Red Dead Redemption 2

 PlayStation 4
User Score
8.7

Generally favorable reviews- based on 21344 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18,146 out of 21344
  2. Mixed: 1,261 out of 21344
  3. Negative: 1,937 out of 21344
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. cr81d
    Jun 3, 2023
    9
    The most detailed, impressive and realistic open world to date with a story that tops Hollywood's best.
    Though it does have a few annoying elements that take away from the immersion
  2. Mins76
    Jun 11, 2023
    9
    This game will have you entertained by a thousend different ways, it's perfect to chill out, just a masterpiece. I don't put the 10 because, personally, the fights/battles have something that doesn't makes me enjoy them.
  3. sagemilli92
    Jun 21, 2023
    9
    Gameplay - 9 (just feels a little wonky at times)
    Visuals - 10 (nothing out there looks better)
    Story - 9 (some incredible moments, but can be a little drawn out)
  4. sideshownate
    Aug 13, 2023
    9
    What can go wrong with a western and one of the greatest characters in video game history? I wanna give this a 10 so bad but there are some issues (like length) that make the game kind of drag. Still easily like one of the greatest games ever made LOL
  5. Crowolff
    Jul 15, 2023
    9
    Definitely a good game, the story is great and it's quite immersive, you really connect with the main protagonist this game is worth your money and that is rare in this age and time so take your time and enjoy
  6. magnolia6
    Jun 30, 2023
    9
    The best story I have ever encountered in any game to date. The ending in particular was very memorable.
  7. Kur0
    Aug 8, 2023
    9
    Uno de los mejores juegos de todos los tiempos, poco mas que añadir........
  8. andrilitvynchuk
    Aug 23, 2023
    9
    The gameplay is fine but the story is totally great. I loved it. We just need money
  9. deig0
    Aug 13, 2023
    9
    It was perfect, perfect, down to the last detail... Not exactly. The game is 95% perfect. The story is great, characters are amazing but gameplay (especially on shootouts) it's sometimes a bit rough. Except for that absolutely recommended.
  10. KeenGamer6
    Aug 14, 2023
    9
    One of the best stories in gaming. World felt lived in and mechanics are best in class. Graphical fidelity was incredible for PS4 pro and I cannot recommend it enough. Its a very in depth game in terms of world building but some of it can feel like a grind. Push through to reap the rewards of a 10/10 story
  11. aesirus96
    Aug 15, 2023
    9
    Em primeiro lugar, Red Dead Redemption II não é um jogo para qualquer um.

    Em segundo, o jogo foi feito para ser aproveitado lentamente, parte por parte, capitulo por capítulo. Bem lentamente. Cada missão tem o seu próprio ritmo, cada arma tem sua "personalidade", cada cidade tem seu próprio organismo vivo, cada NPC uma vida, com certeza cada uma das milhares de linhas de diálogo foi    Em primeiro lugar, Red Dead Redemption II não é um jogo para qualquer um.

    Em segundo, o jogo foi feito para ser aproveitado lentamente, parte por parte, capitulo por capítulo. Bem lentamente.

    Cada missão tem o seu próprio ritmo, cada arma tem sua "personalidade", cada cidade tem seu próprio organismo vivo, cada NPC uma vida, com certeza cada uma das milhares de linhas de diálogo foi pensada e repensada várias vezes e raramente se repetem... o jogo é uma obra que reúne o melhor das 7 artes, com uma trilha sonora incrível e vibrante, cenários de tirar o fôlego, cinemáticas que são melhores que muitas obras de Hollywood, mecânicas que deixariam muitos outros jogos AAA no chinelo e interações interpessoais jamais vistas antes pela minha pessoa.

    Vivendo a vida de Arthur, você sente o drama de foras da lei num mundo onde eles não têm mais espaço, você sente a rivalidade pós guerra civil entre os estados (mesmo esses do jogo sendo fictícios), sente a raiva, o ódio, a alegria e a satisfação que o jogo tenta passar durante todos os momentos. Não tem como jogar apenas uma vez.

    Não sou fã dos títulos da Rockstar, inclusive mal joguei o maior sucesso até então, mas, na minha mais humilde opinião, RDR II poderia ser classificado facilmente como um dos jogos mais impactantes da década, senão um grande divisor de águas de gerações, pois cada centavo que eu paguei valeu a pena.    … Expand
  12. Lollllkkj
    Sep 11, 2023
    9
    re dead redemption 2 è uno dei videogiochi open world meglio esistenti sul mercanto con una storia lunga più di 50 ore complessive. Una grafica che, per essere stato rilasciato nel 2018, è meravigliosa.

    Una storia emozionante che ti coinvolge dall'inizio alla fine, facendoti vedere e giocare cose che non ti saresti aspettato. Ottima anche la scelta dell'ambientazione che fino ad'ora non    re dead redemption 2 è uno dei videogiochi open world meglio esistenti sul mercanto con una storia lunga più di 50 ore complessive. Una grafica che, per essere stato rilasciato nel 2018, è meravigliosa.

    Una storia emozionante che ti coinvolge dall'inizio alla fine, facendoti vedere e giocare cose che non ti saresti aspettato. Ottima anche la scelta dell'ambientazione che fino ad'ora non ha eguali sul periodo storico in cui è ambientato il gioco. 9/10    … Expand
  13. endergunayu
    Aug 25, 2023
    9
    Such an amazing experiment for me. Unique easter eggs and infinite open world.If l talk about the story it is not the best work but still impressive!
  14. Axiom_show
    Aug 31, 2023
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. If you haven't played this game yet, you have made a big mistake. No matter how much I describe this game, I said too little. This game is wonderful. In terms of graphics, the story has no equal. I gave it a score of 9 because of the online part, which is not good at all, and there are very few updates for the online part. is coming… Expand
  15. SuperSonicJunus
    Sep 9, 2023
    9
    Writing this in 2023 and I’m not so sure a game has been as impressive as RDR2 since that it came out. I think there might be too much land in the game to horseback through and the story takes a while to pick up and a lot of filler. But if that’s the only things I think is wrong with the game, you might think it’s the best game ever. Simply put, another masterpiece from Rockstar. OnlineWriting this in 2023 and I’m not so sure a game has been as impressive as RDR2 since that it came out. I think there might be too much land in the game to horseback through and the story takes a while to pick up and a lot of filler. But if that’s the only things I think is wrong with the game, you might think it’s the best game ever. Simply put, another masterpiece from Rockstar. Online mode has its moments but nowhere near as fun as GTA Online. Do think it would be better if there were up to 100 players in your lobby.… Expand
  16. SabreSouls
    Sep 8, 2023
    9
    Red Dead Redemption 2: A Triumph in Gaming Excellence

    Rockstar Games has once again delivered a tour de force in the realm of video game entertainment with their release of "Red Dead Redemption 2." This latest instalment in the Red Dead series stands as a testament to the studio's prowess in crafting immersive worlds and compelling narratives, reaffirming their place at the forefront of    Red Dead Redemption 2: A Triumph in Gaming Excellence

    Rockstar Games has once again delivered a tour de force in the realm of video game entertainment with their release of "Red Dead Redemption 2." This latest instalment in the Red Dead series stands as a testament to the studio's prowess in crafting immersive worlds and compelling narratives, reaffirming their place at the forefront of the gaming industry. In this review, we delve into the intricacies and grandeur of this masterpiece, exploring the remarkable attention to detail, the sprawling open-world environment, the multifaceted characters, and the emotional journey of Arthur Morgan, all of which contribute to elevating this game to a well-deserved 9/10 in our evaluation.

    A World of Astonishing Detail:

    One of the most remarkable aspects of "Red Dead Redemption 2" is the sheer depth of detail infused into every facet of its world. From the bustling streets of Saint-Denis to the tranquil beauty of the Heartlands, every location exudes authenticity and historical accuracy. The flora and fauna that inhabit the landscape feel alive, and the dynamic weather system adds an extra layer of immersion. The meticulous attention to detail extends to the characters, whose expressions and mannerisms reflect the nuances of their personalities and experiences. Players can spend hours simply wandering the world, discovering hidden secrets, and soaking in the breathtaking scenery.

    A Living, Breathing Open World:

    The game's open world is nothing short of a masterpiece in itself. It's a sprawling, living, and breathing entity that reacts to your actions and choices. Whether you're exploring the wilds, engaging in intense gunfights, or embarking on side quests, the world of "Red Dead Redemption 2" remains consistently engaging. It's a place where your choices matter, impacting not only your interactions with other characters but also shaping the overall narrative. The game's commitment to a living world is evident in the way NPCs go about their daily lives, the passage of time, and the evolving events that unfold as the story progresses.

    Multifaceted Characters:

    The characters in "Red Dead Redemption 2" are nothing short of extraordinary. Arthur Morgan, the game's protagonist, undergoes a profound journey of redemption, and his character development is nothing short of a triumph. His moral dilemmas, conflicts, and emotional depth draw players into his world, making you genuinely care about his fate. But Arthur is just one piece of the puzzle; the entire cast is richly developed, each with their own motives and desires. Whether it's Dutch's charismatic yet enigmatic leadership or the colourful assortment of gang members, every character adds depth to the game's narrative and keeps players invested in the unfolding drama.

    An Emotional Rollercoaster:

    At its core, "Red Dead Redemption 2" is a story of redemption and the consequences of one's choices. The emotional journey that players embark upon as Arthur Morgan is nothing short of harrowing and poignant. The game masterfully weaves a tale of loyalty, betrayal, and self-discovery, which leaves a lasting impact on the player. The moral choices presented throughout the game force players to grapple with their own sense of right and wrong, adding a layer of emotional investment that few games can match. It's a testament to the storytelling prowess of Rockstar Games that "Red Dead Redemption 2" can elicit such a range of emotions, from sorrow to triumph.

    Conclusion:

    In conclusion, "Red Dead Redemption 2" is a gaming masterpiece that excels on multiple fronts. Its meticulous attention to detail, sprawling open world, multifaceted characters, and emotionally charged narrative combine to create an experience that stands as a high watermark for the industry. It's a game that not only entertains but also challenges players to reflect on their own choices and moral compass. With its well-deserved 9/10 rating, "Red Dead Redemption 2" stands as a shining example of what can be achieved in the world of video game storytelling and world-building. It's an experience that will linger in the hearts and minds of players long after the credits roll, firmly solidifying its place among the greatest games of all time.    … Expand
  17. Samuestianloev
    Sep 10, 2023
    9
    Uno de los mejores videojuegos de la historia
    sino el mejor, el mejor mundo abierto jamás visto en ningún otro juego, una narrativa fantástica, un apartado jugable exquisito, ambientación increíble, preciosos paisajes acompañado de unos gráficos que algunas veces parece next-gen, pero, como todo juego, este también tiene sus fallas
    Las misiones se le pueden hacer repetitivas a más de uno,    Uno de los mejores videojuegos de la historia
    sino el mejor, el mejor mundo abierto jamás visto en ningún otro juego, una narrativa fantástica, un apartado jugable exquisito, ambientación increíble, preciosos paisajes acompañado de unos gráficos que algunas veces parece next-gen, pero, como todo juego, este también tiene sus fallas
    Las misiones se le pueden hacer repetitivas a más de uno, el juego es largo, y aunque para mi eso no sea un problema, sí es cierto que algunas personas eso les pueda tirar para atrás, por lo demás, increíble
    Un juego faraonico, con millones de detalles, con un realismo i-m-p-r-e-s-i-o-n-a-n-t-e
    y una profundidad que nunca he visto en ningún otro juego.
    Una obra maestra, espero que rockstar mejore el error de las misiones en gta 6 y haya un equilibrio entre gran narrativa y misiones geniales, ya que en el gta 5 invirtieron más en misiones que en historia y en Red Dead Redemption 2 han invertido más en historia que en misiones, espero que sepan encontrar un equilibrio en su próximo gran juego. Obra maestra de los mundos abiertos, el mejor videojuego de la octava generación.    … Expand
  18. Captiosus
    Oct 29, 2018
    8
    I'm well into Chapter 3 as I type this and the more I play the more I realize this game isn't a 9 or 10 game. I'm not even sure it's an 8, even though that's where I'm going to round my score to; I'd give it a 7.5 if I could do half scores.

    Pros: + Beautiful open world + Engaging story, though the protagonist is extremely dense + Open world elements present to the player organically    I'm well into Chapter 3 as I type this and the more I play the more I realize this game isn't a 9 or 10 game. I'm not even sure it's an 8, even though that's where I'm going to round my score to; I'd give it a 7.5 if I could do half scores.

    Pros:
    + Beautiful open world
    + Engaging story, though the protagonist is extremely dense
    + Open world elements present to the player organically rather than as a checklist of things to collect/do.

    Cons:
    - Minutia bogs down every aspect of the game.
    - Gunplay is horrid, significantly worse than the first.
    - Wildly inconsistent crime system.

    The pros speak for themselves, but I must elaborate on the cons. From the very onset of the game, it's made clear that you will be spending a large amount of your playtime managing the minutia of gameplay systems. Wear the appropriate clothing so you're not too hot or cold, or you'll lose stamina. Brush your horse or your horse loses stamina. Eat regularly or you'll lose health and stamina, but don't eat too much or you'll become overweight and have less stamina. Hunt for the camp, pay money for the camp, upgrade the camp (no one else does). Shave and bathe or the townsfolk won't interact with you positively. Clean your guns or they'll lose stats and eventually jam. Make sure you hunt silently and stay downwind so your scent doesn't startle your prey (or use scent masker).

    These systems start out enjoyable but devolve into complete tedium within a few hours -- and they NEVER let up. The quality of the story telling is bogged down entirely by the constant need to play Camping and Outlaw Simulator 1899.

    Also one of the most frustrating elements of the game is the crime system and how inconsistent it is. A couple examples: At one point I forgot to stow my Lancaster Repeater on my saddlebags and accidentially walked into the town of Strawberry holding it. A townsfolk decided I was disturbing the peace by doing so and ran to tell the Sheriff. I thought nothing of it, concluded my business, and left town. Moments later, I had a $10 bounty on my head and lawmen closing in on every side, shooting at me indiscriminantly, all for a disturbing the peace charge. Riding down the road in the second chapter, an O'Driscall man opened fire on me as I passed by and knocked my horse out from under me. I killed him in self defense and hid the body in the woods. A few moments later, after I'm LONG gone from the area, I get a notification that a crime has been reported and I'm wanted for murder with a $40 bounty. Despite no one having seen me there beyond the guy I shot dead.

    These incidents happen frequently. Defending yourself in fist fights or gun fights often ends up with YOU being the target of law. Even if you have high honor and no other bounties on your head. Then sometimes you can get into a fistfight in the middle of town, beat a guy to death, and get no repurcussions at all.

    Rockstar has always been hit-or-miss with their gunplay mechanics and when they initially released the first RDR in 2010 I was scared it would be a miss. Pleasantly the gun play in that game was top notch, better than most other Rockstar games. The same cannot be said for RDR2. The gun mechanics are back to the same old GTA5, sluggish, awful, design that leans heavily on aim assist to be useful. Even Dead Eye is a shell of its former self. I find myself avoiding gunfights entirely because the gunplay is so underwhelming and unrewarding.

    Unlike the first game, I'm not finding myself wanting to complete every challenge, or find every herb, or upgrade every item. The minutia has had an opposite effect on my play. I have one maxed horse and I couldn't give a damn about any others. I'm not busting my ass to buy item upgrades and I'm no longer bothering with camp chores because I'm only going back to camp when I have to launch story missions. It's easier to stay in a hotel or camp out anyway. The first RDR is a game I happily platinumed; RDR2 is a game I'll probably play once and never play again.    … Expand
  19. MrMT
    Oct 27, 2018
    8
    It’s a beautiful story driven game, but it’s also slow and clunky. The first hours move at glacial pace, and it’s easy to make simple UI mistakes which make them even longer. Looting is slooooow. Searching cabinets is sloooow. Changing weapons is sloooow. Getting from a to b is sloooow. I may amend this over time, but so far I’d say it’s best in class as a living world with interestingIt’s a beautiful story driven game, but it’s also slow and clunky. The first hours move at glacial pace, and it’s easy to make simple UI mistakes which make them even longer. Looting is slooooow. Searching cabinets is sloooow. Changing weapons is sloooow. Getting from a to b is sloooow. I may amend this over time, but so far I’d say it’s best in class as a living world with interesting events and scenarios, but functionality is flawed.… Expand
  20. Catchy
    Nov 17, 2018
    8
    This is an updated review after completing the game.

    Story mode was great, attention to detail is the best I’ve seen in a game. However, controls and mechanics in this game is really annoying. The controls really felt clunky especially in some tight fighting scenarios, it was really frustrating. One example is when I was walking in town, I suddenly kicked a dog because my character    This is an updated review after completing the game.

    Story mode was great, attention to detail is the best I’ve seen in a game. However, controls and mechanics in this game is really annoying. The controls really felt clunky especially in some tight fighting scenarios, it was really frustrating. One example is when I was walking in town, I suddenly kicked a dog because my character wanted to do extra steps after I released the run button. I ended up getting wanted for “animal abuse”, got gunned down, and of course my manual save was 2 hours ago, autosave was after I got “resurrected”. Which brings me to the point of some annoying mechanics. I lost my horse which cost me 1400dollars, because some sneaky bounty hunters decided to jump me, I died and my horse died apparently, I respawned, but for some reason my horse didn’t respawn?!? I was left with some random horse, and again my manual save was long ago.

    All in all, a game I would recommend to complete the story, manual save often and have patience with the controls.    … Expand
  21. duffmanth
    Nov 13, 2018
    8
    So I just finished the main story and I was generally very impressed with the game. The visuals, story, open world, characters, voice acting are all very impressive. The game is slow paced and there are stretches of the game that are boring/repetitive/tedious, but it's trying to tell a story, trying to immerse the player in the world, making the characters progress, and building towardsSo I just finished the main story and I was generally very impressed with the game. The visuals, story, open world, characters, voice acting are all very impressive. The game is slow paced and there are stretches of the game that are boring/repetitive/tedious, but it's trying to tell a story, trying to immerse the player in the world, making the characters progress, and building towards something overall. Too many people, especially gamers, have the attention span of a 2 year old. It seems people just want run and gun garbage games like Call of Duty that you can blow through in an afternoon!?

    Now, that being said, RDR2 has its issues. The shooting controls/mechanics need some tweaking, the hand to hand combat is frustrating cuz you can barely get a block in, the weapons/items menus could have been better laid out, and controlling your f*cking horse is an issue sometimes.

    RDR2 is a solid effort from Rockstar, it may not be a masterpiece, and it has its issues, but it's a GOTY/system seller that's better than most of garbage that's out there!    … Expand
  22. Gradstudent
    Oct 27, 2018
    8
    It's a good but flawed open-world title. Certainly superior to several of those mediocrities that have come out this generation (I'm looking at you, Mass Effect: Andromeda and The Witcher 3), but it could've used shoring up in a number of areas.
  23. Agarwel
    Nov 4, 2018
    8
    Huge detailed word, impressive technical presentation with sone never-seen beautifull effect and impressive amount of handcrafted content (story, locations, dialogue). From the technical point of view there is nothing to complain about.
    But also - repetitive gameplay (most of the time you ride horse, shoot enemies or stealth them). And some gamedesign choices jsut takes time, but dont add    Huge detailed word, impressive technical presentation with sone never-seen beautifull effect and impressive amount of handcrafted content (story, locations, dialogue). From the technical point of view there is nothing to complain about.
    But also - repetitive gameplay (most of the time you ride horse, shoot enemies or stealth them). And some gamedesign choices jsut takes time, but dont add anything to the gameplay. Looting is detailed and slow, browsing shops is detailed and slow, hunting is detailed and slow... considering the game size and length this is nice first few times. But looting a house after 50 hours of gameplay is pain.
    The game is fun and difficult to put down because of the exploration, but not the gameplay itself.    … Expand
  24. karco
    Oct 26, 2018
    8
    Good game. Graphics, animation and detalization of the environment are top notch. But game is not even close to 10/10 gameplaywise. Gameplay in latest Zelda and MGS 5 is much better and more fresh. Kingdom Come have more unorthodox open world and more creative quests. So RDR 2 is good game, a little bit more complex and a little bit more fresh than your average openworld, and a much moreGood game. Graphics, animation and detalization of the environment are top notch. But game is not even close to 10/10 gameplaywise. Gameplay in latest Zelda and MGS 5 is much better and more fresh. Kingdom Come have more unorthodox open world and more creative quests. So RDR 2 is good game, a little bit more complex and a little bit more fresh than your average openworld, and a much more polished, but not mindblowing (like Zelda, MGS 5 and Kingdom Come) gameplay experience.… Expand
  25. Velsuan
    Dec 1, 2018
    8
    Score (Setting-Story-Gameplay) :
    - Wonderful world! 10/10
    - Great story! 7/10 - Very clumsy and bad gameplay... 2/10 Verdict : 10+7+2 / 3 = 6.33 At this point, Rockstar should stop doing video games and start making movies... That would be very nice! OR... hire some game designers that are able to focus on actual good gameplay mechanics... The game is almost unplayable as it is    Score (Setting-Story-Gameplay) :
    - Wonderful world! 10/10
    - Great story! 7/10
    - Very clumsy and bad gameplay... 2/10

    Verdict : 10+7+2 / 3 = 6.33

    At this point, Rockstar should stop doing video games and start making movies... That would be very nice!

    OR... hire some game designers that are able to focus on actual good gameplay mechanics... The game is almost unplayable as it is right now.

    ****

    You know what... I played the game for 20 hours more... and I have to adjust my verdict on this game...

    I raise the score to 8/10.

    I have to admit... playing the game twice, what a breathtaking achievement! Sorry for the misguided first verdict. I was childish. Sorry for that.    … Expand
  26. tbouniverse
    Nov 28, 2018
    8
    You can see how R* has gone above and beyond by the sheer details in this game. I disagree with the 9-10s and the 0-3s because they are either fanboys or trolls. I agree with constructive praise and criticism focused reviews which is what this is.

    Pros: - MASSIVE open world - bigger than GTA V. - Long and intense story campaign (70+ hours for me) - Reimagined fast travel mechanics    You can see how R* has gone above and beyond by the sheer details in this game. I disagree with the 9-10s and the 0-3s because they are either fanboys or trolls. I agree with constructive praise and criticism focused reviews which is what this is.

    Pros:
    - MASSIVE open world - bigger than GTA V.
    - Long and intense story campaign (70+ hours for me)
    - Reimagined fast travel mechanics makes you have to ride to your destination(encountering random events or NPC) and makes the game far more IMMERSIVE.
    - DYNAMIC characters and their actions keeps you at the edge of the seat on anticipation
    - fun side-activities like poker, five finger fillet, train/stagecoach robbery, NPC encounters with its own story.

    Cons:
    - Controls sometimes feel sloppy. Taking cover from a standing position is not smooth.
    - Can't skip a bath, grooming horse, and eating truckloads of food to stay healthy. This serves to make the game more annoying as skipping these chores influences your character stats and has to be done fairly regularly. In my experience, this served to kill momentum a lot of the time.
    - Lack of smooth fast travel mechanics in the endgame takes the immersion and adds in a headache since it can take you 7+ minutes to get to your destination.
    - Long story, if you work full-time, this will take you a while to complete since this is a 70-80 hour journey that requires a real commitment if you intend to complete it.

    This is a GOTY contender. It is a fantastic game where you can spend countless hours immersed in this world. It still has its shares of setbacks. The 97 is inaccurate as the critics failed to do a good job assessing a title for what it is, name recognition seems to play a big part in how they rate games. A better indicator is the user score, because most of the helpful reviews tells you what you need to know. 8.4/10.    … Expand
  27. Gonzi
    Jul 21, 2020
    8
    Everything is pretty much stellar. My only (but significant) critique is about the Rockstar formula, where there is open world in which I can be a stellar citizen, only to be showed in the shoes of a borderline serial killer in the cutscenes. This false freedom really rubs me the wrong way.
  28. sityoazzdown
    Dec 10, 2018
    8
    Great game, but it's an overrated 97 critic score. Red dead redemptionv2 is a third person or first person shooter/adventure game. You are trasnported back to the wild west, and this game is a prequel to red dead redmeption. You are part of Dutch's gang, which for some reason only has like 10 people.. nonetheless you basically try to survive and reach the "promiseland". Gameplay consist ofGreat game, but it's an overrated 97 critic score. Red dead redemptionv2 is a third person or first person shooter/adventure game. You are trasnported back to the wild west, and this game is a prequel to red dead redmeption. You are part of Dutch's gang, which for some reason only has like 10 people.. nonetheless you basically try to survive and reach the "promiseland". Gameplay consist of shooting, looting, side/main missions, hunting/fishing, and some side activities like poker.

    Pros: Random encounters.. you will meet strangers in your travels that may activate a string of side quests, strangers who may try to harm/ and or steal from you, strangers where your choices will effect your "honor", and a lot of random goodies that will organically only happen once, and never again. The random encounters are legit 10/10 in this game.

    Ton of content in this game.. there are tons and tons and tons of stuff to do in this game (not even talking about the main missions), side quests are decent, there are over hundreds of animals, and even some fun side activities.

    FInally, interesting group of characters you deal with.

    The So-So's: The story.. it's ok, but it has the same theme of the walking dead tv series.

    The cons: Unrewarding gameplay... there is legit nothing to buy, and all this game is about is making money, yet what's the point? Another example is hunting legendary animals... only to run 1 second faster?

    Clunky controls.. everyone's complaining about it, nuff said.

    The gunplay... meh..first there's auto aim..then you flick the analog stick up to headshot someone.. try doing this for 50+ hours, and imagine my huge eye roll when there's wave of enemies I have to kill. (and no I will not turn off auto-aim, it's the way the game was designed to be played!)

    The bounty system, total fun killer, remember the early assasins creed game where if you kill an civilian you get de-synchronized? multiply that by 100.. in the middle of nowhere and accidentally blew up an horse.. BOUNTY.. i can literally go on, but I'm sure other reviewers here already has.

    This game is great but it has a lot of flaws.. did I mention there's a decent amount of bugs? I enjoyed it, took me over a month to beat this game and not many games can do that. A huge polished world with magic in every corner, but with a questionable fun factor and flawed gameplay, it's going to be polarizing for a lot of people I believe.    … Expand
  29. spyrosmicha
    Apr 10, 2020
    8
    Good game but not as great as rdr1. Not a masterpiece as they try to present it. Becomes boring at some times and the multi-player is really bad
  30. ZaPaAl
    Sep 28, 2020
    8
    Game has huge quantity and quality in regards of characters, story, voicing, visuals. But the gameplay is basic and easy, as you can abuse dead eye over and over, which trivializes nearly any combat situation, no matter what your equipment is. Most combat is something like beeing swarmed by 50 people, which does not feel very realistic or very interesting. Game tries to aim for immersion,Game has huge quantity and quality in regards of characters, story, voicing, visuals. But the gameplay is basic and easy, as you can abuse dead eye over and over, which trivializes nearly any combat situation, no matter what your equipment is. Most combat is something like beeing swarmed by 50 people, which does not feel very realistic or very interesting. Game tries to aim for immersion, but walking at crawl speed in camp areas, slow transitions on fast travel, crafting, or even just using the interface can really strain patience.

    There are many side quests and random encounters to discover, and they can be quite fun, but you probably should stay away from all the other activities, hunting, fishing, gambling, challenges, the collecting and the open world in general. Most are not fun and very, very tedisome, they take days of playtime to complete and give you hardly any interesting reward. Some make combat even more easier and some are for unlockable fashion, but I never found any of it really worth it.
    For example, after a huge test of endurance I got myself the satchel of the east, which is a gigantic inventory upgrade. In after thought, this again made the game easier in a way it does not need, at all. Don't try to complete this game 100% or you are bound for serious exhaustion.

    Game somehow does not actually feel like it has much of "Western" vibe.

    Still, story and presentation are fantastic, but it downspirals into a very depressing last Arthur chapter. That lift's up again in the epilogue and after that reading up on what Red Dead Redemption is about, the complete story does leave a very moving emotional impact.    … Expand
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2018

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
97

Universal acclaim - based on 99 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 98 out of 99
  2. Mixed: 1 out of 99
  3. Negative: 0 out of 99
  1. CD-Action
    Nov 14, 2019
    95
    It’s an huge, outstanding piece of art – worth the hard-earned cash as well as countless hours that are needed to get to know at least some of the attractions of Rockstar’s rendition of Wild West. For those who put story first – the biggest virtue of Red Dead Redemption 2 is that it sets the stage for RDR 1 and does it wonderfully. [13/2018, p.40]
  2. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Dec 31, 2018
    100
    Amazing not only for Western lovers. No other game has probably offered so many options to express yourself in the open world, and at the same time did not have such an interesting, rough and moving story. A magnificent experience, with a slightly slower start. [Issue#291]
  3. TrueGaming
    Nov 30, 2018
    95
    The first new game from Rockstar for this generation of consoles doesn't disappoint, it is as impressive as you hoped it to be.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »