Hillbilly Elegy
Netflix | Release Date: November 11, 2020
7.5
USER SCORE
Generally favorable reviews based on 220 Ratings
USER RATING DISTRIBUTION
Positive:
158
Mixed:
29
Negative:
33
Watch Now
Stream On
Review this movie
VOTE NOW
 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Check box if your review contains spoilers 0 characters (5000 max)

User Reviews

User scoreBy dateMost helpful
9
iwatchfilmsNov 17, 2020
My biggest takeaway from this experience was an unintended one.

The critics have no idea what people like. This movie is perfectly fine. I get it that maybe it’s schlocky and maybe it’s Oscar-baity but... a lot of people like movies likeMy biggest takeaway from this experience was an unintended one.

The critics have no idea what people like. This movie is perfectly fine. I get it that maybe it’s schlocky and maybe it’s Oscar-baity but... a lot of people like movies like that. My grandma and mom will love this movie.

It’s not my favorite movie of the year, but the hate this movie has garnered is laughable. It’s actually a heartfelt and beautiful film about growth and family. Watch for yourself and make your own judgement!… Expand
11 of 11 users found this helpful110
All this user's reviews
10
Wook1775Nov 19, 2020
Hillbilly Elegy in my opinion, is a great story about a families trials in the US. This book is my required reading for American History in my college course. Everyone should read this and watch the movie. It's been portrayed wonderfully byHillbilly Elegy in my opinion, is a great story about a families trials in the US. This book is my required reading for American History in my college course. Everyone should read this and watch the movie. It's been portrayed wonderfully by Ron Howard and the cast. This story is also about my Sister Marines family. She and her family are extremely proud to share their history, so everyone should be respectful and keep politics out of it. This story is not political one bit.… Expand
8 of 8 users found this helpful80
All this user's reviews
9
edb111358Dec 4, 2020
I must be watching a different movie than what the so called critics reviewed. Well acted, well directed, as usual by Ron Howard, with a compelling and interesting story to tell. This isn't the best movie I've ever seen, given a few moreI must be watching a different movie than what the so called critics reviewed. Well acted, well directed, as usual by Ron Howard, with a compelling and interesting story to tell. This isn't the best movie I've ever seen, given a few more banal moments, but it is still well worth watching, and provides many endearing features. The only reason I can think that this movie got panned by critics is the fact that the author doesn't meet the critic's requirements that his political view of the world conform to theirs. Is this just another example of how the media landscape is horrifically dominated by just one point of view that no other point of view should be allowed to survive, let alone thrive? Is this the country we now live in??… Expand
7 of 7 users found this helpful70
All this user's reviews
10
balta_vicNov 13, 2020
Very good movie, Amy Adams is fine and Glenn Close performance is amazing!!
7 of 7 users found this helpful70
All this user's reviews
10
CupidetteNov 14, 2020
my family loved this film, we’re planing to watch again when it arrives on Netflix.
7 of 7 users found this helpful70
All this user's reviews
10
MAD77Nov 19, 2020
OMG, This movie is great!!! It touches on everything true about Appalachia. They did a great job.
7 of 7 users found this helpful70
All this user's reviews
10
Stephjordan2Nov 20, 2020
Great movie that aligns with the book. Glenn Close portrays the character very realistically!
7 of 7 users found this helpful70
All this user's reviews
10
shikamaru31789Nov 25, 2020
Just watched Hillbilly Elegy with my parents, who both have family in Appalachia and spent summers there growing up. They really enjoyed the movie, as did I. It's a heartwarming tale of trying to overcome adversity and better yourself. TheJust watched Hillbilly Elegy with my parents, who both have family in Appalachia and spent summers there growing up. They really enjoyed the movie, as did I. It's a heartwarming tale of trying to overcome adversity and better yourself. The performances by the main cast were fantastic, I particularly enjoyed Glenn Close as J.D.'s grandmother. I really don't know what the critics have against this movie, seeing how hard most of them slammed it (with the exception of Richard Roeper, one of the oldest and most respected film critics in the business), only further cements my belief that movie critics are an extremely poor representation of what general audiences like. This is exactly why I watch the movies that I want to watch instead of letting film critics influence what I watch.… Expand
6 of 6 users found this helpful60
All this user's reviews
10
JoshLeeNov 13, 2020
It was not as bad as the reviews suggest, I enjoyed it and Glenn Close can act!
6 of 6 users found this helpful60
All this user's reviews
10
gabcrayNov 13, 2020
A good movie with a great message. Glenn Close is incredible, she's the best.
6 of 6 users found this helpful60
All this user's reviews
10
Swyas2Nov 15, 2020
This is such an accurate portrayal of many of the family dynamics present in Middletown, Ohio. J.D.’s story is not unique, as a large amount of the population hails from Kentucky, and is relatable as many of the millennial citizens ofThis is such an accurate portrayal of many of the family dynamics present in Middletown, Ohio. J.D.’s story is not unique, as a large amount of the population hails from Kentucky, and is relatable as many of the millennial citizens of Middletown left, yet are still tied to the town by drug-fueled family members. Again, it may not be what you want to see, you may not think it believable, but it is ACCURATE. Many people will feel seen when they watch this movie.… Expand
6 of 6 users found this helpful60
All this user's reviews
10
rachael1775Nov 19, 2020
I love this book and the movie did not disappoint. I hope everyone sees it!
6 of 6 users found this helpful60
All this user's reviews
10
JpjeskeNov 19, 2020
Perfect depiction of the mix of love and disfunction that can occur in families. Great movie that ties in beautifully with J.D. Vance’s best selling book!
6 of 6 users found this helpful60
All this user's reviews
8
RtheomDec 1, 2020
I was surprised by this movie. Going into it, I thought it was just going to be some drama about rednecks and problems that relate specifically to them. Instead, I came out with a story that reflected some of the trauma I experienced growingI was surprised by this movie. Going into it, I thought it was just going to be some drama about rednecks and problems that relate specifically to them. Instead, I came out with a story that reflected some of the trauma I experienced growing up with an addict. This is one of those movies where you've either experienced what's happening in the film and it just hits home really hard, or you haven't and you should consider yourself fortunate, but know that what they're showing here is surprisingly genuine.… Expand
5 of 5 users found this helpful50
All this user's reviews
10
EduardoAdamsNov 21, 2020
Actuaciones para todas las edades!!, Amy Adams y Gleen dotan de increíbles actuaciones y la película se disfruta básicamente por los.pleitos entre estás dos.
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
10
fettyvertahaiDec 5, 2020
Excellent movie. If the critics can put aside their biases, they would agree with me.
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
10
TylaBallz91Dec 3, 2020
Excellent movie .. don’t listen to these woke lib-tard critics .. damn shame the reviews they gave thus movie
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
10
TV_famNov 13, 2020
Family drama with great performances, Amy Adams and Glenn Close did not disappoint.
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
8
andrearmandoNov 13, 2020
A surprisingly heartfelt and tender family drama with a powerful message. Amy Adams gives her all, but it’s Glenn Close who steals the film. She’s winning the Oscar. Lovely score and stunning cinematography as well. A win for everyone involved.
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
10
RVailNov 19, 2020
I never get excited for the movie version of a book that I really like but this was fantastic. Like the book, you relate to the store regardless of where you grew up. Amy Adams was awesome!
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
10
word321Nov 23, 2020
Perfect adaptation of the book. What else do you need to say to get to 75 characters
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
8
mattaluckNov 24, 2020
Family Drama was written by JD, which the movie by Ron Howard leave out plenty of politic out the film, but the family drama about single mother, raise 2 kids and having trouble with father passing away, Amy Adams is a revolution as aFamily Drama was written by JD, which the movie by Ron Howard leave out plenty of politic out the film, but the family drama about single mother, raise 2 kids and having trouble with father passing away, Amy Adams is a revolution as a drug-addicted-single mother, Glenn Close is marvelous as Mamaw, Gabriel Basso lead, voice his story his glow-up story as JD. Score is amazing.… Expand
4 of 4 users found this helpful40
All this user's reviews
8
jesuisandreNov 24, 2020
Perhaps the most telling shot of Hillbilly Elegy comes when everything is still fine and dandy, one happy family. Mamaw insists on taking a family shot of that fine moment, which then traces back across generations in that same house - it's aPerhaps the most telling shot of Hillbilly Elegy comes when everything is still fine and dandy, one happy family. Mamaw insists on taking a family shot of that fine moment, which then traces back across generations in that same house - it's a simple montage, reminiscent of Spike Lee's authorship, that says more volumes than the dialogue is so obsessively trying to convey. It says, without necessarily pronouncing it, one of the already most quoted phrases "Family is only thing worth goddamn" without uttering a single word. It also announces something tragic is about to happen, and something that is much more hereditary than just following the American Dream or die trying.

