User Score
4.2

Generally unfavorable reviews- based on 163 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 58 out of 163
  2. Negative: 95 out of 163

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
  1. Jun 8, 2021
    6
    Sadly legitimately one of the worst iterations. It caters way too much to online diamond dynasty players while ruining offline modes like RTTS. I do NOT care for PvP and cards. Stop forcing that on us. Heavily disappointed with the check swing system too where 98% are strikes. If you're going to make separate balance for online (the competitive setting) why are controls in other modesSadly legitimately one of the worst iterations. It caters way too much to online diamond dynasty players while ruining offline modes like RTTS. I do NOT care for PvP and cards. Stop forcing that on us. Heavily disappointed with the check swing system too where 98% are strikes. If you're going to make separate balance for online (the competitive setting) why are controls in other modes identical? I'll give them credit for the stadium creator which is absolutely phenomenal. It has some ways to go but I'm amazed in their first implementation. Franchise is unchanged per usual, so the only enticing factor is making a team and stadium. Worst feature missing is sounds of the show. This is by far the most immersion breaking missing feature and MUST be brought back in the future. Expand
  2. May 5, 2021
    7
    Pretty good since all the bug fixes and updates. The only reason I'm only scoring it a 7 is because they charged PS4 customers full price for this game but punished them for not buying a PS5 by locking them out of using stadium creator and seeing the videos for the story progression in road to the show. WHAT? What's worse is because of the semiconductor shortage, Most people don't evenPretty good since all the bug fixes and updates. The only reason I'm only scoring it a 7 is because they charged PS4 customers full price for this game but punished them for not buying a PS5 by locking them out of using stadium creator and seeing the videos for the story progression in road to the show. WHAT? What's worse is because of the semiconductor shortage, Most people don't even have the option to buy a console right now unless you want to pay three times what the things worth. It's just so scum-baggy. Expand
  3. Apr 29, 2021
    6
    DIVIDING YOUR ATTENTION IS NEVER A GOOD THING

    Somehow, Major League Baseball got under PlayStation's skin and threatened them forcing PlayStation to make a move they NEVER would've made in the past, and it's a move that could ultimately cost them the PlayStation brand. We want to give them the benefit of the doubt they can be grown men and tell the truth but you never know in todays
    DIVIDING YOUR ATTENTION IS NEVER A GOOD THING

    Somehow, Major League Baseball got under PlayStation's skin and threatened them forcing PlayStation to make a move they NEVER would've made in the past, and it's a move that could ultimately cost them the PlayStation brand. We want to give them the benefit of the doubt they can be grown men and tell the truth but you never know in todays world. When the 10 Commandments were given, there was a reason "Thou Shalt Not Bear False Witness" was given, because people some four-thousand years later still can't seem to understand the damage a little "white lie" can do not only to ones self, but to those around them so hopefully, PlayStation can be honest and transparent in their communication to the people that supply their paychecks so they can buy their third house.

    Somehow, Major League Baseball (MLB from here on out) were able to talk the PlayStation brand into threatening their own console by taking The Show to competing platforms and they let another company that doesn't know anything about video games or the video game business tell them how to run THEIR business. PlayStation has been acting very conservatively (financialwise) over the past few years since new CEO Jim Ryan took over former CEO Shawn Laydens roll, does that mean PlayStation is hurting financially so much that they'd agree to do the unthinkable to port their bread and butter to not a company that isn't there's, but a company that offers their game for free under the guise that it'll help better promote the game, sure, for Xbox. The problem with it is that one of PlayStation's top developers is essentially a third-party developer now. Sony will front the bill 100%, MLB will pay nothing, MLB will collect royalties, Microsoft will pay pocket change to have the game on their console, and Xbox will put up PlayStation's work for free every year to frustrate PlayStation's fanbase every year to win over ball players knowing that PlayStation can't afford to give away the game they paid for every year to sink more in the hole.

    My point with this is the same with any third-party development company, when you have to divide your teams over multiple platforms, you lose quality because you can't just focus on just one. When quality suffers, the fun of the game suffers. So, San Diego Studio now gets to develop one game for: Xbox One, Xbox Series S and X, PS4, PS4 Pro, and PS5. We're still waiting to see if Nintendo will see PlayStation's game will become Switch and potentially Switch Pro. That's stretching your team thin for a little bit of money and that's what happened this year and from here on out, rather than PlayStation having the spine to put their foot down and say "Who are you to tell us how to run our business. We're good at what we do and we'll walk and then you'll have no game!"

    I was really looking forward to MLB The Show this year on a new console with a fresh new take. It's usually the same for hockey games every year from me as well but, this year felt a lot like the first NHL that released on PS4, no Season Mode.

    Season Mode is laid out the way it is for a reason. You start out learning the controls and getting a feel for the game and progressively get better and by Playoffs and World Series, you've got a good chance. But March for October "MFO" this year is sad. If you're one of the underdog teams, you really suffer. You play through a weird sort of season where you don't control your wins or losses, you're placed into impossible situations and the game then loves to watch you fail and the commentators will talk you up and embarass you and make you feel like a sad sack. The better you do, the better your teams morale, but the worse you do, the game makes you feel like turning a gun on yourself as worthless. I mean, I don't expect it to hold my hand or anything, you win some you lose some but, when you're working hard with a low rated team to score a run and with ease the game comes back and humiliates you, this game is supposed to be for gamers new to The Show altogether or maybe to March to October. I don't buy sports games because of incremental upgrades every year but, this seemed like a good time to jump in but, the modes have been frustrating, embarassing, and I haven't played a game in a long time that really makes you feel unimportant or worthless, and the game really rubs it in. All I wanted was a Season Mode and instead what I got, was the Middle School yard, I really wanted something better and expected better. Maybe having to worry about developing for Xbox took their focus and time away from developing a game for everyone, this was supposed to be the introduction of The Show, PlayStation style, to Xbox fans who haven't play this before, and somehow, even the Xbox version is scoring higher than the PlayStation version. Maybe when you don't have to pay anything for the experience are you expectations really low. Conservative PlayStation? Maybe not anymore. Too bad.......
    Expand
  4. May 5, 2021
    6
    the thing is , this game is the same thing as the past games , with a couple new animations , but i guess if it ain't broke don't fix it type of situation, just wish they would have at least gave us way better graphics for the next gen games
Metascore
78

Generally favorable reviews - based on 36 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 27 out of 36
  2. Negative: 0 out of 36
  1. May 20, 2021
    88
    The Show has been one of the more consistently excellent and complete sports series for years, and MLB The Show 21 maintains that excellence as it steps into the next-gen batter's box. The cover athlete choice of the aforementioned Fernando Tatis, Jr., is no coincidence, as the young star is being seen as one of baseball's next big things, ushering in a possible new era of personality and Q-rating power that the game could sorely use. He can also do everything, and everything is what this series has offered to fans for years at a high level. Time will tell if there is yet another level to reach.
  2. May 11, 2021
    70
    It really all comes down to your love of baseball. Even as a fan who watches the game regularly, I've had a hard time finding my footing in The Show 21. It's a hard game and that's OK. Challenges should always be welcomed. But there needs to be a way to bridge the gap, especially with The Show 21 now being made available to a much wider audience. If it can happen with other sports games, it's time it happens for baseball's biggest title.
  3. May 10, 2021
    78
    Sony San Diego develops a conservative delivery, with hardly any improvements in gameplay and content. Being intergenerational, in addition, the technical leap is invaluable, but nevertheless, it is still a very solid baseball game.