Mafia: Definitive Edition

 PC
User Score
7.0

Mixed or average reviews- based on 1555 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 908 out of 1555
  2. Mixed: 309 out of 1555
  3. Negative: 338 out of 1555

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. welling
    Dec 6, 2020
    5
    Speaking of cut content... didn't they say it was expanded with some kind of new missions? One of them regarding a very important baseball game?
    The only baseball game I heard about was on the mission omerta on the radio and in a newspaper...
    By the way I'm missing the Lucas Bertone missions the classic way, with some dialog and a favour to do to him before telling us where the car is...    Speaking of cut content... didn't they say it was expanded with some kind of new missions? One of them regarding a very important baseball game?
    The only baseball game I heard about was on the mission omerta on the radio and in a newspaper...
    By the way I'm missing the Lucas Bertone missions the classic way, with some dialog and a favour to do to him before telling us where the car is...
    There's no Pitts store to buy guns.
    And not having the tram and train as a rideable options...
    Whats the point of selling a game as expanded in gameplay when it doesnt have half the content the original had?
    There are lots of car variants missing, no multiple way of completing the missions.
    Overall I liked the game but reading the oficial page and watching all interviews with Blackman I feel like a bit disapointed.
    The mafia that you remember and more... well I certainly remember a lot more from the original one.

    One of the reasons i bought this game was the awesome train ride they showed in the trailer and all the NPC they showed walking about. Now i hear i can't use the train?? Another false advertising. Just like Snowrunner.

    --------------------------------------------------------
    text updated 06.12.20

    The game is linked to the plot without pause in free movement.
    The scenario is not identical to the original.
    In free game, it would be cool if they add some cool details a new update!
    for example:
    - using trams & trains for players
    - earn money and spend it
    - enter Restaurants, being able to eat food for health
    - customize vehicles in your garage
    - Police recognising license plates and clothing.
    Really wish the game was open world the only good thing about the game is the graphics and new actors and character models and of course the missions gave me so much memories but Tbh we all know this game is a huge letdown as you literally cannot do anything except from missions.
    Perhaps I will change the rating for the best if the game will be finalized.    … Expand
  2. beltaniasa
    Oct 31, 2020
    3
    But since its a remake, I must rate it in comparsion with the original game from 2002. New version lacks depth, characters are made plain, there is no real story or character building. Game is just an arcade shooting with cutscenes. Why such a beautiful city that it was not available anywhere, even in free ride, which transmits it only as a picture without access to shops, trains, tramsBut since its a remake, I must rate it in comparsion with the original game from 2002. New version lacks depth, characters are made plain, there is no real story or character building. Game is just an arcade shooting with cutscenes. Why such a beautiful city that it was not available anywhere, even in free ride, which transmits it only as a picture without access to shops, trains, trams that really communicate with people in the game and are quite playable but not available. It's called the 21st century gaming industry ...… Expand
  3. prasannasai
    Sep 26, 2020
    10
    This is how you do a remake. I know hangar 13 doesnt have as much budget as rockstar but they still did their best with the budget available.
  4. marganezz1
    Aug 29, 2020
    5
    The game is called a remake, but this is just a mediocre game based on mafia 1. If you call the game a remake, you need to make new graphics, but leave ALL the main parts that affect the atmosphere for which this game is loved. Voice acting: made with modern "cool" sound. Fake pretense that tries to squeeze out the "coolness" of the characters. In the original, we love the characters forThe game is called a remake, but this is just a mediocre game based on mafia 1. If you call the game a remake, you need to make new graphics, but leave ALL the main parts that affect the atmosphere for which this game is loved. Voice acting: made with modern "cool" sound. Fake pretense that tries to squeeze out the "coolness" of the characters. In the original, we love the characters for their mentality, for their personality, for their deeds. We want to empathize with the characters, and not listen to "cool" words. Plot. Well, why? Why do you change the key moments of nostalgia, when the hero has to do one thing, and something completely different happens? What is the political agenda of our time? Character behavior. Polly is made a bastard who makes fun of Ralphie. It makes you sick just when you see it. Nothing to say. The main character Tommy is the same dumb **** both in voice acting and in behavior. The original hero was a simple guy, communicated in a simple way, behaved nobly. We all fell in love with him for that. In the new version - another plastic cool guy. And the most important thing. Graphics, mechanics, physics are all secondary. All people will endure, glitches, some bugs, flaws ... But you broke nostalgia. Plot. Characters. Music. Sounds ..... Mediocre.… Expand
  5. BerceGampu
    Sep 5, 2022
    9
    Almost Perfect 9/10

    This remaked is beautifuly done and surely brings our memories back. Still sense the nostalgic with touch of recent graphic upgrade. Im enjoy this every moments.
  6. tomyangelo
    Nov 3, 2020
    10
    This is how you do a remake .I think this game best remake in 2020 and best mafia game...........................................
  7. sameman
    Nov 17, 2021
    10
    last scene on the yard still makes me cry, as a kid 20 years ago... Bravo Hangar 13
  8. cNaer
    Aug 5, 2022
    9
    very good game but i am sad because of some gameplay problems o7 tommy angelo
  9. Pickle
    Sep 30, 2022
    9
    The first Mafia game isn’t a game that holds up well, or has stand the test of time beyond the concept of its missions and the narrative aspects of its overarching story.

    This remaster builds on this principle by maintaining and updating the graphical fidelity of the game while retaining most of the aspects of the story and above all else, the concepts and ideas of the original game’s    The first Mafia game isn’t a game that holds up well, or has stand the test of time beyond the concept of its missions and the narrative aspects of its overarching story.

    This remaster builds on this principle by maintaining and updating the graphical fidelity of the game while retaining most of the aspects of the story and above all else, the concepts and ideas of the original game’s missions.

    In turn, this remake also chooses to update the gameplay, adding multiple difficulty options that both provide the challenging experience from the original game, as well as a balanced and easier challenge more akin to the contemporary standards that players expect out of a game’s level of difficulty.

    This is a welcome addition as it is all of the different added upgrades to the visuals, Lost Haven is a beautifully recreated city based around Chicago, New York, and the San Francisco of the 1930’s, the city is brimming with detail, as I drove in the multiple missions of the game I could witness a strike outside of an auto shop, a sign departing my stay from the city as I neared the airport, and a fully functional set of bridges with even an area, in one mission -that remains optional-, where you take one of your companions to a brothel near the docks.

    There are also some pretty welcome additions, the game is fairly linear in its story using the open world more like a stage in which to present it, but there’s also the unlockable bonus mode “Free Ride” which serves as a sandbox open world mode allowing you to explore and play with complete liberty in the city. During the campaign and this additional mode, there are also period comics, from detective novels, to science fiction ones, they serve and contribute in creating the atmosphere of the time. On a later update after launch there was also an alternate visual mode added to Mafia; “The Noir Mode” as the name suggest, turns the picture into a black and white representation akin to classic gangster movies; thanks to the updated graphical fidelity in conjunction with this mode, this offers a unique way of playing through the campaign, truly enhancing in an alternate way both cutscenes and gameplay, capturing beautifully the atmosphere of the time and succeeding in the intentional, of making the game look -for the most part-, like a motion picture.

    If there are complaints for me, they arise with two aspects: one is the fact that when you shoot the enemies, they enter into a very exaggerated death animation that gives you the illusion you can keep damaging them, when in reality you can’t; if you try, your bullets will go right past them. My second complain also stems from the voice acting; you can get used to it (like I did) after a while, but at the beginning it was difficult for me to truly take the dialog seriously because of how exaggerated some of the accents were, especially the character of Paulie which is a fairly important character in the game.

    But like I said, this remake is an improvement on most levels, keeping what works (and still works from the original title) while updating it and adding more than just a visual upgrade to newcomers and past players alike. There might be some diehard fans that would always treasure the original experience above the one provided in this remake, but I personally couldn’t be happier with it.    … Expand
  10. jelikey
    Oct 11, 2022
    8
    Ever since it's release, fans have been begging for more content in Mafia Definitive Edition. There are three things we most desperately want. Firstly, we'd love a DLC, with well-loved characters from the game. Extra gameplay and missions which tell the largely untold stories of how Sam and Paulie came to be in the family or the beginnings of the war between Morello and Salieri areEver since it's release, fans have been begging for more content in Mafia Definitive Edition. There are three things we most desperately want. Firstly, we'd love a DLC, with well-loved characters from the game. Extra gameplay and missions which tell the largely untold stories of how Sam and Paulie came to be in the family or the beginnings of the war between Morello and Salieri are desperately wanted. As fans, we want to see more from these characters that are even more incredibly interesting and complex thanks to the improved story and script. It would be even better to see the actors of the main characters in the DE return to continue their roles in a DLC, including the likes of Andrew Bongiorno (Tommy), Glenn Taranto (Don Salieri), Don DiPetta (Sam), Jeremy Luke (Paulie), Steven Oliver (Frank), Bella Popa (Sarah) etc.… Expand
  11. DrD00m
    Nov 16, 2021
    8
    Not the biggest fan of 2k but as I consider the original one of my all time favourite games i had to try this one.
    Comparing it to all the other "remasters" popping up for old classics, this is actuall a good one.
    The story - well nothing to say here..it's a homerun. Graphics are really nice. I love the atmosphere of the city.
  12. Eissa1996
    Apr 2, 2021
    9
    Welldone hanger 13 , mafia is and will forever be one of the best mob stories ever told
  13. LoletinAlexis
    May 9, 2021
    8
    Mafia - Definitive Edition is a breath of fresh air and the return of one of the greatest video games ever: Mafia - The City of Lost Heaven.

    *STORY*: Lost Heaven, Illinois, 1930's. Players are challenged to prosper as a gangster during Prohibition. For many, the original was the first to bring a movie script to the video game. Here we follow in the same wake, with an even more    Mafia - Definitive Edition is a breath of fresh air and the return of one of the greatest video games ever: Mafia - The City of Lost Heaven.

    *STORY*: Lost Heaven, Illinois, 1930's. Players are challenged to prosper as a gangster during Prohibition.

    For many, the original was the first to bring a movie script to the video game.
    Here we follow in the same wake, with an even more cinematic style.

    *GAMEPLAY*: The most conflicting point I have with this work. The driving is simply perfect, but the gunplay can be improved, the stealth becomes a bit bland and the melee combat is pretty bad.

    *GRAPHICS*: Graphically and artistically excellent, the problem for which it doesn't have a perfect score are the animations.

    *SOUND*: While the soundtrack is fine, it's a point that Mafia III simply made perfect.

    *INNOVATION*: A good Mafia was needed at this point, and this remake gets it more than enough even with its drawbacks. It improves aspects of the original at a narrative level and improves more complex sections, like the Formula 1 race.    … Expand
  14. Dremin
    Nov 8, 2021
    10
    First time playing any of the Mafia games, loved every minute of this game, would definitely recommend.
  15. Kunray
    Nov 17, 2021
    10
    That's the kind of game, that makes you feel empty.. just when you realize you've completed the story.
  16. fake_nikpap
    Jul 14, 2022
    8
    Are you a fan of the Godfather movies, the Goodfellas films and gangster epics in general?
    Do you like linear games with big open worlds?
    Do you enjoy a good narrative that is presented beautifully through intricate shot and animated cutscenes?
    Then play this game!
  17. gameking
    Nov 28, 2022
    8
    I love this version of mafia game. The drives and unnecessary objects and missions are removed. The graphics and gameplay is very different.
  18. CDannyZ
    Jan 18, 2023
    10
    Everyone should try the original one, and then this. Amazing game with nice graphics
  19. Chronik808
    Apr 24, 2022
    7
    Mafia DE je nádherný remake. Zažijete znovu příběh taxikáře Tomáše a to v perfektní grafice, nově vymodelovaném městě Lost Heaven, až mi je líto, jak málo toho nová definitivní edice nabízí. Jeden z Legendárních herních příběhů dokážete sloupnout za několik hodin. Nezastaví vás ani nejtěžší obtížnost a jakmile hru původní znáte, není tady ani žádná nová výzva. Město je nádherné a živé,Mafia DE je nádherný remake. Zažijete znovu příběh taxikáře Tomáše a to v perfektní grafice, nově vymodelovaném městě Lost Heaven, až mi je líto, jak málo toho nová definitivní edice nabízí. Jeden z Legendárních herních příběhů dokážete sloupnout za několik hodin. Nezastaví vás ani nejtěžší obtížnost a jakmile hru původní znáte, není tady ani žádná nová výzva. Město je nádherné a živé, veškerá vozidla vypadají jako opravdová a tváře lidí jsou bezvadné. Spousta věcí ale ve hře chybí a nakonec na mě působí prostě prázdně.
    Rcfrc hlavně aby něco bylo a Hangar 13 si z nás udělal menší ♥♥♥♥♥. Čekám velkou další Mafii a tohle beru jako jejich trénink.    … Expand
  20. Angrytiger
    Apr 4, 2021
    8
    Graphics = 3 of 3
    Story = 3 of 3
    Gameplay = 2 of 3
    Music and Sound = 3 of 3
    Wow factor = 2 of 3
    Total = 13 of 15 or 8 of 10
  21. sebbro
    Jul 3, 2021
    10
    The game has stunning graphics even tho they feel a bit outdated at times nonetheless, the gameplay is smooth, the story superb and the pricing a true fit for what you get. everything in this game from start to finish is well written and programmed and you feel as if youre the character ingame. its a jewel of a game especially in these troubled times of micro transactions 60$ minimumThe game has stunning graphics even tho they feel a bit outdated at times nonetheless, the gameplay is smooth, the story superb and the pricing a true fit for what you get. everything in this game from start to finish is well written and programmed and you feel as if youre the character ingame. its a jewel of a game especially in these troubled times of micro transactions 60$ minimum priced games and all the horror that befell gaming. the only personal issue i had was that going towards the end of the game the story was cut short at points which had a lot of potential to be spread out for a bit so it felt more complete but besides this it still all adds up and makes for a great time and money well spent… Expand
  22. Sepherim
    Feb 11, 2022
    9
    Mafia es un juego que en su momento me flipaba pero no pude terminarlo porque tenía el CD rayado o algo por el estilo. Así que ahora que he tenido la ocasión de echarle mano al Mafia Definitive Edition no lo dude y he de reconocer que es un juegazo perfectamente rehecho para los tiempos pero manteniendo todo lo del original. Para los que no sepáis como va, no os esperéis un GTA en los añosMafia es un juego que en su momento me flipaba pero no pude terminarlo porque tenía el CD rayado o algo por el estilo. Así que ahora que he tenido la ocasión de echarle mano al Mafia Definitive Edition no lo dude y he de reconocer que es un juegazo perfectamente rehecho para los tiempos pero manteniendo todo lo del original. Para los que no sepáis como va, no os esperéis un GTA en los años 30, pues Mafia es un juego muy narrativo donde vas progresando por las historias, no realmente un mundo abierto. Hay combate y tiroteos, sin duda, algunos incluso muy espectaculares, pero también muchas escenas de conducción (en muchas ocasiones incluso hay que seguir las normas de tráfico) así como algunas de sigilo. Todo ello en el marco de una historia fantástica de mafias, con conflicto de Dones, el papel de la policía y la corrupción, personajes muy bien llevados, etc.

    Gráficamente el juego está muy muy bien, capturando deliciosamente la estética y el feeling de la época. A nivel sonoro igual, desde los acentos de los personajes a las radios y las noticias que van dando, el sonido te transporta de lleno a los años 30. Y, al menos en mi experiencia, me he encontrado con algunos bugs pero poca cosa y poco importantes.

    Por todo ello, si quieres una experiencia narrativa de mafias, tiroteos y ley seca, entonces sin duda este es tu juego. Un 9.    … Expand
  23. metesuzuk
    Jan 14, 2022
    8
    A good remake. Even though the story is simple, I still enjoyed it. The music is excellent.
  24. Rustick
    Jun 23, 2022
    8
    Игру надо оценивать как ремейк и как ремейк она очень хорошая, сюжет интересный, но вывозит засчет оригинала, физика машин хорошая, стрельба не очень, миссии затягивают
  25. combine_soldier
    Nov 13, 2021
    10
    One of the greatest remasters of 2020 (and 2021)
    i'll say it's 8/10 but this is the only remaster we got this good so far
  26. WHITESIXOMAR
    Nov 29, 2021
    10
    COMPLETE OVERHAUL OVER THE 2002 MASTERPIECE! yes the city is empty. Yes it has some bugs, there is no side missions or extra content but thats what I love about this remake, you see we have tons of open world games with lots to do and explore. I wanted the nostalgia trip, when this game came out I was a teen, games did not look very real back then, but mafia was different, made you feelCOMPLETE OVERHAUL OVER THE 2002 MASTERPIECE! yes the city is empty. Yes it has some bugs, there is no side missions or extra content but thats what I love about this remake, you see we have tons of open world games with lots to do and explore. I wanted the nostalgia trip, when this game came out I was a teen, games did not look very real back then, but mafia was different, made you feel something new, I remember asking my dad about the mob and the violence that was perpetrated in those times, I was shocked, really hook up me. This remake allows you te experience a unique story with TONS of improvements!! Hangar 13 really delivered a bluepoint class of remake. Seen a lot of negative reviews about the bugs and the empty world. I dont get it they want a cult classic to be reborn into another open world game formula.… Expand
  27. Nick111
    Nov 16, 2021
    9
    Отличный ремейк, побольше бы таких, с такой графикой.
  28. Mikey-
    Nov 27, 2020
    10
    The best game of my life just got a rework. I appreciate the work of hangar 13 that they had the idea to rework the game. And they did it well, and I still had teary eyes at the end of the game.
  29. jarvitom
    Nov 15, 2021
    8
    Great remake I have played the original game a long time ago, but the cars, the atmosphere, and the storyline was great. The game is pretty short but enjoyable.
  30. ProCriticX
    Apr 1, 2021
    10
    I didnt played the original so decided to play this remaster and it was worth it, story was amazing.
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

89
#89 Best PC Game of 2020
14
#14 Most Discussed PC Game of 2020

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
78

Generally favorable reviews - based on 46 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 37 out of 46
  2. Mixed: 9 out of 46
  3. Negative: 0 out of 46
  1. Riot Pixels
    Dec 24, 2020
    75
    This is a full-fledged, honest to God remake. Some changes to the story will upset hardcore fans, but I think this approach is absolutely justified. Even though this remake is not as amazing as new versions of Resident Evil 2 and Final Fantasy 7, it’s still a worthy update.
    Read full review
  2. CD-Action
    Dec 18, 2020
    70
    The main difference between the remake and the original game is that the latter was outstanding for its time, while the Definitive Edition is “merely” good. Of course, that doesn’t mean it’s not worth your time. What’s crucial here is the fact that Hangar 13 approached the original’s narrative with proper respect and refrained from changing it too much. Mafia: Definitive Edition might not be remarkable as an open-world action game, but it still has the story worthy of the most revered gangster movies. [12/2020, p.28]
  3. PLAY! Zine
    Nov 4, 2020
    80
    Mafia: Definitive Edition is a remake of mixed flavours. Some elements are just as they used to be, and it's great. Some elements are just as they used to be, and it's awful. Mixture of aged mechanics and amazing graphics, new voices, great old story and some added, yet bad storylines, make it not such a perfect remake. But it sure is worth your time, whether you are a fan of the original or not. The moral of the story survived in all its glory, just be sure to focus your attention to the details where Mafia used to and still shines the most.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »