Mafia: Definitive Edition

 Xbox One
User Score
7.5

Generally favorable reviews- based on 196 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 134 out of 196
  2. Mixed: 31 out of 196
  3. Negative: 31 out of 196
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. FatHatman2003
    Oct 9, 2020
    10
    I played the original mafia some months ago, and by playing the remake I can just say that its great. The way ut feels, the atmosphere, cars, and story are just fantastic. I really weren't expected a good remake from Hangar 13, after mafia 3 and its unoriginal story, but now i see they made a hard work to not to disappoint gamers. Yeah I've seen a lot of people critisising mafia becauseI played the original mafia some months ago, and by playing the remake I can just say that its great. The way ut feels, the atmosphere, cars, and story are just fantastic. I really weren't expected a good remake from Hangar 13, after mafia 3 and its unoriginal story, but now i see they made a hard work to not to disappoint gamers. Yeah I've seen a lot of people critisising mafia because its more casual than the original one, or people saying that they are quitting game because of that race, I've seen people critisizing the remake for its story changes and etc.. but lets be more rational, compared to new pay to win or 1000 hours online games, or left wing propagandistic games, and games without any esthetic sense, mafia remake is just fantastic. The gameplay, and by this i mean shootings, driving and etc... doesn' make you be bored. Story changes are logical and make story more inteeesting. Saras romance is now more clear, and because of new graphics, the game is looking more cinematic and more dramatic. I love this game, especially when I've seen the updated ending, that's looking more emotional. The games is really great, and after I ended the orginal one, I can truly say that people saying that the original is way beter, I surely just missing the good old games, but the gaming industry is changing. I also miss the good old days of ps2, but i admit the fact that like any other media branch, gaming is in cinstant developpement. Mafia definitive edition ans RE 2 remake are by far my favourite remakes, an mafia definiive edition truly deserves a nomination at game awards.… Expand
  2. Filmanwalt
    Sep 29, 2020
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Mafia 1 Definitive Edition

    Nearly perfect. I finished the game after around 14 hours (560 achievement points), and only played very little free drive (hidden cars unlocked).

    story

    Everything I want to see in a Mafia game (conflict, violence, brutality, networking, etc.). The story is perfect for me, even if there were predictable moments, especially for mafia connoisseurs. But the entire story presentation in all of its cut scenes, the characters and the course are phenomenally good. The many references to Goodfellas, Pate and co. let you enjoy joyfully, two examples in the spoiler.

    spoiler: corleone Hotel or Joe Pesci FunnyGuy Scene.

    The story about Tommy is simply a successful mafia story.

    graphic

    Hangar13 did a really good job on this remake. It looks really fabulous. At the end of the story, I jumped straight into the free ride and looked at the entire map, it's done well. The individual scenes look nice, as do the character models and everything around them. The only thing that bothered me a little was the eyelashes: D, which is only a minor thing.

    Gameplay

    First of all, I didn't play in classic mode and without aiming aids. The level of difficulty (medium) was appropriate, I would have only wished that cops could be shaken off a little more difficult. Regarding combat gameplay, I have to say that this is my only weakness. The shooting and especially the close combat do not seem as smooth as the rest, here it might have needed a little more time, also to e.g. the cover mechanisms mature further (in particular the cover change is implemented too half-baked).

    It would have been nice to make the open world somewhat interactive in free travel mode, e.g. Activities or the like.

    A great trump card is the variety of different missions within the story. Everything feels different but also completely harmonious, boredom never arises here.

    The collectibles have great pictures / comics, etc. (I have to look for some) and some great hidden cars. Unfortunately I didn't unlock the achievement for 30 carts, quite difficult to find out which ones are still missing.

    Conclusion

    A fantastic remake for me that I hope many others will play. Anyone who is only approximately interested in the topic, knows the predecessor or is up for a good story again should strike. Only in combat would they have had to go a step further to make it absolutely smooth. 9/10 offers you can't refuse.    … Expand
  3. AquaArcher
    Oct 4, 2020
    8
    Mafia Definitive Edition was just about what I expected to get when I bought it, a great story and detailed open world with pretty good combat and realistic driving. I don’t think it’s better than Mafia 2 but it was still good and I highly recommend playing this first if you ever want to play Mafia 2 as it ties in quite well. There were some bugs but nothing game breaking and most wereMafia Definitive Edition was just about what I expected to get when I bought it, a great story and detailed open world with pretty good combat and realistic driving. I don’t think it’s better than Mafia 2 but it was still good and I highly recommend playing this first if you ever want to play Mafia 2 as it ties in quite well. There were some bugs but nothing game breaking and most were just funny to see. Overall it was a good experience with a lot of likable characters and cool set pieces that took me about a week to 100%, I’d definitely play it again someday.… Expand
  4. imshady45
    Sep 30, 2020
    10
    Mafia 2002 was for me the best game ever made. This remake is not perfect for sure. But brings back all good memorys. Good work Hangar 13. Now do patch for nextgen consoles.
  5. BusyBee93915
    Sep 28, 2020
    10
    This game is amazing. I dont know how to start. The story and characters are perfect. The gunplay, sound design, driving and graphics are incredible. If you want to dont trust Hangar 13 i would say you can trust and you should buy now.
  6. Jatki21
    Oct 10, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Some people have said the story is boring and that only those who played the original would appreciate it, but this is my first time experiencing the original Mafia story and I enjoyed every second of it! It even ties in perfectly with Mafia 2, which cleared up some of the questions I had after playing Mafia 2 several times. After finishing the game, I came away extremely satisfied.r… Expand
  7. vaulttec
    Nov 3, 2020
    10
    Literally the best Mafia Game!
    Everything has been improved, overhauled and enhanced!
    The Graphics look great. The Cutscenes are really well done and well animated. The Characters are great, and it really revives the vibe of Mafia we all know and love. The Story is awesome! Verdict: 10 / 10. Simply the best Mafia in Graphics, Storytelling and Characters! It is well worth its 40$ price.    Literally the best Mafia Game!
    Everything has been improved, overhauled and enhanced!
    The Graphics look great. The Cutscenes are really well done and well animated. The Characters are great, and it really revives the vibe of Mafia we all know and love.
    The Story is awesome!
    Verdict: 10 / 10. Simply the best Mafia in Graphics, Storytelling and Characters! It is well worth its 40$ price. I recommend it to everyone who reads this review!    … Expand
  8. Connormayser
    Sep 28, 2020
    10
    In terms of its content, this is a rather modest game - apart from the main plot, there is practically nothing to do here, except to ride around the city in the "Walk" mode and look for collectibles. And every single element of the remake, whether it's graphics, shootouts or chases, lags slightly or seriously behind its competitors in the genre.

    But this "Mafia" justifies its means. All    In terms of its content, this is a rather modest game - apart from the main plot, there is practically nothing to do here, except to ride around the city in the "Walk" mode and look for collectibles. And every single element of the remake, whether it's graphics, shootouts or chases, lags slightly or seriously behind its competitors in the genre.

    But this "Mafia" justifies its means. All of its pieces, put together, serve only one damn important task - again tell us the incredible story of Tommy Angelo in a new, convenient wrapper. For this, the game wants to give the highest rating and elevate to the top line of the best gangster games of all time.    … Expand
  9. Kashau
    Feb 15, 2021
    8
    It's not flawless, and it actually has a couple of issues, but it makes up with a fantastic story, even better acting and the feeling you're in a proper Hollywood mafia movie.

    The not so good: -A few graphic glitches. Nothing too offensive if you're not an absolute graphic nerd - which luckily I'm not -On an Xbox One S you will experience some frame rate drops. Again, not an issue if    It's not flawless, and it actually has a couple of issues, but it makes up with a fantastic story, even better acting and the feeling you're in a proper Hollywood mafia movie.

    The not so good:
    -A few graphic glitches. Nothing too offensive if you're not an absolute graphic nerd - which luckily I'm not
    -On an Xbox One S you will experience some frame rate drops. Again, not an issue if you're in this for something more than amazing graphics @ 75fps
    -Controls can be slightly clunky. You do get used to them and the game is perfectly playable and enjoyable, although it might not be the best experience of your life regarding this matter.

    The good:

    -Atmosphere is ace
    -If you played the original one when it came out, you will love the way everything has been remade in a more modern way but keeping that essence that made the first game awesome.
    -Acting - out of this world. I genuinely don't understand that some people have criticisedthe acting and/or the story. They are impeccable, period. Characters are even better than in the original game. Absolutely awesome.
    -Most of the basic features that the first game was missing are here, like being able to cover or a better melee combat.

    Overall, fantastic game. I might not pay £35 for it, but if you find it on offer don't hesitate. Is it perfect? No it isn't, but how many games are?

    Now, is it a very enjoyable experience (specially if you have nostalgia on your side) and potentially one of the best games I've ever played regarding directing and acting? Absolutely!    … Expand
  10. Alexgangster
    Sep 26, 2020
    9
    Incredible remake, it shows that Hangar 13 learned from its mistakes from Mafia 3, improved the lighting a lot, the deformations of the cars are more realistic and easier to do, the cinematics are beautiful, I liked the original soundtrack and the music of the game, some animations are recycled from Mafia 3 but most of them are new, the melee combat is great, I have noticed few bugs but itIncredible remake, it shows that Hangar 13 learned from its mistakes from Mafia 3, improved the lighting a lot, the deformations of the cars are more realistic and easier to do, the cinematics are beautiful, I liked the original soundtrack and the music of the game, some animations are recycled from Mafia 3 but most of them are new, the melee combat is great, I have noticed few bugs but it does not compare with Mafia 3 in the bugs. Also the story is expanded and more complex, the missions are good, I liked the introduction of motorcycles to the saga, the free mode is good, I recommend this game if you want to have a good experience of nostalgia if you played the original game.… Expand
  11. Xbox_Alive
    Oct 13, 2020
    8
    Mafia Definative Edition is a Re-Imagining of the Original 2002 Hit. Revisiting the Story of Tommy, and how he meets Paulie and Sam and ends up a good fella in Don Salieri's Family. I just want to start with, this game is gorgeous! The sound, animation, textures... There was obviously a lot of love and effort poured into this remake. From the ground up everything was redone, with theMafia Definative Edition is a Re-Imagining of the Original 2002 Hit. Revisiting the Story of Tommy, and how he meets Paulie and Sam and ends up a good fella in Don Salieri's Family. I just want to start with, this game is gorgeous! The sound, animation, textures... There was obviously a lot of love and effort poured into this remake. From the ground up everything was redone, with the exception of the core story. The Voice acting is on point, and the writing seals the deal. The entire game was always an homage to the 30's crime noir, and gangster fiction. The game does an incredible job immersing you into Tommy's life durring his run with Don Salieri's Family. The two radio stations help drive the feel of the time, more in the talking and adverts than the music, but I can't deny that the music is also on point! Nothing quite like getting chased and shot at while some good swing music adds to the discord of the situation. I've always been a fan of that eras cars, and they did an incredible job embodying the look and feel of that periods automobiles. I've seen a few remakes over the last few years, but few have made such an impressive change as Hangar 13 and 2k Games pulled off. If you were a fan of any part of the series, this is a MUST HAVE. If you're new to it, there isn't a better time to start the series than now!… Expand
  12. PrinceNBD
    Sep 30, 2020
    10
    Mafia: Definitive Edition is a brilliant and faithful reincarnation of the original Mafia game. It remains true to its predecessor which released about two decades ago.

    I've been waiting for this game to be released since the day it got announced. It's simply because I loved Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven (the original game). It was a definitely a masterpiece. The story was excellent and    Mafia: Definitive Edition is a brilliant and faithful reincarnation of the original Mafia game. It remains true to its predecessor which released about two decades ago.

    I've been waiting for this game to be released since the day it got announced. It's simply because I loved Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven (the original game). It was a definitely a masterpiece. The story was excellent and highly impactful, it was an extremely rare gem in the video game industry during that time.

    This game is gorgeous, highly polished and it retains all the memorable missions from the first game. It's a no-brainer for the long-time fans of the series.

    And for those of you who haven't played the original game and have absolutely no idea about the plot: THIS IS A MUST-PLAY, BUY IT IMMEDIATELY!    … Expand
  13. miver
    Sep 26, 2020
    9
    The remake feels and looks great. Even though the game shows it's age, like facial expressions are not as we used to see in 2020, it's still got that magic which kept me in front of my PC for hours 18 years ago. It's just so awesome to drive around the magnificent city from 1930s, enjoying the feel of classic boaty cars.

    Still got it!
  14. Anatoliy_DeVile
    Apr 13, 2021
    8
    Первая оригинальная Mafia вышла аж в 2002 году, и в то время игрушка хорошо заходила, помнится. Так как затем захотелось пройти и вторую, и та тоже была что надо. До третьей как-то руки не дошли, хотя дойдут обязательно ибо в библиотеке она уже имеется. Правда ругают ее кому не лень, но это меня не сильно беспокоит. Watch Dogs Legion тоже все поносили, а игра-то в итоге отличнаяПервая оригинальная Mafia вышла аж в 2002 году, и в то время игрушка хорошо заходила, помнится. Так как затем захотелось пройти и вторую, и та тоже была что надо. До третьей как-то руки не дошли, хотя дойдут обязательно ибо в библиотеке она уже имеется. Правда ругают ее кому не лень, но это меня не сильно беспокоит. Watch Dogs Legion тоже все поносили, а игра-то в итоге отличная получилась! Так вот о Мафии первой давайте. Имеем по сути дело с игрой, сделанной с нуля, а не с подтянутой графикой 2002 года. Действительно выглядит новоявленная Мафия великолепно, всё как завещал великий и могучий Рэйтрэйсинг. Сюжет Мафии старой я помню с трудом, обе ее части чем-то схожи и из них в голове сложился у меня порядочный винегрет. Так что в 2021 году история Томми Анджело простого таксиста, ставшего волею судьбы правой рукой Дона Сальери — второго крупнейшего мафиозного босса в вымышленном городе Лост-Хэвен для меня воспринималась как нечто уже новое. Не особо я люблю все эти напыщенные так называемые произведения о бандитских разборках шумных итальянцев, они как-то разнообразием сильно не балуют. Как бы-то ни было сюжеточка и главные действующие персонажи в Mafia Definitive Edition заходят весьма неплохо. Наблюдать за происходящим было мне лично в меру интересно. Знаменитую локацию с гонкой пофиксили и в новом виде ее мы прошли со второй буквально попытки на нормальном уровне сложности. В далеком прошлом эта миссия сожгла в пепел не один пукан. Правда американцы из Hangar 13 решили смастерить новую игру на нервах в миссии погони с броневиком. Из n-ого количества попыток за второй десяток осилить эту чертову башню удалось только один раз практически на полностью всратом здоровье, но когда выяснилось что там еще две стадии раздевания бронемашины, не подкрепленных промежуточными сохранениями, принято было решение тупо пройти на изи и не испытывать на прочность вторую элиточку от майков. В общем и целом миссии в игре относительно разнообразные и в меру интригующие, до вау эффекта конечно далековато, но увлекательно спорить не стану. Из того что не понравилось в игре — это прежде всего стрельба. Не понимаю почему было не сделать аналогичную метку как в The Division, когда ты точно знаешь в какое место будешь стрелять, когда вылезешь из укрытия. В Мафии же ты примерно вроде бы наводишь камеру на потенциальный выстрел, по факту же вылазки получается что тебе всё равно нужно доводить прицел до цели, а за это время вражеская непись не стоит по стойке смирно, а весьма прицельно шпигует нашего Томми свинцом. К этой кривожопой стрельбе со временем привыкаешь конечно, но это не есть хорошо. Также не могу сказать за управление персонажем, что шибко оно отзывчивое, косяки незначительные имеются.… Expand
  15. KaliusMaximus
    Oct 3, 2020
    10
    This game is having the recipe for being a total masterpiece. Amazing detailed graphics, facial animation and lip sync. And above that a GOTY worth story.
  16. CraigYorkshire
    Sep 29, 2020
    10
    Mafia: Definitive Edition is a remake of one of the greatest games of the early 2000s, Mafia (2002).

    The original game's narrative was what made it, one of the best games of its generation. The story missions were so memorable that even playing through this remake nearly 20 years later, I still had a vivid recollection of the story, a testament to its greatness. I finished the main story    Mafia: Definitive Edition is a remake of one of the greatest games of the early 2000s, Mafia (2002).

    The original game's narrative was what made it, one of the best games of its generation. The story missions were so memorable that even playing through this remake nearly 20 years later, I still had a vivid recollection of the story, a testament to its greatness.

    I finished the main story in around 12 hours, which is relatively short compared to many modern games (something which I personally think is a nice change, games don't need to be 20+ hours). There is also a free ride mode, where you can drive around in the open world and find some secret cars and collectables. I would recommend this game to those who played the original and will get the same wonderful nostalgia I felt during my play through. I would also recommend it to those who didn't, who will get to experience the story for the first time. 10/10    … Expand
  17. XxNuckeXx
    Sep 29, 2020
    9
    The remake is simply incredible, it maintains the essence of the original, the characters, the story, everything is faithful and even improved, hangar 13 took the opportunity to improve the story and emphasize more on Some characters, the graphics are impressive, and the added cover system is good but not so good, I feel like the game is missing some more mechanics that make it moreThe remake is simply incredible, it maintains the essence of the original, the characters, the story, everything is faithful and even improved, hangar 13 took the opportunity to improve the story and emphasize more on Some characters, the graphics are impressive, and the added cover system is good but not so good, I feel like the game is missing some more mechanics that make it more memorable but It is a remake in style. Congratulations, I was delighted.… Expand
  18. Gabrielkenway
    Dec 11, 2020
    8
    Okay it's 2020, not 2010. The game is okay, graphics are good but not "that" good. The plot is great, very interesting, not like Mafia 2 but okay.
  19. Joaotmdj
    Dec 16, 2021
    9
    I remember playing the original version as a kid and I thought it was a really cool game but I was always stuck on the mission to burn and destroy the cars (yes, right at the beginning of the game lol) and so I never managed to finish it, but this time I did it.

    Positive points: Story (very good, I'd say it would be comparable to the "Godfather" of games but I'm a big fan of the    I remember playing the original version as a kid and I thought it was a really cool game but I was always stuck on the mission to burn and destroy the cars (yes, right at the beginning of the game lol) and so I never managed to finish it, but this time I did it.

    Positive points:

    Story (very good, I'd say it would be comparable to the "Godfather" of games but I'm a big fan of the mafia theme, so such a claim might be biased)

    Graphics (they are very beautiful, especially the city at night)

    Immersion (I felt very immersed in the game but maybe it was something personal, I even respected the traffic rules)

    Soundtrack

    Characters (I really liked them, felt like a sibling with Paulie and Sam, Don Salieri who passed the weight of being an authority figure and Sarah who had great chemistry with Tommy)

    End of story (it's a nice plot twist, unfortunately I already knew about this plot accidentally, but it's still amazing)

    Negative points:

    Bugs (I played this game close to launch and there were bugs that bothered me, like melee combat that sometimes looked clumsy)

    Empty open world (although very beautiful, it is lifeless and I consider this a terrible mistake, it would have a lot of potential for exploration with secondary activities,side missions and maybe even an online game mode but...)

    So, for those who are a fan of mafia theme, this is a game that cannot be ignored, it is really worth it.    … Expand
  20. SlavaKuzmin
    Sep 27, 2020
    10
    Remake really good, hangar 13 make a great job, and resurrect classic!!! Mafia remake it's a game with soul, mafia soul, thank you Hangar 13!!!
  21. Adelbek
    Sep 27, 2020
    10
    Шикарный ремейк великолепной игры который превзошёл оригинал. На xbox one x смотрится потрясающе
  22. ALANA-BRAKE
    Oct 4, 2020
    10
    Без сомнений отличная игра! Всем советую! Как фанат первой части.
  23. esquilo_png
    Nov 3, 2020
    10
    Jogo muito bom, cada segundo de gameplay são anos de nostalgia, nem tem oque falar dos gráficos estão ótimos, lembrou MUITO meu tempo de infância, o jogo está muito polido, quase nunca tem bugs, a dificuldade é alta assim como o jogo original mesmo que na média, se você jogou/gosta de mafia você PRECISA jogar esse jogo, é algo que todos devem experienciar no mundo dos games.
  24. jayjayjackob
    Oct 7, 2021
    9
    I love playing this game on Classic difficulty. It reminds me these good old days. I wish every Remaster will be made so good as this one.
    I recommend Ps.
    I give 9 only because there is one thing that deserves a 10:
    It is the Witcher Trilogy
  25. C4S44
    Jan 3, 2021
    8
    Güzel bir deneyim olduğunu söyleyebilirim. Hikayesi ve oynanışı cidden çok başarılı. 1-2 karakter haric karakterler çok derin olmasa da o dönemi yansıtan çok güzel bir dünyası var tavsiye ederim.
  26. osprey
    Aug 6, 2021
    9
    I did not play the original but I played Mafia 2 to death and loved it. I was very excited about Mafia 3 but hated it. This game is awesome!! You can change the weather and time of day and explore the beautifully rendered world to your hearts content. Hat's off to those who can play on classic difficulty and win the infamous race but for those of us content to complete the game andI did not play the original but I played Mafia 2 to death and loved it. I was very excited about Mafia 3 but hated it. This game is awesome!! You can change the weather and time of day and explore the beautifully rendered world to your hearts content. Hat's off to those who can play on classic difficulty and win the infamous race but for those of us content to complete the game and find all the cleverly hidden and diverse collectibles it is great fun. The better cars handle great, even the motorcycles! I loved the phone booth challenges and all the Easter eggs. Everything I want in a game and more. Sad when I finished it as I loved being in that world. The acting and characters were perfect and I liked how they ended the story. I had no issues with performance on my xbox one and none of the bizzare facial deformities that I have seen in videos. Highly recommend and congratulations to the developers on a job well done!!! Forgot to mention for those who say the world is empty in free ride I don't agree, the people you pass respond to you, there are air ships in the air and planes flying by pulling banners. Look around, the world is incredibly alive!!!… Expand
  27. Miguelbpaes
    Aug 14, 2021
    8
    Nota: 8.3

    Mafia: Definitive Edition é um presente para os fãs da franquia Mafia. Mafia DE não é uma completa releitura do clássico de 2002. Enquanto há uma clara semelhança na jogabilidade e nos gráficos se comparados ao antecessor Mafia III, Mafia DE apresenta gráficos mais bonitos, jogabilidade responsiva, história espetacular e um mundo aberto mais vivo que o seu material    Nota: 8.3

    Mafia: Definitive Edition é um presente para os fãs da franquia Mafia.

    Mafia DE não é uma completa releitura do clássico de 2002. Enquanto há uma clara semelhança na jogabilidade e nos gráficos se comparados ao antecessor Mafia III, Mafia DE apresenta gráficos mais bonitos, jogabilidade responsiva, história espetacular e um mundo aberto mais vivo que o seu material original.

    Mas, é visível que a desenvolvedora Hangar 13 sofreu com um pequeno orçamento em mãos. A falta de conteúdo pós-conclusão da história principal e seus gráficos não são espetaculares se comparados a outros títulos que o sucederam.    … Expand
  28. DzmitryBoston
    Apr 7, 2023
    10
    I couldn't ask for a better remake of a 20-year-old game. We don't need to rate the story or missions, as those are almost perfect. Developers who made the remake loved the original and did everything possible to provide a modern graphics experience. Must play.
  29. iSnow96
    Jan 31, 2021
    8
    Good graphics, story and characters, but the freeride mode world feels empty. Tommy and don salieri are my favorite characters, voice acting is very good also
  30. ElYisussss
    Sep 27, 2020
    10
    Un remake excelente, respetando al material original, y agregando diálogos/interacciones que realmente te hacen empatizar con todos los personajes.
    La historia principal es buenísima, te mantiene atento a lo que pasa y lo que pasará.
    Las misiones son muy variadas, y divertidas Incluso en free ride hay misiones por hacer. Gráficos excelentes, actuaciones excelentes. Espero que agreguen más    Un remake excelente, respetando al material original, y agregando diálogos/interacciones que realmente te hacen empatizar con todos los personajes.
    La historia principal es buenísima, te mantiene atento a lo que pasa y lo que pasará.
    Las misiones son muy variadas, y divertidas
    Incluso en free ride hay misiones por hacer.
    Gráficos excelentes, actuaciones excelentes.
    Espero que agreguen más contenido al free ride en un futuro.    … Expand
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

41
#41 Best Xbox One Game of 2020
16
#16 Most Discussed Xbox One Game of 2020

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
79

Generally favorable reviews - based on 21 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18 out of 21
  2. Mixed: 3 out of 21
  3. Negative: 0 out of 21
  1. Video Chums
    Oct 21, 2020
    78
    Mafia: Definitive Edition is a must-play for any fan of the franchise. Although it doesn't quite have the narrative cohesion of Mafia II, it still offers a memorable and gripping story that's set in a gorgeous virtual adaptation of 1930s America.
    Read full review
  2. Xbox Tavern
    Oct 13, 2020
    81
    Mafia: Definitive Edition is how a remake should be done. By taking and meticulously remoulding the original game, Mafia: Definitive Edition sings with a deliciously authentic 1930’s gangster shooter experience that’s enriched to no end by a chapter-based story that keeps the focus on the story and its characters. The aiming and target reticule aren’t ideal, and the Free Ride mode is a missed opportunity, but when the smoke clears and all you want is a classy hard-boiled gangster shooter there are few better options available.
    Read full review
  3. MGG Spain
    Oct 9, 2020
    85
    Mafia: Definitive Edition is the perfect game for those who loved the original work of Illusion Softworks back in 2002. A travel back to Lost Heaven that should be mandatory to meet Tommy, Paulie, Don Salieri and many others from a current and much fresher perspective. With more polished gameplay, a spectacular city perfectly set in those thirties and an identical plot, but with slight modifications that make the script grow in quality. The graphics element is just spectacular.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »