Red Dead Redemption 2

 PlayStation 4
User Score
8.7

Generally favorable reviews- based on 21344 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18,146 out of 21344
  2. Mixed: 1,261 out of 21344
  3. Negative: 1,937 out of 21344
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. UTM-
    Nov 7, 2018
    9
    This is a game that looks and feels far beyond any game that is created to this date.
    The story was Good althought the pacing was very slow at the start of the game.
    The gameplay Is very realistic and satisfying but it can feel to straightforward witch can create tentionless moments.
  2. ChomoArigato
    Nov 7, 2018
    9
    These are just my personal thoughts on the game.

    From start to finish this story of Red Dead Redemption 2 slowly works at almost masterfully telling not just Arthur's journey, but that of each member of the gang. I say “almost masterfully” due to the fact that some of the character's development can be missed if the player decides not to engage with each member frequently. And this too    These are just my personal thoughts on the game.

    From start to finish this story of Red Dead Redemption 2 slowly works at almost masterfully telling not just Arthur's journey, but that of each member of the gang. I say “almost masterfully” due to the fact that some of the character's development can be missed if the player decides not to engage with each member frequently. And this too has its own narrative aspects, ignore the gang too often, and they grow to dislike you. In my playthrough, I took every chance I could to engage each member, and with that… very seldom have I played a game where each character feels so genuine, unique, fully fleshed out, and alive. That doesn’t mean that everyone will like it, and not everyone does, but for me the slower pacing and build up really helps aid the narrative. Nothing feels too rushed or too forced, characters seem to react according to their personalities and perceptions, and when dealing with such a large cast that is a difficult thing to achieve. Although Rockstar's writers have attempted to curb a lot of their typical humor in favor of writing a compelling narrative, there is still plenty of humor to be found in the world, and it would seem to me that the dialogue finds itself to be much more authentically funny and realistic than some previous Rockstar titles.

    Personally, this game thrives on the mundane... and I think that's kind of the point. Things like taking a bath, resting at camp, going fishing, hunting, playing cards, dominos, or just chatting by the fire. All of these little things help establish a world that allows you to be human, to settle in and enjoy yourself, to relax before the inevitable gunfight or the long rides across an open wilderness full of threats and adventure. After catching Arthur up on some much needed rest after taking on a few chores and missions at the gang camp, I remember riding out into the forest to go hunting, only to find that I was the one being hunted by a cougar. Before I knew it, my trek to obtain meat for sustenance became a life or death situation when I realized that there was also a pack of wolves nearby who had come for the cougar's carcass. Stories aside from the narrative in RDR2 are plentiful and often... and they often have consequences and rewards. Spend too much time out in the wild without setting up a camp to eat and recover, and Arthur becomes drained of energy, which alters how he's able to hunt and fight. Neglecting food and Arthurs health deteriorates faster, rely on Dead Eye for too long and his ability is drained making gunfights and precision hunting more skill dependent. The introduction of cores to these elements was daunting at first, but as I continued through the game, I came to appreciate them and understand their purpose. Seldom was it that I found myself sitting at the other end of the controller not having a great time. Random events occur pretty frequently and include Ambushes, robberies, bounties, kidnappings, prisoner transports, and others and are fairly abundant.

    I did, however, encounter some technical and graphical issues. Things such as when mounting a horse near certain objects causing the animations to bug-out, I was unable to loot certain bodies after a gunfight if they were near other interactable objects (like weapons, tonics, and the like, where the solution was to move the body), and some texture pop-ins when riding really fast through densely forested/populated areas, but otherwise I had very few issues with the game. All things considered though, these issues were not game breaking and were honestly not surprising given how extensive this game truly is. I have tried to find any real major faults with the game from my personal perspective and honestly the positives far outweigh any negative in my book. And I do understand that the slower pacing will dampen some people's experience in the world of RDR2, but as I stated earlier, I found that aspect of it to actually aid the narrative and overall theme the game is attempting to establish.    … Expand
  3. JavaSquirt
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. 10/10 за что что не идёте на поводу всякого рода "меньшинств" и феменистического отребья.… Expand
  4. pvliesdonk
    Nov 7, 2018
    5
    Agree with all the other negative reviews. Stopped playing after approx 8 hours as I couldn't be bothered to continue through all the glitches and control mess. I really hope Rockstar will patch these issues, as the game looks and sounds fantastic.
  5. Goldenhammer
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    This game is Perfect in every way. Yes if you are a person who is not interested in Open World game it is possible that you get bored after a while but if you are interested in open world games it's your game.Full of details,Perfect Gameplay and Gunplay and amazing Story. You just need to get used to the game after a while you'll find out how great this game is.
  6. GamergodsFail
    Nov 7, 2018
    9
    Even at its worst, Red Dead Redemption 2 is just as great as its predecessor. It's bigger, more detailed, more realistic and improved upon in almost every way. Current technical issues could cease it from being Game of the Year quality, but for those who loved the last game will find plenty to enjoy here once again - so long as they don't mind it feeling a bit too similar at times.
  7. BRAVOac130
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    Alright I want to start by saying I have put in atleast 15/20 hours of gameplay I think, I'm on chapter IV and this game still amazes me to this moment I still have things happen that blow my mind, like weather and environmental physical effects walking through a town with dust kicking up from the wind will cause dust and dirt to gather on your clothes, all the footprints in the dirt haveAlright I want to start by saying I have put in atleast 15/20 hours of gameplay I think, I'm on chapter IV and this game still amazes me to this moment I still have things happen that blow my mind, like weather and environmental physical effects walking through a town with dust kicking up from the wind will cause dust and dirt to gather on your clothes, all the footprints in the dirt have been created by the people living in that town but enough about that im more about gameplay, graphically its a masterpiece but gameplay is where it makes its money, you may talk to every NPC and you may vaguely choose the dialoge between you and them, the gunplay is very realistic urging players to aim more accurately and punishing you for taking bad shots at your enemy its not a run and gun shootem up western, there is a large level of strategy that goes into decisions knowing when to move when to shoot and when to run all are decisions you will have to make or it could mean death which has a monitary penalty and you keep the bounty should you get into a fight with the law, the level of detail they have gone into with just your horse is insane to keeping your horse clean happy and fed was well as yourself, The story starts off slow but is very well detailed and worth the time, it keeps you reeled in and makes you feel attached to characters (for me atleast), there is no shortage of things to do in this game from hunting, fishing, exploring, robbing, camping, customizing, and talking with strangers, this goes on all the way down to personal hygiene, sleeping, eating, drinking, and even getting your portrait taken, I believe this game is now the new standard for open world games Rockstar games 10/10.… Expand
  8. Beaunerman
    Nov 7, 2018
    0
    I CAN'T BELIEVE I PAID $60 FOR A HORSE SIMULATOR. Pretty to look at, but it is a chore to play. The gunplay is clunky. Searching things is wonky (you will miss a lot of searchable items). Approaching people is hit or miss. I approached a lady stuck under a horse, lifted the horse off of her, and then hit L2 to talk to her like I had been doing with all other NPCs in the game. Instead itI CAN'T BELIEVE I PAID $60 FOR A HORSE SIMULATOR. Pretty to look at, but it is a chore to play. The gunplay is clunky. Searching things is wonky (you will miss a lot of searchable items). Approaching people is hit or miss. I approached a lady stuck under a horse, lifted the horse off of her, and then hit L2 to talk to her like I had been doing with all other NPCs in the game. Instead it interpreted L2 as ASSAULT THE LADY. And you want micromanagement? You've got it. If your f'in horse is DIRTY it tires more easily? How about just letting me PLAY the game? My entertainment time is too valuable for this. I want to play a game, but this feels like work. Hey Rockstar, once you have ONE HEALTH METER, get rid of the STAMINA stupidity (for horse AND main character? Really?), and bring back the stuff that made the previous title great I may repurchase. I LOVED RDR, I'd rate it a 9/10. This is just tedious. I'd rate it lower if I could. I bought this yesterday, played for 8 hours, returning it tomorrow. This game sucks so bad that I created a metacritic account for the sole purpose of writing this review. I've never been so disappointed in what had the potential to be a great game. IT'S JUST NOT FUN. I wrote a complaint letter to Rockstar. I've never written a complaint letter to anyone for anything. I'm sure it will fall on deaf ears. It seems they forgot what makes video games fun.… Expand
  9. Linx_13
    Nov 7, 2018
    7
    Clumsy controls, buggy gameplay and questionable mechanics keep Rockstar’s prequel to the excellent western Red Dead Redemption far from being a perfect game, but its characters and story still make up for a memorable experience.
  10. Voidlust
    Nov 7, 2018
    0
    If you like watching paint dry and having your opinion spoon fed to you by games media and YouTubers, 10/10 . For those of us in the real world.... not so much.
  11. turnerpike20
    Nov 7, 2018
    9
    I felt like this game was actually really good when it came to story and graphics and other things that games don't do as much like being able to grow facial hair. I played Red Dead Redemption back when that came out and I played it quite a lot and it's the same with this game. I bought this game on the Friday it came out and completed the story on Thursday with the only thing reallyI felt like this game was actually really good when it came to story and graphics and other things that games don't do as much like being able to grow facial hair. I played Red Dead Redemption back when that came out and I played it quite a lot and it's the same with this game. I bought this game on the Friday it came out and completed the story on Thursday with the only thing really getting in the way was school. When it comes to this game not being on PC I think when it does get on PC it will be a little bit better than what PS4 and Xbox One players have to go through like a bit more better graphics. This game was actually realistic and I felt that it really caught women's struggles to vote at the time which is a history setting of the game. However the problems I have with this game are the bugs that I am sure can be fixed but a problem I kinda do have that isn't much of a problem is the fact that the map is so big and to ride on a horse it can take up to a long time to get from point a to point b, but however it's pretty nice to have a big map and I felt this game really did bring back more than Red Dead Redemption I think it did improve from the last game. Really don't listen to all the people giving this game a 0 because they really don't know what a good game is as of right now I would say this is the game of the year or at least the game of the year so far. But really people giving this game a 0 have no real reason to argue because they either hate the fact that it's not on PC or they don't like the fact that it's mostly horse riding or they don't like the fact that they aren't getting passed chapter 1 of the game. Really complete this game and then tell me that it's bad because really there is a good story to this game and it explains a lot more to the first game. Really if you don't think you'll like this cowboy activity then don't play the game it's really that simple.
    I don't want to promote myself too much but check out my YouTube 'turner pike' if you want to see me play this game.    … Expand
  12. rednutgaming
    Nov 7, 2018
    8
    I think a lot of these negative reviews are just impatience people who should maybe stick to something a bit more fast paced. i think the game is good there are a few issues no questioning that but every game has had some teething issues in the first stages of release before the patches come along and fix things. well worth the money and i would make that purchase again without question.I think a lot of these negative reviews are just impatience people who should maybe stick to something a bit more fast paced. i think the game is good there are a few issues no questioning that but every game has had some teething issues in the first stages of release before the patches come along and fix things. well worth the money and i would make that purchase again without question. as a returning red dead fan i was content with the prequel even thou it is questionable were the character actually fits into the story given there was no prior mention of him. all and all good solid game with a potential to grow with a few updates!… Expand
  13. 22jhanson
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    I have played 100% through this game, and I would say it is 100% worth the money. Some people may have some issues, but it does a very good job developing the story, and really making you love the main character. I personally think the game was very fun, and enjoyable to the point where I could hardly stop playing it. It's very good.
  14. bazookapat
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    Wonderfully beautiful game with a fantastic story with twists and turns throughout. Filled with all sorts of minute and great details that just had me staring at the screen for longer than I usually would with any other game. Though it does start out slow, it is something one should expect with the western genre, not every game needs to start out with giant shootouts to get the playerWonderfully beautiful game with a fantastic story with twists and turns throughout. Filled with all sorts of minute and great details that just had me staring at the screen for longer than I usually would with any other game. Though it does start out slow, it is something one should expect with the western genre, not every game needs to start out with giant shootouts to get the player involved, but rather have the story fleshed out to entice them to keep going; which this does perfectly. So filled with different events and secrets, with over 50 hours, I am only 51.4% through the story and have not yet used fast travel once. A must by for anyone.… Expand
  15. Pekaru_cocnylu
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    Ревьювы на метакритике работают хуже, чем в ё*****м стиме. Тебе нужно хотя-бы иметь игру, чтобы делать на неё отзыв, но хрен там плавал. Здесь любой пекарь может оставить горелый след от своего пукана.
    Восстанавливаю справедливость этим отзывом, так бы поставил 9-9.5/10, но вообще, кто я такой, чтобы ставить оценку. 10, и пусть пекари сосут до выхода игры на пк, а она скорее всего выйдет    Ревьювы на метакритике работают хуже, чем в ё*****м стиме. Тебе нужно хотя-бы иметь игру, чтобы делать на неё отзыв, но хрен там плавал. Здесь любой пекарь может оставить горелый след от своего пукана.
    Восстанавливаю справедливость этим отзывом, так бы поставил 9-9.5/10, но вообще, кто я такой, чтобы ставить оценку. 10, и пусть пекари сосут до выхода игры на пк, а она скорее всего выйдет на пк.    … Expand
  16. W1ZSAM
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    Классная игра, прошёл примерно за 35+ часов.
  17. NCPROD
    Nov 7, 2018
    9
    Плюсы:Пекари бомбят, Открытый мир, Проработка, Графика, Система NPC, Охота, Гемплей
    Минус:Сложноватое управление
  18. Araripe
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2 is hands down one of the best open world games I have ever played. To begin with, the universe it takes place is quite massive and full of life. It is convincing, let me just say that. Often enough, game developers come out with massively detailed maps that lack the most important part: life. Rockstar did it right as usual, and the map truly breathes. Animals, NPCs,Red Dead Redemption 2 is hands down one of the best open world games I have ever played. To begin with, the universe it takes place is quite massive and full of life. It is convincing, let me just say that. Often enough, game developers come out with massively detailed maps that lack the most important part: life. Rockstar did it right as usual, and the map truly breathes. Animals, NPCs, everything feels consistent and coherent. They all have a purpose, never there for placeholding or to make it feel like there is something going on but not really, like it usually happens with massive open world universes. Rockstar made an universe of their own and it shines.
    As we all know, a game is not only made of big and living maps. It needs objectives, a storyline, strong characters and something to get you hooked on. Luckily enough, RDR 2's story is nearly as perfect as the universe it takes place. You will fall in love with Dutch Van der Linde's gang, and you will also hate them, at times. It's unpredictable, cruel and sometimes funny. It feels like something straight out of a good western book, and it really does make you play the game for countless hours nonstop. For nearly 60 hours, you say goodbye to your true self and take Arthur's body into quite an adventure.
    It has quite a slow start as most people mentioned in the reviews, but it definitely gets better as you rack up the game hours. It's good to the point you don't want it to end, and the closer you get to the final chapter, the more you want it to last longer. It's like that expensive Danish Cookies box you got for Christmas, except you can't really have more of it once it's over. Unless one could wipe his memories and play it again like it was the very first time.
    And not only it's a good storyline, but it also sticks with you. It's rather memorable, with lots of ups and downs and unexpected twists. Truly one of the best stories ever written for a game, despite some saying otherwise. Let's just say those are used to the standard AAA storytelling technique, which is sort of predictable at all times. RDR 2's story might be everything, but not predictable. If you have never gotten any spoilers, the outcome of the campaign will be definitely a surprise. And it's better that way. Predictability takes a lot away from the overall enjoyment.
    Rockstar took full advantage of the "next generation" of consoles - or should we say "soon to be obsolete" generation? - delivering an impressive visual quality tied to a huge environment and excellent artificial intelligence. Just like in 2013 with Grand Theft Auto V on PS3 and X360, the game is quite a closure to the current generation. Xbox One and PS4 are soon to be gone, but they are going with a bang. Full style, like a true gunslinger. A decent goodbye. The Housers once again proving that they master the extremely challenging task of taking the full potential of the hardware they got to work on, like making juice out of rocks. With that much money to spare, it is definitely not unexpected.
    It's a 10 from me, but it definitely does not mean that it's perfect. There's no such thing as perfection. Everything has its flaws and RDR 2 could not run away from that, but those are minor and don't affect the overall experience. It's definitely worth the 60 dollars and it's a life you have to live. Arthur Morgan's journey is one of a kind.    … Expand
  19. Deez_Nuts
    Nov 7, 2018
    5
    All I have to say is that this game is kinda overrated if we talk about Gameplay, the game is not near perfect .
  20. Moony545
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    Rdr2 приподнял планку качества игр, еще на один уровень, пока это лучшая игра в данном сеттинге и одна из лучших игр вообще. Игра заслуживает оценку 10 из 10.
  21. Ave_Fenix
    Nov 7, 2018
    4
    OMG this game is not as good as RDR1, is overhyped and overrated, famboyism and marketing is real.
    Gameplay is slow and can't enjoy it that much.
    Controls are bad, a game can't have 97 rating with theses issues are you kidding me and thats not all but I have no time for this joke, not bad as some claim but not awesome either.
  22. Kalty
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    I never played RDR before. I was never been much fan of Western, except Vinnetou from K.May. But RDR2 swallowed me totaly.
    Absolutely TOP class. Level of detail in graphics, music, atmosphere, story, people, nature, environment.
    I love this game. I love these rides in wilderness, hunting, fishing, robing or helping people. I love conversations with every single NPC. The changing    I never played RDR before. I was never been much fan of Western, except Vinnetou from K.May. But RDR2 swallowed me totaly.
    Absolutely TOP class. Level of detail in graphics, music, atmosphere, story, people, nature, environment.
    I love this game. I love these rides in wilderness, hunting, fishing, robing or helping people. I love conversations with every single NPC. The changing atmosphere of game through playtime.
    There are people which are not satisfied with RDR2. But for me its one of the best games. And I play video games for nearly 30 years now :)    … Expand
  23. Exproda
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    This game is awesome. It is very strange to score it 0 out of 10 because it hasn’t created on pc platform. Open world is marvelous, main story is interesting. Good job Rockstar 10/10 as always.
  24. backInBone
    Nov 6, 2018
    8
    Looks great but plays not so great.
    Good: graphics, story, dialogue, voice acting, attention to details, content volume, etc..
    Bad: control, gameplay, game mechanics, quest design, etc..
    It takes a lot of time to finish and it can get tiresome at times. But the main story along with the side quests in Chapter 6 got me emotional so overall it was worth it.
  25. Mcdugan
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    This game is why i failed no nut November. Perfection in my eyes, absolutely deserves the praise its getting from critics and if you haven't picked it up yet I most certainly should xo
  26. vigoroth0402
    Nov 6, 2018
    7
    I'd say this game is way too long and drawn out story wise, and the actions are clunky and slow. But, there are many silver linings. The open world is beautiful and has so much to be admired, and the the exploration itself is fairly rewarding. However, it's truly just another Rockstar game.
  27. JordanH
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    I've played 30+ hours of the game and find that it's amazing, graphics are amazing and the gameplay is flawless, I'm a PC gamer myself but purchased on a console just to experience a masterpiece. The game is slow at the start but is clearly there to ease the player into the mechanics of the game. I found it to be one of the most satisfying and immersive games I've ever played.

    If this    I've played 30+ hours of the game and find that it's amazing, graphics are amazing and the gameplay is flawless, I'm a PC gamer myself but purchased on a console just to experience a masterpiece. The game is slow at the start but is clearly there to ease the player into the mechanics of the game. I found it to be one of the most satisfying and immersive games I've ever played.

    If this game is released on PC then I will most certainly be purchasing again as there is so much replay-ability and fun experiences that can be created from encounters with the npcs.    … Expand
  28. Darkfalcon
    Nov 6, 2018
    6
    As a 3A game, Red dead redemption had a horrible user interface and so many bugs. Although the Sound/graphics is very good, the game experience is so bad.
  29. Etrone
    Nov 6, 2018
    9
    Just Completed 100% Of The Game. Amazing Story Line. Memorable Characters. Player Movement Does Feel Chunky And A Bit Slow. Aiming while on a horse is difficult but you will get used to it. Dead Eye, sure you can kill easier and in a cooler way but I personally perfer to not use it while playing. 95% Of missions are well done and enjoyable. I Do however wish that they included moreJust Completed 100% Of The Game. Amazing Story Line. Memorable Characters. Player Movement Does Feel Chunky And A Bit Slow. Aiming while on a horse is difficult but you will get used to it. Dead Eye, sure you can kill easier and in a cooler way but I personally perfer to not use it while playing. 95% Of missions are well done and enjoyable. I Do however wish that they included more of the west side in early parts of the game. Overall Nice and smooth game definitly worth the price.… Expand
  30. Onask
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Rockstar lo vuelve a hacer con su juego más ambicioso hasta la fecha.

    Red Dead Redemption II es casi perfecto, estableciendo el mínimo exigible a partir de ahora en cuanto a mundos abiertos y sandbox se refiere. 8 años de esfuerzo y dedicación (y quién sabe, quizás horas extra forzadas) dan sus frutos, y estos están maduros y deliciosos. A día de hoy, debe de ser del 5% (siendo    Rockstar lo vuelve a hacer con su juego más ambicioso hasta la fecha.

    Red Dead Redemption II es casi perfecto, estableciendo el mínimo exigible a partir de ahora en cuanto a mundos abiertos y sandbox se refiere. 8 años de esfuerzo y dedicación (y quién sabe, quizás horas extra forzadas) dan sus frutos, y estos están maduros y deliciosos.

    A día de hoy, debe de ser del 5% (siendo optimistas) de videojuegos de los que volvería a pagar su precio completo de salida orgulloso una vez terminado, porque lo vale.

    Pocas veces ves una campaña que de verdad dura 40h (mínimo) y con unos estándares de calidad altísimos. De hecho, su epílogo tiene mayor duración que muchos de los juegos que he tenido la oportunidad de jugar.

    Arthur (personalmente) super a Marston en muchos sentidos, aunque también tendremos una buena dosis del bueno de John en esta entrega, así como de muchos otros miembros de la banda. Gráficamente es imponente, sobre todo teniendo en cuenta la absurda magnitud del mapa, la historia está muy bien contada y planteada, el gameplay sigue en las líneas de Rockstar pero tomando mucho en cuenta lo que lograron con Max Payne 3 y una banda sonora que infinidad de juegos soñaría con tener. Recalcar la absurda cantidad de detalles que contiene el juego, simplemente no entra en mi cabeza como es capaz que un juego de estas dimensiones con tal cantidad de pequeños alicientes pueda siquiera ejecutarse en una máquina actual.

    Qué más decir. Al igual que la primera entrega (sin contar Red Dead Revolver), RDR2 es ya un clásico instantáneo, con escenas simplemente brutales que se quedan grabadas en tu memoria, y no te dejan soltar el mando, así como el juego del año y uno de los mejores de la generación sin ninguna duda.

    Morgan pasará al libro de iconos de los videojuegos junto a Marston, y Rockstar recogerá de nuevo premios como lleva haciendo toda su carrera.

    Sin duda, un antes y un después en el ámbito de los sandbox así como mundo abierto, que establecerá las bases como nuevo referente a nivel de calidad. No todo el mundo es Rockstar, y muy pocos serían capaces de lograrlo, así que de momento, están invictos en el género e incluso en la industria.

    Sin duda, imprescindible.    … Expand
  31. Kittykat725
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Even with the bugs that most games have from a launch, the game is amazing, personally i hadn't ran into any bugs myself, I have completed the main story of the game and strayed a little away from side missions, something i do honestly regret, my overall completion of the game is around 75% so far and the game is amazing, i cant wait for the online segment to be released but that's notEven with the bugs that most games have from a launch, the game is amazing, personally i hadn't ran into any bugs myself, I have completed the main story of the game and strayed a little away from side missions, something i do honestly regret, my overall completion of the game is around 75% so far and the game is amazing, i cant wait for the online segment to be released but that's not exactly a bad thing, i'm sure that the game will have a few Single player Expansions and then a bunch of Free Online Updates, the game play of this game is a bit clunky as with most Rockstar titles, the thing i do not like however is some features of the game it doesn't tell you about and i had to learn them from Online Sources or by experimenting myself, but that won't make me review the game any less… Expand
  32. Mycoolo69
    Nov 6, 2018
    5
    So I am 25% in to this game and constantly saying to myself.. I'm sure its going to get better than this... but no.. not yet.. argh....

    The game looks great, almost photo realistic graphics and I have full appreciation for that! But: -Controls are so bad... coming from Black ops 4 and Spider man these controls just suck.. no getting used to them they just suck.. -Shootouts are    So I am 25% in to this game and constantly saying to myself.. I'm sure its going to get better than this... but no.. not yet.. argh....

    The game looks great, almost photo realistic graphics and I have full appreciation for that!
    But:
    -Controls are so bad... coming from Black ops 4 and Spider man these controls just suck.. no getting used to them they just suck..

    -Shootouts are sooo cumbersome, clunky and just not fun.. I find myself saying fuk I just want this stupid fight over...

    - Walking around camp is so slow for some reason, like fingernails down chalkboard

    - Missions are dull

    - Horse riding is fun for 5 minutes then boring as hell for the next 20 minutes..

    - I did a mission last night where I had to deliver letters between 2 lovers on opposing feuding families.. How is that supposed to be fun? or Bad ass?

    I like games that make me feel like a super hero or bad ass.. this is just a horse riding and chore simulator!    … Expand
  33. Wolfinthefable
    Nov 6, 2018
    7
    This game is really overrated.
    The amazing environment is the only thing that really stands out if you ask me. Controls are bad and every interaction looks slow and clumsy. The menus are outdated. Missions lack variety: most of them consist of several tedious minutes of horse riding and some trivial gunfight... without the rides each mission would probably lasts 5 minutes or less. Game    This game is really overrated.
    The amazing environment is the only thing that really stands out if you ask me. Controls are bad and every interaction looks slow and clumsy. The menus are outdated. Missions lack variety: most of them consist of several tedious minutes of horse riding and some trivial gunfight... without the rides each mission would probably lasts 5 minutes or less. Game progression/difficulty WANTED.
    The plot becomes interesting halfway through while in the first chapters you have that "nothing important happened today" feeling. The second part of the story and the dialogues are nice.
    The soundtrack is ok, moving sometimes but only good as a whole.
    Details as growing hair, dirty clothes and other stuff like that are cool but Rockstar should have spend more time improving gameplay mechanics and controls.    … Expand
  34. MrBum
    Nov 6, 2018
    7
    They set the game in 1899, so I guess they wanted their control scheme out of the same era. The game controls like a drunk oxen trudging through cold molasses. The run and gun gameplay is some of the worst I've ever seen since the PS2 era. I had to constantly look up how to do things, nothing is ever explained, and i think i'm getting carpel tunnel syndrome from mashing x so damn manyThey set the game in 1899, so I guess they wanted their control scheme out of the same era. The game controls like a drunk oxen trudging through cold molasses. The run and gun gameplay is some of the worst I've ever seen since the PS2 era. I had to constantly look up how to do things, nothing is ever explained, and i think i'm getting carpel tunnel syndrome from mashing x so damn many times just to run (you know, the movement speed that should be default and has been in every decent game in the last two decades).

    Barring those gross --and in my opinion negligent-- deficiencies, what the game does well it does very well. The environmental design is top notch from lighting to art direction to sound design, all incredible and amazing. It's a shame we have to experience all of it through the absolutely inexcusably bad player interface.

    It's a shame, as this game would have easily been a 9, maybe even a 10 if Rock$tar wasn't stuck in the 19th century when it came to controls. As it stands now, I can barely manage to play a few hours at a time before walking away for a day or two in frustration.    … Expand
  35. Paulocamilo
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    this is well good game made and a sollid game ,beautifull graphics rdr2 is masterpiece.
  36. Fredystark
    Nov 6, 2018
    0
    The game is not seen in 4k as it says on the label, and the gameplay is not as good as the critics say.
  37. Gralic
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Played the game for 23 hours and i have not been bored a single second. I dont know why so many people are hating on i actually found it a lot more entertaining than the first one
  38. TravisFinn
    Nov 6, 2018
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. An amazing game and landmark achievement for Rockstar Games. It's truly almost perfect except for a major problem I have.

    Regarding the Epilogue of the game - I think it was a complete misfire and sloppily done. It's hard not to compare to RDR 1's epilogue but it just pales in comparison in a major way.

    Looking at RDR 1's epilogue, it set out on two goals; One, the player's agency to seek revenge for John's death, and what better way to achieve that than to play as a grown-up Jack! The second goal was to bring a poignant end to the game that added to the overall theme of the story - violence is fruitless and cyclical - "People don't forget. Nothing is forgiven". This was truly one of the greatest endings to a video game ever, and it was a shame to see RDR 2 fall so flat. Like 1, it set two goals: the Player's agency to kill Micah Bell as revenge for Arthur's death. And second, to set up the events of RDR 1 as you play John Marston.

    Rockstar surprisingly misses the mark on both points. My two major complaints lie in the length and pay off of the epilogue. First off, it is WAY too long. RDR 1's had one mission, 4 check points on the map and you were done. And it was simple and beautiful. RDR 2 however has two parts of an epilogue, most of it only concerning John's building of the Beecher's Hope ranch, and it is utterly boring. Character wise as well - John and Abigail are the only ones who further develop their relationship, wile returning characters like Charles, Sadie and Uncle really only serve to prop up John's goal of building a better life. What you get are last minute subplots and not too much character development which is a shame. Then, what really ruined the ending for RDR 2 for me was the final mission.

    It was totally CHEAP of Rockstar to cheat us out of a final confrontation with Micah, and instead we have to cower behind cover while we aren't allowed to shoot at him ever. Sadie gets captured like an idiot and then also Dutch appears... for some reason? I thought it was evident Dutch no longer trusted Micah at that point. If he did reconcile, where did Bill and Javier go? So many plot holes in a single moment and then boom... Dutch shoots Micah anyway and just leaves. Then John and friends go home and happy ending music plays. What a joke, seriously. Completely took me out of the game. Even worse, you get stuck playing John Marston if you didn't have a second save as Arthur. Just my opinion in the end but I was really let down with this epilogue.    … Expand
  39. ApplehacksXD
    Nov 6, 2018
    9
    Great game big open world the start is a bit slow and alot of riding but nothing to big great ending if you have played rdr gun play is nice hunting is really good somethings dont get explained like how to equip your 2 ''big guns'' permanet
  40. Solar_9
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Maybe it's because i love Red Dead Redemtion 1 or western genre, but it's the best game i've ever played. 100h for now and i can't stop playing.
  41. Alfogulas
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    This game easily deserving of a 10 from anyone willing to play and listen to the game. the areas, towns, random encounters, scenery and wildlife all seems so real in every second of the 50+ hours I've pumped into this game, despite this many reviews are still saying this game deserves a 0. off the top of my head I can't think of a single criticism to give to this game, I have had funThis game easily deserving of a 10 from anyone willing to play and listen to the game. the areas, towns, random encounters, scenery and wildlife all seems so real in every second of the 50+ hours I've pumped into this game, despite this many reviews are still saying this game deserves a 0. off the top of my head I can't think of a single criticism to give to this game, I have had fun playing no matter what I am doing. From the hunting to robberies to exiting characters and plot, the game never seems to get old. I have seen this game being described as a "horse riding simulator", and for the first 2-3 hours, I agree, but once you unlock the whole open world you can go to any location you desire or just grind through the story which i'm still only 73% through, the missions themselves are all very diverse, some involve running and gunning through masses of enemies while others have you carefully taking out guards one in satisfying stealth sections. Overall this game has already lasted me longer than most and I know it will last for a long time to come with the unbelievable amount of content available right from the start with more unlocked as time goes on. Please ignore any reviews that say otherwise, if you are yet to play RDR2, do yourself a favour and pick it up as soon as you can, you will not regret it.… Expand
  42. Yozakura
    Nov 6, 2018
    6
    I really wanted to love it. The over-world is beautiful and detailed, but my God do the controls suck the fun out of the game. Arthur moves like he has a refrigerator stuck to his back, and don't get me started on the no-fun-allowed law system, not to mention being punished for acting evil to a certain extent. The fishing and hunting are nicely done, however, and for those who enjoyI really wanted to love it. The over-world is beautiful and detailed, but my God do the controls suck the fun out of the game. Arthur moves like he has a refrigerator stuck to his back, and don't get me started on the no-fun-allowed law system, not to mention being punished for acting evil to a certain extent. The fishing and hunting are nicely done, however, and for those who enjoy interactive movies this is a fine "game".… Expand
  43. Protospark
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    I'm going, to be honest before it's release I was extremely excited but after all the details and small pieces of information, I began to have doubt on this game. I was mistaken and this game is just a gorgeous work of art. I haven't even finished the story but the world itself has become its own character and I spend my time discovering its secrets, marvel at its beauty, and spend my timeI'm going, to be honest before it's release I was extremely excited but after all the details and small pieces of information, I began to have doubt on this game. I was mistaken and this game is just a gorgeous work of art. I haven't even finished the story but the world itself has become its own character and I spend my time discovering its secrets, marvel at its beauty, and spend my time with all the extra content. Easily worth the $60 dollar price tag with the hours of gameplay that this game contains. The controls do feel clunky, which is a bit disappointing but I am used to it from Rockstar games. The shooting was a problem at first but there are many options to make the shooting experience much better. I'm excited to finish the story and it is a game that constantly brings me back.… Expand
  44. BLK99
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Genial, 100% recomendado, es increiblemente adictivo... graficos increibles, una excelente historia y un gameplay solido, no muy espectacular pero es un shooter de epoca, no es que se le pueda sacar mucho... se necesitan es mas actividades.

    Espero con ansias varios DLCs para single player, no me interesa tanto el online pero de seguro va a ser una locura, no se puede esperar menos de    Genial, 100% recomendado, es increiblemente adictivo... graficos increibles, una excelente historia y un gameplay solido, no muy espectacular pero es un shooter de epoca, no es que se le pueda sacar mucho... se necesitan es mas actividades.

    Espero con ansias varios DLCs para single player, no me interesa tanto el online pero de seguro va a ser una locura, no se puede esperar menos de los desarrolladores    … Expand
  45. Reaperofsouls4h
    Nov 6, 2018
    9
    Don’t listen to these bad reviews on here either they are trolls, pc users upset because they don’t have the game or Xbox one users / PS4 users bashing the other version of the game. This game is not for gamers with short attention spans . This game is for people who like to take there time and enjoy the scenery, enjoy the game. Now granted no game is perfect that’s why I gave it a 9Don’t listen to these bad reviews on here either they are trolls, pc users upset because they don’t have the game or Xbox one users / PS4 users bashing the other version of the game. This game is not for gamers with short attention spans . This game is for people who like to take there time and enjoy the scenery, enjoy the game. Now granted no game is perfect that’s why I gave it a 9 instead of a 10 because no game is perfect. Now if rockstar does a few patch updates to address a couple problems the game has it would be a 9.5.. this is game of the year contender for sure. Either this or God of war will win game of the year but if I had to bet money on what it would be I would give it to red dead redemption 2. If you like westerns or open world games buy the game you won’t regret it.… Expand
  46. spicygoatcurry
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Rockstar has again pushed the boundaries of gaming. Never before have I felt so immersed in a game. From the beginning, you feel personally transported to the Wild West. The graphics are amazing, the voice acting is top-notch, characters are extremely fleshed out and provide the most depth into a game that I have ever experienced. Even "minor" characters have dialogues that speak to theirRockstar has again pushed the boundaries of gaming. Never before have I felt so immersed in a game. From the beginning, you feel personally transported to the Wild West. The graphics are amazing, the voice acting is top-notch, characters are extremely fleshed out and provide the most depth into a game that I have ever experienced. Even "minor" characters have dialogues that speak to their pasts and personalities.

    Before purchasing the game I saw user reviews complaining about how there's no fast travel, it takes time to get places on the horse, there are so many little meticulous things you need to do. And I will admit I was worried by these reviews. But once I started playing, the horse rides and the little chores did not feel meticulous. They made me feel more integrated into the game, as if I am not just controlling Arthur Morgan, I AM Arthur Morgan.

    Gameplay is incredibly fun. Bank heists, train robberies, gun-fights are super exciting. This game will define the future of gaming as developers look to emulate the depth of the world that Rockstar has created.    … Expand
  47. GenericGamer283
    Nov 6, 2018
    9
    Red Dead Redemption 2 is the cultivation of Rockstar's entire gaming development history and sets new bars and expectations we as gamers will have for future games being released, especially Rockstar titles. Graphically, it is the most beautiful game in the market, as well as being more immersive than it probably should be. Some may say the "ultra-realistic immersion" hurts the gameplay asRed Dead Redemption 2 is the cultivation of Rockstar's entire gaming development history and sets new bars and expectations we as gamers will have for future games being released, especially Rockstar titles. Graphically, it is the most beautiful game in the market, as well as being more immersive than it probably should be. Some may say the "ultra-realistic immersion" hurts the gameplay as a whole, and while I don't agree with these statements, I could do definitely see how casual players might be annoyed by these aspects. In terms of the game's story, it's without a doubt the best modern western in recent years and a proper prequel to its predecessor. You will find a wide array of new and returning characters, each memorable in their own way, and with over 500,000 lines of dialogue, every person you meet feels "alive." All in all, with its expansive open-world and fun gameplay loop, this is a game I believe everyone should experience.… Expand
  48. unostoper
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    more games to the god of games!

    need to fix some bug's, but it's definitely awesomeness!
  49. Dont4get2wipe77
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Red dead redemption 2 is a masterpiece. It takes time to learn but it’s very rewarding when you do. The world is huge, varied and detailed. There’s a lot to do, to some it may be overwhelming but once you work out what’s important it can be taken at a reasonable pace. Every trip to camp or town has a purpose instead of feeling like a chore. Obviously this is just my take on it, the gameRed dead redemption 2 is a masterpiece. It takes time to learn but it’s very rewarding when you do. The world is huge, varied and detailed. There’s a lot to do, to some it may be overwhelming but once you work out what’s important it can be taken at a reasonable pace. Every trip to camp or town has a purpose instead of feeling like a chore. Obviously this is just my take on it, the game may not be for everyone. It might be a bit slow paced at times for some but, for me, the pacing made it stand out and feel unique. All in all it’s been a hell of a ride and a great experience. 9.7/10… Expand
  50. KasperPSR
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Generally speaking, there are two types of negative reviews for RDR2.
    1. People annoyed about the game not being out for PC, or upset about 30 fps.
    2. People who thinks that the game is too slow and repetitive. You have to understand that it's deeply unfair to give a game a bad rating because it's not out for PC or has a frame cap that—frankly—most console games have. You gotta judge    Generally speaking, there are two types of negative reviews for RDR2.
    1. People annoyed about the game not being out for PC, or upset about 30 fps.
    2. People who thinks that the game is too slow and repetitive.

    You have to understand that it's deeply unfair to give a game a bad rating because it's not out for PC or has a frame cap that—frankly—most console games have. You gotta judge the game based on its content, narrative, gameplay—by judging it on external factors such as fps or PC-availability you're severely hurting the reliability of its rating.
    If you're in the second demographic who thinks the game is too slow, it's probably because you're used to playing fast-paced games. Rocket League, God of War, Fortnite, etc.

    YES, RDR2 is a slower game than the aforementioned, but in that slowness is where you find its quality. Its slowness makes you notice the little things around you—the landscape, animals, birds, the changing light. The slowness makes you appreciate the games atmosphere, it makes you feel involved in its world. The fact that you have to ride on horseback to several quest-points is a deliberate choice from R* in getting you to know your fellow characters better through conversation while stressing the world's scale by having you travel the actual distances.

    Releasing a game like this is a very bold move by R* in a time where our attention-spans have become ridiculously short. I'm a firm believer that this approach is good and healthy for the gaming industry and for gamers, demonstrating that games don't have to be over-the-top, unrealistic and FAST in order to succeed. Maybe we can get back to a frame of mind that's not just about a quick fix.

    The pacing of the game will sadly throw some people off. These are people who have this shortened attention-span, are unable to appreciate the beauty of the game-world and the game's excellent writing, but who are interested in games that are more arcade-ish, colourful and crazy. Having different preferences is totally fine. As an example, I personally don't like to play Fortnite. Its art style is not for me and the gunfights too hectic. But that doesn't mean that I can't see its quality on a mechanical level. And just because I don't like this type of game myself, doesn't mean I'm gonna give it a terrible review on Metacritic. It just means I won't review it. Similarly, I think more people reviewing RDR2 ought to consider if it's even a game for them before reviewing it.

    Lastly, I give the game a perfect score, and I do so after much consideration and after having completed 58% of the game. I think it deserves a 10 because no other game has made me feel this much like I wasn't playing a game. The world looks lived in, the NPC's feel human to an almost unsettling degree, and my choices feel like they have impact. And the music is sensational. Sure, the game has some glitches here and there, you can't avoid that with an open world game. But if there ever was a game more deserving a perfect score, it's Red Dead Redemption 2.    … Expand
  51. SoulreaverDE
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    At first i thought this game was overhyped and people are too excited for this. Then it released and i gave it a chance. I played through like 30 mins. of the game and i felt like: "Yeah this is cool and stuff but theres nothing special to it, kinda boring." Then i watched a few reviews. I thought: "ok, one last try."

    And that´s the best thing i´ve ever done :D The Game opens it´s Open    At first i thought this game was overhyped and people are too excited for this. Then it released and i gave it a chance. I played through like 30 mins. of the game and i felt like: "Yeah this is cool and stuff but theres nothing special to it, kinda boring." Then i watched a few reviews. I thought: "ok, one last try."

    And that´s the best thing i´ve ever done :D The Game opens it´s Open World after like 45min. - 1 hour (for me at least, i played a bit slow/relaxed).
    The game starts slow and you learn something about almost all characters (within missions or just talking in the camp). And once the game immerses you and gets its grip it takes you on a rollercoaster ride with one of the best stories i´ve ever experienced. (note: i played games like: the last of us, uncharted, Horizon: Zero Dawn, God of War)

    Every single mission is different from the other, that makes that game good. The story is getting more intense but can also have times to call down and lets you breathe, before it gets more intense. That made it great.

    Then you have this big, detailed, interactive and immersive Open World. It felt entirely alive. I suffered with every character and believed that all of this characters were alive a long time ago. I lost myself many times in this game.

    And that makes it almost PERFECT. 10/10 - a must buy.    … Expand
  52. BrutalBarracuda
    Nov 6, 2018
    9
    The only thing that bugged me a little was the controls, clunky at best and so annoying when the game forces you to walk when i want to run, time and time again it does this. Apart from that the game is amazing. Not a single crash in the entire time spent finishing the game on a standard PS4. Great story, great variety in missions and tons to do if you want to 100% this game. Another thingThe only thing that bugged me a little was the controls, clunky at best and so annoying when the game forces you to walk when i want to run, time and time again it does this. Apart from that the game is amazing. Not a single crash in the entire time spent finishing the game on a standard PS4. Great story, great variety in missions and tons to do if you want to 100% this game. Another thing is the game is too easy, only failed a couple missions a few times. Characters are great, especially Dutch.… Expand
  53. Tony_lender_ps4
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Лучшая игра за это год. ПК бояре вы не бояре а холопы
  54. Rofalot
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    All of my complaints with this game can be fixed by having it released on PC. There's a bit of a noticeable input lag, making the controls feel clunky, but I don't mind the game prioritizing realistic animations over responsiveness in this particular game. The textures are a bit low res sometimes when up close, and the meshes are low-poly up close. Those are all issues that can be fixedAll of my complaints with this game can be fixed by having it released on PC. There's a bit of a noticeable input lag, making the controls feel clunky, but I don't mind the game prioritizing realistic animations over responsiveness in this particular game. The textures are a bit low res sometimes when up close, and the meshes are low-poly up close. Those are all issues that can be fixed with a PC version. I won't take points away from a game just because PS4 Pro has outdated specs compared to PC.… Expand
  55. Vladislav88
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    Прекрасная игра с чудесным сюжетом и отлично прописанными персонажами
    Свою цену отбивает полностью ведь сюжет на 60 часов это мастхэв
    А все эти дегродные пекари что пытаются снизить оценку , ну так всем адекватным людям на вас похуй Моя оценка 10/10    Прекрасная игра с чудесным сюжетом и отлично прописанными персонажами
    Свою цену отбивает полностью ведь сюжет на 60 часов это мастхэв
    А все эти дегродные пекари что пытаются снизить оценку , ну так всем адекватным людям на вас похуй
    Моя оценка 10/10
  56. spiderkobe
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    Played between 20-30 hours of this game so far and I’m in awe. This game has a true soul and it is so easy to get lost in the marvellous world rockstar has perfected!

    There is so much to do! Hunting, challenges, robbery, bounty hunting, treasure hunting and of course, the incredible story! I see many bad reviews complaining about clunky controls and spamming X to run, yet in the    Played between 20-30 hours of this game so far and I’m in awe. This game has a true soul and it is so easy to get lost in the marvellous world rockstar has perfected!

    There is so much to do! Hunting, challenges, robbery, bounty hunting, treasure hunting and of course, the incredible story!

    I see many bad reviews complaining about clunky controls and spamming X to run, yet in the settings you can change to the standard L3 FPS experience which I love! The controls are also pretty much GTA, moderated to the western open world!

    The world is insanely beautiful and really has a soul and story behind almost everything! I personally can not put this game down!

    Complaints about frame drops don’t occur with my game ever and the aim assist is completely customisable as many people complain about that! The deadeye feature is awesome and really fun and smooth!

    The slow style of the game is historically accurate and relaxing which I love, yet you can also go on a high speed train robbery and shoot up half a town!

    Sure the bounty system can get a tad annoying but unless you have just started the game and are super broke it is simple to just pay it off!

    Horses are incredible and when I lost my horse and couldn’t get it back I was devastated, which proves how interactive this game is! There are many species of horse with different speeds, styles, attributes and builds. ( You can also name them which I love!)

    It is impossible to get bored in this game as I get lost searching for some 200 species of animal, almost 40 species of fish, and almost 100 guns and weapons with constant Easter eggs and tiny side missions to distract you on your horse journeys which can get repetitive, but fast travel is easy to acquire early on and trains cost $2 or $3 but can get you anywhere!

    The map is so diverse with big bustling cities, smaller community-based town and farms and homesteads scattered around! Deserts, swamplands, urban areas, snowy mountains and beautiful animal-filled plains cover the map which makes it hard to get bored of the map.

    Rockstar has done it again and anyone giving negative reviews are either PC players just jealous of this amazing game, want the game for the wrong reasons or have played only 1-2 hours of the slow-paced yet fun and informative prologue!

    If you like an interactive and diverse open-world, incredible stories and just want a new game that isn’t a battle Royale, this is definitely the game to have!    … Expand
  57. Siivonen
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    yes the game is slow paste, and thats why it not for little kids whos attention span is from 15 mins to an hour at max.

    i my self in joyed the story and Rockstar Games really made me actually feel for these characters. There is a slight frame drop when ever entering into a city/town but the frames come back pretty quickly and i played RDR2 on my 4 year old PS4. The only glitches    yes the game is slow paste, and thats why it not for little kids whos attention span is from 15 mins to an hour at max.

    i my self in joyed the story and Rockstar Games really made me actually feel for these characters.

    There is a slight frame drop when ever entering into a city/town but the frames come back pretty quickly and i played RDR2 on my 4 year old PS4.

    The only glitches that i ran into was when a box fell of a map and a bear T-posed for a couple seconds.    … Expand
  58. oldmanecane
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    RDR2 has enormous world with always something going on. Story is pretty awesome. graphics are top notch. Horse movement and physics are good. The game has nothing in common (as gameplay) with GTAV, not even close. Weapons actually have some learning curve and are not the same at all. I can say my money on the game are well spent and is worth it.
  59. Superflyguy
    Nov 5, 2018
    3
    I created an account just to post this.

    I bought RDR2 Friday and played maybe 15 - 20 hours over Saturday and Sunday. Toward the middle of the day on Sunday the "new game"ness effect wore off, and it finally became apparent to me that this game just isn't very much fun. It's repetitive and tedious, and frankly kind of sucks despite the gorgeous landscapes and visuals. Don't believe the    I created an account just to post this.

    I bought RDR2 Friday and played maybe 15 - 20 hours over Saturday and Sunday. Toward the middle of the day on Sunday the "new game"ness effect wore off, and it finally became apparent to me that this game just isn't very much fun. It's repetitive and tedious, and frankly kind of sucks despite the gorgeous landscapes and visuals. Don't believe the critics reviews. The negative and mixed user scores reviews are all spot on.

    As many have mentioned, the controls are inconsistent and confusing. The main character's movement speed is sluggish. Simple actions like tying up your horse horse are annoying to perform. There are animation sequences you can't skip for many basic actions like skinning animals, which get old really quick. The intro is long and boring and doesn't do a great job of introducing you to core game mechanics. There's little replay value because it's so boring sitting through the intro all over again. Every mission is the same: spend 10 minutes riding your horse, do your task for 5 minutes, spend 10 minutes riding back. Want to hunt? Ride your horse for 10 minutes, hunt for 5 minutes, ride your horse 10 minutes back. I kept expecting more mechanics to open up that would make the game more enjoyable. It never got better. The game is just tedious and dull. It's not fun to do mundane tasks over and over. It's not fun to spend 10 minutes riding your horse to get somewhere, do a task for 5 minutes, and ride your horse back 10 minutes tapping X over and over again.

    It's just not a fun game. Don't waste your money.    … Expand
  60. chec13
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    Almost perfect, but there are some issues.

    Pros: - Great Graphics, seriously the graphics around Rhodes is just amazing. -Great voice acting -Great Gameplay -An extreme amount of depth -Great twists in the story (the journey is great) -Extremely good main character development Cons: - Can't run in camp and some other places. The game cherry picks what is wants to be realistic    Almost perfect, but there are some issues.

    Pros:
    - Great Graphics, seriously the graphics around Rhodes is just amazing.
    -Great voice acting
    -Great Gameplay
    -An extreme amount of depth
    -Great twists in the story (the journey is great)
    -Extremely good main character development

    Cons:
    - Can't run in camp and some other places. The game cherry picks what is wants to be realistic about, and this is one of them. Except it isn't to the benefit of the player or to anybody. Maybe they did it to try and extend the average players playtime.

    - Delayed shooting. With some guns, you will find that you have to first press the fire button to pull back the hammer, and then press the fire button again to fire. But a lot of times I would press the fire button to pull back the hammer so I could line up a shot, only to have it fire for me afterwords, which resulted in me dying multiple times.

    -Unlikable characters, at least at the beginning. Compared to the first Red Dead Redemption, these characters are a lot more cold-blooded. They will kill innocent people for the stupidest reasons. They then seem to try and redeem them by bringing in social issues. Great, so our main character isn't a racist, that cool, but I fail to see how that compares to mass murder. It just doesn't make sense that the whole world is bigoted except for our character. At least in the first red dead redemption, Marston killed because he wanted to get back to his family, in this game it really just comes down to greed though.

    Predictable ending- This isn't to say that the ending was bad. All I can say is that it could have easily been better. When I beat the game, I was angry, because I didn't think Rockstar would be so predictable. If you have played the first game and have a prediction about how this game is going to end, you are probably correct. Even though the ending was predictable, they could have at least made it meaningful (like the first rdr), they could have at least made it satisfying. All it really feels like though is a kick in the nuts.

    Camp Upgrades are pointless- sure fast travel is cool, but raising the happiness of people didn't really have a benefit, i never found myself needing ammo off my cart, or medicine, or even food. The camp system in this game is just something to motivate you to earn money, and then spend it.    … Expand
  61. RedShiftXIII
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Beautiful world that is alive with animals and npcs that offer the player opportunities to play the game as they wish. A few of the controls are clunky - sometimes I'll tackle a close pedestrian instead of hopping on my horse as I intended - but once you get use to them, the freedom of choice offered to the player transcends most other open world games.

    The main plot isn't a witcher 3 masterpiece, but it fits the game perfectly and allows you to play as you wish without feeling like your breaking the overarching narrative, but rather you feel like you're enhancing it.

    The consequences, however, don't feel as rewarding. If you play an evil character, you'll see a few benefits - some people will run in fear rather than fight you and you might have an easier time robbing - but it's easy to pay off bounties and it's as if murdering half a town is fine as long as you pay. Playing a good character is a bit better, but not by much.

    Overall, I think just the exploration of the world is fun enough, with the story and the character paths just being icing on the cake.    … Expand
  62. Minge
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption II Red Dead Redemption II Red Dead Redemption II ?
    Yes pretty great LMAO
  63. Luka8102
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    I went and bought PS4pro with RDR2. I'm in 30% of the story. So far the BEST game I played. Everything that appears in Reviews 9 and 10 is true. It does not cost to repeat it. I am an older player (37) and RDR2 has everything. I understand that it's not too much for kids ... well, what? I'm damn enjoying it. Something is still going on or I'm going hunting, or I'm going to fish or lookingI went and bought PS4pro with RDR2. I'm in 30% of the story. So far the BEST game I played. Everything that appears in Reviews 9 and 10 is true. It does not cost to repeat it. I am an older player (37) and RDR2 has everything. I understand that it's not too much for kids ... well, what? I'm damn enjoying it. Something is still going on or I'm going hunting, or I'm going to fish or looking for treasure ... oh god. Music is great. It is brilliant. Shooting and control is at rest. The weapon selection menu makes me most upset, but after a while you do not get it.

    Go and buy it. Because this game has everything, it's a treasure.

    I had to make a registration here:) 5

    edit:
    I read how the game is slow, how long it takes, how long it takes to loot, etc. RDR2 is all done great. Only the developers of other games are constantly reducing the demands on players because today's player just wants to quickly consume stupid entertainment. RDR2 is for real players.

    google tr.    … Expand
  64. italo151
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    First and foremost, please understand RDR 2 is not an FPS (thank the universe), it is not a plat-former (again, thank the universe), and it is most definitely not a MMO or RPG. Now what is it you ask? Well I would say even with its flawed controls and quirky, kill a bird that runs into your body instantly, it is an amazing simulation/mini-rpg/single player god send game ever created. ItFirst and foremost, please understand RDR 2 is not an FPS (thank the universe), it is not a plat-former (again, thank the universe), and it is most definitely not a MMO or RPG. Now what is it you ask? Well I would say even with its flawed controls and quirky, kill a bird that runs into your body instantly, it is an amazing simulation/mini-rpg/single player god send game ever created. It is a gamre where you can pour 50+ hours into the story alone, 50+ hours into hunting and fishing, 50+ hours into anything you can think of and do it beautifully and with amazing attention to detail. So for the other people with opinions who hate it........ I suggest don't play it then. The sad part is a lot of those reviewers probably gave COD 8-10 and Battlefield an 8-10 and any other horrible FPS game in the last 10 years an 8-10, but that is your opinion and one you have the right to have, just like this is mine. If you want a game that you can pick up whenever or actually play through it in a week or take the next 2 years to play it a different way every time, then this is the game for you.

    I will give you one example of detail, I had just got in a shoot out, shot the guy in the head, one shot and saw some a 3 star buck in the distance, so I decided to go hunt the buck well about 5-10 minutes passed and I though well I forgot to loot the body let me see if it is still there. So I went back and there was the body but there where three California vultures in it so as I got closer I realized that the body had a huge hole in its chest, the vultures started picking at the body and a hole appeared in his chest, THAT WAS AWESOME. The attention to detail in most areas is astonishing.

    So, play it, don't play, i don't care because I will be playing it for the next 3-5 years on and off until the next amazing Rockstar game. GTA VI Vice City II??????    … Expand
  65. aspire9287
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Great great. Really enjoying the immersion. Can't wait for online play!!!!!
  66. RYANIMAL795
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Completely perfect, couldn't recommend this game enough! graphics are amazing, even down to the little things. The game plays really smotthly, and there is SO much to do!
  67. fairwayshateme
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Better than any movie, tv show, play or book... I am completely engrossed with this game. I loved GTA V, but this game has a soul. Its just f**king fantastic, my favorite game of all time.
  68. Floosticky
    Nov 5, 2018
    8
    Rockstar forced their staff to work 100 hour weeks. I wish they would have had them fix the movement and shooting mechanics.
  69. cgandrade
    Nov 5, 2018
    7
    Horse Riding Simulator.

    esta es una peliculas disfrazada de videjuego. Le llamo Simulador de montas a caballo porque la mayor parte del tiempo te la pasas cabalgando. La jugabilidad deja mucho que desear ya que son demasiadas combinaciones de botones que se vuelve complicado el manejo del personaje. En cuanto a los graficos son excelentes no he visto un juego que se vea como este.    Horse Riding Simulator.

    esta es una peliculas disfrazada de videjuego.
    Le llamo Simulador de montas a caballo porque la mayor parte del tiempo te la pasas cabalgando. La jugabilidad deja mucho que desear ya que son demasiadas combinaciones de botones que se vuelve complicado el manejo del personaje.

    En cuanto a los graficos son excelentes no he visto un juego que se vea como este.

    No me atreveria a llamarlo un clasico porque es mas una pelicula interactiva de cabalgatas.    … Expand
  70. dantah
    Nov 5, 2018
    0
    this game is a good example of why "marketing power" is important.Obviously this game is overrated and lost the essence of the game.
  71. ginosaji
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    One of the best games I've ever played. The first game had already been very good but this for me is a perfect game. is a true masterpiece of rockstar.
  72. Dev78
    Nov 5, 2018
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. 0 ЗА ОТНОШЕНИЕ К ПС ГЕЙМЕРАМ И ЗА ЛЕНЬ(НА КОНСОЛЬ ПРОЩЕ ВЫПУСТИТЬ ИГРУ НА ПОРЯДОК)… Expand
  73. Yorikkillall
    Nov 5, 2018
    4
    Да игра хорошая со стороны ролеплэй, но сюжет абсолютно не зависит от тебя, сюжет абсолютно линеен и твой выбор ни на что не влияет, хотя все так гордилис этим количеством строк диалога, ХОТЯ ИХ МОЖНО БЫЛО ВОВСЕ НЕДОБАВЛЯТЬ ТАК КАК СЮЖЕТА ВОВСЕ НЕТ, я разочарован в этой игре, будь моя воля я бы вернул и деньги и игруДа игра хорошая со стороны ролеплэй, но сюжет абсолютно не зависит от тебя, сюжет абсолютно линеен и твой выбор ни на что не влияет, хотя все так гордилис этим количеством строк диалога, ХОТЯ ИХ МОЖНО БЫЛО ВОВСЕ НЕДОБАВЛЯТЬ ТАК КАК СЮЖЕТА ВОВСЕ НЕТ, я разочарован в этой игре, будь моя воля я бы вернул и деньги и игру
  74. PS4LoverDavid
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    I just love this game. You must play it to understand. NPCs are like PEOPLE. You believe them, understand them. But sometimes you just say:"Why?" It is really hard to explain this. Just play it.
  75. warxtimes_1992
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    I´ve been playing Red Dead Redemption 2 for almost 30 hrs now. I still haven´t end the story, in fact im at a 36% completion, but i got to say that this game is one of the best gaming experiences i´ve ever had. The open world is alive, full of side activities and random instances which help the world feel alive. Graphics are good for a MASSIVE sandbox game. Frame-rate works fine on PS4I´ve been playing Red Dead Redemption 2 for almost 30 hrs now. I still haven´t end the story, in fact im at a 36% completion, but i got to say that this game is one of the best gaming experiences i´ve ever had. The open world is alive, full of side activities and random instances which help the world feel alive. Graphics are good for a MASSIVE sandbox game. Frame-rate works fine on PS4 except for maybe sometimes you enter a town, but it´s nothing bad. Main quest are interesting and very story driven, side quest are excellent and vary a lot, which is great. Music is awesome, full western style, the same with sound design. I´ve encounter some bugs here and there, especially during some conversations, but that maybe is the only low point. Overall great game, a must buy/own. You wont regret it.… Expand
  76. Kammaur
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    amazing game with stunning game play and graphics. My favorite game of the year, the story is also amazing. I can't wait to play some more, it's just wow
  77. Netz34
    Nov 5, 2018
    3
    To be honest... This is Most Overhyped Boring Game Ever...
    1. The Story was so SLOW
    2. The Gameplay was so Clunky 3. The Control was Horrendous, (Need 5 Sec to loot) (1 Minutes to Skinning) ?? 4. There's only a few memorable moment for this game... 5. SPOILER Your main Character is useless... They Died and replaced with John Marston... Every Clothes I buy, Every Horse I have it's    To be honest... This is Most Overhyped Boring Game Ever...
    1. The Story was so SLOW
    2. The Gameplay was so Clunky
    3. The Control was Horrendous, (Need 5 Sec to loot) (1 Minutes to Skinning) ??
    4. There's only a few memorable moment for this game...
    5. SPOILER

    Your main Character is useless... They Died and replaced with John Marston...
    Every Clothes I buy, Every Horse I have it's GONE, just to claim the Ending...
    What a WASTING GAME OF ALL TIME...
    Game meant to be PLAYED, not to be WATCHED...
    This is nothing more than Movie Cowboy Simulator... That's it...    … Expand
  78. Jk9785
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    Story-wise, Red Dead Redemption II is one of the best games I've ever played. Fleshed-out characters, good side quests, sharp dialogue, and a 60-hour adventure that is satisfying for the entire time. Technically speaking, the graphics and attention to detail are nothing short of phenomenal, though the cleaning of the guns and tending to your horse is a pain in the ass. My only major flawStory-wise, Red Dead Redemption II is one of the best games I've ever played. Fleshed-out characters, good side quests, sharp dialogue, and a 60-hour adventure that is satisfying for the entire time. Technically speaking, the graphics and attention to detail are nothing short of phenomenal, though the cleaning of the guns and tending to your horse is a pain in the ass. My only major flaw is that the gameplay is a little clunky, but you get used to it.… Expand
  79. Vitess
    Nov 5, 2018
    0
    Эти уебки не портировали ее на ПК, купил консоль, ахуел от мыла, оценка 0
  80. ProNoob
    Nov 5, 2018
    8
    Deep, rich in variety and with an excellent story. RDR2 is masterful in so many ways, but let down slightly by clunky gun mechanics and minor gripes. The world we play in is the most alive I've seen in an open world game, the details in execution of side missions, NPC's who go about their daily lives, random events and the beauty of the map itself are all astounding. The exploration,Deep, rich in variety and with an excellent story. RDR2 is masterful in so many ways, but let down slightly by clunky gun mechanics and minor gripes. The world we play in is the most alive I've seen in an open world game, the details in execution of side missions, NPC's who go about their daily lives, random events and the beauty of the map itself are all astounding. The exploration, hunting, crafting and mini games are all fun in their own right and you can lose a lot of hours within them, which is what I'm doing on my second journey through the game, slowly slowly. My biggest problem is that the gunplay doesn't flow and is rather clunky for the most part, and there isn't really enough of it through main missions as you will spend more time getting to them than you will actually shooting, and being a cowboy game shooting should be done way better than it is. Dead-eye makes it all easier, but it is already quite easy, so I rarely use it, unless I use quick draw which is actually very well done. The story is brilliantly written and acted out, and especially by Arthur, which gets better as the game goes on.

    I recommend this game to anyone who wants a great story, deep world and wants to sink a lot of hours into.    … Expand
  81. salihs81
    Nov 5, 2018
    0
    oyun çok yavaş aksiyon az devamlı uzun at sürmeleri ile geçiyor grafiklerde beklediğim kadar iyi değil
  82. LuisMapl
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    It's REVOLUTION Jonny Game of the year 11/10 Take my money Thanks Rockstar Games
  83. Dementia
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    What can I say about this game that hasn't already been said. The whole experience is just amazing. the immersion, the graphics, the environments, the interaction with the world itself, the nature, the NPCs, the random encounters... it's just **** awesome. INSANELY detailed in every way, just awesome.
    BUT, it's not perfect. I was really expecting an important improvement in the movement    What can I say about this game that hasn't already been said. The whole experience is just amazing. the immersion, the graphics, the environments, the interaction with the world itself, the nature, the NPCs, the random encounters... it's just **** awesome. INSANELY detailed in every way, just awesome.
    BUT, it's not perfect. I was really expecting an important improvement in the movement and control of the main character, and maybe in the gunplay section, and it is just Max Payne 3 without some of the cool mechanics (just like the first RDR). The movement of the character is still clunky like all the Rockstar games, at this point I'm afraid to ask why the **** they didn't change that.
    Also, they could improve the witnesses systems, sometimes it seems like they're looking at you via satelite.
    And finaly, I **** hate the hunting system. I mean, yea it has the most realistic hunting mechanics I've ever seen in a non-hunting focused game, and THIS is the problem, i don't like hunting that much and I got bored and annoyed after chasing **** badgers for hours..
    Nonetheless, in general it's an awesome and insanely immersive game.    … Expand
  84. Spectrophobia
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    All around great and polished game. Simply a new level of story telling. if you like open-worlds, action, exploration and great story telling, this game is definitely a must play!
    Can't wait to see what Rockstar comes up with in the future. 9/10
  85. OsamabinLoobin
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    1. You CAN fast travel. You just have to be bothered to play the game in enough detail. Anyone saying they hate riding horses, probably should have NOT bought a western game. Most likely Butthurt PC Players. That being said, Arthur's Map actually uses fast travel (in camp)

    2. Arthur IS fast! You need to NOT SPAM FOOD. They make a point of explaining this pretty early in the    1. You CAN fast travel. You just have to be bothered to play the game in enough detail. Anyone saying they hate riding horses, probably should have NOT bought a western game. Most likely Butthurt PC Players. That being said, Arthur's Map actually uses fast travel (in camp)

    2. Arthur IS fast! You need to NOT SPAM FOOD. They make a point of explaining this pretty early in the game, so anyone saying he's slow, probably didn't play past 5 hours.

    3. FPS does NOT drop below 30. That's insane, and a blatant lie.

    4. Empty World? There's animal attacks, weather, random events, and NPC's out the ying yang. I have not felt alone in this entire game.

    5. Someone said you can't enter all the houses? Another Liar. Every building can be entered, and even robbed.

    6. Realistic features that are complained about, AREN'T required. You can always just buy food, fast travel, and use Legendary Animal trinkets. If you enjoy earning it, you'll have LOTS to do. "oh ma gerd, I can't wear a t shirt in snow"    … Expand
  86. GustavVasa
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    The game is Ali and Daryan, they both suck. The game is lol. ABABABABABABABADBABABABABABADBABABABABABBABABABABABABABABABABABABABABABABABABBBBABAABABABABABABABABABABABA
  87. Tcar-Batyushka
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Игра сделана просто восхитительно! Даже самые мельчайшие детали проработаны отлично! Идеальная по мне графика! Спасибо, Rockstar!… Expand
  88. ptkuz
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    Rockstar, как всегда, смогли меня удивить. Настолько проработанного мира я не видел никогда. Уже неделю прохожу игру и понимаю что притронусь к сюжету еще очень не скоро. Я просто катаюсь по этому миру и исследую его. Просто великолепно. В этой игре хочется жить. Она просто великолепна. Но есть конечно и свои минусы. Ну, ужас, неудобный интерфейс. Я 3 дня разбирался как стрелять в воздух.Rockstar, как всегда, смогли меня удивить. Настолько проработанного мира я не видел никогда. Уже неделю прохожу игру и понимаю что притронусь к сюжету еще очень не скоро. Я просто катаюсь по этому миру и исследую его. Просто великолепно. В этой игре хочется жить. Она просто великолепна. Но есть конечно и свои минусы. Ну, ужас, неудобный интерфейс. Я 3 дня разбирался как стрелять в воздух. На геймпаде кнопок мало, а старались впихнуть все. Ну и конечно же, ждем на PC. Такую игру нельзя ужимать в рамках текущего поколения консолей. И я не понимаю логику сайта Metacritic. Сделайте авторизацию по аккаунту PSN, Microsoft и Steam. Никому не хочется читать отзывы малолетних дурачков, у которых даже игру нет.… Expand
  89. Kirgis1337
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Игра поколения кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст кст
  90. Exdark
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Это прекрасно. Очень обидно , когда твои старания оценивают не по количеству багов , слабого сюжета или ещё каких геймленых недостатков , а потому , что у тебя никчемная платформу , на которой нет возможности поиграть. В противовес не могу поставить меньше 10 ( Хотя и без сложившейся ситуации с бомбящими боярами , эта игра меньшей оценки не заслуживает )Это прекрасно. Очень обидно , когда твои старания оценивают не по количеству багов , слабого сюжета или ещё каких геймленых недостатков , а потому , что у тебя никчемная платформу , на которой нет возможности поиграть. В противовес не могу поставить меньше 10 ( Хотя и без сложившейся ситуации с бомбящими боярами , эта игра меньшей оценки не заслуживает )
  91. tetr1s
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    хорошая игра! играл долго и втерался в сюжет, реакция нпс на все действия очень крутая
  92. ischtwan
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Absolutely fantastic game! On par with Witcher 3, Uncharted 4 and TLOU! Take your time with this game, it´s an unforgetable journey.
  93. Freeuser
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Абсолютное погружение в мир дикого запада и отличную историю. Живая классика.
  94. mohannedd
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    The game improves nearly every aspect on it's predecessor , visuals and graphics , Music and sound , Story and cinematics , gameplay , content and side quests , missions .
    It's a masterpiece .
  95. henrycavilson
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Очень жаль, что этой игры нет на пк. Но значит, что игра плохая. Очень жду выхода игры на мою платформу. Или это ещё один повод для покупки консоли.
  96. ProgRules
    Nov 5, 2018
    9
    It's VERY, VERY simple, are you the kind of person who plays Fortnite, COD, Battlefield, or for that matter, any kind of multiplayer game? Yes? Then Red Dead Redemption 2 is NOT for you. It's as simple as that.

    It is absolutely brilliant in so many ways and the only way to experience it, is of course, to play it. These idiots complaining about the controls and the chores and the fast    It's VERY, VERY simple, are you the kind of person who plays Fortnite, COD, Battlefield, or for that matter, any kind of multiplayer game? Yes? Then Red Dead Redemption 2 is NOT for you. It's as simple as that.

    It is absolutely brilliant in so many ways and the only way to experience it, is of course, to play it.

    These idiots complaining about the controls and the chores and the fast travel and the way the horse responds and the slow beginning and the slow burning manner of the game, well they are the kind of person I mentioned in my very first sentence.

    Is it better than GTAV? Yes.
    Is it better than the first Red Dead Redemption? Yes.
    Is it the best Rockstar game to date? Yes.

    Rockstar, I thank you for this masterpiece. It is appreciated.    … Expand
  97. RockingJewish
    Nov 4, 2018
    9
    Personally I think that this game might be a one of the most dramatic games I've ever played.The story line is actually great.
    First 5-7 hours of the game may be boring because in this period of time developers try to teach you how to do necessary things and how to do all the other stuff like hunting,fighting,crafting etc. Those people who says this are:
    1)PC players without ability to    Personally I think that this game might be a one of the most dramatic games I've ever played.The story line is actually great.
    First 5-7 hours of the game may be boring because in this period of time developers try to teach you how to do necessary things and how to do all the other stuff like hunting,fighting,crafting etc. Those people who says this are:
    1)PC players without ability to play
    2)People who don't know what they buying
    Thank you R* Games for making our life more interesting than it was.    … Expand
  98. Agarwel
    Nov 4, 2018
    8
    Huge detailed word, impressive technical presentation with sone never-seen beautifull effect and impressive amount of handcrafted content (story, locations, dialogue). From the technical point of view there is nothing to complain about.
    But also - repetitive gameplay (most of the time you ride horse, shoot enemies or stealth them). And some gamedesign choices jsut takes time, but dont add    Huge detailed word, impressive technical presentation with sone never-seen beautifull effect and impressive amount of handcrafted content (story, locations, dialogue). From the technical point of view there is nothing to complain about.
    But also - repetitive gameplay (most of the time you ride horse, shoot enemies or stealth them). And some gamedesign choices jsut takes time, but dont add anything to the gameplay. Looting is detailed and slow, browsing shops is detailed and slow, hunting is detailed and slow... considering the game size and length this is nice first few times. But looting a house after 50 hours of gameplay is pain.
    The game is fun and difficult to put down because of the exploration, but not the gameplay itself.    … Expand
  99. serhattas
    Nov 4, 2018
    10
    Usually, I never give art in any medium a perfect score. But Red Dead Redemption 2 is gaming at its finest, and is likely one of the strongest contenders against the idea that "video games are not art."

    From it's striking visuals of the barren wastelands of the west, to the vivid landscapes of the swampy south. Every moment in Red Dead is a picture and it's really easy to lose yourself    Usually, I never give art in any medium a perfect score. But Red Dead Redemption 2 is gaming at its finest, and is likely one of the strongest contenders against the idea that "video games are not art."

    From it's striking visuals of the barren wastelands of the west, to the vivid landscapes of the swampy south. Every moment in Red Dead is a picture and it's really easy to lose yourself just looking at the scenery. While I won't call this a perfect game; no game is perfect. There's a lot to love.

    -- Story --

    As it should be known by now, Red Dead Redemption 2 is a prequel to RDR, where we follow protagonist Arthur Morgan during the downfall of Van der Linde Dutch's gang during America's transition into the industrial age. The setting itself provides the conflict, in that the outlaw -- the romantic ideal of a rough gunslinger ruling by the law of a gun -- is being snuffed out.

    I don't want to spoil the game, but I have to note that it is powerful. We know where the characters are and where they are going to go because of the previous game. That inevitability is a constant reminder to the player, and while you may know it, it haunts you. But what I really love about this game, is that as Arthur Morgan, you feel like you're fighting a unwinnable war to remain free. And it really doesn't matter if you win, you just want to be free.

    -- Characters --

    A lot of the older characters, characters like Dutch, Bill Williamson, and John Marston, are almost put second seat to the newest additions. We get to see a lot of the people that made up Dutch's 'infamous' gang. And these characters almost come to life. Rockstar did an amazing job breathing personality into them, and through the conversations they have with Arthur and the other people in the camp, you slowly get attached to them.

    But the character that steals the show is likely the protagonist, Arthur Morgan. There is a Don Draper- esque quality to this character. He is depressed and hyper-aware of his life. Cynical and caring. What matters to him more than his own life and even money itself, is his gang. He becomes such a sympathetic character because of what he wants, which is to remain with his family of outlaws.

    -- Gameplay --

    The gameplay is alright. It's okay. There's not much to write about it. You ride on a horse for most of the game. You shoot people, and sometimes use an ability to slow down time to line up your shots. This isn't anything new from Rockstar gaming. But that's okay. In frankness, the gameplay serves as a supplementary addition to let people immerse themselves in the gameplay. And if I were to be honest, it really does. I spent countless hours just hunting cougars, bears, deer, and other animals just because it was so easy to lose yourself.

    What I really love about the Red Dead series is that while you're not playing a voiceless protagonist like games like Skyrim, you can still really lose yourself and become a character from a hundred years past.

    -- Side Missions --

    The side missions are very near the Witcher 3 quality of story telling. While I won't lie and say they are pulitzer prize winning short-stories, which they aren't. They are incredibly entertaining to the point where you actively purse them and not like in other games where they are pointless fetch quests.

    For example, there's one quest where you find beheaded and decorated bodies all across the map. You have to find multiple pieces of clues to pinpoint the serial-killer and eventually turn him into justice. Rockstar took their time putting some variety and quality in these stranger missions.

    -- Visuals --

    The visuals are good. The details are amazing. As an avid PC gamer, I am hard pressed to find something that matches the quality of this open world game. My only fault is the limitation of the hardware, which forces the game to remain at 30 FPS. But then again, if this were on PC, it likely be difficult to get it to 60 fps without lowering some settings.

    -- Conclusion --

    The game is good. And I wrote too much. If you like the old west and losing yourself in an epic story then pick up a copy and have a blast.    … Expand
  100. Weses
    Nov 4, 2018
    10
    It's rare to find a game of this quality and with so much emotional depth. You feel personally involved in its world, no matter how many other people may have played it. Rockstar has certainly done it again. Best game I ever played, right next to RDR1. I just wish these games weren't such a difficult task to create and that there was less "crunch" involved.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2018

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
97

Universal acclaim - based on 99 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 98 out of 99
  2. Mixed: 1 out of 99
  3. Negative: 0 out of 99
  1. CD-Action
    Nov 14, 2019
    95
    It’s an huge, outstanding piece of art – worth the hard-earned cash as well as countless hours that are needed to get to know at least some of the attractions of Rockstar’s rendition of Wild West. For those who put story first – the biggest virtue of Red Dead Redemption 2 is that it sets the stage for RDR 1 and does it wonderfully. [13/2018, p.40]
  2. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Dec 31, 2018
    100
    Amazing not only for Western lovers. No other game has probably offered so many options to express yourself in the open world, and at the same time did not have such an interesting, rough and moving story. A magnificent experience, with a slightly slower start. [Issue#291]
  3. TrueGaming
    Nov 30, 2018
    95
    The first new game from Rockstar for this generation of consoles doesn't disappoint, it is as impressive as you hoped it to be.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »