User Score
7.5

Generally favorable reviews- based on 81 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 55 out of 81
  2. Negative: 15 out of 81

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
  1. Apr 9, 2018
    6
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The game is essentially a maze book you'd buy from an airport store to kill time between flights but instead of flipping to the next page to get to the next puzzle, you walk around a pretty landscape.

    The art style is very similar to Zelda: Breath of the Wild so that's a huge positive. Looks clean, vibrant and I never had any frame rate drops or other issues. I got a Myst "vibe" from the game in that you're walking around a seemingly abandoned, silent island with different puzzles to solve that, in turn, play their own part in solving a bigger mystery.

    But all throughout playing it I couldn't shake the feeling that this game was just a generic maze book you'd buy for a few bucks to pass the time between connecting flights at an airport. The mazes are definitely challenging so if you like good puzzles, I'd definitely recommend it. But if you're looking for anything more than a conglomeration of puzzles where you walk from puzzle to puzzle instead of turning a page or hitting "next," then I think you'll be highly disappointed. They incorporate some of the aspects of the world into solving some of the puzzles but overall they just seem derivative. "How do we make a maze harder? Make it so you can't see where your line is! Need some more challenge? Make it so you need to look through different colored panes of glass to reveal the correct path!" It feels as if the devs really wanted to make a really good maze game (which they did) and then realized that not many people will buy a game of mazes, let alone for more than $10 so they created an island for you walk around on in an attempt to make it seem like it's more than a maze game.

    Most of the challenge of the game ultimately comes down to how quickly you realize which item in the open world corresponds to the maze. Once you realize that the maze (and most of the mazes around it) reference the same object, they become child's play. For example [SPOILERS], there's a group of mazes in an apple orchard. As soon as you realize the puzzle solution is based off of a tree that has an apple on one branch, it just becomes tracing the tree branch on your maze...and the next 5 mazes too. So it's just looking at a tree, tracing, going to the next, looking at the tree, tracing, etc. Another, requires you to box alike colors together before reaching the end of the maze. The next step up from this is to use colored panes of glass to view the maze so that the correct colors are showing. My points is that most of the ideas the devs came up with the make the mazes harder seem like things that were just spit out during a random brainstorming session: "Ok, how can we make a maze, one of the oldest types of puzzles in human society, and make it a bit more challening? Ooh! Have the solution be tracing an object in the open world! Have a pane of glass show the solution if you look through it!" None of the ideas struck me as organic or even original.

    It's not a bad game, it just isn't much more than a $5 book with a pretty picture. If you go into the game knowing that solving top-down mazes is 99.9% of what you are doing here then you will most likely enjoy your experience. But if you're going into it thinking it'll be anything remotely similar to other puzzle games with "open worlds" like Portal, then you'll be highly disappointed. The open world is not even close to being necessary and only serves as a pretty lobby to walk around in between solving mediocre mazes.
    Expand
  2. Aug 7, 2017
    6
    This is a puzzle game but was a little to obtuse for me. I had to look up a lot of solutions - I wasn't very patient most are solvable. Overall I felt time remorse when playing it as there didn't seem like there were "rewards" for solving puzzles and a lot of the puzzles could of been done on a tablet.

    Pros: - Solid visuals - Most puzzles are interesting and solvable Cons: -
    This is a puzzle game but was a little to obtuse for me. I had to look up a lot of solutions - I wasn't very patient most are solvable. Overall I felt time remorse when playing it as there didn't seem like there were "rewards" for solving puzzles and a lot of the puzzles could of been done on a tablet.

    Pros:
    - Solid visuals
    - Most puzzles are interesting and solvable

    Cons:
    - Some puzzles were too obtuse
    - The "rules" for solving puzzles weren't always clear to me
    - Lifeless environment
    Expand
  3. Apr 9, 2017
    5
    This game is neither a 10 nor a 0 in my opinion. First of all the environments are beautiful and at first the puzzles are fun and interesting and I particularly loved the environmental ones. As the game continues and you come upon more and more multiple panels of puzzles and frustratingly slow bridges and boat rides you start to get annoyed. Then after labouring through all this you areThis game is neither a 10 nor a 0 in my opinion. First of all the environments are beautiful and at first the puzzles are fun and interesting and I particularly loved the environmental ones. As the game continues and you come upon more and more multiple panels of puzzles and frustratingly slow bridges and boat rides you start to get annoyed. Then after labouring through all this you are tortured and timed and in the end you get two endings, both of them pretentious in my view. I went from loving to hating this game and I imagine quite a few people were left feeling this way. To the ones who loved it I get it, I just didn't have that experience. Expand
  4. Mar 13, 2019
    6
    This game is fine. But that's really all it is.
    It has great and interesting puzzles, however, the game is generally a waste of time , most puzzles are easy, movement is slow, and certain puzzles are just impossible to solve and have no general correlation with puzzles that seem to have similar patterns/themes. I never did finish the game, not only because of these impossible puzzles but
    This game is fine. But that's really all it is.
    It has great and interesting puzzles, however, the game is generally a waste of time , most puzzles are easy, movement is slow, and certain puzzles are just impossible to solve and have no general correlation with puzzles that seem to have similar patterns/themes. I never did finish the game, not only because of these impossible puzzles but also just from the general slowness of the game. However, the puzzles that didn't insult your intelligence or purposely waste your time were fun to solve and the environments were gorgeous, this game is great to just relax and look at for a while. In all, a great game that was hindered by the developers trying to be pretentious.
    Expand
  5. May 1, 2018
    6
    Uma direção de arte incrível,muito boa para apenas um jogo de Puzzle,mas esses são os únicos destaques do jogo,se você procura uma progressão de level relativamente boa,esqueça,o jogo não te pega pelas mãos,explorar é necessário para achar os painéis de lazer e entender como os puzzles funcionam,demora tempo e é necessário dedicação para passar sem ajuda de um guia.
    é ótimo BASEADO em sua
    Uma direção de arte incrível,muito boa para apenas um jogo de Puzzle,mas esses são os únicos destaques do jogo,se você procura uma progressão de level relativamente boa,esqueça,o jogo não te pega pelas mãos,explorar é necessário para achar os painéis de lazer e entender como os puzzles funcionam,demora tempo e é necessário dedicação para passar sem ajuda de um guia.
    é ótimo BASEADO em sua PROPOSTA,mas não agrada a maioria dos jogadores,principalmente pela dificuldade que o jogo proporciona.
    Expand
Metascore
86

Generally favorable reviews - based on 11 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 10 out of 11
  2. Negative: 0 out of 11
  1. Oct 14, 2016
    90
    Just a phenomenal title which stands up well on Xbox One. Despite its 30 FPS presentation which results in feeling like trudging through molasses, the game still features intelligent puzzles and rewards the player when they finally figure it out.
  2. Oct 6, 2016
    100
    The Witness has an abundance of content, and even after 25+ hours I feel I have barely scratched the surface of the secrets the island holds for me.
  3. Oct 5, 2016
    80
    An unique experience with mountains of puzzles to solve, a great look and an intangible mystery to discover, but lacking on the storytelling side and with a sometimes unbalanced difficulty progression.