Madden NFL 23

 PlayStation 5
User Score
1.3

Overwhelming dislike- based on 214 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 16 out of 214
  2. Mixed: 13 out of 214
  3. Negative: 185 out of 214
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. Alias_Zero
    Feb 12, 2023
    0
    Zero talent behind this game, a pathetic cash grab by a pathetic company. Another copy past madden, everyone who worked on this game should be embarrassed.
  2. Dreww12
    Aug 19, 2022
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Terrible game. EA loves to sucker people with their marketing strategy.. seriously people, if we want change, we HAVE to quit buying Madden.… Expand
  3. oshkoshthejosh
    Aug 19, 2022
    0
    You're never going to believe it but the game is stilly buggy beyond belief to the point of not correctly functioning. There is no day 1 patch to fix franchise modes glitches so you're just stuck with a nonfunctional mode for an undetermined amount of time. There's over 70 feature that were in Madden's PS2 era that aren't in Madden 23. The NFL needs to open up the license because this gameYou're never going to believe it but the game is stilly buggy beyond belief to the point of not correctly functioning. There is no day 1 patch to fix franchise modes glitches so you're just stuck with a nonfunctional mode for an undetermined amount of time. There's over 70 feature that were in Madden's PS2 era that aren't in Madden 23. The NFL needs to open up the license because this game is an embarrassment to football and to videogames. We haven't had a good football game since Madden 08, and we haven't had a great football game since NFL 2K5. We're several console generations removed from good football games, and it doesn't look to change anytime soon . Save your money, don't buy this, and just accept that there won't be a good football game anytime soon and it won't come from EA. The Madden franchise is going to make me become a nihilist, nothing changes, the games continue to suck, football remains the most popular sport with no videogame capable of replicating it even a little. It just all feels so meaningless.… Expand
  4. Jdogg34
    Aug 17, 2022
    0
    Some game every year, no improvements, only more technical problems with no plans on fixing them.
  5. SheetStainzZz
    Aug 19, 2022
    0
    Another year, another disappointment from EA. I’ve seen the same tackling animations I’ve seen in the game for 10 years, same commentary, and overall just the same game. Graphics look better but it still looks and plays like a mobile game. Do better EA
  6. ihategeezy
    Aug 18, 2022
    0
    Same polished
  7. IxAMxNIGHTMARE
    Aug 18, 2022
    0
    And here we go again. Madden 15 part 8. Once again people love the early access version and think it's good until EA patches it right back into Madden 15. At no point will you actually have control of the game. EA will again decide who wins.
    They will make sure to rush you into ultimate team so you can become addicted to buying packs and hoping for a few more good players so you can    And here we go again. Madden 15 part 8. Once again people love the early access version and think it's good until EA patches it right back into Madden 15. At no point will you actually have control of the game. EA will again decide who wins.
    They will make sure to rush you into ultimate team so you can become addicted to buying packs and hoping for a few more good players so you can finally get over that hump and dominate.
    You never will. Do this... Go into MUT H2h and set it to friends only. You will see that you AND your friends all win between 45 and 63 winning percentage. That's to encourage you to buy those packs then you wonder why all your reliable cards begin to play like garbage as the new card you just upgraded to is absolutely on fire. After a month the new card is trash. Time to upgrade again. In fact you spend money and get cards, do quicksell for training which is a currency that you can't buy in cash but obviously you spent money in some way to get those training points. Also the same with certain holiday promotions. To make one player you have to buy his whole collection of cards. It all adds up but in EAs bank account.    … Expand
  8. dabirdman23
    Aug 19, 2022
    1
    Very buggy game. Lots of glitches in franchise mode, including the same one from last year that corrupts offline saves. My first franchise mode game, both teams wore practice jersey and Qbs wore Red, there was also no sound overlay, just crowd noise. They literally sold this game on it's polish this year because they didn't really add anything. So far... bleh
  9. Jets24
    Aug 17, 2022
    0
    I used to be proud to say that I own every madden. EA is an absolute joke and they made a copy and paste version of last year‘s matter for the 5th time in a row. The franchise mode is still just as dull as it was before. The game play still uses sucked in animations to force interceptions instead of just doing physical based gameplay(NCAA14). The practice mode is the laziest feature! TheI used to be proud to say that I own every madden. EA is an absolute joke and they made a copy and paste version of last year‘s matter for the 5th time in a row. The franchise mode is still just as dull as it was before. The game play still uses sucked in animations to force interceptions instead of just doing physical based gameplay(NCAA14). The practice mode is the laziest feature! The only thing that feels like practice is the fact that the quarterback has a red jersey. But the practices mode is set inside of a stadium in front of fans and the rest of the players are wearing full game day gear. EA sports is just awful with immersion. I want to feel like I’m living week to week in the NFL. Instead I feel like I paid $70 for a child arcade game that doesn’t actually represent football. Every year they promise A game and every year they don’t listen to what people want…#DONEWITHEA… Expand
  10. IGIN2019
    Aug 18, 2022
    0
    Nothing new same game for over ten years now. Animation still feels artificial for a "simulation" football game.
  11. Papshady
    Aug 19, 2022
    1
    Honestly, its an insult to societal intelligence to release this "updated" version of the game again. If this doesnt prove that EA is exploiting gambling addiction in youth, im not sure what will. The game really has been close to the same for a decade. Very little effort seems to go in the way of actually upgrading the game. There our bugs in the current version that were there theHonestly, its an insult to societal intelligence to release this "updated" version of the game again. If this doesnt prove that EA is exploiting gambling addiction in youth, im not sure what will. The game really has been close to the same for a decade. Very little effort seems to go in the way of actually upgrading the game. There our bugs in the current version that were there the past 4 years. I hope people can break the cycle instead of re-upping.… Expand
  12. badnewz323
    Aug 17, 2022
    0
    some EA guy just told nfl.com that they read feedback on various websites (LMAO)
    there is a decade long list of bugs and issues that are still present in the so called "game"
    go read all the feedback we as gamers left for you mr. incompetence mentioning the false advertisement of this product is not even worth my time can't wait for the day they get prosecuted for this atrocity    some EA guy just told nfl.com that they read feedback on various websites (LMAO)
    there is a decade long list of bugs and issues that are still present in the so called "game"
    go read all the feedback we as gamers left for you mr. incompetence

    mentioning the false advertisement of this product is not even worth my time
    can't wait for the day they get prosecuted for this atrocity (including DDA or whatever you wanna call it as it's even more ridiculous this time)

    would not recommend, sincerely a madden 22 legend division player (if it means anything to anyone) after 50 games of H2H in madden 22.1 (yeah it sucks that bad)    … Expand
  13. jexner325
    Aug 18, 2022
    4
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Purchased the Ultimate Edition. So disappointed. Constant issues and numerous bugs remain. I will pick a play and the game decides to choose a random different play. Apparently the LB’s have 63 inch verticals because they are picking off everything. Core gameplay is bad, the commentary is stagnant and boring and the constant push for Ultimate Team/Loot Boxes is just annoying. Trash game.… Expand
  14. Nowe
    Aug 18, 2022
    2
    It's a sad day again for simulation football fans. Gone are the days of innovation and originality. Bringing back a few options that was cut from older Madden games is not going to hide the fact that EA doesn't care about the NFL brand that the have a monopoly on. We deserve better
  15. Rectorn
    Aug 18, 2022
    0
    Same thrash as always. Takes 2 minutes to see the hype was all bs. Please let someone else make a damn nfl game.
  16. blazer8487
    Aug 18, 2022
    2
    As usual another copy paste with some minor changes that more or less does nothing to enhance the game. Steelers stadium is still hienz field and was just copy and pasted from last year. Will they tweak and fix things in game, probably. Am I pretty disappointed this year as for the first time in a long time I bought into the hype? Yup.
  17. BanditoBurrito
    Aug 19, 2022
    0
    I really wanted this version of the game to redeem my faith in what EA are creating. But I am so disappointed with this years version. I have been buying Madden since 05, but I feel that now its time to step away from the franchise. Its the same as Madden 21/22 but with a new roster. The game feels like its on rails and is the furthest thing from a football simulation. This is the lastI really wanted this version of the game to redeem my faith in what EA are creating. But I am so disappointed with this years version. I have been buying Madden since 05, but I feel that now its time to step away from the franchise. Its the same as Madden 21/22 but with a new roster. The game feels like its on rails and is the furthest thing from a football simulation. This is the last Madden I will buy until the franchise is moved elsewhere.… Expand
  18. Dahibachi
    Aug 19, 2022
    0
    I don’t understand how “professional critics” continue to rate the game decently especially when you compare madden to other sports games like NBA2k and MLB the Show. The standards need to be much higher and right now Maddens franchise mode wouldn’t be acceptable for the PS2 generation much less the PS5. NBA 2k is about to give us MyEra which gives us the ability to start a franchise fromI don’t understand how “professional critics” continue to rate the game decently especially when you compare madden to other sports games like NBA2k and MLB the Show. The standards need to be much higher and right now Maddens franchise mode wouldn’t be acceptable for the PS2 generation much less the PS5. NBA 2k is about to give us MyEra which gives us the ability to start a franchise from 3 different eras in the 80s, 90s and 2000s each with UNIQUE presentations to those eras and representative of those eras style of play and contracts. Compare that to Madden Franchise mode which doesn’t have realistic contracts, doesn’t have restricted FA, doesn’t have compensatory draft picks, has horrible CPU logic such as letting a franchise QB enter free agency without receiving franchise tag. Like they don’t even get the BASICS of how the real NFL is run much less give us deep features. Presentation is awful compared to what some other sports games give us. And gameplay, while improved, is still run on an animation based system and still features terrible CPU logic and predetermined play outcomes based on how an animation is playing out. How is this considered acceptable when we SEE what other sports games give us. WHY are we letting madden off the hook??? The only thing EA is good at is marketing because they somehow convince people to buy this trash every year and convince people it’s the best that can be done with a football game. I wish people would see the light on this but sadly they won’t. I’ve stopped buying this trash as much as I love football and want to play a football game but what good is it if I’m disappointed every time I play the game?… Expand
  19. Djwoods23
    Aug 19, 2022
    1
    Same pig, new lipstick. Minor "upgrades" to franchise mode. Yet again all significant time and energy was spent by EA in their MUT microtransactions bullsh1t. Yet another year to stay away. Hopefully enough of you are smart enough to do it for once so REAL changes are done to franchise mode.
  20. BarnDogg27
    Aug 19, 2022
    0
    This is the same game we’ve had the past few years. This is literally the same game. There are no major improvements to Franchise Mode - like, what were they doing? Quit overhauling on the field stuff & PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT YOUR COMMUNITY IS SAYING! This is ridiculous. 3 years in a row I’ve returned a preorder on this title. You seriously still are a black empty picture for created ownerThis is the same game we’ve had the past few years. This is literally the same game. There are no major improvements to Franchise Mode - like, what were they doing? Quit overhauling on the field stuff & PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT YOUR COMMUNITY IS SAYING! This is ridiculous. 3 years in a row I’ve returned a preorder on this title. You seriously still are a black empty picture for created owner & coach. … Expand
  21. marccochadora
    Aug 19, 2022
    5
    Positive:
    Great graphics (even it was normal for example NBA2k22)
    Animations look great Scouting in Franchise got a lil better Negative I still have the feeling my Playcalling or execution has too little impact on the game. Inaccurate passes always result in Interceptions, defense player jumping ridiculous high to intercept passes and players glitching through one another resulting in big    Positive:
    Great graphics (even it was normal for example NBA2k22)
    Animations look great
    Scouting in Franchise got a lil better

    Negative
    I still have the feeling my Playcalling or execution has too little impact on the game.
    Inaccurate passes always result in Interceptions, defense player jumping ridiculous high to intercept passes and players glitching through one another resulting in big players, even in great coverage.

    Bad teams like the for example Jets are way to strong when playing them in Franchise Mode, exspecially QBs seem to be way overpowered.
    DBs Never lose coverage on streak routes, even with Receivers with above 95 Speed Rating.

    Draft presentation is so boring and didn’t change at all, no big problem but annoying.

    But what makes me sad most, is Field Sense. The Idea for a new passing mechanic was great and it is so good to use. BUT because of almighty defensive animations it just makes no sense.
    You can not „place a pass where only your receiver can get it“ when because of the animations and glitches there is no such place where defenders won’t defend your pass.

    All in all the game is BETTER than Madden 22. but not 89,99€ better.
    And it’s not better enough, to get a positive review.    … Expand
  22. swaers
    Aug 18, 2022
    1
    I’ve bought madden every year since 2008 and this has been the first time I’ve truly not had fun. The passing system is dumb. The DB’s play like randy moss and always get crazy interceptions and they literally didn’t do anything with franchise mode at all. EA promised to put more effort into franchise and it’s clear they’ve lied. I haven’t played face of the franchise yet but I’m sure itI’ve bought madden every year since 2008 and this has been the first time I’ve truly not had fun. The passing system is dumb. The DB’s play like randy moss and always get crazy interceptions and they literally didn’t do anything with franchise mode at all. EA promised to put more effort into franchise and it’s clear they’ve lied. I haven’t played face of the franchise yet but I’m sure it sucks too. If you like throwing your money in the trash then this game is for you.… Expand
  23. Shauns614
    Sep 1, 2022
    0
    First gripe.. no "real changes" the gameplay is sped up and feels extremely arcadey.. This does not feel like a sim at all. They removed Campus Legends (NCAA) from superstar KO mode which i loved and played all the time in Madden 22. I think the graphics while bright and shiny look cartooney.. Have you seen the rendered hair of Trevor Lawrence during the intro? Laughable.. of course youFirst gripe.. no "real changes" the gameplay is sped up and feels extremely arcadey.. This does not feel like a sim at all. They removed Campus Legends (NCAA) from superstar KO mode which i loved and played all the time in Madden 22. I think the graphics while bright and shiny look cartooney.. Have you seen the rendered hair of Trevor Lawrence during the intro? Laughable.. of course you haven't though because no one uses the Jags but I did.. I am sure other player models are atrocious.. The added game play gimmicks don't add anything.. refs are missing from the field yet again.. I prefer the pace of 22, as i said, way too fast and not realistic on the field.. Defense intercepts almost every pass that isnt wide open throws.. the game is a mess.. I read EA wants players word of mouth to sell this game.. got bad news for them, i think as people play this game more over the next few days they will not like it. This is the first year i started a trial instead of blindly buying it and im happy i did that... I don't plan to purchase this year.. will wait for game pass and play madden 22 and get to use college teams in superstar KO mode.. Face of the franchise is still contrived and boring and not worth playing BTW.. penalties are NEVER called even set at 99!… Expand
  24. meangene22
    Aug 19, 2022
    0
    there were some cool things added but the game is borderline unplayable. defenses pick EVERYTHING off, fumbles relentlessly, WR's not playing the ball. OL men standing watching people run by them. It s the same broken piece of garbage. I really bought into the hype this year with the the 'focus on franchise' and 'most polished version in recent years' but ffs this is the last straw. I'vethere were some cool things added but the game is borderline unplayable. defenses pick EVERYTHING off, fumbles relentlessly, WR's not playing the ball. OL men standing watching people run by them. It s the same broken piece of garbage. I really bought into the hype this year with the the 'focus on franchise' and 'most polished version in recent years' but ffs this is the last straw. I've always had fun with Madden, even in years when it was bad and things didn't change. But I just do not have fun with this madden. pure frustration.… Expand
  25. loungefly85
    Aug 29, 2022
    0
    Yet another entry into what all sports games have become these days, glorified card collecting games. All these devs and EA care about is MUT and the rest of the game be damned.

    Can we have just 1 sports game in 2022 that isn't almost 100% focused on fake team, card modes? Gotta make that $ from kiddie gambling though.
  26. Bmckay87
    Sep 3, 2022
    0
    Same recycled BS for the last 10+ years. Really wish there was a football game to satisfy us NFL fans but EA doesn’t care about us. Avoid at all costs.
  27. KennRapp
    Aug 20, 2022
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I want a refund EA should be ashamed of themselves profiting off the death of a legend. Didn't even have the decency to make his model look good. Last-gen user get absolutely nothing more than a $67-$100 re-skinned roster/soundtrack update and the re-skin legit is painful to the eyes. All the "new" features are on current-gen only. Oh and unfortunately Sony Is Not refunding the purchase making them equally guilty of this Criminal, emotional and financial raping and fan/consumer disservice. #FixMaddenFranchise4Real #RefundMadden23Sony… Expand
  28. GameDudeChris
    Aug 20, 2022
    0
    It's a $60-$70 roster update, depending upon your console of choice. For no reason at all, PC does NOT get the next gen update, once again. The animations are still bad. Franchise mode is still terrible. "A step in the right direction" means nothing when you are at the bottom. It is a shame what EA has done to the name of the great John Madden. Same trash as last year.
  29. Beatztronic
    Aug 18, 2022
    5
    +Visuals look amazing with new attention to uniforms and player movement in cut scenes.
    +New throwing meter works well and makes passing enjoyable.
    -Same game engine with very few tweaks to actually improve on gameplay. -Same boring commentary and presentation. -Field Sense does absolutely nothing. -Lots of I'm game and franchise mode bugs. -No flow or feeling to the gameplay, it gets    +Visuals look amazing with new attention to uniforms and player movement in cut scenes.
    +New throwing meter works well and makes passing enjoyable.
    -Same game engine with very few tweaks to actually improve on gameplay.
    -Same boring commentary and presentation. -Field Sense does absolutely nothing.
    -Lots of I'm game and franchise mode bugs.

    -No flow or feeling to the gameplay, it gets stale fast.
    -Feels like Madden 22 with a fresh coat of paint and some new animations.    … Expand
  30. Halupa22
    Aug 20, 2022
    0
    Ultimate team is a mode for twitch streamers who get donations, rich people, and kids who steal their parents credit cards. Your average loyal buyer of the game can’t even have fun with the mode. EA is the cancer of the video game industry and they don’t care about anything rather than “pay me more money to have fun”
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

21
#21 Most Discussed PlayStation 5 Game of 2022

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
69

Mixed or average reviews - based on 30 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 10 out of 30
  2. Mixed: 19 out of 30
  3. Negative: 1 out of 30
  1. We Got This Covered
    Oct 17, 2022
    80
    Madden NFL 23 honors its namesake in nearly every facet of the game, but the highly-touted FieldSense is overcomplicated and detracts from what should have been a fun and heartfelt tribute to the great John Madden.
    Read full review
  2. PLAY
    Oct 15, 2022
    60
    The generational change hasn’t been felt since PS4, and the PS5 jump is marginal. It’s still awkwardly presented, quirky with glitches, and fighting between simulation and arcade play. Madden 23 never feels comfortable in its own skin, but hopefully Coach, wherever he is, can take solace in what his legacy built. [Issue#20, p.88]
  3. Gamers' Temple
    Oct 6, 2022
    66
    Madden NFL 23 is another incremental update in a franchise known for putting out incremental updates. Updated rosters, a few minor additions to existing game modes, and a couple of gameplay tweaks – you know the drill. The presentation is still thoroughly dull and even the soundtrack feels tired. The gameplay engine is in need of more than an incremental update, though. The “if it’s in the game, it’s in the game” game still feels more like you’re playing a Madden game than a simulation of an NFL game. With the passing of its namesake, perhaps it’s finally time to build a new game, one that NFL fans can really get excited about.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »