Project CARS 2

 Xbox One
User Score
5.6

Mixed or average reviews- based on 77 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 37 out of 77
  2. Mixed: 11 out of 77
  3. Negative: 29 out of 77
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. Lukinhapc
    Oct 3, 2017
    1
    The game is good, but oh my f**** god...again ? the game has tons of bugs, like PC 1, but even after all the problems they had with the first game, the second came with unforgivable mistakes...I just lost all my career progress after just closing the game... I recommend that you wait a few months to acquire this game, or you can just play another game, it's best than give money to this lazy studio
  2. Gregpeplinski
    Dec 28, 2018
    0
    Absolute garbage. Undriveable out of the box- then you'll go read reviews, and about half the people on here will say "oh just fiddle with the settings for an hour, and it'll still feel off, and sort of drive okay.."

    I did fiddle with it and try to adjust controls, and car settings, and views, and difficulty to no avail. still just crap. car is uncontrollable, and i've played tons of    Absolute garbage. Undriveable out of the box- then you'll go read reviews, and about half the people on here will say "oh just fiddle with the settings for an hour, and it'll still feel off, and sort of drive okay.."

    I did fiddle with it and try to adjust controls, and car settings, and views, and difficulty to no avail. still just crap. car is uncontrollable, and i've played tons of racing games -GT 1,2,3,4, forza, project gotham, etc.

    A very poorly made game with no thought given to the user at all. A couple nice menus and thats about it.

    AVOID THIS GAME.

    Hands down, worst racing game i've play and one of probably the 3 worst games to exist period. shambolic.    … Expand
  3. Dave100e
    Jul 21, 2018
    0
    To me this has been the most disappointing game in the last 5 years. It's been out now for 10 months and I keep returning to it only to go through the process if disappointment. Pretty much all of the problems from PC1 still exist and it doesn't feel like enough of an upgrade over the last game to even warrant it's existence.

    Negative points..... - Don't even bother with a    To me this has been the most disappointing game in the last 5 years. It's been out now for 10 months and I keep returning to it only to go through the process if disappointment. Pretty much all of the problems from PC1 still exist and it doesn't feel like enough of an upgrade over the last game to even warrant it's existence.

    Negative points.....

    - Don't even bother with a controller. You'll spend hours upon hours of trying to calibrate it, but you'll never be quite 100% comfortable and you're settings will always be a compromise.
    - Be prepared to spend just as much time setting a wheel up. Again, it will always be a compromise, but it'll never quite feel natural and like a wheel should feel.
    - Some of the concepts and mechanics don't quite work, such as tire warming. Sometimes it will take 10 minutes of lapping just to warm your tires up, which is just silly and unrealistic. 10/10 for effort, 1/10 for actually pulling it off. It genuinely took me a full lap of the Nurburgring once to hate the tires up on an LMP car, and in a Group C car it took 2 laps of Le Mans to get them hot, both super high down force cars which would have no issue hating tires up.
    - The AI is the worst AI I've come across in my 20 years of playing racing games. It makes Forza AI look competent. What makes it even worse is that the tire heating mentioned above doesn't seem to apply to the AI, so when you're in qualifying, taking your 17 laps to heat your tires up the AI will be out at full pace, if you slow down and move over to let them past they'll sit behind you instead of overtaking, however, when you're actually doing the qualifying laps at full pace they'll be nudging you and inappropriately diving down the inside at the most ridiculous times imaginable.
    - "Alternative physics". Yep, they got the physics so wrong that they have had to implement a second set for when a car loses traction. The problem with this is that cars lose traction constantly. If you go over a small bump and a wheel loses contact with the ground that is the same as losing traction. What this means is that if you drive along a bumpy track or in a low grip car, the alternate physics start kicking in, which means the handling becomes a mess. This limits you to high grip cars and smooth circuits to even stand a hope of driving. If you don't believe me and would like like to test this out you need a steering wheel. If you drive along the Le Mans straight and let go of the wheel, without any input watch how the steering wheel starts violently veering left to right, this is your alternate physics fighting the regular physics.
    - The (badly thought out) car setting menu requires a game pad alongside a wheel. The problem with this is that it's 50/50 whether the game will pair the game pad alongside the wheel. I've never had this issue with any other game before. I recently spent 40 minutes turning my console on and off, disconnecting my wheel and controller, resetting the game, resetting the controller and generally pissing about to get it to pair them both at the same time. This happens far too often.

    I could go on for hours, so lets look at some neutral and positive points.

    Neutral points.

    - There isn't as much variety as people seem to think.

    Positive points

    - After you have spent 30 hours getting your calibrations right, selected the right car, the right track and then spent a considerable amount of time setting the car up to behave like it would in real life, it can be a mildly good game, like a 5/10. It probably would've been a decent game in 2004.

    I bought PC1 quite excited, but was disappointed. I let it slip and expected PC2 to be better. It was far worse. I will never buy an SMS game again. Buy Assetto Corsa instead, It has less content but it's actually a fully functional game.    … Expand
  4. Darklordnutsac
    Sep 28, 2017
    3
    This review is specific to the Xbox and the game simply doesn't work well on this console. User reviews are all over the map on this game and I think they come from different places. I can imagine this works great on PC and maybe even PS4 Pro but the Xbox One is simply not powerful enough to run this game. I recently played Forza 6 and that is still better graphically than PC2 on theThis review is specific to the Xbox and the game simply doesn't work well on this console. User reviews are all over the map on this game and I think they come from different places. I can imagine this works great on PC and maybe even PS4 Pro but the Xbox One is simply not powerful enough to run this game. I recently played Forza 6 and that is still better graphically than PC2 on the Xbox (by a wide margin). I've seen some beautiful graphics from online reviews so I have to think the Xbox is being dumbed down graphically for it to work functionally. Case in point, when driving in the rain the spotter goes silent and doesn't talk to you, that is until the sun comes out and its a bright sunny day, then he's back to his usual peppy self. The track lines and edges of cars are simply way to jaggie and take away from the experience. I have also noted that the driving dynamics are off when its wet, I was practicing and qualifying in the rain and the car was simply on rails, virtually no slippage and no tire squeal on braking. The race started in rain and handled the same but as the rain stopped and the track dried out the car started to squeal and slide (as I would have expected) yet lap times were the same. I am assuming this is Xbox related and that the devs wanted the dynamic weather to work so the game has to throttle graphics, sound and driving dynamics to ensure its dynamic weather function works.

    Without these performance and graphical issues I can see this game getting the approx. 80% reviews it is getting as I really like the track options, car list and general focus on 'race day'. The tuning options are way beyond my knowledge and the race engineer is a great option. There are some kinks that need to be fixed such as random AI (for example I was racing, qualified in pole but on the formation lap the second place guy sped past me, I was then penalized for going too slow and not catching him even though I couldn't catch him at full race speed, once we started the first lap he slowed down to the level he was set to and I passed him within 2 corners, yet I got a drive through because of the formation lap issue). Another game issue is the aggressive race director, its a bit random, you can sometimes go slightly wide on a corner and he will forfeit your entire lap time or if you get one wheel over a rumble strip as you pass he will make you go back to your original position in the race. I would expect some of these issues to get fixed with patches down the road.

    For now I would say skip this on the Xbox One, I don't think it can handle the software well and not sure if the devs will be working on this to optimize it for the console. Hopefully it will run much better on the Xbox One X when that comes out, but for now this is nowhere close to a HD racing experience (let alone 4k) on the Xbox. Its playable but the graphics and performance issues are not worth it right now and not sure if they will or can be fixed for the current gen. I have the digital version and am hoping these improvements fix themselves when the Xbox X comes out.    … Expand
  5. Foehammer
    Sep 25, 2017
    2
    Project cars 2, maybe fans shouldnt create their own game after all... the AI is laughable, the graphical glitches are abismal and really off putting and the controller support is severely lacking despite suposedly being better! Im glad i have a ps4 and can play GT sport soon!
  6. likeshampoo
    Sep 25, 2017
    0
    To anyone who might be considering this game, it is nowhere near finished for the Xbox One. The sound, graphics, performance issues, even the cars handling is all substantially worse that Project Cars 1.

    I really wanted this game to be great but it seems like yet another developer is rushing out a game to make a quick buck rather than waiting and releasing a completed game. I reported    To anyone who might be considering this game, it is nowhere near finished for the Xbox One. The sound, graphics, performance issues, even the cars handling is all substantially worse that Project Cars 1.

    I really wanted this game to be great but it seems like yet another developer is rushing out a game to make a quick buck rather than waiting and releasing a completed game. I reported many of the issues I had on the official forum of the game and that got deleted once it got enough views and replies from others with similar issues. Responses from SMS and the Moderators seem to mostly disagree with users and their experiences. Ian Bell (CEO of SMS) was quick to point to the Metacritic Critic Review score but when I why the User Score for the Xbox One was substantially lower, he decided to ignore the post and delete the thread. It's really not a positive to take away if they're not going to own up to their mistakes.

    Overall, not only did the experience of the game fall far below expectation (expectations being that I was hoping this would be as good as Project Cars 1 with extra cars and tracks), I was also made out to be a liar by people working for the studio behind the game, even though there were around 70+ posts from people sharing a similar experience to me.

    Its good for people to say enough is enough when it comes to paying £50+ (I paid £75 for the deluxe edition) and you receive a substandard product, hopefully more voice this because the industry as a whole is becoming a bit of a joke with releasing unfinished games and charging a premium for it.

    Too bad they seem to be either just denying, shifting the blame of issues to others (one moderator blamed Microsoft for their policy on how they release updates - maybe you shouldn't release a substandard game with game breaking bugs in the first place) or deleting posts and threads on their forum of people criticising the standard of the game rather than reassuring customers that their complaints are being acknowledged and fixes are on their way. The only threads that seem to stick around are ones that only report bugs when there's a lot more wrong than that with the game - they're just not interested to hear about it.

    Overall I would give:

    3 / 10 for the game
    -10 / 10 for the customer service
    Which comes to a grand total of -7.

    Unfortunately 0 is the lowest I can post on here so I'll settle for that. I'll be happy to change my score for the game once it starts getting patched, can't see the customer service rating getting much higher though.    … Expand
  7. fabittar
    Sep 26, 2017
    0
    Unless you own a wheel and pedals - most of us don't think it's worth the "investment", not to mention the trouble of connecting that thing, stowing it away, moving the couch etc -, do NOT touch this game. It is horrible and the media lied to us again. Developers made false promises: handling the cars with a controller is, to say the least, frustating. Game is nearly unplayable and thusUnless you own a wheel and pedals - most of us don't think it's worth the "investment", not to mention the trouble of connecting that thing, stowing it away, moving the couch etc -, do NOT touch this game. It is horrible and the media lied to us again. Developers made false promises: handling the cars with a controller is, to say the least, frustating. Game is nearly unplayable and thus not fun at all.… Expand
  8. ACE222
    Sep 17, 2021
    4
    PC2 looks very nice, game engine still terrible, default settings are terrible, used Johnson settings from youtube improved a fair bit but car still handles badly due to physics engine, steering sensitivity is much higher the slower you go so hard to keep straight starting off but wont corner at speed so the opposite of what you want, also have to brake miles away from corner to not slamPC2 looks very nice, game engine still terrible, default settings are terrible, used Johnson settings from youtube improved a fair bit but car still handles badly due to physics engine, steering sensitivity is much higher the slower you go so hard to keep straight starting off but wont corner at speed so the opposite of what you want, also have to brake miles away from corner to not slam into walls even with brakes on 100 and ABS off, also loses traction when accelerating even with full traction control and acc sens turned down, so instead of fixing game engine made it prettier, should be called epic fail 2.… Expand

Awards & Rankings

20
#20 Best Xbox One Game of 2017
42
#42 Most Discussed Xbox One Game of 2017
64
#64 Most Shared Xbox One Game of 2017

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
84

Generally favorable reviews - based on 22 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 21 out of 22
  2. Mixed: 1 out of 22
  3. Negative: 0 out of 22
  1. CD-Action
    Dec 19, 2017
    80
    An uncompromising simulation that expects you to devote all your free time but will reward you with immense satisfaction. [12/2017, p.78]
  2. Cubed3
    Nov 12, 2017
    60
    Whereas Project CARS felt like a finished and polished product, Project CARS 2 maybe needed another couple of months in development to iron out the wrinkles. There is undoubtedly a good game in there as the handling and visuals are exceptional, but it is capable of so much more.
    Read full review
  3. Generación Xbox
    Oct 26, 2017
    90
    Project Cars 2 comes with strength this year as the best simulator developed by Slightly Mad Studios, reinforced with a surprising physics system and also including a new online competition mode and accompanied by the debut of Rally Cross. A jewel you can't miss.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »