin. also yellows's-story or blacks's and the other something like's too.
    World being messed up by ugly PC's twisted idea. we should stop. stop the mud competition and find own color and keep their nature what it already have.    … Expand
  19. Orion8725
    Jan 1, 2020
    3
    I neither believe in 0's nor 10's unless a show or game has a great impact on the genre. The books were enjoyable and on par with the Sword of Truth or GoT books. The Witcher 3 ruined RPG games for me. By that i mean I cannot think of another RPG that comes close to it and now find all others rather boring. That being said, The Witcher 3 for me was a 10 with the books being a high 7 or 8.I neither believe in 0's nor 10's unless a show or game has a great impact on the genre. The books were enjoyable and on par with the Sword of Truth or GoT books. The Witcher 3 ruined RPG games for me. By that i mean I cannot think of another RPG that comes close to it and now find all others rather boring. That being said, The Witcher 3 for me was a 10 with the books being a high 7 or 8.

    The more invested you are in the books and especially the games, the less you will find this show enjoyable. Casting, like others have mentioned, is poor for several characters. Henry does a good job, but he is not enough to save this series for me. I really wanted this show to shine but it simply falls short of expectations from missed opportunities with story to odd changes to the story that adds nothing to the show.

    if you have no clue what you are getting into, you will find this probably a 6 out of 10. If you read the books, perhaps a mid to high 4 or perhaps even a 5. If you are a huge fan of the games, you are looking at a 3 or lower. In a perfect world, HBO would have picked this up and contracted with some of the CD Project Red writers. Instead, we are left with something that is simply mediocre and not a TV series that I will watch a second time.

    A great review of the show can be found by someone I consider an even larger fan than myself, Witcher George on YouTube, who did a great job of revealing the issues with this series. For all the gamers out there, we still have Cyberpunk coming soon. For book fans, perhaps HBO will pick up The Sword of Truth and we can finally have our fantasy escape many of us are looking for after the end of GoT (excluding the last season) and whatever this is trying to be.    … Expand
  20. Bulletsponge69
    Jan 1, 2020
    2
    It’s like Game of Thrones ;but without all the good acting and storytelling getting in the way of juvenile jokes and contemporary references and language that seem out of place in a setting that seemingly takes place in the past.
  21. Gulla1
    Dec 30, 2019
    3
    First episode was good. The rest are lowering your hopes for the next one. The technology in making is good - but the manuscript lacks pace and smartness.
    Sorry to say this is a great opportunity gone bad.
  22. AthanasiosT
    Dec 29, 2019
    1
    TV writers never fail to disappoint me. They always manage to take prime material and transform it to sh...t. All main characters' stories are twisted beyond recognition and chronically mixed together. Geralt's adventures, which take 20 and more pages in a book, are shortened to half an episode's duration, resulting in incomprehensible stories. The medieval epoch is polluted with modernTV writers never fail to disappoint me. They always manage to take prime material and transform it to sh...t. All main characters' stories are twisted beyond recognition and chronically mixed together. Geralt's adventures, which take 20 and more pages in a book, are shortened to half an episode's duration, resulting in incomprehensible stories. The medieval epoch is polluted with modern phrases. The bard's songs have rock'n'roll riffs. The elves live in caves instead of their forests. Etc,etc. 1 point for Henry Cavill, his acting and his honest and apparent efforts to stay loyal to Geralt of Rivia. The rest get a zero.… Expand
  23. Discorder
    Dec 29, 2019
    1
    Чёрные дриады с копьями и арбалетами!?Трисс цыганка !?Фрингилия - обезьяна!?Нильфгардская броня...
  24. Kalcired
    Dec 29, 2019
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This show fails under every aspect.
    It's not a show for someone who doesn't know about the witcher because it lacks in background, still it's not for fans because there are too many mistakes.
    The actors are dogs mainly Henry performs a poor Geralt always with that grin.
    Mistakes on customization, mistakes in characters (black Triss is just unbelivable sad), errors of regia between scenes, poor special effects and fights...    … Expand
  25. Graand04
    Dec 28, 2019
    0
    **** this TV show just failed under tolerated laws of western world. Slovak person should be white. I am Belarusian I know what I am talking about.
  26. ChocoPotatoe
    Dec 28, 2019
    2
    It's a good fantasy show, but a very bad adaptation. Netflix wanted to push their ethnic quota on The Witcher, and replaced several established white characters in the book with actors of colour. It took away all the immersion we could have had. If you read the books, you'll know that making Fringilla black doesn't make sense in the story. Dark elves don't exist in the world of TheIt's a good fantasy show, but a very bad adaptation. Netflix wanted to push their ethnic quota on The Witcher, and replaced several established white characters in the book with actors of colour. It took away all the immersion we could have had. If you read the books, you'll know that making Fringilla black doesn't make sense in the story. Dark elves don't exist in the world of The Witcher. Even Zerrikanians should be of arabic ethnicity, which makes sense, but not black.
    Why do they always ruin a good story by pushing political correctness? This show is literally The Witcher in America.

    Even the dwarves are a joke. They should be strong, small, but big. But in the show, they're literally human dwarves who can't even carry a sword.

    They've made the world of "The Witcher" totally inconsistent. I'm a big fan of the books, I didn't play the games, but I'm really disappointed in the show. It doesn't do justice to the books at all.    … Expand
  27. Falorin1999
    Dec 28, 2019
    0
    I expected a lot more from the series. He expected that he would narrate the book well, or at least close to it.
    Instead, I got a disgusting plot, disgusting scenery and disgusting actors who do not know how to play their roles. It was necessary to shoot a normal series, and not to shoot a series in which they are trying to please someone. I am disappointed
  28. V0X_Populi
    Dec 28, 2019
    2
    Плохая экранизация книг. Всё переиначили и не в лучшую сторону. Логика местами вообще покидает данный сериал. Единственное что радует так это сам Геральт.
  29. mad851
    Dec 28, 2019
    2
    This is one of the worst adaptation ever made, really disappointing TV show, nothing like the books, forcing diversity (blackwashing characters) in a polish European fantasy is horrible! Bad CGI, bad writing, bad acting, they didn't followed the chronology of the books, it's not the mature dark Fantasy that we want it's more like XENA level of tv show than game of thrones. Too bad
  30. StephanL
    Dec 27, 2019
    3
    Perhaps this show is drawing in people who love soap opera's posing as fantasy and thus the discrepancy between viewers comments and critics. I love fantasy, and good storytelling. This is poorly made. Henry Cavill is great but miscast here. Sets too clean and boring. My disbelief was not suspended. Racial inclusiveness is important but at the cost of good storytelling? Poor choice in showrunn
  31. drewanenomor
    Dec 27, 2019
    3
    This show does not fill the void of Game of thrones. I really can't stand the way Cavill has decided to deliver his lines..
  32. Dantelion
    Dec 27, 2019
    0
    0/10 спасибо шитфликс,поел говна,тем кто читал книгу строго противопоказано к просмотру.
  33. SeussMyTub
    Dec 27, 2019
    3
    The production values are good, and Henry Cavill is a decent actor, but the story sucks. The Bard is the most annoying character on TV and he sings in each episode? Awful. Like a poor man's version of Game of Thrones.
  34. 123esh123
    Dec 25, 2019
    2
    A painful waste of potential. After being handed a blueprint to success in the excellent books the show runners decided to warp the very soul of the franchise and turn a series that was an excellent meta commentary on fantasy and fairy tale cliches into the generic fantasy it was meant to subvert. By woefully attempting a story made up from three fractured timelines to very little effectA painful waste of potential. After being handed a blueprint to success in the excellent books the show runners decided to warp the very soul of the franchise and turn a series that was an excellent meta commentary on fantasy and fairy tale cliches into the generic fantasy it was meant to subvert. By woefully attempting a story made up from three fractured timelines to very little effect they have produced a final product that will undoubtably confuse any newcomers with its shambolic delivery of the story, whilst also it should enrage existing fans with its disrespectful shortcomings in terms of adapting the narrative and worldbuilding. The only positives are a small selection of performances and brief moments of fight choreography, but it's hard to see the silver lining in this tempest cloud.… Expand
  35. PS4_PC_LIFE
    Dec 25, 2019
    0
    what an atrocity, they bastardized such a great series, how much did they offer to the author to let this kind of **** slide, the guy has no pride in his work to just let ****flix destroy it. the only saving grace is Cavill, and even then he alone can not save this steaming pile. 0/0.
  36. kamgeforce
    Dec 25, 2019
    0
    Didnt expect much, its neflix after all, still disappointed. Dialogues are **** acting is so so, most actors didnt capture their characters and that includes Henry Cavill, whom I like as an actor. Yes, you can tell he played the games, but i would question he read the books, because he tries to portray the game Geralt with his stoic badassery, but gives no attempt to show off Geralt´s witDidnt expect much, its neflix after all, still disappointed. Dialogues are **** acting is so so, most actors didnt capture their characters and that includes Henry Cavill, whom I like as an actor. Yes, you can tell he played the games, but i would question he read the books, because he tries to portray the game Geralt with his stoic badassery, but gives no attempt to show off Geralt´s wit and intelligence, which is understandable because like I said, the dialogues are pure garbage. I dont think the writers have the capacity to come up with witty or intelligent lines to begin with, so I dont blame only Cavill for that. However Geralt has never been a character defined primarily by his excellent swordsmanship or his stoic demeanor as the games or the show would have you believe. The show is filled with out of place diversity, men bashing, all the queens and authorities are black or female, its progressive garbage of first order. The audio and visuals are nice for a tv production, netflix has the money if not the talent. Fight scenes are probably the only thing I actually enjoyed. You can tell lot of time and thought have been given to the choreography, but thats where the positives start and end. The show has no regards for the slavic roots of the material and the lore is never implemented in any but the most basic and surface level way. This isnt the witcher, its progressive americanised generic fantasy for politically correct audience that took the names and tropes from the witcher and left the balls out.… Expand
  37. JackProctor
    Dec 25, 2019
    3
    This show just doesn’t make a lot of sense. Yes it has magic which isn’t supposed to make sense but the storyline is just so choppy. The fight scenes look good but are just so far fetched. When the Witcher slays roughly 10 men in the queens court at the end of the fight there are suddenly no bodies on the floor and no injuries. God and the Witcher’s low raspy voice sounds so forced youThis show just doesn’t make a lot of sense. Yes it has magic which isn’t supposed to make sense but the storyline is just so choppy. The fight scenes look good but are just so far fetched. When the Witcher slays roughly 10 men in the queens court at the end of the fight there are suddenly no bodies on the floor and no injuries. God and the Witcher’s low raspy voice sounds so forced you don’t get any emotion from his character. The characters fall in and out of love with each other in an instant. It’s just garbled story telling. I’m a fairly intelligent person, and by episode 8 I honestly don’t know what’s going on. The Witcher is trying to find the princes to fulfill a prophecy...? With tons of side missions and a musical idiot following him around and signing?… Expand
  38. Broyax
    Dec 24, 2019
    1
    De mon point de vue, l'attente était double : d'abord eu égard à la prodigieuse saga de Sapkowski, ensuite par rapport aux superbes adaptations en jeux vidéo de la part de CD Projekt Red qui a su montrer un immense respect des bouquins tout en apposant sa propre marque et personnalité au meilleur univers d'heroic-fantasy jamais créé...

    C'est dire si les espérances étaient élevées... et    De mon point de vue, l'attente était double : d'abord eu égard à la prodigieuse saga de Sapkowski, ensuite par rapport aux superbes adaptations en jeux vidéo de la part de CD Projekt Red qui a su montrer un immense respect des bouquins tout en apposant sa propre marque et personnalité au meilleur univers d'heroic-fantasy jamais créé...

    C'est dire si les espérances étaient élevées... et n'ont pas été comblées, bien au contraire. Mais le tableau n'est pas si noir ici (encore que...) puisque Henri "Superman" Cavill incarne avec un allant inattendu un super sorceleur ; il paraît que l'acteur est fan de la licence et le fait est que ça se voit à l'écran : il se déplace, parle et respire comme ce bon vieux Gérard ! cynique et désabusé, ronchon et anti-héros... héroïque à l'insu de son plein gré.

    Alors, si Gérard va, tout devrait rouler... et d'ailleurs les effets spéciaux et la réalisation sont de bonne facture ; et quelques trop rares moments feraient même croire au miracle... sauf que... la narration reste bordélique comme c'est pas possible dans cette "première saison" s'inspirant nettement du premier tome (de nouvelles) de la saga mais la transformant, la dénaturant entièrement ou presque. L'épisode du dragon par exemple est complètement à côté de la plaque... entre autres.

    Mais ce n'est pas tout, car la série balance ses enjeux n'importe comment et de façon si désordonnée que même en ayant lu tous les livres, on a du mal à s'y retrouver... alors on imagine pas la perplexité confuse que doivent ressentir les béotiens à cet égard. Décousues et souvent incohérentes, les situations se succèdent jusqu'au ridicule s'il le faut (par exemple, le magicien qui se tape la bossue...!).

    A part Cavill, on ne constate que des erreurs de casting : ils sont tous soit mauvais, soit incompétents ou bien les deux à la fois. Jaskier par exemple est une caricature insupportable... Ciri est une cruche nunuche, Yenefer est seulement... bien roulée et c'est tout.

    Par ailleurs, la diversité forcenée incluse au forceps nuit à toute la crédibilité du monde décrit ici, un monde de légendes slaves à l'origine... et cette diversité omniprésente manque elle-même de diversité puisqu'elle n'inclut aucun ou aucune asiatique... la diversité à sens unique en somme.

    A part ce bon vieux Gérard, trop de choses sonnent faux dans cette série. Dommage pour Cavill mais ce défilé d'impostures n'est pas vraiment regardable. Ce gros simulacre découpé en épisodes irrite au plus haut point, sans cesse, sans espoir de rédemption : parti sur les mauvais rails dès le départ, il n'arrivera jamais à destination.    … Expand
  39. skvbgf44
    Dec 24, 2019
    0
    Netflix = political correctness, there were ONLY white people in the book!!!! This is not America, England or another country, these are Slavic areas, there were no black people there at that times!!!!!. Have you seen Triss in Netflix series? It's just pathetic how they did it..... The series is terrible, but it's good that we still have a AMAZING game which is Witcher 3, this is a REALNetflix = political correctness, there were ONLY white people in the book!!!! This is not America, England or another country, these are Slavic areas, there were no black people there at that times!!!!!. Have you seen Triss in Netflix series? It's just pathetic how they did it..... The series is terrible, but it's good that we still have a AMAZING game which is Witcher 3, this is a REAL story based on the book!… Expand
  40. imori
    Dec 24, 2019
    1
    Чудовищная халтура.
    1 балл только за Генри Кавилла - он старался.
    Самый провал - это основной сценарий, ради странной идеи показать по-чуть-чуть главных персонажей в каждой серии, нарезав повествование на якобы параллели в событиях, сценаристы в итоге получили неинтересный винегрет и путанное повествование. Истории с Геральтом сильно упрощены и добавлены нелогичные изменения. Линию Йен    Чудовищная халтура.
    1 балл только за Генри Кавилла - он старался.
    Самый провал - это основной сценарий, ради странной идеи показать по-чуть-чуть главных персонажей в каждой серии, нарезав повествование на якобы параллели в событиях, сценаристы в итоге получили неинтересный винегрет и путанное повествование.
    Истории с Геральтом сильно упрощены и добавлены нелогичные изменения.
    Линию Йен увеличили, но придуманные эпизоды выглядят чужеродными, Аретуза-концлагерь, странный Исттред, невнятное нападение неизвестно кого с огромным насекомым на даму с ребёнком и прыжки через порталы, ужасное объяснение невозможности иметь детей для Йен.
    Линия Цири получилась просто скучной - она все 8 серий чего-то боится, бежит и участвует в бессмысленных сценах в Брокилоне, которые потеряли весь смысл из-за сильного изменения сценария - с ней нет Геральта и не объясняется ничего про воду Брокилона. Всё участие Цири можно было свести к двум сериям - с маленькой Цири и после резни в Цинтре, т.к. в итоге все неописанные в книге скитания Цири до Геральта можно смело выкинуть. Особенно обидно за ужасную идею злого допплера-маньяка и Мышовура.
    Кагыр - в сериале из него сделали воплощение зла. Цири его вообще не интересует теперь, как он в будущем сможет присоединиться к команде Геральта в поисках Цири - непонятно.
    Фрингилья - безумная сектантка, как увяжут её дальнейшее участие в событиях - непонятно. Это же просто совершенно другие персонажи получились. А точнее не получились.
    Лучше всего получилась Плотва.    … Expand
  41. Alexplissken
    Dec 24, 2019
    1
    The narrative looks crumpled and unconnected, many things are left without description. Why does Herald drink potions and what kind of drinks? Most likely he drinks vodka.
    Monsters look worse than in the game, cgi cheapest as possible, the scenario is predictable in advance and there is no interest in watching.
    I don’t understand why so many black actors were added, a fantasy world in    The narrative looks crumpled and unconnected, many things are left without description. Why does Herald drink potions and what kind of drinks? Most likely he drinks vodka.
    Monsters look worse than in the game, cgi cheapest as possible, the scenario is predictable in advance and there is no interest in watching.
    I don’t understand why so many black actors were added, a fantasy world in Slavic culture, where their presence is surprising and this is racism and an insult to the Polish medieval heritage.
    Disappointment and sadness, thank you Netflix I knew you can ruin things    … Expand
  42. RegisMonteflou
    Dec 24, 2019
    2
    It’s just disgusting, 2 pluses Henry Kevil and roach, and the fact that in the Russian localization of the witcher is voiced by the same actor as in the game. That's all the pluses.
    Cons scenario, (They perverted and pohёr all everything is normal in the book)
    I can write a full analysis of each series, **** 1 book is ideal for an adaptation of the film, they simply would have defended    It’s just disgusting, 2 pluses Henry Kevil and roach, and the fact that in the Russian localization of the witcher is voiced by the same actor as in the game. That's all the pluses.
    Cons scenario, (They perverted and pohёr all everything is normal in the book)
    I can write a full analysis of each series,
    **** 1 book is ideal for an adaptation of the film, they simply would have defended it and everything would have been normal.
    There are no all-in-one episodes in your mix.
    Further. castes of actors and the game, Foltest Tris Tisai Borja, Ciri, Eist, and this is if you do not take into account all blacks and mulattos, the presence of which can not be explained.

    Horrible solutions for the images of elves and dwarves.
    Just disastrous battle scenes, they are disgustingly stupid and illogical, you can’t do not do it !!!
    On the whole, he didn’t have anything left of the books of a realistic Middle Ages, the modern contemporary licked
    Speech characters style, clothes,
    Nilfgard suits are just something, no words -100 10.
    The motivation of the characters is cut into the trash, especially the motivation of the nilfgaard empire.
    The whole line of Ciri is destroyed, it’s just a girl from some made-up world, not having an idea about reality, about the war about hunger, poverty and suffering, but it should.    … Expand
  43. Baggi
    Dec 24, 2019
    1
    Очередная толерантная хрень от Netflix изобилующая неграми, особенно эльф - негр вместе с Трисс и Енифер убили. Зачем Сапковский права на съемку дал этому рассаднику маразма????!!!!!
  44. Mcmcaruso
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    The Witcher has some great elements. CG and the lead actor are especially great, but this show fails in the writing and storyline. It goes off the rails, feels more like the video game equivalent to a bunch of side quests instead of the main quest.
    + There is an overall tone of immasculated, unintelligent men at the aid of every powerful woman. It's obvious the writer/director is a woman    The Witcher has some great elements. CG and the lead actor are especially great, but this show fails in the writing and storyline. It goes off the rails, feels more like the video game equivalent to a bunch of side quests instead of the main quest.
    + There is an overall tone of immasculated, unintelligent men at the aid of every powerful woman. It's obvious the writer/director is a woman that is angry at the world.

    Also I love how the main actress, which was the ugliest, deformed woman just starts putting on make up and stops hunching over. Now she is the most beautiful girl in all the land. Thank God for medieval Sephora.    … Expand
  45. Evilpoo
    Dec 23, 2019
    3
    GOD Awful.. seriously? People like this? How can someone be SO disgustingly biased. Can't you see the 'netflix' horrific casting? horrific actors? horrific story, effects..

    BELLOW ZERO
    I turned it off (mid Djinn episode) and never watching again , except maybe if i wana browse my phone while this crap is playing.
  46. RupoR
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. By the time the games were released - I had already read the books three times in a language - much closer to the original than some fans. I reshooted the games twice each, and re-read the book ten more times. I can quote any passage or quotation from a book from memory. And I am normal about adaptations - I am a fan of the game of thrones and calmly relate to the last season, which also has huge problems with the script.
    But the witcher of netflix is ​​an absolute disrespect for the original source and its fans. The authors of the series and some fans do not understand him at all. You do not understand the meaning, mythology and generally this culture. All that you can do is to make a horror story with religious fanatics and the struggle between good and evil from the analogy of Roman empire - Nilfgaard, cut off the deepest meaning of the original short stories of the first two books and shove the inarticulate story about the formation of a strong woman. You made this fast food like Marvel and other garbage like the Black Panther. Well, do it further with your culture. Do not climb and do not litter in our culture - if you do not understand it.    … Expand
  47. AmanoDZ
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    Полный мискаст актеров, единственный, кто действительно хорош - Лютик. Отсутствие логики и нормального повествования. Афроамериканские эльфы. Краснолюды карлики. Ужасный таймлайн. Отсутствие нормальной графики. Про зашкаливающие неточности и глупости даже и писать как-то лень, их очень много.
    Ну вот как яркий пример - Йеннифер САМА решает пойти на пластику, заплатив соответствующую цену    Полный мискаст актеров, единственный, кто действительно хорош - Лютик. Отсутствие логики и нормального повествования. Афроамериканские эльфы. Краснолюды карлики. Ужасный таймлайн. Отсутствие нормальной графики. Про зашкаливающие неточности и глупости даже и писать как-то лень, их очень много.
    Ну вот как яркий пример - Йеннифер САМА решает пойти на пластику, заплатив соответствующую цену (неспособность к деторождению). В последующих сериях она говорит, что хочет возможность иметь детей т.к. ей не оставили выбора!!! WTF    … Expand
  48. MScofield33
    Dec 23, 2019
    3
    Série bem fraca , não estou aguentando assistir. As partes de "comédia" com o Jasker são muito irritantes. As trilhas sonoras deixam a desejar. Gerald mal usa magia, só aard de vez em quando. A série não é envolvente.
  49. Ghua
    Dec 23, 2019
    3
    Cavill really fits the role. Thats about it - all good things I can say about the series.
    The rest is... mediocre. There are good moments, but rather due to good original book material than to netflix.
  50. SilentNoise
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    Ничего не ожидал от этого сериала после просмотра трейлеров. Актеры подобраны ужасно. Манера повествования ужасная, если зритель не читал книгу то он вообще не поймет что происходит. Да, это адаптация книги а не игры, но так бездарно все провалить нужно еще уметь.
    Первые серии еще можно смотреть, но чем дальше тем хуже. Когда я увидел Вильгефорца(главного антагониста книг), то захотел    Ничего не ожидал от этого сериала после просмотра трейлеров. Актеры подобраны ужасно. Манера повествования ужасная, если зритель не читал книгу то он вообще не поймет что происходит. Да, это адаптация книги а не игры, но так бездарно все провалить нужно еще уметь.
    Первые серии еще можно смотреть, но чем дальше тем хуже. Когда я увидел Вильгефорца(главного антагониста книг), то захотел заплакать и выключить сериал, это уже перебор. Можно много критиковать его, потому что он вышел действительно ужасным. Очень обидно за Ведьмака, очень. Пусть они лучше на этом и закончат, надеюсь если его разгромят то дальше первого сезона дело не пойдет. Одним словом ТОЛЕРАНТНОСТЬ !    … Expand
  51. Tiakin
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    So what we have here) it is not a medieval Poland and Slavic mythology, we see a trivial American film. The authors have absolutely no idea about the fantasy culture that was in the game and the book. Those who conducted the casting, you are zero. You don't create the new, you spoil the good. The elves are Negros? Black dryads? Gypsies? To hell with, this tolerance pisses me off. AndSo what we have here) it is not a medieval Poland and Slavic mythology, we see a trivial American film. The authors have absolutely no idea about the fantasy culture that was in the game and the book. Those who conducted the casting, you are zero. You don't create the new, you spoil the good. The elves are Negros? Black dryads? Gypsies? To hell with, this tolerance pisses me off. And Yes! If you want to see a good movie, the poles also made a 2019 film about Witcher. Yes, it's Amateur, but they took it off with the soul, not for the money.… Expand
  52. howdareyou
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    sjw propaganda , the cast choices , and other weird scenes , its just sad , boycott it
  53. ArhiDiablo
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    Русский / English (google)
    Это сериал противопоставлялся "Игре престолов". Расхваливал себя на каждом углу! Потому снисхождения не заслуживает!
    Я не фанат "Ведьмака". Не читал все книги и играл только в третью часть ведьмака. Но даже у меня есть море вопросов по вселенной, придуманной сценаристами, не опираясь на вселенную книг и игр. Сценарий очень рваный и скомканный. Возможно его    Русский / English (google)
    Это сериал противопоставлялся "Игре престолов". Расхваливал себя на каждом углу! Потому снисхождения не заслуживает!
    Я не фанат "Ведьмака". Не читал все книги и играл только в третью часть ведьмака. Но даже у меня есть море вопросов по вселенной, придуманной сценаристами, не опираясь на вселенную книг и игр.
    Сценарий очень рваный и скомканный. Возможно его писали - просто вычёркиванием глав из книги, причём не особо задумываясь над тем, что остаётся. Потом, то что осталось - перемешали и вытянули наугад. Так получилась серия. Следом в неё добавили здоровое такое ведро феминизма. Из сильных (по логике здорового человека) женских персонажей сделали глупых куриц наделённых властью. Так получилась бабка Цири, например.
    Минусы этого сериала можно описывать бесконечно долго:
    - Отвратительная работа сценаристов.
    - Ужасный кастинг героев.
    - Слабая актёрская игра большинства персонажей.
    - Правильно сделали, что уволили костюмера.
    - Графика уровня прошлого века (вспомните резиновый костюм стрыги из 3-ей серии).
    - Ужасный монтаж с кучей киноляпов и, возможно, вырезанным чем-то важным. Ибо перескакивается всё настолько нелогично, что сложно проследить причинно-следсвтенную связь. Или это опять косяк сценаристов.
    - Очень глупый феминизм. Сильные женские персонажи из книг превратились в наиглупейших неадекватных истеричек наделённых властью.
    - Совершенно не уместная толерантность на грани тупой шутки, вызывающей недоумение.

    Этот сериал - оскорбление всем здравомыслящим людям, которых сочли за всеядных дураков авторы сериала.
    ---------------------------------

    This series was contrasted with Game of Thrones. Praised himself on every corner! Because condescension does not deserve!
    I'm not a Witcher fan. I did not read all the books and played only in the third part of the witcher. But even I have a sea of ​​questions about the universe invented by the scriptwriters, not based on the universe of books and games.
    The script is very ragged and crumpled. Perhaps they wrote it - simply by deleting the chapters from the book, and not really thinking about what remains. Then, what was left was mixed and pulled at random. So it turned out a series.
    The relationship of the characters, apparently, occurred on those discarded pages of books. Their motivation and logic remained there. The stupidity of the consequences spilled over onto the audience, which he must somehow try to realize and relate, having thought up the universe on his own. It is worth noting here that those who know the universe spit right away, and those who do not know spit a little later.
    Cons of this series can be described indefinitely:
    - The disgusting work of the scriptwriters.
    - Awful casting of heroes.
    - Weak acting of most characters.
    - They did the right thing to fire the dresser.
    - Graphics of the level of the last century (remember the rubber suit of the scruff from the 3rd series).
    - Awful installation with a bunch of kinolapov and, possibly, cut out something important. For everything jumps so illogical that it is difficult to trace a causal relationship. Or is it again a jamb of screenwriters.
    - Very stupid feminism. Strong female characters from books turned into the stupidest inadequate tantrums endowed with power. if I were a woman - I would be offended by such humiliation of female heroes
    - Absolutely inappropriate tolerance on the verge of a dumb joke that causes bewilderment.

    The authors of the series wanted to go on trends, but they don’t know at all how to do it. As a result - a series that offends any sane person.    … Expand
  54. superbmikey
    Dec 23, 2019
    2
    I am giving this a 2 only because Henry did a good job. The rest of the show is garbage. I am not sure why its called The Witcher. It should have been named 'The Yennefer show that does not give a **** about source material' WOKE edition gold. Plot is superficial, dialogues are superficial. I had my hopes so high and yet netflix delivered another sjw mush without any deep.
  55. badtactic
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    You would think by now that production companies would have learned that a viewer must also be familiar with the books, games, etc to enjoy a series - than it shouldn't be made. But, in the case of the Witcher, it seems like the creators have either blatantly ignored this lesson - or simply not understood it.

    The Witcher presents a slew of issues: a groaning and bland performance from    You would think by now that production companies would have learned that a viewer must also be familiar with the books, games, etc to enjoy a series - than it shouldn't be made. But, in the case of the Witcher, it seems like the creators have either blatantly ignored this lesson - or simply not understood it.

    The Witcher presents a slew of issues: a groaning and bland performance from Cavill, a film stylistic choice more reminiscent of a CW tween show, an exceptionally mundane storyline, and more.

    If you're looking for something to skip - this is one of them.    … Expand
  56. veilen
    Dec 23, 2019
    3
    Everything except the visuals and, probably, music is just not good enough for the source material potential. Poor acting and screenplay
  57. Mangoost51
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    В целом - отвратительно. Единственное что более менее радовало - боёвка и ряд второстепенных персонажей. Главные персонажи - просто отвратительные, чернокожие рыцари, Йен индийской внешности... Трисс какая-то мулатка с тёмными волосами... Чёрные эльфы... Смотреть противно лишь по причине того, что специально протолкнули свою токсичную толерантность во все моменты картины, причём этим неВ целом - отвратительно. Единственное что более менее радовало - боёвка и ряд второстепенных персонажей. Главные персонажи - просто отвратительные, чернокожие рыцари, Йен индийской внешности... Трисс какая-то мулатка с тёмными волосами... Чёрные эльфы... Смотреть противно лишь по причине того, что специально протолкнули свою токсичную толерантность во все моменты картины, причём этим не просто веет, а именно несёт... Расизмом не страдаю, но такое наплевательское отношение к здравому смыслу в скором времени это может изменить...Посмотрел весь сезон, единственное что хотел это напиться и забыть этот ужас, ну и поставить вообще 0 баллов из 10, но предел для этого сериала 2 из 10.… Expand
  58. Subtank
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Просмотрев весь сезон я пришел только к одной мысли, как же мне обидно за Пана Сапсковского. Люди которые говорят что читали книги и знаю лор, да еще и в игры играли Вы вообще головой думаете?! Вашу любимую вселенную изнасиловал нетфликс как армия нильфов прошедших по землям севера. Столько лжи и надругательства я еще никогда не видел! Они все облили грязью, ВСЕ! В этом сериале нет ничего общего с книгами великого Пана и никогда не будет, из-за отсутствия фантазии нетфликс ничего не смог придумать своего, по этому они взяли всего по чуть чуть из книг и игр, смешали в котле, процедили оставив процентов 30 и остальное залили мочой из своих голов исказив все до неузнаваемости. До этого момента я был совершенно равнодушен к студии нетфлик, но теперь для меня это студия перестала существовать как таковая.Я неоднократно читал книги, это моя самая любимая вселенная на просторах фэнтези мира, Ведьмак первая из частей игры до сих пор вспоминается в самых теплых тонах, я люблю эту вселенную!Считаю то что сделала нетфликс это оскорбление и плевок каждому истинному поклоннику вселенной Ведьмака. Если бы можно было поставить -100 я бы с радость это сделал сотню тысяч раз.У меня все.… Expand
  59. SlavicWitcher
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    Why there are so many blacks in roles that are not suitable for them and why women protagonists are so extremely ugly? Check CD Projekt's Red Witcher 3 and check how the slavic culture should be portrayed. Are we Poles and Slaves not allowed to show our history or culture the way we want it, without forced multiculturalism, political correctness and feminazi undertones scattered all overWhy there are so many blacks in roles that are not suitable for them and why women protagonists are so extremely ugly? Check CD Projekt's Red Witcher 3 and check how the slavic culture should be portrayed. Are we Poles and Slaves not allowed to show our history or culture the way we want it, without forced multiculturalism, political correctness and feminazi undertones scattered all over the place? We are not even allowed to criticize blackwashing and ridiculing the source material as we are immediately called "racist" "homophobes" and other terms coined by the modern liberals ;/ You destroyed one of the most pure, slavic, and beautiful stories - for that, you should burn in your forced diversity (meaning less white) hell, Netflix ;/… Expand
  60. wagabunga93
    Dec 23, 2019
    3
    The series is tragic and has little to do with books, many characters and stories have been cut out for new unnecessary threads. Black-skinned elves, kransoludy without beard, magic like Harry Potter - many wrong decisions were made, the series became another tube for liberal activists and the potential of books was wasted by them. Don't watch the show first! Read the books, they are muchThe series is tragic and has little to do with books, many characters and stories have been cut out for new unnecessary threads. Black-skinned elves, kransoludy without beard, magic like Harry Potter - many wrong decisions were made, the series became another tube for liberal activists and the potential of books was wasted by them. Don't watch the show first! Read the books, they are much better than Netflix. The Netflix series is tragic and has little to do with the book Witcher. If you don't like reading, at least play the game... Although you will miss a lot of great stories, your loss. Make no mistake - don't judge a book by show.

    PS. Henry Cavill is a great actor and even better Witcher (you can see that he understands his character), but all the rest (not counting sword fights) is not an agreement, people created the script and realized the series created something that has nothing to do with the great story written by Andrzej Sapkowski. Please, no - I'm begging you - reach for the books!    … Expand
  61. reality_check_
    Dec 23, 2019
    0
    NFLX is a group of racist maggots for offering zero East Asian representation /sarc. In all seriousness, it's not "racist" to ask to stay true to the source material. It's clearly described in the books that Triss has "chestnut" hair and "cornflower blue" eyes. Further, Fringilla Vigo is described to be "pale with a truly deathly, morbid, utterly ghastly paleness." Seriously, doesNFLX is a group of racist maggots for offering zero East Asian representation /sarc. In all seriousness, it's not "racist" to ask to stay true to the source material. It's clearly described in the books that Triss has "chestnut" hair and "cornflower blue" eyes. Further, Fringilla Vigo is described to be "pale with a truly deathly, morbid, utterly ghastly paleness." Seriously, does blackwashing a Slavic myth novel make any sense? As an ethnic minority myself, these SJW morons can shove their agenda up their bums and actually show respect to the source material as well as the original fans. Oh but they never will, because they somehow think they are better than everyone else, including the ethnic minorities that they are so desperate to represent, ironically. In case this doesn't bother you, think of taking your favorite "white" character and turning him black/Asian/whatever. Can you imagine Disney casting Luke Skywalker as a minority? Actually, that might as well happen in the near future.… Expand
  62. GarlDeathHand
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    Awful cast, hilariously bad acting, horrendous costumes and just a bad adaptation of the book.
  63. shurte
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    Very weak show from Netflix. They absolutely do not understand what they are showing. Positive things are only Cavill, music and battle with Renfry.
  64. Penisman
    Dec 23, 2019
    3
    Henry Cavil turned out as amazing geralt and his interactions with Jaskier are on point. Those are, alongside good fights scenes, the only good things I can say about this mess. Yennefer turned out terrible. Instead of a confident stubborn female lead she feel weak and confused. The way magic is portrayed is a joke. Politics are confusing and not engaging at all. The story between threeHenry Cavil turned out as amazing geralt and his interactions with Jaskier are on point. Those are, alongside good fights scenes, the only good things I can say about this mess. Yennefer turned out terrible. Instead of a confident stubborn female lead she feel weak and confused. The way magic is portrayed is a joke. Politics are confusing and not engaging at all. The story between three people, with three timelines that are an immense mess and viewer can't rightly tell when did what happen untill later half of the series. CGI looks clearly like CGI, Villentrenthemerth is awful. Directing was another problem. Some scenes completely lack build up, others are just awkward (like geralts famous speech about greater/lesser evil). Even the Geralt/Jaskier interactions that I have mentioned are few and far between, especially when compared to books.… Expand
  65. Vasia99_99
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    The series is great, but... but there is one big but, alas because of which I put 0 or 10... and the reason, your uncontrollable desire to shove pretty boring TOLERANCE... My God, just no , look at this, the TOLERANCE and shove where you do not get where necessary and where not, in every hole poked just boring TOLERANTNOSTI, I want to ask :" CALM down, ENOUGH.".. authors want say hugeThe series is great, but... but there is one big but, alas because of which I put 0 or 10... and the reason, your uncontrollable desire to shove pretty boring TOLERANCE... My God, just no , look at this, the TOLERANCE and shove where you do not get where necessary and where not, in every hole poked just boring TOLERANTNOSTI, I want to ask :" CALM down, ENOUGH.".. authors want say huge thank you, you, would directly kill its TOLERANCE KROVI and spat in face all their ignorance in carriers SLAVIC CULTURE, wiped its feet about CANON BOOKS. You killed just the atmosphere of Slavic fantasy, culture and mythology, every time you deliberately fuss in the frame of the Negro you just kill the entire Slavic calorite and atmospheric. You call for respect, and you spit in the face of the Slavs and our ethnic group, if you make a series about US-about the SLAVS, then RESPECT US and OUR Culture and do not STICK here INAPPROPRIATE SMELLY TOLERANCE. And there is no I not racist, this simply cry souls, you simply Argumenty with their minorities, tolerance that you shove everywhere for TICKS, even there WHERE THIS FUNNY and EVEN INAPPROPRIATELY, you pardon me but BLACKS in Slavic culture and mythology INAPPROPRIATELY, precisely so and is born intolerance and aggression...If you think that Negroes in Slavic culture is appropriate, then I'm curious when it will be appropriate that Martin Luthor king will be played by a WHITE ACTOR...The series is great, but... but there is one big but, alas because of which I put 0 or 10... and the reason, your uncontrollable desire to shove pretty boring TOLERANCE... My God, just no , look at this, the TOLERANCE and shove where you do not get where necessary and where not, in every hole poked just boring TOLERANTNOSTI, I want to ask :" CALM down, ENOUGH.".. authors want say huge thank you, you, would directly kill its TOLERANCE KROVI and spat in face all their ignorance in carriers SLAVIC CULTURE, wiped its feet about CANON BOOKS. You killed just the atmosphere of Slavic fantasy, culture and mythology, every time you deliberately fuss in the frame of the Negro you just kill the entire Slavic calorite and atmospheric. You call for respect, and you spit in the face of the Slavs and our ethnic group, if you make a series about US-about the SLAVS, then RESPECT US and OUR Culture and do not STICK here INAPPROPRIATE SMELLY TOLERANCE. And there is no I not racist, this simply cry souls, you simply Argumenty with their minorities, tolerance that you shove everywhere for TICKS, even there WHERE THIS FUNNY and EVEN INAPPROPRIATELY, you pardon me but BLACKS in Slavic culture and mythology INAPPROPRIATELY, precisely so and is born intolerance and aggression...If you think that Negroes in Slavic culture is appropriate, then I'm curious when it will be appropriate that Martin Luthor king will be played by a WHITE ACTOR...… Expand
  66. RIPtheWitcher
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    Атмосферы славянской нет. Каст отвратительный. За все время вы не увидите ни одной красивой женщины, а только уродин. Таймлайн очень кривой и запутанный. Мне как читавшему книги леко понять что происходит но вот знакомые мои которые с ведьмаком не знакомы дается сериал очень сложно. Плюс они еще добавилили кучу отсебятины которая релизована очень убого и по большей части не несет в себеАтмосферы славянской нет. Каст отвратительный. За все время вы не увидите ни одной красивой женщины, а только уродин. Таймлайн очень кривой и запутанный. Мне как читавшему книги леко понять что происходит но вот знакомые мои которые с ведьмаком не знакомы дается сериал очень сложно. Плюс они еще добавилили кучу отсебятины которая релизована очень убого и по большей части не несет в себе какого либо смысла. Чем думал сценарист не понятно, видимо как угодить SJW комьюнити. В итоге получилось не понятно что с запутаным, скомканым сюжетом, слитыми сценами котораые реализовали просто ужасно не до конца расркыв их. Карой ай. Я бы написал еще много чего но не хочу тратить на это время. Если сравнить с игрой престолов то у нетфликс даже близко не получилось хоть немного подобраться к ним.… Expand
  67. thebaggins
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    My thoughts and prayers go out to those who don't have the ability to fast forward.
  68. username93
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    oh boy i can't wait to see the black panther with all withe actors. this bs racism needs to stop.
  69. bosgon
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    1 балл за Лютика и 1 за Цири. Битва Геральта в первой серии очень хорошо поставлена, что нельзя сказать про остальные (типичная голливудщина с отбрасыванием в стены). Картинка оставляет желать лучшего. Йеннифер сыграла не плохо, хоть и не подходит на эту роль, про Геральта тоже самое. Трисс - женщина лет 45, это просто пи......ец, такое чувство что актрису выбрали в последний день на1 балл за Лютика и 1 за Цири. Битва Геральта в первой серии очень хорошо поставлена, что нельзя сказать про остальные (типичная голливудщина с отбрасыванием в стены). Картинка оставляет желать лучшего. Йеннифер сыграла не плохо, хоть и не подходит на эту роль, про Геральта тоже самое. Трисс - женщина лет 45, это просто пи......ец, такое чувство что актрису выбрали в последний день на от...ись. Вообщем сериал не вызывает гнева или радости, он просто никакой.… Expand
  70. ay1908
    Dec 22, 2019
    2
    I really wanted to like this but I can't. The dialogs are terrible, the GCI and the acting are not believable. The narration is all over the place, jumping from one character to another, one scene to another, moving between timelines, not building attachment to characters nor a proper dramatic arc.. I watched all episodes but I had to fast forward several scenes to be able to finish,I really wanted to like this but I can't. The dialogs are terrible, the GCI and the acting are not believable. The narration is all over the place, jumping from one character to another, one scene to another, moving between timelines, not building attachment to characters nor a proper dramatic arc.. I watched all episodes but I had to fast forward several scenes to be able to finish, especially in the last episode. The dramatic effects just fall flat. The books didn't had the best writing but this much worse.

    The whole thing is very Americanized and has lost all its Slavic color. The casting is just very awkward. I don't mind having different races present but make it coherent! The books contain several detailed physical descriptions of many characters and lineage/origins (you can also figure the origins by the names). Here you can't even guess where a character is from by watching the show unless you've read the books. This is a medieval setting with a Eastern European flavor and genetics traits are attached to geographical regions; it's not NYC in 2019. The world they created is not convincing at all.

    ...and Nilfgaard...what are those costumes????    … Expand
  71. TheDevilCorrect
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    Horrible casting, horrible acting and an absolutely incoherent story. I like the game, but these fan boys raving over this pile of crap is mind boggling. Most of them 12 year old males no doubt (or equal in mentality). Every actor in this series is totally forgettable. The fight scenes are pretty good, but short and better watched on youtube. If you have any taste at all-I'd seriously avoid.
  72. Helihayes
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Steamy pile of poo. Never did I think a TV adaptation of an excellent video game could put me off of an excellent video game.… Expand
  73. Halvard
    Dec 22, 2019
    1
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I liked Geralt.
    Everything else was ****
    Ruining the story with race-swapping. Removing red heads from the story.
    Slow. Boring. The evil people not intimidating at all. Pathetic change of armor on soldiers. Stupid and useless people all around. Battle tactics nowhere to be seen.
    Identity politics wreaking havoc again.    … Expand
  74. Esthete
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    Poland, 2017...creak of rocking chair...knock knock
    - «What the hell, who is there !?» - Andrzej Sapkowski grumbling asking from a chair.
    - «It's Lauren Hissrich, I am a professional writer» - voice from behind the door - «Get out! I didn't invite you» - Andrzej said even more grouchy. - «This is about buying rights to the TV adaptation of your books!» - Lauren objected. - «Well come    Poland, 2017...creak of rocking chair...knock knock
    - «What the hell, who is there !?» - Andrzej Sapkowski grumbling asking from a chair.
    - «It's Lauren Hissrich, I am a professional writer» - voice from behind the door
    - «Get out! I didn't invite you» - Andrzej said even more grouchy.
    - «This is about buying rights to the TV adaptation of your books!» - Lauren objected.
    - «Well come in, the door isn't locked» - Andrzej said.
    Lauren Hissrich: «Netflix want make TV-adaptation your books»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «You mean The Witcher series?»
    Lauren Hissrich: «Yes, and I will be a showrunner»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «No, i don't like this idea, Lauren you even haven't serious creativity background!»
    Lauren Hissrich: «So what? When Benioff and Weiss became showrunners of Game of Thrones they also didn't have.»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «Yes, but Martin helped them for the first seasons. And, then in the last seasons, they just fu**ed up.»
    Lauren Hissrich: «You can become a co-showrunner.»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «Nope. Netflix makes trash stuff, I don't like it.»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «The Witcher is a large fantasy universe based on Slavic culture, folklore, as well as Slavic-Norse-Germanic mythology and tales. How can you adapt this?»
    Lauren Hissrich: «Diversity»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «But the Witcher world it's Europe in the Middle Ages.»
    Lauren Hissrich: «Are you racist?»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «Europe in the Middle Ages»
    Lauren Hissrich: «Netflix will pay you many $$$$$$$»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «The Witcher never been about Slavic culture, folklore, as well as Slavic-Norse-Germanic mythology, tales, you know. And Europe in the Middle Ages was multicultural, people of different races were everywhere in medieval Europe.»
    Andrzej Sapkowski: «So rights on the Witcher series sold!»

    pros:
    No

    cons:
    - Absolutely, total miscast
    - It's all cheap, battles are terrible
    - Bad acting skills for all
    - Trying to please as newcomers as well fans of books/games. Eventually makes shapeless nonsense

    Lauren you didn't disappoint, Netflix you too. Now it’s clear where the money, for minions writing the same type reviews 10/10    … Expand
  75. wizards
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    It's poor distorted copy universe Witcher. For the efforts made, I will add three points. Rating 3.
  76. sarisa
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    Well, what did we expect from Netflix anyway? They need to sell this product worldwide somehow. To be honest it could be much worse considering their agenda. And we all know it. Simply saying it's the only possible Witcher that could have emerged in XXI century. Its bad testimony of our times, but it is some sort of testimony.
  77. MrNonono
    Dec 22, 2019
    1
    Might be interesting for people who played the game. Otherwise, skip this show and you won't miss out on anything. There are better quasi-medieval fantasy shows to watch in the limited time you have.
  78. Pipestan
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    Это не ноль, но надо как-то попытаться нивелировать 10ки от копрофилов. Не будь это сериалом по вселенной ведьмака, его никто не заметил бы. Из плюсов музыка местами гуд, фехтование в сценах без магии и на этом все. Истории порезали,перекрутили и переврали. Было ощущение, что смотрю сериал "Великолепный век", но с магией. Бюджетность можно вытерпеть, но сценариста нужно менять. ИзЭто не ноль, но надо как-то попытаться нивелировать 10ки от копрофилов. Не будь это сериалом по вселенной ведьмака, его никто не заметил бы. Из плюсов музыка местами гуд, фехтование в сценах без магии и на этом все. Истории порезали,перекрутили и переврали. Было ощущение, что смотрю сериал "Великолепный век", но с магией. Бюджетность можно вытерпеть, но сценариста нужно менять. Из Вильгефорца сделали немоща, из Калантэ клоунессу (сильного женского персонажа в книге превратили в бой-бабу без мозгов), ребята со скеллиге превратились либо в восточных торгашей, либо в метросексуалов. Я бы поставил 4 /10 за то что Нетфликс кидает деньги в бездарных сценаристов и костюмеров. Очень сомневаюсь, что сериал станет на голову выше во втором сезоне, который вроде как будет.… Expand
  79. DeN_DarK
    Dec 22, 2019
    1
    Awful casting. At first I feared Cavill will be bad as Geralt. Actually he isn't. But other actors... not even close to character.
    Sadly casting is lesser problem in this series.
    1. Writing no good. First two episodes was average but after that it is just bad. Scriptwriters add too much to the story and do it very unnatural for plot and characters. 2. Effects. Sometimes nice. But mostly    Awful casting. At first I feared Cavill will be bad as Geralt. Actually he isn't. But other actors... not even close to character.
    Sadly casting is lesser problem in this series.
    1. Writing no good. First two episodes was average but after that it is just bad. Scriptwriters add too much to the story and do it very unnatural for plot and characters.
    2. Effects. Sometimes nice. But mostly bad. Especially floodlights in Brokilon.
    3. Sequence of events. In one episode things mixed together and it is just a mess - not a storytelling.    … Expand
  80. ouideer
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    My problems with the new Wither series is the total lack of taste and creative design of every aspect of the episodes while it lacks authenticity and credibility. You can see no good acting neither, but I‌ could live with that if at least the creators of the show would have tried to make the characters look like they are coming from an age where they were fighting with swords and magic.My problems with the new Wither series is the total lack of taste and creative design of every aspect of the episodes while it lacks authenticity and credibility. You can see no good acting neither, but I‌ could live with that if at least the creators of the show would have tried to make the characters look like they are coming from an age where they were fighting with swords and magic. Like Game of Thrones attempted, where people are sometimes dirty and disgusting. Here nothing feels disgusting as even the protagonist is kind of a weird version of Barbie’s bf: Ken and the crippled girl in the second episode is basically Penelope Cruz with something in her mouth and some wadding under her clothes at her shoulders so she looks like Penelope Cruz dressed as Quasimodo for Haloween. It’s hard to let go that right in the first episode, first second you can see Gerald, the Witcher jumping like flying while you can be sure he’s in a studio connected to a rope in front of a green screen and as he struggles with the monster you can see the absolute worst CGI of 2019, in such a big title. His clothes are also more of an amateur comic con version and I'm pretty sure some has a better one, on the actual comic con. A good fantasy doesn’t have a bard singing Robbie Williams/bar style songs in the local pub and it requires tons more of careful touch to make it feel realistic and rich in it’s world. That includes well-chosen real locations, scenery, good lines of characters, so it won’t feel like it’s the 9 trillionths random cheap Netflix show.… Expand
  81. Miamao
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    Are you seriously? Colored in the Polish saga? Yes, you are completely crazy. To complete the kissing of the asses of minorities, Geralt had to be made homosexual, and Enifer had to be transvestist. Lol
  82. WildFireR2
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    I can only assume that people giving it a 10 have never actually read the books or played the games.

    Simply put here are some reasons to avoid watching this embarrassment of a show: - Really weak & cringe worthy dialogue - The Showrunner clearly cares more about diversity than being true to the source material - The best scenes are with Geralt in fight scenes, which you'll barely    I can only assume that people giving it a 10 have never actually read the books or played the games.

    Simply put here are some reasons to avoid watching this embarrassment of a show:

    - Really weak & cringe worthy dialogue
    - The Showrunner clearly cares more about diversity than being true to the source material
    - The best scenes are with Geralt in fight scenes, which you'll barely see anyway because this show is 75% about the women and their stories.

    This is just another example of a great story being **** ruined by a moron in Lauren Hissrich.

    It's WAY too much emphasis on the female characters... The Witcher is unique in that it's writing in the source material is SO GOOD that you already have established powerful female characters that aren't obnoxiously over the top and in your face.

    But of course, its 2019 so that's not enough, they have to make every little moment about how women are stronger, can overcome anything, and are inherently better than all men apparently.

    They've basically butchered Yen... & that leads me to another point.... Casting:

    - Black Fringilla
    - Black Eithne & Brokilon forest women are black
    - Mixed race Triss
    - half Indian Yen

    Are you taking the piss? ALL of these characters are supposed to be **** white, clearly listed as "PALE" in the source material.

    But it's 2019, and you're not allowed too many white people in the same room otherwise it's racist apparently... The casting choices for this are an absolute disgrace & are just so immersion breaking it's ridiculous.

    I feel bad for Henry Cavil, he is literally carrying this whole show on his shoulders & clearly is the only person that gives a **** about his character or the story.    … Expand
  83. garnerc07
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    While I enjoyed the performances of Geralt and Ciri, there were some others who sort of ruined it for me. Yennefer and Triss' casting was not good at all in my opinion. Tried being an interesting character in the books and games came across as nothing but unimportant and a throw away character. Fringilla Vigo was also another character who I quite enjoyed from the books and movies butWhile I enjoyed the performances of Geralt and Ciri, there were some others who sort of ruined it for me. Yennefer and Triss' casting was not good at all in my opinion. Tried being an interesting character in the books and games came across as nothing but unimportant and a throw away character. Fringilla Vigo was also another character who I quite enjoyed from the books and movies but together with a bad choice of casting and a complete personality change, she also didn't stand out either. This as you might know comes down to the politics of the creators of the series. Back from when they put the casting call for Ciri for BAME actresses, i knew this would be a let down, and i was mostly right. I love the Witcher franchise so it's a shame for its legacy to be tainted with people trying to push their politics onto the fans of the series. They just had to follow the source material and the fans would love it, so it's a shame it is getting such a mixed reception. Let this show and the many others who have suffered the same fate be a lesson to those who think they can smear a well loved franchise to push a political agenda.… Expand
  84. Ky3mi4_raider71
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    Black people in Eastern Europe???Are you kidding? No, thanks. It's obviously not how i imagined adaptation of this book
  85. ivanchanel
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    I would give the series 10 points, because this is a good series, I would even say excellent, but why would you push black people to the left and right? this is Poland and this Slovak fantasy there couldn’t be black people there
  86. ReevJax
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    I did not hate the story, what I did hate was how everything has to be "diverse" at all costs. I guess we are lucky they didn't make Geralt gay .
  87. DenysVerizhenko
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    Игра актеров ужасная, сюжет скомканный и плохо изложен, слишком много ненужного насилия в сериале с постановкой уровня детей 6 лет. Полный провал. Все что сделал этот сериал - это удовлетворил лгбт движение. Показывать негров в Польше 13 века это моветон.Игра актеров ужасная, сюжет скомканный и плохо изложен, слишком много ненужного насилия в сериале с постановкой уровня детей 6 лет. Полный провал. Все что сделал этот сериал - это удовлетворил лгбт движение. Показывать негров в Польше 13 века это моветон.
  88. Gor1945
    Dec 22, 2019
    2
    Западная толерастия и SJW диграданты еще одну франшизу загубили, негры где не поподя, ложа чародеек, ставшая ложей феминисток и прочая чушь современной повестки - в саге о средневековье восточной Европы пусть и в фентезийном обрамлении.
    Помимо этого - отвратительный каст актеров - Трисс, Кагырн, Йенифер - просто в утиль слиты - остальные в лучшем случае средне.
    Сюжет рваный и подан    Западная толерастия и SJW диграданты еще одну франшизу загубили, негры где не поподя, ложа чародеек, ставшая ложей феминисток и прочая чушь современной повестки - в саге о средневековье восточной Европы пусть и в фентезийном обрамлении.
    Помимо этого - отвратительный каст актеров - Трисс, Кагырн, Йенифер - просто в утиль слиты - остальные в лучшем случае средне.
    Сюжет рваный и подан кусками - в не хронологическом порядке, человеку не знакомому с вселенной в принципе что-то понять сложно будет, знакомый будет постоянно пробивать себе фейспалм.
    Отдельно стоит отметить костюмеров и декораторов, и постановщиков битв - доспехи Нильфгарда и битвы - просто донное днище.    … Expand
  89. Somewhat
    Dec 22, 2019
    3
    So what did I learn from Netlflix The Witcher pilot?

    - buff guy and giant ass monster can easily hide in a shallow pond while fighting, but only until the little deer will spot them, after that they can barely fit in - when facing enemy forces, fighting inside a castle is gay - better leave it with little to no defense and face them in the flied - bad guys have magical sniping    So what did I learn from Netlflix The Witcher pilot?

    - buff guy and giant ass monster can easily hide in a shallow pond while fighting, but only until the little deer will spot them, after that they can barely fit in
    - when facing enemy forces, fighting inside a castle is gay - better leave it with little to no defense and face them in the flied
    - bad guys have magical sniping abilities and can shoot a target in the eye during a battle from a solid distance
    - cavalry is useless
    - armor is made of tin foil and can be cut through and penetrated with a single blow
    - arrows and missiles are gay, that's why only bad guys use them
    - spears are big gay, that's why no one uses them in combat
    - siege equipment during sieges is not cool - better charge at the giant ass gates with swords and axes, three people at a time
    - when enemies are at the gates, better wait till they breach and only then start running away
    - having sex with someone will make your partner prophet and give you magical mind reading abilities
    - refuse to help someone when they are in grave danger, but run to their help as fast as you can 12 hours later
    - city market is apparently an alley with no shops, stands or goods in general
    - army, that conquered half the world, has no concept of shields - good thing that they are useless anyway
    - you can walk through the entire city, while holding a knife near little girls throat and no one will bat an eye
    - what should you do, when someone just butchered your entire gang single-handedly and now begs you to leave? Threaten to kill a little girl and then the entire town, sure nothing can go wrong with that

    But the biggest lesson I've learned is to not waste my time on a mediocre TV-adaptation of fantasy novels.    … Expand
  90. m1r4
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    Ведьмак, которого мы заслужили. Сериал сделан мало того, что без души, так ещё и бездарно.
  91. igorGurd
    Dec 21, 2019
    0
    Надежды были до последнего. Но. Ужасно всё. И лишь Плотва идеально сыграла свою роль...
  92. Pranker03
    Dec 22, 2019
    0
    How is in Eastern Europe can be as a lot of Afo-American people in 13 century??? In book have no one Afro-American people. Why do you spoil this wonderfull and beatyfull world of Andrzej Sapkowski?
  93. HermesMegist
    Dec 21, 2019
    0
    1. Henry Cavill plays furniture. That is why he is the perfect Superman, but disgusting Geralt.
    2. It seems to me that the authors of the show did not read the book, but read a strange retelling written by a black lesbian feminist.
    3. When the author does not have blacks in the novel (yes, we can say that in Russia, because we should not reckon with slavery and US history - we didn’t    1. Henry Cavill plays furniture. That is why he is the perfect Superman, but disgusting Geralt.
    2. It seems to me that the authors of the show did not read the book, but read a strange retelling written by a black lesbian feminist.
    3. When the author does not have blacks in the novel (yes, we can say that in Russia, because we should not reckon with slavery and US history - we didn’t have this), this does not mean that he is racist.
    4. The entire series resembles an adaptation of the complexes of a dumb teenage girl who, instead of losing weight, started shouting “respect my rights”    … Expand
  94. moothemagiccow
    Dec 21, 2019
    2
    If you want to listen to someone talk about sending fifty ships from Bryvidia with zero context, this is the show for you.
  95. Dantalian
    Dec 21, 2019
    3
    Я не являюсь фанатом саги о Ведьмаке , я не играл в игры , и не читал полностью книгу , поэтому я могу судить не предвзято .Мне нету дела до цвета кожи , откуда они , какой у них пол и предпочтения в любовном плане.
    Но я ненавижу когда актёры не гармонично смотрятся.
    Геральд, Енифер , Трисс . Одни из главных персонажей этой саги . и к каждому я хочу предаться 1. Геральд - Когда я его    Я не являюсь фанатом саги о Ведьмаке , я не играл в игры , и не читал полностью книгу , поэтому я могу судить не предвзято .Мне нету дела до цвета кожи , откуда они , какой у них пол и предпочтения в любовном плане.
    Но я ненавижу когда актёры не гармонично смотрятся.
    Геральд, Енифер , Трисс . Одни из главных персонажей этой саги . и к каждому я хочу предаться
    1. Геральд - Когда я его вижу , я вижу не Ведьмака , а Геркулеса который подсел на дешевые стероиды , от которых он меняет цвет глаз и у него галлюцинации по ночам .
    Енифер - Хоть горбатая , хоть измененная ,даже под тонной косметики , она выглядит как серая мышка , и прямая походка и косметика этого не меняет , что есть , то есть
    Трисс - Я честно не понимаю чего хотели от данного персонажа на выборе актёра. Но давайте по их словам как они говорили , мы будем двигаться по книге . Так вот Описание Трисс.
    В книге «Кровь эльфов» упоминается, что у неё были роскошные волосы цвета «октябрьского каштана», её гордость и «опознавательный знак», тонкая талия и проницательный взгляд голубых глаз.«Две из них были в платьях, очень скромно застегнутых под горлышко, —- суровая, одетая в чёрное Шеала де Танкарвилль и молоденькая Трисс Меригольд с голубыми глазами и изумительно красивыми каштаново-рыжими волосами»«Весёлая Трисс Меригольд с каштановыми волосами, хохочущая по любому поводу, выглядевшая как девчонка. (Что говорит нам о девушке с прекрасным красивым телосложением , которая выглядит как "девочка" что никак нельзя сказать о сериальной деве , очень противоречивой внешности , который с виду , уже около 40.
    Я могу похвалить за красивую картинку , не плохих монстров , реплики , не плохи , хоть я и хочу больше фентези .    … Expand
  96. kot_exe
    Dec 21, 2019
    0
    Сюжет кусками + ужасный кастинг + либеральные скандалы, спасибо хоть Геральта геем не сделали.
  97. ValentinOzhi
    Dec 21, 2019
    3
    И тааак, Ведьмак.
    Меня хватило на две серии и честно мне стыдно за Нетфликс. Начну с плюсов этого «сериала» так как их меньше чем минусов.
    Это озвучка актеров, она действительно классная и было приятно слушать персонажей если бы они не разговаривали друг с другом, потому что диалоги сосут огромный, невероятный, термоядерный... сенджигрон (я играл в Ведьмака и только я это пойму). Ну и еще    И тааак, Ведьмак.
    Меня хватило на две серии и честно мне стыдно за Нетфликс. Начну с плюсов этого «сериала» так как их меньше чем минусов.
    Это озвучка актеров, она действительно классная и было приятно слушать персонажей если бы они не разговаривали друг с другом, потому что диалоги сосут огромный, невероятный, термоядерный... сенджигрон (я играл в Ведьмака и только я это пойму). Ну и еще мне понравился персонаж Лютик - бард, его очень хорошо там показали. Ну и все, все остальное сплошные минусы. Даже я, настоящий фанат ведьмака, который перечитал все книги, прошел игры, в самом начале нихрена не понял. Я боюсь представить что случится с человеком который даже игру не прошел, не считая книг. Актеры подобраны ужасно, Йеннифер - чародейка, в книге ей 180 лет, но как говорилось в книге выглядит она на 30-40. Здесь Йеннифер выглядит на 14... Сам ведьмак Геральт, ну это пиздес, не многословный, понтовщик, и ваще ховно. Еще меня пробомбило с сюжета, они хотели сделать по книге, но вышло так будто они книгу читали задом наперёд или по диагонали, ну или я хз. Короче пиздес и ничего больше. Если вы не хотите читать книгу про ведьмака то в принципе с закрытыми глазами и закрытыми ушами можно смотреть. Ставлю 3 из 10. Очень пробомбило    … Expand
  98. BenjiButton
    Dec 21, 2019
    3
    Casting is bad with a few exceptions. (Did a hit job on the Elder Races/Dryads) The pacing of the story is jarring and the story itself lacks gravitas, at times manages to be corny (Yenn swinging sword like a pro, mid fight peck with Geralt) Had they adopted a slower, more impactful approach, (Show us Geralt on a methodical hunt episode 1, not in an underwater rumble and cut scene) then weCasting is bad with a few exceptions. (Did a hit job on the Elder Races/Dryads) The pacing of the story is jarring and the story itself lacks gravitas, at times manages to be corny (Yenn swinging sword like a pro, mid fight peck with Geralt) Had they adopted a slower, more impactful approach, (Show us Geralt on a methodical hunt episode 1, not in an underwater rumble and cut scene) then we might have actually cared a little for the characters.

    Wanted this to be good/great but has fallen on its face, which is disappointing considering the material they’ve had to work with.    … Expand
  99. KB5K
    Dec 21, 2019
    3
    The Witcher delivers a fantasy experience like none other---it's the kind of fantasy experience you haven't felt since a Sunday afternoon rerun of Xena: Warrior Princess came on after another Sunday afternoon rerun of Hercules: The Legendary Journeys.

    Eesh...

    ...On the bright side, it's not a bad show to fall asleep to. It also works as effective background noise while doing housework.
  100. Ferzenand
    Dec 21, 2019
    3
    The flaws of the first episode:
    1. The fight with kikimora was in the middle of nowhere. Instead of the usual swamp area, they decided to use some vomit graphics from the late 90s.
    2. The role of Renfrey completely failed. Instead of a person with a difficult fate and nature, we’ve got an offended “next door girl”. 3. The Witcher’s atmosphere has been **** up. We’ve like it in video    The flaws of the first episode:
    1. The fight with kikimora was in the middle of nowhere. Instead of the usual swamp area, they decided to use some vomit graphics from the late 90s.
    2. The role of Renfrey completely failed. Instead of a person with a difficult fate and nature, we’ve got an offended “next door girl”.
    3. The Witcher’s atmosphere has been **** up. We’ve like it in video games. But we haven't seen any of it on the screen. Btw, blacks in the world of slavic fantasy look as foolish as penguins in the midle of savannah.
    5. Designer responsible for the nilf armor should be kicked out of the profession. And Lauren Schmidt should take less vine and pay more attention to organization of the filming process.
    6. Battle scene - main nominee for the award "Shame of the year".
    7. Soundtracks of the series in quality lose to tracks from free libraries.
    8. The motivation of characters is not disclosed. Actually, nobody tries.    … Expand
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Most Discussed TV Season of 2019
77
#77 Most Shared TV Season of 2019

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
53

Mixed or average reviews - based on 17 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 6 out of 17
  2. Mixed: 8 out of 17
  3. Negative: 3 out of 17
  1. The Independent
    Reviewed by: Nick Hilton
    Jan 3, 2020
    40
    The Witcher is a messy tangle of plotlines in a world underdeveloped to the point of obscurity.
    Read full review
  2. The Telegraph
    Reviewed by: Ed Power
    Jan 3, 2020
    60
    As a mindless fantasy rollercoaster, Geralt’s journey is five stars all the way to tea-time. Sadly, for those who like brains with their brawn, it may be more of a slog.
    Read full review
  3. Time
    Reviewed by: Judy Berman
    Dec 20, 2019
    30
    It takes a while for viewers to learn how these characters are connected, via an exasperating Westworld-esque narrative knot that takes much of the season to unfurl. ... The Witcher heightens our confusion by fumbling details that would have helped it set a cohesive tone. Dialogue vacillates, from line to line, between theatrical fantasy-speak and modern colloquialisms (“Dragons are, in fact, a thing!”).
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »