Red Dead Redemption 2

 PlayStation 4
User Score
8.7

Generally favorable reviews- based on 21344 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18,146 out of 21344
  2. Mixed: 1,261 out of 21344
  3. Negative: 1,937 out of 21344
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. SrirachaChicken
    Oct 30, 2018
    7
    The game is absolutely amazing and there is plenty to be astounded over and loved, but there are some game play issues that muddles over the fantastic core experience and dirties the game into the mud.

    The question is, how much realism do we actually need in a game. Rockstar has tried to nail down the realism of RDR2 to its core but instead of enhancing the gaming experience, to me it    The game is absolutely amazing and there is plenty to be astounded over and loved, but there are some game play issues that muddles over the fantastic core experience and dirties the game into the mud.

    The question is, how much realism do we actually need in a game. Rockstar has tried to nail down the realism of RDR2 to its core but instead of enhancing the gaming experience, to me it feels like there is more control over the player and what he can do then actual freedom within the game.

    One thing that is really bothersome is when Arthur tries to do anything in camp. He moves at a slow pace and there is no work around to have Arthur move faster within camp. Horses cannot be ridden to your bed and skinned animals cannot be dropped off at the butcher. Trying to successfully accomplish a task within camp can sometimes feel like you're fighting the controls when you are trying to achieve a button prompt. I think it has something to do with the camera and the way Arthur steps around, he could sometimes hum over certain prompts within camp just because he isn't positioned right or directly over the object.

    The button prompts have drastically changed from Red Dead 1 to 2. Now you can essentially "engage" someone by holding L2 and focusing in on them. This has caused me more problems with the NPC's then good ones... I don't know why but everytime I try to talk to someone or focus in on them, I get into more fights then friendly banter. I'm also not really into holding the square button when trying to pick up a body or animal pelts and then you use the Triangle button to loot bodies and mount your horse. Its confusing what i'm trying to say and can really halt the progress of normal mundane tasks because the player is confused trying to figure out how to achieve his goal. Picking up someone else's gun is the same concept too. You have to Press R1 to scroll over the option menus to choose the right prompt and then press L1 to switch a weapon you wanted to pick up. Its just a mess really and game play wise extremely confusing.

    The menu is cluttered, making it confusing for the user making it a hard time understanding what exactly could be sold at a market or used for practicality. There isn't a sorting option available that organizes your pack for you, which I feel like they sorely needed to implement or give the option to manually sort items for ourselves so we can clearly define exactly what we need and what we don't need.

    One last thing.. The hunting is really bad. Really really bad. Its VERY hard to track and find an animal let alone kill it properly to get the perfect skin. it takes more time out the game when trying to hunt and it does it in way that doesn't feel satisfying. Hunting gameplay needs a huge look at and needs to be made in a way thats more friendly and rewarding to do.

    There are things that bother me about RDR2, its more about the controls then anything but the story and quests are engaging. Its a rockstar game in an open world scenario. You're going to be fetching things, you're going to be an errand boy but thats how its always been. Nothing new there and thats why we come back to these games for the immersion and silly quests. The game is beautiful and the world feels alive.    … Expand
  2. Kira_Si
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Пожалуй один из лучших опенворлдов на данный момент. В отличии от других этот мир интересно изучать, проводить в нем время. Например, просто играть в покер по 5 часов увлекает. Постоянные "рандомные события" дополняют простое изучение локаций. Одна из лучших график на консолях.Пожалуй один из лучших опенворлдов на данный момент. В отличии от других этот мир интересно изучать, проводить в нем время. Например, просто играть в покер по 5 часов увлекает. Постоянные "рандомные события" дополняют простое изучение локаций. Одна из лучших график на консолях.
  3. Squanchy
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    It's a really great and very ambitious game. So many different abilities. I just want to live in that world. Thanks, Rockstar you're Rock! oh yes, you know it :D
  4. Bwqgo614CDEz23A
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    1. The gameplay is very mediocre. Shooting feels boring, there's no difference between guns and they all act like water guns. The enemy AI is pretty dumb, the enemies are dangerous only when you are alone and significantly outnumbered.
    2. The storyline is incredibly stupid - the characters act like absolute morons and the dialogs are one big cliche.
  5. Veils
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    немного снижу оценку, ибо смысл во всем этом реализме если играть совсем не интересно, еще и стрельба на джостике вымораживает ибо на пк ее не купить пришлось брать на ограниченную плойку
  6. DEEK4991
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    While some may say the realism is annoying, I find that it grounds the experience and helps immerse yourself in the wild west. You may only be able to carry a few guns on your person at a time, but you can easily switch them out on your horse which can store all of your guns. Whatever you think of when you think about the wild west in film or television, you can do it in this game, fromWhile some may say the realism is annoying, I find that it grounds the experience and helps immerse yourself in the wild west. You may only be able to carry a few guns on your person at a time, but you can easily switch them out on your horse which can store all of your guns. Whatever you think of when you think about the wild west in film or television, you can do it in this game, from robbing trains in missions, or free roam on your own time, to hunting, capturing bounties, getting **** at the saloon and brawling, gambling, robbing literally any npc or store, lassoing someone and dragging them from your horse, you can do it. The world is massive and cohesive and truly feels like it is transcending the concept of a videogame and is closer to actual living and breathing art. The wildlife is insane and really behaves like their real life counterparts, deer will butt antlers while playing, coyotes will sniff out dead bodies, ravens or other scavengers will be attracted to the dead etc. If you love exploration, freedom, and an experience grounded in realism in the old American west this game has it. Rockstar and the wild west seem to be made for each other, ever since their success with GTA it has seemed like the wild west was perfect for their mature and violent, lawless videogames. on a last note, the music is epic! It's even more diverse than the first game. If you can respect the slower pace of the game. you will find enjoyment that surpasses most other gaming experiences.… Expand
  7. ironwolf56
    Oct 30, 2018
    5
    Overproduced. That's the word I'd use for RDR2. I think this game may have shown us the "uncanny valley" of simulation vs gaming. The attention to detail in some aspects is certainly impressive, but at the same time it doesn't quite hit that level of full realism that maybe, someday, games will have.

    Before there's any pushback, I'm around Chapter 4 so this isn't a situation of "well    Overproduced. That's the word I'd use for RDR2. I think this game may have shown us the "uncanny valley" of simulation vs gaming. The attention to detail in some aspects is certainly impressive, but at the same time it doesn't quite hit that level of full realism that maybe, someday, games will have.

    Before there's any pushback, I'm around Chapter 4 so this isn't a situation of "well get past the first few hours it gets better." I understand what they were going for with having to balance everything, but the controls are so fiddly it often actively fights you from doing anything. If nothing else, I think this game has made me realize WHY studios put in shortcuts and unrealistic animations etc so that the core of gameplay is smoother and more fun.

    There is fun to be had here, in short bursts though. When I was doing something like shooting up a logging camp full of a rival gang, it was a blast, but those kind of moments seem few and far between punctuated by long stretches of time of slowly searching through cabinets, riding your horse across a surprisingly empty map, making sure you eat but not too much now, methodically hunting, and juggling things at the campsite.

    I think RDR2 may have taken my top spot as the most overrated game of all time; at least this generation certainly. For the hardcore simulationist types, it's probably a dream come true, I just wish there was a lot more "game" inside this fiddliness.    … Expand
  8. solairedontcare
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    This game is garbage and the critics reviews of the game speaks volumes as to the sorry state of video game press. Nobody wants to be the guy who calls such a hyped up game for what it is: garbage. Play the game and tell me I’m wrong. Bounty system: broken. Controls: god awful. Pace: objectively boring.

    The graphics are real nice, if you’re into that sort of thing. But the actual    This game is garbage and the critics reviews of the game speaks volumes as to the sorry state of video game press. Nobody wants to be the guy who calls such a hyped up game for what it is: garbage. Play the game and tell me I’m wrong. Bounty system: broken. Controls: god awful. Pace: objectively boring.

    The graphics are real nice, if you’re into that sort of thing. But the actual game part of the game is straight garbage. Period.    … Expand
  9. Ben_91
    Oct 30, 2018
    4
    What the hell is this Rockstar? Because it is not the Red Dead game that I was expecting...

    Sure the graphics are great, but just about everything else sucks. And I mean it sucks! It might have a nice polished shell on the outside with amazing graphics, but on the inside there is a lack of content and it just isn't fun. It feels more like a chore. Apart from the main story, the open    What the hell is this Rockstar? Because it is not the Red Dead game that I was expecting...

    Sure the graphics are great, but just about everything else sucks. And I mean it sucks! It might have a nice polished shell on the outside with amazing graphics, but on the inside there is a lack of content and it just isn't fun. It feels more like a chore. Apart from the main story, the open world just feels kind of empty and boring with too many mundane tasks. Having to feed your camp each day, polish your gun and collect cigarette cards is boring.