I wasn't a big fan of Vanessa Taylor's The Shape of Water, because it put way too much emphasis on archetypes, and once again, it shows here. That said, this is likely to be most quotable film this side of COVID19's pandemic. Contradictory much? You'd think, coming from a social media frenzy.

In fact, Opie's camp opus is in fact all the things at once, dialed up to 11. He manages to be snarky about the irritating neoliberal job interviewers J.D. so fairly calls out for, but he depicts white trash misery like a liberal.

I'd say, despite all the archetypes, everyone is depicted in this film as a Neutral Terminator, except for three people: Lindsay, J.D. and his then girlfriend (now wife) - precisely the last generation of this family. He gets into serious flashback and wig play, and yes, this is as baity (90s bait at that) as advertised. And yet, everything here is grand - cinematography by the great Maryse Alberti captures brilliantly the clash between two mindsets, two eras, while the "rustic" countryesque score by Hans Zimmer in partnership with David Fleming is just as exquisite.

Howard's obsession to film piss (first from a dog, and then from J.D. himself) is funny, because as we know, urine is sterile, and so is usually an Opie joint. Yes, politics were conveniently removed from here, apart from Al Gore and Lewinsky mentions by J.D.'s younger self - even those references try to put this Good Terminator in a Democrat path. But to deny that Howard hasn't always been like this, now that's **** up.

Oh, the actresses. Say what you will, but you've never seen Amy Adams and Glenn Close like this. Close's Mamaw in particular injects a humanity with her tradictional eye acting, and close up moves, that is way beyond the pages. The film (and the book?) looks up to both of them as no necessary losers by themselves, but as women who either gave up of the rigged system because of bad parenthood (Bev) or... well... decided to amend the wrongs they did in the previous generation (Mamaw, obv). And then there's Haley Bennett's more...subtle deglam, as a field spectator of the mess/one of the viewer's eyes.

So, yes this is Mommie (and Mamaw) Dearest by Ron Howard, which means he finally let it all out, but not without sanitizing all the area before filming.

Two quick final notes:
1) Bev rollerskating in Intensive Care to the sound of Banamarama's Cruel Summer is such a 2020 mood.
2) Where were all these "justice" critics in 2001, when A Beautiful Mind took home the Oscar for Best Picture?… Expand
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
10
Jade7Nov 23, 2020
Great family drama with amazing performances from everyone - and especially Amy Adams and Glenn Close!
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
10
lizetKarimNov 23, 2020
this is my favorite movie of the year!!! Amy beatiful performance and gleenie
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
10
CatrionaGrayNov 24, 2020
I have said this and now I repeat: DON'T TRUST THE CRITICS ALL THE TIME BECAUSE THIS IS ONE OF THE GREATEST MOVIE OF 2020. Get ready for Glenn Close and Amy Adams powerhouse performance. people can say whatever they want but Glenn Close willI have said this and now I repeat: DON'T TRUST THE CRITICS ALL THE TIME BECAUSE THIS IS ONE OF THE GREATEST MOVIE OF 2020. Get ready for Glenn Close and Amy Adams powerhouse performance. people can say whatever they want but Glenn Close will win the Oscar with this role… Expand
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
10
BobbieMNov 24, 2020
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This movie made me laugh and cry. Glenn Close is phenomenal. Amy Adams looks rough, but her acting is so great and raw. Loved it!… Expand
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
10
hmeibersNov 24, 2020
The film showcases a beautiful piece of Vance’s memoir that many want to ignore — the bond and importance of family.
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
10
jacknpNov 25, 2020
Adore this movie so much, dont know why so much criticism on it. Glenn Close gives a award-worth performance, amy is also very good. Highly recommended!
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
9
Amberds1Dec 3, 2020
Very shocked the critics rated this movie so bad. It’s one of the best I’ve watched in the past 5 years. Very relatable movie and the acting was awesome by Amy Adams and Glen Close. I would definitely recommend watching this movie.
3 of 3 users found this helpful30
All this user's reviews
10
cesar1990Nov 24, 2020
One of the best performances Ive seen in years. Amy Adams and Glenn Close deserve the Oscar. Finally.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
8
MikeZL55Nov 27, 2020
Gritty true story, great performances, uplifting message, especially for today.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
Method__ManDec 7, 2020
Truly excellent. Dont believe the “critics”. This story speaks to those who have struggles, and i mean real struggles. Family Poverty, drug abuse, mental illness, elderly struggles, etc. Perhaps those who have never experienced such thingsTruly excellent. Dont believe the “critics”. This story speaks to those who have struggles, and i mean real struggles. Family Poverty, drug abuse, mental illness, elderly struggles, etc. Perhaps those who have never experienced such things would be confused by it; but this is not only an excellent commentary on these issues, it is also a beautiful tale of a mans struggle to do right by his family. The acting is superb from moment to moment, drawing you into the story. Not a single member of the cast botched even a second.

The story, obviously gripping and touching. It doesnt play on cheap tropes, rather delivering with elegance.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
9
oldskoldNov 28, 2020
Critics say we don’t get enough movies like Hillbilly Elegy, but once this type of movie gets made they grab at straws to find some political reason to pan it. This is a great modern family drama film.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
9
fishforbrainsDec 7, 2020
I really liked it. The "critic" reviews are a joke. They hate the fact it shines a light on problems they think dont exist. If critics review bomb something you know it's worth watching.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
8
imtheonlytyeDec 13, 2020
I thought this movie was going to be bad because of the critics' score, but don't listen to them. This movie is actually really great. To me personally, it hit pretty close to home. Overall amazing performances. These critics just don't wantI thought this movie was going to be bad because of the critics' score, but don't listen to them. This movie is actually really great. To me personally, it hit pretty close to home. Overall amazing performances. These critics just don't want movies to exist that don't have the same views or perspectives that they have. It's a shame.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
MetteeNov 26, 2020
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Very nice movie . Very motivating and educational . Will highly recommend to watch. Loved it… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
9
DogeGamer2015Nov 26, 2020
Es una película muy buena; su trama es deprimente pero a la vez conmovedora, tiene excelentes interpretaciones y una muy buena cinematrografía.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
9
ChestwigDec 5, 2020
Absolutely fantastic gritty tale of pulling yourself up by your bootstraps.
Ignore the collective hivemind scorn from the "critics". This film is worth a watch for the performances of Amy Adams and Glen Close alone.
Great performances andAbsolutely fantastic gritty tale of pulling yourself up by your bootstraps.
Ignore the collective hivemind scorn from the "critics". This film is worth a watch for the performances of Amy Adams and Glen Close alone.
Great performances and directions all round. This movie shows that you can break the cycle and succeed despite your upbringing.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
ReirdoDec 12, 2020
Enjoyed this movie very much. Amy Adams and Glenn Close performance were particularly exceptional. Nice to see this movie wasn't infused with politics the way the media and movie critics want it to be.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
MaxSILVANov 27, 2020
Filme Maravilhoso ooo, a "crítica especializada" tá tudo com recalque, as negativas é claro, pq as notas verdes foram as sensatas. Amy Adams e Gleen é um deleite ver essas duas atrizes em cena, o Oscar já é pra ser das duas!!
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
SquatchieNov 24, 2020
JD's book has been overly politicized as this is a fundamentally raw and powerful family saga with gritty intensity and relatable values. A mesmerizing Glenn Close highlights a moving roller coaster of emotions. An engaging viewing for peopleJD's book has been overly politicized as this is a fundamentally raw and powerful family saga with gritty intensity and relatable values. A mesmerizing Glenn Close highlights a moving roller coaster of emotions. An engaging viewing for people of all backgrounds and does not require knowledge of the novel.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
LmdezNov 26, 2020
The movie was such a roller coaster of emotions. I cried, laughed and got angry. I absolutely loved the movie.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
kennhesgurlNov 27, 2020
Moving story of triumph over repeated average American hard knock life. Shows the real people at the end & they did a great job making the actors look like them. Glenn Close, especially. She is an exact match!
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
8
GaereonNov 27, 2020
It seems the critics would prefer to turn a blind eye to the subject matter of this film. The plight of the rural poor is not something that often garners attention because its not something one can get noticed for caring about. It is aIt seems the critics would prefer to turn a blind eye to the subject matter of this film. The plight of the rural poor is not something that often garners attention because its not something one can get noticed for caring about. It is a well-written and acted film. For a college graduate from similar circumstances it presents a fairly accurate depiction of its subject. It was a good watch that held my attention for the whole movie. The only thing that made it hard to watch were the sore spots it hit. I surmise the reason its positive aspects fell to be noticed by critics was due to their desire to look towards films that fit into a more privileged worldview that can overlook the suffering of certain groups.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
mbelgiornoNov 28, 2020
Heartfelt movie with a great message. Exposes many people to a culture that is generally underrepresented in film. It would be very difficult to overrate Glenn Close’s performance.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
kellixlawsonNov 28, 2020
This movie was phenomenal. The acting was incredible and I was captivated every moment of the film. Don't listen to the negative reviews written by people who are offended by everything. Stop what you're doing and watch this great movie.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
9
IfiskNov 28, 2020
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Too many look at everything through a prism of isms, which is sad, because so many great stories either don't get told or are buried under an avalanche of political and cultural sludge. Fortunately, this great story gets wonderfully told and should not be smothered by the sludge. See this.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
KenjieNov 30, 2020
A real story by real people for real people. The actors are amazing especially Glenn Close.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
BJ33Nov 30, 2020
This movie made me very emotional. I felt a connection to each character, for different reasons. After being in law enforcement for 20 years, and experiencing these family struggles first hand, I felt it was very accurate. The guilt and painThis movie made me very emotional. I felt a connection to each character, for different reasons. After being in law enforcement for 20 years, and experiencing these family struggles first hand, I felt it was very accurate. The guilt and pain that children face with parents that are addicts. The mood swings, the anger, and the manipulation that the addict uses to continue their drug use. The overwhelming desire everyone has to protect their family. The abuse that can carry on for generations. Many of these issues are vicious cycles that continue in family trees for generations to come; chemical dependency, teen pregnancy, poverty. It does a good job making the viewer experience the pain that each character is going through, and exposes the sad truth of how unfair life can be. We definitely don’t all have equal opportunities to succeed. And many times the children in these situations don’t have anyone to “save” them. They are left to fail, and continue the family cycle. It was all very raw and real. Highly recommend.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
OlgaYDec 1, 2020
It's a great story that having a family is as important as having freedom. I watch it on Netflix Russia and like so much.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
KirstenUSMCDec 1, 2020
The only reason this movie has received bad ratings is because the critics can’t separate politics and Hollywood. Perhaps we should start rating the critics. This film is raw and real and tells the story of people — actual people, who haveThe only reason this movie has received bad ratings is because the critics can’t separate politics and Hollywood. Perhaps we should start rating the critics. This film is raw and real and tells the story of people — actual people, who have lives. Our lives aren’t always pretty, as portrayed so well by Glenn Close and Amy Adams. This movie allows us to see the hardships faced by so many. Sometimes, those hardships create pretty awesome results.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
RddstaffDec 1, 2020
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Great movie. Usually the movie isn't as good as the book but in this case they are both great. Movie only protrays a small part of the book.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
MommaBearPaid4Dec 5, 2020
Once again critics have no idea what people actually like. Living in Eastern Kentucky I can relate to this movie and the message. Life is hard and it is NOT fair but there is a way out and the most important thing is family. UnbelievablyOnce again critics have no idea what people actually like. Living in Eastern Kentucky I can relate to this movie and the message. Life is hard and it is NOT fair but there is a way out and the most important thing is family. Unbelievably great acting in this movie. Exactly like an Eastern Kentucky grandma. Hard as nails and full of love… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
9
neprDec 6, 2020
I came to this film b/c of Amy Adams' work in Arrival; in Hillbilly Elegy, she does not disappoint. Her Bev is on par with Meryl Streep's Sophie in Sophie's Choice. Glenn Close' portrayal of Mamaw caught me by surprise & she's truly anI came to this film b/c of Amy Adams' work in Arrival; in Hillbilly Elegy, she does not disappoint. Her Bev is on par with Meryl Streep's Sophie in Sophie's Choice. Glenn Close' portrayal of Mamaw caught me by surprise & she's truly an amazing actor: she plays the riveting, fiercely loyal, tough, flawed, & undeterred matriarch to save her family from very hard life obstacles & from poor life choices, just so her children may have a chance 'to get out' & in JD's case, 'be somebody'. The fact that this film is based on JD Vance' biography (& not some conjured screenwriter's fiction of the overcoming hero) strengthens me all the more, & Mamaw's courage, total sacrifice, & hard-earned wisdom deeply touches. Do not be dissuaded by the professional critics' low ratings: they are paid to push an agenda. The 70's & 80's vibe in style, cars, locations, characterizations, & even the smallest items are so authentic: mise en scene is superb. Ron Howard hit another home-run!… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
10
hamus14Dec 6, 2020
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Well written, well acted. As someone from the area with family still around southern Ohio, this really rings true.… Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
7
carldamnitNov 24, 2020
el·e·gy noun 1. a poem of serious reflection, typically a lament for the dead. This does feel like that to me, less about being a slice of life and more about presenting universal themes that you can watch and let your mind wander about. Bestel·e·gy noun 1. a poem of serious reflection, typically a lament for the dead. This does feel like that to me, less about being a slice of life and more about presenting universal themes that you can watch and let your mind wander about. Best Amy Adams performance ever in my opinion. Of course, you can't forget it's her, that's how the whole star system works. If you want to watch a documentary, watch that. This is a Ron Howard movie through and through. It's not exploitative where it could have been. If I could change anything about this movie, it would be all the scenes Amy Adams isn't in. She's that great.… Expand
1 of 1 users found this helpful10
All this user's reviews
7
JimmyBaginskiDec 23, 2020
A solid human drama with a lot of heart. Critics, of course, despised this as it runs contrary to their woke narrative. Sadly, their fanatical drive to promote their agenda has blinkered their ability to see a movie that should be evaluatedA solid human drama with a lot of heart. Critics, of course, despised this as it runs contrary to their woke narrative. Sadly, their fanatical drive to promote their agenda has blinkered their ability to see a movie that should be evaluated outside of identity politics or the looming culture wars that it is embedded in. But, unfortunately everything is politically fair game these days and the fanatics can only see nails whilst wielding their monomaniachal woke hammer. It's a shame. Is this film the best movie ever made? Nope. It's not even in the conversation. But, the story is digestible, promotes individual human trying, family, community, self-belief and most of all, the power of good choices to overcome your situation. So, you can see why woke critics couldn't let this slide. The woke agenda sees the world as competing identity groups that think in groups, all vying for power. At the top of this hierarchy of power is the evil whites who are privileged and therefore unsympathetic. This film isn't trying to say anything about socioeconomics or ethnicity. It's simply portraying the reality of poor white families in America struggling under crippling unemployment, drug epidemics, loss of industry and the breakdown of the American family. That's all very real whether critics like it or not. But, you can see how it flies in their face if all they've been printing and writing about for the last 5 years is how racist and privileged white people are, and how the nuclear family is a patriarchal, outdated and oppressive model for human development. Well, one of the themes in this film is how when traditional family structure breaks down, through tragedy, drug abuse or anything else, you have to be extremely hard working and steadfast to get out from under. It took one of JD Vance's relative's (his grandmother) to actually support him and encourage him for him to claw himself out of poverty. We are left to imagine what a whole family that supports each other could accomplish. But, again that's 'white supremacy/capitalism/patriarchy' in full stride or something. Others think it's just common sense. Are the people portrayed in this movie likely Trump supporters? I'd say yes. Does it humanize them and breath empathy into the characature of rednecks the media has depicted? Yes. Are they all white supremacists? No. And, that's what makes critics uncomfortable. They want you and me to believe their nonsense, low-resolution version of reality. Lastly, the performances are to be commended. Even when the drama feels a little unbelievable or trite the actors elevate the material through raw emotion and believability. Like I said, this is no masterpiece. But, Amy Adam's and Glenn Close particularly are such arresting actors they hold you to your seat throughout. So, I'm glad this movie was made. If it's not a giant triumph of cinema exactly it is a victory for relatable human stories being made by Hollywood again. Remember: it's okay to be white and it's okay to be Conservative. It doesnt make you evil or even superior in any innate way. This film isn't even about those two things. It just doesn't apologise for them. Which is tantamount to sin these days. *sigh*

Very lastly, I have no idea if any of JD Vance's story is true or if it's embellished and rounded off at the edges. I have no idea why the film doesnt explore his grandmothers steak in his own mothers failures. I think that was a heavily absent piece of the cause and effect puzzle to be quite honest. And, I've no idea what life is like in the Appalachian mountains. But, I do know his life circumstances. His situation echoes mine in multiple ways. And, I know that when you situation is totally **** and you have almost no one in your corner, society, the government, the culture or even a family member, all you have is your damn self. That's a tough rap. That part of the story is very real and deserves to be told.… Expand
1 of 1 users found this helpful10
All this user's reviews
7
Rick444Dec 5, 2020
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The movie is clearly not that bad as reviewers claim it is. For an 'oscar movie' things that thrown me off was the shaky cam which is like a 'nono' 'no bueno' 'nein nein nein!' For a movie with such ambitions in my humble opinion. However it's strength is the story behind it about how from such a bad environment all of the members were able to come out of addictions and all that. If not the ending true story credits scene i would rate it lower, maybe a 6 or 5.5. The story itself deserves like 9, the movie is somewhere in between then… Expand
1 of 1 users found this helpful10
All this user's reviews
8
PulSyNov 13, 2020
That's not the mess I expected. Traditional film with some emotional moments, several flaws but two gritty, fierce, unforgettable lead actresses (without them it would have been a lesser grade).
1 of 1 users found this helpful10
All this user's reviews
10
cristian_alNov 14, 2020
Don’t believe what the critics have to said. It is a very good movie, with unbelievable performances, especially from Glenn Close. REALLY, a award winning show.
6 of 7 users found this helpful61
All this user's reviews
10
GitmoNov 20, 2020
Fabulous story. Any one who disagrees is living in a box. This story is based on real events that is America's story. Its not perfect, but that's real life. See this movie!
10 of 12 users found this helpful102
All this user's reviews
10
Paul_91Nov 12, 2020
I had the feeling that it was all done for the Oscar, but damn it, it was an interesting melodramatic story. Do not listen to negative reviews from critics and viewers, but rather just watch and evaluate for yourself.
4 of 5 users found this helpful41
All this user's reviews
7
HerickDienerNov 24, 2020
Vou ser cancelado por ter gostado do filme? Absorvi boas mensagens da história, e acredito que muitas pessoas poderão aplicá-las em seu próprio contexto. Glenn Close deixa claro porque tanta gente quer que ela ganhe, enfim, o seu primeiroVou ser cancelado por ter gostado do filme? Absorvi boas mensagens da história, e acredito que muitas pessoas poderão aplicá-las em seu próprio contexto. Glenn Close deixa claro porque tanta gente quer que ela ganhe, enfim, o seu primeiro Oscar. Ela rouba milimetricamente toda cena em que aparece.… Expand
3 of 4 users found this helpful31
All this user's reviews
10
EscapologyNov 12, 2020
Great movie! Amy Adams and Glenn Close have the best Oscar-worthy performances of their careers!
3 of 4 users found this helpful31
All this user's reviews
10
DizzylouNov 28, 2020
As someone who comes from a dysfunctional working class family this movie really hit home. I almost didn’t bother watching due to the bad reviews but then my sister said it was good so I gave it a go and loved it. Don’t listen to all theAs someone who comes from a dysfunctional working class family this movie really hit home. I almost didn’t bother watching due to the bad reviews but then my sister said it was good so I gave it a go and loved it. Don’t listen to all the woke middle class critics they’re so far removed from reality they couldn’t possibly understand what it’s like to grow up with no money in such a hostile and toxic place but then defy the odds and make something of yourself.… Expand
3 of 4 users found this helpful31
All this user's reviews
8
FaxthtaxNov 28, 2020
Nothing wrong with this movie. It does not break any barriers about moviemaking or hillbillies for that matter but it was a good film to catch on a Sunday. Solid performances.
Glenn Close absolutely nails her role in fact. She has the bestNothing wrong with this movie. It does not break any barriers about moviemaking or hillbillies for that matter but it was a good film to catch on a Sunday. Solid performances.
Glenn Close absolutely nails her role in fact. She has the best line i heard for a long time. (That one about how "the Polish people are burying their dead"
Killed me over..… Expand
2 of 3 users found this helpful21
All this user's reviews
2
fabsrochaJan 15, 2021
There are people that are pleased with little, poor quality. That's the explanation for a so terrible movie have more than a hundred positive votes lol. It's really a pack full of cliches and superficial characters that only will touch thoseThere are people that are pleased with little, poor quality. That's the explanation for a so terrible movie have more than a hundred positive votes lol. It's really a pack full of cliches and superficial characters that only will touch those who doesn't know the minimal of cinema. The screenplay is poor, the acting is emotionless, the dialogues are boring. The only thing that stopped me from giving it a 0 it's Glenn Close. She has some few good scenes, but yet, not enough to make it worth it.… Expand
2 of 3 users found this helpful21
All this user's reviews
10
vatzjrNov 23, 2020
Ron Howard shows us a little often seen section of the American demographic while tying in a moving story about untraditional family dynamics. Unsurprisingly, Glenn Close is a revelation. And Amy Adams shows us once again why she'sRon Howard shows us a little often seen section of the American demographic while tying in a moving story about untraditional family dynamics. Unsurprisingly, Glenn Close is a revelation. And Amy Adams shows us once again why she's America's leading lady. Excellent cinematography and breathtaking score.… Expand
2 of 3 users found this helpful21
All this user's reviews
9
clever173Dec 1, 2020
The book is always better than the movie, and this is the case with Hillbilly Elegy. If the critics don't like a movie, I make it a point to watch it, because rarely are they correct. I loved Mamaw and how NOT politically correct she was.The book is always better than the movie, and this is the case with Hillbilly Elegy. If the critics don't like a movie, I make it a point to watch it, because rarely are they correct. I loved Mamaw and how NOT politically correct she was. We need more Mamaws in the world today.… Expand
2 of 3 users found this helpful21
All this user's reviews
1
bertobellamyDec 13, 2020
This film feels like it was made in the 90's. Everything feels so antiquated about it. The use of music, the acting, the lame drama... And the story about "white suffering" can't be taken seriously. This very well may be Ron Howard's lowestThis film feels like it was made in the 90's. Everything feels so antiquated about it. The use of music, the acting, the lame drama... And the story about "white suffering" can't be taken seriously. This very well may be Ron Howard's lowest point in his career.… Expand
4 of 7 users found this helpful43
All this user's reviews
2
UncleWillardDec 21, 2020
I haven't read the book, but I saw it got a lot of praise and was on a lot of lists. I was optimistic that with Glen Close and Amy Adams attached, this would be an exciting interpretation. If the book is anything like this; whiny, smarmy,I haven't read the book, but I saw it got a lot of praise and was on a lot of lists. I was optimistic that with Glen Close and Amy Adams attached, this would be an exciting interpretation. If the book is anything like this; whiny, smarmy, overwrought tale of family woe, then I'm glad I didn't waste my time. The movie immediately devolves into "woe is me. my mama was an alcy and a drug addict, but what else you gonna do? We're Hillbillies!" [cue banjo music].

It really is melodramatic and the scene where he gets all offended by "redneck" makes me want to punch that dick in the culture.

Unbearable is what this is.… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
4
Dan_BDec 14, 2020
Horrrible melodramón donde el pobre J.D. niño lidia con una madre violenta y luego adicta, cuya desgracia lo persigue aún en su vida adulta y una abuela más sosegada pero con un pasado también turbulento y enfrentada con su hija.Horrrible melodramón donde el pobre J.D. niño lidia con una madre violenta y luego adicta, cuya desgracia lo persigue aún en su vida adulta y una abuela más sosegada pero con un pasado también turbulento y enfrentada con su hija.
Hillbilly... es una grotesca sucesión de gritos, golpes y chantajes emocionales, sobreactuados y al borde de la caricatura. Más que elegía, un exceso de miserabilismo white trash y rural de la "América profunda" y un elogio de la meritocracia. Padres y abuelos ausentes (y violentos), madre bruja y abuela ex bruja pero salvadora.
Lamentablemente, algunos (pocos) verán a este engendro superficial con pretensiones de Oscar como "un profundo drama como la vida misma" con "actuaciones intensas y arriesgadas".
Una pena que actrices de la talla de Glenn Close y Amy Adams se hayan prestado a meterse en la piel de estos personajes grotescos pero "oscarizables".

Horrible melodrama where poor J.D. The child deals with a violent mother and later addicted, whose misfortune haunts him even in his adult life, and a calmer grandmother but with a turbulent past that is also in conflict with her daughter.
Hillbilly ... is a grotesque succession of emotional yelling, punching and blackmail, over-acting and bordering on caricature. More than elegy, an excess of white trash and rural miserabilism of "deep America" and a praise of meritocracy. Absent (and violent) parents and grandparents, witch mother and ex-witch but savior grandmother.
Sadly, some (few) will see this superficial monstrosity with Oscar pretensions as "a deep drama like life itself" with "intense and risky performances".
A pity that actresses of the stature of Glenn Close and Amy Adams have lent themselves to get into the skin of these grotesque but "Oscar-winning" characters.

J.D. Vance (Gabriel Basso) es un estudiante derecho en Yale a punto de tener una elegante cena para acceder a un importante trabajo. Pero recibe un urgente llamado de su hermana pidiéndole que regrese al pueblo de Ohio donde acaban de internar a su madre Bev (Amy Adams). Esto da pie a una serie de improtantes flashbacks sobre la infancia de J.D. (Owen Asztalos) con su madre y con su abuela Mamaw (Glenn Close).
Ojalá el único problema de esta película de Ron Howard fuera esa permanente alternancia temporal que no deja consolidar ninguna de las dos tramas.

Hillbilly, una elegía rural es un horrrible melodramón donde el pobre J.D. niño lidia con una madre violenta y luego adicta, cuya desgracia lo persigue aún en su vida adulta y una abuela más sosegada pero con un pasado también turbulento y enfrentada con su hija. Lo quieren presentar como un drama fuerte pero es una grotesca sucesión de gritos, golpes y chantajes emocionales, sobreactuados y al borde de la caricatura. Más que elegía, un exceso de miserabilismo white trash y rural de la "América profunda". Padres y abuelos ausentes (y violentos), madre bruja y abuela ex (¿?) bruja pero salvadora. Sólo se salvan la hermana Lindsay (Haley Bennett) y... él, por supuesto. En espíritu Hillbilly... se asemeja a El diablo a todas horas (The Devil All The Time), sólo que ésta última es más pretenciosa y con más personajes.

Obviamente, esta película tenía que estar basada en hechos reales (para Hollywood esto siempre es un mérito) para realzar su "valor testimonial": una memoir del propio Vance ya abogado exitoso, un best seller donde parece que se venga de su familia retratándola sin piedad y de paso nos pasa el mensaje meritocrático de "yo triunfé aún con una familia de mierda pero a su manera amorosa". No se trata precisamente de Regreso a Reims...

No podían faltar los títulos finales con fotos los J.D., Bev y Mamaw reales para que veamos lo bien que disfrazaron a los actores y actrices. Para Hollywood, la transformación física y la caracterización son méritos absolutos.¡Cómo engordó Amy Adams para hacer su papel!

Lamentablemente, algunos verán a este engendro con pretensiones de Oscar como "un profundo drama como la vida misma" con "actuaciones intensas y arriesgadas".

Una pena que actrices de la talla de Glenn Close y Amy Adams se hayan prestado a meterse en la píel de estos personajes grotescos y "oscarizables".

[link omitted per site rules]… Expand
2 of 4 users found this helpful22
All this user's reviews
9
DrandyDec 16, 2020
WONDERFUL acting, in particular by Glenn Close, Amy Adams, Gabriel Basso, Haley Bennett, and Owen Asztalos. Having lived in Ohio, Kentucky, and West Virginia, I recognize these people. Beautiful and touching. I do not understand the criticsWONDERFUL acting, in particular by Glenn Close, Amy Adams, Gabriel Basso, Haley Bennett, and Owen Asztalos. Having lived in Ohio, Kentucky, and West Virginia, I recognize these people. Beautiful and touching. I do not understand the critics on this one; see it and decide for yourself.… Expand
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
0
katezoeFeb 19, 2021
More like Hillbilly Tragedy. Performances by Glenn Close and Amy Adams are deplorable. Worse movie Ron Howard has done.
1 of 3 users found this helpful12
All this user's reviews
1
marriottNov 14, 2020
I don't know why anybody decided to make this movie, this film is a mess and fails to do anything
4 of 16 users found this helpful412
All this user's reviews
0
chronicrenegadeNov 30, 2020
Dopesick (Beth Macy) is what you need to read/watch instead, and the movie that should have been made in place of this engineered narrative that Appalachians are all lazy hillbillies. The movie, and by proxy the book, entirely miss the pointDopesick (Beth Macy) is what you need to read/watch instead, and the movie that should have been made in place of this engineered narrative that Appalachians are all lazy hillbillies. The movie, and by proxy the book, entirely miss the point of systemic and generational poverty. The movie can be summed up in one ignorant statement: "poor people are poor because they're lazy." It's a bootstrap narrative, and a terrible one at that. The book even contains a passage where the author makes the claim he was held down and forced to drink sparkling water by socialites at a restaurant. Please.… Expand
3 of 13 users found this helpful310
All this user's reviews
1
ZaganEDFNov 26, 2020
It would have been a okay movie if not for the over romantization and so many cheesy fleeting youth moments. I understand that it's based on autobiographical materials and people tend to look at their childhood in romantic way but you're aIt would have been a okay movie if not for the over romantization and so many cheesy fleeting youth moments. I understand that it's based on autobiographical materials and people tend to look at their childhood in romantic way but you're a filmmaker, it's your job to make it work. Unremarkable cinematography, editing and directing. But a good story. My challenge to American directors: try not to **** up good american stories.… Expand
2 of 9 users found this helpful27
All this user's reviews
3
ArtKNov 25, 2020
Amy Adams and Glen Close star in director Ron Howard's adaptation of J.D. Vance's 2016 memoir. Netflix released to the theatre's for a couple of weeks before moving to their platform this week. Glad I waited.

"Hillbilly Elegy" explores J.D.Amy Adams and Glen Close star in director Ron Howard's adaptation of J.D. Vance's 2016 memoir. Netflix released to the theatre's for a couple of weeks before moving to their platform this week. Glad I waited.

"Hillbilly Elegy" explores J.D. Vance's relationship with his troubled mother (Adams) and her ongoing addiction to heroin and the care of his supportive grandmother (Close). Close is very good in this film (and could be remembered during awards season), but Adams felt "off" in her role. I just didn't feel any empathy for her downward (and overacted) spiral. J.D. (Gabriel Basso) also flatlined here. In a film that's supposed to challenge us on provocative social issues such as welfare, social rot, and the "hillbilly culture", Howard (who I normally love) was probably the wrong director to explore this world. Messages are largely lost and the film is simply a series of vignette's whereby J.D. (now finishing Yale Law School) remembers his troubled childhood. Netflix has a miss here.… Expand
2 of 10 users found this helpful28
All this user's reviews
5
TheWaffleNov 27, 2020
It's not "the worst movie ever" as some critics have claimed. But I think this story deserved a better film. The book is an excellent memoir of life amidst poverty, drug abuse, and self-destructive behavior. I find the book and film'sIt's not "the worst movie ever" as some critics have claimed. But I think this story deserved a better film. The book is an excellent memoir of life amidst poverty, drug abuse, and self-destructive behavior. I find the book and film's moralizing pretty repugnant, since both glorify plenty of violence in service of "protecting the family name," but it is interesting to read that perspective.

Unfortunately, while the book is chronological, the film skips back and forth without any real cohesive structure. Instead of sequential chapters in JD's life, the film just skips around to different terrible moments in his life: his grandfather's death, his mom's suicide attempt, overdose, his mom yelling at him for no reason, etc. Instead of telling JD's story (he seems to have been fully grown up at the age of 12), the film just revels in his mother's most awful moments. Instead of jump-cutting around, I would have preferred to see why she behaved so terribly, what led her to pain and drugs and overdosing.

It's not bad, but it's not very good.… Expand
1 of 5 users found this helpful14
All this user's reviews
5
Stream2BigScreeDec 5, 2020
In a non-pandemic year, late-November/early December would be the sweet spot for releasing films with their eyes on that prize, the Academy Awards. Although theaters are generally still closed, Netflix’s prestige picks are coming out weekly,In a non-pandemic year, late-November/early December would be the sweet spot for releasing films with their eyes on that prize, the Academy Awards. Although theaters are generally still closed, Netflix’s prestige picks are coming out weekly, even though the “awards season” has been extended into April. Last week, Ron Howard’s Hillbilly Elegy premiered with mixed advance buzz and the Oscar hopes of a duo of “overdue,” multi-nominated actresses, Amy Adams and Glenn Close, in tow. Award worthiness is subjective – here’s how I see it.

Based on the memoir by J.D. Vance, Hillbilly Elegy tells the story of J.D., a Yale law student, who is in the middle of interviews for summer associate positions, when he receives word that his mother has overdosed on heroin. J.D. has to go home to his family in Ohio in order to take care of his mother. Through flashbacks on his journey home, we see how J.D. got from his meager beginnings, enduring abuse and his mother’s drug addiction to Yale with the fierce, no nonsense support of his grandmother. The perspective of people in Appalachia is not a typical one depicted in films, but family drama can be universal as many people in urban, suburban and rural areas endure hardships, lack of opportunity, addiction and abuse. There is also love, sacrifice and support that fill families across the board. While this story is specific to a people in a specific place and time in America, it feels pretty generic – disappointingly so.

Ron Howard does not do anything particularly interesting in directing this film. The only exceptions are the two sequences where we see how this Appalachian area has changed and decayed over the decades. Otherwise, Howard lets the emotions of the story drive the action. And, the emotions are very high.

Amy Adams plays J.D.’s mother, Bev. She’s mired in drug addiction. She’s abusive. She’s impulsive with men and clearly has trauma and mental health issues. Adams chews all of the scenery. She plays every angle to the hilt, which becomes a bit much to take.

The other pillar in J.D.’s life is Mamaw as played by Glenn Close. Close has the wig and make-up to transform her into the chain-smoking, Terminator loving matriarch. Close moves and speaks in a way that helps her embody the character and attempt to make the “hillwoman” more than a caricature. Close is more successful in her portrayal than Adams as she strikes the right tones and gets the inspiring, emotional touches needed to ground the movie. Unfortunately for both Adams and Close, their scene partners who play the teenage and adult J.D. are flat and uninspired, which drags down each of their scenes.

In fact, the J.D. character just solidifies how blandly generic Hillbilly Elegy feels. J.D. should not be the main character of the film since he is the least interesting aspect of the story. I can’t tell if it is the poor writing of the character or the lackluster performances by Gabriel Basso and Owen Asztalos, as adult and young J.D., respectively, that make him so blah. It’s probably failures on both ends – on top of the fact that his arc is in no way compelling.

While there is merit to this story, the focus of Hillbilly Elegy is misplaced. Glenn Close makes her scenes emotional and engaging, but the rest of the movie is either over-the-top or bland. It is a worthy experience, but other than Close, I wouldn’t say award-worthy. Grab a handful of kettle corn and judge for yourself.… Expand
1 of 6 users found this helpful15
All this user's reviews
5
jzermenoNov 24, 2020
This is a very poignant depiction of middle America that is not usually portrayed on the big screen. At a time when there is so much division in this country, this film reminds us that the struggle to survive and thrive is something that weThis is a very poignant depiction of middle America that is not usually portrayed on the big screen. At a time when there is so much division in this country, this film reminds us that the struggle to survive and thrive is something that we can all relate to. This isn’t just JD Vance’s story. This is the story of so many Americans (in every class, culture or religion) who have had to endure the hardships of growing up in poor America. It’s a reality that is shared by so many. Amy Adam’s breaks my heart with her portrayal of Bev. I love Mamaw. I never knew a woman like this in my life; but I wish I had. Glenn Close gives us an Oscar worthy performance.… Expand
1 of 6 users found this helpful15
All this user's reviews
4
JLuis_001Dec 4, 2020
It would be truly sad and miserable if both Amy Adams and Glenn Close get the Oscar nomination and the award for this film, because I'm not gonna say they have done a bad job, but this is the typical kind of exploitative and manipulative filmIt would be truly sad and miserable if both Amy Adams and Glenn Close get the Oscar nomination and the award for this film, because I'm not gonna say they have done a bad job, but this is the typical kind of exploitative and manipulative film who specifically seeks for that, and neither actress deserves it. On Ron Howard's part, this film is as uneven as it has been his entire career.… Expand
1 of 7 users found this helpful16
All this user's reviews
4
tropicAcesNov 11, 2020
Well-acted, but thats about it. It screams Oscar-bait, and is just simply way too disjointed
1 of 9 users found this helpful18
All this user's reviews
8
TBallDec 23, 2020
Surprise. Another film that critics hated because it has a conservative POV. If you don't blame society for all woes and vote Democrat, I CAN"T HEAR YOU! Glenn Close, Amy Adams and Gabriel Basso are all tremendous in their roles.
0 of 1 users found this helpful01
All this user's reviews
7
namelessJan 2, 2021
An imperfect but good movie. It is worth your time. The negative reviews from critics are much more about the biases they brought than the movie they saw. The acting is incredible. For Amy Adams to play this role took a lot of courage becauseAn imperfect but good movie. It is worth your time. The negative reviews from critics are much more about the biases they brought than the movie they saw. The acting is incredible. For Amy Adams to play this role took a lot of courage because it is not a likable character. Yes, it is imperfect, the screen adaptation from the book is not very good but the story will resonate.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
7
Brent_MarchantFeb 13, 2021
It may have its flaws, but this domestic drama with a twist is far from the cinematic debacle that most reviewers have labeled it, making me wonder what film they watched and/or what agenda they may have. This story of a family withIt may have its flaws, but this domestic drama with a twist is far from the cinematic debacle that most reviewers have labeled it, making me wonder what film they watched and/or what agenda they may have. This story of a family with Appalachian roots with a history of crises has been unfairly called boring (far from it) and cliched (something that's hard to imagine, given that it's based on a fact-based memoir), attributes that, because of issues with its writing and editing, are only partially deserved at best. To be sure, the "hillbilly" aspect of the story could have been better developed, the intercutting of the flashback and contemporary sequences could have been handled better, and the dialogue could have used retooling in some scenes. However, there are heartfelt sentiments aplenty here, not to mention the outstanding performances of Amy Adams and, especially, Glenn Close, award contenders in a number of competitions. Don't buy into the bashing that's been happening with this release; it's patently undeserved.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
3
MattBrady99Aug 12, 2021
Man, Amy Adams and Glenn Close really want that Oscar that they will star in something like 'Hillbilly Elegy'.

A shallow, predicable, and the most obvious "Oscar bait" movie ever made. However, it's not the worst thing ever despite what someMan, Amy Adams and Glenn Close really want that Oscar that they will star in something like 'Hillbilly Elegy'.

A shallow, predicable, and the most obvious "Oscar bait" movie ever made. However, it's not the worst thing ever despite what some people have said. Nothing captures the human struggle of lower-class people than rich celebrities, who think they have a gasp on reality, but after filming has finished, they go back to their rich lives until the next million-dollar role comes to them. If you're going to make a movie around this type of topic, you better get it right.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
8
twall3May 21, 2022
I'd seen the trailer a few times and found it uncomfortable. Last night when my wife and I were trying to decide what to watch, we decided to look for something that did more than entertain us. If we're going to sit still and do nothing for 2I'd seen the trailer a few times and found it uncomfortable. Last night when my wife and I were trying to decide what to watch, we decided to look for something that did more than entertain us. If we're going to sit still and do nothing for 2 hours, we want to be inspired when it's done. When I saw that Ron Howard directed it, I decided to give it a chance. It was uncomfortable at times, but also engrossing and likable. Near the end we were rewarded by a very cool, clear picture of what it looks like to climb out of a life that's going nowhere and redirect it. It was also an interesting glimpse of family looking out for each other. Glenn Glose's character was terrific. The adult lead male actor was very natural and likeable. Amy Adams brought great realism to a troubled character. Very happy we watched it. Thank you Ron Howard, the terrific actors and all involved to make this film-watching experience possible!… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
7
manningn15Mar 1, 2021
Hillbilly Elegy was not a perfect movie by any means but there were some excellent parts of this movie. Glenn Close and Amy Adams performances were exceptional, some of the best of the year. Gabriel Basso, Haley Bennett, and Owen AsztalosHillbilly Elegy was not a perfect movie by any means but there were some excellent parts of this movie. Glenn Close and Amy Adams performances were exceptional, some of the best of the year. Gabriel Basso, Haley Bennett, and Owen Asztalos gave pretty great performances as well. The makeup and hairstyling especially on Glenn Close and Amy Adams was remarkable. The costumes were pretty great as well. The writing was decent, the screenplay was pretty funny at times but others times it seemed over the top and cheesy specifically certain phrases Glenn Close said and the story was ok but didn't seem to tell the story clearly enough. Overall his was a pretty entertaining movie that made me laugh but also had very deep emotional moments.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
2
Mauro_LanariDec 2, 2020
(Mauro Lanari)
If they give the Oscar for the number of screamed, exaggerated, exasperated consecutive big scenes, this time Howard wins for I don't know how many years in a row.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
10
M10MessiDec 30, 2020
I don’t understand the critic reviews. Perhaps because of the fact that their lives that have no relation nor awareness of these types of lives. Regardless, the movie is heart wrenching and a good look in the lives of some in the AppalachianI don’t understand the critic reviews. Perhaps because of the fact that their lives that have no relation nor awareness of these types of lives. Regardless, the movie is heart wrenching and a good look in the lives of some in the Appalachian region.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
10
BarnabyTaylorNov 19, 2020
Raw but honest and emotional. Very realistic fir lots of people in the region. Glenn Close and Amy Adams really nailed it
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
10
p_moonNov 27, 2020
Glenn Close’s performance lingers in memory. This is already worth watching this movie. She really deserves the Oscar this year! Forget the “overdue” thing they say about Glenn, it is absolutely insulting to her immaculate career. Glenn CloseGlenn Close’s performance lingers in memory. This is already worth watching this movie. She really deserves the Oscar this year! Forget the “overdue” thing they say about Glenn, it is absolutely insulting to her immaculate career. Glenn Close is the best. Each performance is usually a blast. This one is not different!… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
10
achiintoDec 24, 2020
At least in this year, while staying at home and not many choices to entertain myself, this has been the only movie I enjoyed watching. The acting from the casts was very natural to me, and the story was intense and meaningful. It was a joy to watch.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
9
BlueSky21Dec 25, 2020
Audience scores are nearly spot on in their rating. I think it’s debatable to be anywhere from a 7.5 through a 9.0. I tend to score it higher due to the excellent performances from the whole cast and how consistently strong the tone heldAudience scores are nearly spot on in their rating. I think it’s debatable to be anywhere from a 7.5 through a 9.0. I tend to score it higher due to the excellent performances from the whole cast and how consistently strong the tone held throughout. With a movie like this (that has frequent flashbacks) it can be extremely challenging to maintain the tone, but the editing team did a remarkable job in my opinion. The critic reviews though...waaaay off. I read through more than a few and most of the criticisms aren’t valid at all. But then again, I don’t think critic opinions carry a fraction of the weight that they used too. In all, if you found the trailer interesting this is an excellent watch.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
10
RashadaDec 30, 2020
Raw and unfiltered, this movie shines a light on a boy who overcame a legacy of poverty and drug addiction. The acting, especially of Owen Asztalos, is outstanding as the narrative doesn't shy away from intense and difficult emotion.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
10
ZrayishDec 31, 2020
A great story about trials and what it takes to find success in hard circumstances. A painful and inspiring story about an underrepresented demographic group.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
9
megomikeFeb 19, 2021
At the end of the day, we are all a product of our family. Hillbilly Elegy explores the impact of a family on the past, present and future of a young man with potential. J.D. is called back to his humble hometown in Ohio when his mother,At the end of the day, we are all a product of our family. Hillbilly Elegy explores the impact of a family on the past, present and future of a young man with potential. J.D. is called back to his humble hometown in Ohio when his mother, Bev, suffers a setback in her life. Throughout the film we see how Bev’s influence on her family has stunted her own life, put her children frequently at risk, and extended her own mother’s matriarchal duties. Faced with the unlikelihood that his mother will ever change, J.D. must decide how much he must sacrifice in his own life in order to perpetuate hers. Hillbilly Elegy is written by Vanessa Taylor (The Shape of Water) based on the book by J.D. Vance. It is directed by Ron Howard (Apollo 13, A Beautiful Mind, and, of course, Opie). It stars Amy Adams (Arrival, American Hustle) as Bev, and Glenn Close (Fatal Attraction, 101 Dalmatians) as Mamaw in an Oscar-worthy supporting role. The role of J.D. is played as an adult by Gabriel Basso (Super 8) and an emotionally thoughtful performance as young J.D. by Owen Asztalos (Jessica Jones, Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Long Haul). J. D. is called home by his sister as his mother relapses into drug use, after many years of sobriety. The timing is unfortunate, as J. D., escaping the stereotype of his upbringing, is on the verge of accepting an Ivy League paid internship, which he needs to continue to pay for his remaining education. All he has to do is ace one of a number of interviews that are occurring just as his mother is falling back into addiction. And while J. D. acknowledges that his early years in Kentucky, then Ohio, were some of the happiest of his life, it is these moments that he has had to rise above all throughout. And we are shown that at many points throughout the movie, different people have had to take up slack where others were falling. But that’s exactly what family is, as this film defines. Hillbilly Elegy asks and answers the question: How much do we owe our mothers, and how deep does the debt lead. The answer is not simple, but winds around to what is best for everyone, as is often true with most families. Ron Howard will be cheated of an Oscar nomination within a crowded field, for a beautiful work well executed. Amy Adams will be on a lot of short lists for the honest portrayal of a lost lonely mom standing in her own way. Both Basso and Asztalos are remarkably sharp in playing a subtly angry and torn J. D. Vance, on whose life this film is based. But Glenn Close is a miracle playing Mamaw in an authentic turn of a present-day hillbilly, neither contrived nor satirical. Her message is the most important of the hillbilly: Family comes first, a creed she follows at all stages of life. When it comes to Academy voting, Close should come first in the Best Supporting Actress category and finally come home with an Oscar. Hillbilly Elegy has a lot of layers, but I recommend to anyone that will enjoy a sweet story about how families fail, yet affect us all in ways that allow us to succeed beyond the scars. I give Hillbilly Elegy 4.5/5 Stars for the story, the message, and one of the strongest acting ensembles in the category this year.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
9
Ebony1Jan 20, 2021
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I really enjoyed this movie. I’ve watched it three times! Once was while I was alone so I could have a good cry. The things I disliked was there wasn’t very much backstory on JD and his sisters relationships with each actor and while you could tell there was supposed to be a strong bond between the siblings I felt like it could’ve just shown more history. More history of the entire story would be so interesting. This story seems like it has many nooks and crannies that could have been explored, however this is Hollywood and it’s for profit so they’re only interested in a short story/history, big scene, “fixing” things and then, something to learn. A lesson. This could’ve done better in some areas but overall I suggest it to people and like I said, I’ve watched it three times and each time I notice something different and I get all in my feels. Maybe a part 2? Maybe a series? Loved Mamaw. Amy Adams was amazing. Young JD seemed to have gotten the nail on the head. AND WOW!!! I didn’t realize how many people would use words like “smarmy”, “woe is me”, “shameless Oscar bait” when describing this movie. I feel like people hate what they may never have or experience or people hate because they have suffered as well. No one’s story is more or less important than this one. We all have experienced totally different scenarios. We may even have siblings, parents and friends that experienced the same thing at the same time but your thoughts and memories aren’t going to be the same. But neither would be wrong. I just don’t understand bashing someone’s heartfelt story telling... LIFE TELLING, makes anyone feel good. We should try to lift each other up.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
prev
Page:
More From This Movie

38 Critic Reviews

7.5 User Reviews

Details & Credits|Trailers

Current Movie Releases
By MetascoreBy User Score
1 81 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple
2 77 Project Hail Mary
3 75 Send Help
4 73 Hoppers
5 72 The Sheep Detectives
SEE ALL
Essential Links
New on Amazon Prime Video
New on Netflix
Coming Soon to DVD/Blu-ray
SEE ALL