Gone Girl

1

mbbharley1Oct 20, 2014

One of the stupidist movies I have ever seen besides "Dumb and Dumber"! I should have known as the book was ridiculous as well {thought I would give the movie the benefit of the doubt}, and if that is what people consider good literature, noOne of the stupidist movies I have ever seen besides "Dumb and Dumber"! I should have known as the book was ridiculous as well {thought I would give the movie the benefit of the doubt}, and if that is what people consider good literature, no wonder the nation is going down the tubes! People were actually laughing at the absurdity of it!!… Expand

6 of 8 users found this helpful62

All this user's reviews

8

BradySmithOct 20, 2014

This was a very, very good movie. Fincher is a master of style, and he knows how to make almost any material absorbing, and sometimes even electrifying. The cinematography, acting, music, and plot are all first rate. I felt like I wasThis was a very, very good movie. Fincher is a master of style, and he knows how to make almost any material absorbing, and sometimes even electrifying. The cinematography, acting, music, and plot are all first rate. I felt like I was viewing something destined to become some sort of classic. That being said, I didn't find it flawless. Something about it felt somewhat artificial, there were some pretty dirty scenes, and the ending greatly disappointed me. It's still probably one of the best thrillers of the past couple of years though, and that definitely counts as high recommendation coming from me. Oscar season has officially begun.… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

9

NerdConsultantOct 20, 2014

i loved this film there was a few plot holes but if you can get around that (and it is easy to get around) it is a movie that will keep you guessing and you really will not know where it will end up

Rosamund Pike should really be put upi loved this film there was a few plot holes but if you can get around that (and it is easy to get around) it is a movie that will keep you guessing and you really will not know where it will end up

Rosamund Pike should really be put up for best actress at the oscar and i'm looking forward to Ben Affleck playing Batman on the back of this film and Argo… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

1

BithersOct 19, 2014

Starts off as in interesting thriller, some good shots, and intro to the characters, but quickly turns into nonsense and predictability. There are lots of back in for which makes sense for the case, but it becomes one of the worst hollywoodStarts off as in interesting thriller, some good shots, and intro to the characters, but quickly turns into nonsense and predictability. There are lots of back in for which makes sense for the case, but it becomes one of the worst hollywood endings I've seen in years. I literally saw half a theater start to boooo and say are you kidding me.

I also think that the number of positive reviews is just hacked by the film business as I literally saw half a theater start to boooo and say are you kidding me at Sundance Kabuki. If if that audience dislikes it most audiences do to.… Expand

4 of 7 users found this helpful43

All this user's reviews

8

BshopOct 19, 2014

Played out like the book it was written off of I suppose.
Reminded me of a murder mystery/ crime book more than anything else. Also, had hints of those Dateline specials you see on TV late at night.
In summary, see it in theaters for moodPlayed out like the book it was written off of I suppose.
Reminded me of a murder mystery/ crime book more than anything else. Also, had hints of those Dateline specials you see on TV late at night.
In summary, see it in theaters for mood setting and presentation. Don't expect a date-type movie, it's more of a slow-moving thriller.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

0

MDQOct 19, 2014

Very predictable I knew in the begining it was her. I knew every step of the movie. NO surprises here. It could have been good with bettter writers. A movie does not take good to make millions. What a joke. I almost fell asleep in theVery predictable I knew in the begining it was her. I knew every step of the movie. NO surprises here. It could have been good with bettter writers. A movie does not take good to make millions. What a joke. I almost fell asleep in the beginning, and the scene where she was robbed was stupid. Hollywood making money off of garbage.… Expand

3 of 19 users found this helpful316

All this user's reviews

8

FranzHcriticOct 18, 2014

An extremely Fichereseque film; a stylish and polished nicely, with an inventive script to help it. The chemistry of Affleck and Pike is a must watch, and really keeps the film going, although I wouldn't sell the remaining cast so short. PikeAn extremely Fichereseque film; a stylish and polished nicely, with an inventive script to help it. The chemistry of Affleck and Pike is a must watch, and really keeps the film going, although I wouldn't sell the remaining cast so short. Pike is the main triumph, and Affleck, I hate to admit, falls not very far from blatantly wooden. Otherwise of a different male protagonist casting choice, the film succeeds in what it is; a no nonsense mystery thriller.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

7

EdeltraudOct 18, 2014

Entertaining enough, fun to see NPH in this role...I'm not a fan of Affleck so can't get excited about his performance and he's one of the main characters. The movie went on a little long for my tastes, could have wrapped at least 15-20 mins.Entertaining enough, fun to see NPH in this role...I'm not a fan of Affleck so can't get excited about his performance and he's one of the main characters. The movie went on a little long for my tastes, could have wrapped at least 15-20 mins. earlier. Good, not a masterpiece and if you miss at the cinema its a good get for Netflix this winter.… Expand

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

8

TVJerryOct 18, 2014

The apparent question is: Did a happily-married man (Ben Affleck) kill his wife (Rosamund Pike)? It's not long before the dark water gets very cloudy, even murky. What's really going on and who's actually involved? The performances are strongThe apparent question is: Did a happily-married man (Ben Affleck) kill his wife (Rosamund Pike)? It's not long before the dark water gets very cloudy, even murky. What's really going on and who's actually involved? The performances are strong and the pressure is constant. Director David Fincher has crafted a smart & slyly suspenseful investigation into love and deception on any number of levels.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

Mom23boysOct 17, 2014

Boring..... The word excruciating comes to mind.....it seemed like it would never end! Rosamund Pike was brilliant as Amy, but that was not enough for me. It did pick up towards the end ,but by then I was ready to go.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

potatoes351Oct 16, 2014

I went into Gone Girl with little understanding of what the film was actually about but with high expectations thanks to some good recommendations from both critics and friends. Gone Girl follows the story of Nick & Amy Dunne. After losingI went into Gone Girl with little understanding of what the film was actually about but with high expectations thanks to some good recommendations from both critics and friends. Gone Girl follows the story of Nick & Amy Dunne. After losing their jobs in the economic downturn and when Nick's mother is terminally diagnosed with breast cancer the newly-wed pair move to Missouri to look after her.
Taking place a small number of years after her death, Nick has become lazy and an irritation to Amy who in turn has grown tired of his new attitude and also hurt by her husbands affair with a student of his.
On their fifth wedding anniversary Nick returns home to find the house trashed and Amy gone, after contacting the police and forensic examination taking place Nick is accused of the murder of Amy, though no body is to be found.
Nick begins a journey to clear his name and find his wife, though what he uncovers is not quite as clear cut as he had hoped, but rather something quite sinister with several months of malicious thought and precise planning in order to execute.
David Fincher's adaptation of the 2012 novel of the same name is impeccable, much the same as his adaptation of Fight Club back in 1999. Thanks to some great directing, editing & a great soundtrack Gone Girl is dark, twisted, thrilling and keeps you guessing right until the end; everything a good mystery film should do.
Though the film comes in at 2 hours 30 minutes, it manages to keep you captivated for every single minute. Just make sure you're comfy, you're going to be there a while.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

3

pteraOct 16, 2014

I was very disappointed with this movie. It built the suspense quite well but then all of a sudden the characters began acting wildly out of character. One character who was portrayed as extremely intelligent in the beginning of the filmI was very disappointed with this movie. It built the suspense quite well but then all of a sudden the characters began acting wildly out of character. One character who was portrayed as extremely intelligent in the beginning of the film began acting as if they had suddenly had a frontal lobotomy. The other character who was portrayed as an ethical person suddenly lost all their moral sense. Perhaps something was missing in the film that was in the book, but I cannot see how the last third of the film realistically would have followed from the first, well-done (except for the very annoying music) 2/3 of the film. I was so disgusted by this turn of events that I made an account on meta critic so I could express just how disgusted I was! Don't waste your money!!!!… Expand

4 of 6 users found this helpful42

All this user's reviews

7

BrutalBran95Oct 16, 2014

fantasic film interesting well put together fantasic story one MASSIVE LET DOWN is WTF happened to the last 30 mins of the film the film just flopped and didnt make sence everything just magiclly worked out worst ending ive seen this yearfantasic film interesting well put together fantasic story one MASSIVE LET DOWN is WTF happened to the last 30 mins of the film the film just flopped and didnt make sence everything just magiclly worked out worst ending ive seen this year apart from the good film would watch again but wouldnt buy due to ending just killed film… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

8

tvhandyOct 15, 2014

Gone Girl is a wild thriller that takes you on a crazy journey of a marriage and the things people will do in the name of love. It's hard to imagine his film done by anyone other then David Fincher, just an absolute masterpiece, that grabsGone Girl is a wild thriller that takes you on a crazy journey of a marriage and the things people will do in the name of love. It's hard to imagine his film done by anyone other then David Fincher, just an absolute masterpiece, that grabs you in and takes you through an emotional journey from start to finish.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

7

analogkid280Oct 15, 2014

Well that was awkward. This thing just keeps getting weirder and weirder until the ending when you feel this strange feeling of ludicrousness flowing through your veins.

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

5

JamesLOct 15, 2014

I am a big Fincher fan but this film fell apart at the pivotal plot point. The problem was that there was never any viable alternatives to the two outcomes and once one outcome was eliminated, the remaining outcome became coical andI am a big Fincher fan but this film fell apart at the pivotal plot point. The problem was that there was never any viable alternatives to the two outcomes and once one outcome was eliminated, the remaining outcome became coical and implausible. Nobody was buying that ending. There was simply no payoff to the viewer in this film.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

9

beingryanjudeOct 13, 2014

Every once in a while, a film is able to live up to the yearlong hype that precedes its release. Gone Girl goes above and beyond. It's enthralling and epic. Rosamund Pike's performance as Amy Elliott will live on for years. I guarantee it.

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

KayleighLouOct 13, 2014

Absolutely loved this film! Kept me on the edge with constant twists throughout the story. A little disturbing in some scenes but clever storyline which keeps the audience gripped, left the cinema feeling very satisfied!

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

9

MattyiceOct 13, 2014

If I could give Gone Girl an 8.5, I would. Gone Girl proved to be worth my money and time over my weekend. There are a lot of good things about the movie, but the main thing that kept me engaged throughout the entire film was the plot. TheIf I could give Gone Girl an 8.5, I would. Gone Girl proved to be worth my money and time over my weekend. There are a lot of good things about the movie, but the main thing that kept me engaged throughout the entire film was the plot. The sinister plot and multiple twists actually got me to say "Oh s**t" at several moments during the film, but the plot did have a couple of holes, but none of them were detrimental to the film. I wanted the kidnapping/revenge mystery to keep going on. In addition, the characters were performed very well by all. No actor/actress played their role badly and the development of these characters makes you feel for them even more. Overall, this film is definitely worth seeing right now.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

7

netflicOct 12, 2014

This is a crime mystery drama.

But it is more than that. It is an attempt to look at problems that many married couples have: financial problems, loss of work, infidelity, unhappiness. As a drama it does not really cut it but as aThis is a crime mystery drama.

But it is more than that. It is an attempt to look at problems that many married couples have: financial problems, loss of work, infidelity, unhappiness.

As a drama it does not really cut it but as a mystery the movie gets more interesting as it goes on. First, we see a line of events though HIS eyes. Then we see HER version of the same events. They are so dramatically different as two sides of the same coin.

I was not very happy with the lead performances.
On the other hand, supporting cast was excellent, and so was cinematography. A healthy doze of satire definitely makes watching the movie more enjoyable.

Overall for the entertaining value and the style I give it 7 out of 10.… Expand

5 of 7 users found this helpful52

All this user's reviews

7

AxgrinderOct 12, 2014

I didn’t love this movie, but I can’t dismiss it either. Ben Affleck stars as the husband, Nick, whose wife Amy (Rosamund Pike) has ‘disappeared’. The general public and most of the police think she is probably dead and that he has killedI didn’t love this movie, but I can’t dismiss it either. Ben Affleck stars as the husband, Nick, whose wife Amy (Rosamund Pike) has ‘disappeared’. The general public and most of the police think she is probably dead and that he has killed her. However, we (the audience) learn almost immediately that she has engineered her own disappearance. I’m not giving anything away by telling you that. The movie is about why she has left and resolving that situation.
Tension comes from the fact that we know Nick didn’t do it, but don’t really understand why he doesn’t seem to care all that much that his wife is missing. Nick’s public appeal for his wife’s return lacks any emotion or sincerity and everyone notices. Missy Pyle plays a TV commentator, who is a dead ringer for real life commentator Nancy Grace, and has a field day trying Nick’s case in the court of public opinion. Soon everyone hates Nick. One of his neighbors believes she has compelling evidence of Nick’s guilt and relentlessly tries to volunteer her information to the police. Unsatisfied with their uptake, she feels compelled to confront Nick with her ‘knowledge’ in a very public setting. Strangers emerge on the scene, like parasitic larva, seeking a vicarious thrill. Women show up to have their selfie taken with Nick. Hordes of people begin to patronize the quiet small town bar owned by Nick and Amy. Still, it’s hard to feel any sympathy for them. The more we learn about Nick and Amy the more there is to dislike about both of them.
Recently, there have been a lot of movies about dismal and depressing dystopian societies set in the relatively near future (such as Hunger Games, Divergent, and Her). What I found interesting about this movie is that it provides a window from which to view the dystopian elements of our present society as well as some of the more disturbing elements of our individual personas that could lead us down the path toward that sort of unpleasant future.
There are only three normal people in the whole movie: Nick’s twin sister Margo (Carrie Coon), police detective Rhonda Boney (Kim Dickens) and high-profile, celebrity defense attorney Tanner Bolt (Tyler Perry). The most depressing part of the movie comes when Margo and Boney ultimately recognize that they are completely impotent in affecting behaviors or outcomes. Bolt seems to have come to this same conclusion sometime in the past, but sees it all a game. The most memorable line in the movie is given by Bolt when, with a chuckle, he tells Nick that, “You two are the most f**ked up people I’ve ever met.”
Around the two hour mark, the movie has a “Carrie” moment, where Amy returns home drenched in blood. It was shortly at this point where I thought Gillian Flynn’s story started losing all believability (and I started losing interest) as Nick’s character undergoes a total transformation (from complete jerk to total wimp) and the public gets fooled by Amy for a second time.
My final conclusion: At 2½ hours, this movie is just too darn long.… Expand

3 of 5 users found this helpful32

All this user's reviews

0

JMaryOct 12, 2014

I do NOT recommend the movie Gone Girl. If I knew how bad it was I would not
have gone to see it. It was mostly suspense and held the attention in that way, however
it is really dark, and there was one particularly violent and disgustingI do NOT recommend the movie Gone Girl. If I knew how bad it was I would not
have gone to see it. It was mostly suspense and held the attention in that way, however
it is really dark, and there was one particularly violent and disgusting scene. You want
to avoid having that in your mind forever. It did hold my attention, but not for good reasons.
It was bizarre and frightening and damaging to the soul. Don’t go.… Expand

6 of 39 users found this helpful633

All this user's reviews

5

MJRMD1Oct 12, 2014

Did no one have any control over the novelist/screenwriter? If they had only dropped the whole Neil Patrick Harris sub-plot, it would have been (still trashy/lurid, but) a much tighter and better-made film.
On the plus side, many remindersDid no one have any control over the novelist/screenwriter? If they had only dropped the whole Neil Patrick Harris sub-plot, it would have been (still trashy/lurid, but) a much tighter and better-made film.
On the plus side, many reminders of Hitchcock, Gus Van Sant and DePalma.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

5

pryankeeOct 11, 2014

What is the heck was that ending? The movie goes on so long, it could have had 2 separate movies but add a little more details in different situations and they could have been good. Half way through would have been good given the set up ofWhat is the heck was that ending? The movie goes on so long, it could have had 2 separate movies but add a little more details in different situations and they could have been good. Half way through would have been good given the set up of the movie, but then it kept going.......and going.....with no real pay off for why it kept going. And they completely wasted the Barney Stinson/Controlling Boyfriend character. Like, gimme a break. It starts off really good but the last half ruins it… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

8

SpangleOct 11, 2014

Damn, Gone Girl really ropes you in and does not let go until the final bell tolls, which is very impressive for a film that is two and a half hours long. At really no point does it lag and while it is certainly very slow at times, it neverDamn, Gone Girl really ropes you in and does not let go until the final bell tolls, which is very impressive for a film that is two and a half hours long. At really no point does it lag and while it is certainly very slow at times, it never becomes boring and leaves you hanging on the edge of your seat for much of it. Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike are stellar here, as are Neil Patrick Harris and (oddly) Tyler Perry. The cast, on paper, seemed odd, but in practice, David Fincher shows why he is one of the best around and got the best out of everybody. The general feel and mood of the film is also brilliant and entirely chilling. However, beyond the whole murder mystery type deal, the most interesting part to me here was the total indictment of the media and the 24 hour news cycle, which Fincher does a great job showcasing throughout and how the media will believe just about anything and then jump to conclusions based off of what small information they may have. The twists and turns here are also very interesting and the script from Gillian Flynn is very strong. The way the story was told at times was odd, but that would be my only complaint really and it was nothing major. As a whole, this is certanly not Fincher's best work (Seven, Fight Club, and Zodiac, would be my top three from him), but it is certainly not his worst (excluding Alien 3) and is overall, a very well made, well acted thriller that will leave you wanting more. Would be surprised if Affleck and Pike are not major contenders at the Oscars.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

3

DirkVOct 11, 2014

the last 45 minutes are so preposterous that it wipes out the memory of the great performances and stylish production that come before. It becomes laughably silly, so that the film morphs from a semi-gripping who dunnit drama into a bit of a joke.

7 of 10 users found this helpful73

All this user's reviews

2

GlorywarOct 11, 2014

Found myself checking my watch in the first hour. Slow to start. Affleck's acting seemed like he was sleepwalking. Seen him do better. Guessed the surprises. Was neither in suspense or connected to this film. What a letdown.

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

10

ericisadogOct 10, 2014

Movie Review: Gone Girl
Directed by: David Fincher (The Social Network, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Fight Club)
Starring: Ben Affleck, Rosamund Pike, Neil Patrick Harris, Tyler Perry By Justin Madore One of the most prominent andMovie Review: Gone Girl
Directed by: David Fincher (The Social Network, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Fight Club)
Starring: Ben Affleck, Rosamund Pike, Neil Patrick Harris, Tyler Perry

By Justin Madore

One of the most prominent and distinguished directors in Hollywood, David Fincher, returns to theaters this October to kick off awards season with Gone Girl, the slick, darkly humorous, murder mystery based off the bestselling book of the same name. Fincher brings his A game, with impeccable casting, his signature cinematography, and a deliciously disturbing tale of revenge, anger, laziness, narcissism, betrayal, and manipulation. The screenplay (written by the books author, Gillian Flynn) examines the hardships of marriage and sensationalism of the media in ways that, while not groundbreaking, ultimately are constructed incredibly well by a fantastic cast of interesting and relatable characters.
Gone Girl Trailer

Tragedy and misery has never before been so enjoyable. Continuing his hot-streak, Ben Affleck stars as Nick Dunne, whose wife (Rosamund Pike) mysteriously disappears on their fifth wedding anniversary. His sense of detachment in an increasingly perilous situation finds its way through the screen and manifests itself in the viewer, to the point where I oddly felt calm and detached myself. The character of Nick Dunne is that persuasive. His performance as a well off, self loathing, arrogant writer fits the bill perfectly. Opposite him, Rosamund Pike, the standout of the film, comes off as the cool, calculated, meticulous, and narcissistic wife. Her role had much more complexity that I believed there was based on marketing materials. The rest of the casting, while on paper may seem questionable (Tyler Perry seems like he’s trying to change his image at the moment), is perfect, and full of surprises.
From the opening shots, viewers will immediately recognize the style of director David Fincher. A shadowy dark blue tint encapsulates the screen, and wide shots of Dunne’s Missouri hometown are shown, interspersed with the credits. At this point, Fincher has become known for his intricate title sequences. His body of work reveals that he loves to revel in dark, tension filled murder mysteries (Zodiac, Seven, Girl with the Dragon Tattoo). While not his best film (that honor belongs to the incredible Social Network) overall, it is his best crime thriller, of which there are an abundance to choose from. While not quite as dark and twisted as his 2011 adaptation of Stieg Larsson’s über popular series, that is most definitely for the better. One of the best surprises of the film, is how often humor is interlaced in this decidedly bleak looking tale.
Prolific composer and frequent collaborator Trent Reznor graces his audience with another fantastic soundtrack, following his work in The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and The Social Network. The long, strung out cords creates an ruthlessly eerie mood, which helps perfect the tone and presentation of the film. The score is never too and is used sparingly to great effect.
DF-01826cc - Nick Dunne (Ben Affleck) finds himself the chief suspect behind the shocking disappearance of his wife Amy (Rosamund Pike), on their fifth anniversary.
Throughout most of the film, Nick Dunne is ruthlessly hounded by the media. He becomes a prime suspect in the disappearance of his wife, and for palpable reasons easy enough to understand for audience members. “Nick Dunne, you’re probably the most hated man in America right now” says the Nancy Grace character that Dunne agrees to be interviewed by to help clear his name. And he is the most hated man in America, not because he had been proven guilty, but because of the sensationalism present whenever a case like this happens. This point isn’t fiction, and it’s one of the valid, and strong points driven home by the script. People love to hate. I was reminded of one of the more famous trials in recent memory. Zimmerman v State of Florida. News coverage was vastly misleading, from editing of evidence, to misrepresentation of the subjects, to allegations of the shooting being a hate crime. It’s a strange phenomenon, but when you can make someone look really bad, people gobble it up. Although Zimmerman was ultimately acquitted of his second degree murder charge, I’m not advocating that either him or Trayvon Martin were certain types of people, and that’s the point. Both Nick and Amy Dunne are deeply flawed individuals, with their own sets of problems that they deal with away from the spotlight. While the ending is not maybe as ambiguous as one might hope, no one gets away scot free. There is a definitive villain revealed before the credits role.
Gone Girl impresses on every front. The presentation of the film is flawless. The score, cinematography, performances, create a sleek, atmospheric mood that suits the film fine. While I haven’t read the book, and therefore can’t speak for the quality of the adaption, what you find here is a fully fleshed out story, and I never once felt like anything was missing. The two and a half hour running time disappeared before my eyes. There are a astounding amount of onscreen clues for the attentive viewer, grabbing your attention, and fixing your eye on the screen. The ridiculousness of the plot at certain points, covered in layers of satire, are utterly intoxicating. This is a film for the engaged movie goer. About 40 minutes in, when the first twist presents itself, the hooks sink in, and they never come loose. Do yourself a favor and go see this one.

5 out of 5 Stars… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

7

dangerfarOct 10, 2014

A solid mystery/suspense thriller, Gone Girl keeps you guess up until the very end. Even when the cards are on the table it's not easy to see where the story will take you. Fincher masterfully brings the threads of the tale to tension 15A solid mystery/suspense thriller, Gone Girl keeps you guess up until the very end. Even when the cards are on the table it's not easy to see where the story will take you. Fincher masterfully brings the threads of the tale to tension 15 minutes in and holds that tension throughout the 2 and a half hour movie, rarely letting up or giving reprieve.

The performances of all involved are more than competent. The actors here are all more than capable of holding the suspense and adding their nuances. Nothing stand out here, no one should be getting any best actor/actress nominations, but they carry the movie well and keep outrageous characters mostly believable.

I say mostly because some turns are a bit difficult to stomach. Some character motivations and actions seem out of place, and there are a few fairly large plot holes that aren't explained, and presumably the viewer is just supposed to assume to chalk these up the "Well it's a movie, maybe they did this or this." I personally don't mind making these leaps sometimes. They make the movie less impressive, but don't completely ruin the experience, though I'm surprised they don't ruin it for more people.

There's also little substance here worth taking away. That isn't necessarily a bad thing, though a lot of the hype seemed to dress this movie up in thinking man's clothes, holding the promise for some unmasking of life in some degree, or at least contemplation of it. However once the movie stripped to its core it was revealed to be just another suspense thriller. Certainly carefully crafted with unique and intriguing contours, and it performs its function of instilling doubt and unease throughout. But that is pretty much all that it's good for.… Expand

4 of 7 users found this helpful43

All this user's reviews

0

wood4055Oct 9, 2014

No spoilers here, only a warning..., stay away! This movie employs so many plot manipulations that border on the absurd only to be followed by the moronic. The actors are forced into playing characters ranging from imbeciles to embarrassinglyNo spoilers here, only a warning..., stay away! This movie employs so many plot manipulations that border on the absurd only to be followed by the moronic. The actors are forced into playing characters ranging from imbeciles to embarrassingly stupid. It's amazing and sadly disappointing to be living in a world where the majority of movie goers likes this kind of movie. Think of Body Heat, take away the terrific plot, writing, acting and directing..., mix in a bit of Scary Movie (one or two, either way will do), and there you have it - a ridiculous movie pretending to be serious. Laughable if it wasn't so bad. I guess you can tell, I didn't like this movie.… Expand

7 of 18 users found this helpful711

All this user's reviews

2

RogerdobOct 9, 2014

This film has more plot holes than any other film I have seen in a long while. Events transpire that are seemingly quite unlikely to happen. The story only moves forward because the writer wills it forward. Ben Affleck gave an uninspiringThis film has more plot holes than any other film I have seen in a long while. Events transpire that are seemingly quite unlikely to happen. The story only moves forward because the writer wills it forward. Ben Affleck gave an uninspiring performance...he was not acting...he was just being Ben Affleck. Neil Patrick Harris was badly miscast (due to his decision to publicize his lifestyle) as a heterosexual stalker. The film could have edited out about 30-45 minutes of its 2 1/2 hours running time...there were many, many scenes that were unnecessary that did nothing to advance he story.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

9

sammurphy66Oct 8, 2014

Visually stylish and narratively sound, Gone Girl boasts not only some fantastic performances, but one of the most engaging story lines strengthened by a colossal plot twist.

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

jstein1992Oct 8, 2014

This movie was downright incredible. This may just be my new favorite David Fincher movie. The movie is a fantastic adaptation of Flynn's novel. It makes it even better that she wrote the script as well. Her script combined with Fincher'sThis movie was downright incredible. This may just be my new favorite David Fincher movie. The movie is a fantastic adaptation of Flynn's novel. It makes it even better that she wrote the script as well. Her script combined with Fincher's dark and visually stunning directing style makes for an incredible mystery drama. As I said this movie looks beautiful. The cinematography and lighting are both excellently done. The writing contains a surprising yet fitting amount of humor. The narrative unravels in an intelligent and unique manner. The acting in this film is top notch. Everyone in this movie was truly outstanding. Rosamund Pike is the standout performance here though. She absolutely becomes the character of Amy Dunne. She is on point with every single thing she does in the movie. Affleck's performance as Nick Dunne has to be touched upon as well. His character is very mysterious and unclear in his motives. His awkward personality causes people to become suspicious of him throughout the movie. This awkwardness is something that Affleck does excellently. This movie touches on themes of marriage, social norms, economic hardships, and the behavior of the media; all these themes are brilliantly intertwined throughout the movie's narrative. Gone Girl is strangely hilarious, intriguing, and disturbing. It is a perfect movie.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

8

simonnOct 7, 2014

Gripping film, with good performances all round, a few good twists, but a slightly disappointing ending. Affleck/Pike are both very good in this. The soundtrack is also a star of the show, not intrusive, but pitched just perfectly.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

0

TheDavoOct 7, 2014

Dreadful Hollywood crap. Completely unbelievable. I don't know how something this bad gets made. I realize it is full of faces people will recognize but it is still crap.

6 of 25 users found this helpful619

All this user's reviews

2

seastarOct 7, 2014

Oh, so disappointing! Bad lighting, bad sound, story interesting but the ending was crap. What a waste of time and money. Don't know how it got any good reviews.

2 of 11 users found this helpful29

All this user's reviews

4

Eilidh2Oct 7, 2014

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The reviews were so good. This year's movies have been so terrible (with a couple of exceptions). I was so hoping this would be great - though suspected it wouldn't as the source book was truly third-rate.

Fincher improves on the book (not difficult) with a beautiful film. The Emperor has beautiful clothes but the story itself? More plot holes than a spaghetti sieve. And the character of Amy? Obviously neither the writer nor Fincher has ever met a person with mental illness. Amy's unbelievable characteristics seem to be based on the study of crazy people as portrayed on daytime soaps.

Such a disappointment and would critics start to criticize their "hero" directors when they make inferior pulp like this?… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

5

HucksterOct 7, 2014

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This film would score higher except for the weak and disappointing ending. The film looks good and throws lots of red herrings to create an interesting mystery. Along the way, you're not sure who did what, and the flashbacks suggest a particular outcome. Up to a certain point it is mysterious if not very slow. Then it becomes a bit clever and intricate as details emerge. The third act at the lake house is surprising, compelling and confronting. But the final sequence reeks. There are so many loose ends which would deliver justice but none are explored or even acknowledged. For a film with good potential and even better word of mouth, this is ultimately a disappointment.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

10

batlantern_87Oct 7, 2014

I don't usually give 10 out of 10 but this is pure movie making perfection! The direction is flawless, the acting is nuanced and amazing, and music is electric. Every frame of this movie is perfect! I loved the book but for the first timeI don't usually give 10 out of 10 but this is pure movie making perfection! The direction is flawless, the acting is nuanced and amazing, and music is electric. Every frame of this movie is perfect! I loved the book but for the first time ever a movie has surpassed the book!… Expand

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

10

NightReviewsOct 7, 2014

“Everyone told us and told us, marriage is hard work”.

Gone Girl is the one film that will embed itself permanently in your psyche. A bold statement, to say the least, but it is the only statement that comes close to describing the“Everyone told us and told us, marriage is hard work”.

Gone Girl is the one film that will embed itself permanently in your psyche. A bold statement, to say the least, but it is the only statement that comes close to describing the frightening physiological paradigm created by suspense maestro Divid Fincher. Emotionally charged, disturbed and at times simply terrifying, Fincher’s analysis of what can go wrong with contemporary marriage is the ultimate battle of the sexes and search for answers; whether right, wrong, or completely unexpected.

An adaption of the widely sought-after 2012 novel by Gillian Flynn, Gone Girl paints a bloody portrait of battle between husband and wife Nick and Amy Dunne (Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike) that asks the question asked by many who’ve had a relationship fall apart before their eyes: how much do you really know about your partner?

Contrary to its appearance courtesy of the narratively manipulating and heavily contrived editing and fragmented storytelling, the real issues in Nick and Amy’s marriage begin long before either of them even meet. Amy, who is introduced as the atypical yet very real trust-fund baby, lives most of her life steps behind her fictional alter-ego “Amazing Amy”, a character in a children’s series authored by her parents, Rand and Marybeth Elliot (David Clennon and Lisa Banes). Nick (Affleck) may very well portray himself as the perfect man. A writer for a men’s magazine, Nick finds himself at a yuppie party in the lower-east side of Manhattan before bumping into Amy, where he charms his way into her heart by confessing how he thought quinoa was a type of fish. The two depart the party where Nick leads Amy behind a bakery, the air glistening with sugar flakes, until the moment he kisses the specs of refined white power off her lips, the two perfect lovers fall in love.

But like everything that seems too good too be true, their magic doesn’t last. Both suffering in their relationship from the failed American economy and Nick’s ailing mother, Nick must pick-up his picturesque wife and life in urban New York City, and relocate to his Mid-Western hometown of North Carthage, Missouri. With the passing of Nick’s mother and his father’s admittance to the local nursing home for treatment of his Alzheimer’s, the couple is burdened with financial woes, prompting Nick and his quick-mouthed twin sister Margo (the fantastic Carrie Coon) to open a bar, perfectly named ‘The Bar’. Coming home to Amy for their fifth wedding anniversary, Nick drives into his perfect “McMansion” home and ideal wife, only to find the cat on the driveway, a wide opened front door, and Amy no-where in sight.

While many will spoil so much of what the film has to offer, it is best you go into it with a completely untainted opinion regardless if you’ve read the novel or not. Fincher and Flynn offer a completely revitalized reincarnation of Flynn’s novel with many layers, twists and turns, and most of all questions.

Fincher has given himself quite the reputation as a noble successor to Hitchcock, mastering the art of Hitchcockian thrillers and suspense. From Fight Club, to his highly stylized American interpretation of The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo, Fincher has become the most consistent American director working today. Staying true to his ominous and truly septic vision, faithfully collaborating with editor Kirk Baxter, cinematographer Jeff Cronenweth and music with Oscar winners Atticus Ross and Trent Reznor, Fincher is a meticulously relevant cinematic auteur who knows how to deliver in a tonal, visual, and deep subliminal forum that has quickly become his signature. Trying to ignore big set pieces, he goes to the most basic scenes in all films: two people seated in a room having a conversation. Fincher’s greatest cinematic tool is his focus on information, buried in the revelations between characters and their conflicts expressed in their dialogue. Exposition is his greatest asset, with drama driven by audience reaction to a character’s divulgence of new information—and Gone Girl is a testament to this.

While Gone Girl becomes the most sadistic cinematic version of he-said/she-said outside the walls of a courtroom, the film is pillared perfectly by its cast as well as its crew. Ben Affleck’s interpretation of Nick Dunne draws fine lines of empathy and calmness, as well as unhappiness and deception for his wife and the people in his mundane, quickly shattering life. Nick’s character, charming throughout the first act of the film, like any other man, shares his concerns about marital life, self-image, and the mistakes he makes as a man and as a husband. Affleck has never been better; yet, the next Caped Crusader isn’t the true runaway star of Gone Girl.… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

6

gfnyOct 7, 2014

The movie started out well and was entertaining and a solid 80, but the 2nd half was a disappointment and the story line started to lose credibility and dropped to a 50. A shorter movie with one story line would have been better. Overall IThe movie started out well and was entertaining and a solid 80, but the 2nd half was a disappointment and the story line started to lose credibility and dropped to a 50. A shorter movie with one story line would have been better. Overall I would give the movie a 65. I enjoyed it but was somewhat disappointed.… Expand

7 of 9 users found this helpful72

All this user's reviews

10

MJKPSTANOct 6, 2014

In my opinion, Gone girl is the best film of the year so far. It is complex, it is creepy, it is satirical, it is some of Fincher's best work.

The cinematography is beautiful, the performances are perfection ( Especially Rosamund Pike ).In my opinion, Gone girl is the best film of the year so far. It is complex, it is creepy, it is satirical, it is some of Fincher's best work.

The cinematography is beautiful, the performances are perfection ( Especially Rosamund Pike ). But my one big problem with the film is, Neil patrick harris. Not that he was bad he was actually very good but it was his character that was the problem. Quite an underwritten character, but the character served a major purpose and that makes me forgive the film.

9.610. Just brilliant.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

4

amboyOct 6, 2014

Noir has to be believable at some level, and darkness should not extend to near invisibility. The film wears its trashiness like a caste mark--let's show the middle classes what gore and sex is all about. And then the film suddenly thinksNoir has to be believable at some level, and darkness should not extend to near invisibility. The film wears its trashiness like a caste mark--let's show the middle classes what gore and sex is all about. And then the film suddenly thinks it's saying something about marriage, society, human nature. Hitchcock--are you kidding?! The master had finesse--this just has pretension and gall.… Expand

8 of 12 users found this helpful84

All this user's reviews

9

mbeckfordOct 6, 2014

David Fincher has a fetish for taking complex novels of suspense and intrigue and turning them into delightfully dark and twisted tales that make damn good cinema. He did it with Fight Club and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, and he's nowDavid Fincher has a fetish for taking complex novels of suspense and intrigue and turning them into delightfully dark and twisted tales that make damn good cinema. He did it with Fight Club and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, and he's now done it with Gone Girl, the "it" novel of 2012.

Ostensibly a simple story of a wife that vanishes mysteriously under suspicious circumstances, it expertly weaves parallel and divergent narratives through multiple twists and alternative time-lines while skewering the "trial-by-the-media" culture and the real-life horrors of mid-life marriage angst.

Ben Affleck is perfectly cast as Nick Dunne, the protagonist/antagonist husband of the missing wife. The book/movie works so well because Affleck's character is very hard to pin down. He's flawed but like-able, clueless but clever. Rosamund Pike is excellent but to reveal more would be a spoiler.

Fincher even works magic with the minor characters. Who would have thought of Neil Patrick Harris as a creep-manipulative sad-sack stalker. Carry Coon, a standout in the HBO series The Leftovers, plays Nick's sister and the audience's voice of reason when you just want to scream "Nick, you freaking idiot!"

It's not always perfect. Affleck is obviously buffing up for his upcoming role as Batman with bulging shoulders/biceps that are juxtaposed in tight shirts with his character's slovenly "pot-belly." Another character goes from thin to over-weight in just a few days while trying to go incognito. It also seems to struggle to figure out how/when wrap things up.

These are all "nits" as the story churns in your head as the credits roll which is the true test of excellent film-making.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

6

Mike_MOct 6, 2014

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This is a difficult movie to rate because its strengths and weaknesses are tangled together. I have not read the book, and I'm reviewing the film as its own entity.

The movie’s worth seeing, if only because of the twists, the character of Amy, and the post-movie talking points that are meant to provoke a battle of the sexes debate.

I did enjoy Fincher branching out in a new direction, and I wouldn't say that it's the wrong direction for him as much as it was a difficult tone to hit for anyone. The movie sets out to mix melodrama, realistic satire and absurdism. Though I love weird tones and shifting tones, to me the tones in Gone Girl don't always land well or mix well.

Worse still, there’s inconsistent acting, and wobbly story logic. The movie isn’t deliberately unreal enough (whether absurd or dreamlike or mythic or farcical etc) to get away with the wobbly story logic.

I'm not sure the actors are always successful at staying in the same movie together, as mentioned by user-reviewer benutty. And Affleck (as A-lister personality actors often do) seems to be so intent on 'playing a character with a backbone' that it's basically frigid, unflinching acting where his 'character' doesn't really change or have an interior. We're left watching Affleck bring the role to himself so entirely that he's not really doing anything. It's just flat acting that has about the same tone all the way through. (And it's not unlike the frigidity that Casey Affleck has in Gone Baby Gone, directed by Ben Affleck) I think this is partly dismissible by the character's degree of narcissism and shallowness, but not entirely.

But… I have toyed around with the idea that Fincher and Flynn are jazzing around metafictionally here. I’m not convinced that they are, or that they did it well if intended. But at some point, two intelligent artists may have discussed how a man is to direct a woman’s novel/screenplay of this sort.

IF they baked a metafiction joke into it, the setup clearly runs through Affleck’s under-emoting, under-engaged acting that undermines the story, and through the way that nearly every story logic problem serves to make Amy more amazing. And the meta-joke, if there is one, only plays if you see the characters as puppets, more or less: The psychopathically overengaged, self-justified modern wife who gets to always be right, and the self-centered, resentful boy-husband who takes her just barely seriously enough to subtly manipulate back and stay alive.

Yet... I'm not sure I want to give Affleck the benefit of the doubt that his practically unchanging tone and lack of interior were all just a brilliant meta-joke.… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

9

LowbrowCinemaOct 6, 2014

GONE GIRL is simply extraordinary in every way. A masterful work that achieves high levels of art, pure twisty and wacky entertainment, plus a pretty serious meditation on marriage. The film is really three in one--act one is serious and ohGONE GIRL is simply extraordinary in every way. A masterful work that achieves high levels of art, pure twisty and wacky entertainment, plus a pretty serious meditation on marriage. The film is really three in one--act one is serious and oh so strong like a marvelous Lifetime move, then comes act two with film noir twists, and finally, the pitch perfect final act. GONE GIRL is truly David Fincher's best since FIGHT CLUB but unlike that important work, GONE GIRL never cops out. It ain't perfect though, act two is too long and weak compared to the opening and final sequences. The stunt casting of Tyler Perry and Neil Patrick Harris also doesn't pay off with neither giving particularly interesting performances. But all is redeemed by the strengths of GONE GIRL which include a superb screenplay and two stellar central performances. GONE GIRL is actually kind of indescribable. Just go see it and love it!… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

4

BusdrivermikeOct 5, 2014

There are some heavy hitting names on the screen, and behind the camera. But this is a plot not even worthy of a lifetime movie. The only believable character is the media savvy lawyer.

Seriously, NPH as a love interest? A woman goneThere are some heavy hitting names on the screen, and behind the camera. But this is a plot not even worthy of a lifetime movie. The only believable character is the media savvy lawyer.

Seriously, NPH as a love interest? A woman gone missing, who has the national spotlight, goes to a mall, and nobody notices her? Then Ben Affleck takes her back at the end? I dont want to spoil it too much, but the things that happen that the characters overlook is laughable.

Who does this stuff?

It is just a ridiculous plot. The movie has about the same basis in reality as Star Wars.

I wanted to watch this and like it. After "The Town" I made a point of seeing this because Ben Affleck and David Fincher. But it is just preposterous.… Expand

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

9

blazerXOct 5, 2014

It is a great movie, worth seeing, great cast (except for NPH, I don't think he really fit in on that role), and great acting (Rosamund Pike OMG!!!). It's not a cliche movie, it's truly unique and David Fincher did another great job.

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

9

francisrgoOct 5, 2014

Powerfully captivating and suspenseful movie of the year. The movie lead audiences to a full ride with twist and turns at every corner. Ben Affleck gave a great performance. Only flawed was Neil Patrick Harris playing his normal self Barney.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

7

jrodfilmsOct 5, 2014

so far, one of the most entertaining films of the year. great soundtrack, dark moody film, and sometimes funny. its pretty uneven as a whole movie, but each section was interesting it its own way.

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

9

aguyglobalOct 5, 2014

A very well made and disturbing film about how bad a long term marriage can potentially be. Rosamund Pike was truly menacing to watch, and Ben Affleck did an exceptional job as Nick Dunn.

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

9

PeteStaivOct 5, 2014

First legitimate contender for oscars picture if the year! The movie is 149 min long, but want more of it! Fantastic adaptation of the book! It has some flaws but overall its a masterpiece!

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

8

Filmwatcher123Oct 5, 2014

This movie was very entertaining and intense, but is not perfect. Ben Affleck as the main character Nick made for a relate-able and sympathetic main character as you begin to feel for and suspect him as he works through the situation he hasThis movie was very entertaining and intense, but is not perfect. Ben Affleck as the main character Nick made for a relate-able and sympathetic main character as you begin to feel for and suspect him as he works through the situation he has found himself in. For me the person who stands out most in this film is Rosamund Pike for reason i can't give without spoiling everything, but you'll have to trust me when i say that she was brilliant. The story itself was well thought out, well written and well paced making the 2hr 20mins run time entertaining and enjoyable for the most part. The reason i haven't given this film a 10 is because of the ending. Again without revealing anything i can't give specifics but there are a few things that don't add up and the reaction that the policewoman gives to the out come seems to be there just so the director could get the ending he wanted. That being said i would definitely watch the movie again for the suspense and brilliant writing in this film and if you are a fan of David Fincher's other work, then this film is a must see for you.… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

GustavoTalainiOct 5, 2014

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A busca pela vida, homem e casamento perfeitos são ambições de Amy Dunne, a “Incrível Amy”, a garota exemplar (Rosamund Pike).
Mas...
Ela desapareceu, e o principal suspeito é o seu marido Nick Dunne (Ben Affleck).
Falam que o livro é sempre melhor do que o filme, se isso for verdade Gone Girl de Gillian Flynn será imensamente prazeroso de se ler, sim eu ainda não li, mas já vou comprar, pois sua adaptação é majestosa.
Você irá se perguntar se a sua namorada é uma sociopata, se alguém está armando algo e mentindo nas suas costas entre outras tantas perguntas; David Fincher mostra novamente sua incrível e precisa direção, o tom de suspense do começo ao fim, as reviravoltas e a insanidade roubam a cena juntamente com atuações que fazem o cinema enlouquecer.
O grande número de voice-overs, a perfeita trilha sonora (é simplesmente sensacional tem momentos que os sons lembram um menu de vídeo game que está pronto para iniciar quando na verdade os protagonistas estão jogando um jogo da vida, literalmente isso, a vida real), bons personagens secundários(Carrie Coon está fenomenal como Margo Dunne)e uma esperta edição criam tenso e delicioso thriller composto por um clima de verdades e mentiras, conflitos, manipulações e competições entre os personagens.
Até mesmo um filme perturbador e sombrio tem seus momentos engraçados, neste caso o falso amor e até mesmo as cenas sádicas são muito divertidas e irônicas.
Ben Affleck marca seu ponto com sua ótima atuação, mas quem realmente se destaca é Rosamund Pike com sua brilhante, insana e assustadora performance que certamente chamará a atenção dos Oscars, não somente ela mas o filme já garantiu muitas indicações.
Vejam o mais rápido que puderem vocês não tem como se arrepender somente elogiar e, por favor, não tentem ser uma “garota exemplar”.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

MelkorMorgothOct 5, 2014

David Fincher has never quite disappointed me with any of his previous films, and this one is no exception. This hitchcock like mystery defies the viewers expectations again and again and executes every plot twist masterfully. the film alsoDavid Fincher has never quite disappointed me with any of his previous films, and this one is no exception. This hitchcock like mystery defies the viewers expectations again and again and executes every plot twist masterfully. the film also has an excellent cast; ben affleck does an excellent job portraying a border line idiotic average joe who becomes the prime suspect in his introverted wife's disappearance, this is a potentially career changing role for Rosamund Pike who plays Afflecks wife whose disappearance quickly spirals into the scrutinizing eyes of sensationalist media and even becomes a murder investigation , this film even made Tyler Perry look good! TYLER PERRY! the only issue i had with the film was that the final act felt a little sluggish and drawn out, otherwise this an intriguing and memorable mystery that you should definitely see… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

8

anshimanOct 5, 2014

What makes a cult classic? Picking up from Fight Club, it's almost like Fincher thought about this novel adaptation and thought, "Okay... how can I make that bigger? How can I make that better?" Being an artist of suspense of Hitchcock-ianWhat makes a cult classic? Picking up from Fight Club, it's almost like Fincher thought about this novel adaptation and thought, "Okay... how can I make that bigger? How can I make that better?" Being an artist of suspense of Hitchcock-ian proportions, Fincher engages us throughout with fist-balling mystery, moral ambiguity, worldly satires and a psychotically jumpy plot progression that mirrors the portrait of which it aims to be. Gone Girl is a treasure hunt that may have gone too long, and gotten too ahead of itself - but the overwhelming sense of dread and atmosphere is enough to tip me over to the other side. Rosamund Pike's performance is to the film as Ledger was to 'The Dark Knight', delivering the crisp, cold and sinister psychopath that takes a lot of the credit for pushing the story to its limits. Disturbing, engaging, raunchy and provocative, Gone Girl is an impeccable magnifying glass into the minds of the clinically insane.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

1

ericdeppOct 5, 2014

i am astounded by the number of positive user reviews here. were people not watching? do they have no standards? the critics gave the movie a 79, however, if you look at the credible reviewers, like the NY Times,
you'll see a rating of 60 -i am astounded by the number of positive user reviews here. were people not watching? do they have no standards? the critics gave the movie a 79, however, if you look at the credible reviewers, like the NY Times,
you'll see a rating of 60 - which is mediocre at best. This movie, played out like a cheap movie on Court Tv
or Lifetime! I found it offensive - the twists and turns - like a bad soap opera. Puh- leez! The big story before the movie came out was that Affleck wouldn't wear a Yankees hat in one scene -- the story now should be Affleck never even read the script.… Expand

10 of 21 users found this helpful1011

All this user's reviews

8

Compi24Oct 5, 2014

Fincherisms are cranked up to eleven in "Gone Girl," a visually thick, powerfully acted thriller that maintains its gripping sense of intrigue all throughout its expansive running time.

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

0

gwamOct 4, 2014

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Way too much plot twists and a short lived mystery. You get the real twist by the half of the movie. You'd think it would just unfold but then you're caught amidst a maze of incoherent surreal turns of events. Many loose ends! This movie is like a bad dream: you'd think it's going somewhere but it ends right where it started!… Expand

11 of 30 users found this helpful1119

All this user's reviews

10

jcfilms17Oct 4, 2014

This film is vibrant, and an overall great piece of filmmaking. David Fincher proves again to be one of the best still directing today and this movie based on a novel sure does show that. With a great soundtrack, a eerie feel, and its longThis film is vibrant, and an overall great piece of filmmaking. David Fincher proves again to be one of the best still directing today and this movie based on a novel sure does show that. With a great soundtrack, a eerie feel, and its long run time, Gone Girl is one movie you must see this fall. With its great cast and plot development you can still be stunned by the storyline itself. Despite some sex scenes, the movie is very profitable on how it uses character dynamics and other features that make movies great. This is one of the best I have seen this year...
9.5/10… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

9

TSockMonkeyOct 4, 2014

Wow! I saw this movie with no prior knowledge of the book or even an idea what this movie was about. I was in for quite a ride! This movie is amazing! The plot twist and turns quickly and powerfully often leaving the viewer's grasping forWow! I saw this movie with no prior knowledge of the book or even an idea what this movie was about. I was in for quite a ride! This movie is amazing! The plot twist and turns quickly and powerfully often leaving the viewer's grasping for anything that might be solid and true. Something that anchors you as the movie twists out of control. This is a masterpiece. Fincher at his best. I highly recommend it!… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

10

dylan111Oct 4, 2014

Minus the, shall we say, rather revealing sex scenes, this is the kind of movie my parents used to complain that Hollywood doesn't make anymore. You know, films with a great storyline and topnotch performances. Well, guess what. HollywoodMinus the, shall we say, rather revealing sex scenes, this is the kind of movie my parents used to complain that Hollywood doesn't make anymore. You know, films with a great storyline and topnotch performances. Well, guess what. Hollywood did make it, and it's terrific. Even though I read the book and basically knew what was coming, I was still caught up in the suspense of it. Needless to say, I recommend "Gone Girl" to anyone who appreciates a great night at the movies.… Expand

4 of 11 users found this helpful47

All this user's reviews

6

kevinburbridgeOct 4, 2014

Felt like it was two movies forcibly merged together to form one. First 2/3 of the movie was deliberate, and highlighted by great acting. The final 1/3 was a painfully meandering.

7 of 11 users found this helpful74

All this user's reviews

6

foxgroveOct 4, 2014

Gillian Flynn's book 'Gone Girl' is one of the best novels that I have read in years. It has great characters, intrigue and a bold ending that would definitely not be to everyone's taste. It's a real intelligent page turner that once startedGillian Flynn's book 'Gone Girl' is one of the best novels that I have read in years. It has great characters, intrigue and a bold ending that would definitely not be to everyone's taste. It's a real intelligent page turner that once started can't be put down. The problem with 'Gone Girl' the film is that it has been so faithfully adapted, too faithfully even, by Flynn herself that there are no surprises to be had. I acknowledge that this sounds churlish when there are so many book adaptations that are bad, but the lack of surprise unfortunately dulls the movie experience. The film is well cast. The setting feels right and the score sets an appropriate tone. However, David Fincher's unfussy direction does nothing to add an extra visual dimension to the story. As a result I felt somewhat disappointed by my own reaction, even whilst rationalising the reason for it. As already stated the actors are almost perfect fits for their roles. Ben Affleck is better than I had expected and really carries the film. Rosamund Pike, although over praised, is still good and the supporting cast are pretty much spot on, with a special mention to Neil Patrick Harris. The sequences that involve him are amongst the best in the film.
In summation I can only say that for people who have not read the book this should be a most rewarding experience. Fans of the source material, however, might want to think a little harder about there expectations before viewing.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

6

LynOct 4, 2014

There are movies that make you ponder marriage/relationships -- yours and other people's. This isn't one of them. Nick and Amy are (one hopes!) nothing like you and your significant other. Their twisty story is darkly funny and provocative,There are movies that make you ponder marriage/relationships -- yours and other people's. This isn't one of them. Nick and Amy are (one hopes!) nothing like you and your significant other. Their twisty story is darkly funny and provocative, although I think I might have enjoyed it more had I not read the novel. (Same plot problems, in my opinion.) Ben Affleck -- whose acting was the worst thing in "Argo" -- is the best thing here, perfectly cast. Rosemund Pike is a weak link, seeming like an American Doll whose descriptive theme is "sociopath." Trent Reznor's score is not so much a soundtrack as just sound effects.… Expand

8 of 11 users found this helpful83

All this user's reviews

9

moviemitch96Oct 4, 2014

A VERY near-perfect adaptation of Gillian Flynn's novel! I don't read very much, so normally I don't read the books of a movie before I see it. However, the film's premise intrigued me so much that I decided to read the book a couple weeksA VERY near-perfect adaptation of Gillian Flynn's novel! I don't read very much, so normally I don't read the books of a movie before I see it. However, the film's premise intrigued me so much that I decided to read the book a couple weeks prior to seeing this. And after watching this film, I'm very glad I read the book first, since the film remained extremely faithful to it. Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike each give without a doubt career-best performances! The film sets the same ominous and mysterious tone the book created so well. And of course, David Fincher's brilliant directing also made this film amazing. I was fully intrigued from start to finish, just like I have been with every one of Fincher's films. Aside from what I felt to be a slightly underwhelming ending compared to how the book ended it, I couldn't recommend this film any higher! Definitely check it out if you loved the book or are a fan of David Fincher.… Expand

5 of 14 users found this helpful59

All this user's reviews

10

RealMuthaFOct 4, 2014

Finally, after a long time a movie came out that truly deserves a ten out of ten. Gone Girl is so full of suspense that it keeps you on your toes and thinking what is true and what is not and trying to figure out the characters' next movesFinally, after a long time a movie came out that truly deserves a ten out of ten. Gone Girl is so full of suspense that it keeps you on your toes and thinking what is true and what is not and trying to figure out the characters' next moves for the whole lengthy 149 minutes. Speaking about the plot would mean spoilers, so I'll refrain from it, but it should be mentioned that it is full of twists, some more or less predictable, and some just shocking. The actors are brilliant, and Rosamund Pike here is truly the queen of the show. In other words, go watch this movie, it's not that easy to find a better way to spend two and a half hours.… Expand

3 of 13 users found this helpful310

All this user's reviews

8

Beowulf4862Oct 4, 2014

Pretty effective thriller. And like many good thrillers, it has its share of laughs--our appreciative audience guffawed numerous times and at the right times! People are trying to read too much into it: is it anti-marriage, anti-husbands,Pretty effective thriller. And like many good thrillers, it has its share of laughs--our appreciative audience guffawed numerous times and at the right times! People are trying to read too much into it: is it anti-marriage, anti-husbands, anti-wives, ant-media, etc? Who cares! Very satisfying, and, yes, the ending will unsettle you like few other films.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

7

JengolferOct 4, 2014

I thought the movie was really good, but my biggest complaint was that we couldn't hear the dialogue especially in the beginning which made it very hard to follow the plot. I am 54 with good hearing and I was with three people from 70 to 83.I thought the movie was really good, but my biggest complaint was that we couldn't hear the dialogue especially in the beginning which made it very hard to follow the plot. I am 54 with good hearing and I was with three people from 70 to 83. We all had a problem hearing the dialogue either due to the background music being to loud, or the actor were mumbling their lines. The movie industry needs to be more aware of their audiences ability to hear what being said. It's not the first time this has happened!… Expand

4 of 16 users found this helpful412

All this user's reviews

9

ImRelaxinOct 4, 2014

150 minutes of brilliance. Suspenseful, smooth, stylish and sinister. Slightly unconvinced by Rosamund Pikes performance, but the direction and plot are intense. Any fan of the novel should check out this film purely for its precise150 minutes of brilliance. Suspenseful, smooth, stylish and sinister. Slightly unconvinced by Rosamund Pikes performance, but the direction and plot are intense. Any fan of the novel should check out this film purely for its precise representation of the story. Consistently appealing all the way through.… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

3

marco34laOct 4, 2014

I believe today is a jewish holiday, so this word may best sum up Gone Girl -- OY! What started off as a reasonably interesting mystery, turns very ridiculous very quickly, and then descend into absurdity. Once the movie takes "that" dreadedI believe today is a jewish holiday, so this word may best sum up Gone Girl -- OY! What started off as a reasonably interesting mystery, turns very ridiculous very quickly, and then descend into absurdity. Once the movie takes "that" dreaded turn, everything from the acting and dialogue turns into a cheap made-for-tv melodrama you'd find on Lifetime. This is a rental folks.… Expand

17 of 37 users found this helpful1720

All this user's reviews

8

ArgeonOct 4, 2014

A dark and disturbing movie, with touches of humour along the 2.5 hours of material. It's a great movie - simply fantastic. The actors, especially the two stars, are absolutely amazing, the directing is phenomenal, and the plot is tense andA dark and disturbing movie, with touches of humour along the 2.5 hours of material. It's a great movie - simply fantastic. The actors, especially the two stars, are absolutely amazing, the directing is phenomenal, and the plot is tense and unpredictable.

After this movie, I can't help to think that it was trying to talk about social issues, but that's my interpretation. I cannot say much without spoiling, but I definitely recommend watching the movie, especially if you are into movies that make you bite your nails (like Prisoners starring Hugh Jackman last year)… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

10

BrianMcCriticOct 3, 2014

Wow this film is looney tunes and I loved every minute of it. First what can you say about David Fincher the man is a master craftsman behind the camera with every shot in this film more gorgeous than the last. The acting is all great hereWow this film is looney tunes and I loved every minute of it. First what can you say about David Fincher the man is a master craftsman behind the camera with every shot in this film more gorgeous than the last. The acting is all great here but the standout by far is Rosamund Pike who gives an Academy Award winning performance. As funny as it is thrilling Gone Girl deserves to be in the conversation with Fincher's best. A+… Expand

8 of 18 users found this helpful810

All this user's reviews

9

GinaKOct 3, 2014

Gone Girl is a very enjoyable movie. After a slow start, I laughed out loud throughout most of the film. I thought Rosamund Pike was perfect, managing to show us both an inner and outer “Amazing Amy.” Although I felt Ben Affleck did a greatGone Girl is a very enjoyable movie. After a slow start, I laughed out loud throughout most of the film. I thought Rosamund Pike was perfect, managing to show us both an inner and outer “Amazing Amy.” Although I felt Ben Affleck did a great job, he was more sympathetic because his back story (his relationship with his mother and so his complete personality) was omitted. Since the author of the novel wrote the screenplay, perhaps she changed her mind. Nick is no better than Amy in the book, but somehow he came out more sympathetic in the movie. They are, after all, the perfect couple – they deserve each other. The rest of the cast was great, and David Fincher came through again (I am a fan). I look forward to buying the DVD and savoring this film over and over. I didn’t initially like “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo,” but appreciate its artistry and craft more each time I watch it. I expect to enjoy this film many more times too.… Expand

4 of 11 users found this helpful47

All this user's reviews

6

ScribeHardOct 3, 2014

If American Hustle is David O. Russell‘s “Martin Scorsese film,” then Gone Girl is David Fincher‘s “Adrian Lyne movie.” With its high gloss, shocking twist, threads of infidelity and revenge, and an overactive sex-drive, this neo-noirIf American Hustle is David O. Russell‘s “Martin Scorsese film,” then Gone Girl is David Fincher‘s “Adrian Lyne movie.” With its high gloss, shocking twist, threads of infidelity and revenge, and an overactive sex-drive, this neo-noir wannabe is entertaining fodder, but something better suited to sit atop its cable kin, instead of fighting for multiplex attention.… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

7

GreatMartinOct 3, 2014

As Amy Dunne in “Gone Girl” Rosamund Pike joins the ranks of Sharon Stone in “Basic Instinct” and Glenn Close in “Fatal Attraction” and to say more would give away the last hour and twenty-five minutes of the film.

The film is mostly aAs Amy Dunne in “Gone Girl” Rosamund Pike joins the ranks of Sharon Stone in “Basic Instinct” and Glenn Close in “Fatal Attraction” and to say more would give away the last hour and twenty-five minutes of the film.

The film is mostly a ‘He said-She said’ narrative of a possible kidnapping and/or murder, starting with Amy and Nick Dunne (Ben Affleck) returning home, after both losing their jobs in New York City, to North Carthage, not far from St. Louis, to take care of his mother dying of cancer and his father drifting into Alzheimer’s. Amy’s parents, psychologists, (David Clennon and Lisa Banes), have become wealthy writing books about a child, Amazing Amy, who was always just a bit better than their real daughter. We see brief scenes of Amy and Nick meeting and falling in love.

Within a few minutes we see Nick coming home to an empty home leased by the couple with money from her trust fund from the books, their cat outside, a table upended, the glass top smashed and Amy missing. It isn’t long before evidence points toward Nick as the murderer of his golden wife Amy, his being pursued by detectives Rhonda Boney (Kim Dickens) and Jim Gilpin (Patrick Fuhgit), his twin sister Margo, (Carrie Coon) supporting him 100% while a sensation seeking TV cable reporter/host, played by Missy Pyle, slowly turns the public against Nick. Eventually Margo makes Nick hire news making lawyer, Tanner Bolt, (Tyler Perry). Along the way we meet Desi Collings (Neil Patrick Harris), Amy’s boyfriend, so he thinks, in high school, Carrie Wilson as Noelle Hawthorne, a neighbor of Nick and Amy’s, Emily Ratajkowski as Andie Hardy, a student in the one college class Nick teaches, plus Boyd Holbrook and Lola Kirke, as Jeff and Greta, plus a cameo by Sela Ward as another cable TV host.

With the exception of Neil Patrick Harris in a wasted, undefined role, and the roles of Boyd Holbrook and Lola Kirke, though acted strongly, could have been cut without taking anything away from the story except making it shorter, the acting by the cast is of the first order with Ben Affleck at his best while Rosamund Pike is definitely going to be up for most of the acting awards.

The screenplay by Gillian Flynn, based on her best selling novel, and the direction by David Fincher, serve the film well to hold the audiences attention as all the production values do.. They have made it one of those movies that will make people who haven’t read the book to do just that to see what, if anything, they have missed.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

8

neocomp92Oct 3, 2014

A delicious thriller filled with red herrings, best lies reinforced with cherry-picked truths, and an exploration into the mind of a sociopath as well as the inherent rules of a "normal" society that ends up being its own greatest obstacle inA delicious thriller filled with red herrings, best lies reinforced with cherry-picked truths, and an exploration into the mind of a sociopath as well as the inherent rules of a "normal" society that ends up being its own greatest obstacle in delivering justice to the victims.

Truly the star of the show is Rosamund Pike, and its becoming a strange trend that Bond girls 10 years from their performance in 007 movies get to achieve greater things. Famke Jansen in Goldeneye 1995 played that insanely powerful witch-like figure in X-Men 3 (OK let's ignore how terrible that movie is to some). Rosamund here manages to exude the performance necessary for her character, and then some.

Ben Affleck, on the other hand, is less stellar, but probably because of how his character is written. Though a matter of personal preference, I always get thrown off by how similar he looks to Ryan Reynolds. He presents himself as a husband that doesn't seem to be as loving to his wife as some may think, and the movie brilliantly highlights these quirks, and explore why he is behaving in such a manner. Without going into too much spoiler, the reason for his behaviour is central to the plot of Pike's disappearance, but not in a straightforward manner as some might guess from the trailer.

And as mentioned, there is a sociopath in the movie, and its one that is beautifully written and acted. It truly shines on how this character manages to find the weakness in social expectations, behaviour, norms, and the justice system. The court of public opinion is a terrible thing once it goes against you, and this character knows it and exploits it, without remorse. I truly feel hatred for this villain, not because of the genius behind the crime, but because of the very rules of "normal" we as a collective society bind ourselves to that stops justice from being delivered, and this sociopath knows it.

There are some social issues on economic recession, job losses, and the "talk shows" that powerfully influence the public opinion. This is quite strong in the first and second act, but by the third, it does dial down due to how the plot is laid out.

What I don't like about the movie is some of the cinematography involved. Its clear from the opening credits that there are lots of fade in and out effects used in certain scenes, and quick transitions. Whilst it may work for some, there are certain scenes that lowered the intended impact and made me feel like I'm passing out.

This is also an 18+ movie; there are sex scenes here that are very open, though non-pornographic in nature. Just a reminder in case they didn't tell you so in the cinema.

Finally, its 2 hours and 50 minutes long. Its not that bad until the third act, where the direction of the movie could sometimes be a bit meandering, though not painfully dragging its feet. Though considering the emotional impact from how the second act concluded, you might not find what you truly are looking for by the closing of the movie.… Expand

1 of 11 users found this helpful110

All this user's reviews

10

WiscoJoeOct 3, 2014

A masterpiece of genre film-making. I felt like I was watching a long-lost Hitchcock classic (but one with all the sex and violence Hitch was only allowed to hint at). No spoilers. The less you know about the story going in, the more you'llA masterpiece of genre film-making. I felt like I was watching a long-lost Hitchcock classic (but one with all the sex and violence Hitch was only allowed to hint at). No spoilers. The less you know about the story going in, the more you'll enjoy it. Fans of the novel are in for an impeccable and precise adaptation of the source material. Fincher nails the tone and sustains it effortlessly for the entire running time.… Expand

43 of 71 users found this helpful4328

All this user's reviews

5

benuttyOct 3, 2014

I refuse to join the chorus of applause for this film. Gone Girl is predictably Fincher-ish--visually stylish and slick but cold and soulless. I find both lead performances entirely vacant and robotic, with Rosamund Pike's Amy Dunne borderingI refuse to join the chorus of applause for this film. Gone Girl is predictably Fincher-ish--visually stylish and slick but cold and soulless. I find both lead performances entirely vacant and robotic, with Rosamund Pike's Amy Dunne bordering on having been inspired by Haley Joel Osment in A.I. While the supporting cast steals the show (Lisa Banes, Lola Kirke and Neil Patrick Harris are highlights for me), Carrie Coon's Margo seems to have come from an entirely different film where all the actors weren't told they were making a film noir parody.

On a positive note, there are three moments emblazoned in my memory where Cronenweth's photography is quite remarkable.… Expand

14 of 21 users found this helpful147

All this user's reviews

9

PoundthoOct 3, 2014

Not at all a replication of the text in style and thematic focus, but utterly in substance and content. Fincher adds to this blissfully melodramatic mystery thriller in a multitude of ways.

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

Gone Girl

User Reviews