Metascore
71

Mixed or average reviews - based on 25 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 8 out of 25
  2. Negative: 0 out of 25
Buy Now
Buy on
  1. 90
    NHL 23 completely revamps crowd reactions and adds women IIHF players and new desperation moves, and it all works splendidly to create not only the best hockey game in a generation -- but one of the best sports games ever.
  2. Oct 14, 2022
    90
    NHL 23 is a vast improvement from last year's entry, featuring better control on the ice, the inclusion of women in HUT, and so much more.
  3. Oct 19, 2022
    85
    NHL 23 is another solid outing of EA Sports Hockey-Series. The gameplay sees minor improvements, that actually makes NHL 23 surpass ist predecessor. But overall the lack of real innovation is missing and therefore experienced players may give this one a pass.
  4. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Jan 25, 2024
    80
    It's getting harder and harder to find revolutionary elements without expanding the NHL itself. But despite these challenges, this year's edition of virtual hockey has something going for it and offers surprisingly great gameplay. [Issue#323]
  5. Nov 28, 2022
    80
    The NHL series really needs some competition. Once again, we get improvements in just one game mode while the others gather dust. This year, however, the amount of joy that has been added feels greater than usual.
  6. Oct 21, 2022
    80
    It’s overdue, but NHL 23 finally looks and feels like it belongs on these beefier consoles. The visual tech upgrade adds stellar reality to the on-ice play, which also benefits from players who are willing to dive for the puck to make a desperate goal or save. It gains new energy from crowds reacting to the action like real crowds would, bringing a definitive audio design that’s best-in-class for stadium effects. Franchise mode customization greatly expands, and seeing women in the fold for the first time feels right – and also overdue. At the same time there are several modes that are outright ignored, including the Be a Pro single-player campaign, and its microtransaction-driven Ultimate Team mode comes with the usual caveats about its predatory, profit-driven nature.
  7. 80
    If you’re looking for something that makes you feel closer to the ice than ever before, NHL 23 is going to be your favorite game that you play this year. The electricity that oozes from this title is something that will bring me back to playing it over and over again, even if there are a few nagging problems that need to be addressed very shortly.
  8. Nov 29, 2022
    75
    NHL 23 is a good if not revolutionary entry into an already commendable simulation sports game. It might not bring anything new to the ice, but it builds on the already pretty precise gameplay and its additions to the current modes make it a very solid entry to the series.
User Score
2.6

Generally unfavorable reviews- based on 56 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 11 out of 56
  2. Negative: 42 out of 56
  1. Oct 18, 2022
    0
    This game is the exact same garbage as the last. All the lazy developers did in this game is slapped the number 23 on the cover and called itThis game is the exact same garbage as the last. All the lazy developers did in this game is slapped the number 23 on the cover and called it a day. When it comes to physics, NHL games have the worst physics out of any EA sports game. The developers heavily advertised the presentations, but it is only available for 6 teams. It only last for less than 10 seconds. Are you freaking kidding me? It just goes to show how lazy these developers are. This is clearly an unfinished game. And the greedy developers have the audacity to charge $70 for this pile of garbage.

    The multiplayer is trash as always. For goodness sake, why are developers so obsessed with adding one male and one female in the cover of sports games? Enough already. I don't recommend this poor excuse of a game at all.
    Full Review »
  2. Oct 14, 2022
    4
    I have owned every NHL game ever made. Since 2015 the NHL series has removed all that was good and started to implement new and fresh ideasI have owned every NHL game ever made. Since 2015 the NHL series has removed all that was good and started to implement new and fresh ideas that really doesn't compare to the quality of years past. The BAP bugs are still present, completely unchanged and boring now that you get to hear the same crap in a new year. Franchise mode has a cool new customization feature but largely pretty vanilla and not any better than last year. I hate HUT and think it should be scrapped for GM Connected.

    I don't understand why EA can't do a 2-year game release with big updates throughout or a fairly inexpensive DLC to add new things. This would greatly improve the product and its playability.

    For the first time in 29 years, I may not buy an NHL game but wait for it to be sold on a used website for a fraction of the cost so EA doesn't get any of my money.

    Pure laziness and blatant robbery of our hard-earned money. I wish 2K would return to the NHL franchise. They always made the better games out of the two companies.
    Full Review »
  3. Oct 14, 2022
    4
    NHL 23 is not a bad game. None of them are. I and many paid 100$ for a slight upgrade. If you're a offline player like me, do not buy, there'sNHL 23 is not a bad game. None of them are. I and many paid 100$ for a slight upgrade. If you're a offline player like me, do not buy, there's isn't enough content to even be considered a new game from 22. The new features are just improvements. The last ditch shot is rarely used as well as the new Zegras flip. It's not even funny anymore. If you own NHL 22, I strongly recommend for the best experience to go download some UGC rosters.

    pros and cons

    ✅ You can Customize franchise mode teams and add up to 48 teams.

    ✅ Some bugs are fixed from 22

    ✅ Women Players can be used in Hut

    ✅ New X Factors notably the Trevor Zegras Flip

    ✅ Last ditch shot

    ✅New Crowd

    Full Review »