- Network: Apple TV
- Series Premiere Date: Jun 27, 2025
Critic Reviews
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
“Smoke” has everything fans of Lehane’s books or TV shows have come to expect, mystery, action, violence, foreboding atmosphere but this series also has dark comedy and bits of fantasy. There are times when you’re not so sure where the fictional Dave’s fictional book ends and this fictional version of a true story begins.
-
It is hugely entertaining, though it is a shame that the main story slightly swamps Freddy’s and gives Mwine less to do as time goes on. But Egerton serves up an increasingly layered, clever performance as Gudsen, hitting every ball Lehane and the true story on which Smoke is based throw at him out of the park.
-
“Smoke” drifts into so many places one doesn’t expect, or shouldn’t, that it earns its multi-episodic length and space and breadth.
-
“Smoke” is well-made and tremendously acted, and while the plot does go up in — ahem — smoke late in the game, the actors always keep us invested.
-
While “Smoke” might feel like a derivative of “Black Bird” without having the same narrative and thematic heft, it’s still a compellingly watchable show. It also allows for a fascinating acting showcase for Taron Egerton.
-
The first two episodes take a while to get going, but once we get to the “ohhhh” moment, it moves at a decent pace. Smoke ultimately gets to where it wants to go and I can honestly say that it was quite the journey.
-
An extraordinarily well-acted, formally inconsistent adaptation of the podcast Firebug.
-
The story spirals a bit too far out of Lehane and company’s control in the final chapters, particularly with some choices that Michelle makes. But even they have some thrilling moments, and some thoughtful things to say about the lives we tell the world — and ourselves — about who we are.
-
It might not be an instant smash hit like other shows that become addictive from the get-go, and a few too many similarities to Black Bird might make it seem a bit been-there-done-that, but in the end, Smoke is nothing less than a carefully assembled crime drama.
-
Smoke suffers from its overly ambiguous storytelling. Yet despite all the frustrations that presents, the performances by Egerton, Jurnee Smollett, and the rest of the ensemble make this an endlessly watchable and compelling series.
-
There are a number of moments where the series feels like it takes things too far, whether it’s in the minor details or major plot twists. But if you can accept “Smoke” as a gonzo piece of sensationalism, it’s a thoroughly entertaining ride.
-
The results aren't entirely satisfying, but the moments that click into place, particularly those spotlighting performances that strike the balance the series attempts, suggest it was worth a try.