The developers created an interesting game with some novel features, but they then saddled it with controls that completely negate the experience. [Jan 2002, p.114]

The attention to detail is extremely high, the Direct 3D graphics are fantastic, and the story is worth pursuing. [Jan 2002, p.106]

You won’t lack for things to fiddle with in this game, and at times you may feel a bit besieged by how much you need to manage. [Jan 2002, p.102]

While it’s fun to go back in time for a little while, I found my attention flagging after a few rounds of each game. [Jan 2002, p.96]

Trying to create a winning team through trades and the draft is remarkably compelling. [May 2002, p.90]

A great scenario editor can't lift this average grand-tactical war game above "Korsun Pocket." [Nov 2003, p.142]

Clusterball is one serious cluster-fu...No, I said I wouldn't do it, and I won't. [Apr 2002, p.101]

From start to finish, it is a poorly conceived, ill-executed, and time-wasting piece of coasterware designed to suck money away from both fans of the much-lauded series and unsuspecting newcomers. [Nov 2003, p.138]

Unfortunately, as much as Siege of Avalon improves upon "Diablo"-esque storytelling, it's a huge step backward in terms of gameplay. [May 2002, p.84]

Diablo is the perfect example of a game that transcends its genre.

A good-looking shooter that's only fun for the first few hours.

The real challenge comes not from a smart enemy, but from a bad interface. [May 2003, p.90]

As dry and inviting as the Arabian Desert. [Nov 2003, p.146]

As a simulation of the full flying experience, this one-man project can't compete with the refinement of "FS2004," but for the tinkerer or virtual pilot looking for unique flying experiences, it's a fun toolkit to dive into. [Ver 7.40; Apr 2004, p.93]

It believably simulates the pro game, and for a text game, that's the most important thing. [June 2004, p.81]

This game is lazy and derivative - and it's your fault. [Holiday 2004, p.104]

A great technical simulation that just isn't much fun. [Holiday 2004, p.98]

This game definitely isn't for everyone, but masochists who find fascination in supply wagons, attrition, and the confusion of horse-powered communications might find it enjoyable...and become closer friends with their inner geek. [Dec 2004, p.99]

So far ahead, you can't see the competition. [Feb 2006, p.79]