    After playing AC: Odyssey for over 130 hours during the past 3 weeks (which I loved), having to switch to RDR2 now feels like a massive step down. The whole game feels kind of slow and boring, like it is a chore. The controls and whole combat system are absolutely awful (and where it really loses me) and it clearly needs reworking, and the open world actually feels quite empty. It's just not immersive beyond the graphics. How it took them 8 years to come up with this is beyond a joke. I would be lying if I said that I wasn't disappointed with it.

    There are a number of other issues that are frustrating me - like being forced to walk around camp constantly, or the fact that the weather goes from foggy to clear in the click of a finger. Or rainy to sunny in an instant. Literally in the click of a finger. And it switches from dark to light in an instant and vice versa. Literally in the space of a second, rather than gradually changing. The bounty system is stupid as well and excessive, which becomes very frustrating very quickly. There's hardly any guns as well which really sucks. And not much to discover in the map. Looting people gets you like 40 cents, so you never have much money. There's just a lack of content in general and a lack of stuff to unlock. I wonder if Rockstar are saving it all for the online launch, when they can charge us more money for it...? Either way it's annoying.

    Sort it out Rockstar!    … Expand
  10. fzzywarbles
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    RDR2 is not only the greatest open world accomplishment in the history of video games. It is also the greatest video game attempt at story telling. Anyone ranking this game 0/10 is clueless and that's a fact.
  11. hunter3880
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    годно что тут еще скажешь покупайте не пожалеете, особенно тем кому очень нравится дикий запад
  12. davidestaub
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    An absolutely brilliant game.
    The story and the world really drag you in!
    The graphics are superb and the world is extremely detailed and immersive.
    For me this game never got boring.
  13. Counter_Balance
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Gave a 10 to solely counteract the losers giving this a 0 because they want to be "different" or simply can't afford to buy the game : ) KMA
  14. Amazingmao
    Oct 30, 2018
    1
    As a cinematic experience this is a masterpiece. Immersive and gorgeous.
    But as a video game this is the most abysmal experience in the past 10 years.
    A video game is expected to be fun and entertaining, not always realistic. RDR2 on the other hand focus entirely on realism and forego any fun, that it feels only as fun as doing chores in real life. Gunplay suffers from this, as in    As a cinematic experience this is a masterpiece. Immersive and gorgeous.
    But as a video game this is the most abysmal experience in the past 10 years.
    A video game is expected to be fun and entertaining, not always realistic.
    RDR2 on the other hand focus entirely on realism and forego any fun, that it feels only as fun as doing chores in real life.
    Gunplay suffers from this, as in favor of realism, the game makes you feel like a toddler trying to operate a firearm while dueling against a seasoned gunslinger.
    Story also suffers from this, as every small bit of plot point is separated by literal hours of riding your horse across the county, cooking, skinning animals and so on.
    If you turn off the game, go out the door and simply live real life, you'd have more fun than playing this game.
    The best parts of this game can be experienced by watching youtube videos of the cutscenes, that's about all the positive things the game has to offer.

    To put it in a simpler term:
    The game was marketed as Ace Combat, but what you actually get is Flight Simulation X.

    Unless you're excited about going through all the same annoyance of real life in your game, it would be more advisable to steer way clear of RDR2, and save your money for an actual video game, and not some over obnoxious real life simulator featuring some cowboys.    … Expand
  15. Gibaja
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    It is an absolute peace of Art. For those fake reviews and "there is no pc version" for god sake... You guys did not even play the game. Why do you write reviews of something you don't test yourself?
  16. BlakeHREW
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    Игра шляпа, механика хороша, движок шикарный, но ничего интересного в игре нет.
    Управление убогое даже для консоли.
  17. aiTarget
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    I don't want to say what Rockstar did and especially did not. Peple, who did'nt remember their past has no future. You can't change your past.
  18. richo1441
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    Полный провал, попытка выехать на волне ожиданий продолжения великолепного оригинала. Отсутствие русской озвучки. Отсутствие PC версии, в попытках больше заработать на якобы "эксклюзиве". Хотя скорее всего с ней поступят как и с GTA 5.Полный провал, попытка выехать на волне ожиданий продолжения великолепного оригинала. Отсутствие русской озвучки. Отсутствие PC версии, в попытках больше заработать на якобы "эксклюзиве". Хотя скорее всего с ней поступят как и с GTA 5.
  19. Revers
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Игра довольная увлекательная, хоть я и не играл, я сужу субъективно, и моя высказывание об этой игре нелицеприятные, но приходя к парадигме, я официально заявляю, и повторяю еще раз, это мое личное мнение, мое кредо, и в отличии от экспансивных школьников, я пишу обдумав все свои мысли.И не утомляя вас-читателей, я говорю... игра шедевр...Игра довольная увлекательная, хоть я и не играл, я сужу субъективно, и моя высказывание об этой игре нелицеприятные, но приходя к парадигме, я официально заявляю, и повторяю еще раз, это мое личное мнение, мое кредо, и в отличии от экспансивных школьников, я пишу обдумав все свои мысли.И не утомляя вас-читателей, я говорю... игра шедевр...
  20. frankrij23
    Oct 30, 2018
    2
    To be perfectly honest I was let down by two main factors. the main one being horse mechanics along with the fact that you literally spend 30% of the game on horseback which is incredibly tedious. The second being the story which towards the end was unfortunately a let down for me.
  21. RATIBOR_STRANNI
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Прекрасно! Играешь, будто сам проживаешь жизнь героя! Давно не играл в такую обалденную игру! Жду дополнения!
  22. Delov
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Не могу попробовать эту игру, потому, что нет консоли, но я ставлю десять баллов в противовес петухам, которые дизят игру.
  23. Collaps666
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Хоть игра и скучноватая по сравнению с паучком, но реальности происходящего это не отбавляет! молодцы рокстар!… Expand
  24. xxxsssjjjk
    Oct 30, 2018
    9
    great game but the graphics and hdr need fixed. poor 4k and hdr on the ps4 and xbox versions.
  25. Thomas0968
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Best game, 10/10, love you, Rockstar!! But, I don't understand, why so many trolls in comments?… Expand
  26. Freebird1984
    Oct 30, 2018
    1
    The Rant begins

    CLUNKY in the controls, this itself is an unforgivable clumsiness that in my 30 years of gaming I would compare to BART VS THE SPACE MUTANTS on NES. I have beef with the teasing open world view and the linear game play that comes with it. I also want you to remember my review when you are transported to the moon while walking through camp, yes you can't run in your own    The Rant begins

    CLUNKY in the controls, this itself is an unforgivable clumsiness that in my 30 years of gaming I would compare to BART VS THE SPACE MUTANTS on NES. I have beef with the teasing open world view and the linear game play that comes with it. I also want you to remember my review when you are transported to the moon while walking through camp, yes you can't run in your own camp, you must walk slow, a zero gravity slow like Neil Armstrong on the moon. I hear his voice while walking through camp. "That's one small step...." You are forced to walk back and fourth through camp like this to do tedious tasks such as shave,Eat, put money in a piggy bank, help shop for groceries...every anointing task of your life is here, i'm sure later there is a mission where you must wipe your crack clean. The missions are annoying things I want to skip over to get to the rest of the game...that doesn't exist. Enjoy driving a wagon, you will be doing it for hours, don't get you wagon stuck either, your painful and I mean painfully slow wagon. Careful in town too, if you accidentally bump into someone with the clunky controls the whole town may find you in contempt and shoot you too your death. Oh I almost forgot, your hat falls off all the time, if you play through the game you will spend hours on switching and swapping your hat, i'm serious. The actual content of play makes me wonder if I would enjoy a game with a constant button sequence to press more than this. The realism is terrible too, they actually show dead deer being hung on a gambrel without being gutted. You ride with an ungutted deer 5 miles back to camp and start to butcher it without gutting it. I think the Devs must have lacked some real world experience to say the least. The hunting is a complete joke and waste of time. I also wish to condemn the horse riding itself as it is clunky and you hit something and go flying and have to pick up your hat before getting back on.

    I am a Rockstar fan boy, I played GTA on ps1 as a teenager, I love in depth games with expansive RPG characteristics like Final Fantasy, Castlevania Symphony of the night, Metroid, Ogrebattle, I love long games, hard games. The days of Rockstar getting by on taboo subject matter and atmospheric bliss are over, the games have changed again and this linear boorish style is not coming along.I'd rather play GUN for ps2 or Sunset riders for SNES, Blood Brothers, Gunsmoke for NES, I would much rather play the original GTA with Birdseye view than this. There are better games than this that came out this year like Mega Man 11, Mega man X collection, COD or the last few years, XCOM, Mario Odyssey. If you have played BOTW it renders this abomination unplayable. I think I will go play Castlevania for NES to wash this hideous taste out my mouth.

    (The struggle is the glory)    … Expand
  27. leaveit
    Oct 30, 2018
    7
    It's a fine game and the intense dedication of the developers is obvious. Most of what it accomplishes, however, is at the cost of designing an entertainment product as a "game," though. The game incentivizes keeping a main horse and even has an icon for it, but regularly teleports you away from the horse so that you have to backtrack. The game boasts an open world but you have practicallyIt's a fine game and the intense dedication of the developers is obvious. Most of what it accomplishes, however, is at the cost of designing an entertainment product as a "game," though. The game incentivizes keeping a main horse and even has an icon for it, but regularly teleports you away from the horse so that you have to backtrack. The game boasts an open world but you have practically no choice in the outcome of the missions. There are rewards for collecting perfect animal pelts but the availability of the pelts is random to the point where it is no longer skill-based to find an animal with a perfect pelt. The graphics are truly incredible but they regularly slow to sub-projector-framerates, even in battle. Is this a game or an interactive movie? The player may pass most of the game believing that they're still in the tutorial. In the end, the time is passed but we are not better humans and haven't seen anything new or more refined, just old and perhaps even un-fun mechanics done more professionally.… Expand
  28. CyclePlus
    Oct 30, 2018
    6
    This game has the clunkiest character movement I have ever seen in a current gen game. It's super unresponsive and feels like you are swimming against a light current that's pushing against you all the time. Also, good luck shooting at anything requiring precision, it's pretty much impossible even with controller dead zone set to 0 and the velocity/sensitivity turned up so you are forcedThis game has the clunkiest character movement I have ever seen in a current gen game. It's super unresponsive and feels like you are swimming against a light current that's pushing against you all the time. Also, good luck shooting at anything requiring precision, it's pretty much impossible even with controller dead zone set to 0 and the velocity/sensitivity turned up so you are forced to use auto-aim.

    Game looks gorgeous, I will give it that, but it's not even remotely close to a 10.    … Expand
  29. ignore78
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    When you first start the game, some people can feel dissapointed because it is a linear 2 hours story! The everything opens up and becomes a Masterpiece! Go and buy it right now!!
  30. L1nkAnd
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Игра класс столько мелочей и проработок,классная английская озвучка как будто окунулся в фильм вестерн ,а то что она только на консолях вообще все равно, потому что ради таких игр стоит покупать консоли.
  31. TomasoNBlyat
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Последнее время считал что Rockstar зажрались смотря на GTA V, но увидя RDR 2 я охуел (Извините за эмоции), столько мелких деталей я нигде не видел
  32. Dronbalt
    Oct 30, 2018
    1
    Симулятор чтения, разрабам плевать на иностранцев даже не удосуживаются озвучить на Русский язык игры, при игре отвлекаясь на гребаное чтение упускаешь картинку и сюжет в ней. За те деньги что они за неё хотят пускай озвучивают или идут на ,,,,,й.Симулятор чтения, разрабам плевать на иностранцев даже не удосуживаются озвучить на Русский язык игры, при игре отвлекаясь на гребаное чтение упускаешь картинку и сюжет в ней. За те деньги что они за неё хотят пускай озвучивают или идут на ,,,,,й.
  33. VexyR
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Hello, here is finally the output of this giant .. Without doubt the most anticipated game this year and how! The 1 was simply masterful, the 2 is the worthy heir of the first.
    The atmosphere that gives off the game is superb, as much as the graphics, the grip rather "heavy" at the beginning can cool a lot .. However over time we get used to it and it becomes one of the strengths of the    Hello, here is finally the output of this giant .. Without doubt the most anticipated game this year and how! The 1 was simply masterful, the 2 is the worthy heir of the first.
    The atmosphere that gives off the game is superb, as much as the graphics, the grip rather "heavy" at the beginning can cool a lot .. However over time we get used to it and it becomes one of the strengths of the game.
    A great game, really!    … Expand
  34. slayer94
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    i never bothered to review a game ever in my whole life , this my friend is how good this game is :)
  35. raulpkgovno
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    игра охуенная спасибо rockstar обожаю вас делайте игру редко но метко кстати пекари хватит кудахдать
  36. Rainbow666g
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Это игра отлична во всех направлениях этого года! культовая игра 2018 года и не даст вам скучать!
  37. gotik29
    Oct 30, 2018
    9
    Ради этой игры,стоит купить консоль.Она прекрасна,в ней проработаны настолько мелкие детали,что попросту на них,многие разрабы забивают болт.Игра полностью оправдывает свою стоимость,и я не жалею,что её купил.Поставил 9,потому,что не русского языка в диалогах,и приходится фокусировать своё внимание только на субтитры.Ради этой игры,стоит купить консоль.Она прекрасна,в ней проработаны настолько мелкие детали,что попросту на них,многие разрабы забивают болт.Игра полностью оправдывает свою стоимость,и я не жалею,что её купил.Поставил 9,потому,что не русского языка в диалогах,и приходится фокусировать своё внимание только на субтитры.
  38. Uncle_Buzzy
    Oct 30, 2018
    6
    This game looks gorgeous, but is simply not fun - many players will not want to admit this, given the hype and the expectation, but while I usually have to make an effort to STOP playing a game, with RD2 it is an effort to CONTINUE playing, hoping that it will pick up.

    I do not play video games to simulate mundane demands that are bothersome in reality. Shaving and bathing? And having    This game looks gorgeous, but is simply not fun - many players will not want to admit this, given the hype and the expectation, but while I usually have to make an effort to STOP playing a game, with RD2 it is an effort to CONTINUE playing, hoping that it will pick up.

    I do not play video games to simulate mundane demands that are bothersome in reality. Shaving and bathing? And having to individually scrub EACH LIMB?!?!! Watching your weight?!?! Changing clothes for the weather? Why not brush your teeth and rinse your underwear? Maybe trim your nails and change your grandpa's catheter?

    The combat is much less cinematic and the fist fights are laborious. LA Noire had a better fist fight system! There seems to be no fast travel, excepting the train, and it's surprisingly dull to explore. Maybe play straight through the storyline if you must, but don't expect to have a lot of fun roaming. The script is decent and the acting is good, but the storyline seems telegraphed a LOOOOOOONG way off - I'm pretty sure I know what REALLY became of that Blackwater money....

    Far Cry 5, for example, is much more fun - you run around and blow stuff up!! That's what games are for.    … Expand
  39. I_DEPTH_I
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Смотрю видео на ютубе и мне нравится,но нету на ПК что очень меня печалит,но портить оценку игре я не очень то и желаю,ведь разработчики сделали и проработали кучу приятных глазу мелочей
  40. welshrifty89
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    okay firstly this game is easily the best game i have ever played ever period! Now the nay sayers if you read there reviews youl notice a common theme among them...winging about chores moaning about eating or riding your horse moaning about taking your time its simple these people are probably kids or the very impatient gamers who we always see moaning when something is delayed. this isntokay firstly this game is easily the best game i have ever played ever period! Now the nay sayers if you read there reviews youl notice a common theme among them...winging about chores moaning about eating or riding your horse moaning about taking your time its simple these people are probably kids or the very impatient gamers who we always see moaning when something is delayed. this isnt for kids this isnt for the impatient the world and all it has to offer doesnt even open up for hours even then the game constantly dishes out more activities ie fishing home roberys stage coach robberys as the game goes on this is to giver you chance to master all there is to as there is an awful lot. those who say its empty never stepped foot in sant denis the city and probably never traveled further than valentine.

    REMEMBER this is a 60 hour campaign id also say to eevryone whos playing spend time at the camp invest in people have some stew and a cofee go speak to people sit at the fire with them youl learn alot about them and become more invested in them, when theres a party party with them get drunk dance be one of them walk around see things im yet to hear the same thing twice except at shops when your biying stuff but thats it so far and im 50 percent done. the people moaning are those players you see on youtube who sprint everywhere all the time smash the x or a button moan when they die and so on.

    id call this a westworld simulation with a **** brilliant story allbeit the story takes time to open up but why you trying to rush anyway? you spent 60 to 70 quid on it get your moneys worth take your time enjoy the fact its so long because beleive me **** starts happening and its **** brilliant. this is easily the best looking game i have ever played EVER im playing in 4k on the one x and its beautiful yes there are some drops like in a certain room in a certain house in a certain camp without saying to much and some places in the city but nothing thats taken me out of it. its been a long time since i cared about characters within a game maby i havnt since the last of us?

    buy this game if your looking to be lost in your own westworld invest time in characters and play a game you can lose hours in. THIS IS NOT GTA this more realistic and slow aproach to a fantastic world that is more ALIVE then iv ever seen, iv lost hours just trotting and walking and stopping taking things in im 50 percent thorugh the sotry so 30 hours? and im still being wowed BRILLIANT!! if my review sounds like what your after please pick this game up you wont regret it ALSO UPDATE NOTICE ALOT OF RUSSIANS DOWN VOTING BECAUSE THEY DONT HAVE RUSSIAN LANGUAGE SUPPORT GET A GRIP!! THEM AND THE PC COMMUNITY DOWNVOTING A GREAT GAME IT WILL CHANGE NOTHING ALL I SEE IS KIDS AND RUSSIANS AND THE PC LOT MOANING GROW UP ...OH AND NOTICE THAT ITS KIDS AND DUMB IDIOTS WITH TERRIBLE SPELLING WHO MOAN ABOUT IT OR FOREIGNERS WITH **** END PCS sporting gtx 1050ti's and thinking they have a high end pc moaning cus they cant play it or afford a **** console ...you can afford a pc you can afford a one x not owning a console is not a reason to downvote and sorry you need a brain for this game dumb asylum seekers need not apply    … Expand
  41. pablo918
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Simply a fantastic game, a great story (So far, about 1/2 through the game) with fantastic characters and a truly human protagonist, great gameplay, especially shootings I just found them satisfactory, and despite what people say controls are simple, responsive, and if you’ve played gta intuitive, GREAT soundtrack. Rockstar has truly delivered a master piece full of details to discover andSimply a fantastic game, a great story (So far, about 1/2 through the game) with fantastic characters and a truly human protagonist, great gameplay, especially shootings I just found them satisfactory, and despite what people say controls are simple, responsive, and if you’ve played gta intuitive, GREAT soundtrack. Rockstar has truly delivered a master piece full of details to discover and tons of hours of fabulous content.… Expand
  42. Nigme
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Сосните х.йца пк-бояре, как же всё-таки бомбят ваши жопы от отсутствия игры на Intel core I9 и RTX 2080ti! муахахахахахаха

    10 сморщенных яичек из 10!

    P.s. Игра унылая...
  43. m1stik
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    I'm sorry this game wasn't released on PC, but some games just should be exclusive at least for some time. Red Dead Redemption 2 is actually a revolutionary game on consoles.
  44. adrewtoremember
    Oct 30, 2018
    9
    This game will be used in future discussions of milestones in gaming. The graphics, world, and exploration accomplished here is nothing short of a masterpiece at the time of this review.

    I will boil down the pro's and cons to bullet point, because I know a lot of people wont bother reading a full amateur review. Pro's - Amazingly detailed open world - Gripping story - Graphics    This game will be used in future discussions of milestones in gaming. The graphics, world, and exploration accomplished here is nothing short of a masterpiece at the time of this review.

    I will boil down the pro's and cons to bullet point, because I know a lot of people wont bother reading a full amateur review.

    Pro's
    - Amazingly detailed open world
    - Gripping story
    - Graphics that are second to none on a game of this scale
    - Characters you grow to care about

    Cons
    - The line between what is fun, and what is too mundane is crossed way too often for the sake of realism
    - Looting and interacting animations take a painfully long time in a game that is centered around looting and robbing.
    - Travel in the world can feel terrible when you are essentially taking 5 minutes to go from point A to point B, (though this can be nice if you are like me, and trying to multitask.    … Expand
  45. Dipexi
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Я считаю,что эта игра достойна 10!Открытый мир проработан очень хорошо.Каждую секунду происходит что либо интересное и нету ощущения,что это все картонные декорации и это создает тебе потрясающую атмосферу.
  46. crazymurdock
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    The world is so detailed, it is quite incredible. It takes a while to get between objectives, but I like the break, and the views are spectacular. The missions are all really fun, which is great, because with the desperate nature of the story, I was worried it might be depressing to play. This is fortunately not the case.
  47. Danielsjack
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Best Game 12/10
  48. Empereur
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Мне стало обидно за очередной шедевр от Рокстар и от того, что просто игра не вышла на PC и дурачки побежали обваливать оценку игры. И я, как адекватный ПК-бояре, намерен хоть чуточку восстановить баланс и ставлю 12/10.
  49. diamand_dog
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    It's boring. PlayStation 4 **** Buying this console was a mistake. All because of the fact that on the console do only boring games like this.
  50. Ncbelt84
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Greates Game of all Time! Stop hating and accept it. Hands down to Rockstar Games!
  51. WeeZee
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    just a beautiful and elaborate game, happy to buy this game and I advise everyone to play it
  52. Gazcom
    Oct 30, 2018
    8
    Looks amazing and for the most part I find it excellent. Don't waste your money on the special additions. The items are very poor and don't come until chapter 2.
    Needs some patches to improve to a 9 or 10 rating for me.
    For me these would be: Fast Travel (yes they have it but it's very poor) - Can take an age to get / do anything. Sometimes I like a quick hour blast at a game.    Looks amazing and for the most part I find it excellent. Don't waste your money on the special additions. The items are very poor and don't come until chapter 2.
    Needs some patches to improve to a 9 or 10 rating for me.
    For me these would be:
    Fast Travel (yes they have it but it's very poor) - Can take an age to get / do anything. Sometimes I like a quick hour blast at a game.
    Getting bounties - They come about far too easily, someone comes riding fast into you and they get hurt, you get the bounty. Whats the point in the mask? It offers no protection. I'm not expecting immunity, but it literally does nothing.
    Having to slow walk around a camp to do anything - Why? Just why
    Weight levels - No need for it. It's trying to be too real. Takes away some of the enjoyment when you have to start dealing with it.
    For me it could easily get a 10 rating. Just whats wrong with it at the moment makes the game tedious to deal with at times.    … Expand
  53. chynarich
    Oct 30, 2018
    6
    Нету консоли, но ставлю 10 чтоб вышла на пк.
  54. joseshivers
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Created an account mostly because the 0 reviews are driving me nuts.
    This is a technical masterpiece so even if it's not your kind of game 0 out of 10? Get real, if you want to play Fortnite or COD go and play them, they are available. If you are a PC gamer then sorry the game is not available (yet) but I'm sure it will come. As a PC gamer myself I really hope it does, to be able to    Created an account mostly because the 0 reviews are driving me nuts.
    This is a technical masterpiece so even if it's not your kind of game 0 out of 10? Get real, if you want to play Fortnite or COD go and play them, they are available. If you are a PC gamer then sorry the game is not available (yet) but I'm sure it will come. As a PC gamer myself I really hope it does, to be able to play this on my laptop on a train.... But to be fair to the supposed 'PC Master Race' - you can by a PS4 and this game for about as much as you probably paid for your last graphics card so if you really need to play it now then go get it.

    Anyhow something hopefully helpful, I am loving this game/interactive film/cowboy simulator it is just so immersive and I'm spotting new details I love constantly. It took me a while to get into the pace but once I did I really began to appreciate how beautiful the whole thing is. The graphics the animation, the pace the way it almost seamlessly moves from action to cut scene. The automatic travel system works really well, but be careful not to leave it unattended it can go wrong as I found out when leaving it to get a glass of water, to come back and find myself surrounded by O'Driscals and a dead horse.

    I have put in (too) much time already and just can't get bored there is so much to do and explore you do create your own story as you travel into the game, getting sidetracked while on your way to point b and next thing you know you running through the woods hunting the KKK.

    Anyhow I'm finding the longer I play it the more I love it. Is this Rockstar's finest game? Maybe, probably I don't know yet but it is wonderful. I'm really looking forward to seeing what the online mode has in stall and what content they add. Right now for £50 you are getting an absolute steal it is not perfect but it feels about as close as any game has ever got. Right now though this is a must play single player masterpiece if you like open world games.    … Expand
  55. L_dead_F
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    I have played for over 50 hours by now and I must say, this is by far one of the best gaming experiences I had in years. As a fan of the original Red Dead and the open world genre, I came into this game with a lot of expectations and I must say, my expectations were still blown away. The game does however have a few cons which I will start with.

    For starters, the game at times feels    I have played for over 50 hours by now and I must say, this is by far one of the best gaming experiences I had in years. As a fan of the original Red Dead and the open world genre, I came into this game with a lot of expectations and I must say, my expectations were still blown away. The game does however have a few cons which I will start with.

    For starters, the game at times feels unresponsive, as if your controls aren't really doing anything, and it can take you out of the immersion for a moment. Second, the survival aspect is a bit of a chore at first but at some point you get used to it and it becomes enjoyable, the only thing that annoys me about it is how quickly the quality of your weapons can degrade, it seems as if your gun can go from perfect condition to nearly broken in just one firefight. Aiming can also sometimes be rather clunky.

    There is one complaint I see a lot and it's that the game is slow, this was done intentionally. The game FEELS like a western, it feels immersive, not fast paced like a modern game such as Grand Theft Auto, I personally love the pace and feel like it fits perfectly. But it's not incredibly slow like some of these reviewers are making it seem to be, it's still a rather fast game.

    Now for the pros.

    This game is a graphical marvel, I have honestly never seen such a good looking open world game on console, every little thing blows me away. The lighting is just perfect and god, I get overwhelmed just thinking about it. Gameplay is also fantastic, despite being clunky sometimes, gun play is awesome and can sometimes make you feel like you're in real danger, fights are realistic and will force you to think things through instead of shooting aimlessly. Horse controls are perfect, every horse is unique and delivers a different experience, the bonding progress is also one I found enjoyable. Exploring whilst on horseback is just great, sometimes you'll find an amazing view and you'll have to stop for a moment and just say wow. And voice acting? I have never seen a game where every single character, including small NPCs have amazing voice acting like this, it blows me away. On the point of voice acting, let me talk about the story.

    The first half of the story is rather slow, you get introduced to the characters but your actions feel like they don't have any heavy toll, however, this does change a lot towards the middle of the story. The second half of chapter 4 is when things really start to pick up and things start going wrong for the gang and all you can do is sit and ask "what's going to happen next???" and force yourself to play more to find out. The way character's change through the story is fantastic, just purely fantastic. An example that shouldn't be too spoilery due to the first Red Dead is Dutch's character. At the start of the game he is a smart, respectable and sensible man, he's an outlaw with a code and at times is a character that you as the player will even look up to. However, a particular event in the middle of the story, we see that change. Dutch becomes violent, he abandons his code, he does things that put the gang at risk for no particular reason, we see Dutch transform into who he is in the original Red Dead, including the whole natives part, we can see how that came intro fruition. He's not the only character that shows a lot of change however. Just to drop a few names of fantastically written characters: Arthur, Dutch, Sadie, Micah, Rev Swanson, Molly (despite her rather small role). I wouldn't say that so far John is the best written character, but his voice acting is fantastic and it feels good to see him again.

    In conclusion, this game is truly something else, and if it weren't for really small technical flaws, this game would be perfect. I can say though that this is now by far my favorite game and definitely deserves GOTY. Well done Rockstar on another amazIng title!    … Expand
  56. Vule
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Reading negative user reviews... there are more and more idiots in this world by the day
  57. Afenix
    Oct 30, 2018
    9
    If there's one thing that Red Dead Redemption 2 taught me, is that we must stop wasting our time and money on yearly releases, such as COD, AC and so on. Played Odyssey before buying RDR2 and I was feeling absolutely miserable, knowing that Ubisoft had put no effort to show the respect for me, as a players, time. RDR2 on the other hand feels like something from another world. EverythingIf there's one thing that Red Dead Redemption 2 taught me, is that we must stop wasting our time and money on yearly releases, such as COD, AC and so on. Played Odyssey before buying RDR2 and I was feeling absolutely miserable, knowing that Ubisoft had put no effort to show the respect for me, as a players, time. RDR2 on the other hand feels like something from another world. Everything that is put into this game is there because it needs to be there, nothing feels forced or unnecessary. At first it may be a handful, but once you get the grips on it, it opens up in an amazing way and suddenly everything in this game (and mostly it's core mechanics) makes sense.
    It's an amazing game, a true masterpiece even.
    Is it the best game I've ever played? Definitely no, there is no such game out there. But this comes close.
    But is it the the most engaging and immersive game I've ever played? Yes, definitely. The world feels alive all the time, the interactions you can have with EVERYONE in this game is just game-changing. While other game worlds feel scripted and programmed, this one is truly dynamic: always changing and adapting to you and your actions.
    I've never been so immersed into a gameplay experience like this so far. By now, I think the only game that can come as close to immersion as RDR2 is CDPR's Cyberpunk 2077, but that's a different story.
    All in all, an amazing game. A 9, not a 10, since on the PS4 Pro they utilized the worst Cherboarding implementation I've seen yet. How did this pass Sony's Quality Control is beyond me, but once you get used to it it's okay I guess, but hopefully Rockstar patch this horrible rendering solution to make it look at least a tiny bit less washed out and pixelated.    … Expand
  58. FrederikDraborg
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    By far the most immersive game there ever was. It's like a tv-series where you control the main character. The slow-paced style in the first part of the game fits the game perfectly, as high-paced action wouldn't be in-line with the realism regarding a gang of outlaws trying to lay low. This is not GTA in the wild west, this a realistic story-driven tale of a group of people trying toBy far the most immersive game there ever was. It's like a tv-series where you control the main character. The slow-paced style in the first part of the game fits the game perfectly, as high-paced action wouldn't be in-line with the realism regarding a gang of outlaws trying to lay low. This is not GTA in the wild west, this a realistic story-driven tale of a group of people trying to survive in a world which has outgrown them.
    The graphics and scenery's are some of the most beautiful I've ever seen, and i frequently stop what I'm doing and just look around the landscape.
    Red Dead Redemption is just something else. Rockstar did what they promised; and immersive, open-world where you feel like you are living in the cowboy-age.    … Expand
  59. carulli
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    il miglior gioco di sempre su qualsiasi piattaforma....un sogno che diventa realta'...Grazie RockStar I Love YOU
  60. JayPenrith
    Oct 30, 2018
    6
    I really really wanted to love this game but.. I don't even like it. It looks amazing... Granted but it's realism taken too far. I'm an older gamer and all I want to do after a hard day at work is relax and not having to worry about gun oil and coffee brewing. As others have said, controls are clunky and not very organic. I'll stick with Odyssey and Forza ..
  61. Apsilon
    Oct 30, 2018
    6
    I liked the first RDR. Despite the fact it didn’t grip or didn't thrill me as GTA did, it certainly had a personality all of its own and western plains never looked so good. I could look past the clunkiness of the controls and the hassle of the fast travel system and enjoy what it offered – a sprawling western adventure – albeit a rather shallow one.

    Fast forward a decade and finally,    I liked the first RDR. Despite the fact it didn’t grip or didn't thrill me as GTA did, it certainly had a personality all of its own and western plains never looked so good. I could look past the clunkiness of the controls and the hassle of the fast travel system and enjoy what it offered – a sprawling western adventure – albeit a rather shallow one.

    Fast forward a decade and finally, we’ve been given the sequel (prequel?) and my hopes for this game were that Rockstar would hopefully improve on the negatives of the first game to bring us another sprawling western but, this time alive with a living breathing world full of adventure and action because – it’s a game, right?

    10-12 hours in on chapter 3 and I have to admit that it’s been a grind to get this far. Of those 10-12 hours, I would wager that only an hour of that has been actual action. The rest has been horse riding, performing menial tasks, walking around aimlessly (and slowly) and cut-scenes.
    Not only that but, they have not addressed the two biggest issues from the first game. The controls and fast travel. As I said higher up, I could overlook the issues in the first game because it was last gen and what they achieved irrespective of issues, was marvellous. They don’t have that crutch this time and for the length of time this has been in development, these issues which are central to the playability of the game should have been addressed.

    1) The Controls – The controls are reminiscent of Resident Evil. A slow-burning horror game where they work by creating tension. They don’t work in a western where you need to move, sometimes very quickly, in reaction to events. They are cumbersome and unintuitive and as someone else has posted, they make Arthur appear arthritic in his movements. The buttons you have to manipulate to perform the most mundane task is ridiculous and far too many times, I have shot people in the face because the R2 button which is used for shooting from the hip is also used for performing actions.

    2) Fast Travel – if I thought fast travel in the first game was a ballache to use, the fact they have hidden it in RDR2 is a monumental mistake. Rockstar in trying to create a sense of immersion want gamers to ride their horse across the plains to get from A to B – every time. That’s fine if the ride is 5 or even 10 minutes, but, we’re talking upwards of an hour in some cases. This is a game remember. It’s for enjoyment. I do not want to simulate the life of a cowboy down the nth degree. I want to cut out the real-time inconsequentiality to get to the meat of the task. I don’t like travelling anywhere as it is, so why the f**k would I want to travel in real-time in a game. It’s a colossal waste of time and is the main issue of boredom.

    3) Cut-scenes – I get it; they drive the story or give background. However, they start to jar when they are 15 minutes long and I don’t want to see a cut-scene every time I perform a menial action.

    4) Stats – I mean come on; a sense of reality is one thing – total immersion is entirely another. Like in GTA SA, I now have to look after myself by eating, drinking, wearing the right clothes and not pushing myself too hard. Not only that, but I also have to take care of my horse! Cue more cut-scenes, more time wasting and more banality. It didn’t work in GTA SA and it doesn’t work here. Again, this is a game and I don’t want to have to have to worry about my characters well-being. It should be a given that he looks after himself.

    There are many more issues I could list but, those four are primary for me. Reading between the lines of reviews and gamer comments, some appear to be in clear denial and I think that is simply because it’s Rockstar and Red Dead Redemption 2. They are refusing to acknowledge its genuine shortcomings preferring instead to regale its beautiful environment. However, many games have beautiful environments such as; The Witcher 3, Horizon, ACO etc, and all these games incorporate stellar gameplay mechanics and do not burden the player with unnecessary faff that detracts from the adventure.

    Would ACO be a better game if you had to travel the length and breadth of Greece by horse and boat? Nope. In fact, do people who are raving about RDR2 play any open world games without using fast travel? I doubt it and that in itself is a contradiction by those proclaiming RDR2’s realism as the defacto reason for its immersion. A game is an escape for fun but, when that fun is duller than ditchwater, then it’s no longer a game. RDR2 is less an action game and more a simulation of life as a cowboy but, it’s not a particularly interesting one because too much needless nonsense bogs it down making it a chore to play.

    RDR2 is quite simply, a glorious looking world saddled with a shallow and monotonous gaming experience made worse by mechanics that are a decade old.    … Expand
  62. Rglamoso
    Oct 30, 2018
    5
    Control del personaje lento y engorroso. Bajadas frecuentes de framerate en Ps4, sobre todo en los combates. No está doblado al castellano. Sistema de delitos "ridiculo". Basta con tropezar con alguien para entrar en busca y captura.
    Te pasas la mayor parte del tiempo cabalgando entre largas distancias.
    etc etc...
    SOBREVALORADO
  63. RockSoldierTom
    Oct 30, 2018
    3
    I 100% completed first game and I had high hopes for this one. In a nutshell; gunfight gameplay is terrible, Arthur is way too slow it's not even realistic, 80% of the game is chores, honor system wants you to be a good guy or it will ruin your game experience. I used to love hunting in the first one, it has become boring as hell in this one because of sloooowww movements. Story is boringI 100% completed first game and I had high hopes for this one. In a nutshell; gunfight gameplay is terrible, Arthur is way too slow it's not even realistic, 80% of the game is chores, honor system wants you to be a good guy or it will ruin your game experience. I used to love hunting in the first one, it has become boring as hell in this one because of sloooowww movements. Story is boring too, nothing really happens. No thrilling mission. Yeah nice graphics though. But it's not even funny to look at the beauty of the nature because it's so long to go from point A to point B you don't want to go anymore.… Expand
  64. ghassenga
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    MASTAPIEACE ! nuff said.

    btw i'm only rating writing this "review" to counter all the trolls that only came here to rate the game down due to them being console haters or playstation haters.
  65. SPARTY
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Эта игра стоила ожиданий, потраченных средств, и самое главное - времени!
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - это искусство. Но к сожалению или к счастью, не все в этом разбираются..
  66. ammet
    Oct 30, 2018
    5
    Advantages:
    - Intro is what I really liked. Beginning of the game looks incredible.
    - Details - steps on the sand, the way you can customize the clothes, small animations like picking up something or eating. Tons of small details which made on 10/10 level - Looks Really beautiful. Graphics level is very high. Animations are the best! Like to just look on the landscapes. Disadvantages:    Advantages:
    - Intro is what I really liked. Beginning of the game looks incredible.
    - Details - steps on the sand, the way you can customize the clothes, small animations like picking up something or eating. Tons of small details which made on 10/10 level
    - Looks Really beautiful. Graphics level is very high. Animations are the best! Like to just look on the landscapes.
    Disadvantages:
    - Just look on the landscapes is the only fun thing. All gameplay is around "go there and kill those". With rare difference.
    - Riding 3-6 on horse to the quest giver, picking up quest, 3-5 minutes to the quest location, 5 minutes of quest, 5 minutes to get back on horse (if you didn't miss it - then you need to go 10 minutes on foot or steal a new one). This games is Horse Riding Simulator. (Which is not fun as I don't like pressing the X button rapidly for full ride)
    - Content: Boring boring boring. Don't know what I waited, but it's really boring. After finishing quest I didn't want to pick up next one. Don't know why, may be because it will be the same with little difference.
    - Horse can die!!! I made my horse my friend, it was with me from the beginning of the game. And then on the mission when you need to jump on train roof it was following me for some reason and jumped under the train... I realise it died straight after the mission end.. So I was need to start from beginning just because of randomnes/bug. This fact pushed me to close the game in that evening. I don't need *such* "realism" in the game to be honest.

    Verdict:
    - Game is big bright and beautiful gift box with nothing inside. You can look on it and that's all. Not suggest to buy unless they do something with that. Or until the online come out. Really hope online will fix it for me and show something different.    … Expand
  67. NorwayGamer
    Oct 30, 2018
    1
    the reason I'm giving this such a low score isn't to troll, but to show that I find it unacceptable that they continue to release games with profanity & blasphemy. the Lord's name is taken in vain trough-out the game numerous times, and I haven't even made it past 2 hours in it..
  68. Javogallegos
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Rockstar has done it again, it is nice to see companies like this, Santa Monica or CD Projekt strive to give us a great experience playable, not only deliver games of the year, deliver generation games that mark time and continue to last for years , what games do not come out every year and this year have given us this jewel is quite nice, with this only clear as Rockstar again slaps thoseRockstar has done it again, it is nice to see companies like this, Santa Monica or CD Projekt strive to give us a great experience playable, not only deliver games of the year, deliver generation games that mark time and continue to last for years , what games do not come out every year and this year have given us this jewel is quite nice, with this only clear as Rockstar again slaps those companies (ubisoft or ea) that the games are made with love and passion and not thinking about taking money right and left, bravo Rockstar for this and it is a pity what users are doing with the version of xbox, is a great game on both platforms, go that this game is a purchase insured, whether or not fan of the shooters.… Expand
  69. lirlandais
    Oct 30, 2018
    8
    Il est clairement surcoté, beaucoup trop de choses à gérer, la maniabilité est encore plus lourde que le 1er, franchement déçu de se côté.
    Et que dire de la localisation? Entre être sans arrêt en train de lire les petites aides en haut à gauche en même temps lire les sous-titres et jouer, c'est horrible. Parfois il manque même des phrases entière. Avec tout l'argent qu'amasse Rockstar je    Il est clairement surcoté, beaucoup trop de choses à gérer, la maniabilité est encore plus lourde que le 1er, franchement déçu de se côté.
    Et que dire de la localisation? Entre être sans arrêt en train de lire les petites aides en haut à gauche en même temps lire les sous-titres et jouer, c'est horrible. Parfois il manque même des phrases entière. Avec tout l'argent qu'amasse Rockstar je pense qu'ils pourraient se donner la peine de faire des doublages dans plusieurs langues, d'autres studios moins fortunés le font alors pourquoi pas eux!
    Le framerate fait le yoyo, Faire un jeu magnifique ok, mais qu'il soit stable c'est mieux.

    C'est un très bon jeu, mais il ne mérite pas les notes qu'il se paye juste parce que c'est Rockstar....ça rappelle les notes ahurissantes que se prennent les Call of Duty chaque année.    … Expand
  70. MemesOverlord
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    True masterpiece. Russian PC gamers are trying to lower the rating, so do not consider their negative scores.
  71. Jodn
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Best game ever without any doubt !

    Impressive in any aspect, the best looking game on consoles and the best open world ever...

    What a game R* !
  72. Hardy35
    Oct 30, 2018
    9
    Игра с душой. Игра с большой буквы. Игра в которую вложены силы, средства и талант. Все это чувствуется с первых минут проведенных в ней. Хороший сюжет, в котором интересно смотреть и слушать диалоги до конца,графика радующая глаза и отлично проработанный звук. Идиоты которые минусуют игру за отсутствие русской озвучки и ПК версии, очнитесь! Нас и так заливает Free-to-Play каллом и играмиИгра с душой. Игра с большой буквы. Игра в которую вложены силы, средства и талант. Все это чувствуется с первых минут проведенных в ней. Хороший сюжет, в котором интересно смотреть и слушать диалоги до конца,графика радующая глаза и отлично проработанный звук. Идиоты которые минусуют игру за отсутствие русской озвучки и ПК версии, очнитесь! Нас и так заливает Free-to-Play каллом и играми сервисами. Rockstar пошли против этого течения и сделали отличную игру.… Expand
  73. NoTalentHack
    Oct 30, 2018
    3
    I'm beyond frustrated with the horrible controls. Whenever I get into any "action", the game is basically over - not only is there no fine control, there's basically no control whatsoever - just button mash and hope for the best. But hey, the game is beautiful, right? But I'm afraid I'll never get to enjoy it - after I spend 3 hours or whatever traveling around, I end up almost literallyI'm beyond frustrated with the horrible controls. Whenever I get into any "action", the game is basically over - not only is there no fine control, there's basically no control whatsoever - just button mash and hope for the best. But hey, the game is beautiful, right? But I'm afraid I'll never get to enjoy it - after I spend 3 hours or whatever traveling around, I end up almost literally ripping my controller apart every time I get into a gun fight. For me, that's the opposite of fun - wish I'd saved $60 and just watched the YouTube videos for the graphics.… Expand
  74. GrimmOpt
    Oct 30, 2018
    0
    Скучный сеттинг. Нудные квесты. Медленный геймплей. Отвратительная производительность на
    PS 4. Так себе графика. Баги.
  75. Jugbaw
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    This is one of the best games I have ever played. It should get 11/10 at least.
  76. DTanilG
    Oct 29, 2018
    0
    Русская озвучка просто ужасна, как поменять на оригинальную озвучку?
  77. AlagarYa
    Oct 29, 2018
    2
    Графоний норм, процесс норм. Отсутствие ПК версии не норм.
  78. masterplan
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    One of the greatest games you could ever hope to play. Simply stunning in too many ways to mention here.
  79. ReaperxSpider
    Oct 29, 2018
    9
    I love this game, playing a game world and getting lost in it for hours just having a blast. its an amazing game for sure almost flawless really, however it does have its annoy bits nothing to crazy just tedious. I definitely would recommend this game to anyone is a great fun world to lose yourself in.
  80. bedheadred
    Oct 29, 2018
    3
    In trying to create a deep world, Rockstar has outdone itself in the worst possible way. At its surface, the game appears to have everything promised to fulfill a glorious sequel to Read Dead Redemption: beautiful landscape, rich lore, and endless unscripted fun. Instead, Read Dead Redemption 2 takes itself too seriously. Cinematic for the sake of cinema. It begs the question: In all ofIn trying to create a deep world, Rockstar has outdone itself in the worst possible way. At its surface, the game appears to have everything promised to fulfill a glorious sequel to Read Dead Redemption: beautiful landscape, rich lore, and endless unscripted fun. Instead, Read Dead Redemption 2 takes itself too seriously. Cinematic for the sake of cinema. It begs the question: In all of the countless hours it took to create this game, did anyone bother to actually play it? Games, after all, are supposed to be play.

    The controls of RDR2 may be the biggest surprise that I have experienced so far. If you think you are familiar with Rockstar controls after playing GTA V (and prior releases), think again. There is a lack of intuitiveness that can result in undesired consequences. In order to compensate for the overly complex controls that would be cumbersome, if not impossible, for one to fully grasp, there is an overlay that details different button actions.

    The potential issues with controls are amplified by relatively slow and arduous animations. At times, you are restricted in motion (i.e. unable to run, unable to pull out gun, etc.) and it is not clear when/why this occurs. There are numerous instances where the game resets (weapons, horse hitch location, etc.) that result in the player needing to constantly micro-manage inventory and re-adjust.

    The world is stunning at first glance. Graphically it may represent the peak capability of this console generation. The old adage “looks aren’t everything” comes to mind, because while the beauty will surely captivate you for hours, like all things it will begin to lose its charm in due time. The trees and the shadows cast from them are glorious — until your horse runs into them after you say ‘hello mister’ to a passing stranger and the camera’s re-direction causes you to instantly veer in the new direction. Try saying ‘hello’ to folk in town and see how straight you can maintain your horse. In stark contrast, consider Until Dawn, which maintained directional input through camera cuts, that is until a player stopped input all together, triggering the game to smartly re-adjust to the new orientation on the fly.

    It is a cumulation of oversights and questionable development choices that undermine a monumental creation. Just how many hours is a player expected to spend in doing mundane tasks such as shaving, bathing, and brushing the horse. How many times must you pick up your hat? How many times must you watch the same looting animation? Or eat the same meal (stew) at the same interval (god forbid you have seconds).

    The bounty system discourages, or even prevents, players from engaging in criminal activity. Yes, you are in a criminal gang. No, you may not gain money from doing things a gang typically does. Take for instance, looting a train. You may earn $100 from looting it. But you will have lost $200+ in the growing bounty that you must pay. Red Dead Redemption 2 takes it one step further than student loan debt in the U.S. - your bounty will actually carry through past your own demise - It only is resolved once the debt has been paid in full. The unbalance between reward & risk creates a sense of morality that Rockstar intents to bestow upon its gamers. Pick the role of noble Arthur, lest you find yourself a poor destitute as you bounce between cities getting killed or hauled away by bounty hunters.

    High on the heels of success in GTA V Online, Rockstar intends to re-capturing the elusive lightning in the bottle of substantial micro-transaction purchases on the backs of loyal gamers. Despite its lack of availability upon launch, make no mistake, this feature will surely become a primary focus for Rockstar and its parent company Take-Two Interactive. After all, there are executives with a fiduciary responsibility, and shareholders that want a return. The absence of any “Season Pass” or bundled DLC at a flat rate is striking considering the Ultimate version comes in at $99 MSRP.

    Ultimately, Red Dead Redemption 2 falls flat. It fails the simple test of: Is it fun? For those willing to overlook the numerous frustrations that could have easily been avoided, there lies an open-world Cowboy Western genre with no other competition in sight. For an average gamer looking for play, consider watching a Western movie, reading a Western book — you will have saved yourself 50 hours from a cinematic horse simulator, complete with a compelling cast & environment, and crippled gameplay mechanics.    … Expand
  81. ToxicGent
    Oct 29, 2018
    9
    Not a perfect game, with the controls being clunky and the horse not riding up to you. There are things that should be options for the player to choose, such as if you keep the guns on you at all times or not, to skip the bathing thing or not, aiming options should be way more accessible and not buried within menus. There are glitches that have caused me to get wanted while not being inNot a perfect game, with the controls being clunky and the horse not riding up to you. There are things that should be options for the player to choose, such as if you keep the guns on you at all times or not, to skip the bathing thing or not, aiming options should be way more accessible and not buried within menus. There are glitches that have caused me to get wanted while not being in the area or having my guns vanish when i load into my game for the first time that day. Despite this and the complaints saying they dont want to have to eat or hate riding their horse, its a good game, its the wild west, what did you expect to ride? Duels are not at all explained so be careful when entering one, your horse can die easily if you dont take care of it, and dont trust your bandanna to keep your identity safe, wear the full head mask if you can. Animal conditions are not explained at all and sometimes feel like they are stacked against you as even the best shot may not yield a good pelt. A bit repetitive but this does feel immersive, the upkeep is annoying but it adds to the atmosphere. I got this game and spiderman within a week of each-other and i have to say that i am enjoying Red Dead Redemption 2 way more, the graphics, game-play and tone all come together to provide an enjoyable experience.

    Obviously some patches are needed and im sure they will come, the online being delayed gives people time to enjoy the single player so dont be put off by the lack of it. Alot of activities and npc's are locked behind missions but traveling the world in chapter 2 will still feel worth while. If you are trying to pick between Spiderman, ACO, and RDR2, go for RDR2.
    (I also own ACO but its basically an origins DLC).    … Expand
  82. yexiaoai
    Oct 29, 2018
    0
    This is the most overrated game ever.
    What's bad in Ubisoft open-world games are even worse in RDR2.
    First of all, the controls are bad, it feels really clumsy. I couldn't believe this is a 2018 game. When you push your left stick, the character won't immediately move. Whenever I wanted to interact with something or somebody, if you are not perfectly positioning yourself, you will not    This is the most overrated game ever.
    What's bad in Ubisoft open-world games are even worse in RDR2.

    First of all, the controls are bad, it feels really clumsy. I couldn't believe this is a 2018 game. When you push your left stick, the character won't immediately move.
    Whenever I wanted to interact with something or somebody, if you are not perfectly positioning yourself, you will not be able to succeed.
    So you want to do some minor adjustments about your positioning or facing direction. Then you realize that the clumsy character won't move or just moved too much.
    There are actually two sets of controls you have to learn, or you'll get into big trouble. When you have your gun in your hand, you have to be very careful because pressing L2 means point your gun to someone, not to interact with. So you'll get yourself wanted very fast.

    You are going to do a lot of fetch quests in which you have to ride your horse by constantly pressing button X, and you just kill/chase one or two bad guys and go back. This is no better than any other open-world games, and not even remotely close to those fun quests in BOTW.

    And you're about to do a lot of chores in RDR2, which actually is not fun. I do not understand why anybody could think it fun.
    I even expected to wash my plate after the first time i've eaten something, while Rockstar didn't give me this option.

    Hunting is fun, but rewards are little and I won't bother doing this much. You can't hunt while doing a quest 'cause you'll lose things you hunted.

    What's even worse about this game is the bounty part. You get yourself wanted usually because of : 1. clunky control (run into someone with your horse or accidentally pressing wrong buttons resulting in shooting someone) 2. self-defense. If you kill, your bounty goes higher even if nobody saw it; if you don't, you'll get killed.

    Do yourself a favor to not buy this game, or at least read more honest reviews before buying the most disappointment probably in your gaming life.    … Expand
  83. Boo59
    Oct 29, 2018
    1
    ne mohu naiti ingru v stime, na strimah vigladit na 1, tak je nekotorie strimeri ne chitaut subtitri, poetomu hotelos bi i ozvuchku na moi yazik
  84. AngeredWalrus
    Oct 29, 2018
    9
    This game is everything I loved about Red Dead Redemption and then some. Solid 9/10.
  85. DazSavage
    Oct 29, 2018
    2
    An utterly beautiful and deep game with the beginnings of great beleivable character development... utterly ruined by controls that are overly complex. There's too much frustrating and superfluous detail which does nothing but stand in the way of the fun. The horse system is stupid. There's a crafting system that requires combinations of animal pelts but nowhere to store anything evenAn utterly beautiful and deep game with the beginnings of great beleivable character development... utterly ruined by controls that are overly complex. There's too much frustrating and superfluous detail which does nothing but stand in the way of the fun. The horse system is stupid. There's a crafting system that requires combinations of animal pelts but nowhere to store anything even though you have a large camp. So I ended up just selling my hard hunted perfect skins because I needed room... so I don't even know how the crafting of some high end kit would be even possible. The horse steals back all your rifles every time you sit on it so you always end up in fights with the wrong weapons in hand and if you try to sort out your weapons every time you get back on the horse (which is advisable) you end up pulling out a gun in an area where you shouldn't because it's impossible to even look at a weapon without it then being drawn. You push one button to draw a weapon but then you need another button press to raise the weapon and then another to actually open fire... at which point you realise that the horse stole back your guns and the reason your not firing back is that you're unarmed!
    This control scheme is obviously being kept so as to link with GTA 5 and allow players to go from one to another more smoothly. There's no way this scheme would ever have been chosen otherwise because it's simple unusable. There's even some things that are only comfortably achieved if you have three hands.
    I have struggled through about 20 hours now and have always ended my session in a rage quit because I'm always failing mission s or dying due to the game's overly complex system. In one case the horse stopped in front of a door I needed to go through. The horse will not move for you! So I placed the injured man I was rescuing on the ground so I could get back on the horse to move it away and suddenly the guy dies. Not only was this a mission fail but also for no reason everyone in town immediately assumed I had killed him and went for the lawmen. Not very realistic.
    Red Dead 2 is too busy wowing us with how detailed it is to remember that the gamer is looking for some fun and escapism... but here I am just waiting to make a hundred bullets one by one, each with animation. Or waiting for my horse, or waiting to get from A to B because the hopeless fast travel doesn't even do properly the little it tries to. Everything is waiting and waiting... and then even more waiting.
    This is a cowboy simulator not a game.
    My score was a 2 out of 10 due mainly to complete disappointment.
    It's like finding the perfect restaurant, being served amazing food and then being told you have to eat blindfolded while wearing boxing gloves... you will be annoyed, especially when everyone else is getting their control systems right.
    KEEP IT SIMPLE STUPID.    … Expand
  86. salahbelal
    Oct 29, 2018
    6
    This game is over hyped. I don’t like wild west era games but was hoping this game would change my mind but it failed miserably. The gun play is awful and the covering system fails to achieve the fun part of gunfights. The story starts very slow and it gets a little boring afterwards. The main camp that you are staying at is kinda useless as it doesn’t generate any money and all theThis game is over hyped. I don’t like wild west era games but was hoping this game would change my mind but it failed miserably. The gun play is awful and the covering system fails to achieve the fun part of gunfights. The story starts very slow and it gets a little boring afterwards. The main camp that you are staying at is kinda useless as it doesn’t generate any money and all the crafting upgrades are costly and require some special materials which requires long and boring hunting trips. The need to eat, sleep, smoke and repeat is literally breaking the game as it kills the fun part. And last but not least, this game should be called Horse Simulator: Boring Edition. The amount of time you spend on just tapping X to keep it running is long enough to rage quit. If your horse dies or it’s far from you you have to run like a minimum of 5 minutes to reach a nearby town. I had high hopes for this game but I am already thinking of selling or trading it after only 3 days and I am not even interested in completing the story. Shame on you Rockstar.… Expand
  87. megudyeh
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    This game is a pleasant masterpiece just like GTA5 was. But Rdr2 is more than a game. It's a history simulator, like a live museum where you get the authentic American western experience in the 19th century. The amazing details leaves me no doubt of this masterpiece. I think some people need to drop this instant gratification mentality because this game introduces new things in a naturalThis game is a pleasant masterpiece just like GTA5 was. But Rdr2 is more than a game. It's a history simulator, like a live museum where you get the authentic American western experience in the 19th century. The amazing details leaves me no doubt of this masterpiece. I think some people need to drop this instant gratification mentality because this game introduces new things in a natural pace. It's all butter smooth, doesn't feel forced upon you. But if you lack the appreciation for this damn fine game go play Fortnite or Blops4 to get your adrenaline fix.… Expand
  88. Maxxx1911
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    The game is very good Rockstar Games knows how to create an incredible and extremely detailed world. Certainly one of the best games of this generation. I recommend everyone
  89. stiglitzz
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    Returning after all recently released AAA games, Rockstar show you that you need such a real AAA project.
  90. kk84
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    How on earth can some people give this 6 or below for this beautiful game?
    Yes it can be slow some times but everything in this game is amazing its a masterpiece, from the sound, graphics, story, gameplay its really great. I bet the haters dont play this on a big tv screen one of the high ends tv on a ps4 pro. the difference is big! Or else they are to busy playing the children game    How on earth can some people give this 6 or below for this beautiful game?
    Yes it can be slow some times but everything in this game is amazing its a masterpiece, from the sound, graphics, story, gameplay its really great. I bet the haters dont play this on a big tv screen one of the high ends tv on a ps4 pro. the difference is big! Or else they are to busy playing the children game fortnite! Meeh.
    Everyone should try out this game and take it from what it is.
    Clearly game of the year without any doubts!    … Expand
  91. and1one
    Oct 29, 2018
    0
    The game crashes. The graphics are poor. Expensive. In vain bought, very sorry.
  92. Jum
    Oct 29, 2018
    0
    Terrible gameplay and lousy graphics make the game fall into mediocrity is simply very bad, nothing recommended if you plan to buy.
  93. Haytham22
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    Amazing game with unbelievable atmosphere and a really realistic experience.
  94. Tico18
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,II love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,I love horse,… Expand
  95. Xelluse
    Oct 29, 2018
    2
    Single player Korean MMORPG-like game in Cowboy setting....
    One of the most boring games in last 2 years...
  96. Hillmaus
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    This is "must have game" beautiful scenery of wild west,hunting animals,absolute freedom, you can do whatever you want.
  97. Kean_1
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    I was a fan of RDR and RDR2 simply improved on that in so many ways. I've already spent many hours on the game and only just scratched the surface.

    I've been a gamer for over 30 years when consoles and PCs were just becoming mainstream. I've played a lot of games over that time and RDR2 is one of those few that I would even consider giving a score of 10 out of 10. That's not to say it    I was a fan of RDR and RDR2 simply improved on that in so many ways. I've already spent many hours on the game and only just scratched the surface.

    I've been a gamer for over 30 years when consoles and PCs were just becoming mainstream. I've played a lot of games over that time and RDR2 is one of those few that I would even consider giving a score of 10 out of 10. That's not to say it is absolutely perfect or can't be improved upon, but there is so much that makes this game good. It keeps me immersed as I'm continually discovering new activities, mechanics, sites, etc. IMO, they delivered on what they promised.

    This will certainly become one of those I will consider one of my all time favorites.    … Expand
  98. Stresspresso
    Oct 29, 2018
    7
    Beautiful game(?), but like a piece of modern art it takes too much effort to enjoy. It's annoyingly complex with minor details, yet frustratingly basic on so many other levels. This game will show you a glimpse of fun but take it away with random **** that will make you question why you even play games? Oh right, this isn't a game, it's an "experience." Just go ahead an experience thisBeautiful game(?), but like a piece of modern art it takes too much effort to enjoy. It's annoyingly complex with minor details, yet frustratingly basic on so many other levels. This game will show you a glimpse of fun but take it away with random **** that will make you question why you even play games? Oh right, this isn't a game, it's an "experience." Just go ahead an experience this from the videos of your favorite youtuber, this is really meant to give them content rather than make it a fun experience for you.… Expand
  99. Smc88
    Oct 29, 2018
    9
    Well I have been anticipating this game for some time. The graphics and storyline are absolutely amazing. The immersion is second to none and attention to detail is on point and in a class of its own. However it took me about 15-20 hours of gameplay before I really started to enjoy the game. The one issue I have are the controls being so clunky and trying to shoot people without dead eyeWell I have been anticipating this game for some time. The graphics and storyline are absolutely amazing. The immersion is second to none and attention to detail is on point and in a class of its own. However it took me about 15-20 hours of gameplay before I really started to enjoy the game. The one issue I have are the controls being so clunky and trying to shoot people without dead eye or using the wide lock on is very unsmooth. I feel like between the dead eye and lick on combat becomes mundane like highlight your enemy’s and then watch them drop. But if you disable all of those things it’s so clunky and glitchy that you can’t really enjoy the combat at all. If they can fix the combat system it would be an absolute 10 out of 10!… Expand
  100. DanielVNDM
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    It's a great great game, one of the best games for this consoles generation, besides The Witcher 3 and The Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wiild. The fight for be the best game of this generation have a new aspirant
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2018

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
97

Universal acclaim - based on 99 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 98 out of 99
  2. Mixed: 1 out of 99
  3. Negative: 0 out of 99
  1. CD-Action
    Nov 14, 2019
    95
    It’s an huge, outstanding piece of art – worth the hard-earned cash as well as countless hours that are needed to get to know at least some of the attractions of Rockstar’s rendition of Wild West. For those who put story first – the biggest virtue of Red Dead Redemption 2 is that it sets the stage for RDR 1 and does it wonderfully. [13/2018, p.40]
  2. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Dec 31, 2018
    100
    Amazing not only for Western lovers. No other game has probably offered so many options to express yourself in the open world, and at the same time did not have such an interesting, rough and moving story. A magnificent experience, with a slightly slower start. [Issue#291]
  3. TrueGaming
    Nov 30, 2018
    95
    The first new game from Rockstar for this generation of consoles doesn't disappoint, it is as impressive as you hoped it to be.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »