Star Trek: Discovery

:

Season 4
Season #: 5, 4, 3, 2, 1
User Score
2.8

Generally unfavorable reviews- based on 55 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 10 out of 55
  2. Mixed: 6 out of 55
  3. Negative: 39 out of 55
Watch Now

Where To Watch

Stream On
Stream On
Stream On

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

view
per page
  1. Maxalba
    Dec 18, 2021
    3
    This show should be called "Star Trek: Discovering emotions". It seams like the only sense in this garbage is to explore the feellings of the crew, everyone has serious emotional issues, they are crearly not ready to be in starfleet, Picard would have fired everyone. Michael Burnham want to cry in every chapter and the plot is always creating conflict in the main characters just to takeThis show should be called "Star Trek: Discovering emotions". It seams like the only sense in this garbage is to explore the feellings of the crew, everyone has serious emotional issues, they are crearly not ready to be in starfleet, Picard would have fired everyone. Michael Burnham want to cry in every chapter and the plot is always creating conflict in the main characters just to take them into a deep depresion!… Expand
  2. Sammyskill
    Dec 12, 2021
    1
    Season 1& 2 were fantastic. Season 3 good with a few blemishes but season 4 is utter rubbish. They have stopped following a great and well organized Star Trek methodology to become very very woke which every show that has gone this way has pretty much failed along with woke advertising that has reduced sales worldwide. Get back to what Star Trek is about… give Star Trek back to the fansSeason 1& 2 were fantastic. Season 3 good with a few blemishes but season 4 is utter rubbish. They have stopped following a great and well organized Star Trek methodology to become very very woke which every show that has gone this way has pretty much failed along with woke advertising that has reduced sales worldwide. Get back to what Star Trek is about… give Star Trek back to the fans and remove the culture that is ruining a great series. Very disappointed as it’s become unwatchable… Expand
  3. Sveinbjorn
    Dec 20, 2021
    3
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The 4th season has done away with all characters that created friction or drama. While such characters are maybe not typical for later star trek (Shatner was no diplomat), they were the tentpoles of Discovery.
    So far we have a menace that is random and uncomfortable, a mystery that is given little progress and no definition to add interest.

    And the crew have the air of a crowd of people that have very recently started therapy. Everyone makes their boundaries everyone elses problem, leading up to a shark-jumping scene in episode four, where a group of cadettes in imminent mortal danger from some boring space monsters feel entitled to stop, in an undefensible open area, to shout racism at each other(!), at a point where they should be running tovards a defendable position close by. While the show is painfully trying to be in touch with feelings, the moral lessons are terrible: Book deals with trauma with a space mindmeld, and learns that... If you suffer great loss, find the nearest Vulcan.

    The moral clarity is fundementalist, no tough choices here, not really. No train track conundrums, just the everpresent fantasy, moral certainty is good, nothing is really complicated, you just need to break free from the shackles of moral relativity.

    The subplot with the genderfluid Gray seeking a body is dreadful. They and their body co-occupant Adira seem to be an avatar for charmlessness, all dour, cowardly and pretty ok with it. In season 3 they had arcs and gravity, in s04 they just whine.

    Its all so on the nose.

    Star Trek made us all more open minded by meeting us half-way, and playing little tricks, that piqued empathy.

    Discovery has done away with that, its moral world alien to anyone over 35, anyone who never got help or support, anyone who never got their feelings validated this much.

    I’ve done a ton of therapy, but I’m still a 42 year old child of the old world, and these characters are unnerving. They just seem so entitled, like they’d all suck up all the energy in the room, and none seem to have picked up even a whiff of humility from their lives, except Saru, who’s a fantasy father-figure, a masculine sponge of everyone elses bullsh*. I want the world more open-minded. However I hate when the “open-minded” set close ranks. And thats the problem. The series has done away with “evil”, by writing out any characters that had oppurtunity to grow.

    The new characters are either blobs of jelly like the Admiral, demigods like Ma’ Burnham, or exposition printers like David Cronenberg’s character.

    The pressure for moral purity has dumbed the series down. And it was never smart to begin with.

    But it hade a core, “constant evolution”

    But now its found its final form, tv comfort food for people who are returning to america’s christian fundementalist roots, that there is clear good, clear evil, and you need church, where you are fed moral clarity.

    I was so pissed off after episode 4, that I decided to take another run at The Orville. O is unabashedly mediocre TV, but by making the most of Trek tropes, plus Bro idiot side characters for comedy, it gives its writers space to explore ideas. We have a reversal of trans issues episode, when Bortis, who’s male like all of his race, hatches a female, and cultural mores call for gender re-assignment surgery. Female characters taking offense to the lethal misoginy, males looking at the cultural norms, a flawed outcome and its effect on the relationship. And dick-jokes to boot.

    While Orville is teaching us to accept loss, be modern men like the captain, who has to rein in his feelings and respect his ex wife and xo’s new relationship… Discovery is all “my way or the highway”. Stranded in space, having lost all connection to all she’s ever been or known, Tilly’s main goal is to “move out of the comfort zone”. Must be nice.

    The writers’ absolute lack of experience with any real hardship becomes so blisteringly clear. The problems of Discovery’s crew are all of their own making, and they intend to learn nothing, and reject growth.

    And when the Family Guy guy has you beat on maturity, don’t you need to reconsider your priorities?

    Some of what I’ve written is clearly hyperbolic. There are exceptions, and I’ve over-generalised. But I will not have an unconditionally loving saru-dad in my life, I have to love my cranky one with all his flaws.
    I will never live in Discovery’s fantasy world, I’ve tried to be their characters and gotten rejected for it.
    Most of the trolls that hate this have similar experience, but no emotional language to express it. Often they live in worlds with Discovery-like characters, oppressive, smug, monopolising their feelings as the only valid ones.

    The ship was steered into the center of the culture wars, and left there.

    Its an unwelcoming place. And in reality, you always get eaten by the boring space monsters.    … Expand
  4. james-cordoban
    Dec 25, 2021
    0
    OMG! In german there is a word called "Fremdscham" which means to feel ashamed on someone else's behalf. Being overwhelmed by this feeling I had to stop watching after 20 minutes of the first episode.
  5. hfur
    Dec 30, 2021
    0
    Except for maybe one percent of the episodes, a few in the beginning, Star Trek Discovery is not just bad. It's a torturous nightmare to watch. I literally moan in pain and suffering through every episode and yell at the screen, hoping that maybe, suddenly, there will be something to watch remniscient of Star Trek or any kind of tolerable entertainment. The people who are writing StarExcept for maybe one percent of the episodes, a few in the beginning, Star Trek Discovery is not just bad. It's a torturous nightmare to watch. I literally moan in pain and suffering through every episode and yell at the screen, hoping that maybe, suddenly, there will be something to watch remniscient of Star Trek or any kind of tolerable entertainment. The people who are writing Star Trek, the people who did the casting, everything except the graphics, are not just extremely unintelligent. They are disgusting, deluded, quasi-pretentious, quasi-woke freaks of nature. You couldn't make a parody of Star Trek Discovery, it already is one, except there is no laughing track. Star Trek Discovery is so bad it's not just the most sickening dumpster fire ever broadcast, it's one of the clearest symptoms of the downfall of Western civilization.… Expand
  6. choochookid
    Dec 31, 2021
    2
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I'm sad to rate a Star Trek series so low. I've seen every episode of every series multiple times and love the various ideas and ideals, even when I don't agree with the premise of a particular show or episode. Discovery is such a waste of the talents of its actors. Warning, spoilers ahead. I understand that each ST series usually reflects the issues of their time, and the various anxieties, stresses and mental/psychological health issues that the characters have to deal with in Discovery continue this tradition. But we're being bombarded, constantly, with everyone's troubled mental and psychological states. Episode 6...I've had it. Everyone jump in the pattern buffer so you don't die. But wait, if we can store everyone in the pattern buffer, why can't we just print you out again if you DO die...like a file we stored on a hard drive?! A woke, sentient ship that has somehow evolved and has to deal with emotions and choices. If I was the ship, I'd cut oxygen and give all of the characters a merciful ending to this dreadful series created by so-called "Star Trek fans" who increasingly miss the point of Star Trek's mission to explore and make us think. We the audience are apparently too stupid to consider the plots and ideas to draw our own conclusions and instead must be told what is right and wrong, and our attention is too poor to deal with plotlines that don't have some existence-threatening problem every season. too bad.… Expand
  7. SineCurve
    Jan 4, 2022
    3
    I'd never fast forwarded through any episode of any Star Trek show, but, I just did. Through the entire second half of S04E05. I have S04E06 still to watch, but I can't bring myself to go through that again. A sad end to a promising show, full of characters that I loved, and stories that I cared about. I really don't see season 5 happening without a massive overhaul of the writer's room.
  8. khos77
    Dec 10, 2021
    3
    Very disappointing after 4 episodes...die hard fan of star trek and lived the first 3 seasons however acting is sub par this season and story line is plain
  9. jfrisby
    Nov 27, 2021
    0
    I've made it through 4 episodes now. Some of the worst dialog, unprofessional behavior from star fleet members, endless quips, every character feels the same, things happen for no reason except for some dialog they wanted to write...it's just an amateurish nightmare...just painful to watch.

    On top of all that theyve wasted David Cronenbergs time...
  10. Originaltrekkie
    Dec 1, 2021
    0
    Been a Trekkie from the beginning in the '60s. Followed all iterations from TOS timeline to Kelvin timeline. Season 3 was hard to swallow sometimes as the crew would ooze sappiness and 'wokeness'. But the first 2 episodes of S4 were just too unbearable to finish watching. Juvenile and Fraggle Rockish. The butterfly people were just plain stoo pid. However you slice it, this is no longerBeen a Trekkie from the beginning in the '60s. Followed all iterations from TOS timeline to Kelvin timeline. Season 3 was hard to swallow sometimes as the crew would ooze sappiness and 'wokeness'. But the first 2 episodes of S4 were just too unbearable to finish watching. Juvenile and Fraggle Rockish. The butterfly people were just plain stoo pid. However you slice it, this is no longer 'my parents' StrTrk. Looks like mankind just keeps getting more touchy-feely in the future.

    Let us boldly go where no one has hugged before, because, we are Star Fleet!
    Ok, everyone on the bridge, let's hold hands, and... ENGAGE!
    Oooo.....!
    I've got goose pimples!    … Expand
  11. daniel_
    Dec 11, 2022
    0
    Oh what would be the universe without the Discovery. It´s kind of boring that now everything has to be saved again by Captain Burnham & Co.
  12. Morgrain
    Mar 21, 2022
    0
    It's not good. Dialogues are, well, bad (incoherent, simplistic, often make little sense, do not advance the story) and the plot is not executed in a coherent way. In the end, one 2 minute speech "THE POWER OF FRIENDSHIP AND EMOTIONS COMPELL YOU", and kaboom, everyone is happy, and the mighty alien species is instantly ceasing all hostile activity. Of course.
  13. MetacriticOnur
    Mar 18, 2022
    3
    bad
    [ bad ]

    adjective, worse, worst;(Slang) bad·der, bad·dest for 36.
    not good in any manner or degree.

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
tbd

No score yet - based on 3 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3 out of 3
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 3
  3. Negative: 0 out of 3
  1. Decider
    Reviewed by: Alex Zalben
    Nov 18, 2021
    80
    With the crew established and the characters beloved, the series is now taking the time to lead boldly not with surprises, but with tremendous amounts of heart.
    Read full review
  2. IndieWire
    Reviewed by: Christian Blauvelt
    Nov 18, 2021
    75
    Star Trek: Discovery” Season 4 has reached that level of eye-tickling worldbuilding and has done so seamlessly. ... But if depth of character — other than Burnham — is still sorely missing from “Discovery,” at least there’s a lot of dazzle to feast on.
    Read full review
  3. Pittsburgh Tribune-Review
    Reviewed by: Rob Owen
    Nov 18, 2021
    65
    Episode four suggests this new threat might be an allegory for Earth’s response to covid-19, but more concerning for fans will be how the show handles a beloved character’s growth.
    Read full review