Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 feels soulless and mercenary, doing just enough to avoid major outcry, while always feeling like a nip and tuck version of the games you once knew. This game may not be the worst game in the franchise, at least not for long, but it makes you question what we as an industry are even doing anymore.

Lost Soul Aside can only ever be the sum of its parts. I wish I could play a version of the game that worked with its combat, rather than simply letting the sole good element of the game buoy an otherwise disappointing experience. That game doesn’t exist, and so it’s impossible to recommend Lost Soul Aside – precisely because of all its frustrating promise. This version isn’t worth the heartache.

Bywater looks like the kind of Hobbit town I’d want to live in. Its rolling hills are gorgeous in all seasons, with well thought-out sightlines letting you see far into the distance at the settlement’s variety. It’s full of lush plant life and chirping birds, with scattered structures accenting rather than disrupting the natural landscape. But it doesn’t feel like the Shire as we know it from The Lord of the Rings books and films, seeming more like a pale imitation rather than a faithful recreation. There’s some cozy joy to be had in the slow-paced daily life of a Hobbit here, but Tales of the Shire ultimately fails to capture the magic of The Lord of the Rings or invent much of its own.